Game Detail

Choosing Alice, my neighbor, so I can easily whisper to her tomorrow and coordinate our votes. Being neighbors makes secret communication easier.

Coordinate with Bob on cover stories and targets, and make sure he knows I am the Scarlet Woman backup so he avoids risky self-kill or drawing heat.

Start building trust with my neighbor David to exchange information and establish an early alliance.

Inform Alice that she is my master so we can coordinate voting behavior during nominations. This is mechanically necessary for me to participate in voting.

Start building trust and gathering information early. Whispering to a neighbor helps establish a connection and potentially coordinate on future info.

Share my Librarian starting info with my neighbor Charlie to build trust and gather reciprocal information before nominations begin.

Start building trust with my neighbor Frank and see if he has any info or wants to coordinate. Early connections help verify claims later.

Coordinate bluffs with Alice, set me up as Fortune Teller so I can drive misexecutions while she protects me and prepares to inherit if needed.

Respond to Frank's outreach honestly but cautiously. Establish rapport without revealing my Mayor role yet, and turn the conversation to see what he knows.

Keep the Butler master link private to avoid public association and to maintain uncertainty for town, while preserving influence over Heidi’s votes later.

Reciprocate David's trust by engaging in information sharing without revealing my Ravenkeeper role, preserving my ability to bait the Demon into killing me at night while building a secret alliance.

Reach out to my other neighbor Grace to gather information and avoid relying solely on Alice, in case she is not trustworthy.

Respond to Grace to build a trust relationship. Share minimal safe info and ask for her reads to evaluate her alignment and gather intel before nominations.

Respond to Charlie's question to maintain trust with my neighbor, while being honest that I don't have a behavioral read yet between Heidi and Alice. Keep the conversation open so we can share more info later.

Talk to Alice to get an independent perspective on early whispers and see if her story matches what Frank and others have said.

Start building trust network for my Fortune Teller bluff, collect claims, and create a future channel to steer nominations away from me and Alice.

I need to gather information from central players like Alice to cross-reference claims and identify who has real data. Talking to Alice helps me map the social network and spot contradictions before nominations.

Build early credibility for Bob as a plausible Fortune Teller and keep the day from crystallizing into a fast execute on him, while keeping my own bluff hard to disprove.

I need to broaden my information network and verify David's claim by speaking directly with Alice, one of the two players he named.

Nominations are about to begin. I will wait and observe who nominates and on what basis, since I currently lack hard information and want to avoid over revealing my role before seeing public accusations.

I want to gather early information before nominations begin. Alice has spoken to many people, so she may have useful reads or have heard claims. I will keep my own role hidden for now.

Share my Librarian info with Bob while questioning his suspicious phrasing to see if he is genuinely good or probing as evil.

Check with Bob before nominations to see if Alice's claim that he has info is true. Day one info is scarce and any lead helps narrow suspects.

Calm David’s suspicion about my phrasing, reinforce my Fortune Teller bluff, and introduce a plausible reason his Librarian info could implicate Alice falsely, protecting my minion.

Alice mentioned Bob might have real information. With nominations approaching, I want to hear directly from Bob whether he has anything useful that could guide today's vote.

Encourage the group to share any real information before we nominate, and avoid a random Day 1 execution unless there is a strong lead. This preserves our numbers and lets info roles work.

I want to support Eve's call for information and discourage a blind execution since I have no night zero info and no one else has spoken up with a lead yet.

With zero mechanical leads and multiple villagers advocating caution, forcing a blind nomination now is more likely to hurt the good team than help it. I will wait and let night one generate actual information.

Share my Librarian information publicly to help the town map roles, and advocate against a blind Day 1 execution to avoid killing a good player unnecessarily.

Reinforce the emerging no-execution consensus, establish my Fortune Teller cover with no N0 info, and discourage pressure on Alice from the Librarian ping.

Agree with the group consensus to avoid a blind Day 1 execution. Build trust by sharing that I also lack night zero information and want to wait for actual data.

Align with the group consensus to avoid a blind day-one execution, establish I have no night zero info, and preserve numbers until we have verifiable information tomorrow.

Use the last nomination tick to steer town to no execution without locking into a risky bluff that conflicts with Heidi’s real Butler claim.

Heidi’s death supports our minion’s future Butler claim via David’s info, removes a potential strong Townsfolk, and avoids killing David who is currently indirectly clearing Alice.

Check with Alice about David's Librarian claim naming her or Heidi as Butler. This helps verify David's truthfulness and narrows down outsider possibilities.

Answer Frank without locking myself into a contradiction, while undermining David’s confirmation and fishing for Frank’s role/info to steer heat away from Bob.

I need to gather Bob's Fortune Teller night one information to cross-reference the Alice versus David claims and find contradictions.

Confirm David's Librarian claim with my actual role to validate him, and request Bob's Fortune Teller results to compare information and help identify the Demon for my ghost vote.

Maintain my Fortune Teller bluff, steer nominations toward David or Frank, and keep Alice out of danger while influencing Heidi’s ghost vote.

Confront Alice with Heidi's Butler claim to force her role claim before nominations. Resolving my Librarian pair is top priority for narrowing the evil pool.

I need to gather actionable information. Bob claims Fortune Teller and should have a Night 1 result by now. Whispering him directly is the fastest way to learn it and gauge his honesty.

Bob claimed Fortune Teller and should have N1 information by now. I need to gather his check result to evaluate claims and find the demon.

Ask Bob for his Night 1 Fortune Teller result. If he is the real Fortune Teller, this is the most actionable info for finding the Demon. If he is bluffing, his answer will be telling.

Answer David fast with a safe bluff, build credibility via agreement on Butler ping, and steer nominations away from Bob onto other targets.

Share Alice's Soldier claim with Bob to help him interpret his Fortune Teller data, and compare notes on whether David or Frank is more likely the Demon.

Gather intel from Alice and Grace before deciding where to spend my ghost vote. I need independent reads on Bob's claim and the David versus Frank suspicion.

Answer requests consistently, seed suspicion on David, and keep the town focused on a David versus Frank world so they do not look at me or Alice.

I need Bob's claimed Fortune Teller result from Night 1 to evaluate whether he is genuine or bluffing. This is the most important missing piece of information right now.

Verify David's Librarian claim by asking Alice about her role. If Alice denies being Butler, David is more suspicious, especially since Bob flagged him.

Gather information from Frank, who was implicated by Bob's Fortune Teller claim, to evaluate whether Bob is truthful before nominations.

Confront Bob directly about what Eve relayed to me. His pattern of whispering everyone except me after I specifically asked for his night info is highly suspicious, and I want to pin him down before nominations.

Mislead Heidi into trusting Bob and using her ghost vote against David or Frank, while keeping my Soldier bluff consistent and deflecting suspicion away from Bob.

I need to cross-reference Alice's private conversation with Frank against Bob's Fortune Teller result. If Alice has useful reads from Frank, it helps me determine whether World A or World B is more likely before nominations.

I am dead with one ghost vote left. I need to cross-check Bob's Fortune Teller claim against David's Librarian claim by asking them and Charlie for their reads before nominations begin.

Answer David so I look consistent, but angle it to make him the preferred execution and keep heat off me and Alice.

Expose Bob's false framing to Heidi and Charlie before nominations. His claim of an info conflict is fabricated. Heidi confirming Butler validates my Librarian, so pushing me as suspicious is a red flag that Bob may be evil.

Share my trust analysis with Heidi and David before nominations. Heidi needs info for her ghost vote, and David should know I support his claim against Bob.

Confront David with Bob's Fortune Teller result to gauge his reaction and test consistency with his Librarian claim before nominations begin.

Bob is using false logic to frame me despite my Librarian info being confirmed by Heidi. I need to nominate him now to test his Fortune Teller claim and stop a likely evil player from steering the town.

Avoid my execution by sounding consistent as Fortune Teller, framing David’s push as overconfident/deflecting, and keeping town focused on David or Frank instead of me.

Bob is on the block and I need to cast my vote to execute him. His claim of an 'info conflict' with my verified Librarian result is fabricated, which strongly suggests he is lying about being Fortune Teller.

I need to prevent Bob's execution because his Fortune Teller claim is our best lead, and David being correct about Heidi does not clear David of being evil.

Bob avoided my direct questions and is the center of suspicious whispering. As Undertaker, I need an execution today to gain information. I find Bob more likely evil than David, and even if Bob is the Fortune Teller, his death confirms it and validates his check result.

I want to share that Bob and Frank whispering together after Bob accused Frank is highly suspicious. If Bob is truly Fortune Teller and got a yes on David and Frank, he should not be privately cozying up to Frank. This undermines Bob's credibility. I should not vote for Bob yet, but I want the group to see this contradiction.

I need to highlight that Bob's private coordination with Frank directly undermines his Fortune Teller claim. A real Fortune Teller would not secretly buddy up with a prime suspect. This inconsistency is the strongest evidence we have right now, and the living players need to weigh it heavily before letting Bob survive.

Stop Bob’s execution by lowering votes and redirecting suspicion onto David/Frank; preserve Demon and keep town focused on the yes-pair rather than Bob.

Bob whispering with Frank while claiming Frank might be Demon is highly suspicious behavior that does not match a real Fortune Teller. David's Librarian claim is mechanically backed by Heidi. I believe Bob is more likely evil than good, so I will vote for his execution.

Stop the fourth vote, explain the Frank whisper as consistency-check, keep FT bluff credible and survive to night kill.

Bob will likely survive today with only three votes. I need to crystallize his suspicious behavior for the group so that tomorrow people remember why he is the most likely evil player, and to pressure the undecided voters to reconsider.

Bob is on the block with 3 votes and needs 4 to die. I need to discourage the final vote, highlight that David is not mechanically cleared, and point out Charlie's sudden vote is suspicious given his prior quietness and whispers with David.

I need to justify my vote, pressure for the execution, and leverage my Undertaker ability to turn a suspicious situation into concrete information. Claiming my role now gives the remaining players a mechanical reason to vote with me.

The vote is at three with no indication Alice or Grace will flip. Executing Bob on Day Two is premature when his claim could be verified or contradicted by future nights. I already stated I am not voting, and I will hold that position to avoid killing a potentially good information role.

Bob is exhibiting classic evil behavior: inventing false conflicts, whispering with his alleged suspect, and attacking mechanically confirmed good info. Executing him either kills evil or lets Frank verify his Undertaker claim. My ghost vote should be used here to secure the execution.

Prevent Bob’s execution by creating immediate doubt in Frank’s Undertaker push and by pressuring Charlie to reconsider his vote, keeping the Demon alive.

Explain to Alice why I am voting for Bob: his manufactured conflict with confirmed info and suspicious whispering with Frank outweigh the risk of losing a claimed Fortune Teller, especially since Frank claims Undertaker can verify Bob's role if executed.

Create an alternate execution with equal or more votes, leveraging my public FT yes to shift town onto David and keep myself alive.

Eve is the swing vote. If she votes for me, I tie Bob at four votes and he survives, wasting Frank's Undertaker verification. I need to convince Eve that keeping her vote down lets us verify Bob mechanically tonight.

Vote David to force a four vote tie, preventing my execution and keeping me alive to control night kills and mislead tomorrow.

David's pre-claim whispering with Charlie looks like coordination. Even a true Librarian result does not clear him of being a Spy. I am voting for David to protest executing our only claimed Fortune Teller before we can verify more.

Prevent David from reaching 4 or 5 votes by explaining that Bob's FT argument is deceptive and that executing Bob gives us mechanical Undertaker verification tomorrow. A tie or David execution both hurt the good team.

Bob's manufactured conflict and secret whispering with Frank looked like evil coordination from the start. I will not vote to save him. However, Frank's Undertaker claim is untested and convenient, so I am letting the execution proceed while warning Frank that I will scrutinize his information tomorrow.

Warn the living players not to treat Frank as automatically cleared tomorrow, regardless of Bob's alignment, because the Bob-Frank whispering was highly suspicious and Frank's Undertaker claim is self-serving.

Try to force a tie on David to prevent Bob’s execution and keep Demon alive; at minimum, show David is not cleared and create doubt.

I need to prevent a tie that saves Bob. Speaking now reinforces why Bob is the better execute, keeps pressure off David, and signals I am not blindly following Frank since I explicitly hold him accountable for tomorrow's claim.

The vote on me is stuck at three with Charlie, Frank, and Eve all committed to keeping their votes down. I should wait and let the phase close so Bob is executed and Frank's Undertaker claim is tested tonight.

Get exactly one more vote to tie/surpass so I survive, then kill Frank at night if needed. Reframe ‘conflict’ as David using Butler confirmation to launder himself, and undermine Undertaker as not auto-trustworthy.

Register that Frank's Undertaker claim and David's Butler-based clearing remain suspicious, so the group scrutinizes them tomorrow rather than accepting their narrative blindly. Keep pressure on David bloc.

Address the suspicion about my whisper with Bob before night falls. Explain it as self-defense when named as a suspect. Recommit to my Undertaker claim and redirect focus to Bob's fabricated role conflict, which is the stronger tell.

I publicly refused to vote for David and called Bob's behavior suspicious. Keeping my vote down is consistent, removes a likely liar, and lets us test Frank's unverified Undertaker claim tomorrow before trusting him.

Bob is likely to be executed. I need to prepare the living good players to properly evaluate Frank's Undertaker claim tomorrow and not treat it as gospel, while also keeping David in the suspect pool.

Push one more voter to tie David, saving Bob from execution, while sounding like cautious Soldier who distrusts unverified Undertaker confirmation.

I need to counter Alice's lobbying for a tie, which would save Bob and prevent us from verifying Frank's Undertaker claim tomorrow. Bob's invented conflict is the clearest evidence of evil intent, so I must keep my vote down and ensure he is executed.

Solidify that Bob's execution is correct based on his fabricated conflict, and prepare the group to scrutinize both Frank's Undertaker claim tomorrow and Alice/Grace's defense of Bob.

Sow doubt on executing me as 'verification', redirect town to execute a different player (preferably Frank) to avoid my death and keep demon alive.

Bob is about to be executed. I need to push back against David's accusation that defending Bob was coordination, and prepare the group to remain skeptical of Frank and David tomorrow regardless of what Frank claims.

Bob is being executed. I need to highlight that Alice and Grace's tie attempt is suspicious if Bob is evil, while preparing everyone for my Undertaker result tomorrow. Speaking now plants these seeds before Night.

Warn the group that a Spy can perfectly counterfeit an Undertaker claim because they already see the Grimoire every night. This prevents Frank from getting undeserved trust tomorrow if Bob's role matches Frank's claim.

I am dead with no vote left. My only value is to warn the living not to treat Frank's tomorrow claim as proof, since a Spy could mimic it, and to keep David and Frank as suspects if Bob was good.

Get a competing nomination that can reach four votes, creating a tie to prevent Bob’s execution and keep the Demon alive (or at least disrupt town’s confidence).

I must prevent Alice and Grace from tying this vote and saving Bob. A tie gives us zero information. Bob's invented mechanical conflict is the strongest tell, and his death lets me prove my Undertaker claim tomorrow.

I want to stop a tie vote that would save Bob. Speaking against the Frank nomination and keeping my vote down ensures Bob dies, which is the best move for good regardless of whether Bob is evil or just confused.

I must stop my own execution. Voting Frank can either execute him or at least tie the block count, keeping me alive into the night.

I distrust Frank's convenient Undertaker claim and the Spy possibility Eve raised. Voting for Frank records my opposition, maintains pressure on an unconfirmed player, and keeps the door open for a tie if others join.

I already warned the group that Frank could be a Spy faking Undertaker. However, Bob invented a nonsensical role conflict and Alice and Grace look coordinated in defending him. I will not vote for Frank because a tie means no execution, which gives the Demon a free kill and potentially saves an evil Bob. Letting Bob die tests Frank tomorrow while keeping momentum.

I am dead with no vote left, so I need to sway the one swing voter. Eve is the key to a tie. I want to stop a hasty execution that hands Frank unearned trust and possibly kills a good player.

Get Frank to 4 votes to tie top count with Bob so no execution happens, protecting our Demon and buying a night kill.

I have already committed publicly to letting Bob die because his invented Fortune Teller versus Librarian conflict is the most objectively suspicious behavior we have seen. Voting for Frank now would tie the vote, let Bob walk free, and contradict my stated position. I will keep my vote down and let Bob's execution proceed.

Convince Eve not to tie the vote. A tie means no execution, no Undertaker info, and another Demon kill tonight. Letting Bob die gives us information tomorrow regardless of my alignment.

Keep Eve from tying the vote so Bob gets executed today. Bob's fabricated conflict is the clearest tell we have.

Get Eve to vote Frank to create a 4 vote tie so I survive today; preserve me as “info” and keep town split on Frank/David.

Keep pressure on Frank. Eve is the swing vote; arguments have been made by others. Waiting lets the vote resolve without over-pressuring, while maintaining my vote on Frank.

I publicly warned that Frank could be a Spy faking Undertaker perfectly. Letting Bob die gives Frank exactly the credibility boost I cautioned against. A tie is safer than executing a potentially good Fortune Teller on an unproven claim.

Reinforce that a tie is safe: if Bob is good we keep a real Fortune Teller, and if Bob is evil we can still execute him tomorrow. Warn that Frank naming a role is not proof against Spy.

Lock in the tie at four to save Bob without looking overtly coordinated; discourage any extra hands that would execute Frank.

I need to keep my vote down on Frank. Bob's suspicious behavior and the coordinated defense from Alice and Grace suggest Bob is evil and Frank is likely good. Executing Frank instead of Bob lets a probable Demon walk free tonight.

Point out the mechanical disaster of the tied vote: no execution means no Undertaker info for me tonight, and the Demon gets another free kill regardless of Bob's alignment. Frame the tie as the worst possible outcome to shift blame onto Alice, Grace, and Eve.

Keep pressure on the suspicious Alice-Grace-Bob cluster while reminding everyone that Frank is unverified too, positioning for Day 3 analysis.

Lock in the idea that the tie was correct, keep credibility as FT, and pre-frame Frank and David as possible evil so town executes them before me.

Push back on David's coordination accusation, point out that Frank's desperation for an execution fits a Spy trying to set up a fake Undertaker claim, and keep the focus on behavior rather than blind trust in any one player.

Set clear expectations for tomorrow by demanding Bob's pending N1 check and mechanical proof from Frank, keeping pressure on information claims without revealing my Mayor role before night.

Confirm my role publicly to validate David's Librarian information, highlight Bob's suspicious invented conflict, and remind the living that character naming does not clear Frank from Spy suspicion.

Reframe the tie as rational, set a tomorrow plan that targets David or Frank instead of Bob, and reduce heat on me while keeping Bob alive.

Reinforce that role names are not proof and hint that my death would still yield verifiable information for the town, keeping pressure on mechanical confirmation tomorrow.

Remove the most credible daytime leader and avoid triggering a Ravenkeeper confirmation that could out me or my minion; set up tomorrow to steer suspicion onto Frank.

I need Bob's exact Fortune Teller results to verify consistency, and Frank's execution target to see if his Undertaker plan is logical. Pressing both for specifics will reveal holes in any fabricated claims.

I need to coordinate with Alice and Eve, the two players I already have a private alliance with, to compare notes on today's developments and decide who to push for execution.

Share my confirmed Librarian information with a trusted living player to help them narrow down evil candidates and coordinate the ghost vote.

Answer Charlie with specific, consistent FT checks, hedge with red herring, and steer Frank toward executing Grace or Eve instead of me or Alice.

Recommend executing Eve today so my Undertaker ability can confirm her exact role. Her swing vote saving Bob is the most suspicious political act we've seen, and Bob's Fortune Teller flags her. Whether Bob is truthful or lying, this execution gives us maximum information.

Deflect suspicion off Bob by amplifying distrust in Charlie’s whispering and Frank’s Undertaker push, steering town toward executing Charlie or Frank instead of Bob.

Coordinate with Alice and Grace, my likely good allies. Share that Charlie's behavior is most suspicious and we should hear Bob's promised info before deciding on an execution target.

As a confirmed non-Demon dead player, I want to arm the two most independent thinkers with my key suspicion: Bob's missing Fortune Teller check is damning, and Alice and Grace's coordinated defense is suspicious. I want them to pressure Bob publicly before nominations.

Confront Alice and Grace with Bob's private checks and the fact that two dead good players suspected Bob. Their reaction will help me determine if they are knowingly covering for an evil Bob or if they can be broken from his influence before nominations.

I must turn Charlie's pressure back onto him. His behavior as a messenger between both warring sides and his mechanically impossible role claim are stronger evidence of evil than our caution about Frank. Highlighting that Bob is alive after two Demon pings is damning.

Share my confirmed Butler information with likely good players, expose Bob's fabricated conflict, and gather their current reads so I can coordinate my single ghost vote for maximum impact.

Coordinate with Alice to steer today’s execution onto Eve and keep Alice out of the frame, while setting up a clean story for my Fortune Teller Yes results.

I need to solidify the plan to execute Eve today so my Undertaker ability gives us confirmed mechanical information tonight, testing both Eve and Bob in one move.

Stabilize my trust block with Grace and Eve, focus them on executing Charlie instead of Bob, and justify why we did not rush Bob yesterday.

Put direct pressure on Bob to produce his promised Night 1 Fortune Teller check before nominations begin. If he cannot provide it, it confirms he is likely the Demon. Including Alice shows her I am serious and gives her a chance to drop her defense of Bob.

Bob's continued refusal to share his claimed Night One Fortune Teller check is the strongest lead. I need to recruit Frank to pressure Bob, since Frank has been active in pushing for information and nominations.

Push back on Grace's false accusation and force Alice and Grace to explain their defense of Bob instead of deflecting onto me. I need to break their coordination before nominations.

Coordinate with trusted allies Alice and Eve to lock in a nomination target. Charlie’s behavior as Bob’s messenger and his lie about his own claim make him the most suspicious info nexus. I want to nominate him today.

Push back on Frank's Eve target and refocus the good team on Bob, who mechanically lied about my Librarian info. I need to keep Charlie aligned with executing Bob today.

Defuse Eve’s threat to nominate me by immediately giving my FT results to her, then steer her into being the execution target as ‘best Undertaker test’.

I need to consolidate support for executing Eve before nominations begin. She is the only player with a mechanically proven suspicious action, and executing her tests Bob's claim regardless of whether Bob is good or evil.

Steer Grace and Eve onto executing Charlie instead of Bob or Eve, while sounding consistent with our prior suspicion of Spy-style info laundering; protect Bob without hard defending.

I need to form an execution bloc against Bob before nominations begin. Sharing his private checks with Frank and Grace and declaring my flip to anti-Bob will either secure the votes needed or expose resistance from Alice or Grace if they are evil.

I have already shared my suspicions with Charlie, Eve, and Frank. As a dead player with no ghost vote left, I should conserve actions and observe the nomination phase. Pushing more whispers without new information adds little value.

I am dead with no vote. This is the last nomination tick. I must publicly pressure Bob to share his Night One Fortune Teller check or force a living player to nominate him before night falls.

Bob is the most suspicious player with the highest upside for execution. If he is Demon we win immediately; if he is good I confirm his Fortune Teller reads. We must nominate now or we get no Undertaker info again.

Stop my execution by publicly giving consistent FT checks, framing this as wasted execution versus a better info kill (Eve or Grace), and pushing voters to withhold votes.

Bob's refusal to share Fortune Teller checks until forced by nomination is behaviorally inconsistent with a good player. I need to highlight this to swing votes onto him before time runs out.

I nominated Bob and the town desperately needs an execution today after two days of none. My Undertaker check tonight will definitively confirm or refute his claim, giving us a clear path forward. Even if he is good, we learn his exact role and can trust his checks on Grace and Eve.

Bob being alive on Day Three after claiming a Night One Demon ping is almost impossible for a real Fortune Teller. I must vote to execute him now before the Demon kills again tonight.

I committed to voting for Bob and his behavior is overwhelmingly suspicious. Raising my hand applies pressure, is consistent with my stated position, and may execute the most likely Demon. Even if Bob is good, he has been useless and his checks point at living players we can evaluate later.

Bob already has three votes, which meets the execution threshold. I should conserve my single ghost vote for a future nomination where the outcome is uncertain, rather than wasting it now.

Stop Bob’s execution by persuading at least one voter to drop their hand; if Bob dies I become demon but that is riskier than keeping Bob alive and sowing doubt.

Bob is the most suspicious player in the game. He invented a mechanical conflict, withheld his checks until he was on the block, and his N2 check conveniently points away from himself and Alice. David and Heidi both died suspecting him. We need an execution today, and Bob is the best candidate.

Try to get at least two voters to drop their hands by reframing execution as low-value versus executing Grace or Eve for Undertaker info, buying me a night kill on Frank.

Support Bob's execution by highlighting his suspicious behavior, flag Alice as suspicious for defending him, and warn the town that Scarlet Woman will likely activate since 5+ players will remain alive.

Bob has four votes and I want to reinforce that executing him is valuable because my Undertaker ability will provide definitive mechanical proof of his role tonight. This counters Alice's argument that we should preserve the Fortune Teller.

Reaffirm my vote on Bob and explain why his behavior is inconsistent with a real Fortune Teller, solidifying my position as good and countering Alice's defense.

Charlie might lower his hand if Bob begs, dropping us to exactly three votes which is only half and fails. I must speak to keep all four votes solid so Bob is executed and Frank's Undertaker claim is tested tonight.

Bob already has four votes and will be executed. I should save my ghost vote and use my last tick to warn the living players about the Scarlet Woman succession and demand Frank's Undertaker info immediately tomorrow.

Bob is almost certainly going down; voting with the majority reduces suspicion on me so I can survive as the Scarlet Woman-turned-Demon and control the endgame.

Bob is executed regardless of my vote. I need to warn the town that Alice's last-minute flip after defending Bob all day fits Scarlet Woman inheriting, and lock in Frank's obligation to go public tomorrow so we aren't misled by whispered half-truths.

Create a competing nominee that can match or beat my 5 votes. Even if Alice is my minion, trading her life for mine keeps the Demon alive and likely wins.

Stop a tie or execution on me so Bob dies and I inherit as Demon; frame Alice nomination as deflection and keep town focused elsewhere next day.

Push for 5 votes on Alice to create a tie and prevent my execution, buying another night kill and keeping Alice positioned as plausible evil if needed.

Alert the living players that Alice and Grace are the Scarlet Woman suspects, instruct Frank to share Bob's role publicly tomorrow, and remind everyone that with only one Minion in play, the game could end today if Bob is the Imp and that Minion is not Scarlet Woman.

I must speak to stop Alice from being tied with Bob. Bob needs to die today so my Undertaker ability provides mechanical proof tonight, either ending the game or giving us confirmed facts to hunt evil.

Bob likely Demon due to fabricated mechanical conflict and hiding checks. Executing him wins immediately or gives Frank mechanical proof. Voting Alice wastes our execution.

Reinforce that we must not vote for Alice, let Bob be executed, and trust Frank's Undertaker check to guide us tomorrow regardless of whether Scarlet Woman exists.

Prevent a tie or wrong execution. Ensure Bob dies so Frank proves his Undertaker claim and we get mechanical facts. Keep my ghost vote for when it matters.

Bob is trying to engineer a tie by getting 5 votes on Alice. Everyone including Frank, Grace, Eve, and the ghosts is saying to keep hands down. I must not raise my hand for Alice. Waiting passes the tick and lets Bob's execution proceed, preserving Frank's Undertaker proof and preventing Bob from escaping the block.

Push a tie as the ‘anti-Scarlet-Woman-jump’ line to save Bob, or at least create doubt and stall to let evil kill tonight.

Raise hand to push the tie on Alice so I survive and can kill Undertaker tonight, denying mechanical proof and buying evil time.

Point out that in a single-Minion game, Alice knows whether Scarlet Woman is in play. If she is evil and not SW, she knows Bob's death as Imp wins the game for good, which explains her desperation to tie the vote.

I must stop Alice from tying the vote so Bob is executed and my Undertaker ability produces mechanical proof of his exact role tonight.

Bob is on the block with five votes and only Bob has voted for Alice. Executing Bob gives Frank Undertaker information tonight. Speaking again is redundant when multiple players already urged keeping hands down, so I will wait and let the vote fail on Alice.

Keep my vote off Alice. Bob has five votes and will be executed, giving Frank Undertaker information tonight. Voting for Alice risks a tie that saves Bob and wastes our mechanical proof.

I will not waste my ghost vote on Alice. Bob is on the block with five votes and is the primary suspect. Raising my hand for Alice risks tying or redirecting the execution away from Bob. I need to preserve my single ghost vote for when it has maximum mathematical weight, likely tomorrow after Frank reveals Bob's exact role.

Do not vote for Alice. A tie only keeps Bob alive and denies us Frank's Undertaker proof. I want Bob executed so we get mechanical confirmation of his exact role tomorrow morning.

Bob is almost certainly dying; I need to reduce heat on me, undermine Frank’s ‘mechanical proof’ narrative, and set up doubt for tomorrow if I inherit as Demon.

Try to trigger a last second nomination and vote pile onto Frank or Grace to move the block off me; seed doubt on Undertaker so town cannot use my death as certainty.

The execution is locked on Bob with one tick remaining. Speaking now is unlikely to change votes or prevent last-minute chaos, and others have already reinforced keeping the vote on Bob. I will wait for night and Frank's public Undertaker report tomorrow.

Shut down Bob's desperate distraction, confirm Bob will be executed, and promise public Undertaker information tomorrow to maintain town confidence and prevent last-minute chaos.

I want to support executing Bob while maintaining healthy skepticism about Frank, positioning myself as independent and rational for tomorrow's discussion if the game continues.

The execution is decided with no time to change outcome. Preserving my nomination and staying quiet avoids tipping my hand as Mayor before tomorrow's reassessment.

Broadcasting that Alice cannot be Scarlet Woman proves she is the minion and no SW exists, so executing Bob wins instantly. This prevents last-second confusion.

Lock in the execution plan, highlight Alice's inconsistent behavior using SW logic, and demand Frank's public Undertaker reveal tomorrow with no delays or whispers.

Frank living is the biggest risk because he can mechanically frame tomorrow around Bob being Imp and hunt the Scarlet Woman. Removing him cuts off that confirmation and a strong voice, increasing my survival odds at 4 alive.

Share my deduction that Frank's death confirms he was real Undertaker and Grace is the most likely current Demon, so the good players can coordinate the critical execution today.

I need to rally the good players to scrutinize Grace, who is the most logical Demon candidate if Bob was the Imp and the only plausible Scarlet Woman. Whispering Alice and Charlie lets me coordinate before nominations.

Share my deduction that Bob was likely the Imp and the Demon killed me to prevent my Undertaker check. Since Alice and Eve both acted to save Bob, they are unlikely to be Scarlet Woman, narrowing the new Imp to Charlie or Grace.

Coordinate with Alice to preempt Frank’s Undertaker reveal, set a unified push onto a good target, and reserve my ghost vote to secure the mis-execution.

Align with Eve’s existing suspicion on Grace so she drives the vote. Create a clean execution target that is not me, setting up a night kill to reach 2 alive.

I need Frank's Undertaker information to distinguish whether Bob was the Imp and a Scarlet Woman inherited. Asking Alice and Eve directly is the fastest way to get this critical fact before nominations.

Alert two alive players that Bob could not have been the Imp since Frank died after his execution and Scarlet Woman cannot inherit with four alive. Share my Librarian info that Heidi was the Butler, not Alice. This should refocus the hunt on the actual Demon among the four survivors.

Share my Virgin claim with two players to establish my alignment and test their reactions to the Eve suspicion. If Bob was truthful, Eve is the Demon. I need allies to coordinate the final execution.

I already shared my Grace theory with Charlie and Eve, but since one of them could be evil, I want to balance the information by sharing my broader suspicions with Alice and Grace so all living players have access to my analysis.

Share Frank's critical dying theory with Charlie and align with Alice to test reactions. Frank believed Bob was Imp and the new Imp is Charlie or Grace. I need to see where Charlie stands and consolidate the good players against the likely Demon.

I already shared my main theory with Alice and Eve. With heavy whisper activity happening and limited ticks before nominations, I should wait to see what information surfaces before committing my ghost vote or making another move.

Preempt Frank’s Undertaker reveal by undermining its certainty and nudging the live swing votes toward executing Charlie instead of Alice, protecting the current Demon.

Steer town into a Virgin test that either immediately kills Charlie (great) or exposes Grace as liar. Either way protects me from execution and sets up night kill to end game.

Commit to mechanically testing Grace's Virgin claim by nominating her. I know I am Townsfolk, so the outcome is definitive. I want both Alice and Grace to acknowledge the plan before nominations open.

Correct my earlier mistake about Scarlet Woman timing and guide Charlie and Eve to treat Alice as suspicious in all logical scenarios, reinforcing my credibility as the dead Librarian.

Agree to the Virgin test but frame the failure condition carefully: if Charlie nominates me and nothing happens, it proves Charlie is not a Townsfolk rather than proving I am lying. This protects me from execution if Charlie is evil while still allowing the mechanical confirmation if he is good.

Push for public accountability before nominations since I cannot vote. Transparency about night actions will help the living players identify the Demon in these final moments.

I need to pressure Charlie and Grace to explain their behavior around Bob's execution. One of them is the new Imp, and their answers may reveal who is lying before nominations begin.

Nominations are imminent. I have already shared my theory with Alice and Eve. I should wait to observe who nominates whom and what arguments surface before committing my single ghost vote.

Keep Alice from being executed by creating doubt around Undertaker confirmation and steering today’s execution onto Charlie (or Grace as backup), saving my ghost vote for the key moment.

Guide Charlie into the Virgin test and keep the day focused on Grace versus Eve, not on me, setting up a safe misexecution and an immediate winning night.

Pressure Alice to claim her role, correct Grace's misleading Fortune Teller logic for Eve, and reaffirm that I will test the Virgin claim while making it clear Grace's deflection won't work.

Alert Charlie and Eve to the mechanical urgency: with four alive, a mis-execution means Demon kills tonight and evil wins with two players left. They must identify the Demon correctly today.

Keep Alice committed to the Virgin test plan, pressure Eve to claim a role before nominations start, and prepare the group to pivot to Eve if Charlie's test confirms me good.

Push the Virgin test as the town’s ‘logical’ move, aiming to spend today’s execution on Charlie or Grace and keep heat off me while setting up a winning night kill.

Prevent the game-losing Virgin test by Charlie, which would leave us at 3 alive going into night. Nominate Eve because Bob's Fortune Teller check directly implicated her and she has never claimed a role. This is our last chance to execute the Demon before they win.

I must claim Mayor immediately to prevent my execution, which would guarantee an evil win with four alive. I need to expose Grace's unverified claim about Bob's FT check and redirect suspicion toward her.

Lock in an execution that is not me. With 4 alive, any non-me execution sets up a winning night kill to reach final two.

Eve directly contradicted her earlier statement to me and Frank about Bob admitting his checks. That lie makes her the most likely Demon. Bob's N2 check also pointed to her. I must vote to execute her.

Nudge Charlie to vote and lock in Eve’s execution without spending my ghost vote, preserving it in case a later vote needs it.

Stop Eve's execution. Grace's refusal to be mechanically tested is the smoking gun—if she were Virgin, the test would confirm her and kill Eve today. Executing a claimed Mayor with four alive is game-losing if wrong. I need to steer the group toward Grace.

Stop Eve's execution by highlighting Grace's suspicious refusal to be tested and fabricated information. If Grace is the Demon as I suspect, executing Eve loses the game instantly.

With four alive, executing a good player today means instant loss. Grace's invented Fortune Teller check and refusal to be tested make her the most likely Demon. Alice and Grace have already voted for Eve; adding my ghost vote could cement a game-losing mistake. I should hold my vote and let the living reconsider.

I believe Grace is the Demon because she fabricated Bob's check and I previously suspected her. Executing Eve would likely kill a good player and lose the game. I need to warn the living and withhold my ghost vote.

Point out Grace's critical rules error regarding the Mayor victory condition to prove she is evil and stop anyone from casting the final vote against me.

Lock in Eve execution with minimum threshold. Downplay the Mayor logic and keep Grace committed, so we reach 3 alive then win with a night kill.

Defend my credibility by correcting Eve's lie about Bob's check, explain the time constraint prevents Charlie's test anyway, and urge Alice to keep her vote on Eve as the strongest Demon suspect.

Use my ghost vote to lock in Eve’s execution and push the game to final 3 where the demon (likely Alice after my death) can win overnight.

Stop Eve's execution by explaining Frank's mechanical Undertaker info that Grace must be the inherited Imp, and warn that executing good today guarantees a night kill and evil victory.

Point out Grace's critical slip: she fears a 3-alive no-execution outcome, which would be an automatic good win if Eve is Mayor. This reveals Grace knows Eve is not Mayor. Urge Alice to stop voting for Eve before good loses.

Point out the mechanical contradiction that Frank's night death proves a Demon still lives after Bob's execution, which means Scarlet Woman must exist, which means Alice cannot be the Minion. Therefore Alice defended Bob as a Scarlet Woman bluff and is now the Imp. I need to stop Eve's execution.

Correct David's flawed theory publicly and refocus suspicion on Grace before the final tick leads to a mistaken execution of Eve.

I must nominate Grace to try to shift execution off myself and onto the Demon. Her statement that three alive with no execution means we lose is the exact opposite of the Mayor ability, which means she knows I am not the Mayor and is deliberately lying to execute a good player.

End the game tonight by reaching 2 living players. Charlie is the most dangerous and most likely to be protected only if he is Soldier; killing him is still the best win line.