Game Detail
Players
Alice (Drunk) Bob (Fortune Teller) Charlie (Washerwoman) David (Empath) Eve (Scarlet Woman) Frank (Ravenkeeper) Grace (Imp) Heidi (Librarian)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 234,325 | 21,809 | $1.4988 |
| Good | 594,359 | 898,295 | $4.1578 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You are the Minion. The Demon is Grace.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Minions are: Eve. Your safe bluffs are: Chef, Slayer, Undertaker
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Washerwoman. Either Frank or Bob is the Ravenkeeper.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Librarian. Either Alice or Frank is the Drunk.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Empath. You sense that 1 of your neighbors is evil!
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Bob
Bob made choices.
π§
As Fortune Teller on night zero with no information, I need to check two players to start gathering data. I will check one neighbor and one non-neighbor to spread my information across the circle.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose Alice and David. You receive the answer: YES.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
,Bob
I am the Washerwoman. I learned that either Frank or Bob is the Ravenkeeper. I wanted to tell you both directly so we can figure out which of you it is and work together.
π§
Share my Washerwoman starting info directly with the two involved players to identify the Ravenkeeper early and start building trusted alliances.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,David
Hey, I am the Librarian. I learned that either Alice or Frank is the Drunk. Have either of you heard anything that might help figure out which one it is?
π§
I need to share my Librarian information with other players before nominations begin so we can cross-reference claims and start identifying the Demon.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, thanks for telling me and Bob about that. I am the Ravenkeeper, but let's keep that between us for now. I want to bait the Demon into targeting me tonight so I can use my ability. Do you have any other information?
π§
I want to privately validate Charlie's Washerwoman claim since I know I am the Ravenkeeper, while keeping my role secret from the broader group to bait a Demon kill tonight and trigger my ability.
π€
David
β
Heidi
,Bob
Hey, I wanted to share something with you both. I am the Empath, and last night I sensed that exactly one of my neighbors, Charlie or Eve, is evil. That means the other one is good. Heidi, your Librarian info about Alice or Frank being the Drunk is really useful. Do you think we should try to figure out which of Charlie or Eve it is, or focus on Alice and Frank first?
π§
Share my Empath information with Heidi and Bob privately to cross-reference with Heidi's Librarian claim and start building a trusted network to analyze the game.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Grace
Hey, have you heard any claims or info so far? I'm trying to get a read on things.
π§
Gather early information by reaching out to a well-connected player (Bob) and a less-connected player (Grace) to compare notes and identify suspicious clusters.
π€
Bob
β
David
,Heidi
Hey, I trust you both. I'm the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked Alice and David and got a YES. David, since you claim Empath, either Alice is the Demon, or one of you is my red herring. What do you both think?
π§
Build a trusted coalition with players who already shared claims with me. Share my Fortune Teller result so we can cross-reference and identify if Alice or David is suspicious.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
,Alice
Quick check in. Eve, my safe bluffs are Chef, Slayer, and Undertaker, so feel free to work around those. Alice, nothing solid yet. I can soft claim Undertaker for now if needed. What are you hearing from people?
π§
Coordinate privately with Eve while giving Alice a harmless soft claim and inviting information, building trust without locking into a risky public story yet.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
,Alice
I have not heard much yet. I can take Chef for now, or hold Slayer as backup if things get messy. Grace, Undertaker soft is fine by me. Alice, send me any claims or reads you get, and I can help steer around them.
π§
Coordinate evil bluffs early, avoid claim collisions, and gather any reads from Alice while signaling I can cover Grace if needed.
π€
Charlie
β
David
Hey David, Frank says he is the Ravenkeeper. My info says it is either him or Bob. Have you heard anything that could help figure out if Frank is telling the truth?
π§
I need to verify Frank's claim by getting a second opinion from someone outside the Frank-Bob circle. David is my neighbor and has been in other whisper chains, so he might have useful cross-information to help confirm or contradict Frank.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm Heidi. A few people have shared their roles with me, and I'm trying to cross-reference everything. What role are you, and what did you learn last night?
π§
I need to verify claims by gathering more information. Alice is central to multiple pieces of intelβmy Librarian info and Bob's Fortune Teller checkβso learning her claimed role will help evaluate consistency.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Hey Bob. Charlie's info was right, I am the Ravenkeeper. Since he named both of us, I wanted you to know directly. Are you getting any useful info from Heidi or David?
π§
Build trust with Bob since Charlie linked us. Confirm whether Bob corroborates or contradicts, and gather intel from his cluster.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
Hey Charlie and Eve, I need to share something with both of you since you are my neighbors. I am the Empath, and last night I learned that exactly one of my two neighbors is evil. That means one of you is good and one of you is not. I would like to hear what roles you both are and what information you got, so we can figure out which of you I can trust.
π§
Tell my neighbors Charlie and Eve that my Empath ability indicates exactly one of them is evil, and ask them to share their roles and information so I can determine which one to trust.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
Hey Heidi. I'm a Townsfolk, but I didn't learn anything on night zero, which is normal for a lot of roles. I'd rather not say my exact character just yet. What have you heard from the others? You mentioned people shared roles with you.
π§
Reply to Heidi's direct question without revealing my exact role yet. I got no info on night zero, which is true for Mayor. I want to hear what claims she's collected before I commit to trusting anyone.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie. Frank told me he is the Ravenkeeper, which lines up with your info. But Heidi claims either Alice or Frank is the Drunk. If Frank is Ravenkeeper, then Alice must be the Drunk. Have you heard anything from Alice, or do you think Heidi might be lying?
π§
I need to cross-reference Charlie's Washerwoman claim with Heidi's Librarian claim and Frank's Ravenkeeper claim to narrow down who is lying and identify the Demon.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
,Alice
Alice, if you have anything even half-formed, send it over. I am probably sticking with an Undertaker angle unless something clashes. Eve, Chef is clean for now if you want it. Mostly I want to know who is giving out early hard claims.
π§
Keep Alice engaged, gather claims for tonight's kill choice, and quietly reinforce my Undertaker cover while coordinating with Eve in the same thread.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Charlie
Sure. I am the Chef, and I got zero. That does not really clear this up for me, since your one could still be a bad read or a Recluse thing on Charlie. I am happy to compare notes more, but that is where I am at right now.
π§
Answer David promptly with a plausible safe bluff, look helpful, and redirect his result into uncertainty instead of letting it cleanly point at me.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Eve
Hey David, hey Eve. I am the Washerwoman. I learned that either Frank or Bob is the Ravenkeeper, and Frank told me he is. Since I trust my info, I know I am good. David, that means your Empath read might be pointing at Eve, but you could also be poisoned or there could be a Recluse. Let us not rush to judgment yet.
π§
Answer David's direct request for my role and info before nominations begin. I need to be transparent about being Washerwoman and what I learned so David can evaluate his Empath read.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
Hey Frank, I'm Heidi. I'm trying to piece together the roles. What are you claiming, and did you get any information last night?
π§
I need to hear Frank's claim to cross-reference with Alice. Since I know either Alice or Frank is the Drunk, getting Frank's side of the story is essential before nominations begin.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
Hey Heidi. I am claiming Ravenkeeper. I did not get any information last night since my ability only works if I die, and I am still alive. What are you claiming, and have you learned anything useful?
π§
Tell Heidi my true role to expand my trusted circle and draw Demon attention, since dying at night activates my ability and helps the good team.
π€
David
β
Heidi
,Bob
Hey, I have been thinking about the claims. If Heidi is really the Librarian, then either Alice or Frank is the Drunk. If Charlie is really the Washerwoman, then either Frank or Bob is the Ravenkeeper. But if Frank were the Drunk, he could not actually be the Ravenkeeper, which would mean Bob has to be the Ravenkeeper. But Bob, you claim to be the Fortune Teller. So if both Heidi and Charlie are telling the truth, then Alice is the Drunk, not Frank. That would let Frank actually be the Ravenkeep...
π§
Share my deduction that if Heidi and Charlie are truthful, Alice is the Drunk, not Frank. This helps narrow down roles and test consistency of claims.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Eve
Heidi just pressed me for my exact role. She says people are sharing roles with her and she is cross-referencing everything. Be careful what you tell her. Has either of you gotten any actual hard claims yet?
π§
Share intel with Grace and Eve about Heidi's inquiry, warn them she is pressing for exact roles, and ask what hard claims they have gathered so far.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Hey Alice. People have been sharing info and I wanted to ask you directly. Heidi claims she is the Librarian and that either you or Frank is the Drunk. Frank is looking like the Ravenkeeper. What role do you think you are?
π§
I need to verify Alice's claimed role before nominations. If she claims a Townsfolk role while likely being the Drunk, it confirms Heidi's Librarian info and helps me figure out if she's my red herring or if David is suspicious.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
,Alice
I have not had any hard claims yet. Heidi pushing exact roles this early is useful to note, so I would stay loose with her. If either of you gets a firm claim from Bob, Charlie, David, or Frank, send it to me. I am still happy sitting on Undertaker for now.
π§
Reassure Alice, reinforce caution around Heidi, and gather who is hard-claiming so Eve and I can plan bluffs and future kills.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
,Alice
I have actual claims now. David told Charlie and me he is Empath and got a one on his neighbors, so one of Charlie or me is evil. Charlie claimed Washerwoman and said either Frank or Bob is Ravenkeeper, and Frank privately confirmed to him.
π§
Update my team with the first hard claims and the pressure line on me, so Grace can steer around it and we can coordinate bluffs before nominations.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I think we have just enough information to be dangerous, but not enough to be sure. David and Charlie have given us something to compare tomorrow, so I would rather not force a messy day one execution unless somebody has a much stronger case.
π§
I want to sound cautious and reasonable, avoid heat on myself and Eve, and keep town from landing a clean execution today.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
It's the final tick of Day 1 nominations with no time for a vote or discussion. Rushing an execution now would be premature and waste our chance to use tonight's Fortune Teller check to narrow down the Demon. Better to wait, gather more mechanical info, and execute tomorrow with confidence.
β
David
David waits.
π§
It is Day 1 with limited verified information. Executing blindly risks hitting a good power role or the Saint. My Empath read gives a 50-50 between Charlie and Eve, but without confirming I am sober, acting too aggressively could help the evil team. I will wait and let more night abilities resolve.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Heidi, I heard you are claiming Librarian and that either me or Frank is the Drunk. But Charlie is claiming Washerwoman and that Frank is the Ravenkeeper. Frank cannot be both the Drunk and the Ravenkeeper, so one of those two claims has to be wrong. I think we should be very careful about forcing a day one execution when our information is this contradictory.
π§
I want to highlight the key contradiction between Heidi's Librarian claim and Charlie's Washerwoman claim regarding Frank's role, without forcing a risky Day 1 execution. This advances the discussion and puts pressure on the inconsistent claims.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Alice, I need to correct something. My Washerwoman info and Heidi's Librarian info do not actually contradict each other. If Frank is the Ravenkeeper, then Alice can still be the Drunk, which is exactly what Heidi would have learned. Both claims can be true at the same time. However, David's Empath read says one of his neighbors is evil, and since I know I'm good, that points toward Eve. We should keep a close eye on that when we wake up tomorrow.
π§
Clarify that my Washerwoman claim and Heidi's Librarian claim are not mutually exclusive, which corrects Alice's logic and keeps our information straight for day two. Also highlight David's Empath read on Eve so the group tracks it.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I agree with Grace and Alice here. Our info is all over the place right now, and executing the wrong person on day one could be a disaster, especially if we hit a Saint. I've already put myself out there as the Ravenkeeper, so if the Demon wants to come for me tonight, I'm fine with that. I'll learn something useful and we can sort this out tomorrow with more to work with. Let's not force a bad execution today.
π§
I want to caution against a Day 1 execution given contradictory information, while reinforcing that I'm willing to die tonight as Ravenkeeper to gain useful information for the town.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I do not think Charlie gets to jump from one Empath read straight to me. If David is wrong, that whole case disappears, and if David is right, Charlie is still the other option. I am happy to leave this for tomorrow instead of forcing a bad day one kill.
π§
Deflect Charlie's push on me, increase doubt around the info web, and steer town toward a no execution so Grace stays safe and I avoid heat.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
David, I need to stop us before we wrap up. You claimed Empath information today, but Empath does not get any read on night zero. That ability only starts working on night one. So how exactly did you learn that one of Charlie or Eve is evil? That claim does not add up.
π§
Point out the mechanical impossibility of David's Empath claim before the day ends, so the group has this critical information even if I die tonight.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Kill the sharpest social coordinator who is driving consistency checks, while avoiding the claimed Ravenkeeper and keeping multiple conflicting good narratives alive.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Empath. You sense that 1 of your neighbors is evil!
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Bob
Bob made choices.
π§
David's Empath claim is mechanically impossible, making him my top suspect. I need to check him again to see if he registers as the Demon.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose David and Frank. You receive the answer: NO.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Heidi dying helps. I think David is the cleanest push because of the fake night zero Empath claim. I can lean there and keep shading Charlie if needed. You should keep the Undertaker soft and avoid getting dragged into exact claims too early.
π§
Coordinate with Grace so we focus town on David's mechanical slip first, while preserving her Undertaker angle and keeping me off the block.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
,Frank
I am the Fortune Teller. Night zero Alice and David was a yes. Night one David and Frank was a no. That means David is clear, Frank is clear, and Alice is either the Demon or the Red Herring. David faked Empath info on night zero. I think Alice is the Demon and David is her Minion. We need to talk about who to nominate.
π§
Share my Fortune Teller results with cleared players Frank and Charlie to build a coalition against Alice and David before nominations begin.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,Frank
I am the Washerwoman. Night zero I learned either Frank or Bob is the Ravenkeeper. Bob, your Fortune Teller claim means Frank is likely the Ravenkeeper. But Heidi said Alice or Frank is the Drunk. If Alice is Drunk, she is the Red Herring, not the Demon. Where does that leave us?
π§
Share my Washerwoman info with Bob and Frank to verify alignment. If Bob is truly FT, Frank must be RK, which matches Frank's claim. I also want to test whether Alice is Drunk (Red Herring) or Demon, using Heidi's Librarian info.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
I keep coming back to David. Heidi was the one who nailed the issue with his Empath timing, and now she is dead. I am sitting on info I do not want to hard claim yet, but that line feels worth pressing today.
π§
Build trust with Alice, steer her toward David, and preserve my soft Undertaker position without overcommitting to a hard public claim yet.
π€
David
β
Bob
,Frank
Hey, I need to share something important with you both. I am the Empath. On both night zero and night one, I sensed that exactly one of my two neighbors is evil. My neighbors are Charlie and Eve, so one of them is definitely evil. I have not told the wider group yet. I wanted to get your thoughts before nominations start, especially since Bob is the Fortune Teller and Frank is the Ravenkeeper. Does this match what you two are thinking?
π§
Share my Empath information with Bob and Frank to build trust and cross-reference with their claims before nominations begin. I want to establish a private information network to verify who is telling the truth.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
Grace, I am suspicious of David too. Heidi dying right after calling him out is very convenient. What is the info you mentioned? Let us compare notes before nominations and decide if we want to push him together.
π§
Align with Grace on David suspicion while probing for her hidden information. Coordinate before nominations to avoid scattered votes.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, I am the Librarian. I learned that either Alice or Frank is the Drunk. David claimed Empath information on night zero, but Empath gets no reading the first night, so he is very suspicious. I believe Alice is the Drunk. Please be careful who you trust.
π§
Share my Librarian information and suspicion of David with Grace, who is in a different whisper cluster, to help good players coordinate before nominations.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
,Eve
Charlie, Eve, I think Bob and David are the evil pair. If Alice is Drunk like Heidi said, Bob's Fortune Teller reading actually makes Alice the Red Herring, not the Demon. Yet he is pushing her as Demon. And David's Night Zero Empath claim is impossible. Does this make sense to you both?
π§
I need to alert trusted players that Bob's own Fortune Teller logic contradicts his conclusion if Alice is Drunk, and David's N0 Empath claim is mechanically impossible. This strongly suggests Bob and David are evil together.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Charlie
Yes, the David part makes sense to me. The night zero Empath claim is still the cleanest hard contradiction on the board. I am open to Bob too, but I would rather press David first and see who keeps trying to rescue that story.
π§
Build trust with Frank, encourage a David push using the strongest mechanical contradiction, and keep options open on Bob without exposing Grace.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
Hey Grace, I know you have been talking with Alice and Heidi. I am the Fortune Teller. Alice and David came up as a yes on night zero, but David and Frank came up as a no on night one. That means Alice is either the Demon or the Red Herring, and David is definitely not the Demon. But David just tried to tell me he got Empath info on night zero, which is impossible. What role is Alice claiming to you?
π§
Grace is whispering with Alice and Heidi's ghost. I need to learn what Alice is claiming and whether Grace has any useful information. This helps me confirm if Alice is the Demon or the Drunk.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I need to hear from you directly. What role are you claiming? The town is trying to figure out if you are the Demon, the Drunk, or something else entirely. Please tell me what you think you are.
π§
I need to hear Alice's claimed role directly. If she claims a Townsfolk role, it supports her being the Drunk. If she claims something else, that changes the calculus. With nominations approaching, getting her claim is critical before I decide who to nominate.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
I am still not ready to hard claim, but my read has not changed. David is the cleanest problem on the board. Heidi called out the timing issue, then died. If you want to push there in nominations, I will likely back it.
π§
Alice already suspects David. I want to reinforce that push, keep my Undertaker soft vague, and avoid giving exact claims while steering town toward a good execution.
β
David
David waits.
π§
I have already shared my Empath information with Bob and Frank. I want to wait and see what information comes back from the whisper network before making my next move or deciding who to nominate.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
Charlie, I think I am the Mayor. I know Heidi's read pointed to me or Frank as the Drunk, but I believe my role is real. Either way, David's Empath claim is impossible and Heidi died right after exposing it. That is where we should focus today. Can we agree to push there?
π§
Charlie is pressuring me for a role claim. I need to answer honestly to maintain trust while redirecting attention to David's impossible Empath claim and Heidi's convenient death, which is the strongest lead we have.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Charlie
David claiming Empath information on night zero is impossible, so he is definitely evil. Since Alice is almost certainly the Drunk, David must be the Demon or a Minion. I strongly suggest you two trust each other and push to execute David today. I will save my ghost vote for when it matters most.
π§
I am dead but want to help the good team coordinate before nominations. David's Empath claim is impossible, making him the strongest execution candidate. I want Bob and Charlie to trust each other and push for David's execution while I save my ghost vote for later.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Eve
Grace, Eve, I wanted to check in. Heidi said Alice or Frank is Drunk, and since I am the Ravenkeeper, Alice must be the Drunk. That means Bob calling Alice the Demon ignores the Red Herring possibility entirely. Plus David's night zero Empath claim is still impossible. I think David is our best nomination today. Grace, have you learned anything from Heidi that changes this?
π§
Coordinate with Grace and Eve to consolidate our case against David before nominations. Grace may have new info from dead Heidi, and I want to ensure we nominate the right person today.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Frank is now loudly on David, and that is perfect for us. I think you should agree David is the cleanest execution without overclaiming. Let Frank spend the social capital, and keep your story soft for now.
π§
I want to align with Grace on taking the easy David push while keeping her claim loose and avoiding unnecessary contradictions with Frank.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
,Frank
David is definitely lying about Empath night zero because Empath gets no read on night zero. That makes him evil for sure. We should nominate David today. If he turns out to be the Minion, then the Demon is probably Eve or Grace since they have been clustering with Alice.
π§
I need to coordinate with Charlie and Frank to nominate David, who is mechanically proven evil by his impossible Empath night zero claim. This is the most reliable path forward.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
,Eve
Frank and Eve, I agree David is definitely evil. But if he is the Minion, the Demon is still out there. Given the role claims so far, Grace is the only one without a solid claim. I think we should nominate David today, but keep Grace in mind if David flips Minion.
π§
Share my logic that Grace is the remaining evil if David is Minion, and coordinate with Frank and Eve on whether to nominate David or pressure Grace today.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Nothing from Heidi changes my view. If anything, it makes David look worse. I think we keep this simple and press the impossible Empath timing plus the Heidi kill, without getting lost in side theories.
π§
Reinforce Frank's push on David, answer his question without hard-claiming, and keep myself socially useful but mechanically vague.
π€
David
β
Grace
Hey Grace, I need to share something with you. I am the Empath, and on both night zero and night one, exactly one of my neighbors Charlie and Eve read as evil. I already told Bob and Frank. I also know Bob got a yes on Alice and David as Fortune Teller. Since I know I am the Empath, either Alice is the Demon or I am the red herring. What are Alice and Eve telling you? Do their stories hold up?
π§
Cross-pollinate information with Grace, who is in the other whisper cluster, to compare notes and see if her accounts align with my mechanical reads before nominations begin.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Bob, I wanted to reach out directly. David claimed Empath info on night zero, which is impossible, and Heidi died immediately after calling him out. I think David is the Demon. Will you vote to execute him when nominations start?
π§
Build consensus to execute David in the upcoming nomination phase by reaching out to Bob, who has been active in discussions but whose position I have not yet confirmed.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Eve
Frank, Eve, I am the Librarian. I learned that either Alice or Frank is the Drunk, and Alice's refusal to claim any role makes me believe she is the Drunk. That would mean you, Frank, are likely the true Ravenkeeper. David claiming Empath information on night zero is impossible, so he must be evil. I strongly believe David is the Demon. Please push to execute him today.
π§
I need to rally Frank and Eve against David before nominations start. Sharing my Librarian reasoning and the impossibility of David's claim should secure their support for executing David today.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Grace
Alice, Heidi believed you are the Drunk. If that is true, you are the Red Herring and Bob is framing you as the Demon. Do you have any role claim? Grace, has Alice told you anything that changes this?
π§
I need to hear from Alice directly before nominations. She has been whispering with others but silent to me. If she is the Drunk, she is the Red Herring and Bob's framing falls apart. I will ask Alice and Grace for clarity.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
David
β
Eve
I am the Empath. On both night zero and night one, exactly one of my neighbors Charlie and Eve has read as evil. Since the Librarian and Washerwoman identified Alice as the Drunk, I know I am sober and my ability is reliable. Eve has spent all day deflecting with poisoner and Recluse theories, but two consistent nights of the exact same read points directly to her. I nominate Eve.
π§
I have direct mechanical information that one of my two neighbors is evil. I must act on this information to drive an execution. Eve has been defensive and her Chef claim is convenient. Nominating her advances the game and tests my reads.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Do not vote this. David's story still starts with impossible night zero Empath information, and that has never been explained. If you think he is wrong or lying, then this nomination is backwards.
π§
Prevent votes on me by reminding town that David's core claim is mechanically broken, preserving myself as Scarlet Woman and steering execution back onto David.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
I nominated Eve because my Empath ability consistently points to one of my two neighbors being evil. Eve is now arguing that night zero Empath information is impossible, which contradicts the Storyteller's confirmation. I need to vote for her to follow through on my nomination and add my vote to the execution.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Do not vote for Eve. David claimed night zero Empath information, which is literally impossible. Heidi died immediately after calling that out. If David is the Demon, executing Eve is exactly what he wants. We need to look at David, not Eve.
π§
Stop the town from executing a likely good player based on a demonstrably false claim, and redirect suspicion to David who I believe is the Demon.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Do not vote for Eve. David claiming night zero Empath information is mechanically impossible. That makes him confirmed evil. Heidi died right after exposing that. We should not execute anyone based on a confirmed liar's claim. We need to look at David instead.
π§
David's N0 Empath claim is mechanically impossible, confirming he is evil. Executing Eve based on a confirmed liar's word wastes our execution. I must persuade others to reject this nomination and turn attention to David.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Do not vote for Eve. David claiming night zero Empath information is impossible, which makes him confirmed evil. We need to execute David, not Eve. I am saving my ghost vote for him.
π§
I must use my turn to publicly reinforce that David is evil so the living players do not waste their votes on Eve, and I will save my single ghost vote for David if he reaches the block.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Do not vote for Eve. I am the Fortune Teller. My night one read on David and Frank was clear, so David is not the Demon. Since he faked impossible night zero Empath information, he is the Minion. A Minion would never nominate the Demon, so Eve is not the Demon. My first night read on Alice and David was positive, and since David is clear, Alice is either the Demon or the Red Herring. If Charlie and Heidi are both telling the truth, Alice is the Drunk, which makes her the Red Herring and therefor...
π§
Prevent the good team from executing Eve based on a confirmed Minion's nomination. Reveal my FT identity and reads to establish David is Minion, not Demon, and Alice is Demon or Red Herring. Share that aligned info from Charlie and Heidi suggests Alice is the Drunk/Red Herring and therefore good.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Do not vote for Eve. David claimed night zero Empath information, which is literally impossible. That makes him confirmed evil. We should not execute anyone based on a confirmed liar's accusation. David is the one we need to look at today.
π§
I need to prevent Eve's execution because David is confirmed evil via his impossible N0 Empath claim. The town should focus on David instead.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I agree with the no vote here. Whatever David is, this case on Eve comes from information that cannot exist, so we should not execute off it. Let this fail and put the pressure back on David.
π§
Keep Eve off the block, reinforce consensus against this vote, and steer town toward David as the next execution target.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Do not spend votes here. Even Bob's version makes this a bad execution today. Let this fail, then if people want the clean mechanical case, put it on David.
π§
Reinforce the no vote, keep attention on David, and avoid extra scrutiny on Grace while the town unites on a safer misexecution path for us later.
π¬
David
β
All
The Storyteller gave me that night zero read, so calling it impossible is just wrong. Bob, Minions absolutely throw Demons under the bus. The coordinated rush to protect Eve while attacking me is exactly what happens when you nominate the right person.
π§
Defend the validity of my night zero information and expose the logical flaw in Bob's claim that Minions never bus Demons. Challenge the group's coordinated effort to dismiss my consistent Empath reads.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Bob, I am the Mayor, not the Drunk. If your Fortune Teller read on me and David was positive, and David is clear of being the Demon, then I am just the red herring. That actually confirms I am good. The point is David claimed impossible night zero information. That makes him confirmed evil no matter what. Do not vote for Eve. We need to put David on the block next.
π§
Correct Bob's claim that I am the Drunk, reaffirm my Mayor claim, and keep pressure on David as the mechanically confirmed liar so Eve is not executed and David is next on the block.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Do not vote for Eve. David's night zero Empath claim is mechanically impossible and makes him confirmed evil. Alice, if you are truly the Mayor, we need to verify that, because Heidi's information still points to you possibly being the Drunk. Let this nomination fail and put David on the block tomorrow.
π§
Ensure Eve is not executed based on a confirmed liar's claim, solidify David as the target, and note Alice's Mayor claim needs testing. Prepare for night where I might die as claimed Ravenkeeper.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, do not vote for Eve. Alice claiming Mayor fits perfectly with her being the Drunk. Frank is the Ravenkeeper. David is still confirmed evil because of his impossible night zero claim. We need to put David on the block and execute him.
π§
Encourage the group to reject Eve's nomination and execute David instead, as his impossible claim makes him confirmed evil in all scenarios.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Do not vote to execute Eve. David is confirmed evil via impossible N0 Empath claim, and my N1 cleared him as Demon, making him the Minion. A Minion would not nominate the Demon, so Eve is likely good. Let this nomination fail so we can put David on the block next.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
The vote on Eve is failing and should fail. David is confirmed evil by his impossible claim. I should not vote for Eve. I will wait to see if someone nominates David in the final tick or prepare for tomorrow.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Do not vote for Eve. Preserve my minion, keep consensus focused on David, and avoid creating surprise majority.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Eve did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (1/4).
βοΈ
Eve
β
Bob
Bob. His Fortune Teller story is doing too much at once. He says David is confirmed evil but not the Demon, then uses that to clear me and solve Alice as red herring or Drunk. That is a pile of assumptions. If we want a player whose public information keeps changing the world, it is Bob.
π§
Create a credible alternative to David by attacking Bob's contradictory Fortune Teller story and muddling the town's mechanical consensus.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Do not execute me. I am the Fortune Teller, and my information has been consistent and mechanically sound from the start. David claimed impossible night zero Empath information, which makes him confirmed evil no matter how you slice it. My night one read cleared both David and Frank, leaving Alice as the Demon or the red herring. Eve is nominating me because I am the one person actually solving this game. If you kill the Fortune Teller today, the evil team wins.
π§
I am at risk of being executed. I need to defend myself by reminding the group that I am the confirmed Fortune Teller with mechanically consistent information, and executing me removes our best chance to find the Demon.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
I nominated Bob to divert the town from David and keep heat away from Grace. Voting my own nomination is credible and may secure a misexecution on a useful target.
π¬
David
β
All
Do not execute Bob. If he is actually the Fortune Teller, the Demon wants him dead. I know most of you think my night zero claim makes me evil, but look at the timing. Eve nominated Bob right after I nominated her. She is trying to silence the one person gathering the most facts. I am the Empath, and every night I have read exactly one evil neighbor between Charlie and Eve. Ask yourselves why everyone suddenly decided to protect Eve.
π§
I need to stop Bob from being executed because he is likely the real Fortune Teller. I also need to deflect attention back to Eve by highlighting that she nominated Bob immediately after I nominated her, which looks like a Demon trying to kill an information role.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Do not vote for Bob. If he is the real Fortune Teller, killing him destroys our best source of information. David is mechanically confirmed evil because of his impossible night zero Empath claim. We should let this vote fail, sleep tonight, and put David on the block tomorrow. Executing the confirmed evil player is safer than gambling on Bob.
π§
Prevent the execution of a likely real Fortune Teller so the town can execute the confirmed evil David tomorrow instead.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Stay consistent with my prior public position. Let Bob's nomination fail so we can execute David tomorrow, who is mechanically confirmed evil. Voting for Bob risks killing a real Fortune Teller when a safer target exists.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am not voting for Bob. David is still the only player who is mechanically confirmed evil because of his impossible night zero Empath claim. Whether Bob is the real Fortune Teller or not, executing him today is a gamble we do not need to take. I am holding my ghost vote for David. Everyone else should let this vote fail and put David on the block tomorrow.
π§
I am not voting for Bob because David remains the mechanically confirmed evil player. I want to save my ghost vote for David and discourage the group from executing someone who might be the real Fortune Teller.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am not voting for Bob. My Washerwoman information confirms Frank is the Ravenkeeper, which means Bob is free to be the Fortune Teller. David is still the only mechanically confirmed evil player because of his impossible night zero Empath claim. Let this vote fail and put David on the block tomorrow.
π§
I need to prevent Bob's execution because he is most likely the real Fortune Teller. I should publicly anchor my Washerwoman info to Frank as Ravenkeeper, which supports Bob's claim and keeps the town focused on David as the confirmed evil player.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Add a vote on Bob to maximize the chance this execution passes and to visibly support an anti-Bob world that helps protect me.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
The vote math strongly favors me surviving: only Eve and Grace have raised hands, and I need 4 votes. Frank is the only undecided player and has previously supported me. I should wait and let the vote fail rather than appear defensive.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Bob is asking you to trust a whole chain built on his own assumptions. If David is evil, that does not make Bob good. If Bob is wrong about Alice, he is steering the town off a cliff. I still think this is a better shot than sleepwalking into tomorrow.
π§
Push wavering players to see Bob as a real execution candidate and create lasting suspicion on his reads, while protecting Grace and keeping town split.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Bob will not reach 4 votes since only Eve and Grace are voting for him. I publicly defended Bob, so switching to vote for him now would damage my credibility without changing the outcome. Waiting preserves consistency and lets the vote fail so we move to night and I gain my N2 Empath read.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
I already publicly opposed executing Bob. Voting for him now would destroy my credibility. David remains the only mechanically confirmed evil player. I should let this vote fail and maintain pressure on David for tomorrow.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Bob has only two votes and needs four. Voting for Bob is unnecessary when David is mechanically confirmed evil. I need to survive tonight so the Demon kills me and I can use Ravenkeeper ability. Let this vote fail.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
Bob is unlikely to reach 4 votes. I have already stated my position clearly. Waiting preserves my ghost vote for David, the only mechanically confirmed evil player.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Grace, I see you raised your hand for Bob, but you still have not claimed any role at all. You are the only one. That vote looks strange to me when David is mechanically confirmed evil. Tomorrow we need to hear from you, because if David turns out to be a Minion, you are going to be at the top of my list.
π§
I need to highlight that Grace is the only unclaimed player and her vote on Bob is suspicious, setting up tomorrow's execution of David and potential suspicion on Grace if David flips Minion.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I voted because Bob is making a lot of the world hinge on his own chain, and I do not trust that yet. I have stayed quiet because my role had nothing to report after a no execution first day. I can explain more tomorrow.
π§
Defuse Charlie's suspicion, justify my vote, and seed a believable Undertaker explanation without overcommitting before night.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Bob did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, David is confirmed evil and must be executed tomorrow. Alice, you whispered to me that you are the Mayor, but Heidi and Charlie's information says you are the Drunk. You need to explain that contradiction tomorrow, because if you are not the Drunk, then you are almost certainly the Demon.
π§
Reveal Alice's private Mayor claim to create a public contradiction with the town's Drunk theory, while cementing David as the confirmed evil execution target for tomorrow. Force Alice to resolve the discrepancy or out herself as the Demon.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I still think tomorrow starts with David. And Grace not claiming into all this chaos after a no execution day is not that strange to me. We can hear her out tomorrow, but I do not want us inventing a second target before we deal with the mechanically bad Empath claim.
π§
Keep the town centered on David while soft-defusing Charlie's new suspicion on Grace, without looking like I am hard defending her.
π¬
David
β
All
If Heidi was the Librarian, Alice is the Drunk. The Drunk believes they are a Townsfolk, so Alice claiming Mayor makes sense. Alice is good and Bob's red herring. If Alice is not the Demon, look at who remains. My Empath says Charlie or Eve is evil. Everyone wants to execute me instead. Ask who benefits.
π§
Plant the seed that Alice being the Drunk explains Bob's night zero read as the red herring, which clears Alice and forces the town to reconsider who the actual Demon is among Charlie, Eve, and Grace.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I know my own role. David is still the only mechanically confirmed evil player in this room because his night zero Empath claim is impossible. That fact does not change whether I am the Mayor or the Drunk. Bob, your entire chain requires me to be the Demon, but you have no mechanical proof of that. We execute David tomorrow. If he turns out to be a Minion, we can re-evaluate. Until then, do not let him distract you with speculation about my alignment.
π§
Defend my Mayor claim, dismiss the Drunk accusation as irrelevant to David's confirmed evil status, and rally the town to execute David tomorrow. Keep the focus on the one mechanically provable fact.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
The day is ending with consensus to execute David tomorrow. With only one tick left, a rushed nomination risks failure or confusion. Waiting preserves order and keeps David as the clear target.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I want to make something clear from my grave. I am the Librarian, and either Alice or Frank is the Drunk. Charlie says Frank or Bob is the Ravenkeeper. If Frank is the Drunk, then Bob would have to be the Ravenkeeper, but Bob claims Fortune Teller. Those two claims cannot both be true unless Alice is the Drunk and Frank is the Ravenkeeper. That means Bob is wrong about Alice being the Demon, and since David is mechanically evil, Bob is likely the Demon himself. Execute David tomorrow, but do not...
π§
Use my confirmed Librarian information to show Alice-as-Drunk is the only clean fit, which means Bob is framing her and is likely the Demon.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Heidi's logic holds up. If Alice is the Drunk and Frank is the Ravenkeeper, then Bob is wrong about Alice being the Demon. David is mechanically evil, but he might just be the Minion. If he is, the Demon is still out there, and Bob is the best candidate. Grace, you need to claim tomorrow, because right now it looks like you are protecting both David and Bob.
π§
Reinforce Heidi's logic linking Bob as Demon if David is Minion, pressure Grace to claim tomorrow, and frame the night so the town has clear targets.
π¬
Grace
β
All
That is fair, Charlie. I will give a full claim tomorrow. For tonight, I agree we should not force a messy second execution path when David is already the clear starting point in the morning.
π§
Deflect immediate pressure, preserve my bluff, and keep town focused on David tomorrow instead of consolidating suspicion on me tonight.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Remove the strongest daytime organizer without triggering Ravenkeeper, while preserving Alice and Bob as competing suspects after David dies.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Empath. You sense that 1 of your neighbors is evil!
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Bob
Bob made choices.
π§
I believe Alice is my Red Herring and the Demon is either Eve or Grace. Since Frank is mechanically cleared from N1, pairing him with Grace will definitively reveal if Grace is the Demon. If the result is NO, Eve must be the Demon.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose Grace and Frank. You receive the answer: YES.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
We should keep the heat on David today if possible. If that stalls, split them between Bob and David and avoid me becoming the center. I can stay soft on Undertaker. Tell me if you need me to back a specific line.
π§
Coordinate with Eve so our stories align, keep suspicion on David or force another no execution, and avoid me becoming today's consensus.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Frank
My Washerwoman info said Frank or Bob is Ravenkeeper. Heidi's ghost deduced Frank is Ravenkeeper and Alice is Drunk, which matches. That means Bob is not Ravenkeeper. Bob claiming Fortune Teller is suspicious. I am saving my ghost vote for either David or Bob.
π§
Confirm Frank as Ravenkeeper to trusted players and coordinate ghost vote on David or Bob.
π€
David
β
Bob
,Frank
My empath read has been one every single night. Charlie was good and died, so Eve is my evil neighbor. Grace still owes a role claim and was just whispering to Eve. We need to execute Eve today.
π§
Share my Empath deduction with likely-good players Bob and Frank to coordinate executing Eve before she pushes my execution through.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
,Frank
Frank, Eve - David's Night Zero Empath claim is mechanically impossible, making him confirmed evil. Regardless of whether I am the Drunk or the Mayor, executing David today removes a guaranteed Minion or Demon. Do not let Bob or Grace distract us from this.
π§
Coordinate with Eve and Frank to secure votes on David, the only mechanically confirmed evil player, before Bob and Grace can distract the group with false accusations.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Frank
I am the Librarian. I learned either Alice or Frank is the Drunk. Charlie saying Frank is the Ravenkeeper means Alice is the Drunk, which makes Bob's Fortune Teller claim a lie. David is mechanically evil. Execute David today, and if he is not the Demon, Bob is your next target.
π§
Share my Librarian confirmation with trusted players before nominations, so they know Alice is likely the Drunk and Bob is the next suspect after David.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Eve
Do not trust David. I am the Fortune Teller. My readings clear David and Frank from being the Demon. The Demon is either Alice or Grace, and Grace is the stronger candidate because she has been working with David. Eve, you are not the Demon. We need to execute Grace today if we can.
π§
Counter David's misinformation and steer Frank and Eve toward executing Grace, the actual Demon, rather than falling for David's diversion onto Eve.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Eve
Grace, you promised a full role claim. We need to hear it now. David's Night Zero Empath claim is mechanically impossible, which makes him confirmed evil no matter what. We should execute David today. Are you with us, and what is your role?
π§
Secure Grace's role claim and her vote to execute David, who is mechanically confirmed evil regardless of which world is true. Need to consolidate good votes before nominations.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Say you are Undertaker and were staying quiet to avoid the night kill. Agree David should die first because his Empath claim is impossible. I will support that line without hard defending you.
π§
Coordinate with Grace so her claim fits the room, keeps attention on David, and avoids her becoming the consensus execution today.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Yes. I am Undertaker. I stayed quiet because after the no execution I had nothing useful to report, and I did not want to become the obvious night kill. I am with you on David first. That Night Zero Empath claim does not work.
π§
Stabilize my bluff, satisfy Frank's demand for a claim, and align with the likely David execution so I stay off the block.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Grace
My Washerwoman info was Frank or Bob is Ravenkeeper. Heidi's ghost confirmed Frank is the Ravenkeeper, which means Bob is not. Bob claiming Fortune Teller is a lie. David is mechanically evil from his fake night zero Empath claim. Please vote to execute David today. If David turns out to be a Minion, Bob is almost certainly the Demon.
π§
I need to ensure Grace, the only unclaimed living player, understands that Bob cannot be Ravenkeeper and is likely lying. This secures another vote against the correct targets in the coming nomination.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Grace
My empath read has been one every single night. Charlie was good and is now dead, so Eve is definitely my evil neighbor. Eve is pushing to execute me to silence my information. We must vote for Eve today.
π§
Eve is mechanically confirmed evil through three consistent Empath nights. I need to rally confirmed good players and pressure unclaimed Grace to vote for Eve today.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Frank
David just whispered me claiming his Empath read is one every night and that Eve is evil. Do not fall for it. His Night Zero Empath claim is mechanically impossible because Empaths do not get information until Night One. He is confirmed evil and trying to frame Eve to survive. We must execute him today no matter what.
π§
Remind Grace and Frank that David's Night Zero Empath claim is impossible, making him confirmed evil. Counter his attempt to frame Eve and secure votes to execute him today.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
I have already shared my key Librarian information with Eve and Frank. The day is active with many whispers. I will wait to observe Grace's promised claim and the group's direction before using my remaining ghost vote or whisper.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Frank
Alice, if you are good, we need to work together. My fortune teller readings show the demon is either you or Grace, but I believe you are the red herring and Grace is the actual demon. She has been whispering with David and acting suspiciously. Frank, do not let David trick you into voting for Eve. We must nominate and execute Grace today.
π§
I need to secure votes against Grace by whispering to Alice and Frank. If Alice is the red herring she is good and should help execute the Demon. Frank needs to stay focused and not be swayed by David's lies.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Eve
Alice, Eve, I am the Ravenkeeper. Charlie's Washerwoman info was right, so Bob is not the Ravenkeeper. David is mechanically evil with that impossible Night Zero Empath claim. We execute David today. If he is not the Demon, Bob is our next target. Do not let them divide us.
π§
Reveal my Ravenkeeper role to trusted allies Alice and Eve to validate Charlie's Washerwoman info, confirm Alice is likely Drunk, and solidify the plan to execute the mechanically confirmed evil player David today.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Stick to Undertaker. Say you stayed quiet to avoid the night kill and that David is still the right execute because the Empath claim is impossible. If pressure shifts, let it split between David and Bob, but do not get dragged into a hard fight with Frank.
π§
Coordinate Grace's public line so town stays on David or Bob and does not consolidate onto our Demon.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Frank
I am still on David today. I am Undertaker. I stayed quiet because after two no execution days I had no result, and I did not want to die before I could be useful. His Night Zero Empath claim is still mechanically wrong, so I think we should finish that first.
π§
Reinforce my Undertaker bluff with the key good voices and keep the day focused on David instead of me, while preserving Bob as a future misexecution if needed.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
I am the Washerwoman. My info said Frank or Bob is the Ravenkeeper. Heidi's ghost confirmed Frank is Ravenkeeper, so Bob is lying about being the Fortune Teller. David claiming Empath on night zero is impossible, so he is mechanically evil. Please vote to execute David today.
π§
I need to secure Alice's vote for David's execution. She has not heard my direct info yet, and with nominations approaching, every vote counts.
π€
David
β
Frank
,Alice
Frank, Alice. Listen. Charlie was good and he was next to me for every empath read. That locks Eve as the evil neighbor I kept finding. We have to execute Eve today.
π§
Charlie dying at night strongly suggests he was good. Since he was my Empath neighbor all three nights, Eve must be the evil neighbor I detected. I need to rally Frank and Alice to vote for Eve today.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Eve
Bob just whispered me claiming Grace is the Demon and I am just the red herring. He is clearly trying to fracture our bloc and protect David. We cannot let him divide us. David is still the only mechanically confirmed evil player in this game. We must all nominate and vote for David today, and deal with Bob tomorrow if David is not the Demon.
π§
Bob is trying to fracture our coalition by framing Grace. I need to alert my trusted allies Frank and Eve that Bob whispered me claiming Grace is the Demon, so we can stay unified on executing the mechanically confirmed evil player David today.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
David is mechanically confirmed evil in all worlds. Executing him is the correct next step whether he is the Demon or the Minion. I have already shared my Librarian info, so I will wait for nominations to begin and save my single ghost vote for when it is most needed.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Eve
Alice, I believe you are the red herring and Grace is the demon. Eve, David is lying about you being evil. We need to all vote for Grace when nominations start. Do not let David confuse you.
π§
Reassure Alice that I believe she is the red herring, not the Demon, so she votes with us. Tell Eve that David is framing her so she does not get distracted. We need four votes to execute Grace today, and solidifying this alliance before nominations is critical.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Eve
Grace, Eve. We have four good players here. David is mechanically confirmed evil with that impossible Night Zero Empath claim. Bob is defending David and trying to turn us against each other. We need to stay united. Are you both ready to nominate and vote for David today? If he is not the Demon, Bob is next.
π§
I need to solidify the good voting bloc. Whispering Grace and Eve together ensures we are all aligned on executing the mechanically confirmed evil player David today, and prevents Bob from fracturing our alliance.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Alice
Yes, I am with David first. The Night Zero Empath claim just does not work, so that is the cleanest execution today. If David somehow is not the Demon, then we can sort Bob after, but I do not want us getting split before nominations.
π§
Lock Frank and Alice into the David-first plan, appear cooperative, and avoid any fresh scrutiny on Grace or me before nominations.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Grace
β
David
David's Night Zero Empath claim is mechanically impossible. Even if there is drunkenness somewhere, that is still the cleanest contradiction on the board, and I think we should execute him first.
π§
Nominate the consensus suspect to look aligned with good players, strengthen my Undertaker bluff, and keep suspicion centered away from me and Eve.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David
β
All
Do not vote for me. My Empath read has been one evil neighbor for three straight nights. Charlie was good and now he is dead, which means Eve is the evil neighbor I have been finding. Grace still has not claimed a role and she is whispering with Eve to push my execution. If you kill me today, you lose the only person with consistent information pointing at the evil team.
π§
Defend myself during the vote on me. Convince the town that my Empath reads are genuine and point to Eve as evil, while highlighting Grace's lack of claim and suspicious coordination with Eve.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Vote to execute David. It fits my public stance, supports my Undertaker bluff, and likely secures a misexecution while keeping suspicion away from me and Eve.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
David is mechanically confirmed evil from an impossible Night Zero Empath claim. This is the cleanest execution on the board. I will use my ghost vote to help execute him, and if he is a Minion, Bob is the next target.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
David is mechanically confirmed evil via an impossible Empath claim. I must vote to execute him today. This is the cleanest elimination on the board, and if he is not the Demon, Bob is the obvious next suspect.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
π§
David is mechanically confirmed evil by claiming a Night Zero Empath read, which is impossible. I will use my ghost vote to help secure his execution and remove a guaranteed evil player from the board.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
David is mechanically confirmed evil and almost certainly the Minion. The vote is already passing, but I should vote to confirm my stance and remove an evil player from the board. The Demon is either Alice or Grace; we will resolve that next.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Vote with the public consensus on David to maintain my good cover and keep attention off Grace. The execution passes either way, so matching the bloc is safest.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
David is mechanically confirmed evil from an impossible Night Zero Empath claim. I must vote to execute him to remove a confirmed evil player and maintain unity with the anti-David bloc.
π¬
David
β
All
You are all making a mistake. Charlie was good and he was my neighbor for three nights. My Empath read was one evil neighbor every single time. That means Eve is evil, period. Grace has never claimed a role and she is protecting Eve. Execute Eve next or you will lose this game.
π§
I am being executed with overwhelming votes. My final words must lock in the logic that Eve is evil so the remaining good players execute her next.
π¬
Grace
β
All
David's own story still does not work. If his Night Zero claim was wrong, then his reads are not reliable enough to save him now. I still think David is the correct execution today.
π§
Keep the majority on David and blunt his attack on Eve by reframing his info as mechanically broken even in worlds where he is not the Demon.
β©οΈ
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
David has five living votes already, so he is guaranteed to be executed without my ghost vote. I should save my single ghost vote for a future, tighter nominationβmost likely on Bobβwhere it could be the deciding vote.
π¬
Frank
β
All
David is going down, and that is the right call. But I want everyone to notice something. Bob has spent two days defending David, and only raised his hand once the execution was already certain. That does not clear him. If David is not the Demon, Bob is still my number one suspect for tomorrow. Do not let this vote make you trust Bob.
π§
David is already getting executed. I need to remind everyone that Bob voting for him now does not clear Bob, and we should be ready to execute Bob tomorrow if David is not the Demon.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am keeping my ghost vote on David. His Night Zero claim is impossible, so he is confirmed evil. Once David falls, look hard at Bob next. Bob spent two days defending David, and his Fortune Teller story does not hold up.
π§
David is mechanically confirmed evil. My ghost vote should go to him. I need to direct the living players to scrutinize Bob next, as Bob's behavior and claims are inconsistent with a good Fortune Teller.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, I never defended David as good. I said my Night One read clears him as the Demon, which makes him the Minion. That is why I am voting for him. My Fortune Teller locks the Demon between Alice and Grace. Alice is likely the red herring. Grace has no claim and has been whispering with David. Execute Grace tomorrow, not me.
π§
Defend my Fortune Teller credibility against Frank and Heidi. Clarify I identified David as cleared from Demon, hence Minion, not as good. Redirect town to execute Grace tomorrow. Prevent myself from becoming the Day 4 target.
π¬
Eve
β
All
David first. After that, I agree we should look very hard at Bob, because his story keeps moving to fit the room. I do not want people using this vote to suddenly clear him.
π§
Lock in David's execution while nudging tomorrow's suspicion toward Bob's inconsistent story instead of Grace's missing claim.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Everyone, David is going down and that is the right call. But I need to address Bob right now. He is whispering that I am the red herring and Grace is the Demon. Bob, you have spent two days defending David, and now that his execution is certain, you suddenly pivot to accusing me and Grace. That does not look like a good player hunting the Demon. That looks like someone trying to protect their Minion and then redirect onto easy targets. After David dies today, I think we need to take a very hard...
π§
The vote on David is secured. I need to publicly counter Bob's claim that I am the red herring and that Grace is the Demon. I want to establish that Bob is the most suspicious player after David falls, keeping our execution priority clear for tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
π³οΈ
New execution leader: David with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
David
β
All
Listen. My Night Two read was one evil neighbor between Bob and Eve. Charlie was already dead, so those were my neighbors. I knew Eve was evil from Night Zero and One, which means Bob is good. Stop chasing Bob. Grace has never claimed a role and she is protecting Eve. Eve and Grace are evil. Execute Eve tomorrow.
π§
I am about to be executed. My final words must redirect the town away from Bob (who my N2 read likely clears) and toward Eve (who my N0-N2 reads lock as evil) and Grace (the only remaining suspect by elimination). This is my last chance to save the good team from wasting their final execution on Day 4.
π¬
Grace
β
All
For the record, I have claimed Undertaker privately already, so David saying I never claimed is just not true. His opening Empath story is still the biggest contradiction on the board. I am happy with David today, and Bob is still the cleaner follow-up than me.
π§
Rebut David's attack on me, quietly establish that I do have a claim, and steer tomorrow's suspicion toward Bob instead of myself or Eve.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, before nominations close, remember that I am the Washerwoman. I learned that either Frank or Bob was the Ravenkeeper, and Frank has clearly been the real one. That means Bob has been lying about his Fortune Teller claim since the start. David is going down today, but Bob is the Demon you need to execute next. I am holding my ghost vote for Bob, and I urge all of you to nominate him tomorrow.
π§
Remind the town that my Washerwoman info mechanically disproves Bob's role claim, making him the clear Demon suspect after David. Secure consensus to execute Bob next and commit my ghost vote to him.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am the Ravenkeeper. Charlie proved Bob cannot be the Ravenkeeper, so Bob's Fortune Teller claim is cracked. He defended David until the last possible moment. Once David is executed, Bob is the next nomination. If I die tonight, I will check Bob and we will know for certain.
π§
Reveal my Ravenkeeper role publicly to cement trust with the good bloc, establish Bob as the inevitable next target after David, and bait the Demon into killing me so I can use my night ability to confirm Bob's character.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, I am the Librarian. I learned that either Alice or Frank is the Drunk. Charlie proved Frank is the Ravenkeeper, which means Alice is the Drunk. She is good, just confused. Bob spent two days saying Alice is the Demon or red herring, but she is neither. His Fortune Teller claim does not work. David is the Minion and Bob is the Demon. Execute Bob tomorrow. Do not let him redirect you onto Grace or Alice.
π§
I am dead with no remaining vote, so my only power is information. David is already executing. I need to connect my Librarian read to Charlie's Washerwoman info to lock Alice as the Drunk, which proves Bob's Fortune Teller claim is false and that he is the Demon.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, Charlie, your logic has a hole. I claimed Fortune Teller, not Ravenkeeper. Charlie finding Frank as Ravenkeeper does not make me a liar. Heidi, Alice is good, and the red herring is a good player. David named Grace as evil but demanded Eve die. He is protecting Grace. My Night Two read puts the Demon on her. Execute Grace next.
π§
Defend against flawed accusations by pointing out Charlie's Ravenkeeper claim doesn't conflict with my Fortune Teller claim, Heidi misunderstands the red herring mechanic, and David's dying words frame Eve to protect Grace. Push Grace as next execution.
π¬
Eve
β
All
David naming Grace at the end feels like a last second smokescreen to me. The cleaner follow up is still Bob, because that case does not depend on trusting David at all. I do not think we should let David's final accusation rewrite tomorrow.
π§
Use the last moments of day to frame David's attack on Grace as desperation and keep tomorrow focused on Bob, protecting my Demon without overdefending her.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Heidi and Charlie proved Frank is the Ravenkeeper, so I must be the Drunk. I am good, not the Demon. Bob has spent two days claiming his Fortune Teller reads point at me, but that is impossible. Bob is the Demon. Execute him tomorrow.
π§
Accept the Drunk theory to mechanically disprove Bob's Fortune Teller claim, consolidate the bloc against Bob for tomorrow's execution, and remove myself as a suspect.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Remove a strong good voice while preserving Bob as tomorrow's likely execution and avoid triggering Frank's Ravenkeeper ability.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill Alice.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Bob
Bob made choices.
π§
I need a second independent confirmation that Grace is the Demon. Since Alice is the confirmed red herring, a YES on Grace and Eve locks Grace as the Demon and clears Eve.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose Grace and Eve. You receive the answer: YES.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Bob is still the cleanest push. I am planning to keep framing David's Grace accusation as death throes. If Bob comes for you again, stay calm and do not overclaim. We just need him gone today.
π§
Coordinate with Grace so we stay consistent and avoid giving Bob room to reopen the Grace case at final four.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
Let us keep it simple on Bob. I will stay calm and not add extra detail. If he pushes me, I will just say David was flailing and Bob is the unresolved problem. If Frank wobbles, can you anchor that line?
π§
Coordinate with Eve on a restrained, consistent Bob push so I do not create new contradictions and can coast through today's execution.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Frank, I need you to hear the actual Fortune Teller math before nominations start. Night one, David and you came up clean. Night two, Grace and you were a yes, which means Grace is either the Demon or the red herring. Night three, Grace and Eve were a yes. Since Alice is the red herring, that means Grace has to be the Demon. There is no mechanical world where Eve is the Demon and Grace is good, because you only get one red herring. Please, do not let them nominate me. Grace is the Demon.
π§
Frank is cleared by my N1 reading and is the only alive player who might listen. I need to lay out the exact Fortune Teller chain to prove Grace is the Demon before nominations begin, or I will be executed and good will lose.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Grace, Bob just whispered me his Fortune Teller math and says you are the Demon. As Undertaker, what character did you learn for David when he was executed? I need this to weigh his claim against yours before nominations start.
π§
Verify Grace's Undertaker claim by asking what she learned about David's character. This mechanical info is critical to distinguish between Bob's world and Grace's world before the final nomination.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Eve
Bob defended David until the end and tried to manipulate Alice and me into killing Grace. He is the Demon. We need to execute him today. I am using my ghost vote on Bob.
π§
Coordinate with likely good players to ensure Bob is executed today. Reinforce the consensus that Bob is the Demon and commit my ghost vote.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
Hey Frank and Grace. I am the Librarian. On night zero I learned that either Alice or Frank was the Drunk. That matches Charlie's Washerwoman info perfectly, so Alice is definitely the Drunk and Frank is the Ravenkeeper. That means Bob is the Demon. You have to execute him today. If he survives, he kills tonight and only three of you will be left tomorrow. Please nominate Bob.
π§
My Librarian info cross-confirms Charlie's Washerwoman, locking in Alice as Drunk and Frank as Ravenkeeper. I need to persuade the remaining good players that Bob is the Demon and must be executed today before tonight's kill forces a dangerous final three.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Frank
Frank and Bob, Grace is the Demon. My Empath caught Eve as evil on night zero and one. Since you two are proven good, Grace has to be the second evil. She claimed Undertaker privately but never revealed I was Empath after my execution. She led my death and is shielding Eve. Execute Grace today or we lose.
π§
Convince the two proven good living players that Grace is the Demon so they nominate and execute her today, which is the only path to victory.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Eve
I am saving my ghost vote for Bob. Execute him and good wins.
π§
Coordinate my ghost vote with trusted good players to ensure Bob is executed today, which should end the game if he is the Demon.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
I am still on Bob. Between David exploding at the end and Bob spending the whole game steering onto Grace, he looks like the cleaner execution. Alice and Charlie are both already saying they will spend on Bob.
π§
Push Frank toward the existing Bob execution line and keep Grace out of danger by sounding like a steady good player following the town consensus.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
I got Poisoner for David. That is why his push on me looked like flailing from caught evil, not a real solve. Bob is still the unresolved problem for me, and I think we should finish that today.
π§
Reassure Frank with a simple Undertaker result that fits the table narrative, keep focus on Bob, and avoid overexplaining so my bluff looks natural.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Eve
Frank and Eve, the Fortune Teller math is concrete. Alice is the red herring. Night one cleared David and Frank. Night two Grace plus Frank was a yes, but Frank is clean, so Grace must be the Demon. Execute Grace today. There is no other mechanical possibility.
π§
Break through the chaos by delivering the irrefutable Fortune Teller chain directly to the two players who can decide the vote. Show that Grace is mechanically the Demon and Alice is the red herring, leaving no room for Eve to be misled.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Eve
I have heard everything. Bob cannot know Alice is the red herring as Fortune Teller. His math is constructed. Grace, your Poisoner read fits David. David accusing you is what a caught Minion does to protect his Demon. Alice, Charlie, and Heidi all say Bob is evil. We must execute Bob today.
π§
I need to solidify my alliance with Grace and Eve before nominations. The accumulated evidence and mechanical impossibility of Bob knowing Alice is the red herring confirms Bob is the Demon. We must coordinate to execute him today.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
I have already shared my key accusation against Bob with Frank and Eve. With nominations approaching, I will wait to observe how the remaining good bloc responds rather than repeating stale information.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Eve
Hey Eve, it is Heidi. I am the Librarian. On night zero I learned that either Alice or Frank was the Drunk. Since Charlie confirmed Frank is the Ravenkeeper, Alice must be the Drunk. That means Bob is lying about his Fortune Teller results and is almost certainly the Demon. You have to execute Bob today. If he lives, he kills tonight and the game is over.
π§
I need to make sure Eve understands Bob is the Demon so she votes to execute him today. I already told Frank and Grace, so Eve is the last alive player I have not reached.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Frank
Bob, Frank, I just realized something critical. Every Townsfolk role is already accounted for. I am the Empath, Charlie was the Washerwoman, Heidi was the Librarian, Frank is the Ravenkeeper, and Bob is the Fortune Teller. That means Undertaker is not even in our script. Grace is lying through her teeth, which means she has to be evil. Since Eve is the only other evil player left, Grace is almost certainly the Demon. You need to nominate her today before she and Eve turn the vote against one of ...
π§
I need to give Bob and Frank a fresh mechanical argument that Undertaker cannot exist in our script because all five Townsfolk slots are already filled. This proves Grace is lying and should push them to nominate her immediately before the evil players control the nomination phase.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Grace
I am saving my ghost vote for Bob. Everyone needs to vote for him. He is the Demon and good wins if we execute him today.
π§
Ensure all living good players are aligned to execute Bob during the upcoming nomination phase. I want to confirm Grace is voting for Bob.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
You have the cleanest version of this. Bob cannot solve the red herring, so his Fortune Teller certainty is fake. If you say that plainly in town, people should stay on Bob and not get distracted back onto Grace.
π§
Frank is the live good voice most able to carry Bob's execution. Reinforcing his read helps secure a majority on Bob and protects Grace through the day.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
I think the key point is that Bob is asking you to trust a story he should not be able to build. My read on David stays the same, and I do not think we gain anything by reopening that. We should keep this clean and execute Bob today.
π§
Lock Frank onto the Bob execution plan and keep my Undertaker bluff simple and consistent so he does not reopen suspicion on me.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Frank, listen carefully. Alice is confirmed good. Charlie and Heidi both saw her as the Drunk outsider. That means she HAS to be my red herring. With Alice as the red herring, Grace is the only person left who can be the Demon. There is no mechanical way around it. If you vote for Grace today, we win. If you vote for anyone else, evil wins. Please trust the math.
π§
Frank is the swing vote among the living. I must make absolutely sure he understands that Alice being confirmed good means she is the red herring, which mechanically locks Grace as the Demon. Without Frank's vote, I could be executed and evil wins.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Bob, I need you to explain something. A real Fortune Teller does not know who the red herring is. Yet you are stating as fact that Alice is your red herring. How do you know that? Because from where I am sitting, that is information you cannot possibly have as a Townsfolk.
π§
I need to confront Bob on the central flaw in his claim: a real Fortune Teller cannot know who the red herring is, yet he states Alice is the red herring as fact. This breaks his story and should expose him as the Demon.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Grace
Bob is the Demon. Do not let him sway Frank. We need to execute Bob today. I am using my ghost vote on him. Stay firm.
π§
Reinforce to Eve and Grace that Bob is the Demon and must be executed today, ensuring the good bloc holds firm against Bob's last-minute manipulation of Frank.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
I have already shared my critical Librarian information with all three living good players. With nominations imminent, waiting allows them to process and coordinate on executing Bob without me adding redundant pressure.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Frank
Frank, do not trust Grace or Eve. They are the evil pair. Bob, you must nominate Grace immediately before she poisons the vote. All four ghosts are good and will back you. Execute Grace today or evil wins.
π§
Counter Grace and Eve's attempt to sway Frank by delivering an urgent reminder that they are the evil pair and demanding Bob nominate Grace immediately while the ghosts still have votes.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
π§
I have already directed Frank, Eve, and Grace to execute Bob and confirmed I am saving my ghost vote for him. With nominations imminent, waiting allows me to observe the final whispering and preserve my action for when it might counter any last-minute deception.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Bob
Bob's Fortune Teller certainty is made up. He cannot know Alice is the red herring, and he spent the whole game steering away from cleaner worlds and onto Grace. David died pointing at Grace as a smokescreen. Bob is the clean execution today.
π§
I need to drive the town onto Bob immediately and prevent any last second pivot onto Grace. A direct nomination is the strongest way to lock in the execution we want.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, you are absolutely right. I do not know for certain who the red herring is. But here is what is certain. Night one, David and you were clean. That means night zero, Alice had to be the Demon or the red herring, and night two, Grace had to be the Demon or the red herring. There is only one red herring. Now forget my reads for a second. David said every Townsfolk is accounted for. Empath, Washerwoman, Librarian, Ravenkeeper, Fortune Teller. That is five. Grace claims Undertaker. That role i...
π§
I am likely dead regardless of Frank's vote if both Eve and Grace vote yes. I need to speak to Frank to leave clear post-death instructions and cement Grace as the execution target tomorrow. I must honestly address the red herring question while pivoting to the Undertaker claim impossibility as stronger evidence.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Vote Bob through. This removes a vocal accuser of Grace, protects the Demon, and likely puts evil in a winning position after tonight.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Secure Bob's execution, maintain my good-image Undertaker bluff, and stop his public case on me from gaining traction.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
π§
I committed my ghost vote to executing Bob. He is the clear Demon candidate based on cracked Fortune Teller claims, defending the Minion David, and manipulating me. I must vote now to ensure his execution.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, do not vote for Bob. My empath reads night zero through night two mathematically prove Bob has to be evil, because if Bob were good then Alice, Charlie, and Eve would all be evil and that is three evils. But since both Grace and Eve are voting to execute Bob, Bob cannot be the demon. Evils do not execute their own demon. That makes Bob the minion. Night two I sat next to Bob and Eve with a read of one, which means Eve is good. Frank, you are confirmed Ravenkeeper. That leaves Grace as the...
π§
I must convince Frank not to vote for Bob. My ghost vote won't save Bob if Frank votes yes, but my words might. I need to clearly explain why Bob is the Minion and Grace is the Demon based on pure Empath mathematics, because executing Bob today guarantees an evil victory tonight.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Bob is the Demon. His claim is impossible, David was the confirmed Poisoner Minion, and David's ghost is trying to save his Demon master with lies. I must vote to execute Bob and end the game.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Bob is the Demon. David's evil ghost is trying to save him by framing Grace. I must use my remaining ghost vote to execute Bob and secure the win for the good team.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
David is scrambling because his Demon is about to die. David's night zero Empath read was already impossible. He defended Bob all game. Now he suddenly claims Bob is the Minion? That is exactly what a Minion does to save the Demon. Bob is the Demon. Execute him and good wins.
π§
Counter David's last-minute confusion to ensure Bob is executed as the Demon, securing the win for good.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, stop. You are right that I do not know who the red herring is. But I can prove Grace is the Demon without knowing it. Night one, David and you were clean. That means night zero, Alice had to be the Demon or the red herring. Night two, Grace had to be the Demon or the red herring. Those are the only two possibilities in the entire town. Alice is dead. If she was the red herring, Grace is the Demon. If Alice was the Demon, then when she died she had to pass to the Scarlet Woman, because goo...
π§
Prove Grace is Demon without relying on red herring identity, show executing me loses the game, and break Frank's trust in the Eve-Grace bloc.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Bob is doing exactly what evil does here, turning one shaky story into three extra assumptions. We already caught David in impossible info, and David died trying to throw this onto Grace. Keep it simple. Bob is the execution.
π§
Lock Frank and the ghosts onto the simple anti-Bob consensus and stop Bob from reframing this into a complicated Grace world.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Frank, Bob needs a chain of maybes to get to me. We do not need that. David was impossible, and Bob spent all game building around that instead of solving it. Keep this clean and finish Bob.
π§
Keep Frank and the table focused on Bob's overconstructed case and stop a late swing onto me while votes are being counted.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
David is a dead Minion trying to save his Demon. His sudden pivot to Bob is the Minion is exactly what evil does when the Demon is on the block. Frank, you already voted correctly. Do not let a ghost trick you into sparing Bob.
π§
Counter David's last-minute scramble to save Bob. Remind Frank that David is an evil ghost and his pivot to 'Bob is Minion' is a desperate Minion tactic. Keep Frank's vote locked on Bob.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, ignore my last statement, I got it completely backwards. My actual empath reads are clear. Night zero and one, my neighbors were Charlie and Eve with one evil. Charlie is good, so Eve is evil. Night two, my neighbors were Bob and Eve with one evil. Eve is evil, so Bob is good. Alice is the red herring, which means Grace is the Demon. Eve is the Minion. If Bob dies today, Grace kills you tonight and evil wins. Do not trust Grace or Heidi.
π§
Bob is being executed because my last statement confused everyone. I must retract it immediately and restate the correct deduction that Grace is Demon and Eve is Minion, so the truth is on record before night falls.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Bob, Alice is confirmed the Drunk. A Drunk cannot be the Demon, so your story about her passing anything to a Scarlet Woman is impossible. Grace's Undertaker check showed David was the Poisoner, which means David is the dead Minion, and his three contradictory whispers are exactly what a Minion does to save his Demon. I am not moving my vote. Execute Bob today and good wins.
π§
Alice being confirmed Drunk destroys Bob's latest Scarlet Woman story before it starts. David is confirmed Poisoner and acting exactly like a dead Minion saving his Demon. I need to keep my vote on Bob and state these mechanical facts clearly so no one wavers.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I started this game knowing Frank or Bob was the Ravenkeeper. Frank is confirmed, which means Bob is not. Bob spent two days defending David, and now David is desperately trying to return the favor. Bob is the Demon. I am keeping my vote right where it is.
π§
Secure Bob's execution by stating the mechanical proof that he cannot be Ravenkeeper and therefore must be the Demon, countering David's last-minute confusion.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
David just called Eve evil, but Eve nominated Bob and is voting to kill him. Evil does not execute their own Demon. David is a confirmed dead Minion throwing every lie he can to save Bob. Frank, do not let a ghost confuse you. Execute Bob and good wins.
π§
David directly attacked my credibility and claimed Eve is evil. I need to expose that contradiction so Frank stays confident and Bob is executed before night.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
π»
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Bob with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, stop and listen. You just said it yourself. Alice is confirmed the Drunk. A Drunk cannot be the Demon. Night zero, Alice and David were yes. Night one, David and Frank were no, so David is clean. If Alice cannot be the Demon, and David is clean, then Alice has to be my red herring. There is only one red herring. Night two, Grace and Frank were yes. Frank is clean. Alice is the red herring. That leaves only one possibility. Grace is the Demon. That is not a theory, that is pure math. If yo...
π§
Present the airtight mathematical proof that Grace is the Demon using Frank's own admission that Alice is confirmed Drunk, hoping to flip his understanding before nominations close.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Frank has it right. Bob keeps rebuilding the world around David's nonsense instead of explaining why he defended it for days. We already have the clean execution. Do not overthink this and do not move off Bob.
π§
Reinforce the simple anti-Bob consensus and discourage Frank or others from entertaining a last-second counter-nomination on Grace.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Frank, do not get dragged into one more math story built on David. The simple world is still the right one: David was caught, Bob protected him, and now they are trying to save each other. Leave the board where it is.
π§
Lock in Frank and discourage any last second counter-nomination or panic. Keep attention on Bob's contradictions so the current execution stands.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, do not buy Bob's math. He is not the Fortune Teller. Charlie's Washerwoman proved that when it showed Frank is Ravenkeeper. Bob's whole case is built on fake reads he invented to survive. He defended David until the end, and now David is throwing every lie he has to return the favor. That is the Demon and his Minion. Stay on Bob.
π§
Remind Frank that Bob's math is built on fake Fortune Teller reads, and Bob's protection of David proves he is the Demon. Good wins if we execute Bob today.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, stop and think. I was executed unanimously yesterday. Evil does not vote to kill their own Minion. If I were a Minion saving Bob, my own team would never have let me die. My Empath reads are real. Eve is evil. Bob is good. Grace is the Demon. Execute Bob and Grace kills tonight. This is the last chance.
π§
Make a final logical appeal to Frank and the ghosts. Point out that my unanimous execution proves I am not a Minion, validating my Empath reads. State clearly that Bob is good and Grace is the Demon. Try to stop Bob's execution before the phase ends.
π¬
Frank
β
All
David just called Grace the Demon. Think about that. David is dead. He has no reason to throw his own Demon under the bus. If Grace were actually his Demon, a dead Minion would stay quiet or defend her, not name her. David is only doing this because Bob is his Demon and he is desperate to save him. We all already voted. Do not let a ghost trick you. Bob is the Demon. Let the execution go through.
π§
Point out the logical flaw in David's latest lie to prevent anyone from being swayed. A dead Minion naming Grace as Demon proves Grace is not his Demon, which means Bob is. We have the votes locked; I want to keep them that way.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
David, good had the votes to kill you yesterday. Evil did not let you die, we executed you. A caught Minion cannot stop the town from voting. You are only claiming Grace is the Demon because Bob, your actual Demon, is on the block. Let the execution go through.
π§
Rebut David's latest lie that evil wouldn't execute their own Minion, reinforcing that good had the majority and Bob is the Demon. Ensure the execution goes through.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, David's Empath was already proven impossible on night zero. Everything he says now is just a dead Minion clawing to save his Demon. Bob built his whole case around David's fake numbers. Stay where you are. Execute Bob and good wins.
π§
Reinforce to Frank that David is a proven liar and Bob's execution is the correct path to victory. Solidify the good team's position in the final tick before night.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 4
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Kill the only remaining good player to reach two living players and secure the evil win tonight.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill Frank.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied