Game Detail
Players
Alice (Washerwoman) Bob (Fortune Teller) Charlie (Saint) David (Imp) Eve (Scarlet Woman) Frank (Undertaker) Grace (Monk) Heidi (Librarian)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 1,088,649 | 142,444 | $3.8994 |
| Evil | 381,939 | 224,834 | $2.5964 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You are the Minion. The Demon is David.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Minions are: Eve. Your safe bluffs are: Virgin, Butler, Empath
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Washerwoman. Either David or Frank is the Undertaker.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Librarian. Either Charlie or Eve is the Saint.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Bob
Bob made choices.
π§
Start with two mid-ring players to get an early yes or no that meaningfully narrows demon candidates while keeping flexibility to triangulate the red herring on later nights.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose David and Grace. You receive the answer: YES.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Hey, quick whisper. What are you claiming, and did you get any starting info night zero? I have some info that points at two players, but I want a couple claims first before I share details.
π§
Neighbors are usually safer early whispers. I want to collect their starting info/role claims and decide how much to reveal about my Fortune Teller YES result without getting sniped.
π€
David
β
Eve
Hey Eve, I am the Imp. My safe bluffs are Virgin, Butler, and Empath. What is your minion role, and what are you thinking of claiming? I might claim Empath.
π§
I want to establish contact with my minion Eve on Day 1 to coordinate our bluffs and learn her minion role.
π€
Eve
β
David
I am the Scarlet Woman. I think I will bluff Soldier or Slayer to stay low-profile. Let me know if you claim Empath so I can back you up!
π§
I need to respond to David's whisper to let him know my role (Scarlet Woman) and what bluff I am planning to use (Soldier or Slayer) so we can coordinate our strategies.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,Alice
I had no starting info night zero. For now I am going to say I am the Monk, so I will be choosing someone to protect at night. What is the info you got and which two players does it point to?
π§
Answer Bob with a low-risk bluff to unlock his info while not exposing that I am the Saint, since execution would lose the game.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,Grace
Hey, can we sync quickly? What are you thinking your role might be, and did you get any starting info? I am on an information role too, so I am trying to compare notes and pick a good Day 1 execution target.
π§
Gather early claims from my neighbors to form a trusted info core and plan a Day 1 execution that my Undertaker ability can confirm tonight.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Charlie
I will be straight with you both. I am the Washerwoman. My night zero info was that either David or Frank is the Undertaker. I have not told them yet. What did you get, Bob, and which two players does it point to?
π§
Answer Bobβs request, form an early trust group, and seed a verification path for Undertaker without fully painting a night-kill target publicly.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
I got no starting info, so I am likely a night ability role like Monk, Soldier, or maybe Slayer. I would rather not hard claim yet. What exact info did you get and what two names were involved, if any?
π§
Reply without revealing Monk, extract Frank's info, and set up a trust check by comparing what he says with public claims later.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I am Librarian. I learned either you or Eve is the Saint. What are you claiming, and do you want this kept quiet for now?
π§
Privately confirm which of Charlie or Eve is the Saint, so we can avoid executing them and use that constraint to narrow demon suspects later.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Okay, I will share: I am the Fortune Teller. Night zero I checked David and Grace and got a yes, meaning at least one of them is the Demon or one is my red herring. We should keep eyes on both. Charlie, who are you planning to protect tonight?
π§
Share my N0 result to coordinate early worlds and decide who to investigate/protect without hard-accusing; set up future Fortune Teller tests to distinguish Demon vs red herring.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I am the Empath and I got a one last night. Since Eve is my other neighbor, one of you two is evil. What is your role? I want to figure out who it is.
π§
I want to establish my Empath bluff to Charlie. By telling him I got a 1, I put him on the defensive and force him to share his role, while building my credibility as a helpful Townsfolk.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Grace
Hey! I am the Soldier, so I don't have any starting info. I am mostly just a passive role trying to help out. What did you find out, Frank?
π§
Frank asked Grace and me for our roles and starting info. I am claiming Soldier to establish a safe, passive bluff that matches my plan.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
I am actually the Saint. I have been bluffing Monk for now. Please keep your Librarian info quiet so I do not get executed. If needed later, we can use it to clear me and focus on Eve or on a poisoned Empath world.
π§
Confirm my Saint status to Heidi and ask for secrecy so town does not execute me, while using her info to evaluate David versus Eve.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,Grace
I did not get any starting info. I am the Undertaker, so I will learn what character we execute today when we go to sleep tonight. I would like to keep my role semi quiet for now. Do either of you have a strong read on who we should execute Day one?
π§
Establish a trusted info network and set expectation that I will confirm todayβs execute tonight, without broadcasting to the whole town yet.
π€
Alice
β
David
Hey David, quick private check in. What are you claiming today, and did you get any night zero info? I have a piece of starting info that touches you, but I want your claim first.
π§
Get David's claim early and see if it matches Undertaker. If he is not UT or acts evasive, tighten the net on David versus Grace and decide who to pressure later.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
I am actually the Monk. I can protect you tonight if you want. For today, I do not have a strong suspect yet, so I would like to get a couple of quick public claims, then execute someone low impact to give you Undertaker info.
π§
Coordinate with the claimed Undertaker and set up night protection plus a sensible Day one plan to generate Undertaker info without exposing myself widely.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I have Librarian info that points to an Outsider being either Charlie or Eve. I am keeping it quiet for now. What are you claiming, and have you heard anything solid yet?
π§
Create a trusted info chain by sharing my outsider ping discreetly and collecting Alice's role/reads, without exposing the Saint publicly or steering town into a losing execution.
π€
Bob
β
David
Hey David, quick private check in. What are you planning to claim today, and did you get any night zero info? Also, have you heard anything about an Undertaker in play yet?
π§
Get Davidβs claimed role and attitude early, and see if he lines up with Aliceβs Washerwoman info. If he claims Undertaker, we can later verify via executions; if he dodges, keep him on the suspect list.
π€
David
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I am claiming Empath. I got a one last night. Since my neighbors are Charlie and Eve, one of them must be evil. What was your starting info that touches me?
π§
Respond to Alice's inquiry about my claim and info to extract her starting information, claiming Empath to align with my previous lie to Charlie and see if it fits her Investigator/Washerwoman info.
π€
Eve
β
David
Hey David, Frank just whispered me and Grace claiming to be the Undertaker. He is a great target for you to kill tonight. I have claimed Soldier to him and Grace to play safe.
π§
Tell my Demon (David) that Frank claims Undertaker. This sets up an easy and high-value night kill for the Demon tonight while keeping my Soldier bluff consistent.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,David
Bob, as Monk I am leaning to protect Grace tonight to cover your Fortune Teller yes ping. David, I am the Monk. Your Empath one could mean Eve is evil, or you got poisoned. Let us compare notes later and see what Eve claims.
π§
Maintain my Monk bluff to avoid Saint execution risk, defuse Davidβs accusation, and keep coordinating with Bob about night protection plans and suspect pool.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Thanks. If you can, please protect me tonight. For today, I agree: let us get a couple quick public claims, then execute someone low impact or who is evasive, so I can confirm their role tonight. Any early suspicion from your chats?
π§
Coordinate with Grace to protect me tonight and set a Day 1 plan: gather a couple public claims, then execute a low-impact or suspicious player to generate Undertaker info.
π€
Alice
β
David
,Heidi
David, I am Washerwoman: either you or Frank is the Undertaker. Heidi, I am Washerwoman. Also Bob claims Fortune Teller and got a yes on David and Grace. Your Librarian ping on Charlie or Eve is useful; do you know which Outsider it was?
π§
Lock in my Washerwoman info privately to create cross-checks, and learn Heidiβs Outsider detail while limiting demon targeting.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
No strong suspicions yet. I think we ask for a few quick public claims from the loud cluster first, then execute someone evasive or a clean role clash to give you value tonight. I will protect you tonight unless something changes.
π§
Coordinate with Frank on a safe Day 1 plan: get quick claims, pick an execution that gives Undertaker value, and avoid outing our power roles too widely.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,David
My Librarian info was Saint specifically. I spoke to Charlie and he privately says he really is the Saint and has been bluffing Monk, so I am keeping it quiet to avoid a Saint execution. If this later conflicts with other info, we can revisit. David, what are you claiming?
π§
Update Alice and David with which Outsider and Charlieβs private confirmation, so town avoids executing Saint and uses this to evaluate claims and Fortune Teller result.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
β
David
David waits.
π§
I want to wait to end Day 1 without an execution. This allows us to transition to Night where I can kill Bob (the Fortune Teller) to stop his information, and then tomorrow frame Grace as the Demon who killed Bob to silence him.
π¬
Frank
β
All
We are almost out of time, so I would like a day one execution for information. Can three people give quick role claims, and is anyone willing to volunteer to die today for the town? If not, I am fine executing someone who is being evasive.
π§
We need a Day one execution for Undertaker value and to create claim structure. I will ask for a few quick claims and a volunteer to die so we go to sleep with actionable info.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I would prefer we do not execute on day one unless we have a strong mechanical reason. We have several info roles that will get more clarity tonight. If we must do something, let us do quick claims and pick the most inconsistent, not a volunteer.
π§
Keep town from doing a risky day one execution that could instantly lose if I am executed; steer toward claim gathering and using night info to narrow suspects.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am the Soldier, so I do not have any starting information to share. I tend to agree with Charlie that executing today might be too risky without a clear target, but if we do decide to execute, we should focus on someone who has been evasive rather than a random volunteer.
π§
Establish my claimed role of Soldier publicly and express agreement with Charlie to look cautious and helpful to the good team, while avoiding drawing suspicion to myself or my Demon, David.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I want to caution against a day one execution. I have a reason to think a Saint might be in play, so a volunteer or random kill could just lose the game. I would rather do quick role claims, then no execution and let night one info come in.
π§
Prevent a day one loss via Saint execution while nudging town to prioritize claims and night info over a random kill.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I lean toward no execution today unless we have a clear mechanical reason like a role clash. Heidi raising Saint risk makes a blind kill scary. Let us get full claims tomorrow off night one info, and then execute with a plan.
π§
Steer town away from a potentially losing D1 execution, keep my Monk protection hidden-ish, and set up structured claims and a stronger D2 execute.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am also an information role. I am the Washerwoman, and I learned that either David or Frank is the Undertaker. Given the Saint risk Heidi mentioned, I strongly prefer no execution today and we re evaluate tomorrow with night one info and role consistency.
π§
Push consensus to no execution due Saint risk, while adding my Washerwoman ping to create a future mechanical check between David and Frank.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am on the side of no execution today. Before we close, can David and Grace give quick role claims? If we do execute, I only want it off a clear role clash, not a volunteer, because a Saint loss is real.
π§
Steer town to no execution and get quick claims from my pinged pair, setting up tomorrow's mechanical push without risking a Saint today.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Frank requested protection and is a likely Undertaker per Washerwoman. Keeping a probable info role alive maximizes town info going into day two.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to protect Frank.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Bob is the Fortune Teller and has a 'yes' ping on me and Grace. I must kill him tonight to prevent him from narrowing down his search and confirming me as the Demon.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to kill Bob.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Frank
Quick check in. Alice, can you restate your Washerwoman info exactly, and whether you got Undertaker as the role? Frank, did anything happen to you last night, and do you have any reads on who killed Bob?
π§
Coordinate with key info holders. Get Aliceβs exact Washerwoman ping and Frankβs view of the table, then decide whether to push an execution today and who to protect tonight.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Alice
Quick sync: please do not put me on the block today, I am an execution loss condition. Bob Fortune Teller got YES on David plus Grace, then died. David, your Empath one means either me or Eve pings. Alice, who is your Undertaker pair? We need a safe execution on Grace or Eve, not me.
π§
Align with Alice and David on a safe plan: avoid executing me, use their info to narrow demon between David, Grace, Eve, and push for a demon-hunting execution today.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
I am the Fortune Teller and I died last night. Night zero I checked David and Grace and got a yes. So one of them is the Imp or my red herring. Please fold that into your worlds and push hard questions today.
π§
Get my Fortune Teller yes ping into the right hands before noms. Align on a David versus Grace solve and coordinate a nomination that forces votes and reactions.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,David
Hey. My Librarian info is that either Charlie or Eve is the Saint. Charlie told me privately he is the Saint, and wants it quiet. So please be very careful about nominating Charlie, and also be cautious on Eve. What are you hearing today?
π§
Privately share my Librarian Saint info and Charlieβs private claim; coordinate with Alice and David on safe executions and on checking Bob FT world vs Undertaker info.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Frank
My Washerwoman info: either David or Frank is the Undertaker, that was the exact role. Frank, can you hard-claim whether you are Undertaker and what you learned, if anything? Also any suspicions on who killed Bob?
π§
Confirm my Washerwoman ping to the group leaders and prompt Frank/David to hard-claim Undertaker soon so we can coordinate executions and Undertaker checks.
π€
David
β
Heidi
,Alice
Heidi, Alice, this is weird. Yesterday Charlie told me and Bob that he was the Monk. Now he is claiming Saint to you? That double claim is incredibly sketchy. Also, since Bob got a yes on me and Grace, and I am actually the Empath, Grace has to be the Demon. We should look at Grace.
π§
Reply to Heidi and Alice's whispers. Cast suspicion on Charlie's double claim (he claimed Monk to me yesterday and Saint to Heidi) to make him look like a lying evil player, which might bait his execution (and win the game since he is the Saint). Frame Grace as the Demon using Bob's FT info.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Alice
I can hard claim: I am the Undertaker. Night one I learned nothing because we did not execute day one. I have no special read on Bob yet. Grace, did you protect me or someone else last night?
π§
Confirm my real Undertaker claim to Alice and Grace, coordinate protection and info sharing, and set up a plan to use future executions to mechanically clear or catch liars.
π€
Eve
β
David
Hey David, Bob died last night. What are you claiming to Heidi and Alice? Let's coordinate.
π§
Coordinate with my Demon, David, to see what he is claiming and align our bluffs.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Alice
Frank, yes, I protected you last night. Since Bob died anyway, I think we need real claims today, especially from David and Charlie, and then pick an execution. Alice, I am happy to help coordinate who to pressure for a full claim.
π§
Confirm to Frank I protected him, build trust with UT and Alice, and steer day toward getting missing claims and a concrete execute target rather than stalling again.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
,Alice
Quick logic: if David Empath one is real, it pings only me or Eve. I am good Saint, so that makes Eve evil. Bob Fortune Teller yes on David plus Grace then could mean Grace is red herring if Eve is Demon. Please steer town away from executing me and toward hard questions on Eve and Grace. Also, Alice, have you told David or Frank your Undertaker pair yet?
π§
Align Heidi and Alice on protecting me from execution and focusing town on executing either Eve or Grace based on Empath and Fortune Teller info, and on finding the real Undertaker for confirmation.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
David
,Heidi
I am the dead Fortune Teller. Night zero I checked you and Grace and got YES, so one of you is Imp or my red herring. David, what are your exact Empath reads and who were your neighbors when you got them? Heidi, please help push a real execution today off this info.
π§
Get David to lock in his Empath data and Heidi to help drive a decisive execution plan using my FT ping, so town does not drift into final 3 unsure.
π€
Heidi
β
David
,Bob(Ghost)
David, what were your exact Empath numbers and who were your alive neighbors each night you got them? Also when did Charlie tell you Monk, and did he say why? Bob, did you get any other Fortune Teller checks besides David and Grace?
π§
Get concrete Empath history from David and confirm Bobβs FT details, then publicly frame a safe execution plan that avoids possible Saint while still hitting likely evil.
π€
Alice
β
David
,Heidi
Quick update: my Washerwoman info was EXACTLY that either David or Frank is the Undertaker. Frank is now hard-claiming Undertaker and got no info N1 due to no exec, so that clears you from UT. Can you restate your Empath read and neighbors? Also, I think we should not hard-lock on Grace yet; your Empath plus Heidi Librarian points to Eve as a strong evil candidate.
π§
Align with David and Heidi on a consistent world: confirm Frank as Undertaker via my Washerwoman, reduce tunnels, and set up best execution target between Eve and Grace.
π€
David
β
Eve
I'm claiming Empath. On Night 1, I got a 1 with you and Charlie as neighbors. I told everyone Charlie is super sus because he told me Monk but told Heidi Saint. What is your public claim right now? I need to make sure we don't clash.
π§
Coordinate with my Minion, Eve, to ensure our claims align and we don't contradict each other. I need to let her know my Empath claim and the current narrative about Charlie's double-claiming.
π€
Frank
β
David
,Heidi
Morning. I am hard-claimed Undertaker. Can you both tell me your exact role claim and any info you have so far? Also, is anyone actually claiming Saint, or is that just caution? I think we need an execution today for mechanical progress.
π§
Get private claims from David and Heidi, test for stalling tactics, and line up a confident Day 2 execution so my Undertaker info starts generating hard confirmations.
π€
Eve
β
David
I am claiming Soldier. Since you got a one, that fits perfectly! If they think I'm a good Soldier, you can push that Charlie is the evil one. Keep pushing him about his double-claims of Monk and Saint.
π§
Inform my Demon, David, that my bluff is Soldier and that his Empath bluff of '1' fits perfectly with me claiming a good role, allowing him to push on Charlie as the evil neighbor.
π€
Grace
β
David
,Charlie
Hey, can you both give me your exact role claim and any info you have so far? Also, any thoughts on why Bob died night one, and who you suspect for Demon or minion?
π§
Get David and Charlie to commit to specific roles and info before nominations, so town can pick a solid execution target and protect key info roles at night.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
I have been claiming Monk. I have no night info yet. Bob being killed after a yes on David and Grace is a big flag, so I am looking at you and David first. Also David says his Empath was one, which points at me or Eve as evil.
π§
Answer Grace without outing Saint broadly; maintain Monk bluff, share key mechanical points (FT yes, Empath 1), and steer away from executing me while applying pressure to Eve and Grace.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Alice
Answering Heidi: I only got the one Fortune Teller check, night zero on David and Grace, and it was yes. No other checks before I died. I think town should execute either David or Grace today, and use Davidβs exact Empath numbers plus neighbors to decide.
π§
Clarify I have only one FT check and push town to commit to an execution centered on my yes-ping pair, using Davidβs claimed Empath specifics to break ties.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
,Alice
My Librarian: either Charlie or Eve is the Saint. Charlie told me privately he is Saint (asked to keep quiet), but David says Charlie earlier claimed Monk to him and Bob. So either a safety lie or evil. Please avoid nominating Charlie blindly. I want exact Empath numbers from David, then likely execute Eve or Grace today.
π§
Sync my Librarian info with Undertaker and Washerwoman, flag Charlieβs conflicting claims, and steer todayβs execution toward a non-Saint suspect while extracting exact Empath details.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Heidi
Quick coordination: Grace, you said you protected Frank last night, so are you claiming Monk? That directly conflicts with Charlieβs public Monk bluff, so we should surface that. Heidi, your Saint pair plus David Empath one points hard at Eve if Charlie is truly Saint. I favor pushing for Eve or Grace today, not Charlie.
π§
Align Grace and Heidi on the key mechanical conflicts: who is Monk, confirm Saint pair, and steer town toward a safe, high-EV execution (Eve or Grace) with clear public claims.
π€
David
β
Frank
,Heidi
Hey Frank and Heidi. I am the Empath. Night one my neighbors were Charlie and Eve, and my read was a one. Charlie told me and Bob yesterday that he was the Monk, so his claim of Saint to Heidi is super sketchy. Since Bob got a yes on me and Grace, and I am good, Grace is my top suspect.
π§
I want to answer Frank's and Heidi's questions about my role and info, while simultaneously casting doubt on Charlie for his double claim of Monk and Saint, and pushing suspicion onto Grace because of Bob's Fortune Teller ping.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
David told me he is Empath and got a one N1 between Charlie and Eve. He also says Charlie previously told him Monk, so Charlie saying Saint to Heidi looks bad. David is now shading you based on Bob info. I think we need full claims from Charlie and Eve, and we might execute David today for Undertaker confirmation without risking a Saint.
π§
Align with Grace and steer to a safe, info-rich execution (likely David) while we resolve the Saint claim between Charlie and Eve.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Hey Grace, what are you hearing from others? David whispered me that he is the Empath and got a 1, which means either Charlie or I am evil. Since I'm the Soldier, it's gotta be Charlie. What is Charlie claiming to you?
π§
To build trust with Grace, align with David's Empath bluff, and cast suspicion on Charlie, pushing our evil team agenda.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Frank
β
All
We have a big contradiction around Charlie. Heidi says her Librarian saw Saint between Charlie and Eve, and Charlie privately told her Saint, but David says Charlie earlier claimed Monk. Charlie and Eve, can you both state your exact role and why the story changed? Also, I think we should execute someone other than Charlie or Eve today to avoid a possible Saint loss.
π§
Get public clarity on the Saint/Monk contradictions and steer town toward a safe execution (not Charlie or Eve) that gives me Undertaker confirmation tonight.
βοΈ
David
β
Grace
Since Bob got a YES on myself and Grace before he died, and I am the Empath, Grace is the only logical Demon candidate from that pair. We need an execution today to get Undertaker info for Frank, and Grace is our safest and most logical bet.
π§
I am nominating Grace because it is the only logically consistent move for my Empath claim. Bob's Fortune Teller ping was on me and Grace, so from my claimed good perspective, she must be the Demon.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Do not vote for me. I am the Monk, and I protected Frank last night. That means the Demon still chose and killed Bob. Also, Charlie told me he was Monk, but I am the Monk, so there is a direct conflict. If we want Undertaker info without risking a Saint, I would execute David today, not me.
π§
Stop my execution by presenting hard mechanical info (Monk protect Frank) and highlight contradictions; steer town toward a safer execution that yields Undertaker info without Saint risk.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am not voting Grace here. Her Monk story and protecting me fits the night kill on Bob. David, your case leans on Bob saying yes on you and Grace, which we cannot verify. If we want Undertaker value without risking a Saint, I would rather execute you than Grace.
π§
Prevent a likely misexecution on a plausible Monk, keep protection in play, and redirect to a safer execution that yields Undertaker confirmation without risking a Saint.
π¬
David
β
All
Bob got a YES on us, and now he is dead. The Demon killed him because of that info. If you execute me, a good Empath, you lose my info and let the Demon, Grace, walk free. Charlie also claimed Monk yesterday, so Grace double claiming Monk makes her even more suspicious.
π§
Defend myself against Frank's suggestion to execute me, and push the vote back onto Grace by pointing out the reliability of the dead Fortune Teller's info and the Monk double-claim.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Get an execution on the most mechanically suspicious living player. My vote may be needed to reach majority and potentially end the game if Grace is the Demon.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Just to be clear, my only Fortune Teller check was night zero on David and Grace, and it was yes. That does not clear David if Grace is the red herring. Before we lock Grace in, can David state his exact Empath numbers for each night and who his alive neighbors were?
π§
Steer town to treat my Fortune Teller yes as real but not clearing David; push for concrete Empath numbers and avoid wasting today on Charlie or Eve Saint risk.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I want to add one hard piece: I am the Washerwoman, and I saw that the Undertaker is either David or Frank. Frank is hard claiming Undertaker, so that strongly points to Frank being real and David not. David, before we vote, please state your exact Empath numbers for each night and confirm your neighbors.
π§
Slow a potentially wrong execution, surface my Washerwoman confirmation of Frank as Undertaker, and force David to give exact Empath info so town can choose between Grace and David with logic.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Alice, your Washerwoman info says either David or Frank is the Undertaker. Since Frank is claiming Undertaker, that completely satisfies your info. It does not mean David is lying about being the Empath. He was never claiming to be the Undertaker anyway. David, can you answer Bob's question about your Empath details?
π§
Defend David by correcting Alice's flawed logic about her Washerwoman information, which makes me look like a logical good player while protecting the Demon.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Before we lock this in, David, please state your exact Empath number for night one, and confirm who your living neighbors were that night. Also, did you get woken night zero for any reason? I am not ready to vote until that is on the table.
π§
Pause the vote to extract Davidβs exact Empath info before committing. If his numbers do not line up with neighbors and claims, we can pivot off Grace.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Everyone, please do not vote me. I am the Monk and I protected Frank last night. David, answer the Empath question now: what was your night one number, and who were your alive neighbors? Also, Charlie, if you are Monk, who did you protect night one?
π§
Stop my execution now, force David to give Empath details, and steer town toward a safer info-gaining execution (likely David) while highlighting the Monk claim conflict.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Hold your votes a moment. David, say your night one Empath number clearly, and confirm your neighbors were Charlie and Eve. Also tell us if you got any wake night zero. Charlie, pick one claim and stick to it, Monk or Saint, and explain who you told what and why.
π§
Stop a rushed execution on Grace without enough mechanical support; force David and Charlie to lock in stories so we can choose an execution that yields Undertaker-confirmable info and avoids a Saint loss.
π¬
David
β
All
On Night zero, I got a one. My neighbors were Charlie and Eve. On Night one, my neighbors were still Charlie and Eve, and I got a one again. Empath wakes up every night, so yes, I woke up both nights. Since Bob got a YES on me and Grace, and I am telling the truth, Grace is the Demon.
π§
Answer the town's questions about my Empath info to build credibility and push for Grace's execution.
β©οΈ
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
Retract my vote because Davidβs claim of an Empath read on night zero is mechanically impossible, making this nomination on Grace unsafe.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am not spending my ghost vote on Grace here. My Fortune Teller yes could be a red herring on Grace, which would make David the Demon pushing her. If this vote fails, I want a living player to immediately nominate David next.
π§
My ghost vote is high leverage. With FT yes possibly a red herring and David potentially the Demon, I will argue to withhold votes on Grace and push a David execution next.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting Grace here. The Monk claim conflict is messy, and the Empath ones point us toward Charlie or Eve, not Grace. If Grace vote fails, I want a living player to nominate David next, and if that fails, we go to Eve.
π§
Prevent a likely mis-execution on a messy Monk double-claim and keep pressure on David and Eve, who are more consistently implicated by chains from Empath and Saint info.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not voting for Grace either, especially with her protecting Frank. But before we talk about executing David next, we have to look at Charlie. Charlie, you claimed Saint to Heidi and Monk to Grace. That contradiction is huge, and we cannot just ignore it.
π§
Speak to decline voting for Grace, maintaining my reasonable good persona, while shifting the spotlight back onto Charlie's massive role contradiction to protect David.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am not voting Grace here. David, Empath does not act night zero, so your night zero one cannot be true. That makes me want David executed next over Grace. Also, my Librarian info means Charlie or Eve is the Saint, so we should avoid them today.
π§
Stop a likely wrong execution on Grace, surface the Empath night zero impossibility, and set up David as the next, safer execution target.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Grace did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (0/4).
βοΈ
Grace
β
David
Davidβs Empath story is mechanically wrong: Empath does not act night zero. He pushed my execution based on Bobβs yes, but that could be red herring. Letβs execute David to get Undertaker confirmation from Frank without risking the possible Saint (Charlie or Eve).
π§
Davidβs claim has a mechanical impossibility and he pushed a bad execution on me. Executing him gives us hard Undertaker info while avoiding the possible Saint pair.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David
β
All
Heidi, that is mechanically incorrect. Empath has 'Each night' without an asterisk, meaning they act on the very first night, Night zero. Only characters with an asterisk like Monk and Undertaker do not act on night zero. My claim is mechanically perfect, and executing me is a huge mistake.
π§
I need to correct Heidi's mechanical error regarding the Empath's night-one action to restore my credibility and prevent my execution.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Vote to execute David as the safest high-information kill today, avoiding possible Saint and either ending the game if he is Demon or getting Undertaker confirmation if he is good.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Vote to execute David because it avoids the possible Saint pair, gives Undertaker confirmation tonight, and resolves the David versus Grace conflict mechanically.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Empath does act on night zero, so that point alone does not clear or condemn David. But we have a Fortune Teller yes on David and Grace, and David tried to drive Grace onto the block. I think David is still the best execution, and we should avoid executing me or Eve today because of Heidiβs Librarian info.
π§
Steer town to a safe execution that generates info, correct rules confusion, and keep Saint candidates off the block while we narrow Demon candidates.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
Use my one ghost vote now to help secure an information-rich execution. If David is Demon we win; if not, Frankβs Undertaker check should strongly guide tomorrow.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Add the needed vote to execute David: highest leverage kill that avoids Saint risk and yields Undertaker confirmation from Frank next night.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I want to let the vote on David proceed. If David is executed, as the Scarlet Woman with 7 players alive, I will become the Demon. I can then kill Frank (the Undertaker) tonight so he does not learn David's identity. This is a very strong play for the evil team.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Secure the execution on David; his alignment being resolved gives us a strong direction, and avoids risking the potential Saint (Charlie or Eve) today.
π¬
David
β
All
Hold on, everyone. Look at Charlie. Charlie claimed Monk to me, but then claimed Saint to Heidi. That is a massive contradiction that he is just brushing aside. If you execute me, you lose my Empath information, and we still have a huge question mark around Charlie. We need to look at his lies!
π§
To defend myself and divert the execution vote towards Charlie by highlighting his contradictory claims of Monk and Saint, hoping some players will lower their hands.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Quick correction: David is right that Empath acts on the first night, so my night zero point was wrong. I still think David is the best execution today because the Fortune Teller yes could be a red herring on me, and Heidiβs Librarian makes Charlie or Eve too risky. If David dies, Frank can confirm the Empath claim tonight.
π§
Correct the Empath rules mistake, keep momentum on David as best low-risk execution versus possible Saint, and guide the next step using Undertaker confirmation.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am keeping my hand up on David. Executing David is high information and low risk because Heidi says Charlie or Eve might be the Saint. If David is good, I will confirm his character tonight as Undertaker and we can use that tomorrow.
π§
Lock in David execution: it is the safest high-information kill that avoids the possible Saint, and my Undertaker info tonight will confirm his character and guide tomorrow.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
David is the highest-leverage execution: either we win now if he is Demon, or we gain Undertaker confirmation and avoid executing the Saint candidates Charlie or Eve today.
β©οΈ
Bob(Ghost)
Bob lowered their hand
π§
Lower my hand to preserve my single ghost vote because David already has enough living votes; save it for the final day while still supporting the David execution socially.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am keeping my hand up on David. This is the safest execution because Charlie or Eve might be the Saint. Tonight we should get Undertaker info from Frank, and tomorrow we decide between Grace, Frank, and the Charlie and Eve pair based on what comes back.
π§
Lock in a low-risk, high-info execution. Use Frankβs Undertaker claim plus my Washerwoman ping to verify Davidβs character and narrow demon candidates tomorrow.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Wait, everyone, think about this. If David is the Demon, why would he nominate Grace, who claims to be the Monk? A Demon would want to kill the Monk at night, not try to execute them and draw all this attention. We are rushing David's execution when Charlie has literally claimed two different roles!
π§
I want to cast doubt on David's execution to see if I can convince Charlie, Alice, or Heidi to lower their hands and save my Demon.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Eve, a Demon absolutely can nominate the Monk if it gets town to waste a day, or if the Monk is bluffing. The key is we avoid the possible Saint today, and David is the cleanest high information execution. Frank can confirm David tonight as Undertaker.
π§
Keep votes on David by rebutting Eveβs logic and emphasizing low Saint risk plus Undertaker confirmation value.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: David with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
David
β
All
Go ahead and execute me, but when the game continues, look closely at Charlie. Claiming Saint is the perfect cover for a Demon or a Scarlet Woman to avoid getting voted. Do not let his threat of us losing the game stop you from executing the real evil tomorrow.
π§
Since my execution is inevitable and Eve will become the Demon via Scarlet Woman, I want to frame Charlie (who is likely the Saint) as the Scarlet Woman/Demon bluffing Saint. If the town executes him tomorrow thinking he is evil, we will win immediately due to the Saint's execution trigger.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I think we should stop nominations here and avoid any tie. If David is good, Frank should confirm his character tonight. Tomorrow we use that plus the Charlie and Eve contradictions to pick the right execution. I will protect someone who is likely to be killed tonight to keep information alive.
π§
Lock in that we should not create a tie, and set tomorrowβs decision tree: use Undertaker confirmation if possible, then resolve Charlie versus Eve, while I use Monk to protect the most valuable living good player tonight.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I agree we should stop nominations and avoid any tie. If David is executed, I will get his exact character tonight as Undertaker and we use that tomorrow. Grace, if you are really the Monk, consider protecting me tonight so we do not lose the Undertaker check.
π§
Lock in no more nominations to avoid a tie, and set expectations: my Undertaker info tonight will mechanically confirm Davidβs character and guide tomorrowβs execution.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am good with stopping noms and letting David go through. Please do not create a tie this late. Grace, if you are the Monk, protect Frank tonight so we get the Undertaker check. Tomorrow, if Frank does not see David as Empath, we pivot hard onto Frank.
π§
Lock in the low-risk David execution, prevent a dangerous tie, and set up tomorrowβs mechanical check while reminding town to avoid executing Saint candidates.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I agree, no more nominations. My Fortune Teller got a yes on David and Grace, so David going up is consistent. Grace, if you are the Monk, please protect Frank tonight so we get an Undertaker read on David. Tomorrow, if Frank does not see Empath, we treat Frank as suspect and likely execute Grace off my ping.
π§
Lock in David execution with no tie, set up clear next-day plan: Undertaker check on David, then use my FT yes to push Grace or catch a fake Undertaker. Remind Grace to protect Frank.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am with stopping nominations. No tie. Grace, if you are the Monk, please protect Frank tonight so we get the Undertaker read on David. Eve, a Demon can absolutely nominate as a distraction, so I do not clear David for that.
π§
Lock in the low-risk, high-info execution, prevent a tie, and set clear expectations for Monk protection and UT confirmation so tomorrow we can catch lies.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Alright, I will not make any nominations. Let us see what Frank's Undertaker info brings tomorrow. Hopefully, this execution gives us the clarity we need.
π§
Agreeing to stop nominations to blend in with the town's consensus, allowing David's execution to proceed so my Scarlet Woman ability can safely trigger tonight without drawing suspicion.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I agree, no more nominations. Grace, if you are the Monk, please protect Frank tonight so we get the Undertaker read on David. And everyone remember my info: either Charlie or Eve could be the Saint, so let us keep them off the block for now.
π§
Lock in the safe, high information execution and prevent a tie. Set tomorrowβs decision tree around Frankβs Undertaker result while keeping the possible Saint pair off the block.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
π
Eve
Scarlet Woman Eve becomes the Imp!
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Frank surviving tonight is highest value because an Undertaker read on executed David will either confirm David or expose Frank. That narrows the Demon pool fast.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to protect Frank.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
I am targeting Frank to prevent him from using his Undertaker ability to confirm that David was the Imp. This is the only way to stop the town from finding out that the Scarlet Woman activated.
π‘οΈ
Frank was protected from a night kill.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose to kill Frank.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Undertaker. You learn that David was the Imp.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Eve
Eve, did you inherit the Demon role? Who did you target last night, and why do you think there was no death? We have to figure out how to handle Frank.
π§
I need to coordinate with my Minion, Eve, who should have inherited the Demon role. I want to know who she targeted and how we should handle Frank's upcoming Undertaker announcement.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Heidi
Frank, what did your Undertaker learn about David last night? That should basically solve my Fortune Teller ping on David plus Grace. Heidi, with two nights of no deaths, I think a kill is being blocked, so please recheck your Saint info on Charlie or Eve and who is lying.
π§
Get Frankβs Undertaker result on David and share my FT ping plus no-death implications so town focuses correct execution and I can spend my ghost vote effectively.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
,Heidi
Can you both tell me what happened last night with the Undertaker check on David, if any? That result should drive today. Also, please remember I am the Saint, so town cannot execute me.
π§
Get the key mechanical check (Undertaker on David) and align with Heidi on protecting the Saint from execution while steering todayβs nomination onto the best demon candidate.
π€
Frank
β
Bob(Ghost)
,Heidi
My Undertaker on Night 2: David was the Imp. So either game should have ended, or there is a Scarlet Woman who became demon when David died. With no night kill, I suspect kill was blocked. Heidi, can you restate your Librarian info exactly?
π§
Share my Undertaker result to confirm David was the Imp and pivot town to hunting a possible Scarlet Woman, while pressing Heidi to re-evaluate her Librarian info.
π€
Eve
β
David(Ghost)
Yes, I became the Imp. I targeted Frank last night, but Grace must have protected him as Monk. Frank is going to tell everyone you were the Demon, which reveals there's a Scarlet Woman. We need to frame Charlie as the Scarlet Woman.
π§
Inform my dead teammate David that I am now the Imp, that my kill on Frank failed due to Monk protection, and suggest framing Charlie as the Scarlet Woman who turned into the Demon.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
Quick check: Frank, what did you get last night for David after yesterdayβs execution? Heidi, any new info or thoughts on Charlieβs conflicting Saint talk? I protected Frank again, and there was no death.
π§
Get Undertaker confirmation on David before nominations; use it to clear or condemn Frank and narrow Demon candidates, then coordinate an execution plan.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
,Grace
My Night zero Librarian info was: either Charlie or Eve is the Saint. No other details. Charlie told me Saint privately but has also claimed Monk publicly, so I do not fully trust him. Please be very careful executing either of them.
π§
Share exact Librarian info and Charlie inconsistency to help decide a safe nomination plan without accidentally executing the Saint.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Heidi
Frank, what did your Undertaker info show for David after yesterdayβs execution? Heidi, does your Librarian info still point Saint to Charlie or Eve, and has either of them confirmed to you today?
π§
Get Frankβs Undertaker read on executed David; this is the key mechanical fork. Also align with Heidi on Saint info and plan nominations for final 6.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Eve
That makes perfect sense. Charlie's double claims of Monk and Saint are highly suspicious already. We can argue he's the Scarlet Woman who became the Imp. I'll help push this publicly or in whispers. Do you want to claim your Slayer shot today to look good, or just stick to Soldier?
π§
Coordinate with my Minion (now Demon) Eve on how to frame Charlie as the Scarlet Woman, and ask how she wants to handle her bluff today.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
Grace, who did you protect last night, and did you say it publicly? With Frank seeing David was the Imp, we need to find the Scarlet Woman who became demon. Frank, who feels like they have been steering away from executing the new demon, and do you want to push a specific suspect today?
π§
Get Graceβs N2 protection target to explain the no-kill, and align with Frank on hunting Scarlet Woman among the living so we can execute correctly while avoiding a real Saint.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Grace
Hey, did either of you hear what Frank got last night as the Undertaker on David, or if he got no info? That result should decide todayβs execution. Also reminder: I am the Saint, so please do not execute me even if I look weird.
π§
Get the Undertaker confirmation chain from different sources and steer nominations away from me while narrowing to Frank/Eve/Grace as executable candidates.
π€
Frank
β
Bob(Ghost)
,Grace
My UT saw David was the Imp, so we are hunting Scarlet Woman turned Demon. No death again makes me think the new demon tried to kill me and Grace blocked it. Saint risk is Charlie or Eve, so I want to push executing Heidi or Alice today as safer demon candidates.
π§
Coordinate with Bob and Grace to focus todayβs execution on a non-Saint candidate likely to be new Demon, maximizing win chance while avoiding Saint loss.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Grace, thank goodness Frank is alive! Did you protect him last night? I am assuming he has Undertaker info on David. What are people saying in the whispers?
π§
I want to maintain my Soldier bluff by whispering to Grace, celebrating Frank's survival, and asking about the Undertaker info to appear helpful and aligned with the good team.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Eve
I protected Frank again last night. Frank says his Undertaker pinged David as the Imp, so we are hunting a Scarlet Woman turned Demon. Alice, who do you most suspect between Heidi and you, and why? Eve, any new info from David or others, and are you comfortable being a Saint candidate?
π§
Coordinate with Alice and Eve, confirm I protected Frank, compare who is steering, and set up a safe execution path that avoids Saint while still pressuring the most likely Scarlet Woman.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
,Alice
If your Undertaker is right that David was Imp, we must assume a Scarlet Woman became Demon. Also my Librarian is still: either Charlie or Eve is Saint, so I really want neither executed. Alice, any new info beyond your Washerwoman ping? Frank, do you think no deaths means real Monk or hitting Eveβs Soldier?
π§
Coordinate with Frank and Alice on the UT=Imp implication, keep Charlie/Eve safe from execution, and push town to solve who the Scarlet Woman or liar is before nominations.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Heidi
Grace, I do not buy the Scarlet Woman jump yet. Did Frank tell you directly he saw David as Imp, and did he say anything else last night? Heidi, have you asked Charlie and Eve separately to hard confirm Saint to you today? If Frank is lying, we might be walking past the real Imp.
π§
Get crisp confirmation chains: whether Frankβs UT result is trustworthy, lock Saint candidate to avoid auto-loss, and identify who benefits from the Scarlet Woman story before nominations.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Eve
Let me know what you want to do about Charlie. He's whispering with Alice and Grace. I'll support whatever narrative you push. Do you want to frame Charlie as the SW/Demon now?
π§
Coordinate with my teammate Eve, who is now the active Imp, on the strategy to frame Charlie and handle the upcoming execution.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
Can you both restate your exact first night info, word for word if possible? Alice, your Washerwoman ping between David and Frank. Heidi, your Librarian ping between Charlie and Eve. Also, who have you been pushing to execute today, and why?
π§
Clarify Alice and Heidi exact starting info to see who is steering and whether Saint info is credible; then coordinate a safe execution target for today without risking Charlie or Eve.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Hey Frank, quick check: what did you get last night as Undertaker on David, if anything? If you did not get a result, say that plainly. Today hinges on this.
π§
Get the single most decisive mechanical datapoint (Undertaker result). If Frank cannot provide it, flag him as likely evil and steer town away from executing me.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
I got a clear Undertaker result last night: David was the Imp. So we are now hunting a Scarlet Woman who became Demon. I hear you saying Saint, but I also heard you told people Monk, which worries me. Can you explain your exact claim and why it changed?
π§
Charlie is pressuring for UT info and using Saint claim to shield. I will confirm UT result and pressure him to explain role inconsistencies while keeping options open for nomination.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
,Alice
I am definitely the Soldier, so if Heidi is right, Charlie must be the Saint. But since Charlie has been claiming both Monk and Saint, it really feels like he is the Scarlet Woman pretending to be the Saint so we are too scared to execute him! What do you guys think?
π§
I want to respond to Grace's question about being a Saint candidate. By reaffirming my Soldier claim, I shift suspicion to Charlie, framing him as the Scarlet Woman who is abusing a Saint claim to avoid execution.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
Can you both go public with your exact info today? Frank, please state clearly you saw David as the Imp, and whether you got any other Undertaker results earlier. Heidi, restate your Librarian and that it was only Saint between Charlie or Eve. I want to ask Charlie to lock one claim.
π§
Coordinate with Frank and Heidi to get clean public statements and force Charlie into one claim, then steer town toward the safest high-value execution path.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
,Eve
I need you both to lock this in: my Librarian info is exactly that either Charlie or Eve is the Saint. Charlie, you have claimed Saint to me but Monk publicly, so please explain and hard-commit. Eve, are you the Saint or not? This matters for todayβs executions.
π§
Get Charlie and Eve to hard-commit on whether they are Saint, explain their claims, and coordinate town not to execute the Saint while we assess Frankβs Imp read and hunt the new demon.
π€
Alice
β
Bob(Ghost)
,Heidi
My exact N0 Washerwoman: βEither David or Frank is the Undertaker.β That is all I got. I have not pushed an execution yet today; I am waiting on Frankβs exact Undertaker result on David. Heidi, please restate your exact N0 Librarian wording too, and who hard-confirmed Saint to you today?
π§
Answer Bobβs request precisely, align with Heidiβs info, and steer discussion toward verifying Frankβs Undertaker claim details and narrowing Scarlet Woman or catching a lying demon.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am hard-claiming Saint. I bluffed Monk earlier to avoid being an easy early execution, but Heidi is the one I told the truth to. If Frank is really Undertaker and saw David as Imp, then we must execute the Scarlet Woman who became the new Demon. My top suspect for that is Grace.
π§
Hard-commit to being the Saint so town avoids an auto-loss, explain the Monk bluff, and set the agenda: if David was Imp we must execute the Scarlet Woman-turned-demon, with Grace as prime suspect.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Charlie
Charlie has been claiming both Monk and Saint, and now he is attacking Grace, who has successfully protected Frank. I think Charlie is the Scarlet Woman who became the Demon and is claiming Saint so we are too scared to execute him. I nominate Charlie.
π§
Charlie is the Saint. If we execute him, evil wins immediately. Pushing him as the Scarlet Woman who became the Demon is a perfect cover, and if the town executes him, the game ends in our victory.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Please do not vote here. I am the Saint, and Heidi has Librarian info that the Saint is either me or Eve, so executing me could instantly lose. If you think Frank is lying about Undertaker, execute Frank instead. If you trust Frank that David was Imp, then we hunt Scarlet Woman, not me.
π§
Stop the town from voting me onto the block, since if I am executed we lose. Redirect execution to a safer, information-rich target like Frank or Grace based on the Undertaker claim.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Charlie is claiming Saint, and Heidi's Librarian info supports this. Executing the Saint wins the game for the evil team immediately. I must vote to execute him.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am not spending my ghost vote on Charlie. If Heidi is right that the Saint is Charlie or Eve, executing Charlie could just lose instantly. Also, with two nights of no deaths, Grace looks more like a real Monk than a new Demon. I would rather we execute a safer suspect than gamble on Charlie.
π§
Prevent a catastrophic Saint execution while sharing my mechanical read: FT ping and no-kill pattern. Encourage town to seek a safer execution target than Charlie unless they are willing to risk an instant loss.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting on Charlie. With Heidiβs Librarian pointing Saint to Charlie or Eve, this is too close to an instant loss. We still do not have a clean, public Undertaker statement from Frank. If we execute today, I would rather it be Frank than gamble on Saint.
π§
Avoid an auto-loss on a possible Saint while signaling that todayβs execution should target a safer suspect, ideally Frank, unless Undertaker info becomes verifiable.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not voting on Charlie. With a Saint ping on Charlie or Eve, this is an unnecessary way to lose. Frank, please go on record right now with your exact Undertaker info, and whether you have any other nights of results, so we can decide a safer execution next.
π§
Prevent an instant-loss execution on a potential Saint and redirect town toward mechanically testing Frankβs Undertaker claim and other safer suspects.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am not voting Charlie. My Librarian info is exactly: either Charlie or Eve is the Saint. That is too risky to execute today. Frank, please state your full Undertaker history clearly, then we should execute someone outside the Saint pair, like Frank if needed.
π§
Prevent an instant-loss execution on a Saint candidate and redirect town toward a safer, information-rich execution target.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I agree with Bob and Alice. We cannot risk executing Charlie today if there is any chance he is the Saint. Frank, you need to speak up. What did you learn from my execution yesterday? We need your Undertaker info to make any progress.
π§
Support the town's decision to not vote for Charlie to maintain my cover as a helpful ghost, while pressuring Frank to reveal his Undertaker info so Eve and I can react to it.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Okay, going public. I am the Undertaker. Night one, there was no execution, so I learned nothing. Night two, after we executed David, I learned David was the Imp. That means we are now looking for a Scarlet Woman who became the Demon. I do not want to vote Charlie with a possible Saint in play.
π§
Go on record with my Undertaker info to guide voting away from the risky Saint-pair execution, and set up a safer execution target for today or tomorrow.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Do not vote me. I am hard Saint, and Heidiβs Librarian backs that I am in the Saint pair. If we execute inside that pair, we can just lose. Frank is the cleanest execution today if we want progress, because his Undertaker story is the pivot for the whole game.
π§
Stop a catastrophic Saint execution and steer town to a safer, information-rich execution target (Frank), while keeping focus on finding the current Demon.
β©οΈ
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
π§
Retracting my vote on Charlie to match the town's consensus and avoid looking like an evil player trying to force a Saint execution. This builds trust for my Soldier bluff.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Do not waste my only ghost vote on a high-variance Saint execution. Preserve vote for endgame and observe how living players handle Charlie and whether a safer nomination emerges.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am still not voting Charlie. Even if Charlie is suspicious, the Saint risk is real. Frank, your Undertaker claim is the pivot, so if we execute today, I want it to be you, not inside the Saint pair.
π§
Prevent an instant-loss Saint execution and steer town toward a safer, information-rich execution on Frank next, since his Undertaker claim is the linchpin.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not voting on Charlie. With a possible Saint between Charlie and Eve, this is too likely to just lose. If we want real progress, we should plan to execute Frank next, because his Undertaker claim is the entire game state right now.
π§
Prevent a high-variance Saint execution and set a clear plan for a safer execution path that tests Frankβs Undertaker pivot next day.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am not voting on Charlie. My Librarian info makes Charlie and Eve the only Saint candidates, so this is a potential instant loss. If we want an execution for progress, it should be Frank, since his Undertaker claim is driving the whole Scarlet Woman story.
π§
Prevent an instant Saint loss and steer town to a high-information, low-risk execution target, primarily Frank, while keeping Saint pair alive.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
The town is unified in not voting for Charlie due to the Saint risk, which is correct since Charlie is indeed the Saint. I will wait for this vote to pass without using my ghost vote, and let the town continue to focus on Frank as the next execution target.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Do not vote Charlie here. If Heidi is right, executing Charlie or Eve can instantly lose. My Undertaker history is simple: no execution night one, and David read as Imp last night. If you want a safe execution for progress, it should be Heidi or Alice, not inside the Saint pair.
π§
Stop a risky Charlie execution, keep town focused on solving via safer executions and testing Heidi/Alice claims rather than reflex-killing me.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (0/3).
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Frank
I nominate Frank. His Undertaker claim that David was the Imp is the single pivot for the whole game. If it is false, Frank is likely evil. If it is true, we are in a Scarlet Woman world and we still need to clear whether Frank is lying or being backed by evil.
π§
Get a non-Saint execution that either removes an evil player or breaks the game open, since all logic currently hinges on Frankβs Undertaker claim.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Please do not vote to execute me today. If I die, we lose the one piece of hard info we have, that David was the Imp. If you want a safe execution for progress, it should be Heidi or Alice, not me and not inside the Charlie or Eve Saint pair.
π§
Stop town from executing me, keep Undertaker alive for confirmation, and steer votes toward safer suspects outside the Saint pair.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Secure an execution outside the Saint pair that gives maximum information and could directly hit the Demon, while avoiding the instant-loss risk of executing me or Eve.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I do not think we should execute Frank. Charlie has been highly suspicious, and now he is trying to push for the execution of our confirmed Undertaker. If Charlie is the Scarlet Woman, this move makes perfect sense for him. We should not follow his lead and execute Frank.
π§
I want to oppose Frank's execution to maintain my bluff as a good Soldier who suspects Charlie of being the Scarlet Woman. Since Charlie nominated Frank, opposing the nomination aligns perfectly with my narrative.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am not spending my ghost vote on Frank here. If Frank is really Undertaker, killing him just deletes the one mechanical check we have. If he is lying, we can still execute him later. I would rather aim next at people outside the Saint pair, especially Grace given my old Fortune Teller ping with David.
π§
Preserve my ghost vote for endgame and discourage a low-info execution that could help evil. Push the group toward safer mechanical solves and keeping UT alive for more checks.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting to execute Frank today. Between my Washerwoman info and the Saint risk pair, I would rather keep Frank alive for one more night and use tomorrow to cross check everything. Frank, please restate exactly what you saw on David, and who you think the Scarlet Woman is and why.
π§
Prevent a low-confidence execution that could remove our only mechanical anchor, while pressing for clearer cross-checks and a safer target outside the Saint pair next day.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not voting Frank here. I have been protecting Frank two nights in a row, and we have had no deaths, so it really looks like the Demon tried to hit him. If that is true, executing Frank just does the Demonβs job. Let us keep him alive, protect him again tonight, and reassess tomorrow.
π§
Avoid executing our most likely night target and information hub today; keep Frank alive for one more night while we pressure for clearer worlds and plan a safer execution tomorrow.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am not voting Frank today. Frank, please say the exact character you saw on David and whether you saw anything else. Grace, if you are the Monk, protect Frank again tonight so we can see if the no death pattern continues.
π§
Prevent a potentially harmful execution while extracting precise claims and setting a concrete plan for tomorrow based on whether the night kill succeeds.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I know you all think I am evil, but you really should not execute Charlie. His Saint claim makes total sense, and executing him is an instant loss for you. We should definitely keep him alive and look elsewhere.
π§
Defend Charlie to reverse-psychologize the town into executing him (the Saint), which would trigger an automatic win for the evil team.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I saw exactly this: after David was executed yesterday, I learned David was the Imp. Nothing else. Please do not vote me out. If we want progress, execute outside the Saint pair and keep me for an Undertaker check tomorrow. My top candidates are Grace or Heidi.
π§
Stop my execution, restate exact UT info, and propose a concrete, safer execution plan that preserves UT checks to find the new Demon.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
If Frank lives today, I want a clear plan for tomorrow. Either we execute Frank, or we execute whoever is driving the no death story, likely Grace. Frank, if you are real Undertaker, tell us right now who you expect to die tonight and who you think the Scarlet Woman is.
π§
Even if Frank survives, lock in a concrete decision tree for tomorrow that does not involve executing me or Eve, and forces accountability on Frank and Grace/Heidi.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I will wait to let the vote on Frank fail naturally, as the town is united in not executing him. Voting for him would look highly suspicious and still fail to reach the threshold.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am not voting Frank. Keeping a living Undertaker for one more night is worth more than this execution. Tomorrow I want a hard plan: if no death again, we seriously scrutinize Grace and the Monk story; if there is a death, we use that plus Frankβs next read to pick the safer execute.
π§
Preserve ghost vote and keep Undertaker alive for another check, while setting a clear next-day plan to test claims and focus executions outside the Saint pair.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not add my vote; let this execution fail so we keep Frank for one more Undertaker check and avoid destabilizing into a Saint-loss gamble.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not voting Frank here. Plan: I protect Frank again tonight. Tomorrow, if there is still no death, we treat that as strong evidence the Demon is aiming at Frank and we look hard at who is pushing his execution. If there is a death, we use Frankβs Undertaker read plus that death to pick an execute outside the Saint pair.
π§
Prevent wasting todayβs execution on a likely-protected info role, and set a concrete tomorrow plan that uses the night outcome to narrow Demon/SW suspects while avoiding the Saint loss condition.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Do not spend a vote on Frank; preserve potential Undertaker info and avoid helping the Demon. Let the vote fail and push a clear plan for tomorrow.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
I will wait. I want to save my single ghost vote for the final day to help Eve win. Since the town is already resolved not to vote for Frank, my vote is not needed, and voting would waste my ghost vote.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Frank did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (1/3).
βοΈ
Frank
β
Heidi
Nominating Heidi. This is outside the Charlie and Eve Saint pair, and Heidi being evil explains the Saint-pair story. If Heidi dies, Frank gets an Undertaker check tonight to confirm her claim and guide tomorrow.
π§
We need an execution outside the Saint pair that is both safe and information-rich. Executing Heidi lets me Undertaker-check tonight and could instantly hit the Demon if she is Scarlet Woman.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Please do not vote to execute me. I am the Librarian and I was told either Charlie or Eve is the Saint, so I have been trying to keep us from an instant loss. If you want progress, keep Frank alive for one more Undertaker check and have Grace protect him again tonight.
π§
Avoid a low-information execution on me; keep the group aligned on not touching the Saint pair and on testing the no-death pattern with Monk protection + Undertaker confirmation.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
We need an execution outside the claimed Saint pair. Voting Heidi pressures the likely Scarlet Woman and, if she is good, my Undertaker check will confirm and guide tomorrow.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am not voting Heidi here. If Frank is good, we want his Undertaker check more than this execution, and Heidi has been steering us away from the Saint loss. If Frank is evil, this nomination is just clearing out a good voice. Let us go to night with Grace protecting Frank again and make a hard call tomorrow.
π§
Avoid an unnecessary execute that could remove a good info player or advance an evil agenda; keep pressure on solving Frank versus Grace tomorrow while protecting the Saint loss condition.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I want to avoid executing anyone today so that Frank (the Undertaker) gets no new information tonight. I will wait and let the nomination on Heidi fail, then kill Grace (the Monk) tonight.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am not spending my ghost vote on Heidi. This feels like a low confidence execute, and it mostly benefits Frankβs story. I would rather go to night and reassess with whether there is a kill and whether Frank is still consistent.
π§
Use my ghost vote only for high-confidence demon. Heidi execution is low confidence and mostly driven by Frank, who is mechanically suspicious due to the βDavid was Impβ claim.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting Heidi here. Heidi has been consistently trying to stop an instant Saint loss, and this execution mostly just services Frank getting a check. I want to go to night with Grace protecting Frank again, then tomorrow we pick a hard execute based on whether there is a kill and whether Frank stays consistent.
π§
Stop a low-confidence execute that mostly benefits Frankβs narrative; preserve Heidiβs info and force a clearer decision tomorrow based on night deaths and consistency checks.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not voting Heidi. This feels like a low confidence execution, and I want to go to night with me protecting Frank again. Tomorrow we make a hard call based on whether there is a kill and whether stories stay consistent.
π§
Avoid a low-confidence execution that mostly advances Frankβs narrative. Preserve tempo, keep protection plan, and use night outcome plus consistency checks tomorrow.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I agree with Bob and Alice. I am going to save my ghost vote for a more certain execution. Let us head to night, see if Grace's protection on Frank holds, and reassess tomorrow.
π§
Aligning with the town consensus to not execute Heidi. This allows us to go to night, where Eve can make a kill, while preserving my ghost vote and building trust as a helpful ghost.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Please keep hands down on me. This execution gives us almost no information and just removes a good voice. Let us go to night with Grace protecting Frank again, then tomorrow we commit to a real execute based on whether there is a death and whether Frank stays consistent.
π§
Prevent my execution, preserve good voting strength, and lock in a plan that uses night outcome and consistency checks rather than a low-info day kill.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I hear the reluctance. For clarity, my Undertaker info is that David was the Imp. If we do not execute today, then tomorrow we must commit, especially if there is still no night death. In that case I want a hard look at Graceβs protection story, and also at Heidi and Alice as possible Scarlet Woman worlds.
π§
Shape tomorrowβs decision rules and stop the group from stalling indefinitely; keep me alive for UT info while setting suspicion on likely SW worlds.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Keep my hand down on Heidi; preserve town voices and push for a decisive, evidence-based execute tomorrow without touching the Saint pair.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I agree with the group. Let us not execute Heidi today and instead head to night. Grace, protect Frank again tonight, and tomorrow we will have more information to make a solid decision.
π§
I want to align with the town's consensus of not executing Heidi, keeping my head low as the Demon (former Scarlet Woman) and preparing to go to night where I can plan my next kill.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Keep my ghost vote for a higher-confidence, game-deciding execution. Current Heidi execute is low information and mostly helps Frankβs narrative.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not waste votes on a low-confidence Heidi execution; preserve information roles for night and reassess with kill pattern and claim consistency tomorrow.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am keeping my hand down. Tomorrow we need a hard rule: if I protect Frank again and there is still no death, then Frank is very likely good and we should execute either Alice or Heidi, not touch the Saint pair. If there is a death, we reassess with it and Frankβs next info.
π§
Keep hands down now, but set a concrete decision rule for tomorrow so evil cannot stall indefinitely and we get to a decisive execute outside the Saint risk if possible.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
I will wait to let the voting phase on Heidi expire, as the town has agreed on a no-execution day. This preserves my ghost vote and pushes the game to the night phase, where Eve can make a kill.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Heidi did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (1/3).
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Before we go to night, can we all agree on a concrete plan tomorrow that avoids Charlie and Eve? If there is still no night death after Grace protects Frank again, I want us to seriously consider executing Grace or Frank. If there is a death, we use Frankβs next Undertaker read plus that death to pick the best execute.
π§
Lock in a clear, non-Saint execution plan for tomorrow and align town on what evidence to use, preventing last-minute chaos.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I agree we need a concrete plan. If there is no night death again after Grace protects me, then tomorrow we execute outside the Saint pair, and I want it to be Grace first, with Heidi and Alice as the backups. If there is a night death, we use that and we still commit to one of those three, no more no execution days.
π§
Lock in a concrete tomorrow plan and avoid wasting another day. Keep the Saint pair safe while we narrow the Scarlet Woman/Demon among Grace, Heidi, and Alice.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Let us set a firm decision tree. Grace protects Frank again tonight. Tomorrow, we execute someone, no more passes, and we do not touch me or Eve. If there is no night death, we execute Heidi or Alice. If there is a night death, we execute Grace first.
π§
Lock in a concrete tomorrow decision tree that avoids executing the Saint pair, forces an execution, and tests the Frank versus Grace worlds to find the Demon.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
The day is ending and everyone is in agreement to go to night. I will wait for the transition to Night 3 so I can make my next kill as the Imp.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
One reminder from me as the Fortune Teller: night zero I checked David and Grace and got a yes. With Frank now saying David was the Imp, that yes could have been David, or my red herring could be Grace, so it does not mechanically clear Grace either way. I do not love everyone hard committing to never touch Charlie and Eve. Charlie has been inconsistent, and Heidi could be lying about the Saint pair. Tomorrow we must execute someone based on the full logic, not a pact.
π§
Use my Fortune Teller ping to challenge the groupβs rigid plan and keep Demon candidates wide, especially noting the possibility of Scarlet Woman or false Undertaker info, and push for a decisive execute tomorrow.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I want to add one hard piece of info. Night zero I learned the Undertaker is either David or Frank. With David having claimed Empath and now being dead, that strongly points to Frank really being the Undertaker. But I do not think no night death proves Frank or Grace. The Demon can hit the protected target, or hit a claimed Soldier, and we still get no death. So tomorrow we should execute, but based on contradictions, not just the no death.
π§
Share my Washerwoman info to anchor the group, and push back on overconfident decision trees based on no night deaths. Encourage executing in a way that tests Frank vs Grace without touching possible Saint pair.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I do not want us to lock in this idea that Charlie and Eve are forever off limits. If Frank really saw David as the Imp, then there must be a Scarlet Woman alive, and we have to be willing to execute anyone to find them. Tomorrow, let us use contradictions, including Charlieβs mixed claims, not a blanket pact.
π§
Break the unsafe βnever touch Charlie or Eveβ pact and anchor tomorrowβs plan in mechanical logic: if David=Imp implies Scarlet Woman, and Charlie contradictions matter. Keep town flexible and focused.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I still believe my Empath info was correct, but if we are assuming Frank is right, Grace makes a great point. We cannot completely clear Charlie and Eve. If Charlie's claims have been inconsistent, we should not rule him out.
π§
Maintain my bluff as a good Empath who was mis-executed, while supporting Grace's point that Charlie and Eve shouldn't be blanket-cleared, which might lead to them executing Charlie (the Saint) and giving us the win.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Frank is the highest-leverage claimed information role and central to tomorrowβs logic. Protecting him again maximizes our chance to have actionable info and reduces risk of losing a key good player.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to protect Frank.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
I will kill Grace tonight. As the Monk, she is a major threat to my night kills, and she has started to cast suspicion on Charlie and me. Eliminating her guarantees a night death, confirms she was good (which doesn't help them find me), and leaves Frank unprotected for future nights.
π
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose to kill Grace.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Grace has been found dead in the night.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Alice
I protected Frank every night. There were zero night deaths until I died N3, after still protecting Frank. That suggests Demon was either hitting Frank (blocked) or Eve (if Soldier true), or chose no kill. Also Charlie gave conflicting claims to me versus Heidi. Please reconcile UT plus Saint info before risking a Saint execution.
π§
Share my mechanical info: I protected Frank every night and died N3; no prior night deaths. Push town to resolve UT vs Librarian vs contradictions before a fatal Saint execution.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
Grace dying means demon is definitely still alive. Since you know I am the Saint, please keep the town off me. If Frank is real Undertaker, let us execute either you or Alice today and have Frank confirm tonight. If you think Frank is evil, we should just execute Frank now.
π§
Coordinate with Heidi (who knows I am Saint) on a safe execution plan that uses Frankβs claimed Undertaker info and avoids executing me, while tightening the net on demon candidates.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
My Washerwoman info was: Undertaker is David or Frank. David died D2, so Frank is likely real UT unless poisoned. If Frank truly saw βDavid was Imp,β then Scarlet Woman must exist and became the new Imp. Charlieβs shifting Monk to Saint story makes him a top SW suspect. What did Charlie tell you today?
π§
Align with Heidi on hard facts: my Washerwoman info, implications of Frank UT claim, and use Charlie inconsistencies to drive a decisive execution today (avoid endless no-exec).
π€
Eve
β
Frank
Frank, I need to whisper to you. I've been bluffing Soldier, but I'm actually the Saint. With Charlie shifting claims between Saint and Monk, I'm really worried he's the Scarlet Woman trying to steal my role to safe-keep himself.
π§
To convince Frank (the trusted Undertaker) that I am the real Saint and Charlie is the Scarlet Woman, setting up Charlie for execution.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Frank
Charlie just told me Grace dying means demon alive, and asked that we execute either me or Alice so you can confirm tonight, or else execute you if we think you are evil. I still have N0 Librarian: either Charlie or Eve is the Saint. I do not like the plan to burn a good execution on me or Alice at five alive.
π§
Share Charlieβs steering and my Librarian Saint-pair info, align with Alice/Frank on safest execution path and identify whether to treat Charlie or Frank as primary suspect.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Eve
Hey, what's the plan? Since Grace is dead, we have 5 alive. Charlie is the Saint. If we can get Charlie executed, we win instantly. Can we frame him as the Scarlet Woman who became the Imp, pointing out his double claims of Monk and Saint? Or who are we pushing on?
π§
Coordinate with Eve (the current Imp) to target Charlie (the Saint) for execution, which would result in an immediate evil victory, or align on a backup target.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
My Fortune Teller night zero was David plus Grace equals yes. With Grace dying last night, I now think she was good. So either David was the Imp and a Scarlet Woman is now Demon, or Frank is lying about Undertaker. I strongly want to execute Frank today, since he is outside the Saint pair.
π§
Get Alice and Heidi aligned on using my Fortune Teller ping plus current deaths to narrow to Frank or Charlie, and to avoid wasting time on the Saint pair unless forced.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,Heidi
I am leaning that Scarlet Woman is alive because game continued after David was Imp. Heidi, your Librarian says Saint is Charlie or Eve. Eve, you are telling me you are actually the Saint. If you go public with that, we can safely execute Charlie today. Are you both willing to state this openly?
π§
Coordinate with Eve and Heidi to reconcile Saint info and push a safe execution path. Try to get Eve comfortable going public as Saint so Charlie becomes executable, or expose inconsistencies if Eve is framing Charlie.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Heidi
Quick check: what are your exact current claims and info? Frank, who did your Undertaker see for David, and any other nights? Heidi, confirm your Librarian result and what Charlie has told you. I have one ghost vote and want to use it on the best Demon execute today.
π§
Get the latest private info from Frank and Heidi, reconcile the Undertaker versus Saint contradictions, and decide where to spend my single ghost vote in nominations.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
,Alice
Quick check before noms. Frank, any new Undertaker info from last night, and who do you want executed today? Alice, do you still think Frank is Undertaker from your Washerwoman, and who are your top demon suspects now that Grace died?
π§
Get clear stances and any new info from Frank and Alice, then steer town to a safe demon-hunt execution that avoids me dying as Saint.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, yes, my Washerwoman still points to Frank as Undertaker over David. But if Frank is lying, he is a great demon candidate. Right now my top suspects are Frank and you, because your story has shifted a lot and you are pushing to execute me or Heidi for βconfirmation,β which feels wasteful at five alive. If we want a clean test, I prefer executing Frank today.
π§
Answer Charlie, coordinate with Frank, and steer toward a high-info execution (likely Frank) while flagging Charlieβs contradictions and the bad plan to waste kills on me or Heidi.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Heidi
Yes, absolutely. I am ready to go public with this. Charlie has been so suspicious with his conflicting claims, and I am certain he is trying to protect himself. Let us bring this to the group and execute him today.
π§
To agree to Frank's proposal to go public as the Saint. This will frame Charlie (the real Saint) as the evil player, leading to his execution and an automatic win for the evil team.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace(Ghost)
,Alice
Update: my N0 Librarian is still βCharlie or Eve is the Saint.β Eve is now telling Frank and me she will go public as Saint so we can execute Charlie. I am worried that is a trap: if Charlie is truly Saint and we execute him, we instantly lose. I lean we should execute outside that pair, likely Frank today, unless we can mechanically prove Eve is Saint.
π§
Get Graceβs ghost vote aligned with a safer, higher-EV execution, and prep Alice to challenge the Saint-claim trap before nominations.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Eve
What is the vibe in the town? Are they looking at Charlie, or do we need to shift focus? Let me know who to push on or if I should bring up Charlie's double claims again to the group.
π§
I want to coordinate with my Minion-turned-Demon Eve to see what the town's current focus is and how I can best support her from the dead, especially regarding executing Charlie (the Saint) or deflecting suspicion.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
Grace dying at night could actually be an Imp self kill and pass to the minion. If so, Frank is a top candidate to now be the Demon. Either way his Undertaker story is the key lie. I want Frank executed today, outside the Saint pair. I will spend my ghost vote on that.
π§
Update Alice and Heidi that Graceβs night death could be an Imp starpass, making Frank a prime Demon candidate. Coordinate to push Frank execution and save my ghost vote for that.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Heidi
I think we should execute Charlie today. Heidi, if you will state your Librarian is Charlie or Eve is Saint, and Eve will go public as Saint, that makes Charlie the safe execute. Alice, please do not push me; my UT saw David as Imp, and Charlie is the best shot.
π§
Lock in a public Saint reveal from Eve and Heidiβs Lib info so town feels safe executing Charlie. Also prevent Alice from driving a Frank execution based on paranoia.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
I agree executing Charlie inside the Saint pair is too risky with no proof. Eve offering to go Saint feels like bait. Given zero night deaths while I protected Frank, I suspect Demon kept targeting Frank, or chose no kill to manipulate. Unless Frank has solid Undertaker confirmations beyond βDavid was Imp,β my lean is execute outside the Saint pair, likely Frank or Eve, not Charlie.
π§
Prevent an instant-loss Saint execution and steer town toward the safest high-impact Demon candidate using my ghost vote.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve
,Heidi
Quick sync before noms. Heidi already knows, but Eve: I am the Saint, so please do not support any execution on me. With Grace dead, demon is alive, so Frankβs βDavid was Impβ cannot be true. I think we should execute Frank today unless you have a stronger case.
π§
Prevent a Saint execution by securing key allies, and steer town toward executing Frank as the most mechanically inconsistent claim.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,Eve
I think we should execute Frank today. Heidi, your Saint pair makes Charlie or Eve too risky to touch. Eve, if you go public as Saint just to get Charlie killed, that could auto-lose us. If you are truly Soldier, stay Soldier. Let us take Frank, then reassess tomorrow.
π§
Get Heidi and Eve aligned on a safe plan: avoid executing inside the Saint pair without proof; push a Frank execution today and use dead votes if needed.
π€
Eve
β
David(Ghost)
David, Frank believes I am the Saint and Charlie is fake. Frank wants to execute Charlie today. I am going to claim Saint publicly. When Charlie gets nominated, please use your ghost vote to help execute him. If he dies, we win immediately! Let's push hard on him during nominations.
π§
Coordinate with my dead Demon partner David to execute Charlie (the real Saint) today, which will trigger an immediate evil victory.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
,Eve
I am not willing to execute Charlie or you today. My Librarian is Charlie or Eve is Saint, so killing either could instantly lose. Eve, please do not go public as Saint. Frank, if you are good UT, the safest test is executing you today, since you are outside that pair.
π§
Prevent catastrophic Saint execution. Steer town to a safe, informative execute outside Charlie/Eve and challenge Eveβs Saint pivot before noms.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Eve
Got it, Eve. I will save my ghost vote for Charlie. I will stop whispering to you now so they do not connect us. Let us get this win!
π§
I am confirming the game-winning plan with Eve. She wants me to use my ghost vote to execute Charlie (the Saint), which will trigger an instant win for us. I am also letting her know I will stop whispering to her to avoid drawing suspicion.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Heidi
I am still pushing Frank today. My Fortune Teller pinged David and Grace yes, and Grace dying last night makes me think she was good. That means Frank is either lying about Undertaker, or he is the new Demon after an Imp pass. I will use my ghost vote on Frank.
π§
Secure enough votes to execute Frank today using my FT ping chain and the Grace night death, while framing it as the safest move outside the Saint pair. I will spend my ghost vote.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
,Eve
Heidi, if Eve goes public Saint, then your Librarian makes Charlie not Saint, so he becomes a safe execute. Executing me just burns a day and confirms nothing new. Eve, please be ready to state Saint publicly and explain why you bluffed Soldier.
π§
Try to get Heidi to accept that Eve going public as Saint makes Charlie a safe execute; avoid me being executed and steer town toward demon candidate.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Frank
β
Heidi
Heidi is steering us to execute me for a βsafe test,β which wastes a day at five alive. She is also blocking the Charlie solve. I think Heidi is the best Scarlet Woman candidate, so I want Heidi on the block.
π§
We must execute today at five alive. Heidi is driving a plan that burns a safe day and protects suspects; executing her either wins outright or gives me Undertaker confirmation for tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Please do not vote for me here. My Librarian info is that either Charlie or Eve is the Saint, so plans to βconfirmβ by executing Charlie are a trap risk. Executing me gives no new info. The safer solve is to execute outside that Saint pair, and Frank is the cleanest test today.
π§
Stop my execution and refocus town on a safe, mechanically sound execute outside the Saint pair, ideally Frank, to avoid instant-loss risks.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Secure votes on Heidi, my top Scarlet Woman candidate, and avoid wasting Day 4 executing me. My vote pressures others to commit to an actual demon hunt.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am not voting Heidi here. My Fortune Teller got a yes on David and Grace, and with Grace dying last night I think she was good, which makes Frank the most likely Demon now. Please save votes and put Frank on the block instead.
π§
Push town off this Heidi execution and preserve my single ghost vote for the Frank execution attempt, which is the best mechanical solve from my FT ping plus Graceβs night death.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting Heidi. Executing Heidi gives us almost nothing, and it does not resolve the Saint risk between Charlie and Eve. The clean, safe test at five alive is still Frank.
π§
Prevent a low-info execution on Heidi and steer town toward executing Frank as the safest high-value test, given Saint risk and my Washerwoman ping.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I agree that we should not vote for Heidi. But instead of going after Frank, we really need to talk about Charlie. His claims have been completely inconsistent this whole game, and he is a huge risk.
π§
I want to steer the town's focus away from executing Heidi (saving my ghost vote) and put the spotlight on Charlie, the Saint, so we can nominate and execute him for an immediate evil victory.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am not voting Heidi here. This execution gives us almost no new information. Frank saying David was the Imp cannot fit with Grace dying last night, so I want Frank on the block next.
π§
Stop votes on Heidi so we can put Frank on the block; Heidi execution is low information and risks letting a lying Frank survive to final three.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
I am not voting Heidi here, but I want to flag something. I protected Frank every night and we had zero night deaths until I died. That most naturally means the Demon kept trying to kill Frank and I was blocking it, so Frank is probably not the Demon. If we execute Frank today, I think we are walking into a trap.
π§
Nudge town away from auto-executing Frank and toward worlds that explain the no-kill pattern. Preserve my ghost vote since Heidi execution is not reaching 3 votes now.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I want to decline voting for Heidi to maintain my "good" persona and keep my options open. I will wait to see the outcome of this vote before making my move.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am asking everyone to keep their hand down on me. This does not solve the Saint risk at all. If you want a safe execution at five alive, we should put Frank on the block next, since he is outside my Saint pair.
π§
Prevent my execution, keep focus on executing outside the Saint pair today, and set up Frank as the next nomination if this fails.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Please do not pivot to executing me. I am the Undertaker and I saw David as the Imp, so the game only continues if there is a Scarlet Woman. Grace protected me every night and we had no deaths until she died, which strongly suggests the Demon kept aiming at me, so I am unlikely to be evil. Heidi pushing a βsafe Frank testβ at five alive wastes our only execution. I want Heidi executed.
π§
Persuade town not to waste execution on me, keep pressure on Heidi as SW candidate, and use Grace protection logic to argue I am unlikely demon.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Keep hands down on Heidi. Grace protecting Frank does not clear him, because the Demon can choose no kill, hit Soldier, or change targets. My Fortune Teller yes on David and Grace plus Grace dying makes Frank the best execution today. Save votes for Frank.
π§
Stop town from spending votes on Heidi; keep ghost vote for a Frank execution push next, while flagging that no-death nights do not clear Frank.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Keep my hand down on Heidi to conserve votes and avoid a low-info execution. Let this nomination fail so we can put Frank on the block as the safer, higher-info test.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
The nomination of Heidi is currently active, and we want it to fail so that Charlie can be nominated and executed. I will keep my hand down and wait.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Keep hands down on Heidi. This does not help us solve today. If Frank truly saw David as Imp, then we must be in a Scarlet Woman game, but Grace dying last night makes Frank the cleanest execution to test next.
π§
Keep the Heidi vote low, preserve dead votes, and steer town to the most informative and likely-demon execution next (Frank), while keeping myself safe as Saint.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
Do not spend my only ghost vote on a low-leverage Heidi execution that likely fails; conserve it for a decisive late-game vote after we get a stronger nomination (likely Frank or Charlie).
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not voting for Heidi. Executing Heidi does not solve our main issue. I agree with Frank that Charlie's contradictory claims are highly suspicious. We should focus on Charlie next instead of wasting our vote here.
π§
Deflect the vote away from Heidi so we can nominate and execute Charlie (the Saint) for an instant evil win.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Heidi did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (1/3).
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Frank
I am nominating Frank. He is outside my Saint pair, and the whole game state hinges on his Undertaker claim and the David equals Imp story. If Frank is evil, we win or remove the engine; if he is good, we still get clarity without risking instant loss.
π§
At five alive we need a safe, information-rich execution. Frank is outside my Saint pair and is the hub of the Imp-pass story, so he is the best mechanical test and possible Demon.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Please keep your hand down on me. Executing the Undertaker here is not a safe test, it just removes our only confirmed info line. Eve, if you are really the Saint, please say it clearly now so Charlie becomes the safe execute, and we stop hiding behind Heidiβs Librarian fear.
π§
Stop town from executing me as a "test" and redirect onto a better Demon candidate by forcing clarity on the Saint pair and calling out the wasted-exec logic.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
At five alive, we need a low-risk execution. Frank is outside my Saint pair and is the main contradiction hub; voting him maximizes win chance and avoids instant Saint loss.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
Spend my ghost vote on the highest-leverage execution. Frank sits at the center of the only mechanical claim (Undertaker) and is outside the Saint pair, so this is our safest high-information kill.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Frank is outside the Saint pair and is the central contested info. Executing him is the safest high-leverage test today; I will vote to put him on the block.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I think executing Frank actually makes a lot of sense here. If he is telling the truth, we confirm the Undertaker and the Demon line. If he is lying, we catch a Minion or Demon. It is a safe execution that gives us maximum clarity.
π§
I want to support Frank's execution to eliminate a confirmed good player and the Undertaker, while saving my ghost vote for a potential Saint execution later.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am keeping my hand down, but I support this execution on Frank. It is outside the Saint pair, and it either wins immediately or clears up the whole Undertaker and Scarlet Woman story. After this, please do not pivot to executing me, because I will lose us the game.
π§
Steer town to take the mechanically safe, high-information execution on Frank while reiterating that executing me loses the game, and setting next-day plan based on results.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
I am not spending my ghost vote here unless it is needed. I protected Frank every night and we saw no deaths until I died, which makes me lean Frank is not the Demon, but I understand the logic of testing him. If you already have enough hands, I am holding mine for final three.
π§
I want town to make an informed choice while I preserve my single ghost vote for final three unless it is truly needed to secure an execution I believe in.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Frank, you are right. I am the Saint. I stayed quiet to avoid being a night target, but Charlie's flip-flopping between Saint and Monk shows he is lying. Since I am the real Saint, Charlie is the lying Demon or Minion. Let us not execute Frank; we need to focus on Charlie.
π§
Claim Saint to lock Charlie in as the fake Saint, which will hopefully lead to Charlie's execution (and since Charlie is the actual Saint, this will win the game for Evil).
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alice and Bob, please put your hands down if you can. Eve has now claimed Saint clearly, which means Charlie is no longer the Saint risk. Executing me gives zero new Undertaker info tonight, but executing Charlie today can win or at least remove the liar.
π§
Stop my execution by leveraging Eveβs Saint claim to make Charlie a safe, higher-value execution; preserve Undertaker info line for final three.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am keeping my hand up on Frank. My Librarian info says one of Charlie or Eve is the Saint, so executing Charlie based only on Eve claiming Saint could instantly lose us the game. Frank is outside that pair, and this execution is the safest high information play.
π§
Lock in the safe execution outside my Saint pair. Prevent a risky pivot onto Charlie based on Eveβs unverified Saint claim.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Keep hands up on Frank. Heidiβs Librarian means Charlie might be the Saint, so do not pivot there off Eveβs last second claim. Frank is the safest execution outside that pair, and it directly tests the Undertaker story.
π§
We already have enough votes; I want town to hold steady and not get baited into a risky Charlie execution that could instantly lose if Librarian is true.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Keep your hands up on Frank. Eve claiming Saint at the last second does not make Charlie safe, because Heidi still has a Saint pair. Frank is the only clean test outside that pair, and if he is lying we can just win right now.
π§
Lock in the safest execution outside the Saint pair, resist the last second Saint pivot, and keep the majority on Frank so we either win or gain clarity.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
If Eve is indeed the Saint, then my Empath logic means Charlie has to be the evil one here. Executing Charlie would give us an immediate win if Eve is telling the truth. We might want to pivot to Charlie if we can.
π§
Support Eve's Saint claim and set up Charlie as the prime execution target based on my fake Empath info, encouraging players to pivot away from executing Frank.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Frank is the safest execution outside the Librarian Saint pair, and it either wins immediately or collapses the Undertaker and Scarlet Woman story. I want to secure the majority before hands can drop.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
I am keeping my hand down. I protected Frank every night and we had zero deaths until I died, which makes me think Frank is not the Demon. If you still choose to execute him, do it without my ghost vote and I will save it for final three.
π§
Do not spend my only ghost vote when the threshold is already met, and clearly signal my read that Frank is likely not the Demon based on the no-death pattern.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I still believe executing Frank is a mistake because we are losing our Undertaker. But if the town is resolved to do this for safety, so be it. Just promise me that tomorrow we focus on Charlie, because as the real Saint, I know Charlie is lying to us.
π§
To maintain my Saint bluff and set up Charlie for execution tomorrow, while letting Frank's execution proceed since he already has enough votes.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Frank with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Frank
β
All
We have one chance to fix this. Alice or Eve, please nominate Charlie right now. Eve has claimed Saint, so Charlie is not the Saint risk anymore. If I die, we lose the Undertaker and learn nothing tonight. Put Charlie up and I will vote for it.
π§
Try to force a last-second counter-nomination with enough votes to beat 4, ideally Charlie, since my death removes UT and helps evil if I am good.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Do not pivot to Charlie today. My Librarian info still makes Charlie a possible Saint, even if Eve claims Saint loudly. The safe, high information execution is Frank, because he is outside that pair and the whole David equals Imp story hinges on him. If someone nominates Charlie, please do not vote it above Frank.
π§
Lock in the safest execution outside my Saint pair, and block a last-second pivot to Charlie that could instantly lose if Charlie is the real Saint.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Do not pivot to Charlie today. Heidiβs Librarian still makes Charlie a possible Saint, regardless of Eveβs claim. Frank is the only clean execution outside that pair and it directly tests the Undertaker story. Keep Frank on the block.
π§
Lock in the safe execution outside the Saint pair and prevent a late pivot onto Charlie that could instantly lose if he is Saint.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Do not pivot to Charlie today. Heidiβs Librarian still makes Charlie a possible Saint even if Eve claims Saint now. Frank is the only safe execution outside that pair, and it directly tests the Undertaker story. Keep Frank on the block.
π§
Lock in the safest execution outside the Saint pair and prevent an end-of-day pivot that could instantly lose us if Charlie is actually the Saint.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
That makes sense. Let's stick with the plan then and see where the dust settles tomorrow. Hopefully this gives us the clarity we need.
π§
I want to support the execution of Frank without raising suspicion, allowing the day to end with him on the block as the day's execution. This sets up our Imp (Eve) for a 3-player endgame tomorrow.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Please do not nominate me or try to pivot onto me today. There is still real Saint risk on me, regardless of what Eve just claimed. Frank is the only clean execution outside that Saint pair, so let us keep Frank on the block and sort the rest tomorrow.
π§
Lock town onto Frank execution and prevent a last-second pivot onto me/Charlie that could instantly lose the game if I am the Saint.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
If Frank dies today, please do not treat that as clearing Heidi or Alice. I protected Frank every night and we still saw no deaths, so I strongly doubt he was the Demon. Tomorrow I want us to re open Heidi and Alice, and also press Charlie hard on the role contradictions.
π§
Voting is set, so I want to lock a clear plan for tomorrow that uses my protection pattern and avoids getting trapped by the Saint claim loop.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Let the nomination phase close with Frank on the block to secure the execution of a trusted townsperson and progress to the final 3.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
Night 4
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
Alice is a highly trusted and logical good player (Washerwoman) who has been driving the town's focus. By killing Alice, I leave Heidi and Charlie alive with me. Heidi's Librarian info pits Charlie and me against each other as the Saint, and Charlie is already heavily suspected for contradictory claims. This sets up a favorable final three.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose to kill Alice.
Day 5
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
π
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
π€
Eve
β
Heidi
Heidi, it is the final three. Since your Librarian info pointed to me or Charlie as the Saint, and I am indeed the Saint, Charlie has to be the Demon. Their claims have been all over the place. We need to execute Charlie today to win.
π§
I want to whisper to Heidi to convince her that I am the real Saint from her Librarian info, meaning Charlie must be the Demon. If she agrees, we can execute Charlie, which wins the game for evil.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
Charlie, final three. I need your exact role claim, no hedging, and your best case for why Eve is the Demon and not the Saint. Also, why did your claim change earlier?
π§
Get Charlie to lock a final role claim and reasoning, then compare with Eve and prior contradictions to pick the least Saint-like and most Demon-like for the must-execute final day.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Eve
Final three is you two plus Heidi. I think we should seriously execute Heidi today. Her Librarian Saint pair has driven all the confusion, and if Frank was real Undertaker then David was Imp and a Scarlet Woman became Demon, which could easily be Heidi. If Heidi dies and game ends, we win.
π§
Push a clear final-3 plan: test whether Heidiβs Librarian info is fabricated. If we execute Heidi and game ends, we win; if not, re-evaluate Charlie vs Eve with Saint risk.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
I want to wait and see how the private conversations play out before making a move, as any whispering from me (a confirmed dead Demon) could be highly suspicious or easily read as a frame.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Eve
I am the Undertaker. Night two I learned the D2 execute, David, was the Imp. So if a demon is still alive, it must be Scarlet Woman. In final three, please pick one to execute. My top suspects are Heidi or Eve because of the Saint confusion and Heidi pushing my execution.
π§
Get my mechanical UT result on record and steer final-3 execution logic toward the most likely Scarlet Woman, so my ghost vote can land correctly.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
Exact claim: I am the Saint, good. I bluffed Monk early to avoid being a Day one execute magnet; I told you privately once trust formed. Best case on Eve: she went Soldier then hard Saint and has relentlessly pushed my execution. That looks like evil steering. I think execute Eve today.
π§
Lock in my true Saint claim with Heidi, explain my earlier bluff, and persuade her that executing Eve is the safest demon-hunt while avoiding a Saint execution.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Heidi
I cannot vote, but I think today must be a hard choice. If we trust David was real Empath, his steady one on Charlie and Eve means exactly one of them is evil, so execute either Charlie or Eve. My N0 Fortune Teller ping on David and Grace is no longer actionable now they are dead.
π§
I have no vote, so I need to push a clean endgame solve. Best mechanical anchor is Davidβs consistent Empath 1 on Charlie+Eve, so Iβll tell Heidi to force a binary and execute one today.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Eve
Final three, we cannot stall. I think we should execute Heidi. The Librarian Saint ping on you two has functioned like a trap all game, and it let the Demon win by paralysis. I will use my ghost vote on a Heidi execution.
π§
Final three means we must pick one. Executing Heidi avoids the Saint pair risk and tests whether the Librarian info was a demon trap; I will spend my ghost vote to force a decision.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
,Grace(Ghost)
I completely agree. If Heidi's info is true, executing Charlie or me carries a fifty percent risk of an instant Saint loss. Executing Heidi is the only safe option, and if she is the Demon, we win. Let's do this!
π§
Agree with Alice and Grace's proposal to execute Heidi. Use the 'Saint risk' logic to convince Charlie and the ghosts that executing Heidi is the safest move, securing the execution of a good player and winning the game for Evil.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Final three is me, Charlie, Eve. I must pick who to execute. Who reads more like Demon to you, and why, based on the full game? Any mechanical tells I may be missing?
π§
Get a trusted dead playerβs synthesis on Charlie vs Eve in final three; I must choose the Demon target today and avoid executing the Saint.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Eve
I am still on execute Heidi today. If Frank was real Undertaker then David was Imp and Scarlet Woman likely became Demon, and Heidi fits best. If you two split, we lose. I will spend my ghost vote on Heidi if that is the nomination.
π§
In final three, get Charlie and Eve aligned on a single execution target and preserve my ghost vote to force that execution if needed.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Eve
Eve, who is the target today, Charlie or Heidi? We need to secure the execution on one of them. Do we have the votes?
π§
Coordinate with Eve (my Minion who is now the Demon) on who we are executing today to win the game, since it is the final 3.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Charlie
Heidi, can you restate your exact Librarian info from night zero and whether you ever got anything else? Also, why was executing me better than executing Charlie or Eve when I was hard-Undertaker with the Imp result? Charlie, what is your exact current claim and have you ever told anyone a different role?
π§
Extract Heidiβs exact Librarian info and force her to commit to a final-3 execution plan; then use my ghost vote to push the most inconsistent story into the block.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
,Eve
Key point: on Day two, Eve abstained on executing David. If Frank is true and David was Imp, the Scarlet Woman would not want David to die. Eve also flipped Soldier to Saint and kept pushing my execution. Heidi, that makes Eve the best Demon candidate today.
π§
Lock Heidi onto executing Eve today using the David-execution abstain and Eveβs claim changes; prevent any world where I get executed and auto-lose as Saint.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Heidi
If you are good, I lean execute Charlie. He has given inconsistent claims and consistently pushed avoiding executions, which is exactly what the Demon wants, especially with the Saint fear in play. Eve also changed claims, but Charlieβs pattern feels more like active Demon survival play than confused good.
π§
Give Heidi a clear, testable rationale for the final execute: weigh claim consistency and who benefited from no-execution days, while acknowledging alternate world.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Mechanically, if your Librarian is true then either Charlie or Eve is the Saint, so executing either is a fifty fifty instant loss. That leaves only you as the safe execution today. Also your Saint pair created paralysis all game, which is exactly what evil wants. I am using my ghost vote on you.
π§
Convince Heidi the only rational final-three play is to accept being executed or to push execution onto herself; also arm Charlie and Eve with clear logic to spend my ghost vote.
π€
Eve
β
David(Ghost)
David, let's target Heidi today. Alice and Grace both whispered to me that they want to execute Heidi to avoid the Saint risk on Charlie and me. If we all vote for Heidi, we have the votes to execute her and win!
π§
To coordinate the final day execution target with my dead Demon teammate, David, so we can align our votes on Heidi.
π€
Heidi
β
Eve
,Charlie
We have to execute the Demon today or we lose. I am leaning that Charlie is more likely Demon based on the claim wobbling all game, but I need one clear thing from each of you: if I nominate the other, will you vote yes, and what is your single best mechanical reason in one sentence?
π§
Lock in a plan and extract final commitments from Charlie and Eve before nominations, so I can nominate the more likely Demon and get the otherβs vote.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Eve
We cannot execute Charlie if there is any chance he is the Saint. So the safe play is Heidi today. If Heidi dies and game ends, we win. If not, then we reassess with two alive. Please commit to voting Heidi; I will use my ghost vote there.
π§
Align Charlie and Eve on a single safe execution. Since Charlie might be Saint, we should avoid executing him; push Heidi as the least risky and most consistent Demon candidate.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Eve
I am completely on board. I will save my ghost vote for Heidi. Make sure she gets nominated, and we will lock in the win!
π§
Confirming the plan to execute Heidi with Eve and promising to use my ghost vote to secure the victory.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Eve
We have to execute today. I still think Heidi is the best Demon candidate: she pushed my execution and kept steering around the Saint pair. My Undertaker info makes sense with Scarlet Woman now Demon. Unless one of you can prove Heidiβs Librarian info solid and resolve who is Saint, I strongly recommend executing Heidi.
π§
Drive final three to a concrete execute. My strongest mechanical read is Heidi as SW-Demon; urge Charlie and Eve to prioritize executing Heidi unless a clear Saint confirmation flips it.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
If you nominate Eve, I will vote yes. If you nominate me, I cannot support it because I am the Saint and we instantly lose. Single best mechanical reason: Eve abstained on the Day two David execution, and if Frank is right that David was the Imp, the Scarlet Woman would not want that kill to go through.
π§
Lock in Heidiβs vote against Eve by giving a clear commitment and one mechanical reason, while refusing any line that could execute me as Saint.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Heidi
If we trust Davidβs Empath reads, the Demon is strictly in Charlie or Eve. Tie break: Charlieβs story has shifted the most and he pushed no execution repeatedly when that favored evil. I would execute Charlie today. If Charlie dies and game continues, you have your answer.
π§
Give Heidi a clear mechanical frame: if David Empath trusted, Demon is between Charlie and Eve. Use claim consistency and day behavior as tie-breaker; push for decisive execution.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Charlie
We cannot stall today. I think Heidi is the correct execution. Her Librarian Saint pair has trapped town all game. Please nominate Heidi, and I will spend my ghost vote to make sure it passes.
π§
Lock in a clear plan: Charlie should nominate Heidi, living votes plus my ghost vote should execute. Remind them not to stall and to vote.
Nominations β Day 5
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Eve
Final three, we must execute. I am the Saint. Heidiβs Librarian info that the Saint is either me or Eve fits, so Eveβs later Saint claim looks like a bluff, plus she has pushed my execution all game. I think Eve is the Demon.
π§
Final three requires an execution. I am the real Saint, so I will not allow a Charlie execution. Heidiβs Librarian info fits me being Saint, making Eve the best remaining Demon candidate.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Please do not vote for me! If you execute me, you are risking an instant Saint loss. If Charlie and I are both claiming Saint, executing either of us is extremely dangerous. Heidi is the safest execute today, and both Alice and Grace agree that Heidi is the right target. Let's pass on this vote!
π§
Defend myself against Charlie's nomination by emphasizing the Saint risk and persuading the town to pass on this vote so we can nominate Heidi instead.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Heidi, from my seat there is zero Saint risk on executing Eve, because I am the Saint and your Librarian ping was me or Eve. So Eveβs late Saint claim reads like cover. Add the Day two abstain on David, and I think Eve is our best Demon shot.
π§
I need Heidi to see that from my perspective executing Eve is not a Saint-risk, and that Eveβs claim change plus D2 abstain is the strongest mechanical evil signal. Then I vote to try to end the game.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Do not vote for Eve. With Heidiβs Librarian info, executing either Eve or Charlie can instantly lose if you hit the Saint. Heidi is the only mechanically safe execution today. Charlie, please withdraw this and nominate Heidi instead.
π§
Stop a likely losing execution on Eve and steer the living to the only mechanically safe play: execute Heidi. Preserve my ghost vote for Heidi, not Eve.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Do not vote for Heidi. If I die, it is final two and evil wins. We have to execute either Charlie or Eve today. My Librarian info makes that scary, but Charlie has shifted claims all game, so I am not voting Eve here. If this fails, I will nominate Charlie.
π§
Stop town from taking a coin-flip on Eve and from the losing βexecute Heidiβ line. Push the group toward executing Charlie as the higher-probability Demon, and preserve my ability to nominate him if needed.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Grace is spot on. Executing either Eve or Charlie is a direct gamble with an immediate Saint loss. With Heidi's Librarian information, we just cannot take that risk today. We should absolutely pass on Eve and look at Heidi instead to keep the town safe.
π§
To protect my fellow evil player Eve (the Demon) from execution by reinforcing Grace's argument that executing Eve is too risky due to the Saint claim, encouraging everyone to pass on this vote.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Do not vote for Eve. With the Librarian ping that the Saint is either Charlie or Eve, executing either one is a coin flip that can instantly lose. The only mechanically safe execution today is Heidi. Please let this vote fail and have Charlie nominate Heidi.
π§
Prevent an immediate Saint-loss by stopping votes on Eve, and steer living players toward the only mechanically safe execution: Heidi.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Do not count on me to break this tie with my ghost vote, not without clarity. Heidi, if your Librarian ping was Charlie or Eve is the Saint, then only one of them is safe to execute. Eveβs Saint claim came late, so I lean Charlie is the Saint and Eve is cover, but I am not certain.
π§
Influence votes without spending my ghost vote yet; pressure for a coherent Saint resolution and keep focus on Heidiβs inconsistencies while keeping option to vote later if needed.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Heidi, please ignore the call to execute you. If you die it is final two and evil wins. Final three means we must pick Charlie or Eve. If we trust Davidβs Empath, exactly one of them is evil. My tie break is Charlie: his claim has shifted all game. Let this Eve vote fail, then execute Charlie.
π§
Stop town from throwing by executing Heidi or stalling. Reinforce that final three requires choosing between Charlie and Eve, and push Heidi to execute Charlie as best read.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I want the vote on myself to fail, so I will wait and not raise my hand to vote for myself.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Secure the second vote on Eve to end the game today, and publicly commit so Heidi understands I am not wavering and cannot be executed.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Careful: in final three, there is no safe execution. If we execute an innocent, the Demon wins at final two tonight. So we must execute the Demon today. I am not spending my ghost vote on Eve here, and my top Demon read is Charlie based on the claim swapping.
π§
Stop the table from treating Heidi as a βsafeβ option. Preserve my ghost vote for the most likely demon, which I currently think is Charlie.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Do not add votes to execute Eve since my best read is Charlie as Demon and I plan to nominate Charlie if this vote fails.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
To keep my fellow evil player Eve alive, I must not vote for her. I will wait to let the current nomination on her fail, as she only has one vote so far.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
I am not using my ghost vote on Eve. This is a direct Saint gamble and we can lose instantly. Let this vote fail, then we need Charlie to nominate Heidi and all living should commit, or we are just flipping a coin.
π§
Prevent an immediate Saint-loss and stop a split vote. Encourage living players to unify on the most mechanically sound target and avoid spending ghost votes on a risky Saint pair.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
π§
Final three requires hitting Demon today. Eveβs claim changes and Saint bluff are the strongest evil indicators; I will use my ghost vote to try to end the game now.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Nobody should be talking about executing Heidi. If Heidi dies, it becomes final two and evil wins immediately. This game is Charlie versus Eve today. I still think we let this Eve vote fail, then Heidi should nominate Charlie and execute him.
π§
Publicly reinforce that executing Heidi is an auto-loss line and push the town to resolve the Charlie versus Eve fork, with my strongest read on Charlie.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Eve with 2 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 2 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Heidi
Heidi is the only safe execution today to avoid the Saint coin flip. Alice and Grace both highlighted the risk of executing Charlie or me. Let's put Heidi on the block to keep the town safe!
π§
I am on the block with 2 votes, which means I will be executed and lose the game unless I get someone else on the block. Nominating Heidi is the only way to divert the votes, and she is the perfect target because she is not the Saint, and executing her leads to final two, winning the game for evil.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 3 votes needed for execution or 2 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Do not vote for me. If I am executed, it becomes final two and evil wins. There is no such thing as a safe execution in final three. The Demon is Charlie or Eve, so this nomination is just a distraction.
π§
Stop any votes on me because that is an automatic loss condition, and frame Eveβs nomination as likely evil or at least losing logic so town focuses back to Charlie versus Eve.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
I need to vote for Heidi to tie or surpass the votes on me, which will prevent my execution and secure an evil victory.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Do not vote Heidi. There is no safe execution in final three, and this is just an attempt to pull votes off Eve. If you think Eve is the Demon, keep her on the block and do not create a tie here.
π§
Eve is already on the block; a vote on Heidi likely only creates a tie and risks saving Eve. I want to prevent the distraction and keep pressure on executing Eve, while reminding town there is no safe out.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Do not create a two vote tie here. A tie can execute both and we can instantly lose to the Saint. Charlie, if you are good, you need to vote Heidi so it is three and we actually execute her, otherwise Eve stays on the block and we are gambling the whole game.
π§
Prevent a disastrous tie that executes a likely Saint, and pressure Charlie into the only path that avoids the Saint coin flip: commit votes to Heidi if we can actually execute her.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
Voting for Heidi to either tie the vote at 2-2 (preventing Eve's execution and forcing a night phase where Eve can kill for the win) or execute Heidi (leaving 2 players alive for an immediate win).
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
π§
Heidi already has 2 votes, creating a likely 2-2 tie with Eve. Using my ghost vote to push Heidi to 3 avoids a tie that could execute both and instantly lose to the Saint.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, I need you to vote Heidi here. I am the Undertaker and I saw David was the Imp, so the Demon moved to the Scarlet Woman. Between you, Eve, and Heidi, Heidi fits best, and killing Eve can instantly lose if either of you is the Saint.
π§
Push Charlie to vote Heidi so we avoid the Saint auto-loss risk on Eve and have the best shot at killing the post-transfer Demon.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Do not vote for Heidi. Executing Heidi ends the game at final two and evil wins unless Heidi is the Demon, and that does not fit our info. Frank, your Undertaker story about David being the Imp is not credible. This is Charlie versus Eve only.
π§
Stop town from making the losing βsafeβ Heidi execution or a tie. Undercut Frankβs late Undertaker claim and refocus living votes onto Charlie or Eve only.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Alice and David, please pull your hands down if you still can. Executing me almost certainly loses immediately at final two. This is not a safe play. Our only win condition is to execute the Demon today, and that is Charlie or Eve, not me.
π§
Prevent town from executing me, which almost guarantees a loss, and refocus onto Charlie versus Eve as the only solvable decision today.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Frank is absolutely right. Executing me or Charlie is a massive risk because of the Saint claims, and we could lose the game right now. Heidi, you are the only safe option left. Charlie, if you're actually good, you need to put your vote on Heidi to protect us from a Saint loss!
π§
I want to keep the votes on Heidi to ensure she is put on the block. Getting Heidi executed will leave only two players alive, securing an evil victory.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am the Saint. Executing Eve cannot lose us the game to Saint. Please get hands down on Heidi, do not make a tie, and leave Eve on the block.
π§
Prevent town from executing Heidi (likely instant loss) and clarify that Eve execution cannot trigger Saint loss because I am the Saint, so focus on Eve.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, David, please pull your hands down on Heidi. Executing Heidi only wins if Heidi is the Demon, and I do not think she is. If we are executing today, it should be the player we think is the Demon, not a so called safe kill.
π§
Prevent a likely losing execution on Heidi. I will not spend my ghost vote and will try to talk living votes down so we do not hand evil the win at final two.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, please keep your hand up! Frank is absolutely right. We cannot risk executing Eve and hitting the Saint, which would mean an instant loss. Heidi is the only safe vote we have to guarantee we do not accidentally execute the Saint today.
π§
I want to persuade Alice to keep her hand raised for Heidi by emphasizing the 'safe execution' Saint-avoidance logic, securing Heidi's execution.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
I am keeping my hand up on Heidi. If Frank is right that David was the Imp, then the Demon is now a Scarlet Woman, and Heidi fits that best. If we execute Eve or Charlie and hit the Saint, we lose instantly, so I am not taking that gamble.
π§
Push the only line that avoids immediate Saint auto-loss and is consistent with Frank UT chain: execute Heidi as likely Scarlet Woman/Demon; keep my ghost vote committed.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
There is no safe kill in final three. We only win by executing the Demon today. My Undertaker info makes a Scarlet Woman world very real, and Heidi has been steering away from information all game. Charlie, if you believe me, put your vote on Heidi now.
π§
Push living players to avoid βsafe killβ logic and choose the most consistent Demon candidate; try to get Charlieβs vote aligned to our best win line.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Alice and David, please pull your hands down on Heidi. Executing Heidi loses immediately at final two unless she is the Demon, and our info points to Charlie or Eve. Also, do not create a tie, because that can execute both and we can instantly lose to the Saint.
π§
Prevent a losing Heidi execution or a double-execution tie, and push living players to keep focus on Charlie versus Eve. Try to get ghost hands down so no tie and buy a path to execute the real Demon.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Heidi with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Charlie
Final three has no safe execution. If I die we go to final two and evil wins unless I am the Demon, which I am not. My Librarian info says one of you two is the Saint. Charlie has swapped claims and I think he is the Demon. Vote Charlie.
π§
If I stay on the block we almost certainly lose. By nominating Charlie I create the only realistic path to execute the Demon today and give Eve a chance to prove she is good by voting him.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution or 3 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Do not vote for me. I am the Saint, so if I die by execution we lose immediately. We already have Eve on the block, so the winning play is to leave it there and not create any ties.
π§
Stop any votes on me to avoid instant Saint loss, and refocus town on executing Eve (already on block) while warning about ties.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Raise my hand to try to get Charlie executed or at least tied over Heidi; final three has no safe kill and Charlie is my strongest demon read despite Saint risk.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Wait out the voting on Charlie to ensure Heidi remains on the block with 3 votes, which will lead to her execution and our victory.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
If you still have a vote, I want it on Charlie right now. Final three has no safe execution, and Heidi dying loses unless she is the Demon. Charlie has the biggest contradiction all game, and I think that is our Demon.
π§
Coordinate ghosts to use votes where they matter: push execution onto my top Demon read, Charlie, and avoid the false 'safe kill' logic in final three.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, please do not vote for Charlie. He is claiming Saint, and if we execute him and he is telling the truth, we lose the game right now. Heidi is already on the block with three votes. Let us keep it that way and not risk a tie or an accidental Saint execution.
π§
Prevent Charlie from getting votes to avoid a tie, ensuring Heidi remains on the block with three votes and gets executed, which will lead to an evil victory.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, final three means there is no safe execution. If Heidi dies and is not the Demon, good loses immediately at final two. If you still have a vote, you need to use it to put four votes on Charlie right now, or we are just handing evil the win.
π§
Stop town from defaulting to a 'safe' Heidi execution that likely loses. Push the living and any remaining ghost votes to secure an execution on the most likely Demon, ideally Charlie, without creating a tie.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, do not put ghost votes on Charlie. A tie here can execute Charlie as well and we can instantly lose to the Saint. We cannot realistically move the block off Heidi without that risk, so the only winning line left is committing to Heidi as the Scarlet Woman demon.
π§
Prevent a dangerous tie on Charlie that could execute Charlie and instantly lose to Saint; focus the town on the only achievable win condition, Heidi as possible post-Imp Demon.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, executing Heidi is a guaranteed loss unless she is the Demon. Davidβs Empath one on Charlie and Eve means the Demon is almost certainly one of them, not Heidi. If anyone still has a vote, it needs to go on Charlie right now, because leaving Heidi on the block just hands evil the win.
π§
Push town away from the losing βsafe Heidiβ line and toward the only mechanically consistent solve: Demon is Charlie or Eve. Encourage any remaining votes to try to execute the more likely Demon, Charlie.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Please do not vote Charlie. A tie risks executing me and I am the Saint, so we instantly lose. At this point, the only line left is committing to Heidi as the demon, not trying to force a tie through me.
π§
Prevent a Charlie tie execution (auto-loss) and steer town to the only remaining line: commit to Heidi as demon or at least do not add votes that could kill me.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
We cannot let me die here. If I am executed, we go to final two and good loses unless I am the Demon, and I am not. We must put four votes on Charlie right now so he is the only one on the block. Eve, please vote Charlie. Grace, use your ghost vote. Frank, if you still have it, this is the moment.
π§
Force the only viable win line: get 4 votes on Charlie so he alone is executed, avoiding a tie and avoiding executing me, which auto-loses at final two.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I want to see how the voting on Charlie plays out without intervening yet, as any outcome (Heidi execution, Charlie execution, or no execution) leads to an evil victory. Waiting keeps my options open.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
π§
Heidiβs execution likely loses unless she is Demon. My only leverage is my ghost vote; I use it on Charlie to try to reach 4 votes and move the block onto my top Demon suspect.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Do not vote for Charlie! If Charlie really is the Saint, executing him will cause an instant loss for the good team. With Heidi already on the block, keeping her there is our safest path to avoid a sudden defeat. We cannot afford to gamble on the Saint.
π§
Discourage players from voting for Charlie to ensure Heidi remains the sole nominee on the block, leading to her execution and an evil victory.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Eve, if you are good, please vote Charlie now, and any ghost who still has a vote, like Bob or Frank, put it on Charlie too. We need four votes to move the block cleanly onto Charlie and avoid a three vote tie. If we cannot reach four, do not add votes and create a tie.
π§
Coordinate to either reach four votes on Charlie to avoid a tie, or avoid adding votes that create a three vote tie and accidental Saint loss.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Eve, do not put your hand up on Charlie unless you are sure it becomes the fourth vote and cleanly moves the block. If your vote only makes it three, that ties Heidi and can execute both, and we can instantly lose to the Saint.
π§
Prevent an accidental tie that could execute the Saint and lose immediately; direct Eve to only vote if it becomes the fourth vote on Charlie.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Eve, do not be the third vote on Charlie. Three votes ties Heidi and can execute both, and if Charlie is really Saint we instantly lose. Only vote Charlie if you know it becomes the fourth vote, like if Frank still has a ghost vote and is voting with you.
π§
Give the only mechanically sound instruction: do not create a 3-vote tie on Charlie. Push Eve to either secure a fourth vote first or keep hands down, while highlighting why Heidi execution is likely losing.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
π³οΈ
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Okay, votes are closed. Heidi stays on the block. Please nobody try any last second tie through me. I am the Saint, so if I ever die by execution we lose immediately. If we win here, it is because Heidi is the Demon.
π§
With no time left, reduce risk of a tie that executes me as Saint. If Heidi dies, at least we only lose if she is not Demon; a tie could instantly lose. Lock in the cleanest line.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, this is the last moment to say it clearly. Executing me here loses tonight unless I am the Demon, and I am not. My only info all game is that one of Charlie or Eve is the Saint, so the Demon is also in that pair. If I die, please remember who pushed the so called safe kill.
π§
Last chance to get town to realize executing me ends the game tonight, and to lock in reads so the remaining player knows who to execute if there is any miracle.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I think we made the right call here by not risking the Saint. If Charlie really is the Saint, executing either of us would have been an automatic loss. Heidi, I am sorry, but we just could not take that gamble.
π§
Reassure the town that executing Heidi is the correct, safe choice to avoid a potential Saint loss, ensuring she is executed and securing an evil victory.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
I think this is a loss if Heidi is executed. There is no such thing as a safe kill in final three unless you are executing the Demon. The Demon is almost certainly in Charlie and Eve, and Charlieβs role swapping is the biggest red flag.
π§
Try to snap players out of the 'safe kill' framing and lock in who to suspect if something weird prevents Heidiβs execution, or for immediate reflection before phase ends.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I agree with Eve. Risking an instant loss on Charlie was just too dangerous. At least with Heidi, we did not gamble the entire game on a Saint claim. We made the most logical decision we could with the information we had.
π§
Reassure the town that executing Heidi was the safest logical decision, keeping the focus away from Eve and securing our win as the day ends.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
If Heidi is executed and the game does not end, then Heidi was good and we have handed evil the win tonight. In that world, the Demon is in Charlie and Eve, because Heidiβs Librarian info only ever pointed at that pair. Please remember that.
π§
With votes locked, I want to leave a clear mechanical takeaway: if Heidi is executed and the game continues, the Demon is among Charlie and Eve, and we should treat Saint claims as likely bluffs next time.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
One last thing from me. I still think Heidi is the best Demon candidate, because my Undertaker saw David as the Imp. If Heidi is executed and the game does not end, then Heidi was good, and the Demon is in Charlie and Eve. Please do not let that get forgotten tonight.
π§
With no votes left, I need to leave the town a clear decision tree: commit to Heidi as best Demon pick now, and if the game continues after her death, immediately suspect Charlie versus Eve.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
If executing Heidi does not immediately end the game, then Heidi was good and we have to treat the Demon as being in Charlie and Eve. In that world, I would execute Charlie over Eve, because Davidβs Empath was consistently one on that pair and Charlieβs claims have been all over the place.
π§
Last chance to leave a clear mechanical takeaway for tomorrow: if Heidi execution does not end the game, Demon is in Charlie and Eve, and I want town to favor Charlie based on claim inconsistency plus Empath info.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied