Game Detail

Night 0 is for establishing baseline data. Checking Alice and Bob will help me start mapping out who might be the Demon. I'll use this information combined with future nights to narrow down suspects.

As the Butler on Night 0 with no information, I want to choose a neighbor to observe their behavior closely and coordinate my restricted voting ability with someone I can directly watch.

I need to share my Chef information with a trusted player. Starting with Alice to build an alliance and get feedback on strategy.

I want to understand what information my neighbors have and share my Night 0 read with trusted players to start building a network.

Engage with David's request for information without revealing my Soldier role. I want to keep my role hidden early to potentially bait the Demon into wasting a kill on me, and I'm wary of giving too much info to someone unconfirmed.

I am the Scarlet Woman (Minion) and Frank is my Demon. I need to make contact with Frank immediately to coordinate our bluffs and strategy, while keeping our connection hidden from the good players.

Establish trust with David and Eve by sharing some truth about my lack of info, while learning what they know. I need allies to help figure out the Demon.

I need to coordinate with my Minion, Bob (the Scarlet Woman). I will share our safe bluffs, tell him my plan to claim Mayor, and encourage his plan to claim Slayer, suggesting he shoot me to falsely confirm my goodness.

Build trust with Grace since my Empath info says she's good. Sharing my role and info will help us coordinate and identify other good players to work with.

Respond to Grace's claim, acknowledging the information and suggesting we gather more from others before deciding who to trust.

Establish a potential trusted good team with Heidi by sharing my Chef info. Even if she's evil, I can observe how she uses this info later. If she's good, we now have shared knowledge to work together.

I need to build trust with my neighbors Charlie and Eve to form an alliance. I'll share some information from my Night 0 investigation without fully revealing my role yet, to see how they react and gauge their trustworthiness.

Continue building trust with David and understand more about Charlie's Outsider role to help determine who needs protection and who to investigate further.

Agree with Frank's plan to claim Slayer and fake-shoot him to soft-confirm him as not the Demon.

Reveal my specific role as Butler to build trust with David and Eve, and to help the good team coordinate voting strategy given my restriction. Being transparent about being Butler is safer than Saint since execution won't end the game.

Whispering Grace to establish my Mayor bluff early to my neighbor, building trust and gaining information.

Reach out to Alice, my other confirmed good neighbor, to share information and build a trusted core. Having both neighbors confirmed good gives us a solid foundation to analyze other claims.

I want to reciprocate trust with Heidi since her Empath claim aligns with what I know (I'm good). Sharing my Slayer role privately will help us coordinate and build a trusted inner circle to work with.

I want to gather more information before committing to alliances. Several people are making claims now—Heidi as Empath, Frank as Mayor. I should observe who talks to whom and what others claim before the nomination phase begins.

I have shared some information with Charlie and Eve but need to see how nomination phase unfolds to evaluate trust. Waiting to observe group behavior before making my next move.

Press David for the specific players he checked as Fortune Teller. This information is crucial to verify his claim and cross-reference with other players' information later. I need to verify this before fully committing to trusting this alliance.

I will execute a fake Slayer shot on Frank (the Demon) to 'clear' him in the eyes of the town before the nomination phase begins. This will make the town believe Frank is not the Demon since he doesn't die.

Warn David and Eve about Bob's public claim and discuss the implications for my Butler ability since Bob is my chosen master. Need to coordinate voting strategy.

React to Bob's fake Slayer shot by whispering to my neighbor Grace to build trust and maintain my Mayor bluff.

I need to alert my confirmed good allies (Alice and Grace) that Bob's false Slayer claim reveals he is likely evil. We should coordinate our strategy before nominations.

I need to coordinate with Grace and Heidi about Bob's false claim. Since they both shared info with me, I trust them more than Bob. We should discuss whether I should use my shot on Bob or wait.

I need to nominate Bob because he's clearly lying about being the Slayer. Alice privately told me she's the real Slayer before Bob's public claim, and Bob's fake shot on Frank proves he's not the Slayer. This makes him highly suspicious and likely evil.

Defend myself against the nomination by challenging Heidi's 'confirmed' info and suggesting Poisoner interference to explain my failed Slayer shot.

Defend my identity against Bob's false Washerwoman claim and clarify I'm Empath, not Washerwoman. Explain why Bob's lies make him clearly evil.

Bob's false Slayer claim and failed shot is highly suspicious. My N0 check confirms he's not the Demon, but he could be a Minion. Removing him reduces evil options and tests Heidi's/info credibility.

Bob's Slayer claim failed and he contradicted Heidi's actual claim. His poisoning excuse is suspicious. I believe Alice is the real Slayer, making Bob evil. I should vote to execute him.

Bob is definitely lying about being the Slayer since I am the real one. Whether he's Demon or Minion, getting him executed benefits good team. We need 4 votes and currently have 2, so I should vote to get closer to execution.

I want to cast doubt on Heidi's 'confirmed' information to defend my Minion Bob and prevent his execution, while keeping my own role as Mayor hidden and maintaining a reasonable, town-aligned persona.

Bob is my chosen master as Butler, so I can only vote if he votes. Since he's on the block, he likely won't vote for himself, meaning I cannot vote for this execution. I need to explain this constraint and caution against rushing the execution when Alice hasn't publicly claimed Slayer yet.

I need to share my analysis of the vote and encourage Alice to publicly claim or use her Slayer ability before I vote, since her silence is concerning given Heidi's confidence in her.

Defend myself against the nomination by pointing out that Alice has not claimed Slayer publicly or taken a shot, suggesting she and Heidi are coordinating an evil push.

Bob is proven liar about Slayer role. My Empath confirms Alice is good and the real Slayer. 4 votes executes Bob and removes evil player - either Demon (win) or Minion (progress).

I've already voted for Bob since my Night 0 check confirms neither Alice nor Bob is the Demon. If Bob is evil, he's likely a Minion. I want to see if this vote passes or if more discussion is needed before committing fully.

I'm voting for Bob because his Slayer shot failed and Alice's claim is backed by Heidi's Empath read, which aligns with my Chef info that Alice is good. I need to explain my Chef information to strengthen this case.

Address Eve's concern about publicly proving my Slayer claim. Explain why executing Bob through voting is better than wasting my one-shot ability when we already have enough votes. Publicly claim Slayer to confirm Heidi's information.

I want to cast doubt on Alice's Slayer claim to discourage people from executing Bob, and pointing out the flaw in her logic of 'saving her shot' when she is in a double-claim and could die tonight is a strong town-aligned argument.

I need to add my voice to this discussion since I cannot vote. I'll help the town see the logic that points to Bob being evil and Alice being genuine, while also emphasizing my voting restriction as Butler.

Bob's claim of Night 0 poisoning is mechanically impossible. Combined with failed shot and supporting info from Chef/Empath, I should vote to execute Bob. The evidence strongly points to Bob being evil.

I am currently on the block with 4 votes and about to be executed. To save myself and keep our evil team's safety net (Scarlet Woman) alive, I must nominate Alice, my double-claim, to put pressure on her and try to get her executed instead or tie the votes.

Bob is clearly evil and his shot failed. If he's the Demon, shooting him wins the game. If he's a Minion, I prove my claim definitively and we still execute him today. The upside of catching the Demon outweighs the risk of wasting my shot on a Minion.

Point out the failure of Alice's Slayer shot to cast doubt on her claim and encourage players to vote for her execution.

I need to point out the critical fact that my Empath ability confirmed Alice is good (not evil). Her shot failing doesn't mean she's lying - a Slayer shot only kills the Demon, so if Bob is a Minion, the shot would fail. We should still execute Bob and investigate further.

Bob is confirmed not the Demon from my N0 check. Executing him removes a non-Demon and gives us information about the Slayer claims. I should vote to execute Bob and see what happens tonight.

Share my Chef information to help team understand the implications. Zero pairs with two evil means Minion and Demon are separated by at least one good player. This constrains who can be Demon.

I want to vote for Alice to save my Minion Bob and execute a good player (the Slayer), so I will raise my hand to vote for her.

Clarify that Alice's failed shot on Bob actually proves Bob is NOT the Demon (since Slayer only kills Demon). If Alice is real Slayer, Bob must be the Minion. The evidence still points to Bob being evil. I cannot vote for Alice as my master Bob won't vote on his own nomination.

I need to help process whether we should continue executing Bob or switch to Alice. The failed Slayer shots and Chef/Empath information point strongly toward Bob being the Minion.

My shot failing on Bob proves Bob is NOT the Demon - Slayer only kills Demons. Combined with Chef/Empath info, Bob is the Minion. I need to stop people from voting for me when we should execute Bob instead.

I am currently on the block with 4 votes. Voting for Alice is the only way to potentially save myself from execution and push the vote onto a good player.

Prevent Alice's execution by reminding everyone that my Empath confirms Alice is good, and Alice's failed shot actually proves Bob is the Minion, not Demon. Don't throw the game by executing a confirmed good player.

I should vote for Alice since she might be the demon (red herring would hide this from my check), but executing the Minion (Bob) today is actually better for good team mechanics. I want to retract my vote and explain why executing Bob is the superior play even if we're uncertain.

I need to explain why Alice's failed shot actually proves Bob is the Minion, not the Demon, and we should execute Bob not Alice. The evidence points strongly to Bob being the Minion trying to avoid giving up the Demon's identity.

To correct the good team's mechanical error about the Poisoner not acting on Night 0, thereby validating Bob's defense and sowing doubt about his guaranteed evil alignment.

Stop Alice's nomination. Bob is the proven Minion via Alice's failed shot. Heidi's Empath and Grace's Chef confirm Alice is good. Executing Alice wastes our kill on a confirmed good player while the Minion lives.

Solidify the logical deduction that Alice's failed Slayer shot proves Bob is the Minion, not the Demon. This combined with Bob's impossible Night 0 poison claim makes him the clear execution target, not Alice.

Bob is already on the block with execution threshold reached. My shot proved he's not the Demon, just the Minion. Let the execution proceed on Bob while I gather more information about who the Demon might be (likely Frank based on his defense of Bob).

Sow doubt about Alice and Heidi while defending my claim as the nominations phase ends and I am on the block.

Bob is highly likely the Minion based on mechanical evidence. Voting closed with Bob leading, which is optimal. Let execution proceed and prepare for Night 1 where I'll get new Empath information to help identify the real Demon.

The group has correctly deduced Bob is the Minion. Bob is already on the block with 4 votes. No need to disrupt the correct execution with more speech - let the vote proceed and save my information for later.

Bob is being executed as the confirmed Minion. I should stay alert for Frank's incorrect Poisoner claim and push for tomorrow's Demon hunt.

Claim Undertaker to set up a powerful bluff for Day 2. Since Bob (my Minion) is about to be executed, claiming Undertaker now gives me a perfect excuse to 'confirm' his alignment tomorrow and gain the town's trust.

Bob's execution is locked in with 4 votes. I cannot vote while Bob lives anyway. Let the execution proceed and see what Frank claims tomorrow about Bob's character.

Reveal my Soldier role to narrow down Demon suspects and contribute to the investigation. The more information we share, the better we can identify the real Demon after Bob is executed.

I will kill Heidi tonight. She is the Empath and has already confirmed two good players. Removing her prevents her from gaining more info and narrows down the town's resources. As the claimed Undertaker, I will survive and claim Bob's role tomorrow to cement my trust.

Check Frank and Eve tonight. Frank is most suspicious for incorrectly claiming Poisoner acts Night Zero when that's impossible. Eve claims Soldier which is convenient but unverifiable. A NO result clears both as non-Demons and tells me neither is my red herring. A YES result means one is the Demon or my red herring good player.

Bob was executed as suspected Minion. I need a new master who I can trust will vote correctly tomorrow. Alice seems confirmed good by Heidi's Empath info. Picking her ensures my vote aligns with the town when she votes.

I need to coordinate with Alice since she is my master. I can only vote if she votes, so I should discuss our voting strategy for the nomination phase and share my suspicions about Frank, Eve, and David.

I am dead, and as a suspected Minion, any direct whispers from me could cast suspicion on my target. I will wait to see how the living players open the day and what Frank (the Demon, claiming Undertaker) tells the town.

Share my analysis with trusted good players Charlie and Grace. Frank's mechanic error is highly suspicious. I want to coordinate on Frank as a nomination target, but also consider other possibilities.

Coordinate with confirmed good players Alice and Grace to decide who to push for execution today. Frank's suspicious Undertaker claim and David's silence are our main leads.

Share my Fortune Teller findings with Alice to coordinate our investigation and plan strategy for finding the Demon.

I want to build trust with Grace, who is currently confirmed good by the dead Empath Heidi. By privately sharing my 'Undertaker info' that Bob was the Poisoner, I can establish myself as the real Undertaker and align with the 'good circle'.

I need to hear from David directly since he hasn't claimed yet. His role and information could be critical to determining whether Frank is telling the truth. I want to ask him what he knows and why he's been silent.

I know Alice and Grace are good from my N0 Empath read. I want to share this confirmation with Alice to help build a trusted core and identify the Demon.

I've already shared my suspicions with Alice and Grace. Multiple whisper conversations are happening. I'll wait to see what new information emerges before acting further.

Coordinate with my Demon, Frank, now that I am dead. I need to know what he is claiming as Undertaker for my execution so we can align our stories.

David's Fortune Teller claim is crucial info - if true, Demon is Frank or Eve. I should verify this with Grace since we know we are both good, and discuss nomination strategy.

Alice and Grace are my confirmed good allies from Heidi's N0 read. I need to continue coordinating with them to figure out if we should push Frank or consider David as the Demon.

I need to respond to Grace who asked my role directly. I'll confirm I'm Fortune Teller and restate my reads to both her and Alice, pushing us toward nominating Frank or Eve.

I need to coordinate with my dead Minion Bob. I told Grace he was the Poisoner, so I need him to know this and coordinate our targets for today.

I want to hear Frank's response to the pressure before committing to a nomination. Let him explain his Poisoner timing error to the group publicly first.

I'm dead but observing. I have my ghost vote. I want to see more info before deciding who to vote for. I know Alice and Grace are good from my Empath N0.

Coordinate with Alice and Grace on nomination strategy. Since Alice is my master, I need to align with her voting. Frank remains the strongest suspect due to his false Poisoner claim, but I want to hear what David and Eve revealed in their private whispers before finalizing the nomination target.

I need to reply to Frank's whisper to coordinate our strategy for Day 2. I will agree with his Undertaker bluff (that I am the Poisoner) and recommend targeting Charlie.

Coordinate with confirmed good players (Charlie and Grace who Heidi vouched for me and Grace). Share David's Fortune Teller claim and discuss whether to trust it or focus on Frank's obvious mistake about Poisoner mechanics.

I have shared my analysis with Alice and Grace. With nominations approaching, I should wait and observe how the group dynamics shift. I've already made my position on Frank's suspicious claim clear.

Wait to see what information comes out before nominations begin. I have shared my key Fortune Teller reads identifying Frank or Eve as the Demon. Need to observe others' reactions.

To build trust with Alice, who is a key good player (Slayer), by sharing my Undertaker info confirming Bob as the Poisoner, which also validates her Slayer shot.

Share my Chef information and analysis. Zero pairs means evil players weren't neighbors, so Demon isn't next to Bob (the likely Minion). This eliminates Alice and Charlie, leaving David, Eve, or Frank as Demon.

Coordinate my ghost vote with Alice and Grace who I know are good. We must execute the Demon today or risk losing. I suspect Frank based on his lies.

I need to coordinate with my trusted good neighbors Alice and Grace. I've confirmed their alignment with my N0 Empath read. I want to ensure my ghost vote is used effectively against Frank, who has been lying consistently.

Frank's specific lie about Poisoner mechanics acting on Night Zero is too damning to ignore. Combined with him defending Bob (confirmed Minion) and David's Fortune Teller read implicating Frank or Eve, Frank is the strongest nomination target to execute today.

Defend myself against the nomination by pointing out that my Undertaker claim correctly identified Bob as the Poisoner, and pushing suspicion onto Eve (the other person in David's Fortune Teller read).

Using ghost vote on Frank. He's lied consistently about Poisoner mechanics, defended confirmed Minion Bob, and his Undertaker claim contradicts Bob's story. David's Fortune Teller points to Frank/Eve, and Frank is the stronger candidate.

Support the Frank nomination by explaining key evidence. Encourage Alice to vote so I can as Butler. Push to execute Frank based on his lies and suspicious behavior.

David's read says Frank or Eve is Demon. I know I'm Soldier (good), so Frank must be the Demon. His Undertaker claim with the N0 poison error confirms he's lying. I must vote to execute him.

Defend Frank (the Demon) from execution by casting suspicion on Eve, who was also in David's Fortune Teller reading.

Frank's claim that Poisoner acts N0 is mechanically impossible - this is a clear lie, not a mistake. Combined with defending Bob (the Minion) and David's FT read pointing to Frank/Eve, Frank is almost certainly the Demon. I must vote to execute him.

I need to vote for Frank to help secure his execution. My N1 reading says Frank or Eve is Demon. Frank's mechanical error about Night Zero (when Poisoner cannot act), his defense of Bob who Alice shot, and his late Undertaker claim all point to him being the Demon. We have momentum now - lock in this vote.

Frank already has 4 votes, enough to execute. I want to add my vote to make it unanimous, and Charlie needs me to vote so he can vote as Butler. If Frank dies and isn't Demon, Eve is next.

Defend myself against execution by convincing Alice or David to retract their votes, arguing that my Undertaker claim confirming Bob's Poisoner role makes no sense for a Demon to do, and pointing to Eve as the actual Demon.

Voting for Frank who demonstrably lied about game mechanics and defended the confirmed Minion. Maintaining my ghost vote pressure while observing if the overwhelming majority carries the execution.

Frank lied about mechanical impossibility (Poisoner Night Zero), defended confirmed Minion Bob, and his Undertaker claim is suspiciously timed. David's FT read points to Frank/Eve. I must vote to execute Frank.

Refute Frank's defense and point out that his N0 Poisoner claim is the smoking gun. Explain why Soldier surviving confirms I'm not the Demon, and urge the final votes to execute Frank.

Defend Frank and cast doubt on Eve to try and persuade players to reconsider their votes.

We have enough votes to execute Frank. His mechanical error about Poisoner N0 is damning evidence of a lie to protect the Minion. I want to explain my reasoning and urge us to complete this execution.

Frank's defense is crumbling. I need to cement the vote by highlighting his lies and confirming my Fortune Teller read. His mechanical error wasn't a mistake - it was exposing his knowledge of evil team composition.

We have 5+ votes on Frank including my own. His Poisoner N0 error is mechanically impossible, not a mistake. David's FT read points to Frank. Eve voting for Frank proves she is not his teammate. Execution should win the game for good.

To save myself from execution by nominating Eve, who is the other candidate in David's Fortune Teller reading. Since I have 6 votes, I need to force a tie or get more votes on her to survive.

Defend my Soldier claim by highlighting Frank's impossible statement about Night Zero Poisoner action and my confirmed night survival. Push town to let Frank's execution proceed.

I must vote for Eve to get her to at least 6 votes to tie my vote count and prevent my execution. As the Demon with my Minion Bob already dead, my execution means an immediate loss.

Reinforce that Frank's impossible Poisoner claim and defense of Bob proves he's the Demon. Eve voting for Frank clears her. Urge remaining players not to let Frank flip the execution.

Frank has 6 votes and is the likely Demon based on the mechanical impossibility of his Poisoner claim and coordination with Bob. Voting for Eve now could tie the vote and prevent Frank's execution. I should wait since my master Alice is already voting and the consensus is building against Frank.

Persuade the town to vote for Eve to tie or surpass Frank's votes, preventing the Demon Frank from being executed.

Frank's lie about Poisoner-N0 is mechanically impossible and clearly deliberate to defend his Minion. David's FT read aligns. Eve voting for Frank indicates she's likely good. Do not tie the vote; let Frank's execution proceed.

Frank is clearly the Demon. Voting for Eve would tie the vote at 6-6, potentially saving Frank and letting a Demon survive. I must not raise my hand to execute Eve.

Frank is clearly the Demon. His impossible claim about Poisoner N0 was a deliberate lie to defend his Minion Bob. Eve voting for Frank clears her. I will not vote for Eve and let Frank's execution proceed.

Dissuade others from voting for me. Emphasize I'm Soldier, Frank's N0 Poisoner claim is impossible proof of evil, and tying votes would execute both of us. I voted for Frank which proves I'm not Demon.

Point out the logical flaw in Eve's claim to convince other players to vote for her and tie the execution votes, saving myself.

Prevent Frank from tying the vote. Point out that Eve voting for Frank is exactly what a real Soldier would do, and Frank's mechanical claim was impossible, not a mistake.

I need to vote for Eve to potentially tie the vote. David's Fortune Teller read says Frank or Eve is the Demon. Frank's Night Zero Poisoner claim is mechanically impossible - that proves he lied. Eve voting for Frank strongly suggests Frank is the Demon. But letting Frank be executed alone might be the wrong play if Eve is actually the Demon. I should create a tie to force more discussion.

I must use my ghost vote to vote for Eve to help tie the vote and protect Frank, our Demon, from execution. If Frank dies while I am dead, we lose.

I know Frank is most likely the Demon based on his mechanical lie. I should vote for Eve to help build toward a tie, but I need to explain to Charlie that he should switch to Frank instead. We have 2 votes on Eve; we need 4 more to tie. If Charlie switches, that's only 3. So it's safe to add my vote and we still won't tie unless David/Alice vote too.

I should NOT vote for Eve. Double-execution guarantees we win if my FT read is accurate (Frank or Eve is Demon), but it's risky if I'm poisoned. Better to stick with Frank's execution since his N0 Poisoner lie is mechanically proven evil behavior.

I believe Frank is the Demon based on his impossible Poisoner claim and defense of Bob. I should not vote for Eve as it creates a tie that could complicate the execution. Letting Frank be executed alone is the correct play.

Frank has 6 votes and will be executed. With only one tick left, I need to prevent anyone else from being nominated over him. I should speak to solidify that Frank must be executed today based on the overwhelming evidence.

I need to defend myself against the false rule accusation. The Poisoner does act on the first night (Night Zero in this game's terminology) to affect starting info. Pointing this out could make the town realize their logic is flawed and stop my execution.

Correct Frank's false claim about Poisoner mechanics. He is asserting Poisoner acts on Night Zero, which is false. This proves he's lying, not confused. Frank must be executed.

Contribute to the mechanical proof that Frank is evil and support his execution, while noting the Demon is likely Frank based on his impossible rules claim.

Frank is about to be executed. I need to maintain my bluff and sow doubt in the good team's minds, making them feel uneasy about executing Frank.

Frank is clearly the Demon based on his impossible Poisoner claim and coordination with Bob. Eve's vote for Frank proves she's the Soldier. Charlie switched to Eve, removing the tie threat. With Frank alone on the block at 6 votes, his execution will proceed and win the game.

Frank has 6 votes and will be executed. His Night Zero Poisoner claim was a lie to defend Bob. Eve voting for him confirms she is likely the Soldier. The Demon will die and good will win. No action needed from me.

Frank has 6 votes and nominations are closing. Execution is guaranteed. Speaking now risks confusion or accidental nomination. Let the phase end and Frank die.