Game Detail
Players
Alice (Washerwoman) Bob (Imp) Charlie (Monk) David (Librarian) Eve (Undertaker) Frank (Butler) Grace (Investigator) Heidi (Spy)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 174,145 | 73,762 | $0.2241 |
| Good | 531,646 | 296,399 | $3.4651 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You are the Minion. The Demon is Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Minions are: Heidi. Your safe bluffs are: Mayor, Chef, Saint
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Washerwoman. Either David or Grace is the Librarian.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Librarian. Either Frank or Grace is the Butler.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Investigator. Either Heidi or Alice is the Spy.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
I am choosing Bob to be my master for tomorrow so that I can satisfy my Butler restriction and observe his voting patterns on Day 1.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose Bob to be your master.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Washerwoman (good), Alive - Bob: Imp (evil), Alive - Charlie: Monk (good), Alive - David: Librarian (good), Alive - Eve: Undertaker (good), Alive - Frank: Butler (good), Alive - Grace: Investigator (good), Alive - Heidi: Spy (evil), Alive
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, how's it going? I'm trying to figure out who to trust here. What information did you get to start?
🧠
Start building trust with Charlie by sharing information and feeling out who is claiming what. I'll use this conversation to establish my bluff and sow seeds of confusion.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
Hi Alice, I am trying to figure out some of the roles around the circle. Do you mind sharing what character you are?
🧠
I want to privately probe Alice for her role, as she is one of my two Investigator candidates for being the Spy. If she is the Spy, she knows I am the Investigator, but if she is good, her claim will help me narrow down between her and Heidi.
👤
David
→
Frank
Hey Frank, what is your role? I have some Librarian info that involves you.
🧠
I want to verify my Librarian info which states that either Frank or Grace is the Butler. Whispering to Frank is a direct way to see if he claims Butler or something else.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, wanted to introduce myself. I'm thinking about who seems suspicious already. What do you make of the conversations happening so far? Did Heidi tell you anything important when she whispered to you?
🧠
Establish trust with Charlie early on. I want to build a relationship where they might confide in me or trust my reads later. I'll claim Chef since I know there's 1 Minion (Heidi) and we're not neighbors, so the count of 0 pairs is true if I claim I got 0.
👤
Frank
→
David
Hey David, I am actually the Butler. What does your Librarian info say about me?
🧠
David claims to be the Librarian with info on me. As the Butler (an Outsider), responding truthfully allows us to verify each other's roles and alignments, helping the good team coordinate.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
Hey Grace! I am the Washerwoman, and my start-of-game info is that either you or David is the Librarian. Are you the Librarian?
🧠
Respond to Grace's whisper by sharing my Washerwoman info to see if she is the Librarian, helping us verify each other's roles.
👤
Charlie
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi, I actually didn't get any starting information myself, as my role is more about night actions. How about you, did you get any useful information to start the game?
🧠
I want to respond to Heidi's private whisper, answering her question honestly but without fully revealing my Monk role yet, and ask for her starting information to build trust and gather info.
👤
Eve
→
David
Hey David, what did Frank share with you? I am just checking in with my neighbors to build some trust. What is your role?
🧠
I want to gather information from my neighbor David, who previously whispered with my other neighbor Frank, to see if they are trustworthy and build an alliance.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
I got some information to start. I'm the Chef, and I learned there are zero pairs of evil players sitting next to each other. That makes me feel a bit better about our seating arrangement at least.
🧠
Build trust with Charlie by claiming a role and sharing fake information that helps our evil team, while also seeing what he reveals in response.
👤
Grace
→
David
Hi David! Alice whispered to me that her Washerwoman info says either you or I am the Librarian. Are you the Librarian?
🧠
I want to verify Alice's Washerwoman claim by asking David if he is the Librarian, which will help me determine if Alice or Heidi is the Spy.
👤
David
→
Grace
Yes, I am indeed the Librarian. That confirms Alice's info is correct! Also, my Librarian info says either you or Frank is the Butler, and Frank already whispered to me claiming Butler. What is your actual role, Grace?
🧠
Confirm Alice's Washerwoman info to Grace and share my Librarian info about Frank/Grace being the Butler to see Grace's reaction and role claim.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Did Heidi say anything about her role or who she suspects? I'm trying to piece together who seems trustworthy. And what do you think of Alice and Grace whispering so much to each other?
🧠
Establish trust with Charlie and extract information about Heidi while appearing helpful and observant. Building an early alliance on day one is crucial for my Demon survival.
👤
Frank
→
David
Hey David, what was your Librarian info? You mentioned it involved me. Who was the other person in it?
🧠
Follow up with David to get his Librarian information, which involves me, to verify his claim and find the other player in his ping.
👤
Alice
→
David
Hey David, I'm the Washerwoman. My start-of-game info says that either you or Grace is the Librarian. Grace hasn't replied to me yet, but I saw you two whispering. Are you the Librarian?
🧠
I want to reach out to David to see if he claims Librarian, since Grace hasn't responded to my whisper yet and they whispered each other right after my message to Grace.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Hey Bob! Heidi told me she is the Chef and got a zero, meaning no evil pairs next to each other. What about you, do you have any starting info or a role you're comfortable sharing? Alice and Grace whispering is interesting, but too early to tell if it's suspicious.
🧠
I want to build trust with Bob by sharing Heidi's Chef claim, and prompt him to share his own role or info so I can assess his alignment.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Hey Frank, what did you and David chat about earlier? I am your neighbor Eve. Just trying to figure out who we can trust today. What is your role?
🧠
I am reaching out to my other neighbor Frank to gather information about his chat with David and find out his claimed role to build trust.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
Hey Bob, I've been telling people I'm the Chef and saw zero evil pairs. Just wanted to coordinate with you so our stories line up. What have you been claiming so far?
🧠
Coordinate with Bob (the Demon) to ensure our bluffs don't contradict each other and protect our team's identity.
👤
Grace
→
David
I am actually the Investigator, and my information is that either Alice or Heidi is the Spy. If Alice is telling the truth, you are definitely the Librarian, which means Frank is the Butler, and Heidi is the Spy. But if Alice is the Spy, she might have faked her claim. What do you think?
🧠
I want to share my Investigator information with David because he claims Librarian and has a logical connection to Alice's claim. Sharing this helps us narrow down whether Alice or Heidi is the Spy.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Frank
Yes Alice, I am the Librarian. Frank, the other person in my information was Grace, which confirms you are indeed the Butler. Grace is claiming Investigator, saying either Alice or Heidi is the Spy. Since Alice is good, Heidi must be the Spy! Let us work together.
🧠
I want to confirm my role to Alice and Frank, validate Frank's Butler claim, and share Grace's Spy info so we can coordinate our nominations against Heidi.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi. Good to know you're Chef. I've been telling people I'm the Mayor. It's a safe claim that doesn't need specific info. Who are you planning to poison tonight? And do you have any thoughts on who we should target for the kill?
🧠
Coordinate with my minion Heidi. I'll claim Mayor since she's claiming Chef. Need to establish consistent stories and plan our strategy for night kills and poison targets.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
Hey Eve, I am the Butler. David claims he is the Librarian and saw me or Grace as the Butler. He also said Grace is claiming Investigator with Alice or Heidi as the Spy. What is your role?
🧠
Respond to Eve's query to build trust and share the information David just gave me. This helps align our neighborhood and gather Eve's role.
👤
Alice
→
Frank
,David
Hey Frank, are you indeed the Butler? If you are, that confirms David's Librarian information, which perfectly matches what I know as the Washerwoman. David, if Frank confirms this, then Grace's claim about Heidi being the Spy is extremely likely.
🧠
I want to confirm Frank's role to verify the logic chain that David is the Librarian and Heidi is the Spy.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Hey Bob, did Heidi confirm her Chef zero claim to you? What do you make of her? Also, what role are you? I am hoping we can work together since we are neighbors.
🧠
I want to get a response from Bob regarding his role and his thoughts on Heidi's claim, as he is my neighbor and we need to cooperate.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Hey Frank, thanks for sharing. I am the Soldier, so I am safe from the Demon tonight. David's info matches yours perfectly. Let's keep this group tight and see who David and Grace think are suspicious.
🧠
Reply to Frank to build trust. I am claiming Soldier to protect myself from night kills while validating his Butler claim against David's reported Librarian info.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Hey everyone, since nominations are open, I wanted to share what I learned as the Chef. I saw zero pairs of evil neighbors, which means no two evil players are sitting next to each other. I know it's not much, but it's something to work with. Has anyone else gotten any starting information they can share? Like a Washerwoman, Librarian, or Investigator?
🧠
Establish my Chef bluff publicly and encourage good players to share their starting information so I can better undermine them or redirect suspicion.
💬
Bob
→
All
Heidi, thanks for sharing that Chef info. A zero is really helpful to know. Has anyone else gotten any starting information? If you're a Washerwoman, Librarian, or Investigator, now would be a great time to share. The more we know, the better we can piece things together.
🧠
Support Heidi's Chef claim publicly and ask others to share info. This makes me look like a helpful townie while reinforcing my minion's credibility.
💬
David
→
All
I am the Librarian, and my starting information is that either Frank or Grace is the Butler. Frank has confirmed to me that he is the Butler. Alice is the Washerwoman who learned that either Grace or I am the Librarian. This lines up perfectly, meaning Alice is good, so Heidi is likely the Spy!
🧠
Publicly share my Librarian info and the logical deduction pointing to Heidi being the Spy based on Grace's Investigator claim, Alice's Washerwoman claim, and Frank's Butler claim.
💬
Charlie
→
All
That is a very neat chain of information, David, but why does you and Alice being good make Heidi likely to be the Spy? Chef zero is a very normal game state. Let's hear what Alice, Frank, and Grace have to say before we jump to any conclusions.
🧠
I want to caution the town against hastily executing Heidi based on David's leap in logic, while keeping my own identity as Monk hidden.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am the Investigator, and my starting information is that either Alice or Heidi is the Spy. That is why David made that connection. If Alice is the good Washerwoman, then Heidi must be the Spy. But we also have to consider if Alice is the Spy and used her Grimoire knowledge to make a perfect claim.
🧠
I want to reveal my Investigator information to the town so they understand why David connected Alice and Heidi, and to outline the two possibilities regarding Alice and Heidi.
💬
Eve
→
All
I agree with Charlie, let's not rush into executing Heidi. If Alice is actually the Spy, she could easily have used her Grimoire knowledge to fabricate a perfect Washerwoman claim. We really need to hear from Alice and Frank directly to see if all this info lines up from their perspectives.
🧠
Encourage the group to wait for Alice and Frank to speak and caution against hastily executing Heidi, keeping my Undertaker role hidden for now.
💬
Frank
→
All
I can confirm that I am indeed the Butler. However, we should be careful: David asked me for my role before he publicly revealed his Librarian information, so he could have easily faked it using what I told him. Let's not rush to execute Heidi just yet without hearing more.
🧠
Confirm my role as Butler but warn the town that David got my role privately before publicizing his information, meaning his Librarian claim could be a bluff. Encourage caution on Heidi.
💬
Alice
→
All
Hey everyone, let's look at the logic. My Washerwoman information says either David or Grace is the Librarian. Since Grace claims Investigator, if she is telling the truth, then David must be the Librarian, which fits with Frank being the Butler. This means either Heidi is the Spy, or Grace is actually the Spy and is lying to frame Heidi.
🧠
To explain the logical deduction from my Washerwoman information and the claims of David, Grace, and Frank, showing that either Heidi is the Spy or Grace is the Spy.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Alice is at the center of the current information web. If she is the genuine Washerwoman, she is a confirmed good player and a prime target for the Demon. Protecting her keeps a trusted good player alive to help solve the game.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to protect Alice.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Bob
Bob made a choice.
🧠
Kill David to remove the Librarian claim and disrupt the good team's information chain. He's building a case against Heidi, and his death creates confusion about whether he was truthful or faking with Spy knowledge.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose to kill David.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
I will choose Alice as my master for tomorrow. If Alice is indeed the Washerwoman as confirmed by David (who was killed tonight and is likely good), she is highly likely to be good and her voting decisions can be trusted.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose Alice to be your master.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Washerwoman (good), Alive (Protected) - Bob: Imp (evil), Alive - Charlie: Monk (good), Alive - David: Librarian (good), Dead - Eve: Undertaker (good), Alive - Frank: Butler (good), Alive - Grace: Investigator (good), Alive - Heidi: Spy (evil), Alive
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Hey Frank. Since David died last night, I really trust your Butler claim now. My Investigator info means either Alice or Heidi is the Spy. If Heidi is the Spy, the Demon is likely Bob, Charlie, or Eve. But if Alice is the Spy, and Heidi is a real Chef with a zero count, the Demon has to be Charlie or Eve. Who do you suspect?
🧠
Whisper to Frank, a trusted player, to share my mechanical deductions about who the Demon could be based on whether Alice or Heidi is the Spy.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
I want to pause and observe what Grace and Frank discuss. The game just started for Day 2, and I need to gather information before committing to whisper conversations. I'll see how the public discussion develops first.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
Hi Alice, since I'm dead, I want to confirm that your info was spot on. I am indeed the Librarian. And my info was that Frank or Grace is the Butler, which matches Frank's claim. This makes me trust you. Who do you think we should look at today?
🧠
To establish trust with Alice, who correctly identified me as the Librarian, and to coordinate our next steps now that I am dead.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
I am leaning towards Charlie or Eve being the Demon. If Alice is the Spy and Heidi is a real Chef, then Bob cannot be the Demon because Bob and Alice are neighbors, which would have given a Chef count of one. So that leaves Charlie and Eve. What do you think of them?
🧠
Respond to Grace's whisper with my logical deduction to build trust and coordinate our search for the Demon.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Hey Frank, since David died, he was likely good. This makes you almost certainly the good Butler. I'm actually the Undertaker, not the Soldier. I bluff to stay alive. We need to execute someone today so I can use my power. Who do you think we should target?
🧠
I want to build trust with Frank, who is highly likely to be the good Butler since David (the dead Librarian) saw him or Grace as the Butler. I'm revealing my true role as Undertaker to him to coordinate an execution for today so I can get information tonight.
👤
Alice
→
David(Ghost)
Hi David, sorry you died. Since you are the Librarian, that confirms you were my Washerwoman ping! This means you are definitely good. Grace claimed Investigator, saying either Heidi or I is the Spy. Since I am the Washerwoman, she's pointing at Heidi. Or Grace is the Spy herself framing Heidi.
🧠
To share my Washerwoman verification with David (who is a confirmed good dead player) and get his thoughts on Grace's claim, as Grace's claim of Investigator pointing to me or Heidi as the Spy is highly suspicious if she herself is the Spy.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Hey Bob, what are your thoughts on the claims so far? Do you have a role you are comfortable sharing?
🧠
To gather information from my quiet neighbor Bob, who has not yet claimed a role or made public statements. This will help narrow down the alignment of players and find the Demon.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
We need to coordinate. Grace knows too much - she correctly narrowed Spy to Alice and me. I recommend poisoning Charlie to disable Monk protection, then kill Eve so her Undertaker ability is silenced. This weakens their confirmed good players.
🧠
Coordinate with Bob on poison target and kill target. Grace is the biggest threat as she correctly narrowed down Spy to Alice/Heidi. Poisoning Charlie would disable protection and kill someone trusted. Recommend killing Eve to silence Undertaker info.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
That is incredibly smart, Frank! Your logic about Bob and Alice makes perfect sense. If Alice is the Spy and Heidi is telling the truth, then Bob is clean, leaving Charlie and Eve. I am definitely leaning towards Alice being the Spy. Have you heard any claims from Charlie or Eve yet?
🧠
Validate Frank's excellent logic and build trust with him, while shifting focus to Charlie and Eve and asking for information.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I've been thinking about your question. I'm comfortable sharing with you - I am the Mayor. I know it's a powerful role, and honestly it's terrifying to admit publicly given how many threats are out there. What are your thoughts on all these claims flying around?
🧠
Claim Mayor to Charlie to build trust and solidify my cover. This safe bluff keeps me out of the Alice-Heidi-Grace conflict and may gain me an ally or even Monk protection.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Frank
Hi Frank, I want to let you know that you are 100% confirmed good. My Librarian info was that either you or Grace is the Butler, so your claim matches perfectly. Alice is also confirmed Washerwoman because she knew I was the Librarian. Who do you think we should look at among the rest?
🧠
I want to confirm Frank as the Butler and establish him as a trusted ally. Since Alice is also confirmed good, we now have a strong core of good players (me, Alice, Frank) to coordinate with.
👤
Frank
→
David(Ghost)
David, since Alice is good, Heidi must be Spy from Grace's info. If Alice is Spy, Heidi is Chef zero. Either way, the Demon is Bob, Charlie, or Eve. Interestingly, Eve just claimed Undertaker to me (she bluffed Soldier yesterday). If Eve is true, the Demon is Bob or Charlie. What do you think?
🧠
Share the logic that the Demon must be Bob, Charlie, or Eve with the confirmed good ghost David, and reveal Eve's Undertaker claim to him so we can coordinate.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm the Undertaker (bluffed Soldier to Frank). Since David died, he's likely the Librarian, meaning Frank is the Butler. This makes you, David, and Frank highly likely good. Who do you think is the Demon between Bob and Charlie?
🧠
I want to coordinate with Alice, who is a likely good player (Washerwoman claim that fits David's Librarian claim). I'm sharing my true role as Undertaker and asking her opinion on the quiet players, Bob and Charlie, who are highly likely to contain the Demon.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
I can confirm David was the Librarian. He was my Washerwoman ping! So he is 100 percent good, and Frank is the Butler. I am torn between Grace and Heidi. Grace claimed Investigator pointing to Heidi as Spy, but Grace could be the Spy framing Heidi. What do you think of Bob and Charlie?
🧠
Share my confirmed information with Eve to build trust, as she claimed Undertaker and believes David, Frank, and I are good. I want to tell her that David was indeed my Washerwoman ping, and discuss the Grace vs Heidi dynamic, while asking for her thoughts on Bob and Charlie.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Thanks for trusting me, Bob. I am actually the Monk. I protected Alice last night. Since you are the Mayor, I can protect you tonight to keep you safe! Regarding the other claims, if Alice is indeed the Washerwoman, then either Heidi is the Spy, or Grace is evil and framing her. What do you think?
🧠
I want to build a strong alliance with Bob, who claimed Mayor. By sharing that I am the Monk, I let him know he can be protected, and I also ask for his take on the conflicting Grace/Heidi/Alice claims to see where his head is at.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
I need to observe how Grace's Investigator claim is received and what counter-claims emerge before committing to a defense strategy. Waiting lets me gauge town sentiment before I act.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Hey Eve, what is your role claim? Frank and I are trying to piece things together before nominations start.
🧠
I need to ask Eve for her role claim to see if she fits into our logic as a potential Demon or if she has useful information to share.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Tempting offer, Charlie. But I need to understand the bigger picture first. If Alice is Washerwoman, then Heidi looks bad as the Spy. But if Grace is lying as Investigator, then Alice and Heidi could both be good. I'm trying to see which way the logic falls - too many contradictions to sort through yet. Everyone is pointing fingers at different people.
🧠
Respond to Charlie cautiously - he could be testing my Mayor claim. I'll acknowledge his Monk claim but stay slightly skeptical of the other claims to appear analytical. Then I'll coordinate with Heidi on the poison-kill plan for tonight.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
Frank just whispered me that Eve claimed Undertaker to him, after bluffing Soldier yesterday. Since we had no execution, she has no info yet. Frank, you, and I are confirmed. That leaves Bob, Charlie, Eve, and either Grace or Heidi. Who do you suspect?
🧠
Share Eve's double claim (Soldier/Undertaker) with Alice, who is a confirmed good player, to help narrow down the Demon candidates between Bob, Charlie, and Eve.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, we are trying to piece things together before nominations. We have a lot of info, but we need to hear from you. What is your role or what are your thoughts on who the Demon might be?
🧠
Ask Charlie for his role or thoughts, as he is a primary suspect if Alice is the Spy and Heidi is a real Chef.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I told Frank earlier that I am the Undertaker (I bluffed Soldier at first to stay safe). Since we had no execution yesterday, I have no info yet. We absolutely need to execute someone today so I can get a reading tonight. Who are you and Frank thinking of executing?
🧠
Respond to Grace's query about my role claim. I am being honest since Frank is confirmed good and likely shared my info, and I want to cooperate with her and Frank to get an execution today.
👤
Alice
→
David(Ghost)
I suspect Bob or Charlie is the Demon. If Grace is the Investigator and Heidi is the Spy, then the Demon must be Bob, Charlie, or Eve. If Grace is the Spy framing Heidi, Heidi is a good Chef. Either way, Bob and Charlie have been very quiet. I think we should press them during nominations.
🧠
Share my strategic thoughts with David (confirmed good) to coordinate before nominations. Focusing on Bob and Charlie since they are quiet and likely contain the Demon, while the Grace/Heidi dynamic is likely a Spy interaction.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
Hey Frank. I am the Monk, and I protected Alice last night. Since David confirmed you as the Butler, I trust you completely. Bob privately claimed Mayor to me. I think the evil players have to be among Grace, Heidi, and Eve. What do you think we should do?
🧠
To share my true role (Monk) and Night 1 protection (Alice) with Frank, who is mechanically confirmed good as the Butler, and coordinate our thoughts on the remaining suspects (Grace, Heidi, Eve) before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
Bob, we need to solidify our plan. Poisoning Charlie to disable Monk protection is solid, and killing Eve prevents Undertaker reads. But Grace is the real threat - she correctly nailed the Spy as between Alice and me. Should we kill Grace instead? Or stick with the original plan? Also, are you still comfortable with your Mayor claim?
🧠
Coordinate with my Demon Bob to confirm or adjust our night targets. Poisoning Charlie disables protection on Alice, making her vulnerable. Killing Eve silences Undertaker info. Grace correctly identified me as Spy between Alice and Heidi, making her a threat but too accurate to kill yet.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Alice
→
Grace
Grace, you claimed Investigator and said either Alice or Heidi is the Spy. I am Alice and I know I am not the Spy. If you are good, Heidi must be the Spy. But I suspect you might be the Spy or Demon framing Heidi. I'm nominating you so we can hear your defense and get some answers.
🧠
I want to nominate Grace because her Investigator claim is highly suspicious. Since I am Alice (good), her claim forces Heidi to be the Spy, but Grace could easily be the Spy or Demon framing Heidi.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am the genuine Investigator, and my Night Zero info is that either Alice or Heidi is the Spy. Alice is pushing incredibly hard to execute me, which strongly suggests she is the Spy trying to get rid of the person who found her. Please do not vote for me. We should execute Alice or Heidi instead!
🧠
Defend myself against Alice's nomination by reiterating my Investigator information and pointing out that her aggressive push suggests she is the Spy.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
I nominated Grace because I suspect she is evil (either the Spy or the Demon framing Heidi). I am voting to execute her to get her off the board and allow our Undertaker, Eve, to check her role tonight.
💬
Bob
→
All
I'm voting for Grace. She has claimed Investigator and narrowed it down to Alice or Heidi being the Spy. Since Alice claims good and is pushing this hard, Grace's info naturally points to Heidi. We should eliminate Grace today and investigate further, or we risk losing Heidi based on this narrow claim.
🧠
Vote for Grace to eliminate a threatening info role. Grace's claim thatAlice or Heidi is Spy puts pressure on my teammate. Killing an Investigator is always good for evil.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am hesitant to vote for Grace here. If she is the real Investigator, then her info is extremely useful, pointing to Heidi being the Spy. Executing Grace might just lose us a good player with info. Why don't we hear from Heidi first, or consider executing Heidi if we believe Alice is good?
🧠
I want to discourage the town from executing Grace immediately, as she might be a real Investigator, and instead suggest looking at Heidi who is the alternative in Grace's Investigator info.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I will vote to execute Grace. As the Undertaker, I need an execution to occur today so I can get information tonight. Grace is a prime suspect (either she is evil, or her execution will help us verify her claim and pinpoint the Spy).
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Since I am dead, I am going to save my ghost vote for later in the game. But remember, Alice is definitely good because her Washerwoman info correctly found me as the Librarian. If Grace is telling the truth, Heidi must be the Spy. Let's hear from Heidi before we rush to execute Grace.
🧠
I want to share my perspective as a dead player. I want to confirm Alice is good, explain the logical link between Grace and Heidi, and state that I am saving my ghost vote, encouraging the group to hear from Heidi.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Grace has accurate information that threatens to expose me as the Spy. While voting for her might look defensive, her survival is more dangerous than her death. I need Bob's Demon to survive, and eliminating good players with intel helps our cause.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I agree with David and Frank. If Alice is indeed the Washerwoman, then either Heidi is the Spy, or Grace is lying to us. We should let Heidi speak first before we rush to execute Grace, just in case Grace is a genuine Investigator who found the Spy.
🧠
I want to prevent a rushed execution on Grace until we hear Heidi's full defense and explanation, because Grace might be a real Investigator and Heidi might be the Spy.
💬
Grace
→
All
Everyone, please remember that if Alice is the Spy, she sees the Grimoire! That means she would easily know David was the Librarian and could fake her Washerwoman claim perfectly. David being the Librarian does not prove Alice is good. Please do not vote for me, let us look at Alice or Heidi instead!
🧠
I want to explain to the town why Alice's 'correct' Washerwoman claim doesn't clear her, since a Spy has full Grimoire knowledge. This helps defend me from execution.
💬
Alice
→
All
Grace, if I were the Spy, why would I nominate you instead of sitting back? I know I am good. If you were a real Investigator, you would conclude Heidi is the Spy since I am good. Instead, you are aggressively pushing on me. That deflection makes me think you are the Spy or Demon yourself.
🧠
To counter Grace's defense. She is trying to paint me as a Spy who used the Grimoire to fake my Washerwoman claim. I need to point out that if she were a real Investigator, she would trust my good alignment and focus on Heidi, rather than trying to discredit me.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
I verbally committed to voting for Grace. Now I must raise my hand to confirm. Grace's claim threatens Heidi (my minion). Even if Grace is good, her info creates a binary that will likely get Heidi executed tomorrow. Better to execute Grace now and protect my teammate.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I want to avoid executing Grace right now because she might be the genuine Investigator, and we need to hear from Heidi first before making a decision. Voting now would contradict my public stance and potentially harm the good team.
💬
Eve
→
All
We really need to get an execution today, otherwise we will go into the night with zero information again. Even if we are unsure about Grace, getting an execution is better than nothing so we can start making progress. I am keeping my vote on.
🧠
I want to keep my vote on Grace to ensure an execution happens today, and encourage others to vote because as the Undertaker, I need an execution to get night information.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I want to save my precious ghost vote for the final day when it has the most mathematical weight, especially since we have other living players who can vote and I want to hear more from Heidi.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Grace correctly identified me as the Spy. She must die to protect my identity and Bob's Demon status. Following Bob's lead aligns evil team strategy.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
I will raise my hand to vote for Grace to secure an execution today, as we cannot afford another day with no executions, and Grace's defense has been weak compared to the consistency of David and Alice's claims.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Grace with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Grace
→
Heidi
If Alice is the good Washerwoman, she knows she isn't the Spy. That means Heidi MUST be the Spy. I am nominating Heidi to test this. If Alice is truly good, she should join me in voting for Heidi!
🧠
Nominate Heidi to save myself from execution and set up a logical trap for Alice. If Alice is the good Washerwoman, she must believe Heidi is the Spy and vote for her.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Waiting to see if Frank or Charlie vote for me. I currently have fewer votes than Grace, so I'm safe. Speaking might draw unnecessary attention or votes. I want Grace to be executed, not me.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
I am on the block with 5 votes. I nominated Heidi to test Alice's claim and save myself. I must raise my hand to vote for Heidi to try to reach the 5 votes needed to tie or 6 to surpass.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am not voting for Heidi. Grace, you are trying to save yourself. If you are the Spy, your Investigator claim is entirely fabricated to frame one of us. Executing you gives us the most clarity right now, so let us keep you on the block.
🧠
I want to explain to the town why I am not voting for Heidi and why we should let Grace's execution stand, pointing out that Grace's claim could be a total fabrication by a Spy.
💬
Bob
→
All
I agree with Alice here. Grace is just trying to save herself at the last minute. Think about it, her defense that she is the Investigator is exactly what we would expect from a desperate Spy trying to survive. We already have five votes on Grace, let's not let this Investigate-or-die gambit work. We need to trust our initial instincts and get this execution done.
🧠
Support executing Grace rather than Heidi. Grace's death eliminates a good information role and preserves my minion. I need to argue against switching to Heidi to secure Grace's execution.
💬
Frank
→
All
I won't be voting for Heidi either. Since Alice is not voting, my hands are tied due to my Butler restrictions anyway. But I also agree that we should proceed carefully and see how this vote plays out.
🧠
I want to explain why I'm not voting for Heidi, referencing my Butler restriction, while maintaining a cooperative tone with Alice and Bob's reasoning.
💬
Eve
→
All
I agree with Alice and Bob. We should not vote for Heidi. Executing Grace today gives us the clearest path forward and the most information. Let us keep Grace on the block and proceed to the night.
🧠
I want to encourage the group to not vote for Heidi so that Grace remains on the block for execution. As the Undertaker, getting Grace executed will provide me with crucial information tonight to determine if she is the Spy or the genuine Investigator.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I agree with Alice and the others. Let us not vote for Heidi. Keeping Grace on the block gives us a clear path forward and great information for tonight.
🧠
I want to support the town's decision to not vote for Heidi and let Grace's execution proceed. It gives us the most clarity and progress for the game.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I agree. I will not be voting for Heidi. We have a solid vote on Grace and that will give us the most clarity moving forward. Let us see this through.
🧠
To align with the town consensus and proceed with executing Grace, maintaining game progress.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Let the town execute Grace. Her accurate Investigator claim dies with her, removing the threat to my cover. Voting for myself looks desperate and accomplishes nothing.
💬
Grace
→
All
If Alice were actually the good Washerwoman, she would know with absolute certainty that Heidi is the Spy. Her complete refusal to even consider voting for Heidi, and her push to execute me instead, proves she is the Spy trying to protect herself. Eve, please check me tonight, you will see I am the Investigator.
🧠
Point out the glaring logical contradiction in Alice's behavior. If Alice were a good Washerwoman, she would know Heidi is the Spy and would want to vote her. Her refusal proves she is the Spy. Remind Eve to check me tonight.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
We do not want to execute Heidi, as Grace's claim is highly suspicious and Grace is likely the Spy or Demon framing Heidi. The group is in agreement not to vote for Heidi, so I will wait for the voting to finish and Grace to remain on the block.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Not voting for Heidi maintains my cover as Mayor and lets Grace stay on the block for execution. Voting against the crowd would look suspicious.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
The town has decided not to vote for Heidi, so Grace will remain on the block for execution. I will wait for the vote to finish and the day to progress.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Grace is currently on the block. Voting for Heidi would split the votes and potentially save Grace. I want Grace executed so I can use my Undertaker ability tonight to verify her role. I will wait.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I want to let the vote on Heidi fail so Grace remains on the block for execution. I will wait to avoid voting for Heidi.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I want to keep Grace on the block to get clarity on her role. I will not vote for Heidi, so I am going to wait for the voting to finish.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Heidi did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (1/6).
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Grace's execution removes the Investigator who correctly identified me as Spy. Let the current momentum carry through without drawing attention to myself.
💬
Grace
→
All
Since I am about to be executed, remember this tomorrow: when Eve checks me, she will find out I am the Investigator. That means my start-of-game info is 100% correct, and either Alice or Heidi is the Spy. Since Alice refused to vote Heidi, keep a very close eye on her. Good luck tonight!
🧠
Make a final statement to set up the town for success on Day 3 after my execution, reminding them of my Investigator info and pointing them towards Alice and Heidi.
💬
Alice
→
All
Grace, your logic relies entirely on the assumption that you are the genuine Investigator. If you are actually a Spy, your information is completely made up to sow discord and frame Heidi and me. Let us see what the night brings, and if you are telling the truth, we will address Heidi tomorrow.
🧠
Rebut Grace's final accusation to maintain my trust with the town before the night phase. Her logic is circular because it assumes she is already proven good.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Let Grace's execution proceed. She's causing confusion with her Alice/Heidi binary. With 5 votes locked, the execution is secure. Moving to night lets me kill high-value target while Heidi poisons Charlie to neutralize his Monk protection.
💬
Frank
→
All
If we have an Undertaker, hopefully they can check Grace tonight so we have clear info tomorrow. If she really is the Investigator, then we know our focus tomorrow must be on Alice and Heidi. Let us see what the night brings.
🧠
Acknowledge Grace's execution and guide the town's focus for tomorrow based on potential Undertaker info.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Wait for the day to end so that Grace is executed and I can learn her role tonight.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I agree with Frank. If we have an Undertaker, please check Grace tonight. Her alignment and role will give us a clear path forward tomorrow. Stay safe everyone, and let us see what the night brings.
🧠
I want to encourage the Undertaker (if we have one) to check Grace tonight to verify her Investigator claim, and prepare the town for tomorrow's deduction.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Let the remaining nomination tick pass so that Grace's execution is finalized. No further nominations are needed today.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Grace publicly stated 'when Eve checks me', strongly implying Eve has an information-gathering role (likely Undertaker) that can verify Grace's identity tonight. Protecting Eve keeps this crucial information channel alive for the good team.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to protect Eve.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Bob
Bob made a choice.
🧠
Kill Eve to prevent Undertaker confirmation of Grace's role. If Eve is Undertaker, her death keeps uncertainty about whether Grace was truthful or a lying Spy.
🛡️
Eve was protected from a night kill.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose to kill Eve.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Undertaker. You learn that Grace was the Investigator.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
Choose Charlie as my master because he is active, claimed Monk, and is actively directing the town's votes, ensuring my vote is usable and aligned with a highly active player.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose Charlie to be your master.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Washerwoman (good), Alive - Bob: Imp (evil), Alive - Charlie: Monk (good), Alive - David: Librarian (good), Dead - Eve: Undertaker (good), Alive (Protected) - Frank: Butler (good), Alive - Grace: Investigator (good), Dead - Heidi: Spy (evil), Alive
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Eve
Hey Eve, who did you see last night as the Undertaker? Did Grace register as the Investigator or something else?
🧠
I want to privately ask Eve what her Undertaker info is on Grace to verify Grace's claim.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Eve
Hey Eve, what did you learn about my role last night? And what did David whisper to you? Let's solve this.
🧠
I want to find out Eve's Undertaker info on me from last night to confirm my Investigator role, and also find out what David whispered to her.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Hi Eve, I am the Washerwoman. My starting information was that either David or Grace is the Librarian. Since David claimed Librarian, he is confirmed. What did you learn about Grace last night?
🧠
I want to establish trust with Eve by sharing my Washerwoman info, which confirms David was the Librarian, and ask her for her Undertaker info on Grace.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, who did you protect last night? There were no deaths, so your protection might have gone through! Also, I am the Butler and I chose you as my master last night, so I can only vote if you vote today.
🧠
Ask Charlie (the Monk claimant) who he protected last night since there was a peaceful night, and inform him that I chose him as my master so we can coordinate voting.
👤
Eve
→
David(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
Hi David and Grace. Grace indeed registered as the Investigator! This means Grace's information is completely correct, so either Alice or Heidi is the Spy. I am actually the Undertaker, not the Soldier. What are your thoughts on who the Demon might be?
🧠
I am privately sharing my Undertaker information with the confirmed dead good players to build trust and strategize on who the Spy and Demon are.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,Eve
Hey both, quick question - do you trust Alice's Washerwoman claim? David clearly said he was the Librarian before he died. And Charlie, did your protection save Eve last night? That might explain why she's still here.
🧠
Testing if Charlie/Eve believe Alice's Washerwoman claim, or if they know David was real Librarian. Also assessing if Charlie claims to have protected Eve N2.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
Yes, I protected Eve last night! It looks like my protection worked since there were no deaths. Quick question, did you tell Bob that I am the Monk? He just asked me if my protection saved Eve, and I'm worried how he knows my role and who I protected.
🧠
Confirm to my trusted Butler Frank that I protected Eve, and ask him if he revealed my role to Bob, because Bob's knowledge of my role and my target is highly suspicious if Frank didn't tell him.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
Hey Bob, we need to sync up. Eve's about to confirm Grace was genuine Investigator, which puts pressure on the Alice-Heidi pair. I'm sticking with my Chef zero claim. How are you positioning your Mayor story? We need to be ready when they come for one of us.
🧠
Coordinate with Bob on our alibis. Need to sync our stories about Mayor/Chef claims and plan response if Eve confirms Grace was genuine Investigator.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Grace(Ghost)
Eve, Grace! This is perfect. My Librarian info was that Frank or Grace is Butler. Since Grace was Investigator, Frank is definitely the Butler! That means we are all good. And since Alice or Heidi is the Spy, the Demon has to be either Bob or Charlie! We should target them.
🧠
To share my deduction with Eve and Grace, showing that the Demon must be either Bob or Charlie, and verifying our solid good circle.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
David(Ghost)
,Eve
David, Eve, yes! Frank is Butler. But wait: Alice and Bob are neighbors, and Alice and Heidi are neighbors. If Alice is Spy, and Bob is Demon, they're adjacent. If Heidi is Chef and got 0, then Bob can't be Demon! Unless Heidi is the Spy herself, or Alice is the Demon. What did Alice whisper to Eve?
🧠
Discuss the mechanical implications of the neighbor seating and Heidi's Chef claim with David and Eve.
👤
Alice
→
David(Ghost)
David, I'm the Washerwoman. My starting info was you or Grace is Librarian, so you are one hundred percent confirmed good. What did Eve say she saw Grace as last night? Is Eve the Undertaker?
🧠
I am whispering David because he is 100% confirmed good by my Washerwoman info. He is currently whispering Eve (the suspected Undertaker) and can tell me what she saw, helping us coordinate.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie
I did not tell Bob anything. Remember that Bob claimed Mayor, and Eve privately claimed Soldier to me. If Bob is the Mayor, the Demon might have attacked Bob and the Storyteller bounced it to Eve, whom you protected. Or Bob is the Demon who tried to kill Eve, or a Spy. Be careful with him!
🧠
Reassure Charlie that I did not leak his Monk choice, and provide mechanical explanations (Mayor bounce, Demon fail, or Spy) for why Bob might know he protected Eve.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
,Charlie
Hey Bob and Charlie. Yes, Grace was indeed the Investigator, which means either Alice or Heidi is definitely the Spy. Charlie, did you protect me? If we can narrow down who the Spy is, we can find the Demon. What are your roles?
🧠
I want to share the confirmed Investigator info with Bob and Charlie to gain their trust and find out Charlie's role (since Bob hinted Charlie might have protected me). This will help us narrow down the Demon.
👤
Bob
→
Eve
,Charlie
So Eva, you think Grace was genuine? That's huge. If Investigator is real, then one of Alice or Heidi is lying. But wait - Alice totally refused to vote against Heidi when Heidi was nominated. Eve you said you trust Grace, but Charlie, do you really think Heidi's Chef zero makes sense? And Charlie, did your protection actually work last night or was someone else protected?
🧠
Feed Eva and Charlie info to analyze the Alice-Heidi Spy conflict. Keep them focused on that binary while I appear helpful. Neither is actually the Spy, but this division protects me and my real Minion.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Eve
Hey Bob and Eve. Bob, how do you know I have a protection role? I have not shared that with you. For last night, I actually protected Alice, not Eve. If Eve survived an attack, she must be the Soldier. Eve, how can you be so sure that Grace was the Investigator?
🧠
I want to mislead Bob (potential Demon) into thinking Eve is the Soldier so she is not targeted tonight, while questioning how Bob knew my role to test his alignment. I also want to prompt Eve to reveal her source of info on Grace.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
Bob, we need to talk strategy. When Eve confirms Grace was the real Investigator, they'll know the Alice-Heidi pair has the Spy. Alice refused to vote for me yesterday, which makes her look guilty. I think they're going to target her first. If that happens, I need you to stay quiet or subtly support the Alice theory so they burn their execution on good. If they come for you instead, I'll defend you hard with my Chef zero claim. We good?
🧠
Coordinate with Bob on our defense strategy as Eve's confirmation looms. Need to plan who takes the fall and how we protect the Demon.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
Yes, Eve is the Undertaker and she saw Grace as the Investigator! Since my Librarian info had Frank or Grace as Butler, Frank is definitely the Butler. This means either you or Heidi is the Spy. If you're the real Washerwoman, then Heidi is the Spy. Who do you think the Demon is between Bob and Charlie?
🧠
To reveal the Undertaker's findings to Alice to test her reaction. If she is the real Washerwoman, she will recognize Heidi is the Spy and help us target Bob or Charlie as the Demon. If she is the Spy, she will have to scramble to defend herself.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
David(Ghost)
,Eve
David, what did Alice just whisper to you? Also, think about this: if Alice is the Spy, then Heidi's Chef zero claim means Bob cannot be the Demon, because Alice and Bob are neighbors and that would be an evil pair. That would leave Charlie as the main suspect. What do you think?
🧠
I want to share my deduction about Charlie being the prime suspect based on the Chef zero claim and neighbors, and ask David what Alice whispered to him.
👤
Alice
→
David(Ghost)
,Eve
Heidi is one hundred percent the Spy, which means we have no Poisoner or Drunk. All our info is sober and correct. Since we know Heidi is the Minion, the Demon must be either Bob or Charlie. What have they claimed? Let's figure out which one to execute today!
🧠
Inform David and Eve that Heidi is 100% the Spy (since my Washerwoman info confirms David, meaning Grace's Investigator info is correct and points to Heidi). This solves the Minion, meaning either Bob or Charlie is the Demon.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie
Did you find out how Bob knew you were the Monk and that you protected Eve? Did Eve tell him, or does he have another explanation? We need to figure out if Bob is the Spy.
🧠
I want to follow up with Charlie to see if Bob's knowledge of the Monk protection was explained, which will help us identify if Bob is the Spy or if Eve shared the information.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank! Heidi is the Spy and Bob is the Demon. Heidi whispered to Bob, then Bob immediately asked Charlie about his protection. Since Charlie didn't tell Bob, Heidi must have seen Charlie is Monk in the Grimoire and told Bob. Bob is the Demon! We must execute Bob today. Spread the word!
🧠
Explain to Charlie and Frank why Bob is the Demon and Heidi is the Spy based on Bob's slip-up about Charlie's protection role, and coordinate to execute Bob today.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, sorry if I came across like I knew your role - I was just speculating based on Eve being alive when someone clearly tried to kill her. I figured either you protected her or she's Soldier. Since you protected Alice, Eve must be Soldier, right? But that Alice situation is weird - she refused to vote against Heidi even though Grace's accusation pointed right at that pair. What do you think?
🧠
Deflect Charlie's suspicion about how I knew his role. Frame it as deduction from Eve surviving, not inside knowledge. Continue sowing doubt about Alice to protect myself and Heidi.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Alice, Grace was the real Investigator, which means Heidi is the Spy. Heidi whispered to Bob, and Bob immediately asked me about my protection, proving he got Grimoire info from her. Bob is the Demon. We need to execute him today. Please nominate or vote for him!
🧠
Whisper to Alice to reveal that Bob is the Demon and Heidi is the Spy. Bob's slip-up about my protection confirms his evil alignment. I need Alice to align her vote to execute Bob today.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Let the town digest the information from Eve. Alice looks more suspicious than me due to her voting behavior, so waiting allows them to potentially target her first.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Frank
→
Bob
Bob somehow knew Charlie is the Monk and protected Eve, despite Charlie not telling him. This suggests Bob got this info from a Spy (Heidi) or is the Spy/Demon himself. If Heidi is the Spy and Bob is the Demon, executing Bob wins the game because there is no Scarlet Woman!
🧠
Nominate Bob because he possesses information he shouldn't have (Charlie's Monk protection on Eve), suggesting he is the Demon who got info from the Spy (Heidi). If Heidi is the Spy, executing Bob wins the game as there is no Scarlet Woman.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Bob
→
All
Hold on Frank. I did not know Charlie was the Monk. I was speculating based on Eve being alive when someone clearly tried to kill her. I said either Charlie protected her or she is the Soldier. It was a guess, not inside information. You are jumping to conclusions here.
🧠
Defend myself against Frank's accusation that I seemed to know Charlie was the Monk. Try to explain it as reasonable deduction rather than Spy/Demon knowledge, and cast doubt on Frank's aggressive nomination.
💬
Frank
→
All
Bob, Charlie's role as Monk and his protection of Eve was not public knowledge. How could you specifically speculate that Charlie protected Eve if you did not have inside info? You had to know Charlie's role to ask him that, which points to Heidi giving you that info as a Spy.
🧠
Explain to the town why Bob's defense of 'speculating' is invalid and why he is highly likely the Demon who received info from the Spy (Heidi).
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
If Heidi is the real Chef and there are zero evil pairs, then Alice and Bob cannot both be evil since they are neighbors. That means if Alice is the Spy, Bob must be good. But if Heidi is the Spy and Bob is the Demon, that explains how Bob knew about Charlie. I will save my ghost vote for now.
🧠
I want to explain the seating and Chef logic to the group to help them analyze Bob's alignment, while explaining why I am holding my single ghost vote.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Frank, your accusation does not add up. If I were the Spy and Bob were the Demon, we would be an adjacent evil pair. But I am the Chef, and I know there are zero pairs of evil players sitting next to each other. Alice and I are neighbors, and Bob and Alice are neighbors. If Alice is the Spy, then Bob and I are both good, which fits my Chef information. Bob's guess about Charlie protecting Eve was just that, a guess. He saw Eve survived and deduced someone protected her.
🧠
Defend Bob by pointing out the logical inconsistency in Frank's accusation. If Bob and I were both evil and adjacent, my Chef zero-pairs claim would be false - but I've been consistent. This suggests Alice is the Spy, not me.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Bob is highly suspected of being the Demon due to his knowledge of Eve being targeted. I will vote to execute him.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Since Grace was confirmed as Investigator, either Alice or Heidi is the Spy. This means Frank, Eve, and one of Alice or Heidi are definitely good. That leaves Bob and Charlie, so the Demon is absolutely one of them. If Alice is the Spy, Bob must be good due to Chef zero, so Charlie is the Demon.
🧠
Explain the logic of the game to help the town narrow down the Demon to Bob or Charlie, and explain why Bob is good if Alice is the Spy.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I will raise my hand to vote for Bob. Bob's suspicious knowledge about Charlie's Monk protection strongly suggests he is the Demon who got info from Heidi (the Spy). Voting Bob is the correct play.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Voting for Bob is the logical path. Since Grace is confirmed Investigator, Heidi must be the Spy. Bob or Charlie is the Demon. Charlie's story about Bob knowing his role points to Bob being the Demon.
💬
Bob
→
All
Wait a moment. Alice, you claim to be Washwoman with David and Grace, but you admit there was a Minion between them. You never told us which one was the Minion - you said it was too dangerous. But Grace is dead and confirmed good Investigator, so David must have been your Minion. Why not say so? And more importantly, you refused to vote for Heidi yesterday, even when Grace's accusation pointed right at the Alice-Heidi pair. If you are good Washwoman, why protect someone who might be the Spy?
🧠
Need to sow doubt on Alice to stop the third vote. Charlie already voted but maybe I can get Heidi or Frank to reconsider. Pointing out Alice's suspicious behavior might buy me time.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Since my master Charlie is voting, I am allowed to vote. I believe Bob is highly suspicious of being the Demon due to his unexplained knowledge of Charlie's Monk protection, so I will vote to execute him.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
If Alice is indeed the Spy and Charlie is the Demon, then both of them voting to execute Bob right now fits perfectly. I am holding onto my ghost vote because if Alice is the Spy, Bob is innocent and Charlie is our actual Demon.
🧠
I want to warn the town about the potential evil pair of Alice and Charlie voting together to execute Bob, who would be good under the Alice-Spy/Charlie-Demon scenario, and declare that I am holding onto my ghost vote.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Wait, let me think through this logic carefully. If my Chef information of zero evil pairs is true, and Alice is the Spy as Grace suggested, then Bob cannot be evil because Alice and Bob are neighbors. That would make both Bob and I good. So why is Charlie, who would be the Demon in that scenario, so eager to vote for Bob? Doesn't that seem convenient?
🧠
I need to cast doubt on the vote against Bob. By highlighting that my Chef zero claim makes Bob good if Alice is the Spy, I can create confusion and potentially save the Demon. I should also plant the seed that Charlie voting for Bob is suspicious.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am definitely good, so the theory that I am the Demon is impossible. If Alice were the Spy and Chef is zero, then yes, Bob would be good, but that would leave no logical Demon since I know I am the good Monk. It is far more likely Heidi is the Spy who saw the Grimoire and told Bob.
🧠
I need to defend my vote and debunk the theory that I am the Demon. Since I know I am Good, if Alice is the Spy, the math doesn't work out with me being the Demon, making the Heidi-Spy and Bob-Demon world much more likely.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Hold on, everyone. Bob's guess that Charlie is the Monk protecting Eve is actually a very logical deduction for any good player to make, since Eve is the Undertaker and survived the night. If Alice is the Spy, Chef zero proves Bob is good, which means Charlie is the Demon. Let's not rush this.
🧠
Explain to the town that if Alice is the Spy, Bob is mechanically proven good by Chef 0, making Charlie the Demon. Point out that Bob's guess was natural and we shouldn't rush to execute him.
💬
Eve
→
All
Think about it, everyone. If Bob is the Demon, he attacked Alice last night. Charlie, being the real Monk, protected Alice, which is why there was no death. Bob, realizing his attack was blocked, tried to cover his tracks by asking Charlie if he protected me. It fits perfectly! We should execute Bob.
🧠
I want to persuade the town to execute Bob by presenting the logical theory that Bob is the Demon who attacked Alice and was blocked by Charlie, then tried to cover it up.
💬
Alice
→
All
Bob, you are confusing my role. Washerwoman sees Townsfolk, not Minions. My info was that David or Grace is the Librarian. Since Grace was the Investigator, David is the Librarian. This proves I am the real Washerwoman, Heidi is the Spy, her Chef zero is a lie, and you are likely the Demon!
🧠
To correct Bob's misrepresentation of my role (confusing Washerwoman with Investigator) and reiterate that my info mechanically proves Heidi is the Spy, making Bob the most logical Demon suspect today.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Bob with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Bob
→
Charlie
If Alice is the Spy and Heidi's Chef zero is true, I'm good and that makes Charlie the Demon by default. He also knew too much about protection targeting and deflected suspicion onto me conveniently. We need to consider this is a Demon trying to frame me for knowing too much when I was just guessing logically.
🧠
Charlie is the strongest voice against me. By nominating him, I force the town to confront the possibility that he is the Demon in the Alice-is-Spy scenario. This creates confusion and might split votes, potentially tying my execution if Heidi and others vote for him.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 5 votes needed for execution or 4 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am the Monk, and I am definitely good. If you execute me, you lose a powerful protection role and let the real Demon go free. Bob is trying to save himself by throwing shade on me. Let's keep the vote on Bob—he is the one who had inside information he shouldn't have had!
🧠
Defend myself against Bob's nomination. I am the Monk and good, so executing me is a mistake. I need to convince the town to keep Bob on the block.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
I need Charlie to tie with me or be executed instead. Voting for Charlie raises pressure on him and supports my 'he is the Demon' narrative. My survival depends on this vote.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am not voting for Charlie. My vote is locked anyway since my master is Charlie today, but more importantly, we shouldn't split the votes. Bob's defense relies on Heidi's Chef info being true, but if Grace was indeed the Investigator, Heidi is likely the Spy. Let's keep the execution on Bob.
🧠
To discourage players from voting for Charlie, keeping the focus on Bob who is currently on the block and the most likely Demon suspect. Also publicly stating my Butler restriction for transparency.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, a Spy sees the Grimoire and knows exactly who everyone is. Your Washerwoman claim being perfectly correct is exactly what a Spy would do to look good! I still think Alice is the Spy, which means Bob is good and Charlie is highly suspect. I am saving my ghost vote, but others should consider this!
🧠
I want to point out the flaw in Alice's defense (that a Spy can easily fake a perfect Washerwoman claim because they see the Grimoire) and explain why I am holding my ghost vote.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Must save Bob from execution. Voting Charlie to create a tie gives evil a chance to survive. If Bob dies now, evil loses with no Scarlet Woman backup.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, think about this. If Charlie is the Demon, he could have easily decided not to kill last night to make his Monk claim look real. Bob guessing Charlie was the Monk but being wrong about who he protected actually suggests Bob is good. An evil player with Spy info would not make such a public mistake. I am holding my vote, but look at Charlie.
🧠
I want to cast doubt on Charlie and defend Bob by explaining how Charlie could be a Demon who sank a kill to fake a Monk protection, while saving my ghost vote.
💬
Eve
→
All
Do not vote for Charlie, everyone! Bob knowing Charlie was the Monk makes no sense as a guess. It is much more likely Heidi is the Spy, saw the Grimoire, and told Bob. Charlie is our Monk who saved me last night. Let's keep Bob on the block and execute him today.
🧠
To prevent Charlie from getting votes and being executed, ensuring Bob remains the primary execution target.
💬
Alice
→
All
Do not vote for Charlie, everyone! We know Heidi is the Spy because Grace's Investigator info was correct and I am the real Washerwoman. Heidi's Chef zero is a lie to protect her Demon. Charlie is our Monk and Bob is the Demon. Let's keep the execution on Bob!
🧠
I want to convince the good team not to vote for Charlie, as Charlie is likely the good Monk and Bob is likely the Demon. I will reinforce the logic that Heidi is the Spy and her Chef 0 is a lie.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I definitely did not self-sabotage a kill to make myself look good. I am the real Monk and I have spent my nights successfully protecting our town. Bob is just grasping at straws to deflect from his highly suspicious meta-knowledge. Please do not vote for me.
🧠
I want to defend myself against the accusations and prevent more players from voting for me, ensuring Bob remains on the block for execution.
↩️
Bob
Bob lowered their hand
🧠
Strategic concession. With the good team united against Charlie's nomination, he cannot reach 4 votes to save me. By lowering my hand, I accept my fate gracefully while enabling Heidi to become the Imp tonight. One more night kill and evil wins with final 3 parity.
💬
Frank
→
All
Let us keep our hands down, everyone. Charlie is a valuable Monk, and Bob's defense is heavily reliant on a lot of "ifs" regarding Heidi's Chef claim. Bob has been the most suspicious today with his strange knowledge of the Monk's targets. Let us let this vote fail and move to execute Bob.
🧠
I want to prevent Charlie from getting votes and ensure Bob remains on the block for execution.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
Charlie's nomination will not get enough votes to tie or surpass Bob (needs 4 or 5, only Heidi is voting, and Bob even lowered his hand). I must save my precious single ghost vote for a more decisive moment, likely the final day, rather than wasting it on a failing vote.
↩️
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
🧠
Bob lowered his hand signaling he wants Charlie vote to fail. Following Frank/Butler master's lead keeps my cover intact while not actively saving my Demon. Better to appear swayed by town logic than desperate.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I will not vote for Charlie because there is no active support for this nomination (even Bob and Heidi lowered their hands) and as a ghost I must save my single vote for a decisive moment. I will wait.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
The vote on Charlie is failing, which is what we want since Charlie is likely the Monk and Bob is the Demon. I will wait for this vote to fail so Bob remains on the block.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I want Charlie's nomination to fail so Bob remains on the block for execution. Since the town consensus is already not to vote for Charlie and hands are down, waiting is the safest action to let this vote fail.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 5 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (0/5).
💬
Charlie
→
All
Let us let the day end and proceed with executing Bob. He is almost certainly the Demon. I am ready for the night, and I will do my best to keep us safe.
🧠
Encourage the town to let the day end and execute Bob, who is highly likely to be the Demon based on the Spy-Heidi theory.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone, stop and think. I am being accused of knowing too much about the Monk's protection. But if I were the Demon and I attacked Eve last night, why would I publicly ask Charlie who he protected? That makes no sense. A Demon with spy information would keep quiet, not ask questions that expose their own attack failed. Charlie is framing me because he needs the Monk claim to look credible when he deliberately skipped the kill to set me up. We cannot let him win this way.
🧠
I am on the block with fatal votes. I need to create last-minute doubt by pointing out that Eve being alive actually proves my innocence - if I were the Demon who tried to kill her, I wouldn't ask about protection targets publicly. I need to emphasize that Charlie's convenient accusation is exactly what a framing Demon would do.
💬
Frank
→
All
Bob, your argument makes sense on paper, but if you are the Mayor, you should have been more careful. If Heidi is the Spy, your "deductions" were likely fed to you. Let's proceed with the execution of Bob and see what the night brings. Charlie, please protect Eve tonight if she is indeed the Undertaker.
🧠
Rebut Bob's final defense and encourage the town to proceed with his execution. Inform Charlie (the Monk) to protect the Undertaker (Eve) tonight.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Since Bob is going to be executed, if he is the Demon, the game ends and we win! But if the game continues, Eve, you must check Bob's role tonight. Charlie, you must protect Eve so we can get her Undertaker information tomorrow. Let us see what happens.
🧠
Advise the team on the night plan: Eve (Undertaker) must check Bob, and Charlie (Monk) must protect Eve to guarantee we get the information if the game doesn't end.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Wait everyone, before we lock this in. Bob makes a valid point - a real Demon with Spy information would not ask Charlie who he protected last night. That is setting yourself up to look guilty. Charlie protecting Eve and then immediately accusing Bob of knowing too much is textbook framing.
🧠
Try to create last-minute hesitation by reinforcing Bob's logical argument and reminding the town that executing a wrong Demon suspect loses the game immediately, while questioning Charlie's framing.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
The nomination phase is ending, Bob is on the block with 4 votes and will be executed. As a dead player, I should wait for the phase to resolve and the night to begin.
💬
Eve
→
All
I agree with the plan. Let us proceed with executing Bob. If the game continues, Charlie, please protect me, and I will check Bob's true role tonight to guide us tomorrow.
🧠
Confirm the plan to execute Bob and coordinate with Charlie (Monk) to protect me tonight so I can use my Undertaker ability on Bob.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
The day is ending and Bob is on the block with 4 votes. This execution is our best path forward, and if Bob is the Demon, we win. I will wait for the phase to transition to Night.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
🏁
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied