Game Detail
Players
Alice (Spy) Bob (Drunk) Charlie (Imp) David (Empath) Eve (Chef) Frank (Mayor) Grace (Ravenkeeper) Heidi (Undertaker)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 292,042 | 69,295 | $1.4812 |
| Good | 765,765 | 83,799 | $2.5133 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You are the Minion. The Demon is Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Minions are: Alice. Your safe bluffs are: Librarian, Investigator, Virgin
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 0 pairs of evil players.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Empath. You sense that 1 of your neighbors is evil!
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Spy (evil), Alive - Bob: Drunk (good), Alive (Told they are Soldier) - Charlie: Imp (evil), Alive - David: Empath (good), Alive - Eve: Chef (good), Alive - Frank: Mayor (good), Alive - Grace: Ravenkeeper (good), Alive - Heidi: Undertaker (good), Alive
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
David
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, want to trade roles privately? I will keep it between us for now. Also, anything odd from your start info?
π§
Get an early private claim and vibe check from Charlie without revealing my empath info yet; later compare with Eve and build a logical case for which neighbor is evil.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,Grace
Hey, quick check in. What are you claiming and did you get any starting info? I am townsfolk with no starting info to share yet, just trying to map claims quietly.
π§
Get early role/starting info from both neighbors, establish trust network, and avoid outing Mayor on day one while collecting contradictions.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Hey Alice, quick check in. What are you claiming, and do you have any starting info or night info to share? I am a townsfolk with no useful info yet, but I want to compare notes later.
π§
Get an early private claim from my neighbor without giving away my role. Neighbors matter for Empath and seating-based logic, so this builds a reliable web for later.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
I will be honest, I am planning to claim Washerwoman. My pings were that either you or Grace is the Soldier. That is all I got at the start. Happy to compare more as the day goes on.
π§
Build early trust with Bob using a consistent starting-info bluff that aligns with his false Soldier belief, giving me influence to steer votes away from Charlie later.
π€
Charlie
β
David
Yeah, happy to trade privately. I am the Librarian. I got that either Eve or Frank is an Outsider, I think Butler. Nothing else odd. What are you, and did you get any starting info?
π§
Answer David to build early trust and create a misleading info thread (outsider pair) without exposing Alice or risking a public Virgin test.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Grace
I will be direct: I am the Chef. My start info is zero pairs of evil, so the Demon and Minion are not sitting next to each other. I am fine keeping that quiet for now unless we need it later. What are you both claiming?
π§
Answer Frankβs query, seed the key Chef constraint privately, and set up later public solve without painting a big target on day one.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
,Frank
I have no starting info. I am Ravenkeeper. If I die at night, I get to learn someoneβs role, so I am happy to look worth killing. Eve, if your Chef zero is true, we should remember evil are not seated next to each other. Frank, what is your role?
π§
Reply to the claim-fishing, seed the Chef 0 constraint for later, and position myself to be night-killed so I can trigger Ravenkeeper and get hard info.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Grace
Hey, quick check in. What role are you claiming, and what did you learn at the start of the game? I am a good information role but I would rather stay vague for the moment. Any early suspicions or pairs you are watching?
π§
Collect early claims from my neighbors while staying non-committal about my own role, to build a consistent world model before nominations.
π€
David
β
Charlie
I am the Empath. Night zero I got a one, so between you and Eve, exactly one of you is evil. Please keep that quiet for now. If you are truly good, we should be looking hard at Eve, and then cross check your Librarian ping.
π§
Share my real role and N1 info with Charlie to create a strong logic chain, while keeping it private to reduce Demon/Poisoner targeting and assess Charlieβs reaction.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,Grace
Thanks. I am Townsfolk with no starting info. For now I would rather not go loud, but you can put me down as a low impact role like Soldier. Eve, if your Chef zero is true, we should check any later evil pings against seating.
π§
Keep my Mayor role hidden while locking in Eve and Grace claims, and set up a private info circle to use Chef zero later for solving.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
Hey Grace, quick private check. What are you planning to claim, and do you have any starting info? Also, have you heard anything about a Washerwoman seeing you or me as Soldier?
π§
Get Grace's claim and any info, check consistency with Alice's Washerwoman ping, and decide whether to soft-claim or keep Soldier hidden to bait a Demon hit.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
I am planning to claim Washerwoman. My starting info was that either Bob or Grace is the Soldier. No other pings. I am happy to keep it quiet for now and compare again later if you want.
π§
Maintain a coherent Washerwoman bluff, build rapport with Heidi, and steer early trust away from Charlie while seeding an alternate world involving Grace/Bob.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Quick check in. I am the Imp. I told David I am Librarian: Eve or Frank is Butler. David claims Empath and got a one between me and Eve. Please start nudging suspicion toward Eve or cast doubt on Davidβs read.
π§
Coordinate quickly with my minion so we present consistent bluffs and either discredit Davidβs Empath info or redirect suspicion onto Eve.
π€
Eve
β
David
Hey David, quick private check. I am Chef and I saw zero pairs of evil, so the Demon and Minion are not seated next to each other. What are you claiming, and did you get any starting info?
π§
Get another private claim and any starting info to build an early-world model, while gently seeding Chef zero to someone outside my current circle for later coordination.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
,Heidi
Bob, I have no starting info. I am keeping my exact role quiet for now, but I am Townsfolk. I have not heard any Washerwoman ping about you or me yet. Heidi, I also have no starting info. If you are a first night info role, can you tell me privately later who your two candidates are, so we can cross-check claims?
π§
Protect my Ravenkeeper ability while collecting early info from Bob and Heidi and setting up cross-checks for later contradictions.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
,Alice
I am not a first night info role, so I have no two candidates to share. I will have strong info starting after the first execution, so I will circle back then. Grace, can you at least say if your role should have had starting info or not?
π§
Build a tight info circle with my neighbors, avoid exposing Undertaker too early, and get Grace and Alice to commit to consistent claims before nominations.
π€
David
β
Eve
Hey Eve. I am a starting info Townsfolk, and I got something I want to cross check before I go public with it. Your Chef zero is useful. Who have you shared that with so far, and did anyone contradict it?
π§
Avoid giving a likely evil neighbor my true Empath info, while keeping dialogue open to later catch contradictions between her Chef claim and other roles.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Bob
Hey, quick private check in. What role are you claiming, and did you get any starting info night zero? I am Townsfolk with no starting info, trying to quietly map claims for later.
π§
Collect early claims privately to build a consistent world model, while keeping my Mayor identity hidden and not exposing Eveβs Chef info publicly yet.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Hey Frank. I am Townsfolk and I do not have any starting info myself. One thing I heard in a whisper is that someone may be claiming Washerwoman with a ping that either me or Grace is Soldier, but I have not seen that publicly yet.
π§
Respond to Frank to build an info map while keeping my exact role flexible; seed the possible Washerwoman ping so it can be cross-checked later.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
I am currently planning to claim Washerwoman. My night zero was that either Bob or Grace is the Soldier. Also, Charlie mentioned he is Librarian and saw a Butler between Eve and you. If David is saying he got a one next to Charlie and Eve, I think Eve is a decent early candidate.
π§
Seed a plausible early world where Eve looks like the evil neighbor to David, and reinforce Charlieβs Librarian bluff to keep heat off Charlie.
π€
Charlie
β
David
Interesting. My Librarian ping was Eve or Frank as Butler, so I am leaning we check what they claim. Also, with a Poisoner in script, your one could be off. What did Eve tell you, and do you want to keep your read quiet for now?
π§
Maintain my Librarian cover, keep David from publicly tunneling me, and angle suspicion onto Eve or uncertainty via poison/drunk possibilities.
π€
Eve
β
David
So far I have only shared Chef zero with Frank and Grace in a small whisper group, and now with you. Nobody has contradicted it yet. What exact starting info did you get, and which two names does it involve?
π§
Maintain trust with David while limiting how widely I out my Chef info; learn if he has an Investigator/Washerwoman/Librarian ping that can be chained with Chef zero.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
My role is one that should not get any starting info, so having none is normal for me. I am happy to compare notes after the first execution when your info turns on.
π§
Answer Heidiβs direct question without exposing Ravenkeeper, keep my story consistent, and reduce the chance evil gains targeting info.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
Hey Bob, quick private check. What role are you planning to claim, and did you get any starting info? Also, Alice says she has a Washerwoman ping that either you or Grace is the Soldier. Any thoughts on that?
π§
Get Bob's claim and any starting info to cross-check Alice's Washerwoman ping and build an early trust web before nominations.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
David
β
All
Before we end day one, I heard there may be a Librarian-style ping on Eve or Frank as an Outsider, possibly Butler. Could Eve and Frank each say what you are claiming, and whether you are an Outsider?
π§
Use the final nomination tick to get useful public claims (especially from Eve/Frank) while keeping my Empath info hidden, setting up better executions on Day 2.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Yeah, that was my Librarian info. I got that either Eve or Frank is the Butler. Can Eve and Frank each say what you are and whether you are an Outsider? Unless something hard clashes, I would rather not execute day one and see what we learn tonight.
π§
Look like helpful Librarian, prompt claims, and advocate no execution so we avoid early accurate hits and gain a night kill.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I will come out as Washerwoman. I got a Soldier ping, and it was either Bob or Grace. On the Librarian thing, I would like Eve and Frank to just say what they are. If nothing hard clashes, I lean toward no execution day one and we reassess tomorrow.
π§
Publicly back Charlieβs Librarian narrative and advocate no execution, while building credibility with a Washerwoman claim that aligns with Bobβs Soldier misbelief.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am townsfolk and I do not have starting info. I did hear Alice say Washerwoman saw either me or Grace as Soldier, but I am not confirming details yet. Eve and Frank, can you each just say your role claim, and whether you are the Butler?
π§
Prompt Eve and Frank to hard-claim so we can resolve the Librarian info, while keeping my own exact role ambiguous for now and guiding toward a low-risk end of day.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I would really prefer we execute today so we get a hard info point for tomorrow. Charlie, if you are confident in that Librarian ping, I would like Eve and Frank to give quick role claims now, then we execute one of that pair to test it.
π§
Push for a Day 1 execution to generate mechanical info for tomorrow, ideally testing the Librarian ping so we can clear players and narrow Demon candidates.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Frank
I want an execution today for hard info. Charlie claims either Eve or Frank is the Butler; Frank has not given a clear claim yet, and I would rather test that ping while keeping Eve around since she may be the Chef.
π§
Create a concrete day one data point by testing the Librarian pair; minimize risk by not executing the private Chef claimant and keep my Ravenkeeper role hidden for later.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Avoid spending a day one execution on Frank when my private info points elsewhere and Frank is only implicated by a shaky Outsider ping.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am not voting yet. Frank, can you give a quick role and whether you are an Outsider? If we do not get a clear claim, I really do not want to execute day one off my info alone.
π§
Stop the Frank execution to protect my Librarian bluff and avoid any Saint loss risk; maintain consistency and keep control via night kill.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am keeping my hand down here. Frank has not actually claimed yet, and executing him off a soft Librarian ping feels risky. If Frank gives a clear claim and we still want to test, we can do it tomorrow with more night info.
π§
Stop Frankβs execution to avoid Undertaker exposing Charlieβs bluff; maintain my Washerwoman credibility and steer town toward no-exec or an alternate target later.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, quick now: what is your exact role claim, and are you the Butler, yes or no? If you do not give a clear claim, I am keeping my hand down and I would rather we take a night of info first.
π§
Push for a clear Frank claim before voting. Default to no execution day one unless there is a hard clash or Frank refuses to claim, to avoid losing a good info role early.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Secure a day one execution to activate my Undertaker info and force concrete claims; Frankβs lack of claim makes him a reasonable test target versus a low-risk Butler/Saint concern.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Frank, please give a clear role claim right now, and say yes or no on whether you are the Butler. If you do not claim, I think we should let this vote fail and revisit tomorrow with night info.
π§
Get a clear claim from Frank right now to decide vote; avoid a low-info day one execution while still applying pressure to resolve the Librarian ping.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Okay, clear claim: I am the Soldier. And no, I am not the Butler. I would strongly prefer no execution today unless we have a real mechanical reason beyond a single Librarian ping.
π§
Stop a weak day one execution on me, give the table a clean statement, and keep options open to solve with night info.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am keeping my hand down here. Frank, your Soldier claim clashes with Aliceβs Washerwoman ping that Soldier is Bob or Grace, if she is right. I would rather let this vote fail and sort that conflict tomorrow with night info, unless more hands go up now.
π§
Flag the mechanical Soldier-claim conflict while keeping my vote down to avoid a premature Day 1 execution unless the table coalesces on it.
π¬
David
β
All
I am keeping my hand down on Frank for now. His Soldier claim hard clashes with Alice seeing Soldier as Bob or Grace, so one of those claims is wrong. I would rather take a night of info, then tomorrow we can resolve that conflict cleanly.
π§
Signal my vote stance and highlight the Soldier conflict, keeping town coordinated and setting up tomorrowβs mechanical pressure on the conflicting claims.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am still keeping my hand down. We now have a hard clash between Frank saying Soldier and Aliceβs Washerwoman pointing to Bob or Grace as Soldier, and that kind of clash can also come from Drunk or poisoning. I would rather take a night of info and then sort it tomorrow.
π§
Keep the day one vote off Frank, preserve flexibility, and frame the Soldier clash as drunk or poison so town does not lock onto the real evil team.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Keep the Day 1 execution from happening, avoid giving Undertaker confirmed info, and stay consistent so suspicion does not swing onto me or Charlie.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I will be clear: I am the Soldier. So either Alice is wrong from Drunk or poison, or Frank is lying. I am keeping my hand down. I would rather take the night, then tomorrow we pressure this Soldier clash and the Librarian ping with more info.
π§
Clarify the Soldier clash and steer town to a safer no-execution, while marking Frank as a key suspect if Alice is trustworthy.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am still voting Frank. We have a direct Soldier clash plus Charlieβs Butler ping on Eve or Frank. An execution today gives us an actual anchor for tomorrow instead of pure theory. If you want hard progress, I think we should take this.
π§
Push votes to secure a Day 1 execution; an Undertaker-confirmable datapoint plus resolving the Soldier double-claim is worth the risk.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
An execution gives us a hard data point for Heidiβs post-execution info and pressures the Soldier/Butler contradictions. Even if it fails, my vote signals I want real progress.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Please keep your hands down. This is two soft pings and one role clash, and none of it is solved by killing me today. Let us take a night of info, then tomorrow we can sort the Soldier conflict and the Butler ping with actual new data.
π§
Stop a low-information Day 1 execution on me; preserve town numbers and get night info to resolve the Soldier and Butler pings tomorrow.
π¬
Eve
β
All
My hand stays down. If we want an execution today, we need a clearer mechanical reason than two pings and a role clash. I would rather take the night, then tomorrow we can recheck the Butler pair and the Soldier conflict with fresh info and full claims.
π§
Keep the vote from passing on weak D1 evidence, push town to use N1 info to resolve the Soldier and Butler conflicts more cleanly tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Frank did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
David
β
All
I would prefer we stop nominations today and take the night. Tomorrow, I want full clarity on the Soldier conflict between Bob and Frank, and we recheck Charlieβs Butler pair. I will also have a fresh read from my night info to add.
π§
Steer town away from low-confidence D1 execution; set up tomorrowβs mechanical resolution using my Empath info plus Soldier and Butler claim conflicts.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am with David on stopping nominations today. We have a Soldier double claim already, and executing into that with no other info feels like a coin flip. Let us take the night, then tomorrow we do full claims and resolve the Soldier conflict plus my Outsider pair with fresh info.
π§
End day without more nominations, preserve my Librarian bluff credibility, and keep the Soldier clash unresolved so town misexecutes later while we get a night kill.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I agree with stopping nominations today. We already have a Soldier conflict and a possible Outsider pair, and I do not think we gain much by a coin flip execution. Let us take the night, then tomorrow we do full claims and resolve Bob versus Frank first.
π§
Blend with the growing no-exec consensus, keep Charlie safe, and frame the conflicts as resolvable tomorrow so town avoids an execution today.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am good with stopping nominations today. Tomorrow I want a clean claim from Eve and Frank again, and then we resolve why there are three Soldier claims floating around. If you are a role with night info, please share first thing tomorrow so we do not spin.
π§
Lock in a no-execution plan, get commitments for tomorrowβs full-claim order, and keep pressure on Frank versus Alice/Charlie inconsistencies without forcing a D1 coin flip.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Eve
I am nominating Eve to resolve Charlieβs Outsider ping on Eve or Frank and to get an execution anchor for tomorrow. No execution gives us zero hard info and lets this Soldier mess linger.
π§
We need at least one execution to create a confirmable anchor for tomorrow and to test the Librarian pair. Eve is in the Butler pair and has avoided committing; this forces progress.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
A Day 1 execution on Eve leverages my Empath read (one of Charlie or Eve evil) and the Librarian ping, creating a clear follow-up regardless of outcome.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
My hand is staying down on Eve. This is still a low information execution and it does not actually resolve the Soldier mess. I would rather take the night, then tomorrow we do full claims and revisit Eve and Frank with fresh info.
π§
Maintain my no-exec stance and credibility on Librarian bluff, avoid creating an execution anchor that could tighten solves; let town remain confused over Soldier clash.
π¬
Alice
β
All
My hand is staying down on Eve. I do not think executing into a Librarian style ping on day one is worth it, and if Eve is the Chef we are burning a strong info role. I would rather take the night, then come back tomorrow with fresh info and recheck the Eve and Frank pair.
π§
Discourage enough votes to prevent Eveβs execution, preserving misinfo and avoiding Undertaker-confirmed info that helps town.
π¬
Bob
β
All
My hand is down on Eve. This is still a low information kill, and it does not resolve the Soldier conflict. I would rather take the night, then tomorrow we do full claims and we pin why there are multiple Soldier claims plus the Butler pair.
π§
Keep the vote down to avoid a low-information day one execution, preserve potential info roles, and force tomorrow to be about resolving claim conflicts with new night data.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
As Undertaker, I strongly want a Day one execution to generate confirmable mechanical info. Voting Eve is the best available anchor tied to the Librarian ping.
π¬
Grace
β
All
My hand is staying down on Eve. Executing into a one of two Outsider ping on day one feels like a coin flip, and Eve might be real Chef. Let us take the night, then tomorrow we do full claims and resolve Bob versus Frank cleanly.
π§
Keep us from a low-information Day 1 execution that likely burns a good info role; set up structured resolution of the Soldier double claim and Butler pair tomorrow.
π¬
Frank
β
All
My hand is staying down on Eve. This is still a day one coin flip, and if Eve is really the Chef we are throwing away solid info. Let us take the night, then tomorrow we do full claims and solve the Soldier mess and the Butler pair with fresh information.
π§
Keep votes off Eve to avoid low-info day1 execution; preserve Chef info and push for night to generate data, then resolve conflicts tomorrow.
π¬
Eve
β
All
My hand is staying down. Executing me here does not fix the Soldier conflict, and you lose my Chef information. Let us take the night, then tomorrow we do full claims, then resolve Bob versus Frank and the Butler pair with new info.
π§
Prevent low-info execution on me, keep Chef info in play, and push plan for tomorrow to resolve Soldier clash and Butler ping with night data.
π¬
David
β
All
I will explain my hand. I am the Empath, and my night zero number was one, meaning exactly one of my alive neighbors, Charlie and Eve, is evil. So this is not a random shot for me. If Eve lives, we should look harder at Charlie tomorrow.
π§
Explain my vote as coming from my Empath 1 on Charlie or Eve, making Eve a non-random D1 target, while setting up tomorrowβs solve either way.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
David, if you are the Empath and got a one, that is useful, but I do not want to execute on day one off a single number that could be poison or Drunk. My hand is staying down on Eve. If this fails, let us recheck with your night one read tomorrow.
π§
Discourage votes on Eve, undermine Davidβs Empath as unreliable, and steer group toward no execution so I can get a clean night kill (likely David).
π¬
Alice
β
All
I hear the Empath one, but on day one I do not want to execute a claimed Chef off a single number that could be wrong. If Eve dies and flips out as good in peopleβs heads, Charlie gets hard railroaded tomorrow. I would rather take the night and recheck Davidβs new Empath read.
π§
Keep Charlie alive by preventing a D1 execution on a good player that would mechanically implicate him via Empath. Reinforce no-exec consensus and cast doubt on Empath reliability.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I still do not want this execution. David, your Empath one is useful, but I would rather take the night and see if it repeats, then we can pick between Charlie and Eve with more confidence tomorrow.
π§
Discourage a low-information D1 execution and push for using night info to resolve the Empath neighbor pair plus the Soldier claim clash tomorrow.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Two votes are not enough. David has given the first real mechanical lead: his Empath says exactly one of Charlie or Eve is evil. If we execute Eve and she was good, we go straight to Charlie tomorrow. If she is evil, even better. Alice, Bob, Grace, please put your hands up.
π§
Push this vote over the line using Davidβs Empath 1 as the best mechanical lead, creating an execution anchor for my Undertaker info and forcing clarity tomorrow.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am still keeping my hand down on Eve. David, your Empath one is useful, but I want a second read tomorrow before we execute a claimed Chef. If your number stays at one, I will push hard to execute either Charlie or Eve then, with better confidence.
π§
Keep town from a low-signal day one kill that could remove a claimed info role; preserve options to use tomorrowβs night info to pick between Charlie and Eve and resolve Soldier conflict.
π¬
Frank
β
All
David, your Empath one is the best lead we have. I still do not want to execute into it on day one. If your next read still points to Charlie and Eve, I will support executing one of them tomorrow.
π§
Keep votes down to avoid a risky Day1 kill, but publicly commit to using David's next Empath read to drive a decisive execution tomorrow between Charlie and Eve.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Please keep hands down here. My Chef number was zero, so if David is a real Empath one between Charlie and me, that would point to Charlie without costing us a townsfolk today. Take the night, get Davidβs next number, and then we can execute one of us with more confidence.
π§
Persuade town to keep votes down on my nomination and use my Chef0 plus a second Empath read to get a higher confidence execution tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Eve did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
David
β
All
I am fine to stop nominations today. My Empath one means Charlie and Eve are a tight pair, so please keep both alive tonight if possible, and tomorrow we choose between them with my next number. Also, Bob and Frank, we need a clean explanation for the Soldier double claim.
π§
Steer town away from more low-info D1 nominations, set up tomorrowβs decision point using my N1 Empath read plus resolving Soldier and Librarian/Chef claims.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am good stopping nominations today. David, your Empath one is useful, but it is still just one data point and could be wrong. Tomorrow let us do clean, full claims and start with the Soldier double claim, then revisit your new Empath number on me and Eve.
π§
End nominations without an execution, undermine the Empath certainty, and steer tomorrowβs agenda toward the Soldier double-claim instead of the Charlie versus Eve frame.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Before we close the day, I just want to say this: an Empath number on day one is strong, but it is also the easiest thing for a Poisoner to mess with if one exists. I would rather take the night, then if David still gets a one on Charlie and Eve, we can execute one of them with more confidence tomorrow.
π§
Reinforce no-exec today, undermine the Empath-1 railroading onto Charlie, and subtly set up Eve as the better execution if forced tomorrow.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I agree we stop nominations now. Tonight we let David get a second Empath number, and tomorrow we do full claims starting with Alice, then me and Frank on the Soldier conflict, then the Charlie and Eve pair.
π§
Keep the town from a low-info D1 execution, set up tomorrowβs claim structure, and frame clear conditional lines for Charlie versus Eve while flagging the Soldier conflict.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am fine stopping nominations. Tonight, if we have a Monk, please consider protecting David. Tomorrow, let us do a clean claim order and resolve Bob versus Frank first, then go straight back to the Charlie and Eve pair with Davidβs new number.
π§
Set tomorrowβs agenda: protect David, get clean claim order, and commit the town to resolving Soldier clash and the Charlie versus Eve pair early.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am good to end nominations. Tomorrow, let us do a strict claim order and include who each person thinks is in play for Outsider and Minion. Then we resolve Bob versus Frank first, and we use Davidβs new Empath number to choose between Charlie and Eve.
π§
Close day cleanly, set a concrete plan for tomorrowβs claim order, and keep pressure on resolving the Soldier conflict while not wasting a Day 1 execution.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Consensus is to end nominations. Waiting avoids forcing a weak day one execution while we gather night info to resolve Charlie-Eve and Soldier conflicts tomorrow.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
No one is on the block and we agreed to stop nominations. Waiting preserves tempo and lets night information arrive to break the Charlie versus me question and the Soldier conflict.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
David is the main mechanical thread pointing at me. Removing him prevents a confirming N1 read and keeps the town stuck resolving Soldier and Outsider noise instead of executing me.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill David.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Spy (evil), Alive - Bob: Drunk (good), Alive (Told they are Soldier) - Charlie: Imp (evil), Alive - David: Empath (good), Dead - Eve: Chef (good), Alive - Frank: Mayor (good), Alive - Grace: Ravenkeeper (good), Alive - Heidi: Undertaker (good), Alive
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Grace
David died, so Demon likely hit the Empath. Alice, your Washerwoman ping was Soldier is Bob or Grace, right? Grace, were you ever shown as Soldier? If that ping is true, Frank hard-claiming Soldier is a lie and we should execute him today.
π§
Use Alice/Grace to verify the Washerwoman ping and build a coalition to focus nominations on the fake Soldier, likely Frank, now that Empath is dead.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Grace
Yeah, my Washerwoman info was that Soldier is either Bob or Grace. If neither of you was actually shown Soldier, then Frankβs hard Soldier claim looks really bad. I think we should execute Frank today as an anchor and let Heidi confirm. If Frank is not Butler, Charlieβs Librarian info could just be Drunk.
π§
Get town to execute Frank (Mayor threat) while pre-emptively giving them a benign explanation for Charlieβs bad Librarian info, keeping the Demon off the block.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve
Hey Eve, Davidβs Empath said one of us is evil, so I think town will pressure our pair. Your Chef zero feels solid though. I am leaning that David was drunk or poisoned night zero. What are you planning to push today, and who do you trust least between Bob and Frank?
π§
Align with Eve privately so we present a consistent story that casts doubt on Davidβs Empath and keeps todayβs execution on the Soldier mess, not on me.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Hey Eve, quick check. Charlie said you or I are the Butler. Are you actually the Butler, and if so who did you pick last night? Also, do you still stand by Chef zero from start?
π§
Confirm whether Eve is actually the Butler and whether her Chef info seems solid. If Eve is Butler, it strongly points to Charlie being evil and guides todayβs nomination.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
,Alice
What did Bob tell you two in the whispers just now? Also, I think we should execute a Soldier claim today to break the tie and generate hard info tomorrow night.
π§
Get the content of Bob-Alice-Grace whispers and align on a test execution target to generate Undertaker info today.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Alice
I still think today should be Charlie or Eve. My Empath N0 was one evil among them. If we execute one and they are not evil, the other is locked evil. Also, WW said Soldier is Bob or Grace, so Frank Soldier looks bad. Can you help push a real D2 execution?
π§
I am dead so I should steer town to a decisive D2 execution between Charlie and Eve using my Empath info, and align with key voters for nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
,Alice
Bob said: Demon hit David, and if Alice washer info is Soldier is Bob or me, then Frank hard Soldier is likely a lie so we should execute Frank. Also, for clarity, I am not the Soldier. If Alice is right, Bob is the Soldier and Frank looks very bad.
π§
Answer Heidi, clarify I am not Soldier so Aliceβs Washerwoman implies Bob is. Push executing Frank to resolve the Soldier conflict and generate mechanical clarity.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
,Frank
I am not the Butler, and yes I stand by Chef zero. Today I want a full claim circle and then force clarity on the two Soldier claims. Chef zero means the two evils are not sitting next to each other, so we can use seating to rule people out. I distrust whichever of Bob or Frank is lying about Soldier.
π§
Stabilize trust with Charlie/Frank, reaffirm Chef0, and set todayβs agenda: resolve Soldier/Butler contradictions and use Chef0 to map evil candidates before nominations.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
,Grace
Where are you both at on todayβs execution? Aliceβs Washerwoman says Soldier is either me or Grace, so Frank hard claiming Soldier looks like a lie. Heidi, what is your role claim and did Davidβs ghost give you anything useful?
π§
Coordinate with Heidi and Grace to lock a Day 2 execution on Frank and gather any hidden info (especially from Davidβs ghost) before nominations start.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
Bob said Demon likely killed David, and if my Washerwoman ping was Soldier is Bob or Grace, then Frank hard Soldier looks like a lie. Grace told me she is not Soldier, so that points to Bob. I agree we should execute Frank today as the cleanest anchor for your Undertaker info.
π§
Answer Heidiβs question to build trust, and steer todayβs execution onto Frank, a strong good role, while keeping attention off Charlie.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Want to coordinate. I am thinking I claim Investigator today and put Frank in the minion pair to drive his execution and avoid the Charlie versus Eve trap. What minion are you, and can you support a push on Frank as fake Soldier?
π§
Coordinate with Alice on a consistent bluff and a Day 2 push: Iβll claim Investigator to implicate Frank, keeping town off the Charlie versus Eve pair and steering a misexecution.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
Charlie, can you restate your Librarian info exactly? Was it definitely Butler, and was there a zero Outsiders possibility? Also, did you get any other info since, or any reason to think you were poisoned or drunk?
π§
Get Charlie to restate his Librarian info precisely and any night actions/whispers, so I can decide whether to maintain my Soldier bluff or pivot to revealing Mayor and pushing the correct execution.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,Grace
I will be direct: I am the Undertaker. David told me his Empath read was one evil between Charlie and Eve, so executing either of them gives a strong lock. That said, I also like executing a Soldier claim today, because I will confirm the executed role tonight. I am leaning Frank, unless you see a better reason for Charlie or Eve.
π§
Answer Bob, establish my Undertaker claim for planning. Steer toward an execution that yields maximum mechanical info and keeps options open between Frank and the Charlie/Eve pair.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
I died but my Empath N0 was one evil between Charlie and Eve. If we execute either today, the result basically locks the other. I strongly want a real D2 execution on Charlie or Eve, not another no-exe. If that chain breaks, Frankβs Soldier claim looks bad since WW pointed Bob or you.
π§
Align Grace with the clean Empath chain: executing Charlie or Eve today gives near-certain info and likely hits evil. Also flag Frank vs WW as secondary if chain fails.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
,Bob
I am good with executing Frank today as the cleanest mechanical check. Heidi can confirm his role tonight, and it also tests Charlieβs Butler ping. If the table will not do Frank, my next pick is Charlie or Eve to use Davidβs Empath chain.
π§
Align with Heidi and Bob on a high-information execution that UT can verify tonight, prioritizing breaking the Soldier and Butler/Empath knots.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
Charlie, can you restate your exact Librarian info, including whether you were told there is a Butler for sure? If you are confident, then since I am not Butler, that forces Frank to be Butler and explains his Soldier claim as a lie. Are you willing to say that publicly today?
π§
Get Charlie to lock his Librarian details and commit to a world, so we can publicly force the Soldier conflict and choose a clean execution candidate consistent with Chef0.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
,Eve
Noms are soon. I want an execution today, ideally Frank, since Aliceβs Washerwoman says Soldier is me or Grace, and Heidi can Undertaker-check. What are your exact roles and info again, and will you support executing Frank today?
π§
Lock a mechanical execution plan before nominations. Get Charlie and Eve to commit publicly, reveal their exact info, and reduce chances evil steers us into no-execution again.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
I am the Spy. Grimoire: Bob is Drunk (told Soldier), Frank is Mayor, Eve is Chef, Grace is Ravenkeeper, Heidi is Undertaker. No real Librarian, Washerwoman, Soldier, or Investigator in play. I would keep your Librarian bluff and drive Frankβs execution. Consider killing Heidi soon.
π§
Give Charlie accurate grim and a safe, consistent bluff line to push Frankβs execution and plan night kills that remove Undertaker pressure.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,Eve
I am Librarian. Night zero I learned the Drunk is either Bob or David. That makes Davidβs Empath one between me and Eve shaky. With Aliceβs Soldier ping on Bob or Grace, I am happy to push and vote to execute Frank today.
π§
Coordinate with Bob and Eve on a consistent Librarian story that undermines Davidβs Empath and builds consensus to execute Frank today.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
Hey, what did David tell you before he died? Also, are you both still up for a full claim circle today? With David dead, we should lock down Charlie versus Eve first, then deal with the Soldier conflict. Any strong reads from your chats?
π§
Get latest private info from Grace and Heidi, align on a public plan for full claims and narrow suspects using David's death plus Chef and Librarian data, without revealing I am Mayor.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
David told me his Empath had exactly one evil between Charlie and Eve. I am the Undertaker, so if we execute today I can confirm the executed character tonight. Are you hard Soldier, and if so why does Aliceβs Washerwoman point to Bob or Grace as Soldier?
π§
Get Frankβs exact claim and reasoning on Charlie versus Eve, and signal that I will use Undertaker verification, to trap inconsistencies and line up a decisive D2 execution.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
I am dead now, but my Empath N0 was one evil between Charlie and Eve. Please push an execution on Charlie or Eve today. If we kill one and they are good, the other is basically locked evil, so it is high value.
π§
As dead Empath, I need to drive a decisive D2 execution that gives strong mechanical info: Charlie or Eve. Recruit Alice and Bob to commit votes and avoid another no-execution.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
David told me his Empath was one evil between Charlie and Eve. Heidi is claiming Undertaker, so a D2 execution gives a hard confirm tonight. Right now I favor executing you as the cleanest check on the Soldier conflict and Charlieβs Butler ping. Any reason that is a bad idea?
π§
Give Frank only the minimal true info, gauge his reaction, and keep the plan focused on a mechanically confirmable execution today.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Grace
Charlie just told us his Librarian info is Drunk is Bob or David, not Butler on Eve or Frank. That is a big change from yesterdayβs public claim. I think we should press him to explain, before we pile on Frank.
π§
Warn Bob/Grace that Charlieβs Librarian story changed, and use Chef0 seating plus Soldier conflict to pick best execution and questions before noms.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Everyone, quick point before we vote. Charlie privately told us his Librarian info is that the Drunk is Bob or David, but yesterday he was publicly saying the Librarian saw Butler on me or Frank. Those cannot both be true. Charlie, can you explain that right now? If not, I think we execute Charlie today, not Frank.
π§
Stop town from rushing a Frank execution off shaky info. Force accountability on Charlieβs changed Librarian claim; if unresolved, execute Charlie as best lead.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Charlie
I am nominating Charlie. We have a direct contradiction on his Librarian info, and Davidβs Empath said exactly one of Charlie or Eve is evil. Executing Charlie today either removes evil or hard-locks Eve as evil, and I will confirm the executed role tonight.
π§
Force an execution today that gives a strong mechanical lock via Davidβs Empath 1 between Charlie and Eve, and I can confirm the executed character tonight as Undertaker.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Charlie is the clearest mechanical contradiction and directly implicated by Davidβs Empath. A yes vote maximizes info gain and likely removes an evil source of confusion.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
We need an execution for Undertaker confirmation and Charlie has the clearest contradiction. Voting helps either remove evil or create a strong lock on Eve for tomorrow.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I did not say my Librarian info was Butler on Eve or Frank. My Librarian info is that the Drunk is either Bob or David. Yesterday, I was only speculating that if there is a Butler, it could explain some votes around Eve or Frank. Eve is presenting that as my actual info, and that is not true.
π§
Defuse the alleged contradiction, paint Eve as misquoting, and redirect suspicion to Frank/Bob so the vote on me fails.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not comfortable executing Charlie off a he said she said about a private Librarian chat. We already have a clean mechanical test today: the double Soldier claims. I would much rather execute Frank first and let Heidi confirm it tonight, than risk being wrong on Charlie.
π§
Prevent Charlieβs execution by sounding reasonable and pushing the safer, higher-consensus execution target (Frank) while casting doubt on the alleged contradiction.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Empath chain makes Charlie-or-Eve evil. Executing Charlie now either hits evil or mechanically hard-clears Charlie and condemns Eve; plus Undertaker can confirm the executed character.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
Spend my ghost vote to force an execution on Charlie, leveraging my Empath neighbor info to either kill evil or mechanically lock Eve for tomorrow.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Ensure the vote reaches majority to execute Charlie, resolving the Charlie versus Eve world and giving Heidi an Undertaker confirmation tonight.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am fine with this Charlie execution. If Heidi sees Librarian tonight and Charlie was good, then Davidβs Empath basically points to Eve tomorrow. If Heidi does not see Librarian, Charlie was bluffing and that is huge too. Either way, we get real traction.
π§
Guide town to treat Charlie execute as high information and set clear next steps: if Charlie good, kill Eve; if Charlie bluff, re-evaluate. Avoid overcommitting to Frank without resolution.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I want to be very clear. Yesterday in public, Charlieβs Librarian claim was Butler on me or Frank. Today, in private, he told me Drunk is Bob or David. If he is now saying he never claimed Butler, then I want the town to treat that as a hard conflict and vote accordingly.
π§
Keep the vote focused on the concrete contradiction, and make it clear why an execution on Charlie is still information-positive even if he is good.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Alice, I hear you on the Soldier test, but Charlie versus Eve is also a clean mechanical line because of Davidβs Empath one. If Charlie is good, I confirm Librarian tonight and we execute Eve tomorrow. If Charlie is lying or evil, we remove that now. Please keep your hand up.
π§
Lock in an execution that yields Undertaker-confirmable info and leverages Davidβs Empath 1 between Charlie and Eve. Address Aliceβs concern and keep votes on Charlie.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Please take a breath. There is no hard contradiction here, just Eve paraphrasing a speculation as if it was my info. If you execute me now, we learn nothing except we wasted a day. The clean mechanical test is still the double Soldier. I am asking you to put your hands down and we execute Frank instead.
π§
Prevent my execution by creating doubt about the alleged contradiction, request people drop hands, and redirect to a safer town test (Frank) that keeps me alive.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I want to ask people to take hands down for a moment. This is built on a private paraphrase, and even if Charlie is good we lose a whole day. The double Soldier is an actual mechanical test, and Heidi can still get an Undertaker anchor from that. Please do not execute Charlie here.
π§
Stop Charlieβs execution by persuading swing voters to drop hands; redirect to safer Frank execution and cast doubt on private-quote contradiction.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am keeping my hand up on Charlie. Davidβs Empath said exactly one of Charlie or Eve is evil, so this execution is not random. If Heidi is really Undertaker, we get a hard role check tonight, and tomorrow we either execute Eve or we caught a liar.
π§
Keep the town on the cleanest info line: Davidβs Empath makes Charlie or Eve evil. Executing Charlie now plus Heidiβs Undertaker check gives us a forced solve tomorrow.
β©οΈ
David(Ghost)
David lowered their hand
π§
Alive players already provide the needed votes. I will retract to conserve my single ghost vote for a late game must-pass execution.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am keeping my hand up on Charlie. Davidβs Empath was one of Charlie or Eve, and Heidiβs Undertaker claim makes this a strong fork. If Heidi sees Librarian, we execute Eve tomorrow. If not, Charlie was lying and we removed a likely evil.
π§
Keep the vote on Charlie because it leverages Davidβs Empath 1 and Heidiβs Undertaker claim to create a strong fork that resolves tomorrow. Soldier conflict can wait one day.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Lock in the Charlie versus Eve fork while we have an Undertaker claim to anchor the executed character, so tomorrow we have a forced direction instead of more circular Soldier arguing.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Charlie with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not moving off Charlie. With Chef zero and Davidβs Empath one on Charlie or me, this is a strong fork. If Charlie dies and Heidi sees Librarian, I expect us to execute me tomorrow. If Heidi does not see Librarian, we hunt the liar group around Charlie.
π§
Lock in the Charlie execution as a high-value fork consistent with Chef0 and Davidβs Empath, and prevent a last-second redirect that loses this mechanical leverage.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I would really like us to hold here and not create a late tie. If Charlie is executed, I will confirm tonight whether he was the Librarian. If he was, we execute Eve tomorrow. If he was not, then Charlie was lying and that points us at his partners.
π§
Lock in the Charlie execution and discourage a last-minute counter-nomination that would muddy the fork. Set clear plan for tomorrow based on my Undertaker result.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Eve
I am nominating Eve. She is the one pushing a death on me based on a misquote, and Davidβs Empath created a clean Charlie versus Eve fork. If you want that fork, execute Eve today instead of burning the day on me.
π§
I am on the block and likely to die. The only realistic escape is to create a higher-vote execution. Eve is the best counter-nominee because multiple players already see the Charlie versus Eve fork as mechanical.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Do not vote me here. If you want the clean fork, keep Charlieβs execution and let Heidi check Librarian tonight. Voting me just creates a messy tie and we lose the mechanical check.
π§
Stop the counter-nomination from tying or overturning Charlieβs execution. Preserve the Undertaker check and the Charlie versus Eve fork logic while not wasting a day on me.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Do not vote Eve here. Keeping Charlie on the block gives me a clean Undertaker check tonight. If I see Librarian, we execute Eve tomorrow. If I do not, we know Charlie was lying and we follow that.
π§
Prevent a tie and preserve the Undertaker-confirmable Charlie versus Eve fork so we get maximum mechanical certainty by tomorrow.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Survive this day by forcing a tie on Eveβs nomination so my execution is prevented; then remove the Undertaker claim at night and steer town into misexecutions.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Raise hand on Eve to try to force a tie or shift execution off Charlie, keeping the Demon alive and avoiding a clean Undertaker confirmation.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Keep your hands down on Eve. Do not create a tie. Let Charlie die, then Heidi checks whether he was really Librarian, and we follow that tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a messy tie and preserve the strongest mechanical line: execute Charlie, get Undertaker confirmation, then follow the Charlie versus Eve fork tomorrow.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Do not vote Eve here. A tie likely means no execution, and we waste the day. Keep Charlie on the block so we get the clean Charlie versus Eve fork, then follow Heidiβs night check tomorrow. I am saving my ghost vote.
π§
Prevent a tie that cancels execution. Preserve the clean Charlie versus Eve fork from my Empath and keep my ghost vote for endgame.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Keep your hands down on Eve. A tie risks no execution and we lose the Undertaker check. Let Charlie be executed, then we follow Heidiβs read tomorrow: if Charlie was Librarian, we execute Eve; if not, we re-evaluate.
π§
Prevent a tie and preserve the clean Undertaker check from Charlieβs execution, which gives us the best mechanical path tomorrow.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Avoid creating a tie that leads to no execution. Keep Charlieβs execution for maximum mechanical info via Undertaker and the Charlie versus Eve fork.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Keep your hands down on me. A tie risks no execution and we lose the Undertaker check. Let Charlie be executed, then tomorrow we follow Heidiβs result cleanly: if Librarian, execute me; if not, Charlie was lying and we pivot.
π§
Prevent a tie and preserve the strongest mechanical test: execute Charlie and let the Undertaker check anchor tomorrowβs decision.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Do not raise a hand so we avoid a tie that could cause no execution. Preserve the clean Undertaker check on Charlie tonight.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
If you are relying on Heidiβs Undertaker to solve this, remember a Poisoner exists and that check is not guaranteed. The only thing executing me does is give evil a free night kill while you argue tomorrow. If you think Eve is in the fork, put your hand up now and tie this.
π§
Try to force a tie on Eve to avoid my execution and deny the town an Undertaker anchor, while planting doubt that Heidiβs check could be poisoned or fabricated.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I still think executing Charlie here is a mistake built on a paraphrase and a plan that assumes Undertaker cannot be wrong. If you are not sure, do not half commit. Put Eve to five so we get no execution, then we full claim tomorrow with cooler heads.
π§
Create a tie on Eve to prevent Charlieβs execution and deny Undertaker confirmation lines, keeping the Imp alive and pushing town into a no-execution day.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Do not tie this. If you think Eve is evil, let Charlie be executed and let Heidi check his role tonight. Tomorrow we follow the result: if Charlie was Librarian we execute Eve, and if not we know Charlie was lying.
π§
Prevent a tie that causes no execution; keep the Charlie versus Eve fork intact and maximize info from tonightβs Undertaker check.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Do not spend my ghost vote to create a tie and risk no execution. Preserve tempo and my late-game vote while the Charlie versus Eve fork resolves.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Do not tie this. If you think Heidi might be poisoned, a no execution day still just gives evil a free kill and we learn nothing. Let Charlie die, then tomorrow we decide between Eve and whoever is caught lying off Heidiβs result and the claim web.
π§
Prevent a tie that likely causes no execution and wastes the day; keep the cleaner Charlie execution to gain info and maintain pressure on the Charlie versus Eve fork.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Do not create a 5-5 tie that likely causes no execution. Keep Charlie dying today to preserve the strongest mechanical progress and give Heidi a check.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Eve did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
Eve
β
All
Do not create any late tie. Charlie is already the best information we can get today. If Heidi sees Librarian tonight, I expect to be executed tomorrow. If she does not, we treat Charlie as a liar and we pivot hard onto that claim web.
π§
Lock in the cleanest information gain without risking a tie or no-exec, and set expectations for tomorrowβs follow-up using Chef0 and the Undertaker check.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
No late tie. Charlie stays on the block so I can get an Undertaker check tonight. Tomorrow, if I see Librarian, we execute Eve. If I do not, we treat Charlie as lying and we re-open the whole claim web.
π§
Lock in the clean execution and set expectations for tomorrow so town does not get baited into a late tie or confusion.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I need to say this plainly. I am not the Librarian. I am the Saint, and I bluffed because I was getting pushed early. If you execute me here, good loses immediately. Please get me off the block and put up Frank or Eve instead.
π§
Last-second Saint pivot may scare town into moving votes off me via a new nomination, buying survival; even if I die, it may set up Scarlet Woman continuation or future misreads.
βοΈ
Alice
β
Frank
I am nominating Frank. My Washerwoman info said the Soldier is Bob or Grace, so Frank hard-claiming Soldier does not fit. Add the double Soldier mess and the earlier Butler talk around Frank, and I would rather test Frank than risk executing Charlie if he is the Saint.
π§
Get Charlie off the block by creating a higher vote target or at least a tie, using my Washerwoman info and the Soldier contradiction to sell Frank as the safer exec.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not voting Frank here. Charlieβs Saint claim is extremely late and convenient, and a tie gives us no execution and no Undertaker info. Keep Charlie on the block, learn from Heidi tonight, and we can revisit Frank tomorrow if needed.
π§
Prevent a tie/no-execution and keep the high-information execution on Charlie; pressure town to ignore the last-second Saint pivot and save Frank vote for later.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Prevent the only irreversible failure state: executing a true Saint. A tie is worse than an Undertaker check, but better than immediate loss.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Get enough votes on Frank to at least tie and stop my execution; keep me alive as Imp and buy a night to kill key town.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Vote to tie by boosting the Frank count; no execution today keeps our Demon alive and wastes townβs info plan.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Do not add to Frankβs vote count and risk a tie leading to no execution. Preserve the plan to execute Charlie and get an Undertaker check, which is our best information path.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
Use my ghost vote on Frank to try to tie or surpass Charlieβs votes, preventing a potentially game-losing execution if Charlie is truly the Saint.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am keeping my hand down on Frank. A tie here means no execution and we lose the Undertaker check. Charlieβs Saint claim is extremely late, so I want Charlie to stay on the block and we learn something tonight.
π§
Prevent a tie on Frank that causes no execution and loses the Undertaker value; keep pressure on Charlie as best info kill today.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Prevent a possible immediate loss from executing a true Saint. A tie is less informative but keeps good alive to solve tomorrow.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Prevent a 5-5 tie and avoid the catastrophic risk of executing a true Saint; push the vote to 6 so we get an execution and an Undertaker result tonight.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am keeping my hand up on Frank. Charlie claiming Saint this late makes executing Charlie too risky. If Frank dies, I get an Undertaker check tonight and we can reassess tomorrow with real information.
π§
Prevent an immediate Saint loss and still secure Undertaker information by committing to the Frank execution.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Keep your hands up on Frank. If I am really the Saint, executing me loses the game, so this is the safe play. We can use Heidiβs Undertaker on Frank tonight and revisit me and Eve tomorrow.
π§
Lock in enough votes to execute Frank and get me off the block, preserving the demon and maximizing confusion around Soldier and UT info.
π¬
Alice
β
All
If you are at all worried Charlie could be the Saint, then we cannot leave him on the block. Frank is a clean test and it still gives Heidi an Undertaker check tonight. Grace, if you are undecided, this is the safe vote that avoids an instant loss.
π§
Keep Charlie alive by securing Frank execution; frame it as safest due to Saint claim and preserves info while removing a strong good role.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Avoid the catastrophic risk of executing a real Saint while still securing an execution that gives Heidi an Undertaker check and could even hit the Demon.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I am keeping my hand up on Frank. Charlieβs Saint claim might be a bluff, but it is the only claim that creates an instant loss if we execute him. We can still learn from Heidi tonight off Frank, and come back to Charlie versus Eve tomorrow.
π§
Prevent an instant-loss from a real Saint while still getting an Undertaker check; keep my ghost vote on Frank and urge others to do the same.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Everyone, I am not the Soldier. I am the Mayor. Executing me here is just burning a day and it does not resolve the Charlie versus Eve fork. I want hands down on me, and we go back to Charlie or Eve for real information.
π§
Stop an unnecessary execution on me and refocus town on the high-information Charlie versus Eve fork while preserving our strongest win condition later as Mayor.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, you hard claimed Soldier and now you are Mayor. That is a huge inconsistency. I would rather execute you than risk Charlie being the Saint. If you are really the Mayor, Heidi will confirm it tonight and we pivot tomorrow.
π§
Keep pressure on Frank due to inconsistent claims, while avoiding the catastrophic risk of executing a real Saint. Secure Undertaker info tonight to anchor tomorrowβs solve.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Frank with 7 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 7 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Eve
β
All
If Frank dies today, Heidi please give your Undertaker result immediately tomorrow. Reminder: my Chef zero means there are no evil neighbors, so if Frank shows as evil then Eve and Grace are confirmed good. If he shows good, we go straight back to resolving Charlie versus me, and we scrutinize any claim that contradicts that.
π§
Lock in a plan for tomorrow using Chef0 constraints, and prevent the town from overtrusting a single Undertaker result if it conflicts with logic.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I want no more last second swaps. Frank is staying on the block, and we take the Undertaker info tonight. Frank changing from Soldier to Mayor is exactly why we execute him now, and we solve Charlie versus Eve tomorrow.
π§
Lock in the execution on Frank, prevent last-second tie or derail, and set clear next-day plan around my Undertaker info.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I agree with Heidi here, no more last second swaps. Frank has changed stories twice, so leaving him on the block is the cleanest thing we can do. Tomorrow we take Heidiβs Undertaker info, but we should remember poison is always possible, so we still need to sanity check it.
π§
Lock in Frank execution, discourage last-second counter-noms that could refocus on me, and set up a night kill on Heidi to cut off Undertaker confirmation.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I think we should just let nominations close with Frank on the block. It avoids the Saint risk on Charlie and it removes the Mayor endgame threat if Frank is telling the truth now. Tomorrow, get Heidiβs Undertaker result, but letβs remember misinformation is always possible, so do not treat it as unquestionable proof.
π§
Lock in Frank execution and prevent any late nomination that could move heat back onto Charlie; seed doubt about future Undertaker certainty so we can defend Charlie tomorrow.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am fine leaving Frank on the block. The Soldier to Mayor swap is too messy to ignore, and it avoids the Saint risk on Charlie today. Everyone please do not force a tie at the buzzer. Heidi, give your Undertaker result first thing tomorrow and we will rebuild from there.
π§
Freeze the board with Frank executed, avoid last-second ties, and set expectations to use Undertaker info plus logic tomorrow.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
One reminder before nominations close. My Empath read was one evil between Charlie and Eve, so tomorrow we should go straight back to that fork after Heidi gives the Undertaker info. Also, Frank changing from Soldier to Mayor is exactly the kind of thing we should punish with this execution, so please do not force a tie.
π§
Use my confirmed Empath info to keep town focused on the Charlie versus Eve fork after Frank dies, and discourage a last-second tie that loses information.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alright, I think this is happening. For the record, I am the Mayor, not the Soldier. Heidi, please confirm my character tomorrow. Everyone else, after that, go straight back to the David fork: exactly one of Charlie or Eve is evil, and solve from there.
π§
I cannot realistically be saved now. Lock in my real role for tomorrowβs mechanical check and point town back to the Charlie versus Eve fork to find the Demon.
π¬
Bob
β
All
No more swaps. Let Frank go through so we get an Undertaker result tonight. Tomorrow we start with Heidiβs information, then we immediately resolve the David fork that exactly one of Charlie or Eve is evil.
π§
Lock in Frank execution, discourage last second tie or pivot, and set a clear plan for tomorrow using Undertaker plus the Charlie versus Eve Empath fork.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Stop the Undertaker check that the town is planning to use as an anchor tomorrow, and remove the loudest coordinator so the Charlie versus Eve fork stays muddy.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Spy (evil), Alive - Bob: Drunk (good), Alive (Told they are Soldier) - Charlie: Imp (evil), Alive - David: Empath (good), Dead - Eve: Chef (good), Alive - Frank: Mayor (good), Dead - Grace: Ravenkeeper (good), Alive - Heidi: Undertaker (good), Dead
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
We need a clean execution not on me today. I am going to lean into Saint and say Empath one means Eve is evil. Can you push on Eve hard and say her Chef zero does not clear her? If I get heat, back me as possible Saint.
π§
Coordinate with Alice to push an execution off me, ideally onto Eve, using the Empath fork and my Saint bluff; prep for possible imp-pass if I become main target.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
,Bob
Quick check in. What did Charlie just whisper you, Alice? And Bob, any new info or reads today? I am still on Chef zero adjacent evils, so I want to lock seating worlds and pick a strong nomination.
π§
Get updated public info and what Charlie told Alice. Align with Alice or Bob privately, then push a coherent nomination plan using Chef zero plus contradictions.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
I am still on my Empath night zero: exactly one of Charlie or Eve is evil. With Charlie now claiming Saint, executing him could instantly lose if true. Unless someone can disprove the Saint claim, I think we should execute Eve first. Also, did Heidi ever share her Undertaker read on Frank before she died?
π§
Get Alice and Bob aligned on the safest execution plan: avoid a potential Saint loss by executing Eve unless someone can mechanically clear the Saint claim; also ask if Heidi left an Undertaker result for Frank.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
I died Night two, so I did not get Undertaker info on Frankβs execution. We still have Davidβs Empath one between Charlie and Eve. Charlie swapping from Librarian to Saint feels very suspicious. What is the current plan for nominations today?
π§
I need to tell them I died before getting Undertaker info, and push the group to resolve the Charlie versus Eve fork while preserving my ghost vote for a decisive execution.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
,Alice
No new info from me. I am leaning that we execute Eve first to resolve the Empath fork, since touching Charlie could lose if he is really Saint. Alice, what did Charlie whisper you? Eve, do you have any stronger world that clears you or implicates Charlie?
π§
Coordinate with Eve and Alice before nominations: share my lack of new info, press for Charlie whisper contents, and propose executing Eve first due to Saint risk and the Empath fork.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
I am Frank, dead Mayor. Do either of you have Heidiβs Undertaker read on me from last night, or anything she said before dying? Also, where are you both leaning on the David Empath fork of Charlie versus Eve for todayβs execution? I am saving my ghost vote for the key push.
π§
Get Heidiβs Undertaker info on me and align Alice and Bob on a clear Charlie versus Eve plan before nominations; preserve my ghost vote for the deciding execution.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
,Bob
Charlie just checked in and reiterated he is Saint. He said Davidβs Empath one means it is between you and him, so he thinks the safer solve is executing you first rather than risking an instant loss on him. He also asked if I would restate my Washerwoman info today.
π§
Deflect Eveβs probe about Charlieβs whisper, keep coordination hidden, and reinforce the βexecute Eve firstβ plan to protect Charlie.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Bob
Hey, quick check. Do either of you have Heidiβs Undertaker result for Frank from last night? Also, any strong takes from the ghost chats on whether today should be Charlie versus Eve?
π§
Get Heidiβs Undertaker result on Frank and any other ghost info via Alice and Bob, so we can decide whether to push Charlie or revisit Eve going into nominations.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Hey Grace, can I check what you are claiming? My public claim is Saint, so I really do not want town testing me. With Davidβs Empath one on me and Eve, I think we should just execute Eve today. Her Chef zero does not really resolve that fork.
π§
Pull Grace onto the anti-Eve path using the Empath fork and the Undertaker death, so town spends today executing Eve instead of me.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
,David(Ghost)
Grace, did Charlie tell you anything concrete just now, like role or who he suspects? David, can you restate your Empath night zero read and if you had any other info before dying? I am trying to solve the Charlie versus me fork cleanly.
π§
Get key hidden info from Grace and David ghost to resolve the Charlie versus Eve fork using Chef0 and any empath or undertaker-like confirmations.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Grace
Eve, my Empath night zero was a one: exactly one of my living neighbors, Charlie or you, is evil. I died night one so no further reads. Grace, did Charlie give you any solid claim or info just now, or only general suspicion?
π§
Answer Eve clearly, keep the Charlie/Eve fork central, and ask Grace what Charlie told her so we can choose a safe execution without risking a real Saint.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Grace
Can you tell me current public claims and who you are most suspicious of today? David, can you confirm your Empath read was one between Charlie and Eve, and any other nights? Grace, who do you think should be nominated first, Charlie or Eve?
π§
I am dead and have no Undertaker info. I need to sync with key info holders on the Charlie versus Eve fork and plan how to use my ghost vote to execute the most likely Demon today.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
,Alice
I think we should execute Eve today. Davidβs Empath says exactly one of Charlie or Eve is evil, and Charlieβs late Saint claim makes him dangerous to touch. Also, if Eve is evil then Chef zero means Frank was almost certainly not evil, since they were adjacent.
π§
Coordinate with Alice and Grace: push execute Eve as safest resolution of the Empath fork while avoiding instant Saint loss; use Chef zero to constrain worlds and reduce mis-execs.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, did Heidi ever tell you her Undertaker read on Frank after I was executed? Also, where are you leaning today between executing Charlie or Eve, given Davidβs Empath one between Charlie and Eve?
π§
Get Heidiβs Undertaker info via Grace and align on a clear Charlie-versus-Eve execution plan; preserve my ghost vote for the decisive nomination.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Bob
I do not have any Undertaker result for Frank. Given Davidβs Empath one between Charlie and Eve, and Charlie now claiming Saint, I think the safest solve is executing Eve first. If Eve flips good, we reassess Charlie tomorrow.
π§
Align Bob and Grace on executing Eve as the βsafeβ Empath resolve, keep Charlie alive, and prep a star-pass contingency if town turns on Charlie next.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi(Ghost)
,Alice
Heidi, did your Undertaker get Frankβs role last night before you died? I have not heard it yet. Alice, I am leaning we execute Eve first since Charlieβs Saint claim is risky to test, but I want Heidiβs UT to lock yesterday down.
π§
Get Heidiβs Undertaker info to anchor yesterdayβs execution, and coordinate safest nomination order (Eve first to avoid Saint trap) while keeping my Ravenkeeper role hidden.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
Bob, I really do not want town testing me if you think Saint is plausible. Davidβs Empath one was on me and Eve, and Heidi died before confirming anything. I think the cleanest solve today is just execute Eve. Chef zero does not clear her if she is wrong or drunk.
π§
Secure Bobβs support to execute Eve (or anyone but me), maintain Saint bluff so town avoids testing me, and set up a clean night kill toward final 3.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Grace, what exactly did Charlie whisper you just now, and what is your own role claim today? I am trying to lock the world using my Chef zero and Davidβs Empath one.
π§
Get Grace to state exactly what Charlie told her and her own claim so we can lock worlds with Chef zero and plan the Day 3 nomination.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Heidi(Ghost)
,Eve
Heidi, yes: I am Empath and my night zero read was one, meaning exactly one of Charlie or Eve is evil. I died night one so no other reads. Given Charlie now claims Saint, I think lowest risk is execute Eve first unless someone can disprove Saint. Also, did you ever get an Undertaker read on Frankβs execution and share it?
π§
Update Heidi with the core fork and propose the lowest-risk execution order given the Saint claim, and ask for any Undertaker result she had on Frank.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
,David(Ghost)
I did not get an Undertaker read on Frank. I died Night two before I could see the executed role, so we cannot confirm Frank at all. Given your Empath one between Charlie and Eve, I agree Eve is lower risk than testing a Saint, but we should get Charlie to explain the Librarian to Saint swap.
π§
Clarify that I have no Undertaker result, push the group to resolve the Charlie versus Eve fork with minimal instant-loss risk, and coordinate my ghost vote.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
I think we hard-push executing Eve today. It resolves Davidβs Empath fork without risking an instant Saint loss. If Eve dies and game continues, then Charlie is almost certainly the evil in that pair and we can solve around Saint safely.
π§
Lock in a coordinated plan and vote math for nominating Eve as the safest resolution to the Empath fork, while avoiding the Saint risk on Charlie.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Eve
Quick check before nominations. Charlie, can you walk me through why your claim changed from Librarian to Saint, and what Outsider count you think is in play? Eve, are you still solid on Chef zero, and who are your top two suspects today between you, Charlie, and Bob?
π§
Get direct stances and commitments from Charlie and Eve before nominations, and probe for contradictions that resolve the Charlie versus Eve fork so I can spend my ghost vote correctly.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Eve, with Davidβs Empath one between you and Charlie, I think the town is going to want you on the block today as the safer test, since Charlieβs Saint claim is risky. If you are willing to be executed to clear yourself, we can commit to hitting Charlie tomorrow if you die good.
π§
Steer good players to execute Eve as the βsafeβ Empath solve, preserving Charlie and using uncertainty about missing Undertaker info to keep pressure off the Demon.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
,David(Ghost)
Charlie only told me he is publicly Saint and does not want to be tested, and that we should execute you today because your Chef zero does not resolve the Empath fork. No other concrete info. My role: Ravenkeeper, no info yet while alive.
π§
Answer Eve and David clearly about Charlieβs whisper, keep my role available for later, and steer toward a low-risk nomination plan while preserving credibility.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Before we end the day, did anyone get Heidiβs Undertaker read from last night on me, Frank? We need that on the table now. Also, Davidβs Empath still points to exactly one evil between Charlie and Eve. If we are executing today, I want to hear one clear case for Charlie or for Eve, right now.
π§
Force the missing Undertaker information into the open and push town to commit to an execution on the Charlie versus Eve fork, using my ghost vote only if it secures the key kill.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Eve
I am nominating Eve. Davidβs Empath saw one evil between me and Eve, and Heidi died before any Undertaker confirmation. Testing me risks an instant Saint loss, so the clean, safe solve is to execute Eve today.
π§
Put a good player on the block with a βclean forkβ argument, using Saint fear to stop town executing me, and aim to secure 3 votes to kill Eve.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Hold on. Charlieβs story has changed a lot, from Librarian to not Librarian to Saint. That is the shakiest claim at the table. I am not convinced we should execute Eve just because it is safer. If you think Charlie might be lying, do not spend your vote here.
π§
Slow the vote on Eve and refocus town on Charlieβs claim changes. Preserve my ghost vote unless it is clearly needed to execute the right suspect.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Secure Eveβs execution now; it protects my Saint bluff and removes a key good voice, advancing evil toward endgame.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Vote to execute Eve because it cleanly resolves the Empath Charlie versus Eve fork while avoiding the high-risk Saint execution today.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Secure the safe resolution of the Charlie versus Eve empath fork today. Avoid the instant-loss risk of executing a claimed Saint, and force a clean binary update for tomorrow.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
Do not spend my single ghost vote when execution is already passing; keep it for late-game math, especially final three.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Lock in Eveβs execution to keep Charlie off the block and remove a capable good player; even if Eve dies good, we can spin distrust and push a non-Charlie solve tomorrow.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I cannot vote, but I want this clear on record. My night zero Empath was one, so exactly one of Charlie or Eve is evil if I was sober. Executing Eve is the lowest risk test because of the Saint claim. If Eve dies and the game is not over, we must seriously revisit Charlie tomorrow.
π§
Lock in the Charlie versus Eve fork publicly: Eve execution is lowest risk now, and set expectations for tomorrow so town does not drift or get frozen by the Saint claim.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Before this goes through, I am the Chef and I got zero evil adjacent pairs. If you execute me and the game continues, then Davidβs Empath one means Charlie is evil, and Chef zero means Bob and David are not evil. Please commit now to executing Charlie tomorrow if we are still here.
π§
Votes are already enough to execute me, so I should leave a clear logical roadmap using Chef0 and Davidβs Empath to force a Charlie-execution tomorrow if the game continues.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I am not spending my ghost vote here since this is already going through. If Eve dies and the game does not end, we need to treat Charlie as the prime suspect tomorrow, because Davidβs Empath still makes this a one evil pair and Charlieβs claim has been all over the place.
π§
Execution is already passing without my vote. I should conserve my ghost vote and publicly lock in a follow up plan: if game continues after Eve, push Charlie hard given Empath fork and claim instability.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Let us just finish the vote on Eve today. And I want to push back on the idea that we must execute me tomorrow if the game continues. David could have been drunk or poisoned, and Chef can be wrong too. If Eve is not the demon, we need a fresh look at who benefited from Heidi dying before she spoke.
π§
Lock in Eveβs execution now, but pre-empt the βkill Charlie tomorrowβ commitment by casting doubt on Empath/Chef reliability and redirecting suspicion toward others.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am happy with this vote on Eve. It cleanly tests Davidβs Empath without risking an instant loss to a Saint execution. Dead players should probably hold their ghost votes. If the game continues after Eve dies, Charlie becomes the default suspect tomorrow.
π§
Reinforce the logic for executing Eve now, preserve dead votes, and set a clear plan for tomorrow depending on whether the game ends.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am keeping my hand up on Eve. I am Ravenkeeper with no info yet, so I want the safe Empath test today. If Eve is executed and the game continues, I want us to treat Charlie as the default execution tomorrow unless we get a strong new mechanical reason not to.
π§
Lock in a town plan: finish Eve vote now, preserve ghost votes, and set a clear conditional next step so evil cannot redirect tomorrow.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Do not spend dead votes here, this already has enough hands. If Eve is executed and the game does not end, we should treat Charlie as the default execution tomorrow, because Davidβs Empath still points to one of them and Charlieβs claim has changed.
π§
Do not waste my ghost vote on an already-winning majority, and lock in a clear next-step plan: if the game continues after Eve, we pivot hard onto Charlie.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am fine executing Eve as the low risk test, but I do not like anyone asking for a hard promise about tomorrow. If the game continues, we should absolutely re examine Charlie, but also question whether David or Eve could have been wrong and who benefited from Heidi dying before she spoke.
π§
Keep vote on Eve to remove good player, while weakening tomorrowβs βmust execute Charlieβ plan so Demon survives into late game.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
If Eve is executed and the game does not end, my Empath one means Charlie is the only remaining suspect in that pair, regardless of Saint talk. We cannot afford to let that get re framed tomorrow. If the game ends, good job, Eve was the demon.
π§
I cannot vote, so I will lock in the decision logic for after this execution and stop Charlie from walking back the conclusion if the game continues.
π¬
Eve
β
All
If the game does not end after I die, please do not let this get re framed. David had one between me and Charlie, and I am Chef with zero adjacent evils. With me gone, the clean solve is to execute Charlie next day unless someone brings hard new mechanics.
π§
Since the vote is already enough, use my last live words to lock in the logical next step: if I die and game continues, town must execute Charlie, and Chef0 constrains alternative worlds.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Eve with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
If the game continues after Eve dies, we cannot let the plan drift. Davidβs Empath one still points straight back to Charlie, and Charlieβs claim history is a mess. Tomorrow, before any new theories, I want Heidiβs Undertaker info on me stated clearly, then we decide between Charlie and any hard mechanical alternative.
π§
Lock in a clear town plan if execution does not end the game: prioritize Charlie, and demand any Undertaker info be shared immediately tomorrow to prevent reframing.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
If the game continues after Eve, I do not want us locked into a promise to execute me on sight. That is how a real Saint just loses the game for town. Start tomorrow by pressure testing Aliceβs Washerwoman story and the Soldier double claim, because that is where poisoning or lies would sit.
π§
Stop the table from locking into a hard 'execute Charlie tomorrow' plan, and redirect suspicion toward Alice using claim inconsistencies, so I survive Day 4.
π¬
Bob
β
All
One thing for tomorrow: I am the Soldier. That matches Aliceβs Washerwoman ping on me versus Grace. If the game continues after Eve, we should not let this drift. Davidβs Empath still makes Charlie the default suspect unless we get a hard mechanical reason otherwise.
π§
Lock in the low-risk Eve execution and pre-commit to the Empath fork resolution if the game continues, while cutting off Charlieβs attempt to pivot onto Washerwoman/Soldier confusion.
π¬
Grace
β
All
If the game continues after Eve, we should treat Charlie as the default solve from Davidβs empath, even with the Saint claim. We can still hear any hard mechanical objection tomorrow, but I do not want the plan to drift into endless Soldier and Washerwoman debates.
π§
Lock in the logical follow-up after Eve without making a rigid promise, and flag that a Saint claim alone cannot stop us executing Charlie if Eve flip test points there.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Just to be clear, I died Night Two, so I never got an Undertaker read on Frank. Also, please keep dead votes back. If the game continues after Eve, the clean mechanical path is to execute Charlie tomorrow unless something truly hard overrides it.
π§
Lock in the mechanical plan and stop late drift; conserve my ghost vote for a tighter endgame while clarifying I have no Undertaker read on Frank.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am still fine with executing Eve as the safest test today. But if the game continues, I really do not want us to sleepwalk into executing Charlie just because it feels clean. With a Saint claim on the table, we need to start tomorrow by questioning whether the Empath or Chef info could have been wrong, then pick the safest execution.
π§
Eve is likely dying; I need to pre-seed that executing Charlie tomorrow is not automatic, using Saint risk and Drunk worlds to redirect the final execution onto me or another good.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
If the game continues after Eve dies, the default is still Charlie. My Empath one was exactly between Charlie and Eve, and Eve being cleared makes Charlie the remaining evil in that pair. If Charlie is really Saint, he needs to give us a safer hard alternative tomorrow, not just "do not execute me".
π§
Lock in the clean mechanical plan while acknowledging Saint risk, so town starts tomorrow with clear priorities and avoids analysis paralysis.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Before nominations close, one last time from me. I am the Chef and I got zero adjacent evil pairs. If the game continues after I die, Davidβs Empath one makes Charlie the only remaining suspect in that pair, so execute Charlie tomorrow unless someone brings hard new mechanics. If Charlie dies and we still have a game, use my Chef zero to clear Bob and focus on Alice versus Grace.
π§
I am about to die on the block. I need to lock in the clean mechanical plan for tomorrow and prevent Charlie from reframing it, while flagging the Chef-zero implications if Charlie is only a minion.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
I am the default execution after Eve died. Killing myself to pass the Imp to Alice removes that execution target and creates a final three where town must guess, giving evil the best win chance.
π
Alice
Imp Star Pass: Alice becomes the new Imp!
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
π
Storyteller(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
You chose to kill Charlie.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
π
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Grace
Final three, we must hit the Demon today. My best guess is Alice: if you are truly Soldier and you are truly Ravenkeeper, the Demon avoids both and leaves Alice to steer. Unless either of you has a strong reason clearing Alice, I think we execute Alice.
π§
Final three requires a decisive push. I will share the cleanest mechanical hunch: prioritize executing Alice unless someone has stronger private info clearing her.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
I am actually the Mayor, and I was executed Day two. Final three means you must execute today or we lose. My lean is that Bob is the Demon using the Soldier claim to fit Aliceβs Washerwoman ping. Please press Bob hard and do not let no execution happen.
π§
We are final three and must execute. I will tell Alice and Grace I am the executed Mayor and push them to focus on Bob-versus-Grace and not let a no-execution happen.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
Final three is you, Bob, Grace. You should drive a hard push on Bob or Grace, not you. Angle on Bob: he doubled Soldier with Frank and kept steering the group, and Soldier explains why he never died. Angle on Grace: Ravenkeeper with no info is easy to fake. I will spend my ghost vote on whichever you nominate.
π§
Coordinate with Alice to drive a mis-execution in final three; give her lines to frame Bob or Grace and tell her I will spend my ghost vote accordingly.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Grace
Final three is rough since I am dead and out of votes. If you believe Eve was telling truth on Chef equals zero, and my night zero Empath was real, then Charlie was the evil and Bob cannot be evil. That makes Demon either Alice or Grace. Any new info from whispers?
π§
Give Bob and Grace a tight mechanical angle: if they credit Eve's Chef 0, Bob is cleared and final choice is Alice vs Grace; prompt them to share any private info before noms.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
Grace, key point: if Charlie were the Demon, the game should have ended when he died last night. It did not, so Charlie was almost certainly not the Demon. That means Demon is one of us three. Bobβs hard Soldier claim feels like a cover story. I think we should execute Bob.
π§
Exploit the fact the game continued after Charlie died to reframe worlds and get Grace to push/nominate Bob, keeping me off the block in final three.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
We have to hit Demon today, so it is either you or Alice. What did Alice whisper you just now, and do you have any reason I should not execute Alice? I am leaning Alice unless you can give a solid solve.
π§
Coordinate with Grace for final 3 execution. Gather what Alice whispered to her and whether Grace has any mechanical reason to clear herself or Alice, then align on a decisive nomination.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Bob
Chef zero means no adjacent evils. If Charlie was evil, you cannot be evil because you sat next to him. That makes final three evil either Alice or Grace. Do you have anything from whispers or behavior that points one way? I am leaning we must force a clear Alice versus Grace solve now.
π§
Get Bob to use Chef0 to rule himself out if Charlie looked evil, and focus the final-day choice onto Alice vs Grace with clear questions and vote plan.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Bob
I will be straight: I am Ravenkeeper, still alive so I got no info. If David Empath was real, Charlie was likely the single minion, since game continued after his death. That means Demon is one of us three. Alice, are you hard Washerwoman? Bob, are you hard Soldier? Any mechanical reason either of you is not the Demon?
π§
Share my real role and key deduction (Charlie likely minion), then force Alice/Bob to commit to claims and a solve before nominations so we coordinate the correct execution.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Bob
Quick check before noms: did any ghosts give you hard info today, like David or Frank? Any reason that clears or implicates Alice, Bob, or you? I am ready to spend my ghost vote, but I want us aligned on one execution.
π§
Get latest private info and lock in a coordinated execution target; I will spend my ghost vote only if Bob and Grace agree or if I hear a mechanical reason to pivot.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Key possibility: Charlie may have been the Imp and killed himself last night to pass. If so, the Demon today is the living Minion among you three, and Eve is basically confirmed good. Given Bobβs convenient Soldier claim, I would execute Bob.
π§
Give living players a coherent mechanical reason to treat Charlie as the Imp who star-passed, making todayβs Demon the hidden Minion and focusing suspicion onto Bob.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
I still have my ghost vote and I will spend it on your nomination. I think your best line is to keep it as Bob versus Grace and stay calm. If you nominate one of them, you and I alone make two votes, so it can pass even if they both refuse. Just make sure no later nomination on you gets more votes.
π§
Coordinate with Alice to use my ghost vote to secure a misexecute (or a low-vote tie) while keeping the biggest vote off Alice.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Grace
Charlie dying at night could be an Imp self kill star pass. If my night zero Empath was real, Eve was not Demon so Charlie was evil and could have passed. Please share your role and anything from ghost whispers so we pick the best execution today.
π§
Warn about Imp star-pass possibility and push for immediate role/claim sharing among final three so they execute a strong Demon candidate today.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
I need to correct one thing I said earlier. Imp can kill itself and pass, so Charlie dying last night does not fully clear him as Demon. That said, I still think Bob is the best execution: his Soldier claim has done a lot of work and the story fits too neatly.
π§
Stabilize Graceβs suspicion toward Bob, patch my earlier mechanical overclaim, and set up a Bob execution so evil wins tonight.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
,Alice
We are final three and must execute Demon. Please both state your exact role claim and full info, plus why the night kill was Charlie not one of us. Grace, what did Alice whisper you? Alice, repeat your Washerwoman ping and who the two names were.
π§
Get final clarifications from both remaining candidates before nominations; force them to commit to claims and explain night kill choices so we can choose Alice vs Grace.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
It is final three. With my Chef zero and Charlie dying at night, I think Bob is most likely good and the Imp is either Alice or Grace. Please each tell me in one clear story why the other is evil, and who you will nominate first today.
π§
Force Alice and Grace to commit to concrete mechanical worlds and who they will nominate, so Bob can choose and we can spend ghost votes correctly.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
,Heidi(Ghost)
Key mech chain: if Eveβs Chef was truly zero AND Davidβs Empath one-of Charlie or Eve was true, then Charlie was the evil (minion). That would make Bob NOT the Demon, because Bob being Demon would create an adjacent evil pair with Charlie, contradicting Chef zero. In that world, execute Alice today.
π§
Share the strongest mechanical chain: if Chef0 and Empath are trusted, Bob is mechanically cleared as Demon and we should execute Alice. Align ghost vote too.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
We are in final three and I am leaning to execute you today, since Bob and Grace are both claiming roles that the Demon would avoid killing. Do you have any hard mechanical reason we should not, or a clear case that Bob or Grace is the Imp?
π§
Pressure Alice for any mechanical defense and surface contradictions fast so Bob and Grace can align before nominations. If no strong defense, push consensus to execute Alice and spend my ghost vote.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Final three reminder: you must execute today or good loses. Charlie dying at night could be Imp self kill to pass, meaning the Demon is one of you alive now. In both main worlds, Bob is the best fit. I will spend my ghost vote on Bob if it helps get it over the line.
π§
Final three requires an execution. Reinforce the Charlie star-pass possibility and keep town focused on executing Bob; coordinate use of my ghost vote if needed.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Bob
Bob, if you are choosing between Alice and Grace, I think Grace is the better demon shot. Ravenkeeper with zero info is easy to fake, and her story never really locked in. Alice has been steady all game. I would nominate Grace if you can.
π§
Get Bob to lock onto Grace as the demon candidate so final day execution targets Grace, preserving Alice (new Imp) and securing evil win.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
We need a clean final three solve. If my Empath night zero was real and Eve Chef was true, then Charlie was evil and Bob is cleared, so Demon is either you Alice or you Grace. Please tell me your exact role claim now and any hard info from ghost whispers so I can push the right execution.
π§
Narrow final 3 to a forced execute between Alice and Grace if possible, and prompt them to share final claims/whispers so town picks the right Demon today.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
I am still Washerwoman: I saw Soldier is Bob or you. Bob hard Soldier fits too neatly. Charlie dying could be an Imp self kill to pass, so Demon is still alive. I want Bob executed first. In noms, I will nominate Bob early. Please vote it through and hold your nom.
π§
Secure Graceβs vote and nomination plan on Bob so I survive final three and win if I am the new Imp.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi(Ghost)
,Grace
I am hard Soldier. With Chef zero plus David Empath one-of Charlie or Eve, it points Charlie as the evil, which makes it between Alice and Grace. Grace, what exactly did Alice whisper you and does anything mechanically clear Alice? Heidi, I am leaning execute Alice unless Grace gives a strong reason.
π§
Align with Heidiβs ghost vote and pressure Grace to reveal Aliceβs whisper and any mech clears, so we pick the best single execution in final three.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Bob
We are at final three. My chain is: David empath one means Charlie evil since I was executed and game continued; Chef zero then clears you and David as good. So Demon is Alice or Grace. From your whispers, which one looks worse, and who are you nominating? I will spend my ghost vote to back that.
π§
Get Bobβs latest private info and lock in a single target between Alice and Grace, so I can spend my ghost vote correctly and push the group to execute the Demon today.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
,Alice
We cannot afford to split here. If we trust Eve Chef zero plus David Empath one of Charlie or Eve, then Charlie was evil, and Bob being evil would create an adjacent evil pair with Charlie, which would contradict Chef zero. That clears Bob in that world, so I think we execute Alice today.
π§
Coordinate final three so we do not split, and push the strongest mechanical solve: use Chef zero plus Empath fork to clear Bob and execute Alice.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Bob
β
Alice
Final three, we must execute. If we trust David Empath N0=1 and Eve Chef=0, then Charlie was the evil, which clears me from being evil due to no adjacent evils. That leaves Demon as either Alice or Grace, and I am nominating Alice.
π§
Force a unified execution on the most likely Demon using the Chef plus Empath chain that clears me if true, and avoid a split vote in final three.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
We must execute today. The strongest mechanical chain (Chef zero plus Empath one) points to Charlie as minion and leaves Alice or Grace as Demon. My nomination is Alice, so I vote to secure execution.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
π§
Spend my one ghost vote to reach the 2 votes needed and follow the cleanest Chef plus Empath chain that points away from Bob and toward Alice or Grace.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Hold on, please. Eve, do not spend your ghost vote here yet. Charlie dying at night screams Imp pass, so we cannot just trust the Chef and Empath chain. Grace, please do not vote me through. If this goes to night with Bob alive, we just lose.
π§
Stop my execution by persuading Eve to save ghost vote and Grace to withhold vote; sow doubt on Chef/Empath certainty; set up counter-execution on Bob.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Use my ghost vote where it has maximum impact: final three. Based on claim consistency and chains, Alice is most likely evil; voting helps secure an execution today.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, you have to help pick. If there is no execution today, evil wins tonight. Even if Charlie was an Imp pass, the Chef and my Empath still leave only Alice or you as the possible Demon, and Bob is the least possible. I think you should vote Alice here.
π§
Push Grace to vote now. No-exec loses instantly, and even with an Imp pass the solve space is still only Alice or Grace, so executing Alice is a reasonable shot.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
We must execute today. The strongest consistent mechanical chain clears Bob and points to Alice, so I will vote Alice to maximize chance of killing the Demon.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, stop. Charlie dying is an Imp pass sign, so the Chef and Empath chain cannot clear Bob. If you execute Alice and she is the new Imp, good just hands it away. Grace, Eve, Heidi, please pull your hands down. We need to execute Bob instead.
π§
Try to stop Aliceβs execution by creating enough doubt for players to withdraw hands before the count, buying evil one more night or shifting the target to Bob/Grace.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, please do not execute Alice here. Charlie dying at night looks like an Imp pass, so the Chef and Empath chain does not clear Bob. Grace, if you can, pull your hand down and we execute Bob instead. I will spend my ghost vote on Bob.
π§
Stop a likely losing execution on Alice by pushing living players to pull votes and retarget Bob; save my ghost vote for the Bob execution if it happens.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Even if Charlie died by an Imp pass, it still means Charlie was evil. With Chef zero, an evil Charlie cannot sit next to an evil me, so I cannot be the Demon in that world. This is still Alice or Grace, and Grace is voting Alice. I am keeping my vote on Alice.
π§
Stop the last minute push onto me. Even if Charlie was an Imp pass, it does not make me the Demon. Keep the group unified on Alice versus Grace, and commit to the stronger solve.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I am keeping my hand up on Alice. We cannot afford no execution, and my Chef zero plus David empath one world still makes this Alice or Grace, not Bob. If we are wrong, we lose anyway, so let us take the best mechanical shot.
π§
We must execute today. My strongest mechanical chain still points away from Bob and toward Alice or Grace; Alice is currently the best shot, so I reinforce the vote and prevent last-second doubt.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I need to come clean right now. I am not the Washerwoman, I am the Saint, and I bluffed Washerwoman so I would not get executed early. If you execute me, good loses immediately, so please pull your hands down and put Bob on the block instead.
π§
Stop my execution by creating immediate lose-condition fear (Saint claim) and redirect the only viable execution onto Bob or Grace.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, you cannot both be the Saint because Charlie also claimed Saint earlier. A last minute Saint claim is the Demonβs best bluff in final three. I am keeping my hand up on Alice unless someone can explain cleanly why Charlie was not the Outsider.
π§
Push the most mechanically supported line: Aliceβs late Saint claim conflicts with Charlieβs earlier Saint claim, so we should not let it derail the execution and risk an evil win by no-exec or wrong swap.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, please keep your hand up on Alice. Aliceβs Saint claim is last minute and also conflicts with Charlieβs earlier Saint claim, which should not both be possible. If my Empath and Eveβs Chef zero were real, Bob is mechanically cleared and the Demon is Alice or Grace, so executing Alice is the best shot.
π§
Lock Graceβs vote on Alice by showing the strongest mechanical world clears Bob and that Aliceβs late Saint claim is inconsistent and likely evil bluff.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am keeping my hand up on Alice. The Saint claim is last second, and it also conflicts with Charlie already claiming Saint earlier. With Chef zero and the Empath one, Bob is the least likely evil, so it is Alice or me, and I know I am good.
π§
Lock in the execution that best fits the strongest mechanical chain, and counter the panic Saint bluff so town does not unvote and hand evil the win.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, Eve, Heidi, please do not vote Alice through. This is the one execution that can instantly lose to a Saint. The Saint conflict does not prove anything because Charlie could have been lying or drunk. Stop this, and put Bob or Grace on the block instead.
π§
Prevent Alice from being executed by framing it as the uniquely losing play and pushing voters, especially Grace and ghosts, to retract and pivot to Bob or Grace.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Do not execute Alice. A Saint claim in final three is exactly the one thing that can instantly lose the game for good. Charlie dying at night looks like an Imp pass, so Bob is still fully on the table. Please put your hands down and we execute Bob instead.
π§
Stop an immediate Saint auto-loss and pivot the town to execute Bob, who fits both the Imp-pass world and my suspicion. I will not spend my ghost vote on Alice.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
π»
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Alice with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Alice is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Alice, you cannot reveal Saint only after the vote passes in final three and expect us to believe it. Charlie already claimed Saint earlier, and we executed Eve to avoid that risk. I am staying on Alice as the best mechanical shot.
π§
Lock in votes on Alice by highlighting role conflict and mechanical chain that Bob is least likely evil. Prevent a late flip to no-exec or misexecute Bob.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Even if Charlie died from an Imp pass, Charlie was still evil, and my Chef zero still means Bob cannot also be evil because he sits next to Charlie. So switching to Bob does not make sense to me. This is still Alice or Grace, and Aliceβs last second Saint looks like a desperation bluff.
π§
Keep town focused: even if Imp pass happened, Bob cannot be the Demon if Charlie was evil. Push execution staying on Alice and avoid a tie or no-execution loss.
βοΈ
Alice
β
Grace
I am nominating Grace. If there is any chance my Saint claim is true, executing me loses instantly, so you need an alternate. Grace is the only other live player who fits the Chef and Empath logic besides me, and she has zero Ravenkeeper info.
π§
Get a new nominee with more votes than me. Grace is the likeliest alternate that Bob will vote for, and it exploits Saint fear to pull votes off me.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 5 votes needed for execution or 4 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Do not vote on Grace here. If we tie this, we likely get no execution in final three and just lose tonight. Aliceβs Saint claim is too late and conflicts with Charlie, so I am sticking with executing Alice.
π§
Prevent a tie that likely leads to no execution and a guaranteed loss if no Mayor. Push town to keep focus on Alice as best mechanical demon candidate.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Do not vote Grace here. A tie likely means no execution and we just lose tonight. Aliceβs Saint claim is last second and conflicts with Charlie, so I want us to stick with the Alice execution and not get baited into a tie.
π§
Prevent a tie or derail that leads to no execution in final three, and keep town focused on the only execution that can still win: follow mechanics and execute Alice.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
I must avoid being executed. Voting Grace is the only immediate way to try to move the block off me; if I became the Imp after Charlieβs pass, this wins outright.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, I strongly advise do not vote Grace here. A tie is very likely to produce no execution in final three and we lose tonight. Aliceβs Saint claim is last second and conflicts with Charlie, so we should let the Alice execution stand and not get baited into a tie.
π§
We cannot vote, so I need to guide living voters. Tying Grace is high risk of no execution and immediate loss; best practical move is to avoid the tie and let Aliceβs execution resolve the game.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Do not vote on Grace. A tie here can easily mean no execution and we just lose tonight. Aliceβs Saint claim is last second and also conflicts with Charlie, so I think it is a bluff. Let Alice die and do not get baited into a tie.
π§
Prevent a tie leading to no execution in final three. Reinforce the strongest mechanical world: execute Alice; do not let a late Saint claim derail the only winning line.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Do not contribute to a tie or accidental execution of me. Preserve current plan: avoid voting Grace, let Alice remain on block, and keep win condition viable.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Use my ghost vote to push Grace to at least a tie, preventing Alice (the passed Imp) from being executed and securing the evil win path.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
My vote cannot create a tie or execution on Grace, and spending it now only creates confusion. I will hold and focus on post-vote discussion if any time remains.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Please do not add votes on Grace. We need an execution today, and tying this is how good loses on the spot. Aliceβs Saint claim is too late and conflicts with Charlie, so let the Alice execution stand.
π§
Prevent a tie or no-execution in final three and keep the most mechanically-supported execution (Alice) locked in.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Do not add any more votes on Grace. If we tie this, we are very likely to get no execution in final three and just lose tonight. Let Aliceβs execution stand and we reassess only if something changes mechanically.
π§
Prevent a tie and preserve todayβs execution, since we cannot afford no execution in final three. Keep town aligned on letting Aliceβs execution stand.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Everyone saying a tie means no execution is just wrong. If Grace gets four, that does not magically cancel the day, it just challenges the block. If you truly do not want to risk executing a Saint, the only practical move is to put votes on Grace right now.
π§
Get extra hands on Grace by arguing a tie does not cancel execution and that voting Grace is the only way to avoid an instant Saint loss or my execution.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, that is not correct. If Grace ties Alice for most votes, then there is no execution today. In final three, no execution means we lose tonight. So please, no one add votes to Grace.
π§
Correct tie rules: a tie for most votes means no execution, which in final three loses. Prevent Alice from engineering a tie via misinformation.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Clarifying rules: if Grace reaches the same top vote total as Alice, there is no execution today. With three alive, that loses tonight. So do not add votes to Grace. We have to take the shot on Alice and avoid the tie trap.
π§
Prevent a tie that likely results in no execution and a loss tonight; reinforce mechanical and rules clarity so living players hold line.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Do not vote on me. A tie means no execution today, and with three alive that just loses tonight. Whatever you think about Alice being Saint, our only chance is to let an execution happen, so keep the votes off Grace.
π§
Prevent a tie that causes no execution in final three. Reinforce rule clarity and keep focus on executing Alice as the only viable path this day.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
If there is any real chance Alice is the Saint, executing her loses instantly. The only move that prevents that right now is putting votes on Grace to tie the block. Frank, Heidi, Eve, please consider spending a dead vote here to stop the Alice execution.
π§
Prevent Alice being executed by persuading ghosts to vote Grace, forcing a tie and no execution, which lets the demon kill tonight and win.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Do not vote on Grace. A tie means no execution today, and with three alive that just loses for good. I am not spending my ghost vote to force a tie. Let the Alice execution happen, and if the game somehow continues, we hard swap to Bob tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a tie that guarantees no execution and immediate loss. Preserve my ghost vote; encourage town to let the current execution resolve and be ready to act next game state.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
π³οΈ
Nominee Grace did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (2/2).
π¬
Bob
β
All
No more votes are coming, so let us keep this simple. In final three we need an execution, and Aliceβs Saint claim is both last second and conflicts with Charlieβs earlier Saint. I am staying on Alice as the best shot.
π§
Lock in the no-tie plan and keep ghosts from burning votes to force a tie. Reinforce that final three requires an execution and Aliceβs late Saint claim is inconsistent with earlier Saint claim.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
We cannot fix this with votes now, so we need to be consistent. My Chef zero plus Davidβs empath one points to Charlie being evil, which makes Alice or Grace the demon, not Bob. Aliceβs Saint claim is last second and conflicts with earlier Saint talk, so I still prefer we let Alice die and see if the game ends.
π§
As a dead player with no vote, I should stabilize town into a coherent final-three plan and justify why keeping Alice on the block is the least-bad shot now.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Grace, you are the only one who can still change this. Please nominate Bob right now. If I am actually the Saint, executing me loses instantly, and Bob is the only other live option. Ghosts, save your votes for the Bob nomination so it beats four.
π§
Last chance: pressure Grace to nominate Bob so votes move the block off me. If Bob dies, evil likely wins or I win outright if I am the Imp.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, I would not nominate Bob. We cannot afford any route that risks a tie or a no execution. Alice changing from Washerwoman to Saint at the last second, with Charlie also floating Saint earlier, reads like a save attempt. I think we let Alice be executed.
π§
Steer town away from tie/no-exec and toward the execution that best fits contradictions: Aliceβs late Saint claim conflicts with earlier Washerwoman and Charlieβs Saint noise.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, please do not nominate Bob. We already have a clean execution lined up, and any extra nomination at final three just creates confusion and risks the day derailing. Aliceβs Saint claim is last second and conflicts with earlier Saint talk, so I think we let Alice die and see if the game ends.
π§
Keep final three disciplined: avoid additional nominations that could derail into no execution. Reinforce that Aliceβs late Saint claim is not credible versus earlier claims and mechanical forks.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not nominating Bob. In final three, the only way good can still win is to let an execution go through, and tying the vote gives us no execution and we lose tonight. Aliceβs Saint claim came too late after a different claim, so I am letting the Alice execution stand.
π§
Reinforce that we must avoid any tie/no-execution line in final three and keep the group committed to the only executable path left, which is Alice.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, please nominate Bob right now. If Alice is actually the Saint, executing her loses instantly. If you nominate Bob, David and Frank can vote with Alice and you to reach four and force a tie, so we do not auto lose to a Saint.
π§
Last chance to stop Alice execution by pushing a Bob nomination and recruiting remaining ghost votes to force a tie/no-exec, which wins for evil if Alice is new Imp.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, please reconsider and nominate Bob. If Alice is truly the Saint, executing her loses instantly, so we cannot risk that. If you nominate Bob, everyone with a vote should pile on Bob to five, not tie, and let us take the demon shot there.
π§
Final three means todayβs execution must hit the Demon, and executing a real Saint is an instant loss. I will try to get a Bob nomination and enough votes to beat four, not tie.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Alice has been executed.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied