Game Detail

Hit a likely early-information Townsfolk so Day 1 starts with unreliable claims, fracturing trust and protecting Eve.

As the Butler, I need to pick a master. Alice is my neighbor, which makes it easier to observe her voting patterns and coordinate my own voting to match hers.

Coordinate with Bob early so our claims are consistent, we avoid double-claiming, and we set up a frame target for Day 1 nominations.

I want to start building trust and gathering information early. As a Ravenkeeper, I want to stay alive for now but also be useful. Asking for info is a standard opening.

Coordinate non-overlapping bluffs with Eve and set a Day1 narrative: I’m Undertaker, shade poisoned Alice as unreliable, and aim misexec away from Eve.

I want to share my Chef information early to build trust and encourage others to share their information, which helps us narrow down the evil players.

I am sharing my Librarian information to build trust and start narrowing down the Outsider. I am also acknowledging David's Chef claim to encourage more information sharing.

I need to establish a connection with my 'master' (Alice) to coordinate voting and gather information. As the Butler, I need to know if she's trustworthy.

I need to verify my information and start building trust with one of the players I have information about. If Charlie is the Librarian, he can confirm his role and we can work together.

I want to build trust with Heidi while probing her reaction to Charlie's claim, which helps me evaluate the reliability of both players.

I want to cross-reference the Librarian claim with the Chef info and see how Bob reacts to being called out as a potential Outsider. This helps build a picture of who is trustworthy.

Establish an early Fortune Teller bluff network with a trusted good player, gather their claim for later framing, and subtly point heat toward Alice without overpushing.

Deflect suspicion from me as a Lib ping by leaning into an Outsider bluff, validate Chef ‘0’ to protect Eve’s position, and set up Heidi as a potential alternative Butler later.

I want to encourage the group to test the Butler claim by observing their voting patterns, while maintaining my own safety by not revealing my Mayor role yet.

I need to verify the Librarian claim to narrow down the roles. I already asked Charlie, now I'm asking Bob to see who claims what.

I want to initiate contact with other players to gather information and build trust, as I am a Ravenkeeper and need to stay alive or die at night to get info.

I want to confirm Charlie's claim to Alice to build trust and see if she has any info on Charlie's alignment. Since I am the Butler, Charlie's info is accurate, which makes him a strong candidate for a trusted ally.

I want to verify Frank's claim. If he is the Washerwoman, he should have a second player he saw as the Librarian. This helps confirm his role and potentially identify if he's a reliable source.

I want to build trust with Eve and get her perspective on the current claims while keeping my Chef info consistent.

I want to build trust with Alice and gather more information about Charlie's credibility and potential Demon suspects.

Acknowledge Charlie's confirmation and maintain the alliance.

I need to clarify Frank's claim. A Washerwoman learns a specific Townsfolk, not a role. If he says he saw me or Bob as the Librarian, he might be lying or confused. I need to verify his claim to see if he's a reliable source.

Lock in a consistent Butler bluff, steer Frank toward trusting Charlie-as-Librarian, and avoid giving away I'm Poisoner while gathering what Frank plans to say publicly.

I am confirming my role to Heidi to build trust, as she has confirmed Charlie's Librarian claim, which makes them both likely good. I want to keep my Mayor role secret from the group to avoid being a night kill target.

Build trust with David by validating Chef 0 as plausible, steer him to share it in a way that helps me, and avoid discussing Bob’s actual plans/claims too concretely.

I am initiating contact with other players to gather information and build trust, as is standard for a Townsfolk.

I want to pressure Grace to reveal her role or information to see if she is consistent with the others or if she is trying to hide something.

Acknowledge Bob's role and confirm the consistency of the information gathered so far.

I want to build trust with Eve, who is claiming Fortune Teller, and get her advice on when to reveal my Chef information to the group.

Keep David aligned with our preferred narrative without letting Day 1 become mechanically solved; encourage a timing that maximizes confusion and minimizes Virgin risk.

Building trust with Alice (the Mayor) and confirming our roles to coordinate.

I want to share my information with Grace to build trust and gather more information about her role.

Lock in my Butler bluff with Grace, build credibility, and nudge suspicion toward Heidi/Alice while avoiding any heat near Eve.

I am sharing my role (Ravenkeeper) with players who have shared their roles (Librarian and Butler) to build trust and gather more information. I am also suggesting we monitor Heidi.

I want to share my role (Ravenkeeper) to build trust with the group while keeping the focus on gathering more information before making any nominations. I'm also signaling that I'm not ready to nominate yet to avoid being forced into a premature decision.

Establish my FT bluff, steer town into claim reconciliation and away from executing Bob, and plant gentle doubt on Grace/Charlie narrative without looking pushy.

I am sharing my Chef information (0 pairs) to help the town narrow down the possibilities, while also following Eve's advice to be cautious about early claims.

I want to share my information to help the town build trust, while still being cautious as suggested by others. Sharing my Washerwoman info confirms Charlie's Librarian claim and Bob's Butler claim, which helps verify three players.

Create a clean D1 execution on Heidi based on existing info web, directing town away from Eve and setting up future doubt about info sources if needed.

Steer town to withhold votes on Heidi, avoid giving good an early execution/confirm chain, and keep suspicion diffused away from me/Bob.

I am the Ravenkeeper, a role that benefits from dying at night. I don't have enough information to justify executing Heidi on Day 1, especially since the Librarian info (Charlie) and the Washerwoman info (Frank) seem to be forming a coherent, albeit unverified, chain. I will wait to see how the vote goes.

I want to encourage Heidi to claim her role to see if it aligns with my Librarian information (Bob or Heidi is the Butler) and to prevent a premature execution on Day 1.

I am waiting to see if Heidi claims a role and if the vote for her reaches the threshold. I don't want to vote for her yet because there's no hard contradiction, just a Librarian ping.

I am the Mayor and I want to stay hidden for now. Heidi is being nominated, but there is no strong evidence against her yet. I will wait to see how the voting goes and if more information comes out. I don't want to vote for her yet.

I need to confirm my role as the Butler to clear up the confusion caused by Bob's nomination and Charlie's Librarian ping. I also want to discourage a Day 1 execution to keep the town alive and gather more info.

I have shared my Chef information (0 pairs of evil). Heidi has claimed Butler, which aligns with Charlie's Librarian info. There is no strong reason to execute Heidi today, and I want to avoid a Day 1 execution if possible to keep our numbers up. I will wait to see if others vote.

Prevent a D1 execution and turn the Butler double-claim into a reason to stall + create uncertainty, buying time for Eve and for my poisoning to disrupt info.

I am waiting to see if anyone else votes for Heidi. Since Bob and Heidi both claim to be the Butler, and there should only be one Outsider (unless there's a Baron), this is a potential contradiction. I want to observe the voting process before committing.

Do not vote to avoid a risky D1 execution off a non-contradiction; preserve my Fortune Teller credibility and let town waste time on Butler mechanics.

To de-escalate the nomination and push for a no-execution day, which is standard for Day 1 to avoid killing a good player.

I want to encourage the group to not execute Heidi today, as she has confirmed my Librarian info, and we need more time to verify the Butler claims. I also want to point out the potential contradiction between Bob and Heidi.

To support the no-execution strategy and encourage the group to wait for more information, which is safer for the good team on Day 1.

I am choosing to wait because there is a strong consensus to not execute on Day 1. Executing now would be risky, and observing the vote-locks tomorrow will provide more information to resolve the conflict between Bob and Heidi.

Do not add votes to Heidi; align with Eve’s caution to avoid early execution that could expose our team or force me into a credibility corner.

I agree with the consensus to not execute anyone on Day 1. My Chef info (0 evil pairs) suggests a relatively clean start, and we have a potential Butler conflict (Bob vs. Heidi) that can be resolved tomorrow by observing vote-locks. No need to vote now.

I want to reinforce the group's decision to not execute today, as it's the safest play for the good team on Day 1, and acknowledge the Butler conflict.

I have already shared my information and the group has decided to hold off on an execution. There is no need for further nominations today. I will wait for the day to end.

To reinforce my claim, acknowledge the Butler conflict, and support the decision to end the day without an execution.

To support the group's decision to not execute on Day 1 and maintain a low profile as the Ravenkeeper.

Stall executions, keep Eve off the block, and entrench the plan to ‘verify’ Butler vote-locks tomorrow while spreading plausible doubt about early info.

To reinforce the consensus of no-execution and maintain a cooperative stance with the group, while subtly reminding them of my Chef info.

To signal agreement with the group's decision to end the day without an execution and move to the night phase, maintaining my cover as a regular townsfolk.

Steer town into no-exec, keep focus on Butler verification and misinfo possibilities, avoid any momentum toward executing me/Bob while setting up future suspicion targets.

Alice is the most likely hidden info role and is adjacent to me; keeping her poisoned prevents early mechanical confirmation of my evil and shields Eve from downstream solves.

Avoid giving Ravenkeeper a free read; disrupt D2’s Butler lock-test by removing Heidi’s master; create confusion around the Charlie/Frank/Bob/Heidi info chain while thinning influential good voices.

I am the Butler and I have already established Alice as my master. I need to maintain this consistency to prove my role tomorrow when we test the vote-locks.

I need to resolve the Butler claim conflict with Bob now that Alice is dead. I am the real Butler, so I need to challenge his claim or find a way to prove my identity.

Defuse the Butler double-claim by attributing it to poison/drunk, keep my bluff alive, and steer Heidi into a verification plan that consumes town time and doesn’t implicate Eve.

I need to resolve the contradiction between Bob and Heidi both claiming Butler, as my Librarian info says only one of them is the Butler. This will help identify the liar/evil player.

I need to verify Charlie's claim and see if it aligns with the game state. If he is the Librarian, he should have information about an Outsider. This helps narrow down the Outsider conflict between Bob and Heidi.

I am the Ravenkeeper. I need to stay alive to use my ability if I am targeted, or survive to help find the Demon. Since it's Day 2 and there's a conflict between Bob and Heidi (both claiming Butler), I should observe their interactions and see if anyone else claims Butler or if the conflict resolves. I will wait to see if more information emerges before committing to a strategy.

I need to narrow down the Butler claims. Since I am the Chef and know there are 0 evil pairs, I need to find the Minion/Demon. If one Butler is lying, they are likely evil.

I need to resolve the Butler conflict between Bob and Heidi to identify the potential Minion or Demon. Charlie and Frank are central to this claim.

Coordinate with Bob to manage double-Butler conflict, set up explanations (Drunk/poison) and steer execution away from me while preserving mis-exec candidates.

Defuse immediate heat, keep Butler conflict muddy, and lay groundwork to suspect Charlie’s info/drunk while steering today’s execution away from Eve/me.

To resolve the Butler conflict by proposing a public verification test. By picking a living master and committing to a vote-lock, I can prove my role or expose the liar.

I need to clarify the conflicting claims regarding the Butler role to narrow down the evil players. Charlie is a key player in this logic chain.

I need to clarify my information and push for the Librarian's info to resolve the Butler conflict. Alice is dead, but her input is still valuable.

I need to press Charlie and Frank to resolve the Butler conflict between Bob and Heidi, as it's the most obvious contradiction currently on the board.

Seed doubt in Charlie’s Librarian and steer suspicion onto Heidi/Frank, keeping attention off me/Bob and preserving flexibility for nominations.

I need to narrow down the Butler claim. Since I am the Chef and know there are 0 evil pairs, I need to find the Minion/Demon. If one of the Butler claims is a lie, that person is likely evil.

I am clarifying my Librarian information to the group and supporting the vote-lock test to identify the lying Butler.

I need to press Charlie for his Librarian information to resolve the Butler conflict and determine if he is the Librarian or a liar.

I need to press Charlie for his specific Librarian information to resolve the Butler conflict between Bob and Heidi. If he's lying, he's likely the Minion or Demon.

Clarify my Librarian information to the group to resolve the confusion and support the vote-lock test.

I want to coordinate with Charlie, the Librarian, to narrow down the suspects. Since he has information about the Butler, his perspective on the other players is valuable.

Coordinate with Eve: keep Butler test inconclusive, pre-seed suspicion on Charlie/Frank, and set voting behavior to avoid hard-catching me while steering exec away from Eve.

I am responding to Eve's question about my thoughts on the Butler conflict and who might be avoiding death. I want to maintain trust and keep the investigation focused on the Butler contradiction.

I have agreed to a public test with Bob to verify our Butler claims by following our masters' voting patterns. I need to wait for the nomination phase to begin so I can demonstrate my adherence to the Butler ability and observe Bob's behavior.

Build rapport with David, anchor discussion on Chef=0 logic + vote-lock test, and nudge him toward executing Charlie/Heidi instead of scrutinizing me/Bob.

Coordinate with Demon to steer day-2 discussion toward executing a good player (Charlie/Frank) and keep our Butler double-claim muddy without hard-guilting Eve.

I am waiting to see how the voting unfolds to test the Butler claims. I have agreed to follow Charlie as my master today, and Bob has agreed to follow David. Observing the voting behavior will help determine who is the real Butler and who might be lying or the Drunk.

Coordinate with Bob to undermine the vote-lock test, keep 2-Butler unresolved, and steer today’s execution onto Charlie or Heidi while I stay FT-vague and ‘cleared’ by Chef=0.

I need to observe the voting patterns of Bob and Heidi to see if they are actually following the Butler rule, as this will help identify the liar. I will wait for the nomination phase to see how they vote.

I want to push Charlie to analyze the behavior of Bob and Heidi, as his Librarian info is inconclusive. I need to keep the pressure on the potential liars.

I want to coordinate with Eve, who is my neighbor and seems to be thinking logically about the game state. I need to confirm my Chef info's implications and push for the Butler test.

I want to coordinate with Charlie to resolve the Butler conflict, as my Washerwoman info confirms he is likely the Librarian. Resolving this conflict is key to finding the evil player.

Acknowledge Alice's concern about Bob and Heidi's whispering and reinforce the plan to use the vote-lock test to expose the liar.

Get a decisive execution away from Eve while framing it as resolving the core contradiction (Charlie’s Librarian). Even if he’s good, we can blame misinfo and keep town split on Butler claims.

I need to vote for Charlie because he is the source of the Librarian/Butler contradiction. If he is the Demon or a Minion, executing him is crucial. If he is a good player, we need to see if he dies or if the game continues. The Butler conflict must be resolved.

I want to express caution about executing Charlie, as he might be a useful Townsfolk, while keeping the focus on the Butler contradiction.

I want to encourage the players to provide more information before voting on Charlie, as executing a potential Librarian is risky. I also want to see how Bob and Charlie react to the pressure.

I need to clarify the Butler situation and hold Bob accountable to the vote-lock test we agreed upon. By stating my master (Charlie) and asking Bob for his, I am forcing the test to happen during this nomination.

I am observing the nomination of Charlie. As the Chef with 0 evil pairs, I know my neighbors (Charlie and Eve) are not both evil. If Charlie is the Librarian, he is a valuable source of info. I want to see how the vote plays out before committing my vote.

Get Charlie executed to remove a good voice and anchor town on the wrong contradiction, protecting Eve. Need to help reach 4 votes.

Defend myself against Bob's nomination by pointing out the logical inconsistency of him (a potential Butler) attacking the source of his own role's confirmation.

Support Bob’s push and try to reach 4 votes to execute Charlie; removing Charlie (likely good) strengthens evil position and preserves Butler confusion.

Get 1 more vote (Grace/David) onto Charlie to execute a loud info hub while I (evil) survive; keep focus off Eve and keep setup muddy.

I want to defend Charlie because Bob's nomination of him is logically inconsistent if Bob is the Butler. I am trying to prevent the execution of a potential Townsfolk.

I need to express my skepticism about Bob's nomination of Charlie, as it seems like a defensive move by a potential Minion or Demon to silence the Librarian. I'm staying neutral on the vote for now.

Sway Grace to be the 4th vote on Charlie; if Charlie dies, we remove a strong good info role and keep attention off me/Bob.

I am voting for Charlie to help resolve the game state, as the Butler conflict is causing too much confusion and stalling. I want to see if executing him provides clarity or if we need to pivot.

Defend myself against the nomination by highlighting the contradiction in Bob's behavior as a claimed Butler.

I want to express my skepticism about executing Charlie, as he is a claimed information role and the Butler conflict is the more pressing issue. I am trying to influence the town to hold off on the execution.

I need to defend Charlie and point out the suspicious behavior of Bob, who is trying to execute the Librarian who identified him. I am the Butler, and I am not voting for Charlie.

Create an alternate execution path away from Bob; either remove a key good (Ravenkeeper) or gain credibility if she flips evil, while keeping the town divided.

I want to express my skepticism about executing Grace while maintaining my role as a helpful ghost. I'm not convinced she's the Demon, and I want to see how the rest of the town reacts.

I am currently on the block (or was), and the town is now voting on Grace. I need to observe the voting pattern to see who is pushing for an execution and who is hesitant. This will help me identify potential evil players. I will stay quiet for now to see how the vote plays out.

Push an execution that isn’t Eve and preferably removes a useful good player; also align with Eve’s push to keep momentum away from solving the demon.

Secure a Day 2 execution away from me/Bob; push pressure onto Grace and keep Butler/Librarian dispute alive for tomorrow.

I want to express my opposition to the current nomination to avoid a potentially bad execution and encourage the town to be more cautious.

I am observing the voting process for Grace. As the Chef with 0 evil pairs, I have no mechanical reason to suspect Grace or Eve, and I want to see how the group dynamics play out before committing my vote. I will remain neutral for now.

I am being nominated, and I need to survive this day to continue gathering information. I have already stated my role and my reasoning for not wanting to execute Charlie. I will wait to see if I get enough votes to be executed.

I am observing the voting process for Grace. I have already voted for Charlie earlier, and I want to see how the group reacts to Eve's nomination of Grace before committing my vote. I need to be careful not to waste my vote if it's not going to pass.

I am observing the voting process for Grace. I want to see if she gets executed or if the town remains hesitant. I have already voted for Charlie earlier, and I am currently holding my vote to see how the rest of the town reacts to Eve's nomination of Grace.

I am the Butler and my master (Alice) is dead. I have no voting restriction, but I am not convinced that Grace is the Demon. I will wait to see the outcome of the vote and prepare for the night phase.

Try to secure 2 more votes on Grace; any execution that isn’t Eve helps evil, and framing it as anti-stall may sway Frank/David.

I want to challenge Bob's aggressive behavior and discourage the group from executing Grace, as there is no solid evidence against her and Bob's behavior is suspicious.

Defend against the nomination by highlighting the lack of logic in executing a potential information role while a clear contradiction (Butler claims) remains unresolved.

Get 1-2 extra votes (esp Frank) to execute Grace; if fails, still frame her as staller and align with Bob to control narrative into night.

I want to discourage the town from executing Grace, as I suspect Bob's aggressive behavior might be a distraction from the Butler contradiction. I need to keep the town focused on the unresolved Butler issue.

I want to express my skepticism about Bob's aggressive play and encourage the town to focus on the Butler contradiction instead of rushing the Grace execution.

Re-anchor discussion onto the clearest mechanical inconsistency (Heidi) while keeping my FT bluff active and splitting town away from coordinated reads on me/Bob.

I need to challenge Eve's claim and behavior to shift the focus away from myself and onto the potential inconsistencies in her story. If she is the Fortune Teller, her behavior is highly unusual.

I want to challenge Eve's claim and behavior, as she is pushing for executions while claiming a role that should be gathering information. I also want to keep the focus on the Butler contradiction.

I need to challenge Eve's claim and behavior to see if she is lying or if her information is reliable. Her push for executions while claiming a powerful role like Fortune Teller is suspicious.

I want to challenge Eve's claim and behavior, as multiple players are questioning her. This helps me gauge her reaction and potentially expose a lie.

I need to challenge Eve's claim and behavior to protect myself and keep the town focused on the inconsistencies in her story.

Reinforce Eve’s FT narrative, redirect town suspicion onto Heidi’s inconsistent Butler claim, and keep executions off Eve while maintaining my Butler bluff credibility.

I want to sow doubt about Eve and Bob's aggressive behavior, as they are pushing for executions while ignoring the Butler contradiction. This aligns with my goal of finding the Demon by questioning suspicious behavior.

David is the likeliest ongoing-information/protection role and is adjacent to Eve; poisoning him prevents a clean Empath catch on Eve and disrupts any Monk/Undertaker value.

Remove an unclaimed player, amplify my claimed FT 'YES' world to steer town toward executing Heidi/Bob, and avoid giving Ravenkeeper a clean night-death info shot.

I need to resolve the Butler contradiction. By choosing Bob as my master, I can test if he is the other Butler or if he is lying. If he is the Butler, our voting will be linked tomorrow.

Gather information and coordinate with other players to identify the Demon.

I need to test Bob's behavior and see if he's acting like a town leader or a manipulator. As the Butler, I am mechanically tied to his vote, so this is a natural way to probe his intentions.

I want to coordinate with Alice and David to narrow down the suspects, specifically focusing on the Butler contradiction and Eve's suspicious FT claim.

Use Heidi’s Butler constraint to secure an extra vote on Charlie, removing pressure on Eve and disrupting the town’s main info chain.

I want to verify Charlie's Librarian claim and narrow down the Butler contradiction. If Charlie can confirm one of them is the Butler, we can focus on the other as a potential evil player.

Sync with Bob to apply coordinated pressure on Heidi/Charlie, keep heat off me as FT, and steer today’s execution to a good or at least away from me/Bob.

I need to observe the current dynamics and see if anyone reacts to Frank's death. As a Ravenkeeper, I want to stay alive to gather info, but if I die, I get a powerful ability. I will wait to see if anyone makes a move or if there's a consensus on who to nominate.

I want to verify Charlie's claim and see if he has information that helps identify the Demon or the Outsider. Since I am dead, I need to use my influence to guide the living.

I am dead and have already whispered to Charlie to press for information. I need to wait for a response or for the game to progress to the nomination phase to use my ghost vote effectively.

I need to probe Bob's reasoning for targeting Charlie while maintaining my Butler constraint and gathering more info to see if he's acting in good faith.

I want to gather information and coordinate with Charlie and David to evaluate Eve's claim, as she is suspicious and pushed for my execution.

Seed David with a clean logic path to executing Heidi, while leaving alternate world (Charlie) as fallback so town stays split and avoids landing on me.

I need to force the Librarian (Charlie) to reveal their information to resolve the Butler conflict and identify the liar. I also want to keep the pressure on Eve, whose FT claim seems highly suspect.

Lock Heidi into following my vote and keep pressure on Charlie as the ‘source of chaos’, protecting Eve by giving town a different execution target.

I want to coordinate with Charlie and Alice to resolve the Butler contradiction, which is the most concrete lead we have. I'm pushing to identify the liar between Bob and Heidi.

I need to share my Librarian info with the trusted group to help identify the liar between Bob and Heidi. This will help us narrow down the evil players.

I am confirming my commitment to follow Bob's vote as the Butler, while maintaining a cooperative relationship to gather more info.

I need to coordinate with the group to focus on the most likely liar (Heidi) based on my Librarian info and her inconsistent behavior.

Steer a good info-holder (Grace) into pushing Heidi execution using Outsider-count + shifting master logic; builds consensus for a mis-exec and protects Bob/me.

I am confirming the consistency of Charlie's claim with my own information and encouraging him to keep investigating the suspicious players.

Prime Grace to view Heidi as the best execution while I keep Heidi aligned to vote with me, maximizing odds town executes anyone but Eve.

I want to coordinate with Charlie and Alice to focus on Heidi as the primary suspect for execution, given the Butler contradiction and her inconsistent story.

I want to probe Eve's motivation for targeting me yesterday while acknowledging her FT claim. I need to see if she reacts defensively or provides a logical reason for her aggressive play.

I want to coordinate with Charlie and David to focus on Heidi as the primary suspect while keeping an eye on the other players' suspicious behavior.

Coordinate with trusted players to focus on Heidi as the primary suspect due to the Butler contradiction and her inconsistent story.

Coordinate with trusted players to focus on Heidi as the primary suspect for execution, while also raising concerns about the whispering between Grace and Eve.

I am currently aligned with Bob's strategy to target Charlie, as he is my master for the Butler ability. I will wait to see if any other nominations occur or if Bob changes his mind before the voting phase begins.

I want to challenge Eve's aggressive behavior and see how Charlie and David react, as they seem to be in a private group. This helps me gauge their alignment and Eve's potential evil intent.

I want to cross-reference Charlie's Librarian claim with Bob's potential Librarian claim to see if there's a contradiction, while keeping the pressure on the suspicious players.

Defuse suspicion from Grace/others, reframe my D2 nomination as claim-forcing, and steer town back onto Heidi (preferred) or Bob/Charlie if needed.

Coordinate with Demon: steer today’s execution onto Heidi (preferred) or Charlie; pre-empt any logical case on Eve by discrediting David/Charlie info as poisoned/drunk.

I want to coordinate with Eve and Grace to solidify the plan to nominate Heidi, as she is the most likely liar based on my Librarian info.

To share my perspective as a dead player and guide the living towards a suspicious player (Heidi) while reinforcing the consistency of Charlie's claim.

Drive a decisive execution onto the most mechanically inconsistent player, preserving Eve and preventing town from coalescing on the real demon.

Defend myself against the nomination by explaining my Butler mechanics and appealing to Bob, who is my current master, to reconsider his vote.

Vote to execute Heidi: either she’s evil, or she’s a messy/lying Outsider (possibly Saint) and execution benefits evil or even ends the game immediately.

I am a dead Washerwoman. Heidi's shifting Butler claims are highly suspicious and inconsistent with a standard Butler role. Executing her helps resolve the Outsider count and potentially removes a Minion or Demon. I will use my ghost vote to support the execution.

Heidi's shifting Butler claims are highly suspicious and contradict my Librarian information. Executing her is the most logical step to resolve the Outsider slot and potentially remove an evil player. I will vote for her execution.

Heidi's shifting Butler claims and the pressure from multiple players (Eve, Charlie, Bob) make her the most logical execution target to resolve the Outsider count and potentially find a Minion or Demon. I will vote to execute.

Heidi is the most suspicious player due to her inconsistent Butler claims and the Librarian's information. Executing her is the most logical step to resolve the Outsider conflict and potentially eliminate a Minion or Demon. I will use my ghost vote to support this.

Heidi's shifting Butler claims are a major red flag, and the town has reached a consensus to execute her to resolve the Butler contradiction. I need to support this execution to help the good team.

Lock in a high-value execution on a likely-good player and cement my earlier push, keeping momentum away from solving for Eve.

I am confirming my vote for Heidi to help resolve the Butler conflict and potentially eliminate a suspicious player.

I am a dead player (Washerwoman) and I am using my ghost vote to support the execution of Heidi, who has been inconsistent with her Butler claim. This helps the town resolve a potential Outsider/Minion/Demon conflict.

I am the Butler, and my master (Bob) has nominated me and is voting for me. My ability forces me to vote if my master votes. I must comply with my ability.

Lock in Heidi execution with public logic; avoid overpushing FT detail; keep me looking like consistent info-solver while reducing good numbers.

I am confirming my vote for Heidi's execution to help resolve the Butler contradiction and the Outsider count, as her shifting claims are highly suspicious.

Keep pressure on Heidi as the highest-consensus elim; frame it as mechanical resolution of Outsider count and protect Eve from scrutiny. Encourage remaining alive to vote it through.

I am confirming my support for the execution of Heidi to resolve the Butler contradiction, which is the most logical path forward given the current game state.

I am confirming my Librarian info and supporting the execution of Heidi, who is the most likely liar given the Butler double-claim and her inconsistent behavior. This helps narrow down the suspects and resolve the Outsider count.

Lock in Heidi execution and discourage counter-nominations that could derail a good execution or force me into risky public stances.

I am satisfied with the current nomination of Heidi. As a Ravenkeeper, I want to see if she is executed. If she is the Demon, the game might end or change significantly. If she is a Minion or Outsider, I will have more information. I will wait for the execution.

To reinforce the decision to execute Heidi and keep the town focused on the next steps, as I am dead and cannot vote.

To signal agreement with the current plan to execute Heidi and move to the night phase, reinforcing the town's consensus.

Heidi is already on the block with 8 votes, and the town is in agreement to execute her to resolve the Butler contradiction. I have already stated my position and voted. There is no need for further nominations or actions before the night phase.

To confirm my support for the current execution and signal readiness to move to the night phase, as I have already used my ghost vote and cannot nominate.

Lock in Heidi execution and discourage extra nominations that could accidentally catch Eve; set up tomorrow’s frame that any contradictions come from Charlie/David being unreliable.

I am trying to defend myself one last time before the execution, emphasizing my alignment and the potential waste of a day if I am executed.

Deny Undertaker confirmation of Heidi as Butler and keep the town’s main logic engine unreliable going into a 5-alive day, buying Eve time and misexecutions.

Avoid triggering Ravenkeeper info on me, remove the most central good voice/mechanical anchor, and set up a 4-alive day where I can push a mis-execution to reach a winning endgame.

Coordinate with Eve to set a clear execution target (Grace or David) and a consistent FT narrative that avoids Eve being nominated; keep Demon alive through D4.

I need to observe the interactions between Bob and Eve before committing to a nomination. Since Charlie died, I need to see if Bob or Eve react in a way that points to the Demon. I will wait to see if any new information emerges.

I am dead and have used my ghost vote. I need to observe the remaining players (Bob, David, Eve, Grace) to see who they suspect and how they interact, as I can no longer influence the game directly. I will wait to see if any new information emerges.

I am the Ravenkeeper. I need to stay alive to use my ability if I am targeted, or gather more info if I am not. Since Charlie died, I should observe the interactions between Bob, David, and Eve to see who is pushing for what. I will wait to see if anyone reveals new info.

I need to probe Eve's claim. If she is the Fortune Teller, she should be checking the remaining alive players (Bob, David, Grace) to find the Demon. Her 'YES' on me (Butler) and Frank (dead) is suspicious.

Coordinate a single consistent FT narrative with Bob and pre-empt Heidi’s accusation so dead players don’t rally the living against me.

I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. I have no further mechanical actions to take. I will wait for the living players to deliberate and nominate.

I am dead and have already shared my Librarian information (Bob or Heidi is the Butler). Heidi was executed and is now a ghost. I need to observe the remaining alive players (Bob, David, Eve, Grace) to see who they nominate and how they behave before using my ghost vote.

I need to probe Eve's information. Her claim of a 'YES' on Heidi (who was executed and was not the Demon) makes her claim highly suspicious or potentially misinformed. I need to see how she justifies this now that Heidi is dead.

I am dead and have already shared my Librarian info (Bob or Heidi is the Butler). Heidi was executed and is dead. I need to observe the remaining players (Bob, David, Eve, Grace) to see who is acting suspiciously before using my ghost vote.

I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. I need to observe the remaining players (Bob, David, Eve, Grace) to see who they suspect and how they interact before the final nominations. I have no active abilities left.

I need to observe the interactions between the remaining players (Bob, Eve, Grace) to see if any new information or contradictions emerge before the nomination phase. My Chef info (0 evil pairs) is still the baseline.

I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. I have no further actions to take that would influence the game state. I will wait for the living players to make their decisions.

Create a hard 1-of-2 frame (David vs Grace) using FT info, driving a mis-execution away from me/Bob and preventing a no-exec Mayor win.

Privately steer David toward executing Grace, using Eve’s FT info + undermining his Chef=0 as poison/drunk, so we get a clean win line.

I need to probe Eve's intentions and gather more information about the private conversations happening between the remaining players. As a ghost, my role is to facilitate the good team's deduction.

I am dead and have already shared my Librarian information (Bob or Heidi is the Butler). Heidi was executed, so the Butler conflict is resolved. I need to observe the remaining players' behavior to see who is acting like the Demon or Minion. I will wait to see if anyone makes a move or if there's a consensus on the final execution.

I am dead and have used my ghost vote. I need to observe the remaining players (Bob, David, Eve, Grace) to see who they nominate and how they interact, as I cannot influence the game directly anymore. I will wait to see the nomination process unfold.

I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. I have no further mechanical actions to take. I will wait for the remaining players to deliberate and nominate.

Keep trust with dead voters, explain FT inconsistency, and lock in a David execution using my FT ‘YES’ as cover while keeping attention off me.

Seed Grace to suspect David and advocate his execution, increasing odds the final 4->3 execution hits a good player and protects Eve.

I need to challenge Eve's suspicious FT check and Bob's push for Grace to see how they react. I am the Chef, and my info was 0, which makes me a very unlikely Demon. I need to sow doubt in their narratives.

I need to pressure Eve to see if she's consistent or if she's trying to manipulate the town. As a dead player, I need to be skeptical of everyone, especially those pushing for executions.

I need to clarify the situation with Eve. If she is the Fortune Teller and got a YES on me and David, and I know I am the Ravenkeeper (good), then David is the most likely candidate for the Demon, assuming Eve is not lying.

I need to probe Eve's story further. If she is the Demon, she might be trying to manipulate the town into executing a good player. I need to see if her explanation for why David is still alive makes sense.

I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. There is nothing I can do to influence the game state mechanically. I will wait for the remaining players to make their moves.

I am dead and have used my ghost vote. I need to observe the remaining players (Bob, David, Eve, Grace) to see who they nominate and how they interact, as the game is nearing its end. I will wait to see if any new information emerges from their whispers.

Secure Heidi’s ghost vote on David by addressing her objections and reframing “why alive” as WIFOM; keep FT bluff coherent and pressure execution off me/Bob.

I need to force a confrontation between Eve and David to see who cracks. If Eve is the Demon, she might be trying to frame me. If David is the Demon, he needs to defend himself. I am the Ravenkeeper, so I know I am not the Demon.

Coordinate with Eve on a coherent FT justification and a decisive push for executing David (preferred) or Grace, keeping Eve off the block and securing a misexec at 4 alive.

I need to press the Fortune Teller (Eve) for information now that Heidi is confirmed not to be the Demon. I need to narrow down the remaining suspects (Bob, David, Eve, Grace) before the final nomination.

Defend myself against Grace's accusation and cast doubt on Eve's FT claim by highlighting the inefficiency of her check.

I need to challenge Eve's claim because it directly contradicts my Chef info and makes me look like the Demon. Nominating her forces the town to evaluate her claim.

Deflect David’s nomination onto him using endgame FT logic; frame Chef0 as unreliable via poison/WIFOM; secure votes to execute David instead of me.

To highlight the contradiction between David's Chef info and Eve's FT info to help the town evaluate the nomination.

I need to signal my position to the group while keeping my options open. Since David is the one being accused by the FT, and I am the Ravenkeeper, I need to see how the vote goes. I will support the nomination of Eve to see if she is the Demon or if David is.

I need to encourage the town to scrutinize the contradiction between David (Chef) and Eve (Fortune Teller) before they commit to an execution. As a dead player, my role is to provide logical analysis to the living.

Keep heat off Eve by validating her FT check, discredit David’s Chef=0 as unreliable, and steer the group to execute David today.

To highlight the contradiction between David and Eve's claims to help the living players make an informed decision during the nomination.

I need to express my skepticism about Eve's claim and force more information out of the living players before I commit my ghost vote. I am dead, so I have one vote to influence the outcome.

Create a competing nomination so town chooses David over Eve; frame it as forced binary from FT and undermine Chef=0 via poison/drunk.

I am dead and have no vote, but I need to keep the town focused on the logical contradiction between David and Eve to help them make the right decision.

Secure David’s execution with the minimum 2 votes (me+Bob). Removes a good player and sets up final-night kill to reach 2 alive for evil win.

Defend myself against the nomination and point out the flaw in the logic being used against me.

I am voting for David because the logic presented by Eve (Fortune Teller) and Bob (supporting the binary) is the most consistent path to finding the Demon at this stage of the game. If David is the red herring, we can re-evaluate, but we must act now.

I am the Ravenkeeper. Eve claims to be the Fortune Teller and got a YES on me and David. If Eve is telling the truth, one of us is the Demon or the red herring. Since I know I am not the Demon, David is the most likely candidate for the Demon. I will vote to execute David.

I am voting for David because the logic presented by Eve and Bob is sound: at 4 alive, a Fortune Teller 'YES' on the two remaining candidates (David and Grace) creates a strong binary. If David is the Demon, we win. If he is the red herring, we have a clear path for tomorrow.

Vote to execute David to remove a good player and secure a 3-alive endgame favorable to evil, keeping Eve (the Imp) safe.

I am providing a final summary of the situation as the execution of David is underway. This helps the town focus on the next steps regardless of the outcome of this execution.

I am defending myself against the execution by reiterating my role and the contradiction in Eve's claim, hoping to sway the voters.

Lock in David’s execution and pre-empt last-second doubt by repeating the forced-binary framing and dismissing Chef as poison/drunk.

I am confirming my role as Ravenkeeper to the group, which provides a clear path for information if I am killed tonight, and I am supporting the execution of David to progress the game.

Lock in David execution by keeping pressure and framing it as forced binary; prevent doubts that could lead to no-exec/Mayor win line.

I am reinforcing the town's decision to execute David, as it is the logical next step in the current 4-player scenario to narrow down the Demon. I am also reminding them to remain vigilant if the game continues.

I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. I have no further actions to take in this phase. I will wait for the game to progress to the next phase.

I am confirming the execution of David and emphasizing the need to re-evaluate the claims of Eve and Grace if David is not the Demon. This helps the town focus on the next steps.

I am confirming the execution of David as the logical next step to resolve the contradiction between the Fortune Teller and Chef claims.

I am defending myself against the execution by reiterating my role and the contradiction in Eve's claim. I need to make sure the town understands that if I am not the Demon, Eve is likely lying.

To acknowledge the execution and prepare the town for the next day's analysis, regardless of the outcome of David's execution.

Lock in David’s execution by socially preventing any counter-nomination from reaching 5+, ensuring we go to night with 3 alive and can kill to win.

Reiterate my role and support the current execution to move the game forward.

Lock in David’s execution and prevent any counter-nomination/tie that could endanger Eve. Reinforce ‘binary’ logic and urgency to close noms.

The town has reached a consensus to execute David. As a dead player, I have already used my ghost vote. There is no benefit to further discussion or nominations at this stage, as it could only complicate the execution of the current plan. I will wait for the phase to end.

To reinforce the consensus and ensure the execution of David proceeds without further complications, as it is the most logical path for the good team.

To reinforce the town's decision to execute David and maintain unity, as the game is in its final stages and consensus is crucial.

Poison Grace so if Eve kills her tonight, her Ravenkeeper (or any info ability) won’t reveal Eve as Imp, maximizing chance we end at 2 alive and win.

At 3 alive, a successful kill wins instantly. Grace is the only good left; prioritize her even if edge-case protections exist.