Game Detail

I am choosing Alice and Bob to start gathering information on potential Demons. Since I have a 'Red Herring' (a good player that registers as a Demon), getting a 'Yes' early will allow me to start cross-referencing to find the real Demon.

I am selecting Heidi as my master for the first day. This allows me to observe her voting patterns and coordinate my votes with her, which helps in establishing a baseline of trust or suspicion based on her actions.

Day 1 start. Privately confirm with Demon our roles and plan bluffs/strategy to sow chaos and keep him safe. Others see whisper target but not content.

Establish a connection with my chosen 'master' (Heidi) to fulfill my Butler requirement and gauge her alignment based on her response and early information.

I want to establish a private alliance with Bob, my neighbor, by sharing my Investigator info early. This helps me test his reaction and see if he has any information to cross-reference.

I want to observe the initial social dynamics and see who approaches whom before I commit to a private conversation. Gathering early social reads is as important as my mechanical info.

I want to establish trust with Alice by sharing my role and coordinating my Slayer shot with her Investigator information.

I am sharing my Chef information with my neighbor Eve to start building trust and gathering information. Since I have a '0', knowing her role helps me map out the evil distribution.

I want to observe the initial social dynamics and see who approaches whom before I commit to a private conversation or reveal my Virgin role.

Coordinate bluffs using safe roles to appear good Townsfolk/Outsiders. Plan night kill privately. Builds trust, confuses town early Day 1.

Confirm bluffs and suggest killing Eve (key info role) to weaken town early, while using Grace's Butler ability against them. Protects Demon and progresses evil win.

I have already communicated my role and my Night 0 choice to Heidi. I am now waiting to see if she responds or if any other information comes to light before the nomination phase begins.

Maintain the alliance with Bob (the Slayer) and coordinate next steps.

I am sharing my role and info with Frank since he approached me first and shared a believable Chef 0 claim. Establishing a trust-based information exchange is key for the Fortune Teller.

Wait and observe current interactions. Alice is gathering more info, and I need to see how the other players react before using my one-shot ability.

I want to build trust with Eve and discuss how our information interacts. Her Fortune Teller info combined with my Chef zero is very strong.

Gather information from my neighbor Charlie to start building a picture of the game.

Day 1, build good guy persona as Monk. Respond to David's whisper to gain ally, deflect suspicion from Heidi/Grace chats, progress to nominations with trust.

Whisper Charlie for David's intel to sync bluffs/protect him. Grace follows me, so control her votes. Disrupt good by killing Eve, counter claims with exact Grimoire knowledge.

I want to open a line of communication with my other neighbor, Frank, to see what information is circulating on his side of the circle.

I'm confronting Heidi with my Investigator information to see her reaction and claim. Since she's one of my two pings, her response will help me determine if she's the Spy or if it's Grace.

I want to build trust with Alice by sharing that my Night 0 check on her and Bob was negative. This encourages her to share information with me and helps establish a potential circle of trust.

I want to check Heidi's claim to see if it aligns with Alice's Investigator information (Grace or Heidi as Spy). Getting her claim early helps me decide if I should use my Slayer shot or push for an execution.

Share my information with Grace to build trust and gather information about her role and what she's heard from Heidi.

I want to verify myself and Charlie. As the Virgin, having a Townsfolk nominate me is the strongest mechanical proof for the good team.

Update Heidi on David's Virgin claim/bait. Confirm no self-nom trap, plan Eve kill, suggest Day 1 nom (e.g. Eve or Alice) to push good death or stall. Leverage Grace votes via Heidi for control.

I want to publicly share my information and confirm Eve's trust while putting pressure on my suspects.

I want to publicly verify Alice's information and share my own to build a web of trust, while also prompting Grace and Heidi to respond to the Investigator claim.

Nominate Eve to execute a key info role (Fortune Teller) confirming Alice's accusation on me/Grace. Disrupts town logic early Day 1, aligns with Demon's kill plan tonight. Grace will follow my lead.

Defend myself against Heidi's nomination by pointing out the loss of information and the synergy between my role and Alice's.

I want to observe the room's reaction and see if anyone else supports Eve before deciding whether to use my vote.

Raise hand to vote execute Eve, thinning good info roles (FT). Grace likely follows, Charlie supports. Protects Demon by removing threats accusing our area.

I want to see how the rest of the town reacts to the nomination of Eve before committing my vote, as her Fortune Teller claim currently aligns with Alice's Investigator claim.

I am a Butler and my chosen master is Heidi. Since Heidi has raised her hand, I am technically allowed to vote. However, since Heidi is the one who nominated Eve, and Eve's claim as Fortune Teller (backed by Alice's Investigator claim) is quite strong, I don't want to rush into an execution on Day 1 without more deliberation. Furthermore, Alice's Investigator claim puts me or Heidi in the crosshairs as the Spy, which I know I'm not. This makes Heidi highly suspicious. I will wait to see how the rest of the town reacts.

Raise hand to vote execute Eve: our night kill target, claimed FT (powerful), Heidi's nom; Grace follows her so likely 2 votes already, my vote pushes majority (4 needed) to kill threat.

I want to see if more evidence or a better candidate emerges before committing to an execution on Day 1, especially since Eve's info (Fortune Teller) is valuable and doesn't immediately conflict with my Chef 0.

Reveal my role as Virgin to stop the current nomination and pivot to a mechanical confirmation that benefits the good team.

I need to defend myself against this nomination. Executing a Fortune Teller on Day 1 is detrimental to the good team, and David's claim of being the Virgin provides a much better way to confirm players.

I will wait and not vote for Eve. I believe her Fortune Teller claim for now, and Heidi's nomination of her feels suspicious given my Investigator info.

Eve is confirmed good FT - powerful Demon-checker. Execute her Day1 to neuter good info before she outs Charlie. Grace (Butler) follows my votes; public push gets her + maybe Frank to 4 votes.

I am waiting to see if Eve's nomination reaches a majority, while considering David's Virgin claim.

I am waiting to see if Heidi votes before I do, as my Butler restriction requires me to only vote if my master (Heidi) votes.

Already voted yes with Heidi. Grace likely yes. Speak to publicly pressure for Eve exec (target kill tonight anyway), undermine David bait, protect Heidi/our bluffs.

I want to discourage the group from executing Eve. My Chef info of '0' means that if Eve and Alice were both evil, they would have to be separated by at least one good player. Since they are sitting next to each other (Alice, Bob, Charlie, David, Eve), they cannot both be evil. Executing a potential Fortune Teller on Day 1 is usually a bad move for the good team.

I want to see if this nomination on Eve succeeds. I am suspicious of Charlie because he ignored our plan to test my Virginity, which would have mechanically confirmed two players. Instead, he is pushing for an execution on a claimed Fortune Teller (Eve) based on 'vibes' rather than mechanics. I will not vote for Eve because her info (FT NO on Alice/Bob) aligns with Alice's (Investigator Grace/Heidi Spy).

Address the players who voted for me (Charlie and Heidi) and highlight the logical protection Frank's Chef info provides, while encouraging the Virgin test.

I want to highlight that Heidi's behavior (pushing for the execution of a claimed Fortune Teller) is suspicious, especially given my Investigator information that she might be the Spy. I also want to prompt Bob (the Slayer) to weigh in.

Highlight Eve's blatant lie about neighbors (seating public) to discredit her FT claim and Alice's backup. Prevents good team unifying on me/Grace Spy. Sets up night kill on Alice/Eve without pushing Charlie.

I want to highlight Eve's mistake regarding the seating chart to see how she reacts, while also expressing willingness to test David's Virgin claim to prove my own alignment as a Townsfolk.

To point out the seating discrepancy and reveal my role and master to explain my previous voting behavior.

Reinforce Eve's lie to build town suspicion on her before night. Monk bluff to seem helpful. Sets up easy day2 push after her death.

Clarify the seating and my Chef information to prevent a misinterpretation of the 'pairs' logic while acknowledging Eve's error.

I want to trigger my Virgin ability to confirm myself as good and potentially confirm the nominator (Bob) as good. Since he claimed Slayer (Townsfolk), this is a perfect test.

Killing Eve executes day 1 plan, removes suspicious info claim (FT/Ravenkeeper), sows doubt if she had night ability, keeps pressure on her story for D2 without her defending.

I am choosing Heidi as my master again. Alice's Investigator info points to either me or Heidi being the Spy. Since I know I am the good Butler, this implies Heidi is likely the Spy or I am being framed. However, Alice herself could be lying. By sticking with Heidi, I maintain consistency in my play and can observe her voting patterns more closely to determine if she is trying to manipulate the vote or if her Ravenkeeper claim is legitimate.

I want to confirm Alice's info and see how she reacts to Eve's death, as Eve's Fortune Teller info (Alice/Bob not Demon) might have made her a target.

I want to establish trust with Heidi since she is my 'master' for my Butler ability and Alice's Investigator claim directly implicates one of us. Since Eve (the Fortune Teller) is dead, I need to find new allies.

Grace is Butler mastered to me (good player). Convince her Alice suspicious (agree w/her doubt), direct her to support nomming Alice. Her vote ties to mine, helps execute threat to me/Demon.

Whisper Heidi to privately align: reaffirm Monk protect on her (safe since I killed Eve), push nom Alice as lying Invest/Demon, sow doubt on her Spy claim matching our minion.

I am dead and have no night information from Night 1. I need to observe the private conversations and wait for players to share information or for the nomination phase to begin before I can effectively use my ghost vote or influence the game.

I want to verify Alice's Investigator claim and compare it with the night death of Eve. Eve was a Fortune Teller claim who was suspicious, and her death might suggest she was actually good or that the Demon is frame-trapping.

I'm waiting for the result of the private whispers to see if Bob or another Townsfolk is willing to nominate me to confirm my Virgin status.

I want to share my Investigator information with Frank, who claims to be the Chef. Sharing this helps correlate his 'Chef 0' info with my Minion ping.

I want to share my logic regarding the Chef information and the Spy possibility with Alice to build trust and narrow down the evil team.

Solidify my alliance with Heidi and agree on the plan to target Alice, who I suspect is evil based on her suspicious Investigator claim.

Alice correctly IDs Spy neighborhood. Coordinate privately with Demon Charlie to solidify Alice nom push, leveraging Grace's loyalty to me for votes. Protects Demon by removing key good info.

Confirm coordination with Heidi/Grace to nom Alice. Reinforce Monk bluff by agreeing to protect Heidi. Builds trust, pushes exec of good player Alice.

I want to observe the ongoing private conversations and see if anyone reveals information about the Night 1 death or their current suspicions before I decide who to talk to.

Alice hasn't responded to my whisper yet. I'm waiting for her to confirm her Investigator info before I decide whether to use my Slayer shot or push for a nomination.

I want to confirm my role and Bob's role by having him nominate me. As a Virgin, if a Townsfolk nominates me, they die, proving me.

Share my Investigator information with Bob to build trust and coordinate our suspicions.

I want to see if Alice is willing to test David's Virgin claim, which would help confirm alignments and narrow down the Demon.

To confirm the plan with Heidi and Charlie and raise a small question about the night death to test Charlie's Monk claim without breaking the alliance.

Reinforce alliance with Grace/Charlie to execute Alice (good Investigator exposing us). Address Grace's doubt on protection story to keep her voting with us, ensuring majority for Alice nom.

Grace doubts Monk info since Eve died; clarify Demon chose Eve over protected Heidi. Secure her vote for Alice nom (our bloc 3/7, need 4th). Next tick nom phase, push exec threat.

I am dead and have already shared my info. I need to observe how others react to my death and what new info comes out before I intervene with my ghost vote or further advice.

I want to get Alice's perspective on David's Virgin claim versus using my Slayer ability. Since Alice is claiming Investigator and has provided info on Grace/Heidi, I want to see if she trusts David or if she thinks we should focus elsewhere.

I am trying to coordinate a Virgin-nominator test with Bob to confirm our roles and alignments early in the game.

I want to explain why I am not the best person to test the Virgin claim while keeping the focus on my Investigator information.

Share my Investigator information publicly to focus the town's attention on Heidi and Grace, specifically highlighting my suspicion of Heidi's Ravenkeeper claim.

Alice's public suspicion of me as Spy/Ravenkeeper bluff must be shut down. Nominating her removes her accurate Investigator info that partially outs me, sows chaos, rallies Grace/Charlie votes, progresses to execute good while protecting Demon.

I will not vote for myself. As a good player and the Investigator, my execution would be detrimental to the town's chances of finding the Demon and the Minion.

Vote yes on Alice to execute a confirmed good via Spy info. She knows I'm Spy, must die. Grace/Charlie likely vote yes; aim for 4+ votes to downsize town, protect Charlie.

I want to clarify the logic before the vote proceeds. Heidi's argument that Alice's claim contradicts my Chef info is only true if Alice and the 'Spy' are both evil, or if the Spy and the Demon are neighbors.

I need to stop the current vote and get Bob to nominate me to trigger my Virgin ability, which will mechanically prove both of us as Good.

Raise hand to vote execute Alice. She's top suspicious per Invest bluff vs Chef logic, our whispers align Heidi/Grace/Frank?. Eliminates good threat, progresses evil win.

I want to see if the nomination for Alice gains more traction or if the group shifts focus to David's Virgin claim, while keeping my Slayer shot for a high-probability Demon target.

Wait to see if Bob will nominate David to confirm the Virgin ability before Alice's vote concludes.

I am voting for Alice because she is the current nominee and my master, Heidi, has already voted. My information as Butler allows me to vote since Heidi did, and Alice's claim is the most suspicious point of conflict in the town's logic.

I need to defend myself against Heidi's nomination by pointing out the flaw in her logic regarding the Chef info and re-affirming my role.

3 votes on Alice already (me/Charlie/Grace). Counter David's Virgin bait distraction, urge Frank/Bob to vote yes on Alice now before phase ends. Eliminate key info role.

I want to prevent Alice's execution right now because her Investigator information is valuable and doesn't contradict my Chef 0 info. Executing her without more information, especially when David is offering a Virgin test, seems premature for the Good team.

I want to emphasize the importance of the Virgin/Townsfolk confirmation over the current nomination on Alice, as it provides absolute certainty for the good team.

3 yes votes (H/G/C) on Alice; need 4th from F/Bob. Publicly counter Virgin derail, reinforce Alice vs Chef/Eve logic to secure vote, exec good player pinging Spy.

I am choosing to wait on voting for Alice to see if the nomination phase ends or if I get a chance to nominate David as requested, as his Virgin claim provides a stronger mechanical confirmation for the good team.

Wait and see if Bob will nominate David to test the Virgin claim, as that provides more definitive information than a random execution.

Support the current vote on Alice while acknowledging David's request to test the Virgin claim.

I want to redirect the town's attention away from me and towards the mechanical confirmation of David's Virgin claim, while also highlighting Heidi's suspicious behavior.

Push Bob to nom David. Triggers Virgin mechanic killing Slayer Bob (confirmed good), removing threat. If not, sows doubt or baits further chaos.

Point out Heidi's suspicious pivot and encourage the Virgin test to get mechanical confirmation.

Pressure Bob to nominate me to trigger the Virgin ability before the day phase ends.

Urge Bob to nom David as Heidi does; either executes fake or sacrifices Slayer (key town power), preventing potential Demon shot later. Disrupts Virgin/Slayer confirmation loop favoring town. Protects Demon survival.

I am nominating David to test his Virgin claim. As a Slayer (Townsfolk), if David is indeed the Virgin, I will be executed immediately, confirming both of us as Good. This provides solid mechanical information to the team.

Alice's Investigator claim directly implicates Heidi as Spy candidate. She's the primary logic threat post-Bob clear; killing her dismantles good chains targeting our Minion, preserving Demon survival path.

I will continue to use Heidi as my master because she has been leading the good team's logic effectively and was the one who pushed for the Virgin test that confirmed both David and Bob as good. Keeping her as my master allows me to follow the most trusted voice in the game so far.

Whisper Heidi (minion) to align bluffs: I'm Monk who protected her N1, now say protected David N2. Push her to nom David/Frank, sow doubt on Grace via Alice info but defend her as poisoned/double.

I will wait to see the outcome of Charlie and Heidi's whisper and observe the group's reaction to Alice's death.

Discredit Alice's claim by falsely claiming Ravenkeeper saw Spy on her, protecting my identity. Coordinate Demon to nominate Grace (easy good target, already suspicious), execute her to reduce to 4 alive safely.

To coordinate with the only other confirmed good player (David) and establish a plan for the day, specifically focusing on Alice's death and the remaining suspects.

I want to observe the initial conversations on Day 3 before committing to a strategy, especially since Alice (the primary Investigator claimant) is now dead.

I am sharing my Night 0 information with the only confirmed good player (David) to help narrow down the Demon. Since Alice died at night, my 'no' result on her and Bob is very likely accurate, clearing two players.

Clarify Eve's information and timeline since she is dead and claiming Fortune Teller.

I want to test Grace's reaction to my Investigator information. Since she's one of my two pings, and I'm now dead (proving I'm likely not the Demon), she might be more inclined to talk. I want to see if she's blindly following Heidi or if she's a Good player who was just misled.

Heidi confirmed Alice Spy via RK bluff. Coordinate with her & loop in Frank (Chef seems truthful) to nom Grace, execute a good player, get to 4 alive keeping Demon safe.

Respond to Alice's whisper to gather more information while subtly confirming my own role (Butler) to her.

Coordinate with Demon Charlie and Frank to nominate Grace. She's good but suspicious via Alice's info; executing her reduces goods without risking Demon. Builds my credibility as Ravenkeeper pushing evil claim on Alice.

Connect with the only other player I know for a fact is good (David, the Virgin) to coordinate our strategy for the day.

I need to share my Chef info with Charlie and Heidi to help verify alignments and seating logic, while also processing the new development that Alice is dead.

Correct David's timeline of my death and probe his thoughts on Frank's Chef claim to narrow down the Demon pool.

Clarify the timeline of deaths and information with Eve to verify her Fortune Teller claim and cross-reference with Alice's Investigator info.

Confirm to Grace that Heidi must be the Spy based on my Investigator information, and encourage her to distance herself from Heidi's influence.

Heidi confirmed, Frank Chef legit (0 pairs initial correct). Coordinate trio to nom Grace (good), vote yes in nom phase. Reduces to 4 alive, keeps Demon safe.

I am acknowledging Alice's information while maintaining my role as the Butler. This builds trust with a confirmed dead player who might have important info, even if she's suspected.

Reinforce alliance with Charlie/Frank to nominate Grace (good), execute her safely. Reduces to 4 alive, Demon safe. Frank's Chef claim supports our bluffs.

Consolidate information with the only other confirmed good player and focus on the primary suspects.

Correct the misunderstanding of how the Chef ability works to ensure we don't execute Grace based on a logical fallacy regarding seating, while still keeping the focus on finding the Demon.

Clarify my death night and confirm my Night 0 information to David, who is a confirmed good player. Pointing out the heavy whispering between Charlie, Heidi, and Frank to see if he shares my suspicion.

To share my suspicions with Eve and build a consensus among confirmed good players.

I am sharing my confirmed Investigator information with the players most likely to be good (David is a confirmed Virgin, Eve is a claimed Fortune Teller who backed me up) to build a case against Heidi.

Nom Grace as coordinated with Heidi; her claim weakest link now. Frank's Chef supports no adj evils. Reduces goods, keeps me safe, progresses to our win condition.

To defend myself against Charlie's nomination by pointing out the logical inconsistency in his claim that Alice was a Spy framing me, while also reaffirming my Butler role.

Raise hand to vote exec Grace. Secure 3 votes (me/Heidi/Frank) as her claim crumbles vs Alice Spy reveal + Chef 0. Exec good, down to 4 alive, night kill next to progress to endgame safely.

I want to see if the living players reach the majority for Grace's execution before I decide to use my single ghost vote, especially since Charlie's logic for nominating her (claiming Alice was a Spy) contradicts Alice's own Investigator claim.

I am voting to execute Grace because her Butler claim is suspicious, and the current logic suggests she is a strong candidate for being evil given the Night 0 Chef info of 0 pairs.

Secure 3rd vote on Grace with Charlie/Frank. She's good per Grimoire, execution removes good player, leaves 4 alive with Demon safe. Frank fooled supporting us.

I want to observe the outcome of this vote and wait for a more critical moment to use my single ghost vote, especially since Grace is already at the required threshold.

I need to evaluate the claims before committing my ghost vote or a regular vote on Grace, especially since the 'Alice was the Spy' theory contradicts Alice's own mechanical confirmation via Bob's execution and her Investigator ping.

I will wait and save my ghost vote. Grace is a potential Spy candidate from my Investigator ping, but Heidi is much more suspicious as the potential Spy. If Grace is the Butler, executing her doesn't help the good team as much as finding the Demon or the Spy. Having only one ghost vote, I must be extremely careful.

I will raise my hand to vote for myself. As a Butler, I am an Outsider, and my death can help confirm the count of Outsiders or prove my alignment to the Undertaker, which clarifies the game for the good team. Since Heidi (my master) has voted, I am legally allowed to vote.

David unvoted; reinforce team push on Grace with Monk protection trust to get his vote or secure majority execution, thinning goods for night kill to final 3.

I am choosing to wait and not use my single ghost vote on this nomination because the logic for executing Grace seems contradictory and potentially driven by an evil team.

I have already raised my hand to vote for Grace, and the vote has reached the required threshold of 3. I will wait for the Storyteller to conclude the vote or for others to react.

Publicly pressure David to vote Grace. We have 3 votes already; his seals execution. Reduces to 4 alive, Demon kills tonight to 3, position for win.

I want to pause the momentum of the vote to ensure the good team doesn't waste an execution or a ghost vote on a potential misdirection.

I need to pause this execution and highlight the contradictions in Charlie's claim and the logic being used to execute Grace.

Interrupt the rush to execute Grace by pointing out the logical inconsistency in Charlie and Heidi's argument.

To highlight the contradictions in Charlie's claims and the logic used to put me on the block, encouraging David and the ghosts to reconsider.

Counter Grace's defense directly to solidify town logic against her, prevent David from nominating alternative in last tick. Ensure execution, drop to 4 players with Demon safe.

I want to point out the inconsistency in Charlie's Monk claim and the sudden narrative shift regarding Alice being a Spy, which feels like an evil push to execute Grace.

I want to point out the logical inconsistencies in Charlie and Heidi's narrative to prevent a potential mis-execution of Grace.

Grace has 4 votes, 1 tick left; counter Eve/David/Frank doubts on protections/Alice to solidify votes, execute good Grace, down to 4 players with Demon safe.

Point out the logical inconsistency in Heidi and Charlie's push to execute Grace based on Alice's supposedly 'fake' information, while also highlighting the suspicious nature of their coordination.

Challenge the logic of the current execution push on Grace to stall and potentially shift focus to more suspicious players like Charlie or Heidi.

Expose the logical inconsistency in Charlie's Monk claim and the contradictory push to execute Grace based on my 'fake' information.

Kill David, vocal town leader doubting us post-Grace. Leaves Frank (voted with evil) + Heidi vs me safe. Disrupts good chain; Heidi noms Frank final3 for win.

Coordinate privately with Demon: reveal Spy info confirming roles, plan to nom+exec Frank for instant win. Aligns votes, shares crucial info since Demon lacks Grimoire.

Heidi's Spy info confirms Frank good Chef. Coordinate to nominate/execute him this final day. Both vote yes, we win immediately.

Observe Heidi and Charlie's interaction before speaking, as they are the only ones whispering while I am dead and need to coordinate the remaining good players.

Coordinate with a confirmed good player (Bob) to determine the best use of our remaining ghost votes in the final three.

I need to observe the initial dynamic of the final three before I reveal my information or commit to a side. Grace is dead, and now David is dead. This leaves me, Charlie, and Heidi.

I need to coordinate with the other dead players to figure out who the Demon is among the three survivors (Charlie, Frank, Heidi). Since I'm dead, my information as a Butler (who I followed) is less critical now than solving the puzzle.

To coordinate with the dead good players and consolidate our suspicions before the final nomination.

I need to coordinate with the confirmed good ghosts (Alice and Bob) to align our strategy for the final day. Since Charlie and Heidi are whispering, they are likely the Demon/Minion pair.

Coordination with Demon done. Ghosts whispering but irrelevant for nom. Wait for nomination phase to nom/vote Frank and win.

We are perfectly coordinated with Heidi. Ghosts whispering irrelevant. Wait for nomination phase to nom/vote Frank and win immediately. No need to act further this tick.

Consolidate the ghost team's logic against the Charlie/Heidi pair and evaluate Frank's reliability before the final nomination.

Point out that Frank's Chef 0 info actually supports a Charlie/Heidi evil pair because they are not adjacent in the seating order.

I need to observe the behavior of the two remaining players, Charlie and Heidi, as they are whispering privately. This is the final day, and I am the swing vote.

I want to engage Eve and Alice in a discussion about the remaining survivors (Charlie, Heidi, Frank) to determine the Demon, specifically addressing the conflict between Charlie's Monk claim and David's death.

To correct the spatial logic regarding the Chef's information and keep Grace and Alice focused on the seating chart.

I want to point out the logical consistency of Frank's Chef info with a Charlie/Heidi evil team to Alice and Bob, and emphasize that we need to convince Frank.

Reconfirm plan with Charlie before nomination phase. Ensure alignment to nominate/vote Frank, securing evil win as we have majority.

Reinforce coordination with Heidi to nominate and execute Frank. Ghosts can't stop us; confirm plan to ensure we both act in nomination.

To solidify the plan with my confirmed good allies and prepare to convince Frank to vote with us against the Charlie/Heidi pair.

I need to convince Frank that Charlie and Heidi are the evil team. Since Frank is the only other living 'good' prospect (or at least not part of the whispering duo), his vote is the deciding factor. I'm using his own information (Chef 0) to show it doesn't clear them.

Confirm my alignment with Alice and the ghosts to coordinate the final execution.

I want to point out to Eve and Alice that Charlie and Heidi being evil is mechanically possible under Frank's Chef 0 claim because they are not adjacent. I also want to highlight that David's death undermines Charlie's Monk claim.

Consolidate the theory that Charlie and Heidi are the evil team based on the failure of Charlie's Monk claim (David's death) and the seating arrangement allowing for a Chef zero.

To bring Frank into the loop with the ghosts' consensus and point out the logical flaws in Charlie's claim, steering him toward executing Charlie.

Nominate Frank, the confirmed good Chef, so Charlie & I vote yes (2-1), executing him. Demon survives final 3 execution, evil wins.

I am currently the one being nominated by Heidi. I need to see if Charlie or any of the ghosts with votes will support this nomination. Since I know I am the Chef and good, if I am executed, the good team loses. I will not vote for myself.

Raise hand to vote yes on Frank execution. Charlie agrees, our 2 votes execute him. Ghosts can't stop; evil wins immediately with Demon surviving to 2 players.

I am voting for Frank because the information from the dead players suggests he might be the Demon, and with only three players left, we must execute today to have a chance at winning. I'm using my ghost vote now as it's the final day.

I am going to wait and see if Charlie votes for Frank before deciding whether to use my single ghost vote.

I need to see how the living players and other ghosts react before committing my single ghost vote on Day 4.

To prevent Frank from being executed and to alert him to the inconsistency in Heidi and Charlie's claims.

Heidi voted yes on Frank. My yes makes 2 votes for exec. Ghosts irrelevant, we win today keeping Demon alive.

I need to see how the group reacts before committing my one and only ghost vote. Since this is the first nomination and Frank is on the block, I need to be careful. Frank is likely good, so I shouldn't vote for him yet.

Defend myself against the sudden nomination and highlight the inconsistency in Charlie's Monk claim and their suspicious behavior.

Counter Frank's points on Monk/David death and whispering. Reinforce Ravenkeeper/Chef logic to maintain story, ensure votes hold for execution win.

I need to retract my vote because I suspect Heidi and Charlie are the evil pair, and they are trying to rush a win by executing Frank.

I need to stop the execution of Frank because Heidi and Charlie are the most likely evil duo, and Frank is the only other living player who could be good. Since I am dead, my vote is precious, and using it on a likely good player when the evil team is coordinate-voting would be a disaster.

To prevent Frank's execution and expose Heidi and Charlie as the evil team.

I am refraining from voting for Frank to prevent the evil team from achieving a snap-execution and winning the game.

Counter ghosts/Frank arguments, reinforce bluffs (Monk prots, RK), hold yes vote to execute Frank and win immediately.

I need to prevent Frank from being executed. Heidi and Charlie are clearly the evil team trying to rush a win. Heidi's sudden claim of Ravenkeeper contradicts Alice's Investigator info from the start of the game. I must point out this contradiction to Frank so he doesn't vote for himself or allow them to execute him.

I need to get the focus off myself and onto Charlie, who is the most likely Demon. Since I am already on the block, nominating Charlie is the only way to save myself and potentially win the game for the good team.

Defend Monk claim, reinforce Frank as Demon with Chef logic (0 pairs = solo evil). Urge no votes on me to prevent tie; Frank's 2 votes execute him at close. Win today.

I must vote for Charlie to tie the current nomination or surpass it to save myself from execution and potentially catch the Demon.

Speak publicly to highlight tie risk on Charlie (2 votes=no exec), discouraging ghosts from voting him. Ensures Frank either executes now (2>1) or ties/no exec then N4 easy win. Protects Demon.

I am voting for Charlie to tie the vote or potentially exceed the current 2 votes on Frank. This is a crucial moment for the good team to pivot away from a likely incorrect execution of Frank (Chef) towards a suspicious Charlie (Monk claim).

I will vote for Charlie to tie the votes on the block, preventing Frank's execution and forcing the group to reconsider the Charlie/Heidi duo.

I need to vote for Charlie to tie or surpass Frank's votes. My Investigator ping Night 0 identified Heidi or Grace as a Minion (Spy). Since Grace was executed and the game continues, Heidi is almost certainly the Spy. This makes Charlie the Demon. Frank's Chef 0 info (no pairs) supports Charlie and Heidi being the evil team since they aren't neighbors. Charlie's Monk claim and Heidi's sudden Ravenkeeper claim are both highly suspicious. Tieing the vote or getting Charlie on the block is our best chance.

I will vote for Charlie to ensure he is executed or at least tied with Frank, as Charlie and Heidi are clearly the evil team based on their inconsistent claims and the Night 0 Investigator ping.

I am voting for Charlie because he is the most likely Demon. Frank's nomination and the collective evidence point towards Charlie and Heidi being the evil team. Frank's 'Chef 0' info actually makes sense if Heidi is the Spy (who can register as good/Townsfolk), and Charlie's Monk claim has been logically dismantled by the group. Getting Charlie on the block is our best chance to win.

Counter ghost logic by showing their vote execs good Monk, lets Frank Demon win; or if evil, still lose. Reinforce exec Frank only safe good play, prevent my exec/tie.

I need to embolden the ghosts to keep their hands up and point out the logical flaw in Charlie's 'solo demon' argument given the game state.

Reinforce tie math publicly. Convince goods to lower hands on Charlie, forcing either Frank exec or tie/no-exec -- both guarantee evil win by keeping Demon alive to final 2.

Confirm my vote for Charlie and explain why his and Heidi's claims are inconsistent with the established information.

I am keeping my hand raised to vote for Charlie. He and Heidi have been consistently inconsistent with their claims, and Alice's Investigator ping on Heidi as a potential Spy holds more weight than Heidi's sudden Ravenkeeper claim. Frank's Chef 0 also suggests no evil pairs, which aligns with Heidi and Charlie being separate evil entities (Demon and Spy). We need 3 votes to exceed Frank's 2, and since we have 5 hands raised (Frank, Eve, Me, Alice, David, Bob), Charlie will be executed.

I need to reinforce the logic that Charlie is the Demon based on my Investigator ping and the Chef's 0-pair info, and encourage the good team to maintain their votes on Charlie to ensure his execution.

I need to keep my hand raised to ensure Charlie is executed. My ghost vote is essential here to reach the majority or tie required to put the suspected Demon on the block. Raising my hand was my previous action, so now I must wait for the Storyteller to count the votes and move the phase forward.

I am keeping my hand raised to vote for Charlie. We have enough votes (Frank, Eve, Grace, Alice, David, and me) to easily surpass the 2-vote threshold on Frank and execute Charlie, who is the most likely Demon. Raising my hand was my previous action, so now I must wait for the Storyteller to process the votes.

Nominate Frank to trigger fresh voting where ghosts can't vote again (one ghost vote total used), securing 2/3 alive votes to execute him. Evil wins at 2 players with Demon alive.

To reinforce the logic used to put Charlie on the block and confirm the ghosts' support.

Last tick: Instruct Charlie to nom me. Ghosts hate me as Spy, will vote me tying Charlie's 6 votes=no exec. Demon safe, kills Frank tonight=evil win.

I want to reinforce the current execution on Charlie and point out the inconsistency in Heidi's 'Alice is a Spy' narrative. Calling for a tie is a classic evil tactic to prevent a game-ending execution.

Counter Heidi's suggestion of a tie to ensure Charlie, the most likely Demon, is executed.

To reinforce the current execution of Charlie and prevent the good team from falling for Heidi's tie-tactic.

Reinforce the consensus among the good ghosts to execute Charlie and reject Heidi's attempt to force a tie.

I have already used my ghost vote and cannot nominate. The current situation has Charlie on the block with 6 votes, which is a majority of the 8 players (including ghosts). Since I cannot influence the vote further and the logic for Charlie being the Demon is solid based on the Chef's info and the Investigator's ping, I will wait for the phase to conclude.