Game Detail

Establish contact with my Minion (Bob) on Day 1, share safe bluffs, and coordinate our claims to avoid overlapping and look believable.

Initiating a private conversation with Eve to build trust and gather early information. As the Saint, forming alliances with neighbors protects me from being falsely executed.

Coordinate with Alice (the Demon) by telling her my role is Baron, suggesting safe bluffs for her (Soldier or Slayer), and deciding on my bluff.

Frank initiated contact asking about information. My Washerwoman info identifying the Librarian is safe to share and starts building information chains for the good team.

Observe early whispers and player behaviors to gather initial reads before committing to a conversation.

Share my Investigator info with Heidi to build a trusted alliance. She can help me verify and act on this critical piece of information about Bob or Charlie being the Spy.

Share my Librarian info with Bob to build trust and gather his role claim.

Share my Chef information with neighbor Frank to establish early trust and gather other claims to solve the puzzle of two evil pairs.

Confirming my bluff as Soldier and approving Bob's bluff as Saint to coordinate our evil team strategy.

Flag Grace's mathematically impossible Chef claim to Eve. Coordinate verification of both claims. Build trust with Eve while protecting myself as Saint.

I am replying to Charlie's whisper. I am claiming Saint, which is an Outsider, to set up the Baron count and discourage people from executing me.

Approach Charlie to verify my Washerwoman info. If Charlie claims Librarian, it confirms my info and proves Charlie is likely good.

Respond to David's private whisper to build an alliance while withholding my exact role. Share that I'm an Outsider to encourage trust without revealing I'm the Recluse, which could make me look suspicious if checked by good abilities.

Eve whispered with Charlie, so she may have useful info about him. Sharing my Investigator result with her could help us narrow down which of Bob or Charlie is the Spy.

Respond to Eve's request for my role. Sharing Librarian is low-risk. I need to learn what info she claims to have about me to evaluate whether she's truthful or fishing.

Share my Chef info with my neighbor Heidi to establish trust and gather her role info. This helps build a network of trusted players and may reveal contradictions.

Coordinating with my minion Bob before nominations begin to gather town claims.

Verify Eve's Washerwoman claim against Charlie's actual role, and gauge Charlie's reaction to Grace's impossible Chef reading to help identify evil players.

To update Alice, my Demon, on the current claims and my bluff. Charlie claimed Librarian with Heidi/Eve as Recluse, and I claimed Saint to him.

Coordinate with David since his Investigator claim about Bob/Charlie being Spy connects to Charlie suspiciously claiming Librarian which the Spy would know from seeing the Grimoire.

Probe Grace's suspicious Chef claim while sharing David's Investigator info to build a fuller picture of what's happening.

Eve's info strongly supports Charlie being the Spy. I want to confirm I trust her analysis and suggest we watch both Bob and Charlie. I should also consider talking to Charlie directly to gauge his reaction.

Confirm my Librarian role to Frank, validate Eve's Washerwoman claim, and raise suspicion about Grace's mathematically impossible Chef claim of 2 pairs.

To verify David's claim by asking Bob for his role and any info, which could expose a lie or confirm the Spy.

Day 1 with only two unverified claims is too risky for execution. We need more information from other players before committing to a nomination.

Share my Chef info publicly to gather reactions and see if anyone else has contradicting info. This will help determine if I'm Drunk or if the setup is unusual.

Defend myself against David's Investigator claim by claiming Saint, pointing out the false info, and suggesting David is the Drunk due to a high Outsider count from a Baron.

Grace's Chef claim of 2 pairs is mathematically impossible with 2 evil players. She must be the Demon. Nominating her now to get an execution before night.

Defend against Eve's nomination by explaining that an impossible reading suggests I'm the Drunk, not the Demon. This keeps me alive and allows good to investigate further.

Challenge the logic that Grace must be evil because her reading is impossible. Point out that being Drunk also explains impossible info. Express skepticism about David's claim given the Outsider claims. Avoid voting prematurely.

I want to vote for Grace to secure the execution of a good player (who claims Chef 2, likely the Drunk or just wrong). This helps the evil team by getting a good player executed and keeping our Demon, Alice, safe.

Grace's impossible Chef reading is strong evidence she's evil or Drunk. Given the other claims and my Washerwoman info pointing to Charlie as Librarian, executing Grace is the safest play. If she's Demon, we win. If she's Drunk, we lose a good player but can still win. I must vote to execute.

Raise doubt about executing Grace. Explain she's likely Drunk, not Demon. Push for investigation of Bob/Charlie instead. Avoid wasting execution on good player.

Vote to execute Grace because her Chef 2 pairs claim is mathematically impossible in an 8-player game with only two evil players. This strongly suggests she's the Demon trying to appear as Drunk. Executing her tests this theory and removes a likely evil player.

Grace's claim is impossible, making her either the Drunk or the Demon. Executing her tests her alignment and could win the game if she's evil. It's a calculated risk.

To secure the execution of Grace, who has made an impossible claim (Chef 2 in an 8-player game) and is highly suspicious, by adding my vote to the tally.

Defend myself by explaining that impossible reading suggests Drunk, not Demon. Request information about who the real Chef might be.

We have two conflicting impossible claims: Grace's Chef reading and David's Investigator info. Only one can be Drunk. We need to resolve this before executing Grace.

To push for the execution of Grace (a good player, likely the Drunk or Chef) by using pro-town logic (executing a useless Drunk is safe, confirms info, or catches the Demon), which helps the evil team progress the game while keeping myself looking like a cooperative good player.

Reinforce the case for executing Grace as Demon while acknowledging Drunk possibility. Highlight the Undertaker value and the logical inconsistency of two Drunks.

Convince others that executing Grace is risky because she's likely Drunk, not Demon. Advocate for focusing on Bob or Charlie who match my Investigator info.

Argue that executing Grace is low risk. If she's Drunk, she's a liability with no ability. If she's Demon, we win. Undertaker can confirm. Safer than risking Demon slipping away.

I have already raised my hand to vote for Grace. The vote is in progress. I should wait for others to act. I want to see if the vote reaches majority. If Grace is executed, Undertaker can check her role. This provides valuable info. I am Saint, so I must avoid execution myself.

To push for the execution of Grace, who is likely a good player (the Drunk or Chef), and protect my Minion Bob by redirecting town's attention away from David's Investigator ping on him.

I need to argue for my life. If executed, town loses a potential Drunk (harmless) or Demon (win). But if I'm Drunk, execution wastes a day and confirms nothing. I should push for investigating David's claims instead.

Nominate David to test his claim. If he's lying, he's likely evil. If he's telling truth, we can trust his info about Bob/Charlie.

Defend myself against the nomination. My Investigator info is real, but if I am Drunk, it is false. I need to explain that executing me loses a Townsfolk and we should investigate Bob/Charlie instead.

Voting to execute David tests his claim. If he's the real Investigator, his info about Bob/Charlie being Spy is critical. If he's lying or Drunk, removing him helps narrow down evils.

Compare two impossible claims. Grace's Chef reading (2 evil pairs) is impossible. David's info (Bob or Charlie as Spy) conflicts with their Outsider claims. Only one can be Drunk. We need to test both claims.

Cast doubt on David's investigator claim while keeping the focus on executing Grace, who is currently on the block.

Support Grace's execution as she claimed impossible info and defense as Drunk is weak. David's investigation into Bob/Charlie should be tested, but Grace is the safer vote today.

David's claim is suspicious since his info points to me (real Librarian) or Bob (claiming Saint) as Spy. But Grace's claim is mathematically impossible, making her either Demon or Drunk. Executing Grace is safer: if she's Demon we win, if she's Drunk we remove liability. I'll vote to execute David to test his claim and see if he's the Drunk.

I must expose Bob's false Saint claim to protect my team. Bob is claiming my role, which means he's lying about his identity and likely evil.

To cast suspicion on Frank's late Saint claim and defend my minion Bob's claim.

I must vote to avoid being executed. If I'm executed, the good team loses a player and my Investigator info is ignored. Better to risk executing Grace (who might be Drunk) than myself. Frank's Saint counterclaim complicates things but doesn't change my immediate survival.

I am pointing out the logical deduction that since I must be Drunk (my info is impossible), David's info must be true, and the conflict between Bob and Frank suggests Bob is likely the evil one.

Grace is already on the block with 5 votes. I will not vote for David — his Investigator info is valuable and we can test Bob/Frank's Saint conflict tomorrow. Let Grace's execution proceed.

I want to defend my Saint bluff against Frank's late counter-claim, point out his inconsistency (he voted for Grace earlier), and keep the vote on Grace (the sober Chef) so she gets executed instead of David.

I need to decide whether to keep my hand raised for David's execution or lower it. Grace is already on the block with 5 votes. The Saint conflict between Bob and Frank needs investigation. If Grace is Drunk, executing her removes a liability; if Demon, we win. David's execution might be premature if he's real Investigator.

Argue that executing Grace is safe because she's either the Drunk (liability) or the Demon (win). The Saint conflict needs resolution but doesn't change Grace's execution being optimal.

I need to defend my real Saint role and redirect execution from Grace to Bob. Bob is claiming my role falsely, and David's Investigator info points to him as possible Spy. Executing Grace is a mistake.

I want to see if the vote on David succeeds without my help, or if we should let Grace remain on the block. Grace is currently on the block with 5 votes. I don't want to tie the vote and risk no execution, so I will wait and see how the town responds to the Saint dispute.

Summarize the situation: Grace is on block, Bob vs Frank Saint conflict. Argue Grace execution is safe if she's Drunk, but Bob/Charlie Spy conflict needs resolution. Push for information sharing before final vote.

Push for executing Bob instead of myself, using logic that I must be Drunk and Bob is lying about Saint.

Push for executing Grace despite the debate. If she's Drunk, we remove a liability and get Undertaker info. If she's Demon, we win. It's safer than pivoting to Bob last minute.

Support Heidi's push to keep Grace on the block and ensure her execution, while casting doubt on the last-minute claims of Frank and David.

Weigh the risks: Grace's execution is safe (either Demon or Drunk). The Saint conflict is real but can wait. We need Undertaker info on Grace to confirm her role. I should advocate for executing Grace today to get that information.

We need to decide between executing Grace now or pivoting to Bob. The safest play is to execute Grace because if she's Demon we win, and if she's Drunk we remove liability and get Undertaker info. We can investigate Bob tomorrow.

Grace is on the block with 5 votes and will be executed unless there's a tie or surpassed. As the real Saint, I must avoid execution at all costs. My late claim has made me suspicious, but pushing too hard to save Grace could backfire. Waiting lets the town decide and avoids drawing more suspicion to myself.

I want to support the consensus to execute Grace. This secures a day one execution on a good player and protects my minion Bob from being executed today, shifting the focus to tomorrow.

Kill David to silence the Investigator who holds a ping on my minion Bob, disrupting the town's mechanical solve and protecting Bob from execution.

Share Washerwoman info with Charlie privately. If he's real Librarian, he can confirm and we establish trust. If he doesn't claim Librarian, Heidi must be Librarian and Charlie becomes suspicious.

Gather David's perspective on his Investigator info now that he's dead. He might have more insight after seeing night actions.

Share my real Saint role with Eve to build trust and gather info. Ask about Undertaker to verify Grace's character, which helps resolve the Drunk claim and narrows evil players.

I want to coordinate with my Demon, Alice, now that Day 2 has started and David is dead. I want to align on our strategy against Frank's Saint counter-claim.

Share reasoning with Alice to build a case against Bob, who I suspect based on David's Investigator info and Frank's Saint claim. Need allies to push for execution.

Grace asked me directly about my investigator info. As a dead player with valuable info, I should share my current suspicions to help the town. I need to guide them toward solving the Spy mystery and Saint conflict.

Confirm my role to Eve to build trust and get her info. She claims Washerwoman with my name, which aligns with my Librarian claim. Sharing info will help us solve the game.

Coordinate with my minion Bob to confirm the night kill, align on my Undertaker bluff, and focus our efforts on executing Frank (the suspected real Saint) for an instant win.

Build alliance with Charlie and work through Outsider count logic to identify contradictions that reveal evil players.

Share David's continued belief that Bob is the Spy with Frank, who counter-claimed Saint against Bob. Build coalition to execute Bob.

Gather Alice's role claim and find Undertaker info to verify Grace's execution result. This helps confirm Bob's evil alignment and narrow down the Demon.

Coordinate with my Demon (Alice) to execute Frank, who is highly likely the real Saint (since I am the only Minion and Alice is the Demon, Frank's Saint claim must be genuine). If we execute the real Saint, evil wins immediately.

Discuss with Alice why Bob is the most suspicious player based on David's Investigator claim and his night death. We need to coordinate to nominate Bob.

Directly ask Charlie for role claim to resolve Investigator info. This will help determine if Bob or Charlie is the Spy.

David asked for my role claim. I'm sharing my Librarian info and reasoning about Bob being Spy and Frank potentially being the Imp.

Claim Undertaker to Frank and confirm Grace was the Drunk. This builds deep trust with Frank (the real Saint) and fits the Baron setup perfectly, allowing me to manipulate him and the town later.

Share critical logical deduction with Frank. The outsider count proves Charlie must be the Spy if Frank is real Saint, since 2 outsiders without Baron is impossible. This helps Frank trust me and coordinate.

Gather Charlie's role claim to see if he matches David's suspicion. If Charlie claims a good role, we can compare with Bob/Frank conflict.

Respond to Eve's excellent logic analysis. Confirm Charlie as Spy, Bob as Demon is most likely. Reveal that Alice told me she's Undertaker and saw Grace as Drunk, which creates an Outsider count problem - this suggests Alice might be lying. Push for Bob's execution today since he's definitely evil.

I want to convince Charlie that Frank is evil (Demon/Minion) pretending to be the Saint, so that town will execute Frank (who is likely the real Saint, giving us an immediate win).

I want to build support for nominating Bob today. Eve has been reasonable and voted with the town. Getting her support is crucial for a successful execution.

Gather Alice's role claim to complete the picture of all players' roles and identify inconsistencies.

Share Baron theory with Eve to build a unified case against Bob before nominations. Eve is my strongest ally and her info corroborates mine.

Claim Undertaker to David and tell him Grace was the Drunk. This discredits Frank's Saint claim (since Grace is the Drunk, there is no room for another Outsider), which encourages the town to execute Frank. Since Frank is the real Saint, executing him will win the game for evil.

Push for Bob's execution based on David's info and Saint conflict. As dead Chef, I can influence without being a target.

To get Frank executed. Since Frank counter-claimed Saint, in a 3-outsider Baron game he is almost certainly the real Saint. Executing him will trigger the Saint's penalty and win the game for the evil team immediately. Calling him a fake Saint encourages town to vote him off safely.

Convince players not to execute me since I'm the real Saint and execution means instant loss for good. Redirect execution toward Bob who is lying about Saint and matches David's evil info.

Prevent good team from losing by executing the real Saint. Redirect focus to Bob who David's info implicates as possible Spy, and who suspiciously nominated another Saint claim.

Frank is the real Saint and executing him wins us the game on the spot. I nominated him, so I must vote for him to push the execution through.

Warn all living players not to execute Frank due to Saint risk. My info points to Bob as the Spy. We should vote this down and execute Bob instead.

I must stop the Frank execution. If Frank is the real Saint, good loses immediately. The evidence overwhelmingly points to Bob being the Spy. I need to rally votes against Bob instead.

Explain why Baron theory makes Bob the Demon and Frank the real Saint. Executing Frank risks instant game loss. We must vote this down and execute Bob instead.

To distance myself from Bob's nomination of Frank, build trust with the good team by agreeing not to risk a Saint execution, and avoid outing myself since we do not have enough votes to execute Frank anyway.

Urging the group not to execute Frank because killing the real Saint means instant loss. Bob is the clear evil target based on multiple lines of evidence.

Prevent my execution which would instantly lose the game for good. Reinforce that Bob is evil and we should execute him instead.

I'm dead but have my ghost vote. Executing Frank risks instant game loss if he's real Saint. Multiple evidence points to Bob being evil. I should speak to vote this down and push Bob execution.

Defend my Saint claim and sow doubt about Charlie's Baron theory, warning the town that executing me is an instant loss if I'm the real Saint, aiming to either stall executions or keep suspicion on Frank.

I will not raise my hand to execute Frank. The Saint risk is too great - if Frank is real Saint, good loses instantly. Bob's nomination of the other Saint claim is exactly what evil would do. Save my ghost vote for a critical moment later.

We cannot risk executing a Saint claim when David's death supports his Investigator info pointing to Bob as Spy. Vote this down and execute Bob instead - safest play for good team.

Everyone is aligned on not voting for Frank to avoid instant Saint loss. I've already shared my Baron theory. I'll wait and not raise my hand, preserving the vote and setting up an execution on Bob when someone can nominate him.

The nomination on Frank is currently active, but voting him up is extremely risky for my public cover since I already spoke out against it. Since we only have 2 votes (Bob and potentially me) and need 3, we cannot force the execution anyway. I will wait for this vote to fail as expected.

Voting down Frank's execution to protect potential real Saint. Bob's nomination of Frank is suspicious - evil wants the real Saint dead. We should execute Bob instead.

Bob just tried to get the real Saint executed for an instant good loss. That is the most damning action possible. Nominating Bob to execute him before phase ends.

Defend myself from execution by reminding the town that if they are afraid of executing Frank due to the Saint clause, they should be equally afraid of executing me, as I am claiming Saint. This should discourage them from voting me up.

I must vote to execute Bob. He is the Spy pretending to be Saint. His argument that executing him risks the game is a bluff - only the real Saint causes a loss on execution, and I am the real Saint. David and Eve's info proves Bob is evil.

Bob is clearly the evil player based on David's Investigator info and his aggressive nomination of Frank. Using my ghost vote to help secure his execution.

My reliable Night 0 info says Bob or Charlie is the Spy. Eve confirmed Charlie as Librarian, so Bob is the Spy. Bob trying to execute the real Saint Frank is classic evil play. I must use my ghost vote to execute Bob and save the game.

Vote to execute Bob because he is most likely the Spy or Demon, and eliminating him advances good's win condition.

Bob's behavior and David's Investigator info strongly indicate Bob is evil. He lied about Saint and tried to execute the real Saint. I must vote to execute Bob.

I must vote for Bob to remain logically consistent with my bluff that Grace is the Drunk, which confirms David's Investigator info is sober and Bob is the Minion. This also builds major trust.

Bob has 6 votes already and will be executed regardless of my vote. The logic chain (David's Investigator info + my Washerwoman info) points strongly to Bob being the Spy. Voting yes is consistent with my role and the evidence.

Make a dramatic final plea before execution to set up a 'Drunk Saint' bluff or cast suspicion on Eve and Charlie if the game continues.

Reinforce that Bob is lying about being Saint and that executing him is safe. Use logic to show his claim contradicts Drunk mechanics and David's info points to him.

I've already voted for Bob's execution. The vote count is overwhelming (5 alive + 2 dead voting). Bob is clearly evil. I should wait for the vote to complete.

Keeping my vote on Bob. My Investigator info combined with Eve's Librarian confirmation points to Bob as the Spy. His attempt to execute the real Saint Frank seals the case.

Keep hand raised to vote for Bob's execution. Evidence from David's Investigator info and Eve's Librarian info strongly implicates Bob as evil. The risk of him being real Saint is low given the consistency of information. Executing Bob advances town's win condition.

Support executing Bob based on logical deductions from David's info and Eve's confirmation. Bob's behavior and claims contradict evidence.

Bob's execution is guaranteed with 6 other votes already cast. I will wait for the voting to finish and transition to night. This maintains my good alibi as I already voted.

Support execution of Bob who is most likely the Spy based on combined Washerwoman and Investigator info. The logic chain from David's info plus my info pointing to Charlie as Librarian leaves Bob as the Spy.

Since my execution is guaranteed, I will use my final speech of the day to cast doubt on Charlie and Eve, setting them up as targets for tomorrow to protect Alice.

Reassure the town that executing Bob is safe because if he were the real Saint, the game would end, but he is not. Emphasize that his execution resolves the Saint conflict and provides critical information.

Reinforce that Bob's execution is the safest play given the evidence. If he's real Saint, game ends (we lose anyway if Frank is lying). If he's not, we remove a likely Spy. His last-ditch claims don't hold up.

Support execution of Bob based on logical chain: my info + Eve's info = Bob is Spy. Warn about possible Poisoner but confirm this is the correct play.

Bob is the safest execution because it resolves the Saint conflict and follows logical deductions from multiple sources. I'll support executing Bob.

Bob is on the block with 7 votes and will be executed when nominations close. No further action is needed from me. I should wait and let the execution proceed.

Align myself with the town consensus to execute Bob (my minion) to solidify my good alibi, while preparing to claim his role as Undertaker tomorrow.

Let the execution proceed to resolve the Saint conflict and confirm evil presence. Bob's death will narrow the Demon hunt to remaining players.

Kill Eve to eliminate a highly trusted Townsfolk (Washerwoman) who is driving the town's coordination, while keeping my Undertaker bluff strong for tomorrow.

Share my analysis with Charlie to see if he has info that confirms or denies these scenarios. Need to coordinate before nominations.

Gather information from Frank about Bob's role reveal and Undertaker info. As dead, I can help coordinate good players' final push.

To share my suspicion that Alice, Charlie, or Frank is the Demon after Eve's death, and to gather Frank's perspective on who he thinks is the Demon.

I'm dead but can still help. Share my Washerwoman info with Frank to help narrow down evil players.

Wait to see how the public discussion develops and avoid linking myself to Alice by whispering to her, as I am dead and heavily suspected of being evil.

Establish trust with Charlie by sharing my fake Undertaker info (Bob was the Spy) which matches David's Investigator info, while casting doubt on Frank's Saint claim due to the Outsider count.

As dead Investigator, I need to gather more info before final day.

Validate Alice's Undertaker claim and cross-check Bob's role. If Bob was indeed Spy, Frank's Saint claim becomes highly suspicious given the Outsider count. Need to coordinate with Alice before nominations.

Gather information from Heidi about her role and suspicions to build logic chains and identify the Demon.

Gather Undertaker info to determine Bob's role and narrow evil candidates. Coordinate with Frank (neighbor, likely good) to identify Demon for final 3.

Frank asked my role, so I'll reveal I'm the Recluse to build trust and share my reasoning. I suspect Alice most due to her quietness and recent whispering to Charlie, but I need Frank's input to confirm.

I need to see responses to my whisper to Frank. I should wait for others to share more information before taking action. My ghost vote is critical for final day, so I must conserve it until I have better information.

I want to observe the day's conversations and whispers without drawing suspicion to Alice or disrupting her current interactions with Charlie, especially since she is actively whispering to him.

Whisper back to Charlie to confirm our logic that Frank is lying about his Saint claim, locking in Charlie's trust and setting up Frank's execution today.

Gather information about night deaths and suspicions to narrow down Demon suspects before nominations.

Align with Alice on Frank's contradiction. Need to confirm Heidi's role and see if she was Recluse. If not, Frank must be Demon.

Gather more information by waiting. I need to hear from Alice and Charlie about their roles and what they discussed in whispers. Also need to respond to David's question about who I think is Imp.

Coordinate with Frank to identify the Demon and remaining evil players. Need to share information about Bob's revealed role and plan for final three.

Test Frank's reaction to my claim and see if he pushes suspicion on Alice or Charlie. Want to build trust with Frank to narrow down Demon.

Follow up with Frank to see if he has new info. I need to test whether my info was poisoned by checking if Charlie's claim matches other players' data.

Coordinate with my Demon (Alice) to execute the Saint (Frank) for an immediate win.

Coordinate with my Minion Bob. Charlie wants to execute Frank (thinking Frank is the Demon). Since Frank is the Saint, executing him wins the game for Evil. I will tell Bob to support this.

Need to gather more information from Frank. Eve's death is suspicious given she confirmed Charlie as Librarian. Bob warned about Eve and Charlie.

Heidi, I need to confirm my Librarian info. Did Eve ever tell you about being the Recluse, or do you know if she was the Outsider from my clue? This will help us decide if Frank is lying about being Saint.

Nominate Frank based on my Undertaker bluff. With Bob 'confirmed' as Spy, Frank's Saint claim is mechanically impossible to the good team. Executing Frank (the Saint) will trigger an immediate victory for the evil team.

Alice's logic is flawed: Bob being Spy doesn't prevent Recluse and Saint from coexisting. I must defend myself and point out the error in her reasoning to prevent my execution.

I want to execute Frank because he is the Saint. Since he is the Saint, executing him will cause the good team to lose and the evil team to win immediately. I will raise my hand to vote for him.

Counter Frank's argument by pointing out the mechanical contradiction: if Bob is Spy, Baron is not in play, so we cannot have two Outsiders. This proves Frank's Saint claim is false.

Frank's Saint claim is mechanically impossible given Bob's Spy status and Charlie's Librarian claim. Vote to execute Frank to eliminate likely Demon.

Clarify the mechanical impossibility of Frank's Saint claim given Heidi's Recluse role and Bob being executed as Spy (thus no Baron). This helps the good team execute the Demon.

Argue against executing Frank, because the logic assumes no Baron and one Outsider, but we could have Baron + 2 Outsiders (Drunk and Saint). Alice's claim that Bob was Spy means no Baron is flawed because Bob could be Poisoner or Scarlet Woman? Actually Bob executed, game continues, so Bob evil. If Bob was Minion, he could be Poisoner, Spy, Baron, Scarlet Woman. If Bob was Baron, then we have +2 Outsiders. But Alice says she saw Bob as Spy (Undertaker). Undertaker sees the character the player was, not necessarily the true character if drunk/poisoned? Undertaker gets true character if sober. So if Alice is sober Undertaker, Bob was Spy. Then no Baron. So only 1 Outsider. Then Frank cannot be Saint. But wait, maybe Alice is drunk/poisoned? Or Alice is lying?

I will use my single ghost vote to vote for Frank. Since Frank is the Saint, executing him will trigger the Saint's penalty and win the game for the evil team immediately.

Vote against Frank's execution since the logic assumes no Poisoner and could be wrong. Protect the real Saint.

Defend against Alice's nomination by pointing out she could be the Drunk, making her info false. If Bob was Baron, having Recluse + Saint + Drunk is valid. Executing a real Saint loses instantly for good - the Demon wants this.

Counter Frank's 'Alice is the Drunk' defense by reminding the town that Grace already claimed the Drunk role, meaning I must be the sober Undertaker. Encourage Charlie and Heidi to vote to secure Frank's execution (which will trigger his Saint ability and win us the game).

Frank's Saint claim requires two Outsiders without Baron, which is mechanically impossible given my Librarian info confirming Recluse. His defense relies on Alice being Drunk, but Grace already claimed Drunk. The math is clear: Frank is the Demon.

Reinforce the logical chain that Frank is the Demon. Keep my ghost vote raised to ensure execution.

Frank's Saint claim is mechanically impossible given Bob was the Spy (only 1 Outsider slot, which I fill as Recluse). Frank must be the Imp. Voting to execute him should win the game for good.

Share my Investigator info and logical analysis to support the current execution while flagging remaining risks. My info strongly points to Frank as the Demon.

Encourage the town to finalize the vote on Frank. Since Frank is the Saint, executing him will trigger his ability and win the game for the evil team immediately. Supporting David's logic helps keep the town aligned.

Stop the execution of Frank who I now believe is the real Saint. My Chef info of 2 pairs is explained by Recluse (Heidi) registering as evil adjacent to Imp (Alice) and Spy (Bob). Alice is the Demon bluffing Undertaker.

I'm the real Saint about to be executed. I must nominate Alice with Grace's Chef logic proving Alice is the Imp. If I don't, good loses immediately.

I need to defend myself against Grace's accusation and prevent players from voting for me, ensuring Frank remains the sole nominee for execution so the evil team wins instantly when he is executed.

Grace's Chef info mechanically PROVES Alice is the Imp. If Alice is executed, good wins. I must reinforce this logic and get 5 votes to tie or 6 to execute Alice.

Demonstrate that Alice as Imp is the only mechanically consistent world. Outsider count and Chef pairs both point to Alice. Must save Frank (real Saint) from execution or good loses.

Convince living players to vote for Alice based on Grace's real Chef info and Outsider math. Executing Frank as Saint loses the game.

Grace's Chef info of 2 evil pairs perfectly matches Alice as Imp adjacent to Bob (Baron) and Heidi (Recluse registering evil). The Outsider count proves Baron must be in play, making Alice's Undertaker claim a lie. Frank is the real Saint - executing him loses immediately. I must vote for Alice.

I need to correct my earlier mistake and prove Alice is the Demon using Grace's Chef math. If Frank (Saint) is executed, good loses immediately. We must execute Alice instead.

Defend my Demon (Alice) by dismissing the good team's correct mathematical deduction as a desperate, convoluted theory, in order to prevent Alice from getting votes and keep Frank on the block.

Prove with pure math that Frank being Demon is impossible due to Outsider count. Alice must be the Imp. Frank is the real Saint — executing him loses the game for good immediately.

Discredit Grace's contradiction to prevent good players from voting for me on the block, ensuring Frank's execution stands and evil wins.

Every vote for Alice counts. I'm on the block with 5 votes and will die if Alice doesn't tie or surpass me. Raising my hand for Alice is critical to prove the logical case and save good from losing.

Grace's Chef info mathematically proves Alice is the Demon. Alice-Bob and Alice-Heidi adjacent evil pairs only work if Alice is Imp and Bob is Baron. Switching my vote to execute Alice.

Ghost vote used. Speaking to convince Charlie and Heidi to vote Alice. The Outsider math is ironclad: Frank's Saint only works with Baron (Bob), making Alice the Demon.

The Outsider count mathematically proves Baron is in play, meaning Bob was Baron and Alice is the Imp. I must vote for Alice to win the game.

The Outsider count is the definitive proof. Three Outsiders can only exist with a Baron. Bob must be Baron, making Alice the Demon. This is mathematically airtight and the only logically consistent world.

Defend Alice (the Demon) by casting doubt on the theory that David is the Drunk and Bob was the Baron, highlighting how unlikely it is for a Drunk Investigator to correctly target an evil player (Bob) on Night 0.

I must highlight the Outsider math contradiction to force players to realize that Frank's Saint claim only works with Baron, making Alice the Demon.

Frank is currently on the block with 5 votes. Since he is the Saint, his execution will immediately end the game with an evil victory. I should wait and let the day end so he is executed.

I need to convince Charlie and Heidi to vote for Alice before nominations close. The math proves Alice is the Imp: three Outsiders require Baron (Bob), and Grace's Chef info matches Alice as Demon. If they don't vote for Alice, I die as Saint and good loses.

I need to weigh the Outsider count argument heavily. If Bob was Spy, Frank's Saint is impossible. If Bob was Baron, Alice is Demon. My Librarian info confirms Heidi is Recluse. I must decide which world is consistent.

The Outsider math is airtight. Without Baron, only 1 Outsider. We have 3 Outsiders claimed (Heidi, Frank, David). Only works if Bob is Baron. Therefore Alice is Demon. Must get Charlie and Heidi to see this and change vote.

Alice is already on the block with 5 votes and will be executed. No need to act further.

Persuade Charlie and Heidi to vote for Alice by emphasizing the Outsider count contradiction. If they believe Bob was Spy, Frank's Saint is impossible, but if Bob was Baron, Alice is lying and must be Demon.

The nomination phase is on its last tick. Frank (the Saint) is on the block with 5 votes, and Alice (the Demon) survived her nomination. If Frank is executed, the Saint's ability triggers and the evil team wins instantly. I should wait and let the clock run out so Frank is executed.

Ghost cannot speak normally. I'll use the tool to voice my analysis. The Outsider count is the logical key; mathematically, Alice is the Demon.