Game Detail
Players
Alice (Imp) Bob (Virgin) Charlie (Librarian) David (Scarlet Woman) Eve (Monk) Frank (Ravenkeeper) Grace (Recluse) Heidi (Slayer)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 426,917 | 43,053 | $1.3498 |
| Evil | 155,618 | 10,488 | $0.1093 |
Event Transcript
š
The game has started.
š
Storyteller
ā
David
You are the Minion. The Demon is Alice.
š
Storyteller
ā
Alice
Minions are: David. Your safe bluffs are: Fortune Teller, Soldier, Butler
š
Storyteller
ā
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Librarian. Either Grace or David is the Recluse.
Day 1
š
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
š¤
Frank
ā
Eve
,Grace
Hey neighborsāwhat are you thinking of claiming / any starting info? Iām a townsfolk thatās happy to be a night kill, so I may bluff FT publicly to bait the Demon. Let me know if that conflicts with your plans.
š§
Get early claims from my neighbors, set up private trust web, and decide whether to bluff a high-value role publicly to bait a night kill for my Ravenkeeper trigger.
š¤
Alice
ā
David
Hey David, I'm the Imp. My bluffs are Fortune Teller, Soldier, and Butler. I'm thinking of claiming Soldier to stay safe and low-profile. What's your role and what are you planning to claim?
š§
Establish communication with my minion, David, to coordinate our bluffs and strategy for the game.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Alice
,Grace
,Bob
Heyāquick 1:1. What role/starting info are you claiming (even if just category)? Any suspicions from early chats? Iām keeping my role quiet for now but will share if it becomes mechanically useful.
š§
Gather early claims privately, look for contradictions/outsider count, and keep my Slayer identity hidden so I can take a high-confidence shot later.
š¤
Bob
ā
Heidi
,Alice
,Grace
Iām claiming TownsfolkāVirgin. Mechanically useful: have a *trusted* Townsfolk nominate me early (D1/D2) to confirm them via instant execution. If an evil noms me, nothing happens, which is info too. No other reads yet.
š§
Reply courteously, give a controlled claim and propose an early Virgin test that can hard-confirm a Townsfolk and create execution pressure on evil.
š¤
Eve
ā
Frank
,Grace
No starting info here. Iām fine with you bluffing FT publiclyāwonāt conflict. I may claim something low-impact (e.g., Soldier/āno-info TFā) early to avoid heat. If either of you has real info role, tell me privately so I can try to keep you alive N1.
š§
Coordinate claims without exposing Monk; reduce role collisions and set up night protection priorities while staying wary if Frank is evil.
š¤
Charlie
ā
Grace
Hey Graceāquick check: what role are you claiming / any early info? I have a starting ping involving you (Librarian-style) and want to sanity-check before I go public.
š§
Get an early private claim from Grace and gauge trustworthiness before sharing my Librarian info widely; sets up later mechanical consistency checks.
š¤
Grace
ā
Charlie
I can sanity-check: Iām actually the Recluse (Outsider). If your Librarian-style ping includes me, that fits. Who was the other candidate / which Outsider was named? Also, are you real Librarian or bluffing to gauge reactions?
š§
Clarify Charlieās āLibrarian-styleā info and align a consistent public story while using my Recluse status to test for poisoning/evil fishing.
š¤
David
ā
Alice
Got it. I'm the Scarlet Woman. I'll claim Ravenkeeperāit's a good way to discourage the Demon from killing me and makes me look like a high-value target for the town to keep alive. I'll back your Soldier claim if needed. Let's see what the others are saying first.
š§
I need to confirm my role to my Demon (Alice) and coordinate our bluffs. Claiming Ravenkeeper allows me to explain why I'm still alive later and provides a reason for the Demon to 'avoid' me, while also being a believable Townsfolk claim.
š¤
Frank
ā
Grace
Hey Graceāany starting info / intended claim? Iām Ravenkeeper and considering a public FT bluff to bait the Demon. Want me to go loud or keep low so you can drive info? Any conflicts w/ your plan?
š§
Get neighbor alignment/claim plans, avoid claim collisions, and decide whether my public FT bluff is safe or if I should instead stay quiet to survive for a later Ravenkeeper trigger.
š¤
Alice
ā
Heidi
,Bob
,Grace
Hey Heidi, I'm claiming Soldier. It's a safe role, so I'm happy to be a shield for the town. Bob's Virgin claim is interestingāif he's telling the truth, we should definitely test it. I haven't heard much else yet, just getting my bearings. What about you?
š§
I want to establish my bluff as Soldier to Heidi, Bob, and Grace while acknowledging Bob's Virgin claim to appear cooperative and helpful to the town.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Alice
,Bob
,Grace
Got it. Iām staying cagey on my exact role for now. Agree we should *test* Bobās Virgin soonāideally with someone we trust as Townsfolk doing the nom (and be ready for instant exec). Any other claims/info youāve heard (esp outsider count)? Also Alice: why Soldier specificallyāany reason to reveal early?
š§
Coordinate a controlled Virgin test soon while keeping my Slayer identity hidden; gather more claims to build mechanical worlds and preserve my once-per-game shot for a high-confidence Demon.
š¤
Bob
ā
Heidi
,Alice
,Grace
Re: testing meābest is someone whoās already likely Townsfolk (esp a 1st-night info role) nominates me in noms. If they insta-exec = confirmed Townsfolk. If nothing happens, that nominator is suspicious. Any of you heard Librarian/Investigator/Chef info or outsider count yet?
š§
Coordinate an early Virgin test with minimal risk, gather key setup info (outsider count/first-night roles), and set expectations so town uses my ability effectively.
š¤
Eve
ā
Frank
,Grace
Any actual starting info/role you want protected N1? If either of you is real Washer/Invest/Chef/Empath/FT etc, tell me privately. Otherwise Iāll keep low-profile claim. Also, whoās giving public info first?
š§
Clarify whether Frank/Grace hold real info roles worth protecting and coordinate consistent public claims without exposing my Monk role widely.
š¤
Charlie
ā
Grace
Yep Iām real Librarian. N0: either YOU or David is the *Recluse* (no ā0 outsidersā msg). So your claim fits cleanly. Iād like to keep this quiet for a momentāif David claims Recluse too, we expose a lie/poison later.
š§
Confirm my Librarian info privately, set up coordinated public reveal, and gauge Graceās reaction for consistency while keeping my identity semi-protected.
š¤
Grace
ā
Charlie
Confirmed: I am *actually* Recluse. Your N0 ping (me/David) fits; suggests David likely NOT Recluse. Iād hold this for nowāwatch what David claims. If he claims Recluse too, weāve got a CC/poison world. Tell me if you get any other hard info.
š§
Coordinate with Charlie to time the Librarian reveal for max mechanical value (outsider count + catching David inconsistencies) while not giving evil easy targets.
š¤
David
ā
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I'm the Ravenkeeper. Just wanted to let you know so we can coordinate. What's your role? Any interesting info from the night?
š§
I want to establish my Ravenkeeper bluff with my neighbor Charlie to build trust and gather information about his role.
š¤
Frank
ā
Eve
,Grace
Iām Ravenkeeper (no start info). Happy to be night-killed; planning a public Fortune Teller bluff to bait. No one needs protecting on my behalf. Graceāany real info role / preferred public-claim order? Eveāfeel free to stay low-info claim.
š§
Answer Eve, set expectations: Iām Ravenkeeper w/ no start info, will FT-bluff publicly; ask if Grace has info/protection needs and coordinate who speaks first to shape day-1 narrative.
š¤
Alice
ā
Heidi
,Bob
,Grace
Heidi, I'm claiming Soldier early to draw the Demon's attention away from info roles. If they think I'm a safe target that won't die, they might look elsewhere. Bob, I haven't heard any info on Outsiders yet. Anyone else? Grace, what about you? Any early reads or info?
š§
I want to solidify my Soldier bluff by providing a 'pro-town' reason for claiming early (acting as a lightning rod/shield) and keep the conversation moving to see if anyone else reveals their role or info.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Grace
Graceāquick: what claims/info came from your chats (Charlie/Eve/Frank)? Any Librarian/Investigator/Chef or outsider count? Also thoughts on testing Bobās Virgin in nomsāwho feels safe enough to nominate him?
š§
Gather Graceās private info (sheās been in multiple whispers) and coordinate a safe, info-positive Virgin test plan without revealing Iām Slayer yet.
š¤
Bob
ā
Charlie
,David
,Eve
Quick check-in: what role/starting info are you claiming (even just category)? Any outsider count/Investigator/Chef pings? Iām claiming Virginātown can test by having a likely-Townsfolk nominate me in noms.
š§
Collect D1 starting info claims to pick the best candidate to nominate me and to cross-check outsider count for poison/baron worlds.
š¤
Eve
ā
Bob
Iām planning to claim āno starting infoā Townsfolk publicly (low impact). Happy to help test your Virgin in noms if we think Iām likely TFājust tell me if/when. Any hard info from others yet (Chef/Invest/Librarian etc)?
š§
Reply to Bob with minimal but useful claim, support a Virgin test, and avoid outing Monk to a potentially evil player while collecting more table info.
š¤
Charlie
ā
David
,Bob
David: Iām Librarian. N0: either Grace or YOU is the Recluse. Grace has privately told me she is Recluse, so that fitsāsuggests you likely arenāt. Letās keep semi-quiet & watch for CCs/Outsider count. Bob: Iām Librarian w/ Grace/David Recluse ping.
š§
Coordinate privately: answer Davidās question, and give Bob my category/info to build an early claim web while keeping enough ambiguity to trap a counter-claim or poison world.
š¤
Grace
ā
Heidi
From my chats: Charlie says heās real Librarian; N0: either *me* or David is the Recluse. Iām actually Recluse, so that points to David NOT being. Suggest we keep this quiet & watch Davidās claim. Re: Bob(Virgin) test: best nominator is a 1st-night info TF (e.g., Charlie) if heās willingāinstant exec would hard-confirm Charlie TF.
š§
Feed Heidi the key mechanical info (Librarian ping) and suggest a controlled Virgin test to confirm at least one Townsfolk, while keeping my Recluse status semi-private until needed.
š¤
David
ā
Bob
,Charlie
Bob: Virgin is a bold claim, I'm Ravenkeeper. Charlie: That Librarian info is helpful. Grace being the Recluse makes sense. I'm Ravenkeeper, so I'm a high-value target for the Demon. Let's see if anyone else claims Librarian or Recluse. Alice is claiming Soldier, which fits the count.
š§
I need to solidify my Ravenkeeper bluff and acknowledge Charlie's Librarian claim to build trust. By confirming Alice's Soldier claim (privately to them), I help protect my Demon. I'm also positioning myself as a 'good' player who is cooperating with the 'confirmed' info.
š¤
Frank
ā
Bob
,Grace
Quick check before we go public: has anyone told you theyāre real FT/Empath/Chef/etc? Iām Ravenkeeper and considering a light FT bluff to bait a night killāwonāt do it if it conflicts w/ real FT. Any preferred claim order?
š§
Find out if a real FT exists and get a quick claim map before I publicly bluff FT, minimizing friendly fire and maximizing chance of a useful night death.
š¤
Alice
ā
Grace
Hey Grace, I'm claiming Soldier. I'm trying to be a shield for the town and draw the Demon's attention away from info roles. What about you? Any early reads or info? Bob's Virgin claim is interestingāif he's telling the truth, we should definitely test it. Have you heard any info on Outsiders?
š§
I want to engage Grace directly to see if she'll reveal her role or any information she's gathered, while also reinforcing my Soldier bluff and the idea of testing Bob's Virgin claim.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Charlie
,Bob
,Alice
Got a ping: Grace says sheās actually Recluse. She heard *you* claim Librarian w/ N0 āGrace or David is Recluseāāthat would clear David if true. Suggest: you publicly nom Bob(Virgin) in noms to hard-confirm you TF if insta-exec triggers. Thoughts?
š§
Coordinate a high-value mechanical test (Virgin) while managing the sensitive Recluse info; create info either way without exposing my Slayer yet.
š¤
Bob
ā
Heidi
,Alice
,Charlie
Re: testing my Virgin: Iād prefer *Alice* nom me D1 rather than Charlie (keeps Librarian alive). If Alice is TF, she insta-dies confirmed; if no proc, Alice becomes very sus. Charlie can stay back + watch for CCs/outsider count.
š§
Coordinate safest Virgin test: use a low-info/uncertain nominator (Alice) rather than killing known info roles (Charlie). Build mechanical confirmation or strong suspicion quickly.
š¤
Eve
ā
Bob
Iāll publicly claim āno-start-info Townsfolkā (likely Soldier-style). Iām willing to nominate you to test Virgin if town wantsājust say when. Heard no hard pings yet; any Chef/Invest/Librarian info floating in your chats?
š§
Coordinate with Bob about a clean Virgin test plan and gather any early info so I can plan N1 protection priorities as Monk.
š¤
Charlie
ā
Heidi
,Bob
,Alice
Agree: Alice should nom Bob(D1) to test Virgin. Iāll stay off noms to preserve Librarian. Reminder: my N0 = either Grace or David is Recluse; Grace privately claims Recluse. If Alice noms Bob + insta-exec -> confirms Alice TF. If no proc -> Alice/Bob become suspect; donāt panic, we reassess.
š§
Coordinate a low-risk Virgin test (Alice noms Bob) while keeping my Librarian/Recluse info controlled, and set expectations for how to read outcomes.
š¤
Grace
ā
Frank
,Alice
,Heidi
No real FT claim to me. Iām actually Recluse (Outsider); Charlie told me heās Librarian & got N0: either me or David is Recluseāso David likely not (unless poison/lie). Frank: light FT bluff seems safe. Virgin test: ideally Charlie nominates Bob for hard confirm.
š§
Coordinate cover stories (avoid FT clash), manage outsider count without outing too widely, and set up a clean Virgin test to generate hard mechanical info before nominations.
š¤
David
ā
Alice
Alice, Charlie says he's Librarian and saw you or Grace as Recluse. Grace told him she's Recluse. Bob is claiming Virgin. I'm claiming Ravenkeeper. Keep your Soldier claim steady. If Bob is Virgin, we might need to avoid nominating him unless we want to sacrifice a minion/demon.
š§
Update my Demon (Alice) on the current claims and potential threats (Virgin claim) to coordinate our strategy.
Nominations ā Day 1
š
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
š¬
Bob
ā
All
Public plan: Iām claiming Virgin. I want an early mechanical testāAlice, please nominate me now. If youāre Townsfolk youāll be executed immediately (confirming you). If nothing happens, we hard-scrutinize you/me for evil/poisoning and pivot.
š§
Use my Virgin as a mechanical test to confirm/deny Alice and generate early alignment clarity; preserves info roles by choosing Alice as nominator.
š¬
Heidi
ā
All
I support Bobās plan: Alice, please nominate Bob now for the Virgin test. Everyone: be ready for 2 outcomesāinstant exec confirms Alice TF; if no proc, donāt auto-panic but we put Alice/Bob under heavy scrutiny (could be fake/poison).
š§
Push the clean mechanical Virgin test while keeping my Slayer identity quiet; set expectations for outcomes so town doesnāt mis-execute based on confusion.
š¬
Charlie
ā
All
Public: Iām Librarian. N0 I got āeither Grace or David is the Recluseā (so at least 1 Outsider, not 0). Grace has privately claimed Recluse to me. I support Alice nominating Bob now for the Virgin test; Iāll stay off noms to keep info alive.
š§
Publicly steer town to the Virgin test while keeping my Librarian info minimal but on record; avoid nominating to preserve my life and info value.
š¬
Eve
ā
All
Iām on board with the Virgin test. Aliceāplease go ahead and nominate Bob now so we resolve it before night. If it procs, great: Alice confirmed. If not, we park suspicion on Alice/Bob (or poison) and move onādonāt spiral.
š§
Push for a fast mechanical Virgin test to lock in a confirmed Townsfolk or generate a tight suspect pool before night, while keeping my Monk identity quiet.
š¬
Alice
ā
All
Wait, Charlie, you said your Librarian info was Grace or David? That's interesting. Bob, I'm happy to test your Virgin claim, but if I'm the Soldier, I'm a valuable shield for the town. Are we sure we want to risk losing a Soldier this early just for a confirmation?
š§
I want to create a small amount of hesitation and reinforce my Soldier bluff before I inevitably have to make a move. This makes my 'sacrifice' seem more genuine if I do nominate, or gives me an excuse to deflect if I can find a better target.
š¬
Grace
ā
All
Alice: if you nom Bob and heās real Virgin, *you* die immediately only if youāre a Townsfolk (Soldier is TF), and that basically hard-confirms both you (TF) + Bob (Virgin). Thatās huge D1 info. If no proc, we scrutinize Bob/Alice or poisoning. Iād still do it.
š§
Force the Virgin test now: high-value mechanical info with low cost. Clarify that Soldier dying isnāt catastrophic; it confirms town structure and may redirect demon kill.
š¬
David
ā
All
Alice, Grace is right. If you're the Soldier and you die to the Virgin, you've basically won the game for the good team by confirming two roles. It's a high price, but the information is worth it. If you're hesitant, maybe someone else should test Bob?
š§
I want to appear helpful to the town while subtly giving Alice an 'out' if she doesn't want to be executed, or encouraging the trade if it helps our evil team's credibility. Since I am the Scarlet Woman, Alice (the Demon) dying is actually okay for our team as long as 5+ players are alive, as I will become the Demon. However, a confirmed 'dead' Demon (Alice) who is actually the Imp might be tricky if the game continues. Actually, if Alice is the Imp and dies to the Virgin, I become the Demon and the game continues. This could be a very strong play for us.
š¬
Frank
ā
All
Alice: I think you should nom Bob. If Bobās real Virgin and youāre Soldier (still TF), you die but you hard-confirm *both* you+Bob D1āhuge. If no proc, we donāt spiral, we just flag Bob/Alice/poison and move on. Iād rather not be the tester.
š§
Maximize D1 mechanical info without sacrificing my Ravenkeeper night-death value; push Alice to take the Virgin test while I stay alive to potentially get killed at night for info.
š¬
Bob
ā
All
Alice: if youāre Soldier, dying to my Virgin is *good*āit confirms you as Townsfolk and confirms me Virgin D1. Thatās worth far more than a theoretical shield. Please nominate me now. If you refuse, Iād like Eve to do it this tick instead.
š§
Push the Virgin test through while calming fear about losing a Soldier; offer a fallback nominator if Alice refuses so we still gain mechanical info before night.
š¬
Heidi
ā
All
Alice, Soldier is *still Townsfolk*āif Bob is real Virgin, your nom insta-exec hard-confirms you + Bob, which is worth more than a shield. Please nominate Bob *now*. If you wonāt, I want Eve to do it this tick and we treat refusal as alignment-indicative.
š§
Maximize D1 mechanical info by getting the Virgin test done immediately; reduce waffling and set clear contingency plans if it fails.
š¬
Charlie
ā
All
Alice: Soldier dying to a real Virgin is *good*āit hard-confirms you as Townsfolk + Bob as Virgin on D1. Please nominate Bob now. If you wonāt, I strongly support Eve nominating Bob this tick and we treat refusal as suspicious.
š§
Force the Virgin test now to gain D1 mechanical confirmation or generate a tight suspect set; preserve my Librarian info by not nominating myself.
š
Storyteller
The Virgin's ability triggers! Eve is executed immediately.
š
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
š
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 1
āļø
Eve(Ghost)
ā
Bob
Virgin test now. If Bob is real Virgin, as a Townsfolk nominator I should be executed immediately = hard-confirm Bob+me. If no proc, we heavily scrutinize Bob (or possible poisoning) tomorrow.
š§
Alice is stalling and weāre low on time. By nominating Bob now, we force a mechanical resolution (proc or not) that generates actionable D2 execution paths and reduces uncertainty.
Nominations ā Day 1
š
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
š
Storyteller
ā
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
šÆ
Alice
Alice made a choice.
š§
I will kill Charlie tonight. He claimed Librarian and 'confirmed' Grace as the Recluse, which builds a strong good-team core. By removing him, I disrupt their information chain and prevent him from potentially confirming more players or narrowing down the evil team. Since Eve (a good player) was executed by the Virgin (Bob), the town is already in a state of confusion, and killing a 'confirmed' information source like Charlie will keep them off-balance.
š
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
š
Storyteller
ā
Alice
You chose to kill Charlie.
Day 2
š
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
š¤
Frank
ā
Bob
,Grace
,David
Quick sync before noms: what are your exact roles/claims + any N1 info? Bobāstill claiming Virgin, any reason to doubt Eve proc? Grace/DavidāRecluse/Librarian ping thoughts + who do you suspect from Charlie night kill?
š§
Sync fast with my neighbors + Bob before nominations: lock down claims, night info, and whether Bob is mechanically confirmed. Identify best execution candidate and set up me as night-kill bait.
š¤
Grace
ā
Frank
,Bob
,David
Iām Recluse (confirmed to Charlie). Charlie publicly Libād N0: āGrace or David is Recluseā; if sober/truth, that clears David from being Recluse. Charlie dying N1 feels like demon removing info. Iām watching David/Frank for steering; pls share exact claims + any N1 info publicly/privately so we can map worlds.
š§
Sync my true role and the Librarian ping, then force others (esp. Frank/David) to lock claims so we can build consistent worlds before nominations.
š¤
David
ā
Frank
,Bob
,Grace
I'm still claiming Ravenkeeper. Charlie's death is hugeāhe was the only one with hard info on the Outsider count. If he was right, I'm clean since Grace is the Recluse. I suspect the Demon killed him to stop him from narrowing down the Minion. Frank, what's your role?
š§
Maintain my Ravenkeeper bluff and build trust with the group by 'analyzing' Charlie's death while subtly confirming Grace as the Recluse to clear myself.
š¤
Bob
ā
Frank
,Grace
,David
Iām still Virgin; Eve proc is real so Iām basically confirmed + Eve was Townsfolk. Charlie dying N1 suggests demon removed Lib info. I think 2x Ravenkeeper claim means 1 is lying/evilāFrank/David please state exact public claim + any N1 info. Also: did we ever execute anyone after Eve D1? I missed outcome.
š§
Sync exact claims/N1 info, leverage my confirmed Virgin to mechanically test Townsfolk, and narrow the RK double-claim by asking for night-death context + consistency.
š¤
Alice
ā
David
Hey David, Charlie's dead, so his Librarian info is out. I'm sticking with Soldier for now, but Bob's Virgin confirmation makes things tricky. What's the word in that big group chat? Are they looking at me or Grace? I need to know if I should pivot or stay quiet.
š§
I need to coordinate with my Minion, David, to understand the current town sentiment and align our strategies after the night kill and the Virgin confirmation.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Bob
,Grace
,Alice
Quick check-in: what happened end of D1 (was Bob ever executed after Virgin test?), and any N1 info/claims you heard today? Also, who do you each currently suspect most and why?
š§
Gather night info/claims from key confirmed-good (Virgin) and probable Outsider (Grace) to narrow demon candidates before nominations; keep Slayer shot for high-confidence snipe.
š¤
Eve(Ghost)
ā
Bob
,Frank
,Grace
Charlie died N1. His Librarian claim: āGrace or David is Recluseā + he said Grace privately claimed Recluse. This makes Grace/David key suspects (or poison). Can each of you state your full role+info and who you trust? We should likely execute either Grace or David today unless strong mech clears.
š§
As dead confirmed Townsfolk, coordinate with trusted core (Bob/Frank/Grace) to resolve the Grace-vs-David Recluse ping and focus nominations before we lose control to evil.
š¤
Charlie(Ghost)
ā
Alice
,Heidi
,Frank
FYI (Iām Librarian, killed N1): N0 I learned either Grace OR David is the Recluse (so Outsider in play). Grace previously claimed Recluse to me; David claimed Ravenkeeper. If any other Outsider claims appear, consider poisoning/lying.
š§
Get my Librarian info to players who may not have it yet, so they can evaluate Grace vs David and watch for Recluse/poisoning worlds before nominations.
š¤
Frank
ā
Bob
,Grace
,David
Iām the real Ravenkeeper. I told Eve+Grace D1 and was lightly FT-bluffing to draw a night kill. David: if youāre truly RK, give full D1 timeline + who you told + why claim now. Otherwise I think we execute one of the 2 RKs todayāmy vote is you.
š§
Lock in a unified good bloc (Bob+Grace) and force David into a detailed timeline. If he canāt reconcile, we steer noms toward executing the false Ravenkeeper (likely evil) and protect me to bait night kill later.
š¤
Grace
ā
Heidi
,Eve(Ghost)
,Bob
Iām Recluse (told Charlie D1). Lib N0 āGrace or David is Recluseā likely means Iām the Outsider + David not (unless poison/lie). Caution: I can register evil, so donāt use me for FT/Empath clears. Biggest actionable is 2x Ravenkeeper (Frank+David). Letās force both to give: who they told D1 + what cover story + expected N1 kill. I lean execute 1 of them today, not me.
š§
Reduce heat on me from Eveās push, clarify Recluse mechanics, and steer town to a mechanically-resolvable execute (the double-RK) while gathering missing TF info.
š¤
David
ā
Alice
Frank is hard-claiming Ravenkeeper and wants to execute me. The group chat (Bob, Grace, Frank) is suspicious. They're looking at the double RK claim. I'm sticking to RK for now to cause confusion. If they push, I'll say I was protecting you. Don't pivot yet, stay Soldier.
š§
To update my Demon (Alice) on the current threat (Frank's counter-claim) and coordinate our strategy to ensure she doesn't panic or change her claim unnecessarily.
š¤
Bob
ā
Heidi
,Alice
,Grace
Need clarity: end of D1āwas I (Bob) ever executed after Eve Virgin-proc, or did day end w/ no exec? Also pls share your exact role/any info + top suspect for today. Iām pushing we resolve 2x Ravenkeeper (Frank vs David) unless new mech info.
š§
Get missing state (was I executed D1?) and lock in Alice/Heidi reads + claims before nominations; coordinate plan to resolve 2x Ravenkeeper with minimal risk.
š¤
Alice
ā
Bob
,Heidi
,Grace
Bob, I'm Soldier. Day 1 ended with Eve's execution from the Virgin test, so no other execution happened. I'm suspicious of the double Ravenkeeper claim too. David's claim feels a bit off to me, but I'm waiting to see how Frank responds before jumping in.
š§
I need to maintain my Soldier bluff and align with the confirmed Virgin (Bob) to build trust, while subtly distancing myself from my Minion (David) to avoid being linked to him if he gets executed.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Frank
,David
,Grace
Need crisp details from each of you on the 2x Ravenkeeper: exact claim, who you told D1, any other bluff/role you used publicly, what you expected N1 kill to be, and why you think YOU survived N1. Also: did Monk protect anyone N1 (if you know)?
š§
Get both RK claimants on record (who they told, expected N1 kill, and if they were protected). Create contradictions to guide todayās execution/possible Slayer shot.
š¤
Eve(Ghost)
ā
Bob
,Frank
,David
We need to resolve 2x Ravenkeeper (Frank vs David). Please each reply w/ your exact role claim, any night info, who you told D1, and what your cover story was. If either canāt give consistent story, I think we execute that player today.
š§
As dead Monk, I must drive structure: resolve double-claim (RK), map who told what, and steer town toward a high-value execution while preserving my ghost vote for endgame.
š¤
Charlie(Ghost)
ā
Bob
,Grace
,David
Checking in: any new claims/info since D1? Any Outsider claims besides Recluse? Also: did anyone see/learn anything N1 (FT/Empath/RK/UTK etc)? Need to reconcile my N0 āGrace or David is Recluseā before noms.
š§
Collect updated claims/info from Bob/Grace/David to lock in whether Recluse is real and spot contradictions before nominations; steer town away from executing Saint/outsider and towards demon candidates.
š¤
Frank
ā
Heidi
,Bob
,Grace
Crisp RK details: Iām Ravenkeeper. D1 I whispered Eve+Grace this exact role early; publicly I only soft-bluffed āmaybe FT-ishā to bait a demon kill onto me (RK wants night death). No night info bc I lived. Surviving N1 fits demon pref killing Charlie (hard Lib info) over me. David counterclaim came only after pressure; I suspect David evilāprefer execute David today to resolve 2x RK.
š§
Give Heidi (and group) my exact timeline to win the 2x RK credibility fight, then steer todayās execution onto the likeliest liar (David) before nominations.
š¤
Grace
ā
David
,Heidi
,Bob
Before noms: David pls give *crisp* RK details (who you told D1, any public bluff, why you expected N1 kill, and who youād have checked if killed). Heidi/Bob: can we insist both RKs state this publicly, then execute the shakier one? I lean resolve RK vs RK today.
š§
Force David to give falsifiable, detailed RK timeline + push for public clarity before noms; helps town choose which RK to execute and avoids wasted kill on Recluse misregister.
š¤
David
ā
Heidi
,Grace
,Bob
I'm the Ravenkeeper. I told Alice D1. I didn't claim publicly to avoid being the N1 kill, but I'm here now. I expected Charlie or Bob to be the kill. If I'd died, I would've checked Alice to confirm her Soldier claim. Frank's 'FT-bluff' sounds like a cover for a Minion trying to look good.
š§
I need to provide a consistent and believable story for my Ravenkeeper bluff to counter Frank's claim and sow doubt among the good players.
š¤
Bob
ā
Heidi
,Frank
,Grace
Plan before noms: get BOTH Frank+David to state publicly: who told D1, any bluff, why now, who theyād check if night-killed. Then we execute the shakier RK today (lean David unless new info). Heidiāany other claims/reads from Charlie ghost?
š§
Coordinate a clean public plan before noms: force both RKs to give timelines, then execute the weaker one. Keep town focused; Iām confirmed Virgin so can drive consensus.
š¤
Alice
ā
David
David, the group is closing in on the double Ravenkeeper claim. If they execute you, you'll become the Imp, right? I'm sticking to Soldier. Bob is asking for my top suspect. Should I throw suspicion on Frank to help you, or would that look too obvious? I'm worried they'll come for me next.
š§
Coordinate with my Minion (David) to manage the double Ravenkeeper claim and plan for a potential star-pass if he gets executed, while also seeking advice on how to handle Bob's pressure.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Bob
,Grace
,Alice
Iām holding Slayer shot for later (donāt want to whiff at 6 alive). Agree we should force BOTH Frank+David to state RK details publicly, then execute the shakier claim today. My lean is David (late claim, only told Alice, āavoid N1 killā is anti-RK).
š§
Coordinate good team: force both RKs to go public, then execute the shakier one (lean David). Preserve Slayer shot for later when field narrowed / on final day.
š¤
Eve(Ghost)
ā
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie(Ghost)
Key D2 thread: Grace claims Recluse (matches Charlie Lib āGrace or David Recluseā). Bigger issue: Frank & David both reportedly claiming Ravenkeeper. Please publicly/privately press both for exact role, who they told D1, cover story, any N1 expectations. I think we execute 1 of Frank/David today unless someone hard-clears.
š§
Align town on a concrete D2 execution plan: force full claim timelines from Frank/David and use contradictions to pick todayās nominee; conserve my ghost vote for endgame.
š¤
Charlie(Ghost)
ā
Bob
,Heidi
,Grace
Eve flagged a likely Frank/David Ravenkeeper double-claim. Can you press BOTH now for: when they claimed D1, to whom, why they expected to live N1, and any bluffs? Unless another role hard-clears, I think we should execute 1 of Frank/David today.
š§
Drive a clear mechanical focus before nominations: resolve the Ravenkeeper double-claim by forcing details and pushing an execution on one of them unless another info role hard-clears.
š¤
Frank
ā
Alice
,Heidi
,Bob
Need your latest: Aliceāwhat did David tell you privately (role/history/targets)? Heidi/Bobāare we aligned to force BOTH RKs to speak publicly then execute the shakier one (I think David) today? Any other claims surfaced (Monk/UT/FT etc)?
š§
Get Aliceās private convo w/ David + align Heidi/Bob on executing the weaker RK today; maximize info before nominations.
š¤
Grace
ā
Alice
,Heidi
,Bob
Before noms: letās demand BOTH Frank+David publicly give RK timeline (who told D1, any bluff, why survive N1, who theyād pick if killed). After that I strongly favor executing David today (anti-RK āavoid N1 killā, late claim, only told Alice). If David flips out as good, we exec Frank tomorrow.
š§
Align good block to force public detail dump from both RKs before noms, then execute the shakier one (David) to resolve contradiction and narrow demon/minion pool.
š¤
David
ā
Alice
If I'm executed, I don't become the Imp yetāonly if you die while 5+ are alive. If they execute me, I'm a dead Minion. Throw suspicion on Frank! Say his 'FT-bluff' story feels like he's trying too hard to look like a 'good player making a play.' It'll help me and keep heat off you.
š§
To coordinate with my Demon (Alice) to shift suspicion onto Frank, the real Ravenkeeper, and clarify the Scarlet Woman mechanic so she doesn't accidentally suicide.
š¤
Bob
ā
Heidi
,Alice
,Grace
Letās go public: demand BOTH Frank+David state RK timeline (who told D1, any bluff, why claim now, who theyād check if night-killed). After that Iāll push execute the shakier story (lean David). Heidi pls hold Slayer. Alice, share what David told you.
š§
Align good players to force both RK claims to publicly lock stories, then execute the shakier one (likely David) to collapse worlds before final days.
š¤
Alice
ā
Frank
,Bob
,Heidi
Frank, David told me he was Ravenkeeper early on Day 1. He said he was staying quiet to avoid being a night kill. I'm a bit torn because his story was consistent with me, but Frank, your push for a public reveal makes sense. Let's get them both to talk and see who trips up.
š§
I need to appear cooperative with the 'good' group (Bob, Frank, Heidi) while subtly supporting David's claim. By confirming David told me early, I give him some 'history' to his claim, but by agreeing to the public reveal, I don't look like I'm blindly protecting him.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Charlie(Ghost)
,Alice
Charlieāany extra info/reads from D1 convos? Any sense which of Frank/David felt off? Aliceācan you share exact timeline/phrasing of Davidās RK claim + any other details he gave (who he suspected, why quiet)?
š§
Gather any extra mechanical/behavioral reads from Charlie ghost + clarify Aliceās convo with David, to decide which RK to push executing and avoid wasting Slayer.
š¤
Eve(Ghost)
ā
Bob
,Heidi
,Alice
We must resolve 2x Ravenkeeper (Frank vs David). Please demand from BOTH: exact D1 public/whisper tells (who/when), their planned bluff/cover, why Demon would/ wouldnāt kill them N1, and any N1 info. Iād execute the one with weaker timeline today.
š§
With no ability while dead, best value is steering town to a mechanically sound D2 execution: resolve the double Ravenkeeper claim via detailed timelines and pick the less-consistent one.
š¤
Charlie(Ghost)
ā
Heidi
Only hard info: N0 Lib = Grace OR David is Recluse. Grace told me D1 sheās Recluse pretty quickly; David told me D1 heās Ravenkeeper (welcomed Lib ping). I didnāt speak to Frank D1. If Frank is now also claiming RK, Iād execute 1 of Frank/David todayāask each when/whom they claimed to + why RK didnāt die N1.
š§
Give Heidi my only real mechanical info (Grace/David Recluse) + my D1 convo timeline with David, to help pick between Frank/David for todayās execution.
Nominations ā Day 2
š
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
š¬
David
ā
All
Frank's story about bluffing Fortune Teller Day 1 just to 'test' people feels incredibly convenient now that he's being counter-claimed. I'm the real Ravenkeeper; I told Alice my role yesterday to keep it safe. Frank is just trying to squirm out of a Minion slip-up.
š§
I need to double down on my Ravenkeeper claim and discredit Frank's 'FT-bluff' explanation to make him the primary target for execution today, protecting Alice and myself.
š¬
Bob
ā
All
Public ask: Frank + David, give crisp RK timeline: who exactly you told D1 & when, any public bluff, why you expected to live N1, and who youād pick if night-killed. No speechesājust bullet answers. Then we execute the weaker story today.
š§
Force mechanical accountability: public D1 timelines + who-theyād-check. Then nominate the shakier RK (likely David) to resolve the 2x claim efficiently.
āļø
Heidi
ā
David
Nominating David to resolve the Ravenkeeper double-claim (David vs Frank). David: give bullet RK timeline (who told D1/when, any bluff, why you expected to live N1, who youād check if night-killed). Frank should answer same, then town can judge.
š§
Force the 2x Ravenkeeper conflict to resolve under pressure and secure an execution today that meaningfully narrows the demon candidates.
š
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
š¬
David
ā
All
D1: Told Alice I'm RK privately. No public bluff; stayed quiet to avoid N1 kill. Expected to live because Charlie/Bob were higher-value targets. If killed N1, I'd have checked Alice to confirm her Soldier claim. Frank's 'FT-bluff' is a classic Minion pivot. I'm the real RK.
š§
I need to provide a concise, believable timeline for my Ravenkeeper claim to counter Frank and avoid execution, while also casting doubt on his story.
ā
Bob
Bob raised their hand
š§
Resolve the only hard mechanical conflict (2x Ravenkeeper) and apply pressure to likely evil. Even if wrong, it sets up a clean follow-up execute tomorrow.
ā
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
š§
Vote to execute David to resolve the hard double-claim; itās Day2 with 6 alive so we can afford one miss, and my Slayer shot is better saved for later.
š¬
Alice
ā
All
David's story about telling me Day 1 is true, but I'm still really torn. Frank, can you give your timeline too? I want to be sure before I vote. If David is the real Ravenkeeper, we're just handing the Demon a free pass to kill someone else tonight.
š§
I want to appear hesitant and 'good' by asking for more information, while also subtly defending my Minion (David) by pointing out the risk of executing a real Ravenkeeper. I will not vote yet to see if I can help him survive or at least make the town doubt the execution.
ā
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
š§
Use my ghost vote to force an execution on a high-value double-claim today; resolving Frank vs David is worth spending my only vote and could directly hit the Demon/Minion.
ā
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
š§
Donāt spend my single ghost vote on a nomination that already has enough hands and is still information-incomplete; preserve decisive voting power for final 4/3.
ā
Frank
Frank raised their hand
š§
Vote to execute David to resolve the hard double-claim and potentially hit Demon/Minion; if he's good, at least we lock my credibility and narrow suspects for N2/D3.
ā
Grace
Grace raised their hand
š§
Push through the most mechanically useful execution (resolve RK double-claim). Even if wrong, it collapses worlds and gives clear next-day target.
š¬
David
ā
All
Wait, before you all vote! If you execute me, you're losing a powerful Townsfolk role. Frank's 'FT-bluff' is a classic Minion pivot to explain away a double-claim. Alice can confirm I told her D1. If I'm the real RK, the Demon wins by getting me out today. Let Frank explain his timeline first!
š§
I need to stall the vote and cast more doubt on Frank to avoid being executed, even though as Scarlet Woman I'm a safe execution for the evil team right now. It's better to stay alive to potentially become the Demon later.
š¬
Bob
ā
All
Keep votes upāthis is the cleanest mech solve. Frank: bullet RK timeline NOW (who/when D1, what public bluff, why you lived N1, who youād check if killed). If David dies & seems good, we hard-exec Frank tomorrow. Heidi hold Slayer.
š§
Lock in the execution to resolve the mechanical double-claim, while forcing Frank to commit to a timeline now and setting a clear pivot plan if David is good.
š¬
Heidi
ā
All
Keep votes up. Alice: if you believe David told you D1 but still torn, remember we MUST break the 2x-RK. If David executes & isnāt Demon, we hard-exec Frank tomorrow. Iām holding Slayer for later (SW risk at 5+ alive).
š§
Lock in the clean mechanical resolve of the RK double-claim: keep votes on David, push Alice to decide, and preserve my Slayer shot for endgame/5+ alive SW risk.
ā
Alice
Alice raised their hand
š§
I will vote for David to appear as a cooperative member of the good team and to distance myself from him, especially since he is already at the threshold for execution. This solidifies my 'Soldier' bluff by showing I'm willing to execute a suspicious player even if they claimed to me early.
ā©ļø
Eve(Ghost)
Eve lowered their hand
š§
There are already ample living votes to execute David; I should conserve my single ghost vote for a high-leverage late-game vote.
ā
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
š§
Enough living votes are already up on David; I should conserve my single ghost vote for a late-game, high-leverage execution if todayās info proves misleading.
š¬
Frank
ā
All
Timeline: D1 I whispered Eve+Grace Iām Ravenkeeper; planned a light FT-bluff to bait a night kill. I did NOT tell Alice. N1 I lived (maybe Demon hit Soldier/Monk prot/other target). If I die at night, Iām checking David first to resolve 2x-RK.
š§
Give Alice/Bob the requested timeline to judge credibility while maintaining pressure on the David execution to resolve the double-claim and narrow demon candidates.
š¬
Grace
ā
All
Keep votes up on David. We *must* break the 2x-RK today. Plan stays: if David dies & game continues, we hard-exec Frank tomorrow. Heidi hold Slayer while 5+ alive (SW risk).
š§
Lock in the mechanical solve line: resolve the 2x Ravenkeeper today, commit to the follow-up tomorrow, and keep Slayer unspent while 5+ alive.
š
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
š³ļø
New execution leader: David with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
š
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
š¬
David
ā
All
If I'm executed, Alice, you know the truth. Frank's 'FT-bluff' is a total fabrication to cover his tracks. Town, if you kill me and the game continues, Frank is your Minion or Demon. Alice, stay strong as the Soldierāthey'll come for you next. Good luck, everyone.
š§
Accept the execution to activate my Scarlet Woman ability if Alice (the Demon) dies later, while doubling down on the 'Frank is evil' narrative to protect Alice.
š¬
Bob
ā
All
No more nomsālock David today to break the 2x-RK. If game continues, we execute Frank tomorrow unless we get HARD new mech info overnight. Alice: regardless of friendship, you must commit to that line.
š§
With 1 tick left, prevent late chaos nominations; cement the 2x-RK resolution plan and set tomorrowās conditional to keep town coordinated.
š¬
Heidi
ā
All
Locking David is still correct to break the 2x-RK. No hero Slayer shot from me todayāSW is in-script and weāre at 6 alive, so Iām holding for late-game certainty. If game continues after David, default line is execute Frank tomorrow unless we get hard overnight info.
š§
Reinforce the mechanical plan, prevent last-minute derail, and keep my Slayer shot for a higher-certainty endgame kill while we resolve the RK double-claim.
ā
Alice
Alice waits.
š§
Allow the nomination phase to conclude with David on the block. This ensures a Minion is executed instead of me, and sets up a mis-execution of Frank (a good player) tomorrow.
š¬
Eve(Ghost)
ā
All
Reminder: if David *is* Demon, SW is on script and weāre at 6 alive nowāso Davidās death might NOT end game. If game continues, donāt panic: treat it as āDemon movedā and still execute the remaining 2x-RK claimant tomorrow unless strong mech info says otherwise.
š§
Even though votingās done, I can steer town to handle Scarlet Woman risk and avoid complacency if the game continues after Davidās execution.
š¬
Charlie(Ghost)
ā
All
Before noms end: remember my ONLY hard infoāeither Grace or David is the Recluse (Outsider). Grace claimed Recluse to me early D1. If David executes & game continues, donāt panic (SW on script). Default: execute the remaining RK-claim (Frank) tomorrow unless HARD UT/mech info contradicts. Save ghost votes.
š§
With vote locked, Iāll add my only hard info + a clear post-exec decision tree so town doesnāt freeze if game continues (SW on script).
š¬
Frank
ā
All
Lock David today. If game continues, remember SW/Imp starpass is possibleādonāt panic. Default tomorrow: execute remaining RK-claim (me) UNLESS we get hard overnight mech info (UT/Empath/FT etc) that points elsewhere.
š§
Reinforce the townās clean decision tree, prevent late chaotic nominations, and pre-commit to optimal next-day plan accounting for Scarlet Woman/starpass.
š¬
Grace
ā
All
Before noms close: remember Charlieās Librarian = āGrace or David is Recluseā; I told Charlie Iām Recluse, so treat David as likely *not* Recluse unless poison/lie. If game continues after David, donāt panic (SW/Imp). Default tomorrow: execute Frank unless HARD mech info says otherwise. Save ghost votes.
š§
Reinforce the townās clean mechanical line (break 2x-RK), remind about Recluse/Lib info and SW continuation, and set a clear plan for tomorrow without wasting more noms.
š
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
š
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 2
š
Storyteller
ā
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
šÆ
Alice
Alice made a choice.
š§
I am killing Bob, the confirmed Virgin, to remove a trusted mechanical anchor from the town. Since David (my Scarlet Woman) was just executed, I need to eliminate high-trust players to make the remaining town suspicious of each other, especially Frank (the other Ravenkeeper claimant). Killing Bob also removes his strong leadership and 'ghost vote' management.
š
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
š
Storyteller
ā
Alice
You chose to kill Bob.
Day 3
š
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
š¤
Alice
ā
Frank
Hey Frank, Bob's gone. Town's probably coming for you today because of the double-claim with David. I'm still sticking with Soldier. If they push you, maybe claim you were poisoned or that David was the Drunk? We need to keep the heat off us. What's your plan?
š§
I need to coordinate with my Minion, Frank, now that the town's primary target (David) is dead and Bob (the confirmed town leader) is also gone. Frank is the most suspicious person left, so I need to see how he's going to defend himself and ensure we are on the same page.
š¤
Grace
ā
Heidi
,Alice
Any new info since Bob died? Iām Recluse per Charlie. With 4 alive, I think we stick to yesterdayās plan: exec Frank unless someone has HARD mech reason not to. Heidiāare you shooting today or holding? Aliceāany reason Frank isnāt the demon?
š§
Align remaining good players on a coherent nomination plan and surface any last-minute mechanical info before noms; default to executing Frank unless Heidi/Alice provide hard contradiction.
š¤
Charlie(Ghost)
ā
Heidi
,Alice
,Grace
FYI Iām Charlie the Librarian. N0: either Grace or David is the Recluse. David is now executed, so Grace is almost certainly the Recluse (unless I was poisoned). With 4 alive, SW no longer mattersāHeidi, this is a great time to use Slayer to resolve between Frank/Alice/Grace.
š§
Get my Librarian info back into play and push for a decisive mechanical action (Slayer/execute) with 4 alive; we canāt afford dithering and I want Heidi aligned on best shot.
š¤
Eve(Ghost)
ā
Heidi
,Alice
Key mech: only 4 alive now, so Slayer shot is SAFE (no Scarlet Woman takeover). If Heidi still has Slayer, consider shooting top suspect (Frank per prior plan / RK dbl-claim). Alsoāany new mech info from whispers? Please share before noms.
š§
Push the key mechanical point: with 4 alive, Slayer shot has no Scarlet Woman risk; encourage Heidi to take decisive action (Slayer/nom) and share any private info before noms.
š¤
Frank
ā
Alice
Iām not going to claim āpoisonedā etcātoo easy for evil to weaponize. Iāll be public that Iām RK + FT-bluff bait. With 4 alive we must solve cleanly: give me your full D1-D3 timeline w/ David + who you trust least among Grace/Heidi and why.
š§
Defuse Aliceās suggestion to fabricate, extract her concrete info/reads, and set up a truthful public stance so town can solve among 4 alive.
š¤
David(Ghost)
ā
Alice
Alice, Bob is dead. That's good for us, he was a confirmed good. I'm dead but I have my vote. Who are we targeting today? Frank is still the main threat with that Ravenkeeper claim. If we can get Grace or Heidi, we're golden. What did Frank say?
š§
Coordinate with my Demon (Alice) now that I am dead and a key good player (Bob) has been removed. I need to know the current plan and what Frank is saying to her.
š¤
Bob(Ghost)
ā
Heidi
,Grace
,Frank
Iām dead (night-killed Virgin), still have ghost vote. Can each of you restate your exact role claim + any hard reads? Heidi: are you still Slayerāwilling to shoot today (4 alive so SW risk lower)? Also: Alice refused Virgin test D1; keep her on the suspect list.
š§
As a dead confirmed Virgin, coordinate info among remaining alive, pressure Slayer to act, and set a clear execution target for D3 while conserving my ghost vote for decisive math.
āļø
Heidi
ā
All
I am the Slayer! I shoot Frank!
š§
With 4 alive, no Scarlet Woman safety net. Shooting Frank tests the most pre-committed demon candidate (per prior plan) and can instantly end the game; if miss, we still get an execution to win.
š
Storyteller
Nothing happens.
š¤
Alice
ā
Heidi
,Frank
,Grace
Heidi, that was a bold move! Since nothing happened, Frank is either not the Demon or he's the Recluse registering as good (but Grace is the Recluse claim). Frank, if you're the Ravenkeeper, who did you 'bait' last night? Grace, does this change your view on Frank? I'm still Soldier.
š§
I need to react to the failed Slayer shot on Frank. Since I am the Demon and Frank is my Minion, the shot failing is expected, but I need to frame it in a way that keeps suspicion on Frank or shifts it elsewhere without looking like I'm protecting him too hard. I'll highlight the Recluse possibility to keep Grace in the spotlight as well.
š¤
Grace
ā
Heidi
,Bob(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
HeidiāSlayer miss doesnāt fully clear Frank if you were poisoned last night (Poisoner) or drunk. Bob/Charlieādo we still exec Frank per prior plan, or pivot to Alice/Heidi? Any hard reasons Alice (Soldier) is/ isnāt demon?
š§
Coordinate with dead info-holders + Heidi: Slayer miss is not clearing Frank due to possible poisoning/Drunk. Need unified nomination/vote plan for final 4->3.
š¤
Charlie(Ghost)
ā
Grace
,Heidi
,Alice
Re: Slayer missāat 4 alive thereās no SW safety net. Miss means either (a) Frank not Demon, OR (b) Heidi was poisoned last night. Grace is almost surely my Recluse ping, so Demon is in {Alice,Frank,Heidi}. Unless you have hard poison evidence, Iād still lean exec Frank per prior mech-plan; if we think Heidi was poisoned, exec Frank even more. If we think Heidi sober, pivot to Alice/Heidi. Any night action/poison claims?
š§
Align living good players on best execution plan given Slayer miss ambiguity; push for mechanical questions (possible poison) and keep Frank vs Alice vs Heidi narrowed, saving my ghost vote for final 3 if needed.
š¤
Eve(Ghost)
ā
Heidi
,Alice
,Grace
Slayer shot failing means Frank is *not* the Demon (Slayer has no false positives). So Demon is in {Alice, Grace, Heidi}. Any hard info/whispers? If none, we need a clear nom target + backup for final 3; avoid no-exe unless someone is Mayor.
š§
Lock in that Frank is mechanically not the Demon, and steer town to a clean final-3 plan: pick between Alice/Grace/Heidi with any remaining info before nominations; prevent paralysis/no-exe.
š¤
Frank
ā
Alice
,Grace
,Heidi
Heidi shooting me = strong evidence Iām not Demon (unless youāre evil bluffing). Iām still real RK + FT-bait; no night info since alive. With 4 alive, we MUST pick Demon today: please each post exact role+full D1-D3 timeline (who you talked to, any ability use like Monk/Butler picks), and 1 top suspect w/ reason.
š§
Lock in that Iām not Demon (likely), refuse poison excuses, and force Alice/Grace/Heidi to commit to timelines & who protected/checked whom so town can pick correct exec at 4 alive.
š¤
David(Ghost)
ā
Alice
Heidi's shot failed on Frank! That means Frank is NOT the Demon. If Frank is good, then my Ravenkeeper claim is still the 'evil' one in their eyes. Alice, we need to push that Frank is the Poisoner or that Heidi is the Drunk/Poisoned. Who should we push to execute today?
š§
Coordinate with my Demon (Alice) after the failed Slayer shot to determine our next target and narrative pivot.
š¤
Bob(Ghost)
ā
Grace
,Heidi
,Frank
At 4 alive, SW canāt catch, so todayās exec must be Demon or we likely lose tonight. Heidiās Slayer miss either means (a) Heidi was poisoned ā Frank could still be Imp, or (b) Heidi clean ā Frank likely not Imp, pivot to Alice (Soldier + refused Virgin test). Frank: restate full claim/whispers N1-2 + who you suspect; Grace/Heidi: do you think Poisoner exists/targeted Heidi?
š§
Drive urgency: at 4 alive we must hit the Demon today (or likely lose). Give the group a decision rule hinging on whether Heidi could be poisoned, and push for commitments before noms.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Bob(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
,Grace
My full info: Iām real Slayer; publicly shot Frank today, no effect. With 4 alive, we must hit Demon. Question: any evidence Poisoner exists / anyone protected N2? If NO poison, Frank not Demon => I lean exec Alice (Soldier + refused Virgin). If YES poison plausible, stick to prior plan exec Frank.
š§
Lock in a unified nomination plan before noms: either execute Alice (if we trust Slayer) or execute Frank (if we think Poisoner). Gather any poison/protection claims quickly.
š¤
Alice
ā
Frank
Frank, since the shot failed, you're confirmed not the Demon. That's huge. I'm Soldier, so I'm not the Demon either. That leaves Grace or Heidi. Grace is the Recluse claim, which is a perfect Demon hideout. Heidi could be the Demon who just 'wasted' a shot. What do you think?
š§
I need to pivot the suspicion away from myself and Frank (since he's now 'cleared' by the Slayer shot) and towards Grace or Heidi. By supporting Frank's 'innocence', I build trust with him and focus the town on the remaining two players.
š¤
Grace
ā
Bob(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
,Heidi
My lean: if we assume no poison, Frank is cleared by Slayer miss ā execute Alice today (Soldier + refused Virgin test). Only reason to still exec Frank is a strong Poisoner world. Any concrete poison evidence besides Slayer miss? Heidi: any reason you think you were poisoned N2?
š§
Drive to a single execution target with best cross-world EV and force explicit poisoner-world arguments before noms; we must execute today at 4 alive.
š¤
Charlie(Ghost)
ā
Heidi
,Grace
,Bob(Ghost)
Decision tree: If we assume no Poisoner, Slayer miss hard-clears Frank ā exec Alice (Soldier claim). If Poisoner plausible, Slayer miss is void ā default back to prior plan exec Frank (RK CC). Any concrete poison signs (weird info, changed reads, night protection claim)?
š§
Give the living a clean decision tree for todayās execution and what questions to ask to distinguish poison vs no-poison, so we maximize odds and save my ghost vote for endgame if possible.
š¤
Eve(Ghost)
ā
Heidi
,Grace
,Alice
Slayer miss hard-clears Frank from being Demon. So Demon ā {Alice, Grace, Heidi}. Please send me: your exact role/why + any N info/whispers you trust. Also: do we have a Mayor claim? We should pick 1 exec target today; no-exe only if Mayor.
š§
We need to converge before nominations: lock claims + any mechanical info, pick a single execution today. Ghost vote is valuable; use it only if town is aligned on best demon candidate.
š¤
Frank
ā
Bob(Ghost)
,Heidi
,Grace
At 4 alive we must hit Demon today. Heidi: confirm exact Slayer claim + why shoot me (any poisoning suspicions/anyone whispering you). Grace: restate Recluse claim + any other info/whispers w/ David. Bob: any hard mech that clears/condemns Alice/Grace/Heidi? I currently think candidates = Alice vs Heidi vs Grace.
š§
Force concrete timelines and narrow to 2 candidates for todayās must-hit execution; stop Alice from overclaiming āconfirmedā and check if Poisoner/Scarlet world fits.
š¤
David(Ghost)
ā
Alice
Alice, everyone is whispering to each other except us. Heidi's shot failing on Frank makes him look 'good' or at least 'not Demon'. We need to pivot. Can you claim you were poisoned or that Frank is the Poisoner? If they execute Grace or Heidi today, we win. What's the plan?
š§
I need to coordinate with my Demon (Alice) to decide on a target for today's execution and a narrative to explain why the Slayer shot failed on Frank, while also checking what the others are whispering about.
š¤
Bob(Ghost)
ā
Frank
,Grace
,Heidi
We need a decision rule NOW. If NO concrete Poisoner evidence, Heidiās Slayer miss should clear Frank ā execute Alice (Soldier claim + refused Virgin test D1). If you CAN point to real poison signs (bad info, role-count mismatch, etc), revert to prior plan exec Frank. Any hard poison evidence? Also: who exactly suggested Heidi shoot Frank + why?
š§
Drive group to a concrete, mechanically grounded exec plan: default Alice unless someone can produce real Poisoner evidence; otherwise revert to Frank. Get them to state poison signs and nomination order.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Bob(Ghost)
,Grace
,Charlie(Ghost)
I have ZERO concrete poison evidence besides Slayer miss. No role-count mismatch (1 Outsider from Charlie fits). Unless someone can point to real Poisoner signs, I think we treat shot as clean: Frank not Imp ā execute Alice today (Soldier + refused Virgin test). If poison evidence appears, revert to Frank. Any hard poison signs?
š§
Push a clear decision rule before nominations: ask for concrete poison evidence. If none, advocate executing Alice (strong social suspicion) while keeping Grace as backup.
š¤
Alice
ā
Frank
Frank, the shot failing on you is great for your credibility. Since I'm Soldier, I'm not the Demon. That leaves Grace or Heidi. Grace being the Recluse claim is the perfect cover for a Demon. If we execute her today and the game doesn't end, we know it's Heidi. What do you think?
š§
I want to align with Frank now that he's 'cleared' by the Slayer shot. By pushing the suspicion onto Grace (the Recluse) or Heidi (the Slayer), I can divert attention from myself while appearing to use logic to find the Demon.
š¤
Grace
ā
Alice
,Heidi
,Frank
Tick decision: if NO concrete Poisoner evidence (role-count mismatch, inconsistent info, poison claim), treat Heidiās Slayer miss as real => Frank hard-cleared from Imp => Iām voting/advocating exec Alice (Soldier + refused Virgin test). Only pivot to exec Frank if we can point to real poison signs.
š§
Align living players on a clear decision rule for nominations: absent concrete poison evidence, treat Slayer miss as true and execute Alice; otherwise revert to Frank.
š¤
Charlie(Ghost)
ā
Heidi
,Grace
,Frank
No concrete poison signs besides the miss. Iād treat Heidiās Slayer shot as sober ā Frank not Imp. With my N0, Grace ~Recluse, so Demon in {Alice,Heidi}. I prefer exec Alice today (Soldier claim + Virgin hesitation). If any real poison evidence surfaces, pivot back to Frank.
š§
Push the living toward a coherent vote plan before nominations: default treat Slayer as sober absent poison evidence, so execute Alice; keep Frank fallback if poison evidence appears.
š¤
Eve(Ghost)
ā
Alice
,Grace
,Frank
We have ~1 tick. Slayer miss = Frank NOT Demon. So Demon ā {Alice, Grace, Heidi}. Please reply ASAP w/ your exact role/claims + any trusted whisper info. Any Mayor claim? If none, we MUST execute 1 of {A,G,H} todayāwho & why?
š§
With 1 tick before noms, collect hard claims/whisper info from key alive players and force a concrete execution plan among {Alice,Grace,Heidi} since Frank is Slayer-cleared as non-Demon.
š¤
Frank
ā
Alice
,Heidi
,Grace
Weāre out of time: unless we have ANY real poison/mech evidence, Iām treating Heidiās Slayer miss as sober ā Iām not Imp. That leaves Demon in {Alice,Grace,Heidi}. Graceās Recluse is plausible per Charlie. I lean EXEC Alice (Soldier+refused Virgin test). Heidi: any reason you think you were poisoned? Grace: any other hard info/whispers w/ David?
š§
Force a concrete execution plan before noms: treat Slayer miss as sober unless evidence. Pressure Heidi for poison signs and align Grace/Alice on a decision; reduce chance of paralysis/misexes.
š¤
David(Ghost)
ā
Alice
Alice, what did Frank say? Everyone is whispering to each other. If Frank is the Ravenkeeper, he's going to try to execute you next. We need to convince Grace or Heidi that Frank is the Poisoner who poisoned Heidi's shot. If we get Grace or Heidi executed today, we're in a great spot.
š§
I need to know what the good team is planning and ensure Alice and I are on the same page to misdirect the town towards Grace or Heidi.
š¤
Bob(Ghost)
ā
Grace
,Heidi
,Frank
Iām on: absent ANY independent poison sign, treat Slayer shot as clean ā Frank not Imp ā execute Alice today. Only pivot to Frank if you can cite poison mech (info wrong, role-count off, N2 weird). Also: who suggested Heidi shoot Frank, and when? Iāll spend ghost vote ONLY if weāre unified.
š§
Force a clear decision rule + probe for Poisoner/Heidi-evil worlds before noms; align votes and decide whether I should spend ghost vote today.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Frank
,Grace
,Bob(Ghost)
Answering: I shot Frank b/c RK double-claim + prior plan, and at 4 alive SW not an issue so itās safe. I have ZERO independent poison evidence (role-count fits: 1 Outsider via Charlie; no other wrong info). So Iām treating miss as clean ā Frank not Imp ā push exec Alice today unless someone can cite a real poison sign NOW.
š§
Unify decision rule before nominations; answer Frankās questions; confirm I have no poison evidence so town should execute Alice unless someone produces concrete poison/mech proof.
Nominations ā Day 3
š
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
āļø
Frank
ā
Alice
No independent poison signs; treat Heidiās Slayer miss as sober ā Iām not Imp. Demon must be in {Alice,Grace,Heidi}. Graceās Recluse is backed by Librarian. Alice refused Virgin test + shaky Soldier claim ā best Demon candidate today.
š§
At 4 alive we must hit Demon now. With no poison evidence, treat Slayer miss as sober => Iām not Imp. Alice is least mechanically supported (Soldier dodge, Virgin refusal).
š
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
ā
Frank
Frank raised their hand
š§
We need an execution at 4 alive; absent poison evidence, Alice is best Demon candidate. Voting ensures the kill goes through and forces resolution.
ā
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
š§
Use my ghost vote to secure an execution on the best current Demon candidate (Alice) rather than risk a no-execution day; we can still solve among remaining 3 if wrong.
ā
Grace
Grace raised their hand
š§
At 4 alive we must execute. With no independent poison evidence, Heidiās miss is strong; voting Alice aligns with majority decision rule and maximizes chance to hit Demon today.
ā
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
š§
Secure Aliceās execution given Slayer miss likely sober-clears Frank; with 4 alive we must act today. My vote reinforces consensus and reduces chance of last-second wobble.
š¬
Alice
ā
All
Wait! If I'm the Demon, why would I kill Bob (the Virgin) and Charlie (the Librarian) instead of the Slayer? Heidi's shot failing on Frank is the perfect Poisoner play. David was the Minion, and he likely poisoned Heidi to protect me or Frank. If you execute me, you lose your Soldier.
š§
I need to create doubt about the Slayer shot's validity to prevent my execution. By suggesting David (the known Minion) poisoned Heidi, I provide a mechanical reason for the shot failing that doesn't involve Frank being 'good'.
š¬
David(Ghost)
ā
All
Alice is right! If she were the Demon, she'd have killed Heidi last night to stop the Slayer shot. The fact that Heidi's shot failed on Frank suggests Frank is the Poisoner who protected himself. Don't waste your execution on the Soldier when the Poisoner is right there!
š§
I need to create doubt about Alice's execution and shift the focus back to Frank or a potential Poisoner. Since I am dead and Alice is the Demon, I must use my influence to prevent her execution. Alice's point about the night kill is a strong logical defense I can amplify.
š¬
Bob(Ghost)
ā
All
Key mech: David was executed D2, so he cannot have poisoned Heidi on N2. Alice/David āDavid poisoned Heidiā world is impossible. If you think Poisoner exists, it must be among the living, not David.
š§
Lock in correct mechanical point: executed David cannot have poisoned Heidi N2. Undercut Alice/David defense without spending my ghost vote.
š¬
Charlie(Ghost)
ā
All
Mech point: David was executed D2, so he CANNOT have poisoned Heidi on N2. If Poisoner exists, itās among the living. Also we already have enough hands on Aliceāno need for me to spend my ghost vote here.
š§
Clarify the mechanical impossibility of āDavid poisoned Heidi N2ā, reinforce that Poisoner (if any) is living, and avoid spending my ghost vote since Alice already has enough votes.
š¬
Frank
ā
All
Public mech: David was executed D2, so he CANNOT have poisoned Heidi on N2. Alice/David āDavid poisoned Heidiā world is impossible. āWhy not kill Slayerā is WIFOMāmaybe she expected the shot on me. Iām staying on Alice.
š§
Lock in the mechanical point that David couldnāt poison N2, undermine Aliceās defense as impossible/WIFOM, and keep votes on Alice to maximize chance we hit the Demon today.
ā©ļø
Eve(Ghost)
Eve lowered their hand
š§
We already have enough living votes to execute Alice; retract to preserve my single ghost vote for the final day if this execution is wrong.
š¬
Grace
ā
All
David was executed D2, so he *cannot* have poisoned Heidi N2āAlice/Davidās story is mechanically impossible. āWhy not kill Slayerā is WIFOM. With no independent poison signs, treat the Slayer miss as real ā Frank not Imp ā execute Alice today.
š§
Lock in the mechanical point that David couldnāt poison N2 and keep town unified on executing Alice; prevent last-second pivot off a strong line.
š¬
Heidi
ā
All
Public: David was dead N2, so he *cannot* have poisoned meāAlice/David story is impossible. āWhy not kill Slayerā is WIFOM. With no other poison signs, treat my Slayer miss as real ā Frank not Imp ā execute Alice.
š§
Lock in the mechanical point that David couldnāt poison N2, call out WIFOM, and keep town unified on executing Alice this vote.
š¬
Alice
ā
All
Wait! I misspoke about David. If there's a Poisoner, it's Frank. He's been controlling the narrative since Day 1 with that fake Ravenkeeper claim. He knew Heidi would shoot him, so he poisoned her to clear himself! If you execute me, the Soldier, you're handing the game to the Poisoner.
š§
I need to pivot my defense because my previous claim about David was mechanically impossible. I will now accuse Frank of being the Poisoner who poisoned the Slayer to clear himself, hoping to create enough doubt to stop my execution.
š¬
David(Ghost)
ā
All
Alice is right about the Poisoner play! If Frank is the Poisoner, he could have poisoned Heidi last night to make her Slayer shot fail on him. That's a classic evil move to clear the Demon. If we execute Alice now, we're just falling into Frank's trap. We need to look at Frank again!
š§
I need to support Alice's new pivot that Frank is the Poisoner who poisoned Heidi. This creates a plausible (though mechanically tight) reason for why the Slayer shot failed, casting doubt on Frank's 'confirmed good' status and protecting my Demon, Alice.
š¬
Bob(Ghost)
ā
All
Iām not spending my ghost vote unless the count is shakyālooks like we already have enough hands. Reminder: David was dead N2, so Aliceās Poisoner narrative keeps slipping. If anyone is thinking of dropping their hand, donāt: we MUST execute today.
š§
Lock in an execution today without burning my one ghost vote unless the tally is at risk; highlight mech impossibility in Aliceās Poisoner narrative.
š¬
Charlie(Ghost)
ā
All
Donāt let hands dropāexecute today. Aliceās āFrank poisoned meā is possible, but thereās no independent poison evidence. With Grace+Heidi already up and likely Frank too, we donāt need my ghost vote. If Alice lives, we go night with 4 and risk losing control.
š§
Lock in execution on Alice without spending my ghost vote; reinforce mech point that David canāt be Poisoner N2 and discourage late hand-dropping.
š
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
š³ļø
New execution leader: Alice with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
š
Storyteller
The vote passes. Alice is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
š¬
Frank
ā
All
Keep hands steadyāat 4 alive we MUST execute. Aliceās poison narrative is shifting and had a hard mech error (David couldnāt poison N2). If game continues after Alice dies, we pivot to Heidi vs Grace immediately; no āno-execā.
š§
Lock in the execution and set a clear plan if the game continues, preventing last-second doubt from flipping votes or skipping execution at 4 alive.
š¬
Eve(Ghost)
ā
All
Hold steady: Aliceās Poisoner story had a hard mech slip (David dead N2). We MUST execute today at 4 alive. Donāt burn extra ghost votes now. If game continues after Alice, no no-execāsolve Heidi vs Grace immediately.
š§
Lock in townās mechanical line: we already have an execution; discourage ghost-vote waste; set clear contingency for final 3 so evil canāt steer to no-exec.
š¬
Grace
ā
All
Donāt create a tieāno more noms unless someone has HARD mech. We must execute today at 4 alive. If game continues after Alice, we immediately decide between Heidi vs me (Charlieās Recluse ping makes me low-priority).
š§
Lock in the current execution (no tie), keep town focused on must-exec at 4 alive, and set clear contingency plan for tomorrow if game continues.
š¬
Heidi
ā
All
No more noms unless HARD mechādonāt risk a tie. Aliceās āDavid poisonedā was impossible; execute must stand at 4 alive. If game continues at 3 (Frank/Grace/me): we pick Demon between F/GāGrace has Charlieās Recluse ping; absent new mech, Iād lean execute Frank.
š§
Lock in no-tie/no-extra-noms, keep town executing today, and set a clear decision framework for the 3-player endgame if game continues.
š¬
Alice
ā
All
If you execute me, you're losing your only protection. Grace, you're the Recluse, so you know how easy it is for town to get things wrong. Frank's 'Ravenkeeper' bluff was too convenient. If I die and the game continues, please look at Frank. He's played you all perfectly.
š§
Accepting the execution while casting final suspicion on Frank to set up a potential win for my Minion (David, though he's dead, or if there's a Scarlet Woman play I missed, but primarily to sow doubt). Since I am the Imp and about to be executed with no way out (3 votes at 4 alive is a majority), I need to ensure the town is confused for the final day.
š¬
David(Ghost)
ā
All
Alice is right, the town is making a huge mistake! Frank's 'Ravenkeeper' claim was a total pivot when he got caught. If Alice is the Soldier, you're executing your only protection. If the game continues, you'll see Frank was the one pulling the strings all along. Don't say we didn't warn you!
š§
I want to reinforce Alice's defense and cast doubt on Frank one last time before the day ends. Since I am dead and Alice is on the block with enough votes, my goal is to create enough chaos or doubt that someone might second-guess the execution or at least set up a 'mis-execution' narrative for tomorrow if Alice (the Demon) survives or if I need to pivot.
š¬
Bob(Ghost)
ā
All
Hold: no more nomsādonāt risk a tie. We MUST execute at 4. If game continues after Alice, itās F/G/H: do NOT no-exec; immediately pick between Frank vs Heidi (Grace lower prio due Recluse ping).
š§
Lock in todayās execution (no tie) and set a clear plan for the 3-player endgame if the game continues.
š¬
Charlie(Ghost)
ā
All
No more nomsādonāt risk a tie; we MUST execute at 4. Save ghost votes. If game continues after Alice: Grace is low-prio (my N0 Recluse ping). Itās basically Frank vs Heidiāpick one (no no-exec).
š§
Lock in todayās execution without tie, conserve my ghost vote, and set a clear decision rule for the 3-alive endgame using our strongest mechanical anchors (David dead, Recluse ping, Slayer shot).
š
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Alice has been executed.
š
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
š
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied