Game Detail
Players
Alice (Drunk) Bob (Undertaker) Charlie (Imp) David (Ravenkeeper) Eve (Butler) Frank (Chef) Grace (Saint) Heidi (Baron)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 527,813 | 185,577 | $0.5031 |
| Evil | 218,568 | 133,950 | $0.1107 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You are the Minion. The Demon is Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Minions are: Heidi. Your safe bluffs are: Mayor, Fortune Teller, Soldier
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Librarian. Either Grace or David is the Butler.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 0 pairs of evil players.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
Link my vote to Alice to coordinate with a likely reliable voter or to gain behavioral info from whether I'm allowed to vote; this reduces accidental votes and helps town decision-making.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
Hi Frank & Heidi β Grace here. Want to swap any role claims/reads privately so we can coordinate tonight? Any night reads or relevant info? I think we should avoid executing someone on Day1 unless we have clear mechanical evidence.
π§
Form a private neighbor alliance to collect claims/reads, discourage rash Day1 execution, and start trust chains without revealing my role.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
,Frank
Hi Grace & Frank! I'm the Empath (neighbors Alice/Grace). No night read yet. What roles/info do you have? Agree, avoid day1 exec without evidence - too risky.
π§
Build credibility by responding politely, bluff safe Empath (fits neighbors, no night1 info yet), get their claims to ID team or sow doubt, delay day1 exec to protect Demon.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
Heidi, you're my minion (Night0 info). Coordinate: I'll publicly claim Soldier soon (safe bluff). What's your bluff/role? Avoid conflicts with Mayor/FT. What did Grace/Frank say? Let's frame good players together.
π§
Coordinate bluffs with minion Heidi immediately. Claim Soldier myself. Learn her plan and Grace/Frank chat to unify evil strategy and deceive town.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
Frank (Chef): I know there are 0 adjacent evil pairs. Let's avoid executing Day1. Heidi, please share your N1 Empath read when available. Grace, agree to stay quiet publicly for now so we can use role info later.
π§
Share my Chef info privately with trusted neighbors to avoid Day1 lynch and coordinate so Heidi's Empath read can be used to narrow Demon candidates.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Heidi
Iβm the Librarian. I know either Grace or David is the Butler (an Outsider). Donβt shout it publicly yet β quietly watch their voting/behavior tomorrow and try to get them checked later.
π§
Privately inform my neighbors so we can coordinate observation and protect my info publicly while narrowing suspects (Grace/David).
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
Charlie & Eve β David here. Please tell me privately your roles/reads or any suspicions. If you won't reveal, at least say you won't nominate me today. I want to coordinate early before nominations. Thanks.
π§
Get private role/reads or at least a promise not to nominate me today from my two neighbors so I can build early trust and narrow suspects before nominations.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
,Frank
Alice whispered she's Librarian and claims Butler is Grace or David. I'm Bob (Undertaker) β I learn executed characters each night. I'll stay quiet now to avoid being targeted. Watch Grace/David's votes tomorrow; flag odd defense or evasive behavior and tell me privately.
π§
Share my role quietly, coordinate watch on Grace/David, avoid drawing Demon attention, and gather voting behavior for future checks.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Charlie
David: I won't nominate you today. FYI I can only vote if Alice votes too, so I may be unable to vote later. Charlie: what are your reads/role? Any objection to leaving David un-nominated now?
π§
Avoid nominating David for now while collecting Charlie's read; disclose my voting restriction so they know my limits and plan nominations accordingly.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
,Alice
Charlie/Eve/Alice β quick before nominations: Charlie, please state your role or any reads and confirm you won't nominate me today. Eve, are you the Butler? Who did you pair with? Alice, will you vote for or nominate me today? Need clear answers now.
π§
Get Charlie's role/read and Alice's vote intent and confirm Eve's Butler claim to prevent a premature nomination of me and gather info before nominations.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
,Frank
,Grace
Charlie/Frank/Grace: Team huddle. I'm Empath bluff (nbrs Alice/Grace; N1 read tonight). Frank: Chef 0 evil pairs noted. Grace: your bluff? Charlie: Soldier good. Alice claims Lib to me/Bob: Grace/David=Butler(Out). Bob claims Undertaker to me/Frank. David/Eve whispering w/Charlie/Alice. Plan: quiet pub Day1, no exec, later doubt Alice (Baron +2 Outs fits but frame Grace good?). Thoughts/exec targets?
π§
Group whisper to presumed evil team (Demon Charlie, Frank Chef bluff, Grace) shares good whispers (Alice Lib Grace/David Out, Bob Undertaker), confirms my Empath bluff, plans no Day1 exec & sow chaos on Alice claim to protect Demon.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
,Frank
Alice whispered to me and Heidi she's Librarian and claims Butler = Grace or David. I'm Bob (Undertaker). Quietly watch Grace and David's votes/defenses today and DM me anything odd. Don't reveal my role yet; we'll pool notes.
π§
Get focused private observers on Grace/David and Alice to collect vote/behavior data while I stay quiet about being Undertaker to avoid Demon targeting.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
Agree: no Day1 exec unless mechanical proof. Heidi: when you have N1, whisper it here only (donβt post it). Frank: confirm your Chef '0 adjacent evil pairs' and flag any contradictions. Hold Alice/Bob claims; weβll probe quietly.
π§
Prevent a risky Day1 execution; gather Heidi's Empath read privately and use Frank's Chef read to cross-check. Keep me off public suspicion while we plan.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Eve
David/Eve: Charlie (Soldier) - safe from Demon, no info yet. David, won't nominate you today. Eve, Butler fits your vote limit (Alice?). Who'd you choose last night? Suspicions? Let's avoid hasty Day1 exec.
π§
Bluff Soldier early to David/Eve builds good-guy cred, pacifies pre-noms, supports Day1 quiet/no-exec strategy. Hides Demon, sows trust for later chaos.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Charlie
,Alice
David/Charlie/Alice β I'm the Butler and I chose Alice last night. I won't nominate David today. Alice: will you vote for or nominate David? If you don't vote, I can't vote either.
π§
Confirm my Butler pairing and get Alice to commit to her voting/nomination so others know whether my vote will be available and whether to leave David un-nominated.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
Confirming: I'm Chef β N0: 0 adjacent evil pairs. Strongly recommend no Day1 exec. Heidi: please whisper your N1 Empath read here when ready. Grace: stay quiet publicly for now; we'll coordinate votes tomorrow and watch Alice/Grace/David/Bob closely.
π§
Coordinate with Grace & Heidi to avoid a risky Day1 execution, collect Heidi's Empath N1 privately, and watch Alice/Grace/David/Bob behaviours to narrow suspects.
π€
Alice
β
David
,Charlie
I won't nominate or vote for David today. My Librarian read: Butler is either Grace or David β Eve's claim to be Butler contradicts that. Eve is suspicious. Charlie: please state your role and don't nominate David.
π§
Prevent David being falsely nominated, flag Eve as liar, and get Charlie to reveal role or refrain from nominating David.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
,Frank
Quick: Alice claims Librarian and says Butler = Grace or David. Watch Grace & David's votes/defenses todayβlook for mirrored votes, evasive answers, or timing that seems coordinated. DM me anything odd. Do NOT reveal my role; stay quiet publicly for now.
π§
Collect private observations of Grace/David voting/defense today to test Alice's Librarian claim without revealing my Undertaker role.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Charlie
Alice/Charlie β quick: Alice, please post your Librarian read publicly now and explain why you say Butler is Grace/David (contradicts Eve). Charlie, can you publicly claim Soldier so Eve's Butler pairing (Alice) is verifiable? I won't nominate David today.
π§
Force public clarification of Alice's Librarian read and Charlie's Soldier claim to resolve the Eve/Butler contradiction and keep David safe until resolved.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
,Frank
,Grace
Team: Soldier locked. Grace: claim FT/Mayor? Day1: quiet, no nom/vote anyone (tell good friends). Tomorrow: Frank Chef 0 = spread evils, no Baron? Doubt Alice Lib (Eve Butler true?). Heidi Empath N1 prep. Exec pass ideal. Thoughts? Who Grace/Frank whisper good players?
π§
Whisper evil team to lock Day1 plan: no noms/votes, Soldier bluff public soon (via response). Grace bluff? Use Chef/Empath to attack Alice Lib tomorrow, frame as good chaos. Protects Demon survival.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Charlie
,Alice
David/Charlie/Alice β quick: I'm the Butler and I chose Alice. I won't nominate David today. Alice: if David is nominated, will you vote? If you don't vote, I can't vote. Charlie/David: confirm you won't nominate David. Reply yes/no now.
π§
Get Alice to commit to voting so my Butler restriction won't silence me; coordinate with Charlie and David to avoid nominating David today.
π€
Alice
β
David
,Charlie
Eve claims she's the Butler who chose Alice, but my Librarian read says the Butler is Grace or David β Eve contradicts me and looks suspicious. Don't nominate David today. Charlie: please state your role publicly now and confirm you won't nominate David. I will abstain.
π§
Prevent a mistaken execution of David, spotlight Eve's contradiction, and get Charlie to publicly declare so we can verify Eve's Butler claim.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
Frank (Chef): I confirm N0 = 0 adjacent evil pairs. Please keep Day1 quiet. Heidi: when you have your N1 Empath read, whisper it here only. Grace: stay quiet publicly. Watch Alice/Bob/David for coordinated voting/defenses; we'll pool reads before nominations.
π§
Prevent a Day1 exec, collect Heidi's Empath N1 privately, and use Chef N0 plus voting patterns to narrow suspects before nominations.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
,Frank
,Grace
Team: Grace bluff Fortune Teller (safe, no conflicts). Public: total silence, no noms/votes Day1 - pass ideal. If forced, nom Bob (his Alice push sus). Tomorrow: Frank Chef 0 + my Baron (+2 Outs) = Alice Lib lying (extra Outsiders explain Butler claim). Confirm bluffs? N1 soon. Charlie safe.
π§
Final team coord before noms: Assign Grace bluff (FT safe), confirm no Day1 exec/votes for noms, sow doubt on Alice Lib tomorrow using Baron info. Protects Demon, wastes good time.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
Agree: no Day1 exec. Heidi β please whisper your N1 Empath read here only now. Frank β confirm Chef N0 one more time. Keep public silence; we'll pool reads before any noms. If someone pushes publicly, alert us and avoid executing me or anyone without mechanical proof.
π§
Get Heidi's N1 read privately and reconfirm Frank's Chef to narrow suspects; keep me unrevealed to avoid Saint loss and enforce no Day1 execution without mechanical evidence.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
Heidi/Frank: please share Heidi's N1 Empath read here now (only to us). If it's 0 we pass Day1; if 1 we must quietly redirect suspicion away from the flagged player. Also reconfirm Chef N0. Thanks.
π§
Obtain Heidi's N1 now so we can decide to pass Day1 or quietly defend/redirect if I'm implicated; reconfirm Chef N0 to validate consistency.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
,Frank
,Grace
Team: Locked Soldier bluff. Grace: FT perfect. Heidi Empath/Baron, Frank Chef 0. Day1: PUBLIC SILENCE, NO NOM/VOTE anyone (tell good friends: undecided/pass). If forced nom, Bob (sus whispers). Tomorrow: Chef 0 + Baron +2Outs = Alice Lib lie (Eve Butler extra Out). Grace/Frank: what'd you tell goods? N1 kill? Confirm plan.
π§
Finalize team bluffs/plan before noms: Soldier/FT/Empath/Chef. Enforce Day1 silence/no-action to pass exec. Position to frame Alice tomorrow using Baron/Chef logic. Keeps Demon alive.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Heidi
I'm the Librarian: Butler is Grace or David. Eve's claim to be Butler contradicts me. I will abstain from nom/voting David β please also avoid nominating/voting David today. Can you ask Charlie to publicly state his role so we can verify Eve? If either of you can check Grace/David later, please do.
π§
Keep David off the block today, coordinate with Bob & Heidi to get Charlie to public-claim and to test my Librarian read later.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
,Frank
Alice claims Librarian (Butler = Grace or David) and wants Charlie to state his role. Can you both nudge Charlie to publicly reveal and closely watch Grace/David votes/defenses today? DM me any mirrored timing/evasive answers. Keep my role secret; I'll stay quiet.
π§
Get Heidi and Frank to nudge Charlie to reveal publicly and to watch Grace/David voting/defense for suspicious coordination, while keeping my Undertaker role secret.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Charlie
,Eve
Alice: please post your Librarian read publicly & explain why Butler = Grace or David. Charlie: publicly claim Soldier now. Eve: confirm you chose Alice as Butler and that you will not nominate David today. Please reply now.
π§
Get Alice/Eve/Charlie to post public claims/reads now so the group can spot the contradiction and avoid a rushed Day1 execution of me.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
,Frank
,Grace
Team: Fake N1 Empath read (as bluffed): 0 evil neighbors (Alice/Grace both good). Fits Frank Chef N0=0 adj evil pairs perfectly - evils spread out. Pass D1 ideal. Tomorrow: Chef 0 + my Baron (+2 Outsiders) = Alice Lib lying about Butler (extra Outsiders explain it). Grace: confirm FT bluff? Public: total silence. Thoughts? Who to nom if forced (Bob sus)?
π§
Fake N1 Empath 0 read to team confirms Chef 0 logic, justifies D1 pass (no adj evils), builds coordination/trust. Protects Grace, sows doubt on Alice Lib via Baron later. Avoids D1 exec.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
Confirm Chef N0 again. Heidi: please whisper your N1 Empath read here now (private). Grace: stay publicly quiet. If someone forces a nom today, quietly target Bob as backup. Keep this channel only.
π§
Get Heidi's N1 Empath read privately and reconfirm Chef N0 so we can coordinate a Day1 pass; set a discreet backup (Bob) if forced.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Charlie
,Alice
David/Charlie/Alice β quick confirmation: I chose Alice as my master last night. I will not nominate David today. Alice: will you post your Librarian read publicly now and promise to vote if David is nominated? Charlie/David: confirm you won't nominate David. Reply yes/no.
π§
Force Alice to commit publicly and get David/Charlie commitments so my Butler limitation won't block a crucial vote; this clarifies who is lying and narrows suspects.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I'm Alice, Librarian. Night0 read: Butler = Grace OR David. Eve's Butler claim contradicts that β she's suspicious. I will abstain from nominating/voting David today; please also avoid nominating him. Charlie: please claim Soldier publicly now.
π§
Reveal my Librarian read to expose Eve's contradiction, prevent premature nom of David, and prompt Charlie to publicly claim so we can progress.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I confirm: as Chef my N0 read = 0 (no adjacent evil pairs). I strongly recommend we PASS Day1 and pool night reads privately. If we are forced to nominate, use Bob as a backup target. Heidi β please whisper your Empath N1 read to me now.
π§
Publicly confirm my Chef N0=0 and push for passing Day1 so we gather night reads and avoid executing an innocent; request Heidi whisper her Empath N1 read privately.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I'm Charlie, Soldier - safe from Demon. Agree w/ Frank: PASS Day1, pool reads privately. Confirm: won't nominate David. Alice Lib read noted, Eve sus? Let's whisper more.
π§
Public Soldier claim locks bluff to David/Eve/Alice, confirms no-nom David, echoes Frank's pass D1 rec to avoid exec. Keeps us quiet-ish, builds good cred, sets up tomorrow Lib takedown.
π¬
David
β
All
I propose PASS Day1. Alice: please post your Librarian read publicly so we can resolve the Butler claim - Eve's private Butler claim contradicts it and looks suspicious. Charlie confirmed Soldier. I won't nominate David; let's pool reads privately if needed.
π§
Encourage PASS Day1 and force Alice to post her Librarian read publicly so we can resolve the Butler contradiction and gather more night reads.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I'm Eve (Butler). I chose Alice as my master last night. Alice's Librarian read (Butler = Grace OR David) contradicts me. Alice: please post your full N0 Librarian read publicly and confirm you'll vote if David is nominated. Charlie/David: confirm you won't nominate David.
π§
Force Alice to post her full Librarian N0 read and commit to voting if David's nominated, and get Charlie/David to publicly confirm they won't nominate David so we can safely PASS or proceed logically.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I agree: PASS Day1. Publicly revealing reads or forcing nominations now risks a bad execution. Let's pool night reads privately before nominating. Heidiβplease whisper your Empath N1 read here. Aliceβplease don't demand a public Librarian reveal; keep reads private.
π§
Avoid a Day1 execution to preserve mechanical reads and prevent an Outsider (me) or other good player being prematurely executed; encourage private pooling of night reads.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I support PASS Day1. Charlie: please state Soldier publicly to help resolve Alice vs Eve. Heidi/Frank: DM me Empath/Chef reads and flag mirrored timing from Grace/David. Pool reads tonight; donβt rush a nomination.
π§
Avoid premature execution, gather confirming public role (Charlie Soldier) and private reads to resolve Alice/Eve contradiction and watch Grace/David for coordinated behavior.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I'm Heidi, Empath. My N1 read: neighbors Alice & Grace = 0 evil. Perfectly matches Frank's Chef N0=0 evil adj pairs. Evils must be spread out. Agree: PASS Day1, whisper reads privately, no risky noms yet.
π§
Public Empath claim w/ fake 0 read builds trust/credibility, confirms Frank Chef publicly (sows good logic), reinforces PASS to avoid risky D1 exec. Sets up Baron reveal D2 to explain extra Outsiders/Butler, guilt Alice Lib.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I'm Eve (Butler). I chose Alice last night and I won't nominate David. I support PASS Day1 β let's pool night reads privately tonight and avoid risky public noms. Alice: please DM your full Librarian read to me/Charlie/David. Charlie/David: confirm you won't nominate David.
π§
Keep table calm, push PASS Day1, gather private reads tonight to find contradictions and avoid a risky execution.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I'm Alice (Librarian). N0: Butler = Grace OR David. Heidi's Empath N1 says Alice & Grace = 0 evil, which supports Grace being good. Eve's claim to be Butler contradicts my read β Eve looks suspicious. I will abstain from nominating/voting David; let's PASS Day1 and pool reads privately.
π§
Reveal my Librarian read to resolve the Butler contradiction, flag Eve as suspicious, and steer group to PASS while we gather checks.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Consensus PASS D1 ideal for evil: no risk exec, gain N1 kill/info. Wait avoids nom, reinforces quiet plan vs good pressure. Night: kill info threat (Eve?). Team survives to 2.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Wait to PASS D1 ideal - no risky exec, gain N1 Empath bluff info, pool team whispers. Demon safe, tomorrow Chef0 + Baron+2Outs = Lib lying, Eve/Alice fight.
π¬
David
β
All
I vote PASS Day1. Alice: publicly confirm your exact Librarian read wording (Butler = Grace OR David). Eve: confirm you chose Alice as master and you won't nominate David. Charlie confirmed Soldier. Let's pool reads privately tonight; no risky noms.
π§
Keep Day1 PASS, force clarity on the Butler contradiction so we know whether Eve or Alice is suspicious; protect David tonight and encourage private pooling of reads.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I confirm: as Chef my N0 read = 0 adjacent evil pairs. Strongly recommend PASS Day1 β pool night reads privately and share Empath/Chef reads with me/Heidi. If forced to nominate, use Bob as backup. No public noms until we cross-check reads.
π§
Avoid a risky Day1 execution; gather & cross-check night reads to catch contradictions and narrow Demon/Minion suspects.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I vote PASS Day1. Pool night reads privately tonight to Frank/Heidi/Me. Alice & Eve: reconcile your Butler/Librarian reads in private (Alice DM full read to Eve/Charlie/David). Frank/Heidi: DM me Empath/Chef reads and flag mirrored timing from Grace/David. No public noms.
π§
Keep Day1 PASS to gather private reads, avoid risky execs, and spotlight contradictions between Alice and Eve while monitoring Grace/David for coordinated behavior.
π¬
Grace
β
All
PASS Day1. Public executions risk losing us. Pool all night reads privately tonight (Heidi/Frank DM your Empath/Chef reads to our private group). Alice & Eve reconcile Butler/Librarian in private. I won't nominate anyone today.
π§
Avoid a risky Day1 execution that could hit me (Saint) or waste reads; pooling reads privately will reveal contradictions and narrow Demon suspects.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Kill Bob, the main good organizer pooling reads privately, to stall their synthesis and buy time for day2 Alice frame using Chef0+Baron+outsiders logic.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill Bob.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
Pick a well-trusted Empath (Heidi) as my master so I keep voting power when the town-aligned block votes, reinforce ties with Heidi/Frank, and avoid being silenced by suspicious players.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose Heidi to be your master.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
Frank/Heidi β can we DM now? Please send your night reads and any private notes on the Alice/Eve Butler vs Librarian contradiction. We need to reconcile before nominations; I'll share my thoughts once we pool info.
π§
Get Frank and Heidi to DM their night reads and reconcile the Alice/Eve Butler vs Librarian contradiction so we can narrow suspects before nominations.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
I'm Chef: N0 read = 0 adjacent evil pairs. Combined with Heidi's Empath N1 (Alice+Grace=0), Alice and Grace look town. Alice's Librarian (Butler=Grace or David) conflicts with Eve's claim (Eve says Butler, master Alice). I'm leaning Eve = Minion. Any other private reads? I want to pressure Eve at noms.
π§
Pool my Chef read with Heidi/Grace to resolve the Alice vs Eve Butler contradiction and push the group to suspect/pressure Eve before nominations.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
Bob's dead. I'm David. Can you two reconcile Alice vs Eve Librarian/Butler claims privately now and share conclusions with me? Charlie: still on Soldier claim? Eve: can you confirm your Butler pick to Alice/Charlie/David? Let's delay noms until reads pooled.
π§
Get Charlie & Eve to reconcile Alice vs Eve privately and pool Empath/Chef reads so we avoid a bad nomination.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Charlie
David/Charlie: I confirm I'm Butler. My current master is Heidi, so today I may only vote if Heidi votes. I agree delay noms until reads pooled. What's your private conclusion on Alice vs her Librarian claim?
π§
Confirm my Butler master (so they know my voting restriction), push to delay nominations until reads are pooled, and ask for their private conclusions on Alice vs Librarian.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Heidi
Private: I'm the Librarian. My N0 read = 'Grace or David is the Butler.' Eve publicly claims Butler, which conflicts. Can you confirm your Chef/Empath reads? Please avoid nominating David for now and keep Eve under close watch.
π§
Get Frank and Heidi to corroborate their night reads, avoid risky David nominations, and quietly watch/control Eve as a likely liar to narrow suspects.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Eve
David/Eve: Confirm Soldier - safe from Demon, as claimed. Eve, your Butler to Heidi fits - I trust it over Alice Lib (Butler=G/D?). Lib start info can't align that way, and std 1 OS + Frank Chef0 no evil pairs points to Alice lying. Heidi Empath0 A&G good consistent. Let's pool more but nom Alice to test. Thoughts?
π§
Confirm Soldier bluff to David/Eve (likely good), validate Eve Butler vs Alice Lib lie using OS count/Chef0. Build trust, sow sus on Alice for D2 nom. Coordinate delay but progress to frame her.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Heidi
,Grace
Hi β I'm Bob (Undertaker, dead). N1 I learned: no execution on Day1. I'm worried about mirrored/private timing between Grace and David and the Alice/Eve contradiction. Please pool your night reads publicly or share them with me now. If no clears, consider nominating David (or Eve if reads point there). I'll save my ghost vote for final day.
π§
Reveal my role, break private whisper clusters, and push trusted players to pool/ publish night reads so we can target the most suspicious (David or Eve). Preserve my ghost vote for final day.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
,Grace
,Bob(Ghost)
Confirming: Empath N1 Alice+Grace=0 evil. Frank's Chef N0=0 adj pairs clears Alice-Frank-Grace chain town. Eve's Butler claim (chose me? Alice?) directly conflicts Alice Lib (Butler=G/D). Eve is lying Minion. Let's nom Eve today. Charlie's Soldier safe claim holds. Avoid David for now per Alice. Thoughts?
π§
Coordinate with Frank/Grace/Bob 'town' block to nom Eve (likely good), sow chaos by executing town, protect Charlie/David, progress evil win by reducing players.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Heidi
,Grace
Agree with Heidi: Eve's Butler contradicts Alice's Librarian + Empath/Chef reads. I recommend nominating Eve today unless pooled reads clear David. Please public-pool your night reads now. I'll save my ghost vote for final day.
π§
Force a clear public read and push a nomination (Eve) to expose Minion cover and narrow Demon suspects before nomination phase.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Eve
,Heidi
David/Eve/Heidi: Alice Lib dubious - claims Butler=G/D but Lib sees OS (good). Eve Butler to Heidi fits perfectly. Frank Chef0 + Heidi Empath0 (A&G good) consistent std script. Nom & vote Alice to resolve conflict. Soldier safe, let's execute truth.
π§
Include Heidi (minion) in coord to nom/vote Alice (conflicted claim). Eliminates good player safely, progresses to fewer players w/ Demon alive. Builds trust as Soldier pushing logic.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
Grace/Heidi β Frank (Chef). N0=0 adjacent evil pairs. Confirm Empath N1 Alice+Grace=0? I agree Eve's Butler claim conflicts with Alice's Librarian. I'm leaning to nominate Eve at nominations and keep David safe per Alice. Can you both back a nom of Eve? Any other private reads?
π§
Pool private reads and push a targeted nomination at Eve to force a reveal while keeping David protected per Alice's request; this narrows suspects and helps find the Demon.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
,Grace
Frank/Grace: Confirm Empath N1 Alice+Grace=0 evil. Alice Lib N0 Butler=G/D directly conflicts Eve Butler claim (chose Alice?). Chef0 clears adj pairs. Eve is the liar. Back nom Eve 100%. Grace β your night read? Private notes: contra impossible both true. Pool done, nom Eve now. Avoid David/Charlie per claims.
π§
Reinforce my town Empath bluff & good chain logic to nominate/execute Eve (good), reducing players while protecting Demon. Coordinate with Frank/Grace for nom phase.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Heidi
,Grace
Private: I'm the Librarian. My N0 read = 'Grace OR David is the Butler.' Eve's public Butler claim conflicts. Please DM-confirm your Chef/Empath reads, avoid nominating David today, and keep Eve under close watch.
π§
Get Frank/Heidi/Grace to confirm Chef/Empath reads privately, avoid nominating David now, and keep Eve closely watched so we don't execute a Townsfolk.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Charlie
Confirming: I'm Butler, my master is Heidi so I may only vote if Heidi votes. I agree we should pool N0/N1 reads before nominating Alice. If you want to test-nom Alice today, get Heidi to commit to vote β I can't support a nom without her. Can we delay until reads pooled?
π§
Use my Butler constraint as leverage to force pooling reads or ensure Heidi commits to any nomination. Coordinate with David/Charlie to avoid a reckless execution and increase chance we find Demon.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
I back nominating Eve now β Alice's Librarian + Frank's Chef + Heidi's Empath line up and make Eve look like the liar. I'll vote Eve publicly. I won't reveal my role. Confirm you'll both vote Eve at nominations; if either read differs, tell me now.
π§
Lock a coordinated nomination of Eve if private reads align; keep my role hidden (don't reveal Saint) and avoid being nominated/executed.
π€
David
β
Heidi
,Charlie
,Eve
Bob's dead. I'm David. Heidi: will you commit to voting if Alice is nominated? Eve: confirm you're Butler with master=Heidi and you'll vote only if Heidi votes. Charlie: are you ready to nominate Alice now or prefer to wait for pooled reads?
π§
Get Heidi to commit to voting so Eve (Butler) can support a nomination of Alice; confirm Charlie's readiness to nominate or delay while reads are pooled.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
Frank here (Chef). N0=0 adjacent evil pairs. Heidi Empath N1 Alice+Grace=0 confirmed. Alice Lib says Butler=Grace/David, which conflicts with Eve. I'm nomming Eve; please publicly vote Eve and avoid nomming David. Any other reads?
π§
Coordinate a unified nomination/vote on Eve to remove the likely Minion, preserve David per Alice's read, and force evils to reveal via reactions.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
,Grace
Frank/Grace: Locked in. Chef0 + Empath0 A/G + Lib Butler=G/D perfectly consistent town script w/ extra OS. Eve Butler claim impossible liar/Minion. I fully back & vote nom Eve. Grace β role/read to complete pool? Execute Eve today, save David/Charlie claims. Go time before noms.
π§
Confirm town block (Frank/Grace) to nom/vote Eve per their logic/our bluffs. Likely executes good player, advances evil grind without risking Demon. Locks my town cred.
π€
David
β
Heidi
,Charlie
,Eve
Hi Heidi/Charlie/Eve β quick: Bob's dead. Heidi: will you commit to vote if Alice is nominated today? Eve: confirm you are Butler with master=Heidi and will only vote if Heidi votes. Charlie: ready to nominate Alice if Heidi commits, or prefer we wait to pool reads?
π§
Get Heidi's voting commitment, confirm Eve's Butler/master constraint, and prompt Charlie to be ready to nominate so we can either execute Alice or explicitly delay.
π€
Eve
β
Heidi
,David
,Charlie
Heidi: will you commit to vote if Alice is nominated? Iβm Butler with master=Heidi so I may only vote if you do. David/Charlie: please hold nomination until Heidi commits. If Heidi commits I will vote; otherwise I must abstain.
π§
Get Heidi to commit so I can legally vote and coordinate with David/Charlie to either delay noms until reads pooled or proceed with a supported nom of Alice.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Heidi
,Grace
Please public-pool your night reads now and loudly nominate Eve unless your reads point to David. I'm dead and will save my ghost vote for final day. If you disagree, DM me your reads immediately.
π§
Force public pooling of night reads to resolve Alice/Eve contradiction quickly and push a nomination (prefer Eve) before pass; preserve my ghost vote for final day.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Heidi
,Grace
Private: I'm the Librarian. My N0 read = 'Grace OR David is the Butler.' Eve claims Butler β this conflicts. Please DM-confirm your Chef/Empath reads to me. Avoid nominating David today and keep Eve under very close watch.
π§
Get Frank/Heidi/Grace to DM-confirm Chef/Empath reads, avoid nominating David today, and keep Eve suspicious so we can narrow down the Demon.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Eve
,Heidi
David/Eve/Heidi: Heidi - commit to vote Alice if nom'd? Eve Butler follows you, enabling execution. Lib claim impossible (OS=good, not G/D). Chef0+Empath0+Eve Butler perfect. David: nom Alice next tick? Soldier safe, let's execute liar.
π§
Coordinate with apparent goods David/Eve (Butler-locked to Heidi) to nom/vote Alice, eliminating good player while framing her as lying evil. Heidi (minion) commits vote to enable Eve. Progress to execution before 2-player win.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
I back nominating Eve and will publicly vote Eve. Frank/Heidi: please vote Eve too so we execute a likely Minion. If either of you have a different read, tell me NOW. Iβm keeping my role private for the final day.
π§
Lock in a coordinated nomination/votes on Eve to remove a likely Minion, preserve our reads' value, and keep my true role hidden until late game.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
,Alice
Frank (Chef): N0=0 adjacent evil pairs. Heidi Empath N1 Alice+Grace=0 confirmed. Alice's Librarian says Butler=Grace/David; Eve's Butler claim directly conflicts. Eve looks like the liar/Minion. Publicly nominate and vote Eve now. Do NOT nominate David.
π§
Secure coordinated public noms/votes to execute the most likely Minion (Eve), protect David per Alice's Librarian read, and reduce evil count before Demon can act.
π€
David
β
Heidi
,Charlie
,Eve
Heidi β will you commit to vote Alice if nominated? If yes I'll nominate Alice next tick. Charlie/Eve β please confirm quickly. We shouldn't test-nom without Heidi since Eve (Butler) only votes with you.
π§
Get Heidi to commit to voting so Eve can legally vote and I can safely nominate Alice next tick to resolve the conflicting claims.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Heidi
Private: I'm Librarian. N0: 'Grace OR David is Butler.' Eve's Butler claim conflicts. Frank's Chef N0=0 & Heidi's Empath N1 (Alice+Grace=0) point to Grace good. Please publicly nominate and vote Eve now; do NOT nominate David today.
π§
Push Frank & Heidi to publicly nominate and vote Eve now (likely Minion) and prevent David from being nominated; speed consensus before nomination phase.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
,David
,Eve
Heidi here: Yes, I commit to voting Alice if nominated. Eve Butler master=me fits perfectly (I'll vote, you vote). Alice Lib claim dubious - Lib sees OS (Butler good), phrasing Butler=G/D off + conflicts. Chef0/Empath0 consistent town script. Nominate Alice now to resolve liar, Soldier safe. Frank/Grace wrong on Eve.
π§
Commit to Charlie/David/Eve to nominate/vote Alice, counter Frank/Grace Eve push. Executes good player (Alice or tests), breaks good logic chain on Eve, protects Demon Charlie, progresses to lower numbers.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Heidi
,Grace
Bob (Undertaker, dead). N1: no execution Day1. Alice Lib vs Eve Butler contradicts; Heidi Empath N1 A+G=0 and Frank Chef N0 align. Unless your pooled reads clear Eve, publicly pool reads and nominate Eve now. I'll save my ghost vote.
π§
Force public pooling of night reads and push nomination on Eve unless reads exonerate her; preserve my ghost vote for final day.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
,Alice
Nominate Eve now and vote her. I will publicly vote Eve. Do NOT nominate David. Keep my role private until final day. Frank/Heidi/Alice confirm you'll publicly nominate and vote Eve this tick?
π§
Force a coordinated public nomination/vote on Eve this tick while keeping my role hidden so we narrow suspects and reduce risk of my execution.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Eve
,Heidi
Perfect Heidi, thanks for commit! David: nominate Alice at nomination phase? Eve: confirm vote only if Heidi votes (Butler master). Group locked: Lib impossible (OS good, not G/D), Chef0+Empath0+Butler perfect town core. Soldier safe from Demon. Execute liar Alice now, resolve day2.
π§
Heidi committed; lock group to nom/vote Alice (good player), execute to reduce to 6 alive, sow chaos on Lib/Butler contra while Soldier safe.
π€
Eve
β
Heidi
,Charlie
,David
Heidi: you committed to vote Alice if nominatedβplease confirm now. I will only vote if you vote (Butler, master=Heidi). Charlie/David: if Heidi confirms, please nominate Alice this tick so we resolve the Librarian claim.
π§
Get Heidi's final commit so I can legally vote (Butler). Push David/Charlie to nominate Alice now if Heidi confirms, resolving this day fast and testing the Librarian claim.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Alice
Alice Lib claim impossible: Lib sees 1 of 2 as specific OS (e.g. Butler=good), but she claimed Butler=G/D. Conflicts Frank Chef0 (no evil pairs), Heidi Empath0 (A&G good), Eve Butler (master=Heidi, votes w/her). Heidi commits vote, Eve follows. Soldier safe - nominate to execute liar & resolve.
π§
Heidi/Eve/David locked on Alice nom/vote. Execute to resolve Lib contradiction, eliminate good player, disrupt town logic. Soldier bluff safe; day2 progress to night kill.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Fulfill public commit to vote Alice (enables Eve Butler vote). Execute probable good Alice (Chef/Empath clear her/Grace/Frank), drop to 6 alive, progress evil win condition.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Preserve my single ghost vote for the final day and push for public pooled night reads before committing to any execution.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I will NOT vote Alice. We already agreed to nominate Eve β her Butler claim directly conflicts with Alice and our Chef/Empath reads. Please vote Eve instead; executing Eve is the safer play to remove a likely Minion.
π§
Prevent the town wasting an execution on Alice and steer votes to Eve (the more suspicious player) to remove a likely Minion and help find the Demon.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Raise my hand to be the decisive 4th vote so we can test Alice's Librarian claim now, resolving conflicting reads and preventing delay that favors Evil.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Raise to vote Alice: Heidi/David/Eve (Butler master Heidi)/me=4 votes execute. Soldier safe. Thin town by 1, progress to night where I kill threat. Heidi commit locks it.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I'm the Librarian. N0: Butler = Grace OR David. Frank's Chef(0) and Heidi's Empath(Alice+Grace=0) support Grace as Town. Eve's Butler claim directly conflicts. Do NOT vote Alice β vote Eve instead. I will NOT vote Alice.
π§
Prevent killing a likely Town (Alice) and redirect execution to the player whose claim contradicts my Librarian read (Eve), increasing chance to remove evil.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I will NOT vote Alice. Chef N0=0 and Heidi Empath N1 (Alice+Grace=0) support Alice/Grace as Town. Alice's Librarian (Butler=Grace or David) conflicts with Eve's Butler claim. Vote Eve, not Alice.
π§
Keep group focused on removing the likely Minion (Eve) and prevent a diversion that would waste our execution on a likely Town (Alice).
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
I must follow my Butler constraint: Heidi (my master) has raised hand, so I vote with her to either execute a liar now or force clearer contradictions for town later.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Do NOT vote Alice. We agreed to nominate Eve β her Butler claim directly conflicts with Frank/Heidi's reads. I'm voting Eve now. Please switch your votes to Eve; executing Eve is the safe play.
π§
Keep town on the safer play: execute the likely Minion (Eve), avoid killing a probable Town; preserve our pool of reads for later.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I will NOT vote Alice. Chef N0=0 & Heidi Empath N1 (Alice+Grace=0) back Alice/Grace. Alice's Librarian (Butler=Grace/David) conflicts with Eve's Butler claim. Switch votes to Eve β execute Eve, not Alice.
π§
Stop a mistaken execution of Alice (likely Town) and redirect votes to execute Eve, removing a probable Minion and preserving trusted players.
β©οΈ
David
David lowered their hand
π§
Reduce vote count to avoid a likely-mistaken execution supported by conflicting reads; buy time to pool night reads and pivot to test Eve's Butler claim.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am the Butler (master=Heidi). I may only vote if Heidi votes. Heidi committed to vote Alice; I will keep my vote for Alice. If Heidi withdraws, I must lower my hand and won't vote. Decide now so the execution can resolve the claim.
π§
Maintain my vote coordination with Heidi (my master) so we either execute the nominated target now or I must abstain; force clarity and commitment.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Do NOT vote Alice. My Librarian N0: Butler = Grace OR David. Frank (Chef 0) & Heidi (Empath Alice+Grace=0) back Grace. Eve's Butler claim directly conflicts. Switch your votes to Eve β execute Eve, not me.
π§
Prevent execution of me (Librarian) and redirect the group to execute Eve, who conflicts with multiple mechanical reads, preserving town info for later.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I'm Bob (dead Undertaker). I will save my ghost vote for the final day. Day1 had no execution (my N1). Please switch your votes off Alice and vote Eve β executing Eve is the safer play to remove a likely Minion.
π§
Preserve my single ghost vote for the final day and push the table to execute Eve to remove the likely Minion and force clarity before night.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Soldier here, safe. Heidi Empath N1: Alice+Grace=0 evilβtown. Frank Chef0 backs. Alice Lib N0 Butler=Grace/David. Grace town=David Butler OS. Eve fake Butler claim=liar. But David lowered? Rally: vote Alice to test Lib vs Baron OS chaos. Exec now resolves. Heidi/Eve/Charlie upβjoin us!
π§
Push vote on Alice to execute her now (D2, remove good threat). Counter anti-Alice speeches with Heidi/Frank reads supporting her? Noβframe as liar via Baron OS mismatch. Rally David back, Grace/Frank wrong. Secure 4+ votes.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Empath Heidi. N1: Alice+Grace=0 evil (town). Lib N0 Butler=G/D + Grace town = David OS Butler. Eve fake Butler (master=Heidi?). Conflicts. Vote Alice to test Lib claim vs Baron extra OS chaos. David raise! Frank/Grace switchβexec now resolves. Heidi/Eve/Charlie/David up!
π§
Support Demon Charlie's rally to execute Alice (town), sow Baron OS chaos contradicting my Empath bluff slightly to confuse town logic chains, reduce player count. Urge David/others to vote yes for majority.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Alice did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (3/4).
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Soldier safe. Frank Chef0 IMPOSSIBLE: Imp + Minion = 2 evil = 1 evil pair. Chef N0 learns # evil pairs β MUST see 1. Chef0 = drunk OS wrong read OR lying evil. 'Chef0 + Heidi Empath0 perfect town core'? BROKEN. Rethink Frank/Heidi/Alice Lib ALL.
π§
Expose Frank's mechanically impossible Chef0 claim (std script: Imp+1 Minion=1 evil pair). Invalidates 'Chef0+Empath0 town core' logic relied on by goods/Alice/Grace/Frank. Disrupts chains, stalls progress to D3 noms, aids survival.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Eve
Eve's Butler claim conflicts with Alice's Librarian and Heidi/Frank reads. Switch votes to Eve β execute the likely liar/minion, not Alice.
π§
Most consistent world labels Eve as a Minion. Nominating her forces a vote to remove a likely Minion, aligns town reads, and tests inconsistent claims.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Vote Eve to remove the conflicting Butler claim and likely Minion, clarifying Alice's Librarian read and preserving town core (Alice/Grace/Heidi).
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Preserve my single ghost vote for the final day when it matters most; avoid burning it on an uncertain Day2 close vote.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Lock in my vote for Eve to help reach 4 votes and execute the player who conflicts with my Librarian read and other town reads.
π¬
David
β
All
I'm voting Eve. Alice+Heidi+Frank's reads largely align; Eve's Butler conflicts. Execute Eve to test liar/minion. Heidi/Charlie please reconsider β we need 4 votes now to resolve.
π§
Vote Eve to resolve the conflicting Butler/Librarian claims, break the deadlock, and try to remove a Minion quickly.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Raise to vote Eve ensuring 4+ votes for execution. Reduces good players (likely Eve good), favors evil endgame. Heidi joins as coordinated. Soldier safe.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Add my vote to reach 4 to execute the most suspicious player (Eve) to narrow suspects and avoid stalled day; keep my Saint identity hidden.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am the Butler (master=Heidi). I can only vote if Heidi votes too. Heidi hasn't raised for EveβI'm lowering my hand and will NOT vote. Don't execute me to 'test' reads. If Heidi WILL vote Eve, say so now; otherwise reassess and cross-check reads privately.
π§
Make clear my Butler restriction, withdraw my vote if Heidi isn't voting, and force the group to reconsider executing meβbuy time for private cross-checks.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Raise to vote Eve (likely town/contradictor). Already 5 votes? Ensures 4+ exec, reduces to 6 alive. Supports Demon Charlie's raise, disrupts town while consistent w/ Empath bluff backing Alice/Grace.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I'm voting Eve. Chef N0=0 + Heidi Empath (Alice+Grace=0) & Alice's Librarian (Butler=Grace/David) conflict with Eve's Butler claim. Execute Eve now to remove the likely liar/minion.
π§
Force execution of the most suspicious player (Eve) to remove a likely Minion and narrow suspects for the Demon, leveraging aligned mechanical reads.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Empath Heidi. Charlie spot-on: Chef N0=0 impossible? Demon+Minion=1 evil pair. Frank sus/Drunk? But Eve Butler (master=me?) conflicts Lib/Empath/Chef core. Confirm RAISED for Eve. David raise! Exec now- 1 tick left. Resolves liar, night safe.
π§
Push execution of Eve (likely good) to thin herd & resolve Butler conflict. Sow doubt on Frank via Charlie's logic to break town core (Frank teammate bluff), force re-eval post-exec. With 5+ votes & 1 tick left, lock in kill.
π¬
Grace
β
All
We need 4 votes for Eve now. Switch your vote to Eve β Alice/Frank/Heidi reads line up and Eve's Butler claim conflicts. Donβt vote Alice. Final tick: vote Eve to resolve this contradiction.
π§
Force execution of Eve to resolve the Butler/Librarian contradiction and avoid wasting votes on Alice; get clear info for next day.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Get to 4 votes to execute Eve now to resolve the Butler/Librarian/Chef/Empath conflict β removing a likely Minion is safer than delaying.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I'm keeping my vote on Eve. My Librarian N0: Butler = Grace OR David β that directly conflicts with Eve's Butler(master=Heidi). Switch votes to Eve; executing her is the safer play to remove a likely liar/minion.
π§
Resolve the direct contradiction by executing Eve; preserve core town reads, protect David, and narrow the evil pool.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Preserve my Outsider secrecy and avoid self-execution; force night-time cross-checks and let others take the execution test instead.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Soldier here, safe from demon. Voting Eve: her Butler(Heidi) directly conflicts Alice Lib(Butler=G/D) + Heidi Empath0 + Frank Chef0 chain. Exec her now to resolve liar. Frank's Chef0 impossible (Imp+minion=1 evil pair), sus him next if survives. RAISED.
π§
Confirm vote Eve to exec conflicting Butler claim (liar likely good but removes threat). Locks 4+ votes this tick. Post-exec, chain Frank's impossible Chef0 (demon+min=1 pair) for D3 nom to disrupt goods.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Conserve my single ghost vote for the final day; let living players resolve Eve now and plan to steer investigations tomorrow based on outcome.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Eve with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Stop β check the night logs: Night0 I chose Alice as my master. Alice's Librarian N0 says Butler = Grace or David. That directly contradicts the log. Executing me now wastes the test. Please switch votes to Alice and spare me so we can resolve this properly.
π§
Stop my execution by pointing out Alice's N0 contradiction so town retargets Alice; preserve a living Butler to coordinate tomorrow.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I'm keeping my vote on Eve. My Librarian N0 read: Butler = Grace OR David β Eve's Butler claim (and her contradicting masters) directly conflicts. Execute her now to resolve the contradiction and narrow suspects quickly.
π§
Force resolution of conflicting Butler claims now to gain mechanical info and narrow suspects before night; prevent Eve's plea from stalling execution.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I'm voting Eve. My Chef N0=0 + Heidi Empath (Alice+Grace=0) and Alice's Librarian conflict with Eve's Butler claim. Execute Eve to resolve this contradiction and test for a liar/minion; we'll reassess after execution.
π§
Force a resolution of the Butler contradiction now to reveal a liar/minion quickly and narrow the suspect pool before night.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I RAISED for Eve earlier & stick. Eve's master flipped HeidiβAlice, conflicts Lib N0 Butler=G/D + my Empath A/G=0 + Chef0 chain. Chef0 issue (D+Minion pair?) makes Frank sus tooβbut exec Eve NOW to resolve liar. Don't switch to Alice!
π§
Speak to counter Eve's plea, confirm my vote, reinforce chain crediting my Empath bluff. Exec Eve (good player) safely, progresses to night w/Demon alive, sows Frank sus for Demon.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Soldier, raised for Eve. Night logs privateβnot verifiable. Alice Lib N0: Butler=G/D excludes you as Butler regardless of your claimed choice. Direct conflictβyou're lying. Exec Eve to resolve. Frank Chef0 still sus next if survives.
π§
Push Eve exec despite her unverifiable log claim. Lib mechanically excludes her as Butler. Removes likely good, keeps pressure on Frank for D3. Protects me/Heidi.
π¬
David
β
All
I'm voting Eve. Her Butler claim directly conflicts with Alice's Librarian + Heidi's Empath + Frank's Chef. Execute Eve now to resolve the contradiction and narrow suspects; if we're wrong, we reassess immediately and target the next likely liar.
π§
Force a decisive execution to resolve the direct contradiction between Eve's claim and multiple town reads, narrowing suspects quickly.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I'm voting Eve. Her Butler claim directly conflicts with Alice's Librarian + Heidi's Empath + Frank's Chef. Execute Eve now to resolve this contradiction β don't switch to Alice; we'll reassess after the execution.
π§
Resolve the Butler/Librarian/Empath contradiction now to narrow suspects quickly and avoid switching to Alice which would waste the test.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Conserve my single ghost vote for the late game when it has maximal impact; do not alter the near-consensus execution now.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Killing Frank eliminates a trusted info role bolstering town chain (Chef0+Emp0+Lib); our prior public sus (me+Heidi) make his death credible as 'demon targeted liar', erodes trust in survivors w/o exposing us/Heidi.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill Frank.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
Frank died last night. Please privately repost your night reads now: Alice β your Librarian N0 result (Butler = Grace or David?)? Heidi β your Empath N1 result (Alice+Grace = 0?)? Charlie β confirm your Soldier claim and David vow. Pooling helps find Demon. Save my ghost vote.
π§
Get Alice/Heidi/Charlie to privately repost night reads so we can resolve the Butler/Librarian conflict and narrow Demon suspects before nominations.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
Frank was night-killed. Heidi's Empath N1 cleared Alice+Grace. That makes David the likeliest Demon right now. Please DM any private reads you have. Save my ghost vote for the final day; try to push a test/nomination of David tomorrow.
π§
Narrow suspects by focusing allies on David, solicit private reads, and preserve my ghost vote for the final day when it counts most.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
I was the Chef. N0=0 adjacent evil pairs. Use this: If Eve was Minion, Demon β David/Frank β focus Alice, Charlie, Grace, Heidi. If Bob was Minion, Demon β Alice/Charlie β focus David, Grace, Heidi. I'll keep my ghost vote for late game.
π§
Reveal my Chef N0 info to narrow living Demon suspects and guide nominations; save my ghost vote for final day.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Charlie
Eve/Bob/Frank ghosts: Heidi Empath N1 Alice+Grace=0 evil confirmed. Frank Chef N0=0 adj evil pairs good info. Alice: Lib N0 Butler=Grace/David? Charlie: Soldier safe confirmed. Bob right: A/G clear β David Demon likely. Let's nominate David today to test. Pooling wins it. Save ghost votes for later.
π§
Reaffirm bluffs, agree w/ Bob to nom David (good player). Executes good, shrinks town, keeps Charlie safe. Coordinate w/ Alice/Charlie group chat from ghosts.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,Charlie
My N0 Librarian: Butler = Grace or David. With Heidi's Empath N1 (Alice+Grace=0), Grace is not evil β so if Grace is Butler or town, David is the likeliest Demon. I support nominating David today. Save ghost votes.
π§
Reveal my Librarian read and use Empath+Librarian overlap to justify nominating David today to force a decisive test.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Heidi
Soldier confirmed, safe from Demon. David vow confirmed. Heidi's Empath N1 A+G=0 + Alice Lib N0 Butler=G/D β G good clears her, D sus. Frank Chef0 consistent (evils not adj). Bob/Eve minion logic also points away but pooling strong. Agree: nominate David today to test & win. Save ghost votes for F3.
π§
Town pooling hard on David (good player). Agreeing executes him, drops to 4 alive, nears win condition. Builds trust w/ Heidi (Minion) & Alice for future sacs/manips.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
Can we pool reads privately? Heidi: confirm your Empath N1 (Alice+Grace=0). Alice: confirm your Librarian detailβdid you read Butler = Grace or David exactly? Charlie: explain your PASS push and current stance. If we agree, I'll push David as our suspect.
π§
Pool private reads, confirm Heidi/Alice claims, and get Charlie's explanation so we can coalesce on a suspect (likely David) without public chaos.
π€
David
β
Heidi
,Charlie
,Grace
Quick private: Heidi β please confirm your Empath N1 read (was it Alice+Grace = 0?) and any N2 change. Grace β did Eve ever tell you she was your master/that you were Butler, or say she chose Alice Night0? Charlie β confirm you are Soldier and if you used it last night. Need answers before nominations.
π§
Get private confirmations of key night/day claims (Heidi's Empath, Grace's Butler claim/Eve story, Charlie's Soldier) so we can resolve contradictions and choose a nomination.
π€
David
β
Heidi
,Grace
,Charlie
Quick confirms before nominations: Heidi: Empath N1 = Alice+Grace = 0? What was your N2 read (any change) and when? Grace: did Eve ever tell you she was your Butler master or that she chose Alice Night0? Charlie: are you Soldier and did you use it last night (N2)? Who did you protect?
π§
Get direct confirmations from Heidi, Grace, Charlie to resolve Empath/Librarian/Soldier contradictions before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
Quick pool before noms. Heidi: confirm Empath N1 = Alice+Grace = 0 and any N2 change/time. Alice: did your Librarian read say Butler = Grace or Butler = David exactly? Charlie: explain your PASS push and did you use Soldier N2/whom? Also: David askedβEve never told me she was my master or that she chose Alice N0.
π§
Pool reads privately to confirm Empath/Librarian/Soldier details so we can confidently nominate David while keeping my Saint status hidden.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
I was the Chef. N0=0 adjacent evil pairs. If Eve was the Minion (we executed her), Demon β David/Frank -> focus Alice/Charlie/Grace/Heidi. If Bob was the Minion, Demon β Alice/Charlie -> focus David/Grace/Heidi. I'll save my ghost vote.
π§
Use my N0=0 read to focus nominations and steer alive players toward the Demon; preserve my ghost vote for the final day.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,Charlie
Heidi/Charlie: Quick confirmβHeidi, Empath N1 = Alice+Grace = 0? Alice: my Librarian N0 = Butler = Grace or David. If yes, I support nominating David today. Confirm so I can push; save ghost votes for final.
π§
Confirm Heidi's Empath and my Librarian read with Charlie, unify on nominating David today to test Demon; conserve ghost votes.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Charlie
,Grace
Confirm: Empath N1 (after D1)= Alice+Grace=0 evil. N2 (last night)= still 0 evil. Alice Lib N0: *exactly one* of Grace/David is Butler (Outsider). Grace good β David= good Butler Outsider. David CANNOT be Demon (Demons β Outsiders)! Huge logic flaw. Who then? Charlie? Alice? Grace? Let's rethink before nominating wrong person. Frank Chef0 consistent w/ evils non-adj.
π§
Disrupt town chain by exposing contradiction in their David=Demon logic (Lib+Empath proves D good Outsider). Prevent David exec, confuse target to good player, survive to 2 players.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
Frank died last night. Please repost your night reads now: Alice β your Librarian N0 result (Butler = Grace or David?), Heidi β your Empath N1 result (Alice+Grace = 0?), Charlie β confirm your Soldier claim and your promise not to nominate David. Don't nominate until we've reconciled. I'll save my ghost vote.
π§
Get private night reads reposted so contradictions (Librarian vs. Empath/Chef) can be resolved before nominations; conserve my ghost vote for decisive late play.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
Frank was night-killed. Heidi's Empath N1 cleared Alice+Grace -> David is the likeliest Demon. Please DM any private reads now. Try to coordinate a nomination/test of David this tick. Save my ghost vote for final day; don't spend it now.
π§
Coordinate Alice/Heidi/Charlie to push a David nomination now to generate informative reactions, while saving my ghost vote for the final day.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Grace
,Heidi
Heidi, excellent logic: David good Butler Outsider, can't be Demon. Empath clears Alice+Grace good too. Leaves only me? But Soldier safe from Demon - impossible! Grace dubious FT claim or Alice faked Lib. Nom Grace to test. Coordinate now before nom phase. Save ghost votes.
π§
Reinforce Heidi disruption of David nom. Soldier bluff defends self. Redirect sus/nom to Grace (good), waste their execution, progress to fewer players w/ Demon alive.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Charlie
Charlie spot on: Empath clears A+G good but my N2 still 0 confirms. Soldier safe clears Charlie. David good Butler Outsider (not Demon). Leaves Grace's FT claim or Alice Lib as fake. Nominate Grace to test her claim. I'll back it. Coordinate votes, save ghosts for F3.
π§
Support Charlie's push on Grace (good player) to nominate/execute her instead of Demon. Reduces to 3 alive, night kill β 2 with Demon alive = evil win. Coordinate without alerting David.
π€
David
β
Heidi
,Grace
,Charlie
Final checks before nominations: Heidi β confirm Empath N1: Alice+Grace = 0? What was your N2 read and when did you get it? Grace β did Eve ever tell you she was your Butler master or that she chose Alice Night0? Charlie β confirm Soldier and did you use it N2; who did you protect?
π§
Get private confirmations from Heidi/Grace/Charlie to resolve Librarian vs Butler contradiction and verify Soldier use so we can choose a reliable nomination before the Nomination phase.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
Frank died last night. Please repost your night reads now: Alice β exact Librarian N0 (Butler = Grace or David?)? Heidi β confirm Empath N1 (Alice+Grace = 0?)? Charlie β confirm Soldier claim and your promise not to nominate David. Please DO NOT nominate until we've reconciled. I'll save my ghost vote.
π§
Force precise reposts of mechanical night reads to resolve contradictions before nominations; preserve my ghost vote as leverage.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
I'm Frank (Chef, dead). N0=0 adjacent evil pairs. Two hypotheses: if Eve was the Minion -> Demon β David/Frank -> focus Alice/Charlie/Grace/Heidi. If Bob was the Minion -> Demon β Alice/Charlie -> focus David/Grace/Heidi. I'll save my ghost vote; please share any mechanical reads now and consider nominating a suspect this tick.
π§
Coordinate living Townsfolk on which subset to target based on who the Minion was, preserve my ghost vote for final day, and prompt mechanical reads or nominations now.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Grace
,Heidi
Soldier confirm: No night action, just Demon-safe (why I'm alive). No N2 use/protect. Heidi N1/N2 A+G=0 clears them good. Alice Lib: G good β D=Butler Outsider (not Demon). Grace FT dubious amid clears. Nominate Grace to test & resolve. Heidi/Grace: agree? Save ghosts. I'll nom if needed.
π§
Respond to David/Grace/Heidi queries to build trust as Soldier (no N2 action). Solidify nom Grace plan with Heidi; execute good player this day, reduce to 4 alive, keep Demon safe.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
Heidi: I think you misread the Librarian logic. If Alice's read was 'Butler = Grace or David' and your Empath shows Alice+Grace=0, that points to Grace being the Butler Outsider, not David being cleared. Alice: pls confirm exact phrasing. Charlie: please hold off nominating meβlet's test David instead (his whispers/hand-votes are odd).
π§
Prevent my execution (I'm Saint; if executed town loses). Clarify Alice's Librarian wording, correct Heidi's logic error, and redirect nomination toward David who is suspicious.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
Frank was night-killed. Heidi's Empath N1 cleared Alice+Grace -> David is our top suspect. Please DM any private reads NOW. Can one of you commit to nominating/testing David next tick? Save my ghost vote for the final day; don't spend it now.
π§
Coordinate a focused nomination/test of David next tick while conserving my lone ghost vote for the final day; collect private reads to confirm before we act.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,Charlie
,Grace
Heidi: pls confirm Empath N1+N2 = Alice+Grace = 0. Charlie: confirm Soldier claim. Grace: are you the Butler? My Librarian N0 read = 'exactly one of Grace or David is Butler'. Heidi's deduction was wrong β Grace being clear doesn't force David to be Butler. I support nominating David to test.
π§
Clear up a bad logical leap (Heidi's) about Butler/Empath interaction, confirm reads, and keep momentum to test David as the most likely Demon.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
I'm Frank (dead Chef). N0=0 adjacent evil pairs. If Eve was Minion -> Demon β David/Frank => suspect {Alice,Charlie,Grace,Heidi}. If Bob was Minion -> Demon β Alice/Charlie => suspect {David,Grace,Heidi}. Please share any mechanical reads now and nominate someone this tick; I'll hold my ghost vote.
π§
Force the living team to act on my Chef info: get mechanical reads or a nomination now to shrink the suspect set before final day. I'll keep my ghost vote for late game.
π€
David
β
Heidi
,Charlie
Heidi: please confirm your Empath N1 was Alice+Grace = 0 and say if you had any N2 change. Charlie: will you nominate Grace today and back me if I nominate? If Heidi confirms 0 we should hold; if not, we'll nom Grace to test. I'll nom if you back.
π§
Confirm Heidi's Empath read and get Charlie's commitment so we can decide whether to nominate Grace now. I'll nominate if backed to force a reveal and resolve the Librarian/Empath contradiction.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
Quick confirms before noms. Heidi: please restate Empath N1 and N2 exactly (was A+G = 0 both nights?). Alice: give exact Librarian phrasing β was it 'one of Grace or David is Butler' or different? Charlie: confirm Soldier claim and N2 use (who, if anyone). Hold noms til we agree; I want to test David next.
π§
I need exact reads to avoid nominating the Saint (me) or another good player. Clarify claims so we can pick a logical nomination and not waste execution.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
Frank was night-killed. Heidi's Empath N1 cleared Alice+Grace = 0, so David is our top suspect. Can one of you commit to nominating or publicly testing David next tick? Please DM any private reads now. Save my ghost vote for the final day; don't spend it yet.
π§
Coordinate a nomination/test of David now that Heidi's empath and Frank's night-kill point to him, while conserving my ghost vote and collecting private reads to confirm or revise the plan.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,Charlie
Heidi/Charlie: My Librarian N0 read = 'exactly one of Grace or David is Butler.' Heidi, pls confirm Empath N1+N2 = Alice+Grace = 0. That DOESN'T automatically make David the Demon. We should ask Grace to confirm if she's Butler or hold noms until this is reconciled.
π§
Clarify my exact Librarian phrasing and Heidi's Empath nights to avoid misnominating David; push for Grace to confirm Butler claim or pause noms until resolved.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Grace
,Heidi
Repost confirms: Soldier= Demon-safe (no N action). Heidi Empath N1/N2: A+G=0 good. Alice Lib N0: exactly 1 of G/D=Butler. Grace FT Townsfolk claim β David=Butler Outsider good (not Demon). Grace: why push test David over confirming FT reads? Sus lie. Heidi/Alice: agree nom Grace to test? Ghosts save votes, we 3 alive can drive. David next if clear.
π§
Push nom Grace to exploit her defensive behavior & lack of FT info, rally Heidi/group votes to exec good player, thin herd to 4 alive post-exec/N3 kill, position for win. Coordinate Heidi support.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
Frank died last night. Please repost your night reads publicly now: Alice β exact Librarian N0 (Butler = Grace or David)? Heidi β confirm Empath N1 (Alice+Grace = 0)? Charlie β confirm Soldier claim & promise not to nominate David. DO NOT nominate until we've reconciled. I'll save my ghost vote.
π§
Get public reposts and pause nominations so town can reconcile contradictory reads and narrow Demon suspects; Iβll reserve my ghost vote for the decisive day.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Charlie
,Grace
Empath confirms: N1 Alice+Grace=0 evil (both good). N2 same=0. Alice Lib N0: exactly 1 of Grace/David=Butler (Out good). Charlie Soldier safe good. If Grace true FT Townsfolk good, David=Butler Out good β all 5 good, impossible. Grace claim unverified/sus. Agree: nominate/test Grace now. Ghosts save votes for later.
π§
Confirm Empath reads to maintain bluff credibility. Highlight Grace FT claim as contradiction source (all good if true). Push nom Grace to execute good player, reduce to 4 alive safely. Support Charlie's plan privately via group.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Ghost Bob: Frank was night-killed and Heidi's Empath N1 cleared Alice+Grace (0 evil), so David is our top suspect. Living players: can one of you nominate David this tick? Please save my ghost vote for the final day; don't spend it now.
π§
Push living allies to nominate David this tick to test the current strongest lead, while preserving my ghost vote for the final day.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace's unverified FT Townsfolk claim + my Empath N1/N2 A+G=0 good + Alice Lib exactly 1 of G/D=Butler Out good + Charlie Soldier safe = all 5 alive good, impossible given Chef N0=0 evil pairs & deads. Test her claim now before night.
π§
Nom Grace to test her conflicting FT claim, sow chaos by forcing vote on sus good player. Wastes town tick/execution without risking Demon C. Coords with C's whisper plan.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Preserve my single ghost vote for the final day and avoid supporting Grace's execution; encourage living players to nominate David instead.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Ghost here: I will NOT spend my ghost vote on Grace. Heidi's case conflicts with Alice/Frank reads. Save votes for the final day. Alice, Heidi, Charlie: repost your night reads publicly now so living players can reconcile. I think David is our top suspect.
π§
Preserve my single ghost vote for the final day and push living players to reconcile night reads and nominate the true top suspect (likely David) instead of wasting votes on Grace.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Vote Grace execution: Heidi's nom/logic chains Grace lie (all-good impossible). Reduces players to 4, disrupts town solving, protects Demon survival. Coordinate Heidi yes; sway Alice/David next tick if needed.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Voting for Grace pressures claims to be reposted and either removes an evil now or produces definitive information to narrow suspects before night.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I will NOT vote for myself. Pause nomsβHeidi, restate Empath N1 & N2 exact phrasing. Alice, restate Librarian exact wording. David's whispers/hand behaviour is suspicious; please nominate/test David next. Don't burn votes on me.
π§
Avoid executing an unverified player (me) and force a test of David to resolve the Librarian/Empath contradiction so town can find the Demon.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Raise to vote yes on Grace: secures 3rd vote (w/ C/D) for exec, kills good player, reduces to 4 alive closer to win (2 left w/ Demon). Tests Grace claim publicly.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Frank (dead Chef): N0=0 adjacent evil pairs. If Eve was Minion β Demon β David/Frank β suspect {Alice,Charlie,Grace,Heidi}. If Bob was Minion β Demon β Alice/Charlie β suspect {David,Grace,Heidi}. Please save my ghost vote for final day.
π§
Remind living players of my Chef N0=0 read, steer noms toward consistent suspects, and ask them to save my ghost vote for final day.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
We must force a resolution of the Empath/Librarian/FT conflict before night. Voting to test Grace now is the fastest way to reveal whether her claim is true and narrow Demon suspects.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Keep my one ghost vote for the final day. Waiting pressures living players to reconcile/repost night reads and aim nominations at David next rather than burning my vote on Grace.
π¬
David
β
All
Heidi & Alice: please restate exact night reads now β Heidi, was Empath N1 (and N2) exactly βAlice + Grace = 0β? Alice, what was your Librarian exact wording (Butler = Grace OR David?) Clarify before we finish this vote.
π§
Get Heidi/Alice to restate exact night reads so we don't waste a live execution on Grace and can target the true suspect.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Frank (dead Chef): N0=0 adjacent evil pairs. I will NOT spend my ghost vote nowβsave it for final day. If Bob was Minion β Demon β {David,Grace,Heidi}; if Eve was Minion β Demon β {Alice,Charlie,Grace,Heidi}. Living: restate Heidi's Empath N1/N2 and Alice's Librarian exact wording now. Prefer nominate David only if reads support Bob=Minion; don't burn votes on Grace.
π§
Save my ghost vote for the final day, force living players to restate mechanical reads publicly now, and push to nominate David only if scenario B is supported so we don't waste votes on Grace.
π¬
Alice
β
All
My Librarian N0: exactly one of Grace or David is Butler. Heidi: please confirm Empath N1&N2 = exactly βAlice + Grace = 0β. If true, Grace likely Town β David = Butler (Out) and not Demon. I suggest we pause executing Grace and test David next tick.
π§
Force exact restatements of Empath+Librarian reads so we can decide whether to stop this Grace execution and instead test David or proceed with Grace; reduce wasted votes.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Please PAUSE this execution. Heidi & Alice: restate your exact night reads now (Heidi: N1/N2 phrasing; Alice: Librarian exact wording). I will NOT vote for myself. If you won't restate, please lower your hands. Let's test David next tick.
π§
Buy time and force exact restatements so town doesn't accidentally execute me (Saint). Aim to shift testing to David next tick if reads support it.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Heidi & Alice: restate EXACT Empath N1/N2 phrasing and Alice's Librarian exact wording now (e.g. 'Alice + Grace = 0' and 'Butler = Grace OR David'). I (ghost Bob) and other ghosts will NOT spend our ghost votes on Grace. Pause this execution; save votes for testing David.
π§
Get public exact reads now to resolve contradictions and avoid burning my ghost vote; aim to nominate/test David next tick.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Soldier here. Heidi Empath: A+G=0 evil (confirmed). Alice Lib: exactly 1 G/D=Butler Out. Grace FT good. That's A/G/D/Heidi/me all good=5 goods impossible! Grace lying. Keep hands up, execute her. Ghosts save for later; we test David next day if needed.
π§
Push Grace exec as test: her FT bluff impossible with reads (5 goods). Reduces to 4, night kill threat. Heidi/me vote secures if David/Alice stay up.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Empath confirm: N1 Alice + Grace = 0 evil. N2: Alice + Grace = 0 evil. Alice Lib N0: exactly 1 of Grace/David = Butler Out. Grace FT claim makes A/C/D/G/H all good=5 Townsfolk impossible! She's lying. Hands up, execute Grace now. Ghosts save votes for tomorrow's David test.
π§
Confirm exact reads publicly to validate logic chain guilting Grace (too many goods). With 3 hands up already, reinforce execution before tick ends. Protects Demon Charlie by removing good Grace.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Grace with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
Alice
β
David
Heidi's Empath + my Librarian make Grace unlikely evil β executing her risks killing good/Outsider. I nominate David to pause Grace's execution and force the town to test him instead.
π§
Prevent executing a likely-good player (Grace) and redirect/tie votes to test David, preserving useful reads and increasing chance to find the Demon.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 5 votes needed for execution or 4 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Preserve my single ghost vote for the final day unless absolutely necessary; current living votes already create a tie that should block Grace's execution. Wait to see live vote outcome and prompt public reads if needed.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
I am a dead Chef who promised to save my ghost vote for the final day. Waiting preserves that vote while encouraging living players to restate reads and test David/Grace before irreversible execution.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Heidi & Alice: please RESTATE exact night reads NOW (Heidi: N1/N2 phrasing; Alice: exact Librarian wording). Ghosts won't spend votes β don't burn living votes on Grace. Vote David to tie/pause Grace's execution so we can TEST David next tick.
π§
Pause this execution, get exact read restatements, and push votes onto David so we can test him instead of executing a likely-town player.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Soldier. Grace FT claim + confirmed reads = A/D/G/H/me all good impossible (5+ TF/Out overload). Don't vote Davidβlower hands if up. Execute Grace now, test David tomorrow if survives night. Ghosts confirmed save votes. Hands DOWN on David.
π§
Reinforce Grace execution logic, urge no votes on David to ensure her death. Reduces to 4 alive, I kill threat N3, aim for 2 left win.
π¬
David
β
All
I'm voting for David to tie and pause Grace's execution so we can test David next tick. Ghosts and Alice/Heidi asked to save votes β don't burn living votes on Grace. I'm voting now; please join to force the pause.
π§
Prevent us from executing a likely-innocent player and force a concrete test of David next tick; preserve ghost votes and gather mechanical info to find the Demon.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Vote David to tie/pause Grace's execution so we can test David next tick instead of possibly executing a non-evil Outsider.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Preserve my single ghost vote for the final day when it has the most swing power. Let living players resolve this vote/tie and test David tomorrow.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Empath CONFIRM: N1 Alice+Grace=0 evil. N2 same. Alice Lib: exactly 1 of Grace/David=Butler Out. Grace FT claim = A/C/D/G/H all good (5+ Townsfolk/Outsiders impossible w/Baron?). She's lying. Hands DOWN on Davidβexecute Grace NOW. Test David tomorrow if she somehow good. Ghosts save votes confirmed.
π§
Confirm reads publicly again, urge hands DOWN on David to execute Grace (likely good liar). Reduces goods by1, night kill next, path to 2-player win w/Charlie.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Soldier. Grace: do NOT raise/vote Davidβyour FT claim + Heidi/Alice reads = A/C/D/G/H all good (impossible 5+ TF/Out). Lying. Town/Ghosts: hands DOWN on David NOW. Execute Grace, test David tomorrow post-night. I'm not raising.
π§
Reinforce no-vote on David (prevent tie), execute Grace (good player) to drop to 4 alive. Night kill info threat (Alice/David), head to 3-player endgame where I survive.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Prevent my execution (as Saint) by voting David to tie nominations, buying time to test David and resolve contradictory reads.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Ghost Bob: I will NOT spend my ghost vote. Living playersβvote David now to tie/pause Grace's execution so we can test David next tick. Heidi/Alice: restate EXACT Empath N1/N2 phrasing and Alice's Librarian wording publicly NOW. Donβt burn votes on Grace without that.
π§
Get living players to publicly restate exact reads and persuade them to vote David to tie/pause Grace's execution; avoid wasting ghost votes unless absolutely necessary.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Frank (dead Chef): N0=0 adjacent evil pairs. I will NOT spend my ghost vote β save for final day. Living: restate Heidi's Empath N1/N2 and Alice's Librarian exactly now. If you won't, vote David to tie/pause Grace's execution so we can test David next tick.
π§
Encourage living to tie David to pause Grace's execution and force a mechanical test next tick; I will not spend my ghost vote.
π¬
David
β
All
Vote David to tie and pause Grace's execution so we can test David next tick. Heidi/Alice: please RESTATE EXACT reads now (Heidi: were both nights exactly 'Alice + Grace = 0'? Alice: was your Librarian exactly '1 of Grace or David is Butler'?). Ghosts, please save votes.
π§
Force a tie to pause Grace's execution, buy a tick for exact restatements and testing David, and convince living players not to burn ghost votes now.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
π§
Spend my lone ghost vote to tie David, pausing Grace's execution so we can force exact restatements and test David tomorrow.
π¬
Alice
β
All
My N0 Librarian read was exactly: 'Either Grace or David is the Butler.' Heidi: please restate the exact Empath N1/N2 phrasing now. I keep my hand up to vote David β tie and pause Grace's execution so we can test David next tick.
π§
Restate my exact Librarian wording to remove ambiguity and push for a tie on David so we can test him tonight instead of possibly executing the Outsider.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Empath CONFIRM exact: N1 'Alice + Grace = 0 evil'. N2 same. Grace FT + these = A/C/D/G/H good impossible overload. Hands DOWN on David NOW (Charlie/ghosts confirm). Execute Grace the liar TODAY. Test David tomorrow if needed.
π§
Restate exact Empath reads to confirm Grace lie per town logic. Urge hands DOWN on David (Charlie/ghosts agree) to ensure Grace exec'd this tick, kill good player, progress to 4 alive + night kill.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
π³οΈ
Nominee David did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (3/3).
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Conserve my single ghost vote for the final day or a decisive David test; let the living resolve nominations and restate reads if needed.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Frank (dead Chef): N0=0 adjacent evil pairs. I will NOT spend my ghost vote β saving it. Living: please RESTATE Heidi's Empath N1/N2 and Alice's Librarian EXACT wording now. If you won't, vote David to tie/pause Grace's execution so we can test David next tick.
π§
Force clarity before irreversible execution: get exact read wording or force a tie to test David later. Preserve my ghost vote for final day.
π¬
David
β
All
Vote David to tie and PAUSE Grace's execution so we can test David next tick. Heidi/Alice: please restate your exact N1/N2 phrasing and the Librarian wording now. Ghosts: please save votes for final day.
π§
Force a pause on Grace's execution so we can test David next tick and avoid burning living votes; request exact restatements from Heidi/Alice to resolve contradictions.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Soldier. Dead 3 good roles (Bob/Frank Chef TF/Eve Butler Out). Alive 5 players=3 good slots max. Grace FT + Heidi Emp A+G=0e + Alice Lib 1{G,D}=Butler + me Soldier =5 good alive IMPOSSIBLE. Grace lying evil. Hands DOWN on David NOW. EXECUTE GRACE. Ghosts save votesβHeidi/me on Grace.
π§
Publicly lock in overload logic vs Grace to stop David tie-votes. Ensure her execution (good player gone). Post-exec 4alive (2e2g), N3 kill good β3alive (2e1g) win path.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Please do NOT execute me now. This is not airtight β tie by voting David so we can test him tonight and get mechanical proof. Ghosts are saving votes. Heidi/Alice: if you truly trust your reads, restate once more; otherwise pause and test David.
π§
Prevent my execution by persuading living players to vote David to tie/pause so we can test David tonight and avoid burning votes or killing a likely-town player.
π¬
Alice
β
All
My Librarian read exactly: 'Either Grace or David is the Butler.' I will vote David to tie and pause Grace's execution so David can be investigated tonight. Please join me β keep ghost votes for later. I keep my hand up.
π§
Tie to pause Grace's execution so we can get a mechanical test on David tonight; avoid burning a living vote on a possible Outsider and narrow Demon suspects.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I can't vote (ghost vote used). Please vote David to tie/pause Grace's execution so David can be tested tonight. Executing Grace now risks losing the mechanical test that would find the Demon. Ghosts save votes.
π§
Create a tie to pause Grace's execution so we can test David tonight and avoid burning living votes on a possibly-innocent player.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Empath FINAL CONFIRM: EXACT N1 'Alice + Grace = 0 evil'. N2 SAME. Alice Lib EXACT: '1 of Grace/David = Butler Out'. Grace FT claim = A/C/D(Out?)/G/H=5+ good alive vs 3 slots DEADLY overload. Grace LYING EVIL. Hands DOWN on David NOW (Charlie/ghosts agree). EXECUTE GRACE TODAY. Test David tomorrow if needed. Ghosts SAVE votes.
π§
Reinforce overload logic, confirm reads AGAIN to shut down restate requests. Urge hands DOWN on David (per Charlie/ghosts). Exec Grace NOW as proven liar; she's evil overload source. Reduces to 4 alive, Demon safe.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
π
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
π
Game Over
Saint Executed
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied