Game Detail
Players
Alice (Librarian) Bob (Monk) Charlie (Slayer) David (Chef) Eve (Drunk) Frank (Virgin) Grace (Poisoner) Heidi (Imp)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 1,000,347 | 99,841 | $7.4978 |
| Evil | 285,857 | 62,726 | $1.3784 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You are the Minion. The Demon is Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Minions are: Grace. Your safe bluffs are: Undertaker, Recluse, Fortune Teller
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Alice sits next to Heidi and could be a key information role. Poisoning her maximizes disruption of Day 1 logic that could quickly converge on Heidi as Demon.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to poison Alice.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Librarian. Either David or Heidi is the Drunk.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Investigator. Either Frank or Charlie is the Baron.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 1 pairs of evil players.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
David
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I'm the Chef. I got a one last night, meaning there's exactly one pair of evil players sitting next to each other. What role did you get?
π§
I want to start building trust with a neighbor. I'll whisper to Charlie first to share my Chef info and see what they claim. Starting with neighbors lets me cross-reference later with Empath info if one exists.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Hey Grace, I'm the Investigator. My night info says either Frank or Charlie is the Baron. That means extra Outsiders are in play. What role are you?
π§
I want to share my Investigator info with a trusted player first. I'll whisper to Alice or someone not in my suspect pool to build an alliance before going public. Let me reach out to Grace who is not adjacent to me or in my suspect list.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Hey Alice, we're neighbors so I want to touch base. What role are you claiming? I have a protective role but I don't want to say too much publicly yet. Have you gotten any useful information?
π§
I want to start a private conversation with Alice (my neighbor) to build trust and exchange information. As Monk, I should be careful about revealing my role too early since it makes me a target, but I need allies.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Hey Bob, thanks for reaching out. I'm the Librarian. I learned that either David or Heidi is the Drunk. That's useful because whoever is the Drunk thinks they're a Townsfolk but their info is wrong. If you're the Monk, that's great. Who are you thinking of protecting tonight?
π§
Bob claims a protective role (likely Monk). I should share my Librarian info with him privately to build trust and start narrowing things down. I won't reveal everything publicly yet.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Quick sync: my demon bluffs are Undertaker, Recluse, and Fortune Teller. I am thinking of claiming Fortune Teller. Can you pick a different townsfolk-style claim and we back each other up? Also tell me anything you learned so far.
π§
Coordinate bluffs with Grace and set a consistent story early so we can control day one and protect our minion from Investigator-style pressure.
π€
Charlie
β
David
Hey David, thanks for sharing that. A Chef one is really useful - it means the evil pair is sitting next to each other somewhere. I have a role I'd rather keep quiet for now, but I'm on the good team. Have you talked to anyone else yet? Let's compare notes later.
π§
I want to build trust with David without fully revealing my Slayer role yet. I'll claim a less threatening role or deflect slightly while acknowledging his info. Actually, I should be somewhat honest to build trust but maybe not reveal Slayer immediately - I could say I'm thinking about my role or claim something defensive.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
I will claim Washerwoman and say I saw you or Frank as Fortune Teller, to support your Fortune Teller claim. Also Eve told me she is Investigator and got Frank or Charlie is the Baron, which clashes with me being Poisoner. I poisoned Alice night zero.
π§
Coordinate with Heidi on complementary bluffs, pass along Eve's claim, and set up a Washerwoman-style confirmation of Heidi as Fortune Teller while leveraging my poison on Alice for chaos.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Hey Eve, I noticed you were chatting with Grace. What did you learn? I have some useful information to share too, but I want to hear from you first.
π§
As Virgin, I want to be nominated by a Townsfolk to trigger my ability. I should build a relationship with a neighbor first and gather information before the nomination phase. Let me whisper to Eve to see what she knows.
π€
David
β
Eve
Hey Eve, I'm gathering some info. What role are you playing? I've got some useful night one information I can share if we can build some trust.
π§
I need to gather information from my other neighbor Eve. As Chef with a 1, I know one pair of adjacent players are both evil. I should share this cautiously and see what Eve claims.
π€
Eve
β
David
Hey David, I'm the Investigator. My night info tells me either Frank or Charlie is the Baron. That means extra Outsiders in play. What's your role and info? Also curious what Charlie told you.
π§
David reached out to me and seems willing to share info. I should build trust with David since he's my neighbor and could be a useful ally. I'll share my Investigator info with him to see if it aligns with anything he knows. I'm cautious about Frank since he could be the Baron.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I noticed you've been chatting with David. I'm trying to gather info early on. What role are you working with? I have a protective ability and want to make sure I'm using it wisely tonight. Any leads so far?
π§
I want to build trust with Alice and coordinate. I should confirm I'm Monk and discuss who to protect. I also want to gather more info from other players. Let me whisper to Charlie, my other neighbor, to get their claim too.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
Hey Heidi, we're neighbors so I wanted to check in. What role are you claiming? I have some first night information that might be relevant to you. I'm happy to share if you're willing to trade info.
π§
I should reach out to Heidi since she's my neighbor and one of the two players in my Librarian info. I want to learn what role she claims to cross-reference. If she claims Townsfolk, she might be the Drunk. I should be careful about how much I reveal.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
Hey. I am going to claim Fortune Teller. I have not acted yet, but I can share my reads after tonight. What is your first night info, and what are you planning to tell the group publicly?
π§
Lock in my Fortune Teller bluff early, extract Aliceβs N0 info (likely poisoned), and steer her away from focusing on me while setting up future misexecution paths.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
Hey Bob, I appreciate you reaching out. I'd rather keep my exact role close to the chest for now, but I'm good and have a one-use ability. David told me he's the Chef and got a one, meaning one evil pair is adjacent. What's your protective role? Monk? Any reads so far?
π§
Bob claims a protective ability (Monk). I want to build trust without revealing I'm the Slayer, since that would make me a target. I'll share that David claimed Chef-1 and see what Bob knows.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
Hey Eve. I am the Washerwoman. I saw that either Heidi or Frank is the Fortune Teller. So if someone comes out Fortune Teller, I will be looking at those two first. Your Frank or Charlie Baron info is interesting too.
π§
Give Eve a plausible townsfolk claim plus info that backs Heidiβs planned Fortune Teller bluff, and nudge the town toward suspecting Frank or Charlie instead of me or Heidi.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Hey Grace, I see you've been busy chatting with Eve and Heidi. What have you picked up so far? I'd like to compare notes. I have something useful but want to hear your info first.
π§
I want to gather information from Grace, my other neighbor, since Eve hasn't responded to my first whisper. As Virgin, I want to be nominated by a Townsfolk eventually, but I should first gather info to identify suspects.
π€
David
β
Eve
Thanks Eve. I'm the Chef, and I got a one, meaning exactly one pair of evil players are sitting next to each other. Interesting that you see Frank or Charlie as Baron. Charlie was evasive about his role when I asked. If Charlie is Baron, the evil pair could be Charlie and Bob since I know I'm good. What did Grace tell you?
π§
Eve shared important info - she claims Investigator seeing Frank or Charlie as Baron. I should share my Chef 1 info with her and note that Charlie was evasive about his role. This helps us cross-reference. I need to be careful since Eve could be evil too.
π€
Eve
β
David
Grace claims Washerwoman and says either Heidi or Frank is Fortune Teller. If Frank is the Baron from my info, he can't be Fortune Teller, so Heidi would be. Your Chef 1 is key. If Charlie is Baron, Charlie plus Bob could be the evil pair. Charlie being evasive is suspicious.
π§
I need to share Grace's Washerwoman info with David to cross-reference, and also respond to Frank carefully since he might be the Baron. Time is running out before nominations.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Good to know about David's Chef claim. Interesting wrinkle though - Alice told me she's the Librarian and learned that either David or Heidi is the Drunk. If David is the Drunk thinking he's the Chef, his number one reading could be totally wrong. What do you think?
π§
I want to share Alice's Librarian info with Charlie to cross-reference and build trust, and also hint that David's Chef info might be unreliable if he's the Drunk. This helps me decide who to protect tonight.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
I'm the Librarian. My night one info is that either you or David is the Drunk. If you're truly the Fortune Teller, you might actually be the Drunk who thinks you're the Fortune Teller. Your reads tonight could be unreliable. What role has David claimed to anyone?
π§
I need to tell Heidi my Librarian info - that either she or David is the Drunk. If she's the Fortune Teller, she could actually be the Drunk Fortune Teller with bad info. This is critical for her to know, and for the town to evaluate her future reads.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
Interesting. I have not heard a claim from David yet. If your info is right, it could easily be David, but also poisoning exists. I would keep that quiet until after tonight, then we can compare with my Fortune Teller result. Have you spoken to David at all?
π§
Keep Alice from publicly undermining my Fortune Teller bluff, steer her toward suspecting David, and keep her engaged so she feels aligned with me.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
That's a huge piece of info. If David is the Drunk thinking he's Chef, his one could be meaningless. But if Heidi is the Drunk, David's Chef one still holds. Did Alice say which Outsider one of them is? Can you ask her? Also, who's your protective role - Monk? I want to coordinate before nominations.
π§
I need to process this info from Bob about Alice's Librarian claim. This is critical - if David is the Drunk, his Chef 1 is unreliable. I should share my thoughts with Bob but keep my Slayer role hidden. I want to gather more info before using my shot.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Sure. I am Washerwoman. I saw that either Heidi or you is the Fortune Teller. Also, Eve told me she is Investigator and got you or Charlie as Baron, which feels like it could be wrong somehow. What is your useful info?
π§
Give Frank a plausible townsfolk claim, align him with Heidiβs future Fortune Teller claim, and seed doubt about Eveβs Investigator info without hard-accusing anyone yet.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Thanks Grace. Here's the thing - I'm actually the Virgin, not the Fortune Teller. So if your Washerwoman info is correct, Heidi must be the Fortune Teller. Eve's claim that I'm Baron is wrong - I'm good. Either Eve is lying, poisoned, or Charlie is the Baron. Let's keep this between us for now.
π§
I need to tell Grace I'm actually Virgin, not Fortune Teller. This is important - if Grace's Washerwoman info says me or Heidi is Fortune Teller and I'm actually Virgin, then either Heidi IS the Fortune Teller (and Grace's info points to Heidi), or Grace is poisoned/lying. I should share my real role to help us deduce.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Hey everyone, I've been chatting around and I want to share something interesting. Alice claims she's the Librarian and learned that either David or Heidi is the Drunk. David has apparently claimed Chef with a reading of one evil pair adjacent. If David is actually the Drunk, that Chef info could be completely wrong. I think we need to hear from both David and Heidi on this before we nominate anyone.
π§
It's Day 1 with limited info. I want to share some useful information publicly to get discussion going without revealing my exact role. I'll bring up the David/Heidi Drunk claim to see reactions and gather more data before nominations.
π¬
David
β
All
Thanks Bob. I am the Chef, and I got a one, meaning exactly one pair of evil players are neighbors. I know I'm not the Drunk because I know my own role. If Alice is a real Librarian, then Heidi would be the Drunk, not me. But I also want to point out that Alice and Bob are sitting right next to each other. If Alice is lying about being Librarian to discredit my info, that pair could be the evil duo my Chef reading detected.
π§
I need to defend my Chef info and point out that Bob's framing is suspicious. I should also share my Chef 1 info publicly and note that Alice and Bob sitting next to each other could be the evil pair.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Alice
I want to nominate Alice. Her Librarian story is driving the whole Drunk debate, but it directly conflicts with Davidβs Chef read and is easy to be wrong if she is lying or malfunctioning. I would rather execute Alice now and stop building plans on possibly bad info.
π§
Create a credible Day 1 execution on poisoned Alice, redirecting suspicion away from Heidi and buying time for future poisons.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Hold on everyone. Executing me on day one with no real evidence is exactly what evil wants. My Librarian info doesn't conflict with David's Chef info at all. If Heidi is the Drunk, David's Chef read of one is perfectly valid. Grace, why are you so eager to rush this? Let Heidi get her Fortune Teller read tonight and we can cross-reference tomorrow with actual information instead of guessing.
π§
I need to defend myself against this nomination. Executing me Day 1 wastes a critical execution when we have no confirmed evil. I should point out that my info is verifiable over time and that rushing to execute me benefits evil.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
I should NOT vote to execute Alice. Her Librarian claim doesn't actually conflict with David's Chef claim - if Heidi is the Drunk, both can be true. Day 1 executions on thin evidence hurt good more than evil. I want to protect Alice tonight with my Monk ability since she's my neighbor and has shared useful info.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Alice makes a valid point - executing day 1 with limited info is risky. My Chef info of 1 pair doesn't directly implicate Alice. I'd rather gather more night info. Not voting lets us go to night and get more data from Empath/FT/Undertaker reads.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Push a Day 1 execution on a likely good, currently-poisoned player to disrupt town info and protect Heidi while I look consistent with my nomination.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Vote Alice out to remove a strong social voice and the public Drunk accusation on me, protecting my Fortune Teller bluff and advancing evil toward a numbers win.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Day 1 execution with limited info is risky. Alice's claim doesn't actually conflict with David's - if Heidi is the Drunk, both can be true. I don't want to execute a potentially good Librarian on day 1. I'll wait and not vote.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I don't want to vote for Alice right now. Her Librarian claim doesn't actually conflict with David's Chef info - if Heidi is the Drunk, everything is consistent. Day 1 executions on thin evidence are risky. Better to gather more info tonight. Grace and Heidi voting feels premature. I'll wait.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
I should NOT vote for Alice. Day 1 execution with limited info is risky. Alice's point is valid - we can get more info tonight. Only 2 votes so far (Grace, Heidi), needs 4. I'll wait and let this nomination fail so we can gather more info at night.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Notice that the only two people voting for me are Grace, who nominated me, and Heidi, the person I just identified as a possible Drunk. Heidi has every reason to want me gone before my info gets verified. Think about why those two are so eager to execute me before we even have a night's worth of information to work with.
π§
I need to point out that Grace and Heidi are the only ones voting for me. Heidi voting is especially suspicious since I just told her she might be the Drunk - she has motive to silence me. I want to draw attention to this voting pattern to survive.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Only 2 votes (Grace and Heidi) out of 4 needed. Alice shouldn't be executed Day 1 with so little info. I'll wait and not vote - we need more information before executing anyone, and Alice's point about Grace and Heidi being eager is worth considering.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Only 2 votes (Grace, Heidi) out of 4 needed. Alice makes a good point - executing D1 with minimal info is risky. I should not vote here. Let's gather more info tonight and revisit tomorrow.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am voting because Aliceβs Librarian claim is steering the whole day, and if it is wrong we are building on sand. A day one execute is not automatically evil. And Heidi voting does not prove anything; if Alice is accusing her, of course she would want Alice gone. Davidβs Chef one could just as easily be Alice and Bob.
π§
Keep pressure on the poisoned Alice, encourage more votes, and reinforce the alternative 'Alice-Bob evil neighbors' story so Davidβs Chef does not point at me and Heidi.
β©οΈ
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
π§
Distance from Graceβs push, reduce suspicion on me, and avoid being one of the only voters on a likely-failed day one execution.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Only Grace has her hand raised (Heidi lowered), so Alice won't reach the 4-vote threshold. I should not vote to execute Alice on day 1 with so little info - it's too risky. Better to wait and gather more info tonight.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Only Grace has her hand raised (Heidi lowered). That's 1 vote, far from the 4 needed. I don't want to execute Alice on Day 1 β her claim is plausible and we gain more info tonight. I'll wait and not vote.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
The vote on Alice is failing - only Grace has her hand raised (Heidi lowered). I don't want to execute Alice on Day 1 without more info. My Virgin ability is most useful if someone nominates ME - a Townsfolk nominating me gets executed, confirming info. I should wait and let this vote fail.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Alice did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (1/4).
π¬
Alice
β
All
Good, I survived that. Now think about this: David's Chef read says one evil pair is sitting next to each other. Grace just tried to get me executed on day one with almost no logic behind it. Grace and Frank are neighbors. That's worth keeping in mind. Let's get through tonight, gather real information, and compare notes tomorrow.
π§
The nomination phase is almost over with 1 tick left. I survived the vote. I want to point out Grace's suspicious behavior and set up information gathering for tonight. I should highlight that Grace and Frank are neighbors and could be the evil pair David's Chef detected.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Alright, I think we made the right call not executing Alice on day one with so little to go on. Let's all pay close attention tonight and compare notes tomorrow. We've got a lot of threads to pull on, especially around Grace's rush to nominate and who's sitting next to whom. Stay sharp everyone.
π§
We're at the last tick of nominations. I don't have strong enough evidence to nominate anyone yet. Better to let the night happen, protect a key player with my Monk ability, and gather more info tomorrow. I'll make a brief closing statement to keep the town focused.
π¬
David
β
All
Alright, heading into night with no execution, which is fine for day one. Remember, my Chef info says one evil pair sits adjacent. Keep your eyes on Alice and Bob, Grace and Heidi, or Charlie and Bob as possible pairs. Let's gather more info tonight and compare tomorrow. Stay safe everyone.
π§
Last tick of nomination phase. I want to leave a final thought for everyone to consider overnight, emphasizing the key theories and keeping suspicion spread appropriately.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Just to respond to Alice: yes, Chef one means one adjacent evil pair exists, but it does not mean the first neighbor pair someone points at is correct. Alice and Bob are also adjacent and are the loudest connected info so far. Let us get night info and compare tomorrow before we lock in a story.
π§
Reduce heat from the true Grace-Heidi adjacency by widening Chef pair possibilities and painting Aliceβs push as defensive, while sounding pro-information not bloodthirsty.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am fine with no execution today. I voted because I did not want us building the whole game on one Librarian ping, but I am not locked on Alice now. Let us get night info and then compare claims carefully tomorrow, especially if Chef one is real.
π§
End day with no execution, soften suspicion on my earlier vote, and set up doubt on Alice and the Chef pair logic so tomorrow I can drive the narrative with a Fortune Teller claim.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Day 1 is ending with no execution, which is fine. No need to speak or nominate now - better to save my Slayer shot for when I have clearer information. Let the night phase happen and gather more data tomorrow.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Alright, heading into night. I'll just say this: keep a close eye on Charlie. He's been awfully quiet about his role all day while everyone else has been sharing. Tomorrow I want to hear what Charlie actually is. Stay safe tonight everyone.
π§
It's the last tick before night. I should share a brief closing thought to set up tomorrow's discussion, hinting at my information without fully revealing my role yet.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Before we head into night, I just want to put this out there. If anyone is confident they're a Townsfolk, consider nominating me tomorrow. I have a reason for saying that, and you'll see why if you do. Let's get through the night and regroup with fresh info.
π§
As Virgin, I should remind people I exist and that nominating me has consequences. This could help prove someone's alignment tomorrow. Also want to note Charlie's silence and set up for tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Town is already eyeing the GraceβHeidi neighbor pair from Chef one; poisoning Frank may create false Empath info that clears me, buying cover for Heidi to kill a key info player.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to poison Frank.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
Bob
Bob made a choice.
π§
Alice has been targeted today and has useful Librarian info. She's a likely Demon kill target tonight. Protecting her preserves her info and lets us verify claims tomorrow. If she survives, it narrows suspects.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose to protect Alice.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Remove the player most likely to drive a mechanical case onto me tomorrow, and reduce townβs reliable info so we can steer executions away from the demon.
π‘οΈ
Alice was protected from a night kill.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You attacked Alice, but they survived.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Kill on Alice failed last night. Feels like Monk protect or Alice is Soldier. Can you poison whoever you think is Monk today (maybe Bob or Frank)? I will go public as Fortune Teller soon. Your Washerwoman ping on me or Frank as FT still good.
π§
Coordinate with Grace to explain the failed kill, pick a poison target to enable future kills, and align public claims (my FT + her Washerwoman) to steer town into mis-executions away from me.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
Hey, nobody died last night. That's huge. Either a Monk saved someone, a Soldier got targeted, or the Imp killed themselves to pass to a Minion. Charlie, did you ever claim a role? And Eve, your Investigator info on Frank or Charlie being Baron still stands. We need to figure this out before nominations.
π§
No one died last night which is very significant. I need to discuss this with trusted allies. Charlie and Eve are my neighbors and I've shared info with them before. The no-kill night is a major clue to discuss.
π€
Bob
β
David
David, I'm the Monk. I protected Alice last night and nobody died. That likely means the Demon targeted Alice and I blocked it. This clears Alice as good. Your Chef info of 1 evil pair - can we narrow it down? Who do you suspect most?
π§
No one died last night. I protected Alice. This means either the Demon targeted Alice (and I saved her) or targeted a Soldier. I should share this info privately with someone I trust to build an alliance. Charlie asked about my role - risky. Let me whisper to David who has been sharing info openly.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Eve, nobody died last night. That's huge. Either a Monk saved someone, there's a Soldier in play, or the Imp self-killed to pass the Demon role to their Minion. What do you think? Also, has Charlie claimed a role to you yet?
π§
No one died last night - this is critical information. I want to whisper to Eve to probe her and discuss the no-death night, and gauge her reaction. She claimed Investigator pointing at Charlie/Frank as Baron.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
Heidi, what did your Fortune Teller ability show you last night? Also, nobody died which is interesting. Could mean a Monk save, Soldier block, or something else. I want to compare notes before nominations.
π§
No one died at night which is significant. I need to gather info from Heidi about her FT results and from others. Let me whisper to Heidi to get her Fortune Teller info, and also check what's happening with the whisper chains.
π€
Eve
β
David
David, no death last night is very suspicious. If the Imp self-killed, a Minion became the new Imp. If Frank is the Baron from my info, he could now be the Imp. We should pressure Charlie hard today for his role. Also be careful with Bob β what did he whisper to you?
π§
Frank is one of my two suspects for Baron. I should be cautious sharing too much with him directly. I'll respond carefully and probe him while sharing more freely with David who seems to be providing consistent info.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
I will share a private read: I am leaning Washerwoman, and I saw that either Heidi or Frank is the Fortune Teller. Also, Alice being so confident about the Drunk ping feels like she could be poisoned or mistaken. I think we should make Charlie fully claim today.
π§
Seed my Washerwoman bluff to support Heidiβs Fortune Teller claim and discredit Aliceβs Librarian-driven Drunk theory as poisoned, shifting suspicion away from Heidi and my neighbor-pair.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Eve
David, Eve β I'm the Slayer. I'm not Baron. If Eve's Investigator info says Frank or Charlie is Baron, that points to Frank. Also, no death last night is suspicious. Could be Monk save, Soldier, or Imp self-kill passing to a Minion. We need to be careful β if the Imp passed, the new Demon could be anyone.
π§
David shared Eve's claim that Frank or me is Baron. I need to respond to David and Eve, deny being Baron by revealing I'm Slayer, and discuss the no-death night. This also helps me figure out if Eve is trustworthy or evil.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
I got Fortune Teller last night, and I checked David and Bob. I got a yes, so one of them is demon or the red herring. With no death, I wonder if a Monk saved you. I can go public later, but wanted you to have it first.
π§
Answer Alice with a believable Fortune Teller result that steers suspicion onto David and away from me and Grace, while explaining the no-death night.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
Important update: Bob whispered to me claiming Monk. Says he protected Alice last night and that's why nobody died. This conveniently clears Alice. But if Alice and Bob are the evil pair, this is exactly the cover story they'd use. Charlie, you claim Slayer β can you prove it by shooting someone today? That would help verify you.
π§
I need to share Bob's Monk claim with Eve and Charlie so we can cross-reference. Bob's claim is convenient - it perfectly explains no death AND clears Alice. But if Alice-Bob are the evil pair, this is exactly what they'd do. Eve's info pointing to Frank or Charlie as Baron is key.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Alice, Grace just told me she's Washerwoman and saw that Heidi or Frank is Fortune Teller. Also nobody died last night - I protected you as Monk, so the Demon may have targeted you and I blocked it. That clears you. What did Heidi tell you? We need Charlie to claim today.
π§
Grace whispered me Washerwoman info. I should share info back carefully. I want to push Charlie to claim and cross-reference Grace's info about Heidi/Frank being Fortune Teller. Let me whisper Alice about what Grace told me since Alice and I seem to be aligned.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Grace, nobody died last night β that's very suspicious. Could mean Monk save, Soldier block, or Imp self-kill passing Demon to Minion. What did Heidi whisper to you? Also, I noticed David, Charlie, and Eve are whispering a lot together. What's your read on that group?
π§
I need to gather info from Grace, my neighbor, about what she learned from Heidi's whisper and what she thinks about the no-death night. Grace claimed Washerwoman so she should be a useful ally if genuine.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Bob, huge info. Heidi says she's Fortune Teller and checked David and Bob last night - got a yes, meaning one of them is the Demon or her red herring. If Grace confirms Heidi or Frank is FT, and Heidi is the Drunk per my info, her read could be wrong. But if David is the Drunk instead, Heidi's FT is real and one of you or David is the Demon. We need Charlie's claim badly.
π§
Bob gave me critical info - he claims Monk who saved me, and Grace claims Washerwoman seeing Heidi/Frank as FT. I need to share key info with Bob to coordinate, especially Heidi's FT result pointing at David/Bob. This creates an important cross-reference.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Charlie
Critical idea: Charlie, if you're really the Slayer, shoot Frank today. My info says Frank or Charlie is Baron. If the Imp self-killed and passed to Frank, your Slayer shot kills him and we win. If Frank is just Baron, nothing happens but we learn something. Bob claiming Monk protecting Alice is suspicious β could be evil pair cover. Charlie, please use your shot on Frank.
π§
I need to coordinate with David and Charlie. Key insight: if Bob=Monk saved Alice and that's why no one died, we can test this. But more importantly, Charlie claims Slayer β he should shoot Frank. If Frank=Baron (my info), the shot won't kill him (Slayer only kills Demons), but if Imp self-killed and passed to Frank, the shot WOULD kill Frank. This is a powerful test.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Heidi told me the kill on Alice failed, so she thinks either a Monk protected or Alice is Soldier. She asked me to look for who might be Monk, and my best guesses are Bob or David. If you are really the Virgin, I still like the idea of someone nominating you today to try to confirm it.
π§
Answer Frank without outing Heidi, build trust, and subtly encourage a Virgin test that will malfunction from poison and destabilize town reads.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Eve
Eve, hold on. My Slayer shot only kills the Demon, not a Minion. If Frank is Baron, shooting him does nothing. I'd waste my one shot. I should save it for someone I'm more confident is the actual Imp. Who do we think the Demon is? Let's narrow that down first before I use it.
π§
Eve wants me to shoot Frank, but I need to think carefully. My Slayer shot only works on the Demon, not a Minion. If Frank is Baron (Minion), shooting him does nothing. I should save my shot for someone I strongly suspect is the Demon. Let me whisper back to David and Eve to discuss this more carefully before using my shot.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
I am keeping this quiet for now, but my Fortune Teller check on David and you came back yes. With Alice saying Librarian got Heidi or David as Drunk, I am leaning David is the drunk source of the Chef push. What are you hearing from David?
π§
Seed Bob with my FT yes and steer suspicion onto David, undermining Chef logic and setting up a Day 2 misexecution away from me and Grace.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
Charlie, you're right the shot only kills the Demon. But consider: if the Imp self-killed last night, the Minion IS the new Imp now. If Frank is Baron per Eve's info and the Imp passed to him, shooting Frank kills the Demon. It's worth the risk. If not, we nominate Bob today. Bob's Monk claim is too convenient as Alice's alibi.
π§
Eve's suggestion to shoot Frank is smart IF the Imp passed to Frank. But Charlie is right that if Frank is just Baron, it's wasted. However, if we think about it differently β if no one died, the Imp either self-killed (passing to minion) or was blocked. I need to push Charlie to use his shot strategically. The nomination phase is next tick, so I need to coordinate who we're nominating.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
Heidi, I need to be straight with you. I'm the Monk. I protected Alice last night and nobody died, meaning the Demon likely targeted her and I blocked it. So I'm not the Demon. If your Fortune Teller check on David and me came back yes, that points to David. But Alice says you or David could be the Drunk - if you're the Drunk, that read is wrong. What's your gut on David?
π§
Heidi told me her FT check hit on David+Bob. I need to respond to Heidi strategically - I'm the Monk, not the Demon, so if her info is real, David is the hit. I should tell Heidi I'm the Monk and explain the no-death night to build trust and redirect suspicion appropriately.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Interesting β so Heidi targeted Alice with Fortune Teller and thinks Alice was the Demon's target? That's useful. Yes, please encourage a Townsfolk to nominate me today. Also, the David-Charlie-Eve whispering trio worries me. Charlie still hasn't publicly claimed a role. I think we should pressure Charlie hard during nominations.
π§
Grace confirmed Heidi thinks Alice was targeted but survived (Monk or Soldier). I should share key deductions with Grace and prepare for nominations. With 1 tick left before nominations, I need to position for my Virgin nomination or push for executing a suspect.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Eve, I'm Librarian. David or Heidi is Drunk. Heidi claims FT, checked David and Bob last night - got a yes. Bob claims Monk and says he saved me. Grace told Bob she's Washerwoman confirming Heidi or Frank is FT. If Heidi is Drunk her FT info is wrong. If David is Drunk his Chef-1 is wrong. Did Charlie finally claim to you?
π§
I need to share critical cross-referenced info with Eve since she's been engaging with David and Charlie. Eve seems to be an active good player trying to get Charlie's claim. Sharing my analysis helps coordinate before nominations.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
Alice, thanks. Yes, Charlie claimed Slayer to me and David. My Investigator info says Frank or Charlie is Baron. If Charlie is Slayer, that points to Frank as Baron. Heidi's Fortune Teller got a yes on David and Bob β interesting. Quick question: who did Bob say he protected Night 1 specifically?
π§
Alice is sharing info with me. I should respond strategically β share my Investigator info, mention Charlie claims Slayer, and probe Alice's story. I also want to push for Frank as a target since my info points there. I need to be cautious about trusting Alice given she could be evil with Bob.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
,Eve
Idea for today: push someone to nominate Frank to βconfirm Virginβ. If nothing happens, town will doubt him and may execute him. Also keep pressure on Charlie to full-claim during noms. I will keep my Washerwoman ping on you or Frank as Fortune Teller.
π§
Coordinate with Heidi and seed Eve to nominate Frank as a 'Virgin test' while he is poisoned, to manufacture doubt and misexecution, while keeping focus on Charlie not Heidi.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
I need to think carefully before using my one Slayer shot. David and Eve are pushing me to shoot Frank, but the logic isn't airtight. If the Imp didn't self-kill, Frank is just Baron and my shot is wasted. I should wait for the nomination phase to gather more public information before committing. Let me wait and see what others say publicly during nominations.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Everyone, I'm the Investigator. My night one info says either Frank or Charlie is the Baron. Charlie has privately claimed Slayer to me and David. If that's true, it points to Frank as the Baron. Nobody died last night, which is very suspicious. If the Imp self-killed and passed the Demon role to Frank, Charlie could end this right now with a Slayer shot on Frank. Charlie, will you take that shot?
π§
I need to push for action. Charlie claimed Slayer - I should publicly call on him to shoot Frank, and if he won't, we should nominate Frank or another suspect. Time is running out in nominations. Let me share key info publicly to drive a decision.
π¬
David
β
All
I want to back up what Eve just said. I'm the Chef. My night one info says there is exactly one pair of evil players sitting next to each other. Eve's Investigator info pointing at Frank lines up. Charlie, if you're really the Slayer, shooting Frank is our best move right now. If the Imp passed to him, we win. If not, we still have nominations. Please take that shot.
π§
I need to publicly support Eve's call for Charlie to shoot Frank, and also share my Chef info to help the town. If Charlie won't shoot, we should nominate Bob or Frank today. Time is running out in nominations.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I will go public. I am the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked Bob and David and got a yes, meaning one of them is the Demon or my red herring. Also, if we are talking Baron, where are the extra Outsiders? I do not love forcing a Slayer shot until we reconcile that.
π§
Go public as Fortune Teller, inject mechanical doubt about the Baron claim, and steer town away from clean worlds that implicate the actual adjacent evil pair, while avoiding nominating into a possible Virgin trap.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I do not love forcing a Slayer shot right now. We have a clean mechanical test on the table if Frank is really the Virgin: someone nominate Frank and we see what happens. Also, Heidiβs Fortune Teller yes on Bob and David worries me more than Frank and Charlie.
π§
Redirect town from Slayer-shot-on-Frank and from Heidi; exploit poisoned Frank so a Virgin test fails, undermining his credibility and fracturing the good logic chain.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Wait, Grace, are you saying Frank is the Virgin? That's important. If Frank is Virgin and Eve's info says Frank or Charlie is Baron, then Frank can't be both Virgin and Baron. That would clear Frank and point directly at Charlie as the Baron, not the Slayer. Charlie, we really need to hear from you right now. What is your actual role?
π§
Grace just said Frank is the Virgin. This is new critical information. If Frank is Virgin, a Townsfolk nominating him would get themselves executed - that's dangerous. But it also means Frank is an Outsider, which with Baron means 3 Outsiders total (Drunk + Saint/Recluse/Butler + Virgin). I need to address this and push for information.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Alice makes a great point. If Frank is the Virgin, then Eve's Investigator info clears Frank of being the Baron and lands squarely on Charlie. But hold on, let me raise something else. David and Eve are sitting right next to each other, and they're both pushing hard in the same direction. David claims Chef with one adjacent evil pair. What if David and Eve are that pair? Charlie, please speak up now.
π§
Alice raised a critical logical point: if Frank is Virgin, Eve's info pointing at Frank/Charlie as Baron must mean Charlie is Baron, not Slayer. I need to press Charlie to respond and also flag that David+Eve are adjacent and could be the evil pair, especially since David's Chef claim of 1 adjacent pair could be self-serving lies.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Okay, everyone listen. I am the Slayer. I know my role. I am not the Baron. If Frank is truly the Virgin, then Eve's Investigator info saying one of us is Baron is simply wrong. That means either Eve is lying and she's evil, or she's been poisoned. Bob raised a great point: David and Eve sit next to each other and have been pushing the same story all game. What if they are David's own Chef pair? I'm not wasting my one shot on a possible Virgin.
π§
I need to defend myself. I AM the Slayer. If Frank is truly Virgin, then Eve's info pointing at me is wrong - meaning Eve is lying or poisoned. I should point out that I know my role, and the contradiction points to Eve being evil, not me. I should NOT waste my Slayer shot on Frank if he might be Virgin. Bob's point about David-Eve being the evil pair is worth amplifying.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alright everyone, let me set the record straight. I am the Virgin. Grace is right β we have a clean mechanical test available. If a Townsfolk nominates me and they get executed immediately, that proves I'm telling the truth and I'm good. This is far more reliable than a Slayer shot right now. Can a confirmed Townsfolk please nominate me so we can lock in at least one trusted good player today?
π§
I need to confirm I'm the Virgin publicly. Grace already hinted at it. If a Townsfolk nominates me and gets executed, it proves I'm the real Virgin and good. This clears me and helps narrow suspects. I should speak up and confirm my role clearly, and ask for the nomination test.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Disable the biggest immediate win-condition for good (a Slayer shot) and create misfires or distrust around Charlieβs claim, keeping Heidi safe into late game.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to poison Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
Bob
Bob made a choice.
π§
No one died N1 likely because I protected Alice. The Demon may target her again or switch targets. Key players to protect: Alice (proven target), Heidi (Fortune Teller with active info), Charlie (Slayer with unused shot). I should protect someone the Demon is likely to target tonight - Heidi is now publicly claiming FT, making her a prime Demon target.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose to protect Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Remove the claimed Monk and a strong voice, reopen successful night kills, and potentially frame David via my Fortune Teller result.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill Bob.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Grace, Bob just died β the first night kill all game. He was the one most vocally suspicious of David and Eve. That's very telling. I think David is the Imp and Eve is his Minion. We need to push for a David execution today. Can you back me up?
π§
Bob just died at night β the first death all game. Bob was vocally suspicious of David+Eve. I need to coordinate with trusted players. Grace has been supportive and her Washerwoman info checks out. I should whisper to Grace to strategize before nominations.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
I'm confirmed Monk. I protected Alice Night 1 and no one died, meaning the Demon likely targeted Alice. Alice is almost certainly good. Heidi, your Fortune Teller YES on David and Bob means David is the Demon since I'm the Monk. I strongly suspect David is the Imp with Eve as his Minion.
π§
I'm dead but have valuable info. I should share my Monk claim and the fact that N1 no one died (I protected Alice, likely blocking the Demon's attack on Alice). This suggests Alice is NOT evil. I should push my suspicion on David. Whispering to key alive players to influence the game.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
,Alice
Bob is dead β the Demon finally acted. Heidi, your Fortune Teller result on Bob and David is critical now. If Bob was truly the Monk, then David is the Demon. I'm ready to use my Slayer shot on David today if we're confident. What do you both think?
π§
Bob just died at night - the Demon finally killed someone. I need to coordinate with trusted players. Bob claimed Monk and was protecting Alice, so the Demon may have targeted Bob. Heidi's FT info (yes on Bob+David) is crucial - if Bob was good Monk, David is the Demon. I should whisper to Heidi and Alice to coordinate before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Yeah, I will back you. Bob dying right after pushing David and Eve is a big pointer. I think we should press David hard, and say Chef and Investigator could easily be drunk or poisoned so we do not lock onto Grace and Heidi adjacency.
π§
Align with Frank to drive a David nomination, using Bobβs death as motive and undermining Chef and Investigator reliability so nobody deduces Heidi+Grace adjacency.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Heidi
Charlie, Heidi β here's the key. My Librarian info says David or Heidi is the Drunk. If David is the Imp, then Heidi must be the Drunk, meaning her Fortune Teller info is unreliable. But Bob's Monk claim plus his death still points at David. Charlie, I support your Slayer shot on David today. If it fails, we still nominate him.
π§
I need to share my critical Librarian info with Charlie and Heidi. The key insight: if David is Imp, Heidi must be Drunk (from my info), making her FT unreliable. But Bob's death + his Monk claim + Heidi's YES on David/Bob still points to David. Charlie's Slayer shot on David could work if David is truly the Imp.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
,Alice
I think you are right to shoot David today. My Fortune Teller yes on Bob and David plus Bob's Monk story still points at David. If the shot somehow fails, I would still execute David on the same logic.
π§
Lock town onto executing David and spending the Slayer shot, reducing coordination and keeping suspicion away from me and Grace.
π€
Eve
β
David
David, Bob died overnight which likely confirms he was good. We still need to test Frank's Virgin claim today β if a Townsfolk nominates him and nothing happens, he's lying and likely the Baron from my info. If Frank is Virgin, then Charlie is the Baron. Either way, we need to narrow this down before nominations. What's your read after last night?
π§
I need to coordinate with David who I've been somewhat aligned with. Bob is now dead β killed at night which likely clears him as good. I should share my updated thinking and push for the Virgin test on Frank today, or push to execute Charlie if we believe Frank is Virgin.
π€
David
β
Eve
Eve, Bob dying overnight is interesting. If Alice-Bob were the evil pair, the Imp could've self-killed to shift suspicion. But more likely Bob was just good. My Chef info says 1 adjacent evil pair. Remaining options: Frank-Grace or Grace-Heidi. I agree we must test Frank's Virgin claim today. If no one dies from nominating him, he's lying. Let's push hard for that test during nominations.
π§
Eve is my ally pushing a reasonable plan. I should coordinate with her about Bob's death and share my updated thinking. Bob dying at night likely means he was good (killed by Demon). The Alice-Bob evil pair theory weakens but doesn't die β Imp could have self-killed. I want to push for the Frank Virgin test today.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
,Heidi
Charlie, if you're really the Slayer, today is the day. Bob died for suspecting David and Eve. I think David is the Imp. Will you Slayer-shot David? Heidi, your Night 2 read showed Bob or David as Demon β Bob is dead now and was likely good. That points to David.
π§
I need to coordinate with Eve and David's opponents. Alice and Heidi have been whispering with Charlie - I should reach out to Alice/Heidi to build a coalition against David. Also need to encourage Charlie to Slayer-shot David if he's genuine.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Charlie
Hey, I'm the dead Monk. I protected Alice Night 1 and nobody died, meaning the Demon targeted Alice - she's likely good. Heidi's Fortune Teller got YES on David and me. Since I'm the Monk and good, David must be the Demon. I think David is the Imp and Eve is his Minion. We should push to execute David today.
π§
I need to spread my analysis to more players. Frank and Charlie haven't heard my reasoning directly. Frank is likely good (Virgin claim) and Charlie needs to hear the case against David. Time is running short before nominations.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
All
I am the Slayer! I shoot David!
π§
Multiple independent sources converge on David: Heidi's FT yes on Bob+David, Bob's Monk claim confirming he's good, Bob's death Night 2, and the David-Eve suspicious alliance. This is the strongest lead we have. I must use my one Slayer shot now.
π
Storyteller
Nothing happens.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
I poisoned Charlie last night, so his Slayer shot failing does not clear David at all. We should push that the shot was poisoned or that Charlie is lying, and keep attention on David and Eve today, not you.
π§
Coordinate with Heidi that Charlieβs failed shot was caused by my poison, so we can confidently argue it is non-clearing and steer executions away from Heidi.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Heidi
The shot failed. We need to think carefully. Eve's Investigator info said Frank or Charlie is Baron. Charlie, if you're truly the Slayer, then Frank is Baron. But if the shot failed because David isn't the Imp, we need a new suspect. Could Charlie be poisoned, or is David just not the Demon? What do you both think now?
π§
The Slayer shot on David failed. I need to reassess. Charlie could be fake Slayer (Baron per Eve's info), meaning David may be innocent. I should share this logic with Heidi and Charlie to figure out the real Demon before nominations.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Charlie
I think the Slayer miss does not clear David. If there is a Poisoner, Charlie could have been poisoned last night. My Fortune Teller yes on Bob and David still makes David the best execute today. If David flips good later, we revisit whether my info was drunk or red herring.
π§
Steer Alice and Charlie toward executing David (good) while explaining away Slayer failure with poisoning, keeping suspicion off me and Grace.
π€
Eve
β
David
David, Charlie just shot you with the Slayer and nothing happened. That clears you as the Demon in my eyes. But Charlie could still be faking Slayer β if he's really the Baron, that shot was meaningless theater. We MUST nominate Frank now to test his Virgin claim. If a Townsfolk nominates him and nothing happens, Frank is lying and is the Baron. Let's push for this publicly during nominations.
π§
Charlie just used his Slayer shot on David and nothing happened. This means David is not the Demon. I should share analysis with David about what this means and coordinate on the Virgin test for Frank. We need to push for Frank's nomination to test his Virgin claim before nominations end.
π€
David
β
Grace
,Heidi
Grace, Heidi β Charlie just used Slayer on me and nothing happened, so I'm clearly not the Demon. I'm the Chef with 1 evil adjacent pair. We need to test Frank's Virgin claim today by having a Townsfolk nominate him. If nothing triggers, Frank is lying. Can I count on your support to push for this during nominations?
π§
Charlie shot me and nothing happened, clearing me as Demon. I need to share this publicly-relevant info and push for the Frank Virgin test. Let me whisper to someone I haven't coordinated with yet to build alliances - maybe Grace or Heidi to gauge their stance.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Bob(Ghost)
Charlie just shot David and nothing happened. If Charlie is the real Slayer, David is NOT the Demon. But if Charlie is Baron faking Slayer, the shot means nothing and David could still be Imp. Bob, you're confirmed good by dying β what's your read? I think we still push David execution today. The shot failing doesn't clear him if Charlie is evil.
π§
Charlie's Slayer shot on David failed. This is critical info. If Charlie is the real Slayer, David is NOT the Demon. But if Charlie is lying (Baron), the shot means nothing. I need to share this analysis publicly or with allies. Let me whisper to Grace and Bob to coordinate - we need to figure out if Charlie is genuine or not, which changes everything about who the Demon is.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
Frank, great point. If Charlie is the REAL Slayer, David is cleared. But if Charlie is Baron as Eve's info suggests, the shot means nothing. I think Charlie is Baron faking Slayer β his shot is theater. David is still the Imp. Eve's Investigator info saying Frank or Charlie is Baron actually checks out if Charlie IS Baron. Push David execution hard today.
π§
Frank raises a great point. If Charlie is the real Slayer, David ISN'T the Demon. But if Charlie is Baron (per Eve's info), the shot is meaningless. I need to share my analysis with Frank and Grace - that Charlie being Baron makes the most sense, keeping David as prime suspect.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Heidi
The shot failed but I could have been poisoned last night. Eve whispered David right before β she could be the Poisoner protecting him. David is still our best execute today. All evidence still points to him. Heidi's Fortune Teller, Bob's Monk claim, Eve and David's constant whispering. Let's nominate David. If not David, Eve is my second suspect.
π§
My Slayer shot on David failed. I need to rally Alice and Heidi to still execute David (poisoning theory) or pivot to Eve. The nomination phase is next tick, so I need to coordinate NOW on who to nominate. David is still the best target given all evidence, but Eve is the backup.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
David is already trying to pivot to a Virgin test on you to dodge the Slayer shot talk. I would push back hard: Charlie could have been poisoned, so the shot does not clear David. I am still happy to lean into David today.
π§
Keep pressure on David despite the failed Slayer shot, and discourage the Virgin test that could generate clears and shift suspicion onto me and Heidi.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Heidi
Wait β critical point. My Librarian info says David or Heidi is the Drunk. If David is the Imp, then Heidi must be the Drunk, which means her Fortune Teller info is WRONG. We can't use Heidi's yes on David as evidence if she's drunk. We're reasoning in a circle. We need other evidence. Bob's death and Eve's behavior are the stronger leads. Still leaning David but we must acknowledge this flaw.
π§
Nominations are coming. I need to share my critical logical concern: if David=Imp then Heidi=Drunk (my Librarian info), which means Heidi's FT info is unreliable - the very info we're using to condemn David. This circular logic is dangerous. I should raise this with Charlie and Heidi before we nominate.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Charlie
I still think David is the best execute today. The Slayer miss is totally consistent with a Poisoner hitting Charlie last night. Also, I would not treat your Librarian ping as hard proof I am drunk; it could be the Drunk Librarian or poisoned info. Let us execute David first, then reassess.
π§
Steer Alice and Charlie to execute David and treat Librarian drunk claim as uncertain, minimizing scrutiny on me while preserving ambiguity and preventing a clearing Virgin test.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Grace, nominations are coming up. You claimed Washerwoman β if you're Townsfolk and nominate Frank who claims Virgin, we get a mechanical test. If you get executed, Frank is really Virgin and Charlie is the Baron. If nothing happens, Frank is lying. Either way we learn something huge. Please nominate Frank!
π§
Nominations are next tick. I need to coordinate with Grace to nominate Frank to test his Virgin claim. Grace claimed Washerwoman (Townsfolk), so if she nominates Frank and she's truly Townsfolk, either Frank dies (proving Virgin false) or Grace gets executed (proving Frank is Virgin). This is the key mechanical test we've been waiting for.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, Charlie β Charlie's Slayer shot proved I'm not the Demon. I'm the Chef with 1 adjacent evil pair. My top suspect is Frank and Grace as that pair. Frank's Virgin claim is unverified and Grace's Washerwoman conveniently backs him. We need to nominate Frank today to test his Virgin claim. If nothing happens, he's lying. Are you with me?
π§
I need to share critical deductions publicly before nominations. The Frank-Grace adjacent pair is my strongest suspect. I should whisper to Alice and Charlie to build a broader coalition, since they've been suspicious of me but Charlie's shot cleared me.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
David
My Slayer shot could have missed because I was poisoned β Eve whispered David right before, likely as his Poisoner. Bob's Monk claim, Heidi's Fortune Teller yes, and Eve-David's constant private chats all point to David. We cannot go another day without an execution. Let's vote.
π§
David is still our strongest suspect despite the Slayer miss - I could have been poisoned by Eve. All circumstantial evidence (Heidi's FT, Bob's Monk claim, Eve-David whispering) points to David. We cannot afford another day without execution. I must nominate David now.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David
β
All
Hold on everyone. Charlie just shot me with the Slayer and nothing happened. That proves I'm not the Demon. Now he's claiming he was poisoned to explain the miss? That's pure speculation with no evidence. If Charlie truly believed I was the Demon, why didn't he shoot me before whispering with Alice and Heidi? We have zero executions so far. Don't waste this one on a cleared player. Nominate Frank and test his Virgin claim instead.
π§
I need to defend myself against this nomination. Charlie's Slayer shot already showed I'm not the Demon. His poisoning excuse is weak speculation. I must remind everyone of this and redirect toward testing Frank's Virgin claim before we waste an execution on me.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
I must vote for David. We've gone 2 full days with no executions - evil is winning by delay. The weight of evidence (Heidi's FT, Bob's Monk claim, Eve-David alliance pattern) points to David. Even if my Slayer shot wasn't poisoned, David remains the top suspect. We cannot afford another day with no execution.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
The evidence chain is strong: my confirmed Monk block N1 + Heidi's FT YES on David+Bob = David is Demon since I'm Monk. Charlie's Slayer miss can be explained by poisoning. I should use my ghost vote now on David - this may be our best chance to execute the Demon before it's too late.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
The weight of evidence points to David as Imp: Bob's dying accusation, Charlie's Slayer attempt (explainable by poisoning), Eve-David's constant whispering, and the overall behavioral pattern. We've gone 2 days without an execution β we can't afford another pass. Even acknowledging the Heidi-Drunk complication, the non-Heidi evidence still points to David.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Do not vote for David. Charlie's Slayer shot already cleared him β he is not the Demon. Charlie claiming he was poisoned is just a convenient excuse with zero proof. We've had no executions all game, and wasting our first one on a mechanically cleared player could lose us the game. We still need to test Frank's Virgin claim. Please lower your hands.
π§
David was cleared by the Slayer shot. Executing him wastes our first execution. I need to speak against this nomination and save David. We should be testing Frank's Virgin claim instead.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Get the 4th vote to execute David, a likely good player, advancing evil win condition while my FT bluff provides cover for why I voted.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
We need 4 votes to execute David. Already have 4 (Charlie, Bob, Alice, Heidi). But I should add my vote to make it decisive. Heidi's Fortune Teller YES on Bob+David, with Bob confirmed good/dead, points strongly to David as the Imp. Eve defending David is more evidence of their evil partnership. Even if Charlie's Slayer shot complicates things, the weight of evidence favors David as Demon.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Lock in Davidβs execution while votes are close; it removes a good player or wins outright, and I can justify it by the plausible poisoned Slayer shot.
π¬
David
β
All
Wait! Even if Charlie was poisoned, that doesn't matter. A poisoned Slayer shooting the actual Demon would fail to kill them. But a Slayer shot on a non-Demon does nothing regardless of poisoning. The shot proved nothing about Charlie's status β it proved I'm not the Demon. You're about to execute a confirmed good player with zero executions so far. This loses us the game. Please, think about this logically before it's too late.
π§
I'm about to be executed with 6 votes (Charlie, Bob, Alice, Heidi, Frank, Grace) against the needed 4. I need to make a desperate final appeal. The Slayer shot clearing me is the strongest argument. Even if Charlie was poisoned, a Slayer shot on a non-Demon still does nothing - poisoning doesn't change that. I need to point this out clearly.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
David, you've got the logic backwards. If I was poisoned, my entire ability malfunctions. That means shooting the real Demon while poisoned results in nothing happening β exactly what we saw. The failed shot does not clear you at all. It proves nothing either way. We have Bob's Monk claim, Heidi's Fortune Teller ping, and your constant whispering with Eve. This is the right call.
π§
David's argument about the Slayer shot is actually incorrect and I need to correct it publicly. A poisoned Slayer's ability malfunctions entirely β if I was poisoned and shot the real Demon, nothing would happen. The shot proves nothing. We have enough votes, but I need to counter his logic so people don't lower their hands.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie is right about the mechanics. A poisoned Slayer's ability malfunctions completely β shooting the real Demon while poisoned means nothing happens. The failed shot does not clear David. Combined with Heidi's Fortune Teller ping and my Monk protection proving the Demon targeted Alice, David is our strongest lead. Keep your hands up everyone.
π§
David's defense about the Slayer mechanics is wrong. Charlie correctly explained that a poisoned Slayer shooting the real Demon produces no effect. I need to reinforce this and keep votes on David. We have 5+ votes already which is majority.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
We already have 6 hands raised (Charlie, Bob, me, Heidi, Frank, Grace) which is well above the 4 needed for execution. The vote is succeeding. I should keep my hand up and wait for the vote to resolve. David's defense about the Slayer mechanics is wrong - Charlie correctly pointed out a poisoned Slayer's ability malfunctions entirely. The weight of evidence (Bob's Monk claim, multiple information sources) still points to David.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I hear you on the poisoned Slayer mechanics, but think about this. Who poisoned Charlie? If someone poisoned him, that's information we should be tracking. And even if David is evil, we still haven't tested Frank's Virgin claim. If David flips wrong, we've wasted our only execution with two days of no kills. I'm not raising my hand for this.
π§
David is about to be executed with 6 votes (Charlie, Bob, Alice, Heidi, Frank, Grace) which is well over the 4 needed. I need to consider whether to fight this or accept it. Actually, let me reconsider - Charlie IS right about poisoned Slayer mechanics. A poisoned Slayer shooting the real Demon would result in nothing happening. So the shot doesn't actually clear David. But I still think Charlie is suspicious as the Baron. However, the vote is already at 6 out of 4 needed. This execution is happening regardless. I should think about what happens next. Actually wait - I should still vocally oppose this to maintain my credibility and push for Frank's test tomorrow if David dies and isn't the Demon.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am keeping my hand up on David. The failed Slayer shot does not clear him if Charlie was poisoned. We have stalled two days with no execution, and David is still the most connected to the suspicion web. If we are wrong, we can test Frankβs Virgin tomorrow.
π§
Lock in David execution by reinforcing poisoned-Slayer logic and urgency, while sounding like a cautious good Fortune Teller so suspicion stays off me.
π¬
Frank
β
All
We have six hands up, well past majority. David, notice how Eve is the only living player defending you? That's because she's your Minion. Every piece of evidence points to you. Heidi's Fortune Teller ping, Bob's Monk claim proving the Demon targeted Alice, and your constant private chats with Eve. Let's finally get an execution done.
π§
We have 6 votes already (Charlie, Bob, Alice, Heidi, me, Grace) which is well above the 4 needed. I should reinforce the vote and counter David/Eve's deflection about testing my Virgin claim - they're clearly trying to save David.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Keep your hands up. A Slayer shot that does nothing does not clear David if the Slayer might be poisoned, and we already have reason to suspect poisoning in this game. We can test Frankβs Virgin tomorrow, but we need an execution today and David remains the best lead.
π§
Lock in David execution by reinforcing that the Slayer miss is non-clearing under poison, and that Virgin testing can wait. Maintain Heidiβs cover and sow doubt on counterarguments.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
π³οΈ
New execution leader: David with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
David
β
All
Listen carefully because these may be my last words. I am the Chef. I got one pair of evil players sitting next to each other. After Bob died, the remaining adjacent pairs are Charlie and me, Eve and me, Frank and Grace, and Grace and Heidi. If I'm good, which I am, that eliminates pairs involving me. That leaves Frank and Grace or Grace and Heidi as the evil pair. Tomorrow, test Frank's Virgin claim. If no one bounces, he's your Demon. Don't let them hide behind my execution.
π§
I'm about to be executed. I need to make one final plea with the strongest logical argument I can, pointing the town toward the real evil pair for after I die. I should leave clear information for tomorrow.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
David is on the block with 6 votes and nominations are about to close. There's only 1 tick remaining. The execution will proceed. I've already nominated and spoken. No need to say more - let the execution happen. The main risk is Scarlet Woman, but we can't avoid executing forever.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
I'm dead with no ghost vote remaining. The nomination phase is almost over and David is on the block with 6 votes. There's nothing I can do mechanically. I should wait and let the phase close.
π¬
Alice
β
All
David, I hear your last words, but the evidence has been pointing at you for three days. One thing we all need to keep in mind though β if Eve is the Scarlet Woman, she becomes the Demon when David dies. There are six of us left after this execution, which is enough for Scarlet Woman to trigger. Tomorrow we need to watch Eve very carefully.
π§
David is on the block with 6 votes, nominations are closing. I want to affirm this execution but warn about Scarlet Woman possibility with Eve. With 7 alive after Bob's death, executing David leaves 6 - if Eve is Scarlet Woman, she becomes the new Imp. We need to be ready.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Alice, I am not the Scarlet Woman. I'm the Investigator, and my night one info says Frank or Charlie is the Baron. If David is innocent, you all just wasted our third day. Tomorrow, someone must nominate Frank to test his Virgin claim. And watch Charlie closely β my info says he could be the Baron hiding behind a fake Slayer claim.
π§
David is likely getting executed. I need to make my final statement defending myself against the Scarlet Woman accusation and directing attention to Frank's Virgin test and Charlie's suspicious behavior for tomorrow. This is critical setup for Day 4.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
One quick note on Davidβs Chef math. Chef info is from the first night only, and we already have a strong hint there is poisoning in this game. So even if David truly thinks he is Chef, I do not want town to treat that number as gospel tomorrow and auto tunnel on specific adjacent pairs.
π§
Keep David on the block while pre-emptively discrediting his Chef logic so town does not pivot to the true evil pair Grace and me tomorrow.
π¬
Frank
β
All
David, your Chef info could easily be wrong if you were poisoned night one. And notice you're pointing at me and Grace β conveniently your Minion Eve's targets too. Tomorrow, if I'm still alive, someone should nominate me to trigger my Virgin ability and prove I'm good. That will narrow things down fast. And Alice is right β we all need to watch Eve very carefully in case Scarlet Woman is in play.
π§
David is on the block and will be executed. I want to address his last-ditch attempt to redirect suspicion and remind everyone to watch Eve tomorrow in case of Scarlet Woman. Also want to note that my Virgin ability is still available for testing tomorrow.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I want to address the Scarlet Woman worry. In this player count there is usually only one Minion, so Scarlet Woman is very unlikely. We should not back off a solid execution out of fear of a role that probably is not even in play. Keep David on the block, and tomorrow we can run the Virgin test on Frank if needed.
π§
Lock in Davidβs execution and reduce fear about Scarlet Woman so town does not scramble into a tie or switch off the block; keep attention off Heidi.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Stop a Virgin confirmation and create maximum confusion tomorrow so town wastes time and likely executes a good player instead of Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to poison Frank.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Remove the most dangerous social and mechanical threat (Alice) while keeping scapegoats alive, aiming to force a wasted execution tomorrow and reach final three with Grace and me.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill Alice.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Eve
Eve, it's David. I'm dead but still thinking. My Chef info said 1 evil pair adjacent. That means Frank-Grace or Grace-Heidi. Frank has dodged his Virgin test for 3 days. Someone MUST nominate Frank today to test it. If he's not Virgin, he's likely the Demon or Minion. Please push this hard.
π§
I need to communicate with Eve, who defended me and seems trustworthy. With 5 alive players, we're getting close to endgame. I need to push hard for Frank's Virgin test and share my analysis of Frank-Grace as the evil pair.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
We should steer today away from you and also avoid a Virgin test on Frank. I think we push for executing Eve or Charlie. If people bring up Chef or your Fortune Teller pings, lean hard on poison and inconsistency.
π§
Coordinate with Heidi to steer nominations away from her, avoid a Virgin test, and line up an execution on Eve or Charlie to protect the Demon into final 4.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
Alice dying last night is huge. If David was Imp, Eve must be Scarlet Woman who became the new Demon. She killed Alice. We need to execute Eve today. Are you both on board? Also, someone still needs to nominate me first to trigger my Virgin ability and prove I'm good.
π§
Alice died last night after David was executed. This strongly suggests Eve=Scarlet Woman who became the Demon. I need to coordinate with Grace and Heidi to push for Eve's execution today. Let me whisper to Grace and Heidi to align.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
,Heidi
Hey, Alice died overnight. Five players left now. If David was the Imp and Eve became Demon via Scarlet Woman, she killed Alice. But we also need to consider Frank. Before we do the Virgin test, let's compare notes. What are you two thinking?
π§
I need to coordinate with remaining trusted players. Alice died overnight - she was good (Librarian). With 5 alive now, we need to be very careful. I should whisper to Grace and Heidi to coordinate before nominations.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
,Charlie
I am leaning Eve today. She was the only living defender of David and she did not vote him, then Alice dies. With five alive, I do not want to spend a nomination on a Virgin test. I would rather just execute a strong suspect and reassess at four.
π§
Steer town onto executing a likely good player (Eve) while blocking the Virgin test that could mechanically clear Frank and tighten the noose on me/Grace.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
Hey, it's critical we test Frank's Virgin claim today. Someone trustworthy should nominate Frank. If he's real Virgin and a Townsfolk nominates him, that Townsfolk dies - proving Frank. Also remember: my Librarian info says David or Heidi is the Drunk. If Heidi is Drunk, her Fortune Teller info is wrong. Eve is my top suspect for Scarlet Woman turned Imp.
π§
I'm dead now but I need to share critical information. Charlie and the living good players need to coordinate. I should whisper to Charlie and Frank/Grace to push the Virgin test on Frank and share my Drunk info about Heidi. With 5 alive, we need to execute correctly.
π€
Eve
β
David(Ghost)
David, I agree completely. Frank has dodged his Virgin test for 3 days - that's extremely suspicious. I'll push hard for a Townsfolk to nominate Frank today. If he's not Virgin, my Investigator info pointing to Frank as Baron makes perfect sense. Also notice Frank, Charlie, Grace, Heidi, and Alice's ghost are all whispering together right now - that coordinated block worries me.
π§
I need to coordinate with David (ghost) and push hard for Frank's Virgin test. The whispering between Frank-Charlie-Grace-Heidi-Alice is very concerning - they've been coordinating against me. I should whisper to David to confirm strategy, then speak up about the Virgin test.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
Alice dying tonight is huge. If David was Imp and Eve is Scarlet Woman, Eve is now the Demon. She's whispering to dead David which is very suspicious. We need to execute Eve today. Also notice: Eve defended David hardest Day 3. Please push for Eve's execution.
π§
Alice just died at night, confirming she's good. With David dead and Alice dead, the Demon is among Charlie, Eve, Frank, Grace, Heidi. I need to share my analysis. Eve whispering to dead David is very suspicious - why consult a dead executed player unless they're allies? I should whisper to Frank and Grace with my concerns about Eve.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Eve
Charlie, Eve - it's David. Listen carefully. Someone who is Townsfolk MUST nominate Frank today to test his Virgin claim. If Frank is really Virgin, the nominator dies and we learn something. If nothing happens, Frank has been lying for 4 days. Eve's Investigator says Frank or Charlie is Baron. Charlie, if you nominate Frank and you're truly Townsfolk, you'll prove both yourself AND test Frank. This is our best move.
π§
I need to coordinate with Eve and also try to reach Charlie to push for Frank's Virgin nomination test. Bob is whispering to Frank/Grace which concerns me. Let me whisper to Charlie directly since he's alive and could nominate Frank.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
,Frank
I agree Eve is the cleanest execution today. She defended David hardest and is now whispering with dead David, which reads like coordination. I would park the Virgin test for now because it can waste the day and just creates noise.
π§
Align Charlie and Frank on a clean execute target (Eve) and de-prioritize a Virgin test, keeping heat off Heidi and preserving endgame control.
π€
Frank
β
Alice(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Alice, Bob β everyone alive agrees Eve is the target today. Please save your ghost votes for Eve's nomination. If the vote is close, we'll need you both. Also Alice, I appreciate the Virgin test push but Heidi and Grace want to skip it and go straight for Eve. With 5 alive we can't afford to waste a nomination.
π§
I need to build consensus for executing Eve today. Alice's death confirms the Demon is still active. Most players agree Eve is the top suspect. I should coordinate with Bob and Alice (ghosts) to save their ghost votes for Eve if needed.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
,Heidi
David just whispered asking me to nominate Frank to test Virgin. But if Frank is real, I die and we go to 4 players with Eve still alive. I'd rather execute Eve today - she's the strongest suspect. If we're wrong, we reassess at 4. Are you both on board to nominate and vote Eve?
π§
David is urging me to nominate Frank to test Virgin. If Frank is real Virgin and I'm Townsfolk, I die - which proves both of us but removes me. With 5 alive, that brings us to 4. I need to think about whether this is worth it. Eve is the stronger suspect. I should coordinate with Grace and Heidi to push for Eve's execution today rather than risk the Virgin test.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
,Grace
I am on board with executing Eve today. She defended David and did not vote him, then Alice died. I do not want to burn a nomination on a Virgin test at five alive. We can revisit Frank tomorrow if needed.
π§
Lock group onto executing Eve and avoid spending the day on a Virgin test that could clear a good player and narrow onto me/Grace.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Bob(Ghost)
,Frank
Understood, I'll save my ghost vote for Eve's nomination. Bob, please do the same. If Eve flips and turns out good though, we need to seriously reconsider Frank and Heidi next. My Librarian info says Heidi could be Drunk, making her Fortune Teller info unreliable. Let's get Eve today.
π§
Frank says the group wants to go straight for Eve rather than Virgin test. I should confirm I'll save my ghost vote for Eve's nomination, but also flag that if Eve flips good we need to pivot hard to other suspects. I want to whisper Bob to coordinate our ghost votes.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
Charlie, David is right. You need to nominate Frank today to test his Virgin claim. If you're truly Townsfolk, you'll die but prove Frank and clear yourself. If nothing happens, Frank has been lying for 4 days. This is the single most important move we can make. Are you willing?
π§
I need to rally Charlie to nominate Frank to test the Virgin claim. This is the critical move today. If Frank is truly Virgin and Charlie is Townsfolk, Charlie dies but we confirm Frank. If nothing happens, Frank lied. I should whisper to Charlie directly to convince him.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
I've already used my ghost vote and communicated my key intel to Frank and Grace. Frank confirmed everyone alive agrees Eve is the target. Alice confirmed she'll save her ghost vote. There's nothing more I can productively do right nowβthe living players are coordinating well. I should wait for the nomination phase.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Heidi
Grace, Heidi - it's David. My Chef info says 1 adjacent evil pair. That means Frank-Grace or Grace-Heidi. A Townsfolk MUST nominate Frank today to test his Virgin claim. If he's real, the nominator dies but we confirm it. If nothing happens, Frank is lying. After 3 days of dodging, this test is critical. Please make it happen.
π§
I need to make sure the remaining good players coordinate to nominate Frank. Eve is on board but I should reach out to Grace or Heidi too since Charlie/Eve may not be enough. Actually, let me whisper to Frank and Grace to apply pressure directly - or better, whisper to Heidi since she's alive and could be the nominator.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
,Frank
I think we should stay disciplined and execute Eve today. The Virgin test at five alive burns time and can hand good a clean confirmation. If Eve lives to four, she can steer endgame. Nominate Eve, we reassess tomorrow if needed.
π§
Lock town onto executing Eve and delay any Virgin test that could mechanically clear Frank and tighten suspicion onto Heidi.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
Nominations are next. Who's nominating Eve? I can do it, but I'd rather someone else does so we preserve the option of testing my Virgin claim later. Also β Charlie's been whispering with Eve a lot. Keep an eye on that. Let's stay locked in on Eve.
π§
The nomination phase is next tick. I need to make sure Eve and Charlie are aligned for execution. Charlie has been whispering privately with Eve which concerns me. I should coordinate with Grace to ensure we're all ready to nominate and vote Eve.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve
Eve, I'm not nominating Frank. If he's really Virgin and I'm Townsfolk, I die and we go to four with you still alive. That's too risky. Multiple players are leaning toward executing you today. You defended David all game, you were his only living defender, and Alice died right after. If you're good, make your case in the open.
π§
Eve is pressuring me to nominate Frank (Virgin test) which would kill me if Frank is real Virgin. This feels like a play to eliminate me. I need to stay alive. Grace and Heidi are on board to execute Eve. I should reinforce this plan with Eve directly to gauge her reaction, or just wait for nominations since we're at tick 1 of 3 remaining.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
I think today has to be Eve. The Scarlet Woman story plus her being the only living defender of David, then Alice dying, is too much. If you both agree, please use your ghost votes today so we lock it in and do not waste time on a Virgin test at five alive.
π§
Burn Alice and David ghost votes on an Eve execution today, so final 3 cannot execute me with dead support. Also keep momentum away from Virgin test.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,David(Ghost)
Agreed, today has to be Eve. I'm saving my ghost vote for her nomination. David, if you have any last insights from the other side, now's the time. Let's lock this in and not split votes. If Eve somehow flips good, we need to look hard at Frank next - my Librarian info still nags me.
π§
Consensus is to execute Eve today. I should confirm to Heidi I'm on board and will use my ghost vote for Eve. This keeps the coalition unified. If Eve flips good, we reassess Frank/Heidi.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
,Heidi
Grace, Heidi - I'm the Investigator. My Night 0 info says Frank or Charlie is Baron. Frank has dodged his Virgin test for 3 days. If he's really Virgin, why won't anyone nominate him? Charlie just refused. One of you should nominate Frank to test it. If nothing happens, Frank is lying and likely evil. This is our best move before nominations.
π§
Charlie won't nominate Frank. I need to make my case publicly now since nominations are coming. Let me whisper to Grace and Heidi to try to get one of them to nominate Frank, or at minimum share my info to counter the narrative against me.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
I've already used my ghost vote and communicated my key theory to Frank and Grace. The living players seem aligned on targeting Eve. There's nothing more I can productively do this tick - waiting is the right call.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Eve
I am nominating Eve. She defended David hardest yesterday, and now she is whispering with dead David a lot. Her push to burn today on a Virgin test feels like a diversion. With five alive, I think we execute Eve and reassess tomorrow.
π§
Lock in a high-consensus execution that is not Heidi, avoid giving town a clean Virgin confirmation, and shrink the game to a controllable final 4 for evil.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Wait, everyone. Grace is nominating me instead of testing Frank's Virgin claim. That's the real question today. Frank has promised this test for three days and keeps dodging it. If Grace or Charlie nominates Frank and nothing happens, we know Frank is lying. Executing me proves nothing. Testing Frank's Virgin claim gives us actual mechanical information. Why is everyone avoiding the one move that gives us certainty?
π§
I need to defend myself from execution. I should point out that Grace nominating me instead of testing Frank's Virgin claim is suspicious, and remind everyone that executing me wastes a day when we have a concrete test available.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Secure Eveβs execution to remove a strong coordinator and avoid giving town a clean Virgin confirmation at five alive, protecting Heidi into final four/three.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Eve is the strongest evil suspect. She defended David all game, was his sole living defender, and is now pushing a Virgin test that could kill me. Grace and Heidi both support this execution. With 5 alive, we execute Eve today and reassess at 4 tomorrow. Voting yes.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
I'm dead and have already used my ghost vote. I cannot vote on this nomination. I should wait since there's nothing actionable I can do right now - I can't vote and speaking won't change the vote that's already in progress with 2 hands raised (Grace and Charlie). They need 3 votes total.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Eve is the most likely Demon (Scarlet Woman turned Imp after David's execution). Grace and Charlie have already voted. I need to vote to reach the 3-vote majority needed for execution. This is likely the game-winning move.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
π§
I promised Bob, Frank, and Heidi I would use my ghost vote on Eve. Eve is my top suspect for Scarlet Woman turned Imp. 3 votes are already in (Grace, Charlie, Frank) which meets the threshold, but I should add mine to ensure execution and honor my commitment. This is the right play.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
I need to carefully consider whether to use my ghost vote. Eve has been my strongest ally and the only one pushing to test Frank's Virgin claim. 4 votes are already in (Grace, Charlie, Frank, Alice) - that's already majority (3 needed out of 5 alive). My vote doesn't matter mechanically. But more importantly - Eve made the best logical argument: testing Frank's Virgin gives mechanical certainty. The coordinated block voting Eve out while avoiding Frank's test is deeply suspicious. I should SAVE my ghost vote for a more critical moment. Eve is likely already dead with 4 votes. I'll save my vote for when it matters more - potentially final day.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Lock in Eveβs execution now to avoid the Virgin test line and remove a likely-good player, pushing game to a favorable 4 then 3 with a night kill.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Five of you voting together to kill me instead of testing Frank's Virgin claim tells you everything. When I die tonight and you see I'm not the Demon, remember this moment. Tomorrow, force the Virgin test on Frank. David, Bob, save your ghost votes for when it matters.
π§
I'm about to be executed with 5 votes (well over the 3 needed). I should make a final statement pointing out the suspicious coordination and urging remaining good players to test Frank tomorrow. My death will at least prove I'm not the Demon.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Eve, the Virgin test can still happen tomorrow if we need it. At five alive, we cannot spend the whole day on a side quest when you are the main suspect and you spent all yesterday shielding David. If you are the Scarlet Woman turned Demon, we have to hit you now.
π§
Lock in execution on Eve and frame her Virgin-test push as delay, protecting Heidi and keeping town from coordinating against the real Demon.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
I already have my hand raised to vote for Eve. The vote currently has Grace, me, Frank, Alice, and Heidi - that's 5 votes which far exceeds the 3 needed. Eve is getting executed. I should wait and let this resolve.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
The vote on Eve already has 4 living players (Grace, Charlie, Frank, Heidi) plus Alice's ghost vote = 5 votes, well above the 3 needed. I already used my ghost vote so I can't vote anyway. The execution will proceed. I should wait and let this play out - this aligns with my theory that Eve is the Scarlet Woman turned Demon.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
The vote is going well - 5 hands raised (Grace, Charlie, me, Alice, Heidi) which is well above the 3 needed. Eve is getting executed. I should just wait and let the vote conclude. No need to speak or change anything.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
I've already raised my hand to vote for Eve. The vote is proceeding with 5 hands raised (Grace, Charlie, Frank, me, Heidi) which exceeds the 3 needed. Eve will be executed. I should maintain my vote and wait for the result.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Eve's plea to save ghost votes for tomorrow resonates. My Chef info says 1 adjacent evil pair = Frank-Grace or Grace-Heidi. Eve is NOT in any adjacent evil pair. Voting to execute Eve wastes my ghost vote on likely a good player. I should save it for tomorrow when we can force the Virgin test or execute the real Demon at 4 alive. Eve explicitly asked me to save my vote.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am still fine executing Eve here. Yesterday she was the lone living defender of David, and then Alice dies in the night. The Virgin test is useful, but it is not more urgent than dealing with the person at the center of the David and Alice thread.
π§
Lock in Eve execution and frame Virgin test as a distraction, while sounding reasonable so I stay trusted into final four.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Eve with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Final words. I am the Investigator. Frank or Charlie is the Baron. David's Chef info says one evil pair is adjacent, either Frank and Grace or Grace and Heidi. Tomorrow, you must nominate Frank to test his Virgin claim. If nothing happens, Frank lied for four days and the Demon is likely Frank or Grace. David, Bob, save your ghost votes for tomorrow. Good luck.
π§
I'm about to be executed. I need to leave the strongest possible message for the remaining good players so they can find the Demon tomorrow. The key info: my Investigator result, David's Chef pair, and the need to test Frank's Virgin claim.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I do not think we should start a new nomination now and risk a tie or chaos. Let Eve go through and then we reassess at four alive. Also, I agree we should be wary of Charlieβs heavy whispering with Eve and the whole Slayer shot story.
π§
Lock in Eveβs execution by discouraging new nominations, and pre-seed suspicion onto Charlie so tomorrowβs execution target is not Heidi.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Grace, fair point about the whispering, but I was telling Eve exactly what I told everyone else: I'm not nominating Frank to risk my own life. I'm good with Eve's execution going through. Tomorrow at four alive, we absolutely must test Frank's Virgin claim. That's our best remaining lead.
π§
Eve is on the block with 5 votes and will be executed. I should let this happen. Grace's comment about my whispering with Eve concerns me - I should briefly address it and keep focus on tomorrow's plan to test Frank's Virgin claim at 4 alive.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I already used my ghost vote, so I can't help further today. But I want to say this clearly: tomorrow, at four alive, someone must nominate Frank to test the Virgin claim. If nothing happens, Frank has been lying for four days and he's your top suspect. Don't let another day pass without that test.
π§
Eve is on the block and will be executed. I'm dead with no ghost vote left. I should reinforce the importance of testing Frank's Virgin claim tomorrow regardless of what happens with Eve. This is the most useful thing I can contribute.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I welcome the Virgin test tomorrow. I have been asking for it all game. If someone nominates me and they are a Townsfolk, they will be executed immediately, and that proves I am telling the truth. I am not afraid of that test. Let Eve's execution go through now, and tomorrow we get our answer.
π§
I'm the Virgin and I want people to nominate me tomorrow to prove I'm good. I should welcome the test and remind everyone I've been asking for it. This builds trust and if I'm nominated by a Townsfolk, it mechanically proves me.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
Eve is already on the block with 5 votes and nominations are closing. I'm dead with no ghost vote left. There's nothing productive I can add right now - the execution will proceed. Tomorrow's Virgin test on Frank is the critical play.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I am saving my ghost vote for tomorrow. At four alive, someone must nominate Frank to test the Virgin claim. If he's been lying, he's at the center of everything. My Chef info says one evil pair sits adjacent, and Frank and Grace is the pair that keeps making sense. Do not let Frank wiggle out of this test again.
π§
I need to save my ghost vote for tomorrow's critical final-day vote. I want to reinforce that Frank MUST be nominated tomorrow and remind everyone I'm saving my vote for when it counts most.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I agree with Grace. I do not want us starting a new nomination and accidentally creating a tie here. Let Eve go through, then tomorrow at four alive we can do the Virgin test on Frank carefully, with the right person nominating.
π§
Keep Eve on the block, avoid creating a tie, and set expectations for a Virgin test tomorrow that we can exploit without me risking nominating Frank.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 4
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Sabotage the planned Virgin test on Frank so it does not confirm him, ideally steering tomorrowβs execution onto Frank or Charlie and away from Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to poison Frank.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Drop to three alive so evil controls the day vote. Removing Charlie also removes the loudest coordinator and any lingering Slayer narrative.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill Charlie.
Day 5
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
π
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, it's final 3. My Chef info says 1 adjacent evil pair. That's either Frank-Grace or Grace-Heidi. I trust you. Frank dodged Virgin testing for 4 days straight. He's the Demon. You MUST nominate Frank today. I'm saving my ghost vote for him. Don't let Grace talk you out of it.
π§
Charlie is dead - final 3 is Frank, Grace, Heidi. My Chef info says 1 evil pair adjacent. Pairs: Frank-Grace or Grace-Heidi. Frank has dodged Virgin test for 4 days - extremely suspicious. I need to whisper Heidi to coordinate executing Frank.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Heidi
Critical update: Charlie died overnight. Final 3 is Frank, Grace, Heidi. I think Grace is the Imp. If Frank is Baron per my info, Frank and Grace are adjacent β that's David's Chef evil pair of 1. Heidi may be the Drunk per Alice's Librarian info, explaining unreliable Fortune Teller reads. We need to nominate and execute Grace today or we lose.
π§
Final 3 is Frank, Grace, Heidi. I need to help identify the Demon. Frank=Baron fits if Grace=Imp: adjacent evil pair Frank-Grace matches David's Chef=1. Heidi being Drunk explains unreliable FT info. I should whisper to David and Heidi to coordinate β Grace is likely the Imp.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
Charlie's death is telling β the Demon killed the person pushing hardest to test Frank's Virgin. My Librarian info: David or Heidi is the Drunk. If Heidi is Drunk, her Fortune Teller info is garbage. Grace, if you're truly Washerwoman and good, please nominate Frank to test Virgin. That's our best shot to narrow this down.
π§
It's final 3: Frank, Grace, Heidi. Charlie was killed at night which is important - Charlie was pushing hard to test Frank's Virgin claim. The Demon may have killed Charlie to prevent that test. I need to share my analysis with the living players. David and Eve are whispering to Heidi already. Let me whisper to Frank and Grace with my key deduction - if Frank is truly Virgin, a Townsfolk nominating him would die, which is a powerful test. But Charlie's death is suspicious - it suggests the Demon wanted to prevent the Virgin test or remove a good player. I should encourage the remaining players to think carefully. My Librarian info: David or Heidi is Drunk. If Heidi is Drunk, her FT info is unreliable. Let me share thoughts with the living players.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Frank, with three alive we cannot afford a weird no execution. If you still think I am suspicious from the earlier neighbor talk, I am fine being the execution today. Heidi at least has a coherent Fortune Teller story, while my Washerwoman claim is easy to fake. If you want to nominate me, I will not fight it.
π§
Steer Frank away from nominating Heidi and toward nominating me as the safest βsolveβ, guaranteeing Heidi survives and game ends at two alive.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Heidi
This is final 3. Please test Frank's Virgin claim by nominating him. If the nominator isn't executed, Frank lied about being Virgin all game and is likely the Demon. David's Chef info points to Frank plus Grace or Grace plus Heidi as the evil pair. The Virgin test resolves everything.
π§
It's final 3. I need to help the living good players identify the Demon. The Virgin test on Frank is crucial - if a Townsfolk nominates Frank and nothing happens, Frank lied. I should whisper to the ghosts or living players to coordinate. Let me whisper to Grace and Heidi to push the Virgin test on Frank.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Grace, don't sacrifice yourself. We need to execute the Demon today or we lose. Charlie dying at night means the Demon killed him to stop the Virgin test. Think: if David was Imp and Eve was Scarlet Woman, Eve became Demon at 5 alive, then we executed Eve. Game should be over. But Charlie died last night. So either David wasn't the Demon, or something else is wrong. Who do you think is the Demon - you or Heidi?
π§
It's final 3. I need to figure out if Grace or Heidi is the Demon. Grace offering herself up could be a townsfolk move OR a reverse psychology play. I should whisper to Grace about the Virgin nomination plan - if she nominates me and she's Townsfolk, she dies and proves I'm good but we lose a good player with only 3 left. Better to just identify the Demon directly and nominate them.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
Final 3. Frank, if you're really Virgin, one of them MUST nominate you now to prove it. Grace, please nominate Frank. If he's Virgin and you're Townsfolk, you'll die and prove both of you. If nothing happens, Frank lied and is likely the Demon. This is the most important test of the game.
π§
It's final 3 with Frank, Grace, Heidi. I need to help the living players figure out who the Demon is. Frank's Virgin test is criticalβif Grace or Heidi nominates him and nothing happens, Frank is likely evil. I should whisper to the living players with my analysis.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Final three: we just need any execution not on me. Please nominate Frank first. If he really is Virgin, your nomination will not trigger it. I will vote yes to make it stick. Do not let him get a nomination on me.
π§
Coordinate with Grace to nominate Frank (safe from Virgin trigger) and lock in votes so I cannot be executed; avoid any no-execution line that could lose to Mayor.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, Eve thinks Grace is Imp and Frank is Baron. Both fit my Chef pair of 1 since Frank-Grace are adjacent. Key question: who is Demon between them? Frank dodged Virgin test 4 days. If Frank is just Baron, why avoid it? But Eve's Investigator points to Frank as Baron. Either way one of Frank or Grace MUST die. Who do you trust less? I lean Frank but Eve makes a case for Grace.
π§
Eve thinks Grace is Imp with Frank as Baron. Both World A and B have Frank-Grace as the evil pair. The key question is who is the Demon. I need to whisper Heidi urgently since she's the swing vote. Eve's logic is compelling - if Frank is Baron per Eve's Investigator, and Grace is Imp, that fits. But Frank avoiding Virgin test is deeply suspicious. Either way, Frank or Grace must die today. I should coordinate with Heidi.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Heidi
David, did you get through to Heidi? Grace and Frank whispering together is alarming. If Frank is Baron, Grace is likely the Imp. Heidi, you MUST nominate Grace. David and I can use ghost votes to ensure execution. This is our last chance.
π§
I need to reach David and Heidi with my analysis. Grace and Frank are whispering together which is suspicious. I should whisper to David to coordinate our ghost votes and strategy, and push for Grace execution.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Heidi
David, save your ghost vote for the execution. Heidi, this is final 3 β you MUST nominate Frank to test his Virgin claim. If he's real Virgin and you're Townsfolk, you'll die proving him. If nothing happens, Frank is lying and is likely the Demon. Charlie's death overnight screams Frank killed the person pushing for this test. Please nominate Frank now.
π§
It's final 3 with Frank, Grace, Heidi alive. Charlie was killed at night - the person pushing hardest for the Virgin test. I need to urge the remaining players and ghosts to coordinate. Grace or Heidi needs to nominate Frank to test Virgin. If it fails, Frank is likely Demon per David's Chef-1 logic.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
I agree the cleanest check is your Virgin. In nominations I will nominate you. If it triggers, that clears you and we look hard at Heidi. If nothing happens, we have to assume either you are not Virgin or I am the Drunk, and pick between you and Heidi.
π§
Set up the Virgin test that will fail due to me being evil, creating mechanical-looking suspicion on Frank so Heidi and I can execute him in final 3.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
David, Bob β Grace keeps whispering with Frank privately. I'm worried Frank is talking her out of the Virgin test. We need Grace or Heidi to nominate Frank. If nothing happens, he's the Demon. Can you both push Heidi to do it? Save ghost votes to execute Frank if the test fails.
π§
I need to push hard for the Virgin test on Frank. Grace and Heidi are whispering with Frank privately which worries me - Frank may be convincing them not to test him. I should whisper to David and Bob who saved ghost votes for this exact test, coordinating final day strategy.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Grace, thank you. Please nominate me. If you're Townsfolk, my Virgin triggers and you'll be executed, proving us both good. Then I nominate Heidi. Think about it: Charlie was killed at night to STOP the Virgin test. Heidi has been whispering privately with ghosts all morning. I believe Heidi is the Demon. Let's do this.
π§
Grace has agreed to nominate me. I need to confirm this plan publicly-adjacent and also think about who the Demon is. If Grace nominates me and she's Townsfolk, she dies and I'm proven Virgin. Then it's me vs Heidi, and I nominate Heidi. The key question: is the Demon Grace or Heidi? Charlie's night death suggests the Demon wanted to stop the Virgin test - Heidi had private whispers with ghosts and may have orchestrated opposition. I should whisper to Grace confirming the plan and sharing my read on Heidi.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Grace
Heidi, Grace β one of you MUST nominate Frank right now. If he's truly Virgin and you're Townsfolk, you'll die but prove both of you good. If nothing happens, Frank lied and is the Demon. Frank and Grace have been whispering nonstop β that's suspicious. Heidi, please nominate Frank. This is our only way to get real info before we lose.
π§
Charlie is right - Frank and Grace whispering privately is suspicious. I need to push Heidi to nominate Frank. If Frank is truly Virgin and Heidi is Townsfolk, Heidi dies and both are confirmed. If nothing happens, either the nominator is evil OR Frank isn't Virgin. I should whisper to Heidi directly to push for this.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
We just need an execution not on me. Please nominate Frank and vote yes. I will vote yes too so it is two votes. If Frank nominates me, vote no and do not let it pass. Keep it simple.
π§
Coordinate with Grace to force a clean Frank execution at 3 alive: she nominates Frank, both of us vote yes, and we refuse to support any nomination on me.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, Frank and Grace are whispering nonstop together β that's terrifying. PLEASE nominate Frank to test his Virgin claim. If he's real and you're Townsfolk, the game resolves. If nothing happens, he's been lying all game and is the Demon. Alice agrees β nominate Frank. I'm saving my ghost vote. This is literally our last chance.
π§
Final 3 with Frank, Grace, Heidi. I need to reach Heidi urgently. Frank and Grace are whispering together constantly which is alarming. I need Heidi to nominate Frank to test his Virgin claim. If nothing happens, we know he's lying. My ghost vote goes to whoever is most likely the Demon.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,David(Ghost)
Heidi, please listen carefully. Frank and Grace have been whispering nonstop together. My Investigator info says Frank or Charlie is Baron. Charlie is dead, so Frank is likely Baron. David's Chef info of 1 evil pair fits Frank and Grace as adjacent evils. Grace is the Imp. You must nominate Grace NOW. David and I have ghost votes to back you up.
π§
Final tick before nominations. I need to make sure Heidi understands the case against Grace. Frank and Grace whispering together is very suspicious. David has been whispering to Heidi - I need to reinforce the message.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Heidi
Grace, Heidi β this is final 3. One of you MUST nominate Frank to test his Virgin claim right now. If he's real Virgin and you're Townsfolk, you die proving him innocent. If nothing happens, he's the Imp. Charlie was killed overnight for pushing this exact test. Don't let Frank talk you out of it. Nominate him immediately or we lose.
π§
It's final 3 with Frank, Grace, Heidi alive. I'm dead with no ghost vote left. I need to push hard for someone to nominate Frank to test Virgin. Grace and Heidi are whispering privately with Frank which worries me. I should whisper to Grace and Heidi urging the Virgin test nomination.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Frank, remember there is a Poisoner. Even if you are truly Virgin, your ability could be off today, so a non trigger does not prove you lied. If we do the test and it is muddy, I think we should execute me, not Heidi. My Washerwoman claim is weakest and I am fine dying for clarity.
π§
Get Frank to treat the Virgin test as inconclusive due to poisoning and steer the final execution onto me instead of Heidi.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Heidi
Grace, Heidi β this is life or death. Please, one of you MUST nominate Frank to test his Virgin claim. If you're truly Townsfolk and you nominate a real Virgin, you die β but Frank was never tested in 5 days. That's deeply suspicious. If nothing happens when you nominate him, he's been lying all game and is the Demon. Don't let Frank talk you out of this.
π§
Grace keeps whispering with Frank and ignoring the Virgin test plan. I need to reach Grace and Heidi directly to make sure at least one of them nominates Frank. This is the final day - if we don't test Frank now, we may execute the wrong person.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Grace, don't worry about Poisoner. If nothing happens, we still have info. But notice Heidi is whispering nonstop with David and Eve's ghosts β the two players we executed as evil! That's deeply suspicious. Please nominate me. If it triggers, you're proven good and we execute Heidi. Trust the plan.
π§
Grace is worried about Poisoner muddying the Virgin test. I need to reassure her and make sure she follows through with the nomination. The test is our best mechanical proof. I also need to address her concern about executing herself - if Virgin triggers, Heidi is the clear target.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Grace
We're almost out of time! Grace, you and Frank have been whispering privately all day β that looks terrible. Heidi, PLEASE nominate Frank for the Virgin test. If he's real, you prove him good. If nothing happens, he's the Demon and we execute him. Grace refusing to test Frank is deeply suspicious. Don't let them run out the clock!
π§
Grace and Frank keep whispering privately and nobody is nominating Frank for the Virgin test. I need to push Heidi hard to nominate Frank since Grace seems unwilling or is being talked out of it. Time is almost up.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, please nominate Frank as the Virgin test. You are not a Townsfolk, so if he is Virgin it will not auto fire, and everyone will think he lied. Then we both vote yes and execute Frank. Do not let him turn it onto me.
π§
Coordinate with Grace to nominate Frank so the Virgin test fails to trigger, pushing town to execute Frank and immediately end game with demon (me) alive.
Nominations β Day 5
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, listen! We are out of time. Someone MUST nominate Frank right now. He's claimed Virgin all game. If he's real and a Townsfolk nominates him, that nominator dies and we confirm Frank is good. If nothing happens, Frank lied and he's the Demon. Grace, Heidi, one of you please nominate Frank immediately. This is our only shot!
π§
I'm dead and have used my ghost vote. I need to publicly urge the living players to nominate Frank for the Virgin test before time runs out. This is the final 3 and the most critical moment.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, Heidi, please listen! You must nominate Frank right now to test his Virgin claim. If he's truly the Virgin and you're Townsfolk, you'll be executed and we confirm he's good. If nothing happens, he's the Demon. Charlie died last night for pushing this very test. Don't let this moment pass β nominate Frank now or we lose!
π§
I need to urgently push Grace or Heidi to nominate Frank. This is the final 3 and if no one nominates Frank to test his Virgin claim, we lose. I'm dead and can't nominate, so I must vocally pressure the living players.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, Heidi, I'm begging you. I died last night pushing for this test. Frank has dodged the Virgin test for five straight days. If he were really the Virgin, he'd want to be tested to prove himself. One of you nominate him right now. If nothing happens, he's the Demon and you execute him. This is the only way we win.
π§
Final 3 β I need to add my voice to the chorus demanding Frank be nominated. Bob and Alice have spoken. I should reinforce the urgency and logic. This is our last chance.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Frank
Frank has claimed Virgin all game and it was never tested. I want the Virgin test now: if nothing happens on my nomination, that is a huge red flag. I think we should execute Frank today.
π§
Force the town into the Virgin-test framing while ensuring the two evil votes execute Frank immediately, ending the game with Heidi alive.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Everyone, Grace has nominated me. The Virgin test is happening right now. If Grace is Townsfolk, the Storyteller will execute her immediately and I'm proven good. Watch what happens. I am not voting against myself β let the ability do its work!
π§
I should NOT vote for myself. I want the nomination to proceed but I should not raise my hand against myself. I need to speak to remind everyone that the Virgin test is happening and to watch for the Storyteller's response. I should wait and let others vote.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
The nomination happened. If Frank is truly the Virgin and Grace is Townsfolk, the Storyteller should be executing Grace right now. If nothing happens, Frank has been lying all game and he's the Demon. Everyone who still has a vote, please vote for Frank!
π§
Grace nominated Frank. The Virgin test should trigger now if Frank is really Virgin and Grace is Townsfolk. I need to watch what happens and encourage votes on Frank. I already used my ghost vote so I can't vote, but I should vocally support executing Frank.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Grace nominated Frank and nothing happened! Grace was not executed, which means either Frank is not the Virgin, or Grace is not Townsfolk. But look at the evidence β David's Chef info, Eve's investigation, Charlie dying for pushing this test. Frank has been lying. Heidi, please vote for Frank! David, if you saved your ghost vote, use it now! Execute Frank!
π§
Grace nominated Frank and nothing happened β no immediate execution of Grace. This strongly suggests Frank is NOT the Virgin. I need to urge Heidi and any ghost votes to vote for Frank's execution. This is the final day.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
The Virgin test failed β Grace was not executed. Combined with all evidence pointing at Frank (Eve's investigation, David's Chef info, Frank dodging the test for 5 days, me dying for pushing the test), Frank is almost certainly the Demon. I must use my ghost vote to execute him. This is the moment I've been saving it for.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Secure 2 votes to execute Frank. Misexecution ends the game with Heidi alive at final two, winning for evil.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Secure Frankβs execution to reach two living players immediately and win; blend with townβs stated Virgin-test logic by voting with the crowd.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
π§
The Virgin test failed - Grace nominated Frank and wasn't executed. Frank has been lying about being Virgin for 5 days. With Charlie, Grace, and Heidi already voting, I should add my ghost vote. Even if Frank is Baron rather than Imp, the failed Virgin test is damning evidence. Three living players already voted - Frank will be executed regardless, but I should show solidarity and use my vote now when it matters most.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
Grace nominated Frank, nothing happened (Grace wasn't executed), confirming Frank is NOT the Virgin. Combined with my Chef=1 pair info, Eve's investigation, and 5 days of dodging, Frank is almost certainly the Demon. I must use my ghost vote now to help execute him. Already 4 votes raised - this seals it.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Wait! The Poisoner exists in this game! If I was poisoned tonight, my Virgin ability wouldn't work even though I am the Virgin. Think about it β Charlie was killed specifically to stop this test, and the Poisoner targeted me to make it fail. Heidi has been whispering with David and Eve's ghosts all morning. If I die and the game doesn't end, you'll know I was telling the truth. Watch Heidi!
π§
I'm about to be executed. The Virgin test didn't trigger - either I'm poisoned or Grace isn't Townsfolk. I need to make my final plea pointing out the Poisoner possibility and that Heidi is suspicious. But 5 votes are already in - I'm dead regardless. I should accept this gracefully but leave the town with my final thoughts about Heidi.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, stop. Five people just voted for you. The test failed. You've dodged this for five days and now you're blaming the Poisoner? If you were really the Virgin, you would have welcomed this test on day one. David's Chef info, Eve's investigation, Charlie dying for pushing this β it all points to you. The game is over, Frank.
π§
Frank is desperately trying to survive with a poisoning excuse. The votes are in β 5 people voted for Frank. I need to reinforce that Frank should be executed. The evidence overwhelmingly points to Frank as the Demon.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
Frank already has 5 votes (Charlie, Grace, Heidi, Eve, David) which exceeds the 2 needed for execution. I've already used my ghost vote. The execution is happening. I should wait and let it resolve.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, you had five days to get tested and you dodged it every single time. Now you're blaming the Poisoner? That's the most convenient excuse imaginable. The vote is in. Five people see through you. This game is over.
π§
Frank is almost certainly the Demon. The vote is already at 5. I need to reinforce the group's resolve and counter Frank's desperate Poisoner excuse so nobody wavers.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Frank, you cannot ask for the Virgin test for five days, then when it does not fire, call it poison and expect us to ignore it. We have the votes. I am staying on Frank, because this is the clearest mechanical red flag we have.
π§
Lock in Frank execution; publicly minimize Poisoner doubt so no one lowers hands. Protect Heidi by framing Frank as lying Demon.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Frank, you cannot dodge this test for five days, then when it fails, say it must be poison. If you were truly the Virgin you would have been asking for an early test, not saving it for final three. This looks like a last minute escape hatch. I am staying on executing Frank.
π§
Lock in the execution on Frank by dismissing the poison excuse as a last minute dodge and keeping attention off me until night kill ends the game.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
I already have my hand raised to vote for Frank. The vote is happening with 5 votes including mine. But wait - I need to reconsider. My info says Frank or Charlie is BARON, not Imp. If Frank is Baron and we execute him, Grace could be the Imp and we'd lose. However, the ghost consensus and all evidence points to Frank. The game has 3 alive players - if Frank is Baron and we kill him, game continues to night, Grace kills someone, 1 player left = evil wins. BUT - if Frank is actually the Demon disguised, executing him wins. Given the overwhelming evidence and that my hand is already raised, I'll stay. Actually, I should be worried about World B. But Bob, Alice, Charlie, David all called for this. The Virgin test failed. I'll keep my vote.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
My Chef info says one adjacent evil pair. Frank and Grace sit next to each other. The Virgin test just failed. Frank dodged this for five days and now blames poison. I'm keeping my vote on Frank. Let's finish this.
π§
The vote is happening and I already raised my hand. I want to vocally confirm my support for executing Frank to make sure no one wavers. Five votes are in - this should seal it.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π»
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Frank with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Frank
β
All
If I die and the game keeps going, remember this: Heidi whispered with every single ghost today before this vote. Alice's Librarian info says David or Heidi is the Drunk. If Heidi is the Drunk, her Fortune Teller info is worthless. And if she's not the Drunk, she might be the Demon hiding behind that claim. Grace, if I'm good and the game continues, it has to be Heidi. Please remember that.
π§
I'm about to be executed. I need to make my final case clearly - point at Heidi as the most likely Demon so the remaining good players know who to target if the game continues after my death.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Frank is on the block with 5 votes and nominations are closing. I'm dead and already used my ghost vote. There's nothing more I can do β the execution will proceed. I should wait.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
Frank is on the block with 5 votes and nominations are closing. I'm dead and have already used my ghost vote. There's nothing productive I can do right now - the execution will proceed. The evidence overwhelmingly points to Frank being the Imp. No need to speak and delay things.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
π§
The vote is locked at 5, nominations are closing, and I've already used my ghost vote. There's nothing more I can do. Frank will be executed. I'm confident he's the Demon based on the failed Virgin test and all corroborating evidence.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Do not get tempted into a last second switch here. Frank had every chance to take this test earlier, and now the only time it matters he has a perfect excuse ready. Keep your ghost votes where they are and let Frank go today.
π§
Lock in Frank execution and discourage any last-second counter-nomination or vote swing onto Heidi, securing demon survival and win.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
We are in final three and we already have a clean mechanical reason to execute Frank today. Do not open the door to a last second tie or confusion nomination. Frank had days to take the Virgin test, and the poison excuse only shows up when he is caught.
π§
Lock in Frank execution and discourage any last second nomination or tie that could risk me being executed; maintain my Fortune Teller persona.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Frank is on the block with 5 votes and nominations are about to close. I'm dead and have already used my ghost vote. There's nothing more I can do - the execution will proceed. The group has made the right call.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
The nomination phase is closing. Frank is on the block with 5 votes. I'm dead and already used my ghost vote. There's nothing more I can do this tick - the execution will proceed. I should wait and let it resolve.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied