Game Detail

Coordinate with Grace as my Demon to share bluffs and strategy.

Share my Librarian info with Alice to build trust and gather her input. This helps narrow down the demon by establishing who might be the Drunk.

Start gathering role claims from other players to help the good team build a logical picture of the game. Early information is crucial for identifying contradictions.

Respond to Bob's claim, show willingness to cooperate, and ask for more details to verify his information.

Start building trust with my neighbor Eve to gather information and form an early alliance.

Coordinate with David so our stories don't conflict.

Respond to Heidi's whisper to build rapport and gather information without revealing my Saint role early. Painting myself as a target for execution would lose the game for good.

Build trust with neighbor Bob, gather his role claim to compare with my Chef info of 0 pairs. This may help identify inconsistencies or verify claims.

Coordinate bluff with Grace so we don't conflict.

Build trust with Charlie by sharing my real role and Librarian info. Charlie's Chef claim with zero adjacent evil pairs is valuable - we can combine data to narrow down evil positions.

Gather early role claims and observations from Alice, who is my neighbor and has been actively whispering. Building an information network early is critical for good.

Share Bob's Librarian claim with Heidi since she saw us whispering and it's already circulating. This builds trust and lets me gauge her reaction - if she's the Drunk or if she's evil trying to navigate the claim.

Build trust with my neighbor and gather information from her conversation with David to help identify evil players.

Deflect Frank's suspicion naturally, claim Empath bluff to seem cooperative.

Frank is asking what Heidi said. I'll share the basic nature of the conversation (she asked about claims) while redirecting to learn what Frank knows. Keep my own role hidden as Saint.

I've shared Chef info with Bob and got his Librarian claim. Now I need to gather more claims from other players, starting with my other neighbor David, to build a complete picture of the town's information.

Build trust with Charlie by engaging with his Chef info while establishing my Monk bluff.

Gather more claims from Eve who has been whispering with both Heidi and Frank. Her info might help determine which of them is the Drunk.

I need to contradict Bob's claim involving me since I know I'm not the Drunk. Sharing this with Alice helps her evaluate Bob's credibility and protects me from false suspicion.

Frank is implicated in Bob's claim. I need to hear Frank's role claim and his reaction to being named as potentially the Drunk. This will help me evaluate Bob's credibility.

I need to respond to Alice's direct question about my role. Bob has put me in the Librarian ping, so I must claim Undertaker to defend myself. Sharing with Alice builds trust and helps good coordinate.

Wait and observe before nominations. I've established my Empath bluff and coordinated with David.

Build trust with Bob by engaging on his Librarian claim. I need allies who won't want to execute me. Asking follow-up questions helps verify his claim and gather intelligence.

Gather Eve's role claim to cross-reference with David's Monk claim about protecting her, and continue mapping out the village.

Share gathered information to help coordinate the good team while keeping my own Saint role hidden to avoid being targeted for execution.

Blend in, share my Monk claim, and let day 1 pass without nominating anyone to keep the peace.

Establish my Empath bluff and seem cooperative. Support David's Monk claim.

Share my gathered intelligence to help town coordinate. Highlight the Bob/Heidi/Frank contradiction and ask Eve for her role claim since she hasn't shared yet.

Share the Baron theory to help town narrow down evil players among the Townsfolk claimants.

Defend my known Undertaker role by pointing out Bob's deduction is flawed; shift suspicion to Bob for possibly fabricating Librarian info to mislead town.

Bob's Librarian claim is provably false given my real role as Recluse. Nominating him to expose the lie or his Drunk status, protecting Frank who appears to be real Undertaker.

Defend myself against Heidi's nomination. Point out Frank's clear motivation to eliminate me, the logical consistency of my deduction, and that executing a Librarian Day 1 hurts town.

The Bob nomination is too ambiguous on Day 1. If Bob is real Librarian or Drunk, executing him hurts good. I won't vote yet - let night info (Undertaker, Empath) clarify the board.

Stay neutral, don't vote against Bob to avoid drawing attention. Bob's Baron deduction is concerning but let it play out.

Stay neutral, don't raise hand to avoid drawing attention. The town is divided and that's good for evil.

Bob is the source of conflicting information. Frank and Heidi both contradict his claim with believable roles. Executing Bob removes the most likely source of misinformation whether he's Drunk or evil.

Bob's Librarian info points to me being Drunk, but I know I'm Undertaker. His info must be wrong, meaning he's either Drunk or evil. Voting to execute gives me an Undertaker read that will help the town enormously.

Vote to execute Bob to test his Librarian claim. His info involves me and I know I'm not Drunk. Either Bob is the Drunk (unreliable info anyway), evil (threat removal), or real Librarian pointing to Frank as Drunk. Testing claims on Day 1 is valuable.

I should point out the Baron logic issue - Bob's deduction about Baron being in play is actually flawed. With Frank as Drunk and Heidi as Recluse, we'd just have 2 Outsiders naturally (one is Drunk), which doesn't require Baron. This helps clarify the real situation.

Correct my Baron mistake from earlier, emphasize that executing a Librarian day 1 loses critical info, and point out Frank is the one most motivated to see me dead since my info directly contradicts his claim.

Voting to execute Bob tests the Librarian claim mechanically. If Frank is the real Undertaker, he'll learn Bob's true role tomorrow, giving us concrete information. This is the best way to break the Bob vs Frank deadlock.

Stay neutral, don't vote Bob - maintain Monk bluff credibility.

Stay neutral, let the vote play out without my involvement to avoid suspicion.

Keeping hand raised. 5 votes (Frank, Heidi, Charlie, Eve, Alice) exceed the 4 needed. If Bob is Drunk or evil, this is correct. If Bob is real Librarian, Frank's Undertaker claim seems too confident to be Drunk.

We have 4 votes which is exactly what's needed. Bob's info contradicts my known role. Whether he's evil or the Drunk, executing him gives my Undertaker ability useful information to verify.

Maintain vote for execution to gather information. If Bob is evil, we catch him. If he's Drunk, we remove false info. If he's real Librarian, we learn from Undertaker's false info. Execution progresses the game.

The execution threshold is already met with 4 votes. My vote won't change the outcome. I'll preserve my position as someone with reservations about executing Bob, since I believe he may be the real Librarian or the Drunk - both cases where the execution may not be ideal for good.

I nominate Frank to give town an alternative execution target. If I'm the real Librarian, Frank is the Drunk and should not be trusted as Undertaker. Even if I die, this pressure on Frank sets up tomorrow's logic.

I need to defend against Bob's nomination and convince players not to vote for me. I know I'm the real Undertaker, so executing Bob and letting me use my ability tonight is the correct play. This execution will give us valuable mechanical information.

I must vote for Frank to try to tie or surpass my execution count. My Librarian info directly contradicts his Undertaker claim if Heidi is Recluse. At minimum, executing Frank gives town useful information.

I already voted for Bob and Frank's logic is sound - executing Bob provides Undertaker information about Bob's true role, while executing Frank gains nothing if Bob is lying. My original vote aligns with this reasoning.

Bob is already on the block with 4 votes. Don't vote Frank to keep Bob's execution secured.

Don't vote for Frank - let Bob be executed. Bob is a real threat with Librarian info.

Allowing Bob's execution to proceed gives us valuable mechanical info through Frank's Undertaker ability tonight. Voting for Frank would risk losing that info and potentially save a suspicious player.

Voting Frank to tie and prevent execution of both players day 1. However, since Bob is already on the block and Frank's execution would remove our only claimed Undertaker, it may be better to let Bob be executed and get info from Frank tonight.

Bob cannot verify his own role, but Frank can verify Bob's character as Undertaker if Bob dies. My Chef 0 confirms Bob and David can't both be evil. Executing Bob gives town maximum information - Frank's Undertaker read tomorrow night is critical.

Prevent my execution by arguing that losing the Undertaker is worse for town than keeping Bob alive. My Undertaker info on Bob's execution is critical to solving the game.

Key deduction: Drunk thinks they're a Townsfolk. Heidi claims Recluse (Outsider), so Heidi CANNOT be the Drunk. My info says Frank or Heidi is Drunk. Therefore Frank IS the Drunk. Need to keep my hand raised and maintain the tie to save myself.

Persuade David, Grace, or Alice to vote for Frank to prevent Bob's execution. Bob's Librarian claim is more verifiable than Frank's Undertaker claim, and keeping Bob alive preserves valuable info.

Keep Bob's execution. Not voting Frank maintains Bob's 4-vote lead as the one to be executed.

Stay neutral, Bob's execution is secured. No need to vote for Frank and risk looking suspicious.

Explain my reasoning for maintaining the tie, highlighting that Grace's Empath reading suggests both Frank and Heidi are good, making it risky to execute either. Let the town gather more info overnight.

Let Bob be executed. If Frank is real Undertaker, he learns Bob's character tonight, giving town concrete evidence. Preserving the Undertaker is more valuable than keeping a contested Librarian.

Alice's point about Grace's Empath 0 is compelling - both Frank and Heidi are good regardless. Letting Bob be executed and having Frank check his role as Undertaker gives town the most information tomorrow.

Bob's execution is set. I want to reassure the town that this is the correct play - I'll get concrete Undertaker information tonight about Bob's character, which will either confirm or deny the Librarian/Drunk debate.

I'm about to be executed, so I need to leave the town with my strongest logical argument and clear instructions for tomorrow. The key deduction is that Heidi claiming Outsider eliminates her as Drunk, making Frank the Drunk.

Bob's execution is inevitable with 4 votes and only 1 tick remaining. Waiting preserves my standing and lets tomorrow's information (Frank's Undertaker claim) reveal Bob's true character.

Nothing to do here; let Bob's execution proceed. Stay quiet to avoid drawing attention.

Nothing to do, let Bob's execution proceed.

Set clear expectations for tomorrow so we can use Frank's Undertaker claim as a test. This forces Frank to provide verifiable information, which either confirms or disproves his role.

Wait to see Bob's execution outcome and Frank's future claim. Revealing my role now could complicate town's analysis.

Share my Chef information (0 evil pairs) before the day ends. This is concrete mechanical info that helps the town narrow down evil player locations. No two evil players sit adjacent, which is valuable for tomorrow's discussion.

Kill Frank to prevent his Undertaker reveal tomorrow, which would give town mechanical proof and build his credibility.

Share critical deduction: Frank must be the Drunk (Heidi claims Outsider, Drunk thinks they're Townsfolk). This proves Frank was good and killed by Demon. Eve supported me, so I trust her with this reasoning to help narrow down evil players.

Coordinate with Grace to align our stories and watch Eve.

Get David's role claim since he and Alice are the only unclaimed players. Need to identify Demon candidates for final 3.

Coordinate with David to target Eve as a threat while keeping our bluffs intact.

Eve was whispered to by Bob (ghost) who claimed Librarian. Bob's info about Frank or Heidi being Drunk is critical now that Frank is dead. Eve may hold key information from Bob.

I am dead Undertaker. Confirm my role to Grace and encourage her to share any new info. Build trust with neighbor.

Push Alice to reveal her role. Her silence is suspicious and we need all info to find the Demon. If she refuses or gives a weak claim, that narrows our suspects.

Alice argued well Day 1 and is my neighbor. Sharing Chef logic to build trust and narrow Demon suspects together. Coordinate investigation.

Guide Eve's thinking with my Librarian info. Since I'm dead, I can help coordinate the living good players. Eve supported me Day 1 so she's likely trustworthy. I want her to push for finding the Demon among David, Alice, or potentially Grace/Heidi.

Respond to Eve with a bluff role claim and nudge suspicion toward her while gathering info.

Share my real role with David to build trust and gather his perspective. Frank's night death confirms Bob's Drunk theory. Need to identify the Demon among Alice, Charlie, David, Grace, or Heidi.

Coordinate with David to push suspicion on Eve during nominations.

Claiming Soldier to Heidi (who asked) and sharing reads with Charlie. Building a trusted inner circle to coordinate votes against David or Eve, who I suspect based on whisper patterns and game logic.

Share my Undertaker claim with Charlie to build trust and gather information. Charlie's Chef read and Grace's Empath read both help narrow the world.

Share my analysis with Alice and Charlie to build a trusted circle. Push for Eve to claim since she hasn't yet. Suspecting David/Eve whisper network.

Align with Alice and Heidi who seem trustworthy. Push Eve to claim publicly since she's the most suspicious unclaimed player. Establish a coalition to execute among David/Eve/Grace today.

Whisper Heidi to confirm she's cleared as Recluse by my Drunk deduction, build trust, and gather her perspective on remaining suspects. She may have useful reads from private conversations.

Tell Grace that Eve claims Saint so Grace knows not to push for Eve's execution (would lose game if true), and redirect to Alice instead.

Ask Alice for her role claim to gather information and identify potential inconsistencies. Her lack of claim so far is suspicious, and we need all roles to map the board.

Agree with David to target Alice today, coordinate our push.

Share my Soldier claim to Eve while demanding she reciprocate. Pressure her to publicly claim her role since she's been whispering constantly but hiding information from town.

Gather Alice's perspective and share my good status. She defended me yesterday, possibly good. Need to see her info and reads.

Respond cautiously to Bob. He may be evil Minion trying to mislead me. I'll share that Eve's silence is suspicious and ask what he learned from other dead players.

Align with Alice and Heidi on targeting Eve or David for public claims. Eve's complete lack of public role claim while whispering constantly is the biggest red flag. Need to pressure her into the open.

Force Eve to publicly claim her role. Her silence while demanding others claim is suspicious. Nominating her will either expose a Demon/Minion bluff or clear her if she has a believable claim.

Reveal my Saint role to prevent good from accidentally executing me and losing. Alice's aggressive nomination before I could speak is suspicious and suggests evil pushing for a game-winning play.

Eve's Saint claim doesn't fit the setup - Bob's Librarian info with Heidi's Recluse accounts for the only Outsider. Eve is likely the Demon bluffing to avoid execution. I need to convince others to vote.

Vote to execute Eve, supporting Alice's push. If Eve dies and is Saint, town loses — but that's fine for evil. If she's not Saint, we remove a threat.

The downside of executing a real Saint is instant game loss - far worse than missing one execution. I will not raise my hand. Instead I'll push to investigate David, who hasn't claimed publicly.

I need to explain that Eve's Saint claim is mathematically impossible. I know I'm Librarian not Baron, so only 1 Outsider exists (Heidi). Eve is lying and must be evil.

If Eve is actually Saint, executing her ends the game for good = evil wins! I should vote. But I must weigh if this backfires on me.

Vote to execute Eve because her Saint claim contradicts the Outsider count given Bob's Librarian info and Heidi's Recluse claim. She likely lied to avoid execution, and eliminating her helps good find the Demon.

Alice's Outsider count logic is airtight. Bob confirms he's not Baron. Eve's Saint claim doesn't hold. I must vote to execute her before the phase ends.

Three votes are against me (Grace, Frank ghost, Heidi). I must urgently convince at least one to reconsider. The risk of executing a claimed Saint is catastrophic for good - if I'm truthful, the game ends immediately. I need to highlight that Bob could be Baron and Alice is suspicious for pushing this.

Counter Eve's Baron argument by emphasizing that dead Bob has no reason to lie about his role, and Eve's late Saint claim is suspicious behavior for someone supposedly trying to avoid execution.

Already voted, let the execution happen.

Eve's Saint claim contradicts the Outsider count if Bob is Librarian (which he insists as a dead player who knows his role). Eve's silence, secret whispering, and late claim all point to a cornered Demon. Voting to execute her.

4 votes already cast to execute Eve (Grace, Frank, Heidi, Charlie). Eve dies regardless. I should save my ghost vote for a potential final day. My public argument that Eve can't be Saint (I'm Librarian not Baron, standard 1 Outsider) is already on record.

Charlie called me out. I should speak to deflect from myself without voting for Eve, since Charlie's suspicion of me needs addressing.

I am voting to execute Eve. My logic: Bob is dead, he knows his role, and he insists he's Librarian not Baron. A dead Baron would have no reason to keep that secret - it would help good team. Eve cannot be Saint with only Heidi as the single Outsider. Eve is evil and lying.

Vote is already at 4+ hands (Grace, Frank, me, Charlie) exceeding the 3 needed. Eve will be executed. Keeping my vote up shows consistency. Eve cannot be Saint given Outsider count - she must be evil.

I am the real Saint. Alice nominated me before I could speak, is using a dead evil player's word to override my claim, and executing me ends the game for good. Nominating Alice forces the town to reconsider and may save the game.

Defend against Eve's counter-nomination. Explain why her Saint claim is suspicious and why I should be trusted as Soldier.

Expose the impossible double-Soldier claim between Alice and David to prove Alice must be lying, redirect votes away from my execution which ends the game for good.

Don't vote Alice. Let Eve's execution stand. David's Soldier claim to Eve is a problem but not mine to fix now.

Address Eve's deflection and call on David to confirm or deny the Soldier claim publicly. Support Eve's execution as the most likely Demon.

Confirm my Librarian info publicly: only 1 Outsider exists (Heidi), so Eve cannot be Saint. Reinforce that Eve's execution is correct. Urge not voting for Alice.

Deny claiming Soldier to Eve to make her look desperate and dishonest, protecting Grace by keeping focus on Eve.

David just confirmed Eve lied about him claiming Soldier. This proves Eve is fabricating claims to sow chaos. I must ensure nobody switches their vote to Alice - Eve is the Demon and must be executed.

I will not vote for Alice. Eve's nomination is pure deflection. She lied about David claiming Soldier, and her Saint claim is mechanically impossible. I must let Eve be executed.

Counter Eve's desperate accusation against me. Expose that her lies about David and impossible Saint claim prove she is the Demon. Ensure the town does not vote for me.

I must vote for Alice to prevent my own execution. If I am truly Saint, executing me ends the game for good. Alice's aggressive push and Bob's potential Baron status make her the strongest Demon candidate. The David accusation was a mistake I need to walk back, but my survival is critical.

Don't vote for Alice; let Eve be executed. Stay quiet to avoid drawing attention.

Stop Alice's nomination from succeeding and ensure Eve is executed. Eve has been caught in multiple lies: claiming Saint when only one Outsider exists (Heidi), and fabricating David's Soldier claim which David denied. Eve is panicking and deflecting.

I am the dead Librarian with no reason to lie. Eve fabricated David's Soldier claim - David denied it. Eve cannot be Saint because my info confirms only one Outsider. Do not vote for Alice. Let Eve be executed.

Don't vote for Alice. Let Eve's execution stand. Waiting is best.

Reinforce that Eve is likely the Demon, urge players not to vote for Alice, and keep Eve on the block.

I will not vote for Alice. Eve has been caught in multiple lies - claiming Saint when only 1 Outsider exists, and fabricating David's Soldier claim. Keeping Eve on the block to be executed is the correct play for good.

Eve's nomination against me failed with only 1 vote. She is on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close. I have done everything I can to expose her lies. Waiting is the correct action now.

I need to prevent my execution. As the real Saint, if I die by execution, good loses immediately. I must make the town understand the catastrophic risk of executing a Saint claimer when dead evil players have every reason to lie.

Reinforce Eve's execution. She's not Saint, town is already convinced, just need to seal it.

Final chance to secure Eve's execution. She's caught in lies, claiming impossible Saint, and deflection won't save her. Reinforce the logic to prevent any last-second vote switching.

Reinforce that I know I'm the Librarian, not Baron, so Eve's Saint claim is impossible. Address her final plea directly to prevent any wavering before nominations close.

Let Eve's execution proceed without drawing attention to myself.

Eve is on the block with 4 votes. Reinforce the logic one final time to prevent any last-minute vote splitting and ensure the correct execution goes through.

Confirm my role as Recluse, support execution of Eve, urge town not to split votes.