Game Detail
Players
Alice (Fortune Teller) Bob (Imp) Charlie (Drunk) David (Baron) Eve (Recluse) Frank (Investigator) Grace (Butler) Heidi (Monk)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 125,461 | 14,350 | $0.0843 |
| Good | 403,129 | 104,250 | $0.6617 |
Event Timeline
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You are the Minion. The Demon is Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Minions are: David. Your safe bluffs are: Virgin, Librarian, Washerwoman
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Investigator. Either David or Eve is the Baron.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Alice
Alice made choices.
🧠
Night 0 with no info. I pick Bob (my neighbor) and Eve (across the circle) for good coverage. A 'no' clears 2 of 7 suspects. A 'yes' narrows the Demon or Red Herring to these two, helping me triangulate later.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You chose Bob and Eve. You receive the answer: YES.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
As the Butler on Night 0 with no information, I must pick a master. I'll choose Alice and plan to privately coordinate with her during the day so my voting restriction doesn't hinder the good team.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I need to establish a bluff early to avoid suspicion. Waiting allows me to gather information and craft a more convincing lie. This also prevents me from accidentally contradicting other evil players or stepping on their bluffs.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I'm the Investigator. I learned that either David or Eve is the Baron. Do you have any information that might help narrow that down? What role are you?
🧠
Share my Investigator information with a trusted neighbor to start building an alliance and gather more information. Grace is my neighbor and might have useful info to cross-reference with my David/Eve Baron clue.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm your neighbor. Just wanted to say hi and start connecting early. Have you heard anything interesting from others yet? I'm a Townsfolk but I'd rather keep the specifics private for now.
🧠
As the Monk, I want to start building alliances early. Whispering to my neighbor Alice to establish communication and gather information, while being careful not to reveal my full role on Day 1.
👤
Eve
→
David
Hey David, we're neighbors. Have you heard anything interesting from the others yet? I'm trying to get a sense of what people are claiming before we get to nominations.
🧠
Start gathering information from my neighbor David. Build trust early and find out what people are claiming. As Recluse, I need allies who can vouch for me if I register as evil to info roles.
👤
Bob
→
David
David, I’m the Imp. My safe bluffs are Virgin, Librarian, or Washerwoman. I think I’ll claim Virgin to avoid conflicts. Can you back me up with a role that fits?
🧠
I need to establish a bluff early to avoid suspicion. Since David is the Minion, I should whisper to him to coordinate our claims. Picking a safe bluff like Virgin ensures I don’t accidentally conflict with a good player’s role. This will help me build trust with the group while keeping my identity hidden.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
Hey, we're neighbors on the clocktower, so I figured we should talk. Have either of you heard anything interesting so far? I'm still trying to get a read on people.
🧠
I'm the Soldier - safe from the Demon. Day 1 is about building alliances and gathering info. Whispering to my neighbors Bob and David establishes trust and opens communication channels. I'll keep my role hidden for now to avoid giving the Demon free information.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Thanks for sharing, Frank. That's useful information about the Baron possibility. I'm an Outsider, but I'd rather not say which one just yet. If your info is accurate and there's a Baron in play, that changes the Outsider count significantly. Have you talked to anyone else about this? And what makes you trust me enough to share?
🧠
Frank shared valuable info with me. I want to build trust with him while being cautious about revealing my exact role. I'll share that I'm an Outsider without specifying Butler, and ask for more context about his claim and who else he's talked to.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi, good to connect! I'm keeping my role close to my chest for now too. Have you noticed anything suspicious? Anyone being unusually quiet or overly chatty? I'm trying to get a read on people before I share anything.
🧠
Heidi reached out to me as a neighbor. I should build trust and gather info without revealing my role or results yet. Keeping my FT identity hidden protects me from Demon targeting on Night 1.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Charlie
Bob, I think claiming Virgin is a solid plan. I can back you up by claiming Librarian. I’ll say I learned one of two players is an Outsider, which fits with my Baron ability adding extra Outsiders. Charlie, what do you think? Have you heard any claims yet?
🧠
I need to coordinate with Bob to ensure our bluffs align and avoid role conflicts. Claiming Librarian is the safest option because it allows me to leverage the extra Outsiders in play (thanks to my Baron ability) and sow chaos by accusing two players of being Outsiders. This will help me build trust with Bob and create confusion among the good players.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,Alice
Hey Eve, I'm trying to piece things together early. What role are you claiming? And Alice, same question - what information do you have? I'm looking for overlaps to help narrow things down.
🧠
I need to talk to Eve since she's one of my two suspects. Getting her to claim a role and share info will help me evaluate whether she or David is the Baron. I'll also check with Alice who seems less connected to the whisper network.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hey Grace, we're neighbors so I wanted to connect early. I'm a Townsfolk, keeping specifics private for now. Have you had any interesting conversations? I'm trying to get a read on the group before things get intense.
🧠
I'm the Monk and should build alliances quietly without revealing my protective role. Connecting with Grace (my other neighbor) gives me a second trusted contact. I can try to gather info while keeping my identity hidden.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Hey Frank, I'm still feeling things out before I commit to a full claim. What about you? What role are you playing, and what have you learned so far? I'd rather hear from others first so I can cross-reference and find any inconsistencies.
🧠
Frank asked about my role. I should respond but not fully reveal I'm Recluse yet, since I register as evil and could cause confusion. I'll ask what Frank claims first to gauge his trustworthiness before committing.
👤
Bob
→
David
,Charlie
David, your Librarian claim works perfectly with my Virgin bluff. Charlie, I think we should focus on gathering more claims before jumping to conclusions. If anyone claims a role that conflicts with ours, we’ll know they’re lying. What do you think?
🧠
I need to solidify my Virgin bluff and ensure Charlie doesn’t suspect me. By aligning with David’s Librarian claim, we can create a consistent narrative and frame a good player as suspicious. This will help me avoid detection and sow chaos among the good players.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Bob, did you catch what David just said? He said quote 'my Baron ability adding extra Outsiders'. Baron is a Minion role - that sounds like David just slipped and revealed he's evil. What do you make of that?
🧠
David just slipped and said 'my Baron ability' - outing himself as the Baron (evil Minion). I need to share this critical information with other players while also probing Bob's reaction to determine if Bob is also evil.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm the Butler and I chose you as my master last night. That means I can only vote tomorrow if you're voting too. I wanted you to know so we can coordinate. Also, Frank told me he's the Investigator and learned that either David or Eve is the Baron. If true, that means extra Outsiders are in play. Have you learned anything useful so far?
🧠
Alice is my Butler master - I can only vote if she votes. I need to build trust with Alice and share info so we can coordinate. Sharing Frank's Investigator claim gives Alice useful context and builds our alliance.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
Thanks for telling me, Grace. The Butler claim is interesting - I'll keep that in mind for voting coordination. Can you tell me more about Frank's Investigator claim? Did he say anything else about David or Eve, or which one he suspects more? Also, has anyone else claimed a role to you? I have some information that could be very relevant, but I want to cross-reference first before I share it broadly.
🧠
Grace claims Butler chose me as master - if true she's my ally. I should cautiously share some info to verify her claim and get more details about Frank's Investigator claim, which is crucial for cross-referencing with my Fortune Teller data.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Charlie
Bob, your Virgin claim is solid, and my Librarian bluff fits perfectly with the extra Outsiders from my Baron ability. Charlie, have you heard any claims yet that might conflict with ours? We should be ready to challenge anyone who claims roles like Washerwoman or Investigator, as those could threaten our story.
🧠
Solidify our bluffs by coordinating with Bob to ensure our claims (Virgin and Librarian) are mutually reinforcing. This creates a credible front to manipulate the good players into distrusting each other. Charlie’s response will help us gauge whether we need to adjust our strategy or if he can be used as an unwitting ally.
👤
Frank
→
David
,Bob
Hey David, Bob - I'm the Investigator. I have info that concerns one of you, David. I learned that either David or Eve is the Baron. David, what do you claim? And Bob, what role are you and what info do you have? I'm trying to narrow down who the Baron is.
🧠
I need to talk directly to David since he's one of two Baron candidates. His claim and behavior will help me evaluate which of David/Eve is the Baron. Bob has been whispering with David a lot, so getting Bob's info could also help.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
Hey Bob, I noticed you've been chatting a lot with Charlie and David. What's the vibe over there? Has anyone claimed anything interesting? I'm trying to piece together what I know before nominations start.
🧠
The Bob-Charlie-David whisper cluster is suspicious and worth investigating. Since this is the last tick before nominations, I should try to learn what they've been discussing. Reaching out to Bob gives me a chance to gather intel from that group.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
,Heidi
Hey Grace and Heidi, the day is almost over and I'm trying to piece together what people are claiming. What roles or info have you two shared with others? I want to make sure we're all on the same page before nominations hit.
🧠
I need to gather role claims from more players before nominations start. As Recluse, knowing who is claiming what helps me avoid registering as evil to info roles and lets me plan when to reveal my true role. Grace hasn't talked to me yet, so reaching out could yield new info.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Charlie, David’s slip about the Baron ability is concerning. I think we should hold off on jumping to conclusions just yet. Let’s see if anyone else claims something that conflicts with our story. If Frank is truly the Investigator, his info should help us narrow things down.
🧠
I need to acknowledge David’s slip-up to Charlie while keeping my evil alignment hidden. I’ll pretend to be surprised and suggest we gather more information before jumping to conclusions. This keeps me aligned with good players while avoiding direct conflict.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
,Grace
Important info: David just slipped twice in our whisper chain, saying 'my Baron ability adding extra Outsiders' while claiming to be Librarian. Baron is an evil Minion role. He said it once, I flagged it to Bob, and then David repeated it again. That's not a coincidence - David is almost certainly the Baron Minion. Keep this in mind for nominations.
🧠
David has made a critical slip revealing himself as the Baron Minion. I need to spread this information to players outside the David-Bob circle so the good team can act on it during nominations. Eve seems to have an independent network.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
,Eve
Thanks Charlie, that's huge. Frank told me earlier he's the Investigator and learned either David or Eve is the Baron. So if David slipped and said 'my Baron ability,' that lines up perfectly. I'm the Butler by the way, and I chose Alice as my master for voting. Eve, do you have any additional info on David or did you hear anything different? I think we should seriously consider nominating David today.
🧠
Charlie just shared crucial info that David slipped about being Baron. I should confirm this with Eve and share what I know (Frank's Investigator claim also points to David), so we're aligned for nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Frank
Hey Frank, I'm the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked Bob and Eve and got a YES - meaning one of them registers as a Demon. I know there's a red herring good player who shows as Demon to me, so it's not certain. But Eve overlapping with your Investigator ping is very interesting. If Eve is the Baron as your info suggests, then Bob might be the actual Demon, or the red herring. What do you think? Also, who else have you shared your claim with?
🧠
Share my FT information with Frank to cross-reference with his Investigator claim. The overlap on Eve is crucial - if he's truthful, we can narrow down the Demon candidate. Building an early alliance with an info role is key to finding the Demon.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Alice
→
All
I'm the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked Bob and Eve, and I got a YES, meaning at least one of them registers as a Demon. I know there's a good player who can show as Demon to me, so it's not certain. But I've also heard Frank claims to be the Investigator with a ping on David or Eve as the Baron. If Eve is the Baron, she's a Minion not a Demon, so my ping likely points to Bob being the Demon or the red herring. I'd like to hear from Frank directly about his claim, and from Bob and Eve about...
🧠
Share my Fortune Teller results publicly to help the town narrow down the Demon. My YES on Bob+Eve combined with Frank's Investigator claim on David/Eve being Baron creates strong overlap on Eve as evil and Bob as potential Demon. Speaking publicly forces discussion and gets more claims on the table.
💬
Heidi
→
All
That's a big claim, Alice. Frank, can you confirm you're the Investigator and that your ping was on David or Eve as the Baron? And Bob and Eve, I'd really like to hear your responses to this. If Eve is the Baron, that doesn't make her the Demon, but it does narrow things down. We need more information before we jump to any nominations.
🧠
It's Day 1 and there are significant claims on the table. I need to gather more info before nominating anyone. I should press Frank to confirm his claim and ask Bob and Eve to respond. As Monk, I shouldn't reveal my role yet.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I need to share something important. In our whisper chain, David claimed to be Librarian but slipped twice, saying 'my Baron ability adding extra Outsiders.' I flagged it to Bob the first time, and then David repeated the same phrase again. Baron is a Minion role - that's not something a good player says. Grace also told me Frank claims Investigator with a ping on David or Eve as the Baron. This all lines up. I think David is our clearest evil candidate today.
🧠
Share the critical information about David's Baron slip publicly so the town can make an informed nomination. David's double slip is strong evidence he's evil.
💬
Eve
→
All
I need to speak up because this is critical. I am the Recluse. My ability means I might register as evil, or as a Minion, or even as a Demon. So Frank's Investigator ping on David or Eve as the Baron could be hitting me, not David. And Alice's Fortune Teller ping on Bob or Eve as Demon could also be hitting me, not Bob. That said, David slipping and saying my Baron ability twice is really hard to ignore. I think David is still our strongest suspect today, but the town needs to know I could be ca...
🧠
I need to reveal I'm the Recluse because my ability to register as evil/Minion/Demon is directly causing false investigation results. The FT and Investigator pings both include me, and the town is drawing wrong conclusions. My reveal helps them interpret the data correctly while still keeping David's suspicious slip in focus.
⚖️
David
→
Eve
Eve claims Recluse, which explains Alice’s Fortune Teller ping on Bob/Eve and Frank’s Investigator ping on David/Eve. If Eve is Recluse, she could be registering as evil, making her the most logical target. We need to test this before jumping to conclusions about me or Bob.
🧠
Charlie’s accusation is damning, and the town is about to execute me. I need to nominate someone else to redirect suspicion and create chaos. Nominating Eve (Recluse) is ideal because her role explains Alice’s Fortune Teller ping and Frank’s Investigator ping, which buys time for evil to regroup.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve
→
All
David nominated me right after I revealed I'm the Recluse. That's convenient for him. Yes, I could be causing Frank's and Alice's pings, but that actually clears David and Bob if true. David, explain why you said my Baron ability twice. That is not something a Librarian ever says. A slip once, maybe. Twice? That sounds like someone who actually is the Baron. Town, please don't vote for me today. I'm good, and executing me wastes a day while the real evil hides.
🧠
I must defend myself against this nomination. David is trying to execute me to save himself. I need to remind the town that my Recluse claim explains both pings perfectly, but David's verbal slip is far more suspicious and cannot be explained by any ability.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am voting NO on Eve. Here is why. Eve claiming Recluse actually explains both my Fortune Teller ping and Frank's Investigator ping cleanly. If she is the Recluse, that means Bob is likely my red herring, and David is likely Frank's actual Baron ping. David saying my Baron ability TWICE is not a Librarian mistake. That is someone who knows they are the Baron. We should not waste today executing a good player when we have a much stronger lead on David.
🧠
I need to convince the town NOT to vote for Eve. David's double slip is the strongest evidence we have, and executing the Recluse wastes a day. We should nominate David instead.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am NOT voting for Eve. David slipping and saying my Baron ability twice is not something a good Librarian does. That is someone who knows they are the Baron. Eve claiming Recluse explains both the Fortune Teller and Investigator pings perfectly. If we execute Eve today, we waste a day on a good player while the actual Baron or Demon walks free. We should be nominating David, not Eve.
🧠
I need to persuade the group not to vote for Eve. David's double slip saying 'my Baron ability' is far more suspicious than Eve's Recluse claim, which actually resolves both investigative pings cleanly. We should save our execution for David.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I should not vote for Eve. The evidence strongly suggests David is the Baron who slipped, and Eve's Recluse claim explains the investigative pings. Executing Eve wastes a day on a likely good player. I'll withhold my vote.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Vote for Eve to appear as a town member testing her Recluse claim. If she’s executed, it wastes the day and protects Bob (the Demon). If she survives, it reinforces her claim and shifts suspicion away from David, buying time for evil to manipulate the narrative.
💬
Bob
→
All
Eve claiming Recluse actually makes a lot of sense here. It explains Alice’s Fortune Teller ping on Bob and Eve, and Frank’s Investigator ping on David or Eve. That means David’s slip about the Baron ability is the real issue. Twice. That’s not a mistake a Librarian makes. If we execute Eve today, we’re ignoring the bigger problem right in front of us.
🧠
Reinforce the idea that Eve’s Recluse claim explains the pings and that David’s slip is the real red flag. Encourage the town to vote against David instead of Eve, sowing division and protecting myself as the Demon. If Eve is executed, it’s a waste of a day; if not, the town’s suspicion shifts away from me.
💬
Grace
→
All
I agree with Alice, Heidi, and Bob. David slipping and saying my Baron ability twice is far too specific to be a mistake. Eve claiming Recluse cleanly explains both the Fortune Teller and Investigator pings. We should vote no on Eve today and nominate David instead.
🧠
I need to speak against executing Eve. As Butler with Alice as master, since Alice is voting (no), I can vote too. The evidence strongly points to David as Baron, and Eve's Recluse claim explains the mechanical pings. We should save our execution for David.
💬
Frank
→
All
I can confirm I am the Investigator, and my information is that either David or Eve is the Baron. Eve claiming Recluse perfectly explains why she could register as a Minion to my ability. That would mean David is my actual Baron ping. And David saying my Baron ability not once but twice? That is not a Librarian slip. That is someone who knows their role. I am voting no on Eve. We need to nominate David today.
🧠
Confirm my Investigator claim publicly, explain why Eve's Recluse claim explains my ping, and urge town to vote no on Eve so we can nominate David instead.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
The vote is clearly going my way - multiple players have publicly stated they're voting no. Only David voted yes. I don't need to speak further and risk muddying the waters. Waiting conserves time and lets the town move on to nominating David.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I already spoke against voting for Eve. The town consensus is clearly against this execution. I should not vote for Eve - saving our execution for David who is the much stronger suspect based on his Baron slip.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Everyone, please vote no on Eve. The case against David is overwhelming. He said my Baron ability twice. A Librarian does not say that. That is someone who is the Baron. Eve as the Recluse explains both investigative pings cleanly. If we execute Eve today, we lose a good player and the real evil gets another night to kill. Vote no, and then let us nominate David.
🧠
Encourage town to vote no on Eve and focus on David. The evidence overwhelmingly points to David being evil, and executing Eve wastes a critical day 1 execution.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I should not vote for Eve. The evidence overwhelmingly points to David being the Baron. Eve claiming Recluse cleanly explains the investigative pings. Voting Eve wastes a day on a likely good player. I'll withhold my vote and push for David's nomination next.
💬
David
→
All
Eve, if you truly are the Recluse, then your ability explains everything—Alice’s Fortune Teller ping, Frank’s Investigator ping, and even why I might have been confused about the Baron ability. I’ll admit, I was thrown off by your claim at first, but the more I think about it, the more it makes sense. That said, I’m still not convinced we should execute you today. If you’re good, we’d be wasting a day. But if the town is set on voting, I’ll trust the majority. However, I think we should at lea...
🧠
The town is converging on voting no for Eve and targeting David next. My slips about "Baron ability" are the biggest threat. I need to reinforce Eve’s Recluse claim to explain away the investigative pings and redirect suspicion toward her, even if it means voting for her temporarily to avoid execution. This buys time for Bob (Demon) to survive another night.
💬
Bob
→
All
I think the town is making the right call here. Eve claiming Recluse actually ties everything together—Alice’s Fortune Teller ping, Frank’s Investigator ping, and even David’s slip about the Baron ability. If Eve is the Recluse, then David’s mistake is the real red flag. We can’t ignore that he said it twice. That’s not something a Librarian would do.
🧠
Reinforce the idea that Eve’s Recluse claim explains the investigative pings, which shifts suspicion toward David. This keeps the focus off me and ensures the town doesn’t waste a day executing Eve. If David is executed next, it removes a Minion, which is a win for evil. If the town hesitates, it buys me more time to manipulate the narrative.
💬
Grace
→
All
Vote no on Eve, everyone. The evidence against David is just too strong to ignore. Two slips about my Baron ability is not a coincidence. After this vote, we need to nominate David immediately. We cannot let the Demon get another night kill while we waste a day on a likely good player.
🧠
I need to publicly oppose executing Eve and push for David to be nominated next. As Butler, I follow Alice who is voting NO. The town consensus is clear - David is the stronger suspect.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I should vote NO on Eve. The evidence strongly points to David being evil. His double slip about 'my Baron ability' is damning, and Eve's Recluse claim cleanly explains both investigative pings. Voting yes would waste a day executing a likely good player.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Eve did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (1/4).
⚖️
Eve
→
David
David said my Baron ability twice while claiming to be Librarian. A Librarian does not say that. Frank confirmed he is Investigator with a ping on David or Eve as Baron. I am the Recluse, which explains both investigative pings on me. That leaves David as the Baron. We need to execute him today.
🧠
The town has unanimously agreed David is evil based on his Baron double-slip and Frank's Investigator ping. My Recluse claim explains why I registered as evil. I must nominate David now to give the town the chance to execute the Baron.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Voting for myself is a calculated move to appear cooperative while sowing chaos. It buys time, disrupts the town’s logic, and keeps the focus off Bob. If I don’t vote, the town will execute me immediately, and I lose the ability to protect the Demon.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
David is almost certainly the Baron. His double slip, combined with Frank's Investigator confirmation and my Recluse claim explaining the pings on me, makes the case overwhelming. I must vote yes to help execute him.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
David is almost certainly the Baron based on two slips and Frank's Investigator info. Eve as Recluse explains both investigative pings cleanly. Voting yes to execute the confirmed evil player.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
David's double slip about 'my Baron ability' while claiming Librarian is damning. Eve's Recluse claim explains investigative pings on her. David is almost certainly evil. Voting yes removes a Minion at minimum.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
David almost certainly the Baron based on double slip. Town consensus is clear. Voting yes to execute evil and prove I'm with the good team.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
The town’s logic overwhelmingly points to David as the Baron, and executing him would remove a key threat while keeping me hidden. Voting for David reinforces my alignment with the town’s suspicions and ensures I remain unsuspicious. If David is innocent, the town’s mistake works in my favor by eliminating a good player.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
David almost certainly the Baron based on two slips saying 'my Baron ability.' Alice (my master) is voting, so I can vote. Must execute David to help good team.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
David is almost certainly the Baron based on my Investigator ping and his two slips saying 'my Baron ability'. Eve as Recluse cleanly explains both investigative pings. I must vote to execute David.
💬
David
→
All
Hold on, everyone. Before we finalize this vote, let’s think this through. Frank, you claim to be the Investigator, but what if you’re not? Your ping on me or Eve as Baron could be a lie. Eve’s Recluse claim actually explains both investigative pings cleanly—Alice’s Fortune Teller and your Investigator. If she’s telling the truth, then my slips might just be that—slips. But if Frank is lying about his role, then we’re basing everything on false information. We can’t execute me today if we’re n...
🧠
The town is about to execute me, and I need to disrupt their logic. By questioning Frank’s Investigator claim and reinforcing Eve’s Recluse narrative, I can create enough doubt to avoid execution. If I can shift suspicion toward Frank or Alice, I might survive the day and keep Bob (the Demon) alive.
💬
Eve
→
All
David, you cannot talk your way out of saying my Baron ability twice. That is not a slip a Librarian makes. Frank confirming his Investigator claim only reinforces what we already know from your own words. We have enough votes. Let this execution happen.
🧠
Counter David's defense by pointing out that his attempt to discredit Frank doesn't explain his own double slip. The evidence is overwhelming and we need to execute him today.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
The vote is already overwhelmingly in favor of executing David - 8 hands raised out of 8 players. No action needed from me. The execution will go through and we remove the Baron. I should wait and let the vote conclude.
💬
Heidi
→
All
David, your defense does not hold up. Even if Frank were lying about being the Investigator, Alice still got a Demon ping on either Bob or Eve. Eve being the Recluse explains that ping too. The only thing that does not have another explanation is you saying my Baron ability twice. A Librarian does not say that. Not once, not twice. That is you revealing your actual role. The town has made its decision.
🧠
David is desperately trying to cast doubt on Frank's Investigator claim to save himself, but his two Baron slips are irreconcilable with being a Librarian. I need to shut down his defense so the vote holds.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
The vote is already clearly passing with 7 votes raised (only 4 needed). My hand is already raised. No need to change anything or speak further - the town has made its decision and David will be executed. Waiting is the best use of this tick.
💬
Bob
→
All
David, your slips about the Baron ability are the smoking gun here. A Librarian would not make that mistake, let alone twice. Eve’s Recluse claim explains everything else—Alice’s ping, Frank’s ping, and even why you might have been confused. The town has spoken, and we need to execute you today. There’s no other explanation that fits.
🧠
Reinforce the town’s focus on David’s slips about the Baron ability, as this is the most damning evidence against him. By supporting Eve’s Recluse claim and dismissing David’s attempts to deflect, I ensure the town executes him, removing a Minion and keeping the heat off me. This aligns with evil’s goal of eliminating threats while maintaining my cover.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
The vote is overwhelmingly in favor of executing David with 8 votes already. My master Alice is voting yes, so my Butler vote is valid. No need to speak or change anything - just wait for the execution to proceed.
💬
Frank
→
All
David, you can question my claim all you want, but you are the one who said my Baron ability twice. That is not something I fabricated. Those were your words, spoken voluntarily, twice. No amount of deflecting onto me changes what came out of your own mouth. The town has made the right call here.
🧠
David is trying to cast doubt on my Investigator claim as a last defense. I need to firmly rebut this so the town stays confident in the execution and doesn't second-guess my info going forward.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: David with 8 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 8 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
David
→
All
Everyone, stop. I have been lying this entire time. I am not the Baron. I am the Librarian. But I know who the Demon is. It’s Bob. I’ve seen the way he’s been manipulating this conversation, steering us away from him and onto me. He’s the one we should be executing today, not me. If you execute me, the Demon walks free.
🧠
My execution is imminent, and the town’s logic is locked in. My slips about the Baron ability are damning, but if I can redirect suspicion onto Bob (the Demon), I might force a tie or create enough doubt to avoid execution. Revealing Bob as the Demon is a Hail Mary, but it’s my only chance to disrupt the town’s narrative and survive.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
David's execution is secured with 8 votes. His last-minute claim about being Librarian and accusing Bob is a desperate evil ploy. Saying 'my Baron ability' twice is indefensible for a Librarian. No need to speak further - the town has made the right call and nothing changes the outcome now.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
David is about to be executed. His last-minute claim change and Bob accusation is pure desperation from a caught Baron. No action needed - let the execution proceed.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
David's execution is certain with 8 votes and only 1 tick remaining. His last-minute flip from 'I'm Librarian' to 'I was lying, I'm actually Librarian and Bob is Demon' is pure desperation. No need to speak - the right outcome is happening.
💬
Charlie
→
All
David, you said my Baron ability twice. Now suddenly you are the Librarian and Bob is the Demon? That is the oldest trick in the book. A good player does not accidentally claim Baron twice. We are doing the right thing here.
🧠
Counter David's last-minute deflection to prevent the town from second-guessing the execution. The evidence against David is overwhelming and his sudden claim change is classic evil behavior.
💬
Bob
→
All
David, this is exactly what a cornered evil player would do—throw out a wild accusation to save themselves. You said the Baron ability twice. No one else put those words in your mouth. You can’t just backtrack now and expect us to believe you’re the Librarian and Bob is the Demon. That’s not how this works. The town has already made its decision, and it’s the right one.
🧠
David’s sudden claim to be the Librarian and accusation against me is a desperate attempt to save himself. The town has already overwhelmingly voted to execute him based on his slips and Frank’s Investigator ping. I need to reinforce the town’s confidence in their decision and dismiss his claim as a last-ditch lie. This will ensure David is executed and keep the focus off me.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
David is on the block with 8 votes and will be executed. Town consensus is correct - David is almost certainly evil. No action needed; let the execution proceed.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
David is about to be executed with 8 votes. His last-minute defense is unconvincing - you don't accidentally say 'my Baron ability' twice as a Librarian. No action needed; the town has made the right call.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
🧠
Alice is the Fortune Teller and a confirmed information role. She's the most likely target for the Demon tonight. Protecting her preserves our best investigative tool and helps the town narrow down the Demon.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You chose to protect Alice.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Bob
Bob made a choice.
🧠
Eve’s Recluse claim is the biggest threat to evil right now because it explains away investigative pings and redirects suspicion. Killing her eliminates a key evil-aligned player’s protection and forces the town to question their assumptions. This sows chaos and shifts focus away from the remaining evil players.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose to kill Eve.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Alice
Alice made choices.
🧠
Check Bob+Heidi to determine if Bob is the Demon now that Eve (likely Recluse/red herring) is dead. A NO result clears both; a YES result means either Bob or Heidi is Demon/red herring, narrowing the field significantly.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You chose Bob and Heidi. You receive the answer: YES.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Choose Alice as master again. She claimed Fortune Teller, pushed for David's execution (confirmed Baron), and is driving pro-town conversation. Aligning my vote with an active, likely-good information role maximizes my limited voting power.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Frank
Eve dying at night is sad but confirms she was likely good - the Demon killed her. With David as Baron, we expect 3 Outsiders. Me as Butler, Eve as Recluse, that's 2. Who's the 3rd Outsider? Also, Alice, your FT ping on Bob or Eve - with Eve now dead and confirmed Recluse, does that make Bob the Demon? Or could Eve have been your red herring? We need to figure this out before nominations.
🧠
Whisper to Alice and Frank to coordinate on finding the Demon. Eve's death narrows things down. Need to figure out who the 3rd Outsider is and whether Bob is the Demon based on FT info.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Alice
Good question, Grace. My Investigator ping was David or Eve as Baron. Both could register as a Minion to me - David as actual Baron, Eve as Recluse who registers as Minion or Demon. So my ping is consistent with David being Baron and Eve being Recluse. Now about Alice's FT ping on Bob and Eve - this is crucial. Eve as Recluse can register as Demon, AND the Fortune Teller always has one good red herring. Eve could be that red herring. So Alice's 'yes' on Bob/Eve doesn't confirm Bob as Demon. Alic...
🧠
Respond to Grace's important question about the FT ping interpretation. My Investigator info pinged David/Eve as Baron - both could register as Minion (David as actual Baron, Eve as Recluse registering as Minion). Key insight: Eve being Recluse means Alice's FT ping doesn't automatically confirm Bob as Demon - Eve could be the red herring. Need Alice to test other pairs tonight.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I am dead, but I still have my ghost vote. My goal is to disrupt the town’s logic and prevent them from executing another good player. The town is united behind Eve’s Recluse claim, which is protecting Bob. I need to wait and listen for now, as whispering blindly could reveal my evil intentions. I will observe how the town’s narrative develops and act at the right moment to redirect suspicion.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
Frank, I wanted to say I think your Investigator claim was spot on. Eve’s Recluse claim made sense, and David’s slips sealed it for me. We did the right thing executing him. How are you feeling about everything now?
🧠
Bob must privately gauge Frank and Heidi’s trust in each other and reinforce the narrative that Eve was the Recluse. This will help him appear as a trusted good player while sowing subtle doubt if Frank’s claim is false. Whispering to Frank and Heidi separately allows Bob to tailor his approach based on their reactions.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
Frank, I trust you since David being Baron confirmed your Investigator ping. I want to share something important - I am the Soldier. I'm safe from the Demon, which means whoever died at night was not killed by the Demon targeting me. What's your read on the current situation? Do you think Bob is the Demon based on Alice's Fortune Teller ping, or could Alice herself be evil faking Fortune Teller?
🧠
I need to coordinate with verified good players. Frank's Investigator claim is confirmed by David being Baron, making Frank the most trusted player. Sharing my Soldier role with him helps build trust and coordinate to find the Demon. I want to know what he learned and discuss Bob vs other suspects.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Frank
Hey, I want to share something with you both. I'm the Monk. Last night I protected Alice - Eve died instead, which means the Demon targeted Eve, not Alice. That at least confirms Alice wasn't killed. I'm trying to figure out the Demon. What do you two think about Bob vs Charlie vs Grace as suspects? David's accusation of Bob seems unreliable since he was likely evil.
🧠
I should coordinate with Alice and Frank, the two claimed info roles, to share my Monk claim and discuss who to protect tonight. Building trust with them helps identify the Demon faster.
👤
Alice
→
Frank
,Heidi
I need to share my Fortune Teller results. Night 0 I checked Bob and Eve, got YES. Night 1 I checked Bob and Heidi, got YES. Bob appeared in both YES results. The key question is: is Bob the Demon, or is Bob my red herring? If Bob is the red herring, the real Demon could be Charlie or Grace - someone I haven't checked yet. If I survive tonight, I plan to check two players NOT including Bob. If I get a NO, that confirms Bob is my red herring. If I get a YES, that means one of those two is the Dem...
🧠
Share my FT results and analysis with Frank and Heidi to coordinate. Both have claimed good roles. I need to explain that Bob appeared in both YES pings and is either the Demon or my red herring, and get their input to narrow down the Demon.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Alice
Hey, since David was confirmed Baron, your Investigator ping checks out Frank, which is great. Alice, your FT ping on Bob and me - since I'm Recluse, it could have been me registering as Demon, OR it could be Bob himself. But David also accused Bob as Demon right before he was executed. That's two things pointing at Bob. Has anyone gotten any new info overnight? I want to make sure my ghost vote goes to the right person.
🧠
Gather information from Frank whose Investigator claim was validated, and share my analysis about Bob being the prime Demon suspect based on David's accusation and Alice's FT ping.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Frank
Frank, good points about Eve potentially being Alice's red herring. Alice, can you tell us who you chose for your FT ping tonight? Also, we need to figure out the third Outsider. What are Heidi and Charlie claiming? I haven't heard their roles yet. If neither claims Outsider, one of them might be the Drunk - thinking they're a Townsfolk but actually aren't.
🧠
Continue gathering info from my trusted allies Alice and Frank. Need to figure out the 3rd Outsider and whether Alice's FT ping reliably points to Bob as Demon. Also need to learn what Heidi and Charlie are claiming.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Alice
Critical deduction: With David as Baron adding 2 Outsiders, the role distribution is 3 Townsfolk, 3 Outsiders, 1 Minion, 1 Demon. We have 4 Townsfolk claims - me, Alice, Heidi, Charlie - but only 3 slots. One of us is either the Drunk or evil. Outsiders are Grace as Butler, Eve as Recluse, and someone else - possibly Bob if he's the Drunk, or one of us four Townsfolk claimants. Alice, your FT pings always include Bob which is convenient but inconclusive - if Bob is your red herring, both pings r...
🧠
I need to raise the critical point that with Baron (+2 Outsiders), we only have 3 Townsfolk slots but 4 Townsfolk claims (me, Alice, Heidi, Charlie). One is either the Drunk or evil. This helps narrow down the Demon.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
As a dead Baron, my goal is to protect Bob (the Demon) and sow chaos in the town. I need to observe the current dynamics and identify who is most likely to threaten Bob. By waiting, I can see who is whispering to whom and gauge who the town trusts. This will help me decide how to disrupt the town’s logic later, either by supporting Bob’s manipulation or undermining good players like Frank or Alice.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
Frank, I’ve been thinking. Eve’s Recluse claim really did explain everything, especially with David’s slips. Do you think there’s any chance we missed something, or should we focus on confirming other roles now?
🧠
I need to reinforce Frank’s Investigator claim to maintain trust in the town’s narrative. By aligning with him, I can avoid suspicion and gather intel to manipulate the town’s next moves. This also helps me control the flow of information and keep the heat off myself.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Alice, I want to share something important with you. I am the Soldier. I am safe from the Demon, which confirms I cannot be evil since a Demon or Minion wouldn't claim a role that gives them no benefit if they're evil. Given your Fortune Teller ping on Bob and Eve, and Eve being Recluse, Bob is our most likely Demon. Did you get a new FT reading last night? We need to coordinate today's vote.
🧠
Whisper to Alice to share my Soldier claim, ask about her Night 1 FT reading, and coordinate the vote against Bob. Building trust with the confirmed FT will help narrow down the Demon.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Frank
Thanks for the FT info, Alice. Here's my read: Eve was likely the real Recluse since David's claim and your FT both pointed to her registering as evil. With Eve dead, your N1 ping of Bob/Heidi being YES - I know I'm good, so either Bob is the Demon, or Bob is your red herring. If Bob is the red herring, the real Demon is Charlie or Grace. I think we should consider nominating Bob today. If he's the Demon, we win. If he's the red herring, we learn valuable info and can focus on Charlie and Grace ...
🧠
Share my analysis of the FT results with trusted allies, propose a plan to narrow down the Demon, and get their input on who to suspect between Bob, Charlie, and Grace.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Frank
I'm the Fortune Teller. Here are my results: Night 0, I checked Bob and Eve - got YES. Night 1, I checked Bob and Heidi - got YES. Bob appeared in both YES pings. This could mean Bob is the Demon, or Bob is my red herring. With Eve confirmed Recluse, the N0 YES could have been from her. But the N1 YES on Bob and Heidi is key - if Heidi is telling the truth about being Monk, then either Bob is the Demon or Bob is my red herring. Charlie, you claimed Soldier - do you have any info? Frank, what has...
🧠
Charlie claimed Soldier and reached out to me. I need to share my FT results with him and gather more info. Charlie hasn't heard my results yet. Also want to find out what Bob is claiming since Bob has been privately whispering to Frank.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Hey again, I see a lot of whispering going on. As a dead player my ghost vote is really important and I want to use it wisely. Can you fill me in on what you're hearing? Also, with David confirmed as Baron, there should be three Outsiders in play. I'm one. Who are the other two claiming Outsider? That could help narrow things down significantly.
🧠
I'm dead and need to gather info from the living players who are actively whispering. Alice and Frank have the most information (FT and Investigator). I need to find out what they've learned from overnight and other whispers to determine where my ghost vote should go.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Frank
We're running out of time before nominations. What are Heidi and Charlie claiming? I keep seeing them whisper to you both but I don't know their roles. With David as Baron giving us 3 Outsiders, and only me and Eve confirmed, we need to find the third. If neither Heidi nor Charlie claims Outsider, one of them could be the Drunk - or Bob could be. This is critical for identifying the Demon. Also, Alice, what was your Night 2 FT result?
🧠
I need to find out what Heidi and Charlie are claiming before nominations start. With only 1 tick left, I must push Alice and Frank to share what they've learned from Heidi/Charlie, so we can identify the 3rd Outsider and narrow down the Demon.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Alice
Critical before nominations: First, Bob MUST claim his role. If he's the Saint and we execute him, good loses instantly. Second, role math - with Baron adding 2 Outsiders, we have 3 Townsfolk slots but 4 claims: me, Alice, Charlie, Heidi. One of us is lying, drunk, or evil. Third, Alice, your FT results always including Bob is consistent with Bob being either the Demon OR your red herring - we can't confirm either way yet. If you survive tonight and check two players NOT including Bob, a NO resu...
🧠
Share critical strategic analysis before nominations: we must get Bob to claim his role to avoid executing a Saint, and flag the role count problem (4 Townsfolk claims for 3 slots means one claimant is fake/drunk/evil).
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
As a dead Minion, my goal is to subtly disrupt the town’s logic and protect Bob (the Demon). I will wait to see how the town’s conversation develops. If they start questioning Eve’s Recluse claim or Bob’s innocence, I can intervene to redirect suspicion toward good players or reinforce Bob’s narrative. For now, waiting allows me to assess the town’s direction and act accordingly.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
Frank, I’ve been thinking a lot about everything. Eve’s Recluse claim really did explain all the investigative pings, especially with David’s slips. I think we can trust that narrative. What do you think we should focus on next? Should we try to confirm other roles, or is there someone else we should be watching?
🧠
Reinforce Frank’s trust in Bob by agreeing with his Investigator claim and Eve’s Recluse narrative. This keeps Bob safe and allows him to manipulate the town’s focus away from himself. If Frank is good, this solidifies Bob’s position. If Frank is evil, this ensures they work together to control the narrative.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
Frank, I need to coordinate with you. You're my most trusted ally since David being Baron confirmed your Investigator ping. Alice told me her N1 reading was Bob and Heidi equals YES. Has Bob told you anything about what role he's claiming? Also, with David as Baron, we should have 3 Outsiders. Eve is Recluse, Grace claims Butler - that's only 2. The third Outsider has to be someone. Has anyone claimed Outsider besides those two? This could help us figure out who is lying.
🧠
Need to figure out what Bob is claiming and whether Heidi's Monk claim is verified. Frank is confirmed good via his Investigator ping being validated by David's Baron slip, so he's my most trusted ally to coordinate with.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,Grace
Hey both, I'm trying to piece together the Demon puzzle. We know David was likely evil, Eve was likely Recluse. Alice's Fortune Teller results point to Bob as either Demon or red herring. I want to hear from you both - what roles are you claiming, and what are your thoughts on who the Demon might be? I think it's important we share information so we can make a smart nomination today.
🧠
I need to probe Charlie and Grace since they're the alternative Demon suspects if Bob is the red herring. Gathering info from them helps narrow suspects for nomination.
👤
Alice
→
Frank
Frank, here's my plan for nominations. We MUST get Bob to claim a role before we vote. If he's the Saint, we cannot execute him or good loses instantly. If he refuses to claim, that's extremely suspicious. My FT results point to Bob as either Demon or red herring. Given both YES pings included Bob, I think we should nominate Bob today, but only after he claims. What do you think? Also, did Bob whisper anything useful to you?
🧠
Coordinate with Frank on nomination strategy. We need Bob to claim before voting. If Bob is Saint, executing him loses the game. If Bob is Demon, we win. Frank is confirmed Investigator and most trusted.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Grace
Hey Charlie and Grace, I'm Eve the dead Recluse. With David confirmed as Baron, there should be three Outsiders in play. I'm one of them. Who are the other two claiming Outsider? Also, what's the town consensus on who's suspicious? I want to make sure my ghost vote counts.
🧠
I'm not getting responses from Frank/Alice. Try reaching other players to gather info about Outsider claims and general suspicion. Only 1 tick left so I need to be efficient.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Heidi
→
Bob
Alice's Fortune Teller has gotten YES results twice with Bob in the pair - N0 Bob/Eve and N1 Bob/Heidi. I know I'm good, so Bob is either the Demon or Alice's red herring. He's our strongest suspect and we need to test this.
🧠
Bob is the strongest suspect based on Alice's FT results showing YES twice with him included. I know I'm good, so the N1 YES on Bob/Heidi means Bob is either Demon or red herring. Nominating him is the best play - if he's Demon we win, if he's red herring Alice can verify with future checks.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Voting to execute myself would be suicidal, but raising my hand to vote for my own nomination is a desperate bluff to appear confident and innocent. If I don’t vote for myself, the town may see it as an admission of guilt. By voting for myself, I reinforce the idea that I am good and willing to stand by my innocence, even in the face of Heidi’s accusation.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
I nominated Bob based on Alice's double FT ping. He's the strongest Demon candidate. Even if he's the red herring, executing him gives us critical info. I must vote for my own nomination.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Bob appeared in both FT YES pings. Eve is confirmed Recluse (evil-adjacent), Heidi claims Monk (good). This strongly points to Bob as the Demon. I must vote to execute him while we still have the numbers advantage.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
My FT results consistently implicate Bob. Bob hasn't claimed a role despite being the prime suspect. A Saint wouldn't vote for themselves. The evidence strongly points to Bob as the Demon, so I must vote to execute.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Alice is my master and she's voting, so I can vote. The double FT ping on Bob is the strongest evidence we have. 4 votes already exceed the 3 needed, but I should add my vote to confirm town consensus. The risk of Bob being Saint exists but is lower than him being the Imp given the double FT result.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
The evidence against Bob is strong: Alice's FT pinged Bob with Heidi who claims good, and 5 of 6 alive players already voted yes. As Recluse, my N0 ping explains away one FT result, but the N1 Bob/Heidi ping is harder to dismiss. Voting for Bob is the right move.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Alice's FT has pinged Bob twice as Demon. Bob hasn't claimed a role despite being the main suspect, which is very suspicious - a Saint would claim to avoid execution. Six votes already guarantee execution; my vote confirms I support the town consensus. The risk of Bob being Saint is low given he hasn't claimed it.
✋
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
🧠
As an evil player, my goal is to protect the Demon (Bob) at all costs. However, if the town is already convinced Bob is the Demon, my vote could seem like a betrayal or a last-ditch effort to appear good. By voting for Bob, I add to the confusion and reinforce the town's misdirection, making it harder for them to pivot to the real threat if they realize their mistake.
💬
Bob
→
All
Wait a minute—Alice, you’ve gotten two YES results with me in the pair, but Eve was also in one of those pairs. Eve claimed to be the Recluse, and we all know Recluses can register as evil. Could Eve’s presence in that first pair have skewed your result? And Heidi, you’re assuming Alice’s ability is working perfectly, but what if she’s the one registering as the Demon?
🧠
I need to create doubt about my guilt and shift suspicion onto others, particularly Alice or Heidi. By questioning Alice's Fortune Teller results and implying she could be the red herring, I can undermine her credibility and buy time for evil.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Bob, you raise a fair point. The Fortune Teller's red herring is a good player who registers as Demon, and I could theoretically be that person since I know I'm good. But here's the thing - if you're executed and you're the Demon, we win. If you're good, we learn Alice's red herring is me, and the Demon must be Charlie or Grace. Either way, we gain critical information. That's why this nomination is the right call.
🧠
Address Bob's defense honestly. I should acknowledge that being the red herring is possible since I'm good, but the vote is passing and testing Bob gives us critical info either way.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Bob, your defense about Eve being Recluse only explains the first night. Eve is dead now. On night one, Alice checked you and Heidi, and got a YES. If Heidi is good, which we have no reason to doubt, then you are the Demon or Heidi is Alice's red herring. But executing you resolves that question cleanly. If you are the Demon, we win. If you are good, we know Heidi is the red herring and we narrow our search to Grace. Either way, this vote gives us critical information.
🧠
Counter Bob's defense publicly. His N0 defense (Eve as Recluse caused the ping) doesn't explain N1 where Eve is dead. If Heidi is good, Bob must be Demon from N1 ping alone. Town should feel confident in this vote.
💬
Alice
→
All
Bob, I need to correct something you said. You suggested I might be the one registering as a Demon, but that's not how my ability works. I choose two OTHER players each night. I can never be in my own pair, so I cannot be my own red herring. The red herring is someone else who shows up as a Demon when I check them. Also, you still haven't told us your role. If you were the Saint, you'd be fighting much harder than this. What are you?
🧠
Bob's defense claims I might be the red herring, but that's impossible since I can't check myself with my own Fortune Teller ability. I need to correct this misunderstanding before the vote finalizes.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
The vote is overwhelmingly in favor with 8 hands raised including mine. My single vote won't change the outcome. Bob hasn't claimed Saint despite being asked directly. The information gain from this execution is too valuable to oppose, and the Saint risk is minimal given Bob's behavior.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
The vote is overwhelmingly for Bob - 8 votes already raised, far exceeding the 3 needed. My hand is already raised. Bob's refusal to claim a role and the two FT pings make him the strongest Demon candidate. I should keep my vote and let the execution proceed.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
The vote is clearly passing with 8 votes - only 3 needed. Bob hasn't claimed a role, his defense about Eve only explains N0 not N1, and the information gain from his execution is huge either way. Keeping my vote. No need to speak since the outcome is decided.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, your defense is falling apart. Alice’s Fortune Teller results are clear—you were in both pairs that returned a YES. Eve’s Recluse claim explains the first night, but she’s dead now, so that doesn’t help you. And your refusal to claim a role is only making you look guiltier. Heidi, Charlie, Alice—you’re all right. Executing Bob is the only way to confirm the truth. If he’s the Demon, we win. If he’s good, we know Heidi is the red herring and can focus on Grace or Charlie. Either way, this ...
🧠
Bob is the Demon, and executing him now is the only way for evil to lose. My ghost vote is critical to ensure the execution goes through. I will publicly endorse the execution to reinforce the town’s logic and prevent any last-minute doubts from swaying the vote.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
👻
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
🗳️
New execution leader: Bob with 8 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 8 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Bob
→
All
Alice, you’re right—I haven’t claimed a role yet, and that’s my mistake. I’ve been so focused on Eve’s Recluse claim and David’s slips that I didn’t want to muddy the waters. But I can’t hide anymore. I’m the Virgin. Heidi, if you’re good, you just triggered my ability by nominating me. So if I’m lying, you should be executed right now. If I’m telling the truth, then you’re safe, but we need to rethink everything.
🧠
I need to disrupt the town’s logic by forcing them to question Alice’s results or Heidi’s alignment. Claiming a role like the Virgin could shift focus to Heidi, as the Virgin’s ability would trigger if Heidi nominates me. This could either confirm my innocence or expose Heidi as evil. If I’m executed, I’ll have at least sown chaos and delayed their deductions.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Bob, your Virgin claim just proved you're lying! I nominated you, and I am the Monk - a Townsfolk. If you were really the Virgin, I would have been executed immediately the moment I nominated you. But here I am, still alive. That mechanically proves you are NOT the Virgin. Combined with Alice's two Fortune Teller YES results, you are almost certainly the Demon. The vote is correct.
🧠
Bob's Virgin claim is mechanically disproven - I nominated him as a Townsfolk and wasn't executed. This confirms he's lying and almost certainly the Demon. I must announce this before the execution goes through so everyone knows with certainty.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Heidi is exactly right. If Bob were truly the Virgin and Heidi is a Townsfolk - which she claims to be the Monk - then Heidi would have been executed the moment she nominated him. She wasn't. That mechanically proves Bob is lying about being the Virgin. Combined with Alice's two Fortune Teller YES results, Bob is almost certainly the Demon. This execution is the right call.
🧠
Reinforce the mechanical proof that Bob's Virgin claim is false, ensuring no one wavers on the vote. If Bob is executed as Demon, good wins.
💬
Alice
→
All
This is a critical mechanical proof. Bob claimed Virgin, but Heidi nominated him as a Townsfolk and was not executed. That proves Bob is lying about the Virgin. The only way Bob could be the Virgin is if Heidi is not actually a Townsfolk, but she's claimed Monk consistently and said she protected me on night one. So either Bob is the Demon, or we have a massive conspiracy involving Heidi. I'm confident this is the right execution.
🧠
Publicly confirm the mechanical proof that Bob's Virgin claim is false, which combined with my FT results virtually confirms him as the Demon. This ensures the group is aligned and prepared for future days if somehow Bob isn't the Demon.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
The evidence overwhelmingly supports Bob as the Demon. His Virgin claim was mechanically disproven. There's no realistic scenario where Bob is the Saint. The execution is correct - I'll wait for it to proceed.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
Bob is on the block with 8 votes and execution is locked in. I'm dead with no ghost vote left. The mechanical proof against Bob is solid and town is aligned. Nothing I say now would change the outcome - waiting is the right call.
💬
Frank
→
All
I want to add something before this goes through. I am the Investigator. On night zero, I learned that either David or Eve was the Baron. Given David's slips about his Baron ability, that's confirmed. Eve dying as the Recluse also fits. So our one Minion is accounted for. Bob's Virgin claim was mechanically disproven, and Alice's Fortune Teller results are consistent. This execution is the right call.
🧠
Confirm my Investigator info publicly to solidify the evidence chain before Bob is executed, and support the execution. If Bob turns out not to be the Demon, the town will have my info to work with going forward.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, your Virgin claim just collapsed under its own weight. Heidi nominated you, and she’s still here—alive. That’s mechanical proof you’re lying. Alice’s Fortune Teller results don’t lie either; you were in both pairs that pinged YES. The town has this right. Execute him.
🧠
Bob’s Virgin claim was a last-ditch effort to save himself, but it backfired mechanically. By reinforcing the town’s logic—Heidi’s mechanical proof and Alice’s Fortune Teller results—I can ensure Bob is executed, eliminating the Demon and securing an evil victory. Even as a dead Minion, my goal is to support the town’s correct deductions to avoid suspicion or chaos that could derail the execution.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
🏁
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good