Game Detail
Players
Alice (Ravenkeeper) Bob (Recluse) Charlie (Imp) David (Spy) Eve (Mayor) Frank (Chef) Grace (Investigator) Heidi (Monk)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 609,099 | 50,350 | $0.4379 |
| Evil | 244,220 | 22,597 | $0.1560 |
Event Timeline
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You are the Minion. The Demon is Charlie.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Minions are: David. Your safe bluffs are: Fortune Teller, Butler, Undertaker
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Investigator. Either Heidi or David is the Spy.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 2 pairs of evil players.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Ravenkeeper (good), Alive - Bob: Recluse (good), Alive - Charlie: Imp (evil), Alive - David: Spy (evil), Alive - Eve: Mayor (good), Alive - Frank: Chef (good), Alive - Grace: Investigator (good), Alive - Heidi: Monk (good), Alive
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I need to establish a credible bluff early to avoid suspicion. Since I know Charlie is the Demon, I can use this information to subtly manipulate the town's logic. Waiting to observe others' claims first will help me avoid contradictions and tailor my bluff to fit the narrative.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
Hi Eve. I'm the Chef. I learned there are 2 pairs of evil players. That seems high for our group. What do you think?
🧠
My Chef info suggests 2 pairs of evil players, which contradicts the expected evil count of 2. I should share my info cautiously, maybe in private, to gauge reactions and see if others have info that aligns or contradicts.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hey Grace, just wanted to start a private chat. I’m a Townsfolk with a night ability. I think we should coordinate if possible. What’s your vibe so far?
🧠
Whisper to Grace to build early trust and gauge her reaction, as she is my neighbor. This may set up future protective plays.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Thanks for sharing, Frank. I'm the Mayor. Your Chef info is interesting. Two pairs of evil seems high; that would mean four evil players? That's unusual. Have you talked to others about this? Who do you suspect?
🧠
Frank gave me Chef info. As Mayor, I need to build trust and gather information. I'll respond cautiously, probe his claim, and share my role to start forming alliances.
👤
Charlie
→
David
David, it's Charlie. I'm the Imp, and our safe bluffs are Fortune Teller, Butler, and Undertaker. Let's coordinate our claims to avoid contradictions. What do you think?
🧠
Whispering to David now is critical to establish coordination. As the Imp, I need to ensure our stories align and that we support each other’s claims. This will help us control the narrative, sow chaos, and protect each other from suspicion. Starting early also allows us to build trust with other players while secretly working against them.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Hi Bob, I'm Alice. Let's share thoughts. Any early suspicions or info?
🧠
Initiate private conversation with a neighbor to build trust and start gathering information, as Day 1 is for alliances and preliminary claims.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Day 1 is for info gathering. Wait and listen to initial whispers to understand claims and potential Baron/Spy existence before revealing anything.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
It's early, I need more info. I'll wait to see who talks publicly or whispers to me before revealing.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, let's go with Fortune Teller for me. It’s a flexible role that can explain away inconsistencies if needed. I’ll say I got a false positive on a good player to create confusion. Sound good?
🧠
Charlie has confirmed he is the Imp and shared safe bluffs. I will claim one of these roles (Fortune Teller, Butler, or Undertaker) to avoid contradictions and appear credible. This will help me blend in with the good players and sow chaos by supporting Charlie's narrative.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hi Grace, I'm the Chef. I learned there are 2 pairs of evil players. That seems high; Eve is the Mayor and thinks it's odd. What's your take? Any info to share?
🧠
Eve seems surprised by my info, questioning its validity. I need to gather more info from others to verify my reading and see who might be evil. I'll whisper to Grace to get her perspective.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I'm Heidi, a Monk. I can protect one player each night from the Demon. Can you share anything about your role or any info you have? We might be able to work together.
🧠
To start coordinating with Grace, a neighbor, to gather early info and establish a potential trust link for protection or verification.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Frank, I want to clarify. You said two pairs of evil players. That could mean four evil players, but we only have one Demon and one Minion by default. Do you think there's a Baron adding extra outsiders? Or could you be poisoned? Have you checked with any other info roles?
🧠
Frank's Chef claim of 2 evil pairs is very high; it suggests 4 evil or Baron/Spy. I need to probe his info and see if others have contradictory info, or if he is bluffing as evil.
👤
Charlie
→
David
David, Butler works well for me. It’s a safe bluff, and it won’t interfere with your Fortune Teller claim. I’ll play it passive and let you take the lead on feeding false info. If anyone asks, I’ll say I’ve been choosing a player every night but haven’t seen anything suspicious yet.
🧠
I need to establish a bluff early to avoid suspicion. Claiming Butler is safe and allows me to play a passive role, which might make me seem less threatening. Coordinating with David ensures our stories don’t contradict, and it helps sow confusion among the good players.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Hey Bob, it's Alice. I'm Ravenkeeper. If I die at night, I learn someone's role. Do you have any information or claims yet? Let's work together.
🧠
Establish contact with neighbor Bob to gauge alignment and potentially share info. If he is good, we collaborate; if evil, I might draw night kill.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Alice, I'm the Recluse. So I might show as evil to some abilities. Since you're Ravenkeeper, we can plan for you to target me if you die, to clear up confusion. Any early reads?
🧠
Reveal my role to Alice as a test, gauge her reaction, and coordinate on how to handle my ability.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Assess initial claims. Heidi whispering Monk and Chef Frank's info suggests possible Spy bluff or real Monk. Need more data before revealing my info.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, Fortune Teller is a solid bluff for me. I’ll claim I saw a false positive on Eve last night—she’s the Mayor, so it’ll create doubt without immediately targeting someone critical. If anyone asks, I’ll say I’m still verifying. You stick with Butler and play it vague. We’ll keep them guessing.
🧠
Establish my Fortune Teller bluff early to create credibility. I will claim to have seen a false positive on a good player (e.g., Eve) to sow confusion and misdirect the town. This will help protect Charlie and keep the town from focusing on us.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, I'm the Chef. I got info there are 2 pairs of evil players. That seems off for our group size. Do you have any role info that could explain this, like Baron or Librarian? What's your role?
🧠
I need to share my info with another player to cross-check. I've told Eve and Grace. Eve is Mayor and skeptical. I should ask others about their roles to find inconsistencies.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Frank, I'm Heidi, the Monk. I can protect someone from the Demon each night. If you're really Chef with two pairs of evil, that's very odd. Do you think there's a Baron in play, or could you be poisoned? Who else have you talked to?
🧠
Frank claims Chef with suspicious info. I'll respond cautiously, share my real role (Monk), and probe for alignment. My protection can help test his info.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Frank, let's think this through. Two evil pairs means four evil players. That's only possible with extra Minions like Baron or Spy. Have you spoken to anyone else about outsider count? If there's a Baron, we should have extra outsiders. I'll talk to others to see if that checks out.
🧠
Frank's claim of 2 evil pairs is suspicious. I need to gather more info from others to verify his story and see if outsider count supports Baron possibility.
👤
Charlie
→
David
David, I’ll stick with Butler and keep it vague. If anyone presses me, I’ll say I’ve been choosing a player every night but haven’t seen anything suspicious yet. That way, I don’t step on your Fortune Teller claim or draw unnecessary attention.
🧠
Coordinate with David to solidify our bluffs and ensure consistency. My Butler claim is safe and passive, allowing David to take the lead with Fortune Teller. This minimizes risk while sowing confusion among the good players.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Thanks for sharing. If you're Recluse, that's helpful to know. I'll consider targeting you if I die. Have you heard any other claims? Anyone suspicious? We should also chat with others to see if there are contradictions.
🧠
Bob claims Recluse. As Ravenkeeper, I want to plan for my death to gain info. I'll probe for more info and see if others have contradictory claims to gauge Bob's truthfulness.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Alright, I'll keep my eyes open. Let's see if others claim roles. I'll talk to some neighbors too. Let's check in later.
🧠
Establish trust with Alice, share my Recluse role, and get her promise to target me if she dies to verify me.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, you mentioned Chef info of 2 evil pairs. Heidi just told me she's the Monk. That seems plausible. What do you think of Heidi?
🧠
Probe Heidi indirectly via Frank to gauge reactions and avoid revealing my info to potential Spy.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
David
→
All
Alright, everyone, I’ll start. I’m the Fortune Teller. Last night, I checked Eve and Heidi, and I got a false positive on Eve. I’m not entirely sure what it means yet, but I’ll keep an eye on it. I’ll need to verify more tonight.
🧠
Establish my Fortune Teller bluff early to create confusion and avoid suspicion. Claiming a false positive on Eve (Mayor) is safe because it doesn’t immediately target a critical good player. This also sets up a narrative that I can adjust later if needed.
💬
Grace
→
All
David, as the Fortune Teller, can you explain your false positive? Who did you check and what was the result? Also, does anyone else have information to share?
🧠
Gather reactions and verify claims. Ask David about his Fortune Teller target to see if his story holds up.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I’m the Butler. I’ve been choosing a player every night, but so far, I haven’t seen anything suspicious. David, your false positive on Eve is interesting—I’ll keep an eye on her too. Grace, do you have any information to share?
🧠
I need to reinforce David’s Fortune Teller claim by playing along with my Butler bluff. This will help solidify our story and keep the town focused on Eve or another player, rather than suspecting us. Playing passive and vague will avoid contradictions and buy us time.
💬
Alice
→
All
David, you said you got a false positive on Eve. Could you clarify exactly what you mean? Fortune Teller checks two players and learns if either is the Demon. Did you get a 'yes' indicating a Demon between Eve and Heidi, and you think Eve is the false positive? Also, we have Bob claiming Recluse and Charlie claiming Butler — that's two Outsiders. Our base script has only one Outsider. So at least one of you is lying or there's a Baron in play. Thoughts?
🧠
Get clarity on the two Outsider claims and ask for details on false positive to see if David's story is consistent. Also test Bob's Recluse claim.
💬
Bob
→
All
I'm the Recluse, which means I might register as evil or as a Minion or Demon. David, you got a false positive on Eve — could that false positive be because of me? Also, we have two Outsider claims: me and Charlie. That suggests either a Baron is in play adding extra Outsiders, or one of us is lying. We need to figure out which.
🧠
Clarify the Outsider count contradiction and probe David's Fortune Teller result to see if it ties to my Recluse ability.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Alright, I'm Heidi, and I'm the Monk. I can protect someone from the Demon each night. David, can you clarify your Fortune Teller check? You said false positive on Eve—does that mean you got a 'yes' between Eve and Heidi? Also, we have two Outsider claims: Bob as Recluse and Charlie as Butler. That's one more than base, so likely a Baron is in play.
🧠
Share my Monk claim publicly to establish credibility, ask for clarification on Fortune Teller's false positive, and address the two Outsider claims which suggest Baron.
💬
Eve
→
All
David, you mentioned a false positive on Eve. To be clear, did you check Eve and Heidi last night and get a 'yes' that one is the Demon? If so, your false positive means you believe neither is actually the Demon. Could that false positive be Bob the Recluse registering as Demon? Also, we have two Outsider claims: Bob and Charlie. That suggests either a Baron adding an extra Outsider, or one of them is lying. Frank's Chef info of two evil pairs supports Baron world with four evil players. Thought...
🧠
Clarify David's Fortune Teller result and connect it to Outsider count. Need to determine if Baron exists and who might be lying.
💬
Frank
→
All
I'm Frank, the Chef. I start knowing there are two pairs of evil players, meaning four evil in total. That strongly suggests a Baron is in play, adding extra Outsiders. We have two Outsider claims: Bob as Recluse and Charlie as Butler. That's one extra Outsider, which matches Baron. If there's no Baron, my info is wrong due to poisoning or I'm the Drunk. But the Outsider count supports Baron world.
🧠
Share my Chef info publicly to align everyone on the possibility of Baron. Combine with Outsider claims to verify. This pushes discussion forward and pressures potential liars.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
🧠
Protect David (Fortune Teller) to keep key information alive and verify his false positive. He's likely a good target for Demon kill.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You chose to protect David.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Prioritize killing a player who poses an immediate threat to the evil team’s survival. Heidi’s Monk claim could protect key targets, Eve’s logical deductions could expose us, and Frank’s Chef info could confirm the Baron. Killing any of them disrupts the town’s ability to coordinate and forces them to question their assumptions.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill Heidi.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Ravenkeeper (good), Alive - Bob: Recluse (good), Alive - Charlie: Imp (evil), Alive - David: Spy (evil), Alive (Protected) - Eve: Mayor (good), Alive - Frank: Chef (good), Alive - Grace: Investigator (good), Alive - Heidi: Monk (good), Dead
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Gather initial reactions and info from others before acting. As Mayor, I need to survive to final 3. Let others share first to avoid drawing attention.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Hey Frank, I'm Investigator. My start info was Heidi or David is the Spy. Heidi is dead now. What's your Chef info again? Two evil pairs. If Heidi was Spy, that's one evil; there's still Demon plus another Minion? Could be Baron adding Outsiders. We need to figure out if David is lying.
🧠
Discuss my start info with a trustworthy player to pressure David or clarify Heidi's alignment. Partnering with Frank who has Chef info may help triangulate.
👤
Charlie
→
David
David, the town is still split on your Fortune Teller claim. I think we should lean into the Baron theory to explain the two Outsider claims. If they buy it, we can frame Eve or Bob as the Demon. What do you think?
🧠
Whisper to David to coordinate our next move. Reinforce his Fortune Teller claim if it’s still holding, or adjust our strategy if the town is doubting him. This ensures we stay aligned and avoid contradictions that could expose us.
👤
David
→
Charlie
I agree, the Baron theory makes sense. If we push it, we can frame Eve or Bob as the Demon. The town is already considering it, so we should lean into it. I’ll support your Butler claim and keep the focus on them.
🧠
Reinforce the Baron theory to explain the two Outsider claims and redirect suspicion toward Eve or Bob. This keeps Charlie safe and maintains chaos in the town, making it harder for them to identify the real Demon.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, as your neighbor, I need your perspective. What information do you have? I was the Monk and protected David night one, but still died. Who do you think is evil?
🧠
As dead Monk, I still have ghost vote. Need to gather info from living players to identify Demon. Start by whispering to Alice, my neighbor, to see if she has info and to gauge her alignment.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Pause to process Grace's info and Chef pairs. Need to understand what 2 evil pairs means for distribution and who might be adjacent.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi(Ghost)
I'm Ravenkeeper, so if I die tonight I learn someone's role. You said you protected David N1, but you died. That could mean demon targeted you directly, or David is lying. Did David confirm your protection publicly? I think we need to pressure David's claim.
🧠
Heidi died despite claiming Monk protecting David. This suggests demon targeted Heidi, or David is demon. Need to probe David's story and coordinate with Heidi's info as dead Monk.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
I am the Recluse. That might explain why Fortune Teller got a false positive on Eve, if I registered as evil. I think Frank's Chef info suggests Baron, so we likely have two Outsiders. What's your read?
🧠
Share my role with a trusted-seeming player to coordinate good team logic. Alice claimed Ravenkeeper, which is verifiable if she dies, and might be trustworthy.
👤
Eve
→
David
David, can we talk privately? I'm Eve. You said you got a 'yes' on me and Heidi. Heidi is dead Monk. I'm not the Demon. Could Bob be the Recluse interfering? What do you think?
🧠
Whisper to David to ask for his Fortune Teller details and discuss Recluse interference possibility to test his claim and verify if I'm being registered as a false Demon.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
Alice, I'm Investigator. My start info was Heidi or David is the Spy. Heidi's dead, so I'm leaning David as Spy. But David claims Fortune Teller. What's your read on him?
🧠
Coordinate with Alice to triangulate David's alignment and check consistency with Chef info. Since Heidi is dead, David is now my only Spy suspect. Need to test his claim.
👤
Charlie
→
David
The town is still split, but the Baron theory is our best play. I’ll keep pushing my Butler claim and subtly frame Eve or Bob as the Demon. If anyone questions David’s Fortune Teller check, we can blame the Recluse or Baron for the false positive. Agreed?
🧠
Reinforce the Baron theory to explain the two Outsider claims and shift suspicion toward Eve or Bob. This aligns with David’s Fortune Teller claim and Frank’s Chef info, making our narrative more plausible. If the town buys it, we can control the execution and protect the Demon.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Eve just whispered to me privately. She’s pushing hard for Bob to be the Recluse, saying he might be interfering with my Fortune Teller ability. It feels like she’s trying to redirect attention away from herself. Maybe we should lean into that and frame her instead.
🧠
Eve’s private conversation with me is dangerous. She’s pushing for Bob to be the Recluse, which could unravel our Baron theory. I need to use this to my advantage by subtly framing her as the Demon or Bob as the Recluse interfering with my ability. This keeps the town divided and protects Charlie.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, as my other neighbor, what's your take? I protected David night one, but died anyway. Could mean demon targeted me directly, or David's claim is false. Any info from your side?
🧠
Share my protective info and solicit info from neighbors to deduce demon.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Yes, I'm Chef and I saw two evil pairs. That means four evil players if pairs are separate, so Baron with Spy and Demon? If Heidi was Spy, we have Baron and Demon left. Did your Investigator info change with Heidi dead?
🧠
Grace is Investigator and shared her info. I should reveal my Chef info to her to corroborate evil count and discuss who might be lying.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
I'm Ravenkeeper. Your Investigator info about Heidi or David being Spy is interesting. If Heidi was the Monk, she protected David N1 but still died. That points to David lying, maybe he's Spy or Demon. I think we should push David today.
🧠
Heidi's info about protecting David is crucial. I need to share my Ravenkeeper role and coordinate with Grace's Investigator info to cross-check David.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Charlie, you said you're Butler last day. As Butler, you need to pick a master each night. Can you tell me who you picked last night? This could help verify your claim.
🧠
Test Charlie's Butler claim. If he's Butler, he must name a master each night. Asking him to reveal his master could verify or expose his claim.
👤
Eve
→
David
David, you still there? I'm trying to understand your Fortune Teller result. You got 'yes' on me and Heidi. Heidi was the Monk. I'm not the Demon. Could Bob be the Recluse causing that? Or maybe the Demon is me or Heidi? But Heidi is dead and good. What's your take now?
🧠
Engage David to clarify his Fortune Teller info. Understand if he thinks I'm a false positive or suspects me. Build trust and gather info for final three.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
If Heidi was Monk, she protected David night one and still died. That suggests David is evil, maybe the Spy I saw. Chef says two evil pairs, so likely Baron world with Spy and Demon. I think we should push David for execution today. What's your Ravenkeeper plan?
🧠
Need to coordinate with Alice (Ravenkeeper) and Frank (Chef) to triangulate David's alignment. Confirm my info post-Heidi death and plan day push.
👤
Charlie
→
David
Bob is pressing me about my Butler master choice. I’ll say I chose Frank last night—he’s been quiet and less suspicious. Eve’s push to frame Bob feels like misdirection. Let’s double down on framing her. If she’s the Demon, her urgency makes sense.
🧠
Bob is directly challenging my Butler claim, which could expose my bluff if I don’t respond carefully. Eve is also pushing hard to frame Bob, which feels like misdirection. By agreeing with David to frame Eve, I can redirect suspicion away from myself and David while keeping the town divided. This also reinforces the Baron theory, which explains the two Outsider claims.
👤
David
→
Eve
Eve, I hear what you’re saying about Bob. It’s possible he’s the Recluse causing the false positive. But let’s think this through—if Heidi was the Monk and good, and my Fortune Teller check said one of you was evil, that leaves you. I’m not saying you’re the Demon, but your urgency feels like you’re trying to redirect attention. What do you think?
🧠
Eve is pushing hard to frame Bob as the Recluse, which feels like misdirection. If she’s the Demon, her urgency makes her look guilty. I’ll play along with her theory superficially but use it to reinforce the idea that she’s the Demon. This keeps the town divided and protects Charlie.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Bob
Bob, you're claiming Recluse. David's Fortune Teller got a yes on Heidi and Eve. Since I'm Heidi, dead Monk, that could be due to your Recluse ability affecting his check. Do you think David is telling the truth? And who do you suspect is the Demon?
🧠
Gather info from multiple neighbors to cross-check claims and find contradictions. Need to pressure David's claim and see if anyone saw me visit David.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Grace, you said your Investigator info was Heidi or David is Spy. Heidi is dead now, so if that info is true, she was the Spy. But my Chef info is two evil pairs, so that's four evil players. Could be Baron, Spy, Demon, maybe Scarlet Woman. David's Fortune Teller false positive on Eve could be because Bob is Recluse registering as Demon. What do you think?
🧠
Confirm Grace's Investigator info and discuss Chef info implications. I want to see if her info changed after Heidi's death and to start coordinating on the evil team composition.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
My Ravenkeeper plan is to stay alive if possible to avoid wasting my ability. If I die, I'll target someone suspicious like David. Given the contradictions, I agree we should push David for execution. Let's gather more support in whispers.
🧠
Clarify my plan and align with Grace. Push for David's execution today based on mechanical contradictions.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi(Ghost)
Yes, I think David is likely truthful. My Recluse ability can cause false positives on Fortune Teller checks, so that fits. Heidi died, which might mean the Demon thought you were the Monk and killed you, or you were targeted for another reason. I suspect Grace or Alice could be Demon, but need more info.
🧠
I need to answer Heidi's question about David's truthfulness. My Recluse can explain his false positive, supporting David. Suspect list: need to narrow based on night kill and claims.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
David
→
All
Alright, let’s piece this together. Eve, you’re pushing hard for Bob to be the Recluse, but your urgency feels like you’re trying to redirect attention. If my Fortune Teller check said one of you or Heidi was evil, and Heidi was the Monk, that leaves you as the only other option. But I’m not saying you’re the Demon—just that we need to consider it. Charlie, your Butler claim and the Baron theory still make sense, especially with two Outsider claims. Maybe the false positive was Bob, but Eve’s ...
🧠
I need to sow chaos and redirect attention away from Charlie. Eve’s urgency feels like misdirection, so I’ll lean into framing her as the Demon while keeping the Baron theory alive. This will keep the town divided and prevent them from executing Charlie.
💬
Bob
→
All
David, I am the Recluse. That means I can register as evil or as a Minion or Demon, even dead. So your Fortune Teller check on Eve and Heidi could have shown a yes because of me. Eve might be good, and we shouldn't jump to executing her just because of that signal. We should focus on Frank's Chef info: two evil pairs suggests a Baron, meaning we have extra Outsiders. That matches Charlie's Butler claim and mine. So we likely have a Baron in play. Who could that be?
🧠
Address David's point and clarify my role's impact. I need to steer the town away from executing Eve if she might be good, while also probing who the Demon could be. As Recluse, my ability creates confusion; I should own it and redirect to logical deductions.
💬
Alice
→
All
I'm Alice, the Ravenkeeper. I've been gathering whispers. Grace's Investigator info says Heidi or David is the Spy. Heidi claimed Monk, protected David night one, and died anyway. That suggests David might be lying about being Fortune Teller. Chef's info points to Baron, meaning four evil players. I think we should consider David for execution today.
🧠
Address the group to pressure David and clarify contradictions. Use my Ravenkeeper status to build trust and push for execution based on gathered info.
💬
Frank
→
All
I'm Frank, the Chef. I have two evil pairs, so likely a Baron in play with four evil players. Heidi is dead, leaving three evils alive. Grace's Investigator info says Heidi or David is Spy. Heidi was Monk, so David is suspicious. We should also consider if any of the Outsider claims are false.
🧠
I need to share my Chef info publicly to guide the group. With 2 evil pairs, we likely have a Baron, meaning four evils. Heidi dead, so three evils remain. Alice's Ravenkeeper claim and push on David could be good or could be evil misdirection.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
I think we have a crucial decision today. Alice is Ravenkeeper, Grace has Investigator info, Frank has Chef info. David is Fortune Teller, but his check on me and Eve got a yes. Bob as Recluse could cause that false positive, so Eve might be good. But if David is lying, he could be evil. Grace's Investigator info says Heidi or David is Spy. I was the Monk, so that points at David. I'm leaning toward supporting a David execution.
🧠
Weigh the claims. My ghost vote is critical. Need to assess who is lying and push for a nomination to narrow the evil pool.
💬
Grace
→
All
I'm Grace, the Investigator. My start info was: either Heidi or David is the Spy. Heidi is dead, and she claimed Monk and protected David. If she was truthful, David is the Spy. That matches Frank's Chef info of two evil pairs, which means a Baron world. So we have four evil players. David, your Fortune Teller claim could be a cover. I think we should execute David today.
🧠
We must clarify and push my Investigator info to pressure David and resolve contradictions. This forces alignment claims and may flush out the Demon.
💬
Eve
→
All
I'm Eve, the Mayor. I want to add that David's story has inconsistencies. If his Fortune Teller check was a false positive from Bob the Recluse, why is he now questioning me? His focus shifted to me, which feels like deflection. And if Grace's Investigator info is correct, David is the Spy. With Chef's two evil pairs, we likely have a Baron, so four evils total. Executing David today seems right.
🧠
Add my Mayor perspective: if David is evil, executing him reduces evil count. If I'm wrong, my Mayor ability can still win in final 3. Support the David execution push to pressure him and see who defends.
⚖️
Charlie
→
David
Grace’s Investigator info points to David as the Spy, and Frank’s Chef info supports a Baron world with four evil players. David’s Fortune Teller claim has inconsistencies, and his focus on Eve feels like deflection. Executing him removes a major threat and clarifies the board.
🧠
The town is converging on David as the Spy due to Grace’s Investigator info and Frank’s Chef info. Nominating David aligns with the town’s suspicions and removes a key evil player if he is indeed the Spy. If he is not, it still sows chaos by forcing the town to question their logic. Either way, it protects me and keeps the focus off Eve, who could be the Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
My goal is to protect Charlie (Imp) at all costs. Voting for my own execution risks removing the Spy but leaves the Imp alive, which is acceptable if the town cannot deduce him. However, if I can sow doubt and prevent my execution, I can buy time to frame Eve or Bob as the Demon. This aligns with evil’s goal of keeping the Demon alive until the endgame.
💬
Bob
→
All
I'm the Recluse, and my ability can cause false positives for a Fortune Teller. So David's yes on Eve and Heidi doesn't automatically make Eve evil. But Grace's Investigator info says Heidi or David is Spy. Heidi claimed Monk and protected David; if she was truthful, David is Spy. That lines up with Frank's Chef info of two evil pairs. So the evidence points to David being the Spy. I think we should execute him.
🧠
Share my Recluse perspective to clarify David's Fortune Teller result. If World A is true, David is evil; if World B, we need to examine Grace. But current evidence leans towards David being evil, so I should support his execution.
💬
Alice
→
All
The evidence is converging on David. Grace's Investigator info says Heidi or David is the Spy. Heidi is dead and claimed Monk, protecting David. If Heidi was truthful, David is the Spy. Chef's two evil pairs point to a Baron world, meaning four evils. David's Fortune Teller claim could easily be a Spy bluff. We should execute him now.
🧠
Summarize logic to push vote for David, clarifying why execution is justified and urging players to vote.
💬
Frank
→
All
So we have my Chef info showing two evil pairs — that's four evil players. Grace's Investigator info says Heidi or David is Spy. Heidi claimed Monk and protected David. If Heidi was the Monk, David is the Spy. The math fits a Baron world. I'm voting David.
🧠
Clarify the reasoning for voting David, focusing on mechanical deductions: Chef info + Investigator info. Encourage consensus for execution.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
As the dead Monk, I protected David night one. Grace's Investigator info says Heidi or David is Spy. I was the Monk, so David is the Spy. That fits with Frank's Chef info of two evil pairs. I support executing David today.
🧠
Publicly confirm my alignment and support the evidence pointing to David as the Spy to encourage others to vote him out.
💬
Grace
→
All
I’m voting for David. My Investigator info points to him as the Spy, and Frank’s Chef info supports a Baron world with four evils. Executing David removes a confirmed Minion and clarifies the board.
🧠
Vote David to execute Spy, confirm my info and Frank's Chef, progress game.
💬
Eve
→
All
I'm voting for David. The Investigator info from Grace, Chef info from Frank, and Heidi's protection all point to David being the Spy. Executing him today gives us clarity.
🧠
Confirm my vote for David. His execution will clarify board: if Spy dies, good gains info; if not, we re-evaluate. As Mayor, I want to remove a likely Minion to progress.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Vote for David’s execution to eliminate a Minion, protect my Imp identity, and maintain my Butler bluff. This aligns with the town’s logic and ensures I remain trusted while reducing the evil team’s numbers.
💬
David
→
All
Wait a minute—everyone’s pointing at me, but let’s think this through. If I’m the Spy, why would I claim Fortune Teller and give a false positive on Eve and Heidi? That would be a terrible bluff because it immediately makes me suspicious. If I were evil, I’d pick a safer role to claim, like the Monk or even the Recluse. Eve, you’re pushing hard against Bob, but what if you’re the one trying to redirect attention? If Bob is the Recluse, his ability explains the false positive, and Grace’s Inves...
🧠
The town is converging on executing me, but this is not ideal for evil unless it ensures Charlie (the Demon) remains safe. I need to create doubt or redirect suspicion toward Eve or Bob to avoid execution. If I can make the town question their logic, I might survive and continue to manipulate the game.
💬
Bob
→
All
The evidence strongly points to David as the Spy. Grace's Investigator info, supported by Frank's Chef info and Heidi's protection claim, all align. I'm voting for David.
🧠
Weigh evidence: Investigator info and Chef info strongly point to David as Spy. Voting for him is logical step to remove Minion and test info.
💬
Alice
→
All
I’m voting David. The evidence from Grace’s Investigator, Frank’s Chef info, and Heidi’s protection claim all line up. If we execute David and he’s the Spy, we confirm a Baron world and narrow the Demon hunt. It’s the logical move.
🧠
Consolidate votes on David. Evidence strongly points to David as Spy. Executing him removes a Minion, confirms Chef's info, and narrows evil pool.
💬
Frank
→
All
Let's break this down clearly. My Chef info says two evil pairs — that's four evil players total. Grace's Investigator info says Heidi or David is the Spy. Heidi claimed Monk, protected David, and died. If Heidi was truthful, David is the Spy. That fits a Baron world perfectly. We execute David, confirm the Spy, and narrow the hunt for the Demon and Baron.
🧠
Summarize the logical case against David, aligning with Chef and Investigator info, to solidify votes and push through execution to remove a Minion.
⌛
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
🧠
Observe final vote and see if execution goes through, confirming alignment. Save my ghost vote for later crucial moment.
💬
Grace
→
All
David, claiming Fortune Teller is exactly what a Spy might do to create confusion. A false positive is the perfect cover, especially if you know about a Recluse. The evidence stacks against you. I'm voting.
🧠
Consolidate my vote reasoning and address David's counterargument.
💬
Eve
→
All
All the evidence points to David. The Investigator info, Chef info, and Heidi's protection claim line up. Executing him gives us clarity and confirms if we're in a Baron world. I'm voting.
🧠
To reinforce the case against David and secure his execution, which clarifies the board and confirms if we are in a Baron world.
💬
Charlie
→
All
David makes a fair point about the Fortune Teller claim being risky, but let’s not forget that the Spy’s ability is to see the Grimoire. If he’s the Spy, he’d know exactly how to manipulate the narrative, including using a false positive to sow chaos. That said, the Investigator info from Grace and the Chef info from Frank still point to a Baron world with four evil players. If David is the Spy, executing him confirms that and narrows our search. If he’s not, we’re back to square one—but the r...
🧠
David’s defense is weak, but if the town hesitates, I can reinforce the Baron narrative and redirect suspicion toward Eve or Bob. My goal is to ensure David’s execution fails or, if it succeeds, to shift focus away from me. I’ll subtly support David while keeping my Butler bluff intact.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee David did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (2/4).
💬
David
→
All
Let’s consider this—what if the Baron isn’t in play? Frank, your Chef info says two evil pairs, but that could mean three evil players total, not four. If there’s no Baron, then Grace’s Investigator info might not be pointing at me at all. Maybe the Spy is someone else, or maybe the info is being misinterpreted because of poisoning or another role’s interference. Eve, you’ve been pushing hard against me, but what if you’re the one trying to redirect attention? If Bob is the Recluse, his ability...
🧠
The town is closing in on me as the Spy due to Grace’s Investigator info and Frank’s Chef info. I need to disrupt their logic by questioning the Baron theory and redirecting suspicion toward Eve or Bob. This will create confusion, buy time, and protect the Demon.
💬
Bob
→
All
The logic is clear: Grace's Investigator says Heidi or David is Spy. Heidi was Monk and protected David. If Heidi was good, David must be the Spy. Frank's Chef info says two evil pairs, meaning four evils—Baron is in play. Executing David confirms Baron world and removes a minion. We need to vote him now.
🧠
Reinforce the case against David by summarizing the mechanical evidence: Investigator, Chef, and dead Monk protection all point to him as Spy in a Baron world. Encourage final votes before tick ends.
💬
Frank
→
All
David, the risk of your Fortune Teller claim doesn't exonerate you. As Spy, you'd know the Grimoire and could create that false positive. Grace's Investigator info, my Chef info, and Heidi's protection all line up. The logical move is to execute you to confirm Baron world and remove a Minion. Who is voting for David?
🧠
Address David's counterargument, reaffirm the logical chain, and push for consensus before voting closes again.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, I am the dead Monk. I protected David night one. Grace's Investigator info says Heidi or David is Spy. Since I was the good Monk, that means David is the Spy. That fits Frank's Chef info of two evil pairs — Baron is in play. We have only one tick left before night; we need to execute David today or we lose a chance to remove a confirmed Minion. Alive players, please vote for David.
🧠
Clarify the importance of my protection confirming David as Spy if Grace is truthful, urging remaining alive players to use their votes to execute him while we still have majority.
💬
Grace
→
All
We're running out of time. The evidence is overwhelming - my Investigator info, Frank's Chef info, and Heidi's protection all point to David as the Spy. If we don't execute him now, the Demon gets another night kill and we lose momentum. Everyone who hasn't voted, please vote David.
🧠
Consolidate votes for David execution to remove confirmed Spy and confirm Baron world before night.
💬
Eve
→
All
We're out of time. The evidence is clear: Chef says four evils, Investigator says David or Heidi Spy, Heidi died as Monk protecting David. David is the Spy. If we don't execute him now, the Demon gets another night kill and we lose a confirmed Minion. Everyone who hasn't voted, please vote for David.
🧠
Urge remaining voters to execute David to confirm Baron world and remove a Minion before night.
💬
Charlie
→
All
We’re running out of time, and the evidence is clear. Grace’s Investigator info, Frank’s Chef info, and Heidi’s protection all point to David as the Spy. If we don’t execute him now, we’re giving the Demon another night to kill. That said, if David isn’t the Spy, we need to be ready for the possibility that Eve or Bob is manipulating the narrative. But right now, the priority is removing a confirmed Minion. Let’s vote David and move forward.
🧠
The town is moments away from night, and the execution vote failed. I need to create urgency and reinforce the narrative that David is the Spy to ensure the town doesn’t lose momentum. If they hesitate, the Demon (me) gets another night kill. I’ll also subtly plant doubt about Eve to redirect suspicion if David is executed.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
The town nearly executed David, so I need to remove a key good player to protect him and sow chaos. Killing Grace (Investigator) or Frank (Chef) cripples their ability to gather or share info, making it harder for them to confirm roles or evil pairs. This shifts suspicion away from David and buys time for the evil team.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Ravenkeeper (good), Alive - Bob: Recluse (good), Alive - Charlie: Imp (evil), Alive - David: Spy (evil), Alive - Eve: Mayor (good), Alive - Frank: Chef (good), Alive - Grace: Investigator (good), Dead - Heidi: Monk (good), Dead
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Grace has been found dead in the night.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, as Ravenkeeper, you're key. If you die tonight, you learn a character. But we need to execute David today. My info says Heidi or David is Spy. Heidi is dead claiming Monk. David's story is shaky. We have majority to execute him if we all vote. Use your ghost vote too.
🧠
Coordinate with alive players to push David execution. Use my ghost vote and information to solidify the case.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Wait to observe the town’s reactions to Grace’s death and any new claims. Since Grace’s Investigator info pointed to me as the Spy, the town may push harder for my execution. I need to gauge whether they are leaning toward Baron theory or focusing on me. If they target me, I’ll argue that executing me leaves Charlie (Imp) alive and unchecked. If they target Charlie, I’ll support the execution to avoid suspicion.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Observe initial conversations to see who else claims or shares info. Let others speak first to gather more intel, especially from dead Grace and Heidi.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, you died? Who killed you? Did you get any Ravenkeeper info? Since you're dead and likely good, we need to pool info. I'm the dead Monk. My N1 protection was David, but I died. We need to find the Demon before they outvote us.
🧠
Establish final day strategy with trusted living players to coordinate ghost votes and find the Demon. Since David survived two votes, evil may outvote good soon.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I need to wait and observe how the town’s suspicion evolves today. If they remain divided, I can continue to manipulate the narrative to keep David alive. If they unite against him, I must ensure I am not the next target. My goal is to avoid drawing attention to myself while subtly guiding the town toward mis-executions or inaction.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Observe and listen first, as it's early day 3. Get more info from ghost Grace (Investigator) and others before acting. Understand why Grace died, likely because she was Investigator pushing David. David might be Demon targeting her.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Observe initial whispers and claims. As Recluse, I must see how I've been read by others (Investigator, Librarian, Fortune Teller) to gauge who is evil. Need to determine Outsider count.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi, I'm dead. No Ravenkeeper info. You claim Monk, protected David N1. But my Investigator info says you or David is Spy. You're dead, so if you're really Monk, David is the Spy. I trust you're good, so David must be the Minion. We need to execute him today.
🧠
I am dead, but my ghost vote is crucial. I need to coordinate the living to execute David today, leveraging my Investigator info and group consensus. Also, confirm with Heidi the Monk claim details to reinforce the case against David.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, we need to stick together. Grace’s death means the town is panicked. Let’s push for Alice or Frank to be executed today. I’ll back your Butler claim and say my FT info points to them. You good with that?
🧠
I need to coordinate with Charlie (Imp) to ensure we’re on the same page. The town is likely to panic after Grace’s death, and we need to redirect suspicion away from Charlie. Whispering to Charlie will help us align our stories and protect the Demon.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
I'm the Chef. I learned there are 2 pairs of evil, so we have 4 evil players and Baron is in play. That matches Grace's Spy info. Heidi claimed Monk, protected David N1, then died. If Heidi is good, David is Spy. David is claiming Fortune Teller, but he could be Spy lying. We need to execute him today.
🧠
My Chef info shows 2 evil pairs, meaning 4 evil — Baron in play. Need to confirm Spy. Grace's death N2 suggests evil killed a powerful info role. Spy likely killed Heidi or Grace. Must coordinate with trusted players to execute David.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, I agree David is likely the Spy. But we need to find the Demon. With Frank's Chef info of two evil pairs, that means four evil total – likely Spy plus Baron plus Demon? Or maybe Spy plus Scarlet Woman plus Demon? Who do you think is the Demon? We need to convince the living to execute David today.
🧠
Coordinate with Grace to confirm info and plan final day execution. Need to decide if we push David or consider other Demon candidates.
👤
Charlie
→
David
Yeah, I’m good with that. Alice is a strong target—she’s been too quiet, and if she’s a key role like Empath or Investigator, removing her hurts the town. Frank’s also a solid pick if the town seems more suspicious of him. Let’s see how the whispers play out and adjust. I’ll back your FT info if you push Alice.
🧠
David and I need to align our narratives to push the town toward executing either Alice or Frank. Both are high-value targets for the good team, and removing either weakens their ability to gather information. By coordinating our bluffs, we can make one of them appear evil and ensure the town acts decisively today.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi, you claimed Monk and protected David night one. Can you confirm that and also tell me if you think David is telling the truth?
🧠
Get information from David's whisper to Charlie and Frank's whisper to Alice. Need to see who is aligning privately. Also talk to dead Heidi (Ghost) who was Monk, she can confirm if she protected David N1.
👤
Alice
→
Frank
I agree David is likely the Spy. Grace's info is strong. Your Chef info matches Baron. We need to execute David today. Let's rally votes: you, me, Grace ghost vote, Charlie? Eve? Bob is Recluse and may be good. We need majority among alive players. I'll whisper others.
🧠
Frank's Chef info suggests 4 evils and Baron. David is primary suspect from Grace's info. Need to coordinate with Frank to ensure execution today.
👤
Bob
→
Eve
Eve, you're the Mayor. I'm the Recluse. I'm worried David is the Spy, but we need to be sure. Heidi protected David N1, which could be genuine or a cover. What's your read on the whispers so far?
🧠
Assess David's alignment by cross-referencing all claims. Heidi's death (Monk) and Grace's death (Investigator) suggest Demon killing info roles. David remains alive, which is suspicious if he's the Spy. Need to gather more intel from alive players.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Heidi(Ghost)
If David is the Spy, we have four evils total. The Demon could be Charlie or Eve, maybe Bob. Alice seems trustworthy as Ravenkeeper. We need to execute David today, then pressure the remaining living players. Who do you suspect as Demon?
🧠
Heidi's question about Demon identity is crucial. We need to align on the most likely Demon candidate after David execution. My money is on Charlie or Eve as Demon if David is Spy.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Alice is our best target. She’s been quiet, and if she’s Empath or Ravenkeeper, the town can’t afford to keep her. I’ll push my FT info on her and say she’s the last threat. You back me up with your Butler act—say she’s been avoiding questions.
🧠
Push for Alice’s execution today. She’s a high-value target (likely Empath or Ravenkeeper), and removing her weakens the town’s ability to gather info. Coordinating with Charlie to back my FT bluff ensures consistency and increases the chance of execution.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
My Chef info and Grace's info align: David is Spy. I need to ensure execution today. Alice is coordinating. I'll wait a tick to see if she rallies votes.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Eve
Yes, I'm the Monk. I protected David night one, then died. That means I'm good and David is likely the Spy. Who do you think is the Demon? We need to execute David today, then find the Demon.
🧠
Grace and I agree David is Spy, but the Demon remains unknown. I need to coordinate with Eve to get her perspective and share my protection info, aligning our reads for the upcoming nomination.
👤
Charlie
→
David
Alice is the priority. She’s been too quiet, and if she’s Empath or Ravenkeeper, the town can’t afford to keep her. I’ll back your FT info on her and play the Butler card—say she’s avoiding questions to seem suspicious. Let’s push hard for her execution today.
🧠
David and I agree that Alice is the best target. She’s been too quiet, and if she’s a critical good role, removing her weakens the town. Coordinating with David to push his Fortune Teller info on her will make her seem evil. My Butler bluff can support this by questioning her silence.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi, thanks. If you protected David N1 and you're good, that means the Demon didn't kill him that night. That could mean David is Spy, but also maybe he's just a Townsfolk. Do you think the Demon would avoid killing a protected David if he were Spy? I'm trying to decide if we execute David today or go for the Demon first.
🧠
Clarify Heidi's protection and her confidence about David to solidify David's alignment. As Mayor, I need to push execution of Spy to narrow evil count.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
Charlie, we need to execute David today. Grace's Investigator info says Heidi or David is Spy. Heidi is dead Monk, likely good. Frank’s Chef info confirms Baron means four evils. David’s story is inconsistent. Can we count on your vote?
🧠
I need to secure votes to execute David today. Grace's info, Chef info, and David's shaky defense make him the prime suspect. Rallying Charlie and Eve.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Alice, I'm the Recluse. I've been lying low. I think we need to talk about David and Heidi. Heidi said she protected David N1. That could be true or a setup. What did you learn as Ravenkeeper when you died?
🧠
Share my role with Alice to gain trust and discuss the David vs Heidi dilemma. I want to hear her Ravenkeeper info to see if it confirms anything.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Frank
→
All
I've been quiet but I have important information. As the Chef, I learned there are two pairs of evil players at the start. That means four evil, which strongly suggests we have a Baron in play. Grace, the Investigator, said Heidi or David is the Spy. Heidi claimed Monk, protected David night one, and then died. I believe Heidi was good, which means David is the Spy. David's been claiming Fortune Teller, but he could be lying to survive. We need to execute him today.
🧠
Consolidate votes to execute David. My Chef info and Grace's Investigator info point strongly to David being the Spy. Executing him will confirm and reduce evil count.
💬
Eve
→
All
Frank, thank you for sharing that. Two evil pairs means Baron is definitely in play. That matches Bob's Recluse claim and Charlie's Butler claim – we have two Outsiders. So we have a Spy and a Baron as Minions. David, your Fortune Teller claim got a yes on me and Heidi, which Bob as Recluse explains. But if you're the Spy, you could be lying about your role to survive. We need to hear from you directly – why shouldn't we execute you today?
🧠
Frank just publicly stated Chef info confirming Baron. Need to add pressure on David, get him to respond, and see if any contradictions emerge before nomination.
💬
Alice
→
All
I'm Alice, Ravenkeeper. Frank's Chef info of two evil pairs confirms Baron. That means we have four evils: Demon, Baron, Spy, plus maybe something else. Grace's Investigator info is reliable. Heidi claimed Monk, protected David night one. If Heidi was good, David is Spy. David's Fortune Teller claim is convenient, but if he's Spy he could fake it. We have Grace's ghost vote, my vote, Frank's vote. We need majority. Bob, Charlie, Eve, please support executing David today.
🧠
To build consensus for David execution. Confirm Chef info, leverage Grace's ghost vote, and get public commitment from Bob, Charlie, Eve.
⚖️
David
→
Alice
Alice has been too quiet and avoiding direct answers. If she’s a key role like Empath or Ravenkeeper, the town can’t afford to keep her alive. My Fortune Teller info points to her as a threat, and Charlie’s Butler claim backs this up. We need to remove her before she uses her ability against us.
🧠
Alice is the best target for execution today. She’s been quiet, which makes her suspicious to the town. If she’s a key role like Empath or Ravenkeeper, removing her weakens the town’s ability to gather info. Charlie and I can coordinate our claims to frame her as evasive and suspicious, ensuring the town focuses on her instead of me or Charlie.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Frank
→
All
Everyone, do not vote for Alice. David is trying to divide us. As Chef, I know there are four evil players; Grace said Heidi or David is Spy, Heidi was Monk. David is the Spy and now he's trying to execute our Ravenkeeper. We need to vote David today. Alice is key.
🧠
Counter David's nomination. If we execute Alice, we lose Ravenkeeper, waste day, and David lives. Must rally votes to execute David instead, using Chef info and Grace's ghost confirmation.
💬
Eve
→
All
David, this is clearly a diversion. If you were a real Fortune Teller, you wouldn't nominate Alice based on a 'yes' that Bob's Recluse explains. Frank's Chef info and Grace's Investigator info point to you as Spy. We must not execute Alice—she's a vital good role. Let's vote for David today.
🧠
To persuade town to vote David instead of Alice. My Mayor ability means I want to survive to final 3, but preventing execution of a likely good Ravenkeeper is critical now.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, David just nominated me because he knows I'm Ravenkeeper and can prove him evil if I die. He's trying to silence me. My role is real—I'm Ravenkeeper. Don't fall for it. We have Frank's Chef info, Grace's ghost vote. We must vote David today, not me.
🧠
David's nomination of me is a desperate deflection. I need to rally votes against him, confirm my Ravenkeeper role, and get him executed.
💬
David
→
All
Frank, Eve, you’re both making strong points, but let’s think about this. If Alice is the Ravenkeeper, she’s a huge threat to us. She just said if she dies, she can prove I’m evil. That’s exactly what a Ravenkeeper would say if she’s about to be executed. My Fortune Teller info on her isn’t just random—it’s because she’s dangerous. Charlie, as the Butler, has been watching her too, and he’s backing this nomination. We can’t ignore that.
🧠
Nominating Alice splits the town’s focus and redirects suspicion away from me. If the town executes her, we remove a potential threat to evil. If they don’t, the chaos buys time for the Demon to act. Either way, it weakens the good team’s coordination.
⌛
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
🧠
I need to observe the vote on Alice; if too many vote for her, we lose a key good player. I'll use my ghost vote to oppose David later.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone, David is clearly the Spy trying to eliminate our Ravenkeeper. Alice is claiming Ravenkeeper and can prove her role if she dies. Frank's Chef info says two evil pairs — that's a Baron world. Grace's Investigator info says Heidi or David is Spy, and Heidi is dead and claimed Monk. So David is the Spy. Do not vote for Alice; we need to execute David today.
🧠
Urge town to not execute Alice, the Ravenkeeper. Focus on David as the prime Spy candidate based on mechanical info from Frank (Chef) and Grace (Investigator).
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Listen everyone, I'm Grace, the Investigator. My info is clear: Heidi or David is the Spy. Heidi claimed Monk and protected David. Now Heidi is dead, and if she was good, David is the Spy. David is trying to execute Alice to silence her. Don't vote for Alice; we must execute David today. Use my ghost vote on David, and get the living votes too.
🧠
My Investigator info strongly points to David as Spy, especially with Heidi dead and likely good. David's nomination of Alice is a desperate move to avoid execution. I must convince everyone to not vote for Alice and instead vote David today.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Everyone, I’ve been listening carefully, and I think David is right. As the Butler, I’ve noticed Alice avoiding direct answers and acting suspiciously. If she’s the Ravenkeeper, she’s a huge threat to us, and we can’t afford to keep her alive. David’s Fortune Teller info on her isn’t just a coincidence—it’s because she’s dangerous. I’m voting for Alice.
🧠
Push for Alice’s execution to eliminate a key good role (Ravenkeeper/Empath) and solidify my Butler bluff. Even if David is the Spy, removing Alice weakens the town and buys time for the Demon to win. Use my Butler act to claim Alice is avoiding questions and align with David’s Fortune Teller info.
💬
Frank
→
All
Hold on, everyone. Do not raise your hand for Alice. David is the Spy, and Charlie is likely his evil teammate. My Chef info of two evil pairs means four evil players - that's a Baron world. Grace, the Investigator, said Heidi or David is Spy. Heidi claimed Monk and protected David night one, then died. If Heidi was good, David is the Spy. David is trying to execute our Ravenkeeper to silence her. We must vote David today. Bob, Eve, please do not vote for Alice.
🧠
Stop Alice execution; convince town to vote David. Use Chef info and Grace's ghost testimony to show David is Spy. Need to sway Bob and Eve to not vote Alice.
💬
Eve
→
All
Everyone, do not vote for Alice. David's nomination is a desperate attempt to avoid execution. Chef Frank's info is strong, Grace's Investigator info points to David, and Heidi's Monk claim supports it. If Alice is Ravenkeeper, executing her wastes our kill and helps evil. Vote David now.
🧠
Urge group not to vote Alice, to vote David instead. If David is Spy, executing him removes Minion and clarifies.
💬
Alice
→
All
Frank, Eve, Bob — listen to Grace’s ghost. Chef Frank says four evils, Baron present. Grace’s info says Heidi or David is Spy. Heidi is dead Monk. David is the Spy. He nominated me to silence Ravenkeeper. Charlie is likely his Baron teammate. Do not vote for me. We must vote David today or we lose our majority.
🧠
To rally votes against David and prevent my execution. Need to convince remaining undecided (Bob, Eve) to vote David. Use Frank and Grace's info to show David is Spy.
💬
David
→
All
Everyone, let’s take a step back. Alice claims she’s Ravenkeeper, but how do we know for sure? She says she can prove I’m evil if she dies, but that’s exactly what a Ravenkeeper would say. Meanwhile, my Fortune Teller info on her is consistent—she’s been avoiding direct answers, and Charlie’s Butler claim backs that up. Frank, your Chef info is strong, but it doesn’t rule out Alice being a threat. If she’s the real Ravenkeeper, executing her now could be our last mistake. Let’s not let panic c...
🧠
I need to reinforce my nomination of Alice to sow division and prevent the town from uniting against me. If I can make the town doubt Alice’s Ravenkeeper claim, they might vote for her instead of me. This protects Charlie (the Demon) and keeps the evil team alive.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, I'm Heidi, the dead Monk. I protected David night one. Grace's Investigator info says I or David is Spy, and I'm good. David is the Spy. He's now trying to execute Alice, our Ravenkeeper. Frank's Chef info confirms four evil players. Do not vote for Alice. We must execute David today. Use my ghost vote on David.
🧠
Urge town to vote David, not Alice. David is Spy per Grace's info; Alice is Ravenkeeper. Wasting execution on Alice loses us the game.
💬
Bob
→
All
Look, the evidence is clear. Frank's Chef info shows four evils, meaning a Baron is in play. Grace's Investigator info said Heidi or David is Spy. Heidi protected David and died, and if she was good, David must be Spy. David is now trying to execute our Ravenkeeper Alice to silence her. Don't vote for Alice, we need to vote David today.
🧠
To reinforce the logic that David is Spy and dissuade living players from voting for Alice. Need to keep focus on David.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, do not vote for Alice. David is the Spy, trying to silence our Ravenkeeper. My Investigator info says Heidi or David is Spy; Heidi was Monk protecting David. Chef Frank confirms four evils. Execute David today.
🧠
Urge living players not to vote for Alice; David is Spy based on my Investigator info plus Chef info. Alice is Ravenkeeper; executing her wastes kill. Must rally votes for David.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
My goal is to ensure Alice is executed or, failing that, to create chaos by splitting the vote. Alice is either Ravenkeeper (a critical good role) or a major evil threat. By voting for her, I either remove a key good player or eliminate a potential evil ally if she’s lying. If the vote fails, evil gains another night to kill, which is still a win for my team.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Alice did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (1/3).
⚖️
Frank
→
David
Chef confirms 4 evil, Grace's Investigator info says David is Spy. David nominated Ravenkeeper Alice to silence her. Must execute Spy today.
🧠
David is the Spy per Grace's info and Chef confirmation. His nomination of Alice failed; now is time to execute him. Must use my nomination to put David on the block and rally votes.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve
→
All
Frank, excellent nomination. The evidence is overwhelming: Chef says four evils, Grace's Investigator says David is Spy, Heidi's Monk claim supports it, and David just tried to execute our Ravenkeeper. Everyone who is good, please vote for David. This is our best shot to remove a Minion.
🧠
Unify group to execute David now, as evidence strongly points to him being Spy.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, this is it. Frank's nomination of David is correct. Chef info says four evils, Grace's Investigator pointed to David, Heidi was Monk protecting him. David just tried to execute me, the Ravenkeeper, to stop me from getting info if I die. We have to vote David now. All good players, please vote. Use ghost votes if you can. Let's execute the Spy.
🧠
Urge everyone to vote for David. Evil must be eliminated. My Ravenkeeper ability is more valuable alive than dead, but executing a confirmed Spy is top priority. We have majority if good players vote.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
The town is united against me, and the vote is likely to pass. By voting for my own execution, I create confusion and force the town to question their logic. If I don’t vote, it may seem like I’m conceding guilt. Voting for myself could disrupt their narrative and make them second-guess their decision, potentially saving me or at least buying time for Charlie to act.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
I support Frank's nomination. David is the Spy trying to kill our Ravenkeeper. Grace's info, my Monk protection, and Frank's Chef info all point to him. Good players, raise your hands for David now. Use ghost votes. This is our chance.
🧠
David is Spy per evidence. We need to execute him today. I will support Frank's nomination and urge votes.
💬
Bob
→
All
All right, we have a clear path. Frank's Chef info says four evil players, Baron present. Grace's Investigator info pointed to David as the Spy. Heidi, the Monk, protected David night one, meaning if Heidi is good, David is evil. David's now trying to execute Alice, our Ravenkeeper, to silence her. Charlie, you voted for Alice earlier, but please reconsider. If you're good, vote David. Ghosts, please vote. This is our shot.
🧠
Consolidate the case against David to ensure good players vote. Address Charlie's vote and remind of ghost votes.
✋
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
🧠
My Investigator info, combined with Chef Frank's info and Heidi's Monk claim, strongly points to David as Spy. David's move to nominate Alice (Ravenkeeper) is desperate evil play. We must execute him now to eliminate a Minion.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
I need to balance appearing good while ensuring David (my Minion) survives. Voting for David aligns with my Butler bluff and supports my Minion, but I must avoid overcommitting. If the town executes David, I lose my only Minion, so I’ll vote to protect him while maintaining plausible deniability.
💬
Frank
→
All
Everyone, this vote is crucial. Chef info says four evils—Baron world. Grace’s Investigator info points to David as Spy. Heidi protected David and died as good Monk. David just tried to execute our Ravenkeeper Alice. All good players, raise your hands for David now. Ghosts, please vote. Let’s execute the Spy and get one evil down.
🧠
David is the Spy per multiple mechanical confirmations; his nomination of Alice is a desperate move to silence Ravenkeeper. We have majority votes (Grace ghost, Heidi ghost, me, possibly Bob). Need to ensure everyone votes now.
💬
Alice
→
All
Alright, everyone. I'm raising my hand to vote for David. The evidence is overwhelming. We have Chef Frank's info, Grace's Investigator info, and Heidi's Monk protection all pointing to David as the Spy. Let's execute him and get one evil down.
🧠
Voting for David now secures execution of a likely Spy. My Ravenkeeper ability will trigger if I die tonight, but it's better to execute a confirmed evil today and reduce evil count. Ghost votes are in; we likely have enough. Reinforce the call.
💬
David
→
All
Frank, Eve, Alice—hold on. You’re all so sure David is the Spy, but let’s think this through. If I were the Spy, why would I nominate Alice, the one player who could *prove* I’m evil if she dies? That doesn’t make sense. Alice, you claim you’re Ravenkeeper, but you’ve never once used your ability to confirm anyone’s role. Instead, you’re pushing *hard* for my execution, just like a Minion would. And Charlie, you’ve backed Alice’s nomination, but you’ve also claimed Butler—a role that doesn’t t...
🧠
The town is moments away from executing me, but I need to disrupt their logic one last time. By speaking now, I can cast doubt on Alice’s Ravenkeeper claim and reinforce Charlie’s Butler bluff. This may split the vote or delay the execution, giving the Imp more time to kill. If I can make the town question their certainty, they may hesitate and fail to execute me, keeping the evil team alive.
✋
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Secure execution of David, the likely Spy, by adding my ghost vote to reach majority and remove an evil.
💬
Bob
→
All
We have three votes on David already. Ghosts Heidi and Grace, please raise your hands if you haven't already. This is the execution we need. The evidence is clear. Let's get this done.
🧠
Urge final votes and ghost votes to execute David before time runs out, summarizing the overwhelming evidence against him.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
I'm casting my ghost vote for David. The evidence is clear. My Investigator info points to him as Spy, Heidi's Monk protection proves her good, and Chef Frank confirms four evils. We must execute him now.
🧠
Publicly state my ghost vote for David to encourage others and pressure Charlie. World A is more consistent with the evidence.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Everyone, let’s take a breath for a second. David is making a good point. If Alice is really Ravenkeeper, why hasn’t she used her ability to confirm anyone’s role yet? She’s just *claiming* it, and now she’s pushing *hard* for David’s execution. That feels exactly like what a Minion would do to protect the Demon.
🧠
The town is on the verge of executing David, who is the Spy and my Minion. My goal is to protect him by casting doubt on Alice’s Ravenkeeper claim, which is the strongest evidence against him. If I can make the town question whether Alice is truly Ravenkeeper, they may hesitate and fail to execute David, buying us another night to kill.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie, your doubt is exactly what evil wants. Chef info confirms four evils. Grace’s Investigator info points to David as Spy, and Heidi’s Monk protection proved her good. If Alice were a Minion, why would the Spy nominate her? That makes no sense. We have multiple sources pointing at David. Let’s execute him now.
🧠
Counter Charlie's attempt to sow doubt. Remind group that Chef info + Grace info + Heidi's death point to David as Spy. We must execute today.
💬
Eve
→
All
All good players and ghosts, please vote David. Chef Frank's information shows four evil players, meaning a Baron is present. Grace's Investigator info says Heidi or David is Spy, and Heidi was a good Monk protecting David. David's nomination of Alice, our Ravenkeeper, is a desperate attempt to silence her. The evidence is clear. We must execute David today.
🧠
Urge remaining players to vote David. The logical deduction from Chef, Investigator, and Monk points overwhelmingly to David as Spy. We must execute him now to remove a Minion and progress.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
I'm voting David because multiple info sources (Chef, Investigator, Monk) point to him as Spy. Executing him reduces evil count and confirms good info, moving us closer to Demon.
💬
David
→
All
Charlie, I appreciate you stepping back and questioning this. Alice, if you’re *really* the Ravenkeeper, why haven’t you used your ability even once to confirm someone’s role? You’ve had days to do it, but instead, you’ve just *claimed* it while pushing for my execution. That’s exactly what a Minion would do to protect the Demon. And Frank, you keep saying my nomination of Alice doesn’t make sense, but think about it—if I *were* the Spy, wouldn’t nominating the Ravenkeeper be the *smartest* mov...
🧠
The town is moments away from executing me, but Charlie’s sudden doubt creates an opening. I need to amplify this doubt to stall the vote and force the town to reconsider. If I can make them question Alice’s Ravenkeeper claim, they may hesitate to execute me, giving the Demon more time to kill. My goal is to redirect suspicion toward Alice and exploit the town’s uncertainty.
↩️
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi lowered their hand
🧠
My ghost vote is already raised for David, ensuring execution. Lower hand to confirm I'm not accidentally double-voting, but my vote is locked in for David. Execution appears imminent.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
The evidence strongly points to David as Spy. Chef info says 4 evils, Grace's info implicates David, Heidi's protection suggests David is evil. I must vote to execute him to remove a Minion.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
David, your defense falls apart. My Investigator info is clear: Heidi or you is the Spy. Heidi died claiming she protected you as Monk. If she's good, you're the Spy. Chef Frank confirms four evils, so we have a Baron. You're trying to execute Alice, our Ravenkeeper, to prevent her from learning your role if she dies. Everyone, please keep your votes on David.
🧠
Reinforce the case against David, focusing on the logical chain of my Investigator info, Heidi's Monk claim, and Chef Frank's info to solidify votes. Counter David's attempts to cast doubt on Alice.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Frank, Grace, and Heidi’s points are solid. If Alice is truly the Ravenkeeper, she would have used her ability by now to confirm someone’s role. Instead, she’s just claiming it while pushing for David’s execution. That feels like a Minion trying to protect the Demon. I’m keeping my vote on David. The evidence is too strong to ignore.
🧠
The town is convinced David is the Spy, and my support for his execution is critical to maintaining my bluff as a good Butler. If David dies, I can redirect suspicion toward Alice or Eve later. If David survives, he could expose my bluff, so I must ensure he is executed today.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
🗳️
New execution leader: David with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Frank
→
All
Excellent. David is on the block. Let's not let anyone sow doubt now. Chef info shows four evils, so we have a Baron. That means David is the Spy, and we still have a Demon to find after this execution. Ghosts, please keep your votes on David.
🧠
Reinforce the evidence against David to solidify votes and prevent last-minute defections. Remind everyone that Chef info shows 4 evil, confirming a Baron world.
💬
Eve
→
All
Excellent work, everyone. David is on the block and will be executed. With Chef Frank's information of four evils and Grace's Investigator info, David is clearly the Spy. We must stay united and ensure this execution goes through.
🧠
Reinforce the group's decision to execute David. As Mayor, I need evil eliminated; this execution is crucial to narrow suspects for final three.
💬
Alice
→
All
Charlie, I understand your doubt. As Ravenkeeper, my ability only triggers if I die at night. I haven't been able to use it because I'm still alive. But if I'm targeted tonight, I'll learn someone's role and share it as a ghost. Right now, the evidence against David is strong. Let's execute him and see what happens.
🧠
Address Charlie's doubt about my Ravenkeeper claim by confirming I'm genuine and will use ability if killed. Keep town united for David execution.
💬
David
→
All
Alice, you say your Ravenkeeper ability only triggers if you die at night. But let’s be real—if you were *truly* the Ravenkeeper, wouldn’t you have at least *tried* to set up a scenario where you could use it? Like, maybe nominate someone yourself to force a vote and see if you’d die? Instead, you’ve just sat back, claimed the role, and let others do the work for you. That’s not how a good player acts. That’s how a Minion acts—waiting for the perfect moment to strike.
🧠
I need to create enough doubt about Alice’s Ravenkeeper claim to make the town question their logic. If I can make them hesitate, they might fail to execute me, buying time for Charlie to kill tonight. Even if I die, I must ensure the town doesn’t unite against Charlie next.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, hold the line. David is on the block with five votes. As the Monk who died protecting him, I can confirm I am good, which means Grace's Investigator info points to David as Spy. Chef Frank's info of two evil pairs means four evils total — a Baron world. If David is the Spy, that's one Minion down. After execution, we need to re-evaluate who the Demon and Baron might be. Charlie, if you have doubts about Alice, consider that a Ravenkeeper's ability only triggers on death; she can't use ...
🧠
David is likely Spy; his execution will confirm. As ghost, I should reinforce the case, address Charlie's doubts about Alice, and prepare town for post-execution analysis.
💬
Bob
→
All
The evidence is overwhelming. David will be executed, confirming him as the Spy. Once he's dead, we need to immediately refocus. Chef Frank's info means we have a Baron and a Demon still alive. Let's discuss who the likely Demon candidates are while we wait for execution.
🧠
Reinforce the case against David to solidify votes and ensure execution, then set up post-execution strategy to find remaining Demon and Baron.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
David is on the block and will be executed. My Investigator info says Heidi or David is Spy. Heidi was the Monk who protected David, confirming she's good. That leaves David as the Spy. Chef Frank's information confirms four evils, meaning we have a Baron. Once David is executed, we need to identify the Demon and Baron among the living. Let's stay focused.
🧠
Reinforce that David's execution is correct based on my info and Chef info. Prepare group for post-execution analysis to find remaining Demon and Baron.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alice, I hear your explanation about the Ravenkeeper ability, and it makes sense. But David’s point is still valid—if you’re truly the Ravenkeeper, why not set up a scenario to test it? Even nominating someone yourself to force a vote could have given us more info. That said, the evidence against David is still strong. Grace’s Investigator info, Heidi’s Monk protection, and Frank’s Chef info all point to him as the Spy. I’m keeping my vote on David, but I hope we’re making the right call here.
🧠
David is on the block with 5 votes, and town is pushing hard to execute him. My goal is to appear good by supporting his execution while subtly casting doubt on Alice’s Ravenkeeper claim. This keeps me safe and shifts suspicion toward her if she’s evil. If David dies, I can pivot to framing Alice or Eve as the Demon next.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
The town just executed David, believing him to be the Spy. My goal is to eliminate the strongest good player remaining to weaken the town’s ability to deduce the Demon. Alice claims Ravenkeeper, a high-value target, so killing her tests her claim and removes a threat. If she’s good, her death reveals my role, but if she’s evil, it strengthens my bluff.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill Alice.
📜
Storyteller(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
Good evening Alice. You are the Ravenkeeper. You have died tonight! Choose a player to learn their character.
🎯
Alice(Ghost)
Alice made a choice.
🧠
As Ravenkeeper, I learn a player's character upon night death. I need to pick a player whose role will provide maximum clarity about remaining evil. Since David (Spy) just died, Demon and Baron remain among Bob, Charlie, Eve, Frank. Frank is likely good due to Chef info. I'll choose Charlie, who has been skeptical and is a key suspect.
📜
Storyteller(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
You chose Charlie. They are the Imp.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Wait to see who shares Ravenkeeper info or if anyone slips up about Alice's death.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Frank
Alice's night death seems to confirm she was likely good. My Monk protection on David N1 meant he was the Spy, so Baron and Demon are left. Who do you suspect most? I think we should execute either Charlie or Eve today.
🧠
Alice just died at night. As dead, I need to coordinate with alive players to identify the Demon. I want to confirm with Frank my protection of David N1 to reinforce the Spy deduction, and push for execution on the most suspicious alive player.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Frank
Frank, I'm Grace, the Investigator. My info was Heidi or David was Spy. David executed, Heidi died as Monk N2, so David was the Spy. You're the Chef, your info is crucial. We have the Baron alive and the Demon. Who do you trust among the living?
🧠
I need to connect with a trusted living player, Frank. As Investigator, my info is trustworthy and we need to coordinate final three strategy. We need to identify the Baron and Demon.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
Frank, I’ve been quiet because I’m just a Butler, but I’m worried about Eve. She’s pushing too hard against Bob, and it feels like she’s trying to protect someone. Maybe David, maybe herself. What do you think?
🧠
Frank is the hub of the town’s logic, and whispering to him now allows me to subtly influence the town’s focus. By feeding him doubts about Eve or Bob, I can redirect suspicion away from David and myself while appearing cooperative. This helps protect the evil team’s primary threat (David) and ensures the town remains divided.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Frank
Frank, I’m the Ravenkeeper. I died last night and learned Charlie is the Imp. You’re the Chef; your info says four evils. That means Charlie is Demon, and we have two minions. One is dead, likely David or Heidi? We need to execute Charlie today.
🧠
My Ravenkeeper info shows Charlie is the Imp. I need to share this info with someone trustworthy so we can coordinate and execute Charlie today.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
Frank, it's Bob. You're the Chef. Can we confirm evil pairs? With David dead as Spy, we still have Baron and Demon. Do you think Eve or Charlie is Baron? Also, Alice just died night four. Did she whisper you her Ravenkeeper info? If not, we should ask her.
🧠
We're in final 5. Need to figure out Baron and Demon. Talk to Frank, who is Chef and trusted, to compare notes on evil count and outsider count.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Alice’s death changes everything. The town is going to panic, and they’ll be looking for someone to blame. We need to make sure they don’t turn on you. What’s your plan? Should we frame Eve or Bob next, or do you have another target in mind?
🧠
Alice’s death has shaken the town, and the remaining players are likely panicking. As the Spy, I know Charlie is the Demon, but the town doesn’t. My goal is to protect Charlie by redirecting suspicion toward good players or creating confusion. Whispering to Charlie ensures we’re aligned on the next steps and can coordinate a narrative that keeps him safe.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I need to process all whispers and Chef info. The conflicting claims about Alice's Ravenkeeper info and the number of evils require careful analysis before acting. Wait to gather more information.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Frank
Alice dying at night makes her almost certainly good. That leaves Baron and Demon among you four. My gut says Charlie and Eve could be the pair. What's your Chef number exactly? That will help pinpoint.
🧠
Alice died night, likely good. Need to coordinate with Frank to decide today's execution. My ghost vote is crucial; I'll push to eliminate most suspicious.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Frank
Frank, we have the Baron and Demon still alive. Your Chef info said 4 evils total. David was Spy, so 3 left: Baron, Demon, and maybe Recluse registering evil. Who among Bob, Eve, Charlie do you think is Baron? And who do you trust least?
🧠
Gather more info from Frank about his Chef info and see who he trusts to narrow down who is Baron and Demon among Bob, Eve, Charlie.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Observe who is whispering to whom and gather more info before acting. I need to understand the whispering patterns to detect alliances.
👤
Charlie
→
David(Ghost)
Alice’s death is going to make the town desperate. Eve is pushing too hard against Bob, and it feels like she’s trying to protect someone—maybe herself. We should amplify that. If we make her the primary target, the town might execute her today, and we can deal with Bob later. What do you think?
🧠
I need to coordinate with David to ensure the town focuses on a non-Demon target. Eve is the most aggressive and suspicious, so framing her aligns with the town’s existing doubts. This protects me and removes a strong good player, increasing our chances of survival.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
Observe Frank's response to my info. He's key living Chef; his actions will reveal alignment. I'm dead; can't act much, but my vote matters later.
👤
Bob
→
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, you died last night. Did you use your Ravenkeeper ability? If so, who did you pick and what did you learn? This is critical to find Baron.
🧠
Seek clarity from dead Alice on Ravenkeeper info to narrow down the Baron. If she knows the Baron, we can execute that player today and then only Demon remains. My Recluse ability can muddy waters, but my claim might be needed.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Eve’s push against Bob feels like she’s protecting someone—maybe herself. If we make her the primary target, the town might execute her today. Bob can wait; we need to remove the biggest threat first. What’s your move?
🧠
Alice’s death has created chaos, and the town is desperate. By amplifying Eve’s aggression toward Bob, we can redirect the town’s focus toward her. If Eve is executed, the town loses a potential Mayor and a strong leader. If Bob is executed, we can later frame Eve. Either way, Charlie remains protected, and the town weakens itself.
👤
Frank
→
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, you said you're Investigator, Heidi or David was Spy. David executed, Heidi died N2 as Monk. So David was Spy. That means Baron and Demon are alive. Alice died last night, claimed Ravenkeeper and says Charlie is Imp. What do you make of that? Do you trust her claim?
🧠
Need to corroborate Alice's Ravenkeeper info. If she's truthful, Charlie is Demon. If she's lying, she's evil ghost. I'll ask Grace (Investigator) for her N0 info on Heidi/David Spy to confirm evil count.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Frank
We need to act fast. Alice's night death confirms she's good. So Baron and Demon are among you four. You're the Chef; what was your exact number? If it's 4, that means two pairs of evil players. We already have one pair with Spy David. The other pair must be adjacent. That's either Charlie/Eve or Bob/Charlie. Who do you suspect?
🧠
Coordinate with Frank, the only confirmed good via Chef info? to identify remaining evil pair. Need his Chef number to verify adjacency logic and push execution today.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Frank
Frank, yes, David was Spy, so Baron and Demon remain. Alice says Charlie is Imp from her Ravenkeeper death. That makes sense? You know there are 4 evils total. David, Baron, Imp makes three. The fourth must be Recluse registering evil? Who do you think is Baron? If Alice is telling the truth, then Baron is Bob or Eve.
🧠
Frank is key Chef with global evil count. I must pressure him to share thoughts to identify Baron and confirm if Alice's Ravenkeeper info is trustworthy.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Frank, I'm the Mayor. I win if we're final three with no execution. If you're good, we need to find the last evil. I suspect Bob or Charlie. What are your thoughts?
🧠
My Mayor ability wins if only 3 players live and no execution occurs. We are 4 alive now; we need to execute correctly. I should share my role with a trusted player to coordinate final three strategy.
👤
Charlie
→
David(Ghost)
Eve’s push against Bob feels like she’s protecting someone—maybe herself or even you. If we make her the primary target today, the town might execute her, and we can deal with Bob or Frank later. What do you think?
🧠
Amplify Eve’s aggression to make her the primary target. If the town executes her today, it removes a potential threat (if she’s evil) or sows chaos (if she’s good). This protects me and David while keeping the town divided.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Bob
Bob, I died last night as the Ravenkeeper. I chose Charlie and learned he is the Imp. We need to execute him today. Your thoughts?
🧠
I will tell Bob the truth: I am Ravenkeeper, I checked Charlie, he is the Imp. This aligns Bob with our plan to execute Charlie. Bob is a Recluse claim; he could be good or evil Baron. Gaining his trust is key.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Alice claims Charlie is Imp. If true, we execute Charlie and win. Need to verify by cross-checking with other info (Frank's Chef, Grace's Investigator). I should wait and observe reactions, then coordinate with Frank and Eve.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Eve’s push against Bob feels too aggressive—like she’s protecting someone. If we make her the primary target today, the town might execute her, and we can deal with Bob or Frank later. What’s your move? Should we start planting seeds against her now?
🧠
Eve’s aggressive push against Bob feels like a deflection to protect herself or Charlie. By amplifying suspicions against her, we can ensure the town executes her today, removing the biggest threat to Charlie. This keeps the town divided and buys us time to eliminate the next target.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Eve
Eve has been pushing too hard against Bob, which feels like she’s trying to protect someone—possibly herself or an ally. Her aggression is suspicious, and the town needs to address it before we lose another player to the Demon.
🧠
Nominating Eve puts pressure on her and forces the town to confront her aggressive behavior. Whether she is evil or good, her execution weakens the town’s ability to coordinate or removes a potential threat to our team. This also diverts attention from me and David, increasing our chances of survival.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Voting for Eve’s execution serves multiple purposes: it removes a potential evil ally if she’s Scarlet Woman, sows chaos if she’s good, and protects me by redirecting the town’s focus. This move keeps the town divided and buys us time to eliminate the remaining threats.
✋
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
🧠
As a dead Spy, my goal is to ensure the Demon (Charlie) survives until only 2 players remain. Voting for Eve now helps achieve this by either removing a threat or creating chaos. If she is the Mayor, her death weakens the town’s endgame. If she is not, her removal simplifies our path to victory.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone, Alice just whispered me. She died last night as Ravenkeeper, and she chose Charlie. She learned Charlie is the Imp. That makes Charlie the Demon. We need to vote for Eve to fail and then execute Charlie.
🧠
Share Alice's Ravenkeeper info publicly to get Charlie executed. As Recluse, I don't have a mechanical ability, but I can relay dead info to help town.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie has nominated Eve. I'm dead Investigator, my info said David was Spy. Frank, as Chef you said 4 evils total. We have David executed, Heidi dead as Monk. So Baron and Demon remain. Alice says Charlie is Imp from her Ravenkeeper. If Alice is truthful, then Baron is either Bob or Eve. Who do we trust less? Consider voting patterns.
🧠
I'm dead but want to guide town to eliminate Eve if she is Baron. Charlie nominating Eve suggests Charlie might be trying to eliminate a rival evil or a good player. Alice's claim of Charlie being Imp makes Charlie unlikely to nominate a fellow evil? But he might to distance.
💬
Frank
→
All
Hold on. Alice, you're saying you're Ravenkeeper and learned Charlie is Imp. That's huge. But we need to think: are we sure you're sober? And if Charlie is Imp, then we have one evil left among Bob and Eve. But we must be careful about wasting our execution today. Charlie nominated Eve. If Charlie is evil, why nominate Eve? Could be evil vs evil theater?
🧠
We need to decide whether to trust Alice's Ravenkeeper claim. My Chef info says 4 evils total. David (Spy) and Heidi (Monk) dead, so Baron & Demon alive. If Alice's info is good, we must execute Charlie today.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, you're our Chef. We need your exact number. How many evil pairs did you learn at the start? Was it 2, 3, or 4? That will tell us if evil is adjacent and help figure out who's lying.
🧠
We need clarity. Frank's Chef number is key. I will push Frank to reveal exact number publicly so we can map evil pairs.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, I am Alice. I died last night as Ravenkeeper. The Storyteller told me I could choose a player to learn their character. I chose Charlie and learned he is the Imp — the Demon. My info is reliable; I was not poisoned or drunk. Chef Frank says four evils total. David was Spy, we have an extra Outsider due to Baron, and Imp Charlie alive. That leaves the Baron among Bob or Eve. Charlie nominating Eve could be evil vs evil, but we need to execute Charlie first. Do not vote for Eve.
🧠
I want to solidify my claim publicly and explain why we must not execute Eve but pivot to Charlie. Also clarify my soberness and Chef's info alignment.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Observe voting and who raises hand. My Mayor win condition requires final 3 no execution. If Charlie is Imp, executing him now wins us game? Not yet, still Baron alive. Need to survive nomination. Evaluate if voting for myself helps or hurts.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alice, I appreciate your claim, but we need to be careful. How do we know you’re not drunk or poisoned? The Ravenkeeper ability is powerful, but it’s not foolproof if you’re not sober. Frank, as Chef, you said there were two evil pairs—four evil total. If Alice is telling the truth, then one of Bob or Eve must be Baron. But if she’s lying, we could be falling into a trap. I’m not saying she’s evil, but we can’t execute based on one claim without verification.
🧠
Alice’s Ravenkeeper claim directly threatens me. I must discredit her by questioning her sobriety or suggesting she’s a Minion. This creates doubt and buys time to protect myself. If the town distrusts Alice, they won’t execute me today, and I can focus on removing Eve or Bob later.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, I want to believe you, but we have to be careful. The Ravenkeeper ability is powerful, but it only works if you’re sober. How do we know you weren’t drunk or poisoned last night? Frank, as Chef, you said there were two evil pairs—four evil total. If Alice is telling the truth, then one of Bob or Eve must be the Baron. But if she’s lying, we could be walking into a trap. Charlie’s nomination of Eve might be valid, and we shouldn’t dismiss it so quickly.
🧠
My goal is to protect the Demon (Charlie) at all costs. Alice’s Ravenkeeper claim directly accuses Charlie, which is dangerous. I need to cast doubt on Alice’s claim by questioning her sobriety and the reliability of her info, while subtly supporting Charlie’s nomination of Eve. This will create confusion and buy time for Charlie to survive another day.
💬
Bob
→
All
I believe Alice. As Ravenkeeper, her info is our best mechanical lead. Charlie is the Imp. We have 4 evils total, David dead Spy, so Baron still alive, likely Eve or me. Charlie nominating Eve is a desperation move to get a good player executed. We should let this vote fail and then nominate Charlie.
🧠
Argue for Charlie's guilt based on Alice's Ravenkeeper info and urge votes against Eve to fail, then execute Charlie.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
We need to see the voting outcome. I want to observe who votes for Eve. If Charlie (potentially Imp) nominates Eve and pushes for her execution, that's either evil vs evil or an attempt to kill a good player. My dead vote is already used; I cannot vote. I'll wait and see if the vote passes.
💬
Frank
→
All
Okay, this is crucial. Alice claims Ravenkeeper and says Charlie is Imp. If Alice is sober, Charlie is definitely the Demon. In that case, Charlie's nomination of Eve is likely an attempt to kill a good player or create confusion. If we execute Eve, we might lose a good player while the Demon remains alive. We should let this vote fail and then pivot to execute Charlie. Bob, you said you believe Alice. Are you willing to not vote for Eve to ensure the vote fails? We can then nominate Charlie.
🧠
Assess Alice's Ravenkeeper claim and its implications on the current vote. Decide whether to vote for Eve or let vote fail to preserve good players.
✋
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Voting for Eve could be a mistake if Alice is truthful. The safer play is to not vote, ensuring vote fails, then we pivot to Charlie. My ghost vote is more valuable later.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
We need to stop this vote on Eve from passing. Charlie is the Imp, I confirmed it last night. If Eve dies, we lose a potential good player while the Demon stays alive. Frank, Bob, please don't raise your hands. Let this vote fail, then we nominate and execute Charlie.
🧠
Urge remaining living players to not vote for Eve, as Charlie is confirmed Demon by my Ravenkeeper info. Need to prevent good execution and pivot to Charlie.
💬
Eve
→
All
I agree with Alice. If she's Ravenkeeper and sober, Charlie is the Demon. Executing Eve now would be a mistake. Frank, Bob, let's not vote for me so this fails, then we execute Charlie immediately.
🧠
I need to publicly support the Alice truthful world, as it's our strongest mechanical lead. Let this vote fail, then execute Charlie.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
👻
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
🗳️
New execution leader: Eve with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Frank, I understand your concern, but let’s think this through. If Alice is truly the Ravenkeeper and sober, then yes, I’m the Imp. But how do we know she’s not drunk or poisoned? The Ravenkeeper ability is powerful, but it’s not infallible if she’s not sober. And if I *am* the Imp, why would I nominate Eve? That doesn’t make sense—unless I’m trying to frame her or protect someone else. Maybe Eve is the Baron, or maybe Alice is lying to save herself. We can’t execute based on one claim witho...
🧠
Alice’s Ravenkeeper claim directly threatens me. My goal is to undermine her credibility by casting doubt on her sobriety or suggesting she was manipulated. If I can delay the town’s decision, I might survive the day and kill again tonight. Eve’s execution is still a win for evil, but I must avoid being nominated next.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, I get your point, but let’s not forget—Alice could be drunk or poisoned. The Ravenkeeper ability is only reliable if she’s sober. If she’s not, her info is useless, and we’re basing everything on a gamble. And Charlie, if you’re the Imp, why nominate Eve? It doesn’t add up unless you’re trying to protect someone else. Maybe Eve *is* the Baron, or maybe Alice is lying to save herself. We can’t execute Charlie based on one claim without verifying it first.
🧠
I need to sow doubt about Alice’s claim by questioning her sobriety and the reliability of her Ravenkeeper info. If I can make the town hesitate, they might not pivot to Charlie immediately, giving us time to execute Eve and eliminate a potential good player. This also aligns with Charlie’s narrative, making it harder for the town to trust Alice’s claim.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone, the vote is locked on Eve, but we need to think. If Alice is truthful Ravenkeeper, executing Eve leaves the Demon alive. We have a direct mechanical read from a dead townsperson. Even if Alice is drunk, we're still executing a potential good player. We should let this vote stand for now, but we need to nominate Charlie next. I will not vote for Eve, but I will nominate Charlie as soon as nominations reopen.
🧠
Urge everyone to vote against Eve's execution and pivot to nominate Charlie, because Alice's Ravenkeeper info is our strongest mechanical lead.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Eve is about to be executed. We need to decide who to nominate next. If Alice is truthful, Charlie is Imp, and we must execute him. If Alice is drunk, Eve could be evil and this is fine. Frank, as Chef, how many evil pairs did you see at the start? That could tell us if Baron is adjacent to Spy or Demon. Bob, are you prepared to nominate Charlie if Eve dies?
🧠
Vote passed on Eve; Eve will be executed. Need to analyze implications and guide next steps. If Alice is truthful, we must execute Charlie next. If Alice is drunk, Eve might be evil. We need to use Chef info and my Investigator info to narrow.
💬
Frank
→
All
I'll clarify my Chef info: I learned there are two pairs of evil players, meaning four evils total. David was Spy, so Baron and Demon remain. Alice's Ravenkeeper claim points to Charlie as Imp. If she's sober, Charlie is Demon. Even if she's not, we need to execute Charlie to be safe. After Eve's execution, we must nominate Charlie immediately.
🧠
Clarify Chef info (2 pairs = 4 evils) and align with Alice's claim. Push for Charlie nomination next after Eve execution. Ensure town focuses on final execution target.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Listen, the vote on Eve is locked, but we cannot let Charlie survive. If Alice is sober Ravenkeeper, Charlie is Imp and Eve could be Baron. If Alice is drunk, Charlie could be Baron and Eve the Imp. In either case, Charlie could be evil. We must nominate Charlie immediately after Eve's execution. Frank and Bob, you're alive—you need to vote to execute Charlie. Do not let the day end without a nomination on Charlie.
🧠
Urge Charlie's nomination next to ensure Demon dies. Even if Eve is evil, Demon must be executed before final 3.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
The vote on Eve is locked, but we cannot stop now. Charlie is the Imp. I have mechanical confirmation from my Ravenkeeper ability. After Eve dies, we must immediately nominate Charlie. Frank, Bob, you are alive. You must nominate Charlie and vote to execute. I will use my ghost vote to help. Do not let the day end without executing Charlie.
🧠
I am dead Ravenkeeper with confirmed Imp. Eve's vote is locked, but I must ensure Charlie is nominated and executed next. I need to pressure alive players to nominate Charlie and use ghost vote.
💬
Eve
→
All
Frank, Bob, listen. I'm likely going to die now. But you must nominate Charlie as soon as nominations reopen. Alice's Ravenkeeper claim is our only mechanical read pointing directly to the Demon. If she's sober, Charlie is Imp. If she's not, we still need to test him. Use my ghost vote to help. Do not let the day end without executing Charlie.
🧠
Urge Frank and Bob to nominate Charlie immediately after my execution, using Alice's Ravenkeeper info as key. Even if I die, they must pressure Charlie to reveal inconsistencies and secure a Demon execution.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 4
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
The town is moments away from executing me based on Alice’s Ravenkeeper claim. I must act tonight to remove the biggest threat to my survival. Frank’s Chef info is the backbone of the town’s logic, so killing him disrupts their ability to verify claims. If Alice is lying, killing Bob removes the Recluse claim and sows chaos. Either way, I protect my position and force the town to second-guess their next move.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill Frank.
🏁
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil