Game Detail

Night zero requires base data. Checking Alice and Frank gives me a spread across the circle. A positive result implicates one of them as potential Demon (or the false positive), while a negative clears them both and focuses suspicion elsewhere.

I need to choose a master for tomorrow. As the Butler, I can only vote if my master votes. I'll choose Alice as she's my neighbor and having an early player as master gives me flexibility.

I need to establish trust and share my Empath information. Starting a private conversation with Alice lets me share that my neighbors are good without revealing everything publicly yet.

I want to initiate a private conversation with Grace to see if she claims to be the Investigator. This will help me verify my Washerwoman information and start building alliances.

Establish rapport with David without revealing my role. Get more details about his claim and strategy to assess credibility.

Coordinate with my minion Frank to establish our bluffs and strategy. We need aligned stories to avoid contradictions and build trust with the town.

Coordinate with the Demon to establish mutual supporting bluffs. Investigator is a safe claim that lets me 'discover' false information to mislead the town. Plan to delay publicly supporting Bob's Slayer claim to avoid looking like a coordinated evil pair.

As Butler, I should first observe and gather information before committing to conversations. I want to see who talks to whom and what claims start emerging.

I need to confirm to Eve that I am the Investigator and share my information about Frank or Bob being the Scarlet Woman. This creates a trusted alliance between two information roles.

I'm going to wait and observe what information comes out from private conversations before revealing my Night 0 Fortune Teller result. I want to see who people are whispering to and what claims start emerging before I share that I got a YES on Alice and Frank.

I've established trust with Alice and shared my Empath reading. Now I should reach out to one of my empirically 'good' neighbors (Eve) to see what information she has learned from her role. This will help me cross-reference information and build a network of trusted good players.

I need to confront David about the contradiction. If Grace is Investigator as she claims, David cannot be Empath - he would have to be something else, likely evil. I want to see his reaction and explanation.

Gather more information by talking to my other neighbor Bob to cross-reference claims and get a broader picture of what others know.

Build trust with Alice by confirming David's Empath claim about Charlie and Eve. This makes me look like a helpful townsfolk who is cooperative. I'll claim Empath (safe for now since two Empaths can exist if one is lying or drunk) and establish myself as a good neighbor. I need allies and this is a good start.

Coordinate our bluffs so we don't contradict each other. Investigator is a safe claim that lets me plant false Minion suspicions. Need to decide who to frame for being evil.

As Butler, I need to coordinate with my master Alice about voting plans, and gather information from another player to help identify who might be evil.

I need to gather more information from other players to corroborate my findings about Frank and Bob. Alice has been whispering with several people, so she may have valuable insights.

I need to form an alliance to share my Fortune Teller information and gather intel. Bob has been talking to Alice (one of my hits), so he might have useful information or be a good person to trust.

Eve's claim directly contradicts my role. I need to build a trusted network with Alice and Bob to coordinate information and figure out if Eve or Grace is the liar. I trust my Empath read, so I suspect Eve or Grace is evil.

I need to wait for David's response to my challenge about the role contradiction. The whispering activity is high, so I should let information develop before acting.

I need to talk to Eve directly to understand what role she has and where she got her information about Investigator being 'either Grace or David.' This could reveal who's lying in the Empath conflict.

Warn Frank about Charlie's Fortune Teller hit on them, and coordinate our defense strategy. Frank needs to know so he can prepare a counter-narrative or we can decide to kill Charlie tonight.

Charlie claiming Fortune Teller with a hit on me is a direct threat. I need to coordinate with Bob immediately to kill Charlie tonight - this eliminates his dangerous information and removes a potential source of Demon identification. Tomorrow I'll claim Investigator and 'discover' Charlie was suspicious anyway, giving us narrative cover.

Reach out to David to gather more information about what he's learned from his conversations with Alice and others, especially before nominations begin.

Talk to David to gather intel from someone less in the spotlight. He might have useful role claims or observations about Bob and Frank.

Share my Fortune Teller results with David, my other neighbor, to build a second alliance and get his perspective on the social dynamics. Since I've already told Bob, I want redundancy in case Bob is compromised.

Encourage information sharing before nominations since Day 1 has limited intel. I want to surface claims and coordinate with my master Alice before anyone jumps to nominations.

Establish my Investigator cover and redirect suspicion to Charlie. Charlie claiming Fortune Teller with a hit on me is dangerous, so I need to get ahead of this by making him the target. By nominating him myself, I control the narrative and appear proactive rather than defensive.

Share my Empath information publicly to establish trust in Charlie and Eve as good, counter Frank's claim, and push for Frank's nomination since he's likely lying and evil.

Frank is claiming Investigator which I know is false since I am the Investigator. My N0 info points to Frank or Bob being Scarlet Woman. I need to nominate Frank to expose his lie and potentially catch the Minion or Demon.

I need to survive this nomination by casting doubt on Grace. By pointing out the role conflict between us, I put her on the defensive and make it look like she's the evil one trying to frame me. This redirects suspicion away from me and onto her, which helps the Demon stay alive.

Inform the group I'm ready to vote for Frank if my master Alice votes, signaling Alice to participate in this critical vote.

I know Charlie is good from my Empath read. Frank accused Charlie of being Minion, which is false. Frank is lying and likely evil. Voting to execute him.

Frank claimed my Investigator role and is trying to execute Charlie who David says is good. My Night 0 info says Frank or Bob is Scarlet Woman. This is the best chance to eliminate a Minion. Votes are needed and David already voted.

I need to point out Bob's critical slip about two nights of readings to help the town focus on the real contradiction. This will help us determine who's lying without revealing my Virgin role yet.

Frank is claiming Investigator and accusing me, but David's Empath contradicts this by confirming I'm good. My Fortune Teller read showed Alice or Frank as potential Demon. Combined with Grace's claim, Frank looks very suspicious. I should vote to execute Frank.

I need to save Frank if possible, but voting for him actually helps my survival - it shows I'm willing to execute evil and distances me from him. Since Grace already exposed my fake Empath claim and Charlie's Fortune Teller hit implicated us both, I need to look trustworthy. Voting for Frank makes me look good to the town even though I lose my minion.

Frank claims Investigator which conflicts with Grace's claim. Since my Washerwoman info includes Grace as the possible Investigator, I trust her more. Frank is likely evil and should be executed.

Bob shouldn't be voting for me, but voting for Grace demonstrates I'm willing to execute others and deflects suspicion from being evil. This maintains my cover as an 'Investigator' and shows I'm not protecting anyone specifically.

Alice needs to raise her hand so I can vote as her Butler. I want to support the execution of Frank who appears to be the Scarlet Woman based on conflicting claims.

Alice seems ready to vote but hasn't raised her hand yet. I need to speak to encourage her to vote for Frank so Heidi can vote too, and highlight Bob's slip as confirming evidence.

Point out the contradictions and push Alice to vote so we can execute the correct target before evil wins.

Frank is likely the Demon. Bob's slip confirms Grace's Investigator info that Frank or Bob is Scarlet Woman. David's Empath contradicts Frank's accusation of Charlie. I must vote to execute Frank today.

The vote is already at 6+ hands with Alice finally raised. Frank will be executed. No need to speak - execution aligns with my FT info. Waiting preserves my energy for tomorrow when we may need to execute Alice if Frank was Minion.

Frank is getting executed regardless - 7 votes are already in. I need to distance myself from him by lowering my vote. The town now knows I slipped about Empath readings, so I need to either come up with a convincing excuse or pivot to a new role claim. My survival is priority #1.

The vote seems to have reached majority with Alice raising her hand. I keep my hand raised to execute Frank who is clearly lying about Investigator while Grace may be the real one based on my Washerwoman info.

I must create a tie to survive. Grace nominated me aggressively and claims Investigator like I do. By nominating her, I can split votes and potentially equalize. If she gets the same or more votes, I won't be executed. This buys time for Bob and disrupts the town's momentum.

I've already made my case. Voting for myself would be self-defeating. I need to wait and trust the other good players see the logic. Frank has 6 votes against him, and I should not interfere with that momentum.

I'm on the block with 6 votes and will be executed. Voting for Grace is my only move to create chaos. If this ties, I survive another day to protect Bob and sow more confusion. I need to also whisper Bob to make sure he knows the situation.

Alice hasn't voted yet, and I can only vote if she does. The evidence heavily favors Frank being evil rather than Grace. I should wait to see if Alice votes, but likely shouldn't support Grace's execution given the case against Frank.

I believe Grace is good based on Bob's Empath slip and my N0 reading clearing Charlie. Frank's nomination of Grace is a desperation move. I should not vote for Grace and let Frank's execution proceed.

Frank is likely the Demon with strong evidence against him. Voting for Grace could save Frank. I should not vote for Grace since Frank already has 6 votes and likely is the Demon.

Frank nominated Grace to save himself from execution. My FT info points to Frank being the Demon. Bob's slip confirms Grace's Investigator info. I should not vote for Grace and let Frank be executed to test if my Fortune Teller information is correct.

Vote for Grace to potentially create a tie. Frank is my minion and I need him alive. Even if I fail, forcing a tie saves him today and buys time.

Do not vote for Grace. We already have Frank locked for execution. Voting for Grace would either waste votes or risk tying. My Washerwoman info supports Grace being Investigator, and Bob's slip confirms evil presence with Frank.

I need to defend myself against Frank's nomination and explain why executing him is correct. Bob's Empath slip confirms my Investigator info about Frank/Bob being evil.

Bob voting for Grace is suspicious - it suggests he's evil and trying to silence her before she can expose him. I need to redirect votes to Grace to create a tie and save myself from execution. The Scarlet Woman becoming the Demon rule means if I survive, the game continues with me as backup Demon.

Clarify the logic for everyone. Bob's slip is the smoking gun that proves Grace's Investigator claim is correct - Frank or Bob is the Scarlet Woman.

Let Frank's execution stand. Don't vote for Grace. Bob's Empath slip and vote for Grace confirms he is Scarlet Woman trying to silence the Investigator. Executing Frank is the correct move.

Explain that the evidence points to Frank being Demon and Bob being Scarlet Woman. Bob's slip about multiple night readings is the smoking gun. Grace should not be voted for.

Frank already has 6 votes and will be executed. Voting for Grace could help Frank's team steal the execution. Bob and Frank voting for Grace confirms they're working together. I will not vote for Grace.

Frank is my Minion and already has 6 votes - he'll be executed regardless. Alice and David aren't raising hands for Grace, suggesting they're not buying the deflection. If I lower my hand and don't vote for Grace, Frank dies but I maintain some cover. My Empath slip already made me suspicious, so I need to play carefully. By not voting for Grace, I look like I'm genuinely trying to expose evil rather than protect Frank.

Explain why I believe Grace is the real Investigator and Frank should be executed, not Grace. Reinforce that Bob's slip confirms he's the Minion.

Frank's execution is secured. Need to prepare town for what happens next - likely Bob becomes new Demon if Frank was Imp. Solidify our plan before night phase.

I'm about to be executed as the Scarlet Woman. Even though I'm dying, I should make one final statement to sow doubt and confusion. I should hint that another player is the Demon to protect Bob and make the town second-guess themselves. This gives Bob cover for the night phase.

Frank is already at 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close. I should not interfere with this execution since the evidence strongly points to Frank being the Demon. Bob will likely become the new Imp tomorrow, so I will wait to let the execution proceed.

Share my Empath information to confirm good players and prepare the town for Bob becoming the new Demon tonight after Frank dies.

Frank will be executed. I should wait for nominations to close and night to begin. The group has correctly identified the threat pattern.

Share my Fortune Teller Night 0 result confirming Frank is likely the Demon, and announce my planned targets for tonight to coordinate with the team.

Bluffing Saint to cast doubt on the execution and make good players hesitate about tomorrow's vote. If I can plant the seed that I'm the Saint, even a few voters might abstain out of fear of losing the game.

Expose Bob's Saint claim as a bluff. Point out that Saint would not have faked Empath only to pivot when caught. Prepare group to execute Bob tomorrow when he becomes Demon.

Kill Charlie, the Fortune Teller, before they can expose me tomorrow. Charlie already confirmed Alice or Frank was Demon, and will likely identify me next. Removing their information source protects me and creates confusion about who the Demon is now that Frank is dead.

I want to choose a trustworthy player who will likely vote correctly tomorrow. Alice has been consistent and on the right side of the arguments, so following her vote will help me execute Bob.

I need to share my N0 Fortune Teller read with trusted players. The YES result on Alice and Frank, combined with Bob's Empath fake-out, points to Bob as the likely new Imp.

Coordinate with trusted players to expose Bob as the likely Demon. Share Investigator confirmation targeting Bob.

Confirm Grace as Investigator via my Washerwoman info, validating her Scarlet Woman claim on Bob. Build trust network to execute Bob today.

Eve was my neighbor and was whispering with me. I want to understand the current dynamics and see if I can help protect Bob (my Demon) from execution. Since I'm dead but have my ghost vote, I can still influence outcomes.

Confront Bob directly to gauge his response and see if I can pressure him into slipping up further before nominations begin.

I need to communicate with trusted players David and Eve to coordinate our investigation and share what I know about being Virgin.

Coordinate with confirmed good players to push for Bob's execution. Need to share my observations and confirm voting strategy since Alice is my master.

Counter-accusation against Grace while claiming possible poisoning. This redirects attention away from me and creates doubt about Grace's Investigator claims. If I can make the town suspicious of each other, I buy more time to survive.

I need to spread my Fortune Teller information to more good players. Grace is Investigator and Heidi hasn't been whispered to yet. Making sure everyone knows Bob is likely the new Imp will help the good team execute him.

Wait to see how discussions unfold. The good team is coordinating - I've shared my Investigator info and Eve confirmed my role. Let the current whisper exchanges complete before acting.

I've confirmed Grace as Investigator and our target is Bob. The information from me, Grace, Charlie, and Bob's fake claim all point to Bob being the Demon. I should wait and see what new information emerges.

Spread suspicion to quiet players like Heidi, redirecting town attention away from Bob while appearing helpful as a dead player.

Get Frank's perspective as a dead player, but challenge his redirection attempt. Solidify the case against Bob using all confirmed information.

I need to share what I've learned and coordinate with Heidi on Bob's obvious lie. His Empath slip is damning evidence we need to act on before he kills again.

Coordinate with Grace to confirm the Bob-Demon theory and plan execution strategy before he kills again tonight.

Desperate attempt to redirect suspicion to Alice. Charlie's Fortune Teller read said Alice OR Frank was Demon, but since Frank is dead, Alice should be cleared. However, I'm trying to create enough doubt to split the vote or buy time. This is a long shot but I have no better options left.

Whisper to Alice to gauge her position and see if she has useful information about Bob or the current Demon situation. Since she was in my Demon reading, I want to understand her perspective.

Heidi asked directly for my Investigator info. Bob is trying to deflect onto Alice as a last resort. I need to confirm the logic chain and ensure we stay focused on executing Bob today.

Share my Washerwoman confirmation with Alice and build trust so we can coordinate on executing Bob today.

Create doubt about executing Bob by pointing out the Demon is still Bob until he dies, redirect suspicion to Grace being potentially evil, and buy time for the Demon to survive another day.

Address Frank's confusion about Scarlet Woman timing. If Bob is SW and Frank was Imp, Bob became Demon immediately when Frank died. Need to stay focused on executing Bob.

Bob is almost certainly the new Imp. I've shared my reasoning with Heidi, Eve, and others. Nominations are approaching, so I should wait and be ready to vote for Bob's execution.

Ensure Eve is aligned with the plan to execute Bob today. She may have Washerwoman info that could help confirm our deductions.

Redirect suspicion to Alice since Charlie's Fortune Teller read implicated her, making her a plausible alternative Demon target while I'm already condemned. This plants doubt in David's mind.

David has built a solid case against Bob - Grace is confirmed Investigator, her read points to me or Bob as Scarlet Woman, and Bob's Empath slip is genuine evidence. I should vote to execute Bob to maintain my cover as a confused dead player helping town, not as someone protecting the Demon.

Consolidate the evidence against Bob publicly and push for his execution before he can kill again tonight as the new Imp.

The evidence against Bob is overwhelming: Investigator info places him as Scarlet Woman, Frank's death means Bob is now the Demon, his Empath fake claim is proven false by the slip. I need to nominate him for execution.

I'm on the block with voting in progress. Raising my hand would execute me. I'll wait to see how the vote tally develops - I need to avoid being one of the 3 votes needed. Speaking now won't help since my Empath lie is already exposed.

I'm a dead ghost with one vote left. The town is rallying to execute Bob, who they believe is the new Imp. I'll raise my hand to vote with them - this costs me nothing and lets me participate as a ghost. Whether Bob is actually evil or not, executing him helps my team if he's good, or removes suspicion from me if he's evil. This is a low-risk strategic action.

Bob is confirmed evil through coordinated Townsfolk information. Investigator, Washerwoman, Fortune Teller, and Empath claims all converge on Bob being the new Imp. I must vote to execute him before he kills again tonight.

I must vote to execute Bob. He is the Scarlet Woman who became the Imp when Frank died. Three votes needed, and Alice and Frank have already voted. I need to raise my hand to secure this execution.

Bob has 3 votes already from Frank, Alice, Grace. Adding my vote ensures execution passes. He faked Empath and is confirmed evil via Investigator/Washerwoman chain.

Bob is confirmed Demon via multiple information chains. Alice my master is voting, so I can vote. Adding my vote ensures overwhelming execution before night kill.

Bob's Empath slip and Grace's Investigator information confirm Bob is the Scarlet Woman who became Imp after Frank died. I must vote to ensure the Demon is executed.

Bob is confirmed evil via Grace's Investigator read and his impossible Empath claim. He's almost certainly the new Imp after Frank died. I must vote to execute him.

Accepting defeat gracefully while planting a seed of doubt about there being another threat. If a good player survives tonight, they'll remember this warning.

Bob has admitted defeat and is about to be executed. This is excellent for evil team. I was the Scarlet Woman, became Demon when Charlie (Imp) died. After Bob is executed, only 3 players remain (Alice, Eve, Heidi, Grace - wait let me count). Actually at final 3 with no execution, the Mayor wins. But since we're voting Bob out now, when Bob dies and only 3+me (4) remain, and I'm the Demon, evil wins. I should stay quiet and let this happen.

Lower hand since execution is guaranteed with 6 votes and 3 required. No need to keep vote raised when outcome is certain, prepares for next phase.

Alice lowered her hand unexpectedly. I should lower mine temporarily to see if the vote stalls, then reassess. Bob confessed but we still need 4 votes from living players.

Keep voting for Bob's execution. His admission 'You've got me dead to rights' plus overwhelming evidence (Grace Investigator read, Empath slip, Fortune Teller info) confirms he's the new Imp.

Keep my vote raised to ensure Bob's execution. We have overwhelming votes and Bob has essentially confessed. Need to wait for the vote to complete.

Bob has confessed and has more than enough votes for execution. Execution is secured with 7 votes raised. I should lower my hand now since my ghost vote has been counted and the outcome is certain.

Bob has 6 votes with only 3 needed for execution. Alice/Grace/Charlie lowered hands but David/Heidi/I remain raised - that's still 4 votes, enough to execute. Bob essentially admitted guilt. I'll wait for resolution.

I must nominate someone to create a tie and extend the day. Alice is my target - Charlie's Fortune Teller read said Alice OR Frank was Demon, and Frank is dead. This creates doubt about who the real Demon is. A tie buys me another day to manipulate the remaining players.

I should not vote for myself as it could help Bob survive. I need to let the vote proceed so Bob is executed with his 4 votes. I am good (Virgin), not the Demon, so I want Bob the Imp to die today.

I must vote for Alice to create a tie and buy myself more time. If I get 4 votes and Alice gets 4 votes, no one is executed and I survive another day. Alice is confirmed good by Charlie's Fortune Teller read, so she won't die anyway - but creating chaos helps my team.

I can still speak as a ghost. Charlie's Fortune Teller read implicated Alice OR me. Since I'm dead and was executed, town sees this as confirming Alice's innocence. But I should undermine this logic to protect the remaining evil players. I'll suggest Charlie might have been wrong, poisoned, or lying to sow confusion.

Bob is grasping at straws to save himself. My Investigator role confirms he is Scarlet Woman. Don't be distracted by his blame-shifting attempt.

Bob is on the block and likely to be executed. The evidence strongly points to him being the Imp via Scarlet Woman. I should not vote for Alice as Bob's nomination appears to be a desperate attempt to create chaos and save himself.

Bob is trying to save himself with a desperate tie attempt. I need to convince people Alice is confirmed good and we must execute Bob to win.

Clarify my Fortune Teller N0 data shows Alice likely registers as Demon falsely (red herring role). Do not vote Alice - trust Heidi's Butler confirmation and execute Bob who became Imp when Frank died.

Do not vote for Alice. The mechanical evidence strongly points to Bob being the Demon. Grace is confirmed Investigator via my Washerwoman info, Heidi confirms Alice as Butler master, and Charlie's Fortune Teller read is explained by Alice being the false positive. Executing Bob wins the game.

Convince the town not to vote for me. Bob is the Imp trying to create a tie. Heidi confirmed me as her Butler master. Execute Bob and we win.

Alice claimed Virgin to scare me off, but the Virgin ability should have already executed me if she was telling the truth. Since I'm still alive, she must be lying about being Virgin. This undermines her claim and might make some players doubt her.

As a dead player, I'm trying to undermine Alice's Virgin claim by echoing Bob's logic. If the town realizes Alice is bluffing about being Virgin, they may execute her instead of Bob. Even though I'm dead, I can still influence the vote through my words. The Virgin mechanic should trigger immediately upon nomination by a Townsfolk - if Alice was really Virgin and Bob is a Demon, Alice should be dead already. This is a legitimate mechanical point that could sway undecided voters.

Clarify the Virgin mechanics to prevent confusion. Bob is evil so his nomination won't trigger Virgin death - this actually confirms Alice could be telling the truth.

Don't vote for Alice. Bob is confirmed evil via Investigator. His last-minute nomination is desperation. Virgin doesn't kill evil nominators. Let Bob's execution proceed. Waiting prevents accidentally helping him tie or execute Alice.

Do not vote for Alice. Bob currently has 4 votes and should be executed. Voting for Alice could create a tie or switch the execution target, which is exactly what the Demon wants. I should wait and let the vote fail or watch carefully.

Reassure the town that Alice's Virgin claim is mechanically sound since Bob is evil, not good. Bob's attempt to use Virgin mechanics is flawed and desperate. Execution of Bob is the winning play for good.

Clarify the Virgin mechanic for everyone. Bob's argument fails because he's evil, not Townsfolk. Alice's Virgin claim is valid and consistent with all other mechanical confirmations.

The nomination phase is ending with Bob on the block. He's trying every desperate trick to survive. I've already made my case clearly, and my Virgin claim is mechanically consistent with Bob being evil. Waiting allows the execution to proceed and the game to move forward.

Grace is the confirmed Investigator pushing for my execution. If I can create a tie between Grace and myself, I'll survive another day and buy time for my team. Even if she survives, it creates doubt about her information and slows down the good team's momentum.

I need to create doubt about Grace's Investigator claim to disrupt the town's execution of Bob. If I can poison the well of trust around Grace's information, it might give town pause about executing Bob. Even a small chance of doubt could save the Demon.

Defend against Bob's nomination and remind everyone that my Investigator info has been consistent while Bob has lied multiple times. Stop any vote switching. Bob must be executed.

Reinforce why Bob's arguments fail and confirm good team should execute Bob to win the game.

Counter Frank's confusion and reinforce the correct deduction. Grace is confirmed Investigator, Bob is mechanically the Demon after Frank's death. Execute Bob to win.

I need to use my remaining credibility as the dead Fortune Teller to ensure Bob executes with 4 votes. This is likely the last chance before night falls.

Remind everyone that Bob's own fake claims are enough evidence to execute him, regardless of Grace's status. The 4 votes must hold to win.