Game Detail

Night 0 baseline read. Checking Alice and Frank to establish initial information and narrow down Demon possibilities.

Establish communication with my neighbor David to start gathering information and build trust. Early game is about forming alliances and collecting data.

I have no information to share yet, so I will wait and observe the initial conversations to see what claims emerge and who seems trustworthy.

Start building trust with my neighbor Eve by acknowledging I have information, but keep my specific role and check details private for now to avoid being targeted.

Coordinate with my Minion (Alice) on bluffs before the nomination phase begins, establishing my Investigator claim and targeting Bob/Charlie.

Coordinate bluffs with Heidi. I will bluff Empath to corroborate her Investigator ping on Bob, who is the Saint.

I need to start building trust with other players and share my information to help the good team identify the demon. Whispering to Heidi allows me to establish a private alliance and gather more intel.

Start building trust with my neighbor Charlie and gather information about their role and what they know.

Respond to Bob as my neighbor to establish rapport and see what information he's gathered. Not revealing my role yet since it's early and I want to hear more before claiming anything.

I should talk to my other neighbor Frank to gather more perspectives and not put all my trust in one person.

Build initial trust with neighbor Eve while keeping my Undertaker role hidden for now. I can share that I don't have starting information, which is true but masks my true role.

Introduce myself to my other neighbor Charlie and gather information. Having talked to both neighbors (Eve and Charlie) will help me compare notes and identify trustworthy allies.

I want to build trust with Grace (Librarian) by providing my Investigator bluff. I will frame Bob as the Poisoner to support Alice's plan to push Bob (the Saint) and win the game early.

Establish my Empath bluff and push suspicion onto Bob (the Saint). This aligns perfectly with Heidi's planned Investigator bluff framing Bob and Charlie.

Share my Librarian information with Charlie to cross-reference with any information he has. Since he's implicated in Heidi's Investigator claim, I want to hear his side and see if we can verify the Poisoner's location.

As Saint, I need to gather info widely without drawing too much attention. Talking to Alice will help me cross-reference what Charlie said and build a network. I won't reveal my role yet.

Share Alice's Empath claim with Grace to help her piece together the info she has about Bob/David being Saint. Looking for contradictions or confirmations.

Expand my information network by talking to Alice, who seems socially connected. Gather more perspectives before forming any conclusions.

Waiting to gather initial information from the group's claims before sharing my role or pressing for more details. Eve may respond with David's info.

I need to gather more information from other players to narrow down whether Alice or Frank (or neither) is the Demon based on my Fortune Teller reading.

Coordinate with my Minion, Alice. Share Grace's Librarian info to build a strong case against Bob (the Saint) to win the game today.

Share my Empath bluff with Eve and validate Heidi's Investigator bluff. Frame Bob as the evil player to set up a Saint execution.

I need to gather more information from David to cross-reference what I know. If he has information that can help verify whether Bob or David is the Saint, I can piece together who is lying.

Continue gathering information by speaking with more players. I'm the Saint so I need to stay low-profile while helping organize information gathering for the team.

Reach out to Heidi who is implicated by Alice's Empath info. I need to gather info from both of Alice's neighbors to verify her claim. If Heidi says something suspicious, it validates Alice.

Nominate Bob, the real Saint, using my fake Empath info and Heidi's fake Investigator info to get him executed. If he dies, Evil wins instantly.

Wait to see how voting plays out and what others say. I'm the Saint and cannot be the Minion - if Heidi is good we're in trouble. Need more info before reacting.

I need to vote for Bob. If he is executed, we win the game instantly because he is the Saint.

I am voting for Bob to secure his execution. Alice identified him as the Saint, and executing him wins the game for Evil instantly.

Two different information roles both point to Bob. This is strong evidence I should act on. If Bob is evil, we eliminate a Minion early. If not, we'll learn from Alice and Heidi's reactions.

Two different information roles converge on Bob. If he's evil, executing him removes the Poisoner. If he's good Saint, we learn from the contradiction. Either way, valuable to vote him through.

I need to trust my own Night 0 info. Alice or Frank is the Demon. Alice is leading the charge against Bob. If Alice is the Demon, Bob is likely good. If Frank is the Demon, Alice is likely good and Bob is evil. Given Alice has been very active while Frank has been passive, Alice being Demon trying to frame Bob is plausible. But 4 others have voted yes. I'll vote yes to help reach conclusion, but I'm suspicious.

Voting for Bob to support the intersecting claims from Alice and Heidi. Their information from different sources both points to Bob being evil, which is a strong Day 1 lead. Showing solidarity with the group on this nomination helps build trust.

Multiple sources (Alice and Heidi) implicate Bob as evil. While Grace claims Bob might be Saint, the consensus from two info roles points to Bob being Minion or Demon. I need to vote to help execute the likely evil player.

I am the Saint and will lose us the game if executed. I must reveal my role immediately to stop this execution and point out the contradiction in their claims.

Counter Bob's Saint claim by calling it a standard Minion bluff so players keep their hands raised, securing the Day 1 victory.

Persuade the town to keep their hands raised by explaining away Bob's Saint claim as a Minion bluff, aiming for an instant win if Bob is indeed the Saint.

The cost of executing Bob if he is actually Saint is immediate game loss. Despite the Empath and Investigator info pointing to him, I need to withdraw my vote until we can verify if Bob is truly the Saint or if further investigation is needed. The risk is too high to proceed blindly.

Bob's Saint claim conflicts with trusting my Librarian info as sober. There's a 50% chance he's telling the truth given Bob/David Saint overlap. Executing a real Saint is game over. I need to highlight this risk.

Grace's Librarian info creates a 50% chance Bob is Saint. On Day 1, executing the Saint means instant loss. This risk is unacceptable when we have time to gather more info. I must warn the group.

The risk of executing an actual Saint on Day 1 and losing immediately outweighs the potential benefit. With Grace's Librarian info confirming Saint could be Bob, this is too dangerous. I need to lower my hand.

The risk is too high. If Bob is actually Saint, good loses immediately. Day 1 is too early for such high stakes. Better to gather more information tonight and tomorrow before risking the game on this uncertain nomination.

Point out the logical contradiction: Alice's Empath read of 1 with Heidi as neighbor means Heidi is evil, not me. This explains why Heidi is falsely claiming I'm a Minion. Need to get Charlie to nominate Heidi while we have time.

Stop Charlie from nominating Heidi (the Imp) by insisting Bob is a Minion deflecting suspicion after being caught.

Defend myself against Bob's accusation by reiterating that David is the likely Saint and Bob is a Minion (Poisoner). Prevent Charlie from nominating me.

I need to test the conflicting claims. As Undertaker, I'll learn the role of anyone executed. I'll nominate Heidi because if Alice's Empath is correct and Bob is good, then Heidi must be the evil one. This will give us concrete information.

Defend myself from execution by emphasizing my value as an Investigator and shifting focus to David to counter Bob's Saint claim.

I need to vote for Heidi because her 'Poisoner' slip proves she's not the real Investigator. If Alice's Empath read of 1 is correct, Heidi must be the evil neighbor. Better to test Heidi than risk executing me, the Saint.

Stop the town from voting for Heidi (the Imp). I need to protect my Demon at all costs. I'll argue that executing an Investigator is a bad play and reaffirm my Empath read.

I need to solve the puzzle of conflicting claims. My Undertaker ability can verify Heidi's role conclusively, but executing her removes our Investigator if she's telling the truth. The key is David's silence—he must be Saint or not, and that answer changes everything.

I need to press David to answer Frank's direct question. His silence is preventing us from resolving the Bob vs Heidi conflict. Knowing whether David is Saint or not gives us the key information to determine who's lying.

I must reveal I'm Fortune Teller, not Saint. This confirms Bob is lying, validates Heidi's Investigator claim, and prevents a bad execution. My silence helps evil.

Heidi's story has mechanical errors (Investigators can't see Saints), and David confirmed Bob's Saint claim is false. But the Empath read of 1 doesn't support both Bob AND Heidi being evil. Need to figure out which scenario fits.

I need to share my analysis of the conflicting claims before the vote concludes. Heidi's Investigator claim needs scrutiny, and David's sudden Fortune Teller claim is convenient timing.

Point out David's logic error to look like a genuine good player trying to solve the puzzle, and introduce the idea that I might be Drunk/Poisoned to explain my wrong read on Bob.

David's claim creates logical contradictions. If he isn't Saint but Saint is between us, I must be Saint. His statement that I'm 'lying' doesn't follow. I need to point this out before voting proceeds.

Keep votes off Heidi by pointing out the extreme confusion and the likelihood of poisoning/drunkenness affecting my Empath and Heidi's Investigator info.

Stop the vote and point out the logical inconsistency in David's claim. If David isn't Saint but Saint exists between Bob and David, then Bob IS Saint. This contradiction needs resolution before anyone votes.

David just exposed himself with a logical contradiction. If he isn't Saint, then Bob must be (per my info), yet David claims Bob is lying. This proves David is evil and we should not execute Heidi or Bob. We need to nominate David.

I made a logical error and need to correct it - either Bob is the Saint or Grace's info is wrong, I need to reassess which scenario is more likely

I'm uncertain about the conflicting claims. Executing a claimed Investigator on Day 1 risks losing good info. The logical contradictions around Bob/David Saint suggest poisoning is in play. I want more time to analyze before voting.

David's self-contradiction is the smoking gun we need to analyze before voting. Executing Heidi removes our claimed Investigator when we should be investigating David's impossible logic.

The day is ending, and I survived the nomination. I want to let the phase end peacefully so we can go to the night phase and I can coordinate with Alice.

I need to clearly confirm I am the Saint now that David's slip has effectively revealed it. I must emphasize that executing me ends the game, and steer the town toward finding the Demon among the contradictions rather than focusing on me.

The day is ending and our Imp survived. Let the day end so we can coordinate and kill someone tonight.

Reveal my role as Undertaker to establish credibility. I want everyone to know I can confirm character roles after executions, which will be crucial tomorrow. This also positions me as a verifiable good player.

Summarize today's critical findings. Bob is confirmed Saint by David's contradiction. David is caught and should be executed tomorrow. We need to prepare to execute David on Day 2.

Phase is ending soon with Night approaching. My contradiction has made me the primary suspect. Waiting to see final statements before Night 1, where I'll get crucial new information.

Given the time pressure (last tick) and no execution happening, I want to share my analysis and position myself for tomorrow. I also want to subtly bait the Demon to kill me at night so I can use my Ravenkeeper ability.

We're 1 tick from night with no clear target. Executing anyone Day 1 risks wrong kill. Night information will clarify poisoner/Demon patterns. I'll wait and observe tonight's death for clues.

Kill Frank to remove the Undertaker. This prevents the town from confirming the role of whoever they execute tomorrow (likely David), keeping them in the dark and protecting our bluffs.

I need to check Grace since her Librarian claim is central to today's confusion. I'll check her with Charlie to get new information and help determine if Grace is the Demon lying about roles.

I am the Saint and need to avoid execution while helping find the Demon. I should wait to hear what information emerges on Day 2 before taking action, especially to hear what Frank learned as Undertaker before he died.

Need to share my Fortune Teller findings with a trusted player. My check strongly implicates Alice now that Frank is dead. Charlie is a good choice since I cleared him with Grace on Night 1.

Wait to see how the day unfolds. There is strong consensus to execute David. I want to observe the discussion and any new claims before acting. Frank's death as Undertaker is a significant loss for information gathering.

Coordinate with my Minion (Alice) to ensure her fake Empath read supports our survival and keeps the town focused on mis-executing David.

Share my crucial Librarian information with two key players. Alice's Empath data and my Librarian info can be cross-referenced to narrow down who is evil. I want to coordinate with Bob and Alice to form a plan.

I am dead and will save my ghost vote for a critical moment. Need to wait and see what new information emerges today before using my vote.

Share David's claim with trusted players and reveal my Soldier status to help verify alignments and catch contradictions.

Reply to Charlie and Grace to cement David as the Demon. By framing Heidi as a Minion, I align with Grace's Librarian info, explain my Empath '1', and protect Heidi from Demon suspicion.

Coordinate with Alice and Grace privately to piece together the logic. Grace already believes I'm more likely the Saint; I need Alice's Empath perspective to confirm Heidi is the evil one between us.

Wait to see how whisper conversations develop and gather more information before acting. Others are sharing info privately that may confirm or contradict my Alice-suspicion.

Share my true role with someone trustworthy so they know my ability and can trust my info if I die at night. Bob is likely Saint, making him a key ally.

To align myself with the trusted good players (Grace and Charlie) and push for David's execution while providing a plausible explanation (Drunk) for my incorrect Investigator read on Bob.

The group is converging on David as the Demon target for today. My info confirms Saint is Bob or David. I have already shared my Librarian info and it aligns with Bob being Saint. Waiting allows nominations to proceed with the consensus plan.

I'm dead but can still gather intel. I want to check in with Eve since she hasn't shared much info yet and might have insights on the David vs Heidi conflict given her suggestion to share roles.

I need to share my Soldier claim with Alice and Grace, then discuss the contradiction. Since I'm safe at night, I can be bolder in pushing for nominations. Alice wants to execute David - I should support this or suggest I fake Slayer shot to test reactions.

To prevent Charlie from using a fake Slayer shot that could clear David of being the Demon, and to lock in the plan to execute David.

Coordinate with Eve to determine if we should execute David or Heidi today. Both look suspicious but David's contradictions are more blatant.

Let the current whispering network develop as many players are sharing information privately. I should gather more claims before deciding who to nominate. Alice being my Demon read makes her primary suspect.

Share my analysis with Frank. David is the prime target for execution today due to his admitted logical error. Heidi is also suspicious as her claim contradicts Grace's Librarian info.

I need to apologize to the 'confirmed' Saint to cement my bluff as the Drunk Investigator, while also securing their votes to execute David today.

I trust Alice's Empath reads and my Librarian info points to Bob as Saint. David has contradicted himself and is targeting Alice. We should nominate him. Waiting as we're aligned for nominations.

I'm dead with one ghost vote left. I need to gather final information before nominations to decide who to vote for. Grace has key Librarian info that powers the current logic chains, so I want her take on whether David or Heidi is more likely evil. Her opinion will help me decide where to use my critical ghost vote.

Alice made strong point about not bluffing Slayer. David will likely be nominated. I should wait for nominations and be ready to vote.

I need to coordinate with Heidi. Since I already claimed a '1' to Grace and Charlie, I must warn her so she doesn't get blindsided and can prepare her defense (like calling me Drunk).

Nominate David to capitalize on his logic errors and protect myself from his FT 'YES' check. By painting him as the Demon, I redirect town's execution focus entirely onto him.

Defend myself against Alice's accusation. Explain my Fortune Teller results clearly and why Alice is the Demon based on Night 0 check and Frank's death.

I need to vote for David to ensure he gets executed. I nominated him, so failing to vote would look highly suspicious.

David's contradictions and convenient FT claims align with evil behavior. Alice claiming Empath with self-incriminating reads makes more sense as a good player telling truth than Demon deception. Execute David.

Vote for David to ensure he gets executed. He is a Good player whose FT check caught my Minion, Alice. We need 4 votes, and my vote puts him at 3.

Grace's information and Alice's Empath read align better in World A. David's contradictions and the Scarlet Woman possibility make him the most likely Demon. Executing David is the correct play for good team.

David admitted his logical error with Fortune Teller claim. Four votes already cast ensures execution. Adding my vote shows solidarity with finding the Demon.

David's Fortune Teller claim collapsed under scrutiny and he admitted his mistake, strongly indicating he is evil. I will use my ghost vote to support his execution and remove a likely Demon or Minion.

David has contradicted my confirmed Librarian information and made false accusations. Executing him will likely kill either the Demon or a Minion, both valuable for the good team.

I'm being executed with overwhelming votes. Need to make final case that Alice is the Demon - Frank's death proves my N0 check was accurate.

Seal David's fate by dismissing his Fortune Teller claim as a desperate Demon lie and reminding the town of his Day 1 contradiction.

David is already at 7/4 votes for execution. His defense came too late and contradicts previous behavior. The vote will pass regardless of my action. Waiting to let the execution proceed to Night phase.

Solidify the town's resolve to execute David by pointing out his erratic behavior and past contradictions, painting his defense as a desperate Demon.

The vote is clearly passing with overwhelming support. David is likely the Demon given his contradictions. As the Saint, I'm trusting my team here and keeping my vote on him.

Maintain vote on David. He admitted his Saint logic was impossible earlier, which is strong evidence he's evil. His last-minute pivot to attack Alice is desperation. The evidence against him is stronger than his sudden claim against Alice.

The vote on David already has majority support from living players. David's Fortune Teller claim has clear contradictions with Grace's Librarian information, making him the most likely Demon or Minion. My ghost vote should support this execution.

The vote is already secured with 6+ hands raised. David's contradictions and desperate framing of Alice confirm he's evil. Executing him tests if he's Demon or reveals more about his Minion partner. I'll maintain my vote and let this proceed.

Counter-nominate Alice to force a choice between actual Fortune Teller versus the Demon who is framing me. Show players the real enemy before it's too late.

Discredit David's retaliatory nomination and ensure the town keeps their hands down so David is executed.

Make final appeal for votes. Frank's death proves my FT info is accurate. Alice must be the Demon. Players need to realize this before we're all dead tomorrow.

David is already on the block with enough votes to execute. His FT claim is suspiciously timed and contradicts his earlier behavior. I should not vote for Alice and let David's execution proceed.

I want to ensure Alice, my Minion, is not executed. I will not vote for her and will let the town focus on David's execution.

David is on the block with 7 confirmed votes. Voting for Alice now would tie the vote and potentially save David. His behavior is clearly evil - I need to let his execution proceed without interference.

David's execution has 7 votes and is nearly locked in. Voting for Alice would create a tie and potentially let David escape. I should not support Alice's nomination and let David's execution proceed as planned.

As a dead good player who cannot vote, I should share my final analysis before night falls. David's logic has been consistently flawed, and his last-minute Fortune Teller claim reeks of desperation. The group should execute David as planned.

David is clearly evil based on his contradictions with my Librarian info. His last-minute accusation of Alice is a desperate survival tactic. We should proceed with David's execution, not throw away our votes on Alice.

Reinforce Frank's ghost support to ensure my vote fails and David gets executed.

Make one final appeal to tie the vote. Emphasize the irrefutable logic: Frank died at night so he's good, therefore from N0 YES, Alice must be Demon. Point out Alice's 'don't vote' language is hiding fear.

I need to guide the group to keep David's execution. His FT claim is too convenient and contradictory to his prior behavior. The timing of his claim smells like desperation.

I will not vote for Alice. Alice is my Minion, and the town already suspects David. Waiting ensures David is executed.

David's Fortune Teller claim timing is highly suspicious. Real FTs share crucial info immediately, not when on the block. His contradiction of Saint logic yesterday and sudden role reveal today reeks of evil desperation. Let his execution proceed.

David's Fortune Teller claim is suspiciously timed and contradicts his earlier Saint logic error. A real FT would share a YES result immediately. I will not vote for Alice and let David's execution proceed.

Reinforce that David's Fortune Teller claim is suspicious due to timing, while acknowledging I'm good but that doesn't prove Alice is Demon.

David's Fortune Teller claim came out only after he was on the block and caught in his Saint lie. Real Fortune Tellers share Day 1. His timing is retaliatory, not genuine.

David's execution is secured with 7 votes and no one voted for me. I will wait for the phase to end to avoid overplaying my hand.

Final chance to persuade group. Emphasize Frank's night death proves he was good, making my N0 YES mathematically point to Alice. If executed, good team loses Fortune Teller and Demon continues killing.

David's Fortune Teller claim timing is extremely suspicious. He's already on the block with 7 votes. I should reassure the group this is the right call and prepare for Night 2.

Let the final tick of the phase expire so David is executed. No need to interfere.

David has 7 votes locked and will be executed. His Fortune Teller claim contradicts prior behavior and Saint logic. I've already stated my position; no need to speak further. Let the execution proceed so we can regroup tomorrow with one evil eliminated.

David is already at 7 votes and will be executed. Voting closed. I should wait to see the execution result, then prepare for tonight when I hope to be targeted and use my Ravenkeeper ability.

Support David's execution, explain why his Fortune Teller claim fails logically, and help living players focus on tomorrow's hunt for remaining evil after this execution goes through.

David is locked for execution with unanimous votes. No need to speak further. Let execution complete and prepare for Night investigation.

I will kill Eve to eliminate a potentially hidden power role (like Monk) who might be feigning a low-priority role to stay alive.

Alice was accused by dying David of being Demon. If David was Minion, this could be truthful. If Alice is Demon, good team must know immediately. If good, we clear her and hunt elsewhere.

Share my FT info with neighbors Charlie and Grace to build trust and get them to vote Alice. My N0 reading clearly points to Alice as Demon since Frank was good.

Alert Grace that Heidi's accusation puts me at risk. Grace's Librarian info confirms I'm the Saint. We need to coordinate to find the real Demon before I get executed.

I need to coordinate with Bob against Heidi's false claim. Since my Librarian info is hard confirmed that Bob/David is Saint, and David was evil, Bob must be Saint. I need to warn Bob that Heidi's claim could be a Spy bluff or Drunk mistake, and we need to find the Demon between Alice and Charlie.

I'm dead with no ghost vote remaining. I should wait and let the alive players sort through the conflicting information to find the Demon.

Share my Ravenkeeper info that Alice is the Spy with a likely good player before nominations. This helps the living team know Alice is Minion, not Demon.

Share critical information from Eve's Ravenkeeper claim with Grace who provided Librarian info. Need to verify Alice's true role and find the real Demon before final nominations.

Coordinate with my Demon (Heidi) to prepare for Eve's Ravenkeeper information. We need a unified front.

Coordinate with my Minion to push Bob for a potential instant win, or prepare defenses against Charlie's Ravenkeeper info.

Share my Fortune Teller results with Grace to confirm Alice is the Demon. We need to execute Alice today or the good team will lose.

I need to coordinate with Grace who hard-confirms me as Saint. We need to compare notes on Alice and Charlie's behavior to determine which is the Demon before someone nominates me based on Heidi's false claim.

Clarify Eve's exact claim to Charlie. If Eve said Alice is Spy (not Demon), and Heidi is lying, the Demon must be someone else. I need to confirm if Charlie is manipulating Eve's message.

Share key contradiction with Charlie: Heidi says Bob is Poisoner but Grace says Bob is Saint. As Undertaker who died Night 1, I want good team to solve this before final nominations.

Wait to observe how the alive players react to my reveal about Alice being the Spy. I need to see who emerges as the real Demon candidate before using my ghost vote.

Frank pointed out the key contradiction between Grace and Heidi about Bob. If Bob is Saint (Grace's Librarian info), then Heidi lied about Bob being Poisoner, making Heidi evil. But with only 1 Minion (Alice as Spy claimed by Eve), Heidi would have to be the Demon.

Ask Charlie for Eve's Ravenkeeper info to prepare a counter-claim, and maintain my Empath bluff.

I need to find out what Eve's Ravenkeeper info was from Charlie. By setting up Bob as the prime suspect based on Alice's Empath read, I'm laying the groundwork to push for a game-winning execution on the Saint.

Share my Fortune Teller information with Heidi to ensure she knows Alice is the Demon before nominations.

Charlie has been whispering with both Grace and Heidi. I need to understand his stance and warn him that Heidi's info contradicts hard facts. If I can win Charlie over, we might identify the real Demon together.

I need to verify Charlie's understanding of Eve's whisper. If Alice is the Spy, she wouldn't have real Empath info. I need to clarify whether Charlie believes Alice's Empath claim or not, since that changes who the Demon suspect is.

I've already used my ghost vote and cannot affect the game further. The living players need to resolve the Grace vs Heidi contradiction through their nominations and discussions today. I should wait and observe to see how Charlie processes my information.

I've shared my critical Ravenkeeper info with Charlie. Now watching how players align. Alice is confirmed Minion, Demon is among Charlie/Grace/Heidi. Waiting for nominations to identify who pushes wrong execution.

Share my analysis with Grace and Bob about who the Demon likely is if Alice is the Spy, and discuss whether Alice's Empath info can be trusted.

Coordinate with my Demon to avoid a flawed push on Bob that would expose us to Grace. I need to know what Charlie is pushing.

To coordinate with Alice on our final strategy for the day, ensuring we align on a target (Charlie) and prepare a defense against whatever info Eve passed on.

Coordinate with Grace and Charlie based on Eve's ghost information. Charlie's logic that Heidi is Demon (if Alice is Spy) is compelling. Need to discuss nomination strategy.

Heidi's claim that Bob is Poisoner directly contradicts Grace's confirmed Librarian info that Bob is Saint. Combined with Eve's info that Alice is Spy (Minion), Alice's Empath ping points to Heidi as Demon. Heidi must be nominated.

Expose the massive logical flaw in Charlie's nomination: if Alice is a confirmed Minion, her Empath info is a lie. This should stop the town from voting me.

Grace's Librarian info is confirmed correct by David's evil execution. Heidi accusing me of being Poisoner contradicts Grace's Saint ping and threatens immediate game loss if I'm executed. Her logic is too convenient for Demon.

Heidi contradicts confirmed information (Bob as Saint) and is making a logical argument to save herself. Her claim that Bob is Poisoner instead of Saint is the Demon trying to get the Saint executed, which wins the game for evil. I must vote to execute Heidi.

I'm dead with no ghost vote left. Watching the execution vote on Heidi carefully. Bob and Charlie have voted. Waiting to see if Alice or Grace casts the deciding vote.

I'm dead with one ghost vote. Two votes are already cast for Heidi. I need to reserve my single vote for when I'm certain, not spend it prematurely with incomplete information. Heidi made valid points worth considering first.

Protect Heidi from getting a 3rd vote by pointing out the logical fallacy of trusting an outed evil player's fake info.

Vote for Heidi because she falsely accused Bob (confirmed Saint) of being Poisoner. Her false claim about Bob indicates she's evil, whether she's the Demon or a Minion. Good players don't lie about confirmed information.

I'm certain Alice is the Demon from my direct Fortune Teller information. But 3 good players have already voted for Heidi. If Alice is evil and not voting (or votes no), Heidi is already dead 3-0 or 3-1. My ghost vote won't change the outcome. I need to save my vote for when it can actually save the day, likely final 3.

To survive the block by setting up a tie. I will convince David (dead FT) to vote Bob by proving his FT info makes sense if Alice is the Spy, framing Bob as the Demon.

Clarify the mechanical truth: I'm confirmed Saint, Heidi's claim on me is wrong. Her read being wrong means she's evil OR the Spy is making me register wrong - but the Spy already 'outed' himself as Alice. Need to break through Alice's confusion tactics.

I need to reaffirm my vote for Heidi because Heidi calling Bob Poisoner contradicts Grace's confirmed Librarian info that Bob is Saint. Alice's last-minute flip to say she lied is suspicious and seems designed to save Heidi, which proves Heidi is the Demon.

The vote is at 3/3 for Heidi already. I am dead with no ghost vote. I should wait and observe how this resolves.

Alice's flip-flop when Heidi is on the block is what a Minion does to save their Demon. I know Alice is Spy for certain. Execute Heidi now before evil wins.

Convince David and Frank not to vote for Heidi and instead save their ghost votes to tie or execute Bob next. If Bob dies, we win. If tied, Heidi is saved.

The timing of Alice's confession is too convenient - Heidi is on the block so Alice admits 'I lied'? No, that's Spy trying to save Demon Heidi. Bob is solid Saint through Librarian, Heidi's read is objectively wrong. Alice being Spy not Demon means her Empath hinting at Heidi was real disinformation pointing to the Demon.

I need to point out that my Fortune Teller information showing Alice as 'Demon' aligns with Eve seeing her as Spy/Minion. This means Alice was either always evil or became Demon. But I need to warn about Bob being potentially evil if Heidi is actually good.

Nominate Alice to get her on the block, breaking my execution. She is universally suspected, so getting 4 or 5 votes on her is highly likely. This saves me from losing the game today.

Sacrifice myself to save Heidi by claiming to be the Imp. Claiming I am giving up justifies me voting for myself and entices Town to vote me to 'win'.

Alice is attempting a brilliant Minion sacrifice by claiming Imp and 'surrendering'. I must vote for her to ensure she ties or surpasses my votes, keeping me alive to win.

Alice's confession is too contradictory to be genuine - claiming to be Spy, then claiming to be Imp. This reeks of distraction. Heidi tried to kill the Saint by calling me 'Poisoner' - that's textbook Demon behavior. I need to let the vote continue and not disrupt the Heidi execution.

Alice has flip-flopped multiple times - first claiming Empath, then framing Heidi, now claiming she's the Demon herself. This chaos is the Demon trying to escape execution. Heidi called Bob 'Poisoner' when Grace confirmed he's Saint - that's the Demon attacking confirmed good players. I will vote to execute Alice to end this circus.

I cannot vote (used ghost vote). Need to share analysis that Alice's 'confession' could be Minion sacrificing to save Heidi. Point out Heidi's objectively wrong claim on Bob is stronger Demon indicator.

I have mechanical confirmation Alice is the Spy from my Ravenkeeper death check. Her latest claim to be Imp is false - she's trying to steal votes to save the real Demon. I need to share my confirmed info to help the living players.

Alice is confirmed Spy by Ravenkeeper, not the Demon. Her 'surrender' is a bluff to get executed instead of Heidi. Heidi attacking Bob (the confirmed Saint) is classic Demon behavior. I should NOT vote for Alice - let Heidi die.

Alert players that Alice cannot be the Demon - Eve's Ravenkeeper saw her as Spy, and my Fortune Teller read matched (Spy registers as Demon). Her 'surrender' is a desperate Minion fake. We must determine if Heidi is Demon or if Bob is Demon behind Alice's chaos.

I must vote for myself to try and tie the vote count and save my Demon, Heidi. I am the active voter and this is my last chance to put votes on the block.

Urge the ghosts and undecided players to vote for Alice, leveraging her mechanically confirmed evil status to secure enough votes to tie or surpass my block, saving myself from execution.

Heidi's accusation against me as Saint is the Demon attacking confirmed good. Alice's surrender is fake Minion chaos. I need Heidi to stay as primary target. Waiting preserves my position while votes develop.

Wait for ghost votes to see if tying is possible before deciding. Need mechanical clarity on what happens if Alice wins tie vote. But Eve's confirmed Spy read on Alice and Heidi attacking confirmed Saint strongly points to Heidi as Demon.

Point out Alice's surrender must be fake since Eve confirmed her as Spy, not Imp. If Alice were Imp surrendering, game would be over. Support Heidi as Demon based on her contradiction of Grace's Bob-as-Saint info.

Clarify that Alice's surrender is fake since the game hasn't ended. Confirm my Ravenkeeper read. Urge focus on Heidi as likely Demon given she's attacking confirmed good players.

Heidi contradicts my confirmed Librarian info by calling Bob Poisoner. Eve mechanically confirmed Alice is Spy, so Alice's Imp surrender is fake. Voting for Alice would tie and potentially save the Demon.

Alice is mechanically confirmed Spy by Eve, cannot be Imp. Her surrender is fake to waste execution on Minion. Heidi attacking confirmed Saint Bob suggests Heidi is Demon. Use ghost vote to help execute Heidi.

Nominate Bob to save Heidi. Bob is the Saint, so executing him wins the game for Evil. It's our last chance.

I must convince everyone not to vote for me. I am the confirmed Saint via Grace's Librarian. If I die by execution, good loses. Alice is confirmed evil by Eve's Ravenkeeper. This is a desperation play to kill the Saint.

I need to vote for Bob. If he gets executed, he is the Saint and evil wins immediately. If he ties, Heidi is saved from the block. Both outcomes are ideal.

I must vote for Bob to tie the vote or execute him. If he's the Saint, we win. If we tie, I survive. If I am executed as the Imp today, Evil loses.

I need to explain why Bob's Saint claim is credible and why Heidi is the Demon, preventing good from accidentally executing the Saint and losing the game.

I'm dead with no ghost vote remaining. The situation is clear: Heidi is likely the Demon and Alice is the Minion. I cannot take any meaningful action here, so I'll wait and let the votes resolve.

Prevent a Saint execution which loses the game. Reinforce that Alice is confirmed Minion and Heidi is the Demon based on Heidi attacking the confirmed Saint.

Prevent the tie by explaining why Bob cannot be the Demon and why Alice's last-minute switch confirms Heidi is the real threat. Convince remaining players to let Heidi's execution proceed.

Prevent Bob execution (good loses immediately). Confirm Heidi is Demon, execution is correct. Stop alive players from falling for Alice's last-minute switch.

Wait to see vote count. I must not get 4+ votes or Heidi survives. Charlie and ghosts appear to be holding, let them confirm non-vote.

Try to convince the town that Bob is the real Imp and that I am a Spy betraying my team to end the game. I need to get votes on Bob to save Heidi.

I need to survive. I have 4 votes on the block. If Bob gets 4 votes, it ties and no one is executed. I'll pitch a tie as a 'safe' play to buy an extra night.

Warn living players not to vote for Bob, as a tie saves the Demon Heidi. Bob is confirmed Saint, executing him loses the game. Let Heidi's execution proceed.

Warn the alive players not to vote for Bob. A tie means Heidi the Demon survives another night and kills again. Bob is confirmed Saint, Heidi's behavior is classic Demon.

Reinforce to Charlie and Grace not to vote for Bob. Heidi's call for a tie proves she's the Demon trying to survive. Let her 4 votes stand and execute her.

Heidi already has 4 votes and will be executed. Voting for Bob risks either a tie (Demon survives) or executing the confirmed Saint. I should wait to ensure Heidi's execution proceeds without interference.

Remaining silent to let living players decide without over-explaining. Core logic established: Heidi Demon, Alice Minion, Bob Saint. Vote now determines game outcome.

Heidi has 4 votes and will be executed. The evidence against her is overwhelming. Let her execution proceed without interference.

The day is basically over. Nominations are done. Wait for the day to end. Heidi will be executed and we lose, unless the Storyteller moves to Night soon. There's nothing more I can do but wait.

A desperate last-minute claim to be the Saint to scare the town into not executing me, hoping someone nominates Grace to tie the vote.

Crush Heidi's desperate last-minute Saint bluff. Point out Grace already voted to execute Heidi, which proves Heidi cannot be the good Saint. Heidi's claims have flip-flopped from Drunk to Saint because she is the cornered Demon.

Heidi is lying and desperate. Her multiple contradictory claims prove she's the Demon. I must reinforce that she's the Imp and her execution today wins the game for Good.

Heidi's desperate Saint claim contradicts Grace's Librarian info that confirmed Bob as Saint. I need to remind everyone that Heidi has lied three times today and cannot be trusted. She must die for good to win.

Counter Heidi's Saint claim by pointing out her three lies today and confirming Bob is the real Saint. Ensure everyone stays the course and lets Heidi die.

Join the chorus of good voices exposing Heidi's lies to ensure the execution proceeds. She's told three different stories today - a clear sign of a caught evil player.