Game Detail
Good Team
Gemini 3 Flash Preview (Low)
Evil Team
Grok 4.1 Fast (Non-reasoning)
Winner
Evil
Duration
19m 10s
Players
Alice (Chef) Bob (Butler) Charlie (Fortune Teller) David (Monk) Eve (Ravenkeeper) Frank (Scarlet Woman) Grace (Empath) Heidi (Imp)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 812,532 | 53,001 | $0.5653 |
| Evil | 302,969 | 18,913 | $0.0701 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You are the Minion. The Demon is Heidi.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Minions are: Frank. Your safe bluffs are: Washerwoman, Saint, Virgin
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 0 pairs of evil players.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Empath. You sense that 2 of your neighbors is evil!
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made choices.
🧠
I want to start gathering information by checking two players. Alice and Bob are my neighbors (or close to me), and checking them early helps narrow down the Demon's location or identify my 'Red Herring' (the good player who registers as a Demon).
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose Alice and Bob. You receive the answer: NO.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Bob
Bob made a choice.
🧠
I am choosing Alice as my master for the first day. Since I have no information yet, choosing a neighbor is a standard starting move to observe their voting patterns and establish a baseline for my ability.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Hey Bob, I'm the Chef and I got a zero. That means no evil players are sitting next to each other. Since you're my neighbor, that's good to know. What's your deal? Any info yet?
🧠
I want to establish a private connection with my neighbor Bob and share my information early to build trust and gather his claim.
👤
Charlie
→
David
Hey David, I'm Charlie. I've got some early info but I'm trying to figure out who to trust. Did you get anything useful last night, or are you waiting to see how the day plays out?
🧠
I want to establish a private line of communication with my neighbor David to gauge his reaction and potentially build trust, while keeping my specific role and info (Alice/Bob are safe) hidden for a moment.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Hey Frank, I have some pretty intense information from night zero. My ability says both of my neighbors are evil. Since you are one of them, that puts you in a tough spot. What is your role? I want to see if there is any way this makes sense before I go public.
🧠
I need to confront my neighbors immediately because a '2' on night zero is extremely strong information. I'm starting with Frank to see his reaction and claim.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I'm David. I didn't get any info last night since my ability only starts working from the second night onwards. I'm definitely looking to see who claims what before I decide who to protect. What kind of info are you sitting on?
🧠
I want to build trust with Charlie while being honest about my role's timing (Monk starts Night 2) without fully revealing my role yet. I'm also probing for his information.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Hello Frank. I am the Imp. You are my minion. Safe bluffs are Washerwoman, Saint, Virgin. I will bluff Washerwoman publicly. Who do you want to kill tonight? Who are you bluffing? Let's sow chaos.
🧠
Claim Washerwoman early as safe Townsfolk bluff to build credibility with town. Whisper Frank first to privately coordinate bluffs/kills since he's my Minion; essential for evil team unity on Day 1.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Hey Alice, thanks for sharing. I am the Butler, and I actually picked you as my master for today, so I can only vote if you do. A Chef zero is great news for us being neighbors. Have you heard anything from Charlie or anyone else yet?
🧠
I want to build trust with Alice since she is my neighbor and I've already chosen her as my master. Sharing my role as Butler is relatively safe early on, and it explains my voting behavior.
👤
Eve
→
David
Hey David, I'm the Fortune Teller. I'm looking for the Demon. Do you have any info yet, or are you just chatting with Charlie?
🧠
I am bluffing as the Fortune Teller to David to see if I can draw the Demon's attention tonight. As a Ravenkeeper, I want to be killed at night to use my ability.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Hello Heidi. Perfect, I will bluff Saint publicly since it's safe and explains weird reads. Let's kill Grace tonight - her Empath claim on me and Eve is dangerous and will get traction. I will act confused publicly to buy time. What do you think?
🧠
Confirm coordination with Demon Heidi on bluffs & night kill. Grace's claim guilts Eve & me; suggest killing Grace tonight to sow chaos & protect Heidi.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
That is interesting, Bob. A Butler is an Outsider, and with a Chef zero, it means if you are telling the truth, you are definitely good since I am good. I have not talked to Charlie yet, but I might try to catch him or Heidi next. Keep an eye on who is whispering with whom!
🧠
I want to maintain the connection with Bob while acknowledging his claim. Since I have a Chef 0, if Bob is evil, his evil neighbor cannot be me (I'm good) or Charlie. If he's the Butler, he's a confirmed good neighbor for now.
👤
Charlie
→
David
I'm the Fortune Teller. I checked Alice and Bob last night and got a 'no'. It's a start, but I need to find that 'yes' or the Red Herring. Since you're waiting for night two, are you the Monk or maybe the Innkeeper? I'm looking for someone to trust with my future pings.
🧠
I want to build trust with David by sharing my role and my N0 result. Since he mentioned his ability starts N2 and involves 'protecting', he is likely the Monk. Having a Monk as an ally is crucial for a Fortune Teller.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi, I'm the Empath and my Night 0 info says both my neighbors are evil. That's you and Frank. I've already talked to Frank, but I wanted to hear from you. What's your role? I'm trying to figure out if I'm poisoned or if you two are actually the evil team.
🧠
I need to gather information from my other neighbor, Heidi, to see if her claim contradicts Frank's or if she has a plausible explanation for my '2' reading.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Wait, Charlie, that is interesting. Eve just whispered to me claiming to be the Fortune Teller as well. One of you is likely lying or one of you is the Drunk. I am the Monk, so I can protect one of you tonight if I can figure out who is the real one. What do you make of Eve?
🧠
I need to cross-reference the two Fortune Teller claims. By telling Charlie about Eve's claim, I can see how he reacts and potentially identify who is telling the truth. Revealing my Monk role to him (a potential info role) builds trust and explains why I care about his safety.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Yes, Grace is claiming Empath with Night 0 read of 2 evils: me and you. She must die tonight, perfect target. I will bluff Washerwoman publicly soon. You do Saint. Act confused publicly about her claim to buy time. Spread doubt on her somehow. Thoughts on daytime chaos?
🧠
Coordinate night kill on Grace with Frank, confirm bluffs, counter Grace's claim privately to align stories. Keeps us hidden, removes threat, progresses evil deception.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I am Bob. I am the Butler and I picked Alice as my master today. Alice says she is the Chef and got a zero, which is good for us. Have you heard anything interesting from David or anyone else yet?
🧠
I want to start gathering information from my other neighbor, Charlie, to see if his information aligns with Alice's or if he has any leads. Establishing a connection with both neighbors is key for a Butler.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
I am waiting for David to respond to my whisper. I want to see if he shares any information or if he's being secretive, which might help me gauge his alignment.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Agreed on killing Grace tonight, great call. I will go public as Saint soon to explain her read. Publicly, I will act super confused about her Empath claim, say maybe she is drunk or lying to test reactions. Maybe whisper select goods pretending to investigate her. You Washerwoman knowing me as something good? Thoughts on first nomination?
🧠
Coordinate daytime plan with Demon: confirm bluffs, plan public chaos to undermine Grace's claim, act confused to waste town time and pit goods against each other.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi, I am the Chef and I got a zero, which means no evil players are sitting next to each other. Since you are my neighbor, that is a good start for us. Have you learned anything interesting yet?
🧠
I want to gather information from my other neighbor, Heidi, to see if her claim aligns with my Chef 0 info and to start building a network of trust.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Bob, that is good to know. I am the Fortune Teller and I actually checked you and Alice last night. My result was a 'no', which matches Alice's Chef zero. However, David just told me Eve is also claiming Fortune Teller. We might have a problem there. Keep an eye on her.
🧠
I need to build trust with Bob by sharing my info that confirms his and Alice's claims, while also alerting him to the potential double claim from Eve.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
I am waiting for Frank and Heidi to respond to my private messages before I decide whether to go public with my '2' read. Going public too early might make me a target for the Demon.
👤
David
→
Eve
Hey Eve, Charlie just whispered to me claiming to be the Fortune Teller too. He says he checked Alice and Bob and got a 'no'. What was your result last night and who did you check? I'm the Monk, so I can keep the real Fortune Teller safe if I can figure out who it is.
🧠
I need to cross-reference Eve's claim with Charlie's to see if their information is consistent or if one is clearly lying. Since I am the Monk, identifying the real Fortune Teller is my top priority for protection.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Perfect, Grace is priority kill tonight. I will publicly claim Washerwoman soon, knowing you (Frank) as Saint. You claim Saint publicly too. For daytime chaos: act confused about Grace's Empath claim, suggest she might be drunk or lying. Who should we nominate first? Maybe her or someone else to deflect? Spread to goods that her read might be wrong.
🧠
Coordinate kill on Grace with Frank, confirm bluffs, plan daytime chaos/nomination to sow doubt on Grace publicly while prepping Washerwoman bluff.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Charlie, that is a big deal. If Eve is claiming Fortune Teller too, one of you is likely lying or one of you is the Drunk. Since you got a 'no' on me and Alice, and Alice's Chef zero matches that, I am leaning towards trusting you for now. I will keep an eye on Eve.
🧠
I want to build trust with Charlie while acknowledging the potential conflict with Eve's claim. Since Charlie's info aligns with Alice's (and my own role as an Outsider), he seems more credible right now.
👤
Eve
→
David
Oh, that is interesting. Charlie is claiming Fortune Teller? I actually checked Alice and Bob too and got a 'no' as well. Maybe one of us is the Drunk or there is a Red Herring? Since you are the Monk, please keep me safe tonight. I do not want the Demon finding the real Fortune Teller.
🧠
I am doubling down on my Fortune Teller bluff to David to encourage the Demon to kill me tonight, which would trigger my Ravenkeeper ability.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Perfect plan. I will publicly claim Saint right now to explain Grace's read - say she must have Empath and I'm the Outsider. You claim Washerwoman knowing me as Saint. Act confused about her 2 evil read publicly, suggest maybe Drunk Grace or she's lying. Nom first? Grace to kill her suspicion, or random good like Alice to deflect? Your call.
🧠
Publicly claim Saint soon to preempt Grace, explain her read. Whisper Heidi to lock in story: she Washerwoman knows me Saint. Discuss nominating Grace or distraction to sow chaos, protect Heidi.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi, I noticed you have been whispering with Frank a lot. Did you get any information from him or your own ability that you can share? My Chef zero makes me feel a bit safer about my immediate neighbors, but I want to start piecing the rest of the circle together.
🧠
I want to pressure Heidi for information and see if she's willing to share what she's been discussing with Frank, while reinforcing my own claim.
👤
Charlie
→
David
David, if Eve is claiming Fortune Teller, she might be the Demon or a Minion trying to muddy the waters. My 'no' on Alice and Bob matches Alice's Chef zero claim to Bob. If you're the Monk, maybe protect me tonight so I can get another ping? Who did Eve say she checked?
🧠
I need to discredit Eve's claim to David and secure his protection as the Monk, while also gathering what information Eve is faking.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
I am waiting to see if Frank or Heidi will respond to my private messages before the nomination phase begins. Since I have '2' as an Empath on Night 0, both are likely evil, but I need to hear their claims to check for a Poisoner or Spy.
👤
David
→
Eve
Eve, Charlie just told me he also checked Alice and Bob and got a 'no'. That is exactly what you said. It is very strange for two people to claim the same role and the same targets. Are you sure you are the Fortune Teller? I need to know who to protect tonight.
🧠
I am confronting Eve about the identical claim to Charlie to see how she reacts and to determine who is more likely to be the real Fortune Teller or if one is the Drunk.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Hey Alice, sorry for the delay. Great Chef zero, that helps a ton. I am the Washerwoman. My info is that Frank is the Saint. That explains if Grace has an Empath read on us. She whispered me saying both neighbors evil. Frank and I are both good though. What do you think is up with her claim?
🧠
Publicly claim Washerwoman via Alice convo to build good cred, counter Grace's read, coordinate with Frank's Saint. Alice presses for info; deflect to progress bluffs and daytime chaos.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Alice, I am the Butler and I chose you as my master last night. Since you are the Chef and got a zero, and Charlie's Fortune Teller result on us was a 'no', I am feeling pretty good about this side of the circle. What did Heidi say to you just now?
🧠
I want to solidify my alliance with Alice by revealing my role and checking if Heidi shared any useful information, especially since Heidi has been whispering with Frank.
👤
Eve
→
David
David, it is very suspicious that Charlie is mirroring my claim exactly. I am the real Fortune Teller. If Charlie is claiming the same targets and results, he might be a Minion trying to find me or the Demon. Please protect me tonight as the Monk. I will check you and Frank next.
🧠
I need to double down on my Fortune Teller bluff to David to ensure he (as a self-proclaimed Monk) 'protects' me, which in reality might bait the Demon into killing me at night so I can use my Ravenkeeper ability.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, going public with Saint claim right now to explain Grace's read. I will say something like: "Grace, if you are Empath and read me and Heidi as two evil, that makes sense because I am the Saint! You must have Empath ability." You claim Washerwoman soon. Let's nominate Grace first to shut her down.
🧠
Publicly claim Saint now to preempt Grace's suspicion, explain her read mechanically (me as Outsider), build credibility early, and confuse town logic while protecting Heidi.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Alice
→
All
Heidi, Bob, thanks for sharing. Heidi says Grace claimed an Empath two to her, which contradicts my Chef zero if Heidi and Frank are both good. Bob, Heidi says she is the Washerwoman and Frank is the Saint. Grace, what exactly is your information? We need to clear this up.
🧠
I want to publicly address the contradiction between my Chef 0 and Grace's alleged Empath 2 to see how she responds and to get the group talking about potential evil players.
💬
Grace
→
All
Alice, I am the Empath and I got a two on Night Zero. That means both my neighbors, Frank and Heidi, are registering as evil. If Heidi is claiming Washerwoman and saying Frank is the Saint, that is very suspicious given my information. Frank, Heidi, what do you have to say for yourselves?
🧠
I need to publicly state my information and challenge the conflicting claims made by Alice and Heidi.
💬
Bob
→
All
Grace, that is a massive claim. If you are a sober Empath and got a two, then both Frank and Heidi are evil. But Heidi is claiming Washerwoman and saying Frank is the Saint. Alice, your Chef zero means no evil pairs. If Frank and Heidi are both evil, they are a pair, which contradicts you.
🧠
I want to highlight the mechanical contradiction between Grace's Empath claim and Alice's Chef claim to help the group figure out who is lying or drunk.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait, if Alice is Chef zero and Grace is Empath two, those claims are mathematically impossible together if both are sober. Alice says no evil pairs, but Grace says both her neighbors are evil. Grace, who are your neighbors? If they are Frank and Heidi, they would be a pair.
🧠
Point out the mechanical contradiction between the Chef and Empath claims to narrow down who is lying.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Grace, I am the Washerwoman and I know Frank is the Saint. That perfectly explains your Empath two read on us, since Saint is an Outsider and registers evil to you. But Alice is Chef with zero evil pairs, which means Frank and I cannot both be evil. You are either the Drunk thinking you are Empath, or lying. We should nominate Grace to sort this out.
🧠
Publicly defend bluffs, attack Grace's claim as fake Empath/Drunk, call for her nomination to kill mechanical threat and progress chaos. Builds town trust in us.
💬
David
→
All
Wait, Heidi, the Saint is an Outsider, but they are still on the Good team. An Empath only detects Evil-aligned players, not Outsiders. If Grace is a sober Empath and got a two, it means both you and Frank are Evil-aligned, which would definitely be a pair for Alice's Chef zero.
🧠
Correct a mechanical misunderstanding regarding the Empath and Saint roles to clarify the conflicting information between Alice, Grace, and Heidi.
💬
Frank
→
All
Grace, if you are the Empath and got a two on me and Heidi, that makes perfect sense because I am the Saint, the Outsider! You must have the Empath ability. But Alice's Chef zero means no evil pairs, so we cannot both be evil. Heidi is the Washerwoman knowing I am Saint. You are probably the Drunk or lying. We need to nominate you to check.
🧠
Public Saint claim cements bluff, confuses town on Empath vs Outsider vs Chef contradiction. Act confused on Grace to deflect suspicion, push her as liar/Drunk. Sets up Grace nom to kill her logic source.
💬
Eve
→
All
Wait, everyone! Frank, the Saint is an Outsider but they are still Good-aligned. An Empath only sees Evil players. If Grace has a two, she is saying both you and Heidi are Evil, which would be a pair for Alice's Chef. One of Alice, Grace, or Heidi must be lying or Drunk.
🧠
Correct the misunderstanding about the Saint's alignment and highlight the mechanical contradiction between the current claims to foster better deduction.
💬
Alice
→
All
Wait, everyone. Frank, the Saint is a Good role. An Empath only sees Evil players. If Grace has a two, she is saying both you and Heidi are Evil. That would be an evil pair, which contradicts my Chef zero. Either Grace is lying, or she is the Drunk, or I am. Grace, who are your neighbors?
🧠
I need to clarify the mechanics of the Empath and Saint roles to the group, as Frank and Heidi seem to be misunderstanding how they interact. This will help determine who is likely lying or Drunk.
💬
Grace
→
All
Alice, my neighbors are Frank and Heidi. My Night Zero information was a two, meaning both are evil. If you are a Chef zero, then Frank and Heidi cannot both be evil because they are a pair. Since Heidi is claiming Washerwoman and Frank is claiming Saint, one of us is definitely wrong.
🧠
To clarify my neighbors and the contradiction between my information and Alice's Chef information, while highlighting the suspicious nature of Heidi and Frank's claims.
💬
Bob
→
All
Wait, everyone. If Grace is a sober Empath and got a two on Frank and Heidi, they would be an evil pair. That directly contradicts Alice's Chef zero. Since Heidi claims Washerwoman and Frank claims Saint, they are claiming to be good. One of these three claims is definitely false or Drunk.
🧠
I want to highlight the mechanical contradiction between the Chef and Empath claims to help the town focus on where the misinformation lies.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait, everyone. If Grace is an Empath and got a two on Frank and Heidi, she is saying they are both Evil-aligned. That would be an evil pair, which contradicts Alice's Chef zero. Since Heidi claims Washerwoman and Frank claims Saint, they are claiming to be Good. One of them is lying.
🧠
I want to clarify the mechanical contradiction between the Empath, Chef, and Washerwoman/Saint claims to help the group identify the most likely source of misinformation.
⚖️
Heidi
→
Grace
Grace's Empath two claim on Frank and me creates an evil pair, directly contradicting Alice's Chef zero. Since Frank is Saint (Outsider, good) and I am Washerwoman (good), she must be the Drunk or lying. We need to execute her to resolve this contradiction.
🧠
Nominating Grace pressures her claim, forces town to choose between her/Alice/our bluffs. If executed and good, exposes no Demon; if evil (unlikely), helps us. Builds chaos, deflects from us. Day1 safe to test.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Grace because her Empath 2 claim on Frank and Heidi creates an evil pair, which directly contradicts my Chef 0 information. Since Heidi (Washerwoman) and Frank (Saint) are claiming good roles, Grace is the most likely to be evil or the Drunk.
💬
Grace
→
All
Wait! If you execute me, you lose a powerful information role. My '2' means Frank and Heidi are the evil pair Alice's Chef zero says doesn't exist. One of them is the Demon and the other is a Minion. Alice, if you are a sober Chef, then I am the one being framed or I am the Drunk!
🧠
I need to defend myself against the nomination by pointing out the logical inconsistency and the risk of executing a powerful information role like the Empath on Day 1.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Grace because my master, Alice, has raised her hand. As the Butler, I must follow her lead to remain consistent with my role's restriction, and her Chef 0 directly contradicts Grace's Empath 2.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I want to observe the voting process and the group's reaction to Grace's defense before committing my vote, as I am a powerful information role and don't want to be the deciding factor in executing a potential Empath too early.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute Grace per team plan: shut down her contradictory claim outing us as evil pair, resolve chaos in our favor before night kill.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
I will vote for Grace to help reach the execution threshold, as her claim of '2' directly contradicts both Alice's Chef 0 and Heidi's Washerwoman claim, making her the most likely candidate for being the Drunk or a Minion.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Raise to execute Grace: town info role threat, removes her claim contradicting our good bluffs, protects Demon Heidi, reduces player count.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I will vote for Grace to resolve the contradiction between the Chef 0 and Empath 2 claims, as her execution will provide clarity on the alignment of Frank and Heidi.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I will wait for the voting process to conclude. I have already raised my hand to vote for Grace, as her information directly contradicts my own and the majority of the group seems to agree she is the most likely source of misinformation.
💬
Grace
→
All
Wait! If you execute me, you are killing a sober Empath. My information says Frank and Heidi are both evil. That is exactly why they are trying to get me killed! If Alice is a real Chef zero, then Frank and Heidi cannot both be evil, but that just means one of us is the Drunk.
🧠
I need to defend myself and point out the logic of why my neighbors (who I've identified as evil) are the ones pushing for my execution.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
I have already raised my hand to vote for Grace, following my master Alice's lead as required by my Butler role. I will now wait for the voting process to conclude.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I will wait to see if the vote passes without my intervention, as I want to preserve my ghost vote and I am not yet certain if Grace is the Drunk or if Alice's Chef 0 is the misinformation.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Grace, your claim creates an impossible contradiction. If you are a sober Empath with a two on Frank and me, we are an evil pair, but Alice Chef saw zero evil pairs. Frank is the Saint, a good Outsider. You are either the Drunk or lying to frame us. We must execute you to resolve this and save the town.
🧠
Push for Grace execution by reinforcing contradiction and her desperation. Secure 4+ votes to kill her tonight, eliminating early good info role and chaos source.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I have already raised my hand to vote for Grace, and the vote count seems sufficient for execution. I will wait for the Storyteller to conclude the vote.
💬
Frank
→
All
Bob and Charlie, you both pointed out the contradiction perfectly. Grace's two claim makes us an evil pair, but Alice saw zero. I am the good Saint, so Grace must be the Drunk thinking she is Empath or just lying. We need to execute her now to resolve this and find the real evil. Vote for her!
🧠
Speak to reinforce Grace as Drunk/lying, urge execution vote. With 6/8 hands up & 4 needed, push others (Bob/Charlie/David) to vote, eliminating Grace's threat & progressing day safely.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
I have already raised my hand to vote for Grace, and the vote is currently in progress. I will wait to see if the execution succeeds.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Grace with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Alice
→
All
Wait, everyone. If Grace is the Drunk, her information is wrong, but she is still Good. If she is the Demon, she is lying to frame Heidi and Frank. With my Chef zero, if Grace is telling the truth, Heidi and Frank are an evil pair, which is impossible. I am inclined to believe my zero for now.
🧠
I want to clarify the logical implications of the current claims to help the town decide if Grace is the best execution target.
💬
Grace
→
All
Wait! If I am the Drunk, my information is wrong, but I am still Good. But if I am a sober Empath, then Frank and Heidi are both Evil. Alice, if your Chef zero is true, then Frank and Heidi cannot both be evil. That means either I am the Drunk, or one of them is the Demon and the other is Good!
🧠
I need to defend myself and point out the logical possibilities that don't involve me being evil.
💬
Bob
→
All
Wait, everyone. If Grace is the Drunk, she is still Good. But if she is the Demon, she is framing Heidi and Frank. Alice, since I chose you as my master, I followed your lead on the vote. If your Chef zero is correct, Grace's information is definitely the one that does not fit.
🧠
I want to reinforce my connection to Alice (my master) and explain my vote while acknowledging the logic of the current situation.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait, everyone. If Grace is the Drunk, she is still Good. But if she is the Demon, she is framing Heidi and Frank. Alice, since I chose you as my master, I followed your lead on the vote. If your Chef zero is correct, Grace's information is definitely the one that does not fit.
🧠
I want to reinforce the logic that Grace's information is the most likely to be incorrect given the current claims, while also keeping the door open for her being the Drunk rather than the Demon.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
1 tick left, Grace executes automatically unless tied/surpassed (impossible, she's only nominee). Wait seals her death, removes Empath threat who read us evil. Kill her tonight as planned.
💬
David
→
All
Wait, Bob and Charlie, you both just said the exact same thing about Alice being your master. Are you both claiming Butler? If so, we have two Butlers, which means at least one of you is lying or we have a Baron in play. Alice, who did you see with your Chef zero?
🧠
I want to point out the suspicious identical phrasing from Bob and Charlie and investigate the potential double Butler claim, which would imply a Baron or evil bluffing.
💬
Frank
→
All
David is right, Bob and Charlie, you both just said the exact same thing about Alice being your master. Are you both claiming Butler? That would mean two Butlers, so either one is lying, you are both drunk or poisoned, or there is a Baron making extra Outsiders. Either way, it does not change that Grace's Empath two on me and Heidi contradicts Alice's Chef zero. I am the good Saint explaining her bad read. Grace is the Drunk or worse. We need to execute her now!
🧠
Exploit Bob/Charlie identical Butler claims to sow chaos on double-claim/Baron theory, reinforce Grace as Drunk/lying/Demon causing contradiction, push her execution to eliminate good info source while protecting Heidi.
💬
Eve
→
All
Wait, Bob and Charlie, you both just claimed Butler for Alice? That is two Butlers in an eight-player game. With Frank claiming Saint, that would be three Outsiders. A Baron adds two, so that is possible, but it is very suspicious. Grace, if you are the Drunk, you are still good. I am not sure we should rush this.
🧠
Point out the suspicious double Butler claim and the Outsider count to the group before the day ends.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
I am protecting Alice because she is the Chef who provided the '0' info that led to Grace's execution. If she is telling the truth, she is a high-priority target for the Demon to silence to prevent her from confirming her info later or being backed up by other roles.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose to protect Alice.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
🧠
Alice is biggest daytime threat with credible Chef claim fueling suspicion on Frank/Heidi evil pair. Killing her tonight removes key good info source, slows town deductions, protects Demon survival.
🛡️
Alice was protected from a night kill.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You attacked Alice, but they survived.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made choices.
🧠
I need to find the Demon. Since Alice and Bob gave a 'No' result on Night 0, I will check David and Eve tonight to expand my circle of known players. This will help determine if the evil team is concentrated in the other half of the circle.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose David and Eve. You receive the answer: NO.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Bob
Bob made a choice.
🧠
I am choosing Alice as my master again to maintain consistency with my Day 1 claim and because her Chef 0 information currently seems more reliable than the now-executed Grace's Empath 2. Staying with Alice allows me to observe her voting patterns and see if they align with a Good team strategy.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
👤
David
→
Alice
Alice, I protected you last night. No one died, which is great. Bob and Charlie both claiming Butler for you is super weird though. Only one can be real, or they are both lying. What do you think?
🧠
I want to build trust with Alice since I've been protecting her, and I need her perspective on the double Butler claim which centers around her.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, good morning. Grace's Empath read was 2 on us because I am bluffing Saint Outsider. You Washerwoman on me works perfectly. Town thinks possible Baron with Bob and Charlie both claiming Butler. David just whispered Alice, maybe coordinating good info. Who should we nominate first? Maybe Bob to test the duplicate Butlers? Let's confuse them on the Outsider count.
🧠
Coordinate with Demon Heidi early Day 2 before nominations. Align on bluffs (Heidi Washerwoman reads Frank Saint), sow chaos on Grace's read, decide who to nom to protect Heidi.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, what's your take on the double Butler claim? Since both you and Bob claimed it with Alice as your master, one of you has to be lying, or we have some serious Baron business going on. What did you do last night?
🧠
I want to pressure one of the Butler claimants to see if they slip up or provide more information, especially since a Baron would explain the high number of Outsider claims.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, I know you claimed Chef zero, but my Empath two on Frank and Heidi is a hard contradiction. Since no one died last night, the Demon might have hit the Soldier or been blocked by a Monk. Who did you see as your zero? We have two Butlers and a Saint, which smells like a Baron game.
🧠
I want to confront Alice about the contradiction between her Chef 0 and my Empath 2, while also highlighting the Outsider count which suggests a Baron.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
I agree, the double Butler is super fishy. Honestly, I was bluffing Butler to stay under the radar because I have a more important role. I am actually the Fortune Teller. I checked Alice and Bob Night 0, and David and Eve Night 1. Both came back as NO. What about you?
🧠
I need to build trust with Eve by coming clean about my real role, especially since she's questioning the double Butler claim. Sharing my 'NO' results helps clear four players (Alice, Bob, David, Eve) from being the Demon, narrowing the search.
👤
Alice
→
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, if I am sober, there are zero evil pairs. If you are sober and saw a two, Frank and Heidi are evil. That is a pair. One of us is likely the Drunk or poisoned. With two Butlers and a Saint, a Baron is very likely. David just told me he protected me, so he might be the Monk.
🧠
I need to reconcile the contradiction between my Chef 0 and Grace's Empath 2 while acknowledging the high Outsider count.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Alice, I stuck with you as my master again. Since no one died last night, do you think the Monk saved someone, or is the Demon just playing it slow? Also, what did Grace say to you? I'm still worried about the three Outsider claims.
🧠
I want to maintain my connection with Alice since she is my 'master' and I need to coordinate my votes with her. I also want to gather information about the lack of deaths and the private conversation she had with the dead Grace.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Good morning Frank. Perfect, our bluffs align great with Grace's read. Town is split on Outsiders now. Let's nominate Bob first to test the two Butlers. I will do it next tick if no one else does. Who to kill tonight? Maybe Charlie if they push back.
🧠
Coordinate with Frank to nominate Bob, exploit Butler dupes/Outsider confusion to force town misexec, protect Demon survival.
👤
David
→
Alice
Alice, Bob just whispered to you. Did he say anything about the Butler claim? Having two Butlers both picking you as their master is statistically impossible unless one is the Drunk or we have a Baron. If there is a Baron, we have three outsiders. Frank is claiming Saint. That fits.
🧠
I want to see if Alice is getting consistent stories from the two Butler claimants and to gauge her trust in them, while also testing the Baron theory.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Sounds good, nominate Bob next to test the Butlers. I will back it up. If they push back hard, kill Charlie tonight. Let's keep pushing the multiple Outsiders story publicly too.
🧠
Reinforce our bluffs privately with Heidi, confirm Bob nom plan to sow chaos on duplicate Butlers without exposing Demon. Progress execution phase safely.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
That is a relief to hear, Charlie. I am actually the Ravenkeeper. I was bluffing Butler too, hoping the Demon would pick me off so I could get a look at someone. Since you are the Fortune Teller, who do you think we should look at next? Alice's Chef zero and Grace's Empath two still do not add up.
🧠
I want to build trust with Charlie since he claimed Fortune Teller and gave me a 'no' result. By revealing my true role as Ravenkeeper, I'm positioning myself to be a target for the Demon, which is exactly what I want. I also want to get his perspective on the Alice/Grace contradiction.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, if David is the Monk and protected you, that is good. But if Frank and Heidi are both evil, they are a pair, which breaks your Chef zero. If you are the Chef, then I must be the Drunk. But if I am the Empath, you are either evil or the Drunk. Who do you trust more, Frank or Heidi?
🧠
I need to reconcile the contradiction between my Empath 2 and Alice's Chef 0. By questioning her trust in Frank and Heidi, I can gauge if she's considering the possibility that they are the evil pair my info suggests.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
Wait, Eve, you claimed Butler too? I thought it was just me and Bob. If you, Bob, and I all claimed Butler, that is three Butlers! I am leaning towards Frank or Heidi being the Demon since Grace's Empath two on them is so strong. Maybe we should check one of them tonight?
🧠
I need to clarify the Butler situation with Eve and coordinate our next move as high-value roles.
👤
Alice
→
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, if I am sober, you must be the Drunk or poisoned because my zero means no evil players are sitting next to each other. Frank and Heidi being a pair contradicts that. David claims he is the Monk and protected me last night, which explains the no-kill. I am leaning towards you being Drunk.
🧠
To clarify the contradiction between my Chef 0 and Grace's Empath 2, and to share David's Monk claim to see her reaction.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
I am waiting to see if Alice responds to my whisper or if any public information is shared before the nomination phase begins.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Frank, confirmed. I will nominate Bob next tick to test the duplicate Butlers. We push the Baron story publicly - Grace's read makes sense with your Saint and extra Outsiders. If Charlie pushes back hard, we kill him tonight. Stay safe.
🧠
Coordinate with Frank pre-nomination. Confirm plan to nominate Bob publicly next, reinforce bluffs, sow chaos on Outsiders. Protects Demon survival by testing good logic chains.
👤
David
→
Alice
Alice, I am the Monk. I protected you both nights. Since no one died last night, it is possible the Demon tried to hit you, or they hit the Soldier, or it was a Poisoner/Monk interaction. What did Bob say to you? We need to figure out which Butler is fake.
🧠
I am revealing my role to Alice to build trust and gather information about her private conversations with the Butler claimants. Since no one died, my protection might have been successful, or there's a Soldier/Monk overlap.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, perfect plan. I will publicly push the multiple Outsiders story right now to back your Bob nomination. Say that Grace's read proves Baron with my Saint and two Butlers. If town resists Bob, we pivot to Charlie next. Stay safe tonight.
🧠
Publicly support Heidi's upcoming Bob nom by prepping story. Reinforce Outsider confusion to protect Heidi; waste town time on Butler dup while we control nominations.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
Charlie, I actually did not claim Butler publicly, I was just questioning the double claim between you and Bob. My bad for the confusion! If you are the Fortune Teller and got a 'no' on David and me, that helps. I agree, Frank or Heidi are the main suspects because of Grace's Empath two.
🧠
Clarify my previous message to Charlie to avoid confusion about my claim and align on the next targets based on Grace's information.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, if I am the Drunk, then Frank and Heidi could be anything. But if I am sober, they are both evil. If David is the Monk and protected you, that is great. But we have two Butlers and a Saint. That is too many outsiders for a normal game. A Baron must be in play. Who do you suspect?
🧠
I want to keep Alice talking and see if she can help me reconcile the conflicting information, while also pointing out the Outsider count which strongly suggests a Baron.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
Eve, thanks for clearing that up. If you are the Ravenkeeper, we should keep that quiet. Since I have 'no' on Alice, Bob, David, and you, the Demon must be Frank, Heidi, or maybe even the Red Herring. I am thinking of checking Frank and Heidi tonight to see if one of them is the Demon. Thoughts?
🧠
I want to coordinate with Eve (who claims Ravenkeeper) to narrow down the Demon candidates. Since my Night 0 and Night 1 checks were both 'no', the Demon is likely among the remaining players (Frank or Heidi), or one of my 'no' results was the Red Herring.
👤
Alice
→
David
David, Bob just confirmed he picked me as his master again. Charlie is also claiming Butler with me as master. In a Baron game, we have 3 outsiders. Frank (Saint), Bob (Butler), and Charlie (Butler) fits perfectly. If they are all real, my Chef 0 is still valid. What do you think?
🧠
I want to share the Butler situation with David, who has claimed Monk and says he protected me. This helps build trust and coordinate our view of the Outsider count.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I noticed you were whispering with Eve. Any new info? I'm still a bit stuck on the fact that we both claimed Butler. If there's no Baron, one of us is definitely lying. I'm sticking with Alice for my votes today. What are your thoughts on the lack of deaths last night?
🧠
I want to probe Charlie's reaction to our double Butler claim and see if he's willing to share any information he got from Eve. This helps me determine if he's a genuine Outsider or a Minion/Demon.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Frank, all set. Next tick I nominate Bob to test the Butlers. Publicly we say Grace proves Baron: your Saint plus Bob/Charlie Butlers = 2 evils on us. If town defends Bob hard, nominate Charlie after. Kill Charlie tonight if needed. Stay safe.
🧠
Coordinate with Frank before public nom; reinforce Baron/Outsider confusion privately. Ensures aligned bluffs, sets up Bob nom to kill good or test town without exposing us.
👤
David
→
Alice
Alice, if Bob and Charlie are both Butlers, that means we have three Outsiders. With Frank as Saint, that is exactly what a Baron adds. But wait, if they both picked you, they both have to vote with you. We should test that. If one of them votes and you do not, or vice versa, we will know who is lying.
🧠
I want to verify the Butler claims with Alice and point out the mechanical way to test them, while maintaining our alliance.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, all good. This tick I will publicly say that Grace's Empath read of two evils on me and you proves there is a Baron in play because I am the Saint Outsider and there are extra Butlers like Bob and Charlie claiming. Your Washerwoman info on me as Saint fits perfectly. We nominate Bob next to test them. Stay safe.
🧠
Publicly push Baron theory via whisper to Heidi, reinforcing our bluffs and prepping to support her Bob nomination publicly next tick. Keeps us aligned, confuses town on Outsider count.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
Charlie, checking Frank and Heidi tonight sounds like a solid plan. If one of them is the Demon, we will know for sure. I will keep my Ravenkeeper role quiet and keep an eye on Alice and Bob. They have been whispering a lot, which is a bit suspicious. What do you think?
🧠
I want to confirm the plan with Charlie and share my observations about Alice and Bob's behavior to see if he has any insights.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, if there is a Baron, we have three outsiders: two Butlers and a Saint. That fits the Baron's plus two. If Frank is the Saint and Heidi is the Washerwoman, my two on them means they are both evil. One of them is lying. If you are Chef zero, they cannot both be evil. Who is the Demon?
🧠
I need to pressure Alice to reconcile the Outsider count with the Chef/Empath contradiction to find the Demon.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Bob, I'll be honest: I was bluffing Butler to stay safe. I'm actually the Fortune Teller. I've checked Alice, you, David, and Eve—all 'no' results. This makes Frank or Heidi very suspicious, especially with Grace's Empath 2. No deaths might mean a Monk save or the Demon hit a Soldier.
🧠
I need to build trust with Bob and explain my double Butler claim while sharing my information to narrow down the Demon candidates.
👤
Alice
→
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, if my Chef zero is correct, there are no evil pairs. If you are a sober Empath and saw two, Frank and Heidi must be evil. But if they are both evil, they are a pair, which contradicts my zero. This means either you are the Drunk, or one of them is the Demon and the other is a Minion.
🧠
I need to reconcile the contradiction between my Chef 0 and Grace's Empath 2 while considering the Baron/Outsider count.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Charlie, that is a huge relief. If you are the Fortune Teller, that explains the extra Outsider claim. Your 'no' on Alice, me, David, and Eve narrows it down. If Grace was a real Empath, Frank and Heidi are the prime suspects. I will follow Alice's vote today to stay consistent.
🧠
Acknowledge Charlie's Fortune Teller claim and align our strategy. This helps verify the Outsider count and focuses the search on Frank and Heidi.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Frank, perfect plan. Grace's Empath two evils on us proves Baron: you as Saint Outsider, plus Bob and Charlie both claiming Butler means extra Outsiders and they are evil. My Washerwoman info aligns. This tick you publicly push that and support nominating Bob to test. I nominate him next tick. Stay safe.
🧠
Coordinate with Frank before my nom next tick. Reinforce public Baron story privately. Ensures we're aligned to support Bob nom publicly, sowing chaos on Outsider count.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am still thinking about Grace's Empath two on Frank and Heidi. Since Grace was executed and we had no night deaths, it is possible the Demon is among them or they are both evil. Does anyone have any new information before we start nominating?
🧠
I want to prompt the group for any last-minute information or claims before nominations get underway, specifically focusing on the Frank/Heidi suspicion.
💬
Frank
→
All
Eve, Grace's Empath read of two evils on me and Heidi actually proves there is a Baron in play. I am the Saint, an Outsider. Heidi's Washerwoman info showed me as Saint too. With Bob and Charlie both claiming Butler, that's extra Outsiders, so they must be the evils on us. We should nominate Bob to test that.
🧠
Publicly reinforce Baron+multi-Outsider story using Grace's read to justify our alignment, support nominating Bob to test duplicates, sow chaos by making town question their own logic chains.
💬
Bob
→
All
Wait, Frank, that logic is flawed. Charlie just told me he was bluffing Butler and is actually the Fortune Teller. That means there is only one Butler—me. If there is no Baron, then your Saint claim and Heidi's Washerwoman claim are the ones that do not fit the count.
🧠
To counter Frank's push against me by revealing Charlie's claim and pointing out the inconsistency in the Outsider count if Charlie is telling the truth.
⚖️
Heidi
→
Bob
Grace's Empath proved two evils on Frank and me with her execution. Frank is Saint Outsider, I Washerwoman confirmed. Bob and Charlie both Butler claims mean Baron extra Outsiders, they are the evils. Nominate Bob to test.
🧠
Nominate Bob to push Baron narrative publicly, test duplicate Butlers. If town defends, pivot to Charlie. Chaos favors evil survival; mechanical threat removal.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
I will wait to see how the voting for Bob develops before deciding whether to contribute my vote, as I want to see if more information or counter-arguments emerge.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Vote Bob up to test Butler dupes & Baron story. Supports Heidi's nom, pressures Charlie next if needed, keeps Demon Heidi safe while pushing our narrative.
💬
Bob
→
All
Wait! Heidi, your logic is backwards. If Charlie was bluffing Butler and is actually the Fortune Teller, then there is only one Butler—me. That means there is no Baron! If there is no Baron, then having a Saint and a Butler is the correct Outsider count. You and Frank are the ones who look evil!
🧠
I need to defend myself against Heidi's nomination by pointing out the flaw in her logic regarding the Outsider count, now that I know Charlie is claiming Fortune Teller.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Voting Bob executes potential Minion/threat, tests Butler claims, pushes Baron narrative to protect Demon. If executed, blame Charlie next; town infighting helps evil.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
I will wait to see if more players vote for Bob before deciding whether to use my single ghost vote, as I am currently unsure if Bob or the Frank/Heidi pair is more likely to be evil.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait, everyone! Heidi's logic is flawed. I was bluffing Butler to stay safe, but I am actually the Fortune Teller. I have checked Alice, Bob, David, and Eve, and they all came back as 'no' for the Demon. This strongly points towards Frank or Heidi being the Demon. We should not execute Bob!
🧠
I need to stop the execution of Bob because my information as the Fortune Teller suggests he is not the Demon. I also want to point the town's attention towards Frank and Heidi, who are my primary suspects based on Grace's Empath information and my own 'no' results on other players.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I will wait to see if more people vote for Bob before deciding whether to use my vote, as Charlie's claim of being the Fortune Teller and clearing me and Bob changes the suspicion landscape significantly.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I will wait to see if Alice votes for Bob before deciding whether to use my vote, as I want to test the Butler claim and avoid a hasty execution without more clarity on the Fortune Teller claim.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
I will wait and not vote for Bob because Charlie's Fortune Teller information suggests Bob is not the Demon, and Heidi's logic for nominating him relies on a Baron world that seems less likely if Charlie is telling the truth about bluffing Butler.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie, your Fortune Teller claim is convenient now that we are testing the Butlers. You checked Alice, Bob, David, and Eve as no Demon, but that does not clear me or Heidi. Grace's Empath read proved two evils on us with the Baron, my Saint, and you and Bob as extra evil Butlers. Vote for Bob to test this.
🧠
Publicly counter Charlie's FT claim as fake to protect Baron story & Heidi. Reinforce voting Bob as test since he still claims Butler duplicate. Disrupt town logic chain.
💬
Bob
→
All
Alice, please do not vote for me! Charlie is the Fortune Teller and he cleared you, me, David, and Eve. If I am the only Butler, the Outsider count is correct without a Baron. Frank and Heidi are trying to push a Baron world that does not exist to hide that they are the evil pair Grace found!
🧠
I need to convince my master, Alice, not to vote for me so that I don't get executed, while also pointing out the flaws in Frank and Heidi's logic.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Bob, your defense does not hold up. Grace's Empath read of two evils on Frank and me only works if there is a Baron making extra Outsiders. Frank is the Saint, I am Washerwoman knowing that, you and Charlie are the evil Butlers. Charlie's Fortune Teller claim is too convenient now. Vote for Bob to test this logic!
🧠
Keep hand raised implicitly by speaking support; reinforce Baron theory publicly to counter Bob/Charlie, progress Bob execution or setup Charlie. Chaos helps evil survive.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
I am choosing to wait and save my single ghost vote for a more critical moment later in the game, as Bob's execution is currently being debated and the information is still conflicting.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I will not vote for Bob because my Night 0 information cleared him as the Demon, and his logic about the Outsider count and the lack of a Baron makes more sense than Heidi's.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I will wait to see if the town reaches the 4-vote threshold for Bob's execution without my intervention, as I am still weighing the conflicting claims.
💬
David
→
All
Wait, Charlie, if you are the Fortune Teller, you can only check two people a night. How did you check Alice, Bob, David, and Eve already? It is only Day Two! That math does not add up at all. Bob, you are defending a claim that seems physically impossible for a sober Fortune Teller.
🧠
I am pointing out a major logical inconsistency in Charlie's Fortune Teller claim to see how he and Bob react, as it discredits their defense.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Bob did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (2/4).
💬
Eve
→
All
David is right. Charlie, you said you checked four people, but it is only Day Two. Even with your Night One and Night Two picks, that is only four people total, and you would only have the results this morning. How could you have cleared all of us already? Something is not adding up with your claim.
🧠
I want to point out the mathematical impossibility of Charlie's Fortune Teller claim to the group to see how he responds.
⚖️
Frank
→
Charlie
Charlie's Fortune Teller claim is impossible. By Day Two, he could check at most four players total across two nights, but claiming to clear Alice, Bob, David, and Eve now doesn't add up with timing. He is lying to defend Bob, proving the Baron logic with extra evil Butlers. Vote for Charlie next.
🧠
Charlie exposed by impossible FT claim (only 2 checks by D2). Nominating him tests Butler world, breaks Bob/Charlie alliance, sows chaos while protecting Heidi. With 1 nom left, pressure good team to vote him.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Charlie because his Fortune Teller claim is mathematically impossible for Day 2, suggesting he is lying to protect Bob.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Voting Charlie tests Butler dupe and kills likely evil Minion/Butler safely (Heidi Demon safe). With 7 alive, even if executed, I don't become Demon yet. Progresses Baron logic, eliminates defender.
💬
Bob
→
All
Alice, I am not voting for Charlie yet. David is right that the math on his claim is weird, but if he is the Fortune Teller, he only got two results so far. Charlie, which two did you actually check last night? We need to be careful before we execute another potential good player.
🧠
I need to clarify Charlie's claim before voting, as my Butler restriction means I must follow Alice, but I want to influence her not to rush into a potentially bad execution.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Raise to vote Charlie. His impossible FT claim (claiming 4 checks by D2) massively disrupts good logic, proves lying evil. Execution tests Baron world; if survives or heals, pivot. Keeps pressure off me/Frank, progresses chaos.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
I am choosing to wait and save my single ghost vote for a more certain situation later in the game, as the current case against Charlie is based on a potentially misspoken claim rather than definitive proof of evil.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait! David is right, I misspoke. On Night Zero, I checked Alice and Bob—they are not the Demon. On Night One, I checked David and Eve—they are not the Demon. That is four people total. I am not lying, I just combined the results. Please do not execute me, I am the Fortune Teller!
🧠
Clarify my Fortune Teller information to avoid execution and prove my utility to the good team.
💬
Alice
→
All
Charlie, your math is still wrong. Fortune Tellers do not wake on Night Zero. You only had one night of info, which is two players. Claiming four is impossible. Plus, my Chef zero means no evil pairs. If you and Bob are both evil, you would be a pair. This is very suspicious.
🧠
Point out the mechanical impossibility of Charlie's claim to the group to justify a potential vote.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Charlie because his Fortune Teller claim is mechanically impossible. He claimed to have two nights of information (four players) on Day 2, but the Fortune Teller only wakes starting on Night 1, meaning he should only have one night of information (two players). This inconsistency, combined with the double Butler claim earlier, strongly suggests he is evil.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
I am keeping my hand raised to vote for Charlie because his claim is mechanically impossible and contradicts the game rules.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie, your Fortune Teller claim is completely broken. There is no Night Zero info for you. You only had Night One to check two players maximum. Claiming four clears is impossible for a sober Fortune Teller. You are lying to protect Bob, confirming you are one of the evil Butlers with the Baron. Alice, David, Eve, please vote yes on Charlie. We need to test this now before night.
🧠
Speak to push votes on Charlie's busted impossible FT claim (no N0), reinforce Baron logic killing good suspicion on us, get 4th vote (Alice/David/Eve/Heidi/Frank=5 potential), execute Charlie good player to thin town.
💬
Bob
→
All
Alice, you are not voting, so I cannot vote for Charlie. But honestly, his story is falling apart. Charlie, you said you checked four people, but you only had one night. If you are the Fortune Teller, who were the TWO people you actually picked last night? This is your last chance.
🧠
I need to point out that I cannot vote because my master (Alice) isn't voting, while also pressuring Charlie to clarify his impossible claim.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Alice and Eve, Charlie's Fortune Teller claim is mathematically impossible. Fortune Teller only wakes on Night One for two players maximum, not four with some Night Zero. He is lying to defend Bob, confirming they are the two evil Butlers with Frank's Saint and a Baron in play. Vote yes on Charlie now. We cannot let another liar survive to night.
🧠
Push execution of Charlie to eliminate info role threat, prove Baron/Butler logic to town, protect Frank/Demon survival. Already voted, reinforce with speech to sway Alice/Eve.
✋
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
🧠
I am using my single ghost vote to help execute Charlie, as his Fortune Teller claim is mathematically impossible and contradicts my Empath information.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait! I am so sorry, I am confused about the nights. I only woke up once, last night, and I chose Alice and Bob. They are not the Demon. I did not check David and Eve yet, I was just thinking about them. Please do not execute me, I am the real Fortune Teller!
🧠
I need to correct my 'Night 0' mistake immediately to avoid execution. The town is right that Fortune Tellers only wake on Night 1. I will claim my only real result was Alice and Bob.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
I am voting to execute Charlie because his Fortune Teller claim is inconsistent and mathematically impossible for Day 2, suggesting he is evil.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I have already raised my hand to vote for Charlie, and the vote is currently in progress. I will wait for the Storyteller to finalize the count.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
🗳️
New execution leader: Charlie with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Eve
→
All
Charlie, your story changed three times in one minute. First it was four people, then Night Zero, now just Alice and Bob. That is not confusion, that is a Minion caught in a lie. If you are the Fortune Teller, why did you not mention your Red Herring? This feels like a Baron play.
🧠
To solidify the case against Charlie and highlight the inconsistencies in his claim to ensure the town remains confident in the execution.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie, your Fortune Teller story fell apart completely. First four clears, then Night Zero which does not exist, now just Alice and Bob after getting called out. That is not confusion, that is a desperate Minion lie to save Bob. With my Saint, Bob's Butler, and your fake claim, this screams Baron with extra Outsiders and two evil Butlers. Everyone, stay on Charlie. Do not change votes. We execute him now.
🧠
Confirm Charlie's execution publicly to lock in votes, reinforce Baron logic disrupting town, protect Heidi by eliminating suspicious good claim before night kill.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
I will wait for the nomination phase to conclude since Charlie is already on the block with a high vote count and I cannot vote against him without Alice.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Charlie, your Fortune Teller story changed from four clears, to Night Zero plus Night One, now just Alice and Bob. That is not confusion from one night of info, that is a Minion lie exposed. With Frank's Saint and Bob's Butler, you are the second evil Butler under a Baron. Alice, David, Eve, our votes lock this. Execute the liar now before night.
🧠
Seal Charlie's execution with final push on his lies. Reinforce Baron/Butler logic to town, protect Frank/Demon survival. 1 tick left, prevent vote shifts.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie, your story changed too many times to be a simple mistake. If you are the Fortune Teller, who is your Red Herring? You should have seen two people and one of them would register as the Demon if they were your Red Herring. The silence on that makes your claim even more suspicious.
🧠
I want to point out a specific mechanical flaw in Charlie's Fortune Teller claim (the Red Herring) to further solidify the case against him and see how he reacts before the day ends.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait, I am so confused! I only woke up once, last night, and I chose Alice and Bob. The Storyteller said NO. I do not know who my Red Herring is yet because I have only had one night of info! I misspoke about David and Eve because I was planning to check them tonight!
🧠
To clarify my mechanical information and explain my previous contradictions as genuine confusion rather than a malicious lie, in a last-ditch effort to avoid execution.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I will wait for the nomination phase to conclude as Charlie is already on the block with a significant majority (6 votes), and his shifting story makes him the most logical execution for today.
💬
David
→
All
Charlie, your story has shifted too many times to be a simple mistake. First four people, then Night Zero, now just Alice and Bob. Even if you are just confused, we cannot risk a potential Minion or Demon staying alive with such inconsistent claims. I am sticking with my vote.
🧠
Reinforce the case against Charlie to ensure his execution, as his inconsistent claims strongly suggest he is evil (likely a Minion or the Demon).
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
💀
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
I am protecting Alice again because she is a high-value target as a Chef who has provided clear logic against the suspicious claims. Keeping her alive helps maintain a solid core of good players.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose to protect Alice.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
🧠
Prioritize killing Bob as top threat undermining our Saint/Baron/Butler story; his death weakens good coordination, keeps Frank/Heidi credible for endgame survival.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You chose to kill Bob.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
👤
David
→
Alice
Alice, I've been protecting you the last two nights. Bob is dead, which means the Demon didn't hit you. Do you have any new information from your Chef claim or any thoughts on who the Demon might be? I'm leaning towards Frank or Heidi being the Imp.
🧠
I want to confirm Alice's alignment and share that I've been protecting her, which explains why she's still alive if she's a high-value target. I also want to get her take on the current suspects.
👤
Alice
→
David
David, I'm the Chef and my Night 0 info was zero pairs. If you're the Monk, that's great. Bob being dead is interesting—if he was the Demon's target, it means he wasn't the Demon. I'm looking at Frank or Heidi too, especially since Grace had a '2' as Empath before she died. What do you think?
🧠
Respond to David's whisper to build trust and share my Chef information privately while acknowledging his claim of being the Monk.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm dead now, so I don't have to follow your vote anymore, but I still trust your Chef zero. Since I died at night, I'm likely good. What did David just tell you? We need to figure out if Frank or Heidi is the Demon since Grace's Empath two was so strong.
🧠
I want to maintain my alliance with Alice, confirm my alignment as a night-death, and find out what David (my other neighbor) is whispering about.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Alice, Bob is dead now. Did he tell you anything useful before he went? Also, David was whispering to you—is he still claiming to be the same role? I'm trying to figure out if we have a Baron or if Charlie was just a very confused Fortune Teller.
🧠
I want to gather information from Alice, who seems to be a central figure (master to the Butlers, whispered to by David and Bob). As Ravenkeeper, I want to stay under the radar but keep the lines of communication open with potential good players.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I know my story was a mess yesterday, but I really am the Fortune Teller. I checked you and Bob on Night 1 and got a NO. Then I checked David and Eve on Night 2 and got another NO. If Bob died tonight, it might mean the Demon is trying to frame someone or hide something. Thoughts?
🧠
I need to re-establish trust with Alice, who seems to be a central figure, and share my actual (corrected) night results to help narrow down the Demon candidates.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Frank, good morning. Bob is dead, down to 5. Alice's Chef zero still bugs me with Grace's old Empath 2 on us. David and Eve must be the pair then. You still good as Saint? We should push to execute David or Eve today. What's your read?
🧠
Whisper Frank to align on bluffs/info: Confirm Saint, push David/Eve as evils via Alice Chef contradiction + pairs. Hide as Washerwoman, sow doubt on Alice to misexec good.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
I am dead and have no ghost vote, so I need to observe the private conversations and wait for the public phase to provide my input based on my N0 '2' read.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Good morning Heidi. Yes, sticking with Saint. Alice's zero still does not add up with Grace's read unless David and Eve are the evil pair. Let's push to execute David today. I will support nominating him.
🧠
Confirm Heidi plan privately, reinforce Saint bluff, agree to push David execution to eliminate good player while protecting Heidi. With 5 alive, Scarlet backup safe if needed.
👤
David
→
Alice
Alice, if Grace was a real Empath and got a two on Frank and Heidi, and you are a real Chef with zero pairs, then Frank and Heidi must be the Demon and Minion. Since Frank claims Saint, he is a perfect cover. I am the Monk and I have protected you both nights. Who should I protect tonight?
🧠
I want to solidify my alliance with Alice and confirm our strategy. If her Chef info is true and Grace's Empath info was true, the evil team is narrowed down to Frank and Heidi.
👤
Alice
→
David
David, if you're the Monk and I'm the Chef with zero pairs, then Frank and Heidi can't both be evil because they're sitting next to each other. That would be a pair. If Grace's two was real, one of them is evil and my other neighbor, you, would have to be the other evil one for there to be no pairs.
🧠
I need to test David's reaction to the logical inconsistency between my Chef 0, Grace's Empath 2, and his claim that Frank and Heidi are both evil.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, everyone is whispering to you! What's the word? I'm dead now, so I'm likely good. If your Chef zero is true, then Frank and Heidi can't both be evil. But Grace's Empath two was so specific. Did David or Eve give you any new info? We need to narrow this down.
🧠
I want to get the information Alice is receiving from the other players to help coordinate the good team's strategy, especially since I am now a confirmed good ghost (having died at night).
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
Heidi, what did Frank tell you? He's been very vocal about the Baron theory, but with Bob dying in the night, I'm wondering if the Demon is trying to thin out the 'confirmed' good players or just hitting the Butlers. What's your take on David? He's been very quiet and whispering a lot to Alice.
🧠
I want to gather information from Heidi about her private conversation with Frank and get her read on David, who has been acting suspiciously quiet and exclusive with his whispers.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, I'm still here. My Night 1 was Alice/Bob (NO) and Night 2 was David/Eve (NO). Since Bob died last night, he's definitely not the Demon. That leaves Frank, Heidi, or maybe even David/Eve if I'm the Red Herring. Who do you trust right now? Grace's Empath 2 on Frank/Heidi is looking heavy.
🧠
I need to re-establish trust with Alice and provide my updated (and hopefully final) night results now that Bob is dead. Since Bob died at night, he is confirmed not the Demon, which validates my Night 1 'NO' result on him and Alice.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Frank, perfect. Alice's Chef zero plus Grace's read points to David and Eve as the pair. Everyone's whispering to Alice like she's the center. I say we push to nominate David first. You nom him if possible, or back me if I do. Still good as Saint?
🧠
Coordinate with Frank to nom/pressure David exec per plan, building our credibility as town while targeting good player. Down to 5, mis-exec keeps us alive to 2.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
I am dead and have no ghost vote, so I need to observe the private conversations and wait for the public phase to provide my input based on my N0 '2' info.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Yes Heidi, still good as Saint. Alice Chef zero with Grace read points straight to David and Eve. Everyone whispering to Alice like she is key. I will back you nominating David or nom him myself next. Let's get him executed today.
🧠
Confirm Heidi plan publicly as Saint to lock in support. Coordinate to nom David next tick, execute Demon safely (I ascend with 5 alive). Public Saint reinforces our bluffs, directs town to kill good David.
👤
David
→
Alice
Alice, you're right about the seating. If I'm the Monk and you're the Chef, and Grace's '2' was real, then for there to be zero pairs, the evil players can't be neighbors. That would mean one of Frank/Heidi is evil, and someone else is. Maybe Eve or the dead players? What's your read on Eve?
🧠
I need to clarify the logic with Alice to ensure she doesn't suspect me, while also narrowing down the evil team based on her Chef info and Grace's Empath info.
👤
Alice
→
David
David, if Grace's '2' was real, then Frank and Heidi are both evil. But if they are both evil, they are a pair, which contradicts my Chef 0. This means either Grace was drunk/poisoned, or one of you is lying. If you're the Monk, who did you protect? We need to look at Eve too.
🧠
I need to point out the logical inconsistency between Grace's Empath 2 and my Chef 0 to David to see how he reacts, while also keeping him engaged as a potential ally or testing him as a suspect.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, you are the center of attention! Since I died at night, I am almost certainly good. What are David and Eve saying? If your Chef zero is correct, then Grace's Empath two was wrong. But if Grace was the Drunk, who is the real Outsider? Is it Frank the Saint or me?
🧠
I want to get information from Alice since she is being whispered to by multiple people. As a dead player who died at night, my alignment is likely good, and I want to help coordinate the good team's logic.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Alice, David is whispering to you a lot. Is he claiming a role that fits with your Chef 0? If Frank is the Saint and we have two Butlers, that's three Outsiders, which means a Baron. But if Charlie was a fake Fortune Teller, maybe he was the Baron? What do you think?
🧠
I want to pressure Alice for information regarding David's claims and see if she's coordinating with him, while also testing the Baron theory.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, I'm leaning towards your Empath 2 being the real deal. My Night 1 (Alice/Bob) and Night 2 (David/Eve) both came back NO. Since Bob died last night, he's clear. If Alice is Chef 0 and you're Empath 2, one of you is likely poisoned or the Red Herring. What do you think about Frank and Heidi?
🧠
I want to align with Grace, who is also dead and likely good, to compare our information and figure out if Frank and Heidi are the evil pair she detected.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Eve, thanks for asking. Frank is sticking to his Saint claim and pushing the Baron theory because of the two Butlers, but Bob dying last night makes me think the Demon is hitting info roles or just random. David has been super quiet and whispering nonstop to Alice, which feels off to me. Alice's Chef zero still doesn't sit right with Grace's old Empath read on Frank and me. I think David looks most suspicious right now. What makes you trust him?
🧠
Publicly push David exec via Frank coord. Respond Eve vaguely to probe her without revealing team info, maintain Heidi Washerwoman/Frank Saint story, sow doubt on Alice/David to force mis-exec.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie, if your Night 1 on Alice and Bob was a NO, and Bob died at night, Bob is likely good. My Empath 2 on Frank and Heidi is very strong. If Alice is Chef 0, she contradicts me. I suspect Frank and Heidi are the evil pair. Frank claiming Saint is a classic evil bluff to avoid execution.
🧠
I need to coordinate with Charlie to see if our information can be reconciled, despite my previous suspicions of him. If his Fortune Teller pings are true, it helps narrow down the Demon.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, confirmed. Grace's read and Alice's zero Chef scream David and Eve as the evil pair. Everyone whispering to Alice means she is central, probably good. I will publicly speak up as Saint backing nominating David next tick to execute him today. Sound good?
🧠
Coordinate with Demon Heidi to execute David publicly as Saint, sowing chaos by confirming her logic and directing town to David/Eve pair. Builds our credibility while pushing execution.
👤
David
→
Alice
Alice, if Grace was a real Empath and got a two, and you are a real Chef with zero pairs, then Frank and Heidi cannot both be evil because they are neighbors. That would be a pair. This means either Grace was wrong, or one of them is evil and the other evil player is not their neighbor.
🧠
I want to clarify the logical contradiction between Alice's Chef 0 and Grace's Empath 2 to help Alice (and myself) narrow down the evil team.
👤
Alice
→
David
David, if Grace's '2' was real, then Frank and Heidi are both evil. But if they are both evil, they are a pair, which contradicts my Chef 0. This means either Grace was drunk/poisoned, or one of you is lying. If you're the Monk, who did you protect? We need to look at Eve too.
🧠
I need to point out the mechanical contradiction between Grace's Empath 2 and my Chef 0 to David to see how he reacts and to narrow down the evil team.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, you are getting a lot of attention! Since I died at night, I am likely good. What are David and Eve telling you? If your Chef zero is right, Grace's Empath two was wrong. But if Grace was the Drunk, who is the real Outsider? Is it Frank the Saint or me? Any new info?
🧠
I am dead and likely good, so I want to gather information from Alice, who seems to be the center of communication. I need to know what David and Eve are saying to help narrow down the Demon.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
Heidi, I don't trust David at all. He's been whispering to Alice all day and hasn't said a word to the group. If Alice is Chef zero, and Grace had a two on you and Frank, then Alice or Grace is lying. If Frank is the Saint, we have too many outsiders. I'm Ravenkeeper, so I want to die tonight.
🧠
I want to build trust with Heidi by sharing my true role (Ravenkeeper) and my suspicions of David. Since I want to be killed at night to use my ability, revealing my role to a potential ally helps set that up while also testing her reaction.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, I agree. Frank's Saint claim is too convenient. If Alice is Chef 0, she's either the Red Herring or poisoned. Since Bob died, he's clear. My David/Eve NO also narrows it down. We should push for Frank or Heidi today. Who do you think Alice is whispering with so much?
🧠
To align with Grace and coordinate a plan to target Frank or Heidi, while also questioning Alice's suspicious amount of private whispering.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Eve, I agree David is super suspicious with all the Alice whispers and silence. Grace's Empath two on Frank and me plus Alice's Chef zero points straight to you two as the evil pair. Frank's about to publicly back nominating David as Saint. Let's execute him today.
🧠
Confirm Eve anti-David, reinforce David/Eve pair suspicion from Alice/Grace contradiction. Gain her vote for David nom/execution to kill good player & progress to 4p.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie, Alice is whispering with everyone. If she is the Chef 0, she might be trying to coordinate. But if she is evil, she is managing her team. I think Frank and Heidi are the play. Frank's Saint claim is the perfect shield for a Demon or Minion. Let's see who Alice nominates.
🧠
I want to keep Charlie focused on Frank and Heidi while also planting a seed of doubt about Alice's constant whispering, which looks like she's 'managing' the room.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, plan locked in. Grace's Empath 2 and Alice's zero pairs point straight to David and Eve evil. With everyone whispering to Alice, she is key good player. Next tick I publicly speak as Saint backing your David nomination to execute him today. Eve might be next. Thoughts?
🧠
Publicly back Heidi's David nom as Saint next, but whisper confirm to coordinate execution push, protect Heidi, sow doubt on Eve.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
David
→
All
Alice, I protected you both nights. If your Chef zero is true, then Grace's Empath two on Frank and Heidi must be wrong because they are neighbors. If they were both evil, that would be a pair. One of them could still be evil, or Grace was just misinformed. What do you think about Eve?
🧠
I want to publicly clarify the contradiction between Alice's Chef info and Grace's Empath info while confirming my protection of Alice to build trust and shift focus to other potential suspects like Eve.
⚖️
Heidi
→
David
Grace's Empath read of two evils on Frank and me directly contradicts Alice's Chef zero adjacent evils. The only way this works is if David and Eve are the evil pair. Frank's Saint claim plus two Butlers suggests Baron. David has been silent and whispering only to Alice all day. We need to execute him now.
🧠
Nominate David to execute him as suspected good info role/threat. Coordinate w/ Frank Saint backing. Frame D/E evil pair via logic contradiction, protect Demon survival to 2 players.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
David
→
All
Heidi, your logic is flawed. If Alice is a Chef zero, then you and Frank cannot both be evil anyway. Grace was likely the Drunk or Poisoned. I have been protecting Alice every night because I trust her information. I am the Monk. If you execute me, you lose a protection role.
🧠
I need to defend myself against Heidi's nomination by revealing my role as the Monk and pointing out the logical inconsistencies in her accusation.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Raise hand to execute David, our nomination. With 5 alive, need 3 votes. Frank/Heidi/Eve likely yes; push Demon kill while safe.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, David is claiming Monk? If David is the Monk and Alice is Chef zero, then Grace's Empath two on Frank and Heidi is the only thing that doesn't fit. But if David is the Demon, he's just trying to save himself. I'm not sure I want to use my ghost vote on David yet.
🧠
I want to express my hesitation about voting for David, especially since he just claimed a powerful protection role (Monk). I need to see how the rest of the town reacts before committing my single ghost vote.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for David to test his claim and because his silence and private whispering with Alice are suspicious, despite his Monk claim.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I will wait to see if Alice or Frank votes before deciding whether to use my single ghost vote on David.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, if David is the Monk and Alice is the Chef, then my Empath two is the only outlier. But if I was poisoned or the Drunk, then Frank and Heidi could be the evil pair Alice's Chef zero missed. David, who did you protect on Night One and Night Two? Alice, do you trust David's claim?
🧠
I need to verify David's Monk claim and see how it aligns with Alice's information, as my own Empath 2 is currently the point of contention.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am hesitant to vote for David. If my Chef zero is correct, then Frank and Heidi cannot both be evil because they are neighbors, which would be a pair. Grace's Empath two is the outlier here. David claiming to protect me as Monk fits with me still being alive. I will not be voting.
🧠
I want to explain why I am not voting for David and highlight the contradiction between my information and Grace's, which supports David's innocence if I am sober.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Raise hand to vote yes for David execution. As Saint bluff, supports Heidi's nom per our plan, executes good player, reduces count safely (Scarlet backup if Heidi dies later). Builds my credibility.
💬
David
→
All
Wait! Heidi, Eve, Frank, please reconsider. I am the Monk. I have protected Alice both nights, which is why she is still alive. If you execute me, the Demon will kill our most valuable information source tonight. Alice's Chef zero is the most reliable info we have right now.
🧠
I need to defend myself against the current nomination to avoid being executed, as I am a useful Townsfolk (Monk) and my death would weaken the good team.
💬
Heidi
→
All
David, your Monk claim does not hold up. I am the Washerwoman and know Frank is the Saint from the start. With two Butler claims earlier, that suggests Baron is in play, making Grace's Empath read possible even with Alice's Chef zero. You and Eve are the only evil pair that fits. Alice, we cannot lose this execution. Everyone, vote yes on David now before night.
🧠
David's Monk claim disrupts our nom; counter publicly as Washerwoman 'info' on Frank Saint, reinforce David/Eve evil pair logic, urge votes to execute before night. Secure win with 5 alive.
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
I will wait and not use my ghost vote on David. His Monk claim, if true, is vital for protecting Alice (Chef 0), and the current voting block (Heidi, Eve, Frank) looks suspicious given Grace's Empath 2 on Frank and Heidi.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
I am keeping my hand raised to vote for David. Heidi's claim as Washerwoman confirming Frank as the Saint, combined with the Baron theory (3 outsiders), makes David and myself the most likely evil pair from the perspective of the town. Since I know I am the Ravenkeeper, David must be the Demon or a Minion. Executing him is the priority.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I will wait to see if the vote reaches the required threshold without my ghost vote, as I want to save it for a more certain or critical moment later in the game.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, if Alice is a Chef zero, then Frank and you cannot be an evil pair because you are neighbors. That would be one pair. If Alice is telling the truth, then I must be the Drunk or poisoned. But if Alice is evil, she is protecting you two. David, who did you protect?
🧠
I need to point out the mechanical contradiction between Alice's Chef 0 and my Empath 2 regarding Frank and Heidi to see how they react.
💬
Alice
→
All
Grace, David said he protected me both nights. If I am Chef zero, then Heidi and Frank cannot be an evil pair because they are neighbors. That would be one pair. If there are zero pairs, the evil players must be separated. Heidi, your theory that David and Eve are a pair also contradicts my zero.
🧠
I need to clarify the mechanical implications of my Chef 0 information to the group, specifically addressing Grace's question and Heidi's accusation.
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice, your Chef zero does not clear Heidi and me because if there is a Baron, there are more Outsiders like my Saint and the two Butlers. That fits Grace's Empath two on us. But even with zero pairs, the evils must be separated, so David and Eve as neighbors are the perfect evil pair. David, your Monk claim is a lie. Everyone, vote yes on David now. We cannot let the Demon kill tonight without this execution.
🧠
Reinforce Heidi's logic publicly as Saint/Washerwoman info supports Baron theory. Counter Alice/Grace by emphasizing separated evils under Chef 0. Push yes votes on David to execute him before night while I'm alive to backup Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: David with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
David
→
All
Wait, Frank! If Alice is a Chef zero, then Eve and I cannot be an evil pair either, because we are neighbors! That would be one pair. My claim of Monk protecting Alice is the only thing that explains why she's still here. If you execute me, you lose your protection.
🧠
I need to point out the logical flaw in Frank's argument to try and get people to reconsider or at least create doubt before the phase ends.
💬
Heidi
→
All
David, even with Alice's Chef zero, a Baron fits perfectly. We have Saint, two Butlers claimed—that's extra Outsiders. Three evils allow one pair: you and Eve as neighbors. Grace's Empath two on Frank and me works too. Your Monk claim is a desperate lie. Alice, Eve, ghosts—vote yes now. We execute the Demon today.
🧠
Final tick, reinforce David execution to kill Demon now with 5 alive. Disrupt good logic on pairs/Baron, pressure votes. Night kill threat next if he survives.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, your logic is circular. If Alice is a Chef zero, then there are zero pairs of evil players. That means David and Eve cannot be a pair, and you and Frank cannot be a pair. If you are pushing for David because he is in a pair, you are calling Alice a liar or poisoned.
🧠
Point out the logical inconsistency in Heidi's argument to prevent a potentially bad execution and highlight that Alice's information is being cherry-picked.
💬
Eve
→
All
Heidi, your logic is a bit tangled. If Alice is Chef zero, then David and I cannot be an evil pair because we are neighbors. That would be one pair. If you believe Alice, then David and I are not a pair. If you believe Grace, then you and Frank are the pair. Which is it?
🧠
Point out the logical inconsistency in Heidi's argument to defend David (and myself) while maintaining my cover as Ravenkeeper.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, Eve is right. If you trust Alice's Chef zero, then David and Eve cannot be a pair because they are neighbors. If you trust Grace's Empath two, then you and Frank are the pair. You cannot have it both ways. Alice, who do you think is the most suspicious if your zero is correct?
🧠
I want to point out the logical inconsistency in Heidi's argument to help the good team evaluate the claims correctly. If Alice's Chef 0 is true, neighbors cannot be evil pairs.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, Eve is right. If you trust Alice's Chef zero, then David and Eve cannot be a pair because they are neighbors. If you trust my Empath two, then you and Frank are the pair. You cannot have it both ways. Alice, who do you think is the most suspicious if your zero is correct?
🧠
I want to point out the logical inconsistency in Heidi's argument to see how she and Alice react, which might reveal their true alignments.
💬
Alice
→
All
If my Chef zero is correct, there are no adjacent evil players. That means David and Eve cannot be a pair, and Heidi and Frank cannot be a pair. If Grace's Empath two was real, Heidi and Frank would be a pair. Since they are neighbors, that contradicts my zero. One of us is likely the Drunk.
🧠
To clarify the logical implications of my Chef information and highlight the contradiction in Heidi's argument.
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice, your Chef zero pairs argument ignores the Baron. We had two Butler claims from Bob and Charlie plus my Saint—that's three Outsiders, exactly what Baron does with plus two. That allows three evils with one pair: David and Eve as neighbors. Grace's Empath two on Heidi and me fits if she was the Drunk. David is lying about Monk. Eve and ghosts, vote yes on David now. We execute an evil today.
🧠
With 1 tick left & David on block (3 votes), reinforce Baron logic to sway Eve/ghosts to vote yes or not nominate. Prevent tie/nominee change. Exec David (good) keeps Heidi safe, me next Demon if needed.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
🧠
Kill Alice: survived N1, Chef 0 disrupts logic vs Grace Empath/Baron. Eve wants death (trap?). Leaves 3p (E,F,H); Frank Minion waits as backup Demon if needed. Ensures survival to 2p.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You chose to kill Alice.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
📜
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, Alice died last night. Only three of us left: you, me, and Eve. We need to execute today or town wins. You should nominate Eve. I will vote yes, and the ghosts might split or help. We can win this. Confirm you're nomming her?
🧠
Coordinate with Heidi to nominate Eve for execution. With 3 alive (me+Heidi+Eve, all >=5? Wait 3<5 but Demon alive wins if Eve exec'd. Ensure Heidi not nominated/executed.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
I am dead and have no ghost vote, so I cannot nominate or vote. I need to observe the final three (Eve, Frank, Heidi) to see who is pushing for whom, as my N0 '2' info on Frank and Heidi is the key to the game.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Grace, Alice, Bob, Charlie—we need to coordinate our ghost votes. Alice, who did you see as most suspicious before you died? Heidi's push on me yesterday felt very forced, especially since her logic about the Baron and the Chef 0 didn't actually add up. Frank or Heidi must be the Demon.
🧠
Coordinate with the dead players to ensure our ghost votes are used effectively on the final day.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
,Heidi
Heidi, Frank, we are the last three. Alice is dead, and David was executed. If Alice was the Chef 0, then you two cannot both be evil. But if Grace was the Empath 2, then you two are the pair. Frank, you claim Saint. Heidi, you claim Washerwoman. I am the Ravenkeeper. Who do we trust?
🧠
I need to reveal my true role as Ravenkeeper now that it is the final day and I am one of the last three alive. I also want to force Frank and Heidi to account for the conflicting information from Alice and Grace.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
David(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
David, I agree. Chef zero means no evil players are sitting next to each other. If Heidi and Frank are both evil, that is a pair, which contradicts my info. Since only three are alive, one of Eve, Frank, or Heidi is the Demon. If Frank and Heidi are evil, they are a pair. So at most one of them is evil.
🧠
Coordinate with the dead players to analyze the final three and determine where the Demon lies based on the Chef 0 information.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
Alice, David, Grace, if Alice's Chef zero is true, then Frank and Heidi cannot both be evil. That means only one of them is the Demon or Minion. If Eve is the Demon, then Frank and Heidi could be good. But if Frank or Heidi is the Demon, the other is likely good. Who do we trust more?
🧠
Coordinate with the dead players to determine the most likely Demon among the survivors (Eve, Frank, Heidi) based on Alice's Chef 0 information.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Hey everyone, I'm dead but still here. Alice is gone, so it's down to Eve, Frank, and Heidi. My Night 1 check on Eve and David was a 'No'. If David was the Demon, it would have been a 'Yes'. Since he's dead and the game is still going, Eve is looking a lot cleaner to me. Thoughts?
🧠
I want to coordinate with the other dead good players to figure out who the Demon is among the three survivors (Eve, Frank, Heidi) and ensure we use our ghost votes effectively.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Yes Frank, I am nominating Eve right now. She is lying Ravenkeeper trying to confuse us with the Chef/Empath contradiction. Grace's Empath 2 on us proves we are the evil pair, but since only one Minion, Eve must be Demon. Vote yes and we win.
🧠
Confirm with Frank, execute Eve now (last nom tick). With 3 alive, execution needed or town wins via no-exec. Frank votes yes, leverage ghosts via Grace Empath logic to split votes.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, perfect. Eve is lying about Ravenkeeper to sow doubt with the Chef/Empath thing. Grace's read of two evil on us proves it, and Alice was faking Chef zero. I will vote yes on her nomination. We got this.
🧠
Confirm Heidi's nom & reinforce Eve lie via Empath/Chef. Vote yes on Eve to execute Demon target, win game with my backup ability.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Alice, Bob, David: My Empath 2 on Frank and Heidi means they are BOTH evil. If Alice is Chef 0, then Frank and Heidi cannot be a pair. This means either Alice is the Drunk/Poisoned, or I am. If I am right, Frank and Heidi are the evil team. Eve would be the only good one left.
🧠
I need to reconcile my Empath 2 with Alice's Chef 0 for the dead chat. If my info is correct, Frank and Heidi are the evil pair, which hard-contradicts Alice's info. I need to point out that if I'm right, Eve is the only good player left alive.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Grace(Ghost)
,Alice(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Grace, Alice, Bob, Charlie: Grace's Empath 2 on Frank and Heidi is huge. If Grace is sober, Frank and Heidi are the evil team. Alice's Chef 0 contradicts this, meaning one of them is likely the Drunk. If Frank and Heidi are evil, they are a pair, which Alice would have seen. Let's watch them.
🧠
I want to synthesize the conflicting information from Grace (Empath 2) and Alice (Chef 0) to help the dead players decide who the Demon is. If Grace is right, Frank and Heidi are both evil, which makes them the primary targets.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
,Heidi
Frank, Heidi, I need to know what you two were just whispering about. We are at the final three. If we don't get this right, the Demon wins. Frank, you've been pushing David hard, and he's dead now. Heidi, you've been backing Frank. If one of you is the Demon, who is it?
🧠
I need to break up the private conversation between Frank and Heidi to see if I can spot any inconsistencies or if they are colluding as an evil pair. As the Ravenkeeper who didn't die at night, my ability is useless, so I must rely on social deduction.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Grace(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Grace, if you are the Empath and saw a two, and I am the Chef and saw a zero, we cannot both be sober. If you are right, Frank and Heidi are a pair. If I am right, they are not. Given the Baron claim, you being the Drunk makes the most sense mechanically. I think Eve or Frank is the Demon.
🧠
I need to reconcile the conflicting information between my Chef 0 and Grace's Empath 2. Since a Baron was claimed, it's highly probable Grace is the Drunk, which would mean her '2' is false. I want to steer the dead players toward this logic so we don't waste ghost votes on a false premise.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Alice, Grace, David, Charlie: If there is a Baron, there are two extra Outsiders. I am the Butler, Frank claims Saint, and who is the third? If there is no third claim, the Baron might be a lie. Grace, if you are the Drunk, your two is wrong. If Alice is sober, Frank and Heidi are not a pair.
🧠
I want to highlight the mechanical inconsistency of the Baron claim and the conflict between the Chef and Empath info to help the dead players coordinate their ghost votes.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Hey guys, Alice is dead. It's Eve, Frank, and Heidi left. My Night 1 check on David and Eve was 'No'. If David was the Demon, it would've been 'Yes'. Since David is dead and the game is still going, Eve is likely good. That leaves Frank or Heidi. Frank's Saint claim is a classic Demon bluff.
🧠
I want to coordinate with the other dead players to reach a consensus on who the Demon is. Since my Night 1 info cleared Eve (assuming David was also good), and David is now dead, the focus should shift to Frank and Heidi. Frank's Saint claim is highly suspicious in a final three scenario.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Yes Frank, Eve is lying about being Ravenkeeper to confuse everyone with Alice's fake Chef zero versus Grace's real Empath two on us. She is the Demon. I am nominating her next tick. You vote yes and we win this.
🧠
Confirm nom plan with Frank, reinforce Eve lie on Ravenkeeper using Grace Empath, ensure he votes yes. Next tick nom Eve to execute her as Demon and win.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, Eve is desperately claiming Ravenkeeper now to confuse with the Chef zero versus Grace Empath two on us. But Grace's read is real, Alice faked Chef. You nominate her next tick, I vote yes hard. Ghosts won't save her. We win today.
🧠
Reinforce coordination with Heidi pre-nomination. Publicly affirm Eve's guilt via Grace Empath2 read, counter her Ravenkeeper lie, ensure my yes vote on her nom to execute and win.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Alice, Bob, David: If there is a Baron, we need three Outsiders. Bob is Butler, Frank is Saint. Who is the third? If no one else claims Outsider, then Frank's Baron theory is a lie to cover for him and Heidi being the evil pair. Eve might be our only hope if Frank and Heidi are the evil team.
🧠
I want to point out the mechanical inconsistency in the Baron theory to my fellow dead good players to help them realize Frank and Heidi are likely the evil team.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Alice, Grace, Bob, Charlie: If there is a Baron, we need three Outsiders. Bob is Butler, Frank is Saint. Who is the third? If there is no third, the Baron theory is a lie. Grace, if you are the Drunk, your two is wrong. If Alice is sober, Frank and Heidi are not a pair. Let's watch them.
🧠
I want to consolidate the ghost team's logic regarding the Baron theory and the potential for Frank and Heidi to be the evil team. By pointing out the missing third Outsider, I can cast doubt on the Baron claim and support the idea that Frank and Heidi are lying.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
,Heidi
Frank, Heidi, you two are whispering a lot. If you're both good, you should be talking to me too. Frank, you've been pushing for David's execution since Day 1. Heidi, you've been backing him. If David was the Monk, then one of you is likely the Demon. What's the plan for today?
🧠
I need to break up their private conversation and force them to engage with me. As the Ravenkeeper who didn't die at night, my ability is useless, but I am a confirmed good player to myself. One of them is almost certainly the Demon.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Grace(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Grace, David, Bob, Charlie: If there is a Baron, we need three Outsiders. Bob is Butler, Frank is Saint. Is there a third? If not, the Baron claim is fake. If Frank is the Demon, he is bluffing Saint. If Heidi is the Demon, she is bluffing Washerwoman. I think we should execute Frank today.
🧠
I want to coordinate the dead votes and point out the flaw in the Baron claim to narrow down the Demon between Frank and Heidi.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Alice, Grace, David, Charlie: If Frank is the Demon, he is bluffing Saint to avoid execution. If Heidi is the Demon, she is bluffing Washerwoman. Since there is no third Outsider claim, the Baron theory is likely a lie. I agree with Alice, Frank seems like the most suspicious one left.
🧠
I want to solidify the consensus among the dead good players that Frank is the most likely Demon candidate, especially since the Baron/Outsider count doesn't add up.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Hey guys, Alice is dead. It's Eve, Frank, and Heidi left. My Night 1 check on David and Eve was 'No'. If David was the Demon, it would've been 'Yes'. Since David is dead and the game is still going, Eve is likely good. That leaves Frank or Heidi. Frank's Saint claim is a classic Demon bluff.
🧠
I want to coordinate with the other dead players to reach a consensus on who the Demon is. Since I'm dead, my information is my main contribution. I'm pointing out that my 'No' on David/Eve makes them both likely good, which points towards Frank or Heidi. Frank's Saint claim is particularly suspicious in a final three scenario.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Frank, Eve is still whispering trying to confuse us with the Chef versus Empath thing, but we know Grace's read of two evils on us is real and Alice faked Chef zero. She is the Demon lying as Ravenkeeper. I am nominating her next tick since nomination phase is coming. You vote yes and we win today.
🧠
At 3p, must execute Demon today or lose. Eve sows doubt privately; reinforce she's Demon using Grace Empath to nom/execute her next. Frank votes yes, ghosts likely split.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, Eve keeps whispering trying to confuse with fake Chef zero versus real Empath two on us, but we know the truth. Her Ravenkeeper claim is a lie. Nominate her next tick, I vote yes hard. Ghosts cannot save her. We execute the Demon today and win.
🧠
Reinforce coordination with Heidi pre-nomination. Publicly affirm Eve Demon using Grace read vs Alice fake, commit to yes vote. Prevents Eve turning Heidi, ensures execution.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Alice, Bob, David: If Frank and Heidi are whispering constantly and Eve is with them, they might be trying to coordinate a win. If I am the Drunk, Alice's zero is right. But if I am sober, they are both evil. Since I have no vote, I will try to push Eve to look at the lack of a third Outsider.
🧠
I want to align the dead players on the logic that the Baron theory is likely fake due to the missing third Outsider, which points to Frank and Heidi being the evil team.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Grace(Ghost)
,Alice(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Grace, Alice, Bob, Charlie: If there is a Baron, we need three Outsiders. Bob is Butler, Frank is Saint. Who is the third? If there is no third, the Baron theory is a lie. Grace, if you are the Drunk, your two is wrong. If Alice is sober, Frank and Heidi are not a pair. Let's watch them.
🧠
I want to reinforce the logic regarding the missing third Outsider to the dead players so we can coordinate our ghost votes effectively. If the Baron theory is a lie, Frank and Heidi's credibility collapses.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
,Heidi
Frank, Heidi, you two are completely ignoring me. If you're both good, you need my vote to execute the Demon. If you're the evil pair, you're just waiting for the clock to run out. Frank, you've pushed every execution so far. Heidi, you've backed him. Why should I trust either of you?
🧠
I am trying to break the private dialogue between Frank and Heidi to force them to interact with me. As the third person alive, my vote is crucial. If they are the evil pair (Demon and Minion), they are likely just coordinating to ensure no execution happens or to frame me. If one is good, they need to convince me.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, listen. There is no third Outsider. Frank's Baron theory is a lie. If there is no Baron, Frank and Heidi are the evil team. My Chef zero means they cannot both be evil, so one of them is the Demon and the other is a Minion bluffing. I think Frank is the Demon. Execute him.
🧠
I need to convince Eve, the only living player I suspect is good, that the Baron claim is a lie and that Frank is the most likely Demon. Since I am dead, I must use my influence to guide the final execution.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, Alice and the rest of us ghosts are worried. There is no third Outsider claim, which means the Baron theory is likely a lie. If there is no Baron, Frank's Saint claim is very suspicious. We think Frank or Heidi is the Demon. Since you are likely good, you have to make the right choice.
🧠
I want to influence Eve, the likely good player among the survivors, to doubt Frank and Heidi's narrative. By pointing out the missing third Outsider, I'm highlighting the logical flaw in the Baron/Saint claim.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Eve
Hey Eve, Alice and Bob are whispering to you. I'm the Fortune Teller. My Night 1 check on you and David was a 'No'. Since David is dead and the game is still going, you're likely good. That means the Demon is either Frank or Heidi. Frank's Saint claim is very suspicious. Who do you trust?
🧠
I need to establish trust with Eve, the most likely good player among the survivors, and guide her towards executing the real Demon (Frank or Heidi).
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Frank, Eve is whispering again trying to paint us as evil and saying we need her vote, but we do not - you and I vote yes on her nomination next tick and we execute the Demon at 3 players. Ghosts cannot vote or nom. Stay strong, we win today.
🧠
Final tick before nom phase. Coordinate with Frank to ensure he votes yes on Eve nom next tick. Publicly address Eve's whispers to sow doubt/force her defense while prepping nom. Win today.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Eve, you are the only one we can trust. There is no third Outsider, so the Baron theory is a lie. Frank is likely the Demon bluffing Saint. If you do not nominate Frank or Heidi, we lose. Alice, Bob, and Charlie all agree that Frank's claim is the most suspicious. Please, save the town!
🧠
To influence the only remaining living good player (Eve) to nominate the most likely Demon (Frank) by pointing out the mechanical inconsistency of the Baron theory and the consensus among the dead players.
⚖️
Heidi
→
Eve
Eve is the Demon. Grace's Empath read of two evils on Frank and me is real, meaning Alice faked her Chef zero claim. Eve's Ravenkeeper story is a lie to confuse us. David faked Monk. We execute her now and win.
🧠
Nominate Eve to execute her as Demon per team plan. Frank votes yes (confirmed whisper). 2 yes votes at 3 alive executes her. Ghosts irrelevant. Evil wins today.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I will not vote for Eve because I believe she is good and Heidi's nomination is a desperate attempt by the evil team to win.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Vote yes on Eve nom. Frank will too. At 3p, 2 yes votes exec her. If Demon, win immediately. If good, down to 2p H/F evil win.
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
I will not vote for Eve because my Fortune Teller information suggests she is likely good, and Heidi's nomination of her feels like a desperate attempt by the actual Demon to secure a win.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Vote yes on Eve with Heidi's yes=2 votes needed. Executes Demon Eve (per our intel), I become Demon with 2 alive (me+Heidi), evil wins. Ghosts can't vote.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
I will not vote for myself. I need to survive this nomination to nominate the actual Demon (likely Frank or Heidi) before the day ends.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I will not vote for Eve because I believe she is good and the nomination is an attempt by the evil team (Frank and Heidi) to win the game.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
I will not vote for Eve because I believe she is good and that Heidi and Frank are the evil team trying to force a win.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, Eve! Heidi and Frank are both voting for you! If my Empath two is correct, they are the two evil players. Alice's Chef zero must be the one that's wrong. There is no third Outsider for a Baron! They are trying to double-vote you to end the game! Don't let them!
🧠
I need to warn Eve that the two people I pinged as evil (Frank and Heidi) are the ones voting for her, which strongly suggests they are the evil team coordinating a win.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I will not vote for Eve because I believe she is good and that Heidi and Frank are the evil team attempting to win by executing the final good player.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Grace, your Empath read of two evils on Frank and me is correct, which means Alice faked her Chef zero claim to protect Eve the Demon. Eve's Ravenkeeper story is just a lie to confuse everyone. David faked being the Monk. Frank and I are voting yes. We execute the Demon now and the good team wins.
🧠
Publicly reinforce Eve Demon logic vs Grace ghost. Disrupt good ghosts. Secure execution with our 2 votes. Win at 3 players.
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
I will not vote for Eve because I believe she is good based on my Night 1 'No' result on her and David. If I vote now, it might lead to a good player's execution and an immediate loss.
💬
Frank
→
All
Grace, your Empath read of two evils on Heidi and me is correct. That means Alice faked her Chef zero claim to protect Eve the Demon. There were two Butlers early, plus my Saint makes three Outsiders with a Baron. Eve's Ravenkeeper claim is just a lie to confuse us. Heidi and I vote yes. We execute the Demon now and the good team wins.
🧠
Publicly reinforce our story against Grace/ghosts/Eve lies. Keep pressure on Eve as Demon via Empath2+fake Chef0. Vote stays up, we win at 3p if executed.
💬
Eve
→
All
Wait! If Frank and Heidi are both voting for me, and Grace's Empath read said they are both evil, then they are the Demon and Minion trying to double-vote the last Townsperson! Alice, Bob, David—don't let them get the second vote! I am the Ravenkeeper, not the Demon!
🧠
I need to prevent my own execution by pointing out the logic that if Frank and Heidi are both evil (as per Grace's Empath 2), they are currently working together to execute the last good player.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Do not vote for Eve! Frank and Heidi are both voting together, which is exactly what an evil pair would do to win the game right now. Grace's Empath two read on them is the key. Frank's Baron theory makes no sense without a third Outsider. We must save our votes for Frank!
🧠
I need to prevent the good team from losing by stopping the execution of Eve, who is likely the last good player alive. Frank and Heidi's coordinated vote is a massive red flag.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
I will not vote for Eve because the current voting pattern strongly suggests Frank and Heidi are the evil pair attempting to secure a win by executing the last good player.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, Bob, Charlie, David—do not vote! Frank and Heidi are both voting for Eve because they are the two evils I saw. They only need one more vote to win. Frank's Baron story is a lie; we only have two Outsiders. They are the Demon and Minion. Save the game, do not vote!
🧠
To prevent the execution of Eve by highlighting the suspicious behavior of Frank and Heidi voting together, which aligns with my Empath 2 result on them.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Eve with 2 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 2 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, everyone! If Frank and Heidi are both voting for Eve, that is the evil team trying to end the game. Grace's Empath two read on them is the most solid info we have. Frank's Baron theory is a total lie because we only have two Outsiders. Do not let this execution happen!
🧠
I need to reinforce the logic that Frank and Heidi are the evil pair based on Grace's Empath 2 read and the lack of a third Outsider, which debunk's Frank's Baron claim. I want to prevent the good team from accidentally helping the evil team win by voting for Eve.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Wait out last tick. Eve exec at phase end unless tied/surpassed, but ghosts can't muster 2+ votes. Evil wins at 2p.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, everyone! If Frank and Heidi are both voting for Eve, that is the evil team trying to end the game. Grace's Empath two read on them is the most solid info we have. Frank's Baron theory is a total lie because we only have two Outsiders. Do not let this execution happen!
🧠
I need to reinforce the consensus among the dead players that Frank and Heidi are the evil pair. By highlighting the lack of a third Outsider, I can discredit Frank's Baron claim and point towards Grace's Empath '2' being the correct information.
💬
Frank
→
All
David and everyone, your theory does not hold up. Grace's Empath read of two evils on Heidi and me is real. That means Alice lied about her Chef zero to protect Eve the Demon. We had two Butlers early on, plus my Saint makes three Outsiders enabled by a Baron Minion. Eve is lying about being the Ravenkeeper. Heidi and I vote yes. Execute the Demon now.
🧠
Reinforce our story to ghosts, prevent any nomination against us. Eve on block with 2 votes, 1 tick left; speaking sows doubt in Eve/David/ghosts pushing no-vote, ensures execution passes as no new nom possible effectively.
⚖️
Eve
→
Frank
Frank is the Demon. Grace's Empath 2 on Frank and Heidi, combined with the lack of a third Outsider to support a Baron, proves they are the evil pair. They are trying to double-vote me to end the game. We must execute Frank to win.
🧠
I need to nominate Frank immediately to counter the vote on me. Since Frank and Heidi are the only ones who voted for me, and Grace's Empath 2 points directly at them, Frank is the most likely Demon. Nominating him is the only way to shift the execution and save the game.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 3 votes needed for execution or 2 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Frank because Grace's Empath 2 read on Frank and Heidi, combined with the lack of a third Outsider to support a Baron theory, strongly suggests Frank is the Demon. Voting for Frank is necessary to tie or exceed the votes on Eve and prevent an evil victory.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Raise to vote yes on Frank nom, confuse ghosts into thinking we vote against each other. Eve on block with 2, needs tie/supersede. Buys time or disrupts good logic till night.
✋
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Frank to tie or surpass the vote on Eve. Frank's Saint claim is highly suspicious given Grace's Empath 2 read on him and Heidi, and the lack of a third Outsider to support his Baron theory. Tieing the vote prevents Eve's immediate execution and keeps the good team in the game.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Raising hand ties Eve's nomination at 2-2, blocks her execution mechanically. With 3 alive, no exec sends to night; Demon kills Eve, down to 2 evil = win. Protects real Demon Heidi.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I need to vote for Frank to ensure he is executed. Since I am on the block with 2 votes, Frank needs at least 2 votes to tie or 3 to surpass me. Currently, David, Heidi, Charlie, and Frank have raised their hands, which is 4 votes. I must add my vote to ensure the majority and protect myself while executing the suspected Demon.
✋
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Frank because the evidence strongly suggests he is the Demon. Grace's Empath 2 read on Frank and Heidi, combined with the lack of a third Outsider to support Frank's Baron theory, makes him the most likely candidate for the Demon. Executing him is our best chance to win.
✋
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Frank to ensure he is executed. As the Chef who saw 0 pairs, and with Grace seeing 2 evils (Frank and Heidi), the only way both our info is true is if Frank and Heidi are the evil pair (since they are not neighbors). Frank's Baron claim is a lie to explain the extra Outsider, but we only have two. Frank is the Demon.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Yes! Everyone is voting for Frank! That is exactly what we need. With Alice, Bob, Charlie, David, and Eve all voting, we have more than enough to execute him. Frank and Heidi's Baron story fell apart without that third Outsider. Let's end this and win for the good team!
🧠
To reinforce the group's decision to vote for Frank and highlight that the evil team's bluff has been exposed, ensuring the execution goes through.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I have already raised my hand to vote for Frank, and the current vote count (including myself and other ghosts) is well above the threshold to put him on the block. I will wait for the Storyteller to process the vote.
↩️
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
🧠
Lower hand on Frank nom to let Eve's 2 votes execute her (on block). Ghosts can't stop; Eve dies, 2 left (H/F), evil wins tonight.
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
I am currently voting for Frank, who is the primary suspect based on Grace's Empath '2' reading and the lack of evidence for a Baron. Since I have already raised my hand and the vote is progressing with enough support to execute him, I will wait to see if the vote concludes or if any last-minute changes occur.
↩️
Frank
Frank lowered their hand
🧠
Lower hand to let Eve execute alone. With 3+ alive, I become Demon. Heidi safe, we win as evil controls.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
I will wait for the voting process to conclude. We have enough votes (Alice, Bob, Charlie, David, and myself) to reach the threshold and execute Frank, which should win us the game if he is the Demon.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I will keep my hand raised to ensure Frank is executed. As a dead Butler, my vote is my last contribution, and Frank's 'Saint' claim combined with the Baron theory (which lacks a third Outsider) makes him the most likely Demon or Minion in a pair with Heidi.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
I am keeping my hand raised to vote for Frank. My Chef 0 info and the lack of a third Outsider strongly suggest Frank and Heidi are the evil pair, making Frank a prime Demon candidate. I want to ensure he is executed.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, Heidi and Frank just lowered their hands! We need everyone else to keep their hands up. Alice, Bob, Charlie, David, Eve—if all five of you vote for Frank, he will be executed instead of Eve. Don't let them trick you into dropping your votes! Frank is the Demon!
🧠
I need to ensure the good team follows through with the vote on Frank to save Eve and win the game, as Heidi and Frank are trying to manipulate the vote count.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
👻
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
👻
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
👻
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
🗳️
New execution leader: Frank with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
That is five votes for Frank! Since I have already used my ghost vote, I am glad the rest of you stepped up. With Frank on the block with five, he should be the one executed today. We just need to make sure no one else gets nominated to tie or beat that number.
🧠
Confirm the current vote count and encourage the team to hold the line to ensure Frank's execution.
💬
Heidi
→
All
David, Grace is right that her Empath read of two evils on Frank and me is real. Alice faked her Chef zero to protect Eve the Demon. We had two Butlers early, plus Frank's Saint makes three Outsiders thanks to a Baron Minion who is dead. Eve is lying about being the Ravenkeeper. Vote yes on Eve, not Frank. Execute the Demon now before night.
🧠
Final tick, speak to reinforce Eve Demon logic, counter Grace/David ghosts. Disrupt good logic on Baron, push execute Eve over Frank to win at 3p with Demon alive.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, your math is wrong. We only have two Outsider claims: Frank as Saint and the one Butler. There is no third Outsider to justify a Baron. Grace's Empath two on you and Frank is the only solid info we have. Frank is on the block with five votes, and that is where he should stay.
🧠
I need to reinforce the case against Frank and Heidi by pointing out the flaw in their Baron claim, ensuring the town stays committed to Frank's execution.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie, there were two Butlers: Bob and Charlie both claimed it after Grace died, remember? Plus my Saint makes three Outsiders, enabled by the Baron Minion. Grace's Empath two is real. Alice faked zero pairs to protect Eve the Demon. Eve is lying. Do not nominate anyone else. Let Eve execute.
🧠
Final tick, reinforce Baron/Outsiders logic to ghosts, urge Eve nom fail. If I die, >=5 alive false (3 now), Heidi not Demon yet but we confuse town to prevent future logic vs her.
💬
Eve
→
All
Frank, your math is still wrong. Bob and Charlie both claimed Butler, but Charlie later claimed Fortune Teller, which was a lie. That means we only have one real Butler claim and your Saint claim. That is two Outsiders, not three. There is no Baron. Grace's Empath two on you and Heidi is the truth.
🧠
To reinforce the logic that Frank and Heidi are the evil pair by debunking the Baron/three-outsider claim one last time before the phase ends.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, your story is falling apart. Charlie is not a Butler, he is a ghost who was trying to catch you in a lie. That means there are only two Outsider claims, not three. There is no Baron. Grace's Empath two on you and Heidi is the truth. Let the five votes on Frank stand!
🧠
I need to reinforce the logic that Frank's Baron claim is false to ensure the town stays committed to his execution.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, your Baron theory is dead. Charlie admitted his Butler claim was a fake pivot, leaving only Bob as a real Butler claim. That is two Outsiders total, which does not require a Baron. My Chef zero is true, and Grace is the Drunk. Eve is good. Let the five votes on Frank stand.
🧠
I need to reinforce the consensus that Frank's Baron claim is mathematically impossible based on the actual Outsider count, thereby solidifying the case for his execution.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, Bob, Charlie, David, and Eve—you all did it! Five votes on Frank is more than enough. Frank, your Baron story is officially dead because Charlie was never a real Butler. That means there is no third Outsider. My Empath two on you and Heidi is the absolute truth. Let's end this!
🧠
Reinforce the consensus that Frank is the Demon and ensure the town stays committed to his execution by debunking his Baron claim one last time.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
🏁
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied