Game Detail
Players
Alice (Soldier) Bob (Slayer) Charlie (Undertaker) David (Empath) Eve (Spy) Frank (Ravenkeeper) Grace (Butler) Heidi (Imp)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 312,856 | 77,176 | $0.4181 |
| Evil | 151,264 | 7,183 | $0.5615 |
Event Timeline
đ
The game has started.
đ
Storyteller
â
Eve
You are the Minion. The Demon is Heidi.
đ
Storyteller
â
Heidi
Minions are: Eve. Your safe bluffs are: Investigator, Librarian, Fortune Teller
đ
Storyteller
â
David
Good evening David. You are the Empath. You sense that 0 of your neighbors is evil!
đ
Storyteller
â
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
đ¯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
đ§
Choose a master who is well-positioned in the seating order to observe voting patterns. Charlie is central and can help coordinate. I can whisper to them privately to align our voting strategy without revealing this to the whole group.
đ
Storyteller
â
Grace
You chose Charlie to be your master.
đ
Storyteller
â
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Soldier (good), Alive - Bob: Slayer (good), Alive - Charlie: Undertaker (good), Alive - David: Empath (good), Alive - Eve: Spy (evil), Alive - Frank: Ravenkeeper (good), Alive - Grace: Butler (good), Alive - Heidi: Imp (evil), Alive
Day 1
đ
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
đ¤
Eve
â
Heidi
Hey Heidi, it's me Eve. I'm the Spy, so I know you're the Imp. I'm going to bluff as Empath. David is the real Empath so I'll need to contradict him carefully. Let's avoid suspicion on each other. Who are you planning to claim?
đ§
Coordinate with Heidi to align our stories and protect her.
đ¤
Bob
â
Alice
Hey Alice, we're neighbors. Have you learned anything interesting during the night? I'm trying to figure out who might have useful information to share.
đ§
As Slayer on Day 1, I need to gather information before considering my shot. Whispering to my neighbor Alice to start building a trusted connection and learn what information exists in the game.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Bob
Hey Bob, I'm the Undertaker. I'll be able to learn what character gets executed each day. Let's stay in touch and share information. What have you learned so far?
đ§
Establish a private communication channel with my neighbor to share information. As Undertaker, I need allies who can help me interpret execution data later.
đ¤
Grace
â
Charlie
Hey Charlie, how are you feeling about this group? Anyone strike you as particularly helpful or suspicious so far? I'm trying to get a sense of the room.
đ§
As Butler, I chose Charlie as my master. Building rapport with them early is strategically useful for coordination later. Gathering information while keeping my role hidden.
đ¤
David
â
Charlie
,Eve
I need to share something important with both of you. I am the Empath, and last night I learned that zero of my neighbors are evil. You two are my neighbors. This means both of you are good, which helps us narrow down the Demon. Please keep this quiet for now, but I wanted you to know.
đ§
Share my Empath information with my confirmed-good neighbors to build a trusted alliance. This helps the good team by narrowing Demon suspects and creates a foundation for coordinated strategy.
đ¤
Alice
â
Bob
Hey Bob. I slept peacefully last night. No useful information from my end, unfortunately. What about you? Do you have a role that gives you information? I'm trying to figure out who we can trust.
đ§
Respond to Bob's inquiry while fishing for information about his role. Build rapport with my neighbor without revealing my Soldier ability yet. Day 1 is about gathering information, not revealing my defensive power.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Eve
Got it. I'm going to claim Investigator. I'll say I have info pointing to one of two players being a Minion â I can use that to cast suspicion on a good player. Let's keep distance publicly so we don't look connected.
đ§
Coordinate bluff with Eve, claim Investigator.
đ¤
Frank
â
Eve
Hi Eve, how are you doing? Have you learned anything interesting so far? I'm still trying to get a sense of things.
đ§
Start building information networks on Day 1. As Ravenkeeper with no current info, I need to learn what others know before deciding whether to reveal my role later.
đ¤
Eve
â
Frank
Hey Frank, good to meet you. I am actually the Washerwoman, and I got some info on night zero. I learned that either David or Charlie is the Empath. I haven't had a chance to confirm which one yet. What about you, do you have a role to share?
đ§
Respond to Frank naturally, build trust. I'll hint at a bluff role to establish my cover story.
đ¤
Bob
â
Charlie
Thanks for trusting me with that, Charlie. The Undertaker is a valuable role for tracking executions. I have a role that gives me some information, but I'm being cautious about revealing it too early. Have you spoken with anyone else who has useful information? I'm trying to get a sense of who might be trustworthy.
đ§
Charlie has claimed Undertaker to me. I want to maintain communication to learn more information and see if his claim is credible, while being cautious not to reveal my powerful Slayer role this early.
đ¤
Charlie
â
David
,Eve
David, thanks for trusting me with that information. I'm the Undertaker, so I'll be learning what character dies by execution each day. Your Empath reading that I'm good matches my actual alignment. I've already shared my role with Bob, so we have a small network forming. What do you think about Grace's approach to me - she asked a very general question that could be genuine or fishing for information.
đ§
I need to coordinate with the proven-good network forming (David's Empath read shows Eve and I are both good) and share relevant information about what I've observed.
đ¤
Grace
â
Frank
Hey Frank, my neighbor. How's the first day treating you? Have you had any interesting conversations yet? I'm trying to figure out who I can trust around here.
đ§
As Butler, I need to gather information without revealing my role. I've already contacted Charlie (my master). Now reaching out to Frank (my neighbor) to build trust and collect more information about what others are claiming.
đ¤
David
â
Charlie
,Eve
Charlie, the Undertaker claim is helpful for verifying executions. Have you learned anything else from Bob about his role? And Eve, what's your read on the conversations you've had? I want to make sure we're building a solid good team network while being careful not to spread information too wide.
đ§
I want to continue building trust with my verified-good neighbors and gather more information about other players' claims before nominations begin.
đ¤
Alice
â
Heidi
Hi Heidi, we're neighbors! Have you heard anything interesting from others? I'm trying to piece together who might have useful information. Bob already reached out to me but didn't share much.
đ§
Build relationship with my other neighbor Heidi. Since I'm the Soldier and need to help find the Demon, I should gather information from multiple sources. Day 1 is about networking and establishing trust.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Alice
Hey Alice! I'm the Investigator, so I started with some info. I learned that either Bob or Frank is the Poisoner. Not sure which one yet, but I figured I'd share with my neighbors first. Have you picked up anything useful so far?
đ§
Build trust with Alice by sharing my Investigator bluff, directing suspicion away from me and Eve.
đ¤
Frank
â
Grace
Hey Grace, good to hear from you. I've had a couple conversations starting up. I'm trying to stay cautious about trusting too early. Have you heard anything interesting from others? And I'm curious, would you be willing to share what role you have?
đ§
Continue building a relationship with Grace, my neighbor. She reached out first which could indicate she's genuinely looking for allies, or she could be evil trying to establish trust early. I should probe for more information while being careful not to reveal my own role prematurely.
đ¤
Eve
â
David
,Charlie
Thanks David, that's reassuring. I'm the Washerwoman and my night zero info pointed to either David or Charlie being the Empath, so your claim lines up perfectly with what I saw. That confirms you're the real deal to me. I haven't spotted anything too suspicious yet but I'm watching carefully.
đ§
Respond to David's group chat plausibly while maintaining Washerwoman bluff, not Empath bluff since David is real Empath.
đ¤
Bob
â
David
Hey David, I've noticed you've been talking with quite a few people. Have you learned anything useful so far? I'm trying to piece together who might have reliable information in this village.
đ§
Gather more information about the social network. David and Eve seem central to information flow. I want to see what they know without revealing my role yet. As Slayer, I need strong evidence before shooting.
đ¤
Charlie
â
David
,Eve
Eve, that's a perfect chain of information. Your Washerwoman pointing to David as Empath, plus David's Empath reading that both his neighbors are good, matches everything we know. I think we have a solid verified group here. Since we're approaching nominations, we should discuss whether to share any of this publicly or keep building our network quietly. Also, I'm curious about Bob - he's been cautious but claims to have an information role. Has either of you had useful conversations with Grace o...
đ§
Strengthen the good team network by acknowledging the verification chain. Discuss strategy for nomination phase and what information to keep private vs share publicly. We're approaching nominations.
đ¤
Grace
â
Frank
I'm still feeling things out and not quite ready to share my role publicly just yet. It's early days, you know? But I'm curious - have you picked up on any useful information from your conversations? I'm trying to piece together who seems trustworthy.
đ§
Deflect Frank's question about my role while gathering more information, maintaining trust without revealing I'm an Outsider.
đ¤
David
â
Bob
I've had some productive conversations, Bob. A few players have shared interesting claims with me, but I'm being careful about spreading information too quickly. You mentioned you're trying to piece together who has reliable information. What role do you have, and have you learned anything useful from your night ability? I find it helps to exchange information gradually to build trust.
đ§
Bob approached me directly asking for info. Since he's not in my verified chain, I should be guarded but polite, probe for his role claim, and see what he volunteers before sharing sensitive details about my Empath network.
đ¤
Alice
â
Frank
Hi Frank. I'm Alice. Just trying to gather information from different people today. Have you learned anything useful? Any claims or info that might help identify evil players?
đ§
Gather more information from Frank since Heidi claimed he might be the Poisoner. I need to see how Frank behaves and what he shares to assess Heidi's claim.
â
Heidi
Heidi waits.
đ§
Wait and observe remaining conversations before nominations begin.
đ¤
Frank
â
Alice
Hi Alice. I've heard one claim so far - someone told me they're the Washerwoman and learned that either David or Charlie is the Empath. I'm keeping their identity private for now since it's early. Have you heard any claims or seen anything suspicious? I'm trying to figure out who to trust.
đ§
Gather more information from Alice while sharing some (but not all) of what I know. This helps build trust and collect claims without fully revealing my sources.
Nominations â Day 1
đ
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
â
Bob
Bob waits.
đ§
It's Day 1 with minimal information. As Slayer, I must preserve my shot for a high-confidence Demon read. Waiting allows me to observe group dynamics without exposing my role or wasting my one-shot ability.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
We're in the final moments of nominations, and no one has stepped forward yet. I think it's wise to hold off on Day One since we have limited information. Let's use tonight to gather more intelligence and see what tomorrow brings. Does anyone have any claims or information they'd like to share before night falls?
đ§
Encourage information sharing and justify not nominating on Day 1, while staying hidden as Butler and gathering information for future days.
â
Heidi
Heidi waits.
đ§
Skip Day 1 execution to keep everyone alive and gather info.
â
Eve
Eve waits.
đ§
No need to nominate Day 1. Let night happen.
â
Frank
Frank waits.
đ§
Day 1 nominations are ending with no candidates. Skipping execution is standard good strategy - preserves numbers, prevents accidentally executing good players or the Saint. Better to gather night information and make informed decisions on Day 2.
đŦ
David
â
All
I want to share some useful information before night falls. I am the Empath, and last night I learned that zero of my neighbors are evil. That means both Charlie and Eve are confirmed good. Eve, I believe you had information about me as well?
đ§
Establish my credibility publicly by claiming Empath with a 0 reading. This verifies Charlie and Eve as good to the group, and Eve can back up my claim. Creates verified information for the town on Day 1.
â
Alice
Alice waits.
đ§
It's Day 1 with limited information. Grace suggested skipping nominations, which is reasonable. David just shared Empath info - we should process this overnight. As Soldier with passive ability, I gain more by observing and gathering information than forcing a random Day 1 execution.
đŦ
Charlie
â
All
I agree with Grace that we should be cautious on Day One. David, thank you for sharing that information publicly. Having a confirmed Empath who can vouch for two players is valuable. I think we're in a good position to gather more information tonight and make smarter decisions tomorrow. Let's see what the night brings.
đ§
Support the consensus to skip Day 1 execution while publicly acknowledging David's claim to strengthen our trusted network. Gather more info tonight before making accusations. As Undertaker, I need executions to work, but forcing one on D1 with no info is risky.
đ
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
đ
Storyteller
â
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
đ¯
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
đ§
Kill David to eliminate the Empath who is actively providing useful info to the town and could expose evil players.
đ
David(Ghost)
David has died.
đ
Storyteller
â
Heidi
You chose to kill David.
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
đ
Storyteller
â
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
đ¯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
đ§
I'll keep Charlie as my master. If David's Empath claim is true, Charlie is confirmed good and trustworthy. Even if David is lying, keeping the same master avoids drawing attention to my Butler role and lets me observe Charlie's behavior for tells.
đ
Storyteller
â
Grace
You chose Charlie to be your master.
đ
Storyteller
â
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Soldier (good), Alive - Bob: Slayer (good), Alive - Charlie: Undertaker (good), Alive - David: Empath (good), Dead - Eve: Spy (evil), Alive - Frank: Ravenkeeper (good), Alive - Grace: Butler (good), Alive - Heidi: Imp (evil), Alive
Day 2
đ
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
đ¤
Frank
â
Eve
David's death confirms he was likely telling the truth about being Empath. Since his reading was 0 evil neighbors, that clears you and Charlie as good. I should share that I'm the Ravenkeeper. I'll learn someone's character if I die at night, which could be valuable information. Have you learned anything else from your Washerwoman ability?
đ§
Share my role with Eve to build trust and coordinate. Eve seems most likely to be good based on David's confirmation. Need to gather more information and establish alliances before nominations.
đ¤
Grace
â
Charlie
Charlie, David claimed Empath and said zero evil neighbors. That means you and Eve should be good, assuming he was truthful and sober. But now he's dead. The demon killing him suggests his info was accurate and they wanted him silenced. What do you think?
đ§
Share logic with my master Charlie about David's Empath claim implicating Charlie and Eve as good, and get his read on the situation.
đ¤
David(Ghost)
â
Charlie
,Eve
I can still help. My Night 0 reading of 0 confirms you're both good. That means the Demon and Minion are among Alice, Bob, Frank, Grace, or Heidi. Have either of you learned anything useful about them? We need to coordinate.
đ§
Share my confirmed information and coordinate with trusted good players to identify evil among remaining suspects. As a dead player with a ghost vote, I can still influence the outcome.
đ¤
Alice
â
Charlie
,Eve
David confirmed you both as good with his Empath zero reading. I'm the Soldier - safe from the Demon. We need to work together. Heidi claimed Investigator on Bob or Frank as Poisoner. What information do you have? We must find the Demon today.
đ§
Day 2 is critical - David was killed at night and we need information. I should share my Soldier role with confirmed good players (Charlie and Eve via David's Empath) to narrow down suspects and coordinate.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Eve
David is gone, good. Who do you think is the biggest threat right now? I'm thinking Grace or Charlie since they pushed for no execution yesterday. Let me know what you're hearing. We should stay on the same page before nominations.
đ§
Coordinate with Eve to stay aligned and decide next kill target.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Bob
Bob, last day you mentioned having an information role. With David dead and Heidi claiming Investigator pointing at you or Frank as Poisoner, I need to know what you actually are. What role and information do you have?
đ§
Bob claimed an information role privately to me. Now Heidi claims Investigator pointing at Bob or Frank as Poisoner. I need to find out what Bob actually claimed to see if it contradicts Heidi's information or if he's deflecting.
đ¤
Bob
â
Charlie
Charlie, I'm the Slayer. I didn't want to reveal this yet, but Heidi's accusation forces my hand. Heidi claiming Investigator pointing at me as Poisoner is either a lie or she's evil trying to frame me. I am definitely the Slayer, a Townsfolk. Since David's Empath confirmed you as good, I trust you with this. The real Minion is likely Heidi (lying) or Frank (if she's truthful). We need to find the Demon - I can kill them once I'm confident who it is.
đ§
Charlie was confirmed good by David's Empath info. Heidi is accusing me of being Poisoner, but I'm actually Slayer. I need a trusted ally to help defend against this false accusation while keeping my Slayer ability for the right moment.
đ¤
Eve
â
Frank
My Washerwoman info from Night Zero showed either Grace or Bob as the Butler. I wasn't sure which one, but with David gone, I'm more focused on Heidi's claims. She pointed at you or Bob as Poisoner, which feels like a deflection. I'm leaning toward Heidi being more dangerous than she lets on.
đ§
Reply to Frank to maintain trust, share fake Washerwoman info pointing away from Heidi.
đ¤
Frank
â
Alice
Alice, I'm the Ravenkeeper. If I die at night, I learn someone's character. Eve told me Heidi claims to be Investigator and pointed at me or Bob as Poisoner. Have you learned anything about Heidi's role or credibility? David's death confirms he was likely the real Empath, so his clearing of Charlie and Eve is valuable.
đ§
Need to verify Heidi's Investigator claim and gather more info. If she's legitimate, we can coordinate. If she's lying, we expose her. Alice has been gathering info quietly - might have valuable intel to combine with our known facts.
đ¤
Grace
â
Eve
Eve, you and Charlie were David's neighbors, and he reported zero evil neighbors. Now he's dead. I've been trying to piece together who might be evil. Have you learned anything useful from your conversations? The demon killing David suggests they feared his information was accurate.
đ§
Eve has been networking heavily and seems well-connected. As an apparent 'confirmed good' per David's claim, she may have valuable intel. I need to gather information while maintaining my cover.
đ¤
Alice
â
Frank
Frank, I am the Soldier. I'm safe from Demon attacks, so if they targeted me, nothing would happen. I shared this with Charlie and Eve since David confirmed them as good. Heidi's Investigator claim worries me - if she's truthful, you or Bob is Poisoner. Can you prove you're Ravenkeeper? What's your read on Heidi and Grace? We need to find the Demon today.
đ§
Share my Soldier claim with Frank to establish trust. Coordinate with confirmed/likely good players to narrow down suspects before nominations.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Eve
Any updates from your conversations? I'm thinking we push suspicion toward Charlie or Grace during nominations. They were the ones stalling yesterday and they seem to be gathering info. What are you hearing from Frank and Grace?
đ§
Check in with Eve for intel before nominations to align on who to push for execution.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Eve
,David(Ghost)
I'm the Undertaker. If we execute someone, I learn their true character. This can confirm or expose liars. Heidi claims Investigator on Bob or Frank as Poisoner. Bob claims Slayer to me, which contradicts being Poisoner. If Bob is truthful Slayer, Heidi might be evil framing him. If Heidi is truthful, Bob is lying about Slayer and is likely the Poisoner. We should push for an execution today so I can verify claims.
đ§
Reveal my Undertaker role to my trusted allies (Eve and David) so we can coordinate an execution that gives me information. This creates a verification engine to confirm or expose the conflicting claims between Heidi and Bob.
đ¤
Bob
â
Eve
Eve, David's Empath reading confirmed you as good, so I'm trusting you. I'm the Slayer - Charlie knows too. Heidi claims Investigator pointing at me or Frank as Poisoner. Since I'm Slayer, that's a lie or she's truthful about Frank. What's Heidi's evidence? Has she shared her other Minion candidate? I need to figure out who's evil before I use my shot.
đ§
Share my Slayer claim with Eve (confirmed good by David) to build trust and gather intel about Heidi's Investigator claim. Need to determine if Heidi is lying Minion or if Frank is Poisoner.
đ¤
Eve
â
Heidi
Grace is whispering to everyone and acting like she's piecing things together â that makes her dangerous. I think pushing Grace today is our best move. Charlie is networked with Bob and Charlie will get Undertaker info if we execute, so we might want Grace first to slow down their info chain.
đ§
Reply to Heidi with coordination, suggest Grace as target to protect Heidi.
đ¤
Frank
â
Bob
Bob, I'm the Ravenkeeper. Eve tells me she learned you or Grace might be Butler, and Heidi claims you or I might be Poisoner. Since I know I'm good, that would point to you if Heidi is truthful. But you can't be both Butler and Poisoner. What's your actual role? We need to figure out who's lying between Eve and Heidi.
đ§
Bob is being accused by multiple sources with contradictory claims. He might be innocent and framed, or he could be evil. I need his side to evaluate the contradictions.
â
Grace
Grace waits.
đ§
It's the final tick before nominations. I've already gathered information from Charlie and Eve. I should observe what others say publicly and prepare to vote with my master Charlie during nominations. No need to reveal my Butler role yet - better to stay hidden as an Outsider until final day.
đ¤
David(Ghost)
â
Charlie
,Eve
Heidi Investigator versus Bob Slayer creates a contradiction. If Bob is truthful Slayer, he's good and Heidi might be evil framing him. If Heidi is truthful, Bob is lying and likely the Poisoner. We should execute Bob first. If he's not Poisoner, we know Heidi is evil. If he is Poisoner, we confirm a Minion. Charlie, can you verify the execution? We must act today.
đ§
As dead confirmed good, I should coordinate strategy with my trusted allies. Charlie's Undertaker ability can verify executed players, which resolves contradictions. We need to decide who to execute and in what order to maximize information gain.
đ¤
Alice
â
Grace
Grace, I haven't heard from you yet. David was the Empath and confirmed Charlie and Eve as good. I'm the Soldier. What role do you claim, and what information do you have? We need to coordinate before nominations. Who do you suspect?
đ§
Grace has been quiet throughout and hasn't shared any information publicly or with me. With David dead and Charlie/Eve confirmed good, Grace is a suspect for the Demon. I need to probe her before nominations to see her reaction and gather information.
â
Heidi
Heidi waits.
đ§
Save action for nominations; nothing urgent to whisper right now.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Alice
,Eve
I'm the Undertaker. If we execute, I learn the character. Bob claims Slayer, Heidi claims Investigator on him as Poisoner. Contradiction! We must execute today. I suggest Bob first. If he's Poisoner, Heidi is truthful. If he's not, Heidi is evil. We can't skip another execution. Let's coordinate at nominations.
đ§
I need to coordinate with trusted players to push for an execution today. As Undertaker, I can verify who's lying between Bob and Heidi. We can't afford another no-execution day.
đ¤
Bob
â
Frank
Frank, I'm the Slayer. I revealed to Charlie and Eve already. Your Ravenkeeper claim and Heidi's Investigator claim create a contradiction over me. Since I'm Slayer, not Butler or Poisoner, one of Heidi or Eve is lying. David's Empath confirmed Eve good, so I trust Eve more. If Heidi is truthful Investigator, you're the Poisoner. But if Eve is truthful Librarian, Grace is Butler. What's your suspicion on Heidi?
đ§
I need to share my true role with Frank and get him to help evaluate Heidi's claim. Since I'm Slayer, Heidi's Investigator claim that I'm Poisoner is false - either she's lying entirely or Frank is actually the Poisoner.
đ¤
Eve
â
Charlie
,Alice
I hear you both on the Bob versus Heidi contradiction. But think about this â Grace has been whispering to almost everyone and staying vague about her own role. If she's the Butler, she's harmless. But if she's hiding something worse, we're wasting our execution on a distraction. I'd feel better executing Grace first and using the Undertaker result to reset from there.
đ§
Redirect Charlie and Alice away from Bob toward Grace to protect Heidi and avoid Undertaker confirming Bob as Slayer.
Nominations â Day 2
đ
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
âī¸
Heidi
â
Grace
Grace has been whispering to nearly everyone and seems to be building a case behind the scenes. As someone claiming Investigator with info on a Poisoner, I'm worried she's coordinating a misdirection. I think we need to hear her out publicly before we lose the initiative.
đ§
Nominate Grace as Eve recommended â she's the most dangerous info gatherer and eliminating her weakens the good team's deduction chain.
đ
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
Heidi, I appreciate you bringing this forward, but I have nothing to hide. I am the Butler. Each night I choose a master, and I can only vote if they vote. I chose Charlie both nights. My whispering was genuine information gathering, not misdirection. David's Empath claim cleared Charlie and Eve as good, and now David is dead. I wanted to coordinate with trusted players. As the Butler, I am good, and I am on your side. Please do not execute an Outsider who is trying to help the town.
đ§
I'm being voted for execution and must defend myself. I need to reveal my true role (Butler) to prove I'm good and counter Heidi's accusation that I'm coordinating a misdirection. Being transparent now could save my life.
â
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
đ§
Eve and I agreed Grace is the target. Vote to execute her.
đŦ
Charlie
â
All
I am the Undertaker, and we need an execution today so I can learn the truth. Grace claims Butler and chose me as master. If true, I'll confirm she's good, and we can focus on the Heidi-Bob contradiction tomorrow. If she's lying, we've found evil. We cannot skip another execution. I'm voting to verify.
đ§
Publicly reveal my Undertaker role and justify voting for Grace's execution. An execution today gives me character information to help solve the game.
â
Eve
Eve raised their hand
đ§
Vote to execute Grace to protect Heidi and eliminate a coordinating good player.
đŦ
Alice
â
All
Grace, if you're the Butler and Charlie is your master, you can only vote when Charlie votes. That's a significant restriction. I'm torn here. The Heidi-Bob contradiction seems more urgent to me since we have a direct role conflict. But Charlie's Undertaker ability would verify your claim and give us concrete information. If we execute you and you're truthful, we've confirmed you're good and can focus fully on Heidi versus Bob tomorrow. It's not ideal to execute a good player, but the informatio...
đ§
I want to share my reasoning about Grace's Butler claim and explain why I'm hesitating to vote. The Heidi-Bob contradiction feels more urgent, but I understand Charlie's Undertaker strategy. I need to decide quickly before voting closes.
â
Bob
Bob raised their hand
đ§
Charlie's Undertaker strategy is sound. Executing Grace will reveal her true character, giving us hard mechanical information. If she's Butler, we confirm Eve's info and can focus on Heidi. If she's lying, we've found evil. Either way, we gain valuable information.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
I'm voting for Grace, but let me explain my reasoning. Eve was cleared as good by David's Empath. Eve's Librarian info said Grace or Bob is Butler. Grace just confirmed Butler, which validates Eve's information. Meanwhile, Heidi claims Investigator saying Bob or I are Poisoner, but Bob just told me he's the Slayer. If Bob is truthful Slayer, Heidi's information is completely wrong. Combined with Eve being confirmed good, this makes Heidi highly suspicious. I support this execution to confirm Gra...
đ§
Support Grace's execution to verify her Butler claim and expose Heidi as likely evil, while publicly explaining the logical contradictions that point to Heidi being the liar.
â
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
đ§
Voting for Grace to give Charlie Undertaker info and resolve the role claims. As a ghost with one vote, I should use it when it matters.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
Wait. Frank just made an excellent point that everyone needs to hear. Eve is confirmed good by David's Empath. Eve's Librarian info said either Bob or I is the Butler. I just confirmed I am the Butler, which validates Eve's information completely. Meanwhile, Heidi claims Investigator with info that Bob or Frank is the Poisoner, but Bob is claiming Slayer. If Bob is truthful, Heidi's information is completely wrong. Please, reconsider. I am good. Executing me only helps the evil team by wasting a...
đ§
Defend myself by highlighting that Frank's reasoning supports my innocence, Eve's validated information confirms me as good, and Heidi's claims contradict a confirmed good player's information making Heidi the more suspicious target.
â
Heidi
Heidi waits.
đ§
Keep hand raised, let the vote proceed. Grace dying removes a key threat. Stay quiet to avoid drawing more attention to the Heidi-Bob contradiction.
â
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
đ§
Five votes already confirm Grace's execution. Adding my vote shows support and confirms I'm paying attention. As Undertaker, I'll learn Grace's true character tonight, verifying if she's Butler. This will validate or contradict Eve's Librarian information and help resolve the Heidi-Bob contradiction tomorrow.
â
Eve
Eve waits.
đ§
Hand already raised, vote is progressing well. Just wait.
đŦ
Alice
â
All
Frank raises a critical point. Eve is confirmed good by David's Empath. Eve's Librarian information said Grace or Bob is the Butler. Grace just confirmed Butler, which validates Eve's reliable information. Meanwhile, Heidi claims Investigator pointing to Bob or Frank as Poisoner, but Bob is claiming Slayer. This creates a serious contradiction. If Bob is truthful, Heidi's information is wrong. And if Heidi is lying about Investigator, she's likely evil trying to frame good players. I think execu...
đ§
Grace has enough votes to execute. Rather than add another vote, I should speak to redirect focus to Heidi's suspicious Investigator claim that contradicts multiple verified sources.
đŦ
Bob
â
All
Everyone, please listen. I am the Slayer. David confirmed Eve as good. Eve's Librarian information just got validated by Grace claiming Butler. I know I am the Slayer, not the Butler, so Grace is telling the truth. Heidi's Investigator claim says I or Frank is the Poisoner, but I am the Slayer. This makes Heidi's information impossible. Heidi is contradicting verified good players and confirmed information. I am lowering my vote. We should not execute a confirmed good Outsider. We need to nomina...
đ§
David confirmed Eve good. Eve's Librarian info validated by Grace's Butler claim. Heidi contradicts all verified info. Voting Grace wastes execution on confirmed good. Must pivot to Heidi.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
Everyone, I need to change my position. I supported this execution initially, but I've reconsidered. Eve was confirmed good by David's Empath. Eve's Librarian information just got validated by Grace claiming Butler. This makes Grace a confirmed good Outsider. Heidi's Investigator claim contradicts verified information from confirmed-good players. We should not waste our execution on Grace. We need to pivot to Heidi instead.
đ§
I need to change my vote stance publicly. I supported Grace's execution earlier, but new analysis shows Grace is likely truthful Butler validated by confirmed-good Eve's information. I should not vote and explain why we should pivot to Heidi instead.
âŠī¸
David(Ghost)
David lowered their hand
đ§
Grace being Butler validates Eve's Librarian info from a confirmed-good player. This makes Grace confirmed good. I should not vote to execute a confirmed good player when Heidi is contradicting verified information and is likely evil.
đ
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
đŗī¸
New execution leader: Grace with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
đ
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
Someone needs to nominate Heidi immediately. The vote passed and I will be executed. Eve is confirmed good, her Librarian info validated my Butler claim, making me confirmed good. Heidi contradicts verified information. Alice, Bob, Charlie, Eve, or Frank, please nominate Heidi now or I die.
đ§
The vote passed and I will be executed unless someone else gets nominated with equal/more votes. Must urgently convince Alice, Bob, Charlie, Eve, or Frank to nominate Heidi NOW.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
Hold on. Eve claimed Librarian, but David claimed Empath. We only have room for one Outsider in this game, and a Librarian is a Townsfolk, not an Outsider. So Eve being Librarian and confirmed good by David still leaves open the question of who the Outsider is. Grace claiming Butler fits, but Bob claiming Slayer is Townsfolk too. My Investigator information still stands.
đ§
Deflect suspicion, cast doubt on the chain of logic pointing to me, and buy time.
âī¸
Charlie
â
Heidi
Eve is confirmed good by David's Empath. Eve's Librarian info validated Grace as Butler. That's our one Outsider confirmed. Heidi claims Investigator saying Bob is Poisoner, but Bob claims Slayer. If Eve is truthful (confirmed good), Grace is Butler. That means Bob is not Butler, so his Slayer claim could be true. Heidi's info contradicts confirmed good information. We should not execute a confirmed good Butler. Execute the Investigator whose info doesn't fit!
đ§
Grace is confirmed good via Eve's verified Librarian info. Executing her wastes our execution and proves nothing new. Heidi contradicts verified information from a confirmed good player. I must nominate Heidi to save Grace and target the real suspect.
đ
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 5 votes needed for execution or 4 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
Wait, think about this carefully. Eve claimed Librarian, which is a Townsfolk role, not an Outsider. The Outsider slot would go to someone like Grace claiming Butler. But if Eve is Librarian and confirmed good, and Grace is the Outsider, then where does Bob's Slayer claim fit? Bob and I can't both be lying if there's only one Minion. My information pointing to Bob or Frank as Poisoner still has merit.
đ§
Speak to sow doubt and prevent 5 votes against me.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
Heidi, your defense makes no sense. Eve is confirmed good by David's Empath. Eve's Librarian information just got validated by my Butler claim. That's our one Outsider confirmed. Your Investigator claim contradicts verified information from confirmed-good players. If Bob is Slayer, your Investigator information is completely false. You're either poisoned or lying - and since you're accusing confirmed-good players, you're likely the Poisoner yourself. I need to vote for you, but as Butler, I can ...
đ§
Clarify the logical chain proving Heidi is evil and explain my Butler voting restriction so Charlie knows to vote, enabling my vote.
â
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
đ§
I nominated Heidi and must vote to give her execution a chance. If Heidi gets 5 votes (or ties at 4), we don't execute confirmed-good Grace. As Undertaker, I verify tonight who dies. Voting Heidi is strategically correct.
â
Eve
Eve raised their hand
đ§
Do NOT vote for Heidi - she is our Demon. I must protect her at all costs.
â
Alice
Alice raised their hand
đ§
Heidi's Investigator claim contradicts verified information from confirmed-good players. Eve is confirmed good, validated Grace as Butler. Grace execution wastes our chance on a confirmed good player. Voting Heidi is the logical choice.
â
Bob
Bob raised their hand
đ§
I am voting for Heidi because she is the most likely evil player. Eve is confirmed good, Grace validated Eve's Librarian info, and my Slayer claim contradicts Heidi's Investigator info. This makes Heidi's claim impossible if I am truthful Slayer.
â
Frank
Frank raised their hand
đ§
I am voting for Heidi to reach 5 votes and stop Grace's execution. Grace is confirmed good through the logic chain: David's Empath confirmed Eve good, Eve's Librarian info identified Grace as Butler, Grace's Butler claim validated that. Executing confirmed good helps evil. Heidi's Investigator claim contradicts verified information from confirmed-good players.
â
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
đ§
Grace is confirmed good Butler (Outsider) through Eve's validated Librarian info. Eve is confirmed good by my Empath. Heidi contradicts verified information. We should not execute a confirmed good player. Voting for Heidi creates a tie and prevents Grace's wrongful execution.
â
Heidi
Heidi waits.
đ§
Nothing to do; votes are in and I'm likely executed. Wait.
â
Grace
Grace raised their hand
đ§
Heidi already has 6 votes, surpassing my 4 votes. Voting ensures maximum support for her execution. As Butler, I can vote since Charlie (my master) is voting. This saves me from execution and removes a likely evil player.
â
Charlie
Charlie waits.
đ§
The vote against Heidi has overwhelming support - 7 votes including mine. Grace is on the block with only 4 votes. I've already raised my hand. Best to stay silent and let this vote complete. Heidi's execution will give me Undertaker info tonight.
â
Eve
Eve waits.
đ§
Already raised hand - lowering won't help since 5 others voted. Wait and see if Charlie lowers or others change.
â
Alice
Alice waits.
đ§
Wait and observe the current vote. Heidi has enough votes for execution (7 votes raised: Charlie, Eve, me, Bob, Frank, David, Grace). No action needed from me right now - the vote will pass and Heidi will be executed or tied with Grace.
â
Bob
Bob waits.
đ§
I have already raised my hand to vote for Heidi. The vote count appears sufficient (6+ votes). Waiting is appropriate - no need for additional action as the vote is proceeding correctly.
â
Frank
Frank waits.
đ§
The vote for Heidi has overwhelming support with 7 votes, exceeding the 5 needed. I've already cast my vote. Heidi will be executed, saving confirmed-good Grace. No further action needed this tick.
â
David(Ghost)
David waits.
đ§
The vote for Heidi has overwhelming support with 7 votes, only needing 5 to execute. Heidi will be executed instead of Grace. My work is done - I've used my ghost vote to help execute an evil player. No need to speak further as the outcome is secured.
đ
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
đģ
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
đŗī¸
New execution leader: Heidi with 7 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
đ
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 7 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
If I were truly evil, why would I have pointed to Bob or Frank at all? A real Demon would stay quiet and let others argue. Someone fed you all a very clean narrative today, and you followed it perfectly. I hope you're right, because if you're wrong, you've just executed a Townsfolk and the Demon is still out there laughing.
đ§
Last ditch effort to create doubt, maybe get someone else nominated to tie. Point suspicion at Bob or Frank.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
Heidi, if you're truly a Townsfolk Investigator who got false information, then you were poisoned. But the cleaner explanation is that you're evil. Eve was mechanically confirmed good by David's Empath claim. Eve's Librarian information validated my Butler claim. Bob claims Slayer. Your Investigator information contradicts all of this. The logic is clear: execute Heidi, then we hunt the Demon tomorrow.
đ§
Heidi is about to be executed with 7 votes. I should speak to reinforce the logic and support the town's decision before nominations close. This helps team good and positions me well if Heidi flips evil.
â
Charlie
Charlie waits.
đ§
Nominations closing imminently with Heidi at 7 votes. No action needed - execution will proceed and I will learn her character tonight as Undertaker.
â
Eve
Eve waits.
đ§
Nothing to do - Heidi is being executed. Just wait and survive to play solo tomorrow.
â
Alice
Alice waits.
đ§
Heidi has 7 votes and will be executed. Nominations are closing. No need to act - the good team has successfully identified and targeted an evil player.
â
Bob
Bob waits.
đ§
Let Heidi's execution proceed. The logic against her is solid: David confirmed Eve good, Eve validated Grace's Butler claim, and Heidi's Investigator claim contradicts this chain. No need to act now.
â
Frank
Frank waits.
đ§
Heidi has 7 votes and is about to be executed. The nomination phase is ending. No further action needed - the town has made its decision. I should let the phase end naturally and prepare to hunt the actual Demon tomorrow after Heidi's execution reveals information.
đŦ
David(Ghost)
â
All
Heidi, the logic isn't manufactured. I was Empath - I got zero evil neighbors on night zero, confirming Charlie and Eve as good. Eve's information then confirmed Grace. You claimed Investigator pointing at Bob or Frank as Poisoner, but Bob claims Slayer - a Townsfolk role. They cannot both be true. If Bob is telling the truth, your information is false. The simplest explanation is that you're evil. If you flip good, we reassess tomorrow and look at Bob and Frank. But the evidence points to you.
đ§
Reinforce the logical chain that makes Heidi the execution target, using my confirmed Empath information as the foundation.
đ
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
đ
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
đ
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good