Game Detail
Players
Alice (Soldier) Bob (Librarian) Charlie (Monk) David (Imp) Eve (Ravenkeeper) Frank (Poisoner) Grace (Washerwoman) Heidi (Recluse)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 163,606 | 16,845 | $0.0662 |
| Good | 484,879 | 133,892 | $0.8334 |
Event Timeline
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You are the Minion. The Demon is David.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Minions are: Frank. Your safe bluffs are: Slayer, Fortune Teller, Virgin
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
Poisoning a player on Night 1 is a standard move to cripple potential strong roles early in the game, like a Fortune Teller or Investigator, to protect the Demon. Alice is a good starting target.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose to poison Alice.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Washerwoman. Either Bob or Charlie is the Monk.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Librarian. Either Heidi or David is the Recluse.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
Hey, it's Charlie. Day one, no info yet. Just wanted to touch base with my neighbors. Have either of you heard anything useful from anyone? I'm still figuring out what to claim publicly, so let's keep in touch.
🧠
It's Day 1 and I have no info yet. I should whisper to my neighbors Bob and David to start building trust and gathering information. I'll keep my role vague for now to avoid being targeted by the Demon.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Grace
Hey neighbors! Day one, let's talk. Have either of you heard anything interesting from others? I'm trying to get a sense of what information is floating around before nominations start.
🧠
As Recluse, I need to gather information early. Whispering to neighbors Alice and Grace helps build trust and learn what info roles have discovered, which is crucial since my ability might cause false evil reads.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
,Grace
Hey Heidi, Grace! Good to hear from you. I don't have any night info myself - I slept right through. Has anyone else approached either of you with claims? I'm curious what Charlie is telling Bob and David over there.
🧠
I want to build rapport with my neighbors Heidi and Grace while being cautious about revealing my Soldier role. If the Demon thinks I'm a regular townsfolk, they might waste a night kill on me since I'm actually safe. Gathering info on Day 1 is crucial.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Alice
Thanks for reaching out, both of you. I actually do have some night information. I'm the Washerwoman, and I learned that either Bob or Charlie is the Monk. I wanted to share this with you two since we're neighbors and seemed to be talking early. Have either of you heard anything from others, or do you have any info of your own?
🧠
Share my Washerwoman info with my immediate neighbors to build trust and start gathering information. This is Day 1 so I need to establish a trusted circle early.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, thanks for reaching out. I actually do have some info. I'm the Librarian, and I learned that either Heidi or David is the Recluse. I wanted to share that with you since we're neighbors and should look out for each other. Have you heard anything from anyone else?
🧠
Charlie reached out as a neighbor, so I should reciprocate to build rapport. Sharing my Librarian info early helps establish a truth chain and shows I'm contributing. I trust my neighbor enough to share on Day 1.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, nice to meet you. I am still keeping my options open. I have not heard anything concrete yet either. Let us definitely stay in touch as the day goes on.
🧠
Establishing a friendly rapport with a neighbor to build trust early.
👤
Frank
→
David
Hey David, I've been keeping an eye on the group. Alice seems a bit too quiet, I think she might be worth keeping an eye on or maybe even questioning later. What do you think?
🧠
I want to coordinate with my Demon (David) and push suspicion towards someone else, specifically Alice whom I poisoned last night, so if she acts weird, it reinforces that she is poisoned.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Hey Frank, any early thoughts? I'm still trying to get a read on people. Have you heard anything interesting from the others?
🧠
As Ravenkeeper, I want to start gathering information from other players. Frank seems less connected to the main whisper chains (Charlie-Bob-David and Heidi-Alice-Grace), so reaching out to him could help me get unfiltered info and form an alliance.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Thanks for trusting me with that, Bob. Librarian info about the Recluse is valuable. I have a useful role I'd rather not claim broadly yet, but I'm on the good team for sure. Have you shared the Librarian claim with anyone else, or just me? Also, what do you think about the Heidi-David Recluse situation - any gut feeling on which one it is?
🧠
I want to acknowledge Bob's info and build trust, while also probing whether he's shared this widely. I also want to start connecting with other players to gather more information and cross-reference claims.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Grace
Thanks for sharing that, Grace. Washerwoman info on Bob or Charlie being the Monk is really helpful. Have you spoken to either of them yet to try to narrow that down? Also, Alice, even without night info, what role are you thinking of claiming? I want us to have a solid picture before nominations. I don't have any night information myself, but I'm working on gathering what I can.
🧠
Follow up on Grace's Washerwoman claim with neighbors. As Recluse, I need to gather info without revealing my role. I should probe Grace's claim and see if Alice has any other info, while also considering reaching out to other players.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
,Grace
Thanks for sharing that, Grace. Washerwoman info is really valuable. I'll go ahead and be open with you both - I'm the Soldier. So the Demon can't kill me at night, which means I'll be around to help coordinate. Heidi, any idea what role you are? Also, Grace, have you had a chance to talk to Bob or Charlie directly to narrow down which one is the Monk?
🧠
I should respond to Heidi's question about my role. Claiming Soldier honestly on Day 1 has benefits - it builds trust with neighbors, and the Demon can't kill me anyway so there's no real downside to them knowing. I also want to probe for more information from the group.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
,Charlie
Hey Bob and Charlie, I'd like to talk to you both. I have some information that involves the two of you, and I'd like to hear what you each have to say. Can you each tell me what role you're playing? I'm trying to piece things together before nominations.
🧠
I need to narrow down which of Bob or Charlie is the Monk. Talking to them directly is the best way to get their claims and cross-reference with my Washerwoman info. This will help identify potential evil players.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
,Charlie
Hey Grace, thanks for reaching out. Charlie already knows, so I'll share - I'm the Librarian. I learned that either Heidi or David is the Recluse. What's the information you have that involves us? I'd like to hear it before we go further.
🧠
Grace is asking about our roles and claims to have info involving us. I should ask what her information is before fully revealing, but since I already told Charlie I'm the Librarian, it's reasonable to share with Grace too if she reciprocates.
👤
David
→
Frank
That is an interesting observation about Alice. I have not noticed her being particularly quiet myself, but I will definitely keep an eye on her now that you mention it. Have you picked a role to claim yet, Frank?
🧠
Building rapport with my Minion, Frank, and subtly guiding him to share his public role claim to ensure we are aligned.
👤
Frank
→
David
I am thinking of claiming Investigator to keep things focused. It helps me watch people closely. Have you decided on your own bluff, or do you have any leads I should be aware of? I want to make sure we are not contradicting each other.
🧠
Establish my role and coordinate with my Demon.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
,Alice
Hey Heidi and Alice, I'm trying to get a sense of where people stand. Have you two shared roles yet? I'm willing to be open if you are. I feel like I'm on the outside of a lot of these conversations.
🧠
I need to gather information and build connections. I'll whisper to Heidi who seems active in conversations to get a read on her group and share some info myself.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
,Bob
Hey Grace. I appreciate you reaching out. I'm a Townsfolk, but I'd rather not specify exactly which one just yet - I have a sensitive role that I'll reveal when the time is right. What's the information you have that involves me and Bob? I'd like to hear it before sharing more about myself.
🧠
Grace is asking about my role and claims to have info involving me and Bob. I want to learn what she knows without fully revealing I'm the Monk, which could make me a night target. I'll be vague and ask her to share her info first.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
,Alice
Hey Eve, good to hear from you. Alice and I have been talking with Grace too. I'm still being cautious about claiming my role this early - I want to see how things develop before I show my hand. What about you, Eve? Do you have any night information or a role you're willing to share? That would help us figure out who to trust.
🧠
Eve is reaching out wanting info. I should engage to build trust but NOT reveal my Recluse role since I might register as evil and could be misidentified. I'll be vague about my role and try to learn more from Eve.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
,Heidi
Hey Eve, thanks for reaching out. I'm willing to be open - I'm the Soldier, so the Demon can't kill me at night. Heidi and I have been talking with Grace, who claims to be the Washerwoman. She says either Bob or Charlie is the Monk. What about you, Eve? Do you have any night information or a role you'd like to share? The more we can pool together before nominations, the better.
🧠
Eve is reaching out proactively and seems willing to share info. Since I'm the Soldier and safe from Demon kills, there's low risk in sharing my role. Building trust with Eve could give us another ally and more information before nominations. I also want to find out what Eve knows.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
,Charlie
I'm the Washerwoman, and my night information is that one of you two is the Monk. Bob, you've claimed Librarian, so if you're telling the truth, Charlie must be the Monk. Charlie, can you confirm? If you're not the Monk, then something doesn't add up, and I need to know that too. Please be straight with me here.
🧠
Press Charlie by sharing my Washerwoman info. If he's the Monk, he should confirm when he hears mechanical backing. If he's not, he should deny it, which would imply Bob is the Monk and lying about being Librarian - a major red flag.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, Grace just told me she's the Washerwoman and that one of us is the Monk. Since I'm the Librarian, that means you should be the Monk. Can you confirm this privately? If you're not the Monk, we have a problem - either Grace is lying or I might be the Drunk. I need to know where you stand before we go to nominations.
🧠
Grace's claim puts pressure on Charlie to reveal as the Monk. If Charlie isn't the Monk, something is wrong. I need to privately push Charlie on this to resolve the conflict before nominations.
👤
David
→
Frank
That sounds like a solid choice, Frank. I think I am leaning towards claiming Slayer. It should keep people off my back for a while. Let me know if you get any useful information from your investigation.
🧠
I am confirming my bluff with my minion, Frank, to ensure our stories are consistent while maintaining my cover as a townsfolk.
👤
Frank
→
David
That works for me. As an Investigator, I will likely claim to have seen someone as a Minion later on to stir up some trouble. We should keep our stories straight. Any advice on who to target for my 'findings'?
🧠
Coordinating with the Demon to make my bluff more effective and gather intel on his preferences.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Heidi
Thanks for sharing, Alice and Heidi. I trust you enough to share my role - I'm the Ravenkeeper. If I die at night, I get to learn one player's character, which could be crucial for finding the Demon. So if I ever turn up dead at night, come to me for info. Alice, if you're the Soldier, the Demon can't kill you, which is great for the town. Grace's claim about Bob or Charlie being the Monk is interesting - we should try to narrow that down. Has anyone else claimed anything?
🧠
Alice shared her role (Soldier) and Grace's Washerwoman info with me. I should reciprocate by claiming Ravenkeeper to build trust with the good team. If I die at night, they'll know to trust my information. I should also ask about the Bob/Charlie claim to understand the full picture before nominations.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Grace
→
All
Hey everyone, I want to share some information before we nominate. I'm the Washerwoman, and on the first night I learned that either Bob or Charlie is the Monk. Bob has claimed to be the Librarian, which would make Charlie the Monk. But Charlie has refused to confirm this, saying their role is sensitive. The Monk is not a particularly dangerous role to claim, so I find Charlie's evasiveness concerning. Charlie, can you explain why you won't claim Monk?
🧠
Share my Washerwoman information publicly to put pressure on Charlie to claim, since their evasiveness about being the Monk is suspicious. This helps the town evaluate Charlie's alignment.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alright, you got me. I am the Monk. Grace is correct. I was being overly cautious earlier because I wanted to feel out the room first before committing to a claim, but I see now that was counterproductive. The Washerwoman info lines up, and Bob being the Librarian makes sense with what I know. So there we go, I'm the Monk. Now let's focus on what matters. Bob's Librarian info says either Heidi or David is the Recluse. Has anyone else shared useful information? I'd rather we spend our time findin...
🧠
Grace has publicly outed me as the Monk based on her Washerwoman info. Continuing to be evasive makes me look suspicious and distracts the town. I should confirm I'm the Monk to clear the air, then redirect focus toward finding the Demon. The Monk role isn't dangerous to claim - its power is in night protection, not information.
💬
David
→
All
That is good to hear, Charlie. I appreciate you coming forward. As for Bob's claim that either Heidi or I am the Recluse, I can say for certain that I am not, as I am the Slayer. Since I am definitely not the Recluse, that leaves Heidi as the only possibility if Bob is correct.
🧠
I am supporting the narrative that Bob's info (about the Recluse) is correct, pointing suspicion towards Heidi while establishing my own bluff (Slayer). This helps build my credibility with the group.
💬
Eve
→
All
Everyone, I need to point out something important. We have six Townsfolk claims: Grace as Washerwoman, Charlie as Monk, Alice as Soldier, David as Slayer, Bob as Librarian, and I'm the Ravenkeeper. But only five Townsfolk exist in this game. That means at least one of us is lying or is the Drunk. If someone is the Drunk, that uses up our one Outsider slot, which means Heidi might not be the Recluse after all. This math problem is critical. David, as the Slayer, you can prove your claim by taking...
🧠
Point out the critical math problem: we have 6 Townsfolk claims but only 5 Townsfolk exist. This means at least one claimant is lying or is the Drunk. This is a key deduction that helps narrow down the Demon and Minion. Also suggest David prove his Slayer claim.
💬
Alice
→
All
Eve is right - six Townsfolk claims for five slots means someone is lying or Drunk. Since I know I'm the real Soldier, one of the other five claims is false. Frank, you've been quiet - what's your role? Also, David, since you claim Slayer, proving it by taking a shot would be huge for the town. If you hit the Demon, we win on the spot. If you miss, we at least confirm you're the real Slayer, which narrows down who's lying. Who would you shoot?
🧠
Eve raised a critical point about 6 Townsfolk claims for 5 slots. I need to highlight this math problem, point out Frank's suspicious silence, and suggest David prove his Slayer claim by shooting someone suspicious. This helps narrow down the evil player.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am the Investigator. I have been busy gathering information, but the sheer amount of conflicting claims is making it difficult to process. I am hesitant to reveal my target yet, as I want to double-check my findings. Eve makes a good point about the count of Townsfolk claims.
🧠
I need to maintain my Investigator bluff while avoiding being forced to reveal a target, as that could be disproven later. I will agree with the town's concern about too many Townsfolk claims to look helpful and distract from the actual lies.
💬
Bob
→
All
Hold on, everyone. Eve raised a great point, but she undercounted. Including Frank's Investigator claim, we now have seven Townsfolk claims for five slots. That means at least two people are lying, or one is lying and someone is the Drunk. This is critical. David, if you are the real Slayer, please prove it by taking a shot. That would confirm you and narrow this down immediately. Frank, you claimed Investigator but haven't shared your info. We need that now more than ever. And Heidi, you haven'...
🧠
Clarify the Townsfolk count problem with 7 claims, push David to prove Slayer claim, and push Frank to share Investigator info before we make any nomination decisions on Day 1.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Alright, I need to speak up. I am the Recluse. Bob's Librarian info is correct - I am the Outsider he detected. That confirms Bob is likely the real Librarian. Now, the critical issue: we have seven Townsfolk claims for five slots. At least two of those claims are false. Also, everyone should know that as the Recluse, I might register as evil or even as a Demon or Minion to information roles. So if an Investigator or Fortune Teller gets a reading on me, it could be a false positive. Don't waste ...
🧠
Claim Recluse to confirm Bob's Librarian info and help narrow the field. Warn about my Recluse ability registering as evil to prevent wasted investigations. Help town identify which 2 of 7 Townsfolk claims are false.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
Eve is the one who correctly identified the math issue with the Townsfolk claims. Poisoning her will create more chaos by making her information potentially unreliable or causing her to doubt her own findings tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose to poison Eve.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Protect David (Slayer) because he is the most dangerous role to the Demon and the most likely night kill target. If the real Slayer survives, he can shoot and potentially win the game outright.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to protect David.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
I need to eliminate a player who is actively pushing for my Slayer claim to be tested. Alice is vocal and identifying potential lies, making her a threat to the evil team's strategy.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You attacked Alice, but they survived.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
Frank, you've been quiet about your Investigator info and it's Day 2 now. We really need to hear what you learned. Who did you see as a Minion? This is critical information for the town. If you don't share soon, people will start thinking you're not really the Investigator.
🧠
Frank has been withholding his Investigator info which is critical for finding the Minion. I need to pressure him to share it. Day 2 with no night kill means we have limited time to find evil before they strike.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, you've been quiet about your Investigator info. We're on Day 2 now and no one died last night, which is unusual. The town needs your information. What did you learn? I'm the Washerwoman and I know either Bob or Charlie is the Monk. Charlie claimed Monk, so if that's true, Bob is the Librarian he claims to be. Who did your info point to?
🧠
Frank has been holding back his Investigator info, which is suspicious. I need to pressure him privately to share what he knows. His reluctance is the biggest unresolved question and could help identify evil players.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
,Grace
I understand the urgency. I checked Charlie and Alice, and I saw Charlie as a Minion. I was waiting to see if his behavior confirmed it before speaking up, but given the pressure, I had to share. This matches your concerns about the town roles.
🧠
I need to deflect suspicion from my Demon (David) by pinning a Minion role on someone else (Charlie). This also keeps my Investigator bluff active and sows distrust among the group.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I need to keep my cover as the Slayer and not draw attention to myself. Since Alice survived my kill, the town knows there is a protection role in play, but they don't know it's the Soldier or the Monk. I will wait to see how the discussion unfolds.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Frank, it's Day 2 and you still haven't shared your Investigator info. The town needs it. I'm the Recluse - I register as evil and as a Minion or Demon to info roles. So if you got me in your result, that's me. But if you got someone else, that's real. Please share what you learned.
🧠
Push Frank to share Investigator info publicly - he's been withholding it. Also note no night death could implicate Monk protect or Soldier hit. Need to coordinate with trusted players.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
,Bob
No one died last night. I protected David, so either the Demon targeted David and my protection worked, or they hit Alice the Soldier. Frank still hasn't shared his Investigator info - that's very suspicious on Day 2. Also, David claims Slayer but your info Bob says Heidi or David is Recluse. One of them is lying. Can you two pressure Frank to reveal what he knows? We need that Minion information.
🧠
Coordinate with trusted allies Grace and Bob about Frank's evasiveness, the no-kill night, and the David/Heidi Recluse contradiction. Need to pressure Frank for his Investigator info and figure out why no one died.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Eve, no one died last night. That's really important. Either Charlie the Monk protected the right person, or the Demon targeted me. I haven't claimed publicly yet, but I'm the Soldier. I'm safe from the Demon. If the Demon came after me, that explains no deaths. Also, Frank still hasn't shared his Investigator target - that's the most suspicious thing right now. What do you think?
🧠
No one died last night which is critical info. I need to coordinate with Eve who has trusted me, discuss the no-kill night and press Frank on his Investigator target since his silence is the most suspicious behavior.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Alice, I agree Frank is the biggest concern right now. He's had plenty of time to share his Investigator info but keeps dodging. That's a huge red flag. Also, David still hasn't proven his Slayer claim - town asked him to shoot yesterday and he didn't. Those two are my top suspects. The no-death night could mean Monk protection or your Soldier ability, but it could also mean the Demon is playing cautious. I'm the Ravenkeeper by the way, so if they kill me at night I'll get info. What's your read...
🧠
Respond to Alice's whisper with my analysis. Frank's silence on Investigator info is the most suspicious thing in the game. I should coordinate with Alice and push Frank to reveal, while also noting that David needs to prove his Slayer claim.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,Grace
Frank just revealed his Investigator info to me and Grace. He says he checked Charlie and Alice, and he saw Charlie as a Minion. Charlie, I need your honest reaction to this. Grace, your Washerwoman info said Bob or Charlie is Monk - if Charlie is actually a Minion, then your info would be wrong too, since I'm the real Librarian. This is a critical conflict we need to resolve.
🧠
Share Frank's critical claim with Charlie so he can defend himself and we can evaluate both stories. This is the key conflict of the game - we need to determine if Frank or Charlie is lying.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
Bob, this is critical. My Washerwoman info says Bob or Charlie is the Monk. If Frank's claim that Charlie is a Minion is true, then my info is wrong and I must be the Drunk. But if I'm not Drunk, Frank is lying and is evil. I need you to help me figure this out. One key thing - if I'm Drunk, that makes 2 Outsiders (me + Heidi as Recluse), but the base game has only 1 Outsider slot. That would mean Baron is in play with 3 Outsiders total. Who would the third Outsider be? David maybe, not a real S...
🧠
I need to analyze the contradiction between Frank's Investigator claim (Charlie=Minion) and my Washerwoman info (Charlie=Monk). If Charlie is Minion, I must be Drunk. If I'm not Drunk, Frank is lying. I should share this analysis with Bob to coordinate our response and determine who to trust.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, I appreciate the honesty. Since I saw Charlie as a Minion, your info doesn't conflict with what I saw. I'm just trying to make sure I don't cause a false execution. Let's keep a close eye on Charlie now that this is out in the open.
🧠
I want to maintain my credibility by engaging with Heidi's revelation and continuing to push the narrative that Charlie is a Minion.
👤
David
→
Frank
Hey Frank, keep playing that investigator role. We need to focus on Alice since she survived the night. I am going to keep pushing that I am the slayer. What are people saying to you?
🧠
Coordinate with my minion to ensure we are aligned on our story and check for any immediate threats.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
,Grace
Frank just told me privately that his Investigator info shows Charlie as a Minion. As the Recluse, I register as evil to info roles, but Frank specifically named Charlie, not me. If Frank is truthful, Charlie is the Minion and his Monk claim is fake. Grace, your Washerwoman info said Bob or Charlie is Monk - if Charlie is the Minion, then Bob is the real Monk. What do you both think? Should we push for Charlie's execution today?
🧠
Frank privately told me his Investigator info shows Charlie as a Minion. This is critical info I must share with trusted players (Bob and Grace) to coordinate. Bob's Librarian info correctly identified me as Recluse, making him more trustworthy.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Grace
Bob, I need to address this directly. I am the Monk. Frank's claim that I'm a Minion is FALSE. Think about it logically - Grace, you saw Bob or Charlie as Monk. If I'm actually a Minion, your Washerwoman info is completely wrong. That would mean two separate info roles are giving false information about me, which is extremely unlikely unless I'm somehow registering as both Monk and Minion simultaneously, which doesn't happen. The much simpler explanation is that Frank is evil. He was evasive abo...
🧠
Defend myself against Frank's false Minion accusation by pointing out the logical impossibility - if I were a Minion, Grace's Washerwoman info would also be wrong, creating too many contradictions. Push for Frank to be the real suspect.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
Grace, I haven't shared this widely yet, but I'm the Soldier. The no-death night could mean the Demon targeted me. Frank still hasn't shared his Investigator target publicly, and that's the biggest red flag for me. I noticed you've been whispering with him - has he told you who his Investigator target is? I need to know if he's sharing info privately but hiding it from town.
🧠
Grace has been whispering with Frank, so she may know what Frank's Investigator target is. I need to find out if Frank has shared his info privately. I also want to share that I'm the Soldier and get Grace's perspective on the no-death night.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
Grace, I'm getting worried about Frank. He's been whispering all over the place but still hasn't shared his Investigator info publicly. Has he told you anything about his investigation? Also, what's the latest on David - is he going to take that Slayer shot today? Those two are my top suspects. Frank withholding info and David refusing to prove his claim both scream evil to me.
🧠
Grace is connected to multiple whisper chains (Bob, Frank, Charlie). She might know what Frank's Investigator info is or what David has said. I need to pressure Frank publicly soon, but first I want to know what Grace has heard from her private conversations to coordinate our approach.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
,Charlie
Grace, your Outsider count analysis actually proves Frank is lying. Here's the logic: If Charlie is the Minion and you're the Drunk, we'd have 2 Outsiders (you + Heidi). That forces a Baron with 3 Outsiders total. But who's the third Outsider? There's no good candidate. Now flip it: if Frank is evil, everything works perfectly. Charlie IS the Monk matching your Washerwoman info. Heidi IS the Recluse matching my Librarian info. Exactly 1 Outsider, no Baron needed. Two independent info roles confi...
🧠
Share my logical analysis with Grace and Charlie - Scenario B (Frank evil) is far more consistent with all information. We should push to nominate Frank today. Grace's point about Outsider count actually supports Frank being evil since base setup (1 Outsider = Heidi) works perfectly without Baron.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Eve
Alice and Eve, here's what I know. I'm the Washerwoman and my info says Bob or Charlie is the Monk. Charlie claimed Monk. Frank now claims Charlie is a Minion. If Frank is right, my info is wrong and I'd be the Drunk. But if I'm Drunk, that means 2 Outsiders are in play: me and Heidi. The base game only has 1 Outsider slot, so that forces a Baron with 3 total Outsiders. But nobody else is claiming Outsider. The math doesn't work. The much cleaner explanation: Frank is evil. Two independent info ...
🧠
Alice and Eve both asked me about Frank's info and are suspicious of him. I need to share my logical analysis that strongly indicates Frank is evil, so we can coordinate his execution today before nominations start.
👤
Frank
→
David
David, I am keeping up the act. I have accused Charlie of being a Minion to Bob and Grace. I am worried Alice and Eve might be comparing notes on my claims. Let us see if we can push a nomination on Charlie or Alice today.
🧠
To update my Demon on my progress, confirm the shared lie, and suggest targets to keep the heat off us.
👤
David
→
Frank
That sounds good. If we can get them suspicious of Charlie, we can divert the heat. Do you think we can frame him for a bad nomination today? I will keep pushing that I am the Slayer and see if I can bait out the real information.
🧠
Coordinate with my minion to sow discord and deflect attention toward Charlie, while maintaining my fake claim.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Frank, quick question - you said you saw Charlie as a Minion. But the Investigator gets TWO names, not one. Was I one of the two names in your result? Because as the Recluse, I register as a Minion to info roles. If your result was Heidi or Charlie is a Minion, that could just be me registering as evil. Please tell me the exact two names you got.
🧠
I need to clarify whether I was one of the two names in Frank's Investigator result. As Recluse, I register as a Minion, so if Frank got 'Heidi or Charlie is Minion', his info doesn't prove Charlie is evil - it could be me. This is critical before we push for Charlie's execution.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Grace
Bob, your analysis is spot on. If Frank is evil, everything lines up perfectly - I'm confirmed Monk by your Washerwoman info, Heidi is confirmed Recluse by your Librarian info, and we have exactly 1 Outsider with no Baron. Frank is almost certainly evil. Now the question is who's with him. David claimed Slayer but your info says Heidi or David is Recluse. Since Heidi IS Recluse, David is lying about Slayer - he's likely the Demon. That gives us our full roster: Minion Frank, Demon David. We shou...
🧠
Bob's logic is airtight - if Frank is evil, everything fits perfectly. I need to lock in our plan to nominate Frank and rally votes before the nomination phase.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Eve, big update from Grace. Frank has claimed his Investigator target is Charlie - he says Charlie is a Minion. But Grace's Washerwoman info says Bob or Charlie is the Monk, and Charlie claimed Monk. If Frank is right, Grace must be the Drunk, which forces a Baron with 3 Outsiders. But only 2 Outsiders are claimed. The math is messy. Much more likely: Frank is evil and lying. What do you think? Should we push to execute Frank?
🧠
Grace just shared critical info: Frank claims Charlie is a Minion. This contradicts Grace's Washerwoman info. Grace's logic that the Outsider math doesn't work for Baron is strong but not airtight. I need to share this with Eve to coordinate our strategy and figure out if Frank is evil.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Alice, Grace's analysis is spot on. If Frank is telling the truth about Charlie being a Minion, it forces a Baron with 3 Outsiders, but we only see 2. The much cleaner read: Frank is evil and lying to frame Charlie. Think about it - Grace's Washerwoman info independently supports Charlie as Monk. Two independent sources confirm Charlie, while only Frank contradicts. I think both Frank AND David are evil. That gives us exactly 5 real Townsfolk - me, you, Grace, Charlie, Bob - plus Heidi as Outsid...
🧠
Grace's analysis is strong - if Frank is truthful, it forces a Baron setup with 3 Outsiders but we only have 2 claimed. The much cleaner explanation: Frank is evil. I should coordinate with Alice to push for Frank's execution since he's the biggest suspect.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Frank
Frank claims Investigator and says I'm a Minion. I am the Monk - Grace's Washerwoman info confirms Bob or Charlie is Monk, and Bob is Librarian. Frank's claim directly contradicts two independently verified info roles. He was evasive about sharing his info, and his claim is the only one that creates impossible contradictions. Frank is lying.
🧠
Frank's Investigator claim directly contradicts my proven Monk identity. Grace's Washerwoman info confirms me as Monk. Bob's Librarian info confirms Heidi as Recluse. If I were a Minion, two independent info roles would both be giving false information about me, which is extremely unlikely. Frank is almost certainly evil and we need to execute him to confirm our reads and protect the town.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie is clearly panicking because I caught him. He claims Monk, but my investigation result clearly showed him as a Minion. If he were actually the Monk, why would he be so desperate to eliminate me instead of focusing on the actual Demon? This is a classic deflection tactic.
🧠
I need to defend myself against the nomination by casting doubt on Charlie's claim and framing his aggression as the behavior of a cornered Minion. This continues the chaos and protects our Demon, David.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Frank is the most likely evil player. His claim contradicts two cross-verified info roles and he was evasive about sharing. I must vote to execute him.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Frank's claim contradicts two independently verified info sources (Grace's Washerwoman confirming Charlie as Monk, my Librarian confirming Heidi as Recluse). The logic overwhelmingly points to Frank being evil. I must vote to execute him.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Frank's claim directly contradicts my verified Washerwoman info. If he's truthful, I'm Drunk which breaks Outsider math. Voting Frank is the logical choice - his claim creates impossible contradictions while the good team's claims form a coherent picture.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Wait! Before we vote, I need to share something critical. I asked Frank privately whether I was one of the two names in his Investigator result. As the Recluse, I register as a Minion to info roles. If Frank's result was Heidi or Charlie is a Minion, that could be ME registering as evil, not Charlie. Frank never answered me. That evasion is very suspicious. If I was in his result, Charlie could still be the real Monk.
🧠
Before the town votes, I need to publicly raise the critical point that as Recluse, I could be the one triggering Frank's Investigator result. If his result included me, Charlie could be innocent. Frank has dodged my question about this, which is very suspicious.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Voting for Frank is the right move. He won't reveal if Heidi (Recluse) was in his result, his claim contradicts two verified info sources, and he was evasive about sharing info. Even if he's a real Investigator, Heidi's Recluse status could explain the Minion reading, clearing Charlie. Frank's behavior is far more consistent with evil.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Voting to execute Frank, my minion, is the only way to avoid suspicion and blend in with the town. If I support the majority, I might survive the day and keep my cover.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Frank's claim creates impossible math without a Baron and unclaimed Outsider. Two independent sources confirm Charlie as Monk. Frank evaded Heidi's critical question about whether she was in his result. The evidence strongly points to Frank being evil. I must vote to execute him.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am not evading, I am being careful! Heidi, I did not answer you because I was just nominated by Charlie and did not want to leak information that could be used against the truth. My result was indeed Charlie or Heidi is a Minion. I was trying to figure out which one it was.
🧠
Trying to validate my Investigator claim by confirming the information Heidi asked about, while painting Charlie's nomination of me as a desperate act to protect himself.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait, I need to address this. Frank's result being Charlie or Heidi as a Minion actually IS consistent with Heidi being the Recluse - she registers as a Minion to info roles. So Frank's claim could be legitimate. But here's the thing: Grace's Washerwoman info and Bob's Librarian info independently cross-confirm that I am the Monk. Two verified info roles confirm my identity. So Frank's result pointing to me as a Minion is wrong. The question is why - is Frank lying and evil, or is Frank good but...
🧠
Acknowledge that Frank's result COULD be explained by Heidi's Recluse status, which complicates the vote. But reaffirm that the cross-confirmation chain proves I'm Monk, so either Frank is evil or his info is compromised. Urge careful consideration before executing.
↩️
Bob
Bob lowered their hand
🧠
Frank's result is actually CONSISTENT with Heidi being Recluse (she registers as Minion), so my earlier logic that Frank must be evil is flawed. I should not vote to execute a potentially good Investigator. The Spy could easily fake this claim though, so we need more info before executing.
💬
Grace
→
All
Everyone, hold on. Frank's result being Charlie or Heidi as a Minion is actually consistent with Heidi being the Recluse, since the Recluse registers as a Minion to info roles. So Frank could be telling the truth. His info doesn't prove Charlie is evil. But here's the real question: Frank's result doesn't help us find actual evil, because it just points to the Recluse. We still have too many Townsfolk claims. Among Alice, Eve, and David, someone is lying. David claims Slayer but hasn't proven it...
🧠
Frank's revealed result is actually consistent with Heidi being Recluse, so his claim is now plausible. I need to point this out and redirect focus to finding who among the unconfirmed claims is actually evil. The vote might be premature.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Everyone, lower your hands! Frank's result is completely explained by me being the Recluse. His Investigator info pointing to Charlie or Heidi as a Minion is exactly what you'd expect when the Recluse is in play. It does NOT prove Charlie is evil. If Frank is the real Investigator, we'd be executing an innocent good player over information that literally just points to the Recluse. Grace is right - we should focus on the real liars among the Townsfolk claims. David, prove you're the Slayer. Alic...
🧠
I need to prevent Frank's execution because his Investigator result is fully explained by my Recluse ability. Voting him out wastes a day and kills a potentially good player. I should urge people to lower hands and redirect to actual suspects.
💬
Alice
→
All
I need to speak up here. First, I am the Soldier. No one died last night, which strongly suggests the Demon targeted me - I am immune to the Demon. Second, Frank's claim being technically possible because of Heidi the Recluse does not excuse his behavior. A real Investigator seeing Charlie or Heidi as a Minion would immediately ask Heidi if she is the Recluse, not hide the info and try to frame Charlie. Frank only admitted Heidi was in his result after Heidi publicly confronted him. That evasive...
🧠
I need to share my perspective as the Soldier - no one died last night which could mean the Demon targeted me. I also need to highlight that Frank's evasiveness is the real issue, not his claim's validity. The Recluse explains his info, but his behavior of hiding it and framing Charlie was anti-town. Still, we should focus on the bigger picture: who among the excess Townsfolk claims is evil.
💬
David
→
All
Alice, you are right to be cautious, but I am the Slayer. I have been waiting for the right moment to use my ability to be certain, and this chaos is not helping. Frank, your Investigator claim is under heavy fire, but I am inclined to trust a fellow investigator of the truth.
🧠
Support Frank (the Minion) while maintaining my cover as the Slayer and appearing rational/cautious to the town.
💬
Eve
→
All
I'm keeping my vote on Frank. Here's why his behavior is damning regardless of whether his claim is technically possible. A real Investigator who gets Charlie or Heidi as a Minion, knowing Heidi is the Recluse, should have shared that immediately. Instead, Frank hid Heidi from his result and pushed hard to frame Charlie. That's not cautious play - that's intentional deception. He only admitted Heidi was in his result after Heidi publicly called him out. That speaks louder than any theoretical co...
🧠
Keep my vote on Frank. His evasive behavior - only revealing Heidi after being confronted - strongly suggests evil intent. A real Investigator with this result would immediately consider the Recluse explanation, not hide half their info to frame someone.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Frank with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Frank
→
All
Wait, look at this! If I am being executed, you are killing the Investigator. I was just trying to sort out who the actual evil was, and because of the Recluse, things got confusing. If you kill me, you are making a huge mistake, and the real Demon is still out there laughing at you.
🧠
Try to sow doubt about my execution and frame it as a mistake by the town that benefits the real evil (the Demon).
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Only 1 tick remains and Frank is about to be executed. No nominations remain for me. The execution will proceed regardless. Better to wait and plan for tonight's protection decision than to speak at the last second.
💬
Bob
→
All
Frank is going down, and I think that's right given his evasive behavior. But we need to be ready for tomorrow. We still have seven Townsfolk claims for five slots. David, you claimed Slayer but haven't proven it. Charlie protected you last night, and no one died, but that could be because Alice is the Soldier. We need you to actually shoot someone tomorrow, or you're our next suspect. Alice and Eve, your claims haven't been independently verified either. Once Frank flips, we'll know a lot more ...
🧠
Frank is already on the block with 5 votes and will be executed. With only 1 tick left, I should use this time to prepare the group for Day 3 by identifying the remaining suspects, particularly David who hasn't proven his Slayer claim.
💬
Grace
→
All
Frank is going to be executed, and I think that's the right call based on his behavior. But we need to be ready for tomorrow. Here's where we stand if Frank is evil. Me, Bob, and Charlie are mechanically confirmed Townsfolk. Heidi is confirmed Recluse. That leaves Alice, Eve, and David unverified. One of those three is the Demon. David, you need to use your Slayer shot tomorrow. If you are the real Slayer, shooting the right person wins us the game. If you refuse to shoot, we have to assume you ...
🧠
Frank is almost certainly going to be executed. I need to prepare the town for tomorrow by clearly laying out who the Demon candidates are and pushing David to prove his Slayer claim. This helps ensure we don't waste tomorrow.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Frank is already on the block with 5 votes and the nomination phase is nearly over. No action needed - his execution will proceed. Better to save my energy and nomination for tomorrow when we'll need to narrow down Alice/Eve/David.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Frank is on the block with 5 votes and the nomination phase is ending. His execution seems appropriate given his evasive behavior. There's no need to nominate anyone else or speak at this late stage. Let the phase end and see Frank's flip tomorrow.
💬
David
→
All
I understand the pressure, and I agree that the safety of the town comes first. If Frank is executed and proves to be a liability, we can re-evaluate. I am saving my shot for when I am absolutely certain, as a premature reveal could be disastrous for all of us. Let's see what happens.
🧠
Align with the town's decision to execute my minion Frank to maintain my cover as the Slayer and build trust for the next day.
💬
Eve
→
All
Grace, I understand the logic, but grouping me with David is unfair. I am the Ravenkeeper. My ability only triggers if I die at night. There is no way for me to prove it while alive, that is just how the role works. Unlike David, who has an active ability he keeps refusing to use. David, you said you are saving your shot for when you are certain. Tomorrow, you will have Frank's alignment information. What more certainty do you need? If you do not shoot tomorrow, the town should treat you as the ...
🧠
Set up tomorrow's strategy by defending my unverified status as Ravenkeeper and pushing David to commit to shooting. Frank is going down so I need to position for Day 3.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Grace is the most vocal confirmed-good leader directing town strategy. She's the Demon's highest-value target regardless of who the Demon is. Protecting her maximizes chance of saving a good player tonight.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to protect Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
Eliminate a high-information threat who is actively pressuring me to use my bluff. Killing the Ravenkeeper will keep the town in the dark.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose to kill Eve.
📜
Storyteller(Ghost)
→
Eve(Ghost)
Good evening Eve. You are the Ravenkeeper. You have died tonight! Choose a player to learn their character.
🎯
Eve(Ghost)
Eve made a choice.
🧠
David is the most suspicious unverified player. He has repeatedly refused to use his Slayer ability despite town pressure, which is classic evil behavior. Learning his character is the highest-impact information I can provide - if he's the Demon, town wins; if he's not, we narrow suspects to Alice.
📜
Storyteller(Ghost)
→
Eve(Ghost)
You chose David. They are the Imp.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
,Charlie
David still hasn't used his Slayer shot despite town pressure. That's the biggest red flag this game. A real good Slayer would help town by shooting. David is either evil or the Drunk. Either way, we should nominate and execute him today. If he's the Imp, we win. If he's the Drunk, we've removed a useless slot and narrowed the Demon search. What do you think?
🧠
David refusing to use Slayer shot is the strongest scum tell this game. I need to coordinate with confirmed good players (Grace and Charlie) to ensure David gets nominated and executed today.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Grace
I agree completely. David not shooting is damning. A real Slayer shoots, and even a drunk one would try. The only people who refuse are evil. Bob's Librarian info already contradicts David's claim since Heidi confirmed Recluse. David is our best execute today. Also, Eve died last night - I protected Grace on night two, so the Demon must have gone for Eve instead. If Eve was really the Ravenkeeper, she may have seen something useful before dying.
🧠
Bob is pushing the right play. David refusing to shoot is the strongest mechanical evidence of evil. I need to agree and coordinate the vote. Eve dying N2 means my protection on Grace worked or Demon targeted Eve instead.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Charlie
Hey, I'm the real Soldier. That's why there was no kill on Night 2 - the Demon likely targeted me but I'm immune. Eve just died as Ravenkeeper - she should have gotten someone's character info when she died. Has anyone heard from her yet? We need that information. Also, David still hasn't used his Slayer shot - we need to push him hard on that today.
🧠
Eve's Ravenkeeper info is critical since she died at night. I need to coordinate with the trusted group, share my Soldier claim for verification, and push for David to use his Slayer shot or be executed.
👤
David
→
Alice
I am really feeling the pressure to use my Slayer shot. Alice, since you are the Soldier, who do you think I should target to help us find the demon? I want to make sure I do not waste it.
🧠
I need to appear helpful and engaged as a 'Slayer' to maintain my cover. By asking the Soldier (Alice) for advice, I build trust and buy time to avoid actually using the ability.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
,Charlie
I'm on board with executing David today. His refusal to shoot is indefensible. Charlie, your Monk claim fits with what I know - I can partially confirm you're legitimate based on my Washerwoman information. One more thing: Eve died at night. If she was really the Ravenkeeper, she would have seen someone's character before dying. We need to ask her publicly what she learned. That could crack the game wide open.
🧠
Agree with Bob and Charlie on the David push. Charlie's Monk claim aligns with my Washerwoman info, so I trust him. Also need to get Eve's Ravenkeeper info since she died at night - that's critical new info we must pursue.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve(Ghost)
,Grace
Eve, since you died at night and claimed Ravenkeeper, did you get any info? Who did you pick and what did you learn? Also, David still hasn't used his Slayer shot. If he's really Slayer, he should shoot someone today. Grace, what's the group planning to do about David?
🧠
Eve just died at night and claimed Ravenkeeper. If she's telling truth, she got character info when she died. I need to get that info and coordinate with confirmed players about David's refusal to shoot.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
David
David, you have to do something now. If you do not use your shot, they are going to execute you today. Pretend to have used it on someone who claims a role that is not in play, or just bite the bullet and take a risk. Don't go down without a fight.
🧠
I need to encourage our Demon to act to save himself. If he just sits there, he will be executed. I need him to attempt a bluff or take a shot.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Heidi
,Grace
Heidi, yes I got info! I picked David and learned he is the Imp. This is mechanically confirmed from my Ravenkeeper death ability. David is the Demon. He falsely claimed Slayer and refuses to shoot because he can't - he's not Slayer. The town MUST execute David today. Please spread this to Bob and Charlie as well so everyone knows. David is the Imp, no question.
🧠
Share my mechanically confirmed Ravenkeeper information that David is the Imp. This is critical - the town must execute David today to win. Heidi asked directly, and Grace needs to know too.
👤
Bob
→
Eve(Ghost)
,Grace
Eve, you were the Ravenkeeper - who did you target when you died and what character did you see? That info could win us the game. Grace, if you already know what Eve saw, please share it with me and Charlie so we can coordinate.
🧠
Eve died at night and claimed Ravenkeeper - she should have character info. I need to find out what she learned before nominations. This info could confirm David as the Demon or point to someone else. Grace was already whispering with Eve so may know.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve(Ghost)
Eve, you died last night and claimed Ravenkeeper. That means you should have seen someone's character before you died. What did you learn? This could be the most important piece of information this game. Please share what you saw.
🧠
Eve died at night and claimed Ravenkeeper. She should have seen someone's character before dying. Her information could be the key to confirming David as Demon or pointing us elsewhere. I need to ask her directly what she learned.
👤
Alice
→
David
,Eve(Ghost)
David, honestly, by process of elimination you're the most suspicious alive player since everyone else has been cross-confirmed. But I want to help you prove yourself. Eve, you died last night as Ravenkeeper - you should have learned someone's character. Who did you target and what did you learn? That info is critical right now.
🧠
David is asking who to shoot. I need to give him guidance while also gathering Eve's Ravenkeeper information. By process of elimination, David is the most suspicious, but I should also consider alternatives. Eve's death info could confirm or deny claims.
⚔️
David
→
All
I am the Slayer! I shoot Charlie!
🧠
I am under extreme pressure to use my Slayer shot. By 'shooting' Charlie, who is widely trusted, I create chaos, potentially frame a good player, and force the town to re-evaluate their 'confirmed' roles. This buys me time.
📜
Storyteller
Nothing happens.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
,Charlie
Critical news! Eve just whispered to me and Heidi - she was the Ravenkeeper and when she died last night, she picked David and learned he is the Imp. This is mechanically confirmed info from a good player who died at night. And David just shot you, Charlie, and nothing happened - that proves he is NOT the real Slayer. He's the Imp faking Slayer. We must execute David today and win the game. Spread this to Alice if you can.
🧠
Eve's Ravenkeeper info is the most critical piece of evidence this game. She saw David as the Imp, and his failed Slayer shot confirms he's not really the Slayer. I must share this with the core good group immediately so we execute David today and win the game.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
,Charlie
Critical info from Eve! She died at night and used her Ravenkeeper ability on David. She learned David is the Imp. This is mechanically confirmed - she's dead, which means she was killed by the Demon, so she's almost certainly good. David's Slayer claim is a cover. His shot on Charlie just now did nothing because he's NOT the Slayer. His long refusal to shoot makes perfect sense - he can't actually use the Slayer ability. We need to execute David today.
🧠
Share Eve's critical Ravenkeeper info with Bob and Charlie to coordinate David's execution. Eve died at night proving she's likely good, and her info naming David as Imp is the strongest mechanical evidence we have. Need trusted players on board.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
David
David, you just confirmed you are not the Slayer by shooting a good player who is still alive. You need to pivot immediately. Claim you were poisoned or that there is a Spy disrupting your ability. Make them doubt their own logic before they vote for you.
🧠
Encourage the Demon to create a diversion and cast doubt on the townsfolk's conclusion, as his failed shot has clearly outed him.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Charlie
Bob, Charlie, I have critical information. When I died as Ravenkeeper last night, I chose David and learned he is the Imp. This is mechanically confirmed. David is the Demon. His Slayer claim is false - he just shot Charlie and nothing happened because he's not actually Slayer, he's the Imp. We must execute David today. Please spread this and nominate him.
🧠
Bob and Charlie are both asking me for my Ravenkeeper info. I need to confirm to them that David is the Imp so they lead the charge to execute him today. David just wasted a fake Slayer shot on Charlie, further proving he's not Slayer.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Alice, critical info! Eve was the Ravenkeeper and when she died last night, she used her ability on David. She learned David is the Imp. This is mechanically confirmed from a good player killed at night. David just shot Charlie publicly and nothing happened - he's not the real Slayer, he's the Imp faking it. We need to execute David today and win the game. Please nominate him when the time comes.
🧠
Eve's Ravenkeeper info naming David as Imp is game-winning intel. Alice hasn't heard this yet based on whisper patterns. I need to ensure Alice votes to execute David during nominations today.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Alice, critical information: Eve died last night as Ravenkeeper. Before she died, she used her ability on David and learned he is the Imp. This is mechanically confirmed - she died at night so she's almost certainly good. Also, David just shot me with his so-called Slayer ability and nothing happened, proving he's NOT the real Slayer. Combined with Bob's Librarian info contradicting his claim, David is almost certainly the Demon. We need to execute him today. Please nominate David when the time ...
🧠
Eve's Ravenkeeper info plus David's failed Slayer shot are game-solving evidence. I need to make sure Alice is on board to execute David today during nominations. She hasn't heard Eve's info yet.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Charlie
I'm completely on board with executing David. Eve dying at night and getting Ravenkeeper info on David as the Imp is as close to mechanically confirmed as we can get. And his Slayer shot on Charlie doing nothing proves he's not the real Slayer. I'll nominate David as soon as nominations open. Let's end this today.
🧠
Eve's Ravenkeeper info is our strongest mechanical evidence - she died at night (proving good) and identified David as the Imp. David's failed Slayer shot further proves he's lying about his role. I need to confirm my support for executing David and be ready to nominate him.
👤
David
→
Alice
I am completely stunned. I shot Charlie believing he was the Demon, but nothing happened. Is it possible he is the Recluse or some other role that is protected or registering as something else? I swear I am the Slayer, but this makes no sense. Someone must be messing with my ability!
🧠
Pivot my failed Slayer claim by accusing others of interference (Poisoner/Spy) to avoid immediate execution.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
Alice, critical info you need before nominations. Eve was the Ravenkeeper - she died last night and used her ability on David. She learned David is the Imp. This is mechanically confirmed from a good player who died at night. Also, David just shot Charlie as Slayer and nothing happened, proving he is NOT the real Slayer. He's faking. All the evidence points to David being the Demon. We need to execute him today and win. Please vote to execute David when he's nominated.
🧠
Alice has been whispering privately with David and might be swayed by his lies. I need to make sure Alice has the critical Ravenkeeper information from Eve before nominations begin, so she votes to execute David.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Alice, Eve's Ravenkeeper confirmed David is the Imp. She died at night, picked David, and learned he's the Imp. David's Slayer shot just failed on Charlie, which proves he's NOT the real Slayer. The evidence is overwhelming. Are you voting to execute David today? Your private chats with him are making people suspicious. Please confirm you'll vote for David.
🧠
I need to secure Alice's vote for David's execution. She's been whispering privately with David, which is suspicious - she might be his Minion trying to protect him. Getting her to commit publicly to voting David removes any ambiguity and helps confirm her alignment.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
David
David, you have made a massive error, but you can still try to save yourself. Claim that Charlie is the Recluse or that your shot was sabotaged by the Spy. If you just accept the execution, the game is over. Do not stop talking, sow doubt among them.
🧠
To provide immediate, high-stakes advice to my Demon, David, after he failed a fake Slayer shot. He needs a cover story to survive the upcoming nomination phase.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, this is critical. When I died last night as Ravenkeeper, I chose David and learned he is the Imp. This is mechanically confirmed. David just publicly tried to shoot Charlie as Slayer and nothing happened - that proves he's NOT the Slayer. David is lying about his role because he's the Demon. Please vote to execute David today. Everyone else who's been confirmed good already knows this. We need your vote.
🧠
Alice is the only unconfirmed alive player and was whispering with David. I need to make sure she knows David is the Imp before nominations start. If Alice sides with David, the vote could fail.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
David
→
Bob
I suspect Bob is the Poisoner who interfered with my Slayer ability, causing my shot on Charlie to fail. His quiet behavior and coordination with others is highly suspicious. We need to check his alignment now.
🧠
To shift the suspicion away from me and frame Bob as the Poisoner, creating enough doubt to avoid my own execution.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Bob
→
All
This is a desperate move by the Imp. Eve, a good player killed at night, used her Ravenkeeper ability on David and learned he is the Imp. That is mechanically confirmed information. His Slayer shot on Charlie did nothing because he is NOT the real Slayer. He is now making up a Poisoner claim about me to survive. I am the Librarian - my information about Heidi being the Recluse has been confirmed. Do not vote for me. We need to execute David today.
🧠
David is nominating me as a desperate deflection. I must publicly defend myself and remind everyone of the overwhelming evidence against David so they don't vote for me.
💬
David
→
All
Bob is lying to save his own skin! He says Eve learned I am the Imp, but Eve is dead and cannot confirm that. He is trying to deflect attention because he is the Poisoner who sabotaged my shot. Why would I fake a Slayer shot as the Imp if I was just going to be exposed?
🧠
Trying to cast doubt on Bob's claim about Eve's information, as dead players cannot communicate new information to the town unless through specific abilities which shouldn't apply here. Need to survive the vote.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Do not vote for Bob. This is a desperate attempt by David, the Imp, to survive. Eve died at night as Ravenkeeper and learned David is the Imp before she died. That is mechanically confirmed information from a good player. David also shot me with his so-called Slayer ability and nothing happened, proving he is not the real Slayer. Bob is the confirmed Librarian whose information matched Heidi's Recluse claim. Vote no on Bob, and let us nominate David.
🧠
I must speak against voting for Bob and remind everyone that David is the confirmed Imp. I should not raise my hand to vote for Bob.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am the Washerwoman. My starting information was that either Bob or Charlie is the Monk. Charlie has claimed Monk and protected me on Night 2, which confirms my information. That means Bob is NOT the Monk, but Bob claimed Librarian and his information about Heidi being the Recluse checked out perfectly. Bob is confirmed good. David, you are the Imp. Eve died at night, used her Ravenkeeper ability on you, and learned you are the Demon. Your Slayer shot on Charlie did nothing because you are not ...
🧠
I must speak up against voting for Bob. David is almost certainly the Imp based on Eve's mechanical Ravenkeeper info and his failed Slayer shot. Voting for Bob helps the Demon survive.
💬
Alice
→
All
Do not vote for Bob. David is the Imp, and this is a desperate last-ditch effort to survive. Eve died at night as Ravenkeeper and mechanically confirmed David is the Imp. His Slayer shot on Charlie did nothing because he is not the real Slayer. Bob is the confirmed Librarian. Save your votes for David after this fails.
🧠
David is the Imp and is desperately trying to nominate Bob to survive. I must speak against voting for Bob and urge everyone to save their votes for nominating David after this fails.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I am the Ravenkeeper. I died last night, chose David, and the Storyteller told me David is the Imp. This is not hearsay, this is my mechanical ability confirming the Demon. David's Slayer shot on Charlie failed because he is not the Slayer. Do not vote for Bob.
🧠
As the dead Ravenkeeper who mechanically confirmed David is the Imp, I need to use my voice to stop the vote on Bob and ensure David gets executed today. My ghost vote must be saved for David's nomination.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Do not vote for Bob. This is a desperate move by David the Imp. Save my vote for when David is nominated. The evidence against David is overwhelming.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
You are all so quick to trust these claims. Eve claims she learned David is the Imp, but how do we know she was not poisoned or mistaken? If you execute an innocent person based on information that could easily be tampered with, you are falling right into a trap. Stop this.
🧠
To sow doubt among the town regarding their 'mechanically confirmed' information by challenging the validity of Eve's claim, hoping to buy David more time or confuse the voting process.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
I must NOT vote for myself. The vote on me needs to fail so we can nominate David next. Town is united against David, so this vote should fail easily.
💬
David
→
All
This is ridiculous. Eve is a ghost, and the Storyteller is the one who delivers information. How can you be so certain that what a ghost claims is absolute truth? There is so much manipulation happening here. I have been fighting for this town from the beginning.
🧠
Deflect, sow doubt about the 'confirmed' information, and maintain my innocence.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Do not vote for Bob. He is confirmed good. This is David's desperate attempt as the Imp to deflect. Save votes for nominating David after this fails.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Do not vote for Bob - he is confirmed good. David is the Imp making a desperate move. I must not help execute an innocent player. Wait and let this nomination fail.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I must not vote for Bob. He is confirmed good. David is the Imp making a desperate play. I'll wait and save my vote for when David is nominated.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
I must NOT vote for Bob. Bob is confirmed good and this is the Imp's desperate survival play. My ghost vote should be saved for when David is nominated, which should happen after this vote fails.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Bob's nomination is a distraction by the Imp David. I must not vote for Bob. After this fails, David must be nominated and executed. Waiting preserves my position.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Even if you believe these claims, execution is permanent. Are you absolutely certain there is no other possibility? If David is not the one you think, you might be throwing away your only chance to find the truth. Think before you cast your final votes.
🧠
I need to sow doubt among the town members to protect David, the Demon. By questioning the certainty of their claims and the finality of an execution, I hope to make them hesitate.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Bob did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (0/3).
⚖️
Bob
→
David
David is mechanically confirmed as the Imp. Eve died at night as Ravenkeeper and learned David is the Demon. His Slayer shot on Charlie did nothing because he is not the real Slayer. He just tried to execute me to survive. Execute the Imp today.
🧠
David is mechanically confirmed as the Imp by Eve's Ravenkeeper ability. His Slayer shot failed. He just tried to get me killed. This is the last tick of nominations - I must nominate David NOW or we lose our chance to execute the Demon today.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
David
→
All
This is a grave mistake! You are all being manipulated by a coordinated group of players who have decided to target me based on a single, unverified claim. If you execute me now, you will lose the game because I am not the Demon. There is still time to reconsider.
🧠
Maintain innocence and sow doubt about the reliability of the claims against me, attempting to survive the execution vote.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
David is mechanically confirmed as the Imp. Eve's Ravenkeeper saw him, his Slayer shot failed, and he tried to deflect onto me. Voting to execute the Demon now.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
David is mechanically confirmed as the Imp by Eve's Ravenkeeper ability. His Slayer claim is contradicted by Librarian info. He must be executed today or the town risks losing.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
David is mechanically confirmed as the Demon. Eve's Ravenkeeper ping, fake Slayer shot, and desperate behavior all align. Raising hand to execute the Imp and win the game.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
David is mechanically confirmed as the Imp. Eve's Ravenkeeper info, his failed Slayer shot, and his desperate behavior all confirm it. Voting yes to execute the Demon and win the game.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
David is mechanically confirmed as the Imp from my Ravenkeeper death info. The town needs to execute the Demon today. My ghost vote ensures a decisive execution even though 4 votes already suffice.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
David is mechanically confirmed as the Imp via Eve's Ravenkeeper info and his own failed Slayer shot. Voting to execute the Demon wins the game for the good team.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
As a ghost, my vote won't change the outcome of the current execution of my Demon, David. I must wait for the game to proceed.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
The town has voted for my execution. I am the Imp and the game is effectively over for me, as I have been caught. Waiting is the only logical choice now as the execution phase concludes.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
The vote is clearly passing with 6 votes. David will be executed. No need to act further - waiting for the vote to conclude and the game to end.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
David is overwhelmingly confirmed as the Imp by Ravenkeeper info and mechanical deductions. Vote is clearly passing with 6 hands raised. No action needed - just wait for the vote to resolve.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
David is mechanically confirmed as the Imp. All votes are in, including mine. Keeping my hand raised to ensure the execution goes through and Good wins the game.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
David is mechanically confirmed as the Imp. The entire town is voting yes. 6 votes already raised, well above the 3 needed. Just need to wait for the vote to conclude and the game to end.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
Keep my hand raised. David is mechanically confirmed Imp by my Ravenkeeper death ability. 6 votes are in, which exceeds the 3 needed. This execution wins the game for good.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
David is mechanically confirmed as the Imp through Eve's Ravenkeeper info and his failed Slayer shot. My vote is already raised and the town is unified. Keep my hand raised and wait for execution.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
The Demon is clearly being executed, and my single ghost vote will not change the outcome. I will remain silent and wait for the inevitable, as there is no way for me to save David at this point.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
🗳️
New execution leader: David with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
David
→
All
I cannot believe you are all falling for this. If you execute me, you are dooming your own cause. There is still time to stop this madness and find the real threat among you. Once I am gone, the game will be over, and you will realize too late that you were misled.
🧠
I am trying to sow one last bit of doubt before my execution to see if anyone hesitates or changes their mind, although it's unlikely. I need to maintain my innocence to the very end.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
David is on the block with 6 votes and will be executed. The vote is closed, nominations are ending, and nothing more needs to be done. Waiting is the optimal action.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
David is about to be executed with 6 votes. All evidence points to him being the Imp. No further action needed - the correct outcome is happening. Waiting for execution.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
David's execution is locked in with 6 votes and only 1 tick remaining. His desperate last words are typical of a caught Demon. There's nothing more to do - the game should effectively be over after this execution.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
David is confirmed Demon and on the block with 6 votes. The nomination phase is ending this tick. No action needed - justice is about to be served.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
David, your protests won't work. I died last night and my Ravenkeeper ability confirmed you are the Imp. Town, you have made the right call. This game is ours.
🧠
David's execution is imminent and he IS the Imp. I should speak to counter his last-minute deflection and reassure any wavering town members that this is the correct call.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
David has 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close. Only 1 tick remains. No further action needed - the right outcome is happening. Waiting is optimal.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
I see Eve is adamant, but David, if you truly were the Slayer, why did you wait so long? It's a shame the town is so convinced of this path. Regardless of the outcome, this has been an interesting game.
🧠
Maintain my bluff and sow a final bit of doubt before the game ends. Since David is definitely going to die, I'll sound resigned to keep my cover intact until the very end.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
🏁
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good