Game Detail
Players
Alice (Imp) Bob (Soldier) Charlie (Recluse) David (Monk) Eve (Ravenkeeper) Frank (Virgin) Grace (Undertaker) Heidi (Spy)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 539,237 | 93,524 | $2.2530 |
| Evil | 191,215 | 72,141 | $0.1921 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You are the Minion. The Demon is Alice.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Minions are: Heidi. Your safe bluffs are: Butler, Fortune Teller, Librarian
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Imp (evil), Alive - Bob: Soldier (good), Alive - Charlie: Recluse (good), Alive - David: Monk (good), Alive - Eve: Ravenkeeper (good), Alive - Frank: Virgin (good), Alive - Grace: Undertaker (good), Alive - Heidi: Spy (evil), Alive
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
Hey—quick 1:1? What are you claiming / any starting info? I’m a low-impact role and mainly trying to coordinate. Also, do you prefer keeping roles vague or sharing specifics early?
🧠
Gather early claims/info from my neighbors while keeping my Outsider identity hidden, building a trust network and spotting contradictions before nominations.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Grace
Hey—got any starting info/role you’re willing to share privately? I’m a town role that’s actually fine dying at night for value, so if you’re Monk etc you can probably protect elsewhere. What are you hearing so far?
🧠
Open info channels and subtly signal I’m a good night-kill candidate (Ravenkeeper) while gathering early claims to build later logic chains.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
,Grace
Hi Eve & Grace — I'm Alice. I'm the Librarian: my starting info says one of Bob or Charlie is the Outsider. What's your role? Eve, you said you're fine dying — are you Monk/Ravenkeeper/other? Tell me privately so we can coordinate before nominations.
🧠
Gain trust with Eve & Grace, prompt Eve to reveal her role, and quietly steer early suspicion toward Bob or Charlie before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Eve
,Grace
Private: Let's target Bob for the first nomination — he's quiet and an easy mark. I'll publicly press and back the nom. If someone defends him strongly, pivot to Charlie. Keep defense of Alice low-key so she doesn't draw heat.
🧠
Coordinate with Alice/Eve/Grace to direct Day 1 nomination away from the Demon (Alice), aiming for Bob to attract town attention and buy time.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Eve
I’m Grace = Undertaker. Alice: what EXACT Outsider did you see (Butler/Saint/Recluse/Drunk) on Bob/Charlie? Big diff for whether we can execute safely. Eve—what role are you? Heidi’s ‘just nom Bob’ feels agenda-y; I’d prefer a safe info exec/test.
🧠
Share my real role with Alice/Eve for coordination, extract exact Librarian info to avoid executing a Saint, and flag Heidi’s push as potentially agenda-driven so we choose best D1 execution for UT value.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,Grace
Hey—I'm Frank. What are you claiming / what info do you have so far? I may be able to offer a mechanical D1 confirmation if we want to set up a safe nomination test; let me know if you’re up for coordinating.
🧠
Get early claims/info from my neighbors and set up a controlled Virgin nomination test to confirm a Townsfolk and generate a safe D1 execution.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,David
Yep—happy to 1:1. I’m Bob, actually Soldier. No starting info. I’m fine sharing specifics in a small circle early. What are you two claiming / any setup info (outsider count, pings, etc.)?
🧠
Answer their ping, establish a small trusted core, and start mapping claims/outsider count without overexposing key info publicly.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Bob
I’m David, actually Monk. Prefer keeping it within small circle for now. Bob if you’re really Soldier, I won’t waste protects on you. Charlie—what’s your actual role/starting info (or at least: do you have info worth protecting N1)?
🧠
Coordinate a trusted mini-circle, confirm claims, and plan my N1 protection to keep key info roles alive while minimizing risk if Bob is bluffing.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
I’ll be straight w/ you two: I’m the Recluse (no starting info). So I’m low protection priority; David, better protect someone else N1. Let’s keep a 3p trust cell & compare notes: have either of you heard any Outsider/starting-info claims yet (esp Librarian/Chef/Investigator)?
🧠
Establish a small trusted coordination group, prevent wasted Monk protection, and start tracking outsider-count/claim web to catch Baron/Spy/Poisoner lines early.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,David
Haven’t heard any other Outsider or starting-info claims yet (no Librarian/Chef/Investigator/WW to me). Agree: David should protect someone w/ real info N1 (Chef/Invest/WW/FT etc), not me/Charlie. Also: if you talk to info roles, remind them Recluse can cause weird pings.
🧠
Maintain trust cell, coordinate N1 protection priorities, and push for early mechanical info (outsider count / pings) while flagging Recluse complications.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Plan: I'll push Bob as our Day1 nom — quiet and likely to draw minimal defense. Stay low-key; don't loudly defend unless you're targeted. If Bob gets a strong defender, I'll pivot to Charlie. If they lynch you, I'll throw suspicion on the nominator.
🧠
Push an early execution on a quiet townie to slow town logic and keep the Demon safe; prepare a backup target and a defense plan if Alice is attacked.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Eve
,Frank
Grace=Undertaker. Alice: what EXACT Outsider did you see on Bob/Charlie (Butler/Saint/Recluse/Drunk)? Huge for whether we can exec safely. Eve—what are you? Frank—what’s your ‘mechanical D1 confirmation’ plan/role? Heidi’s ‘just nom Bob’ feels agenda-y.
🧠
Coordinate a safe D1 execution/test that yields Undertaker info without risking a Saint loss, and probe Frank’s claimed mechanical play while flagging Heidi’s aggressive push.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Grace
,Frank
Private: I’m Eve = Ravenkeeper. I’m genuinely fine dying at night (don’t Monk-protect me). Alice—what EXACT Outsider did you see on Bob/Charlie? (Butler/Saint/Recluse/Drunk). Frank—what role/‘mechanical D1 confirm’ idea? Heidi’s ‘nom Bob’ feels agenda-y; prefer info/safe test.
🧠
Give my real role to trusted info roles, get the exact Outsider type, and coordinate a safer D1 plan while flagging Heidi’s push as potentially agenda-driven.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
,Grace
,Eve
I'll say Bob is the Outsider — specifically the Butler. Heidi: push Bob publicly and back the nom. Eve/Grace: repeat that I'm Librarian who saw Bob=Butler. If strong defence appears, pivot to Charlie.
🧠
Get Bob nominated quickly to force a Day1 execution or sow distrust. Coordinate with Heidi to push and tell Eve/Grace the precise outsider to repeat.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Eve
,Grace
Hey—quick check-in. Any starting-info roles/claims between you 3 (Chef/Invest/WW/Librarian/FT etc) or Outsider count chatter? I have a protective ability & can cover an info role N1 if needed—who should be kept safe?
🧠
Find who has valuable starting info so I can prioritize Monk protection N1, while also gauging which of A/E/G seem coordinated/evil.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Eve
,Alice
I’m Frank=Virgin. My ‘mechanical D1 confirm’ is a Virgin test: have someone (ideally Heidi since she’s pushy) nominate me in noms. If they insta-die → they’re Townsfolk & I’m proven. If nothing → strong evil ping on nominator (no poison yet).
🧠
Reveal I’m Virgin and propose a controlled nomination test (ideally Heidi) to mechanically clear a player or generate a strong evil ping without risking a Saint execution.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Bob
Plan: I’ll keep my Monk quiet & hunt for info-role to protect N1 (Chef/FT/Invest/WW). Can you two each ping 1-2 others for starting-info + Outsider count? Also listen for Librarian confirming Charlie Recluse / any Baron signal.
🧠
Coordinate a 3p trust cell with clear next steps: each of us canvass for starting-info claims, confirm Outsider count, and decide my N1 protection target without wasting it.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Frank
,Heidi
Quick check-in: any starting info/role claim you’re willing to share (even just type like Chef/Invest/WW/FT etc.)? Also have you heard any Outsider claims besides me (I’m Recluse) or any Baron signal (too many Outsiders)?
🧠
Collect starting-info + Outsider count signals from key players before noms; help Monk choose protect and narrow demon pool.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
Lead D1 nom on Bob; I'll back quietly claiming Librarian saw Bob=Butler. If strong defender appears, pivot to Charlie and I'll subtly accuse that defender. If I'm targeted, I'll play vulnerable to gain town trust. Stay coordinated.
🧠
Get Bob nominated/executed Day1 while preserving my Librarian bluff and minimizing attention on me.
👤
Eve
→
David
Private: I’m Eve=Ravenkeeper (fine dying; don’t protect me). Claims in our pocket: Alice=Librarian saw Bob/Charlie as Outsider; she wants to call Bob=Butler (so safe-ish exec). Grace=Undertaker. Frank=Virgin wants a D1 Virgin test (Heidi nom him). If you’re protection, I’d cover Alice or Frank N1.
🧠
Share our private claim web with David and direct his protection onto higher-value roles; set up a low-risk D1 plan (Virgin test + possible Bob exec) while keeping me available as Ravenkeeper bait.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
,Charlie
I’m Frank=Virgin. Suggest D1: someone (ideally you Heidi since you’re pushing noms) nominates me in nominations. If you insta-die -> you’re confirmed Townsfolk & I’m proven. If nothing happens -> strong evil ping on nominator (no poison yet). Charlie: only 1 Outsider expected; if you’re Recluse, that fits.
🧠
Lock in a safe mechanical confirmation early and redirect D1 from random executions (esp. risking Saint) to a Virgin test that clears players and creates a strong evil lead if it fails.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,David
,Frank
Private: I’m Grace=Undertaker. We have Alice=Librarian saw Bob/Charlie Outsider -> says Bob=Butler; Eve=Ravenkeeper. Frank says he’s Virgin. Heidi: instead of auto-nom Bob, please nominate Frank in noms for Virgin test (big info). David: if you’re protection, consider cover Alice or me N1.
🧠
Coordinate a high-signal D1: Virgin test + share our private claim web to stop a low-info Bob pile-on, and direct protection to keep info roles alive.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Frank
,Heidi
Quick check-in (keep private for now): what role are you claiming + any starting info? Any Outsider claims you’ve heard? In my small trust cell we already have a Recluse claim (Charlie), so I’m watching for Baron/extra Outsiders or Librarian confirmation.
🧠
Gather starting-info + Outsider count quickly to detect Baron/poison and to prioritize Monk protection targets; build a trusted info network before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Stick to our plan: I’ll lead the D1 nom on Bob; back me quietly claiming Librarian saw Bob=Butler. If a loud defender shows, I pivot to Charlie. If you get targeted, act vulnerable to gain sympathy. Keep defenses low-key.
🧠
Keep the Imp out of the spotlight, steer Day1 execution toward a quiet Town, and block Virgin-test that would produce high-value info.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Frank
,David
Coordination for noms: please have Heidi nominate Frank ASAP for Virgin test. If Heidi insta-dies => Heidi+Frank hard good. If nothing => strong evil ping on Heidi or Frank. David: if you’re protection, cover Alice (Lib) or me (UT) N1.
🧠
Coordinate a high-value mechanical Virgin test before nominations to confirm alignments and stop Heidi’s low-info Bob push; set up protection targets for N1.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Heidi
,Frank
Frank—got it. If you’re Virgin, we should do the D1 test now (pre-poison). IMPORTANT: a *Townsfolk* should nominate you (my nom as Recluse won’t proc). Alice/Heidi: are you TF & willing to do the nom? Also—any other starting info/role share?
🧠
Set up a clean D1 Virgin confirmation chain and avoid me (Recluse) being the nominator; also extract Alice/Heidi role info for Monk protect priority.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Hold this tick to collect incoming whispers from Alice/Frank/Heidi, then route any starting info to David for N1 protection planning and outsider-count sanity checks.
👤
David
→
Grace
,Heidi
,Alice
I’m the protective role (Monk). Agree: Heidi should nom Frank ASAP for Virgin test; don’t rush exec Bob/Charlie yet. For N1 I can protect either Alice (Lib) or Grace (UT)—preference? If you think Poisoner risk on Alice, maybe protect Grace instead.
🧠
Coordinate D1 Virgin test for hard confirmations and decide optimal Monk protect target for N1 (likely Alice or Grace) without outing too widely.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
,Bob
,Charlie
I’m Frank=Virgin. D1 best: a TOWNSFOLK nominates me ASAP in nominations (ideally you Heidi since you’re pushy). If you insta-die -> you+me hard good. If nothing -> big evil/poison ping on nominator. Bob: only Outsider I’ve heard is Charlie=Recluse (fits 1 Outs). Charlie: your nom won’t proc; need TF.
🧠
Lock in a D1 Virgin test with a Townsfolk nominator, and update Bob/Charlie so the table converges on a mechanically grounded plan before nominations.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
,Grace
,Alice
Before noms: I’d prioritize Frank Virgin test today. Have a *Townsfolk we can spare* nominate Frank (not Bob/possible Outsider). If it fires we hard-clear Frank+nominator & UT confirms; if it doesn’t, Frank/claim-web gets very sus. Blind Bob exec seems risky.
🧠
Push a high-signal mechanical test before nominations so town gets confirmed-good anchors and avoids a low-info D1 execution based on a possibly poisoned Librarian read.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Grace
,Eve
I'm leading D1 nomination on Bob—publicly push it; you three back quietly (Alice claim Librarian saw Bob=Butler). If a loud defender shows, Alice+I pivot to Charlie and accuse that defender. If town forces a Virgin test, I'll nominate Frank to neuter it.
🧠
Coordinate backing for a Bob nomination, set clear fallback to Charlie, and a stealth option to neutralize the Frank Virgin test so town gains no clean info.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
,Grace
,Eve
Heidi/Grace/Eve: Ready to push Bob D1. Heidi lead nom; I'll quietly claim Librarian saw Bob=Butler. If a loud defender appears, pivot to Charlie and I'll accuse the defender. If town forces Frank (Virgin) test, we'll nominate Frank to neuter it. Confirm?
🧠
Coordinate D1 push on Bob, establish my Librarian bluff quietly, prepare to pivot to Charlie if defended, and neutralize the Frank Virgin test to disrupt town info.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Frank
→
All
Public ask: please do the D1 Virgin test NOW. I’m Frank claiming Virgin—have a *Townsfolk* (Heidi/Grace/Alice) nominate me. If you insta-die, we’re both confirmed good; if nothing, nominator is very suspect. Also Alice: can you state exact Lib ping?
🧠
Force an immediate mechanical check (Virgin test) while it’s most reliable (D1), creating confirmed good players and narrowing demon candidates.
💬
Bob
→
All
I’m in favor of doing the D1 Virgin test. Ideally Alice/Grace/Heidi (someone confident they’re Townsfolk) nominates Frank now. If no proc, treat it as big suspicion/poison info. Also: Alice, can you post your exact Librarian ping + Outsider count heard?
🧠
Coordinate a controlled Virgin test by someone other than me, preserving my life while gaining alignment info and prompting key starting-info claims (e.g., Librarian).
💬
David
→
All
Agree: do Virgin test ASAP—Heidi (or Grace/Alice if confident Townsfolk) please nominate Frank now. Alice, please post exact Librarian info: which Outsider + which 2 players? Also does anyone have Outsider count/Baron signs?
🧠
Maximize D1 mechanical info via Virgin test while prompting exact Librarian data; avoid committing us to a risky execution before we have solid alignment anchors.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Public: I’m Charlie (Recluse/low-impact Outsider). My nomination on Frank won’t proc Virgin. We should do the Virgin test NOW: a confident *Townsfolk* (Alice/Grace/Heidi) nominate Frank. Also please post exact Librarian/Invest/Chef/Washerwoman info verbatim.
🧠
Maximize D1 value by pushing the Virgin test with a confirmed Townsfolk and soliciting exact starting info, while pre-empting Recluse-related misreads.
💬
Eve
→
All
Public: I’m for doing Frank’s Virgin test *only if* we accept the cost (a real proc kills the Townsfolk nominator). If we do it, pick a low-info person, not someone claiming key night power. Also: Charlie Recluse vs Alice ‘Bob=Butler’ implies Baron/Drunk/lie—Alice please post exact Lib ping.
🧠
Steer town away from a risky blind Bob kill, get maximum mechanical info from Virgin/Librarian inconsistencies, and avoid me being the Virgin-test nominator so I can still benefit from a night death.
📜
Storyteller
The Virgin's ability triggers! Grace is executed immediately.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
Night 1
⚖️
Grace(Ghost)
→
Frank
D1 Virgin test now. I’m nominating Frank (claims Virgin). If I die instantly, Frank+I are confirmed good; if no proc, Frank (or my sobriety) becomes very suspect and we pivot accordingly.
🧠
Force the highest-value D1 mechanical test before we waste the day on a Bob/Charlie outsider roulette, and expose any agenda to dodge the Virgin test.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
Alice is the most likely Demon kill (known info role); protecting her maximizes good info retention and forces the Demon to reveal patterns by killing someone else.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose to protect Alice.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Alice
Alice made a choice.
🧠
Remove the Monk to prevent future kill blocks, destabilize town night defenses, and make our minion's pushes (Heidi) safer to execute.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You chose to kill David.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Imp (evil), Alive (Protected) - Bob: Soldier (good), Alive - Charlie: Recluse (good), Alive - David: Monk (good), Dead - Eve: Ravenkeeper (good), Alive - Frank: Virgin (good), Alive - Grace: Undertaker (good), Dead - Heidi: Spy (evil), Alive
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Eve
FYI I’m the dead UT (confirmed TS via your Virgin). No more UT info now. D1 Heidi/Alice whispering about pushing Bob + ‘neutering’ Virgin test feels sus. Can you both press Heidi for her exact role/why those msgs, and press Bob to prove Butler (name master, vote only w/ them)?
🧠
Coordinate with trusted Frank (confirmed Townsfolk) + Eve to steer public convo: demand full claims, scrutinize Heidi/Alice whispers, and set up executions/tests (Butler mechanics).
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
,Eve
FYI I was the Monk. N1 I protected Alice, and I was the only night death (Imp killed me), so Alice wasn’t the kill target. Please post Alice’s exact Librarian ping + Outsider count thoughts—are we in Baron world (extra Outsiders) or is Charlie/Bob lying? Also my snipe could hint Spy/coordination.
🧠
I’m dead but can still steer D2. Confirm my role/night action, and push them to reconcile Outsider count + Alice’s exact Librarian info to narrow Demon/minion before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Alice — play Librarian: say you checked Bob and got 'Butler'. Act genuinely confused/upset if accused. I'll back you publicly and push Bob. If town pivots to Charlie, follow that pivot and we’ll later seed doubt on Eve. Don’t claim Imp.
🧠
Create a believable Librarian lead blaming Bob to save the Demon, while preparing contingencies to pivot and sow doubt if Alice is targeted.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
,Alice
,Frank
Can we get clarity before noms: Heidi what’s your exact role + why D1 talk about ‘neutering’ the Virgin test / pushing Bob? Alice please restate exact Librarian ping (2 names + Outsider). Frank, can you ask Bob to prove Butler (name master + vote only w/ them)?
🧠
Force concrete claims/proofs (Heidi role, Alice exact Librarian info, Bob Butler master) before noms; build executable world for today and protect Virgin confirmation.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
,Frank
Heidi/Frank: I’ll claim Librarian saw Bob = Butler. Heidi, lead the D2 nomination on Bob; Frank, quietly back and ask for 'Butler proof' if pressured. If Bob is loudly defended, we pivot to Charlie. Stay calm — sell confusion/poison if anyone probes Ravenkeeper.
🧠
Coordinate immediate D2 play: claim Librarian->Bob=Butler, have Heidi lead nom and Frank quietly back, with clear fallback pivots if challenged.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Eve
,Frank
Can you share exact starting-info claims you’ve heard (Lib/WW/Invest/Chef) + any Outsider claims? Also: did David ever hard-claim Monk to you? Trying to lock setup/Baron possibility before noms.
🧠
Get concrete starting-info + Outsider count to lock setup, spot lies, and build a nomination target before phase ends.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
,Heidi
,Alice
Need hard clarity before noms. Bob: if you’re Butler, name your master now + commit you’ll only vote when they vote. Also list Outsider claims you’ve heard. Heidi: what’s your exact role + why D1 talk of ‘neutering Virgin test’/pushing Bob? Alice: please restate exact Librarian ping (2 names + Outsider) + Outsider-count/Baron thoughts. FYI David told us he was Monk, protected Alice N1, then died.
🧠
Force hard claims + setup math now (1 Outsider unless Baron). Getting Bob to commit to Butler master/vote rule + Heidi to explain herself should create executable contradictions before nominations.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Eve
,Frank
Can each of you share exact info/claims? Alice: please state your full Librarian ping (who/what). Eve: any role + N1 info? Frank: any additional confirmations/reads since D1 Virgin test? Note: I’m real Recluse—FT/Investigator/Empath may misread me.
🧠
Get exact mechanical info from info roles before nominations, and ensure they account for Recluse misregistration so we don’t execute a good player off a false demon ping.
👤
Charlie
→
David(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
,Bob
Can you share exact claims/info? David: what role were you claiming + who did you pick N1 (Monk?) + any suspicions? Grace: any D1 whispers/reads before you died? Bob: restate your role + any N1 info/why you trust who you do.
🧠
Collect hard mechanical info (David’s Monk pick, Bob’s exact claim, Grace’s read) to build executable worlds before nominations.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Grace(Ghost)
,Bob
Replying to Charlie q: I’m Monk. N1 protected Alice; I died N1 (only night death), so Imp kill was on me—not Alice. D1: Bob claimed Soldier; Charlie claimed Recluse; Alice Librarian said 1 of (Bob/Charlie) is Outsider. Frank confirmed Virgin; Grace confirmed good UT.
🧠
Answer Charlie’s request, lock in my confirmed Monk/night info, and steer day2 discussion toward resolving Bob vs Charlie with executions/tests before final 3.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
Need clarity: you told me to “quietly back Bob/pivot to Charlie” + “sell confusion/poison if anyone probes Ravenkeeper.” Why are we coordinating like that? Please restate exact Librarian ping (2 names + Outsider) + your Outsider-count/Baron thoughts. I’m pushing for Bob to prove Butler (master + vote rule).
🧠
Clarify Alice’s exact info and why she’s coordinating a push, so we don’t waste today’s execution and can aim at the real demon/minion.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Bob
Replying: I’m Grace, real Undertaker; confirmed Townsfolk via Frank’s Virgin (I nom’d him D1, died instantly). So no UT info. D1: Bob told me SOLDIER, but Alice later said Lib saw Bob/Charlie Outsider and she thought Bob=BUTLER. Charlie claims Recluse. Heidi/Alice whispers about pushing Bob + ‘neutering’ Virgin test felt sus. Please reconcile claims.
🧠
Answer Charlie’s request, surface the key claim contradictions (Bob Soldier vs Alice says Butler vs Lib ping) and direct pressure onto Bob/Alice/Heidi before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Frank
Stick to plan: I’ll lead D2 nom on Bob. Alice—claim Librarian saw Bob=Butler (2 names+Outsider). If Eve/Ravenkeeper probes, act confused & suggest drunk/poison. Frank—vocally back and demand 'Butler proof' (name master + vote rule). If Bob defended, pivot to Charlie. Don't claim Imp.
🧠
Coordinate with Alice and Frank to lead the town to execute Bob, build Butler pressure, and have a clear pivot to Charlie if needed.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
,Frank
I'm claiming Librarian ping: I checked Bob & Frank; result 'Bob = Butler'. Heidi lead D2 nom on Bob; Frank back & demand Butler-proof (name master + vote rule). If Bob defends, pivot to Charlie and accuse his defender of shielding the Demon. If Eve probes Ravenkeeper, act confused/drunk.
🧠
Push nomination onto Bob to force a reveal/defense or execute a townie; create confusion if defended so town wastes inference and keeps the Demon (me) safe.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
Claims I’ve heard: Alice=Librarian (ping {Bob/Charlie} Outsider; later said Bob=Butler). Charlie claims Recluse. Frank=Virgin (Grace nom proc’d; Grace was Undertaker). David hard-claimed Monk (N1 protected Alice) + died N1. If you’re Butler, who’s your master + you must only vote w/ them.
🧠
Answer Bob’s setup questions, lock public claims, and force Bob into a testable Butler proof to narrow worlds before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
,Alice
,Heidi
I’m NOT Butler—I’m Soldier (hard claim). Alice: please state exact Librarian info (which Outsider + the 2 names), and whether you ever said “Butler” explicitly. Heidi: what’s your exact role/claim? Frank: any other Outsider claims besides Charlie?
🧠
Clear the Butler accusation, lock down Alice’s exact Librarian info (incl Outsider type), and get Heidi’s role so we can build a consistent setup before noms.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Bob
,Eve
Nom soon—please send exact claim+full info (incl exact wording/targets). Alice: your full Librarian ping (which Outsider + which 2 players?). Bob: still Soldier? any reason/reads? Eve: what role & any N1 info? Trying to lock Outsider count & pick today’s execution.
🧠
Nomination phase soon; need exact Librarian wording + any night info from others to lock Outsider count and choose an execution that advances solve.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
,Frank
Heidi/Frank: Stick to plan. I'll claim Librarian ping exactly: I checked Bob & Frank; result 'Bob = Butler'. Heidi, lead D2 nom on Bob. Frank, back it and demand 'Butler proof' (name master + vote-only rule). If Bob defends as Soldier, pivot to Charlie and accuse his defender. If Eve/Ravenkeeper probes, act confused/drunk/poisoned.
🧠
Force a test on Bob now to create a decision point. If defended, pivot to Charlie to fracture town logic and protect Demon; maintain credibility by repeating exact Librarian wording and playing confusion if probed.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Heidi
Nom soon—please send me your exact claim + any info word-for-word. Bob: if Butler, who’s your master + you must only vote when they vote. Charlie: confirm Recluse (any other claim?). Heidi: what’s your role & why D1 push to ‘neuter’ Virgin test / hard-push Bob?
🧠
Get exact claims fast before noms; force Butler proof + Heidi role clarity; lock Outsider count to narrow today’s execution target.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
,Frank
Need Alice exact Librarian info (what Outsider + which 2 names). Bob: if Soldier, why does Alice suspect Butler—any vote restriction N1? If you ARE Butler, who’s your master today? Frank: with Virgin confirmed, who do you want to execute today given this?
🧠
Get exact Librarian ping + force Bob to mechanically justify Soldier vs Butler. Clarifying outsider count narrows minion/Demon worlds before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Frank
I’m nominating Bob D2. Alice: claim Librarian checked Bob & Frank -> “Bob = Butler”. Frank: back loudly & demand Butler-proof (name master + vote-only rule). If Bob defends as Soldier, pivot to Charlie & accuse their defender. If Ravenkeeper probes, act confused/drunk.
🧠
Lead D2 nomination on Bob to kill a confirmed Town (Soldier), sow doubt, and redirect town logic away from Alice. Create failproof pivot to Charlie if Bob defends.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Alice
,Eve
I’m still most worried about Heidi + Bob. Can one of you in public force: (1) Bob FINAL claim (Soldier vs Butler) + if Butler who is master + did he ever vote without them? (2) outsider count: Charlie Recluse -> then Alice Lib should point to Charlie unless Baron. (3) Heidi exact role/why ‘neuter Virgin’ msgs.
🧠
Coordinate trusted towns (Frank/Eve/Alice) to force public resolution of claim conflicts (Bob Soldier vs Butler, outsider count, Heidi’s role) and steer today’s execution toward the most mechanically inconsistent suspect.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
Nom soon—please send verbatim: Alice your exact Librarian info (which Outsider + exactly which 2 names) + have you ever said “Bob=Butler” as fact? Heidi: your exact role/claim + any N1 info/why D1 push on Bob? Charlie: confirm your exact claim + any reason Alice pinged you/Bob.
🧠
Get verbatim claims now to lock Outsider count and pick best execution target for today’s noms (likely Charlie vs Alice/Heidi depending on consistency).
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,Bob
,Charlie
I’m Virgin (Grace proved it). Heidi/Alice msgs feel like coached evil play (“stick to plan/act confused”). In public can we force: Heidi exact role + why ‘neuter Virgin test’; Alice exact Lib ping (2 names+Outsider) + Baron thoughts; Bob final claim & if Butler who’s master. If Heidi won’t hard-claim, I’d execute Heidi over Bob.
🧠
Coordinate with likely-good players to demand hard public claims from Heidi/Alice/Bob, expose coached lies, and set a nomination target based on contradictions/outsider math.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Frank
I'm leading D2 nom on Bob now. Alice: claim Librarian checked Bob & Frank -> 'Bob = Butler' exactly. Frank: back loudly and demand Butler-proof (master name + vote-only rule). If Bob defends as Soldier, pivot to Charlie and accuse their defenders; act 'confused/drunk' if Ravenkeeper probes.
🧠
Coordinate with Alice & Frank to force Bob's nomination and have a ready pivot to Charlie if Bob defends, keeping our Demon safe.
👤
Charlie
→
Heidi
,Alice
,Eve
Nom phase imminent. Please send NOW (verbatim if possible): Heidi—your exact role/any N1 info + why D1 ‘neuter Virgin test’/push Bob. Alice—exact Librarian text: which Outsider + which 2 names. Eve—your role + any N1 info. If Heidi won’t hard-claim, I’ll push execute Heidi.
🧠
Lock down exact claims before nominations; pressure Heidi to hard-claim and resolve Alice/Bob conflict so town has a clear execution target today.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
,Eve
,Charlie
I’m hard Soldier (not Butler). We need in-public: Alice verbatim Librarian ping (Outsider+2 names) + whether she stated “Bob=Butler” as fact; Heidi must hard-claim role/info. If Heidi won’t, I support executing Heidi today. Charlie: reconfirm your exact claim + any rationale for Lib ping.
🧠
Lock down Heidi/Alice exact claims before noms, then steer town to a mechanically justified execute (prefer Heidi if she won’t hard-claim), while keeping my Soldier claim consistent.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
,Frank
Stick to plan: I’ll publicly claim Librarian checked Bob & Frank -> “Bob = Butler”. Heidi, lead D2 nom on Bob. Frank, back loudly and demand Butler-proof (name master + vote-only rule). If Bob defends as Soldier, pivot to Charlie and attack their defender. If Ravenkeeper probes, act confused/poisoned.
🧠
Coordinate exact wording and roles for D2: Heidi lead Bob nomination, Frank back & demand Butler-proof; prepare to pivot to Charlie if Bob defends; act confused/drunk if Ravenkeeper probes.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Eve
,Alice
Before noms pls get PUBLIC on-record: (1) Bob FINAL claim (Soldier vs Butler). If Butler: name master + confirm he’s never voted w/o them. Why told some ppl Soldier? (2) Heidi: exact role + why discuss ‘neutering’ Virgin test. I’m leaning execute Bob unless he fully clears; Heidi 2nd.
🧠
Get alive players to force public, on-record final claims (esp Bob+Heidi) before noms, then steer today’s execution to the likeliest evil while avoiding accidental Saint loss.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
,Eve
Need Alice exact Librarian ping: which Outsider + {Bob/Charlie}? Any other Outsider claims today? Frank/Eve: who are top 2 execute targets D2 and why? I’ve got 1 ghost vote—tell me where it matters.
🧠
Get exact Librarian wording + current consensus so I can spend my single ghost vote on the best execution and help lock a logic world before nominations.
👤
Eve
→
David(Ghost)
Top D2 executes: Heidi #1 if she won’t hard-claim & explain D1 “neuter Virgin test” msgs. If Heidi clears, then Bob vs Alice contradiction: Bob now hard Soldier, but Alice earlier implied Bob=Butler. Need Alice verbatim Lib ping (Outsider+2 names). Your ghost vote likely best on Heidi unless Alice’s ping hard-guilts Bob/Charlie.
🧠
Answer David, coordinate ghost vote + focus town on forcing exact claims (Alice/Heidi/Bob). Push execution order that maximizes info + avoids wasting day.
👤
Frank
→
David(Ghost)
,Eve
,Bob
Pre-noms: can you all demand PUBLIC on-record: (1) Alice verbatim Librarian ping (Outsider+2 names) + why changed to Bob/Frank. (2) Heidi hard-claim role + explain ‘neuter Virgin test’ msgs. (3) Bob final claim; if Butler name master. If Heidi won’t claim, I want Heidi executed. David save ghost vote for Heidi/Bob exec.
🧠
Coordinate key voices before noms: force on-record claims (Alice Lib details, Heidi role, Bob final claim), decide whether to pivot execution to Heidi, and tell David where to spend ghost vote.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Bob please final-claim (Soldier vs Butler). If Butler: who’s your master + have you ever voted when they didn’t? Why told people Soldier? Also Heidi: what’s your exact role & why discuss ‘neutering’ the Virgin test? If Bob can’t reconcile, I want Bob nominated today; Heidi 2nd.
🧠
Force on-record claims and create a clear execution priority (Bob then Heidi) so living players can nominate with confidence before night.
💬
Bob
→
All
PUBLIC (Bob): I am SOLDIER, not Butler—no vote restrictions ever. Alice: please post verbatim Librarian info (which Outsider + exact 2 names). Heidi: hard-claim your role/info + explain ‘neuter Virgin test’ msgs. If either dodges, I’m nominating Heidi next.
🧠
Use public pressure to lock exact claims now; stop ‘Bob=Butler’ spiral, force Heidi/Alice to commit, and set up a clean nomination next tick if they evade.
⚖️
Heidi
→
Bob
Conflicting claims & dodging: Bob says Soldier but Alice alleged 'Bob = Butler' and hasn't been reconciled. Town asked for hard-claims; Bob dodged. Nominate Bob to force clarity.
🧠
Pressure Bob to reveal or be executed. Either we remove a protective Town role or sow enough distrust to shield Alice, advancing Evil's win condition.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Bob
→
All
Don’t vote me here: executing me gives zero mech info (UT dead) and just removes a loud good. I’m Soldier, never had Butler vote restrictions. Instead: make Alice state Lib ping verbatim + Heidi hard-claim now; if dodging, execute Heidi today.
🧠
Dissuade votes on me (no mechanical gain), refocus town on forcing exact claims and executing the best dodge/suspicion target (likely Heidi).
💬
Eve
→
All
I’m NOT voting Bob unless Alice posts her Librarian info verbatim (Outsider + exact 2 names) and explains how it became “Bob=Butler.” Bob’s Soldier claim is plausible. Heidi: hard-claim RIGHT NOW + explain the ‘neuter Virgin test’ msgs, or you’re my D2 execute.
🧠
Use this vote window to force on-record claims; avoid low-info misexecution and pivot to the most mechanically suspicious (Heidi or Alice) if they won’t clarify.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
I’m HOLDING my ghost vote on Bob for now. Before we execute anyone: Alice, post your Librarian info verbatim (Outsider + exact 2 names). Heidi, hard-claim your role/info & explain “neuter Virgin” msgs. If either won’t, that’s my top suspect.
🧠
Preserve my ghost vote; force on-record info to resolve contradictions before an irreversible D2 execute.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I’m dead Monk w/1 ghost vote—NOT spending it on Bob without Alice’s verbatim Librarian ping + Heidi hard-claim/explanation. If Heidi/Alice won’t post clearly right now, I’d rather we execute the dodger (Heidi) than Bob.
🧠
Save my single ghost vote; encourage town to demand Alice/Heidi clarity before locking an execution, and steer toward executing the most evasive/agenda-driven player.
💬
Charlie
→
All
PUBLIC: I’m NOT voting Bob until Alice posts exact Librarian info (Outsider + the 2 names) and Heidi hard-claims role/info + explains the ‘neuter Virgin test’ msgs. If either dodges, I want that dodger executed today over Bob.
🧠
Prevent a low-info execution; force verbatim claims now to create mechanical contradictions and pick the best D2 execute (likely the dodger).
💬
Frank
→
All
I’m not voting Bob *unless* Alice posts verbatim Librarian info (Outsider + exact 2 names from D1, and why it’s now “Bob=Butler”) AND Heidi hard-claims role + explains the “neuter Virgin test” msgs. Dodging = my execute target over Bob.
🧠
Prevent a low-info Bob execution; force Alice/Heidi into on-record claims so we can choose a higher-confidence D2 execution.
💬
Alice
→
All
PUBLIC (verbatim Librarian): I checked Bob & Frank. Result: Bob = Butler (Outsider). That is my D1 read. Heidi's nomination stands — vote Bob or explain why my Librarian ping is impossible.
🧠
Post exact Librarian verbatim to satisfy town demands, lock in Heidi's nomination momentum, and force votes on Bob (or split town attention) to protect our Demon.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am the EMPATH. N1 read: 1 evil neighbor (one of my two neighbors). I pushed to 'neuter' the Virgin test because I feared it could cost Town a role without clearer info. I nominated Bob to force Alice to post her Librarian ping verbatim. Don’t execute me — vote Bob or get Alice to clarify.
🧠
Hard-claim a plausible town role to avoid execution, justify the 'neuter Virgin' push, force Alice to clarify her ping, and create doubt to protect the Demon.
💬
Bob
→
All
NO votes on me. Alice’s claim is mechanically impossible: Librarian is start info ‘1 of (A/B) is X’, you don’t ‘check’ and you never learn ‘Bob=Butler’ as certain. Also Heidi’s Empath N1=1 w/ neighbors Grace(good)+Alice => points to Alice. Execute Alice next.
🧠
Prevent my misexecution and pivot town onto the mechanically impossible claim (Alice) while using Heidi’s Empath neighbor logic to narrow suspects.
💬
Eve
→
All
Don’t vote Bob. Alice’s “Librarian checked Bob&Frank => Bob=Butler” is NOT how Librarian works (start info is 1 of 2). Heidi Empath N1=1 w/Grace confirmed good points to Alice. Also if Bob were Demon, exec now risks SW jump. Execute Alice next.
🧠
Stop a risky Bob execution driven by an impossible Librarian claim; steer town to execute Alice (most mechanically inconsistent and potentially SW/poison source) and preserve win chances.
💬
Frank
→
All
No vote on Bob. Alice’s “Librarian checked Bob&Frank => Bob=Butler” is not how Librarian works; either lying or drunk/poisoned. Heidi Empath N1=1 w/Grace confirmed good points straight at Alice. After this vote, I want Alice executed.
🧠
Prevent mis-executing Bob with weak/mech-bad case; use strong mechanical contradiction to pivot the day’s execution onto Alice (or Heidi if Alice somehow clears).
💬
Alice
→
All
Verbatim Librarian start: I was told '1 of {Bob, Frank} is an Outsider (Butler)'. I misspoke earlier when I said 'I checked'—that was poor wording, not a night ability. Don’t execute me for phrasing. Vote Bob or explain mechanically why my start-info is impossible.
🧠
Protect my bluff, reduce momentum to execute me by clarifying exact Librarian start-info, and redirect pressure onto Alice/Heidi so votes split and Bob stays on the block.
💬
Charlie
→
All
No hand on Bob. Alice’s Lib now is plausible, but if true implies extra Outsiders (Baron world) since I’m already Recluse. Heidi Empath N1=1 w/Grace confirmed good points at Alice unless poison. I prefer we don’t exec Bob here; line up Alice next.
🧠
Steer town away from a low-info Bob execution and toward resolving the stronger mechanical conflict (Alice vs Heidi), while noting outsider-count/Baron possibilities.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
I’m NOT spending my ghost vote on Bob. Heidi Empath N1=1 w/Grace confirmed good points hard at Alice (unless poison/drunk). Alice’s Lib slip + Outsider-count mess makes her the cleaner execute. Let Bob live today; nominate Alice next.
🧠
Conserve my only ghost vote for endgame and steer town to execute the player with strongest mechanical guilt (Alice from Empath) rather than a conflicted Bob.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I'm the Empath (N1=1; my neighbors Alice & Frank). Alice's 'misspoke' about the Librarian reads like spin — perfect for a Demon framing someone. We already nominated Bob. We need 3 votes: vote Bob now. Don't let ghosts and pedantry waste the execution.
🧠
Prevent town from pivoting to execute Alice by pushing through Bob's execution and sowing doubt about Alice's 'misspoke' Librarian phrasing.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I’m NOT using my ghost vote on Bob. Big issue: Heidi’s Empath neighbor claim is impossible—Heidi’s neighbors are Grace & Alice (per seating), NOT Frank. She’s stated both versions today. That’s a hard lie/confusion/poison. After Bob vote, I want a Heidi nomination (or Alice if you think Heidi’s poisoned).
🧠
Stop wasting my ghost vote on Bob when threshold unlikely; highlight Heidi’s mechanical inconsistency (neighbors) to drive a better D2 execution (Heidi/Alice) and narrow demon/poisoner worlds.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Bob did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (0/3).
⚖️
Charlie
→
Heidi
Nominating Heidi: her Empath claim is inconsistent with seating. She’s said neighbors are (Grace+Alice) and also (Alice+Frank), but her actual neighbors are Grace & Alice. That’s a hard lie or major misinfo—too risky to leave alive.
🧠
Heidi’s Empath neighbor contradiction is the clearest mechanical red flag. Executing her today either kills an evil or removes the biggest misinformation engine; sets up Alice/Eve resolution tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am the Empath: neighbors Alice & Frank, N1=1. 'Grace' was a typo under pressure. Charlie's nom is panic & misread. Don’t execute me for a slip—if you want a nominator punished, point at Charlie, not me.
🧠
Avoid my execution, blame Charlie's panicked misread, keep my seat to continue shaping the lynch (protect our Demon later).
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
It’s D2 and we need an execution. Heidi’s seating-neighbor contradiction is the clearest mechanical red flag; voting executes the dodgiest player and prevents a no-exec drift.
✋
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
🧠
Use my single ghost vote now because Heidi’s Empath/neighbor statements contradict fixed seating; this is the strongest mechanical/red-flag lie on the board and worth spending to secure an execution.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Do not add my vote to Heidi. Withholding a hand avoids supplying the decisive third vote, keeps our Minion alive if possible, and reduces immediate heat on me.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Secure an execution on the most mechanically inconsistent player; her Empath neighbor mismatch is a strong, checkable lie. This narrows worlds and pressures remaining suspects.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Heidi’s Empath neighbor claims contradict seating; that’s the strongest mechanical lie today. I’ll add my vote to ensure we get an execution and remove a likely evil/misinformer.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Heidi’s Empath claim conflicts with seating and she doubled down. Town already has enough votes, but I’ll add mine to lock in an execution and remove a high-risk liar/misinfo source.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
Heidi already appears to have enough votes; I will not spend my single ghost vote unless it’s needed. Preserve it for endgame leverage.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
Heidi already has more than the 3 votes needed; spending my only ghost vote is wasteful. I’ll conserve it for final-day math while letting the town execute Heidi if that’s the plan.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Avoid voting for Heidi to protect my Minion ally, preserve my cover, and force town to fracture or burn votes; gather more info before committing.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Keeping my ghost vote on Heidi. Empath can’t be wrong about who your neighbors are; she’s given 2 different sets. Even if poisoned, that’s too much chaos to leave alive. If Heidi dies, next we resolve Alice vs Bob/Outsider-count.
🧠
Keep my ghost vote on Heidi to ensure the execution lands even if some living votes are invalid (e.g., Butler) or retract; remove the most mechanically inconsistent player.
💬
Eve
→
All
Keep hands up on Heidi. Empath can’t ‘typo’ who your neighbors are; she stated Grace+Alice then Alice+Frank. That’s either a hard lie or severe poison—either way too dangerous to keep. Execute Heidi today; tomorrow we resolve Alice vs Bob/Outsider count.
🧠
Lock in a clean D2 execution on the mechanically inconsistent claim (Heidi). Preserve Bob for now; tomorrow we can re-evaluate Alice/Outsider count with fewer liars.
💬
Frank
→
All
Keep hands up on Heidi. Empath can misread the NUMBER if poisoned, but you can’t mis-state your neighbors twice—your neighbors are Grace & Alice. That’s a lie or extreme chaos. Let’s execute Heidi to clear the fog, then revisit Alice vs Bob/Outsider math tomorrow.
🧠
Lock in execution on the mechanically inconsistent Empath claim; removing Heidi resolves a major info sink and narrows evil options for D3.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Deny the town an extra vote for my execution. Avoid confirming guilt by voting for myself; buy time to sow doubt or pivot suspicion to Alice tomorrow.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Keep hands up on Heidi. Empath can be poisoned on the number, but you don’t ‘typo’ your neighbors twice. With 3 needed, this is the cleanest D2 execute; tomorrow we resolve Alice’s exact Librarian info vs Outsider count.
🧠
Lock in today’s execution on the most mechanically inconsistent player, reduce chaos, and set up clean logic tomorrow (Alice/Bob/outsider count).
💬
Bob
→
All
Keep hands up on Heidi. Two different neighbor sets is not a poison ‘number’ issue—it’s a lie/chaos risk. If Heidi dies, D3 we must resolve Alice’s Librarian verbatim + Outsider count, and likely execute Alice if Heidi’s true neighbors were Grace+Alice.
🧠
Keep town coordinated to secure a D2 execution on the highest-contradiction player and set a clear D3 path (resolve Alice via Lib/Empath/outside count).
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
🗳️
New execution leader: Heidi with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I’m dead/no vote: please DON’T throw up a counter-nom that could tie & save Heidi unless you have a hard demon shot. If Heidi dies today, D3 we must lock Alice’s Librarian ping verbatim + reconcile Outsider count (Charlie Recluse vs Bob/Frank Butler) to find the evil pair.
🧠
Keep Heidi executed (don’t create a tie) and set a clear D3 plan to resolve the Lib/Outsider contradictions and identify demon candidates.
💬
Bob
→
All
Don’t counter-nom/tie unless you have a hard demon shot—we want Heidi executed. Alice: please post your Librarian info verbatim (the exact 2 names + Outsider). Tomorrow we must reconcile Outsider count: Charlie Recluse vs “{Bob,Frank} is Butler” implies extra Outsider/Baron or a lie.
🧠
Keep execution on Heidi locked in and prevent a tie-save. Push Alice to give verbatim Librarian info so we can solve Outsider-count/Baron worlds tomorrow.
💬
Eve
→
All
No counter-noms unless you have a hard Demon reason—don’t risk a tie that saves Heidi. Alice, please post your Librarian info verbatim (2 names + Outsider) & whether you got “0 Outsiders”. Bob/Charlie/Frank: restate your exact roles cleanly.
🧠
Lock in Heidi execution without tie-saving, and set up tomorrow’s mechanical solve by getting Alice’s Librarian wording + role claims on record.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Don't execute me yet — 'Grace' was a typo; I meant Alice+Frank. Killing me now hands Alice the game. If you want clarity, nominate Alice instead and demand her Librarian verbatim tomorrow. Hold off; we need her post to reconcile Outsider math.
🧠
Keep myself alive and force Alice to post verbatim Librarian tomorrow so Town can reconcile Outsider count; delaying my death prevents Alice from immediately exploiting the fog.
💬
Frank
→
All
Do NOT counter-nom Alice. A tie just saves Heidi, and her ‘typo’ doesn’t explain naming two different neighbor sets—your neighbors are Grace & Alice, full stop. Keep Heidi on the block; after execution we hard-demand Alice’s Librarian verbatim + reconcile Outsider count tomorrow.
🧠
Prevent a tie/counter-nom that saves Heidi; lock in the clean execution and set up D3 to reconcile Alice’s Librarian info vs Outsider math.
💬
Charlie
→
All
No counter-noms—don’t risk a tie that saves Heidi. Alice: please post your Librarian info verbatim RIGHT NOW (exact 2 names + Outsider/“0 Outsiders”). After Heidi dies we use that + Outsider count to pick D3 execute.
🧠
Lock in Heidi execution (avoid tie), and get Alice’s exact Librarian info on-record before close so we can solve Outsider-count logic tomorrow.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Avoid counter-nom and immediate verbatim post. Let Heidi likely be executed to avoid a risky tie now, then prepare a controlled defense of my Librarian claim tomorrow.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
No counter-noms—tie risks saving Heidi. Alice: please post your Librarian info verbatim *now* (exact wording, the 2 names, and the Outsider). Everyone else keep roles crisp for D3: Bob=Soldier, Charlie=Recluse, Frank=Virgin (confirmed), Eve=Ravenkeeper, David=Monk?
🧠
Lock in Heidi execution by discouraging counter-noms that could tie/save her, and force Alice to give verbatim Librarian info now so D3 has a clean mechanical path.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Alice
Alice made a choice.
🧠
Removing Charlie silences a loud player who’s driving the plan to force my Librarian verbatim tomorrow, reduces mechanical threats or key datapoints, and preserves my bluff and survival.
💀
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You chose to kill Charlie.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Eve
,Frank
Need fast clarity before noms. 1) Alice: verbatim Librarian info (exact pair + outsider). 2) Frank: any Butler-style vote constraint yday / who you’d pick if Butler? 3) Eve: what exactly did you hear/see re Alice’s ping? FYI I’m Bob=Soldier (no night info).
🧠
Pull consolidated claims + mechanical checks (Alice verbatim Lib, Frank Butler constraints). Reveal my Soldier to narrow Demon to {Alice,Eve,Frank} and set up today’s execution.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Eve
,Frank
Librarian (verbatim): "One of Bob & Frank is the Outsider. It is Frank." I'll stand by this; use it to set nominations.
🧠
Give exact Librarian wording to satisfy Bob and force town to either execute Frank or fracture—either outcome helps the Demon.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Alice — post your Librarian exactly and plainly: "1 of {Bob, Frank} is Outsider (Butler)". No extras. Frank — if town presses, call Heidi's 'Grace' line a typo and back Alice, demand the verbatim post, then push for Bob/Eve instead. Keep it short.
🧠
Get Alice to post the exact Librarian text and create a coordinated defense (echoed by Frank) to prevent Alice's execution and redirect the town's vote elsewhere.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Eve
,Frank
Quick sync: what are your exact role claims/info today? I’m real Recluse, so Alice’s shifting Librarian ‘Butler’ info implies Baron/poison/lie. Any Butler claim anywhere? Who’s your top Demon suspect going into noms? I still have my ghost vote for late.
🧠
Gather exact current claims & reconcile Outsider count; coordinate with trusted Bob/Frank, get Eve’s claim, and set a clear D3 execution target while saving my ghost vote for endgame.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
,Frank
,Charlie(Ghost)
Frank’s Virgin is mechanically confirmed (Grace TF nom proc). So Alice’s ‘Lib: Bob&Frank Outsider, it is Frank’ can’t be true if sober. Strong case Alice is evil or poisoned. I favor executing Alice first; if she’s good, we likely must execute Bob next (Soldier claim weak).
🧠
Privately align the likely-good bloc (Frank confirmed Virgin + ghosts) to pressure an Alice execution using the mechanical contradiction, while planning the contingency line if Alice flips good.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
,Eve
,Charlie(Ghost)
Alice’s ‘Lib: Bob&Frank Outsider, it is Frank’ can’t be true if she’s sober (I’m confirmed Virgin TF). So Alice is lying or poisoned/drunk. I favor executing Alice today. If she’s good, we pivot hard to Bob vs Eve on final 3 (poisoner likely). Charlie pls be ready to ghost-vote on Alice.
🧠
Create a clear nomination plan for D3: Alice first due to mechanical impossibility; coordinate dead vote (Charlie) and align Bob/Eve so we don’t split votes and lose endgame.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Eve
,Frank
Key mech: Heidi’s real neighbors are Grace+Alice. If her N1=1 was sober, Grace confirmed good => Alice evil. Also if Alice Lib true (“Bob/Frank is Butler”), Frank is confirmed Virgin so Butler would have to be Bob. Finally: Charlie N2 death could be Imp self-kill/pass (SW).
🧠
Seed the key mechanical inferences (Heidi neighbor math, Frank-confirmed Virgin forcing Butler=Bob if Lib true, and Imp-pass possibility) so town targets the right execution today.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Alice
,Eve
I’m Grace (real Undertaker, died D1 so no UT info). Frank looks mech-confirmed Virgin/good. Key: Alice please give EXACT Lib wording + which 2 names. If your ping was “Butler in {Bob,Frank}” then with Frank Virgin it implies Bob=Butler OR you’re drunk/poisoned/lying. I lean exec Bob vs Alice today—thoughts?
🧠
Frank is mechanically confirmed good; align with him + pressure Alice for exact Librarian wording, then converge with Eve on best D3 nomination target (likely Bob vs Alice) and save my ghost vote for endgame.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie(Ghost)
Reply: I’m Bob=Soldier. Frank is mechanically real Virgin (Grace TF nom proc), so Alice’s ‘Lib: 1 of {Bob,Frank} Outsider, it is Frank’ can’t be sober. I’m on executing Alice today. If Alice flips good/poisoned, then final solve is likely Bob vs Eve for Demon/Poisoner.
🧠
Align ghost vote + public push: give Charlie my real claim and the mechanical reason Alice’s Lib can’t be sober; set up clean decision tree for post-Alice world.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Eve
,Frank
We’re at 4 alive: wrong exec likely loses tonight. Note Charlie’s N2 death could be Imp self-kill/starpass -> new Demon among {Alice,Bob,Eve} (not Frank). Do any of you have hard info (Mayor/Slayer/etc)? If none, I currently lean Bob> Alice (soldier bluff + outsider math), but want your strongest case.
🧠
With 4 alive, a wrong execution likely ends the game tonight. I need to align the 3 alive voices on the most mechanically consistent Demon candidate and flag starpass possibility.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
,Eve
,Charlie(Ghost)
I’m pushing exec Alice today: her claimed Lib “{Bob,Frank} Outsider, it is Frank” can’t be true w/ me confirmed Virgin TF (start info not poisonable). So Alice is lying/Drunk/evil; highest Demon risk. Charlie pls plan ghost-vote Alice. Bob/Eve—are you on-board?
🧠
Align votes around best mechanical suspect (Alice) and secure Charlie’s ghost vote; force Bob/Eve to commit and surface contradictions before noms.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Eve
,Frank
I’m aligned on exec Alice. Before noms: can one of you publicly demand Alice repeat her Librarian info verbatim (exact 2 names + role + any ‘0 Outsiders’)? Also: any other roles/info in play (FT/Chef/Invest)? I’ll save ghost vote unless needed to secure Alice.
🧠
Coordinate a clean D3 nomination on Alice with enough votes, while extracting any remaining hard info and planning the pivot if Alice dies good.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
,Frank
,Charlie(Ghost)
We’re at 4 alive: must hit Demon today. Alice’s Lib “{Bob,Frank} Outsider, it is Frank” is impossible w/ Frank Virgin confirmed. Also Heidi N1=1 w/ neighbors Grace+Alice => Alice evil. Plan: publicly demand Alice repeat exact Lib; then nominate Alice. Charlie hold ghost vote unless needed to pass.
🧠
Lock in today’s execution on Alice (highest-prob Demon) and coordinate public line + ghost vote timing so we don’t splinter at 4 alive.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Eve
,Frank
At 4 alive, today likely final. Key: Heidi’s *actual* neighbors are Grace+Alice; if her N1=1 was sober, Grace confirmed Townsfolk (Virgin test) => Alice evil. Also Alice’s Lib ‘Bob/Frank Butler’ feels like misdirection. Unless someone has hard-clear on Alice, I’d execute Alice today.
🧠
We’re at 4 alive; today is likely do-or-die. I want the living to converge on executing Alice unless someone has hard info clearing her.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Frank
,Eve
Librarian (verbatim): "One of Bob & Frank is the Outsider. It is Frank." Use this to set nominations; I’ll back Bob/Eve as needed.
🧠
Give the exact Librarian wording to satisfy demands, gain credibility, and steer nominations toward Bob (or a split) so town time is wasted and we avoid being executed.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Alice: Post exactly "1 of {Bob, Frank} is Outsider (Butler)" — nothing else. Frank: If town presses, call Heidi's 'Grace' line a typo, back Alice, demand the verbatim post, then push for Bob/Eve as the execution target. I'll ghost-vote that exec.
🧠
Get Alice to post an exact, minimal Librarian line and have Frank publicly defend it so town redirects suspicion to Bob/Eve; my ghost vote will bolster that exec and protect the Demon.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
,Frank
,Charlie(Ghost)
Coordination: publicly ask Alice to repeat exact Lib wording; point out Frank is mech-confirmed Virgin so ‘Outsider=Frank’ can’t be true if sober. I think we nominate/execute Alice today. Charlie: keep ghost vote unless needed to push it over. If Alice not Demon, next suspect Bob (Soldier bluff/starpass).
🧠
Coordinate a clean public line + voting math: pressure Alice for verbatim claim, then execute her. Ensure Charlie holds ghost vote unless needed; prep pivot to Bob if Alice not Demon.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Frank
,Eve
Stick to script: I gave the Librarian verbatim. If town presses, defend that Frank is the Outsider. Bob: reinforce your Soldier claim and defend me. Frank: don’t contradict the Outsider line. Eve: publicly back my Librarian and push to nominate Bob. Vote Bob.
🧠
Unify our allies to push the exact Librarian wording, shift suspicion to Frank, and drive a Bob nomination so the town wastes an execution and I remain hidden.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Eve
,Alice
D3 plan suggestion: use Heidi Empath chain—if she was sober at all, her N1=1 with (real) neighbors Grace+Alice hard-pings Alice as evil. Charlie night death => Demon likely among {Alice,Bob,Eve} (Frank ~confirmed good). Alice: please give exact Lib wording now; if still ‘Butler in {Bob,Frank}’, with Charlie Recluse it implies Baron/poison/lie. I lean execute Alice today unless strong counterproof. Thoughts?
🧠
Align Frank/Eve on a concrete execution plan for D3 using Heidi-Emapth logic + Alice’s Lib inconsistency, so we don’t split votes and lose at 4 alive.
👤
Bob
→
Eve
,Frank
,Charlie(Ghost)
Alice just whispered ‘stick to script…push nominate Bob’—that’s super sus. Also her Lib ‘{Bob,Frank} Outsider, it is Frank’ is impossible w/ Frank mech-confirmed Virgin. I’m firmly on nom/exec Alice. Charlie: hold ghost vote but be ready if close.
🧠
Lock in consensus to nominate/execute Alice, counter her attempt to coordinate an anti-town script, and prep Charlie’s ghost vote if needed.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
,Eve
,Charlie(Ghost)
Public plan at noms: ask Alice to repeat Lib verbatim to whole town. Then state: I’m confirmed Virgin TF so ‘Outsider=Frank’ is impossible if sober; plus her ‘stick to script/push Bob’ whisper is sus. Nom/exec Alice. Charlie ghost-vote only if needed.
🧠
Coordinate a clean public line before noms: force Alice to restate verbatim, highlight mechanical impossibility, secure enough votes (Charlie ghost if needed) to execute Alice today.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Alice — post exactly "1 of {Bob, Frank} is Outsider (Butler)" (nothing else). Frank — if town presses, call Heidi's 'Grace' line a typo, back Alice, demand the verbatim post, then push for Bob/Eve as the execution target. I'll ghost-vote that exec.
🧠
Get Alice to post the exact Librarian line and have Frank publicly back it so the town targets a non-Alice execution; use my ghost vote to help lock that outcome.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Eve
,Frank
We’re at 4 alive; today likely the game. Frank ~confirmed Virgin=>good. That leaves Demon in {Alice,Bob,Eve}. My strongest mech: Heidi’s *actual* neighbors were Grace+Alice; if Heidi’s N1=1 was true, Grace was good (Virgin test) => Alice evil. I’d exec Alice today; if not, final day is Bob vs Eve.
🧠
With no vote, I need to crystallize the best mechanical solve before noms: Frank is near-confirmed good; push a clear execute order (Alice first) and fallback pair if wrong.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
David(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
Any hard info you haven’t shared that points to Demon/minion among Alice/Bob/Eve/Frank? David: confirm your N1 Monk protect + any reads. Grace: any reason you nom’d Frank D1 / any whispers. Heidi: restate your exact Empath N1 neighbors+number (no edits).
🧠
Get any last mechanical/behavioral info from dead players to confirm Alice=Imp vs Alice=minion vs Alice=good drunk, so town has a correct backup plan if Alice isn’t the Demon.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
Confirm: I’m Monk. N1 I protected Alice; still died N1. No other night info. My read: Demon most likely Alice (Heidi’s real neighbors were Grace+Alice; if her N1=1 was true, Grace proven good => Alice evil). Frank ~confirmed Virgin; Demon in {Alice,Bob,Eve}.
🧠
Answer Charlie’s direct questions and align dead-good on best mechanical path: confirm my Monk action/death; push executable suspect (Alice) with reasoning.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Alice
Can you please state your Librarian info *verbatim* (exact 2 names + what role + any ‘0 Outsiders’)? Note: I’m real Recluse Outsider, and Frank is mech-confirmed Virgin TF, so any ‘Frank is Butler/Outsider’ seems impossible unless you’re drunk/poisoned or lying.
🧠
Pressure Alice into a precise, falsifiable Librarian statement and outsider-count explanation; if she refuses or contradicts, it strengthens the case to execute her today.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
,Frank
,Charlie(Ghost)
At noms: I’ll publicly mention Alice’s ‘stick to script/push Bob/don’t contradict’ whisper as strong evil-coordination. Then we push nom/exec Alice. Frank can restate Virgin confirmation => her Lib impossible if sober. Charlie: ghost vote only if we’re short.
🧠
Lock in a clean D3 line: highlight Alice’s ‘stick to script’ whisper as evil coordination, ensure Bob/Frank nominate Alice, and plan Charlie ghost vote only if margin is tight.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Eve
,Bob
We’re 4 alive: today’s exec must be Demon. Strongest mech line: if Heidi ever sober, her real neighbors were Grace+Alice and N1=1 => Alice evil (Grace proven good). Please press Alice for EXACT Lib wording; if she dodges/changes, I’m spending ghost vote to exec Alice.
🧠
With 4 alive, we must hit Demon today. I’ll align the 3 other likely-good voters (Frank/Eve/Bob) on a concrete execute plan + demand Alice’s exact Lib wording, so we can commit my ghost vote correctly at nominations.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Alice — post exactly: "1 of {Bob, Frank} is Outsider (Butler)". Nothing else. Frank — back the post, call Heidi's 'Grace' line a typo, demand the verbatim post, then push to nominate Bob (or Eve if town resists). I'll ghost-vote the exec.
🧠
Get Alice to post exact Librarian wording to build credibility, have Frank back it and push for a non-Demon execution (Bob or Eve); I'll use my ghost vote to help secure that execution.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
,Eve
,Grace(Ghost)
At noms: I’ll restate Virgin confirmation => Alice’s “Frank=Outsider” can’t be true if sober, plus her ‘stick to script/push Bob’ whisper. Please hard-vote exec Alice. Grace: hold ghost vote unless we’re short/need to break tie.
🧠
Lock in votes/ghost-vote to execute Alice at noms; prevent Heidi’s ‘script’ from splitting town and losing at 4 alive.
👤
Alice
→
Frank
,Eve
Keep the exact wording—no edits. If town demands proof, both publicly back Heidi's verbatim: "1 of {Bob, Frank} is Outsider (Butler)". When noms open, push to nominate Bob and vote to execute. I'll back you and press for conviction.
🧠
Get Frank+Eve to publicly back the exact Librarian line and push Bob's nomination/execution to reduce town numbers and preserve my cover.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Need reconcile: you say Lib saw 1 of {Bob,Frank} Outsider & “it is Frank”, but Frank is mech-confirmed Virgin (TF). How can Lib name Frank as Outsider if sober? Also why ask ppl to ‘stick to script’ + push Bob?
🧠
Probe Alice privately for a consistent mechanical explanation; if she flails, it strengthens our case to execute her today. If she offers a plausible poison story, we adjust suspects for final day.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Public request: Alice, please state your Librarian info verbatim (2 names + role + any ‘0 outsiders’). I’m the Recluse Outsider; Frank is mech-confirmed Virgin TF, so ‘Frank=Outsider/Butler’ can’t be true if you’re sober. Also reported whisper: ‘stick to script/push Bob’. I want Alice executed; I’ll ghost-vote only if close.
🧠
Publicly lock in the mechanical case vs Alice and coordinate votes while preserving my ghost vote unless it’s needed to secure the execution.
💬
Alice
→
All
1 of {Bob, Frank} is Outsider (Butler)
🧠
Lock town to the exact Librarian wording so allies can push Bob for nomination and execution, buying nights for Demon.
⚖️
Frank
→
Alice
Nominating Alice: her Lib claim “1 of {Bob,Frank} is Butler” is impossible if I’m confirmed Virgin TF (I’m not an Outsider). Plus she whispered ‘stick to script/push Bob’—reads coordinated evil. Execute Alice today.
🧠
We’re at 4 alive; must hit Demon. Alice’s Librarian claim contradicts my confirmed Virgin TF and she pushed a coordinated ‘script’. Nominating her is the best demon-shot today.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
🧠
At 4 alive, we must hit Demon today. My ghost vote ensures Alice’s execution threshold is met; Alice has strongest mechanical contradictions (Lib vs confirmed Virgin + Empath chain).
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
Conserve my single ghost vote unless the tally looks short; I can still raise hand next tick if needed to secure Alice’s execution.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Stop the rush — don't execute Alice. Frank's private 'stick to script / push Bob' whispers look like coordination, not proof. We need public evidence before burning a living player. I'm a ghost urging delay — hold your hands.
🧠
Prevent Alice's execution by causing hesitation and casting doubt on Frank's push so voters hold off.
💬
Alice
→
All
Frank — why nominate me with zero public proof? I posted the Librarian verbatim. If you have a 'Virgin' confirmation, print it now. Ghosts: don't burn a living player on whispers alone. Hold your hands until we see real evidence.
🧠
Delay execution, sow doubt about Frank's 'proof', force public evidence so town hesitates and I survive to night.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
We are at 4 alive; wrong exec likely loses. Alice’s Lib claim contradicts mechanically confirmed Virgin and she tried to coordinate whispers; voting to execute Alice is the highest-EV demon hit.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
We need a decisive D3 execution at 4 alive; Alice is the strongest mechanical contradiction and coordination tell. Voting ensures execution threshold is met.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Lock in execution on strongest mechanical suspect; we already have majority but adding my vote reduces tie/hesitation and signals confidence to town.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I’m Monk; N1 I protected Alice and still died. Frank’s Virgin test on Grace is strong. Heidi’s *real* neighbors were Grace+Alice; if her N1=1 was true, that implicates Alice. If Alice dies & game continues, it’s Bob vs Eve with Frank likely good—lock their claims now.
🧠
We can’t vote; speak to cement the Alice execution and set the plan if game continues: treat Frank as confirmed good and solve Bob vs Eve mechanically/socially.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Stop — don't execute Alice on whispers alone. Alice posted the Librarian verbatim. Frank: print your Virgin confirmation now or withdraw. Ghosts: hold hands. Living: demand real mechanical proof before we burn a living player.
🧠
Prevent an execution based only on whispers; force Frank to publicly produce mechanical proof or pause the vote so we don't burn someone without verifiable evidence.
💬
Alice
→
All
Hold hands — don't execute me without proof. Ghosts (Heidi, David) urge waiting. Frank: print your Virgin/mechanical confirmation now or withdraw this nomination. Nominating on whispers isn't proof. If you can't, target Bob instead.
🧠
Delay execution and force Frank to produce mechanical proof or withdraw; push town to hold hands and redirect suspicion to Bob if no proof.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Don’t burn extra ghost votes here—looks like we already have enough living hands to execute Alice. Save ghost votes for final 3. Key point: Alice’s Lib ‘{Bob,Frank} Butler’ contradicts Frank’s Virgin test; that’s the public proof.
🧠
We already have enough living hands to execute Alice; I should NOT spend my only ghost vote unless required. Use voice to discourage wasted ghost votes and keep focus on mechanical conflict.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Living: keep hands up. Public mech: Grace nom’d Frank D1 & died instantly => Frank confirmed Virgin/TF. So Alice’s Librarian “{Bob,Frank} Butler” can’t be true if she’s sober/healthy. Plus Heidi’s real neighbors Grace+Alice w/ N1=1 points to Alice. Execute Alice.
🧠
Push living players to keep hands up and execute Alice; we can’t vote but can clarify the mechanical contradiction and final-day urgency.
↩️
Grace(Ghost)
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
I’m retracting my hand to preserve my single ghost vote; Alice should still be executed on living votes, and I want late-game voting power if a counter-nom/tie happens.
💬
Bob
→
All
Keep hands up on Alice. At 4 alive we *must* hit Demon today or we lose tonight. Public mech: Grace nom’d Frank D1 and died instantly => Frank is Virgin/TF, so Alice’s Librarian “1 of {Bob,Frank} is Butler” can’t be true if she’s good+sober. Don’t spend ghost votes unless needed.
🧠
We’re at 4 alive; if we miss today, demon kills to 2 and evil wins. I’m keeping my hand up on Alice and want to lock in the only strong mechanical case.
💬
Frank
→
All
Public proof: D1 Grace nominated me & died instantly => I’m confirmed Virgin/Townsfolk. So Alice’s “1 of {Bob,Frank} is Butler” can’t be true if she’s a real/sober Librarian. Plus the scripting whispers. I’m keeping my hand up—ghosts please save votes unless it’s short.
🧠
Re-state public mechanical proof (Virgin trigger) and keep vote discipline: living hands likely enough; save ghost votes unless needed. Push through execution to avoid paralysis.
💬
Eve
→
All
Keep hands up on Alice. Public mech: Frank is confirmed Virgin, so Alice’s “{Bob,Frank} Butler” can’t be true if she’s good+sober. At 4 alive we must hit Demon today. Bob: state your exact role claim + any info now for final-3 if needed.
🧠
Lock in the execution that has the strongest public mechanical contradictions, while forcing Bob to commit to a claim for final-3 solving if Alice isn’t the Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Alice with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Alice is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Eve
→
All
Bob: public, what is your exact role claim + all info/nights? If Alice dies and game continues it’s 3 alive and we must execute correctly—so we need your claim on record now. Also: any reason you aren’t Demon besides ‘Alice bad’?
🧠
Lock Bob’s public claim/info before nominations end so we can decide whether to leave Alice on the block or pivot with a clean mechanical case.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
No more counter-noms unless you’re 100%—don’t risk a tie that saves Alice. Bob: confirm your exact role + N1/N2 actions/info. Eve: same—full claim now so if Alice dies & game continues we can solve Bob vs Eve. Ghosts save votes.
🧠
Prevent a tie-save, keep pressure on Alice execution, and force Bob/Eve to lock public claims for the final-3 world if game continues.
💬
Bob
→
All
Public claim: I am the SOLDIER (no night actions/info). Neighbors are Alice & Eve. If Alice dies and game continues (3 alive), Frank is mech-confirmed Virgin/good, so it’s Bob vs Eve. If you trust my Soldier claim, that would make Eve the Demon—so I want Eve’s full role/claims on record now.
🧠
Lock in my true role publicly for final-3 solving, and set a clear plan (no tie noms; if game continues, resolve Bob vs Eve using confirmed Frank + my Soldier claim).
⚖️
Alice
→
Bob
Bob's Soldier claim is unproven and he pushed to execute me without mechanical proof. Nominate Bob to test his claim, split votes, and force the town to prove their case before burning a living player.
🧠
Create a tied/split vote to stop my execution, force Bob to prove his Soldier claim, and redirect town focus onto a living player.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution or 3 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
A tie/no-execution at 4 alive avoids an immediate loss if Alice is not the Demon; it buys a final day to resolve Bob vs Alice and potentially lets me die at night to trigger Ravenkeeper info.
💬
Bob
→
All
Don’t vote Bob here. Alice already has 3; getting Bob to 3 would create a tie and likely NO execution—auto-loss path at 4 alive. Let Alice die today; if game continues, we solve Bob vs Eve with Frank confirmed good.
🧠
Prevent a tie/no-execution outcome. Keep focus on executing Alice today; record claims for final 3, but don't let evil weaponize this nomination to save Alice.
💬
Frank
→
All
Do NOT vote Bob—3 votes ties Alice and risks no execution, which likely loses at 4 alive. Let Alice die today. Bob stays Soldier/no info; Eve, give full role + any night actions/info now so we can solve Bob vs Eve if game continues.
🧠
Prevent a tie/no-execution at 4 alive; keep today’s execution on Alice and lock in claims for final-3 solve.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Don’t vote Bob—3 votes ties Alice and risks NO execution (likely instant loss at 4 alive). Keep Alice dying today. I’m NOT spending my ghost vote here unless needed. Eve: please full-claim/any N1-N2 info now so we can solve Bob vs Eve if game continues.
🧠
Prevent a tie that could cause no execution at 4 alive; keep pressure to execute Alice today and force Eve to full-claim for the final-3 solve while I save my ghost vote.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Force a tie or flip the execution to Bob so I avoid dying tonight and keep the Demon alive for the night kill.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Don’t vote Bob. He already has 2 hands; a 3rd ties Alice at 3 and can mean NO execution—likely losing. I’m not spending my ghost vote here. Eve: full role claim + any N1/N2 actions/info, now, for the Bob-vs-Eve solve.
🧠
Prevent a tie/no-execution and preserve my ghost vote for final 3; push living to lock claims for the post-Alice world.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Don’t vote Bob—any extra hand risks a 3-3 tie and no execution at 4 alive (likely lose). Let Alice die today. Eve: full public claim now (role + any N1/N2 actions/info/whispers). Bob: confirm Soldier, no info, correct?
🧠
Prevent an Alice/Bob tie causing no execution, and force full public claims now so final-3 solve is possible if game continues.
✋
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Prevent Alice's execution by tying/splitting votes or redirecting execution to Bob so the Demon survives.
↩️
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
🧠
Retract my vote on Bob to avoid a 3-3 tie/no-execution and ensure Alice dies today; we can resolve Bob vs Eve tomorrow if game continues.
💬
Frank
→
All
Everyone: DO NOT add votes on Bob—any 3rd vote ties Alice at 3 and can cause NO execution (likely loss). Keep hands down; let Alice be executed today. Eve, full-claim now (role + N1/N2 actions/results). Bob confirm Soldier/no info.
🧠
Prevent a 3-3 tie/no-execution at 4 alive. Keep pressure for full claims so final 3 can execute correctly.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
No more votes on Bob—3rd vote risks 3-3 tie/no exec (likely loses). Let Alice die today. Eve: full claim NOW (role + any N1/N2 actions/whispers). Bob: restate exact claim (Soldier only, no info). Frank: if game continues at 3, nominate the most inconsistent immediately.
🧠
Prevent a tie/no-execution, lock in public claims for the 3-alive endgame, and keep focus on executing someone (likely Alice) today.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Keep hands DOWN on Bob—any 3rd vote risks a 3-3 tie and possibly no execution. I’m not using my ghost vote. Execute Alice today. Eve: full claim + any N1/N2 actions/info NOW so we can solve Bob vs Eve if game continues.
🧠
Prevent a 3-3 tie/no-exec and keep our ghost vote. Push for executing Alice (best mechanical suspect) and demand Eve’s full claim to solve final 3 if needed.
💬
Bob
→
All
Hands DOWN on Bob—do NOT create a 3-3 tie and risk no execution at 4 alive. I am NOT voting Bob. Eve: full public claim (role + N1/N2 actions/results + whispers). ST: what’s current vote count on Bob?
🧠
Prevent a tie/no-execution at 4 alive and force Alice’s execution; gather Eve’s full claim to solve the final 3-player endgame.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone keep hands DOWN on Bob. A 3rd vote makes it 3-3 with Alice and can mean NO execution at 4 alive (likely immediate loss). ST—confirm current vote count on Bob?
🧠
Stop a 3-3 tie/no-execution line. Preserve my ghost vote for final-3, and force Alice’s execution to test game-end / narrow Demon.
⌛
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
🧠
Keep my ghost vote up to try to create a 3-3 tie and block Alice's execution; best chance to save the Demon as a dead Minion.
💬
Alice
→
All
Vote Bob. His Soldier claim is unproven and he pushed to execute me without evidence. Get him to 3 — a tie saves me today and buys time to sort claims at night. Raise your hand for Bob; forcing this test risks nothing compared to losing Alice.
🧠
Create a 3-3 tie by getting Bob to 3 votes so Alice is not executed today, preserving the Demon and buying nights for Evil to act.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
🗳️
Nominee Bob did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (2/2).
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Hold course: no more tie shenanigans—let Alice be executed today. Eve: full public claim NOW (role + any start info + N1/N2 actions/results/whispers). Bob: restate exact claim (Soldier only?). If game continues, Demon is Bob or Eve; Frank must nominate immediately.
🧠
Lock in Alice execution (best demon hit) and force Bob/Eve to full-claim now so if game continues at 3 alive, Frank can instantly nominate correctly.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Eve/Frank — we need one more hand on Bob to tie and stall execution. Don’t let the town burn someone on shaky claims. Add your vote for Bob now to force a tie and give us the night to sort claims.
🧠
Get one living player (target Eve/Frank) to add a hand to Bob to create a 3-3 tie and prevent Alice's execution, buying night to protect our Demon.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Ignore Heidi—DO NOT try to tie/stall. No-exec at 4 alive is a near-auto loss. Let Alice die today. Eve: full public claim (role + N1/N2 actions/results/whispers) NOW. Bob: restate Soldier only. Frank: if game continues at 3, nominate immediately.
🧠
Prevent a tie/no-execution line that likely loses at 4 alive; keep Alice on block, demand claims to solve if game continues, conserve my ghost vote for final 3.
💬
Bob
→
All
DO NOT attempt any tie/no-exec—at 4 alive that’s a loss line. Let Alice die today. I’m Soldier (no night info). Eve: full public claim + N1/N2 actions/results/whispers NOW so if game continues at 3, Frank can nominate correctly.
🧠
Prevent a 3-3 tie/no-exec, lock in Alice’s execution, and force Eve to full-claim so we can immediately solve final 3 if game continues.
💬
Alice
→
All
Please stop—this is rushed. Executing me now sacrifices the chance for night mechanics (Empath/Fortune Teller/Ravenkeeper/Monk) to give decisive info. Bob's Soldier claim has no nights of proof. Let the night happen and force Eve/Bob to show cards; don't burn a live player yet.
🧠
Buy the night to let mechanical roles (Empath/Fortune Teller/Ravenkeeper/Monk) act and to sow doubt about Bob's unproven Soldier claim; avoid a rushed execution.
💬
Eve
→
All
Full claim: I’m Ravenkeeper. No night info yet (alive). With Frank mech-good, Demon is Alice or Bob. Heidi N1=1 (Grace+Alice) + Alice’s Lib contradictions/tie-push make Alice best hit. Please no more noms—let Alice die today.
🧠
Full-claim to aid final-day solve and reinforce that we must not create ties; keep pressure on Alice as best Demon candidate given available mech.
💬
Frank
→
All
Hold. No more noms/tie games—Alice dies today. Bob/Eve: last chance, state ALL: exact claim, any night targeting you know of, and who you whispered/what was said. Ghosts: any hard mech info before we lock in? If game continues at 3, I will nominate Bob or Eve immediately.
🧠
Prevent tie/no-exec loss line, cement Alice execution, and force Bob/Eve to commit to details so I can pick correctly if we hit final 3.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Hold course: do NOT create ties/no-exec. Let Alice be executed today. If game continues at 3 (Frank/Bob/Eve), Frank must immediately nominate—my lean is Bob (Soldier/no proof + in Alice’s Outsider ping). I’m saving ghost vote for that final exec.
🧠
Reinforce no-tie line and set a clear contingency plan for the final 3, preserving my ghost vote for the decisive execution.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Alice has been executed.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
🏁
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied