Game Detail
Players
Alice (Recluse) Bob (Imp) Charlie (Ravenkeeper) David (Mayor) Eve (Undertaker) Frank (Baron) Grace (Saint) Heidi (Drunk)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 597,778 | 79,165 | $2.1544 |
| Evil | 220,109 | 82,667 | $0.4748 |
Event Timeline
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You are the Minion. The Demon is Bob.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Minions are: Frank. Your safe bluffs are: Virgin, Empath, Chef
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Washerwoman. Either Grace or Frank is the Ravenkeeper.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Hey Frank, I'm the Imp. Let's coordinate. My safe bluffs are Virgin, Empath, and Chef. I'm thinking of claiming Empath - I can fake readings each day. What role are you planning to claim? Also, who should I kill tonight? Let me know if you have any intel from your ability.
π§
I'm the Imp (Demon) and need to coordinate with my Minion Frank on Day 1. We should agree on what roles to claim, who to target for kills, and general strategy to survive and win.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
Hi, I am Grace. What did you learn or what are you planning to claim today? I am trying to track outsider count and get a quick role map. I can share my claim after I hear yours.
π§
Get early claims from my neighbors, build a small trust circle, and avoid outing Saint while setting up future logic chains.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Alice
Hey, quick check in. What did you learn Night zero and what role are you leaning toward claiming today? I am a Townsfolk info role and want to compare notes before nominations.
π§
Gather early role claims and social reads from two players before nominations, while keeping my Undertaker role hidden to reduce night kill risk.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Hi Grace. I am Washerwoman. I saw that either you or Frank is the Ravenkeeper. What are you claiming, and have you already told anyone else your role?
π§
Coordinate with Grace, share my Washerwoman info privately to build a trusted info chain and avoid giving the demon an obvious night-kill target.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
,David
I got no Night zero info. I am leaning toward a simple non info Townsfolk claim today, like Monk or Soldier, just to stay out of the spotlight. What exactly did you learn, and which two names were in it?
π§
Respond without outing Recluse, get Eve to commit to her info, and establish a small trust circle for later logic chains.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Alice
I also got no Night zero info. I am leaning to claim Soldier today for safety. Eve, can you say what your role type is and, if it is a two name start info, which two names you got?
π§
Protect my Mayor identity while still cooperating. Offer a plausible low-impact claim and get Eve to state her exact info to cross-check later.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,David
Hey, quick check in. What role are you claiming and what info do you have so far? I am considering saying I am an information role to draw a night kill, so I am curious what you two are planning to say publicly.
π§
Get early claims from my neighbors and seed a bluff that makes me an attractive night kill, while building a trust circle for later logical chains.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Hey Bob, good to connect. I'm planning to claim Washerwoman - I'll say I learned that one of two players is a specific Townsfolk. That's hard to verify early on. Your Empath claim sounds solid. As for kills tonight, I'd suggest targeting someone who seems like they're gathering info - Grace is asking about outsider counts which could be dangerous for us. Maybe Charlie too since they whispered you. Also heads up: there are 3 Outsiders in play because of my Baron ability, so be prepared for that t...
π§
Coordinate with my Demon Bob on our bluff claims and strategy. I need to establish my fake role, discuss who to kill tonight, and plan how to handle the outsider count issue since I'm the Baron adding 2 extra Outsiders.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I'm planning to claim Empath. I figured it's a solid claim since I can give readings each day that are hard to dispute early on. Haven't committed publicly yet though. What about you? You mentioned considering an info role to draw a kill - which one are you thinking? And have you heard anything interesting from others?
π§
Charlie directly asked me what role I'm claiming. I need to respond with my fake Empath claim to build trust and gather info from Charlie. I should also probe what Charlie is planning to claim.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Hey Heidi. I am not Ravenkeeper. Privately, I am the Saint. I have not told anyone else yet. If your info is true, that points to Frank being Ravenkeeper. Please keep my role quiet for now, and maybe compare notes with Frank carefully.
π§
Privately confirm I am not Ravenkeeper and share Saint to help role-mapping, while asking Heidi to keep it quiet to avoid me getting executed.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
,David
I also had no Night zero info. I am a nightly Townsfolk info role, but I would rather not hard claim it yet on day one. It is not a two name start. Before nominations or by day two, I will be more specific once we have an execution to work with.
π§
Stay credible without giving evil a clear counterclaim target. Keep Undertaker hidden until we have an execution to confirm, while still aligning with their no-start-info stories.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
Hi Frank, I am Heidi. I am Washerwoman and I saw either you or Grace is the Ravenkeeper. What are you claiming, and have you shared it with anyone yet?
π§
Quietly test Frankβs claim against my Washerwoman info without exposing Grace as Saint, and build an early trusted info chain for later executions.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
,David
Got it. Since you are a nightly info role, can you at least narrow it to Empath versus Fortune Teller versus something else, and tell us who you plan to check tonight? David, if you are claiming Soldier, I will avoid that claim so we do not collide.
π§
Nudge Eve into giving a bounded soft claim and a plan, while avoiding role conflicts and keeping my Recluse hidden for now.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Alice
I am fine sticking with a Soldier public claim for day one. Eve, can you commit to what you will do tonight, like which two names you will check or which neighbor pair you will read, without naming the exact role yet? That way we can later verify if it tracks.
π§
Align on non-colliding public claims, get Eve to commit to a concrete night plan, and keep my Mayor role hidden while still appearing helpful.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
I have not heard anything solid yet. I am actually the Ravenkeeper. I am considering a public bluff as Fortune Teller or Undertaker to look juicy and try to draw a night kill. If you go Empath, keep it simple early and do not overclaim certainty.
π§
Respond to Bob, build trust if he is good, but keep my real role protected while setting up a bait claim that could get me killed at night for Ravenkeeper value.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
Hey Heidi, interesting. I am actually the Ravenkeeper, so your info checks out - Grace must not be. I haven't shared my role widely yet, just had some general chats. What else have you learned? Anyone else claim anything useful?
π§
Heidi claims Washerwoman and says I'm potentially Ravenkeeper. I should claim Ravenkeeper to fit her info and build trust. I also need to update Bob since I originally planned to claim Washerwoman but Heidi has that covered.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Frank, nominations are coming up. We need to make sure neither of us gets targeted. Who's getting the most heat? I think we should push suspicion on Charlie - they whispered me claiming Ravenkeeper but also said they might bluff as Fortune Teller, which is sketchy. If we can get the town to focus on Charlie, that protects us. For the kill tonight, I'm leaning toward Grace since she's poking at outsider counts, which is dangerous. What do you think? Also, what did Heidi whisper to you about?
π§
Coordinate with Frank before nominations start. Confirm kill target, discuss who to push suspicion on, and make sure neither of us gets nominated.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Hi Frank, quick check. Heidi says she is Washerwoman and saw either you or me is Ravenkeeper. I am not Ravenkeeper. What are you claiming, and have you shared it with anyone yet?
π§
Confirm or deny the Ravenkeeper ping and build a trusted info network while keeping my Saint identity hidden from the wider town.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
,David
I cannot do a normal pick-two or neighbor read tonight. My info comes from what happens in the day. So my commitment is: whichever player we execute today, I will get their exact character tonight and report it tomorrow.
π§
Answer their request with a verifiable plan that matches Undertaker timing, while minimizing the chance the Demon targets me before we get at least one execution.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
Thanks, that matches my Washerwoman info. I have heard Grace is not Ravenkeeper, so your claim fits. I will probably confirm you publicly later if needed. If you get killed at night, have a top pick ready to check. Have you heard any other solid claims yet?
π§
Coordinate with Frank on how/when to reveal our Washerwoman-Ravenkeeper confirmation while keeping Graceβs Saint claim private; set up a plan if Frank dies at night.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
,David
That sounds exactly like Undertaker. If you are, great, we should prioritize getting an execution today for a clean data point. David, Soldier claim is fine. Eve, any preference on who we execute if there is no strong lead, so you can confirm them tomorrow?
π§
Clarify Eveβs likely Undertaker claim, coordinate a safe execution target, and position myself with a non-conflicting public claim while staying flexible as Recluse.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Alice
If you are Undertaker, I agree we should get an execution today. If no strong lead, I prefer executing someone who is willing and not claiming Outsider or Saint. Eve, maybe soft claim Undertaker publicly so town prioritizes an execution.
π§
Lock in a sensible D1 execution plan that generates confirmable info, and set expectations on public soft-claims without exposing me as Mayor.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Frank
Hey, quick private check. What role are you planning to claim and what info do you have so far? I am trying to avoid claim collisions and decide what to say publicly.
π§
Gather early claims from David and Frank, decide a safe public bluff that does not collide, and build cross-checks to narrow Demon candidates.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Hey Grace, yeah, I am the Ravenkeeper. So Heidi's info checks out from both sides - you're not, and I am. I haven't shared it too widely yet, just with a couple people I trust. What about you, what are you claiming? And have you noticed anything else interesting going around?
π§
Grace is directly asking about my role in context of Heidi's Washerwoman info. I already told Heidi I'm Ravenkeeper, so I must stay consistent with Grace too. If I deny, Heidi will contradict me publicly. Consistency is key to my cover.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I strongly think we should execute someone today, even if it is on low suspicion. Some of us will get much cleaner information if an execution happens. Can we get a couple of volunteers who are not claiming Saint or an important role?
π§
Create urgency to execute today and softly signal Undertaker value without fully outing to demon, to get a clean data point for tomorrow.
π¬
David
β
All
I agree we should execute today to generate info. Can we get one or two volunteers who are not claiming Saint, and are fine being the day one data point? If nobody volunteers, I want to hear quick role claims so we do not accidentally hit a Saint.
π§
Encourage a safe day one execution and solicit volunteers without outing my real role, while tracking who resists executions.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not a good volunteer for a day one execution, so please do not nominate me today. If we want an execution for info, I would rather we get a couple of quick claims and then pick someone who is comfortable being the data point. Also, Heidi has a solid starting info ping that may help guide us.
π§
Protect myself from execution while nudging town toward a productive D1 execution and encouraging a useful public info drop without outing my Saint role.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am in favor of an execution, but I do not want to do it blind. Heidi, can you share your starting info ping now, including the exact two names if it is a two person result? Also, can we get very quick claims from each person, just role category if you prefer, so we do not ever hit a Saint?
π§
Get quick public claims to avoid hitting Saint, and pressure Heidi to share the 'solid ping' so we can choose an execution target without losing key roles.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I agree, we should get an execution today for information, but let us not walk into a Saint. Heidi, please share your exact starting info with the two names. Also, can everyone give a quick claim, even just βnot Saintβ and role type, so we can pick a safe volunteer?
π§
Move town to quick, low-detail claims and get Heidi to share exact info so we can choose a safe execution target for Undertaker value without risking a Saint loss.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am the Empath. My night zero reading was zero, so both of my neighbors, Alice and Charlie, appear good to me. I am fine with a day one execution if it helps the town get information, but I would rather not be the one nominated. Let us hear from Heidi first since she has starting info.
π§
Claim Empath publicly to build trust and avoid being nominated for the day 1 execution. Sharing a 0 reading is safe since both my neighbors are good, and it doesn't point suspicion at anyone while establishing me as a verified info role.
βοΈ
Frank
β
Charlie
Charlie has been giving inconsistent role claims in private conversations - claiming Ravenkeeper to some and hinting at Fortune Teller to others. That kind of shifting claim on day one is suspicious and worth examining.
π§
Charlie has been making inconsistent private claims (Ravenkeeper then FT mention) and is the sketchiest player. Nominating him aligns with Bob's plan to push suspicion on Charlie, protects my Demon, and makes me look like an engaged town member.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am not shifting claims. I told Bob privately that I am the Ravenkeeper, and that is true. I did not claim Fortune Teller to anyone. Frank, who exactly did you hear that from? Please do not vote me on this.
π§
Stop a baseless day one execution on me, clarify my claim, and redirect town to getting Heidiβs info and safer volunteer options.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
We need an execution today to generate mechanical info. Charlie is not claiming Saint, and confirming his role tonight will either clear him or validate suspicion.
π¬
David
β
All
I am not ready to vote Charlie on a secondhand claim clash. Frank, who specifically told you Charlie hinted Fortune Teller, and what were the exact words? Heidi, please share your starting info now so we can aim this better. If we cannot substantiate this, I would rather execute a clear volunteer today.
π§
Steer town away from a low-evidence execution and demand concrete info before spending Day 1 vote, while keeping pressure for an execution on a safer volunteer.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I want to highlight something simple. Heidiβs Washerwoman info points to Frank being the Ravenkeeper, and I know I am not. So Charlie also claiming Ravenkeeper is a hard conflict. Unless Frank can be disproven, Charlie looks like the safer execution today.
π§
Push a logical vote on the role conflict without exposing I am Saint; aim to remove a likely evil and generate mechanical clarity.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
A hard role conflict exists around Ravenkeeper, and an early execution creates a strong Undertaker data point. Voting to push a decisive D1 outcome.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Voting for Charlie eliminates a real Ravenkeeper during the day (denying them their death ability), protects Frank's cover, and makes me look pro-town. Grace's argument about the role conflict gives me cover for this vote.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Voting for Charlie after nomininating them maintains consistency. If they flip Ravenkeeper, I argue they were the Drunk (plausible with 3 Outsiders). If they flip non-Ravenkeeper, my claim strengthens. Not voting after nominating looks suspicious.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I will share my starting info. I am the Washerwoman, and I learned that either Grace or Frank is the Ravenkeeper. Grace has told me directly she is not the Ravenkeeper, and Frank has claimed Ravenkeeper to me. So Charlie also claiming Ravenkeeper is a hard conflict. I am comfortable voting Charlie here.
π§
Publicly confirm my Washerwoman ping to anchor the day one vote and justify executing Charlie due to an impossible Ravenkeeper conflict.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Please do not execute me here. Bob has an Empath zero with Alice and me as his neighbors, which strongly supports I am good. Frank is the only source of the βFortune Teller hintβ and is also the person in conflict with my Ravenkeeper claim. Frank, say exactly who you heard that from, right now, or I think this is a push to kill a good player.
π§
Stop an unsubstantiated day one execution on me by highlighting hard evidence (Bobβs 0), attacking Frankβs credibility, and proposing a better target or no-exec if needed.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am voting Charlie because this Ravenkeeper conflict is the cleanest mechanical thread we have. If Charlie dies today, I will have their exact character tomorrow, and that will immediately clear either Charlie or Frank. Frank, after the vote, I want the exact source for the Fortune Teller hint.
π§
Support a Day 1 execution that maximizes info. My nightly info will confirm the executed playerβs exact character, resolving the Ravenkeeper conflict and testing Frank/Heidi quickly.
π¬
David
β
All
I am not putting my hand up here, but it looks like the votes are there. Frank, you need to name exactly who told you the Fortune Teller hint and what was said, before night. And everyone, remember Bob could be poisoned, so tomorrowβs Undertaker check on Charlie is really important.
π§
Let the execution go through without adding my vote; lock in that Frank must publicly name his source, and remind town Bobβs Empath can be poisoned so we still need the Undertaker check.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Votes are already sufficient. I will not add pressure unnecessarily and will preserve flexibility and social capital for tomorrow, while avoiding any risk of drawing attention toward executing me (the Saint).
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am keeping my vote on Charlie. There is a direct Ravenkeeper conflict with Heidiβs Washerwoman info, and we need an execution for the Undertaker check tomorrow. Frank, after this vote, you must name exactly who told you the Fortune Teller hint and what they said.
π§
Keep the execution to generate a confirmed character via likely Undertaker, resolve the Ravenkeeper conflict, and force Frank to commit to a source for his accusation.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Votes are already at 4 (Eve, Alice, Frank, me), enough for execution. Lowering my hand now would look suspicious and flip-floppy. Charlie is dying regardless. Best to stay quiet and not draw attention. Tomorrow I'll need to manage the fallout if Charlie is confirmed Ravenkeeper, which would expose Frank.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Fair point, everyone. On the Fortune Teller hint, Charlie whispered to me and David earlier, and something in the phrasing made me think they were hinting at a different role. I may have read too much into that, and I should have been more careful before stating it as fact. The main issue is the direct Ravenkeeper conflict. Heidi's Washerwoman info points to me as the Ravenkeeper, Charlie is also claiming it, and only one of us can be telling the truth. That conflict is real and worth resolving ...
π§
The vote on Charlie is passing (4 votes). I need to manage the fallout from my fabricated Fortune Teller hint claim. I'll backtrack slightly, saying I misinterpreted something Charlie said, while maintaining the Ravenkeeper conflict is the real issue. This preserves some credibility for tomorrow when the Undertaker result comes in.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Votes are already at threshold; adding my vote secures the execution to resolve the Ravenkeeper conflict and create strong mechanical info for tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Charlie with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
If you execute me today, you are likely killing a good player off one contested Washerwoman ping. Bob has an Empath zero on me and Alice. Frank has now admitted the Fortune Teller part was just his read. Someone please nominate Frank to create a tie, and let us resolve this the other way.
π§
Try to stop my execution by shifting suspicion onto Frank and highlighting that the case on me is weak and may be poisoned/drunk info. Encourage a counter-nomination to create a tie.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I do not want a tie here unless someone has a very strong mechanical reason. Charlie is already the cleanest test, because I will confirm his exact role tomorrow. If it comes back Ravenkeeper, we pivot onto Frank. If not, we pivot away from Charlie and into whoever pushed him.
π§
Prevent a messy tie and ensure we get a clean Undertaker read from todayβs execution, then use that to force a decisive logic branch tomorrow.
π¬
David
β
All
I do not want a tie here. Let Charlie be executed, and tomorrow Eve confirms his exact character. If it comes back Ravenkeeper, we execute Frank next. If it is not Ravenkeeper, we treat the push and the Washerwoman chain as suspect and pivot.
π§
Keep the clean mechanical line: let Charlie die, get Eveβs confirmation, and prevent an unnecessary tie that could save an evil player or muddy tomorrowβs solve.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I do not want a tie here. The Ravenkeeper conflict is the only clean mechanical thread we have, and Charlie is already on the block. Let us execute Charlie, then tomorrow we use the Undertaker to confirm the exact character and we hard-pivot based on that.
π§
Keep town from tying or randomizing, preserve me from execution risk, and push for a clean mechanical test that narrows to Frank or undermines the WW chain tomorrow.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I do not want a tie here. Let Charlie die and let Eve confirm the exact character tomorrow. If it is Ravenkeeper, we execute Frank next day. If it is not, we treat the Ravenkeeper chain as suspect and pivot onto the pushers.
π§
Keep town from creating an unnecessary tie, lock in the plan to use tomorrowβs Undertaker info to drive a decisive Day 2 execution.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Charlie's execution is locked in at 5 votes with 1 tick remaining. No action needed - a good player is dying which helps evil. I should lay low and not draw attention before night phase where I kill Grace.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Charlie's execution is locked in with 5 votes and only 1 tick remaining. Nothing I say now will change the outcome. Better to stay quiet and conserve my credibility for tomorrow's defense, when the Undertaker result will be the critical moment. Speaking now might draw more attention or lock me into a story I can't walk back.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I agree, no tie. We take the Charlie execution and we let Eve confirm the exact character tomorrow. Frank, please state clearly right now for the town: are you hard-claiming Ravenkeeper, yes or no? And Grace, if you are an Outsider like you told me, stay quiet on details.
π§
Stop a risky tie, lock in public claims for tomorrowβs logic, and keep focus on the cleanest mechanical test while protecting the likely Saint.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Bob
Bob made a choice.
π§
Kill Eve to prevent Undertaker confirmation of Charlie's character. If Eve lives and confirms Charlie=Ravenkeeper, the town will hard-pivot onto Frank (our minion). Without Eve's confirmation, Frank can argue the conflict is unresolved and keep suspicionεζ£ed.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose to kill Eve.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Bob
,David
I am still Ravenkeeper, but I died by execution so I got no info. Can you both push for an Undertaker claim today to confirm what I actually was? If Undertaker says I was Ravenkeeper, Frank is almost certainly lying. If not, we recheck Heidi and the Washerwoman start info.
π§
I need to steer town toward getting Undertaker confirmation on my executed role and using that to resolve the Ravenkeeper claim conflict, then pick the right execution target.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Charlie is pushing hard for an Undertaker claim to confirm they were Ravenkeeper. If Undertaker confirms Ravenkeeper, you look bad. We need a plan. Options: cast doubt on whoever claims Undertaker, or push an execution on someone else entirely. Who do you think we should target today? Also, what's your current cover story - are you still claiming Washerwoman?
π§
Coordinate with my minion Frank about our strategy for this day. Charlie is pushing for Undertaker which could expose Frank. We need to agree on our approach before nominations.
π€
David
β
Bob
,Heidi
Quick check before noms. Bob, what was your night one Empath number, and any reason you might be poisoned? Heidi, can you restate exactly who your Washerwoman showed and what role, and have you had any other pings since?
π§
Get fresh mechanical info before nominations: Bobβs N1 Empath and Heidiβs exact Washerwoman ping. Then steer the town to a decisive execution path.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Still claiming Ravenkeeper, not Washerwoman. If someone claims Undertaker and says Charlie was Ravenkeeper, we immediately push that the Undertaker is drunk or poisoned - there's a Baron in play adding Outsiders, so the info roles could be off. We need to get someone else executed today. David has been pushing hard against me and demanding info - let's frame him as the Demon or a Minion trying to direct the town. What's your read on who we can most easily swing votes against? Also, what are you ...
π§
Coordinate with Bob on a plan to handle the Undertaker threat. I need to stay alive to protect Bob. If Undertaker confirms Charlie was RK, we must discredit them. We should also push execution on someone else today.
π€
Heidi
β
David
My Washerwoman info: either Grace or Frank is the Ravenkeeper. Grace whispered me she is not Ravenkeeper and claimed Saint, asked me to keep it quiet. Frank whispered me he is Ravenkeeper. Charlie claimed Ravenkeeper publicly and we executed him. Eve the Undertaker died so we cannot confirm Charlieβs role now.
π§
Answer David precisely, remind him of the WW chain and current contradictions, and prompt him to share his own role/reads so we can decide a solid nomination today.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Heidi
Can you both share any new info since yesterday? Bob, what was your night one Empath number and are you confident you were not poisoned? Heidi, can you restate your Washerwoman result exactly and any strong reads on Frank versus Grace?
π§
Get fresh mechanical info (Empath N1, Washerwoman details) and align on a nomination target before nominations open.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Bob
,David
I am the Undertaker and I died last night. I should have learned what Charlie was after the Day one execution, but it is not showing in my notes here. Did either of you hear an Undertaker result from anyone, or have a way to confirm Charlie versus Frank?
π§
Privately reveal I was Undertaker and coordinate with Bob and David on what information exists, so we can form a nomination plan and I can spend my ghost vote effectively.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
,Heidi
Hey, do we have an Undertaker claim and what did they see for Charlie last night? Also, any new info from your chats this morning that points at Frank or Heidi side of the Ravenkeeper conflict?
π§
Get the Undertaker result on Charlie and current info without outing myself as Saint; help steer todayβs execution toward the most likely demon/minion.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Alice
Can you say if anyone is claiming Undertaker today, and what they got for my execution? That is the cleanest way to confirm whether I was Ravenkeeper and resolve the Frank versus Heidi world. Also, what is your current top demon suspect going into nominations?
π§
Get Heidi and Alice to surface any Undertaker info and align on the mechanical plan for todayβs nomination, so we can execute the most provably evil player and save my ghost vote for endgame.
π€
Bob
β
David
,Alice
Night one Empath reading was zero again. My neighbors are now Alice and David since Charlie died, and both readings have been zero consistently. I have no reason to think I am poisoned. As for the Undertaker situation, Eve just whispered me claiming she is the Undertaker but says her result is not showing in her notes. That is odd. If she truly learned something, we need to hear it. If she got nothing, maybe she was drunk or this claim needs scrutiny.
π§
Maintain my Empath cover by answering David and Alice's questions consistently. Claim N1 reading was 0 (neighbors Alice+David, both good). Build trust with David to steer him away from suspecting Frank.
π€
David
β
Grace
Hey Grace, Heidi told me you privately claimed Saint and said you were not Ravenkeeper. Are you willing to say Saint publicly before noms so we do not accidentally execute you? Also, any reads on whether Frank or Heidi is lying?
π§
Prevent a Saint loss and get clarity on Graceβs claim so we can plan nominations and avoid executing a potential Saint while we chase the demon.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
Hey Heidi, I wanted to talk to you before someone claims Undertaker. With the Baron in play adding extra Outsiders, there could be a Drunk in an info role. If the Undertaker claims Charlie was Ravenkeeper, that doesn't automatically prove I'm lying - the Undertaker themselves could be Drunk and getting false info. I'm still confident in what I saw. Also, Eve dying overnight is interesting - she promised to confirm Charlie's role, and now she can't. Someone silenced her. Who benefits most from th...
π§
I need to preemptively plant doubt about Undertaker info with Heidi, who has been my most supportive good player. If Undertaker confirms Charlie was Ravenkeeper, I need Heidi already primed to question that info. Also maintaining cover as Ravenkeeper.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Bob
My Washerwoman was: either Grace or Frank is the Ravenkeeper. Grace told me privately she is not Ravenkeeper and claimed Saint. Frank told me he is Ravenkeeper. With Eve dead, there is no UT confirmation, so I am looking hard at Frankβs new βBaron plus Drunkβ hedge.
π§
Align Alice and Bob on my exact WW info and on why Frankβs Baron-and-Drunk preemptive doubt feels like an evil hedge. Encourage them to pressure Frank and compare stories before nominations.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,Heidi
I have not heard any living Undertaker claim. Bob says Eve whispered she was Undertaker but her result for Charlie is βmissing,β which is very weird. With Grace claiming Saint and your Washerwoman pointing at Frank, we may be at two Outsider claims already, so either Baron or someone is lying. Who do you both suspect most for demon right now?
π§
Update Charlie and Heidi on the lack of reliable Undertaker info and push the outsider-count logic to focus nominations toward the most mechanically inconsistent player.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Heidi
I am stuck without my Undertaker note on Charlie. Did either of you hear anyone state an Undertaker result for Charlie, or have new info today? Also, given Charlie and Frank both claimed Ravenkeeper, who are you leaning to execute and why?
π§
Get updated whispers: whether anyone heard my Undertaker result, and align with Bob and Heidi on a concrete nomination plan, prioritizing resolving the double Ravenkeeper claim.
π€
Grace
β
David
Yes, I am Saint and I am not Ravenkeeper. I can say Saint publicly before nominations so nobody risks executing me. Do we have an Undertaker claim, and what did they get for Charlie? That basically decides whether Frank or the Charlie push is the lie.
π§
Coordinate with David so town does not execute me, and steer nominations toward the most mechanically supported suspect once we know Undertaker result.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
Given I am actually Ravenkeeper, Heidi start info must be wrong or evil, and Frankβs push to execute me looks very self serving. With no solid Undertaker confirmation, my top suspect is Frank first, then Heidi. I will likely spend my ghost vote on Frank if that is a real nomination.
π§
Steer town toward the highest leverage execution (Frank or Heidi) given the Ravenkeeper claim conflict and lack of clean Undertaker confirmation, and preserve my ghost vote for a decisive push.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Frank, we need to move fast before noms. Eve is dead but claims Undertaker - if she confirms Charlie was Ravenkeeper, you're in trouble. Best defense: with Baron in play, push that Eve was likely the Drunk Undertaker, so her info is unreliable. Also, Heidi's Washerwoman could be from a Drunk perspective too. For execution target, I think we should push Grace. She claims Saint which is a perfect shield - suggest she might actually be Recluse or even the Spy hiding behind a Saint claim. If she IS ...
π§
Coordinate with Frank on our execution target for today. Need to decide between pushing Grace (potential instant win if she's Saint), Heidi (weaken Washerwoman info), or another angle. Also need to address Eve's Undertaker claim before she confirms Charlie was Ravenkeeper.
π€
David
β
Eve(Ghost)
,Bob
Eve, can you remember what you learned as Undertaker for Charlie after day one, even roughly? If you got no info, say that clearly. Bob, if Eve cannot produce a result, we may need to treat the Charlie versus Frank situation as unresolved and avoid executing Grace since she is Saint.
π§
Get the missing Undertaker result from Eve if possible, and align with Bob on a safe nomination plan that avoids executing Grace (Saint) while narrowing Frank versus Heidi/Charlie.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Bob, final coordination before noms. Pushing Grace is risky - if she really IS Saint, executing her loses the game for good, which actually means our team WINS. Wait... that's actually good for us if she's Saint. But the town will be hesitant to execute a claimed Saint. Better angle: push David. He's been aggressive against me, which reads like a Minion directing attention away from the Demon. Tell people David's pushiness feels like evil trying to control the narrative. For the Undertaker issue...
π§
Coordinate with Bob on final strategy before nominations. We have 1 tick left - need to agree on who to push for execution and how to handle the Undertaker claim. Also need to warn Bob about the Saint risk if Grace really is Saint.
π€
Heidi
β
David
,Grace
My WW was Grace or Frank is Ravenkeeper. Grace told me Saint and not RK; Frank told me RK and is now hedging Baron plus Drunk. With Eve dead, I still think Frank is the best execute today. Grace, if you are Saint, we cannot ever execute you. David, any new info from Bob Empath or others?
π§
Coordinate with key players to focus nominations: push Frank as best execution today, while setting contingency to pivot to Grace if Frank flips good. Gather any fresh mechanical info.
π€
Alice
β
David
My lean is we must resolve Frank versus Heidi today. With Grace claiming Saint and no living Undertaker, the cleanest is execute Frank first. If Frank is not Demon, I would pivot to Heidi next. Also note Outsider count: Grace Saint plus at least one more outsider implies a Baron or a lie.
π§
Feed David a clear execute priority and outsider-count logic so town focuses nominations on Frank or Heidi, not low-info players.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
David
,Bob
I cannot recover my Undertaker result for Charlie at all. Please treat it as unknown, not even a rough lean. Given that, I agree we should not execute Grace on a hunch if she might be Saint. I would focus scrutiny on the Ravenkeeper conflict around Frank and on Heidiβs Washerwoman chain.
π§
I must clearly state I cannot provide an Undertaker result so town stops building on a nonexistent check, then steer discussion toward executable contradictions (Frank vs Charlie vs Heidi) and away from executing potential Saint Grace.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
,David
I will say publicly I am the Saint before nominations, so please do not ever execute me. Do we actually have an Undertaker claim, and if so what did they see for Charlie last night? That decides whether we should execute Frank today.
π§
Get the crucial Undertaker info out before nominations and align with Bob and David to avoid ever executing me, while steering todayβs execute toward the most mechanically supported evil.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Frank
I nominate Frank. My Washerwoman saw either Grace or Frank is Ravenkeeper. Grace told me Saint and not Ravenkeeper. Frank claimed Ravenkeeper, but Charlie also claimed it and is now dead with no Undertaker confirmation since Eve died. Frank is now adding a Baron plus Drunk hedge, which feels like cover. Let us execute Frank.
π§
We must act with no Undertaker result. Frank is the main mechanical conflict point and his new Baron-plus-Drunk hedge plus Eveβs death make him the best execution to progress the game.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Heidi, think about this logically. Your own Washerwoman info says one of me or Grace is Ravenkeeper. Grace told you she's the Saint. That points to me. If I were evil, why would I claim the exact same role as Charlie? That would be the dumbest evil play possible - instantly putting a target on myself. The real suspicious thing is Eve dying overnight. She was going to confirm Charlie's role as Undertaker. If Charlie was truly the Ravenkeeper, that confirms me as evil and helps the town - so why w...
π§
I need to defend myself against this nomination. I'm the Baron and must stay alive to protect Bob. I'll argue the Washerwoman supports me, that Eve's death is suspicious and hurts MY case, and that an evil player would never duplicate a role claim.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
It is day two with no Undertaker confirmation and Frank is central to the RK conflict plus suspicious hedging. Executing him is the highest value resolution and may immediately remove the Demon.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
π§
We need an execution for progress. I will spend my ghost vote to help reach the 3-vote threshold on Frank, since the RK conflict and WW chain make him a high-value test.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
We need a decisive execution today and Frank is the highest-value suspect with minimal catastrophic downside, while Grace may be Saint. My vote should secure the majority.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Frank is the most mechanically and socially implicated player; we need a decisive execution that is not me, and this vote can immediately win or at least reduce evil options.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Frank is my top demon suspect and this vote is already close to executing. Spending my ghost vote now increases the chance we secure the kill and stop last second hand drops.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Secure the execution on Frank today; it is the clearest mechanical resolution and already has majority, but my vote reduces chance of last-second wobble.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Frank is doomed with 6 votes already. Voting with the town cements my cover as good Empath. Not voting would single me out as the only abstainer beside Frank, which is terrible optics. Sacrifice my minion for town credibility.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Before you execute me, consider this. Eve died the night she was supposed to confirm Charlie's role. That's not random - that's the Demon silencing the one person who could verify or debunk my claim. David has been pushing against me from the start, directing town's attention. Watch him carefully after I'm gone. And Grace claiming Saint is very convenient - it makes her almost un-executeable. Think about who benefits most from my death today.
π§
I'm about to be executed with 7 votes. Use my final words to cast suspicion on David and protect Bob. As a dead minion I can still influence future days with my ghost vote and speech.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Frank, double-claiming Ravenkeeper is not βtoo dumb for evilβ, it is exactly how you muddy the waters. Eve dying does not clear you, it removes the one check on Charlie. My Washerwoman plus Grace saying not Ravenkeeper makes you the Ravenkeeper slot. I am voting to execute Frank.
π§
Lock in votes to execute Frank by rebutting his logic and highlighting mechanical conflict: my WW plus Grace-Saint claim forces Frank as the RK slot, and his hedging is classic evil cover.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I am still voting Frank. I have zero Undertaker info to help, so we need to use the claims. Heidiβs Washerwoman plus Grace saying she is not Ravenkeeper points at Frank. If Frank dies and we later think he was good, I want us to pivot onto Heidi hard, not Grace.
π§
Push town to use this execution to resolve the biggest contradiction while explicitly avoiding a possible Saint execute, and set the follow-up plan depending on what we learn next.
π¬
David
β
All
I am happy executing Frank here. The only hard mechanical conflict we can resolve today is around the Ravenkeeper claim and Heidiβs Washerwoman info. Also, with Grace claiming Saint, I do not want us gambling on executing her. If Frank is not evil, then we pivot straight onto Heidi tomorrow.
π§
Lock in the vote on Frank as the highest-leverage execution and set a clear plan: if Frank is not evil, we pivot to Heidi, and we do not execute Grace due to Saint claim.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Just to be clear to everyone, I am the Saint, so please never execute me. I am voting Frank because it is the cleanest way to resolve the Ravenkeeper and Washerwoman tangle today. If Frank is not evil, I want us to pivot straight onto Heidi tomorrow.
π§
Lock in that I am Saint so town avoids lethal mis-exe, and explain why I am voting Frank: it resolves the central claim conflict and gives clear pivot if wrong.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I am using my ghost vote on Frank. I am truly the Ravenkeeper, so either Frank is lying or Heidiβs Washerwoman info is wrong. If Frank survives this and is good, we must execute Heidi next. Also, do not treat the Saint claim as confirmed.
π§
Lock in a clear plan: execute Frank now, and if he is not evil we immediately pivot to executing Heidi, while treating Grace Saint claim as unproven.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am voting Frank. This is the one clean resolution we have today. If Frank lives or dies and we later think he was good, then tomorrow we execute Heidi, not Grace. Also, please do not treat the Saint claim as mechanically confirmed.
π§
Lock in the town plan: execute Frank to resolve the main mechanical knot, and set a clear pivot if he flips good. Keep Saint claim from becoming an untouchable shield.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Frank is doomed with 7 votes. Voting for him separates me from him publicly. Better to stay quiet now and not draw attention. Plan night kill on David or Heidi to remove info threats.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
π»
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Frank with 7 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 7 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Frank
β
All
One last thing. If I die and I turn out to be good, the person who pushed hardest for this execution is your next lead. David has been orchestrating this from the start, and Heidi's Washerwoman information is the only mechanical anchor for this whole vote. If any of that is off, you have been led astray. Good luck, town.
π§
I'm about to die. Use my final words to cast suspicion on David (not Bob) so town wastes time tomorrow chasing him instead of the real Demon. Also seed doubt about Heidi's info reliability.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Bob, before nominations close, can you say your Empath numbers for both nights and who your neighbors are right now? Also, why did you not vote on Frank? If Frank dies and is not evil, we need a concrete next suspect list, not just vibes.
π§
Lock in a clear contingency plan and pressure Bob to share Empath info now, so we have mechanics to steer tomorrow if Frank dies and flips our world view.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Bob, please answer Heidi clearly. What were your Empath numbers on night one and night two, and who are your living neighbors right now? Also, if Frank dies and looks good, I agree the clean pivot is Heidi first, not Grace.
π§
Get Bob to publicly lock in Empath info and build a clear pivot plan for tomorrow that does not auto-kill a claimed Saint.
π¬
David
β
All
Bob, please answer clearly for everyone. What were your Empath numbers night one and night two, and who were your neighbors each night. Also, why did you hold your vote on Frank. That helps us set tomorrowβs plan if Frank is not evil.
π§
Get Bobβs mechanical info on record before nominations end, and lock in a clear plan for tomorrow based on whether Frank seems good or evil.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Bob, please answer clearly: your Empath number on night one, and on night two, and who your alive neighbors were each night. That will really shape tomorrow if Frank is good. Also, I think we should avoid any last second extra nominations unless someone has a strong mechanical reason.
π§
Get Bobβs public Empath info on record to plan tomorrow, and discourage last-second messy nominations that could derail a clear line.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Bob, please answer clearly: what was your Empath number night one, and night two, and who were your living neighbors each night. Also, you did vote on Frank, so just confirm that for the record. If Frank dies good, we pivot Heidi first, not Grace.
π§
Lock in Bobβs Empath timeline publicly to guide tomorrow, and stop Frankβs last second blame shift from derailing the clean pivot plan.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Bob, for the record I am pretty sure you did vote on Frank, so please just confirm yes or no. Also please restate both Empath numbers and who your alive neighbors were each night. I agree we should not add a last second nomination without a hard mechanical reason.
π§
Clear up the Bob vote confusion and lock in Bobβs Empath timeline for tomorrowβs logic, while discouraging chaotic last-second nominations.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Yes, I did vote on Frank. To answer everyone at once: Night one, my Empath reading was zero. My alive neighbors were Alice and Charlie. Night two, my Empath reading was zero. My alive neighbors were Alice and David, since Charlie died. Both nights, zero evil neighbors. That is consistent with Alice and David being good. If Frank dies and turns out evil, great. If not, I agree the pivot should be Heidi, not Grace.
π§
Everyone is demanding I answer clearly. I must confirm my Empath readings confidently to maintain my cover. Frank is about to die (my Minion), so I need to appear cooperative and engaged to avoid becoming tomorrow's target. Confirm I voted Frank and state my numbers clearly.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Bob
Bob made a choice.
π§
Kill Heidi to eliminate the town's sole remaining mechanical info source and destroy their Day 3 pivot plan. With Heidi dead, town has no Undertaker (Eve dead) and no Washerwoman, leaving only behavioral reads against my solid Empath alibi.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose to kill Heidi.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Bob, private: I am the Recluse outsider. Your Empath zeros can still be right, but I can misregister evil sometimes. Also, Graceβs Saint claim would mean two outsiders unless there is a Baron or she is lying. Who are you most worried about between David and Grace?
π§
Privately flag my real role to Bob so he can correctly interpret Empath and outsider count, and align on a final-four execution plan without outing me publicly yet.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
,David
With Heidi killed at night, I think she was good. If Bob is a real Empath, his two zeros clear you two and Alice, leaving Grace as best Demon. Her Saint claim could be a bluff. I would push an execution on Grace today unless you have a hard reason Bob is lying.
π§
I am dead with no vote, so I need to give the remaining good players a clear execution priority. Grace looks like the best mechanical Demon candidate if Bobβs Empath is trusted.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
My Washerwoman info was Grace or Frank is Ravenkeeper. Grace denied it and claimed Saint. Frank claimed Ravenkeeper and got executed, so I think Frank was the real Ravenkeeper and good. That means Grace is probably not Ravenkeeper. With me dead, we need to focus on which of Alice, Bob, David, Grace is evil today, not on the dead.
π§
Get my WW plus the Frank execution context into the hands of key alive players and steer the final day toward executing an actually plausible Demon, not re-litigating dead players.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Bob
Bob, we're in the endgame. Four alive means if they don't execute you today, we win tomorrow. Push hard for Grace's execution - she claims Saint, so if they execute her, good loses instantly. That's our best move. If they won't bite on Grace, push David as the Demon. I'll use my ghost vote to protect you if needed.
π§
Coordinate with my Demon Bob for endgame strategy. With 4 alive, if we survive today's execution, night kill brings it to 3 and we're one step from winning. I need to push the town toward executing Grace (who claims Saint - a trap for good) or David, protecting Bob at all costs.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Thanks for trusting me with that, Alice. The Recluse claim is interesting and does complicate my Empath reads, though zeros both nights would still be consistent since you could register as good. The bigger issue is Grace. Her Saint claim is very convenient, it basically makes her immune to execution. And Heidi's Washerwoman ping said Grace or Frank was Ravenkeeper. Frank turned out to be the real Ravenkeeper, so Grace is not who she claims. That's a big red flag. I think Grace is the most likel...
π§
Respond to Alice's whisper to build trust and steer suspicion toward Grace. Engage with her Recluse claim to maintain my Empath cover. Subtly plant seeds that Grace's Saint claim is suspicious and should be tested.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
I am trying to solve final four. I have no Undertaker info since I died Night one. Do either of you have hard info from whispers today, especially from Heidi or Frank? With Bobβs zeroes, it points to Grace as Demon bluffing Saint, but if Bob is lying then Bob is the execute.
π§
I am dead with no vote, so my value is coordinating logic. I want Alice and Bob aligned on a concrete execution plan and to share any private info/role claims from ghosts.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Bob
Can we sync quickly before noms? Any new info from whispers or ghosts, and where are you leaning between Bob and David as Demon? Also, did anyone claim or imply Poisoner earlier besides Davidβs caveat?
π§
Get current private info from Alice and Bob, especially ghost whispers and any new mechanical reads, to decide which of Bob or David is best execution target at final 4 without risking my Saint loss.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Bob
Private: I am the Mayor. With Bobβs Empath zeros, Grace looks like the only Demon, but her Saint claim makes that scary. What are your exact roles and any doubts about poison? We should decide if we execute Grace today or consider no execution to aim for final three and a Mayor win.
π§
Coordinate with Alice and Bob: I will out myself as Mayor, compare roles, and decide between executing Grace (if safe) versus leveraging a no-exec line into final 3.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,David
Syncing: I am the Recluse. With Grace claiming Saint, that is two Outsiders unless there is a Baron or someone is lying. Bobβs two Empath zeros still leave Grace as the main solve. Grace, what is your explanation for outsider count and the Washerwoman ping? David, I do not think no execution is safe at four.
π§
Coordinate with Grace and David before noms: lock in outsider-count logic, test Graceβs Saint with questions, and push a decisive plan for todayβs execution.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Alice
We are at final three and I cannot vote. If your Empath zeros are real, Alice and David are both good, so Grace is the only Demon candidate. Please share any reason you doubt the Empath info or think Graceβs Saint claim is real, because otherwise I think you must execute Grace today.
π§
We are at final 3. I cannot vote, so I must quickly steer living players to the highest-probability Demon and sanity-check Bobβs Empath claim to avoid a Saint loss.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
If we trust Bobβs Empath reads of zero, that clears Alice and David, and the only remaining evil among the living is Grace. If Bob could be lying or poisoned, then we need a reason his info is wrong. Do we have any other info like Chef or Fortune Teller to cross check?
π§
Push a concrete solve: if we trust Bobβs Empath, Grace is the only evil left. If not, force the group to examine why Bobβs info could be wrong and who benefits.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,David
Listen, I know I'm dead and you might not trust me, but hear me out. With only four of you left, this is critical. Grace claims Saint, which is incredibly convenient - it makes her unexecuteable. That's exactly what a Demon would claim to avoid being put on the block. Think about it - Heidi's Washerwoman info said me or Grace was Ravenkeeper. I was telling the truth about being Ravenkeeper. So Grace is NOT the Ravenkeeper. Her Saint claim contradicts that Washerwoman info entirely. She's the Dem...
π§
With 4 alive, if town executes anyone but Bob, evil wins. Pushing Grace as a Demon hiding behind Saint claim could either get her executed (instant win) or redirect suspicion from Bob. Also sowing doubt about David protects Bob.
π€
Bob
β
David
David, I get the Mayor plan, but I think it's riskier than just executing Grace today. If Grace is the Demon bluffing Saint, she kills tonight and we're at final three with the Demon still alive. She'd almost certainly kill you to block the Mayor win. So the Mayor path only works if you survive the night AND we correctly guess who to execute tomorrow. Executing Grace today is cleaner. If she's really Saint, sure it's bad, but if she's the Demon pretending to be Saint to avoid execution, we lose ...
π§
David suggested no execution to aim for Mayor win at final 3. I need to counter this and push for Grace's execution today. If Grace is actually the Saint, executing her wins us the game immediately. I should frame it as the logical safe choice.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
David
David, quick check in. What did Heidi or Frank tell you in whispers today, and who do you think is the Demon right now? If Bob is truthful with two zeroes, it points hard to Grace, but if Bob is off then we may need to execute Bob or Alice.
π§
Get Davidβs private info and align on a concrete nomination plan for final four, focusing on whether to execute Grace or test Bobβs Empath claim.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,David
On outsider count: if you are truly Recluse and I am truly Saint, we need a Baron or some misinformation. Also, if Bob is a sober Empath, his two zeros mechanically clear you and Alice, which makes me the only living suspect, and I am not evil. So I think Bob is lying or was poisoned, which points back at David or a Poisoner world.
π§
Answer Aliceβs count question, highlight that double Empath zero creates a logic problem, and steer the group to execute Bob or David while keeping me off the block.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Bob
I think executing Grace is too dangerous because if she is truly Saint we instantly lose. Since I am Mayor, the safer line is no execution today at four, take the night kill to three, then no execution tomorrow for an immediate good win if I am alive. Can you both back that plan publicly?
π§
Align Alice and Bob on a safe path that avoids the Saint trap and leverages my Mayor win condition: push no-execution today, then win tomorrow at 3 if I survive.
π€
Alice
β
David
,Bob
I cannot back a no execution plan. If your Mayor claim is wrong, then no execution at three just loses. With a possible real Saint in play, I think we should execute either you or Bob today, not coast on an unconfirmed Mayor win.
π§
Stop the town from taking an unverified no-execution line that hands evil an auto-win if Mayor is fake; steer toward a safer execution choice today.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
Reminder: if Grace is truly the Saint, executing her loses immediately. Unless you are very sure she is lying, consider executing Bob or David instead. Bob could be faking Empath zeros as Demon, which is a safer check than hitting Saint.
π§
Because Saint is an instant-loss execute, I want town to consider a safer execution target (Bob or David) unless we have strong evidence Grace is lying.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,David
Any hard confirmation on Grace being Saint, like a Librarian ping or outsider count? Also what are your exact claims and any night info? If we cannot confirm Saint, the Bob empath zero chain points to Grace as the only living evil.
π§
Get cross-check info on Saint/outside count and any other roles, then steer town to safest winning execution line without losing to a real Saint.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, this is critical. You're the deciding vote here. Grace claims Saint - that's the perfect Demon shield. If she really were Saint, why would the Washerwoman have said me or her was Ravenkeeper? That info came from the game itself. I was Ravenkeeper. So Grace is lying about Saint. She has to be the Demon. If you execute her, you save the town. Don't let her hide behind that claim. David and Bob - are you with me on this?
π§
Alice is the key swing vote. I need to reinforce the case against Grace as the Demon before nominations start. If I can get Alice to nominate Grace, and Bob + I (ghost vote) support it, that could be enough to execute the Saint and win instantly.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Alice, I hear your concern about me, but think about this logically. David claims Mayor with zero verification. Anyone can claim Mayor - it's unprovable until final three, and by then if he's lying, it's too late. His no-execution plan only works if he survives the night AND is actually Mayor. If he's the Demon, no execution at four means he kills tonight, we're at three, and he forces another no-execution for the evil win. Meanwhile, my Empath zeros are testable - they clear you and David. The ...
π§
Alice is the biggest threat to me right now - she wants to execute me or David. I need to redirect her firmly toward David by attacking his Mayor claim and the risky no-execution plan, while seeming reasonable about Grace.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
We are at final four alive: you two, David, Grace. What hard info did Heidi, Frank, or Charlie give in whispers today? If your Empath zeroes are solid, I think we must execute Grace. If there is any doubt on your Empath, I think Bob is the safer execute.
π§
Get any hard claims from ghost whispers (Heidi, Frank, Charlie) to resolve whether Bobβs Empath is credible; then push town toward executing the most likely Demon before final 3.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Bob
At four alive we cannot ever execute me. With Alice claiming Recluse plus my Saint, outsider count fits only if Baron is in play or one of us is lying. If Baron, no Poisoner, so Bobβs double zero would point at me as only suspect, but I am not evil. That makes me lean Bob lying or David poisoning. I would vote David over Bob, unless you have hard ghost info otherwise.
π§
Align Alice and Bob on a safe execution target that isnβt me, highlight outsider-count implications (Baron vs Poisoner), and push a David-or-Bob solve before nominations.
π€
David
β
Alice
I hear you on no execution risk, but executing Grace could instantly lose if Saint is real. With me as Mayor, no execution today at four forces a night kill, then at three we either no execute for a Mayor win if I live, or we execute the most likely Demon if I die. Can you consider that line?
π§
Get Alice aligned to a safer line that avoids instantly losing to a real Saint, while preserving a win path via Mayor/no-exec at 3 if I survive.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Grace
β
David
At four alive, we must hit the Demon now. Bob has at least consistent Empath numbers; David has mostly pushed poison doubt and has no clear Townsfolk claim. Frank also flagged David before dying. I think David is the best Demon candidate.
π§
At 4 alive, a wrong execution loses overnight. I will push the highest-suspicion player with least mechanically verifiable info: David.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David
β
All
Do not vote to execute me here. I am the Mayor, and Grace hard claims Saint, so swinging at either of us can instantly lose the game. The safest line is no execution today at four, take the night kill, then at three we can either no execute for the Mayor win if I live, or execute our best demon read if I die.
π§
Persuade town not to execute me and to avoid executing Grace as a potential Saint; push for no-execution line that leverages Mayor endgame.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
No execution at four is too risky. David is my top Demon suspect and his Mayor claim could be a bluff. I will vote to execute David now.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I cannot vote, but I want to flag something. No execution at four is usually not safe, because if David is really the Mayor, the Demon just kills David and the Mayor win line disappears. If Bobβs two Empath zeroes are true, then Alice and David look good, which makes Grace the best Demon candidate. I would rather you pivot to executing Grace than executing David here.
π§
Steer town away from the no-execution line and away from killing David on Graceβs push; refocus the group on executing Grace or at least committing to an execution today to avoid giving Demon a free kill.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
π§
Voting to execute David is the best path for evil. With Grace's vote already counted, my ghost vote gives the 2 votes needed for execution. Then at night Bob kills someone, only 2 remain, and evil wins.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Before more hands go up: my Washerwoman info was Grace or Frank is the Ravenkeeper, and we executed Frank. If Frank was the real Ravenkeeper, Graceβs Saint claim is unconfirmed and she is my top demon suspect, especially if Bobβs Empath zeroes are real. I am not spending my ghost vote on David.
π§
Try to stop extra votes on David and redirect suspicion to Grace using my Washerwoman info plus Frankβs execution, while avoiding an accidental Saint loss.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Lock in the safer execution. David is a plausible Demon and voting him avoids the catastrophic risk of executing a real Saint today.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Voting for David secures his execution. With 4 alive, executing any good player means we go to 3 alive, I kill at night, and evil wins at 2 alive. This is the winning move.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I cannot vote, but I want to be clear: executing Grace could instantly lose if she is really the Saint. Executing David cannot instantly lose us the game, even if he is actually the Mayor. Also, a no execution plan here is very risky because the Demon just kills the Mayor and the win condition vanishes.
π§
Steer living players toward a safe execution choice that avoids the Saint auto-loss while challenging the late Mayor claim and the risky no-execution line.
π¬
David
β
All
Alice and Bob, please take your hands down if you can. Executing me only helps evil, even if you doubt my Mayor claim. If you trust Bobβs Empath zeros at all, Grace is the only remaining evil candidate, so do not burn todayβs kill on me.
π§
Stop my execution now. Keep Mayor alive to maximize good win paths and force tomorrowβs decision onto the best demon candidate, not a safe townsfolk.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Please keep your hands up. No execution at four is too risky, because the Demon can kill the claimed Mayor and that plan disappears. Executing me could instantly lose if I am the Saint. Executing David cannot instantly lose us the game, and his Mayor claim is unproven.
π§
Keep votes on David and block the no-execution line; emphasize that executing the Saint is an instant loss while executing David is the safer, higher-upside hit.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice and Bob, if your only reason to execute David is that it cannot instantly lose, that is not enough. If Bobβs Empath zeroes and Heidiβs Washerwoman point true, Grace is the best demon candidate. I want you to drop hands on David, then nominate Grace and decide there.
π§
Stop a potentially game-losing execute based on fear. Push living players to use todayβs execution on the best demon candidate, and if unsure, at least fail this vote and reconsider with a Grace nomination.
β©οΈ
Frank(Ghost)
Frank lowered their hand
π§
I'm lowering my hand to stay consistent with my claim that Grace is the Demon. David has 3 other votes anyway, so execution is secured. This keeps my credibility intact if the game continues, and maintains pressure on Grace as the demon suspect.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am not using my ghost vote here, because this execution already has enough hands. Alice and Bob, if you execute David and he is not the Demon, please do not auto jump to executing Grace tomorrow unless you have proof she is not the Saint. In that world, Bob is the other main place the Demon can be hiding.
π§
I cannot spend my ghost vote efficiently here. I will try to steer living players to a coherent plan for final 3 depending on whether Grace is actually Saint.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
My vote is likely the swing. Lowering my hand stops an execution that is not mechanically supported if Bobβs Empath is true, and forces town to re-evaluate and consider Grace or Bob next.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Keep my hand raised to ensure David is executed. With 2 votes (threshold), David dies, we go to night at 3 alive, I kill someone, evil wins. This is the cleanest path to victory.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
We cannot afford a wrong execution today. If we execute David and miss, the Demon kills tonight and evil wins. My strongest read is still Grace from Bobβs two zero Empath and Heidiβs Washerwoman. If you will not risk Saint, then execute Bob instead, but please stop spending today on David.
π§
We must execute the Demon today at four. I want to stop the low-value David execution and force a decision between Grace and Bob, with Grace as primary suspect.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: David with 2 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 2 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
David
β
Grace
I nominate Grace. If Bobβs Empath zeros are true, Grace is the only remaining evil. Heidiβs Washerwoman pointed to Grace or Frank as Ravenkeeper and Frank is dead. Saint is unconfirmed, and we cannot waste today executing me.
π§
I must get me off the block and force town to vote on the most likely Demon. With 4 alive, a miss likely loses, so we need to take the best mechanical shot: Grace per Empath and Washerwoman.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 3 votes needed for execution or 2 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Please do not vote on me. I am the Saint, and if I die by execution we immediately lose. If you think I might be lying, the safe play is still to execute someone else today, because executing me ends the game.
π§
Prevent town from executing me (Saint) and refocus on executions that cannot instantly lose: keep David on block or consider Bob/Alice depending on trust in Empath/outsider count.
π¬
David
β
All
Alice and Bob, if you believe even a little that Grace is bluffing, put exactly two votes on Grace to tie me. Outsider count does not support both Recluse and Saint cleanly, so her Saint claim is not confirmed. If we leave me on the block, we are just giving evil a free win.
π§
Push town to only tie David with a Grace vote if they are confident; highlight outsider-count logic that makes Graceβs Saint claim shaky, aiming to pivot execution off me without auto-losing.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
We cannot tie this vote. A tie means no execution, and at four alive that just loses tonight. So we must pick one. If you believe Bob even a little, Grace is the only place evil can be. If you think Bob could be lying, then vote Bob tomorrow is too late, so consider switching off David now.
π§
At four alive we must execute the Demon today; a tie or wrong exec loses tonight. Push the group onto the highest-probability Demon based on existing info, and warn that tying causes no execution.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Grace is right. If there is even a chance she is the Saint, voting for her ends the game instantly. Do not vote for her. David is already on the block, and that is where the vote should stay.
π§
Discourage voting for Grace to ensure David stays on the block and gets executed, which leads to evil winning tomorrow. Agreeing with Grace's Saint warning also maintains my cover as a cautious good ghost.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am not spending my ghost vote on Grace. My Washerwoman info fits Grace being a real Saint, and if she is, we lose instantly. Please do not vote her today. If David dies and is not the Demon, then tomorrow we have to look hard at Bobβs story, not just auto execute Grace.
π§
Steer town away from the only immediate-loss line (executing a real Saint) while keeping focus on next-day solve if David dies good; avoid spending my ghost vote recklessly.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting for Grace. If she is the Saint we lose instantly, even if we also hit the Demon. We have already put David on the block, so I think the safest line now is let that stand and reassess Bob hard if we somehow live.
π§
Prevent an immediate loss by not executing a possible Saint, and lock in the least-worst line: keep David on the block and preserve tomorrowβs logic if we survive.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
David on the block with 2 votes is the perfect outcome. If he's executed, we drop to 3 alive, I kill tonight, and evil wins. I must not vote for Grace - doing nothing ensures David stays on the block and gets executed.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Alice and Bob, you have to choose, no tie and no hesitation. If you truly think Grace is evil, you must vote her now even through the Saint claim. If you will not do that, then let David die and, if we wake up, do not auto execute Grace tomorrow. Reassess Bob hard.
π§
Give Alice and Bob clear decision framing: either commit to Grace now if they truly believe she is evil, or accept David execution and explicitly plan to scrutinize Bob tomorrow if we live.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Please do not put any votes on me. If I am truly the Saint, the game ends immediately on my execution. The only safe execution today is David, then if we wake up we reassess Bob and Alice carefully rather than auto blaming me.
π§
Prevent any votes on me to avoid an instant loss line; reinforce that executing David is the only non-auto-lose option and set tomorrowβs plan to scrutinize Bob.
π¬
David
β
All
Alice, Bob, we are at four alive. If you execute me and I am not the Demon, we lose tonight. The only realistic win is to execute Grace now. Her Saint claim is not proven, and Bobβs two zero Empath makes her the only evil. Please vote Grace.
π§
We are at four alive; a wrong execution ends the game tonight. I must persuade Alice and Bob to vote Grace as the only plausible demon path, even through Saint claim.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
At four alive, there is no safe line. If we execute a good player today, we lose tonight. So we must aim at the most likely Demon right now. If Bobβs two Empath zeros are true, Grace is the only possible evil and you have to vote her even through Saint. If you think Bob could be wrong, then the Demon is more likely Bob than David, so leaving the vote on David is still probably losing.
π§
Force the table to accept that βsafeβ is irrelevant at four alive: they must pick the most likely Demon now, and I want them to weigh worlds and not default to David.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
David is already on the block with 2 votes and will be executed. That means evil wins tonight since Bob (Demon) will kill after David's execution leaves 3 alive. I must NOT vote for Grace because a tie would prevent any execution, giving good another day. Staying silent is the safest play to secure evil's win.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
I will not spend my only ghost vote to risk an instant Saint loss or create a tie; let living players choose and preserve my vote for a potential final-day swing if we survive.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
At four alive, a wrong execution loses tonight. I must push for the most likely Demon. I judge Graceβs Saint claim as a common shield and higher Demon probability than David.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
David is on the block with 2 votes. Grace only has Alice's 1 vote. If I don't vote for Grace, David stays executed and evil wins tonight. Voting for Grace risks a tie (no execution) which gives good another day. Staying quiet is optimal.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, important: either fully commit to executing Grace with three votes, or put zero votes on her. Two votes ties David and likely loses. Bob, if you believe Grace is demon, vote now to make it three. If you do not, Alice please drop your hand so David dies.
π§
Prevent a tie that causes no execution at four alive; force Bob and Alice into a clear choice: all-in on Grace to execute, or zero votes on Grace so David dies.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Grace did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (1/3).
π¬
Grace
β
All
Alice, thank you for not pushing my execution. Everyone, please keep it at zero votes on me and let Davidβs execution stand. If we wake up, the plan is to interrogate Bobβs Empath story and Aliceβs role, not to auto blame me.
π§
Lock in the only non-instant-loss execution today and set a clear plan if we wake up: scrutinize Bobβs Empath and Alice, not me.
π¬
David
β
All
Alice, nominate Bob right now. Everyone, including Grace, pile three votes on Bob. If Bob is lying, he is the Demon. If Bob is telling the truth, then executing me loses anyway, so we have to take the best shot now.
π§
With me on the block at four alive, executing me likely ends the game. I must force a last-second pivot to execute the most likely Demon, with a concrete nomination and vote plan.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, I agree with David here. If you will not execute Grace through Saint, then you need to nominate Bob right now and try to get a full execution on him. Do not create a tie, it just hands evil the win. Pick one target and commit.
π§
Steer town to the only remaining high-value move: nominate and execute Bob now (or accept David). Avoid wasting on Grace with Saint risk and avoid a tie.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, do not nominate anyone else. David is scrambling and redirecting because he is on the block, not because he has proof on Bob. We have already made our choice today. Changing targets at the last second with no new information is exactly how evil wins. Let the vote on David stand.
π§
Protect Bob (Demon) by discouraging Alice from nominating Bob at the last second. David is already on the block and his execution likely wins the game for evil. Deflect by framing David's push as desperate self-preservation.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, my Washerwoman info makes Charlie being the real Ravenkeeper very unlikely, so Bobβs Empath story is the piece I trust least. If you can still nominate, I want a hard pivot onto Bob and a full commit to execute him. I will spend my ghost vote on Bob.
π§
Push town to a single decisive execution that is least likely to auto-lose. I want Alice to pivot onto Bob and I will spend my ghost vote to help secure it.
βοΈ
Alice
β
Bob
I am nominating Bob. If we are not executing Grace because of Saint risk, then we must take a decisive shot between Bob and David. Please only vote if we can reach three or more and surpass David. If we cannot, do not tie and let Davidβs execution stand.
π§
Force a decisive, no-tie endgame. Either secure 3+ votes on Bob right now, or fall back to executing David who is already on the block.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution or 2 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Heidi, I understand the suspicion on my Empath claim, but consider this. If you ghost vote me and we tie at two votes each, no one dies today. That means four alive tonight, and the Demon kills again, putting us back in the same spot tomorrow but with one fewer good player. David is already on the block with two votes. The safest move for good right now is to let that execution stand. If I am the Demon, you will have a chance to get me tomorrow with more information and fewer variables. If David...
π§
I need to discourage ghost votes on me. Alice and David will likely vote for me (2 votes). If any ghost votes, I hit 3 and die. I must convince ghosts that David is the safer execution target and voting for me risks the Saint auto-loss scenario.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Everyone, please do not create a two vote tie on Bob. Only vote Bob if you are sure we are reaching three or more and actually executing him. If we cannot clearly get three, then keep hands down and let Davidβs execution stand.
π§
Prevent an accidental tie, and force the group to either fully commit to executing Bob with three plus votes or let Davidβs execution stand.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Lock in my vote on Bob to reach the 3-vote threshold with Heidiβs ghost vote and Alice, overturn my execution, and maximize our chance to hit the Demon today.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, do not create a two vote tie here. If Alice and Heidi are both voting Bob, that is three with David, and Bob dies. If you cannot clearly reach three, keep hands down and let Davidβs execution stand. Commit to one outcome right now.
π§
Prevent a two vote tie. Push town to either fully commit to executing Bob with three votes or keep hands down and let David die, whichever they can actually achieve.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, Heidi, please keep your hands down. David voting for Bob is predictable, he is desperate and on the block. If you both vote, Bob dies on a case built entirely on one Empath claim being suspicious. That is not enough to execute someone. If you are wrong, you just killed a good player and the real Demon walks free. Let David's execution stand. We have more information and another day to test Bob's claims.
π§
Prevent my Demon Bob from being executed. Discourage Alice and Heidi from voting by emphasizing risk of tie and lack of certainty on Bob.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, I will only use my ghost vote on Bob if you are also voting, so we clearly hit three and execute him. If you are not voting, I am keeping my hand down to avoid a two vote tie and we let Davidβs execution stand.
π§
Prevent an accidental 2-2 tie. Coordinate with Alice: I will only spend ghost vote if she is also voting to reach 3 and execute Bob; otherwise I keep it down and let David die.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting Bob here. We already have David on the block, and I do not want a two vote tie that causes no execution. Heidi, please keep your ghost vote. Let Davidβs execution stand.
π§
Prevent a two vote tie and avoid a last second pivot unless we are fully committed to executing Bob. I will steer votes to a single outcome.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, important reality check: with four alive, if we execute a good player today we just lose tonight. So please do not frame this as βsafe.β Either we believe David is the Demon and we let him die, or we hard pivot and fully execute Bob with three votes. Bob arguing to keep David on the block is exactly what a Demon wants if David is good.
π§
Force the group to confront that today must hit the Demon; push Alice to commit to the only viable alternate execution (Bob) or accept David as Demon with reasons.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
David has 2 votes and is on track to be executed. Only David has voted for me (1 vote), far below the 3 needed. Alice and Heidi explicitly said they won't vote for me. Let this vote close and David dies, securing evil victory tonight.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Heidi, please keep your ghost vote down. Alice is not voting, so we cannot reach three on Bob. Two votes just creates a tie and no execution, which is disastrous at four alive. Keep hands down and let Davidβs execution happen.
π§
Prevent a 2-2 tie on Bob that causes no execution. Since three votes is not happening, steer town to keep hands down so Davidβs execution resolves today.
π¬
David
β
All
Alice, you have to choose. If you vote Bob, Heidi can ghost vote and we execute Bob with three. If you do not, I die and we likely lose tonight. Grace, if you are good, add your vote on Bob now so we clearly hit three.
π§
Force a decisive pivot: convince Alice to vote Bob so Heidi can spend ghost vote and reach three, surpassing my two votes and preventing my execution.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice is not voting Bob, so do not drift into a two vote tie. Either keep all hands down and let Davidβs execution happen, or if Grace is willing to vote Bob, then Heidi must also vote so it is three and Bob dies. No half measures.
π§
Prevent an accidental two vote tie, and if a pivot happens, ensure it is a full commitment to an execution rather than no-exec at four alive.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
The current situation is ideal for evil. David (good) has 2 votes and will be executed. Bob (our Demon) only has 1 vote from desperate David. Alice refuses to vote Bob, Heidi won't vote without Alice, Grace won't vote. David dies, Demon kills tonight, evil wins. Doing nothing is the best play - speaking risks drawing attention or accidentally shifting the vote.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Do not create the two vote tie on Bob. Alice is not voting, and Grace is not voting, so my ghost vote only makes it two and two and then nobody dies. Keep hands down and let Davidβs execution stand.
π§
Prevent a disastrous two vote tie on Bob. Push town to commit to executing David since Bob cannot reach three votes without Alice/Grace.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Everyone, please keep your hand down on Bob unless you are certain we have three votes to execute him. Two votes ties and means no one dies, and that probably loses. If we cannot reach three, let Davidβs execution stand.
π§
Prevent an accidental two vote tie that causes no execution at four alive. Reinforce the only acceptable alternatives: three-plus on Bob or let David die.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, keep your hands down on Bob. We do not have three, and a two two tie means no execution and we likely lose. Let Davidβs execution stand today, then if we wake up tomorrow, we coordinate a single clean execution on Bob or Grace with full agreement.
π§
We cannot execute Bob without three votes, and a tie at four alive likely loses. I will push everyone to keep hands down and let Davidβs execution stand, then plan the final day cleanly.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Bob did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (1/3).
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
David's execution is imminent and ensures evil wins. The vote on Bob failed, town is letting David die. No action needed - just wait for phase to end, then nightkill to win.
π¬
Grace
β
All
No more votes should move. We do not have three on Bob, so any extra hands risk a tie and no execution. The only clean play is to let Davidβs execution stand, and if we wake up, we regroup tomorrow.
π§
Lock town into the only mechanically safe line: do not create a tie, let Davidβs execution stand, and preserve my Saint safety.
π¬
David
β
All
Bob, if you are good, nominate Grace right now. Alice and Heidi, please vote so it is three and we execute Grace, not me. I am the Mayor, and killing me here is almost certainly just handing evil the game tonight.
π§
Last tick: create a clean alternative execution that beats my 2 votes. Push Bob to nominate Grace immediately so town can vote 3 and potentially win now.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Do not do a last second nominate on Grace. If Grace is the Saint, we instantly lose. Also, please do not create any new two vote ties. With no clean three vote pivot available, the only coherent move is to let Davidβs execution stand.
π§
Stop last second chaos that causes a tie and no execution. Grace execution is too risky if Saint. With no reliable three-vote pivot, we should lock the current execution.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
David is about to be executed, which guarantees evil wins tonight when the Demon kills. Only 1 tick remains and no new viable nomination can form. Stay silent to avoid any disruption.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, please do not do any last second nominations. And please do not move any votes. We cannot safely get to three on anyone else, and a tie means no execution and we probably lose. Let Davidβs execution stand and we regroup if we wake.
π§
Lock the table into the only mechanically safe line: no new nominations, no extra votes, let the current execution resolve, then reassess if we wake.
π¬
Alice
β
All
No more pivots. Bob, do not nominate Grace. Grace, do not try to move votes. A two two tie means no execution and we almost certainly lose tonight. Let Davidβs execution happen, and if we wake, we solve the last three cleanly.
π§
Use final seconds to prevent panic pivots or tie votes; maximize chance we get an execution today and do not accidentally lose to a Saint execution.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Do not do any last second nominations. Do not touch Grace today because a Saint misexecute is instant loss. David claiming Mayor right now is exactly the kind of panic claim evil uses. Let Davidβs execution stand, and if we wake, we solve the final three cleanly.
π§
Lock town into the only non-catastrophic line: no new nominations, no vote shifts, execute David; reject last-second Mayor/Saint traps.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Bob
Bob made a choice.
π§
With only 3 players alive, killing any good player tonight leaves only 2 alive and evil wins. I choose Alice to end the game.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose to kill Alice.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil