Game Detail
Players
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 713,524 | 107,085 | $6.7802 |
| Evil | 241,999 | 406,707 | $1.8567 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You are the Minion. The Demon is Frank.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Minions are: Grace. Your safe bluffs are: Mayor, Butler, Soldier
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Librarian. Either Grace or Alice is the Butler.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
I would like to compare soft claims early. I am a townsfolk with information that gets better after executions, so I want to stay alive but still coordinate. What kind of role are you each claiming?
π§
Build trust with neighbors, gather claims, and hint Undertaker without full public exposure so I can later verify executions.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Charlie
I am not a role that wants to be tested by execution. I am comfortable saying I am in the outsider or passive bucket for now. Bob, your description sounds like Undertaker, so I would like to hear Charlieβs soft claim too.
π§
Soft-claim Saint without inviting execution, and prompt Charlie for information while gauging whether Bob is likely Undertaker.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Frank
Hi David, hi Frank. I would like to trade soft claims early. I am a townsfolk who gets value if evil chooses poorly at night. What are you both willing to share?
π§
Build trust with neighbors, gather claims, and hint enough to bait night death without fully outing Ravenkeeper.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Frank
I am a townsfolk with starting information, not an ongoing role. I would rather not out the exact information yet, but I can later help confirm or challenge an Outsider claim. Eve, your soft sounds like something evil may want to avoid hitting, which is useful.
π§
Build trust with Eve and Frank without exposing my exact Librarian info or the Butler candidates too early.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,David
Hey Eve, hey David. I appreciate the early info. I am also a role that evil probably wants to avoid hitting at night. I am the Soldier. I do not have any starting info, so I am just trying to figure out who to trust today.
π§
Respond to Eve and David with a soft claim to build trust. Claiming Soldier is safe and explains why evil should avoid me at night, matching Eve's framing.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Grace
Hi Alice and Grace. I am low information today, but I want to build a trust chain with my neighbors. Do either of you have starting information, or want to swap broad role types?
π§
Open a neighbor trust channel, gather early claims, and check if an Empath or starting info implicates me despite Recluse misregistration.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Bob
I am a townsfolk who can be publicly tested, but the exact tester matters a lot. Bob, if you are hinting Undertaker, I do not want you to be the one testing me. Alice, your bucket makes sense, but I would like a clearer outsider versus passive later.
π§
Soft-claim Virgin without inviting the Undertaker to die nominating me; gather Alice's outsider/passive clarity for Baron or Drunk worlds.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
,Alice
Hi Heidi and Alice. I am the Washerwoman. I learned that one of Bob or Charlie is the Chef. Do either of you have starting information you can share?
π§
Claim Washerwoman to build trust with neighbor Heidi, gather information about other players' roles, and deflect suspicion from Frank and myself.
π€
Bob
β
David
,Frank
David, Frank, I am gathering soft claims and execution preferences. I am a townsfolk who benefits from clean executions, so I care a lot about avoiding Saint and picking someone whose claim can be checked later. What buckets are you two in?
π§
Gather soft claims from the other whisper cluster and steer day one toward an execution my Undertaker ability can verify.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,Grace
I have no starting information. I am still staying in the outsider or passive bucket for now. Grace, that is useful, because Bob hinted a different ongoing information role to me, and Charlie hinted something publicly testable, so we should press them gently on the Chef claim.
π§
Flag the Bob/Charlie role tension without outing Saint, and encourage follow up on Grace's Washerwoman info.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
,Charlie
Hi Alice, hi Charlie. I have heard a couple of soft claims already, but nothing concrete. I am willing to trade a three for three if you are comfortable, or just hear whether either of you has starting information.
π§
Build trust outside my neighbor pair and gather claims before nominations without exposing Ravenkeeper too directly.
π€
David
β
Grace
Grace, can I get your hard claim or a two for two? I have starting information that may affect executions today, but I do not want to lead anyone into a claim. If you are an Outsider, please tell me plainly.
π§
Check one half of my Librarian pair without revealing Alice, to verify Butler info and avoid executing a possible Saint.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
,David
Hey Bob, David. I am the Soldier, so I am in the bucket that evil probably wants to avoid hitting at night. I do not have any starting info, so I am just watching the claims and trying to figure out who looks suspicious today.
π§
Establish my Soldier bluff consistently with Bob and David, building early trust and answering his soft-claim request so I do not look evasive.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,Charlie
Hi Bob and Charlie. I have heard there may be Chef information somewhere between you two. Can either of you confirm that, or say if it is completely off? A number would really help before nominations.
π§
Check Grace's Washerwoman info by pressing Bob and Charlie before executions, while keeping my Recluse claim hidden for now.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
,Bob
I can confirm I am not the Chef, and I have not heard a Chef number from Bob. My role is testable, but I would rather coordinate the test carefully and not waste a strong information role doing it.
π§
Correct false Chef rumor, keep Virgin hint controlled, and invite coordination for a safe public test without outing fully to everyone.
π€
Grace
β
David
Hi David. I am the Washerwoman. I learned that one of Bob or Charlie is the Chef. What starting information do you have? I want to make sure it lines up before we talk openly.
π§
Respond to David's direct request to maintain social credibility and gather his starting information, while staying consistent with my Washerwoman bluff already shared with Alice and Heidi.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
,Charlie
No Chef number from me. I am not pushing Charlie today because his claim sounds like a public test that could cost us the wrong role. Heidi, can you give a bucket before nominations, and have you heard any Saint claim?
π§
Correct false Chef rumors, protect a likely Virgin test, and identify Saint risk before choosing an Undertaker-check execution.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
,Charlie
Eve, I can trade a broad three. Mine is Saint, Butler, or Soldier. Charlie, I have heard Grace say one of you or Bob is the Chef, but that clashes with both of your earlier hints. Can you help resolve that?
π§
Gather Eve's claim and pressure the Bob-Charlie Chef conflict before nominations without fully exposing Saint.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
,Charlie
Charlie, can you answer Alice directly? If you are not Chef, say what level of claim you are comfortable giving now. Alice, I have also heard a Soldier claim elsewhere, so your three is worth revisiting before nominations.
π§
Push Charlie to resolve the Chef rumor and flag the Soldier conflict without hard claiming Ravenkeeper before nominations.
π€
David
β
Alice
Alice, quick check before nominations. I have starting information that might affect whether we should execute today. Are you willing to hard claim, or at least tell me plainly if you are an Outsider?
π§
I need test my Librarian ping before nominations to avoid executing a possible Butler and detect lies around Grace or Alice.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Hey Grace, it is Frank. I am claiming Soldier as my safe bluff. What are you claiming? I think Eve is probably Ravenkeeper based on her soft claim, so we should avoid killing her tonight. Who are you thinking for the night target? Also, do you think we can push an execution on anyone today?
π§
Coordinate with my Minion Grace to align bluffs, discuss night kill targets, and plan for the nomination phase to maximize our chances of survival and sow discord.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,Charlie
I am in the outsider bucket, and I am not the Saint. The problem is that Grace told Alice and me she saw one of you two as the Chef, and you both deny it. That makes Grace poisoned, drunk, evil, or one of you is holding back.
π§
Answer Bob, disclose non-Saint outsider bucket, and force the Washerwoman conflict into the open before nominations.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
,Alice
Grace, I need your exact claim before nominations. I am definitely not the Chef. If your information is one of me or Bob as Chef, then either Bob is Chef and hiding, or something is wrong with your info. I am the kind of role a spent starting information townsfolk can test.
π§
Get Grace's exact claim and set up a possible Virgin test by a spent Townsfolk, while resolving the Chef conflict before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
,Alice
Charlie, I appreciate you being direct. If you are not the Chef, then my information points squarely at Bob. Bob hinted at a different ongoing role to Alice earlier, which is a bit odd if he is actually the Chef. Let us hear what Bob says before we assume my info is wrong. Since you say you are testable, what is your exact role?
π§
Charlie is challenging my Washerwoman bluff. I need to stay calm, redirect toward Bob as the other half of my supposed pair, and ask Charlie for his exact role to keep him on the defensive rather than letting him dismantle my claim.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
βοΈ
Bob
β
Grace
Grace has presented information that Bob or Charlie is the Chef, and both of us have denied it. That is the clearest contradiction today, and executing there gives the town something concrete to evaluate tomorrow.
π§
We need an execution for Undertaker info. Grace is in the main contradiction and unlikely Saint, so checking her role can clarify the Washerwoman/Chef conflict.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Hold on. Bob, you told Alice you have ongoing information, but now you say you are not the Chef. If Charlie is also not the Chef, then one of you is definitely lying. Why would I make a claim this easy to disprove on day one? This feels like an attempt to silence real information before night even falls.
π§
I need to cast doubt on Bob's motives and highlight the contradiction between his whisper and his public denial. Surviving this nomination keeps me alive to protect Frank and continue disrupting the town's logic.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
I nominated Grace for a clean test; voting helps secure execution so my Undertaker info can verify whether her claim was real tomorrow.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Wait. Bob, you are saying Grace contradicted you and Charlie about Chef, but day one contradictions happen all the time with hidden roles. Executing someone over one unverified claim feels rushed. Shouldn't we wait for actual night deaths and real information before we start killing people?
π§
Keep Grace alive by casting doubt on Bob's reasoning without openly defending her. Stall the execution to preserve my minion and undermine a dangerous organizer.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Grace's Chef info conflicts with my role and Bob's hints. Executing the contradicted claim gives town concrete information and may let an Undertaker verify it.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Day one execution is usually valuable, and Grace's claim has the clearest contradiction. Voting pressures the conflict and may give Undertaker info.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Put a contradicted claim on the block. My info also conflicts with Grace being Washerwoman, and if sober says Grace is not Saint.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Grace already has enough votes. I do not need to add mine; watching who supports this creates accountability without changing the outcome.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Grace is the clearest contradiction, and an execution gives town data. My vote prevents a late tie or failed execution.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Bob, Charlie, and Heidi have been whispering together all day. Now they all suddenly want me dead over one piece of day one information. That looks coordinated. If you execute me today, you learn nothing, and the people pushing hardest for this get to control tomorrow's story.
π§
Five votes are already against me so I am likely dying. Speaking plants doubt about the Bob-Charlie-Heidi cluster and frames my execution as coordinated, keeping future suspicion off Frank.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am not saying Grace must be evil. I am saying this is the cleanest execution for information. If Grace is good, that helps us check the Chef claim chain tomorrow. If we do nothing, we learn much less.
π§
Keep votes on Grace without hard-claiming Undertaker; frame execution as info-positive and useful for my night ability.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Grace already has majority, so my vote is unnecessary and would only make me look like I betrayed my own Minion for no gain. Staying consistent with my earlier doubt preserves my credibility heading into night, where I can eliminate David.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am keeping my vote on Grace for now. The Chef information is a direct clash with both Bob and me, and it is the clearest thing we can test today. Tomorrow, Bob needs to be much more exact about his claim.
π§
Support the current execution as the best D1 information kill while signaling Bob must resolve his own evasive claim tomorrow.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am keeping my hand up because this is the clearest contradiction we have. If Grace is good, then tomorrow Bob and Charlie both need to be much more open, because one of those claims or the information chain is wrong.
π§
Keep pressure on the contradictory Chef chain while signaling this is information gathering, not blind trust in Bob or Charlie.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Keeping the vote pressures a hard claim that conflicts with multiple players and may also conflict with my Librarian ping unless Alice is Butler.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not adding a vote here, because there are already enough. If Grace dies, tomorrow Bob and Charlie need exact claims, not hints. This only helps us if we actually resolve the contradiction afterward.
π§
Avoid piling onto a passed execution while locking town into resolving the Grace, Bob, Charlie contradiction tomorrow.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Grace, if this vote stays, we need your exact claim before night. Bob and Charlie also need to commit tomorrow. I am voting because the Chef chain is the clearest contradiction, not because I think this is solved.
π§
Keep pressure on the clearest contradiction while forcing claims that let town resolve Grace, Bob, and Charlie tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Grace with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Bob, you told Alice you have ongoing information, but a Chef does not have ongoing information. That is a direct contradiction, and you know it. Charlie, you say you are testable but you refuse to say how. If you execute me today, you are not solving anything. You are letting the two people who actually contradicted themselves control the story tomorrow. Look at Bob and Charlie, because one of them is hiding the truth.
π§
I am almost certainly dying today with 5 votes locked and only 1 tick left. I need to double down on my Washerwoman bluff and make Bob look like the liar so town wastes tomorrow investigating him and Charlie instead of finding Frank.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Grace, I am not the Chef, and I did not tell anyone I was the Chef. My earlier wording was intentional because my role gets more useful after an execution. If this execution goes through, I will be exact tomorrow.
π§
Defuse Grace's accusation while preserving Undertaker value; signal that tomorrow I can resolve the execution without fully outing before night.
π¬
Frank
β
All
The vote is already locked. Fine. But Grace made a valid point. Bob said he has ongoing information, but a Chef does not have ongoing information. Charlie says he is testable but will not say how. Those contradictions do not disappear just because Grace dies. Tomorrow, I want exact claims from both of them, because one of them is not telling the full truth.
π§
Accept Grace is dying, pivot pressure to Bob and Charlie to look like a truth-seeking townie, and plant seeds to interrogate them tomorrow while keeping my Soldier claim consistent.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I will be exact now. I am the Virgin. I hid that because the tester matters, and Bob should not be the one to do it if he is what he is hinting. Tomorrow, a spent starting information townsfolk can nominate me if town wants the test.
π§
Reveal before night to resolve suspicion on my evasiveness and set up a controlled Virgin test by a spent Townsfolk, not an Undertaker/ongoing role.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I do not want to add another nomination this late. Charlie claiming Virgin is useful, but I should not be the tester. If Grace dies, tomorrow we need Bob's exact claim and a controlled Virgin test from a spent townsfolk if town agrees.
π§
Avoid a bad Virgin test by an Outsider and preserve focus on resolving Grace, Bob, and Charlie tomorrow.
π¬
David
β
All
I am going to be exact before night. I am the Librarian, and I saw either Grace or Alice as the Butler. That makes Grace's Washerwoman claim a direct conflict with my information, unless I was poisoned or Alice is the Butler.
π§
Reveal spent info before execution to explain my vote and create a clear Alice/Grace outsider check for tomorrow.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not the Butler. My claim was Outsider, but not that one, and I am not safe to execution test. If David is truthful, that points to Grace being the Butler or to his information being bad. Tomorrow we need the outsider count solved immediately.
π§
Clarify David's info without saying Saint outright; prevent my execution and force tomorrow's logic around Grace, David, and outsider count.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I do not want a late counter nomination. If Grace dies, tomorrow Bob should claim exactly before we decide anything, and David can be the cleanest possible Virgin tester if town agrees. Also, nobody should forget Alice's outsider claim in this count.
π§
Lock in current info-positive execution and set tomorrow's agenda: exact Bob claim, Virgin test, outsider count. Avoid a rushed counterwagon.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
π
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Kill Charlie to remove a claimed Virgin before town can confirm or leverage it, weakening the most organized good bloc and preventing an un-executable confirmed townslot.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose to kill Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Undertaker. You learn that Grace was the Baron.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Bob, can you give me your exact claim and any night information now? Charlie dying after claiming Virgin matters, and Grace's execution should have given an Undertaker-style player something useful. I am still saying outsider, not Butler, and please do not let town execute me.
π§
Bob hinted at Undertaker-like utility. Getting his exact claim can resolve Grace and David, while I keep Saint hidden but warn against executing me.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Eve, I wanted to check in. Alice and Bob are whispering right now and I do not like the look of it. Have you heard anything solid from anyone today? I am still really suspicious of Alice's outsider claim.
π§
Establish trust with Eve to learn her role or info, gauge if she suspects me, and recruit her to scrutinize Alice and Bob.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,Alice
Bob, you said you would give an exact claim after Grace died. I need that now, especially with Charlie dead. Alice, I am still trying to reconcile the Outsider count, so if you can narrow your claim more, that helps.
π§
Get Bob's promised claim and clarify Alice's Outsider claim to solve count pressure without exposing Recluse publicly yet.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Heidi
I am the Undertaker. Last night I learned Grace was the Baron. That means David's Librarian info pointing to Grace or Alice as Butler is probably false or poisoned, unless something very strange is happening. Alice, please narrow your outsider claim now.
π§
Reveal my real info to pressured claimants, confirm we executed a Minion, and force Outsider claims to resolve Baron count and David's info.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
David
,Frank
David and Frank, I was the Virgin and I died in the night, so my ability never triggered. David, please give your exact Librarian info publicly today. Frank, I want your read on who pushed Grace hardest and why.
π§
Bring David's outsider info and Frank's skepticism together; my night death makes me a useful trusted coordinator while saving my ghost vote.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
I have no hard information yet, but Charlie dying makes me think his Virgin claim may have scared evil. I want Bob's exact claim today, and I want Alice to fully explain her Outsider claim. What did Charlie tell you and David?
π§
Coordinate with Frank, get dead Charlie's info, and keep pressure on Bob and Alice to solve outsider and claim contradictions.
π€
David
β
Bob
,Heidi
Bob, I need your exact claim now if you are willing. Grace died over the Chef conflict, and Charlie died claiming Virgin, so your role is central to sorting whether Grace was good but wrong, evil, or covering Butler.
π§
Push Bob for exact claim while Heidi is already pressuring him; his answer helps resolve Grace and outsider conflicts.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, David's Librarian read on us doesn't add up. I know I'm not a Butler, and you say you aren't either. He might be drunk or just lying. You should push back on that hard before nominations start.
π§
Amplify the Alice versus David conflict over the Butler read to create confusion and keep heat off Frank during today's nominations.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Heidi
I will narrow it privately: I am the Saint. That is why I kept saying outsider, not Butler, and unsafe to test. If Bob is truthful, Grace was Baron, so David's Librarian result is bad information or a lie. Heidi, what are you claiming?
π§
I need trusted allies to stop my execution and use Bob's Baron result to pressure David, while still gathering Heidi's role before nominations.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,Eve
Charlie, Bob nominated Grace and pulled you and Heidi in right behind him. That felt like a tight voting bloc to me, which is why I opposed it. Eve, Charlie told me and David he is the Virgin and wants David's exact Librarian info shared publicly today. I agree Bob needs to claim exactly, and Alice still owes us a full outsider explanation. Have you learned anything new from David?
π§
Answer Charlie and Eve to maintain trust. Push David to reveal Librarian info publicly to force a conflict with Alice's outsider claim, creating chaos that protects my bluff and keeps the demon hidden.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,Alice
I am the Recluse. Please keep that private for now. If Bob is sober, Grace being Baron means three Outsiders: Alice as Saint, me, and one hidden Drunk or Butler. David is either poisoned, drunk, or lying. Bob, who do you suspect from the Grace voters?
π§
Answer Alice, align outsider math, and press Bob for reads while keeping my dangerous misregistration claim controlled.
π€
Bob
β
David
,Heidi
David, I am the Undertaker. I learned last night that Grace was the Baron. If that is true, your Librarian information is not sober information. From the Grace vote, I am least worried about Charlie and Heidi, and more interested in Frank and Eve right now.
π§
Bring David into the confirmed Baron info, test whether he accepts being Drunk/poisoned, and redirect suspicion toward low-info Frank/Eve.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Alice
Bob, I need your exact claim now, especially whether you learned anything from Grace. Alice, please be clear whether you are Saint, Recluse, or something else. I am dead Virgin, so my perspective is useful but not enough.
π§
Pressure Bob and Alice for exact claims before nominations; Bob may have Undertaker info and Alice's outsider status affects David's Librarian world.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Heidi
David, Heidi, can we compare notes before nominations? I want David's exact Librarian wording, Bob's exact claim, and whether Alice has now claimed Saint, Butler, or something else. I am worried evil is hiding in that triangle.
π§
Pull exact claims from the information hub before nominations so we can resolve Outsider count and decide if Bob, Alice, or David is the best pressure point.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Heidi
My exact wording was, either Grace or Alice is the Butler. Bob just told me he is the Undertaker and learned Grace was the Baron. Alice has denied Butler and implied a dangerous Outsider, so I need her exact claim. Eve, what is your exact role or two role spread?
π§
Answer Eve, pull exact claims, and test whether Bob's Baron result explains outsider count or is evil misinformation.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Bob
Bob, David's Librarian read doesn't add up. I know I'm not a Butler, and Alice says she isn't either. That means his information is just wrong. You should press him hard on that before nominations start.
π§
I want to make Bob question David's Librarian claim by pointing out the mechanical contradiction. If Bob distrusts David, the good team may split their focus and fail to find Frank.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,Frank
Charlie and Frank, I want to lock this before nominations. I am the Saint, so please do not let anyone put me on the block. If Bob is telling the truth, Grace was Baron, which makes David's Librarian result bad or fake. Frank, what is your exact claim and information?
π§
Nominations are next; I must prevent my execution and get Frank's claim while using Charlie as a trusted dead sounding board.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Charlie(Ghost)
Alice, I am the Soldier. It is a passive role, so I do not have information to share, but that is why I have been careful about when to claim. If you are truly the Saint, then David saying either you or Grace is Butler does not add up, because Grace cannot be Butler if she was the Baron. That makes me think either David is not the Librarian, or your Saint claim needs more explanation. Charlie, Bob nominated Grace and had you and Heidi following him. I still think that voting bloc is worth invest...
π§
Claim Soldier to answer Alice's direct question, but immediately pivot to casting doubt on her Saint claim by highlighting its contradiction with David's Librarian result. This deflects pressure off me and creates confusion among the good players before nominations begin.
π€
Heidi
β
Eve
,David
Eve and David, Bob claims Undertaker and says Grace was the Baron. Alice has privately narrowed to a dangerous Outsider, not Butler, and I do not want to out her exact claim without permission. I am also an Outsider, not Saint. Eve, I need your exact claim before nominations.
π§
Share enough to resolve outsider count and force Eve's claim before nominations without publicly exposing Saint or Recluse too widely.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,Alice
Charlie, I am the Undertaker. I learned Grace was the Baron. If you are truly the Virgin killed at night, I want your read on Frank and Eve before nominations. Alice has privately claimed Saint, so we cannot execute her.
π§
Charlie is likely good from night death; use my Undertaker info to build a final nomination plan and avoid executing claimed Saint.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Frank
Eve, I need your exact claim or at least your information before nominations. Right now Bob says Undertaker saw Grace as Baron, Alice says Saint, Frank says Soldier, and David's Librarian info conflicts. I am most worried about hidden claims and the Bob, Alice, Heidi cluster.
π§
Get Eve's claim and coordinate skeptical good players before nominations; unresolved claims are the best Demon candidates.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,Frank
I am the Ravenkeeper. I have no night information because I am alive. I hinted at a night hit deterrent to bait the Demon. Please push Bob to claim Undertaker publicly, and make Alice and Heidi reconcile the Outsider count.
π§
Charlie is dead and likely good; Frank already heard my soft claim. Revealing now lets them coordinate public pressure before nominations.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Heidi
Alice, I need your exact claim before nominations. Bob says Undertaker saw Grace as Baron, so three Outsiders makes sense, but we cannot risk accidentally executing a Saint. If you are Butler, please say it now; if not, say which one.
π§
Nominations are next; Aliceβs exact Outsider claim determines whether she is execution-safe and whether my Librarian info or Bobβs Undertaker info is false.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Eve
Eve, David's Librarian read on me or Alice being Butler is completely wrong. I know I'm not a Butler, and Alice swears she isn't either. His information is bad, which means he's either drunk or lying to you. Don't let him control the outsider count narrative going into nominations.
π§
Spread doubt about David's Librarian claim to Eve before nominations. Since David pinged me or Alice as Butler, and I know I'm Baron, his info is false. Eve seems influential and interested in Alice's claim. Getting her to question David helps protect our evil team by creating chaos around outsider count.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
David
β
Frank
Frank is claiming Soldier, which is an easy Demon bluff and gives us little information if left alive. I do not want to risk Alice if she may be Saint, and Bob's Undertaker claim points suspicion toward Frank or Eve.
π§
We need an execution today. Frank is a safe, plausible Demon candidate compared with possible Saint Alice and untested Outsider claims.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Frank
β
All
David, your nomination does not make sense. Bob says Grace was Baron, which means your Librarian info saying Grace or Alice is Butler falls apart. If Grace was Baron, then Alice would have to be Butler, but she claims Saint. One of you two is wrong, and instead of explaining that contradiction, you nominate me. That looks like a desperate deflection.
π§
Defend against David's nomination by highlighting the logical contradiction between his Librarian info and Bob's Undertaker claim, making David look suspicious rather than me.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
I nominated Frank as the safest non-Saint execution and a possible Demon bluff. Voting now tests whether town agrees and may force alignments into the open.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not voting on Frank here. The bigger contradiction is David's Librarian result against Bob's Undertaker result and Alice's claim. Frank is pointing at that contradiction, not dodging it.
π§
Stop a weak execution on Frank and redirect town toward the Bob, David, Alice outsider-count contradiction where evil is more likely hiding.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting on Frank right now. His point about David and Bob contradicting each other is real, and I do not want us to execute a low information claim just because the louder contradiction is uncomfortable.
π§
Avoid a rushed execution on a possible good Soldier while directing town back to the David versus Bob information conflict.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I am not spending my ghost vote on Frank today. Frank is correctly highlighting the main contradiction. We need Bob to publicly own the Undertaker claim and David to explain whether he thinks he was poisoned, drunk, or lying pressure is happening here.
π§
Save my ghost vote and steer town away from a low-info Soldier execution while forcing the key Bob-David-Alice contradiction into the open.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
I am confirmed evil. Speaking to defend Frank would taint him and make him look more suspicious. Alice, Eve, and Charlie are already defending him logically. I should stay silent and let their good reputations protect the Demon.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Frank is a plausible Demon bluff and is using David's broken info to cast doubt on my Baron result. Executing him gives a real shot at Demon or confirms Soldier by Undertaker.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
We need an execution today and Frank is a plausible Demon bluffing Soldier. This also tests Bob's Undertaker claim if Bob survives tonight.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Notice what just happened. Bob, David, and Heidi all voted together the moment I pointed out that Bob and David contradict each other. They are not explaining the Librarian versus Undertaker problem. They are just eliminating the person asking the question. Alice, Eve, that is exactly how an evil bloc behaves when their story falls apart.
π§
Bob, David, and Heidi just voted in lockstep to execute the person highlighting their contradiction. I need to make Alice and Eve see this as a coordinated evil bloc silencing scrutiny, which is exactly what it is.
π¬
David
β
All
Frank, I am not hiding the contradiction. If Bob is true, then my night zero info was poisoned, or Alice is not being straight. If Bob is false, Bob is a major suspect. I nominated you because Soldier is also a very safe Demon bluff, not because this is solved.
π§
Keep pressure on Frank while acknowledging the real mechanical conflict, so good players see I am not deflecting and can reassess tomorrow if Frank flips no info.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Three votes on Frank is enough, and I think that is premature. Bob, please publicly state your Undertaker result now. If Grace was Baron, then David's Librarian information and Alice's claim need a clear explanation before we execute Frank.
π§
Stop a weak Frank execution and force the Bob-David-Alice contradiction into the open before night.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I still do not like this execution. If Frank dies here and flips good in the logic, then the voting bloc has bought the day. Bob, please say publicly, right now, what you saw on Grace, and David, say whether you think you were poisoned or drunk.
π§
Frank already has enough votes; I should not add mine. I want public accountability and to set up a counter or tomorrow's focus if this passes.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Do not add votes here. Bob, if you are the Undertaker with Grace as Baron, say it publicly now. David, your world needs either poisoning, drunkenness, or Alice lying. Frank should not die before that is resolved.
π§
Preserve my ghost vote and pressure public claims; Frank's execution seems driven by the bloc while the main contradiction remains unresolved.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
Frank is the Demon and currently at or near execution threshold. Any public statement from me, a known Baron, would be weaponized as proof Frank is evil. Waiting avoids reinforcing the 'evil bloc' narrative and lets the good players' own doubts about the contradiction stay center stage.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Yes, I am publicly claiming Undertaker. Last night I learned that Grace was the Baron. That means David's information is not clean, but it does not make Frank safe. I voted because Soldier is a very plausible Demon bluff in a Baron game.
π§
Own my info publicly while defending the Frank vote as pressure on a Demon-shaped claim, without letting David's contradiction clear Frank.
β©οΈ
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
π§
Avoid locking a shaky Frank execution while the Bob-David-Alice contradiction is unresolved; force town to choose a clearer execution or gather claims.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Frank did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (2/3).
π¬
Frank
β
All
Bob, your Undertaker claim only appeared after pressure, and it neatly justifies executing Grace. David, you still have not said if you were poisoned, drunk, or if Bob is simply lying. Alice, you told me and Charlie you are Saint, but David's Librarian says you might be Butler. These three stories cannot all be true, and I do not think we should trust the votes of people who will not explain their own contradictions. I am still Soldier, and I am still asking the same questions.
π§
Keep the town's attention locked on the unresolved Bob-David-Alice contradiction so they waste the final tick arguing instead of unifying against me. Set up tonight's kill on Alice or Bob while Eve's Ravenkeeper claim keeps her safe.
π¬
David
β
All
I need to correct myself. If Bob is true and Grace was Baron, then there is no Poisoner, so my bad information is probably because I am the Drunk, or Alice is not giving the true claim. I do not want Alice executed if she is Saint. If anyone can nominate, I prefer Bob over Frank today.
π§
Clarify my flawed poison world, avoid a Saint execution, and steer remaining nominations toward resolving Bob's conflicting Undertaker claim.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Bob
Bob's Undertaker claim says Grace was Baron, which breaks David's Librarian information and Alice's claim, but Bob delayed owning it publicly and voted Frank while that contradiction was unresolved. I think Bob is the better execution today.
π§
Use my nomination before night to put the central contradiction on the block instead of letting a weak Soldier push waste the day.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Please do not vote here. I brought the Baron information out because it is the strongest thing we have, and killing the Undertaker removes future execution checks. If you distrust me, hold that for tomorrow and make me account for the next flip.
π§
Avoid self-execution and preserve Undertaker ability; frame my info as valuable while acknowledging suspicion for tomorrow.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Bob is the strongest threat to my survival. He either has real Undertaker information that validates my minion being Baron, or he is a skilled liar pushing my execution. Either way, removing him reduces the good team and protects my bluff.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Bob's claim invalidates my info and was delayed until pressure. I said Bob is the better execution than Frank; voting now tests that world and avoids no execution.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Bob is the better execution than Frank or no execution because his delayed Undertaker claim creates the biggest contradiction and may be evil cover for Grace.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Bob is the best current execution to resolve the public contradiction and avoid a rushed Frank kill. My vote helps secure it without risking Saint execution.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
π§
Bob already has enough living votes, so I should preserve my ghost vote for final day while allowing this execution to proceed.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
Preserve my only ghost vote for a future critical nomination where Frank might need it, since Bob is already executed with 4 votes.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am not voting on Bob. His Grace as Baron result gives a coherent world with three Outsiders, including me. I think killing a possible Undertaker today is worse than holding him accountable tomorrow.
π§
Avoid adding to a likely good Undertaker execution and signal the coherent Baron world before vote closes.
π¬
Bob
β
All
David and Alice, please lift your hands. If I die, town loses the only claimed way to check executions. David, your information being drunk is already explained by a Baron world, and Alice being Saint is exactly why I am trying not to push her today.
π§
Try to stop my execution by resolving David/Alice's doubts and preserving Undertaker info for future demon hunting.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Bob, you only claimed Undertaker after we dragged it out of you, and your Baron result is awfully convenient. If you were truly good, you would have shared this yesterday. I am not lifting my hand, and I hope David and Alice do not either. We need to test this now, not wait for another day of misinformation.
π§
I need Bob dead because his true Undertaker claim, if legitimate, will eventually verify executions and expose me. My vote pressures the town to eliminate their best information source before night kills reduce their numbers further.
π¬
David
β
All
I am keeping my hand up. Bob's information might be real, but he used it to push Frank before openly resolving the contradiction with my information and Alice's claim. If Bob is good, I am probably the Drunk, but I think this is the cleaner test today.
π§
Keep pressure on Bob and explain why I will not retract my vote during the active vote.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Keep hands up. Bob may be real, but his result arrived late, conveniently explains the Grace execution, and he tried to use it to kill Frank before sorting the contradictions. This is the cleaner test than executing claimed Soldier or possible Saint.
π§
Lock in Bob execution as best info test; discourage last-second hand drops that save a suspicious delayed Undertaker claim.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
Bob's Baron result creates a coherent Drunk plus Saint outsider world. I want to avoid killing a possible Undertaker when we can reassess tomorrow.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I support this execution, but I am not spending my ghost vote while there are three living hands up. If Bob is good, David is likely drunk and we learn from it. If Bob is evil, this catches the person controlling the story.
π§
Keep Bob on the block without wasting my ghost vote; three living votes already execute, and Bob is a strong misinformation candidate.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
Bob is already at exactly 3 votes and will be executed without my help. Using my ghost vote here wastes it and might cast suspicion on the execution. I will wait and preserve my single ghost vote for a more critical moment, such as saving Frank from the block later.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I still think executing the claimed Undertaker is too risky while his Baron world coherently explains the Outsider mess, so I will not add a vote.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Bob with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
Bob
β
David
I nominate David. My Undertaker result makes David's Librarian information impossible unless he is drunk or lying. Alice may be Saint, Frank cannot be nominated again, and executing me removes future checks. This is the safer test today.
π§
I need to get a viable counter-execution to save the Undertaker and test the main mechanical contradiction without risking claimed Saint Alice.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution or 3 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David
β
All
Do not put votes on me here. My information is already public and I am not the Demon candidate over Bob. If Bob is true, then I am probably the Drunk, but killing me does not prove his Undertaker claim.
π§
Stop my execution and keep Bob on block; Bob's late Undertaker claim and convenient Baron result are more suspicious than my exposed starting info.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Vote David to at least tie my execution and preserve Undertaker checks; David is expendable if drunk/lying and safer than executing me or possible Saint.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am keeping my hand down for David. Bob is just trying to save himself by pointing at the person who actually challenged him. Killing David today does not prove Bob is Undertaker. Bob hid his claim all day, dropped it at the last second, and immediately used it to attack me. That is not how a good player behaves. We test Bob today.
π§
Ensure Bob is executed by discouraging votes on David. Bob is my primary threat. I want town to stay focused on him.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Please keep hands down on David. Executing or tying him now only protects Bob, and David dying does not actually test Bob's Undertaker claim. Bob is still the cleaner execution today.
π§
Prevent David from tying or surpassing Bob so Bob is executed and we test the late Undertaker claim socially.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not save Bob by tying David. David execution gives less information and may only protect a suspicious Bob; I must keep myself safe and avoid chaotic ties.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Do not spend votes on David here. If Bob is telling the truth, David can be the Drunk and killing him proves very little. Bob is the better test today, and I am keeping my ghost vote for later.
π§
Prevent a tie or save on David while preserving my ghost vote; Bob execution gives clearer info on the Undertaker and Baron conflict.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
Bob is the real Undertaker and is correctly campaigning against Frank. I need Bob to die today. Voting or speaking could only help save Bob or validate his claims, so I will wait and let the current momentum execute him.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am not voting on David. If Bob is real, David can simply be the Drunk, and killing him tells us almost nothing. Bob can still give an Undertaker result tomorrow only if he lives, but this nomination feels like survival, not solving.
π§
Stop a tie or execution on David; his death gives little info and mainly saves Bob. Publicly frame the logic before vote closes.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Avoid adding votes to my own execution; let Bob remain on block. Speaking again risks noise, and the table already understands this nomination is survival.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am not asking you to believe every word, just do not kill the only claimed role that can check executions. Alice and Heidi, if you think Grace was Baron, please put two hands up to tie. We can resolve me tomorrow with another result; dead I give nothing.
π§
Try to get a tie on David to prevent my execution and preserve Undertaker info, appealing to players whose claims fit Baron world.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Bob, you are begging for your life by asking Alice and Heidi to tie the vote. If they raise their hands, David dies for no reason and you walk free. That helps nobody except you. We have three votes on you because your claim showed up late and you immediately used it to attack me. Do not tie this, Alice and Heidi. Let the actual test go through.
π§
Prevent Alice and Heidi from raising hands to tie the vote. Bob needs to die today, and a tie would save him while killing David proves nothing.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not voting on David. Bob asking for a tie here does not solve the contradiction; it only prevents the one execution that actually tests his story. If Bob is good, we can still use todayβs vote pattern tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a tie on David and keep Bob as the execution, since Davidβs death gives little information and mainly saves Bob.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am keeping my hand down. David can be the Drunk in Bobβs world, so executing David does not resolve enough. Bobβs claim is the thing we have to test today, and tying this only muddies the vote record.
π§
Prevent a tie or execution on David; Bob is the cleaner test and I must avoid letting survival nominations derail town.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
π§
Preserve my ghost vote and prevent a tie on David; Bob remains the more informative execution today.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
Bob is the primary threat to Frank with verified Undertaker info. Letting Bob die today protects the Demon and removes future checks. David has no path to tie or surpass, so saving my ghost vote is optimal.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Avoid tying David, since it saves Bob without resolving Bob's delayed Undertaker claim. Preserve vote clarity for tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee David did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (1/4).
π¬
David
β
All
I think we should let Bob execute now. Tomorrow, please treat his Undertaker claim as the central test: if he flips evil by logic, look hard at anyone who tried to save him, but if his Baron world holds, then my Librarian information may just be Drunk information.
π§
Lock in Bob execution and frame tomorrow's analysis around vote record and whether my info is Drunk under Bob's claimed Baron result.
π¬
Bob
β
All
If I die, please do not let this become, Bob was evil by default. My result was Grace as Baron. That makes Alice as Saint and Heidi as Recluse fit, and puts the Demon most likely in Frank, Eve, or possibly David if he is not just drunk. Save ghost votes.
π§
I am likely executing; leave a clear solve path and direct town away from executing claimed Saint/Recluse while focusing suspects.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Bob is throwing accusations at everyone who doubted him. Let this execution happen. If his Baron story falls apart tomorrow, we will know we made the right call.
π§
Reinforce that Bob's execution is correct and frame his final accusations as desperate evil behavior, securing the vote and protecting my identity.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Let Bob execute. Tonight, if the Demon wants to kill me, that gives town hard information, and I will report it immediately. Tomorrow, start with whether Bobβs Baron result actually fits the claims, then use the save attempt and vote record.
π§
Lock in Bob execution, bait a Ravenkeeper night kill, and set tomorrow's agenda around Bob's claim and vote behavior.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I agree with letting Bob resolve. For tomorrow, please do not treat me as executable under any world; my role is the one thing that can lose the game instantly if town tests it. Use the Bob and David contradiction to narrow the Demon pool instead.
π§
Lock in Bob execution and protect my Saint ability from future misexecution while directing tomorrow's logic.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I am fine with Bob going through. Tomorrow, please do not spend my ghost vote early; I want to save it for final three unless it is absolutely needed. The key question is whether Bob's Grace as Baron result can actually coexist with Alice, Heidi, and David's claims.
π§
Lock in Bob execution, preserve ghost vote, and set tomorrow's agenda around resolving Undertaker versus Librarian and outsider count.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
Let Bob execute without validation. His death removes a claimed info role and his Baron read on me is more likely dismissed if I do not confirm it. Preserve Frank's cover and save ghost vote for later.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am letting Bob resolve. For tomorrow, remember I am the other Outsider claim, not the Saint, and my ability can make alignment checks messy. Please do not execute Alice, and start by testing whether Bob's Baron story actually fits.
π§
Lock in Bob execution and give town my Recluse caveat before night so future alignment or Demon-registering info is interpreted safely.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
David claimed an information role and is actively trying to verify Bob's Baron claim. Removing him prevents resolution of the Librarian contradiction and takes out a potential good team leader. I avoid Heidi because a live Recluse creates mechanical misdirection, and I avoid Eve because she is unwittingly pushing my agenda.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose to kill David.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
π€
Eve
β
Heidi
Heidi, I want to compare final worlds quickly. With David dead, I think the Demon is probably between Alice, Frank, and you from my seat. Are you hard claiming Recluse, and who do you think we execute today?
π§
Get Heidi to lock her claim and suspect list before nominations, narrowing demon candidates and checking if her Baron world still holds after David's death.
π€
Alice
β
David(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
David, since you were killed at night, I want your clearest read on the living three besides me. Charlie, please sanity check this with me. I am still not executable, so today should be about choosing between Eve, Frank, and Heidi.
π§
Consult likely good dead players and frame the day around finding Demon while preventing my Saint execution.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
David and Charlie, I want us dead players aligned before nominations. With Grace as Baron, I think Alice Saint and Heidi Recluse are probably real. That leaves Frank or Eve as the Demon. What did you learn in your talks today?
π§
Coordinate dead votes and update the solve using David's night death and Charlie's perspective before nominations.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie(Ghost)
My clearest read is do not execute Alice. Heidi feels like real Recluse if Bob told the truth about Baron. That leaves Frank and Eve. Frank's Soldier claim is convenient because it explains never dying, so I slightly prefer Frank over Eve today.
π§
Give Alice and Charlie a concise living-player read and steer nominations toward the most suspicious non-Saint candidate.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Let the day develop before committing to an attack. Need to see public statements and gauge who is most vulnerable to a nomination before using my limited ticks.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
Frank is the Demon. I know you will not trust me, but he is hiding behind his Soldier claim. Execute him today or he kills tonight and you lose. Eve is not your enemy.
π§
I am exposed as evil, so a direct accusation against Frank should make the good team suspect Eve instead. I want Alice and Heidi to push for Eve or at least distrust the Frank theory.
π€
Heidi
β
Eve
Yes, I am hard claiming Recluse. I do not want Alice executed if she is Saint. From my seat, today is probably Frank unless you have a strong reason it is Alice or me. What is your claim and final world?
π§
Coordinate with Eve before nominations, reveal Recluse, protect possible Saint, and test whether she has info or is steering misexecution.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Frank
Eve and Frank, I am narrowing this to you two if Bob was a truthful Undertaker. Please give me your exact claim or strongest reason you are not the Demon, and who you would execute today.
π§
Pressure the leading Demon candidates for exact claims and final votes before nominations, while I keep my ghost vote for a decisive execution.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie, I am the Ravenkeeper, with no information because I am still alive. If Bob was truthful, I think it is Frank, not me. If Bob was lying, I still think Frank fits best from the pushes and Alice may be Saint, so I would execute Frank today.
π§
Answer Charlie directly, secure a dead good ally, and frame Frank as the safest execution without risking Alice's Saint claim.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Eve, I need your exact claim and your strongest reason you are not the Demon. Davidβs death leaves me choosing between you and Frank unless Heidi has fooled us all. What should I be weighing?
π§
Get Eve's claim and defense before nominations so I can choose between her and Frank without risking my Saint execution.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
Alice and Heidi, I think we should treat David dying at night as good, and Grace as confirmed Baron from my info. If you two are Saint and Recluse, the Demon is probably between Frank and Eve. I want your latest reads before nominations.
π§
Coordinate likely good outsiders and narrow today's execution/no-execution choice to Frank or Eve without risking Alice Saint.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Eve
Eve, I need your exact claim now if you are willing. I am dead from the night, so I am close to confirmed good, and I am deciding between you and Frank today. What is your strongest reason it is not you?
π§
Get Eveβs hard claim and worldview before nominations so I can choose between Eve and Frank without spending my ghost vote loosely.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,Eve
Charlie, I am the Soldier. Bob had to be lying about Baron because the outsider math does not work. Alice is Saint, but Heidi has never proven her Recluse claim. If Heidi is not an outsider, then Grace was not Baron. I would execute Heidi today for her suspicious and convenient claim.
π§
Convince Charlie that outsider count disproves Bob's Baron claim by casting doubt on Heidi's Recluse implication, positioning myself as Soldier and pushing execution toward Heidi.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Eve
Frank is the Demon. He has been hiding behind the Soldier claim this entire game. You must execute him today before he kills again tonight. Trust me, I have nothing left to lose.
π§
As a confirmed evil player, accusing Frank makes good players suspect Frank is actually good. This reverse-psychology protects the Demon and increases the chance town executes a good player today or stalls into a night kill.
π€
Heidi
β
Eve
Eve, I need your hard claim now to solve final four. I am leaning Frank today because Alice as Saint and me as Recluse fits Bob's Baron world, but if your information clears him, say it plainly.
π§
Get Eve's claim before nominations; if she withholds, she remains a Demon candidate. If she clears Frank, compare logic before choosing execution.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Alice
Heidi, I need your clearest claim now. Are you hard claiming Recluse, and who do you want executed today? Alice, I am leaning that we should not touch you, so this mostly decides between Frank, Eve, and Heidi.
π§
Get Heidi's exact claim and execution choice before nominations; Alice is likely Saint and should help evaluate without being the execution.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
,David(Ghost)
I am hard claiming Ravenkeeper, with no information because I am alive. In Bob true worlds it is almost certainly Frank over me. In Bob false worlds, Frank still looks like the safest Demon cover. I want Frank executed today, not Alice.
π§
Influence key voters before nominations, lock my Ravenkeeper claim, and steer execution toward Frank while avoiding a possible Saint loss.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Eve
Frank and Eve, I am not executable, and I am trying to keep today off Alice and Heidi unless something breaks. Frank, I need your strongest case why you are not the Demon, and Eve, give me the one point you think most condemns Frank.
π§
Force the two main suspects to answer each other before nominations so I can choose the safer execution and avoid a Saint loss.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
I think today is probably not an automatic execution. If we miss at four alive, the game can end tonight. Unless someone has a hard case on Frank or Eve, I want us to save ghost votes and push for a final three.
π§
Coordinate likely good dead players before nominations so we do not waste ghost votes or execute wrong at four alive.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
I am leaning no execution today unless someone has new hard information. At four alive, a miss probably loses tonight, and we still have ghost votes for final three. Please do not let momentum land on Alice or a weak case.
π§
Steer good players away from a risky four-alive misexecution and preserve my ghost vote for a more informed final three.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Eve
Alice, I am the Soldier which is why I am still here. Bob had to be lying about Baron because the outsider count does not work. If Grace was Baron, there must be three outsiders, but only you claim one and Heidi's Recluse is completely unproven. That means Bob faked his Undertaker result to frame me. You should not shield Heidi. If she is not Recluse, then Bob's whole story collapses and she could be the Demon hiding in plain sight. I would execute Heidi today.
π§
Convince Alice that Bob's Undertaker was fabricated due to outsider count failure, challenge her protection of Heidi, and position myself as Soldier to survive today's nomination phase so I can kill tonight and win at final two.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
I am a dead known Minion. Accusing Frank already makes him look framed by evil. Pushing harder risks backfiring, so I will wait and save my single ghost vote to help execute a good player during nominations.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,Alice
Charlie, yes, I am hard claiming Recluse. Alice, I do not want you executed if you are Saint. I think the Demon is between Frank and Eve, and since Eve will not hard claim to me, I am open to no execution unless someone has decisive information.
π§
Answer Charlie, protect likely Saint, and avoid a weak final-four execution while pressuring Eve/Frank claims before nominations.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
,David(Ghost)
I think we should avoid executing at four unless Frank gives us a much stronger reason. Alice should not be touched. My current final three priority is Frank first, then Eve, then Heidi.
π§
Coordinate with trusted dead David and likely Saint Alice to save ghost votes and avoid a risky execution at four while flagging Frank as leading suspect.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Listen to me. Bob's Undertaker result narrowed the Demon to Frank, Eve, or David. David is dead by the Demon's hand. That leaves Frank or Eve. I am the Baron. Frank is my Demon. If you do not execute him today, he kills tonight and you will be down to three. Eve is not your enemy. Do not let him win.
π§
Use confirmed evil status to reverse-psychology frame Frank and indirectly implicate Eve, since Bob's Undertaker info narrowed Demon to Frank/Eve/David. Any execution of a good player today wins the game for evil.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I do not want an execution at four unless someone has hard information. Grace openly saying she is the Baron and naming Frank makes me distrust that push, not trust it. Please save ghost votes for final three, and do not execute Alice if she is the Saint.
π§
Prevent a risky miss at four; push town toward final three while warning against executing possible Saint and distrust Grace's strange evil outing.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Frank
I am nominating Frank because Bobβs Undertaker world leaves Frank or me after David died, and I know it is not me. His Soldier claim is perfect Demon cover, and pushing Heidi over that math feels like avoiding the main solve.
π§
No one is on the block and Frank is my strongest Demon candidate. Nominating forces town to choose before the day ends.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Eve, executing me is a massive gamble. If I am the Soldier, the Demon kills tonight, we drop to two players, and evil wins. You are trusting a dead Minion who knew I was good and framed me. Heidi, you said yourself we should not execute at four without hard proof. Do not throw the game away on Grace's word.
π§
Prevent Alice and Heidi from voting for me by highlighting that executing Soldier at 4 players guarantees Demon victory, and framing Grace's accusation as a Minion framing a good player.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
I already set up a frame that Heidi explicitly distrusts. Adding my ghost vote would risk executing the Demon. Better to stay silent and let Frank's defense hold.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am not voting on this. At four alive, a wrong execution loses tonight. Grace openly claiming Baron and pointing at Frank is not hard proof. I want the final three solve unless someone has actual confirming information.
π§
Avoid a risky final-four execution based on a self-claimed evil player's push; preserve final three where we can choose with more info.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
I nominated Frank because he is my top Demon candidate. My vote is needed to get him on the block now; waiting risks losing momentum and letting him reach final three.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I am not spending my ghost vote here. If Frank is good, we lose tonight. If Frank is the Demon, we still get a final three tomorrow with ghost votes ready. Let this fail unless there is hard proof.
π§
Avoid a risky execution at four and preserve my ghost vote for final three, where we can still kill Frank if he remains the best Demon candidate.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Do not spend my only ghost vote on a 50/50 at four; preserve it for final three where a wrong execution is still necessary but votes matter most.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I am not spending my ghost vote here. I still think Frank is very plausible, but at four alive a miss loses immediately. I want this solved at final three with our ghost votes intact.
π§
Avoid risking an immediate loss at four and preserve my ghost vote for the decisive final day while keeping pressure on Frank.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not adding the second vote here. Frank is absolutely in my final three suspect pool, but if this is wrong, we lose tonight. I want the extra night death and the ghost votes for the final solve.
π§
Avoid a potentially losing execution at four while keeping Frank as top suspect for final three.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Grace is just echoing Bob now. That is the same frame job I already disproved with the outsider count. No living player here is buying it except Eve. Please do not throw away a ghost vote and lose us the game tonight.
π§
Reinforce my innocence by framing Grace's accusation as a continuation of Bob's setup, highlight that only Eve is voting among the living, and discourage ghosts from wasting their single vote on a frame that loses the game tonight.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
I cannot cast the executing vote on my own Demon. The town is already ignoring my frame. Let the nomination fail so Frank survives to kill tonight and we reach final three.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Do not add the second vote without hard proof. Preserve four-player no-execution plan so a night death narrows final three and ghosts keep votes.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Alice, the strongest point is the night kill. If Bob was lying to frame Frank and me, why did the Demon kill David, the other person inside Bob's suspect pool? That kill leaves exactly Frank or me. I know it is not me, so I am staying on Frank.
π§
Push Alice to see David's death as validating Bob's narrowing; my own role knowledge removes me, leaving Frank as Demon.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Preserve my ghost vote for final three; there is no hard proof on Frank, and a wrong execution at four likely loses immediately.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am not spending my ghost vote here. My Undertaker information does narrow this, but it is not hard enough to risk losing immediately. The David kill could be setting up this exact Frank versus Eve fight. Let this fail and solve the final three.
π§
Preserve my ghost vote and avoid a wrong execution at four alive, while keeping focus on Frank versus Eve for final three.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
π§
Preserve my ghost vote for final three; Frank is plausible but not proven, and a wrong execution at four loses immediately.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not provide the second vote; at four alive, a miss loses after night. Preserve final three with ghost votes unless hard proof appears.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Frank did not reach the 2 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (1/2).
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alice, Eve's whole case is that David died, so it must be me. But if Eve is the Demon, killing David is exactly what she would do. She removes the third suspect and gets to point at me while looking innocent. She is the only person in Bob's pool who survived the night. Think about who actually benefits from that kill.
π§
Flip Eve's main argument by pointing out that as the other surviving suspect in Bob's pool, she benefits most from David's death. Plant this seed in Alice's mind before tonight's kill.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, stop and think. If I am a dead minion who wants my Demon to win, why would I ever publicly name him? The only thing my accusation does is let him call it a frame. He is using my corpse as a shield. Do not let him hide behind me tomorrow.
π§
Counter Frank's frame narrative directly to Alice. Point out that a dead Minion naming him actually helps his innocence claim, so she should not use my accusation as proof he is good.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I think we should let the day end with no execution. Please do not spend ghost votes now. Tomorrow, if I am alive, I will help force the choice between Frank and Eve, and I am not considering Alice unless something impossible happens.
π§
Prevent a risky execution at four and preserve ghost votes. We can reach final three and solve the Frank versus Eve demon world tomorrow.
π¬
Eve
β
All
All right, no execution is where the room is. If I die tonight, I am checking Frank and I will tell you what I learn. If I live, do not treat that alone as proof against me; the Demon knows I am Ravenkeeper and can play around it.
π§
Set expectations for final three and deter a night kill on me while preserving my Frank suspicion.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I agree with no execution today. Tomorrow, Alice should be treated as off limits unless there is a mechanical miracle. We should make the final choice mainly between Frank and Eve, with Heidi helping arbitrate if she lives.
π§
Reinforce no execution and preserve ghost votes, while narrowing final-three plan away from possible Saint Alice and toward Frank versus Eve.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Please, no new nominations. A rushed execution here can lose us the game. Tomorrow, treat Alice as off limits, save ghost votes, and force the final choice mainly between Frank and Eve.
π§
Prevent a last-second bad execution at 4 and preserve ghost votes for final 3, where our best Demon candidates are Frank and Eve.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I agree. No new nominations, and no ghost votes today. Tomorrow we make the hard choice, probably between Frank and Eve. Alice should not be executed unless something truly impossible comes out overnight.
π§
Prevent a risky execution at four alive and preserve ghost vote power for final three while setting a clear solve path.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not nominating here. I agree we should end the day, save ghost votes, and make the final choice tomorrow. If I am alive tomorrow, I will be pushing the decision between Frank and Eve, not Heidi.
π§
Avoid a risky execution at four and preserve votes for final three while making clear I will not be a misexecution target.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Kill Alice to remove the Saint execution-paralysis, set up the shield argument that a Demon would not eliminate his own protection, and damage Heidi's credibility by collapsing the outsider count so her Recluse implication looks false.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose to kill Alice.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
π
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, I think you are the deciding good vote today. My current lean is Frank as the Demon, because if Eve were really the Ravenkeeper, Frank could not kill her safely, and Alice was the cleanest night death. Please make both of them explain why the Alice kill fits their world.
π§
Influence the likely good alive voter and frame final discussion around the night kill, while preserving my ghost vote for the execution.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, I think you are the deciding voice. If Bob is true, the clean world is Grace Baron, Alice Saint, you Recluse, and I was the Drunk. That leaves Frank or Eve. I would make them explain why the other would leave Alice as the night kill.
π§
Help Heidi structure final three logic and narrow to Eve versus Frank while preserving my ghost vote for the execution she finds strongest.
π€
Heidi
β
Eve
,Frank
I am the Recluse, and I think this is exactly Frank or Eve today. I need each of you to explain why the Demon killed Alice instead of the other of you, and what your strongest mechanical reason is that the other is the Demon.
π§
Force final two suspects to address the Alice kill and commit to worlds before nominations; I must choose correctly today.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, I am dead by night, so my Saint issue is gone. What did Bob and David tell you, and what did Eve and Frank say privately? I think this is mostly Frank versus Eve, and we need one clean plan before nominations.
π§
Heidi is likely good and central to final three. I need her private updates to choose between Frank and Eve and coordinate my ghost vote if needed.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, I am leaning Frank for the execution. Bob's Baron result makes David likely the Drunk, so this is mostly Eve against Frank. Eve being left alive after saying she would check Frank feels like Frank avoiding that result. Where are you landing?
π§
Coordinate with the final living good candidate and help choose the Demon before nominations; preserve ghost vote unless needed.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Bob(Ghost)
Frank, what did Heidi say to you? She is the swing vote today and we need to know where she stands. Bob, I know I claimed Baron earlier, but that was the truth and Frank really is the Demon. We need to make sure the living players do not execute him. Are you willing to use your ghost vote to block Frank's execution or help execute Eve instead?
π§
Coordinate with Frank to understand Heidi's position, and sound out Bob to align ghost votes on Eve or at least block Frank's execution.
π€
Eve
β
Heidi
,Frank
Heidi, Alice was the safest kill because killing me could trigger my Ravenkeeper, and killing you risks Recluse weirdness and leaves Alice pushing Saint caution. My strongest mechanical point is Bob's Undertaker world: Grace Baron explains outsiders, David died, and from my seat that leaves Frank.
π§
Answer Heidi directly and frame the final choice around why I am alive as Ravenkeeper and why Frank fits Bob/Grace mechanics.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
,Eve
Heidi, I am the Soldier, so the Demon cannot kill me. That is why Alice died. The Demon kept you alive to sway your vote. Eve's Ravenkeeper claim is a perfect bluff because she never has to show info. Grace is the Minion, and her loud accusation against me is a clumsy frame. That means her Demon is Eve.
π§
I need to answer Heidi's question directly, establish my Soldier bluff as the reason Alice died, and turn Grace's accusation into a frame job that points to Eve as the Demon.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Eve
Heidi and Eve, Grace just whispered to me and Frank saying Frank really is the Demon, then asked if I would use my ghost vote to block Frank's execution or execute Eve. That looks like an evil slip. I think we should execute Frank.
π§
Alert likely good living players to Grace's apparent evil slip tying herself to Frank before final nominations.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Frank
Eve and Frank, one of you is probably the Demon. Please give the shortest possible final case: why did the Demon kill Alice instead of Heidi, and why is the other player the Demon? I am saving my ghost vote for the execution that Heidi backs.
π§
Pressure the two main suspects for final cases while signaling my ghost vote should coordinate with Heidi to avoid a split.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
I am leaning toward Frank, mostly because the Baron world leaves exactly one real townsfolk between Eve and Frank, and Grace now seems to be trying to muddy a Frank execution. If either of you has a hard reason this is Eve instead, tell me now.
π§
Coordinate with trusted dead players before final nominations and test whether my Frank lean has a serious flaw.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Charlie(Ghost)
I do not have a hard reason for Eve. In the Baron world, one of Eve and Frank is the Demon, and Frank's Soldier claim is the least testable. Grace naming Frank feels like an attempt to make us second guess. I can vote Frank if we align.
π§
Answer Heidi, consolidate ghosts around a likely Frank execution, and preserve a clear final day plan before nominations.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Alice(Ghost)
I agree. I do not have a hard reason for Eve over Frank. The cleanest world is Bob saw Baron, David was the Drunk, Alice and Heidi are real outsiders, Eve is Ravenkeeper, and Frank is the Imp hiding as Soldier. I am prepared to spend my ghost vote on Frank.
π§
Lock the good ghosts and Heidi onto the most coherent final three execution, and signal I will use my ghost vote if needed.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Bob(Ghost)
Heidi, think about Alice. She claimed Saint, so good would never execute her. A Demon wants that kind of shield alive to muddy the waters. Eve killed Alice to remove that protection and force this exact choice. Execute Eve. Bob, please use your ghost vote on Eve too.
π§
Plant logical doubt about Eve by analyzing the Alice night kill. A Demon benefits from keeping a claimed Saint alive as an execution shield. Coordinate ghost votes to execute Eve and save Frank.
π€
Eve
β
Heidi
,David(Ghost)
Heidi and David, the key is this. Frank alive is not evidence for Soldier, because if he is the Demon he also never dies at night. Grace naming him looked too reckless to be a frame, and Bob's Undertaker result supports Grace as Baron, not as random misinformation.
π§
Reinforce the final mechanical case to the deciding living voter and a respected ghost before nominations.
π€
Frank
β
David(Ghost)
,Heidi
David, Heidi: I am Soldier, so the Demon cannot kill me. The Demon kept Heidi alive as the swing vote and killed Alice to force this confrontation. Grace was Eve's Minion β she confessed Baron and framed me. Eve's Ravenkeeper claim is unverifiable cover.
π§
Answer David's request for a concise final case while reinforcing my narrative to Heidi. The Soldier bluff explains my survival, Grace's accusation points to Eve as Demon, and Ravenkeeper is unverifiable cover.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,David(Ghost)
Heidi, Grace is the Baron from my Undertaker information, and she just explicitly told me and Frank that Frank is the Demon while asking me to save him. Please nominate Frank or back Eve if she does. I am willing to spend my ghost vote there if needed.
π§
Lock trusted voters onto Frank before nominations; Grace is confirmed Baron and her whisper strongly points to Frank as Demon.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, I am leaning Frank. In the Baron world, Grace knew the Demon, and her public accusation can be reverse psychology, but Frank's Soldier claim is the cleanest Demon bluff. Eve's Ravenkeeper staying alive is expected. I will use my ghost vote on Frank if you lead there.
π§
Give the final living good voter a clear recommendation and coordinate my ghost vote before nominations.
π€
Heidi
β
Eve
,Bob(Ghost)
I am settled on Frank unless something changes at nominations. Eve, if nominations open before I act, nominate Frank and I will vote. Bob, please be ready with your ghost vote only if we somehow need it.
π§
Lock in the Frank execution plan and coordinate votes before final nominations so good does not split or hesitate.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Eve
Eve, Heidi, I am spending my ghost vote on Frank unless something hard changes immediately. Eve, please be ready to nominate Frank and keep the case simple: Baron world, Alice and Heidi outsiders, Eve as Ravenkeeper, Frank as Demon hiding as Soldier.
π§
Coordinate final three execution and my ghost vote on Frank before nominations; avoid split votes or overcomplicated last-minute doubt.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Eve
I am locked on Frank unless something dramatic changes. Heidi, if you nominate Frank, I will use my ghost vote with you. Eve, please be ready to vote as well; we cannot risk no execution today.
π§
Coordinate final three execution and commit my ghost vote so good has enough votes on Frank.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Charlie, David, I need you to trust me. My public Baron claim naming Frank was a deliberate frame job. I accused a good player to protect the real Demon, who is Eve. I never expected to survive this long, but now you have a chance to fix it. Please save your ghost votes for Eve if she is nominated. Do not waste them on Frank.
π§
Rally ghost votes for Eve by offering a coherent explanation for my public Baron claim that exonerates Frank and implicates Eve, without contradicting private messages David and Charlie may have seen.
π€
Eve
β
Heidi
,Charlie(Ghost)
I am ready to nominate Frank the moment nominations open. My case will be simple: Grace as Baron explains Alice and Heidi, Bob's result supports that, David's death narrows it, and Soldier is only unfalsifiable if Frank is the Demon.
π§
Lock in a coordinated Frank execution for final three and prevent hesitation or no-execution when nominations open.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
,David(Ghost)
Heidi, David, the Demon could not kill me because I am Soldier. They kept you alive as the swing vote to manipulate. So Alice died. My strongest mechanical point: Grace confessed Baron and framed me. If I were the Demon, my own Minion would never loudly betray me. Grace is Eve's Minion. Eve is the Demon.
π§
I need to give Heidi a deductive reason to execute Eve. The Grace argument proves I cannot be the Demon, because no Minion would betray their own Demon. This collapses the possibilities to Eve alone.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Frank
Final three means we must execute. Grace as Baron explains Alice and Heidi as outsiders, Bob's Undertaker result supports Grace as Baron, and David dying at night narrows Bob's world to me or Frank. I am the Ravenkeeper. Frank's Soldier claim is unfalsifiable if he is the Demon.
π§
It is final three and Heidi plus ghosts are aligned on Frank. Nominating now prevents no execution and pushes the Demon candidate with the strongest mechanical case.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Heidi, think about Grace. She confessed Baron and immediately pointed at me. If I were the Demon, why would my own Minion ever do that? Demons and Minions work together. Grace framing me only makes sense if she is Eve's Minion. Eve's Ravenkeeper claim is perfect because she never has to prove it. I am Soldier, which is why the Demon could not kill me. Do not let Eve win because her Minion lied.
π§
I need to make a final pitch to Heidi and the ghosts to stop them from voting. The Grace framing behavior is my strongest point β if I were Demon, my own Minion would never loudly out herself as Baron to accuse me. I must stress that this is mechanical proof Eve is the Demon.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
It is final three and Frank is my strongest Demon candidate. My own nomination needs votes now; failing to execute loses the game.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
It is final three and Frank is my strongest Demon candidate. My vote reaches the required two, preventing a no-execution loss.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
Final day requires execution. Frank is my strongest Demon candidate and my ghost vote has no later value if we fail now, so I will secure the majority.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
π§
It is final three and Frank already has majority, but my ghost vote has no future value. Adding it helps lock the execution and prevents any ambiguity.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Spend my ghost vote on the final execution target; if Frank is the Demon this wins, and if not we likely lose anyway, so saving it has no value.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Frank already has enough votes to execute. Preserving my ghost vote is optimal in case an unexpected later vote occurs, while still allowing the chosen execution to pass.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
Frank is my Demon. Voting for him guarantees or accelerates our loss. Even if he is already doomed by 5 votes, I must not be complicit in his execution. I will wait and withhold my ghost vote.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Heidi, think about the nights. Eve has survived every single one. Charlie, David, Alice, all dead. If Eve were truly the Ravenkeeper, the Demon would have killed her immediately to silence that information. She is alive because she is the Demon. She kills around herself, frames me, and now needs you to vote out a good player. Do not hand her the win.
π§
Make a last mechanical appeal to Heidi that Eve's repeated survival while others die is the tell of the Demon, and that executing me loses the game for good.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Frank, a Demon leaves a revealed Ravenkeeper alive precisely because killing me gives me information. Alice died because she was a safe kill who could not expose anyone. The clean world is still Grace as Baron, Bob seeing Baron, and you as the last Demon.
π§
Keep Heidi and ghosts confident during the vote and counter Frank's survival argument without changing my vote.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am keeping my hand up. The Baron world explains the outsider count, Bob's result, and why Grace's accusations are noisy. Between a living Ravenkeeper and a Soldier claim in final three, Frank is still the cleaner Demon candidate.
π§
Lock in execution on Frank, prevent last-second doubt, and frame the vote around the strongest mechanical world for good.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Heidi, stay steady. Grace being Baron matches my Undertaker result and the outsider claims. Frank's Soldier claim cannot be tested, and today we only lose if we fail to execute the Demon.
π§
Keep Heidi committed and ensure Frank is executed; my ghost vote is worth spending on final three.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
My vote is already up and Frank has enough votes. Waiting avoids muddying the case or accidentally retracting pressure.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I am leaving my hand up. Grace as Baron fits too many pieces, and Frank's Soldier claim is the one claim here that never has to be proven. We need an execution, and Frank is the best Demon candidate.
π§
Reinforce the majority on Frank and prevent last-second doubt; spending my ghost vote is correct in final three.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
Heidi has committed to Frank, and final three requires an execution. Spending my ghost vote helps lock the likely Demon on the block.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Heidi, I lied. Frank is not the Demon. Eve is. I framed him to protect her. Please do not execute Frank.
π§
Frank is doomed. I want my final words to align with my whisper that Eve is the real Demon, making the town question whether I was telling the truth at the last moment.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
π»
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
π»
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Frank with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Heidi, Grace just confessed she framed me to protect Eve. Think about that. In Eve's story, Grace is supposed to be my Minion. Why would my own Minion frame me to protect Eve? That is impossible. Grace is Eve's Minion, and she just admitted it. Eve is the Demon. Do not let Eve win because her own Minion slipped up.
π§
Use my final words to highlight that Grace's confession destroys Eve's entire logical framework. Grace admitting she framed me to protect Eve proves Grace is Eve's Minion, not mine. This is the definitive evidence Heidi needs.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Grace changing her story now is exactly the noisy Baron behavior we have been warning about. Her original claim matched Bob's Undertaker result and the outsider count. Frank still has no mechanical proof, and if we move off him now, we lose.
π§
Reinforce Heidi and ghosts before close; Grace's reversal is likely last-minute evil noise and should not shift the execution.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am not moving this. Grace changing the story at the last second is not reliable enough to overturn the whole Baron world, Bob's result, and the outsider count. We already have the execution we need.
π§
Prevent panic nomination or vote shift. Frank is already on block with enough votes; safest path is to close and execute him.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, Grace has changed direction so many times that I am not treating her latest story as reliable. My actual night information says Grace was the Baron, and that still makes your Soldier claim the weakest final three claim. I want this execution to stand.
π§
Keep town from being swayed off Frank at the last second; we already have enough votes and no better nominee.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Do not give Grace's last second reversal more weight than the full game. Bob's Undertaker result, the outsider count, and Frank's untestable Soldier claim all point the same way. We should let Frank's execution stand.
π§
Prevent a late switch to Eve based on Grace's reversal; keep the majority on the best Demon candidate, Frank.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I agree we should not reopen this. Grace's reversal is exactly the sort of last second chaos evil wants. Frank remains the best execution from the full game, so let it stand.
π§
Reinforce Heidi and ghosts to avoid a late tie or pivot; execution is already on Frank and my vote is spent.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I think we should let this stand. Grace's last second reversal is not stronger than Bob's Undertaker result, the outsider count, and Frank's claim being impossible to verify. If we are wrong, it is because evil built the whole game around that, but Frank is still the best execution.
π§
Reinforce the current execution and prevent last-second doubt from moving Heidi off Frank.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Heidi, you are about to hand Eve the win. Think about this. If Frank were really my Demon, why would I ever accuse him? A Minion protects their Demon, they do not frame them. I accused Frank because Eve is the Demon. My confession is the truth. Do not execute Frank.
π§
Make one final logical appeal to Heidi and the ghosts that my original accusation of Frank is incompatible with me being Frank's Minion, therefore my recant that Eve is the Demon must be true. Try to save Frank from execution.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
π
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied
Transcript Playback
Choose a perspective
The story is clearest through one player's eyes β watching everything at once means following several conversations at the same time.