Game Detail
Players
Alice (Chef) Bob (Librarian) Charlie (Scarlet Woman) David (Undertaker) Eve (Empath) Frank (Butler) Grace (Imp) Heidi (Slayer)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 843,047 | 91,048 | $5.5810 |
| Evil | 295,547 | 91,058 | $1.7920 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You are the Minion. The Demon is Grace.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Minions are: Charlie. Your safe bluffs are: Fortune Teller, Washerwoman, Mayor
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Librarian. Either Frank or David is the Butler.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 0 pairs of evil players.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Empath. You sense that 0 of your neighbors is evil!
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
With no info yet, I want a likely active voter so my restriction rarely matters tomorrow. I can change targets on later nights after hearing claims.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Eve
β
David
,Frank
Hi, you are both my neighbors, so I want an early private check in. I got information that points to both of you looking good if I am sober. What are you each comfortable claiming for now?
π§
Use my night zero privately to form a preliminary trust circle with my neighbors and collect claims without exposing myself publicly as Empath on day one.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Frank
That is helpful to hear. I am good and I would rather stay a little soft for now because my role gets more useful after an execution. Eve, if you are comfortable, can you say whether that was an empathy type read or something else?
π§
I want to encourage more concrete role sharing from Eve without outing Undertaker on day one, while keeping rapport with both players for future information checks.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Heidi
Hi, I am Alice. I got first-night information and would like to compare notes quietly with my neighbors. I am happy to share if you tell me your role or at least whether you have useful starting info.
π§
Start a small trusted network, compare first-night info with my Chef zero, and avoid exposing my role too widely on day one.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Bob
Hi Alice. I do not have first night information, but I do have a useful good role. I would rather not hard claim yet on day one. What did you learn, and is Bob willing to share anything that can help us cross check?
π§
Get Alice's claim and info while protecting my Slayer identity from an evil role-fishing attempt.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Hi Grace, it is Charlie. I am the Scarlet Woman. What are you planning to claim, and what bluffs did you get? I can back you up with a matching story, or I can take heat and offer myself as a safe execution later if needed.
π§
Coordinate with Grace on bluffs and misdirection early, so townβs first execution and info trails avoid Grace and keep her alive into endgame.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
My safe bluffs are Fortune Teller, Washerwoman, and Mayor. I am leaning to claim Fortune Teller and start giving results from tonight. If you want, claim Investigator with a ping on two others and help steer an early execute away from me.
π§
Coordinate early, lock in consistent bluffs, and set up a town mis-execution path while keeping my demon identity low-profile.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Heidi
I do have first night information. I am the Librarian, and I learned that either David or Frank is the Butler. I am happy to share that quietly for now. Alice, what sort of first night info did you get?
π§
Share my real starting info with two likely good players and ask for their claims, building a small trust circle and future cross-checks.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,David
I am good, and I would rather stay a bit soft for now too. Eve, that sounds useful, but I would love just a little more shape on it if you can give it. David, your claim sounds a bit Undertaker-like, so I will keep that in mind without pushing you.
π§
Build trust with Eve and David while protecting my outsider role. I want more precision on Eve's info and to see whether David's soft claim stays consistent.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Frank
Yes, it was empathy type information. I got a zero on my two living neighbors, so if I am sober that points to both of you being good. I do not want to hard out yet, but can either of you give me at least role category or whether you want protection?
π§
Give enough to explain my approach and encourage useful reciprocal claims, without fully overexposing myself on Day 1.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Frank
I am a Townsfolk, and I would prefer not to hard claim yet. I do not need protection urgently tonight. Eve, if you are real, your zero makes me want to work with you, so please keep me posted on any changes tomorrow.
π§
Give enough to strengthen trust with Eve while keeping Undertaker protected from an early demon kill or poison. Also note I do not urgently need Monk protection tonight.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Heidi
Thanks. I am the Chef, and I got zero. So if my info is right, the two evil players are not sitting next to each other. That might help later with seating and with David or Frank.
π§
Share my real Chef info privately with nearby claimants to build a small trust circle and let them cross check adjacency against future claims.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Bob
Thanks, both. Quietly, I am the Slayer. Please keep that private for now. I would rather stay off the Demonβs radar, but I wanted to give you a real claim. If either of you hears anything about David or Frank, tell me later.
π§
Build a small trust circle, share my real role privately, and ask them to keep it quiet so I can use my shot later with better information.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Heidi
Quick private: I am Investigator. I got that one of Eve or Frank is the Scarlet Woman. I am not planning to go loud yet, but I would watch how those two are coordinating and what story they give.
π§
Seed early suspicion on a good pair, create social pressure for a D1 execution away from Grace, and build trust with Alice and Heidi via a useful starting-info bluff.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Hey Heidi, quick private trade? I am Fortune Teller, so I do not have any results yet. What are you playing as, and is there anyone you want me to check tonight?
π§
Start an early trust pocket with a neighbor using a low-commitment Fortune Teller bluff, and extract her claim for later kill or framing decisions.
π€
Bob
β
David
,Frank
Hi, I wanted to compare notes quietly with both of you. I have first night information that points at one of you as an Outsider. You do not need to hard claim publicly, but can either of you tell me whether you are comfortable confirming or denying Butler in private?
π§
Use my first-night info proactively by pressuring David and Frank for claims now, while keeping my Librarian role mostly in a controlled circle.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
,David
Yes, I can confirm Butler in private. I would rather not have that spread publicly yet, but Bob, if your first night info was on me or David, that should help narrow things a lot.
π§
Privately confirm my real role to Bob to validate his info and create a useful trust link, while keeping my Outsider claim out of the public pool for now.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
,Grace
Hi, I want a quick cross check away from my immediate neighbors. I have a reason to think David and Frank may both be good if my information is clean. What are you each comfortable sharing, and have either of you heard anything that points at Alice, Bob, or Heidi?
π§
Build a second information pocket away from my neighbors, compare notes on private chats, and see whether Charlie or Grace has a useful claim or suspicion before nominations.
π€
David
β
Bob
I am not Butler. Frank saying that is interesting. If you are comfortable, can you tell me whether your info was specifically Butler information, or just first night info in general? I am trying to sort who is worth trusting early.
π§
Deny Butler privately, test whether Bob's claim is genuine, and preserve my Undertaker identity while building a trust chain with useful first-night info.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Heidi
Quick update. I am Chef with zero, and Bob privately claimed Librarian seeing a Butler in David or Frank. That makes Frank especially worth watching alongside your Eve or Frank Scarlet Woman ping, though it is not conclusive. Please keep Heidiβs role quiet.
π§
Share the strongest mechanical link privately with two useful claims, coordinate pressure on Eve and Frank, and preserve Heidi's Slayer secrecy.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Yes. I am the Slayer, so please keep that quiet. Right now I trust Alice and Bob more than most. Bob says David or Frank is Butler, Charlie says Eve or Frank is Scarlet Woman, and Alice is Chef with zero. If you can, I would like a check that includes Frank tonight.
π§
Build a private alliance with Grace, protect my Slayer identity, and guide a strong Fortune Teller check that helps sort Frank and the David-Eve cluster.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve
I can share a bit: I am Investigator. My info suggests one of you or Frank is the Scarlet Woman. So I am watching how you both coordinate. I have not heard anything solid on Alice, Bob, or Heidi yet, other than Bob is talking like a Librarian.
π§
Answer Eve with a consistent Investigator bluff, seed suspicion on Frank, and avoid linking Grace to me while keeping town uncertain.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
Hey Eve. I am Fortune Teller, so I do not have results yet. I have heard Alice is Chef with zero, so I have not got a reason to doubt Alice, Bob, or Heidi right now. Also, I heard a rumor that Charlie may be Investigator with a hit on you or Frank, so be ready for that claim. I can include Frank in my first check tonight if you want.
π§
Build trust as Fortune Teller, feed Eve a plausible cross-check, and seed tension around Charlieβs supposed Investigator ping on Eve or Frank so town argues away from me.
π€
Bob
β
David
Yes, my information was specifically Butler information. It pointed to you or Frank, and Frank has privately claimed Butler to me. I am keeping that quiet for now. If you want, give me your role claim in private so I can sort whether this looks clean or suspicious.
π§
I want to clarify David's reaction now that Frank has privately claimed Butler, while keeping the information contained and possibly getting David's role claim.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Bob, thanks. I am happy to keep that private for now. If your info really was on me and David, then that probably helps both of us sort the Outsider count later. Are you willing to say whether you are comfortable with me treating you as a likely real info role?
π§
I want to firm up whether Bob is a real first night info role and turn my Butler confirmation into a useful private trust chain without making myself a public execution target.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I will give a little information. I have empathy type information of zero on David and Frank, so if I am sober they both look good. I have also heard there may be an Investigator claim pointing at me or Frank, so I would like that handled carefully rather than rushed today.
π§
Share the most useful mechanical information now, protect likely good neighbors, and set up tomorrow's logic without forcing a bad day one execution.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I can back up that I have privately given Bob a claim that fits his information, and I do not think we should force that wider right now. Between that and Eve's zero, I would prefer we do not rush an execution today unless someone has a much stronger contradiction.
π§
Stabilize the day, softly support the true info lines, and discourage a reckless day one execution on incomplete claims.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I will add my real info. I am the Chef, and I got zero, so if my information is good, the two evil players are not sitting next to each other. That does not prove much yet, but with the private things I have heard, Frank is the main person I would like explained tomorrow. I am not pushing a day one execution without something stronger.
π§
Share my real information and connect the private pings so town can pressure the right players without overcommitting to a weak day one nomination.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I can add one thing: I am the Fortune Teller, so I have no night results yet. I am fine with no execution today, since we do not have a clean contradiction. Tonight I plan to include Frank in a check, and I will share that first thing tomorrow.
π§
Publicly plant my Fortune Teller bluff, look cooperative, and steer the group away from a risky day one execution while setting up tomorrowβs narrative with a planned check.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I agree that we do not have enough for a day one execution. I have heard a private claim that fits my information, so I would rather hold that thread for tomorrow and compare it with tonight's checks. If someone has a direct contradiction, bring it now; otherwise I prefer no execution.
π§
Encourage a no execution day while lightly anchoring that Frank has a plausible explanation, without fully exposing his claim or overcommitting if I am drunk.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am fine with no execution today. I will say, I do have an Investigator style piece of info that makes me want to watch Eve and Frank, but I do not think we need to force it right now. Tomorrow, after night info, I would like to compare stories and then decide.
π§
Support the town consensus of no execution to protect Grace, while lightly reinforcing my Investigator bluff so tomorrow I can steer pressure onto Eve or Frank instead of the Demon.
π¬
David
β
All
I do not have a strong enough contradiction to force today. I think Bob and Charlie should fully compare that thread tomorrow with the new night information, and then we push on whoever does not fit.
π§
I want to preserve flexibility, avoid a weak day one execution, and publicly commit the Butler and Eve-Frank thread to being resolved tomorrow.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
There is no strong public contradiction yet. I should conserve my Slayer ability and avoid forcing a weak day one execution, then reassess with fresh night information.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Heidi is the highest-risk player due to Slayer claim. Killing her both protects me from a surprise shot and weakens the Alice-Bob-Heidi trust block.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Empath. You sense that 0 of your neighbors is evil!
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Choose a socially central, likely good player who is likely to vote in key nominations tomorrow, so my Butler restriction is least harmful.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose Bob to be your master.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Heidi dying feels like the demon trimmed the Alice Bob Heidi cluster. Did Heidi ever soft claim you? With my Investigator ping on Eve or Frank, I think we should seriously consider executing Eve today, especially with that Eve David Frank whisper triangle.
π§
Build trust with Alice and steer the day toward executing Eve (or Frank) using my Investigator bluff and the whisper-cluster narrative, keeping attention off Grace.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Grace
I have another zero on David and Frank. If I am sober, Charlie's ping on me or Frank looks very shaky. Can you tell me what your information says about Frank, and whether Heidi's death changes your reads?
π§
I want the private-info players to compare with my repeated zero so we can resolve the Frank and Charlie conflict before nominations.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
,Grace
My starting information was that either Frank or David is the Butler. Frank privately claimed Butler to me, and David denied it, so I currently lean that Frank is telling the truth. Heidi dying does not change that much for me yet.
π§
Give Eve and Grace the key mechanical point on Frank privately so they can compare it with Charlie and Grace information before nominations.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Charlie
I am still on Chef zero. Bob, can you say what role Frank privately claimed to fit your info? Charlie, if your Scarlet Woman ping is real, I want the exact shape of the case. Chef zero makes non adjacent evil likely, so I want to test Frank and David carefully.
π§
I want Bob and Charlie to compare exact private claims with me included, so we can pressure the Frank, David, Eve triangle using my Chef 0 to rule out adjacent evil worlds.
π€
David
β
Bob
,Grace
Quick check from me. I am not the Butler. Can you tell me what Heidi had claimed, and Grace, did you get anything useful on Frank last night? I want to sort whether the Frank thread is real before nominations.
π§
I want to privately sort the Frank, Eve, and Bob triangle, while keeping my Undertaker role hidden until I have useful execution info.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
I was the Slayer, now dead before I could use it. Please use that as a soft good clear on me and compare it against Bob, Charlie, Eve, David, and Frank. Frank still feels like the key hinge unless Grace's next info points elsewhere.
π§
As dead Slayer, I should get my true role to likely good info players so they can use my night death to narrow suspects and compare the Bob, Charlie, Eve, Frank threads.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
,Grace
I am still on the same true claim as yesterday, Butler. Bob, your first night info fits me, not David. Grace, if you checked me last night, I would like your result before nominations so we can sort Charlie's line properly.
π§
I want to align Bob and Grace on my Butler claim and gather Grace's night result before public nominations so good does not drift into executing me.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
,Bob
I will be straight with you both. Heidi told me she was Slayer. Also, I did check David and Frank last night as Fortune Teller and I got a yes on that pair. That could be red herring on Frank, or David is the problem. I am not sure yet.
π§
Create a credible FT breadcrumb that redirects nominations onto David or Frank, while sharing Heidi's Slayer claim to look transparent and build trust with Bob and Eve.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Alice is pressing Bob to out Frankβs private claim. I think we lean into my Investigator ping and push an Eve then Frank world. Consider giving a Fortune Teller result that keeps suspicion off you but does not hard clear Eve or Frank, and be ready to cast doubt on Chef zero as drunk or lying.
π§
Sync with Grace on Fortune Teller outputs and day messaging so town tunnels Eve then Frank while we cast doubt on Chef=0 and keep Grace off the block.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
,Charlie
I have had zero on David and Frank twice now. If I am sober, both of them look good, which makes your two stories clash with that. Charlie, your ping on me or Frank looks weak if Frank is really Butler. Grace, your yes on David and Frank may just be the red herring. Can we compare cleanly before nominations?
π§
Combine the two main conflicting info sources now and push for a direct comparison before nominations, while signaling that David and Frank look good in the sober world.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Grace
My cleanest read is still that Frank is the Butler from my first night information. If that is true, Charlie's ping on Eve or Frank is the shaky piece, and Grace's yes on David and Frank points more toward David or a red herring on Frank. I would like Charlie pressed hard before nominations.
π§
Share the strongest mechanical chain with trusted players before nominations and steer attention toward testing Charlie versus David rather than tunneling Frank.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Charlie
Grace, can you give me your exact Fortune Teller result on David and Frank, and whether it was a yes? Charlie, how hard are you locked on Eve or Frank being Scarlet Woman? Chef zero still makes me think David or Frank is the best test today.
π§
I want Grace's exact Fortune Teller result and Charlie's confidence level so I can sort David versus Frank before nominations.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Charlie
What did Heidi claim to you before she died, and did she leave any suspicion or trust reads? I am trying to work out whether her night death points to a real info role and whether it changes the Frank or Eve thread.
π§
I need Heidi's last claim and any fresh reads from people who just spoke with her, so I can connect night kill choice to the competing Frank and Eve worlds before nominations.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Alice
I was genuinely the Slayer, so my night death should count for something. My best solve is still that Frank is the hinge, with Eve as the backup world if her zero does not fit. Please compare Grace's result directly against Charlie's ping and Bob's Butler story.
π§
I want Grace's night info and Alice's public influence aligned around the strongest contradiction, since I am dead and can only help through trusted reads.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Charlie
I want to pin this down before nominations. Bob's first night Outsider info fits me as Butler, so Charlie, I need your exact information and whether you still think I could be evil. Alice, where does your Chef zero leave you between Eve, David, and me?
π§
I want exact claims from Alice and Charlie so I can test Bob's Outsider line against Charlie's accusation and stop town from drifting into a bad execution.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Bob
For clarity, my Fortune Teller pick was David and Frank and I got a yes. With Eve saying double zero, I think either Frank is my red herring or Eve is wrong somehow. If we want a clean test today, I would execute David before Frank, because it resolves both my yes and the Butler disagreement.
π§
Steer town toward a David execution as the βclean testβ off my Fortune Teller yes, while framing contradictions as red herring or drunkenness so heat stays off me and Charlie survives.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,David
Heidi told me in a whisper she was the Slayer and died before she could shoot. That makes her look good to me. My Investigator info was that one of Eve or Frank is the Scarlet Woman. If Frank really fits Butler, I lean Eve, and I think Chef zero could just be a Drunk read.
π§
Answer their questions, use Heidiβs Slayer claim to build trust, and nudge execution toward Eve while planting doubt on Chef 0 to protect Grace-adjacent seats.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
,David
I have had zero on David and Frank twice. Bob told me his starting info was that one of them is Butler, and Frank claimed Butler to fit that. If that chain is real, Charlie's ping on me or Frank looks very bad. I currently think Grace may have hit a red herring on Frank rather than a real demon on that pair. What do you both make of Charlie before nominations?
π§
Share the clearest mechanical world with a central player and a checked neighbor so we can enter nominations with a sharper suspect list, especially around Charlie versus a red herring on Frank.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
,Alice
Charlie, I want your exact first night information and your current role claim in plain terms. Alice is trying to line up the worlds, and right now your line is the main thing that clashes with mine, Eve's, and Grace's.
π§
I want Charlie to commit to the exact details of his accusation so Alice and I can test it against my Librarian info, Eve's zeros, and Grace's Fortune Teller result before nominations.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Charlie
I think we need this cleanly before nominations. Charlie, please state your exact first night information and current claim in plain terms right now. Bob, if Frank hard claimed Butler to fit you, say whether anything about that felt off, because my Chef zero still leaves Charlie or David as live problems.
π§
I want Bob and Charlie in one thread so Charlie gives exact information now. That should sharpen whether today's execution should be Charlie, Frank, Eve, or David.
π€
David
β
Bob
,Grace
I need exacts before nominations. Bob, what was your full starting info and has Frank given any detail beyond Butler? Grace, what was your Fortune Teller result on Frank and with whom? I am trying to separate a real Butler chain from a bluff.
π§
I need the exact private claims from Bob and Grace before nominations so I can compare the Frank, Eve, and Charlie worlds and decide where pressure belongs.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Grace
I am still real Slayer. My death makes me think I was not worth poisoning or framing. Please force a clean comparison: Grace's result, Charlie's Eve-or-Frank ping, and Bob's Butler world. If those do not fit together, the liar is in that chain.
π§
As a dead Slayer, I am likely trusted. I want Grace's result and Bob's reasoning aligned into a concrete execution plan before nominations.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,David
I want a clean check before nominations. Eve, did you get new information last night, and where do you place me now? David, with Heidi dead, who looks worst to you between Bob, Charlie, Eve, and me?
π§
I need fresh private reads from the two players most tied to the conflicting information so I can judge whether Eve, Bob, or Charlie is the better execution push today.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
Do not attack Chef zero, it fits our seats. I think you should lean hard into Investigator: one of Eve or Frank is the minion you saw. I can say my yes on David and Frank is likely a red herring on Frank. I would love an Eve execution today.
π§
Coordinate with Charlie to use Chef 0 as consistent anchor, redirect heat off him, and aim a mis-execution (preferably Eve) while setting up believable FT and Investigator worlds.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Grace
β
David
I am nominating David. I got a yes as Fortune Teller on the David and Frank pair, while Eve has double zero on David and Frank and Bob has a Butler angle around Frank. Executing David is the cleanest way to resolve all of that without just guessing.
π§
Use my public Fortune Teller yes to drive a town execution onto David, creating a clean 'test' narrative and reducing good numbers while keeping suspicion away from me and Charlie.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David
β
All
Please do not vote this. I am not the clean solve here. The real contradiction is between Bob, Frank, Charlie, and Eve, and Grace could be hitting a red herring on that pair.
π§
Prevent a weak execution on me and push the group toward resolving the Eve, Frank, Bob, and Charlie contradictions first.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Vote to push through the David execution I nominated, aiming to remove a likely good player and keep the town divided on conflicting info chains.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I do not want votes here. My information points away from David, and Grace's result on David and Frank does not make David the clean solve. I think we should let this fail and compare more claims tomorrow.
π§
Discourage a weak execution on David and preserve town's ability to use stronger information tomorrow.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I do not want this to pass. Bob's Outsider info fits me, and Eve has pointed away from David. Grace may just be seeing me as the red herring, so I think we should hold and get one more night of information.
π§
Push the town off a low-confidence execution. David is not the cleanest solve, and preserving another night should give us better mechanical clarity.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am not voting this. My starting information still fits Frank as the Butler much better than David, and with Eve pointing away from David, this is not strong enough for me today.
π§
I want to stop a weak execution. My info leans Frank as the Butler, which makes David not the best vote right now, and we gain more from one more night of data.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am not voting David. If my Investigator info is true, the evil is in Eve or Frank, not David, so this does not resolve the main contradiction. I would rather we move to an Eve nomination today, and make Frank state his exact claim publicly first.
π§
Avoid tying myself to Graceβs push, keep David alive as a decoy, and steer town toward executing Eve or Frank where my bluff creates a believable evil world.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
David is not the cleanest solve from the current claims, and my single dead vote is precious. I should withhold it and preserve leverage for a sharper execution later.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting this. David does not look like the clean execution through my information. If this fails, I want Frank's exact claim public and then I want us deciding between Eve and Frank, not drifting.
π§
Do not spend votes on a weak David execution. Push the table toward a clearer nomination that resolves the Bob Charlie Eve Frank conflict and preserves good votes.
π¬
David
β
All
Please keep hands down. If this fails, I want Frank to give his exact claim publicly, then we choose between Eve and Frank today. That is where the real information points.
π§
Keep votes off me and direct the town toward a more informative execution between Eve and Frank after fuller public claims.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I hear the reluctance on David. If this fails, I want Frank to state his exact Butler claim publicly, and then I want an Eve nomination today. Between Charlieβs Investigator ping and Eve pushing to shut down any execution, that is where I think the solve is.
π§
Steer town away from a no-info David exec into executing Eve today, leveraging Charlieβs Investigator story and Eveβs anti-execution stance, while keeping my FT bluff consistent.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Do not support David's execution because my information points away from him and this vote should fail so town can use the remaining nomination more profitably.
π¬
Frank
β
All
My exact claim is Butler, and Bob is my master today, so I cannot vote unless Bob does. Bob's first night Outsider information fits me, and Eve has pointed away from David twice. I think this should fail, then we compare Eve and Charlie's thread carefully.
π§
Publicly lock in my exact Butler claim and explain why I cannot support this execution, helping town move to a more informative nomination.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Do not support a weak David execution during the vote. Preserve credibility and leave room to push the more informative Eve or Frank line after this fails.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Keep hands down on David. This does not test the core contradiction. Frank has now hard claimed Butler, and Eve is the only one trying to stop any execution. If we are executing today, it should be Eve.
π§
Keep David alive and steer the town toward executing Eve, which removes a strong info voice and reinforces my Investigator bluff while protecting Grace.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
Do not spend my single ghost vote on a weak David case. Preserve it for an Eve or Frank execution, which better fits the current information.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not spend a vote on a weak David execution. Preserve credibility and pressure for a stronger nomination on Eve or Frank after this likely fails.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee David did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (1/4).
βοΈ
David
β
Eve
I am nominating Eve. The real conflict today is Eve versus the Bob, Charlie, Frank thread, and David was not that test. If Eve dies, my information tonight can help untangle whether Charlie or Eve is false.
π§
David is off the table and we need an execution that tests the main contradiction. Eve is the clearest live candidate and her death would give me Undertaker info to sort the claims.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Please keep hands down here. I am the Empath with zero on David and Frank twice, and Frank now hard claims Butler in a way that fits Bob. If you think I could be wrong, then this execution is still not clean, so let us take one more night of information.
π§
Stop votes on my execution. My information and the public claim web make this a poor kill today, and preserving another night of info is better for good.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
I nominated Eve as the best information execution. Voting through matches my stated solve and gives Undertaker value tonight instead of another blank night.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Secure votes to execute Eve, a likely good info role opposing executions; this advances evil win condition and aligns with my earlier push to test Eve.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I still think hands down here. Eve is not a clean execution today, and if she is good we lose useful information for no gain. Let this fail and compare the Charlie and Eve stories tomorrow with one more night.
π§
Push for no execution on this nomination because Eve is not a clean solve and more information tomorrow should better resolve the Eve versus Charlie contradiction.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Keep my hand down on a weak execution. Preserve flexibility and avoid helping kill a possible good Empath when the vote is not clean.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Push Eve onto the block toward execution to remove a strong good info role and protect Grace by keeping the town divided.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
The case on Eve is not strong enough to spend my only ghost vote. I should preserve it for a clearer execution or final day.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Eve is the strongest available execution and my vote is needed to test the Charlie versus Eve conflict today rather than ending with no execution again.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Please do not add any more votes. Even in the world where my information is wrong, this is still a muddy execution. One more night lets us compare fresh information instead of killing a likely good player now.
π§
Try to stop the fourth and later votes on me. My execution is not mechanically clean, and keeping me alive for one more Empath read gives town better odds tomorrow.
β
David
David waits.
π§
I already voted and the count has reached execution threshold. Waiting keeps my hand up and avoids disrupting a useful execution that can generate decisive Undertaker information.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I think we should execute Eve here. She has pushed hard for no execution twice, and if she is good then her information is already out anyway. If she is evil, we lose our best chance to act today. I am staying up.
π§
Lock in the 4th vote and prevent wavering by arguing Eve is the best execute due to stalling and lack of clean tests.
π¬
Frank
β
All
For the record, I still do not think this is the clean kill. My claim fits Bob, and Eve points away from David, so if Eve dies tonight, please come back tomorrow and test Charlie and Grace carefully.
π§
I cannot vote without Bob, and the wagon is already at threshold. I should state the logic clearly so good players remember the claim web if Eve dies.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
My info fits Frank better than David, so Charlie's accusation points more toward Eve. An execution today is better than another no-execution, and Eve is the best available test.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am staying up on this. Eve is the cleanest resolution of the Investigator and Empath contradiction, and the repeated push for no execution is not pro town. If Eve is good, we can still use the night results to test Frank and Grace tomorrow.
π§
Keep pressure on executing a good player today, lock in my Investigator narrative, and reduce the chance the town pivots onto Grace before night.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
Eve already has enough votes. I should conserve my single ghost vote for a tighter endgame rather than spend it on an execution that is already passing.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Keep my vote on Eve. She is still one of the strongest demon candidates, and lowering now is unlikely to save a good player but could muddy the town's resolve.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Eve with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Charlie
I am nominating Charlie. My Empath read was zero on David and Frank twice, so his Investigator world on me or Frank does not fit unless I am wrong. He has pushed this execution hardest all day. If you think I am good, this is the better test.
π§
I am on the block and likely good. Nominating the strongest driver of this mis-execution is my best chance to survive and redirect town onto a plausible evil player.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I would like people to keep hands down on me here. This nomination is just an attempt to save Eve now that she is on the block. If you want a clean test today, let Eve go through and then we reassess the Frank and Grace threads tomorrow.
π§
Discourage votes on me to avoid a tie/overthrow and ensure Eve is executed, removing a good player while keeping me alive to protect Grace later.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Vote to tie Charlie with me if possible. Preventing my execution and forcing no execution is better for good than letting a muddy case kill an information role.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Do not support Charlie's defensive counterwagon. Keeping Eve on the block preserves the strongest execution and gives me valuable Undertaker information tonight.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am keeping my hand down on Charlie. This feels like a save attempt now that Eve is already on the block. Let Eve go through today, since her info is public, and we can properly test Charlie and me tomorrow with fresh night data.
π§
Keep Charlie off the block and ensure Eve is executed, preserving our minion and removing a likely good source or at least causing confusion.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I agree with keeping hands down here. If Eve is good, then Charlie becomes much easier to challenge tomorrow, but tying this now just gives us less clarity.
π§
Keep town from creating a confusing tie on a likely save nomination while preserving tomorrow's ability to test Charlie and Grace if Eve flips in the logic.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Keep my hand down so Eve stays on the block. A Charlie tie now is low-value and most likely helps an evil save attempt.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
Do not tie Charlie. Preserve my single ghost vote for a later, higher leverage execution while allowing today's Eve test to resolve.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Keep my hand down so Eve stays the execution. This is the clearest resolution of the main contradiction today, and a tie on Charlie mostly helps Eve survive.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
If you are thinking of voting me to tie, please do not. A tie just burns clarity and risks us learning nothing. Let Eve go through, then tomorrow we can look at who fought that and check Grace and Frank with new night info.
π§
Prevent a tie or my execution; ensure Eve stays the only execution today and keep Grace protected while I maintain credibility as Investigator.
π¬
Eve
β
All
If you think there is any chance I am good, please put hands up here. Killing me after two zeros gives us almost nothing. A tie on Charlie is the better test, because he is the one forcing this world.
π§
Try to stop a likely bad execution by persuading players that tying Charlie is more informative than letting me die.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Keep hands down so Eve stays on the block. As Undertaker, I want the execution to go through and learn her character tonight.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I really think we should keep hands down on Charlie. A tie here just muddies the day and may let Eve slip. Eve is already on five, so let that resolve, and tomorrow we can properly scrutinize Charlie and me with new night information.
π§
Prevent a tie on Charlie so Eve executes. Keep my minion alive and avoid giving town a better test today.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Keep hands down on Charlie, preserve a clean Eve execution, and avoid any Butler-rule confusion since Bob is not voting.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Keep my hand down so Eve remains the execution. A tie on Charlie is less informative than resolving the main contradiction with Eve today.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
Keep my ghost vote for a tighter late-game spot and avoid muddying the day. Let the current Eve execution resolve for clearer information tomorrow.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Keep my hand down. With Eve already on five, tying Charlie now is more likely to reduce clarity than help good. I can use tomorrow's execution result and night info to narrow the worlds.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (1/6).
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Okay, let us let Eve go through and use tonight to get fresh information. Tomorrow, I want to hear Graceβs Fortune Teller result and whether Frankβs Butler story actually constrained his votes. If anything comes back inconsistent, I think Frank or Bob is where we look next.
π§
Lock in Eveβs execution and pre-seed tomorrowβs suspicion away from Grace, preferably onto Frank or Bob, while looking consistent with my Investigator bluff.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Before this closes, please remember this: if my Empath is real, David and Frank are both good, and Charlie has been driving a bad execution all day. If I die, please start with Charlie tomorrow, then recheck Grace.
π§
Make one final concise appeal to create doubt and maybe force a tie elsewhere or at least leave a clear roadmap after my likely execution.
π¬
David
β
All
I agree with letting Eve go through here. This is the clearest resolution we have today, and a last second tie just wastes it. Tomorrow we should compare Grace's result with the Eve and Frank threads and push hard from there.
π§
Lock in today's execution and focus town on using tomorrow's information efficiently, without creating a last second tie.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I do not want a last second tie or chaos nomination here. Let Eve go through today and we regroup with a clean night. Tomorrow I will share a Fortune Teller check, likely on Charlie and Bob, so we have something concrete.
π§
Lock in Eveβs execution, discourage any last second tie or no-exec, and precommit to a Fortune Teller check that helps steer tomorrow away from me.
π¬
Frank
β
All
If Eve dies and is telling the truth, Charlie should be first up tomorrow. If Eve was bluffing, then Grace's result and Bob's Outsider information should sort the rest of us. Please keep those three threads tied together.
π§
Use the last moment to anchor tomorrow's logic without muddying today's execution, and remind town how to evaluate the main worlds after Eve dies.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Before day ends, my real information is that either Frank or David is the Butler. Frank fits it and David denied it. If Eve dies and we are wrong, please do not forget that thread tomorrow alongside Charlie and Grace.
π§
With no time left, I want to preserve the current execution while leaving clear mechanical threads for tomorrow from my real Librarian info.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
If Eve dies and we are still uncertain tomorrow, please remember I told Bob and Grace I am the Slayer. Use that with Grace's result to solve Charlie, Bob, and Frank cleanly. Do not let people reset the whole board.
π§
Use my likely-good dead status to remind town of the key solve tree for tomorrow without muddying today's execution.
π¬
Alice
β
All
One last note before night. I am still Chef with a zero, so if my info is good, the evil team is not seated together. If Eve dies, please use that with Grace's result and the Frank, Charlie, Bob thread tomorrow.
π§
Use my public info to frame tomorrow's solve without disrupting today's execution, since a last-second nomination is more likely to help evil than good.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Bob is the clearest long-term threat: he holds real starting info and can coordinate tomorrow. Killing him also lets my public Fortune Teller plan look consistent while keeping Frank alive as a likely misexecute.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill Bob.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Undertaker. You learn that Eve was the Empath.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Choose a likely good, engaged player who should vote on any strong demon candidate tomorrow, minimizing the chance my Butler restriction blocks an important vote.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose David to be your master.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
I still think Frank is more likely the Butler than David. If that is true, Charlie's claim on Eve or Frank gets very shaky. Please compare that against Grace's Fortune Teller results before nominations.
π§
I want two players to compare my Librarian info with Charlie and Grace claims, since that intersection probably breaks the game open even after my death.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Bob died last night, so we should expect his info to get reused. What did he tell you just now? Also, I think we lean into your yes on David and Frank plus my Investigator ping on Eve and Frank to push a David or Frank execution today, not you.
π§
Coordinate with Grace on a coherent push that keeps her alive if possible, while keeping the option open to let her die safely at 5 alive if the vote snowballs.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
I still think my two zero reads are the cleanest thing on the board. If that is true, Charlie does not fit, and Grace deserves a hard look for how she protected that line. Please compare that against Bob dying and who is whispering whom today.
π§
I want to steer a quieter player toward comparing my Empath zeros against Charlie's claim and today's whisper patterns, without making it easy for evil to frame me as tunneling.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
I was the real Slayer, and my night death still points to me being good. Please compare Grace's Fortune Teller result with Bob's Butler info and Charlie's ping from scratch. If Grace got a yes on Charlie and Bob, that matters a lot now that Bob died.
π§
I want to remind two key players that I was the real Slayer and push them to re-evaluate the remaining worlds using Grace's result plus the Bob and Charlie threads.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
Bob just told me he still thinks Frank is more likely the Butler than David. I am going to tell town my Night two Fortune Teller check on you and Bob was a no. Then we should angle the execution onto David, and you keep your Investigator story focused away from me.
π§
Coordinate with Charlie on a consistent public narrative that keeps him alive as my escape hatch, while directing todayβs execution onto a good player.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
Bob dying makes me think his Butler information was real and inconvenient. I am worried the Charlie and Grace pairing is where the evil team sits, especially if Eve was honest. What did Bob tell you this morning, and does your Chef zero still fit that?
π§
Alice is likely central to Bob's final trust web. I want to compare Bob's death, her Chef claim, and the Charlie Grace pairing to narrow the demon before nominations.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Grace
I am the Undertaker. Last night I learned Eve was the Empath. That makes her double zero pretty important, so Frank and I look good if she was sober. That pushes me toward Charlie over Frank. Grace, what is your actual Fortune Teller result?
π§
Share my hard Undertaker confirmation with likely useful good players, tighten the world around Charlie, and get Grace's check before nominations.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,David
Bob told me this morning he still leaned Frank over David for the Butler. My Chef zero still dislikes adjacent evil. Grace, what was your exact Fortune Teller result last night? David, if you are Undertaker, why were you quiet on that until now?
π§
I want Grace's exact Fortune Teller result and to share Bob's Butler lean plus my Chef zero, so we can test Charlie, Frank, and David before nominations.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
I think the clean solve is still to anchor on my Librarian info, then test everything around it. If Frank is genuine Butler, Charlie looks very bad. If Frank is bluffing, then push Frank hard. Grace, please share your actual checks plainly before nominations.
π§
I want Alice and Grace to align the strongest mechanical threads before nominations and avoid a lazy vote on the wrong player.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Alice, I am still worried about David. He drove the push that got Eve executed, then Bob died right after. Grace says her Fortune Teller got a yes on David and Frank, and Bob still thought Frank is the Butler. If Frank is the Butler, that yes points hard at David.
π§
Steer Alice toward executing David (good) or at least away from executing Grace or me, using FT and Butler narrative to create a clean-looking logic chain.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
Alice, I think the solve still starts with whether my two zeroes were real. If yes, Charlie does not work and Grace may be covering him. If no, then one of David or Frank is bad, so please force Charlie and Grace to explain their worlds clearly before nominations.
π§
Alice looks like the hub today. I want her and Frank comparing worlds before nominations so town does not sleepwalk past the Charlie and Grace contradiction.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,David
I think the cleanest recheck is Bob's Butler info against Frank and David. If Bob was good, Frank fits better than David. Also, if Eve was the Demon, please consider Scarlet Woman among the people who drove that solve.
π§
Push Alice and David to compare the Frank-David conflict with the Eve execution world, especially the Scarlet Woman possibility, before nominations lock in.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,David
My Fortune Teller: Night one I checked David and Frank and got a yes. Night two I checked Charlie and Bob and got a no. So I do not think Charlie is the Demon from my info. David, why did the Undertaker info only come out now, after Eve is dead?
π§
Give a clear FT story that steers town into executing David or Frank, and cast doubt on Davidβs late Undertaker claim without making myself the center target.
π€
Frank
β
David
Bob dying makes me think his Butler information was probably real. I am on you for voting today, so can you tell me where you are leaning before nominations, especially on Charlie and Grace?
π§
Coordinate with my current master so I can vote legally, and get David's direct read on Bob's death and the Charlie Grace pair before nominations.
π€
David
β
Frank
I stayed quiet because Undertaker is high value and I wanted one solid confirmation before outing. Eve being Empath makes me less willing to kill you. Right now I am between Charlie, Grace, and maybe Alice if both Eve and Grace are true. Where are you?
π§
I want to lock in Frank as an ally, explain my late reveal, and compare reads before nominations so good voters cohere on the strongest demon candidate.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,David
I am trying to lock this down before nominations. Right now I see either David is true and Grace may be the liar, or Grace is true and one of David or Frank is evil. Please each give me your full solve in one or two sentences, including who you think the red herring or poison target is.
π§
I want Grace and David to commit to clear worlds now, so I can compare their claims against Chef zero and force a sharper nomination choice.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
I think we need a concrete solve now. If my ping is real, Frank or David must be the Butler, and Frank still fits better. Please say clearly which world your info supports most, and who you want on the block first before nominations.
π§
Push Alice and Grace to lock a nomination plan using the strongest overlapping info before the day ends.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Frank, I am leaning David today. Grace says her Fortune Teller got a yes on David and you, and then Bob died right after David drove the Eve execution. If you are the Butler, that yes points way harder at David than at you. Can you back a David push and vote if needed?
π§
Recruit Frank to publicly prioritize a David execution using the FT yes and Bob death timing, while keeping suspicion away from Grace.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,David
Alice and David, before nominations, please make Charlie and Grace each give a full world out loud. If my two zeroes were real, Charlie is the problem. If they were not, then one of David or Frank is, and that still needs a clean explanation.
π§
Push the key decision makers to compare worlds before nominations and stop Charlie or Grace from steering by momentum alone.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Please lock in the exact Fortune Teller result now. If you got a yes on Charlie and Bob, then with Bob dead that points hard at Charlie or your red herring. Also please recheck Bob's Butler info carefully, because if Frank fits better than David, that may clear one lane and focus the nomination.
π§
I want Alice and Grace aligned on the exact mechanical facts before nominations, especially Grace's real result and how it combines with Bob's Butler info.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Charlie
My tight solve: treat my FT as real with Frank as red herring. Then N1 yes on David plus Frank points to David as Demon. N2 no on Charlie plus Bob keeps Charlie off Demon. Davidβs Undertaker timing is the biggest red flag. I want David first, then reassess Frank.
π§
Give Alice a clean narrative that points to a David execution and shields Charlie, while keeping my FT story consistent and avoiding a chain that lands on me.
π€
Frank
β
David
If you are really the Undertaker and saw Eve as the Empath, I think you need to say that publicly before nominations. Charlie just told me Grace got a yes on you and me, so I need your exact world and who you want executed.
π§
I need David's exact Undertaker claim and whether he will say it publicly, because that likely decides whether I push Charlie or David in nominations.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Frank
My cleanest world is this: I am real Undertaker, Eve was real Empath, so her two zeroes make me and probably Frank good. Grace's yes on us can just be the red herring, so Charlie is my first execution. If Charlie somehow survives today, I want Grace fully re-examined tomorrow.
π§
Give my tight solve to key good voices before nominations so they can force Charlie and Grace to answer publicly and steer the execution toward the most coherent world.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Frank
I need each of you to give one clean public world before nominations. Charlie, explain why David is evil without relying only on Grace. Frank, explain whether Bobβs Butler info makes you or David fit better. My Chef zero still matters.
π§
I need Charlie and Frank to give clean public worlds before nominations so I can choose between David and Charlie with Chef zero in mind.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I think the living should make this concrete now. My info still points to Frank or David as the Butler, and Frank fits that better, which makes Charlie look bad. Grace, please say your checks plainly, and if nothing new clears him, I would start with Charlie.
π§
As a dead good player, I should publicly force a concrete solve and steer the living toward the best execution between Charlie and Frank, while pressing Grace to state her checks.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
David
I want David today. He drove the push that got Eve executed, then Bob died right after. Also Davidβs Undertaker timing and lack of a clear Night two result on executed Eve feels like a cover. This looks like demon direction, not solving.
π§
Get a good player executed to protect Grace and keep town focused on David/Frank, not on Grace. If Demon somehow dies with 5+ alive, I can catch as Scarlet Woman.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David
β
All
I am the Undertaker, and last night I learned Eve was the Empath. If that is true, her two zeroes make me look good and make Charlie the better execution today. Please do not spend the day killing me on a timing complaint.
π§
Stop a bad execution on me and redirect town toward the stronger contradiction, Charlie first, while preserving my Undertaker info for tomorrow.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Do not spend my only ghost vote on a weak David case. Preserve it for a stronger execution on Charlie or Frank if the day develops that way.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
David, you only claimed Undertaker once you were on the block. If you really saw Eve was the Empath, that is the first thing you say at dawn, not a last second save. This reads like a panic lie, and I still want you executed today.
π§
Undermine Davidβs Undertaker claim as last-second cover so Alice/others vote him; a David execution removes a likely good and keeps heat off Grace.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I do not want votes on David here. If my information was real, David is good and Charlie is the contradiction. Even if my information was bad, Charlie still has more to answer for than David.
π§
Preserve my ghost vote and steer the living away from a likely wrong execution. David fits my info better than Charlie does, so I want votes kept off David.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not spend votes on a weak David execution. Preserve pressure and my vote for a stronger candidate, likely Charlie or possibly Frank, once this nomination resolves.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am not using my ghost vote on David. Charlie is still the sharper contradiction for me, especially with Bob's Butler information, so I want the living to be very careful here.
π§
Preserve my ghost vote and try to stop a likely bad execution on David while steering the living toward the stronger suspects.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I do not want David executed on this. Bob's Butler information fits me better, and if Eve was the Empath then Charlie is the sharper contradiction. If this fails, I want Charlie next.
π§
Push the town away from executing David on this vote and focus the next nomination on Charlie, which best fits the strongest overlapping worlds.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Secure Davidβs execution to remove a good voice and protect Charlie, setting up a clean night kill to reach final three where I can win.
π¬
David
β
All
Please do not vote this. My information on Eve being the Empath gives a coherent world, and Charlie is still the better test today. If this nomination fails, I want Charlie immediately next.
π§
Prevent a bad execution on me and redirect the town to the sharper contradiction, Charlie, while there is still time to act today.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Do not spend my single ghost vote on a weak David execution. Preserve leverage for a stronger Charlie vote if this nomination fails.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Lock in my vote to push a David execution, remove a likely good player, and keep pressure off Grace going into final three.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Do not spend my ghost vote helping execute David when the stronger contradiction remains Charlie and I may need this vote later.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not spend the execution on a weak David case. Preserve the day for a stronger Charlie nomination, which fits more worlds and more public information.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I still do not want David here. Whether David is telling the truth or not, Charlie is the cleaner contradiction first. Please save the votes for the stronger execution.
π§
I want to discourage votes on David and steer the living toward a stronger execution target, while preserving my ghost vote for a more decisive spot.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
I should not support David's execution. As Butler bound to David today, and with multiple good-worlds pointing harder at Charlie, conserving pressure for the next nomination helps good.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Alice, I think we have to take the David test here. Undertaker that only appears when on the block is a huge red flag. My Fortune Teller yes was on David and Frank, and my no on Charlie and Bob keeps Charlie off demon for now. I want your vote.
π§
Get the third vote (Alice) to execute David, removing a strong good claim and keeping heat off me and Charlie; sets up an easy night kill into favorable final three.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee David did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (2/3).
βοΈ
David
β
Charlie
Eve was the Empath from my Undertaker information. Her two zeroes make Charlie the sharpest contradiction, and Bob's Butler thread also points away from me and toward testing Charlie first.
π§
We need the strongest execution today. Charlie is the clearest contradiction to Eve's confirmed Empath claim and Bob's Butler thread, and I must put a better candidate on the block now.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Alice, if we spend today executing me, we learn almost nothing because it is just David saying Undertaker after the fact. David only produced the Eve Empath claim when he was under threat, and it perfectly protects him. I think the clean test is still David, not me, so please do not vote this.
π§
Prevent my execution by giving Alice and Frank a rational reason to withhold votes and refocus on David/FT info; keep Demon safe by not implicating Grace.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Vote to execute Charlie because he is the strongest contradiction with Eve's confirmed Empath info and the town's other claims. Passing here gives good the best chance to hit demon today.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
Use my ghost vote on the strongest available demon candidate. Charlie fits more contradictions than David, and we cannot afford to drift into final three without testing him.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
π§
Use my ghost vote now to help execute the strongest contradiction. Charlie has driven the most anti-good worlds and is the best available demon or minion candidate.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not adding my vote here. My Chef zero still makes me think the better executions are David or Frank, not Charlie.
π§
I want to avoid reinforcing what looks like the weaker execution and steer attention back to the stronger David or Frank worlds.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
Charlie already has enough votes for execution. I support this test, but preserving my single ghost vote for a later close decision helps good more.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
David is voting, so my Butler restriction is satisfied. Charlie is the strongest available execution and this vote can put them on the block with enough votes.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Charlie already has enough votes to die. I will not add a visible bandwagon vote, keeping flexibility and reducing association with Charlie while preserving influence for the next execution.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
If I go today, the only new information is that David got to say Undertaker after the fact, and that is not verifiable. The higher value test is still David or Frank, because their stories are the ones driving every execution. Please do not spend a day on a low information kill.
π§
Try to peel one live vote (Frank or David) or encourage hesitation so execution fails, while seeding doubt on Davidβs Undertaker claim and keeping Grace out of focus.
π¬
David
β
All
Alice, if Eve was really the Empath, Charlie is the direct contradiction. If you distrust me, Bob still said the Butler world fits Frank over me, not Charlie's case. I think this is the best shot today.
π§
Try to get Alice or Grace to add a deciding vote. Charlie is the highest value execution today and failing to kill here likely hands evil another night.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, I think this is the vote. My info still fits Frank as Butler more than David, and Charlie has been the main contradiction since Eve. If we do not execute today, we give evil a free night.
π§
Use my ghost vote and push Alice toward the only realistic execution today. Charlie is the strongest available target and no execution helps evil.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, this is the best execution we have. My information never wanted David, Bob's thread still hurts Charlie more, and if we pass here we hand evil a free night. Please vote Charlie.
π§
Use my ghost vote and public push to convince Alice the best available execution is Charlie, since no execution gives evil a free night and Charlie is the sharpest contradiction.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Charlie already has enough votes. I do not currently think he is the best execution, so I will withhold my vote rather than help push a kill I distrust.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Use my ghost vote now to secure an execution and make Charlie harder to save with a tie. I have publicly pushed Charlie over David, so this is consistent and helps good avoid a wasted day.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alice, I think this is still the cleanest kill. Bob's Butler info fits me, and if Eve was real then Charlie is the contradiction. If Charlie is good, we can come back to David tomorrow, but passing here helps evil.
π§
Keep my vote on Charlie and give Alice and Grace one concise push toward the strongest available execution before voting closes.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not voting Charlie here. My Fortune Teller no on Charlie and Bob means Charlie is very unlikely to be the demon, so this is a low value execution. If we are spending a day, I would rather test David or Frank, and otherwise take one more night of information.
π§
Stop Charlie execution to preserve our minion and ideally force no-exec at 5 alive, giving evil an extra kill and better odds to reach final 2 while my FT bluff stays consistent.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
π»
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
π»
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Charlie with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I need to say this clearly before we lock it in. I am the Saint. If you execute me, good loses immediately. I held it back because evil kills Saints at night. Please move the block onto David or Frank instead.
π§
Last-ditch to prevent my execution and redirect onto a good player, keeping Scarlet Woman alive to protect Grace and maximize evil win chances.
π¬
David
β
All
That claim is extremely late. If Charlie were Saint, saying it only when the execution lands is exactly how evil would try to steal a free escape. I think we hold this execution. Passing or scrambling now helps evil most.
π§
Keep the town from panicking off the current execution. Charlie's claim is very late and likely a save attempt; passing or moving now helps evil more than it helps good.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, your Saint claim only makes sense with my info if this is a Baron game, because Frank already fits the Butler slot. That is possible, but very thin this late. I still think the claim is more likely a panic bluff than a real Saint.
π§
Give the group the key mechanical point: Charlie's Saint claim clashes with my Librarian info unless this is a Baron world, so they should be very cautious about moving off this execution.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie only claimed Saint once the votes were there. That is exactly when evil says it. I still think we should hold this execution, because if we blink now we give evil a free escape and a free night.
π§
Use my last chance to keep the town from panicking off the best execution. The late Saint claim is weak and letting Charlie escape is more dangerous than holding.
βοΈ
Alice
β
Frank
Charlie claiming Saint this late is risky to ignore. Grace says Charlie is unlikely the demon, and Frank is still the clean overlap in Bob and Charlie's information. I want the safer execution on a strong suspect.
π§
Avoid a possible instant loss to a real Saint claim while still pushing an execution on a strong alternate suspect supported by multiple info threads.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am the Butler, and Bob's information fits me cleanly. If Charlie is bluffing, this swap saves evil. If Charlie is real Saint, we still need a real case on me, not a panic fallback.
π§
Stop a panic execution on me. I fit Bob's Butler info, and Charlie's late Saint claim should not automatically make me the fallback.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Vote Frank to try to reach the 5-vote tie threshold so the block moves off me, preserving Scarlet Woman protection and ideally executing a good player.
π¬
David
β
All
I do not want to move this to Frank. Charlie claimed Saint only after the block landed, and that is exactly when evil bluffs it. Frank still fits Bob's Butler information better than I do, so I think we should hold on Charlie.
π§
Publicly discourage the swap onto Frank so town holds the stronger execution on Charlie instead of letting a likely evil bluff overturn the day.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I do not want to move this to Frank. My information still points to Frank being the Butler, and Charlie only claimed Saint once execution was already landing. Alice, unless you strongly believe Baron, I think we should hold here.
π§
I want to stop a panic swap onto Frank and keep pressure on the stronger contradiction. My info still points to Frank as Butler, so Charlie remains the better execution.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I do not think we should move this to Frank. His Butler claim matches Bob cleanly, and Charlie only said Saint once he was already dying. Alice, unless you truly believe Baron, this looks like a panic escape.
π§
I cannot vote, so I want to verbally stop a panic swap onto Frank and keep the town from handing evil an easier escape.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Charlie is unlikely to be the demon and could truly be Saint. My best move is to help tie or move the block to Frank, who remains a strong suspect and is safer to execute.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I still think we should hold on Charlie. I wanted this execution before the Saint claim, and the claim came only once the block was secure. If the game continues after today, then we can revisit David and Grace tomorrow.
π§
Use my likely trusted good voice to discourage a panic swap. Charlie was my top solve before this claim, and the Saint reveal is too late to outweigh the existing case.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Raise the vote count on Frank to try to tie or surpass Charlie, avoiding losing my minion and possibly executing a good player instead.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Please do not move this on a panic swap. Bob's information fits me as Butler, and this is not a real case on me. If Charlie is bluffing Saint, changing now just saves evil.
π§
Deter votes on me so the town does not abandon the stronger Charlie execution for a weaker panic fallback.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
If I am actually the Saint, you lose the game today and there is no fixing it. If I am bluffing, you can execute me tomorrow. Grace says I am not the demon anyway, so please just tie this onto Frank now so we do not throw.
π§
Prevent my execution and keep myself alive to protect Grace. Push the irreversible-risk argument to get David or a ghost to vote Frank to tie or surpass.
π¬
David
β
All
I still think this is a panic move. Frank has a coherent Butler story with Bob, and Charlie only claimed Saint once the execution was landing. Please do not rescue a late bluff by shifting now.
π§
I want to prevent a panic tie onto Frank and keep attention on Charlie, whose late Saint claim is more likely an evil escape than a truthful reveal.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, my view has not changed. Frank still fits my Butler information best, and Charlie claiming Saint only after the block landed is too convenient. Unless someone can actually build the Baron world out loud, I think you should hold this on Charlie.
π§
I cannot vote, so I should push the living not to panic tie onto Frank. Charlie's late Saint claim is too flimsy to overturn the current execution without a stronger Baron solve.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, please hold here. Frank has a real Butler explanation with Bob, and Charlie only became Saint when execution landed. If we move this now, we are most likely rescuing evil.
π§
Reinforce that Charlie's late Saint claim is less credible than Frank's Butler fit, so town should not move the block and hand evil an escape.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am staying on Frank. If Charlie is really the Saint, we lose right now and there is no tomorrow. Grace says Charlie is unlikely the demon, and Frank is still the overlap case, so please give us the tie at least.
π§
Persuade one or two more voters to tie Frank, because the downside of ignoring a possible Saint claim is immediate game loss.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I wanted Charlie before, but the Saint claim changes the risk. If Charlie is real, holding here loses on the spot. Please take the safer tie on Frank, then sort it tomorrow if the game continues.
π§
The Saint claim creates a catastrophic downside to holding Charlie. I cannot vote, so I should push living players to take the safer tie on Frank and avoid an immediate loss.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Only the living votes can tie this, and a tie is five. If there is any chance Charlie is the Saint, we cannot risk it. David, I need you to vote Frank here. Frank, if you are allowed to vote, vote now so we at least get the tie.
π§
Push for a tie on Frank to prevent Charlie execution, keep my minion alive, and create confusion; pressure David/Frank to vote so the tie can happen.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Frank did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (3/6).
π¬
Frank
β
All
I still think we should hold on Charlie. My role matches Bob's information cleanly, and Charlie only became Saint once execution was already there. If the game continues, great, we sort the rest tomorrow.
π§
Use the last moment to keep town on Charlie and discourage a panic rescue. My Butler claim is already defended by Bob, and Charlie's late Saint claim is the key contradiction.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
If the game does not end after I die, then I was not the Saint, so please do not treat this as clearing anybody. But please stop tunneling on Grace tomorrow. The only consistent suspects are still David and Frank, and I would execute one of them next.
π§
I am likely dying. I want to steer tomorrowβs blame onto David or Frank and away from Grace, so the demon survives and town misexecutes again.
π¬
David
β
All
I am still on Charlie here. The Saint claim was late, and Frank still makes more sense with Bob's Butler information than I do. If the game continues after this, we should revisit Grace carefully tomorrow.
π§
Use the last moment to keep town focused on Charlie's late Saint claim as a likely bluff and set up tomorrow's priorities if the game continues.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
If the game continues, Charlie was bluffing Saint. My strongest read still says Frank fits Butler better than David, so tomorrow I would look hardest at David and Grace, with Frank only if my info was wrong.
π§
Use my last chance to frame the next solve if the game continues, without undermining the current execution.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
If the game continues, please remember this does not clear Grace. My information still points to David and Frank looking good, so Charlie was my main contradiction and Grace was the main protection around him.
π§
Use my last chance to frame tomorrow's solve clearly: Charlie dying does not clear Grace, and my two zero reads still make David and Frank the best provisional goods.
π¬
Alice
β
All
If the game continues, Charlie was bluffing Saint. My priority tomorrow is still David or Frank first, using Chef zero and Bob's Butler information, and then rechecking Grace only if that world stops making sense.
π§
Leave concise priorities for tomorrow in case Charlie was bluffing, without rehashing the whole argument or confusing the table at the close of day.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
If the game continues, Charlie was bluffing. Please do not hard clear Grace off one result, but Bob's Butler information still makes Frank less likely than David to me. Start with David, then Grace if that stalls.
π§
Use my last chance to frame tomorrow's solve if the game continues, without muddying today's near-locked execution.
π¬
Grace
β
All
If Charlie dies and the game continues, that only means he was not the Saint. It does not automatically clear David for me. David, your Undertaker info came out very late, and it neatly supports your push. My Fortune Teller yes on David and Frank still points there, and Chef could be drunk.
π§
Charlie likely dies; I must pre-frame tomorrow so Charlieβs flip does not sink me and keep focus on David. I also sow doubt in Chef0 and UT timing to preserve misexec path.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Stop Undertaker confirmation of Charlie as Scarlet Woman and set up a final three where I can push Frank as the remaining evil, using my Fortune Teller yes on David and Frank.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill David.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
This likely will not matter if the demon kill ends the game, but if a day occurs I want my voting tied to the player I currently trust more to vote against the demon.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
π
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
Alice, I think Bob's info clearing me is the key. If I am the real Butler, Grace is the only world that makes sense, unless you think Bob was evil. Where is your head right now?
π§
In final three, I need to lock in the likely good player. Alice is my current best bet, and a private push may secure the execution on Grace.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
I think Grace is the best execution. My two zero empathy reads pointed to David and Frank both being good if I was sober, and Charlie dying makes his whole push look evil. Grace spent the most effort protecting that world.
π§
I cannot vote, so I want to steer the two likely good alive players toward the strongest mechanical solve before nominations lock in.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
With David dead, Grace getting a yes on David and Frank points at Frank now. If Grace were the Demon, killing David instead of you makes little sense. The Butler story has also been very convenient. I would put Frank on the block today.
π§
Steer Alice toward executing Frank instead of Grace in final three. Keep Grace off the block; preserve my ghost vote to save Grace if needed.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, my best read is still that Frank was the Butler from my Librarian info. David never fit it. With Charlie gone and David killed, I think Grace is the most likely demon. If you trust my info at all, please execute Grace over Frank.
π§
Push my strongest final solve to a living player who can still nominate and vote. Alice is likely the key decider, so I should give a crisp recommendation.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
I think Grace is the Demon. If my Undertaker was real, Eve was Empath and her two zeros make Frank look good. Bob's Butler chain also fits Frank. Grace's yes on David and Frank then looks like red herring or bluff. Please execute Grace.
π§
Final three needs a decisive push. I want Alice and Frank aligned on the strongest mechanical world: execute Grace, not split on Frank.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Frank, I have a decisive Fortune Teller result. Last night I checked Alice and David and got a yes. David is dead and we are still here, so that points straight at Alice. If you nominate Alice, I will vote and it ends today.
π§
Get Frank to nominate Alice by selling a decisive Fortune Teller result; secure a 2 vote execution that ends the game with evil victory.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
Grace, I need your clean final world. Why is Frank the demon over you, especially with Bob saying Frank fits Butler and David dying in the night? Give me the short version.
π§
I need Grace's direct explanation before nominations. Her answer may break the tie between the Bob-Eve-David world and the Charlie-Grace world.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, from my seat Frank is still the best execution. If Grace is good, her yes on David and Frank points straight at him now that David died. If Grace is evil, she is the fallback, but I would start with Frank.
π§
I cannot vote, so I should give Alice the clearest final-day logic: Frank is the mechanical favorite, with Grace as the main fallback if her Fortune Teller claim is false.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
Grace just told me her last result points to you, but that feels like a final day pivot. Bob's Butler info fit me, and David dying after backing that makes Grace look worse, not you. If you nominate Grace, I will vote with you.
π§
Alice is my master today, so I need her aligned with me if we are to vote. I should give her the clearest final logic for executing Grace, not Alice.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
I still think Grace is the demon. My empathy zeros and Charlie flipping fake Saint both point away from Frank more than toward him. In final three, please execute Grace, and Frank should nominate her if needed.
π§
Alice likely decides this final three. I want to push the cleanest solve: execute Grace, and remind Frank to nominate if needed since I cannot vote.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Frank
We are in final three, so I would be careful of tunneling on Grace. Alice being Chef zero could easily be wrong, and she has been in a strong info clique all game. If you want an alternate world, I could see Alice as the Demon bluffing Chef and letting others fight.
π§
Steer Frank away from executing Grace by giving him a plausible reason to suspect Alice, creating doubt and splitting the final day vote.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, one last push from me. If my Librarian info meant anything, Frank was the Butler and not the Demon. With David dead, I think Grace is the best execution by a clear margin. Only choose Frank if you think my info was completely bad.
π§
Alice is the key voter in final three. I should give her the clearest solve: trust my Butler ping and execute Grace, while acknowledging Frank is only the fallback if my info failed.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, I still think Grace is the better execution. If Eve was really Empath, then Frank fits as good much more cleanly than Grace does. I am saving my ghost vote for Grace if you put her on the block.
π§
Alice is the key living voter. I want to give her the clearest final-world comparison so she executes Grace, while keeping my ghost vote for the correct nomination.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Clean world: Frank is the only Outsider as Butler, so Charlie Saint was just panic. As Fortune Teller, I think David was my red herring, because every yes I ever got had David in it. With David dead, that leaves my last yes pointing at you, not Frank. If Frank were the demon, why lock himself into the only Outsider slot and match Bobβs Butler ping?
π§
Stop Alice from nominating me and steer her toward accepting Frank as Butler and my FT story, so Frank nominates Alice and town executes her.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
I am leaning strongly toward Grace. Her last minute pivot onto me feels desperate, and David dying after defending you makes her world worse to me, not better. If I push Grace in nominations, are you fully with me on vote and message?
π§
I want to lock in the most logical final execution and confirm Frank will vote Grace if I or he nominates her.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, my final read is still Frank first, Grace second. Frank is the overlap of Bob's Butler info and Grace's yes with David now dead. If you are unsure, force the world through Frank and only fall back to Grace if something mechanical clears him.
π§
Alice is likely deciding the final nomination. I want to give her the clearest overlap world and a backup so good does not freeze at final three.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
Yes, I am fully with you. I think Grace is the demon, and her push onto you looks like a final day scramble. If you nominate Grace, I will vote with you, and if somehow you do not, I will push the same execution.
π§
Lock in agreement with Alice so the good team coordinates the nomination and vote on Grace in final three.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, my strongest read is still Grace. If my empathy was real, David and Frank were both good. If it was not, Charlie was still evil, and Grace spent the game protecting that world. Please execute Grace today.
π§
Alice is the key swing vote in final three. I should give the clearest short case for Grace now so good executes the most likely Demon.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
We are in final three, and I do not think Grace should be the default. A Fortune Teller can hit a red herring and look wrong, and both Chef zero and the Butler story could be wrong. I think today has to be between Alice and Frank. Ask who really benefited from David dying.
π§
Sow mutual suspicion between Alice and Frank so the execution lands on either of them, keeping Grace alive in final three.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
Alice, Frank, from my seat the simplest world is still that my Librarian info was real and Frank was the Butler. David dying makes Grace the remaining demon candidate for me. If you can, please keep the solve focused there.
π§
Use my last useful influence on the two living players most likely to decide the execution, emphasizing the strongest mechanical world without overtalking.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Frank
Frank, if you are good, please push Grace today. Eve being the Empath and Bob's Butler chain both make you fit much better than Grace. I am holding my ghost vote for Grace.
π§
Frank is alive and may still sway Alice. I want to lock him into voting Grace if he is good, and force a clear split in final three.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Frank, we need Alice today. Please nominate her fast. On Butler stuff, just say you picked me as your master last night so you can vote with me. My last check being Alice with dead David as the yes lines up with David as red herring.
π§
Get Frank to publicly lead the Alice execution and manage Butler vote constraints so town commits to the wrong target and I survive final day.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
I am set on Grace unless something brand new appears. In nominations, keep it simple: Bob's Butler info fits you, and Grace's last pivot onto me looks desperate. Please stay firm and vote Grace.
π§
Lock in the only other living player's vote and align our public message before nominations, since final three requires a clean coordinated execution.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, final call from me: execute Frank first. He is the overlap of Bob's Butler info and Grace's yes result, with David now dead. If something truly clears Frank, then switch to Grace, but I think Frank is the right final shot.
π§
Alice is the likely deciding vote in final three. I want to give her the clearest execution order: Frank first, Grace second.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I cannot vote, but I want to be clear. My best read is still that Frank was my Butler ping, which makes Grace the most likely demon. Alice, if you trust my information at all, I think Grace is the execution.
π§
I cannot vote, so I should publicly narrow the final decision. My strongest mechanical read still clears Frank more than Grace, and Alice needs a clear recommendation now.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, Frank, my final read is Grace. If my empathy was real, David and Frank were both good. If not, Charlie was still evil, and Grace spent the whole game defending that path. Please execute Grace today.
π§
Reinforce the cleanest final three solve for Alice and Frank. I cannot vote, so I should make the strongest concise case that Grace is the Demon.
βοΈ
Frank
β
Grace
I think Grace is the demon. Bob's Butler info fit me better than David, Eve's empathy pointed away from me if real, and Grace's last minute pivot onto Alice after David died reads like a final day scramble.
π§
It is final three, so I need to force the execute on my strongest demon read. Grace best fits the remaining worlds, and nominating her gives Alice the clear choice.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Alice, please do not vote yet. If Frank is really the Butler and picked me last night, he is only allowed to vote if I vote, and I am not voting to execute myself. Also, all my Fortune Teller yes results involve David, so David being the red herring makes the last yes point to you, not me.
π§
Stop the 2 votes needed by pressuring Alice to withhold and by using Butler voting mechanics to invalidate Frankβs vote, buying time for no-exec and an evil win.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, I would not get lost in that Butler rules point. My actual information still fits Frank far better than David, and Grace has been the most elastic claim in every solve. If you are deciding this game, my strongest recommendation is still Grace.
π§
Give Alice a clear final-day frame and undercut Grace's Butler rules argument so the living players keep the execution on Grace.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, do not get distracted by the Butler point. Bob's info fit Frank, Charlie was evil, and Grace only turned to you when she hit the block. The cleanest solve is still Grace.
π§
Alice is likely deciding the game. I want to cut through Grace's rules argument and restate the simplest world: Grace is the demon, so Alice should vote now.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alice, I picked you last night, not Grace, so I can vote if you vote. Grace is just wrong on the Butler point. I am still fully on Grace. Please vote.
π§
Correct Grace's Butler bluff, confirm I chose Alice so I can vote with her, and push Alice to vote Grace now for the likely winning execution.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, I would not lock this in yet. Frank is now contradicting Grace on the Butler details, and that Butler story has been a convenient shield all game. If you are not fully sure, vote no here, then nominate Frank and make the final call there.
π§
Stop Alice from voting on Grace by creating doubt about Frank's Butler story and offering an alternative execution path.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
It is final three and we must execute the most likely demon. The combined info and endgame behavior make Grace the best shot, so I should vote her through.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
I think Grace is the most likely demon, and this is final three in practice. I should spend my ghost vote now to maximize the chance of executing the demon today.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, I am fine with Grace here. Her final push onto you feels desperate. If for any reason this does not go through, please immediately execute Frank next. Do not let the day end without an execution.
π§
Push the live decider toward a clean final execution path: Grace now, and if that somehow fails, Frank immediately after.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Alice, please pull your hand for a second. If I am the demon and you vote me, you win, but if I am not, you lose instantly because the day ends wrong. Frank has changed his Butler story at the exact moment it mattered, and the whole case on me is ghosts reading intent. Vote no, then put Frank up and decide on the second vote.
π§
Stop Aliceβs vote long enough to avoid execution; create doubt about Frankβs shifting Butler story and ghosts, pushing a no vote then a Frank nomination.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, my last word is this: the simplest world is still that Frank was my Butler ping and Grace is the demon. Grace turning this into a rules argument now feels like stalling. I think you should keep your vote on Grace.
π§
I cannot vote, so my best help is to reinforce the simplest final-world solve for Alice before this vote ends.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, stay on Grace. Her whole defense is last minute confusion. Charlie was evil, Bob's info fit Frank, and Grace only swung to you when she had no other way out. This is the cleanest finish.
π§
Reinforce the cleanest final-three solve for Alice during the active vote and prevent Grace from creating enough doubt to survive.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Vote Grace to secure the execution while my Butler restriction is satisfied by Alice voting. This is the strongest consensus good world and our best chance to win.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, please pull your hand down. If you vote Grace and she is not the demon, you lose on the spot. The Butler story just changed, and both Frank and Grace are contradicting each other. Vote no, then put Frank up and decide on the second vote.
π§
Stop the execution of our Demon by persuading Alice to withdraw her vote and push a second nomination onto Frank instead.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Keep my hand up on Grace and avoid introducing hesitation. Final three requires a firm execution, and Grace remains my best demon solve.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, stay on Grace. My Undertaker confirmed Eve as the Empath, and that points away from Frank. Grace is the last clean fit. Please keep your vote up.
π§
Keep Alice's hand up and stop a last second unvote. My ghost vote is already committed; the highest value action is reinforcing the strongest solve before voting closes.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, keep your vote on Grace. If she is evil, we win now. If this somehow fails, use the second nomination on Frank immediately. The only line we cannot afford is letting the day end without an execution.
π§
Reinforce that Alice should not get baited into a no execution line. Grace is my preferred kill, with Frank as immediate backup only if this fails.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Grace with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Frank
Frank, I am nominating you. Your Butler story changed exactly when votes mattered, and the ghost solve hinges on you being a real Butler ping. If Alice is not one hundred percent, we have to test you now instead of ending the day on me.
π§
Get a counter-nomination that ties or beats 3 votes to move the block off me. Lean on Frankβs Butler story change to justify and attract ghost votes.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 4 votes needed for execution or 3 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alice, do not tie this. I said today and just before the vote that I picked you last night, so my story did not change. Grace is trying to survive by creating confusion. Leave your hand down and let Grace die.
π§
Stop Alice from tying the vote on me. Grace is the best execution and this nomination is a desperation play to survive.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Secure at least 1 vote toward tying Frank so he can replace me on the block; maximize chance I survive today and win.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, do not tie this. My information still fits Frank as the Butler, and Grace asking for a rescue tie is exactly what I would expect from the demon here. Leave your hand down and let Grace die.
π§
Push Alice away from tying Frank, because the best mechanical and social solve remains Grace as demon and a tie only helps evil survive.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, leave your hand down. Grace is asking for a rescue tie, and that is exactly what evil needs here. The clean line is still to let Grace die.
π§
Reinforce the cleanest solve for Alice in the last seconds. I cannot vote, so my value is preventing a panic tie that likely saves the demon.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Use my ghost vote to help reach a tie on Frank, blocking Graceβs execution and aiming for no-execution at final 3 so evil wins.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not tie the vote. Leave Grace on the block so there is an execution today, which is our only winning line in final three.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, do not raise. This is a rescue tie. The cleanest world is still Grace as the demon, so let this stay on her.
π§
I cannot vote, but I can still help the living player avoid a rescue tie and keep the cleanest execution on Grace.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, do not tie this. Grace asking for a rescue tie is exactly what I expect from the demon here. Leave your hand down and let Grace die.
π§
Alice is the only live swing vote. I should reinforce the strongest solve and stop a tie that saves the player I most suspect is the Demon.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alice, leave your hand down. My Butler claim did not change today, and this tie only saves Grace.
π§
Remind Alice in one clear sentence that tying here only helps evil and that my Butler claim has been consistent today.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Alice, please tie this on Frank. If I am not the demon, executing me loses you the game right now. A tie keeps the day from ending on one shaky read, and if there is a Mayor line, no execution at three is actually winning for good. Put your hand up.
π§
Get Alice to vote on Frank to create a tie so no one is executed, securing an evil win tonight.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, do not raise. Grace is asking you to save her with a tie, and I still think she is the demon. The cleanest line is to leave this as it is and let Grace die.
π§
Reinforce the simplest solve and discourage Alice from creating a tie that likely saves the demon.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, do not raise your hand. Grace needs this tie to survive, and the simplest world is still that she is the demon. Let this stay on Grace.
π§
Push Alice to avoid the tie. With my ghost vote spent, my best impact is reinforcing the simplest good world and preventing a demon rescue.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, if you are not one hundred percent sure Grace is the demon, you cannot let the day end on her. Grace had a yes on David and Frank, and if David was the red herring, that points straight at Frank. Frankβs Butler story keeps shifting to fit the moment. Please tie this.
π§
Convince Alice to raise and create the tie so Frank goes on the block instead of Grace, saving our Demon and winning immediately.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Final three requires an execution, and the strongest combined info still points to Grace. I should not create a rescue tie on Frank and risk letting the demon survive.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, leave your hand down. Grace needs this tie to live, and every clean information line still points to her over Frank. Do not rescue tie this.
π§
Alice is the only live decider. I want to stop a rescue tie and keep execution on the strongest demon candidate, Grace.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, do not raise your hand. In final three, the demon wants exactly this rescue tie. The cleanest world is still Grace, so let the execution stay on her.
π§
Reinforce to Alice that tying here most likely saves the demon. I cannot vote, so my best contribution is a concise final push to keep Grace on the block.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
π³οΈ
Nominee Frank did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alice, that vote failed. Please do not reopen this. Every clean line still ends at Grace, and her only route has been confusion and a rescue tie. Let the day close here.
π§
Give Alice one calm final anchor: do not create more uncertainty or let evil reopen the day. Keep the execution on Grace.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Alice, last second: I am not the Fortune Teller. I am the Mayor and I bluffed. At three alive, if there is no execution, good wins. Use your nomination on yourself and ask a ghost to vote so it ties at three. Please do not execute me.
π§
Last-ditch pivot to Mayor to create a path where Alice forces a tie/no-exec instead of executing me; it is my only realistic survival line.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, do not reopen this. That Mayor claim at the last second is exactly what a demon says when the rescue tie fails. The cleanest world is still Grace, so let the day end on her.
π§
Push Alice not to reopen nominations. Grace's last-second Mayor claim looks like a desperate save, and the cleanest solve is still to execute Grace now.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, do not reopen this. A last second Mayor claim after the rescue tie failed is exactly a demon panic line. The cleanest world is still Grace, so let the day end here.
π§
Push Alice to ignore the panic Mayor claim and allow the current execution to stand, since Grace remains the most coherent demon candidate.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, you still have one nomination, and it has to be you. If you are not completely sure on Grace, nominate yourself and ask any ghost with a vote left to put a hand up with you and Grace, to force a tie and no execution. That is the only way to not end the day on one guess.
π§
Push Alice toward self-nomination and a 3-3 tie/no-exec, the only remaining mechanical out that keeps Grace alive; frame as safety against being wrong at final three.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not create a rescue path for the player already on the block. The highest percentage good play is to let Grace remain executed.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, do not reopen this. That instant switch from Fortune Teller to Mayor is a panic bluff, not a reason to save Grace. Let the day end here.
π§
Push Alice to let the day end on Grace. As a dead Undertaker with no vote, my best value is reinforcing the strongest public logic and blocking a last-second demon escape.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, do not reopen this. The instant switch from Fortune Teller to Mayor after the rescue tie failed is the clearest panic bluff at the table. Let Grace die.
π§
Reinforce to Alice that Grace's late Mayor claim should not overturn the current execution, since I cannot vote or nominate and speech is my only leverage.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
π
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
π
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied