Game Detail

I'm choosing Bob as my master for the first day. This satisfies my ability's requirement and allows me to observe his voting behavior early on.

To establish communication with my Demon (Frank) and get the safe bluffs so we can coordinate our claims on Day 1.

As the Virgin, my best move is to be nominated by a Townsfolk to mechanically prove myself and confirm another player as Good. I'm reaching out to my neighbor Heidi to see if she's a Townsfolk who can help.

Establish a connection with my neighbor Alice and share my role to build trust and potentially bait the Demon into targeting me (which I'm immune to).

I want to pressure David privately to see if his claim aligns with my Investigator info (that he or Frank is the Scarlet Woman). If he claims a strong role, I'll compare it with Frank's later.

Respond to Grace's claim while protecting my utility. As Ravenkeeper, I want the Demon to kill me at night, not to be executed by a Virgin during the day.

Bob reached out to me claiming Soldier. As the Butler, I need a 'master' to vote, and since he claimed a solid defensive Townsfolk role, it's beneficial to establish a rapport. I'm being honest about my role to build trust early.

I want to verify my Librarian information by checking if Alice is the Butler. Starting with a private whisper helps build trust and confirm roles without alerting the entire group immediately.

Communicate with my Minion, David, to share the safe bluffs (Mayor, Recluse, Empath) and coordinate our claims.

I want to reply to Charlie's inquiry about my role. Claiming Recluse is a safe bluff from the Demon's list that perfectly explains any negative info (like Investigator seeing a Minion or Empath getting a '1') while potentially confirming Librarian info if he saw me as the Recluse.

Acknowledging Heidi's claim and seeking a better target for my Virgin ability to avoid wasting a powerful night role.

I want to establish a connection with my other neighbor, Charlie, and cross-reference information. Alice's Butler claim is easy to fake, so I'm looking for more data points.

I am sharing my information with Bob, who has claimed a safe role (Soldier), to build trust and get his perspective on David and Frank.

Keep Grace's trust while avoiding being the one to trigger the Virgin ability, as I want to die at night.

Acknowledge Eve's inquiry and confirm her likely role as the Librarian while maintaining my claim.

I want to confirm Alice's role and build trust, while also gauging her thoughts on Bob to see if there's any suspicion there.

I want to build trust with my neighbor Eve by claiming a safe bluff (Mayor) and asking for her role/alignment, as establishing neighborly trust is very useful for a Demon.

Inform my Demon (Frank) that I claimed Recluse to Charlie, and support his plan to claim Mayor.

To maintain my alliance with Heidi and signal my intention to use my Virgin ability to confirm another Townsfolk today.

Coordinate with the Investigator (Charlie) to narrow down the Minion/Demon candidates between David and Frank.

I want to encourage Bob to vet Frank so I can cross-reference Frank's claim with my Investigator info and David's Recluse claim.

Maintain my cover as Ravenkeeper while staying in contact with a potential Virgin.

Confirming my choice of master and checking for more information from the Librarian claim.

I want to maintain my alliance with Alice and keep the information flowing while acknowledging Frank's claim.

Coordinate with my minion David (Scarlet Woman) on his Recluse claim and point out the whispering between Charlie and Bob.

Share Charlie's Investigator information and my own role to start public discussion and pressure Frank to reveal.

I want to reveal my role as Virgin and offer to test Frank, who is one of the suspects in an Investigator ping. This will either confirm Frank as good (and me as Virgin) or suggest he is evil/outsider if he nominates and nothing happens.

Confirm Alice as the Butler based on my Librarian information and encourage Frank (the self-claimed Mayor) to test Grace's Virgin claim to verify both of them.

Deflect the Virgin test invitation by emphasizing my claimed role's (Mayor) endgame value, while validating my minion David's Recluse bluff to explain the Investigator ping.

I want to encourage a Virgin test while gauging the group's reaction to Frank's Mayor claim and Charlie's Investigator claim.

I want to confirm Eve's information and push for a Virgin test if someone is willing, while highlighting that if Frank is the Mayor, he might be right about wanting to stay alive.

I want to offer myself as a sacrifice to test Grace's Virgin claim. As an Investigator who has already received their Night 0 information, my death would confirm Grace as good and verify my own info's reliability, while providing more value than a dead Mayor would.

To encourage Charlie (Investigator) to nominate Grace (Virgin), which will result in Charlie's immediate execution, saving Frank (Demon) from execution today and consuming the day's execution on a good player.

Grace has claimed Virgin. If she is tested, it will confirm two good players, which is highly disadvantageous for the evil team. Killing her tonight eliminates this threat.

I am choosing Eve as my master for tomorrow. Eve's Librarian claim successfully identified me as an Outsider (Butler), which makes her highly likely to be a genuine Townsfolk and thus a trustworthy person to follow in voting.

I want to check in with Charlie since I died. My death suggests I wasn't the target of a Scarlet Woman/Imp play to keep me alive as a suspicious target, and it likely confirms my good alignment to the group. I need to see where Charlie stands on the David/Frank ping.

Coordinate with my Demon, Frank, on how to handle the Investigator ping and plan our defense/targets for Day 2.

I want to confirm Alice's claim and see where her head is at after Grace's death. Since Eve pinged us, and I know I'm the Soldier, Alice must be the Outsider (Butler) if Eve is telling the truth.

I want to build trust with Grace (a dead, likely good player) and get her perspective on the David/Frank situation while sharing my current suspicions.

Confirm my Day 1 master to Bob and discuss Grace's unexpected night death to gauge his perspective.

I need to listen to what others are saying and see if anyone claims responsibility for the kill or if any new information comes to light before I act. Remaining quiet helps me stay hidden as the Ravenkeeper.

Confirm my Librarian information with Alice to build trust and gather more info.

Coordinate with my minion David to support his Recluse bluff which clears me from the Investigator ping, and plan the day's target.

I want to align with Charlie, who seems like a reliable Townsfolk, and share my suspicions about Frank. I also want to share Heidi's claim with him so he can factor that into his logic, while keeping it relatively quiet from the rest of the group.

Coordinate with Frank (the Demon) on our strategy for the day, confirming the Recluse bluff and discussing who to target for execution.

Discuss the night kill and Charlie's Investigator claim with Alice to narrow down suspects.

I want to coordinate with Grace, who is likely confirmed good now that she's dead, to decide when to reveal my Investigator information. Knowing Heidi's claim also helps narrow down roles.

Confirm Eve as my master for the day and discuss the night kill to build trust and gather her thoughts on the game state.

I want to establish a private line of communication with Frank (the Mayor claim) to gauge his thoughts on David (the Scarlet Woman candidate) and potentially setup my own claim.

I want to build trust with Alice, who I have confirmed as the Butler through my Librarian info. Discussing Grace's death helps us evaluate the game state.

I want to build trust with Heidi by acting like a helpful Mayor, validating David's Recluse claim to keep myself clean, and subtly casting doubt on Bob (Soldier) as a potential demon candidate.

I want Charlie to push the information he has into the public sphere to force Frank and David to react, which helps the good team identify the Scarlet Woman.

I am whispering to Charlie to claim Recluse, explaining his Investigator ping pointing to Frank or me. This protects Frank (the Demon) by framing his ping as a false positive caused by my 'Recluse' registration.

I want to gauge Alice's trust in the current information and see if she's picked up on anything from her private chats with Eve or others. I'm also highlighting the David/Frank situation.

I want to pressure David on his 'Recluse' explanation. If he is the Scarlet Woman or the Demon, he's trying to clear Frank. If Frank is the Minion, David's defense of him is suspicious.

I want to confirm Bob's role and alignment by sharing my current thoughts and seeing his reaction, while also maintaining the trust I've built with Eve.

I want to gauge Frank's opinion on Charlie and the Alice/Bob/Eve connection to narrow down potential evil players while maintaining my cover.

I want to compare notes with Alice, who I've confirmed is the Butler, to see if she shares my suspicions about Frank. Frank's refusal to test the Virgin and Charlie's Minion ping make him a strong candidate for being evil.

Reply to Heidi's whisper about Charlie and keep building trust with her as the fake Mayor, while maintaining a cautious and analytical persona.

Encourage Charlie to reveal his Investigator information and pressure Frank to explain his suspicious behavior from Day 1.

Express support for Grace's suspicion of Frank and David while highlighting my mechanical confirmation from Eve to establish trust.

Support Alice and Grace's line of questioning towards Frank while subtly reinforcing my own reliability by mentioning my Librarian information again.

Defend Frank by publicly claiming Recluse, explaining Charlie's Investigator ping, and justifying Frank's caution as Mayor.

I want to push Frank and David for more information and highlight the potential suspicion surrounding Frank's refusal to test Grace's Virgin claim, while acknowledging David's Recluse claim as a possible explanation for Charlie's info.

Defend my Mayor claim and explain why it was correct not to test the Virgin, while redirecting suspicion back to Bob or others who don't understand the Mayor's value.

I need to share my information publicly now that David has revealed his Recluse claim. This puts pressure on both of them and forces the town to evaluate their claims together.

I want to highlight the mathematical inconsistency in the Outsider claims to help the town focus on whether David is actually the Recluse or the Scarlet Woman.

Charlie is the Investigator who has a ping on David and me. Eliminating him reduces the active pressure on us and prevents him from guiding the town's logic.

I am choosing Eve as my master again for tomorrow because she is my most trusted ally. Her Librarian claim perfectly identified my Butler role, and her logic aligns with the good team's goals. Keeping her as my master ensures I can vote alongside someone I believe is good.

I want to touch base with Eve, who I trust because she correctly identified me as the Butler. I'm also limited by my ability to her voting, so coordinating with her is essential.

I want to check in with my most trusted ally, Frank, to see if his perspective on the game has shifted following Charlie's death and to discuss the suspicious behavior of Alice and Eve.

I am dead and Charlie just died. I need to listen to what Alice/Eve and Heidi/Frank were whispering about before I jump into the conversation. Since I have no ability left, my main value is my vote and my voice.

I want to share my thoughts with Alice, my most trusted ally, regarding the Baron possibility and my suspicions of Frank and David.

I want to coordinate with my Demon, Frank, to find out what Heidi whispered to him and to plan our target for today's execution.

Observe current private conversations to see who is grouping up before committing to a discussion.

Share Heidi's secret Ravenkeeper claim and suspicion of Bob with my minion David so we can coordinate our target for execution today.

Since I am dead, I want to observe the conversations between the living players and see if any new information or contradictions emerge before I use my influence or ghost vote.

I want to align with Eve on a strategy for the day. Since Charlie is dead, his information about Frank/David being the Scarlet Woman is our strongest lead. Frank's behavior has been suspicious, and Eve is someone I trust because she correctly identified me as the Butler.

I need to align with Frank, whom I've tentatively trusted, to decide on a nomination target. Since Charlie is dead, his information (David/Frank as Scarlet Woman) is the most solid lead we have.

I want to coordinate with Bob, who is a confirmed good role (Soldier) and has expressed suspicion toward David, to focus on the David/Frank duo. Charlie's death makes his Investigator info even more pressing.

I want to coordinate with Alice to focus the group's attention on Frank, who is the most likely Minion based on Charlie's Investigator ping and David's Recluse claim.

Agree with Frank's plan to target Bob, utilizing Heidi's private suspicion to build a voting coalition and divert attention away from Frank's suspicious behavior.

I want to gather Grace's reasoning for suspecting Frank over David to better evaluate the Scarlet Woman ping, while also testing her perspective on David's Recluse claim.

Reply to Heidi's whisper to redirect suspicion onto Bob and defend David's Recluse claim.

I want to pressure David into revealing more about his relationship with Frank. Since I know one of them is the Scarlet Woman, and David claims Recluse, he might be tellling the truth about his role but registering as evil, or he might be the Demon/Minion. Getting his perspective helps me weigh the Frank/David pairing.

Confirm the plan with Eve to pressure Frank and then transition to gathering more support from Bob.

Coordinate with Frank to target Bob for execution, as Bob's Soldier claim is suspicious and difficult to verify, making him a prime candidate for a hidden Demon or Minion.

I want to convince Bob that Frank is a stronger Scarlet Woman candidate than David, while also suggesting a tactical way to get more information by seeing how David reacts to a push on Frank.

I want to check in with Heidi to see what Frank has been telling her and to seed suspicion regarding the Investigator ping on him, especially since Charlie is now dead.

Respond to Charlie's whisper to maintain my Recluse bluff. Explain that as a Recluse, I caused the Investigator ping, which means Frank could be the real Mayor. Redirect suspicion onto Bob to align with our execution plan.

I want to keep Grace as an ally and see if her plan to use David to test Frank has merit, while also remaining cautious about both Frank and David.

Coordinate Bob's nomination with Heidi to ensure a good player leads the push, making it more credible.

I want to maintain a dialogue with David to see if his story remains consistent while planting a seed of doubt about Frank. I'm also planning my next move to pressure Bob.

I am nominating Bob to put him on the block and push for his execution. This will help the evil team by executing a good player and using Heidi's suspicion of him to get town support.

I need to defend myself against David's nomination and shift the focus back to the suspicious information regarding David and Frank.

I nominated Bob, so I must vote for him to push for his execution and keep up my bluff as a good player trying to find evil.

I want to defend myself against Bob's accusation and build a narrative to execute him, convincing other players to vote for him.

I want to shift the focus away from Bob and highlight the suspicion on David and Frank. Bob's Soldier claim makes him a poor execution target for Good since he's a passive safety net, while David and Frank are directly linked to the Investigator's Minion ping.

I need to wait for my master, Eve, to vote before I can legally vote as the Butler.

I am voting to execute Bob because his Soldier claim is unverifiable and he is a strong suspect for being the Demon or a Minion hiding in a Baron game. Execution is necessary to gain information and reduce the threat.

I want to save my single ghost vote for a more critical execution, specifically one targeting Frank or David who are my primary suspects based on my Investigator information.

I want to discourage the group from executing Bob and redirect focus toward the Investigator's ping on David or Frank. David nominating Bob feels like a deflection.

I need to defend myself and pivot the focus back to the Scarlet Woman suspects (David and Frank) to prevent my own execution and help the good team use the day's execution effectively.

Defend my nomination of Bob and try to convince other players (like Eve or Frank) to vote for him, explaining why executing me (the Recluse claim) or Frank (the Mayor claim) is risky compared to executing an untestable Soldier claim.

I will raise my hand to vote for Bob. This secures the third vote needed to put him on the block, aligning with Heidi and David, and shifts focus away from David and me.

I will save my ghost vote for a more critical execution.

I need to explain why I'm not voting for Bob and reinforce Eve's logic to shift the focus back to the Scarlet Woman candidates (David or Frank). Since Eve is my master and isn't voting, I am mechanically restricted, but I can use this to bolster our argument.

I will wait to see if any other players vote for Bob before the nomination period ends, as I want to see where the majority lies without being the deciding factor too early.

I am waiting to see if more players vote for Bob before deciding whether to use my ghost vote. Currently, there are 3 votes (David, Heidi, Frank), which is the minimum required for Bob to be on the block. Alice cannot vote, and Eve is skeptical. I want to save my vote for a more certain lead like Frank or David, especially since the ping points directly to them.

I am abstaining from the vote on Bob to prevent his execution and focus the group back on the Investigator ping.

I am currently on the block and about to be executed. I need to desperately convince the group to nominate either David or Frank (the Investigator pings) to save myself and hit a more likely evil target.

I want to solidify the vote on Bob and defend the decision to execute him. This ensures that a good player dies today and protects my Demon, Frank, from being nominated at the last second.

Reinforce the case against Bob in the final tick of the day, framing his execution as an informative move for the town and preparing the ground to defend against the Investigator ping tomorrow.

I want to shift the focus back to the Investigator ping (David/Frank) before the nomination phase ends, as Bob's execution seems like a mistake pushed by potential evil players.

To redirect the town's focus from Bob (Soldier) to David (Recluse/Scarlet Woman ping) to save a potential Townsfolk and test a more suspicious player.

Defend myself against the nomination by pointing out that executing a Recluse is low-value and re-emphasizing Bob as the better execution target.

I am voting for David because he is one of the two players pinged as a potential Scarlet Woman by Charlie's Investigator information. Voting for him provides more tactical value than my own execution, as I am a confirmed good role (Soldier) while David's Recluse claim could be a cover for the Minion.

Defend my minion David by pointing out that executing a Recluse claim doesn't give alignment info, urging the town to stick with executing Bob.

I need to vote for David to force a tie or an execution because he is a primary suspect for the Scarlet Woman ping and Bob's death would be a waste of a good player.

I need to encourage Eve to vote for David so that I can also vote, as my Butler restriction prevents me from voting unless she does. This is necessary to put David on the block and potentially save Bob.

I am choosing not to vote for David to ensure Bob remains the primary execution candidate. Frank, who I currently trust more than the others, wants Bob gone, and David's Recluse claim makes his execution less informative than Bob's Soldier claim.

I am voting for David because my Investigator information pointed to either him or Frank being the Scarlet Woman. Since David is a primary suspect and Bob is a Soldier claim, I would rather see David executed to potentially eliminate a Minion.

I am voting for David because he is one of Charlie's Investigator pings for the Scarlet Woman, and putting him on the block allows Alice to vote with me, potentially saving Bob who claims Soldier.

I need to defend myself against the nomination by pointing out that executing a Recluse is low-information for the town compared to executing Bob, whose Soldier claim is untestable. I want to convince Alice and Eve to lower their votes or not push this further.

I have already raised my hand to vote for David to tie or exceed the votes on me. Now I must wait for the voting to conclude to see if he is put on the block.

Defend David from execution by casting doubt on the usefulness of executing a Recluse and redirecting focus to Bob.

Keep my vote raised on David to help reach the execution threshold and shift the block away from Bob.

I am raising my hand to vote for David because Eve (my master) has raised hers, and I believe David is a better execution target than Bob.

I will vote for David to tie the vote. I suspect Frank might be the Scarlet Woman or Demon, and David's nomination of Bob feels like a deflection. My goal is to keep the town's options open or hit an actual evil player.

I have already raised my hand to vote for David, which is the correct play based on my Investigator information. I will wait for the Storyteller to count the votes.

I want to reinforce the reasoning for voting David over Bob. By highlighting that David is a ping from the Investigator and Frank is the alternative, I am focusing the town on the most likely evil candidates. I also want to acknowledge Alice's cooperation to maintain our trust.

I am about to be executed as I have 6 votes on the block on the last tick of nominations. I need to make a strong parting speech that uses my Recluse bluff to cast doubt on the utility of my execution, and more importantly, protect my Demon, Frank, by explaining how my Recluse registration clears him of the Investigator ping.

Let the current nomination on David stand as the day ends.

I want to speak to reinforce David's logic that his execution doesn't help the town, preparing the ground for my defense tomorrow when I will continue to claim Mayor.

Counter David's narrative that his death clears Frank. Point out that if David is the Recluse, Frank remains the only other person the Investigator pinged.

The nomination phase is ending with David on the block. As the Butler, I have already used my nomination and voted for David (following Eve's lead), which was my main goal for the day. I need to see the result of the execution and wait for the Night phase to select a new master.

Allow the current nomination of David to proceed to execution.

Correct David's flawed logic about being 'cleared' and set the focus on Frank for the next day, reinforcing the importance of the Investigator info.

Wait for the day to end as the nomination on David is likely the final one and I have already voted.

Eve is leading the suspicion against me and has been very vocal. Killing her reduces the number of strong voices against me, while keeping Heidi alive avoids triggering her Ravenkeeper ability.

I am choosing Eve as my master again because she is a confirmed Librarian who correctly identified me as the Butler. Her alignment is the most certain in the game, and her voting patterns have consistently aligned with the good team's interests.

Confirm trust with my confirmed Outsider and narrow down the suspect pool between Bob and Frank.

I'm putting pressure on Frank, who is the remaining Scarlet Woman suspect after David's execution. Since I'm dead and have no vote, I'm acting as a social instigator to see how he reacts and if he'll provide any useful information or slip up.

I'm waiting for other players to start the conversation or share information about Eve's death. As the Ravenkeeper, I want to be targeted tonight, so I shouldn't be too aggressive yet.

Coordinate with my Demon (Frank) to find out what Grace whispered to him and agree on today's execution target to win the game.

I want to pressure Frank about the Investigator ping. Since David is dead and Eve is now dead, the circle of alive players is shrinking. Frank is the only remaining candidate from Charlie's Investigator ping.

I want to maintain my alliance with Eve (who confirmed me) and share my current suspicions regarding Bob and Frank.

I am waiting to see the results of the private whispers and to observe the living players' stances before interjecting. As a dead player with no vote, my influence is purely through logic and persuasion.

Defend myself against the Scarlet Woman accusation by pointing out that David being the Minion satisfies the Investigator ping, clearing me, while shifting suspicion onto Alice whose Butler claim is now harder to verify with Eve dead.

Encourage Alice to coordinate with the remaining living players and keep focus on the suspicious claims of Bob and Frank.

I need to gather information from the Alice/Eve pair, as they seem to have a private trust. Since Eve is now dead (and thus more likely to be good/unbiased), I want to know their findings before the nomination phase.

Check in with my neighbor Frank to gather information and see if he's still aligned with me, while also fishing for what Bob (a suspect) said to him.

Coordinate with my Demon (Frank) to ensure we execute a good player today, saving Frank and securing our win.

I want to probe Frank's thoughts on Alice and Heidi while acknowledging his defense, but also pointing out the logistical inconsistencies of Eve's death.

I need to share Eve's suspicion about Bob with Grace while keeping the focus on the Scarlet Woman ping on Frank. This helps coordinate the good team's logic.

Since I am dead and have no vote, my role is to act as an information hub for the living good players (Alice and potentially Bob/Heidi). I need to know what Grace and Eve discussed to help narrow down the Demon.

Secure Heidi's vote against Bob by validating her suspicion of him and revealing that Bob is trying to cast suspicion on her and Alice.

I want to consolidate the group of known/suspected good players (Alice, Grace, Charlie) and share my reasoning about Bob's suspicious claim while Charlie's ping on Frank remains a priority.

I want to align the good team's ghosts and Alice on the most likely suspects. Bob being a Drunk (Outsider) fits Eve's Librarian ping, but Frank is the mechanically suspicious one due to the Investigator ping.

I want to confirm my alliance with Frank and align on executing Bob, who is the primary suspect.

I want to help Frank execute a good player. Since Frank and Heidi are communicating, whispering to Heidi to cast suspicion on Bob (who claimed Soldier) aligns with resolving the Outsider count and helps push a good execution today.

I need to get Heidi's perspective on the current board state, specifically regarding Frank and Alice, since she's been observant but quiet. Her theory about the Baron is still relevant.

I need to gather Heidi's perspective to see if she aligns with the suspicion on Frank or Bob, and potentially use her as my Master for the day since Eve is dead.

Connect the dots regarding the outsider count and the Baron theory to narrow down the Demon candidates. My goal is to keep the focus on Frank while acknowledging the Bob/Outsider discrepancy.

Tell my Minion David to save his ghost vote for Bob so we can secure the execution of a good player and reach the final 3 today.

I want to publicly state my Librarian information one last time and push the group to look at Bob and Frank. Bob's claim contradicts my info, and Frank is a Minion ping. We need to act.

Clarify the Librarian info and suggest a Mayor-win strategy if Frank is telling the truth, while acknowledging Bob's suspicion.

I am nominating Frank because he was one of the two players pinged by Charlie (Investigator) as the Scarlet Woman. Since the other player (David) is dead and claimed Recluse, Frank is the prime suspect for being the Scarlet Woman. Executing the Scarlet Woman prevents the Demon from being safe if we find them later.

Defend myself against the nomination by reinforcing my Mayor claim and pointing out that executing me loses our safety net, while pushing suspicion back onto Bob.

Frank is a primary suspect for the Scarlet Woman based on Charlie's Investigator ping, and executing him removes a likely evil player from the game, even if he claims Mayor.

I want to see if Bob or Alice will vote for Frank first. Since I am the Ravenkeeper, I actually want to die at night, but executing the Mayor (if Frank is telling the truth) is bad for the good team. I need to observe the voting patterns before committing my vote.

I cannot vote for Frank because my master from last night, Eve, has voted, but as a ghost, her vote might not technically count for the Butler's restriction depending on the storyteller's interpretation, however, the more pressing issue is that I cannot vote unless my master votes, and I need to be careful with my vote. Actually, looking at the rules, I must follow my master's lead. Eve voted, but I want to see if Bob or Heidi vote before I commit. Wait, Eve is dead. My ability says 'Each night, choose a player... tomorrow, you may only vote if they are voting too.' Since Eve is dead, can I vote? Usually, if the master is dead, the Butler cannot vote. I should clarify or wait to see how others react. Actually, the rule is usually that if the master is dead, the Butler can't vote. I will wait to see if the vote reaches the threshold or if I'm even capable of voting.

Wait for the living players to decide on Frank's execution while I have no more votes to contribute.

I am dead and have no vote left. I cannot affect the outcome of this vote mechanically, so I will observe the group's reaction to Frank's Mayor claim versus the Investigator ping.

I am voting for Frank because he is a high-probability Scarlet Woman candidate based on Charlie's Investigator ping, and executing the Scarlet Woman prevents the Demon from jumping to a Minion.

To defend my Demon Frank from being executed, as his execution would result in an immediate evil loss (since there are only 4 alive players, my Scarlet Woman ability will not trigger).

Defend myself from the nomination by casting suspicion back onto Bob and reminding Heidi of our plan to execute Bob.

I will wait to see if more living players vote for Frank before committing my ghost vote, as it's the first nomination and I only have one vote.

To prevent the execution of a potential Mayor and redirect focus toward Bob.

I cannot vote for Frank because my master from last night, Eve, is not voting. (Wait, the logs say Eve raised her hand, then said "Eve waits". Checking... the logs show "Eve raised their hand" then "Eve waits." This usually implies she lowered it or the action sequence is updating. If she is currently waiting/not voting, I physically cannot vote as the Butler.) Also, Frank's Mayor claim is a powerful late-game tool for good, and Bob's vote for Frank is suspicious given Eve's suspicion of Bob. I will wait to see if this nomination fails.

I have already used my ghost vote, so I cannot influence the vote count on the current nomination. I will wait to see if the nomination on Frank succeeds or if the focus shifts to Bob.

I want to point out the risk of leaving a potential Scarlet Woman alive, even if they claim Mayor, especially since Charlie's info is mechanical and Frank's claim is just words.

I need to convince Heidi to vote for Frank. Frank's Mayor claim is likely a bluff to stay alive as the Scarlet Woman. I'm pointing out that my survival is a natural result of being the Soldier, whereas an evil player would have more motivation to manipulate the kills.

I need to discourage Alice and others from voting for Frank (the Demon) by highlighting the risk of executing the Mayor claim and pushing the suspicion heavily onto Bob.

I am currently on the block with 2 votes and will be executed, ending the game in an evil defeat. I need to nominate Bob to get him on the block and save myself.

I will wait to see if others vote for me. I should not vote for myself as I am the Soldier and believe I am a key member of the good team. Voting for myself would bring me closer to execution.

I am voting for Bob to put him on the block and save myself from execution.

I cannot vote or nominate, so I will observe the current voting process for Bob to see if he ties with Frank.

I am voting for Bob because his Soldier claim is mathematically unlikely given Eve's Librarian information and the existence of other Outsider claims. Executing him is a safer bet than executing Frank, who might be the Mayor.

I cannot vote for Bob because my Master (Eve) has not voted. I must wait to see if Eve votes before I can contribute to this tie.

I want to highlight that Bob's 'fake' claim isn't definitive proof of him being the Demon, especially when Frank was a direct Investigator ping. I need to influence the living players.

Observe how the living players respond to Bob's nomination, as I am dead and have already used my ghost vote.

Frank is on the block with 2 votes. Bob has 2 votes. I must use my ghost vote to put Bob on the block with 3 votes and save Frank, which will lead to an evil victory.

I am refraining from voting for myself to avoid execution, as I am a member of the good team and my survival is beneficial.

Encourage the players to vote for Bob and keep their hands raised to ensure he goes on the block and gets executed, securing an evil win as we reduce the living player count.

Remind Alice of the Investigator info and cast doubt on Frank's Mayor claim before she decides to vote for Bob.

I need to convince Alice to vote for Bob to tie the vote or put Bob on the block. Bob's Soldier claim is logically inconsistent with the known Outsiders, making him the most likely Demon or Minion trying to hide. Frank's Mayor claim is a valuable potential win condition for good.

I need to clarify the Outsider count with the Librarian (Eve) to see if Bob's claim is mathematically impossible, which would confirm him as evil and justify voting for him over Frank.

Remind Alice of the mechanical leads (Investigator ping and Baron math) to prevent her from being swayed by Frank's defense, even though I am dead and cannot vote.

I want to counter Heidi's logic and support the execution of the Investigator ping (Frank) over the suspicious claim (Bob) by highlighting that Bob could be a Drunk or Baron-added Outsider, whereas Frank has a mechanical ping against him.

I want to convince Alice to vote for Bob to secure his execution over Frank, our Demon. Since Frank is currently on the block, getting Bob on the block with 3 votes is crucial for our survival.

I need to convince Alice that Frank is a more dangerous target because of the Investigator ping, and that my suspicious claim could be explained by being the Drunk in a Baron game.

Bob is on the block with 3 votes and the voting is closed. With only 1 tick remaining, Bob's execution is locked in. This will leave 3 players alive, allowing me to win the game by making a night kill. I will wait to progress to the night phase safely.

Remind the remaining voters, specifically Alice, about the mechanical certainty of Bob's false claim while acknowledging the importance of the Investigator ping on Frank, urging Alice to make a final decision.

Allow the current vote on Bob to stand as the nomination phase ends.

I need to clarify Eve's Librarian info regarding Bob. If Bob was part of the Librarian ping for Butler, his Soldier claim is a lie. This helps determine if he is the Demon or a Minion.

I need to refocus Alice on the fact that while Bob is likely the Drunk (based on the Librarian ping and Outsider math), Frank is still a strong mechanical lead for the Scarlet Woman. I want to prevent Alice from being fully convinced by the 'Bob is evil' narrative without considering the risk of leaving the Scarlet Woman alive.

I need to refocus the town on the mechanical lead against Frank (Scarlet Woman ping) rather than just executing Bob because he's an Outsider. Executing a Minion is higher priority than executing an Outsider.

Reinforce the execution of Bob to ensure he dies today. If Bob is executed, only three players remain, and the Demon can win the game tonight by killing one more.

I will kill Alice tonight. This will leave only Heidi and myself alive tomorrow, reducing the living players to two and securing an evil victory.