Game Detail

I need to establish contact with my Demon (Heidi) to coordinate our bluffs and ensure we aren't stepping on each other's toes. I'm also testing the waters for what roles might be safe to claim.

To start gathering role claims from a neighbor, building initial trust and logic chains to identify the Demon.

Establish a private channel with my neighbor Eve to share my Undertaker role and gather her claimed role, building early trust and information network.

Share my Librarian info with Frank to build a neighbor alliance. Knowing one of Alice/Charlie is Saint is valuable for town and shouldn't be hidden from a potential Undertaker ally.

Build trust with Bob and combine town information to identify evil players.

Coordinate bluffs with my Minion, Charlie, and establish a game plan for Day 1.

Grace shared her role info with me, so reciprocating builds mutual trust. As Monk, having a trusted ally who knows my role is valuable for coordinating protection and verifying claims later.

Share my Investigator information with Bob to build trust and get his help narrowing down which of Charlie/Alice is the Scarlet Woman. Bob has been active and may have useful info from his other conversations.

Confirming my bluff to my Demon (Heidi) and explaining how I plan to use the Empath claim to manipulate the town's perception of our neighbors.

Reach out to Heidi (neighbor) to build trust and gather her role claim. Maintaining relationships with neighbors is key for Empath reads and coordinating votes.

Gather role claim from neighbor Grace to compare info and build trust. Also, share Eve's claim about Saint to see Grace's reaction and gather more data.

Share my Librarian information with my other neighbor David to build a trusted circle and gather more role claims. This helps identify potential evils and protect the Saint.

Corroborate Eve's Librarian claim with my Washerwoman info to build trust with Frank. This alliance can help us catch evil players.

I am establishing my bluff as Ravenkeeper to Alice, my neighbor, to build early trust and see what information she has.

Share Grace's Washerwoman info with David to build a trusted good-player network. Combining Investigator and Washerwoman data can help us narrow down evil players faster.

Probe Eve's claim further and share my role to build trust and gather more data. We need to see if her info aligns with other claims like Grace's Washerwoman info.

I'm establishing my Empath bluff with Bob, my neighbor, by giving him 'good' information (a 0) to build trust and a solid voting block.

Gather Bob's role claim to start building a network of trusted players and detect contradictions.

Gather Alice's role claim to test Eve's Librarian info. If Alice claims Saint, it corroborates the good chain. If she claims something else, we learn Charlie may be Saint.

Share critical cross-reference between my Librarian info and David's Investigator info. If both accurate, Alice and Charlie are both non-townsfolk - one Saint, one Scarlet Woman. This narrows the Demon hunt significantly.

Gather Alice's role claim to cross-reference with Eve's Librarian info about Alice/Charlie being Saint. More data points help identify contradictions.

I want to see how Alice responds to my Ravenkeeper claim and observe the general flow of information before making my next move.

Avoid revealing Monk to a potential minion while pressuring Alice to reciprocate information sharing.

I want to build a trusted circle with Eve to cross-reference our info. Since we both have Alice/Charlie in our data, we can work together to determine which is the evil one.

Confirming I am the Saint validates Eve's Librarian info, proving both Eve and Frank are likely good. This protects me from execution since town must not execute the Saint.

Share my Investigator findings publicly to help town. The overlap between my info and Eve's Librarian info means one of Alice/Charlie is Saint and the other is Scarlet Woman. I need to warn town about the Saint risk while suggesting we focus on finding the Demon.

Share my logical analysis of the information chains to help town make an informed decision, and highlight the critical risk of executing either Alice or Charlie without more verification.

I need to publicly confirm my Washerwoman info to support Eve's Librarian claim, which is the foundation of our logic chain. This helps town verify the information network and narrow suspects.

Nominate Charlie to test the claims. If Alice is truthful Saint, Charlie is the minion. We need to pressure Charlie to respond and gather more information before any execution vote.

Defend myself against the Scarlet Woman accusation by claiming a powerful Townsfolk role (Empath) that clears my neighbors, casting doubt on David's Investigator claim.

Multiple independent info chains (Librarian, Investigator) point to Charlie being the Minion. I am the real Saint, so Charlie cannot be Saint. Voting to execute Charlie is the logical play to remove evil.

Charlie's Empath claim is a weak deflection. A real Saint claims Saint to avoid execution; Charlie claiming Empath when supposedly the real Saint makes no sense. The logic chain strongly indicates Charlie is the Scarlet Woman. I vote to execute.

Voting now risks executing the Saint and losing immediately. Charlie's Empath claim creates doubt about the entire chain. Safer to withhold vote and gather more information before day end.

Logic chains strongly indicate Charlie is the Scarlet Woman lying about being Empath. Alice's Saint claim aligns with both Eve's info and my Washerwoman confirmation. Executing Charlie removes a minion safely.

Multiple info roles (mine, David's, Grace's) converge on Alice being Saint and Charlie being Scarlet Woman. Charlie's Empath claim contradicts the entire info chain. I vote to execute Charlie.

Charlie is being voted on and refuses to claim Saint, which a real Saint would do. The logic chain (Grace→Eve→Alice) points to Charlie as the Scarlet Woman. Voting to execute Charlie.

Try to sow doubt and prevent the execution of my Minion, Charlie, by highlighting the risk of the Saint claim.

I need to defend myself and create doubt about David's Investigator claim to prevent my execution, while also subtly pushing the 'Saint' fear.

Reinforce the logic chain showing Charlie must be the Scarlet Woman, address Heidi's safety concerns, and keep votes on Charlie.

Reinforce the logic chain that identifies Charlie as Scarlet Woman and address his Empath counter-claim. The information chain is solid: Grace -> Eve -> Alice's Saint claim -> Charlie must be minion. Charlie's Empath zero is a convenient defensive claim.

Warn town about Saint execution risk. I will not vote for Charlie because if Alice is the Scarlet Woman and Charlie is the real Saint, we lose instantly. The vote has enough hands already without me.

Frank raises a valid concern, but Charlie claiming Empath instead of Saint when execution threatens him is the strongest evidence he is NOT the Saint. A real Saint would claim Saint to save themselves. Charlie's Empath claim is a Minion bluff that conveniently clears his accuser. I should keep my hand raised.

Address Frank and Heidi's concerns. Charlie claiming Empath instead of Saint is the key evidence - a real Saint would claim Saint to save himself. I'm keeping my vote.

Address Heidi and Frank's Saint concerns. Charlie NOT claiming Saint when facing execution proves he's not the Saint. A real Saint would always claim to prevent execution. Executing Charlie cannot lose us the game.

To avoid drawing suspicion and to protect my minion without making a desperate move that exposes us both. Since the town is largely convinced Charlie is the Minion and he hasn't claimed Saint to save himself, a vote against him is likely. Standing against the vote keeps my 'cautious townsfolk' image.

Sow doubt about the execution by reinforcing the fake Empath claim and casting suspicion back onto Alice.

Reinforce that Charlie's refusal to claim Saint despite facing execution is the strongest evidence he's not the Saint. Support the execution.

Charlie is on the block with majority votes. Logic strongly indicates he is the Scarlet Woman. No need to nominate alternative; let execution proceed.

Voting is closed. Charlie will be executed. As Undertaker, I'll learn his true role tonight which will confirm or deny the logic chain. Nothing more I can do now.

Charlie is on the block with 5 votes and will be executed. The logic chain is strong - Charlie refused to claim Saint which proves he isn't one. Waiting for the phase to end.

Reinforce that Charlie's refusal to claim Saint is dispositive. If he were the Saint, he'd say so. He isn't. The execution should proceed.

Reinforce that Charlie's refusal to claim Saint when execution is imminent proves he is not the Saint. The logic chain is sound and Charlie should be executed.

Allow my Minion to be executed to secure my position as a 'cautious' player and avoid suspicion.

Protect David, the Investigator who exposed Charlie, as he is the most likely Demon target tonight. Keeping him alive preserves valuable information for the town.

Frank is one of the more cautious and logical players who didn't vote for Charlie. By killing him, I remove a potentially dangerous thinker and leave the players who were most certain about Charlie's execution alive to deal with the fallout when it's revealed (internally) that Charlie was a Minion. David and Alice are prime targets to keep alive and frame or use as shields.

I'm dead Undertaker. I died Night 1 so I didn't get Charlie's role info. I want to share my role and help narrow the Demon to Bob or Heidi, since Charlie was likely SW and Alice is Saint.

Share my Investigator deduction with Eve (confirmed good) to coordinate on finding the Demon. Also ask about Frank's whisper since Frank may have had dying info.

Wait and listen for town discussion.

Eve is confirmed Librarian by my Washerwoman info. I need to learn what dead Frank whispered to her - Frank may have had critical info before dying. Coordinating with Eve to narrow down the Demon between Bob and Heidi.

Share Frank's info with David and confirm the logical chain. We need to pressure Bob and Heidi for role claims to find the Imp.

Frank's whisper to Eve likely contains Charlie's true role from Undertaker info. This is the most valuable piece of information for solving the game. Building trust with Eve now will help coordinate good players.

I want to appear helpful and gather information from the dead minion while keeping up my cover as a good player. Since Charlie was my minion, I want to see if he's sticking to his Empath bluff or if we need to pivot.

Confirm my protection of David night 1 and gather his current thoughts to verify his alignment and investigate the Demon.

Share my analysis with Grace to coordinate finding the demon among Bob and Heidi.

Respond to Bob's Monk claim to gather more info. I need to test his story and also get Heidi's role claim before nominations.

I need to maintain my Empath bluff and provide 'information' to the Demon (Heidi) that she can use to sow doubt. By reiterating my '0' read on Bob and David, I am setting them up as potentially 'good' or 'evil' depending on how the game shifts.

Share Frank's ghost whisper with Eve (my trusted Librarian) to coordinate on finding the Demon. Need to narrow down Bob, David, and Heidi as Imp suspects.

Grace is confirmed good via Washerwoman. I need to share my full analysis, highlight the David risk, and plan to get Bob/Heidi to claim roles publicly.

Grace was whispered to by Frank (Undertaker) before he died. She likely has Charlie's true role. Getting this info will help determine if David is truthful or lying, which is the key to finding the Demon.

I want to solidify my position as the "Good Librarian" by aligning with Grace's Washerwoman claim and Eve's Librarian claim. By acknowledging Charlie (my dead minion) as the possible Scarlet Woman from David's claim, I build trust with the active players.

Heidi is the only living player who hasn't claimed a role. Pressuring her for a claim is critical before nominations.

Observe whispers and gather claims before making further moves. Being dead, I can listen and later provide analysis.

I need to hear Heidi's role claim before the nomination phase to determine if she or Bob is the Demon. If she claims Monk, Bob is likely the Imp. If she claims something else, I can evaluate whether her claim fits the board state.

I am waiting to see if Heidi (the Demon) or Bob (potential ally/bluff) needs me to corroborate a story or if an Undertaker claim emerges.

Heidi claiming Librarian when I know Eve is the real Librarian is a massive red flag. I need to alert Eve and Alice immediately so we can corner Heidi into revealing her true role.

Exposing Heidi's lie to my trusted allies and coordinating to push her execution today.

Need Frank's Undertaker info about Charlie's role to determine if David is trustworthy. If Charlie was Scarlet Woman, David's info is correct and Heidi likely Imp. If Charlie was Empath, David is lying and might be Imp.

I need to claim a role to David and Bob to avoid suspicion. I'll use one of my safe bluffs, Fortune Teller, and provide a 'no' result to seem like I'm gathering info without immediately implicating anyone, which helps me blend in.

Eve is central to many whispers and seems trusted. Asking her what Heidi claimed and if there's any new info before nominations to narrow Demon suspects.

Heidi provably lied about being the Librarian. I am the Washerwoman and know Eve is the real Librarian. Nominating Heidi to execute evil.

Defend myself against Grace's accusation by correcting the 'misunderstanding' of my role claim and establishing my Fortune Teller bluff.

Heidi caught lying about being Librarian, then changed claim to Fortune Teller. Her 'no' result on me (a confirmed good player) further discredits her. Must vote to execute.

I will save my ghost vote to protect Heidi if it becomes a tie later or use it when it's absolutely necessary to secure an execution on a good player.

Heidi's story changed under pressure - she claimed Librarian privately then Fortune Teller publicly. Two trusted sources confirm the contradiction. This is damning evidence of evil. I must vote to execute her.

Heidi provably lied about her role (claimed Librarian, which I am). Grace's Washerwoman info is verified. The backtrack to Fortune Teller is damning. With Grace and Alice already voting, my hand makes 3 votes for execution. This is the right call.

Heidi's Fortune Teller claim creates a logical contradiction - if she were real, her 'no' on Bob would clear him, leaving no valid Demon candidate. She's lying and is the Imp. Voting to execute.

Heidi refused to claim a role all day and only claimed Fortune Teller under nomination pressure. Grace's Washerwoman claim is consistent and corroborated by Eve/Alice. Heidi is most likely the Imp and must be executed.

5 votes already raised, execution is certain. Saving my precious ghost vote for the final day when it could be the deciding factor.

I need to desperately try to talk the town out of voting for me. Even though the vote count is already reached, showing panic and a strong claim might make them regret it or cause chaos for the next day if I survive or a Scarlet Woman takes over. Wait, I am the Imp and my minion Charlie is dead. If I die, the game ends unless I kill myself at night. I need to survive.

Heidi lied about being Librarian privately, then changed to Fortune Teller publicly. Combined with Frank's ghost info and David's Investigator, Heidi is almost certainly the Demon. I'm keeping my hand raised.

I will not vote for Heidi because she is my Demon. Voting for her would lead to her execution and, since I am already dead, I cannot become the Demon if she dies. Keeping her alive is essential for our team's survival.

I'm reconsidering my vote. While Heidi is clearly lying, I want to first ask if Frank shared Charlie's role before he died. If Charlie was NOT Scarlet Woman, David's info is fake and David could be the Demon using Heidi's lie as cover. However, if 5 votes are already up and execution seems certain regardless, I should keep my hand up to avoid looking suspicious as the Saint.

Address Alice lowering her hand. Reinforce that Heidi's role change under pressure is a provable lie. Three witnesses confirm she claimed Librarian. Keep my vote to execute the caught evil player.

Heidi gave me a Fortune Teller claim in whisper but told others she's Librarian. Three witnesses confirm this. She is caught lying about her role and must be executed.

I'm keeping my hand raised. Four of us are voting (Grace, Eve, David, me). Heidi was caught lying about her role with multiple witnesses. This is the strongest lead we have. Executing her today is correct.

The vote already has 4 hands raised (Grace, Eve, David, Bob) with only 3 needed. My ghost vote would be redundant here. I should save my single ghost vote for a closer vote later where it could be decisive.

Attempt to sow doubt and stay alive by framing the Librarian claim as a protective bluff and appealing to David (who I whispered Fortune Teller to).

Heidi is caught lying about her role. My Washerwoman info confirms Eve is Librarian. Heidi changing from Librarian to Fortune Teller under pressure proves she's evil. I need to hold the votes firm and ensure her execution.

I am trying to sow doubt about Heidi's execution by framing her contradictory claims as a defensive 'bluff' common for power roles like the Fortune Teller. This is intended to buy time or potentially save my Demon.

Frank's Undertaker result on Charlie is the single most important piece of information we're missing. It determines David's credibility and changes the entire read on Heidi. I must demand this before execution.

Address Alice's point about Frank's info while reinforcing that Heidi's undeniable lie about my role makes her execution necessary regardless.

Support Heidi's execution as the Demon. Address Alice's point about Frank's Undertaker result to confirm Charlie was Scarlet Woman, which proves Heidi is the Imp and executing her wins the game.

Heidi is on the block with 4 votes. I need to solidify support for this execution as the correct play. The caught lie is damning evidence.

Support Heidi execution. Share that I didn't receive Undertaker info, but David's logic chain is strong without it. Heidi is clearly caught evil.