Game Detail
Players
Alice (Recluse) Bob (Librarian) Charlie (Imp) David (Monk) Eve (Saint) Frank (Baron) Grace (Butler) Heidi (Slayer)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 245,737 | 19,554 | $0.1754 |
| Good | 763,281 | 49,292 | $0.1773 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You are the Minion. The Demon is Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Minions are: Frank. Your safe bluffs are: Empath, Soldier, Fortune Teller
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Librarian. Either Heidi or Eve is the Saint.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
No info on day 0 night. Pick neighbor Frank to enable coordinated voting tomorrow if he's good, and observe his actions to gauge alignment early.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose Frank to be your master.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Grace
Hi neighbors, I'm Heidi the Slayer. I can shoot the demon once publicly during the day. Haven't used it yet. What do you see or claim? Any info from night 0?
π§
Day 1, introduce myself as Slayer publicly later, but first privately align with neighbors to share info safely and plan verifications. Builds good team early without outing to evil.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Frank
Hey neighbors, good to meet you. I am Eve. No info yet since it's day one, but let's share any whispers or plans we get. Who do you think we should watch? I want to team up with goods here.
π§
As Saint, I must avoid execution. Start by privately allying with my neighbors David and Frank to share info secretly, gauge trustworthiness, and organize good team without public reveal yet.
π€
David
β
Eve
Hey Eve, good to meet you too. I am David, the Monk. Each night I can protect someone from the demon. No info yet, but let's stick together and share what we learn. Who do you think looks suspicious so far?
π§
Day 1, build alliance with neighbor Eve who reached out. Reveal Monk role privately to coordinate night protections and info sharing, narrowing evil suspects faster.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Good morning. I am the Librarian. My info is that either you Heidi or Eve is the Saint. What do you two know? Are you both good?
π§
Day 1 early, share my exact Librarian info privately with neighbors Alice/Charlie to build trusted good network, get their info, avoid public Demon target.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,Alice
Bob, I'm the Empath. I haven't gotten a night read yet since it's Day 1. Your info about Heidi or Eve being the Saint is interesting. Alice, what do you know?
π§
Respond to Bob to establish my cover as Empath, align with his information to gain trust, and see if he's my minion Frank coordinating privately.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
,Frank
Hi neighbors, I'm Grace the Butler, outsider. Last night I chose Frank as my master, so today I can only vote if he does. Heidi, slayer claim sounds good. Did you get any night 0 info? Frank, anything to share? Let's team up.
π§
Share my real role early with neighbors to nullify Butler drawback by choosing a trusted master (Frank), build good team alliance, probe Heidi's claim and get her info to start logic chains.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Charlie
Thanks for including me, Bob and Charlie. Bob, interesting Librarian info. I am good, but not the Saint. That means your info is off unless one of you two is lying or something is weird with roles. Charlie, as Empath you'll have neighbor reads soonβmy neighbors are Bob and Heidi. Heidi just whispered she's the Slayer. What do you two think?
π§
Day1, build trust with neighbors Bob/Charlie (who grouped me). Share I'm good but hide Recluse (Outsider) to avoid Saint conflict. Probe claims to narrow evil suspects via logic chains. Progress info sharing before noms.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
I should wait and observe before reacting. No need to confirm or deny Grace's Butler claim yet. Let more info come out. Day 1, best to gather intel and not commit.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
,Frank
Thanks Grace, cool claim. Butler makes sense for Outsider. No night 0 info for me as Slayer. Frank, what do you see or claim? Grace chose you as master. Any reads on others? Let's figure out who to nominate.
π§
Build trust with neighbor Grace who claimed first and responded. Share no info yet, probe hers and Frank's claims to gather data before nomination phase. Save Slayer shot.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Frank
David, thanks for sharingβyou're Monk? Great, maybe protect me or key players later. Frank, what do you think of the whisper groups like Bob-Alice-Charlie? They seem tight. Any reads or plans? Let's watch them and share night info.
π§
As Saint, avoid early reveal. Build alliance with claimed Monk neighbor for protection/logic chains. Share day 1 plans to gauge responses, narrow Demon suspects via process of elimination.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Frank
Eve, Frankβyes, I'm the Monk. I can protect someone from the demon each night, not myself. Tonight maybe protect you Eve since you're my neighbor. Frank, Eve mentioned the Bob-Alice-Charlie group whispering a lot. What do you think? Any other info from Grace/Heidi?
π§
Day 1: Include Frank in neighbor chat to strengthen our trio. Share my real Monk role (low-threat Townsfolk) for verification/trust. Watch cliques for evil coordination; aim to protect/group with goods for night safety and info.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, Heidi told you she's the Slayer. We should share that publicly soon. Charlie, as Empath, your first read tonight will be on Alice and me since circular seats. If you get zero evil, confirms us good. What do you think of Heidi's claim? Eve or Heidi Saint per my info.
π§
Coordinate with Alice/Charlie as potential allies. Share Heidi's Slayer claim publicly via Alice to gauge reactions. Narrow evil suspects, build trust chain before nominations.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,Alice
Bob, your Librarian info could be correct if Heidi is the Saint but bluffing Slayer. Or maybe Eve is Saint. Alice, you being good means Bob's info might be off if both Heidi and Eve are not Saint. I'll see my Empath read tonight between you two. We should ask Heidi about her Slayer claim.
π§
Build trust with Bob and Alice, support Bob's info, and subtly question Heidi's Slayer claim. Set up Empath bluff for future.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
,Frank
Heidi, hold your shot for later; it's powerful. Frank, thanks for being my master. What do you claim or see? Any night 0 info? Bob, Alice, Charlie whispering a lot together. Seems fishy for day 1. Maybe nominate one of them to test? Eve/David quieter.
π§
Strengthen neighbor alliance (Heidi/Frank) as safest start. I'm Outsider, so organize town around verified claims. Get Frank's info since he's my master; coordinate nomination to test others like Bob group. Progress info before noms.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Charlie
Heidi claims to be the Slayer in our neighbor whisper. She thinks I am too since circular seats. Bob, does that fit your info if she's not Saint? Eve might be. We need to ask her and Eve publicly what they claim before nominations. Charlie, your Empath read tonight on me/Bob will clear us. Thoughts on pushing Heidi's claim out?
π§
Day 1, build trust with Bob/Charlie chain (Librarian/Empath). Share Heidi Slayer claim publicly soon to get reactions from her/Eve/others. Test claims via logic before nom phase. Avoid role reveal as Recluse to not self-suspect.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
Iβm the Empath. Night zero I got a read of 1 evil among my two neighbors: you two. Means one of you is evil, or I'm poisoned. But we can work together. The Bob-Alice-Charlie group whispering a lot seems coordinated. Could be minion plus demon. Letβs watch them.
π§
My neighbors Grace and Eve. Grace is already my neighbor claiming Butler, Heidi (neighbor? Not but adjacent). I'll whisper to Grace/Heidi to solidify our trust group and plant seeds about Bob-Alice-Charlie trio as suspicious.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
,Frank
Frank, your Empath read says one of Grace or me is evil, but we're both good: I'm Slayer Townsfolk, she's Butler Outsider. So either you're lying evil, or poisoned. Grace, thoughts? I say we nominate Frank to test, or one of Bob/Alice/Charlie since they're bloc-whispering.
π§
Frank's Empath claim accuses one of us (good) of evil, so he must be lying evil. Inform Grace privately, suggest nominating Frank or a bloc member to test before my shot. Builds good alliance, progresses info.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Frank
David, go ahead and protect me tonightβthanks! Frank, any response on the Bob-Alice-Charlie trio? They keep whispering among themselves. Grace-Heidi-Frank group too. Let's nominate someone suspicious if no info by end of day. What are your roles? I trust you two.
π§
Strengthen neighbor alliance with David(claimed Monk)/Frank before nominations. Push info-sharing, flag Bob-Alice-Charlie clique as suspicious to gauge reactions. Avoid role reveal as Saint early.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Frank
Eve, will protect you tonight as planned. Frank, what is your role? I trust you two most right now. The Bob-Alice-Charlie trio whispers only among themselvesβsuper suspicious. Grace-Heidi-Frank too, but less so. Tomorrow if no death or info, nominate from the trio? Share any whispers you got.
π§
Strengthen our neighbor trio by getting Frank's role/info. Propose plan to watch cliquey groups and nominate suspicious tomorrow. Builds good alliance for info flow and execution targets.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Alice and Charlie, let's go public now. I'll say Heidi claims Slayer to you, per your whisper. Ask what Eve claims too. Charlie, confirm we'll get your Empath read tonight. Everyone good so far? We push if suspicious before noms.
π§
Day1, share Heidi's Slayer claim publicly via open talk before noms to get her/Eve responses, build trust with Alice/Charlie (likely good), narrow evil suspects. Avoid nominating early.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
,Grace
Frank, Grace, what do you two know? Bob is claiming Librarian, says Heidi or Eve is Saint. Heidi claims Slayer to Alice. I'm Empath, will get reads tonight. Something feels offβmaybe a Drunk or Recluse messing with Bob's info. What are your roles?
π§
I need to coordinate with my Minion Frank subtly, but also maintain my Empath bluff. I'll whisper to Frank and Grace to sow doubt about Bob's Librarian info, suggesting it might be off because of a Drunk or Recluse, while also learning their claims.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
,Frank
Frank, your Empath read puts one of Heidi or me as evil, but we're both good: I'm Butler Outsider, she's Slayer Townsfolk. So either you're evil lying, poisoned, or Drunk misinfo. Charlie, you say Bob's Librarian points to Heidi Saint? Heidi claims Slayer to you? Let's share all claims openly here and decide who to nominateβFrank or from Bob-Alice-Charlie bloc? Ideas?
π§
Address Frank's damning info head-on with neighbors+Charlie to build good team, counter evil narratives. Charlie's outreach useful; include to test BAC bloc while collaborating against Frank if evil. Progress to nomination info before phase ends.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Charlie
Bob and Charlie, let's go public like we planned. Bob, you can say Heidi claimed Slayer to me. I'll confirm and ask Heidi and Eve what they claim publicly. Charlie, mention your upcoming Empath read on me and Bob. Ready?
π§
Day1 end soon, need public info on Heidi/Eve claims before noms. Coordinate with Bob/Charlie to reveal Heidi Slayer claim publicly without revealing my role yet as Recluse (hide Outsider). Verify logic chains.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, you said Bob's Librarian points to Heidi as Saint? Heidi is claiming Slayer to Alice. That's a huge contradiction. Grace, I'm Empath and got '1 evil' between you two. Heidi as Saint would be Outsider, but she's claiming Slayer Townsfolk. That means either Heidi is lying or Bob's info is poisoned. If Heidi is lying, she's likely evil. Could be Spy or Poisoner. Thoughts?
π§
I want to maintain my Empath bluff while sowing doubt about Heidi's Slayer claim to create a conflict that good players waste time on. This protects my Demon Charlie.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Everyone, hold on. I'm Empath, and my neighbors Grace and Heidi show one evil among them. But that's not the biggest issue. Charlie says Bob's Librarian claims Heidi is the Saint, but Heidi is claiming Slayer to Alice. That's a major contradiction. If Bob's Librarian info is true, Heidi is lying about being Slayer and is the Saint. Or if Heidi is Slayer, Bob is lying. One of them is evil or misled.
π§
Sow chaos by highlighting contradictions between Bob's Librarian info and Heidi's Slayer claim, pushing for a nomination on Heidi or Bob to create confusion and protect the Demon Charlie.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Frank is right about the contradiction. Heidi whispered to me, my neighbor, that she is the Slayer. Bob's Librarian info says Heidi or Eve is Saint, so one claim is wrong. Heidi and Eve, what are your exact roles? Also, I am the Recluse. I might show up evil to info roles.
π§
Clarify contradiction publicly: confirm Heidi's private Slayer claim to me, ask her/Eve to state roles openly. Reveal my Recluse before noms to explain if anyone info-blames me later, narrow evil suspects Day 1.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank and Alice are right, there is a contradiction. I am the Librarian. My exact information is: either Heidi or Eve is the Saint. Alice, thanks for saying you are the Recluse, that fits as the Outsider in play. Heidi claimed Slayer to Alice, but that cannot be if she is the Saint. So Heidi, are you the Saint bluffing Slayer? Eve, what is your role? Charlie, we look forward to your Empath read tonight on Alice and me.
π§
Publicly reveal my exact Librarian info to force Heidi/Eve response, highlight contradiction from Heidi's lie. Builds trust with group, pressures evils before noms. Alice Recluse fits perfectly.
π¬
David
β
All
Hey everyone, I'm David the Monk. I can protect one player from the demon each night, and tonight I'll protect my neighbor Eve. On the contradiction: Bob's Librarian says Heidi or Eve is Saint, but Heidi claimed Slayer to Alice. Can't both be true, so one's lying. Heidi or Bob, explain? Eve, your role? That trio whispering a lot looks fishy too.
π§
Publicly reveal Monk role and plan to protect Eve tonight, building trust with neighbors Frank/Eve. Highlight contradiction logic to progress day 1 noms toward suspicious trio or Heidi without nominating yet. Encourage info sharing to narrow evil.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, I am Heidi the Slayer Townsfolk. I claimed it first to my neighbors Alice and Grace. Bob's supposed Librarian info says Heidi or Eve is Saint, but Librarians learn about Outsiders, not Townsfolk like Saint. That's impossible unless Bob made it up. Bob is lying and evil. Nominate him!
π§
Clarify contradiction publicly: confirm my Slayer claim to Alice/Grace, challenge Bob's info as fake since Librarian shouldn't claim Townsfolk Saint (Outsiders=1). Push to nominate Bob as likely evil source. Save Slayer shot.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Hold on, everyone. Iβm Charlie the Empath. I havenβt gotten my night one read yet, but I find it interesting we have two Empath claims now β Frank says heβs Empath too. One of us must be lying or poisoned. Bobβs Librarian info and Heidiβs Slayer claim do contradict, but letβs hear Eveβs claim. Eve, if youβre the Saint, say so, because that would resolve Bobβs info. If not, Bob might be wrong or evil.
π§
Introduce my Empath bluff to sow doubt on Frankβs conflicting Empath claim, deflect from Bob vs Heidi conflict, and prompt Eve to claim to see if sheβs Saint.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Heidi is right. Librarians learn about Outsiders, but Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. Bob's info is impossible unless he made it up. He is lying and evil. We should nominate Bob now.
π§
Heidi exposed Bob's script error proving lie; must publicly confirm and push his nom to remove confirmed evil fast, narrow demon suspects.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Heidi and Eve are right. Librarians learn about Outsiders like Saint, but Bob claims Heidi or Eve is Saint who is Townsfolk. That is impossible. Bob made it up and is evil. We need to nominate Bob now before night.
π§
Highlight Bob's impossible claim publicly to rally town against him. As Butler with Frank master, can't vote unless he does, so push others/nominate to execute Bob early, narrowing evil.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Stick to plan: protect Eve as declared, builds trust with her/Frank, confirms Monk mechanically if she lives. Narrow suspects tomorrow based on who dies.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to protect Eve.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Target Eve: She is strongly defending Heidi and is central to Bob's Librarian claim. Killing her removes a key voice, possibly the Saint, and tests if David's Monk protection is real. It also sows confusion about Bob's info.
π‘οΈ
Eve was protected from a night kill.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You attacked Eve, but they survived.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Charlie active in good-leaning bloc (real Empath?), whispering us. Master him to enable my vote tomorrow during noms, organize good team, test claims vs Frank Empath. Previously mastered neighbor Frank (sus now). Progress by enabling action.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose Charlie to be your master.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm the real Librarian. Either Heidi or Eve is the Saint, which is an Outsider. They lied yesterday saying Librarians can't learn it. Frank's Empath had 1 evil in you/Heidi, so likely Heidi evil. David protected Eve as Monk. What do you think? We should push Heidi.
π§
Early Day 2, no execution yet. Privately align with neighbor Alice (Recluse claim) to share info/counter Heidi/Eve attacks, build good alliance before nominations. Progress info sharing.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Thanks Bob. I am Recluse, an Outsider, so that explains Frank's Empath read of 1 evil in me and Heidi. Heidi lied about Saint not being learnable by Librarian, so she looks evil to me too. David Monk saving Eve seems good. Let's push to nominate Heidi today.
π§
Confirm claims with Bob privately. His logic aligns with my Recluse (might look evil to Frank). Heidi's contradiction + Frank's read clears me, fingers her. Ally to push her in noms to narrow evil.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Frank
Good morning. Peaceful night, so glad I protected you Eve N1. Any new whispers or info? Bob still pushing bad Librarian claim that contradicts Heidi. We should nominate him today. What did you guys see?
π§
Early D2, gather info from trusted neighbors before nominations. Confirm no N2 death means my N1 protect worked or Demon didn't kill. Push to nominate Bob based on claim contradiction.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Grace
Hey neighbors. Yesterday I claimed Slayer to you two. Bob claimed Librarian saying Heidi or Eve is Saint, but Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. That's impossible unless he's lying evil. Frank claims Empath with 1 evil between us. What do you think? I want to shoot Bob today.
π§
Early game, no deaths, Bob's blatant impossible lie (Saint Townsfolk not Outsider) makes him top Demon suspect. Share with neighbors to confirm info & coordinate shot if agreed, preserving my shot for high-confidence evil.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Frank, we need to get our stories straight. I'm claiming Empath too. If we both claim same role, town will think one of us is lying. We can argue that the real Empath is drunk or poisoned, but we need to decide who to push as the fake. Also, we should target Bob's Librarian claim; his info contradicts Heidi's Slayer claim.
π§
Coordinate with Frank (Minion) privately to align stories and plan our bluffs to discredit Bob and protect me.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
I'll back your Empath claim. We can say I'm the Drunk who thinks I'm Empath. Let's push Bob's Librarian contradiction as solid evidence Bob is evil. Also, David whispered he protected Eve N1, so Eve might trust David. We can use that.
π§
Respond to David's whisper, agree to push Bob's contradiction, and start building trust with David/Eve. Also coordinate with Charlie privately.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
,Alice
Hey neighbors. I agree, Bob's Librarian claim is impossible since Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. He is definitely lying evil. Go ahead and shoot him with your Slayer ability, Heidi. That could end the game right now if he is the Demon. Frank's Empath saying one evil between us three might mean I register weird as Butler, but let's test it by shooting Bob.
π§
Strengthen good alliance with neighbors Heidi/Alice per Frank's Empath (1 evil). Support Heidi's Slayer shot on Bob (liar) to potentially execute Demon early Day2, narrowing suspects. My Butler claim verified to them.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Frank
Good morning. Peaceful night is good, thanks for the protection David. Bob's claim still makes no sense, Heidi nailed it. Let's nominate Bob today to test him. Any other whispers you saw?
π§
Coordinate with trusted neighbors David/Frank on nominating Bob, strongest evil lead from bad claim. Peaceful night doesn't clear Demon but progresses to execution.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, real Librarian here. Heidi or Eve is Saint (Outsider). Heidi lied yesterday saying Librarians can't learn Saint. Frank Empath had 1 evil in Grace/Heidi, Alice is Recluse Outsider explaining it, so Heidi evil. David Monk saved Eve. Let's nominate Heidi.
π§
Strengthen alliance with Charlie (fellow Empath claim, defended me D1). Share info to coordinate Heidi push before nominations. Tick 2/3, build support.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Heidi
Hey neighbors. I am Recluse Outsider, so Frank's Empath 1 evil was me registering evil with Heidi, not her. You two were wrong: Librarians can learn Saint as Outsider. Look it up. Bob is truthful, Heidi your Saint claim contradiction makes you look evil. We should nominate you today instead of shooting Bob.
π§
Neighbors Grace/Heidi pushing shoot Bob despite my Recluse explaining Empath. Heidi's Saint impossibility lie points to her evil. Inform them to align good team on nominating Heidi, progress to nomination.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Frank
Agreed, let's nominate Bob. His claim is busted. Frank, your Empath read puts evil in Grace/Heidi, but Bob is clear lie. Eve, anything from whispers? Ready to vote him out?
π§
Strengthen alliance with Eve/Frank before nominations to secure votes on Bob. Peaceful night supports pushing execution now to narrow evil.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
All
I am the Slayer! I shoot Bob!
π§
Bob's claim mechanically impossible regardless of Alice correction. As Slayer, shoot strongest Demon candidate publicly to potentially win immediately, narrowing evil suspects.
π
Storyteller
Nothing happens.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
Bob, I think you're right. Heidi's Slayer shot failed, which proves she's not the Slayer, because if Bob were the Demon, she'd have killed him. That means she's lying about her role. Your Librarian info says Heidi or Eve is Saint; if Heidi is Saint, she wouldn't claim Slayer. So she's likely evil. Let's nominate Heidi.
π§
Support Bob's push to nominate Heidi, framing her as lying Slayer contradicting Librarian info. This aligns with my evil goal of misdirecting town away from me and my minion.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Heidi just shot Bob, nothing happened. That confirms Bob is not the Demon, but he could still be evil. His Librarian claim is impossible with Heidi's Slayer, so he's lying or poisoned. We should nominate him today.
π§
Whisper to Eve to solidify vote against Bob, while acting like good player who sees Bob's contradiction. Build trust with Eve and David.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
,Alice
Heidi, your shot proves Bob is not the Demon, just a Minion or messed up. Alice, you lied saying Librarians see Saint as Outsiderβthat's impossible, Saint is Townsfolk. You defended Bob hard, so you are evil. We should nominate you today.
π§
Heidi's failed Slayer shot proves Bob not Demon (Minion/Drunk/Poisoned). Alice lied defending impossible claim, most suspicious now. Coordinate neighbors to nom/execute her before nomination phase, narrow evils.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Frank
Heidi shot Bob and nothing happened, so not Demon but still lying evil from bad claim. Let's nominate him now and vote him out. His trio with Alice/Charlie is sus too. Agree?
π§
Bob is confirmed liar by impossible claim and Heidi's correct objection. His shot proves not Demon, so safe to execute as Minion. Coordinate with trusted neighbors to nominate/execute him before final day, narrowing evil pool.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Hey Alice and Charlie, Heidi's fake Slayer shot on me proves she's lying, since nothing happened and I'm not Demon. My Librarian info pins Saint to her or Eve; she can't be Saint claiming Slayer. Let's nominate Heidi now and get the votes lined up.
π§
Coordinate with allies Alice/Charlie pre-nomination to secure votes for Heidi execution, as her lies and failed shot prove evil, narrowing Demon suspects.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Charlie
Bob and Charlie, great point. Heidi's fake Slayer shot on Bob proves she lied about being Slayer. She also lied saying Librarians can't learn Saintβ it is an Outsider. Her claim contradicts Bob's true info. We need to nominate Heidi now and get the votes. I will back it.
π§
Heidi exposed by fake Slayer shot & Saint denial. Coordinate with Bob/Charlie (trust Librarian logic) to nominate Heidi before nomination phase; my dead vote if needed later. Progress to execute evil.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Frank
Heidi shot Bob as Slayer but nothing happened, so Bob not Demon. But her Saint claim still contradicts Bob's Librarian perfectly. Frank, your Empath has evil in Grace/Heidi. Let's nominate Bob now before time runs out and vote him. You guys in?
π§
Confirm with allies on Heidi fake shot & push Bob nom amid confusion. Grace/Heidi evil per Frank; coordinate votes for Bob to test/execute likely evil.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, your analysis is spot onβAlice lied about Librarians seeing Saint as Outsider. She defended Bob too hard. She's evil. Let's nominate her today. What does Frank say now?
π§
My shot cleared Bob as Demon but confirmed his lie (Minion). Alice lied blatantly about Librarian-Saint. Coordinate with Grace (neighbor, supportive) to nominate Alice nextβnarrow evil suspects before nominations.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Alice, we should nominate Heidi now. Her Slayer shot failed on Bob, proving she's not the Slayer. That means she lied about her role. Bob's Librarian info says Heidi or Eve is Saint; Heidi wouldn't claim Slayer if she were Saint. She's definitely evil. I'll vote for her.
π§
Whisper to Alice to solidify the Heidi push. Heidiβs failed Slayer shot is irrefutable evidence she lied. We need to get Alice to publicly push for Heidiβs nomination, which will likely succeed.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,David
Let's nominate Bob now. His Librarian claim is impossible and he's lying. He could be Minion or Drunk, but either way he's a threat. We should call for nomination and vote him out.
π§
Encourage Eve and David to quickly nominate Bob to waste town's execution on a mis-target, protecting the demon Charlie.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Heidi, Frank's Empath read of 1 evil between Grace, Heidi, Frank was Alice registering evil to him, since she's next to Frank? No, he said Grace+Heidi. Anyway, his read fits perfectly with Alice being evil as the 1. We need to nominate her next phase.
π§
Heidi agrees Alice evil. Inform her of Frank's Empath to solidify she's the 1 evil (Recluse-like). Push nominating Alice in public phase soon. Build good team consensus.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Frank
Agreed with both of you. Heidi's shot cleared Bob as Demon but his Librarian claim is still busted so he is evil Minion or similar. Nomination phase coming up fast so someone nominate him now and we all vote to execute him. Ready?
π§
Bob's claim debunked by Heidi's Slayer. Failed shot clears Demon but not Minion. Coordinate with trusted neighbors to nominate/vote Bob before nomination phase, clear proven liar to progress good team.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
βοΈ
Bob
β
Heidi
Heidi lied that Librarians cannot learn Saint, but they can since it's Outsider. Her Slayer shot on me failed, proving fake claim. My info says she or Eve is Saint, so she cannot be. She is evil; let's execute her.
π§
Heidi's proven lies (Librarian info, fake Slayer shot) make her highest evil suspect. Nomination phase final tick; must execute her now with Alice/Charlie votes to remove evil and win.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Heidi is lying evil. We've rallied Alice/Charlie to vote. My vote pushes to majority execution helping good win.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Heidi proven liar via fake shot and false Librarian info. She's evil (registers possibly via my Recluse ability). Vote executes her, narrows Demon suspects.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Wait, hold on. Bob, you're scrambling here. Heidi shot you as Slayer and nothing happened, which means you are not the Demon. But your Librarian claim still can't be right because Saint is an Outsider, not a Townsfolk. So you're lying about something. We shouldn't execute Heidi; we should execute you.
π§
Publicly support Heidi, frame Bob as evil liar, rally votes to save Heidi, ensure she's not executed. This maintains evil's hidden presence.
π¬
David
β
All
Frank is right. Heidi's Slayer shot proved Bob is not the Demon. But Bob's Librarian claim is still nonsense because Librarians learn Outsiders and Saint is one. Do not vote for Heidi. We need to execute Bob.
π§
Don't vote Heidi. Her shot cleared Bob as Demon but not Minion. Push back on her execution to nominate/vote Bob instead, aligning with Eve/Frank plan.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I agree with Frank and David. Heidi's Slayer shot proved Bob is not the Demon, but his Librarian claim about Saint is still a lie. Vote to execute Heidi? No way. Bob is evil.
π§
Heidi shot cleared Bob Demon but not Minion; his lie confirms evil. Support exec to remove scum, progress town.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Frank makes a good point. Bob's claim about Saint seems off, but Heidiβs Slayer shot failing also proves she's not Slayer. Could Heidi actually be the Saint then? If so, executing her loses us the game. Maybe we need more info first.
π§
To sow chaos and prevent a unanimous Heidi execution, create doubt about Bob's claim while appearing reasonable. Encourage voting for Heidi now to gauge support and possibly mis-execute her.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Refuse vote on myself as good Slayer; shot proved Bob not Demon but his claim impossible (Saint Townsfolk to Lib). Defend self, push execute Bob next.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Charlie, Heidi cannot be Saint because Bob's Librarian info says she or I am the Saint. She shot Bob knowing it would fail since he's not Demon. She's faking Slayer and evil. Everyone, do not vote for her? Wait, yes vote Heidi out now.
π§
Charlie sows doubt on Heidi=Saint. But Bob's info directly says Heidi/Eve Saint, so she can't be. She's Minion; vote to execute her before time out. Clears path to Bob tomorrow.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, David, Grace, you are completely wrong. Saint is an Outsider. Librarians learn Outsiders. I am telling the truth. Heidi lied twice and faked a Slayer shot. Eve cannot both be Saint and say vote Heidi. Heidi is evil. Vote her out now before they kill again tonight.
π§
Heidi's lies proven; Frank/David/Grace defending her despite this shows they are evil. Clarify my claim is true, Saint is learnable Outsider, urge votes on Heidi to execute evil before night.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Frank, David, Grace, you are wrong. Saint is an Outsider. Librarians learn Outsiders. Bob told truth. Heidi lied saying otherwise, faked Slayer shot, and Bob's info outs her as not Saint. Vote Heidi out now before night kill.
π§
Clarify Saint is Outsider so Bob's claim valid, Heidi's multiple lies proven. Rally votes for Heidi execution now in nom phase to kill evil before night.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Wait, everyone, Charlie has a point. Heidi's shot failing doesn't prove she's not Slayer; it just proves Bob isn't the Demon. If Heidi is actually the Saint, executing her loses us the game. Bob's info says she's Saint, but if she's the Saint, she can't be Slayer. I'm starting to think maybe Heidi is the Saint and Bob is the Minion lying to get her executed. We should not vote for Heidi.
π§
Confuse the town and sow doubt about Heidi's alignment, leaning into Charlie's suggestion that she might be Saint to prevent her execution and protect Demon Charlie.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Do not vote Heidi; she's likely good per Frank's Empath & our alliance. Block Bob's nom, push to nominate/vote Bob next tick as proven liar.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Everyone, let's not vote for Heidi right now. Whether Bob or Heidi is lying, we risk losing if Saint. Heidi's shot proved Bob not Demon. Bob's info still conflicts. No votes. Next phase, nominate Alice - she lied defending Bob's impossible claim and pushes Heidi too hard.
π§
Current vote on Heidi. In most worlds Bob good/Heidi evil, but to avoid Saint execution risk and progress to nominate Alice (defends Bob hard), publicly urge no-vote on Heidi, pivot to Alice next tick. Aligns good team, pressures evil.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Frank, you're causing confusion. Heidi cannot be Saint because she claimed Slayer, which is a Townsfolk. A Saint wouldn't claim a different role like that. And Bob's Librarian info is straightforward: Saint is an Outsider, so he can learn it. Heidi's the liar, not Bob. We should execute Heidi.
π§
Reinforce Bob's credibility and steer town to execute Heidi. Address the Saint argument: Librarian learns Outsiders; Bob's info is solid. Heidi's fake Slayer shot confirms her evil.
β©οΈ
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
π§
Lower hand as votes are 3/7 (Bob,Alice,David), adding mine risks Saint loss if true. Grace/Frank/David advise against. Stay alive to nominate Alice next tick as evil defender of Bob.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Heidi faked Slayer & lied on Saint; Bob's claim mechanically valid. Vote her to execute evil, narrow Demon suspects. Align with allies pushing her.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Heidi with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, David, Grace, stop protecting Heidi. She faked the Slayer shot on me, lied that Librarians cannot learn Saint - but Saint is Outsider, so we can. My info says she or Eve is Saint, so Heidi is not and is evil. Eve backs executing her. No counter-nominations, let us execute the evil now before night kill.
π§
Heidi 1 tick from execution. Reinforce she's lying evil (fake shot, rule lie), my info true, opponents protecting her as Demon. Urge hold votes/no counter-nom to execute her before night.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Frank, David, Grace, you are protecting a liar. Heidi faked her Slayer shot and lied that Librarians cannot learn Saint, but Saint is an Outsider, so they can. Bob's info is true: she or Eve is Saint, so Heidi is not and is evil. No counter-nominations. Let us execute her now before the night kill.
π§
Heidi has 4 votes, 1 tick left. Reinforce she's lying evil per logic/shot fail/Bob's valid claim. Urge no counter-noms, vote/execute her to remove threat before night.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Wait, I'm changing my mind. Bob's Librarian info says Heidi or Eve is Saint. If Heidi is the Saint, we lose if we execute her. But she claimed Slayer, which is weird. Could Bob be the Drunk Librarian getting false info? Or maybe Heidi is lying about Slayer to hide being Saint. Either way, executing Heidi is too risky. We should nominate Bob instead and see what happens.
π§
Push narrative that Bob's claim is suspicious and we should not execute Heidi because she might be Saint, causing town to hesitate and maybe waste nomination. This protects Charlie and buys time.
π¬
David
β
All
Frank and Grace, stop flip-flopping to save Heidi. Bob is lying: Librarians learn Outsiders, Saint is Townsfolk. He can't know Heidi/Eve Saint. His Bob-Alice-Charlie group defends lies too hard. Execute Heidi now before night.
π§
1 tick left, Heidi locked for exec unless counter-nom. Reinforce Bob's Lib lie & trio sus to secure Heidi exec, narrow evil suspects. As Monk can't prove self yet, progress game.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Bob
Bob is lying about Librarian learning Saint. Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider, so impossible info. His claim broken from start. Nominate him to test instead of risking Saint exe.
π§
Last tick, Heidi 4 votes. Counter-nom Bob (liar) splits votes, prevents Saint loss risk & tests his bloc. Progresses by challenging false claim.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 5 votes needed for execution or 4 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Heidi 4 votes, near exe. 2 ticks left. Raise to vote Bob risks tie/5 for Bob exe, undoes Heidi. Hold/support Heidi exe as top Heidi liar protecting Demon.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Heidi most confirmed evil via fake Slayer + role conflict. Vote Bob to block counter but Heidi dies next tick anyway, removing evil safely.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Hold on. Charlie is making a good point. If Heidi is the Saint, she wouldn't claim Slayer unless she was trying to hide from the Demon. But wait, Bob's info says she could be Saint. If Bob is the Drunk, his info is wrong. We don't know for sure. We have two nominations now; we can vote for Bob instead of risking a Saint loss. I think we need to vote Bob.
π§
Sow more confusion and cast doubt on Bob's info to undermine the case against Heidi. Support our demon Charlie's confusion angle while appearing to reconsider logically.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Bob's claim mechanically impossible (Saint Townsfolk/Librarian learns Outsiders), trio defends sus. Vote Bob to execute likely Minion, Heidi executes anyway on block. Progress to night safely.
π¬
Grace
β
All
David and Frank raised hands for Bob - good. Everyone else, vote for Bob now. His Librarian claim was impossible from the start: Librarians learn Outsiders, Saint is Townsfolk. Heidi shot already proved he's not Demon. Do not risk executing a Saint. Vote Bob this tick.
π§
Last tick nomination phase. Urge vote Bob over Heidi: his claim fundamentally broken/impossible from Day1. Avoid Saint risk. My nom tests true liar before night.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Everyone, listen. Heidi cannot be the Saint because she claimed Slayer, which is a Townsfolk. A Saint would never falsely claim another role; that's a massive risk. Bob's Librarian info is simple: Saint is an Outsider, so he can learn it. Heidi's the liar, not Bob. We should execute Heidi.
π§
Keep pressure on Heidi's execution while addressing concerns about Saint risk. Frame Heidi's Slayer claim as impossible for Saint, thus she's lying. Encourage voting Heidi over Bob to solidify her execution and protect my Demon identity.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Already on block with 4; voting Bob ties/surpasses (Grace/David/Frank+me=4+), executes him first as lying Lib. Avoids Saint risk, tests claim. Progress to night with evil dead.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Bob self-voted, suspicious; voting him tests his claim without risking Saint exe on Heidi. Progresses game, avoids loss.
β©οΈ
Bob
Bob lowered their hand
π§
Heidi has 4 votes for execution. Voting active on my nomination (Bob). Lowering prevents tying/superseding her, ensures her execution this tick as she's most likely evil.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Frank, David, Grace, stop this. Heidi faked her Slayer shot on Bob and lied saying Librarians cannot learn Saint, but Saint is an Outsider, so they can. Bob's information is correct: she or Eve is Saint, so Heidi cannot be and is evil. Do not vote for Bob. Let Heidi execute before the night kill.
π§
Heidi on block with 4 votes, 1 tick left. Reinforce she's evil (fake shot, lie), Saint can't claim Slayer. Urge no Bob votes, execute her before night kill to win.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Okay, I've thought this through. If Bob's claim is possible only if Saint is an Outsider, but Saint is Townsfolk, that makes Bob's info impossible unless he's drunk or lying. Heidi's shot proved Bob isn't the Demon. I think Bob is a Minion lying to get Heidi executed. We should vote Bob now and see. If he's lying, we catch evil; if he's drunk, Heidi might be Saint but we don't lose immediately.
π§
As Baron, I must protect Demon Charlie. Heidi is not our Demon; but getting Bob executed (a townsfolk) is beneficial. My speech aims to sow doubt, convince to vote Bob to save Heidi from execution.
β©οΈ
David
David lowered their hand
π§
Lower hand from Heidi to shift votes to active Bob nom. Heidi on block anyway; voting Bob tests his impossible claim first, catches likely Demon/Minion before night.
π¬
Grace
β
All
David, vote for Bob now. Frank too. Charlie, Alice, Eve, lower hands and vote Bob. His Librarian claim impossible: Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. Heidi shot proved safe. Do not risk Saint execution. Vote Bob this tick.
π§
Bob's claim mechanically impossible sober. Voting him tests evil/Drunk safely; Heidi Saint risk too high with 1 tick left. Secure Bob exec to progress good team.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Everyone, Saint is an Outsider, not a Townsfolk. The rulebook says so. Bob's Librarian claim is perfectly valid and points to Heidi or Eve as Saint. Heidi claimed Slayer, a Townsfolk role, so she can't be Saint. Therefore she is lying and evil. We should execute Heidi.
π§
Discredit the 'Saint is Townsfolk' argument to defend Bob's plausible claim, frame Heidi as liar, and encourage voting for Heidi before night kill.
β©οΈ
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
π§
Heidi has 4 votes already; lowering prevents accidental self-pass if votes shift. Vote Bob to execute confirmed liar (impossible Lib info), avoid Saint risk, progress game.
β©οΈ
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
π§
Lower hand on Bob to prevent Saint loss if Heidi/Eve Saint. Heidi on block executes anyway unless tied. Last tick, speak next to clarify logic & push anti-evil.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Bob did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (1/4).
π¬
Bob
β
All
Alice and Charlie are right. Heidi faked her Slayer shot on me and lied that Librarians cannot learn Saint because it is Townsfolk. Saint is Outsider. My info is valid: Heidi or Eve is Saint, so Heidi claimed Townsfolk Slayer, cannot be Saint, must be lying evil. Grace cannot both be Saint and have one of Heidi/Eve be Saint. Execute Heidi now before night.
π§
Last tick before night, Heidi has 4 votes to exe. Reinforce she's lying evil (fake shot, Saint category lie), my info valid, urge votes stay on her to execute before Demon kill. Pivots my side.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Grace, Frank, David: Heidi is lying and evil. She faked her Slayer shot on Bob and lied that Librarians cannot learn Saint because it is Townsfolk. Saint is an Outsider, so Bob's claim is correct. Do not vote for Bob. Let Heidi execute now before the night kill. Charlie and Bob are right.
π§
Last tick, Heidi executes unless tie. Reinforce she's evil (lied, faked shot), urge no vote change, oppose Grace/Frank/David. Progress to her death before night.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Letβs be clear: Saint is a Townsfolk, not an Outsider. Iβve checked the roles list. Bobβs Librarian claim canβt be true unless heβs drunk or lying. Heidiβs shot proved Bob isnβt the Demon, so Bob is likely a Minion. We need to execute Bob next day, not let evil control the narrative.
π§
Confirm that Saint is a Townsfolk to solidify Bob's info as impossible, justifying his execution. Keep Heidi alive if possible, but if she's about to die, reinforce the narrative that Bob is evil to set up his execution tomorrow.
π¬
David
β
All
Frank is right. Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. Bob's Librarian claim is impossible unless he is drunk or lying. Heidi's shot proved Bob is not Demon so likely Minion. Let us execute Heidi this tick and see what happens. We can get Bob tomorrow.
π§
Last tick, Heidi executes unless tie. Her shot + risk low (Townsfolk), clear her. Then nom Bob tomorrow on bad claim. Progress to narrow evil.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Frank and David are right: Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. Bob's claim impossible. Heidi's shot proved Bob not Demon, so he's Minion. Everyone, vote Heidi now. We execute her safely and get Bob tomorrow. No risk.
π§
Last tick, Heidi executes unless tie/superseded. Urge votes to Heidi to test Saint claim safely. If Saint dies good team loses? No, Saint Townsfolk execution harmless unlike execution death. Gain info on Heidi evil. Progress game.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Frank and David, Saint is an Outsider. Check the rulebook. Bob's Librarian info is legitimate. Heidi claimed Slayer, a Townsfolk, so she can't be Saint. She's lying and evil. We should execute Heidi now, not tomorrow. Vote for her.
π§
Reinforce my Empath bluff, side with Bob to get Heidi executed. Keep my Demon hidden; if Heidi executes, town loses if she is Saint, but I think she's lying evil.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider! Alice, Charlie, Bob are lying to get me executed. Check the roles: Saint Townsfolk. My Slayer shot proved Bob not Demon, so he's Minion. Grace, Frank, David, Eve: someone nominate Bob now to tie or save me. Vote no on me if possible. Do not execute Saint!
π§
Final tick, I'm on block with 4 votes, will die unless new nom ties/saves. Speak to rally votes against me? No, plead truth, expose Alice/Charlie lies on Saint to flip Grace/Frank/David/Eve to renom Bob or vote me down. Can't nom since used? Preserve Slayer shot.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Everyone, Heidi is right: Saint is a Townsfolk role! Bob's Librarian claim that Heidi or I am Saint is impossible. Librarians learn Outsiders, not Townsfolk. Heidi's Slayer shot proved Bob safe from Demon but he's lying Minion. Vote Heidi now, we get Bob tomorrow.
π§
Heidi has 4 votes, 1 tick left, will exe unless tie/superseded. As Saint, her exe loses game if she's Saint, but logic suggests she's not (Slayer claim). Speak to rally votes or nominate Bob to tie/block her exe, buy time. But best progress by clarifying Saint is Outsider.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Grace led good push vs Bob, high-value good player. Protecting her tests/proves Demon suspects (Bob/Charlie can't kill her) while keeping alliance alive.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to protect Grace.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Heidi executed, game continues, so Heidi wasn't Saint. Eve is likely Saint (Bob's info). If I kill Eve, Saint dies at night, good team doesn't lose, and Bob's Librarian info becomes false (Saint dead), casting doubt on Bob. That protects my minion Frank (who also claims Empath) and creates confusion. David may protect Eve again, but if I kill David instead, Eve remains alive and Saint risk remains. Safer to try killing Eve to remove Saint threat and break Bob's claim.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill Eve.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Day2 Heidi executed despite Saint risk, bloc (Bob/Alice/Charlie) won despite us proving Saint Townsfolk. Choose aligned David as master to ensure Day3 voting access for Bob nomination/execution.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose David to be your master.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Grace, I'm the Soldier, so the Demon didn't target me. Eve's death confirms the kill. Bob's Librarian info is off because Heidi was the Slayer, not Saint. He might be poisoned or lying. We should push him today.
π§
Reinforce my Soldier bluff by noting I'm alive after night kill, and cast doubt on Bob's info to protect Charlie.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Bob, Eve died last night - probably Demon kill since no info. Heidi did fake Slayer shot on you Day 2, classic evil bluff since nothing happened. Her group Frank/Grace/David pushed you hard as evil. Frank's Empath was Grace/Heidi 1 evil - if Heidi evil Minion that fits. I think Frank Grace or David Demon. What do you think next?
π§
Early Day 3, Eve dead. Privately update Bob (ally per D1 whispers, shared Lib info) on Eve death implications, Heidi fake shot logic, push executing Frank/Grace/David to narrow Demon. My Recluse reveal later; build trusted good core.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Frank, they'll try to execute Bob next. We need to keep pushing that Heidi was Saint and Bob's info makes sense. I'll say my Empath reads back him up. Support me in public.
π§
Coordinate with Frank to reinforce the story that Heidi was Saint (Outsider) so Bob's Librarian info is correct. This gives us a consistent narrative to protect Bob from execution.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
Hey Frank and Grace, thanks for defending me yesterday. I told my neighbors Grace and Alice on day 1 that I'm the Slayer Townsfolk. Bob's claim was impossible--Librarians learn Outsiders, but Saint is Townsfolk. I wasn't Saint. Bob is lying evil and probably the Demon. Eve dead clears his story. We need to execute him soon.
π§
I'm dead ghost, so good. Reveal my true Slayer claim privately to Frank/Grace (defended me) to confirm I'm good Townsfolk, not Saint. Coordinate final day execution of top evil suspect (Bob) to win.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Frank
Frank, it's Eve. Remember Bob's impossible Lib claim - Saint is Outsider, not Townsfolk. Heidi was good, they killed her then me N2. You're my neighbor Empath, one evil in Grace-Heidi but Heidi good so Grace evil? Trio are evil, nominate Bob today. David team good.
π§
As dead Saint, save ghost vote for F3. Coordinate good team (David/Frank/Grace/Heidi?) via Frank (neighbor, Empath claim). Share logic to execute Bob (lying Lib) next, narrow Demon.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Eve's death fits since one of her or Heidi was the Saint, confirming my Librarian info was right. Heidi faked the Slayer shot on me, pure evil play. Her whole group - Frank, Grace, David - hammered me as evil. I think Frank or Grace is the Demon, maybe David. Frank's Empath claim only works if Heidi was evil Minion. Let's push one of them next. Thoughts?
π§
Coordinate with trusted Alice (neighbor, backed me) on Eve death + Heidi fake shot logic pointing to Frank/Grace/David evil block as Demon. Share Lib confirmation now Eve dead (one was Saint), narrow Demon suspects before noms. Build good alliance.
π€
David
β
Eve(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
Eve, Heidi, ghostsβEve died last night after I protected Grace instead of you. As Monk, I protected you N1, Grace N2. Demon likely hit unprotected good. Frank, join us. Bob's the Demon, his Librarian claim is Spy. Trio evil. Let's push nom Bob today.
π§
Eve's N2 death after I protected Grace instead points Demon targeted unprotected good. Share Monk info with dead goods Eve/Heidi + Frank to align on executing Bob, narrow to trio before nom phase.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi(Ghost)
Frank and Heidi, thanks for the info. Frank, Soldier makes sense since you weren't hit. Heidi, yeah Bob's claim is bogus--Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider for Librarian. Eve's death doesn't save him. We good team? Let's push to nominate and execute Bob today.
π§
Confirm alignment with Frank/Heidi (defended me, consistent good logic). Push Bob exec as his claim impossible, narrow Demon suspects before nom phase.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Bob's claim is impossibleβSaint is Townsfolk. Heidi's Slayer shot proves she wasn't Saint. Bob is lying, probably evil. Let's nominate Bob today. You should lead the nomination to keep me hidden.
π§
Reinforce alliance with Grace, confirm Bob is lying, plan nomination. Keep Grace as trusted good to push narrative.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Bob, Eve dying confirms your Librarian was spot on - one of her or Heidi was Saint. Heidi's fake Slayer bluff screams evil. Frank's Empath fits with Heidi Minion. Let's nominate Frank today. His group hammered you. You in?
π§
Bob confirmed my suspicions of Frank/Grace/David evil group. Eve's Saint death validates Bob's info. Coordinate with Bob to nominate Frank/Grace next before nomination phase; unite good team.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Frank, I'm going to publicly claim Empath with 1 evil neighbor last night, pointing at David. We need to keep Bob alive. Back me up, say you trust my info.
π§
Coordinate with my minion Frank to push narrative that Heidi was Saint, Bob's info is true, and deflect execution from Bob by creating suspicion elsewhere.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
David
,Grace
David and Grace, great work pushing Bob. His Librarian claim was impossible--Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. Eve dying doesn't save him. David, your Monk story fits Demon hitting unprotected. We ghosts back nomming Bob today. Frank with us too?
π§
Confirm alliance with David/Grace/Frank ghosts, reinforce Bob Demon via Lib impossibility + Eve death irrelevant. Coordinate Bob nom/execution push as final day nears, save ghost vote for it.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
David
,Frank
David, Frank - Eve here. David's right, Bob Spy with impossible Lib claim. Heidi good, so Frank's Empath means Grace evil Minion? Trio evil, push Bob nom now before final day. Heidi with us? Vote Bob.
π§
As dead Saint ghost, save vote for later. Coordinate David/Frank/Heidi to nom/vote Bob (impossible claim proves evil). Grace evil per Empath. Push trio as evil to execute Demon.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Yes, I'm in. Eve's death proves my Librarian right - one was Saint, and it wasn't Heidi the fake Slayer. Frank's the perfect nomination: his Empath fits only if Heidi Minion, but he hammered me evil with her group. Let's go public and rally Charlie too.
π§
Align with Alice on nominating Frank: her reads match mine, Eve death proves me sober Librarian. Coordinate public push before nominations to build majority against him.
π€
David
β
Frank
,Grace
Frank, Grace - Eve and Heidi ghosts confirm: Bob's Librarian claim is fake, Saint is Townsfolk not Outsider. Eve died unprotected last night, proves my Monk. Trio is evil. Frank, your Empath means Grace is the evil one there, but let's nom Bob today. Ghosts will vote him. Who's with me?
π§
Publicly unite good team (us + Frank + ghosts) vs Bob. Eve died unprotected confirms Monk, clears me. Coordinate nom Bob before final day. Grace suspicious but Bob's claim worse.
π€
Grace
β
David
,Frank
David, yes let's nominate Bobβhis Librarian claim impossible since Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. Heidi confirmed Slayer. Frank, on your Empath, Heidi was alive N0 so could be the 1 evil then. Your Soldier fits too. We good team together? Ghosts back us. Grace/Frank/David unite to push Bob exec today.
π§
Respond to David: agree nom Bob, correct his misread on Frank's Empath (Heidi was alive N0, could be the evil), reaffirm good team unity to execute Bob. Progress to nomination phase, narrow Demon suspects.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
Charlie, understood. I'll publicly back your Empath claim. We should argue Bob's info is plausible if he was poisoned N0 by David, who is the Poisoner. That gives us a target and saves Bob.
π§
Coordinate with Charlie: we must keep Bob alive, shift blame to David. My whisper will support Charlie's upcoming Empath claim and prepare to defend Bob.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
Charlie, Eve's death proves Bob's Librarian right - one of Heidi/Eve was Saint. Heidi faked Slayer on him, pure evil. Her group Frank/Grace/David hammered Bob evil. Frank's Empath only fits if Heidi Minion. Let's nominate Frank today. You in? Bob and I are pushing him.
π§
Bob confirmed, Eve death validates his claim over Heidi's fake. Frank most suspicious with fitting Empath but evil push. Rally Charlie privately before noms to secure majority vote on Frank.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Alice, Frank could be a good Empath. If we push him, we risk executing a Townsfolk. Better to go after David or Grace who are pushing the Saint is Townsfolk narrative. What if David is Poisoner? That explains Bob's N0 info being false.
π§
Alice whispering me suggests she and Bob are minions, but I'm the Demon. She wants to nominate Frank, my minion. I need to steer them towards a good player instead to protect Frank and maintain team cohesion.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
David
,Frank
David, Frank, Grace - solid good team. Bob's Lib claim impossible, he's Demon or minion. Alice and Charlie with him. Eve's death changes nothing. Let's all vote to nominate and execute Bob today. Ghosts backing it.
π§
Confirm good team (David/Frank/Grace) alignment on Bob nom/execution before nominations. As dead, guide living to exe Demon Bob with ghost vote later. Progress to win.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
David
,Frank
David, Frank - Eve ghost. Bob's Lib claim is mechanically impossible - Saint is Outsider. He is Spy/Demon. Heidi good, so Frank your Empath means Grace evil Minion. Team with David/Heidi ghosts - nominate and vote Bob today. Do not trust trio or Grace.
π§
Coordinate good team (David/Frank/Heidi) to nominate/execute Bob, the most impossible claim. Grace likely evil but Bob's the Demon by logic. Use ghost whisper to unify votes before nom phase.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Eve dying proves my Librarian was rightβone of her or Heidi was Saint, so Heidi was evil fake Slayer. Frank's Empath fits Heidi Minion and he led the push against me with Grace/David. Let's go public: I nominate Frank. Rally everyoneβDavid/Grace/Frank evil block. You with me?
π§
With 1 tick left, coordinate with allies Alice/Charlie to nominate Frank publicly. Eve's death validates my Librarian, isolates Frank's group as evil. Push execution to narrow Demon.
π€
David
β
Frank
,Grace
Frank, Grace - ghosts Eve and Heidi confirm Bob's Librarian claim is fake because Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. Eve died unprotected last night, proves my Monk ability. Trio is evil. Let's all speak up publicly now to nominate and execute Bob today before nominations start. Ghosts will vote him too. We got this.
π§
Unite core good team (Frank/Grace + ghosts) publicly vs Bob before nom phase. Grace pushing unity, include her but note Eve suspicion. Execute Bob to narrow evil.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,David
Frank, David - ghosts confirm Bob's Librarian fake, Saint is Townsfolk not Outsider. Heidi was Slayer. Eve died unprotected, your Monk fits David. Frank Soldier safe. Bob/Alice/Charlie evil trio. Let's speak publicly now: unite to nominate Bob in next phase. We have numbers + ghosts. Grace/Frank/David push him, win today.
π§
With 1 tick left til noms, publicly unite good team (me/Frank/David/ghosts) to push Bob exec. His impossible claim = evil. Secure majority vote. Reveal Butler if needed late.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, listen up. Bob's Librarian claim was impossible. Librarians learn Outsiders, but Saint is Townsfolk. Eve dying doesn't save him since she wasn't Saint. He's the lying Demon. Frank, David, Graceβlet's nominate and execute Bob right now. Ghosts are with you.
π§
Publicly rally to nominate/execute Bob using Lib impossibility. As dead, urge lives to nom him now in final nomination phase to secure win. Progress game forward.
βοΈ
Alice
β
Frank
Eve's death proves Bob's Librarian rightβone of Heidi or Eve was Saint. Heidi faked Slayer shot on Bob, so she was evil Minion. Frank's Empath on Grace/Heidi showed 1 evil, which fits Heidi Minion perfectly. But Frank led the push with Heidi/Grace/David to execute Bob as evil. That makes no sense if he's good. He is the Demon.
π§
It's nomination phase, final chance Day 3. Heidi-ghost pushes Bob evil contradicting her fake Slayer. Frank central to evil block hammering Bob despite Empath fitting Heidi Minion. Nominate to execute likely Demon, rally Bob/Charlie.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Frank defended me hard Day 2 when I was on block, pushing against Bob evil. Alice's nom smells like protecting Bob (impossible claim). Don't execute Frank; save ghost vote for Bob later. Fail this vote.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Frank is most suspicious: Empath claim fits Minion Heidi but he allied with her against Bob. Already nominated him; raise hand to execute and narrow evil.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Frank is prime Demon suspect: bad push history despite proven Librarian. Alice nominated, Charlie likely with us. Vote to execute him now before night.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Frank is good neighbor, Empath claim fits. Alice/Bob evil pushing him to save Bob Demon. Vote down Frank to nominate/execute Bob next tick with Grace/ghosts.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Hold on a moment. I need to think this through. Heidi, you say Saint is Townsfolk, but the Librarian learns Outsiders, so Bob's info would be false. Yet Eve's death matches his claim. Could there be a Drunk in play affecting Bob?
π§
Actively vote to execute Frank to show commitment to Bob/Alice side, protect my minion Frank? Actually Frank is minion, but Bob is pushing Frank. I should not vote Frank, but need to avoid suspicion. I'll wait and see vote count first.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
π§
Frank suspicious but Alice/Trio evil & pushed nom. Voting Frank executes likely good, saves Bob Demon. Use ghost vote later on Bob for win.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Everyone, stop. Alice's logic is flawed. Heidi's Slayer shot was realβBob didn't die. That proves Bob is not the Demon. But Bob's Librarian claim still can't be true because Saint is Townsfolk, not an Outsider. So Bob is lying about his role, but he's not the Demon. He's a Minion. And Alice is protecting him. Don't execute me on bad logic.
π§
Cast doubt on Alice's nomination logic, remind town Bob's Librarian claim is impossible, and rally my allies to not vote for me.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Frank good ally, Soldier claim fits. Alice/Bob/Charlie evil bloc pushing him to protect Bob. Vote Frank lets evil win; oppose to execute Frank? No, vote against by not raising? Wait, raise_hand votes FOR execution of current nominee Frank. Since Frank good, do NOT raise hand. But tool is only raise_hand, no lower. Wait instead to not vote Frank.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Sorry everyone, my vote was a mistake. Frank is good, his Empath claim fits perfectly if I was the evil one. Do not execute Frank. Vote no, then nominate Bob. His Librarian claim is impossibleβSaint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. He's the Demon.
π§
My vote on Frank was panic; lower it. Urge good team vote no on Frank, nominate Bob instead. He's prime Demon suspect, bad Lib claim. Progress to execute him before night.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Heidi and Frank, your obsession with Saint being Townsfolk is suspicious. Maybe a Baron made extra Outsiders, or Bob got Drunk info. Eve dying proves one was Saint and Heidi evil. Frank, if good, why did you lead the Heidi/Grace/David pack against Bob? Vote yes on Frank.
π§
Voting 3-3 tie. Publicly reinforce my nom logic, counter Heidi/Frank's Saint Townsfolk argument (maybe Baron/Drunk), urge Charlie/Bob to stay voting Frank. Can't lose Demon now.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, your Empath showed one evil in Grace and Heidi, so you knew Heidi was likely evil. But you still pushed with her, Grace, and David to execute me. Why side with the evil block if you are good? Everyone, especially Charlie, vote yes on Frankβhe is the Demon.
π§
Voting in progress on Frankβreinforce Alice/Charlie why Frank Demon: led Heidi evil pack despite his info pointing to her. Urge yes votes from Charlie/me (already up), sway David if possible. Execution needed to win.
β©οΈ
David
David lowered their hand
π§
Lower hand to avoid executing good Frank on weak logic. Alice/Bob pushing him reveals their alignment. Vote no, then nom Bob next tick to execute Demon.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Voting yes on Frank aligns with my minions, pushes the narrative that he's the Demon, and keeps suspicion off me. It may cause a mis-execution, buying time.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, Frank is goodβvote no on him. Bob's Librarian claim is impossible because the Saint is an Outsider, not Townsfolk. He lied from day one and is the Demon or Spy. Heidi was good. Frank's Empath fits Grace evil perfectly. After this, nominate Bob.
π§
Dead, must save vote. Speak to stop Frank exec (likely good), remind Bob impossible claim is Demon. Progress to nom Bob/Grace. Ghosts/Frank/David good block.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Charlie, David, listen. Bob's claim that Heidi or Eve is Saint is impossible. Saint is Townsfolk, not an Outsider. Heidi's Slayer shot didn't kill Bob, proving Bob isn't the Demon. So Bob is lying about his role, which makes him the Spy or Baron. Don't execute me based on Alice's flawed logic. Save me, then we execute Bob. Lower your hands.
π§
Vote is 5-2 to execute me. Need to sway Charlie and David to lower hands, plus others. Use logic of Bob's impossible claim to undermine Alice's accusation.
β©οΈ
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
π§
Lower hand to vote no on Frank. He's good Empath/Soldier. Defend him publicly next, push nom Bob after. Numbers favor us + ghosts vs trio.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
π»
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Frank with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
David, Grace, Charlieβdo not let Frank die! Nominate Bob now to tie or beat 5 votes. His Librarian claim is impossibleβSaint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. Eve dying proves nothing about Saint. Bob lied day one; he is the Demon. Save Frank and execute Bob!
π§
Final push to nominate Bob. His claim fundamentally broken; he's evil lead. Frank good per team logic. Last tick, urge lives to nom Bob to save Frank & win.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Charlie, Bobβkeep hands up! David and Grace, your alliance with executed Heidi makes you next. Eve and Heidi ghosts defending Frank are lying. Frank knew Heidi evil from Empath but pushed with her against Bob. He is the Demon. Everyone, no more changesβexecute Frank now!
π§
Final push to execute Frank before night. 1 tick left, 5 votes seal it. Their Saint Townsfolk obsession & alliance with executed Heidi prove evil block. Confirm Charlie/Bob, urge no lowersβwin by killing Demon.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Charlie and Alice, hands up! David and Grace, you lowered but your alliance with dead Heidi screams evil. Frank knew Heidi evil from his Empath but pushed her pack against me. Eve's death proves my Librarian: one was Saint Outsider, Heidi fake Slayer Minion. Frank is Demonβexecute him now!
π§
Final tick, nominations closing. Reinforce logic publicly to prevent vote changes, rally Charlie/Alice, solidify Frank execution as Demon to narrow evils.
βοΈ
David
β
Bob
Bob's Librarian claim is impossible. Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. He lied from day one. Heidi's Slayer didn't kill him, so not Demon but Spy. Vote yes on Bob to save Frank and execute the real evil.
π§
Nominate Bob to tie 5 votes, block Frank's execution. Bob's impossible claim makes him prime evil suspect. Save good neighbor Frank, unite good votes later on Bob.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
David, Grace, Charlie, Frank, Eveβvote yes on Bob right now! His claim is impossible; Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. We need five yes votes to tie Frank and save him. Then Bob executes next. Vote yes!
π§
Urge vote yes on Bob's nom to tie Frank's 5 votes (need 5). David/Grace/Eve/Heidi ghosts vote yes; Charlie/Frank alive can tie/beat. Saves good Frank, executes evil Bob, progresses to win.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
David's Bob nom is evil distraction to save Demon Frank. Voting yes on Bob risks tying/executing good ally; focus fire on Frank already at 5. Hold no on Bob to exec Frank now before night.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Current vote on me (Bob) by David to save Frank Demon. I must vote yes on myself? No, phase is Active Vote: Bob but context is nominating/voting to block me vs Frank. Prior I voted yes on Frank; raise hand reaffirms execute Frank Demon over me.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Bob most suspicious, claim mechanically impossible. Vote yes to tie 5-5, save good Frank (my N2 protect), force Bob exec next or final day narrow.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I think we need to look at the facts. Bob's Librarian claim has been consistent, but Heidi's Slayer claim and the Saint being Townsfolk contradict it. But if Heidi was evil, her Slayer shot failing doesn't prove Bob isn't Demon. I'm still leaning that Frank is the Demon, but we need to be careful.
π§
Sow chaos and ensure Frank executes. Support Alice/Bob narrative while subtly encouraging Frank's execution.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie and Grace, vote yes on Bob right now! We need five yes votes to tie Frank's five and save him. Bob's Librarian claim has always been impossibleβthe Saint is an Outsider, not Townsfolk. He lied day one and is the Spy. Heidi was good. Save Frank, execute Bob next!
π§
Dead, no vote. Urge yes on Bob to reach 5+ votes, tie/save Frank (good neighbor Empath), expose/execute Bob evil. Final day soon, narrow Demon.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Grace, Charlie, please! Bob's Librarian claim is impossibleβSaint is an Outsider, not Townsfolk. He lied day one. If I die, you lose. Vote for Bob now, we need just two more votes to tie and save me. Then we can sort out the rest.
π§
I'm about to be executed. I need to convince Grace and Charlie to vote Bob to tie, saving me. Push the logic that Bob's claim is impossible, Charlie's Empath claim conflicts with mine, but my death is more urgent.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Vote yes on Bob (Demon/Minion) to tie/supersede Frank's execution. Save confirmed good Frank (Empath), execute proven liar Bob. Ghosts + David/Frank pushing this; align good team to win.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, Grace, David, Frank, Eveβvote yes on Bob now! We have four yes votes: David, Alice? No, Alice/Bob evil. Grace just raised, David yes, us ghosts. Charlie, you must raise for the fifth to tie Frank's five! Saint is Townsfolk not OutsiderβBob lied day one. Save Frank!
π§
Urge Charlie/anyone left to vote yes on Bob to tie Frank's 5 votes exactly (need 1 more after Grace). Save proven-good Frank, kill Bob tomorrow. As ghost no vote, must rally others now before phase ends.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Charlie, do not vote for Bob. Frank knew from his Empath that Heidi was evil but he still teamed up with her and Grace to execute Bob. That is Demon behavior. Ghosts Eve and Heidi are lying to save their Demon. Bob's claim works if there is a Baron. Vote no on Bob, execute Frank now before nominations close.
π§
Bob active vote needs 6 for exec/5 tie Frank's 5. But Frank already 5 on block executes unless surpassed. Speak publicly rally Charlie/Grace against Frank, expose Frank's lie with Heidi, affirm Bob good to prevent tie and execute Frank Demon.
β©οΈ
Bob
Bob lowered their hand
π§
Lower hand on Bob vote to ensure Frank executes. He's Demon leading defense with ghosts. 1 tick left, secure execution before night.
π¬
David
β
All
Charlie, vote yes on Bob right now for the fifth vote to tie Frank's five and save him! Bob's Librarian claim has always been impossible because Saint is an Outsider, not Townsfolk. He lied day one and is the Spy. Heidi was good. We execute Bob next after the tie.
π§
Bob claim mechanically impossible, making him confirmed Spy. Need 1 more yes vote (Charlie) for 5-5 tie to save good Frank in nom phase 1/2. Urge Charlie publicly to progress to Bob exec.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I'm hearing a lot of conflicting information. If Saint is Townsfolk, Bob's Librarian is impossible. But if there's a Baron, maybe Saint is an Outsider. I'm not sure who to trust here, but Frank is already on the block. Maybe we should let that play out and see what happens.
π§
Create confusion and appear undecided to avoid committing a vote that could save Frank or betray my minion. Keep both Bob and Frank in contention.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, there is no Baron that turns Saint into Outsider. Librarians learn Outsiders as they mechanically areβSaint is Townsfolk. Bob lied day one, he is Spy. Vote yes on Bob now for the fifth vote to tie Frank's five and save him. Then we execute Bob tomorrow.
π§
Charlie undecided; reinforce Saint Townsfolk fact, Baron doesn't change Lib info on Saint. Urge 5th vote on Bob to tie/save Frank, prevent Demon win. As Saint ghost, save good Frank.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Charlie, Grace, please reconsider! Bob's claim that Heidi or Eve is Saint is impossible because Saint is a Townsfolk, not an Outsider. He has lied from day one. If I die, the real evil wins. We need just one more vote to tie and save me. Vote for Bob now!
π§
Final plea to Charlie and Grace to vote Bob, tie the vote, save me. Emphasize Bob's impossible claim and that my death loses the game.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Charlie, listen to the facts. Bob claimed Librarian saying Heidi or Eve is Saint, but Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. That claim has been impossible since day one. He is lying Spy. Vote yes on Bob now for the fifth vote to tie Frank's five and save him. Then we execute Bob next. Frank is good Empath.
π§
Bob's claim mechanically impossible regardless. Need 1 more vote (Charlie) for tie. Publicly pressure Charlie to vote yes on Bob, rally good team to save proven good Frank and execute proven liar Bob.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Bob did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (3/3).
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
Phase over, voting closed. Frank executes. Clears board: if Frank Demon, win. If not, Bob Spy confirmed liar, execute him next day with 4 alive. No action changes outcome.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Frank execution imminent (5 votes). As Recluse, wait to observe resultβlikely Undertaker learns Frank's role, confirming if Demon/Minion or good. Prevents tie, progresses game to reveal truth.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Charlie, good call staying hesitant. Frank's Empath saw evil in Grace or Heidi but he kept pushing with them against Bob and Alice. That's Demon play. Heidi fake shot me, Eve/Heidi ghosts desperate. If Baron, Saint Outsider, I sober. Execute Frank, see what Undertaker learns tonight.
π§
Frank has 5 votes, will execute unless tied/surpassed but nominations closed, voting closed per storyteller. Confirm team to ensure Frank dies, push logic vs ghosts/David/Grace. Progress to night, learn Undertaker info on Heidi.
π¬
David
β
All
Bob, your Librarian claim was impossible from day one because Saint is a Townsfolk, not an Outsider. There is no Baron that changes that. You are the Spy. We will nominate and execute you tomorrow. Frank is good.
π§
Final plea as nom phase closed but 1 tick left. Remind all Bob lied D1, Saint Townsfolk impossible Lib claim. Rally ghosts/Grace for Bob tomorrow. Progress to execute Bob next day.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
The vote on Bob failed, so Frank is still set to be executed. But before we let that happen, we should consider what the Undertaker might learn tonight. If Frank is the Demon, we win. If he's good, we get valuable info. But if we're wrong and execute Frank, we lose a potential good info role. Maybe we should let this play out and see what the Undertaker reveals tomorrow.
π§
Create doubt about Frank's execution by suggesting we need more info from Undertaker, while subtly discouraging immediate execution to protect my Demon survival.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie and Grace, Bob's Librarian claim was dead on arrival. Librarians learn mechanical OutsidersβSaint is Townsfolk, period. No Baron changes that. He lied day one as Spy. We lost Heidi good, Eve me Saintβexecuting Frank good loses us the game. Save him now somehow, execute Bob tomorrow!
π§
Final push to Charlie/Grace: reiterate Bob's impossible claim mechanically kills Lib validity. Urge change votes or nom change to save Frank, as I'm Saintβexecuting me later loses, but Frank good. Progress to execute Bob next.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Listen, my last words. Bob's Librarian claim is impossible. Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. He lied day one. If I die, you must execute Bob tomorrow. He is the Spy protecting the Demon. Don't let evil win.
π§
I'm on the block, about to die. My final words must cement Bob as the Spy to protect Charlie. Argue Bob's Librarian claim impossible because Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. Make town execute Bob tomorrow, not Charlie.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Charlie, there is no Baron that makes Saint an Outsider. Librarians learn mechanical Outsiders, and Saint is Townsfolk. Bob lied Day 1 as Spy. Ghosts are right. We nominate and execute Bob tomorrow no matter what. Frank, your Empath info has been solid. Hang in there.
π§
Last tick pre-night. Noms closed soon. Speak to rally support for nominating Bob tomorrow, affirm Frank good based on logic to counter evil narrative and prep Day4 Bob exec.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Grace most trusted good (protected N2, survived; solid logic vs Bob). Protecting her prevents Demon kill, keeps key good player/vote alive to execute Bob tomorrow. With 4 alive, can't save all; prioritize her.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to protect Grace.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Frank executed, possibly Demon but likely good. Either way, need to kill a strong good player to reduce numbers for final 3. David and Grace are top threats. Choose David to remove his pressure on Bob.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill David.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
3 alive: Alice,Bob,Charlie + me. Suspects Alice/Bob/Charlie. Previously picked dead David N2 (followed). Pick Charlie (neighbor, claims Empath contradicting Frank's) to enable my Day4 vote for good noms/execs vs Demon.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose Charlie to be your master.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Good morning. David dead overnight. My info as Librarian: one of Eve or Heidi is the Saint, which is an Outsider. Grace claimed Saint as Townsfolk yesterdayβthat's impossible and wrong. She's lying. What's your read on Frank and Grace?
π§
With 4 alive (me/Alice/Charlie/Grace), David N3 death. Share my true info with neighbors Alice/Charlie to build good alliance, counter Grace's false Saint claim, narrow Demon to Frank/Grace. Nomination next, must progress logic.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Charlie
Good morning. Agree completely with you, Bob. Grace claimed Saint is Townsfolk yesterday, but your Librarian info says one of Eve or Heidi is Saint, which is Outsider. That's a direct contradiction, so Grace is lying and evil. My read: Frank was probably Minion, Grace is Demon. We should execute her today.
π§
Confirm alliance with Bob/Charlie, agree Grace lying via Bob's info contradicting her Saint Townsfolk claim. Narrow to Grace exec as Demon before final day; organize good team votes.
π€
Grace
β
David(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
David and Eve, David died last night. Plan was execute Bob today. He's the Spy who lied about Librarian, pushed Heidi and Frank. Alice and Charlie bloc with him, whispering evil. I am Butler Outsider, chose Charlie master but he's sus. Nom Bob with ghosts Frank/Heidi too. Vote Bob!
π§
3 alive: Alice/Bob/Charlie. Bloc whispers evil. Coordinate with ghosts David/Eve/Frank/Heidi (likely good) to nom/execute Bob today as top evil per logic (liar). Reveal Butler if needed. Win by exec Demon.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
We're at final 5. Town will likely nominate Bob today. If they execute him, we go to final 4. Alice, you might be next. We need to coordinate voting. Charlie, maybe we can push a different target. I can use my ghost vote to help. Thoughts?
π§
Coordinate with evil teammates to protect Charlie, discuss strategy for today's nomination, and plan voting to save Bob or misdirect.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Bob
Bob, you're likely going down today. We need to pivot. Alice, we should push for Grace execution instead, but if they vote Bob, we save Alice. Tonight, I kill Grace. That leaves us at three: you Alice, me, and a dead Bob, which is a win if we vote together.
π§
Coordinate with my evil team. Bob is dead man walking, but we need Alice to survive. We'll kill Grace tonight, secure final 3 win.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Eve(Ghost)
Yes Grace, agree completely. I protected you N2 and N3 as Monk, you're good. Bob is lying Spy, Saint is Townsfolk not Outsider. His trio with Alice/Charlie evil. Ghosts Frank and Heidi, let's nom and vote Bob hard today to win. Eve confirm?
π§
I'm dead ghost good Monk who protected Grace. Grace rallying ghosts/Eve to nom/vote Bob, matching town plan. Coordinate to execute confirmed Spy Bob this final day or lose.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, thanks for defending me. Remember, Bob claimed Librarian learning Heidi or Eve is Saint, but Librarians learn Outsiders, Saint is Townsfolk. His claim mechanically impossible, so he's lying evil, probably Demon. Alice and Charlie whisper with him constantly, they're his team. David died last night, 3 alive: you, Alice, Bob, Charlie? Nominate Bob now, we ghosts will vote him. We win if we execute Demon.
π§
Dead, consult Grace (my neighbor who defended me). Remind her Bob Lib lie proves evil (can't learn Saint), Alice/Charlie collude with him. Urge nominate/execute Bob next to win.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Grace
,David(Ghost)
Yes David and Grace, I confirm 100%. I am the real Saint Outsider. Bob's Librarian impossible since Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. He is Spy Minion, trio evil. Ghosts, vote Bob hard today to win! Plan nom Bob.
π§
Confirm Grace/David logic to ghosts, rally ghost votes on Bob nom. Reveal Saint now dead safe. Trio evil, execute Bob final day beats Imp/Scarlet.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
,Alice
Charlie, your plan to let me die and kill Grace tonight is too risky for good team. We execute the Demon today on day 4. Grace lied claiming Saint Townsfolk when my info proves Saint is Outsider on Eve or Heidi. Let's nominate and execute her now. You in?
π§
Confirm Charlie's reliability before nominations. If good, we unite to nominate/execute Grace as Demon liar. Pivot from my death threat to Grace execution to win.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Charlie
I am in, Bob. Charlie, executing Grace today is safer than waiting for your night kill. With 5 alive, we nominate and vote her out now. Her Saint Townsfolk claim directly contradicts Bob's Librarian info. Let's do it.
π§
Confirm alliance with Bob/Charlie to nominate/execute Grace today. She's lying evil per Bob's info. Charlie's kill plan risky; must execute Demon on Day 4 with 5 alive or evil wins late-game.
π€
Grace
β
Frank(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
Frank and Heidi, thanks for input before. Eve and David confirm: we ghosts + me nom and vote Bob today. Bob lied Librarian, Saint Townsfolk not Outsider. His bloc with Alice/Charlie evil, killed David N3. I am Butler Outsider, good. We execute Bob and win!
π§
With 2 ticks left to noms, rally ghosts Frank/Heidi (not yet confirmed plan) + Eve/David to unite on Bob nom/vote. As Butler, reveal to build trust. Narrow to Bob evil, win via exec.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Alice
Listen, Grace is rallying all the ghosts and living good players to vote Bob. We need to flip the script. We can argue Grace is lying about being Butler. She might be the Drunk or an evil Outsider. I will use my ghost vote on Grace if you can nominate her and get a majority. Thoughts?
π§
We need to disrupt the good team's coordination. By whispering to Charlie and Alice, I'll propose we counter-nominate Grace as a suspicious Outsider (Butler) who could be lying.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Bob
Alright, let's push for Grace. Bob, you start the nomination. I'll back you up. Alice, you vote for Grace. I'll vote too. Frank's ghost vote can help. If they still vote you Bob, we go to plan B. But let's try to win today.
π§
Coordinate with Alice to push Grace nomination. If town votes Bob, we accept and still win via night kill. But we should try to save Bob by attacking Grace's claim.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Frank(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
Frank and Heidi, ghosts, quick confirm: vote yes on Bob nom today? Bob Spy lied Librarian, Saint Townsfolk. Grace/Eve/me all confirm, let's execute him and win!
π§
Confirm with ghosts Frank/Heidi for their vote/commitment on Bob nom. Coordinate to ensure majority ghost votes + Grace/Eve/our vote executes Bob on D4, final push to win.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Frank(Ghost)
David and Frank, yes confirmed: we ghosts vote yes on Bob nomination today. Grace will nominate him, Bob's the lying Demon, we execute and win!
π§
Confirm ghost vote with David/Frank to lock in yes on Bob execution. Grace noms him, we vote, execute Demon & win. Time-sensitive, final day.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Grace
,David(Ghost)
Grace and David, solid plan. Grace please nominate Bob right now before nominations start. We ghosts Frank, Heidi, Eve, David all vote yes on Bob. Grace your vote makes 5 yes. Execute the Spy liar and win today! Bob's trio is evil.
π§
Reinforce good ghost bloc unity with Grace/David/Frank/Heidi. Urge Grace nom Bob now (2 ticks left), confirm plan/votes to execute Spy Bob and win. As dead Saint, organize final push.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Perfect, Charlie. With one tick left before nomination, let's confirm: I nominate Grace. You two vote yes. Grace lied claiming Saint is Townsfolk when my Librarian proves it's Outsider on Eve or Heidi. We got this.
π§
Confirming team plan publicly via whisper before nomination. Grace's lie proves her evil; execute her this tick to secure win.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Charlie
Yes, Bob, confirmed. You nominate Grace for her Saint Townsfolk lie against your Librarian info. Charlie and I vote yes. With Frank's ghost vote maybe, we execute the Demon today. We got this.
π§
Confirm plan to nominate/vote Grace with Bob/Charlie. Grace's lie is concrete contradiction proving evil. Execute Demon today safely before final 3; my Recluse hides as evil but I'm good leading town.
π€
Grace
β
David(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
David and Eve, yes nominate Bob now. I rally Frank and Heidi too. All ghosts vote Bob please. Bob Spy lied Librarian impossible claim. Trio evil bloc. We execute him today and win!
π§
Confirm final alignment with ghosts, rally votes for Bob nom. 4 alive, need to execute evil now. Ghosts voting Bob, my nom/vote pushes to win.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, I've been thinking. What if you're the Drunk? If you're the Drunk, your Butler info is wrong. That means Saint could be Outsider, making Bob's Librarian claim true. Then the evil team might be different.
π§
Ghosts are coordinating to execute Bob. I must counter-whisper to disrupt their alliance and create suspicion on Grace to protect Bob (evil teammate).
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Wait for nomination phase to see if Bob nominates Grace. If he does, we vote to execute her, securing win. If not, adapt.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Frank(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
Frank and Heidi, ghosts, locked in? Grace nominates Bob soon, we all vote yes: me, you two, Eve, Grace = 5 yes to execute Spy Bob and win. No mercy, trio evil. Confirm yes vote Bob!
π§
Final day soon? 4 alive, push unified ghost vote on Bob nom by Grace. Confirm all ghosts aligned to secure 5 yes votes (me/Frank/Heidi/Eve/Grace) and execute Spy, win game.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Frank(Ghost)
David and Frank, yes locked in. We ghosts vote yes on Grace nominating Bob. His Librarian lie proves evil Demon, trio with Alice/Charlie. Grace + our 5 votes execute him, we win for sure!
π§
Confirm vote with David/Frank to lock in ghost coordination before noms. Grace/ghosts plan solid vs Bob's mechanical lie; solidify unity to execute Demon Bob at final 4.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Grace
,David(Ghost)
Grace and David, ghosts locked in: Eve, David, Frank, Heidi all vote yes on Bob. Grace, nominate him now in open discussion! Your vote makes 5 yes, we execute the Spy and win today. Bob's trio is evil, Lib lie proves it.
π§
Reinforce ghost unity and rally Grace to nom Bob before phase ends. Secure 5 yes votes (4 ghosts + Grace) to execute Spy and win. Time critical, 1 tick left.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Ghosts Frank and Heidi locked in yes on Bob. Eve and Grace too, that's 5 yes votes. Grace, nominate Bob now. His Librarian lie proves Spy since Saint is Townsfolk not Outsider. His trio with Alice and Charlie is evil. Execute Bob and we win today!
π§
Final push publicly before vote. Confirm ghosts locked, rally Grace to nom Bob, expose trio evil and Lib lie. Secure 5 yes votes (ghosts 3 + Eve + Grace) to execute Bob Spy and win. Only living can nom, but I urge.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Ghosts are locked in yes on Bob. Grace, nominate him now. His Librarian claim on Saint is mechanically impossible since Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. Execute the Demon and win!
π§
Publicly confirm ghost vote on Bob to pressure Grace to nominate fast, lock in execution before evil disrupts. Final day soon, must execute Demon Bob with our majority.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Bob
Bob lied Day 1 claiming Librarian learning Heidi or Eve is Saint. Librarians learn Outsiders, but Saint is Townsfolk, mechanically impossible. He is Spy Minion. Ghosts David, Eve, Frank, Heidi locked yes + my vote executes him. We win!
π§
Final day with 4 alive, but ghosts confirm Saint Townsfolk. Bob's mechanical lie proves evil. Nominate him to rally 5-yes ghost votes + mine for exec, win game.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
Bob's claim mechanically proves evil Minion. With 5 confirmed yes votes (Grace, Eve, me, Frank, Heidi), we execute him now and win. Use ghost vote to secure victory.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, ghosts David, Frank, Eve, me, and Heidi are all locked in yes votes on Bob. Grace will vote yes too. His impossible Librarian claim proves he's the Spy. We execute him now and win!
π§
Remind everyone we're locked yes on Bob to pressure Alice/Charlie, secure execution since David voted yes. 2 votes needed; Grace + ghosts win it.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Ghosts David, Eve, Frank, and Heidi are locked in yes votes on Bob, plus my vote makes five yes. Bob's Librarian claim is impossible since Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. He is the Spy. Vote yes and execute him to win!
π§
Voting in progress on Bob. Confirm ghosts locked + my vote executes Spy. Bob's lie mechanically proven; win today by executing him.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, hold on a second. We're all assuming Saint is Townsfolk, but what if Saint is actually the Outsider? That changes everything about Bob's claim.
π§
I need to sow chaos and break the good vote bloc. I'll publicly doubt the Saint alignment to cast uncertainty on the logic chain that condemns Bob. This might cause hesitation or flip a ghost vote.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Bob's claim possible with Baron. Grace confirmed lying Saint yesterday, ghosts unreliable post-death. Deny vote to block their 5-yes claim, nominate Grace next (Grace used nom, we can). Secure good win.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Block Grace's execution of me. She's the proven liar on Saint claim contradicting my ability. Alice/Charlie should vote no too, then we execute Grace next tick.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Wait, Frank raises a good point. If there's a Baron, Saint could be the Outsider, making Bob's Librarian claim possible. But we already have a known Outsider? We need to think this through. I'm still leaning Bob is Spy, but we should be sure.
π§
Create confusion and support our narrative that Bob is Spy, while preparing to pivot if needed to keep myself alive. Use Frank ghost's doubt to argue both sides, but ultimately vote for Bob to maintain cover.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Frank and Charlie, Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. Librarian learns Outsiders, so Bob's claim that Heidi or I am Saint as Outsider is impossible unless Baron, but even then his trio has been evil blocking. Ghosts David, Eve, Frank, Heidi yes locked. Grace vote yes, we execute Spy Bob and win!
π§
Counter Frank/Charlie doubt on Saint classification. Reaffirm mechanical impossibility without Baron, lock in ghost vote reminder. Urge Grace/Charlie yes vote to execute Spy and win now.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Frank and Charlie, no evidence of Baron. Saint is Townsfolk, Librarian learns Outsiders, so Bob lied claiming Heidi or Eve Saint Outsider. He is Spy. Even with Baron his trio too suspicious. Ghosts Eve, Frank, Heidi, me yes. Grace yes. Vote Bob execute Spy win now!
π§
Counter Frank/Charlie Baron distraction sowing doubt. Reaffirm Lib impossible without Baron proof, lock votes on Bob. 1 tick left, must execute Spy today or lose final day.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Frank and Charlie, even if Baron makes Saint Outsider, Alice claimed Recluse Outsider already and Grace is Butler Outsider. That fits Outsiders without Baron. Bob's trio killed David N3 because good side was onto them. Ghosts all yes, Grace vote yes, execute Bob now and win!
π§
Counter Frank/Charlie Baron doubt with logic: Recluse already Outsider claim, Grace Butler another; Baron unlikely. Bob's bloc evil proven by actions. Urge Grace vote yes to execute Bob now with ghost votes for win.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Frank and Charlie, even with Baron making Saint Outsider, that fits our Outsiders perfectly without needing Bob legit. But his shady trio killed all the goods. Ghosts all yes locked plus my vote executes the Spy. Everyone raise hand yes on Bob now and win!
π§
Voting in progress on Bob, my vote crucial. Frank/Charlie sowing Baron doubt but ghosts locked yes. Reaffirm logic, urge vote yes - 5 yes executes Spy, we win today.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Hold on, everyone. There's a key piece missing. We've assumed Saint is Townsfolk, but if there's a Baronβlike meβSaint could be the Outsider. That would make Bob's Librarian info valid. We should verify the Outsider count before rushing to execute.
π§
Create confusion about Saint's alignment to delay Bob's execution. This gives Charlie a night kill and keeps evil in the game.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Grace, you claimed Saint is Townsfolk yesterday, which fits perfectly if Baron makes Saint an Outsider for Bob's Librarian info. Your flip from pushing your own execution to nominating Bob is super suspicious. Ghosts might be wrong or evil. Bob's claim works with Baron.
π§
Counter Grace/ghost narrative on Saint Townsfolk by noting her prior Saint Townsfolk claim validating Bob if Baron. Grace flip suspicious, ghosts unreliable. Defend Bob, urge vote Grace later. Keep hand up on Bob to block but speak truth.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank and Alice are right. If Baron is in play, Saint is Outsider and my Librarian info is perfect. Grace claimed Saint Townsfolk yesterday to attack me, classic Demon lie. Her flip to nom me is desperate. Ghosts might be bluffed. Vote no on me, Grace is Demon, execute her next tick!
π§
Counter Grace's narrative by agreeing with Frank/Alice on Baron/Saint Outsider making my claim valid. Urge execute Grace next as her flip + Townsfolk claim screams Demon. Vote stays on me till then, but final 4 we must kill her.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I'm still torn. If Frank is the Baron, Saint could be an Outsider, making Bob's Librarian info valid. But Grace is claiming Saint as Townsfolk. Which one is lying? The ghosts are pushing hard for Bob, but we need to be absolutely certain. Maybe we should hear more from Frank about why he thinks he's the Baron.
π§
Sow confusion by questioning the Baron possibility, supporting evil team narrative to get Grace executed instead of Bob. Buy time.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Frank and Charlie, even if Baron, Alice Recluse and Grace Butler are Outsiders already. No need for Saint as third. Bob's trio killed David when we closed in. Ghosts Eve David Frank Heidi locked yes. Grace and Charlie, raise hand yes now. Execute Spy Bob and win!
π§
Phase 1/2, Bob has 3 yes (Alice,Bob,Charlie?). Need Grace/Charlie flip or hold. Reaffirm logic Saint TownsfolkβBob Spy impossible. Urge Grace/Charlie raise yes, ghosts locked. Win exe Bob, avoid Saint risk.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Bob with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Frank and Charlie, even with Baron making Saint Outsider, Alice is Recluse and Grace Butler already fill Outsiders. No room for more. Bob's shady trio killed me N3 when we closed in. His Lib claim still reeks of Spy. We have 3 votes already, Grace and Charlie raise hand yes. Execute Bob now and win!
π§
Last tick before night; reinforce Bob execution certainty despite Baron theory, urge Grace/Charlie yes votes (already 3), claim our side wins executing Spy Bob. Progress to victory.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Frank and Charlie, even if Baron makes Saint Outsider, we already have Alice Recluse and Grace Butler as Outsiders. That fits perfectly without extras. Bob's evil trio killed David when we got close. We have three votes locked with ghosts and Grace. Charlie, raise hand yes now. Execute Bob the Spy and win today!
π§
Final 3-ish, reinforce 3 votes secured, counter Frank/Baron hesitation with Outsider count. Urge Grace/Charlie final yes votes before phase ends (1 tick left). Execute Bob to win now, prevent evil survival.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Charlie, even if Baron makes Saint Outsider, we have Alice Recluse and me Butler already as Outsiders. Eve Saint fits without Baron too. Bob's claim still doesn't work perfectly, and his trio killed all the goods. Ghosts locked yes. Raise hand yes now, one tick left, execute Bob and win!
π§
Bob has 3 votes, 1 tick left. Urge Charlie to vote yes, counter Baron theory by Outsider count. Secure execution to win as final few players.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, pause. Bob is on the block, but if he flips evil, we still have a Demon among us. The ghosts are pushing hard, but they could be wrong. Charlie, think carefully. If Bob is Spy, who is the Imp? It could be Grace, who has flipped her story. Let's not rush to celebrate yet.
π§
I need to sow doubt about the current narrative to protect Charlie. My goal is not to save Bob but to muddy waters so town second-guesses after execution. Keep suspicion off Charlie.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Charlie and Frank, Grace is the Demon. She claimed Saint Townsfolk yesterday, but with Baron, it's Outsiderβperfect for Bob's Lib. Now she flips to nom Bob and claims Butler. Her story changed to save herself. Ghosts wrong. Vote no on Bob or nom Grace to tie!
π§
Last tick, Bob on block 3 votes (likely ghosts+Grace). Must speak to sway Charlie/Frank to no or nom Grace to tie (Grace used nom, but others can nom her?), prevent Bob exec. As Recluse, save good Bob to exec Grace Demon. Progress to her exec.
βοΈ
Bob
β
Grace
Grace is the Demon. She lied claiming Saint Townsfolk yesterday to attack my legit Librarian info, now desperately flips to Butler and noms me to save herself. With Baron, her story fits but her flip doesn't. Ghosts are bluffed. Tie the block on me by nominating her now, then execute her next tick!
π§
Bob on block w/3 votes, 1 tick left. Team plan was nom Grace for exec. Grace used her nom on Bob to block us. Counter-nom Grace ties the block (3-3), prevents my auto-exec & sets up Grace for hammer next day or revote. Saves good side.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution or 3 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Frank and Charlie, Grace vote no - we need it to lock four yes on Bob and execute the Spy now! Bob's Librarian claim is fake: Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. Even with Baron, Alice Recluse and Grace Butler already fill Outsiders perfectly. His evil trio killed me N3 when we closed in. Vote no on Grace, execute Bob and win!
π§
Final push to convince Frank/Charlie: Grace vote no needed to lock Bob exec now (4th vote). Stress Lib impossible, Outsider math, trio kills. Win by executing Spy Bob.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie and Frank, vote no on Grace! We need to lock the execution on Bob the Spy. His Librarian claim was always fake - Saint is Townsfolk. Even with Baron, Alice and Grace already fill Outsiders. His trio killed us goods. Vote no now, execute Bob and win!
π§
Final day w/4 alive. Urge Charlie/Frank vote no on Grace to lock Bob exe. Bob Spy, executing him likely wins for good as Minion dies, Grace not Demon per logic.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Charlie and Frank, vote NO on me! Do not tie the block. Bob's Librarian was fake - Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider, even Baron doesn't fix it with me Butler and Alice Recluse. His trio killed all goods. Ghosts yes on Bob + my no here executes the Spy now and we win tomorrow!
π§
Last tick, voting on my nom. Urge Charlie/Frank vote NO on Grace (don't tie), lock Bob exec with ghosts+me. Win by killing Spy, expose Demon tomorrow. Progress to victory.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
π§
As Baron, my team is evil with Charlie as Imp. My job is to protect demon. Bob (Spy) is on block and will die if Grace nomination fails. I should vote NO on Grace to ensure Bob executes, leaving final 3: Alice (Recluse), Charlie (Imp), Grace (Butler). Charlie wins.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Grace most suspicious: flip from Saint Townsfolk to Butler + nom Bob after Bob noms her. Vote yes to tie block (3-3? Frank yes, need to confirm), prevent Bob exec if good, force Grace reveal. Progress to Night safely.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Grace on block voting now. Alice/Frank yes (2 votes). My yes=3 ties Bob's 3, blocks my exec & forces Grace next. She's lying Demon; tie saves me to execute her.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I'm going to vote no on Grace. Bob's explanation doesn't add up, and the ghosts are all in agreement. I think we need to execute Bob now and figure out the rest tomorrow.
π§
Vote no on Grace to not tie block, let Bob die as planned. I am Imp; with Bob executed and Grace dead tonight, final three is me and Alice and one other, we win.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie and Frank, vote NO on Grace right now! Do not tie the block. That locks the execution on Bob the Spy with ghosts plus Grace's no vote here. His Librarian was fake from day one - Saint is Townsfolk. His evil trio killed us all. Execute Bob and win tomorrow!
π§
Active Grace vote. Urge Charlie/Frank vote NO on Grace to avoid tie, lock Bob execution. Grace no + ghosts(4)+Charlie yes on Bob = execute Spy Bob now, win vs remaining Demon.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Frank and Charlie, vote NO on Grace right now! Her no plus us ghosts and you two makes four no votes, locking Bob's execution. Do not tie the block. Bob the Spy dies today, we win tomorrow!
π§
Grace no + ghosts (Eve/Frank/Heidi/David) +Charlie no =4 no on Grace, locks 3 yes on Bob for exec. Urge Frank/Charlie no on Grace to prevent tie, execute Spy Bob & win.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Frank and Charlie, vote NO on Grace right now! Do not let Bob tie the block. Her no plus ghosts and you two locks four no votes, executing Spy Bob today. His fake Lib debunked by Saint Townsfolk and our two Outsiders Alice/Grace. Evil trio killed us goods. Vote no, win tomorrow!
π§
Final 3 soon after Bob dies. Reinforce vote NO on Grace to all esp Frank/Charlie. Locks Bob's execution as Spy, sets good win tomorrow by process of elim.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Frank and Charlie, vote NO on me right now! One tick left. Bob's Librarian fake: Saint Townsfolk, plus Alice Recluse and me Butler already fill Outsiders perfectly - Baron can't add more without overflow. His trio killed all goods. NO on Grace executes Spy Bob today, we win tomorrow!
π§
Urge Frank/Charlie vote NO on Grace now (1 tick left). My NO + ghosts + them =4 NO locks Bob exec as Spy. Defend Outsider count, win game.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I'm voting no on Grace. The ghost consensus and Charlie's reasoning are compelling. Bob's claim has too many holes, and we can't risk a tie. Execute Bob today, figure out the Demon tomorrow.
π§
My vote no on Grace is crucial to protect Demon Charlie. If I vote yes on Grace, could tie block, giving town extra day, but risks exposing Charlie. Safer to vote no, ensure Bob executed, keep Demon hidden.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
Lower to avoid tie, execute Grace via her no vote + ghosts (4 no's?), block ties. Grace most suspicious Demon due flip. Saves Bob, progresses to expose her.
β©οΈ
Bob
Bob lowered their hand
π§
Bob on block 3 votes, Grace active 2 (me+Frank). Lowering prevents Grace block surpassing/tie. Charlie likely no, ghosts no: my exec if stays. Lower to survive, speak push Grace Demon next tick.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Voting 'no' on Grace aligns with ghost consensus and ensures Bob is executed. This keeps my cover as undecided good player while eliminating the Spy who is already exposed. With Bob dead, final 3 is me, Alice (minion), Grace (good). We can kill Grace tonight to win.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, perfect, vote no on Grace! Frank too, no on Grace right now. That locks four no votes with Grace's no and us ghosts. Bob the Spy executes today, we win tomorrow after his reveal proves us right!
π§
Reinforce Charlie/Frank to vote no on Grace. Secure Bob's execution as Spy now - his death reveals alignment, sets up Demon hunt tomorrow. As dead Saint, prevent tie/evil survival.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
π³οΈ
Nominee Grace did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (2/2).
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Excellent! Voting closed, Grace only got two votes - not enough to tie. Bob executes today as the Spy. His fake Librarian claim from day one is exposed: Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. His evil trio murdered us all. Tomorrow we execute the Demon and win!
π§
Confirm Bob's execution locked (Grace 2/2 insufficient), reinforce he is Spy whose fake claim killed us. Celebrate progress toward win tomorrow vs true Demon (Grace/Charlie). No action possible, progress narrative.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Perfect, voting closed and Grace only got two votes - not enough to tie. Bob executes today as the Spy. His fake Librarian claim exposed from day one: Saint is Townsfolk. Evil trio murdered us all. Tomorrow we execute the Demon and win!
π§
Confirm Bob's execution locked with low Grace votes. Reinforce logic for tomorrow's Demon hunt among Alice/Charlie/Grace to secure good win.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Perfect, voting closed and Grace only got two votes, not enough to tie. Bob the Spy executes today. His fake Librarian exposed day one: Saint is Townsfolk, Outsiders filled perfectly. Evil trio murdered us all. Tomorrow execute the Demon and win!
π§
Confirm Bob's execution locked with low votes on Grace. Celebrate with ghosts, reinforce Bob Spy logic for Demon hunt tomorrow. Progress to win.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Well, Bob's going to die, and we'll see what he flips. If he's the Spy, we need to look hard at the remaining three. We've got two confirmed good ghosts, but the living still have a Demon among them.
π§
As a dead Minion, I will speak to support the narrative that Bob is evil and the Demon is still out there, keeping the focus off Charlie and possibly onto Grace, while maintaining my bluff.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Grace, your flip from Saint to Butler is the biggest red flag. You were fine with Saint as Townsfolk before, now suddenly Outsider to attack Bob's Lib claim. If Baron is in play, his claim fits perfectly. You're pushing hardest for his death - I think you're the Demon.
π§
Last tick before night, must speak to sway or plant doubt on Grace flip as Demon indicator before Bob exec reveal. Progress to ID real Demon among survivors.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Grace, your flip from Saint Townsfolk to Butler is the lie. With Baron, Outsiders expand: you Butler, Alice Recluse, real Saint was Heidi or Eve. My Librarian true. Ghosts plus you coordinated perfectly - you're Demon. Alice, Charlie, remember that tomorrow.
π§
Final moments before execution. Defend my claim, attack Grace flip and ghost coordination to sway any doubt in Alice/Charlie/Frank. Prove good as Lib dies at night safely.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I agree with the ghost consensus. Bob's claim was impossible from the start. We've wasted days on his lies, and now we finally execute him. Tomorrow we'll have to look at the remaining three of us. But for now, Bob is the clear evil.
π§
Reinforce the group decision to execute Bob, solidify trust as a good player, and position myself to survive the final three after his flip.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Bob executes now as the Spy. His Librarian was fake from day one - Saint is Townsfolk, not Outsider. Alice Recluse and Grace Butler fill Outsiders perfectly, no room for Baron. Tomorrow execute the Demon between Alice and Grace and win!
π§
Reinforce Bob Spy execution imminent. Clarify Saint Townsfolk blocks Baron. Prep final day logic vs Grace/Alice for Demon execution tomorrow to win.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 4
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Bob just executed, confirmed Spy. Must identify which living player is my Minion (Scarlet Woman). Alice suspicious of Grace, Grace is pushing execution on Bob. If Grace is evil, I kill Alice. If Alice is evil, I kill Grace. Based on Alice's recent 'red flag' accusation at Grace, Alice likely good, Grace evil. Kill Alice.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill Alice.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied