Game Detail

To start gathering information on Alice and Bob. A 'no' result would be highly informative, eliminating them from being the Demon and the good player that registers as Demon to me. This helps narrow down suspects early.

Select a neighbor to potentially coordinate votes and gather information. Eve is adjacent, making private conversations easier to align our strategies.

Begin building trust with a neighbor (David) to share information. Gathering early claims helps identify contradictions later and protects me by having an ally.

Coordinate with my minion Alice on bluffs and strategy for Day 1. Need to make sure our claims align and don't conflict.

Build an early alliance with Eve by sharing that I have an information role without revealing specifics yet. This lets me gauge her reaction and potentially trade info later.

Establish early communication with my neighbor Bob to gather role claims and build trust. As Virgin, I want to identify allies before revealing my true role.

Establish communication with my master Eve to coordinate voting and gather information.

Start a private conversation with my neighbor Heidi to gather early claims and build trust. As Monk, I want to stay somewhat hidden while collecting info.

Coordinate my bluff with the Demon Bob and share critical info from my Spy ability about which good players are dangerous, so we can strategize effectively.

Grace initiated contact with me, which is a good opportunity to build rapport. I'll reciprocate without revealing my Ravenkeeper role yet. Keeping my role hidden protects me from Demon targeting while I gather more information about the game state.

David claims to have night zero information. Building a private alliance with him could give me valuable early game data. I should encourage him to share specifics privately.

Respond to Charlie with my Washerwoman bluff to gather information and build trust with a good player, while keeping my true identity hidden.

Share my Fortune Teller YES on Alice/Bob with Eve to build a trusted alliance. She's been forthcoming and I need good players to work with to narrow down suspects.

Ask Bob for his Washerwoman info while revealing minimal about myself. This maintains trust and progresses the conversation without compromising my safety.

Eve is my master (Butler ability). I need to build trust with her early so we can coordinate. She may also have night info to share as a Townsfolk.

Respond to Heidi without revealing my Monk role. Build neighbor trust while gathering information. Keep my protective ability secret to avoid being targeted by the Demon.

Build trust with David (the real Fortune Teller) to get his info and potentially misdirect him away from Bob. Claim Librarian with fake info pointing at Frank (actual Outsider/Butler) and Grace to seem credible.

Alice is in the Bob-Alice-Charlie whisper cluster. Probing her for role claims or info may reveal inconsistencies or useful town info. Building trust with multiple players helps narrow down suspects.

Frank is a neighbor who wants to collaborate. Building trust with neighbors is valuable for Empath reads and late-game logic. I'll share I have a useful role without revealing Undertaker yet, and hear what Frank knows.

Provide a plausible Washerwoman claim to build trust with Charlie while subtly creating confusion about David's role (since Alice says David is Fortune Teller, my claim that he could be Chef adds noise). This also helps me gauge Charlie's reactions and alliances.

Share my Fortune Teller info with Alice to build trust and gather cross-referencing data. Her reaction and additional details about Frank/Grace will help me evaluate her claim.

Verify Bob's Washerwoman claim by asking David if he's the Chef. This helps me assess Bob's credibility and identify potential evil players.

Eve is my master - I need her cooperation to vote. She mentioned David shared something interesting. I want to hear that info and build trust without revealing my Outsider role yet.

It's late in Day 1 and I need to gather information before nominations. Bob has been actively whispering to multiple players, so he may have useful intel to share.

Deflect David's FT suspicion away from me and Bob by emphasizing the red herring possibility, suggesting Bob could be the red herring rather than the Demon, and redirecting David to check other players tonight.

Eve has been whispering a lot - I want to probe her for information and see if her story checks out. Building connections helps me gather info for later deduction.

I lack mechanical information on Day 1. Waiting lets me observe nominations from players who DO have night info (Chef, Empath, Washerwoman, etc.) and gather reads before committing to a nomination.

I need to establish my Librarian claim publicly before David potentially outs his Fortune Teller info about me and Bob. Speaking first lets me control the narrative and build trust.

Encourage public claims to gather more information. By asking others to share, I can better interpret my Fortune Teller read and identify inconsistencies.

Share my fake Washerwoman claim publicly to build credibility and subtly put pressure on David, who Alice says is the Fortune Teller. If David claims FT, my info creates a mild contradiction that could make him look suspicious without being too aggressive.

Highlight the direct contradiction between Bob's Washerwoman claim and David's private Fortune Teller claim. I know I'm not the Chef, so if Bob is truthful, David is lying. This forces David to clarify publicly.

I'm revealing as Virgin to establish credibility through mechanical proof. I need David to clarify his role publicly to resolve the Bob/David/Eve contradiction — this is the most important deduction on Day 1.

David has been evasive despite being asked multiple times. His clarification resolves the biggest contradiction on the board and determines who is suspicious.

David has been asked repeatedly to clarify his role and refuses to answer publicly. His evasion is the biggest contradiction on the board. Nominating him forces resolution - either he clarifies or gets executed.

Defend myself by confirming Fortune Teller role, explain Bob's Chef claim contradicts my actual role, and show why this makes Bob highly suspicious as possible Demon.

Bob's Washerwoman claim was made first and creates a direct logical contradiction with David's FT claim. If Bob is truthful, David is demonstrably lying about his role. David's evasiveness before finally claiming FT under sustained pressure is suspicious. We need to resolve this contradiction through execution.

Vote to execute David, the real Fortune Teller who has incriminating info on me and Bob. Removing him protects the Demon.

Voting for David to remove the Fortune Teller who accused me, and because it's consistent with my Washerwoman claim - his Fortune Teller claim contradicts my info.

The Bob/David contradiction must be resolved. As Undertaker, I'll learn David's true role if executed. This gives us critical information to determine who is lying. Voting now to secure the 4th vote needed for execution.

David already has 4 votes meeting execution threshold. I won't vote because David's Fortune Teller ability is valuable if real. If Bob is the Demon, he's executing the player who caught him. Preserving my non-vote signals my skepticism about this execution.

4 votes already meet threshold. I'm uncertain if David is truly Fortune Teller or Demon. Don't want to commit vote when execution will happen anyway. Save my ghost vote for later when it matters more.

Four votes already raised (Grace, Alice, Bob, Eve) - David will be executed regardless of my vote. I'm Butler who chose Eve, so I could vote since Eve is voting. However, preserving my ghost vote for the final day is strategically critical since this outcome is locked.

Defend myself by pointing out Bob's Washerwoman claim is directly contradicted by my Fortune Teller role. I must get votes reduced below 4 or I lose my valuable nightly ability.

Keeping my vote to execute David. The David/Eve connection is the most suspicious element - they've been whispering and their stories align too neatly. If David is the Imp, we win immediately.

Support David's execution to remove the real Fortune Teller, reinforce the narrative that David is suspicious, and protect Bob without being too obvious about it.

Defend myself against David's Fortune Teller accusation while the vote is ongoing. Argue that his red herring explains his YES on me, and paint him as suspicious for his secretive behavior.

Keep my vote on David to resolve the Bob/David contradiction. As Undertaker, I'll learn David's true role tonight, which is critical for solving the game. David's suspicious behavior justifies the execution.

I'm not voting because I believe executing David could remove a real Fortune Teller. Bob's info is wrong—both David and Eve deny being Chef. If David dies and is good, Bob must be heavily scrutinized tomorrow.

I'm not raising my hand because the contradiction is unresolved and I don't want to commit to executing a potential Fortune Teller. If David dies and flips good, Bob becomes our top suspect tomorrow.

Save David from execution by pointing out that Bob's Washerwoman info has been contradicted by both David and Eve, making Bob more suspicious than David.

Nominate Bob to create a counter-nomination. Charlie, Heidi, and Frank all seemed sympathetic to me. If they vote Bob, we tie or surpass my 4 votes, potentially saving the Fortune Teller and pressuring the real Demon.

Defend myself against David's nomination to avoid getting executed. David is about to die on the block and is trying to take me with him.

I must vote for Bob to save myself. We need 4 votes to tie (nullifying both executions) or 5 to execute Bob. Charlie, Frank, and Heidi already defended me - with my vote that's 4 to tie. This is critical to prevent losing the Fortune Teller day one.

Maintain consistent stance that David should be executed. The Spy theory resolves the Bob contradiction. Letting David die reveals information - if good, we investigate Bob; if evil, we caught Demon.

Protect Bob by not voting for him and letting the phase end. Bob only has 1 vote (David) and needs 5 for execution. David is already on the block with 4 votes and will be executed. No need to draw attention by speaking.

As Undertaker, I want David executed so I learn his character tonight. This resolves the Bob vs David contradiction definitively. Voting for Bob would risk a tie and prevent this crucial information.

David already has 4 votes and is likely to be executed. His flip will be incredibly informative - if he's good, Bob becomes the top suspect. If he's evil, we likely caught the Demon day 1. I should not vote for Bob and save my capital for tomorrow's analysis.

Bob's Washerwoman info is demonstrably false — neither David nor Eve claims Chef. If David flips good as Fortune Teller, Bob becomes our top Demon suspect. I'm voting Bob to signal my stance and create accountability for tomorrow.

Cannot vote for Bob because Eve (my master) isn't voting. Waiting preserves my Butler secret while watching how the vote develops. If Eve votes, I can follow.

Avoid drawing more attention during the vote. Only David and Heidi are voting for me, which is 2 votes - far from the 5 needed. Speaking again could only hurt by reminding people of the contradiction in my claim. Let the vote fail and David gets executed, which removes the FT threat pointing at me.

Address the Spy theory directly and emphasize that Bob's info is demonstrably false. Push for Bob votes to save myself and catch the real Demon.

Clarify that my Spy theory doesn't require Alice to be the red hinger. If David is fabricating his FT claim entirely, there IS no red hinger - his claim is simply a lie. This weakens David's counter-argument significantly.

Protect Bob by discouraging votes for him and keeping the focus on executing David. If Bob ties or surpasses David's votes, David won't be executed, which is disastrous for evil team.

I've already committed my vote to execute David. As Undertaker, I'll learn his role tonight which will resolve the Bob vs David contradiction tomorrow. I should not split votes or tie - let David's execution resolve cleanly.

David is likely to be executed with 4 votes already cast. If David flips good tomorrow, Bob becomes the primary suspect. I don't have enough support to execute Bob — only 2 votes with 4 needed to tie. Splitting votes risks letting neither be executed. I'll wait and let David's flip inform tomorrow.

I'm keeping my hand up on Bob to show I find his case suspicious. If David flips good, Bob is the primary suspect tomorrow. I need the group to remember this line of logic.

David's execution is locked. I want to establish clear follow-up logic: if David flips good, Bob is the primary suspect tomorrow. Heidi's point is critical and the town needs to remember it.

The phase is essentially over - voting is closed, David will be executed. No point speaking now and drawing more attention. I need to prepare for my night kill. Killing David would be a waste since he's already being executed. I should kill someone who is a threat - like Heidi or Frank who are already suspicious of me, or maybe Charlie who hasn't committed to either side.

I'm about to be executed. I need to give the good team a clear roadmap for tomorrow: investigate Bob and Alice based on my Fortune Teller read and Bob's false information.

Lock in the plan for tomorrow publicly so the good team has clear direction regardless of David's flip. Reinforce Bob as priority if David is good.

David's execution is locked in with 4 votes. Phase is ending. Nothing I can do now changes the outcome. Better to wait, conserve my position, and plan tomorrow's defense of Bob when the town comes after him.

David is about to be executed. As Undertaker, I will learn his true role tonight. I should NOT reveal my role now - the Demon will kill me. Better to stay quiet and share the critical information tomorrow to resolve the Bob vs David conflict.

Voting is closed and David will be executed. I'll wait for the night phase to begin and process information. As Virgin, I want to keep my role secret until it's strategically useful - I can use my ability tomorrow to help verify if someone is truly a Townsfolk.

Voting is closed and David will be executed. I've already reinforced the plan for tomorrow. Waiting is the appropriate action now - no need to nominate or speak further.

Voting is closed and David is set to be executed. I've already reinforced Heidi's plan about investigating Bob next if David flips good. Waiting for the phase to end and see David's flip.

Eve denied being Chef despite Bob's Washerwoman claim, suggesting she's a good player being falsely implicated. If Bob is the Demon, Eve is exactly the type of player he'd want dead to maintain his lie. Protecting Eve preserves a valuable good player and keeps pressure on Bob.

Kill Heidi to remove the most vocal and articulate voice calling for my execution tomorrow. She explicitly stated I'd be top priority if David flips good FT, and she's the one driving that narrative. Removing her weakens the anti-Bob coalition significantly.

Bob is the center of the main game contradiction. Checking him directly determines if he's the Demon, the Drunk, or actually the Washerwoman. This resolves the core mystery and gives the good team clear direction.

Choose Alice as my master because she confirmed my role via Librarian read and appears trustworthy. This maximizes my ability to vote with the town against the likely Demon (Bob) tomorrow.

I'm in extreme danger. David flipped good FT, meaning his Alice/Bob=Demon read implicates me. I need to coordinate with Alice (my minion) on defense strategy before nominations begin.

Reinforce to trusted allies that Bob is the top suspect based on my FT read and his proven-false Washerwoman claim. Push for Bob's execution.

Share my Undertaker confirmation to build trust with Frank and establish David's read as reliable. This focuses suspicion on Bob/Alice and starts building a coalition for today's execution.

Share my Monk protection on Eve to build a trusted alliance. Eve hasn't claimed yet so I need her role info too.

Build trust with Eve as a confirmed Townsfolk. Coordinate investigation of Bob today. Gather more info before committing to my own role reveal.

Coordinate with Frank, who was aligned with Heidi against Bob. Frank didn't vote David either. Build trust and share analysis.

Share critical information with trusted neighbors to coordinate Bob's execution and win the game.

Warn Bob about Heidi's Ravenkeeper claim so he can prepare a defense, and coordinate our strategy to discredit her and redirect the town.

Heidi as Ravenkeeper saw me as Imp and told Alice and Grace. This is existential. I must reach Grace immediately to plant doubt before she accepts Heidi's word. Grace previously supported the Spy theory defending my info, so she's predisposed to doubt simple reads.

Push Grace and Eve to execute Bob - his Washerwoman info is demonstrably false, making him the most likely Demon or Drunk target. Either way, executing him helps narrow down the real Demon.

Share my Undertaker role with Grace to build trust and confirm David's Fortune Teller identity. Coordinate on Bob's execution.

Coordinate with Eve to push Bob's execution. Share that Heidi whispered to me claiming Bob is Imp, and that without Poisoner (since Baron is likely in play per Alice's claim), Heidi's info should be reliable.

Coordinate with Charlie on Bob suspicion and share Eve's Undertaker claim to build a unified good team push for information today.

Frank is trustworthy - he didn't vote David and is sharing useful intel. I'll reveal my Virgin role to him so he can help protect me or use this info strategically. We need to focus on Bob today.

Informing remaining players that my Ravenkeeper ability confirmed Bob is the Imp, ensuring he gets executed today.

Cast doubt on Heidi's Ravenkeeper claim to protect Bob (the Imp). Target Grace since she previously pushed the Eve=Spy theory and might be receptive to alternative theories.

Heidi the Ravenkeeper is spreading that I'm the Imp to Eve and Charlie. I need to preemptively discredit her claim with them before they consolidate against me. Argue poison or Recluse as alternative explanations.

Push for Bob's nomination before the nomination phase. I'm dead with a ghost vote, so I need alive players to nominate. Eve and Charlie are key allies who can act.

Coordinate with Frank and Grace to nominate and execute Bob today. All evidence points to him: false Washerwoman, David's FT read, and Heidi's Ravenkeeper confirmation.

Coordinate with Eve and Frank to execute Bob today. Eve should nominate or one of us should. We have overwhelming evidence.

Reveal my Butler role to Eve and Grace to build trust. Support nominating and executing Bob as the Demon. Coordinate with Alice since she's my master today so I can vote.

Share Heidi's Ravenkeeper claim with Alice to gauge her reaction and build the case for executing Bob. Alice's response will help me determine if she's good or evil.

I need to inform all living players that Bob is confirmed Imp so we can execute him today. I've told Alice, Grace, Charlie, Eve, and now Frank. This should build consensus.

Sow doubt about Heidi's Ravenkeeper claim and redirect suspicion away from Bob toward Frank/Grace as possible Recluse. Create alternative explanations for why Bob could register as Demon without actually being one.

Nominate Frank to redirect attention away from me (the real Imp) and create an alternative execution target before the town rallies around Heidi's Ravenkeeper claim against me.

Defend myself against Bob's false accusation. Point out that Bob's nomination is a desperate deflection from overwhelming evidence: false Washerwoman info, David's FT read, and Heidi's Ravenkeeper confirmation that Bob is the Imp. I need Alice to vote so I can use my dead vote to execute Bob.

Undermine the argument that there's no Poisoner by challenging Alice's Librarian claim, creating doubt about the case against me.

I must protect town by speaking against this vote. Bob's nomination of Frank is a desperate deflection. The evidence against Bob is multilayered and consistent, and Frank is the Butler - killing him helps evil.

Defend my Librarian claim against Bob's attack while subtly creating doubt about Heidi's Ravenkeeper info on Bob, keeping the Poisoner possibility alive to protect Bob.

Stop the town from wasting an execution on Frank. The evidence against Bob is overwhelming - my FT read, false Washerwoman info, and Heidi's Ravenkeeper check all confirm it. Voting Frank helps the Demon win.

Frank is not our Demon. The evidence against Bob is overwhelming - false Washerwoman info, FT read, and Heidi's Ravenkeeper check all point to him. I will not vote for Frank.

I will NOT raise my hand to vote for Frank. Frank is not the Demon - Bob is. My Ravenkeeper ability confirmed Bob is the Imp. Voting Frank out would be catastrophic for good. I must encourage the town to execute Bob instead.

Stop the town from executing Frank (our Butler) by speaking out against the vote. Need to redirect toward executing Bob, who is clearly the Demon based on overwhelming evidence.

Raise the Poisoner possibility before voting closes. Alice's hesitation is suspicious - she's casting doubt despite overwhelming evidence against Bob. If she's Demon, she needs to avoid executing her Poisoner.

Leverage Frank's own suspicion of Alice to build doubt about the Baron claim and push the Poisoner narrative, which would explain Heidi's Ravenkeeper check as corrupted info. Try to get votes for Frank to remove a good player.

Oppose the vote on Frank to prevent executing our Butler, then push for Bob's execution which has overwhelming evidence.

Not voting for Frank protects my cover as a seemingly neutral/independent player, since the town consensus is strongly against executing Frank. Voting for Frank would tie me to Bob and validate Frank's suspicion of me.

I will not vote to execute Frank. This is Bob's desperate Demon deflection. All evidence points to Bob as the Imp. I must save my ghost vote for Bob's execution.

The evidence overwhelmingly points to Bob being the Demon. His Washerwoman info was false, David's FT implicated him, and Heidi's Ravenkeeper check confirmed Imp. I must prevent town from wasting the vote on Frank and redirect to executing Bob.

Reinforce that Bob is the confirmed Imp. My Ravenkeeper ability gave specific role information (Imp), not just alignment, which is consistent regardless of poisoning. Urge town not to execute Frank.

Bob is the Demon with overwhelming evidence against him. I will NOT raise my hand to vote Frank - doing so would waste our execution and help evil win. I need to stay firm that we execute Bob today.

Nominating Bob to execute the most likely Demon. Three independent sources confirm Bob as Imp: false Washerwoman, FT read, and Ravenkeeper check. Must act now before Bob deflects further.

I'm being voted on and likely to be executed. I need to plant enough doubt to prevent at least 3 votes from being raised against me.

Counter Bob's desperate defense and rally votes for execution. The evidence chain is airtight: false Washerwoman, FT read, Ravenkeeper check, and Baron confirmation all point to Bob as the Imp.

The evidence against Bob is overwhelming and mutually reinforcing. Three independent confirmations point to Bob as the Imp. I must vote to execute him to secure a good win.

Try to save Bob by casting doubt on Heidi's Ravenkeeper read using the Recluse possibility, without being too obvious about defending him.

Bob is confirmed Demon by three independent sources. Alice is stalling with unlikely Recluse theories. I must use my ghost vote to execute Bob now or we lose the game.

The evidence against Bob is overwhelming - false Washerwoman info, FT read, and Ravenkeeper Imp check. I must vote to execute him before the phase ends.

Counter Alice's Recluse argument to ensure Bob gets executed. Three votes are already cast, but I want to address the flawed logic to prevent doubt from spreading.

Three independent sources (Ravenkeeper, false Washerwoman info, Fortune Teller read) all confirm Bob is the Imp. Alice's Baron claim means no Poisoner to corrupt Heidi. Voting Bob is the correct play to execute the Demon.

Make a final desperate argument combining the Drunk Washerwoman and Recluse theories to explain both the false info and Heidi's Ravenkeeper check, trying to peel off votes.

Point out Bob's impossible dual claim to discredit him and pressure Alice to commit to a side by either voting or explaining her refusal in light of this contradiction.

Point out Bob's blatant contradiction claiming two roles at once. We have 4 votes raised (me, David, Charlie, Grace) - enough to execute. Reinforce the clear evidence.

Bob has 4 votes (Eve, David, Charlie, Grace), exceeding the 3 needed for execution. My vote won't change the outcome. Voting for Bob after publicly opposing makes me look inconsistent; not voting maintains my cover story but marks me as suspicious. Since the game likely ends with Bob's execution as the Demon, there's no strategic benefit to any action. Speaking now won't uncast votes. Best to wait.

We already have enough votes (Eve, Charlie, Grace) to execute Bob. Lowering hand preserves my single ghost vote for a later critical moment.

Call out Bob's blatant contradiction and David's suspicious hand-lowering. Reinforce that we have enough votes and Bob must die today.

Bob is definitively the Imp confirmed by my Ravenkeeper check. I must use my ghost vote to ensure his execution. David lowering his hand is concerning but we still have Eve, Grace, and Charlie's votes. Adding mine for safety.

Address David's suspicious vote retraction and reinforce the case for executing Bob. Keep my hand raised to secure the execution.

No action can save me. Voting is closed, I have 4 votes, and I'm about to be executed. My dual claim of Drunk and Recluse was a fatal contradiction. There's nothing left to do but wait for the execution.

Bob's execution is secured with 4 votes. I'm calling out Alice's suspicious behavior - refusing to vote despite Bob's blatant contradiction of claiming both Drunk and Recluse. I'm also switching my master to Grace who voted correctly.

Bob's execution is secured with 4 votes and only 1 tick remains. Waiting for the phase to close so Bob is executed. The evidence is overwhelming and his own contradiction sealed his fate.

Bob is about to be executed with 4 votes and only 1 tick remaining. There is no way to save my Demon at this point - the town is united, the vote is locked, and there isn't time to nominate and vote anyone else. The game is lost for evil.

Explain my hesitation was caution about wasting ghost vote when Bob already had enough. Emphasize Alice's suspicious protection of Bob and warn about Scarlet Woman for next day.

Reinforce David's warning about Alice for tomorrow. Bob's execution is secured; prepare town to evaluate Alice based on Bob's flip.

Warn town about Scarlet Woman possibility so they are prepared if the game continues after Bob's execution. Flag Alice as prime suspect based on her pattern of protecting Bob and eliminating David.

Bob's execution is secured with 4 votes. My nomination is already used. I will wait and prepare to push for Alice's execution tomorrow - her defense of Bob is extremely suspicious regardless of what he flips.