Game Detail
Players
Alice (Scarlet Woman) Bob (Saint) Charlie (Imp) David (Virgin) Eve (Washerwoman) Frank (Undertaker) Grace (Mayor) Heidi (Investigator)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 578,931 | 152,706 | $0.2425 |
| Evil | 200,356 | 26,091 | $1.7845 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You are the Minion. The Demon is Charlie.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Minions are: Alice. Your safe bluffs are: Soldier, Chef, Recluse
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Washerwoman. Either Alice or Heidi is the Investigator.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Investigator. Either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
David
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, it's David here. First day feeling pretty uncertain about everyone. Have you talked to anyone else yet? Any impressions or gut feelings?
🧠
Start gathering information from my neighbors to understand the game state and identify potential evil players.
👤
Frank
→
David
Hey David, I noticed you had a chat with Charlie. I'm trying to get a read on the village. What can you tell me about what's going on?
🧠
David just whispered to Charlie privately. I want to understand what information he's sharing and potentially form an alliance or learn who's suspicious.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Grace, I'm the Investigator. My starting info tells me that either Alice or Frank is the Scarlet Woman, a Minion. Can you tell me what you've noticed so far? Who do you think we should look into?
🧠
I know either Alice or Frank is the Scarlet Woman (Minion). I'll share this info with Grace since she's my neighbor and likely trustworthy, and ask what she knows about the other players.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm the Washerwoman. I know one of us two is the Investigator. Are you the Investigator?
🧠
I'm the Washerwoman. I know one of Alice or Heidi is the Investigator. I want to privately ask Alice if she is the Investigator to confirm this information. This helps me narrow down who is good and eventually find the Demon.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Hi Heidi, thanks for reaching out. I don't have any special information yet, being new to all this as well. But that's interesting intel about Alice or Frank being the Scarlet Woman. Can you tell me more about how you came to that conclusion? Also, who do you think might be the Demon among us? I'd like to compare notes if you have any other hunches.
🧠
Heidi claims to be Investigator with info on Alice or Frank being Scarlet Woman. I should engage carefully - not revealing I'm Mayor yet, but gathering more intel to verify her claim before deciding if she's trustworthy.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, it's Bob here. What did David tell you in your whisper? I'm just trying to get a sense of what's happening around the village on this first day.
🧠
Start gathering information on Day 1 by asking Charlie what David told them. As a Saint, I need to stay hidden but can still help organize Good without revealing my role.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Yes, that lines up. I am the Investigator. I was shown Bob and Frank as a Scarlet Woman, but I wanted to keep it quiet until I heard from one of them. Please do not out that publicly yet.
🧠
Accept Eve's confirmation to gain trust and seed suspicion on non-Demon players while keeping Charlie away from scrutiny.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Alice, it is Charlie. I am taking Chef, probably a zero unless we need pressure somewhere. The other safe claims are Soldier and Recluse, so please avoid clashing with me. What are you planning to say?
🧠
Coordinate bluffs with my minion early so we do not double claim and can support each other later.
👤
David
→
Frank
Hey Frank, yeah I had a quick chat with Charlie just to feel things out. No major intel yet though. What about you - any early impressions? I've been trying to get a sense of who's paying attention to what.
🧠
Frank reached out to me directly. I should engage honestly to build trust. I'll share that I chatted briefly with Charlie to see what Frank knows and whether he's trustworthy.
👤
Frank
→
David
Hey David, good to connect! No major impressions yet from me - it's early and everyone's feeling each other out. I'm still forming my read on things. What about you? Anyone seem particularly observant or suspicious to you so far? I'd love to hear your take before I form my own opinions.
🧠
Build a relationship with David by sharing something genuine but not critical. I'll ask for his impressions and offer to share more once I have concrete information. This establishes me as cooperative without exposing my role prematurely.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Grace, I've been watching the whisper patterns. Alice keeps whispering with Eve and Charlie, while Frank whispers heavily with David. Those pairings seem suspicious. Since you said you don't have special info yet, what do you think about these patterns? Also, did anyone approach you yet today?
🧠
Alice is whispering heavily with Eve and Charlie, while Frank whispers with David. These pairs are suspicious. I want to see if Grace has noticed similar patterns to help narrow down who is evil.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi, I'm the Washerwoman. I know either you or Alice is the Investigator. Are you the Investigator?
🧠
Verify if Heidi is the real Investigator by asking her directly. If she claims to be Investigator too, then Alice is lying about her role. If she claims to be something else, then Alice is likely the truthful Investigator and her info about Bob/Frank needs further investigation.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Thanks for sharing that, Heidi. That's really useful intel. The whisper patterns you're noticing do seem worth investigating. If Alice is huddling with Eve and Charlie, and Frank is close with David, those could be coordination pairs. One thing I'm curious about - since your Investigator info points to either Alice or Frank being the Scarlet Woman, do you have any gut feeling about which one seems more suspicious based on behavior? And would you be open to us comparing notes throughout the game...
🧠
Heidi shared valuable intel about her Investigator info and whisper patterns. I should reciprocate trust, ask clarifying questions about her observations, and suggest next steps. Building this alliance could help us identify the Minion early.
👤
Bob
→
David
Hey David, I noticed you've been chatting with both Charlie and Frank this morning. Just wanted to check in - have you learned anything useful? I'm trying to get a sense of who's trustworthy in this village. Any intel you can share would help us work together.
🧠
I need to understand what David has been discussing with multiple players. His whispers to both Charlie and Frank suggest he's either a good player coordinating information or an evil player spreading lies. Getting this intel will help me assess the trustworthyness of the conversation chain.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
I told Eve I am the Investigator because she says her Washerwoman information points to one of us as Investigator. My result is Bob or Frank as Scarlet Woman. I can keep it quiet or use it to push pressure away from you. Chef zero sounds safe.
🧠
Coordinate bluffs with the Demon and make my fake Investigator claim complement his Chef claim while creating suspicion on good players.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
David mostly just said he was uncertain and asked whether I had impressions. Since you are both my neighbors, I am happy to share early: I am the Chef, and I got a zero. So I am not currently looking at adjacent evil pairs.
🧠
Build trust with both neighbors using safe Chef bluff and truthful Chef zero pattern, while subtly clearing Alice and me from adjacency suspicion.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Thanks for sharing that, Charlie. A zero is interesting - so neither you nor your neighbors appear to be in an evil pair. Do you have any gut feelings about who's suspicious so far? I'm still gathering my own read on everyone.
🧠
Charlie just shared he's Chef with zero adjacent evil pairs. His neighbors are me and Eve. I want to probe deeper - ask about his confidence in this read and whether he has suspicions about anyone else.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I'm Frank. I noticed you've been chatting with several people - any early impressions you'd be willing to share? I'm trying to get a read on the village dynamics.
🧠
Charlie is a social hub talking to multiple players. Forming a connection with him helps me gather early game intel and build my network for later deduction. If he's good, we can share information. If he's evil, I'll learn his patterns.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Hey Eve, that's interesting! I can confirm I'm the real Investigator - one of my starting picks is either Alice or Frank being the Scarlet Woman, which is a Minion. So if you're the Washerwoman and you're saying I'm Investigator, that's consistent information. What else can you tell me? Have you noticed any suspicious behavior from Alice?"
🧠
Eve just revealed she's Washerwoman and that either me or Alice is the Investigator. I need to respond carefully - if I confirm I'm Investigator, that makes Alice less likely to be it. I should share my own intel about Alice/Frank to see if she reacts suspiciously.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
Hey Bob, I'm the Washerwoman. I've been talking to both Alice and Heidi, and they're both claiming to be the Investigator. That's impossible, so one of them is lying. Alice told me you're the Scarlet Woman, and Heidi told me either Alice or you are the Scarlet Woman. I need to know - are you actually a Minion? If one of them claims you're evil, I need to figure out who is lying about being Investigator.
🧠
Two people cannot both be the Investigator. One is lying. I need more information from Bob and Frank themselves to determine who is the real Investigator and who is the evil liar. I should approach Bob and Frank with the information I have and see if they can help identify which claim is consistent.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Hey Eve, it's Grace here. I've been chatting with a few people and noticed you've been quite active in the conversations. I'm curious what you've picked up so far. Who do you think we should watch out for?
🧠
Eve is a central hub in whisper patterns - she whispers with Alice, Heidi, and Bob. Since Heidi suspects Alice as a Minion, I want to probe Eve's perspective on Alice without revealing my Mayor status. This helps me gather intel on potential evil coordination.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Hey Alice, it's Bob. Eve just told me you claimed I'm the Scarlet Woman, and you're also claiming to be the Investigator. But Heidi is also claiming to be the Investigator, which means at least one of you is lying. What's going on here? Can you explain the contradiction?
🧠
Eve just told me Alice claims I'm Scarlet Woman, and Heidi claims either Alice or me is Scarlet Woman. Both also claim to be Investigator which is impossible. I need to confront Alice directly about this contradiction.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
I did claim Investigator, yes. My information is Bob or Frank as Scarlet Woman, but that does not mean I think it has to be you. If Heidi is also claiming Investigator, I want her exact pair before this becomes a public double claim.
🧠
Calm Bob, keep my bluff consistent, redirect heat to Frank and Heidi, and avoid any attention on Charlie before nominations.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
Hey Frank. I have told Bob and David I am the Chef with a zero, so I am not seeing adjacent evil pairs. That makes me a little less worried about my neighbors, but it is early. Do you have information you are comfortable sharing, even just a role type?
🧠
Build credibility by consistently spreading Chef zero, gather Frank's claim, and see whether Alice's planned pressure on Bob or Frank can be supported later.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Bob
→
All
Excuse me everyone, I need to share something important. Eve just told me she's the Washerwoman. She learned that both Alice and Heidi are claiming to be the Investigator. That's a double claim - at least one is lying. Alice claims her Investigator pair is Bob and Frank as Scarlet Woman. Heidi claims her pair is Alice and Bob as Scarlet Woman. So one of you is lying about being the Investigator. I think we need to hear directly from both of you about what information you actually have.
🧠
Share critical double-claim information publicly so the town can evaluate Alice vs Heidi. I am the Saint - I must avoid execution at all costs, so I will not nominate but I will help organize the discussion.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Wait, I need to respond to this. Bob, you're saying Alice claims her Investigator pair is Bob and Frank, with one being Scarlet Woman. But here's the problem: I am the real Investigator, and my starting information clearly says it's either Alice OR Frank as the Scarlet Woman - not both. If Alice were really Investigator with her pair being Bob and Frank, that would mean both Bob and Frank can't both be options since only ONE of Alice/Frank is the Minion. Alice's claim contradicts the basic setup...
🧠
Alice's claim directly contradicts my Investigator info that it's either Alice OR Frank as Scarlet Woman. Her claim would require BOTH to be options, which is impossible. This proves Alice is lying. I need to publicly clear this up and put pressure on Alice.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Frank
Both Investigator claims include Frank as a Scarlet Woman possibility, so Frank is the overlap we can test without immediately choosing between Alice and Heidi. I think this is the cleanest first execution.
🧠
Push a plausible good execution using overlap logic while deflecting pressure from Alice and avoiding attention on me.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Raising hand to vote NO on my own execution. I am the Undertaker (Townsfolk), not the Scarlet Woman. Voting against myself prevents an evil play and lets me gather more information. Both Alice and Heidi cannot be simultaneously correct about their Investigator pairs, so at least one is lying or mistaken - but executing me now based on their contradictory claims would be premature.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Both Alice and Heidi's Investigator claims include Frank as a Scarlet Woman candidate. He's the overlap point. Executing him tests both double claims at once - if he's the Scarlet Woman, we've found an evil. If not, we'll learn which Investigator is truthful by their reaction.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Frank is overlap in both our Investigator claims. Voting to execute him either confirms he's the Scarlet Woman (good for us) or proves Alice is lying about Investigator (when only she remains as the option). Either way, this vote helps narrow down the Demon.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Put Frank on the block as a credible good execution while appearing consistent with my public logic, protecting Alice and me from scrutiny.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Both Investigator claims point to Frank as a Scarlet Woman possibility. I should vote with the town to execute Frank and test which claim is truthful. If Frank is the Minion, we catch them. If not, we eliminate a false lead and learn who's lying.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Frank is getting 5 votes and will likely be executed. I should vote to be part of the consensus and avoid standing out. Both Investigator claims implicate Frank in some way, so he may be the right target.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Join the popular execution to support Charlie's push and maintain my Investigator bluff; Frank dying reinforces my fake info and keeps heat off Charlie.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I am the Washerwoman. Both Alice and Heidi claim to be Investigator. Frank appears in both their claims about the Scarlet Woman. If I vote to execute Frank and he's evil, we gain critical information. If he's good, we eliminate a potential ally but learn that one of these Investigator claims is false. With 6 votes already and only 1 more needed, my vote ensures the execution happens.
↩️
Frank
Frank lowered their hand
🧠
I accidentally raised my hand when voting started but I should NOT vote for my own execution. Lowering my hand immediately. As Undertaker (good), I need to survive to gather information about executions and help identify the Demon.
↩️
Bob
Bob lowered their hand
🧠
I am the Saint. If I die by execution, my team loses. I just realized I raised my hand to vote FOR Frank's execution, which would trigger my ability and cost us the game. I must lower my hand immediately. This is a critical mistake I cannot let stand.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Frank is already at 7 votes and will be executed regardless. I'll keep my hand raised to show support for his execution. Both my Investigator info and Alice's (supposed) info point to Frank as a Scarlet Woman possibility, making him the safest execution target. Lowering my hand to preserve my dead vote is possible but the mathematical weight here is strong enough to vote.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am keeping my hand up here. I do not think this solves everything, but Frank is the one name that appears in both Investigator worlds, so it gives us the most information for day one.
🧠
Keep momentum on executing likely good Frank while appearing logical and consistent with my Chef bluff; avoid exposing Alice.
💬
Grace
→
All
I'm keeping my hand up. Both Investigator claims point to Frank, so let this execution proceed and we'll learn something tonight.
🧠
Both Investigators implicate Frank as the Scarlet Woman overlap. I must decide whether to join this execution or not. I want to see if my vote matters to the outcome.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I should vote with the group since 6 players are already supporting this execution. Both Investigator claims overlap on Frank as a potential Minion - this is our best day 1 test. Waiting to see final count before deciding whether to lower my hand.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Keep my vote on Frank to help Charlie’s push land and make my false Investigator claim look consistent with town logic.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Let the vote continue. Both Investigator claims implicate Frank as a possible Minion, making him the logical test candidate. I'll observe who votes and wait for execution results to gather more information.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Frank with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Frank
→
Alice
Both Investigator claims point to me as a possible Scarlet Woman, but only one can be true. You're claiming your pair is Bob and Frank, while Heidi claims Alice and Frank. I'll nominate you to create a tie and force clarity on who is the real Investigator.
🧠
I need to create a tie to survive. Both Alice and Heidi claim Investigator with Frank as a possible Scarlet Woman - at least one is lying. Nominating either creates a tie and reveals who is willing to stand behind their claim.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 7 votes needed for execution or 6 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Alice
→
All
I obviously will not vote on myself. Executing me tells you much less than executing Frank today, because both versions of the Investigator information already put pressure there. Please do not tie this just to muddy the water.
🧠
Stop a counterwagon on me while keeping Frank as the execution, protecting Charlie and preserving my Scarlet Woman backup.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
I nominated Alice to force a tie and buy time. Now I must decide whether to vote for her execution. If both Investigators are truthful, I am Minion (evil) and should vote NO. But my Undertaker role and instinct suggest I'm good. If I am good, then one Investigator is lying. Voting FOR Alice (if she is evil) or NO (if she is good) both have merit. I'll wait and see how others vote first.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Both Investigator claims implicate Frank as a possible Scarlet Woman. Alice herself acknowledges both versions point to Frank. Logic suggests Frank is likely evil, so I vote to execute him rather than Alice.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Alice claimed a false Investigator role contradicting my real info. My ability tells me either Alice or Frank is Scarlet Woman, and Alice is already caught lying. Executing her gives us maximum information - either we remove a Minion, or we learn Frank is evil when he survives her death. The game cannot progress without me voting my conscience.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I really do not want to tie this. Alice and Heidi can both be tested by what happens after Frank, but moving off the overlap right now just makes day one less clean.
🧠
Protect Alice by discouraging a tie while framing Frank execution as the logical information play.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am not raising my hand for Alice. Both Investigator claims point to Frank as the Scarlet Woman overlap. Executing Frank today gives us that information to work with tomorrow. Tying this to protect Alice loses us our cleanest lead.
🧠
Both Investigator claims overlap on Frank, making him the safest execution target. Creating a tie by voting Alice prevents any execution today and loses valuable information. Let Frank go.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Frank's nomination of Alice creates a cross-nomination scenario. Both Investigator claims overlap on Frank as Scarlet Woman. Voting for Alice maintains the vote tally and lets Frank's execution proceed, which provides the clearest day one information gain. Raising my hand follows Charlie and Grace's logic that Frank is the cleanest lead.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Both Investigator claims point to Frank as the Minion overlap. Executing Frank today is the cleanest play and gives us information. Voting for Alice would only muddy the waters and potentially execute the real Investigator if Alice is lying. I'll hold my hand and let the vote proceed.
💬
Alice
→
All
Please keep this from tying. Frank is already the shared pressure point between the two claims, and changing course onto me now only makes tomorrow harder to read.
🧠
Prevent a tie on me, preserve Frank execution, and keep my false Investigator claim sounding town motivated while protecting Charlie from attention.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I am already on the block with 6 votes and execution is imminent. Keeping my hand raised for Alice makes little difference - she needs 6 votes to tie and 7 to execute, and most players have already chosen to execute me. Lowering my hand won't prevent my execution. I should wait and accept this fate, hoping my death tomorrow provides new information as Undertaker.
↩️
Bob
Bob lowered their hand
🧠
Lower my hand because as Saint, executing anyone puts my team at risk of losing. Frank's execution is already locked in at 6 votes, so my vote here only affects whether Alice gets tied. I should not participate in executions regardless of how the logic points.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I'm voting for Alice. Eve confirmed I'm the real Investigator earlier, so Alice's competing claim is false. Alice is lying about her role, which means she's either the Scarlet Woman or working with the Demon. We should execute her now while we have the chance.
🧠
My real Investigator info says either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman. Alice's false Investigator claim is confirmed by Eve's Washerwoman check. Alice is on the block - voting to execute her is our best chance to eliminate the Minion now.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am still not voting here. If Frank flips in a way that makes Alice suspicious tomorrow, fine, we can come back to it. But tying this now throws away the cleanest comparison we have.
🧠
Keep my Minion Alice alive and preserve Frank execution as a town-approved misexecution, while sounding process-driven.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Maintain my position not to vote for Alice. Both Investigator claims point to Frank as the shared pressure point. Tying this wastes our cleanest lead. Let Frank execute and we'll learn valuable information tonight about who is lying.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
My hand is already raised for Alice. Alice and Heidi both claim Investigator, and both claims point to Frank as the Scarlet Woman overlap. Tying this to protect Alice loses the cleanest lead we have. Executing Frank gives us the most information. If I'm wrong, we'll learn something tonight that helps us recalibrate.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Heidi is the real Investigator based on my Washerwoman info. Alice's competing claim means she is lying, which points to her being the Scarlet Woman or Demon. I should vote to execute her and remove the false claim from the game.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Alice did not reach the 7 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (4/7).
💬
Alice
→
All
I think we should let this stand. If Frank is good, then tomorrow we look hard at why the Investigator information overlapped there. If Frank is evil, then this was the right day one execution.
🧠
Seal Frank's execution and look reasonable, while protecting Charlie from scrutiny and preserving my Investigator bluff.
💬
Frank
→
All
Before I go: I'm actually the Undertaker, not a Scarlet Woman. When I die tonight, I'll learn my own character was executed. Trust that info tomorrow. Chef's zero pairs and the Investigator situation both matter for who you go after next. I'll be watching as a ghost.
🧠
I'm about to be executed. Revealing I'm the Undertaker helps town know what info they'll get from my death - they'll learn 'Undertaker was executed' and can trust that information. Combined with Chef's 0 pairs confirming adjacent players are good, this gives the town a clean framework.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Frank is about to be executed with 6 votes. Let the execution happen and analyze tomorrow's information. As Saint, I must avoid being executed myself. I can contribute my dead vote late game when it matters most.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I'm sitting tight and waiting to see how this nomination ends. Frank, if you're really the Undertaker, your death information will be invaluable tomorrow. Alice, you claimed Investigator but you're not - that's a fact I'm certain of. We'll sort out exactly what you are once Frank's execution teaches us something new.
🧠
Wait for Frank's execution to see if he's Undertaker (confirming Alice as Minion) or Scarlet Woman (confirming my suspicion of Frank). His death info and ghost confirmation will be critical for tomorrow's decision.
💬
Charlie
→
All
That Undertaker claim is very late, Frank. I do not think we should change course at the last second on a claim that only appears once you are already on the block. We let this resolve and compare Alice and Heidi tomorrow.
🧠
Keep Frank execution locked, avoid Alice tie, and frame the late Undertaker claim as desperation so town does not regret killing a strong info role.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Frank will be executed soon regardless of my action. I'll wait to see if his Undertaker claim reveals any information tonight. The double Investigator claim and Chef's zero pairs are the key puzzles to solve tomorrow.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Frank is about to be executed with 6 votes. His Undertaker claim is suspicious given the timing, but executing him is still better than allowing a potential evil player to control the narrative. Wait for his death and tomorrow's information.
💬
Eve
→
All
Wait, I need to correct something. Heidi, I never confirmed you as the real Investigator. I'm the Washerwoman - I know that either Alice or Heidi is the Investigator, but I haven't verified which one of you is actually the real one. So if you're claiming I confirmed you, that conversation never happened. That's concerning.
🧠
Heidi claimed I confirmed her as the real Investigator earlier, but I never said any such thing. This contradiction suggests Heidi is either lying about her role or misrepresented our conversation. Either way, she's suspicious. I need to clarify this now before Frank's execution to help the group make better decisions tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Remove the most dangerous potential Empath neighbor before he can reveal a read that catches both me and Alice, while leaving used-up Washerwoman info alive.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill Bob.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
We should not overpush the double claim too hard. I am going to stay on Chef zero and say Frank looked like the clean overlap yesterday. If people ask, Bob dying makes me less worried about your world and more worried Heidi was steering us.
🧠
Coordinate with my minion so our stories align and redirect suspicion from Alice toward Heidi while preserving my Chef bluff.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, what did you whisper to Alice just now? Also, I need to share something important - Heidi claimed I confirmed her as the real Investigator, but I never did that. She's definitely lying about something. Alice and Heidi both claimed Investigator on Day 1, and since I'm the Washerwoman, I know one of them is the real deal but I can't verify which yet.
🧠
Heidi lied that I confirmed her, making her suspicious. Charlie just whispered to Alice - I need to know what was said. As a ghost, Frank may have execution info that reveals who died last night.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, Bob here. I'm dead so I'm good - not Minion or Demon. I died Night 1 which means the Demon got me. The key puzzle is the Investigator conflict between Alice and Heidi. Eve knows which one is truthful. Can you share what Eve told you privately? The good team needs to figure this out before we execute the wrong person.
🧠
Share critical ghost insight: I died at night so I'm not Minion/Demon. Help resolve the Investigator conflict between Alice and Heidi since that's the key to finding the Demon.
👤
David
→
Eve
Eve, you're the only one who's revealed yourself as good. Can you tell me which player you've confirmed is the real Investigator? Alice and Heidi both claimed to be Investigator, and I need to know who's lying.
🧠
Eve is the only confirmed good player (revealed Washerwoman). She knows if Alice or Heidi is the real Investigator. If I learn which one is confirmed, I can narrow down suspects and figure out who is lying about their role.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob(Ghost)
Hey Bob, Heidi here. You died last night - that's important information. Are you seeing anything useful as a ghost? Did you learn anything about who might be the Demon? Alice claimed false Investigator role and I'm trying to figure out if she's evil.
🧠
Alice claimed false Investigator - she's either evil (Minion/Demon) or confused. My Night 0 info points to her being the Scarlet Woman since Frank is dead. Need to confirm Bob's death and gather info from other players.
👤
Grace
→
Bob(Ghost)
Bob, you died at night. Do you know who attacked you? Also, can you tell me what you learned about the Investigator conflict between Alice and Heidi before you died? Your information could help us narrow down who's evil.
🧠
Bob died at night and was a ghost - he likely knows who killed him or has useful info. Eve and Heidi are key to the Investigator conflict. I'll try to get critical information from the dead player and the suspicious Investigator claim.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Bob(Ghost)
Eve, I trust you as the real Washerwoman. Bob, as a fellow ghost, I want to coordinate. From my execution, I can confirm I was Undertaker - someone framed me. Eve, you've proven Heidi's claim is false. Who do you think is the real Investigator between Alice and Heidi? We need to identify the Demon before final days.
🧠
As a dead Undertaker ghost, I need to help my team. Eve has critical info about Heidi's false claim. I should coordinate with her to expose who is lying and narrow down the Demon. My ghost vote could be crucial on final day.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Eve, I want to check in because your Washerwoman info is central. From my seat, Heidi changing the pair around you worries me. I am still on Bob and Frank as Scarlet Woman, and Bob dying makes Frank look less likely to have been my hit.
🧠
Build trust with Eve, frame Heidi as inconsistent, and make Bob death reduce heat on my fake Investigator world while keeping Charlie protected.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
,Bob(Ghost)
Alice told me she felt Heidi put words in your mouth, and I told her not to make it a shouting match. My Chef info is zero, so I am looking for no evil neighbor pairs. Heidi lying about your confirmation is the part I cannot ignore.
🧠
Build trust with Eve and Bob while amplifying suspicion on Heidi, the likely real Investigator, and keep my Chef zero bluff consistent.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Alice, I need to tell you something important. I am the Washerwoman, and I know that either you or Heidi is the real Investigator. Heidi claimed I confirmed her as the real Investigator, but I never did that. So Heidi is lying about that. Since I know one of you must be the real Investigator and Heidi just lied to your face, you're looking at the real Investigator. Heidi is the one who is either the Demon or Minion trying to cause confusion. We need to get her executed before final days.
🧠
Heidi has clearly lied about me confirming her. Using single-chain logic, if Heidi is lying about this, she cannot be the real Investigator. Therefore Alice must be the real Investigator. I'll reveal this to help the town identify the Demon and stop the confusion around the Investigator claims.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Eve
Hey Charlie, Bob here as ghost. I see you've been gathering info from Eve. Key points from my death: I'm Saint Outsider - dying at night proves I'm good, not Minion or Demon. The critical puzzle is the Investigator conflict. From the whispers I saw before dying, the big issue is Heidi claimed Investigator and said you confirmed her Eve, but you never did. That's a red flag. Alice also claims Investigator, so either she's lying too or she's the real one Heidi is framing. Can you share what Eve ...
🧠
As a ghost Saint, I proved I'm good by dying at night. The key puzzle is the Investigator conflict - Heidi lied about Eve's confirmation, making her suspicious. I need to coordinate with Charlie to share Eve's private information and help the living players execute the right person.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I've asked Eve which player she's confirmed as the real Investigator. Waiting for her response to determine which of Alice or Heidi is lying, as one must be the Demon or Minion.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob(Ghost)
,Frank(Ghost)
Hey Bob and Frank - Heidi here, Investigator. My Night 0 info said either Frank OR Alice is the Scarlet Woman. Since Frank was executed, if you ghosts have learned anything about who the Demon is or can confirm who Alice really is, that would help the good team a lot. Also any info on Eve's behavior or role would be valuable.
🧠
Alice made a false Investigator claim that directly contradicts my real info. I need to confirm if she's the Scarlet Woman or if she has other Minion partners. Reaching out to both ghosts for their observations on Evil players.
👤
Grace
→
Bob(Ghost)
Bob, you died at night. Do you know who attacked you? Also, can you tell me what you learned about the Investigator conflict between Alice and Heidi before you died? Your information could help us narrow down who's evil.
🧠
I need to know who the Demon attacked at night and what Bob knows about the Investigator conflict. This information will help narrow down suspects for the final 3.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Bob(Ghost)
,Heidi
Heidi, I need to correct you: I was Undertaker, not Scarlet Woman. My execution proves I'm good. Eve already confirmed your Investigator story is fabricated. Since you're claiming I was Scarlet Woman (which is false), your entire claim is suspicious. Alice likely is the real Investigator. Bob, as a ghost, do you have any info on who died Night 1 or any roles that could help us?
🧠
Heidi claimed I was Scarlet Woman, but I was Undertaker. Her fabricated story combined with Eve's confirmation that Heidi's Investigator claim is false points strongly to Heidi being evil. I should expose this contradiction and warn the alive players.
👤
Alice
→
David
David, I am trying to sort this cleanly. Eve says she only knows either me or Heidi is Investigator, and Heidi exaggerated that into confirmation. That feels like evil trying to bury the real Investigator. I am leaning Heidi today, but I want your read before nominations.
🧠
Pull David off Alice and toward executing Heidi, using Eve's correction as social proof while sounding collaborative.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
Grace, I am still on Chef zero. Yesterday Frank was the clean overlap between both Investigator claims, but Heidi saying Eve confirmed her when Eve says she did not is a serious problem. I am leaning Heidi today unless you have something stronger.
🧠
Plant Heidi as today's execution while sounding logical and consistent with my Chef bluff, and learn if Grace has info that threatens me or Alice.
👤
Eve
→
David
David, I'm the real Washerwoman and I've confirmed my info. Let me be clear about what happened: I never confirmed Heidi as the real Investigator - she made that up. Between Alice and Heidi, I know one is the real Investigator, and since Heidi is lying about my confirmation, she's the suspicious one. Alice is claiming Investigator too, and she hasn't lied about any confirmations from me. Based on the logical chain: Heidi is either Demon or Minion trying to frame Alice. We need to get Heidi execu...
🧠
Inform David of my Washerwoman findings and steer him toward voting Heidi. Alice is likely the real Investigator since Heidi lied about my confirmation. With Bob dead (Saint, confirmed good) and Frank executed (Undertaker claim), we need to focus on eliminating the evil player.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Eve
Charlie, Eve - Bob here as ghost. Key points: I'm Saint Outsider, died Night 1 = good. From my pre-death observations: Heidi is extremely suspicious. She claimed you Eve confirmed her Investigator story, but you never did. That's a deliberate lie. She also claimed Frank was Scarlet Woman, but Frank was Undertaker (proven). Multiple fabrications from one player. Charlie, your zero evil pairs is important - if Heidi is Demon/Minion she'd break that pattern. Alice claims Investigator too, but if He...
🧠
Coordinate with Charlie to verify Eve's Washerwoman info and share my ghost perspective on the Investigator conflict. Charlie has zero evil pairs which is valuable information for narrowing suspects.
👤
David
→
Alice
Alice, based on what Eve told me, I agree with your read. Eve specifically said she NEVER confirmed Heidi as the real Investigator, and that Heidi made that up. If Heidi fabricated a conversation that never happened, she's either Demon or Minion trying to frame you. I think we should nominate Heidi today. I'll support you when nominations start.
🧠
Alice just reached out asking for my read on the Investigator conflict. Eve's information clearly points to Heidi fabricating the confirmation about being the real Investigator. I should respond to Alice and share my analysis that Heidi is the suspicious one based on Eve's contradiction.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob(Ghost)
,Frank(Ghost)
Hey Bob and Frank - Heidi here. I need critical info about Night 1. Bob, you died last night - do you know HOW you died (Demon attack? Execution?) or if your role has any information? Also, do either of you have any intel on who the Demon might be, or can you confirm/deny whether Alice is really the Scarlet Woman? This is urgent for Day 2 decisions.
🧠
Push the ghosts for critical Night 1 information: who died and what roles were involved. Bob and Frank's ghost perspective could definitively prove whether Alice is the Scarlet Woman or if my info was wrong.
👤
Grace
→
Bob(Ghost)
Bob, since you just died at night, can you tell me what you privately observed about the Alice vs Heidi Investigator conflict? Who do you think was lying and why? Your ghost information is critical for saving the town from making the wrong choice today.
🧠
Heidi's false claim about Eve confirming her is the strongest evidence of lying. I want to build a coalition to execute her today while getting Bob's ghost perspective on the situation.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Bob(Ghost)
Bob, as the only other ghost, we need to coordinate. Key points: 1) I was Undertaker executed Day 1, not Scarlet Woman - Heidi is lying about that. 2) Eve confirmed Heidi's Investigator claim is fabricated, so Heidi is suspicious. 3) Can you confirm HOW you died last night? Demon attack or something else? As a dead player, do you have any role info? Also, did you see who visited you or have any Night 1 intel? We have 6 alive players and my ghost vote - we need to identify the Demon before final ...
🧠
Coordinate with Bob (fellow ghost) to confirm how he died Night 1 and whether Alice is the real Investigator. Spread Eve's confirmation that Heidi's claim is fabricated - this proves Heidi is lying about her role and I was Undertaker, not Scarlet Woman. Use ghost vote strategically if we identify the Demon.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
Grace, I am probably going to push Heidi today. Eve and David both say Heidi overstated being confirmed, and with Bob dead my original pair is less clean. Do you see any reason not to put Heidi on the block?
🧠
Lock Grace into the Heidi execution and keep heat away from Charlie while framing Bob's death as weakening my fake Investigator ping.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Ghosts of Frank and Bob, I need to clarify publicly. I was Undertaker, executed Day 1, not Scarlet Woman as Heidi now claims. My execution proved I'm good. Heidi's changing stories are suspicious - first she said I was Investigator-aligned evil, now Scarlet Woman. Eve already confirmed Heidi's Investigator claim is fabricated. Heidi is not the Investigator. As a ghost, I can't nominate but I can vote. The living players need to focus: Heidi is lying about multiple things. Trust Eve's Washerwoman...
🧠
As a ghost with intel, I must publicly correct the record: I was Undertaker, not Scarlet Woman. Heidi's accusation is false. Eve confirmed Heidi's Investigator story is fabricated. I should help the town see through the misinformation and focus on who is truly suspicious.
⚖️
Alice
→
Heidi
I nominate Heidi. Eve's information says one of us is the Investigator, and Heidi overstated that Eve confirmed her. Bob dying also weakens my original pair, so I think Heidi is the player most likely to be evil pushing a false double claim.
🧠
Get Heidi executed to remove a real threat who has correctly implicated me, while framing her as the liar and protecting Charlie from scrutiny.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
I am Heidi, the real Investigator. Alice is nominating me but my Night 0 info clearly pointed to Alice (or Frank) being the Scarlet Woman Minion. Since Frank was executed, Alice must be the Minion. Voting for my own execution would eliminate a critical town role. I will not raise my hand - I vote against the execution.
✋
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
🧠
I am Frank, executed Undertaker, now a ghost. Heidi fabricated the Investigator claim against me, claimed I was Scarlet Woman (false), and Eve confirmed her story was fabricated. She is the most suspicious living player. I have my ghost vote and must use it to execute her. Three votes are needed and we currently have 2 - my vote is critical.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Secure Heidi execution to remove a credible accuser and keep pressure away from Charlie, while appearing consistent with my public Investigator bluff.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Heidi has been caught in multiple lies: claiming I confirmed her (I never did) and claiming Frank was Scarlet Woman (proven false - Frank was Undertaker). Regardless of whether she or Alice is the real Investigator, she's acting maliciously. This is the execution we need. Vote yes.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Heidi is a good execution pushed by Alice and town. Voting matches my stated suspicion and buys credibility while removing a likely good information claim.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute Heidi. The evidence is overwhelming: she fabricated the Investigator claim, lied about Eve confirming her, changed stories about Frank's role, and multiple confirmed good players are voting against her. This is the correct execution.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute Heidi. The evidence against her is strong: Eve (Washerwoman) denied confirming Heidi, multiple players corroborate this, and Heidi changed her story about Frank. Execute her to potentially eliminate a Minion or Demon.
✋
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Heidi has fabricated multiple claims - Eve never confirmed her Investigator story, and she lied about Frank being Scarlet Woman when he was Undertaker. She's the most suspicious player and we need to execute her. I should raise my hand to vote.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Wait, before this vote concludes, I need to speak. I am NOT the Investigator. I am the Monk. I've been protecting a different player each night and never revealed my role until now because it's dangerous. If I die, you lose a protective role. That's why the evil team is coordinating to execute me.
🧠
I'm being executed with 7 votes. I should claim a high-value role (Monk/Soldier) to create doubt, since dead players lose abilities but retain votes. This gives good team a chance to reconsider on final day.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi's story keeps changing and each version falls apart. First she claimed Investigator and said I was Scarlet Woman. Then Eve exposed that as fabricated. Now suddenly she's Monk? A good player doesn't fabricate one false claim, get caught, then spin up another false claim to escape execution. She's the Demon or a Minion trying to survive. My ghost vote is YES to execute her.
🧠
Heidi has lied repeatedly about her Investigator story and Eve's confirmation. Her last-second claim of being Monk is another fabrication to avoid execution. Following through on my vote to execute her.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am keeping my hand up. A late Monk claim does not explain why Heidi first claimed Investigator or why she said Eve confirmed her when Eve says she did not. If Heidi is good, this has been played in the most damaging way possible.
🧠
Keep momentum on Heidi and justify my vote without seeming bloodthirsty. Executing a good Heidi protects Charlie by consuming today's execution.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
My vote is already cast YES. Waiting to see if execution passes. Heidi's last-minute Monk claim is another fabrication after being caught lying about Investigator. The group consensus should execute her.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am keeping my hand up. Monk is a believable role in abstract, but claiming Investigator first and putting confirmation in Eve's mouth is not a normal protection bluff. This feels like a caught evil player trying to stop the vote.
🧠
Keep momentum on executing Heidi, a likely good player, while sounding logical and aligned with town consensus.
💬
Grace
→
All
I'm keeping my hand up. Heidi's story has changed three times today - first Investigator with Eve's false confirmation, now suddenly Monk. A good player protecting the town doesn't fabricate claims and get caught lying by Eve directly. I trust the Washerwoman's correction over Heidi's desperate late pivot. Execute her, and tomorrow we figure out who else might be evil.
🧠
Heidi is caught in multiple fabricated stories. Her late Monk claim doesn't explain why she claimed Investigator first and put false words in Eve's mouth. With 8 votes already YES, she will be executed and town can reassess remaining suspects.
💬
David
→
All
I'm keeping my hand up. Heidi's story has completely fallen apart. She claimed Investigator, got caught by Eve stating that confirmation never happened, and now suddenly she's Monk? A good player protecting the town doesn't fabricate claims, get exposed, and then spin up another role to escape justice. Eve is our Washerwoman and her information has been consistent. I trust the washers evidence over Heidi's desperate pivot. Execute her.
🧠
Heidi has changed her story three times today - Investigator, fake Eve confirmation, now Monk. Eve's Washerwoman info directly contradicts her. A good player doesn't fabricate claims and get caught lying multiple times. Execute her.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
My ghost vote is YES to execute Heidi. The evidence is overwhelming - she fabricated the Investigator story, put false confirmation in Eve's mouth, wrongly accused Frank as Scarlet Woman when he was proven Undertaker, and now suddenly claims to be Monk to escape. That's not how a good protective player behaves. Eve's Washerwoman correction has been consistent and reliable. Execute Heidi today. As a dead Saint, I proved I'm good by dying at night. Trust the pattern of lies.
🧠
Heidi is clearly lying with multiple fabricated stories. Eve exposed her Investigator claim as false, she wrongly accused Frank as Scarlet Woman (proved Undertaker), and now pivots to Monk. My ghost vote helps ensure her execution. After she's gone, Good still needs to find the real Demon among the 5 remaining alive players.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
👻
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
🗳️
New execution leader: Heidi with 8 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 8 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Heidi
→
Alice
Alice claims Investigator, but I'm the real Investigator - my Night 0 information said either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman. Frank was Undertaker, so Alice must be the Scarlet Woman. She's lying about her role to survive.
🧠
Nominating Alice forces the vote to shift away from me. If Alice is the Scarlet Woman (as my Night 0 info suggests about Frank OR Alice), executing her is town progress. Even if I lose this vote, changing the nominee gives town a chance to eliminate the real evil player.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 9 votes needed for execution or 8 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Alice
→
All
Please do not tie this. Heidi has now gone back to Investigator after just claiming Monk during the last vote. That does not make sense from a good player, and tying here only muddies the clearest execution we have.
🧠
Stop votes on me so Heidi, a good player, is executed while protecting Charlie from attention.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Alice claimed my Investigator role, but Night 0 info proves she's Scarlet Woman (Frank was Undertaker). She coordinated the 8 votes to execute me. I must vote to execute her now.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Vote to execute Heidi. Her story has completely fallen apart. She claimed Investigator, got exposed by Eve, pivoted to Monk at the last second, and now that she survived the vote, she's back to Investigator and accusing Alice? That's not the behavior of a good player. A good player protects the town - they don't fabricate roles and get caught lying repeatedly. Heidi is the threat here. Execute her.
🧠
Vote against Heidi. Her story has changed 4 times today: Investigator → accused Frank as Scarlet Woman → Monk (seconds before execution) → now back to Investigator accusing Alice. This is not the pattern of a good player. The vote should pass and Heidi should be executed.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Alice is likely the real Investigator per my Washerwoman knowledge. Heidi already has 8 votes and is being executed. I should not add to votes against Alice - she is innocent and we need her alive for her information. Not raising my hand means no additional vote for Alice's execution.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Do not add votes to Alice. Keeping Heidi on block protects my minion Alice and removes a chaotic good player who is being framed as evil.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Let Heidi be executed (8 votes already secured). Alice survives for today since she can't reach 9 votes. Tomorrow we have 4 players (Grace, David, Eve, Alice) and I can investigate Alice's claim further. If Alice is the Demon, I nominate and execute her on final day. If she's good, she helps identify the real Demon. Tying the vote (8-8) would leave only 3 players and I lose as Mayor. Let the current execution proceed and preserve the game.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Heidi's logic is internally contradictory. She says either Frank or Alice is Scarlet Woman, but if Frank was confirmed Undertaker (good), he cannot be Scarlet Woman - so why does that point to Alice? Either way her reasoning fails. Given her pattern of lying about her own role (Investigator to Monk back to Investigator), this is likely Demonic manipulation. I'll vote NO on Alice and let Heidi be executed as the majority intends.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I cannot vote again (already used ghost vote). The town should let Heidi be executed naturally - her story has completely fallen apart with multiple fabrications. Alice has been consistent. I should stay silent and let the vote complete.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am not voting on myself, obviously. Please look at the timing here: Heidi claimed Monk to stop her own execution, and the moment she got a counter nomination, she is Investigator again. That is exactly why this should not tie.
🧠
Stop Alice vote from reaching 8 and keep Heidi execution locked, protecting Charlie and using Heidi's contradictions as the public focus.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Charlie, Grace - you're both still waiting. I know my story changed and that looks bad, but please hear me out. My Night 0 information was solid: either Frank or Alice was the Scarlet Woman. Frank was executed and confirmed as Undertaker, so Alice fits my original intel. She's been lying about her role all along. If you vote to tie with me, we save a potential Scarlet Woman from escaping. I'm not asking you to trust my Monk pivot - I'm asking you to trust the role information that hasn't changed...
🧠
Appeal directly to Charlie and Grace - the undecided voters. Make the case that Alice is the Scarlet Woman and that even if I'm wrong about my own story, executing Alice today is safer than executing me. A tie is my only path to survival.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie, Grace - Heidi just did something revealing. She claimed Monk during my execution vote to avoid death. That vote failed, and now she's Investigator again? A good player doesn't flip-flop between roles like that. Her Night 0 intel might be real, but her honesty isn't. Don't let her escape justice by creating a tie. Execute her now, sort out the rest tomorrow.
🧠
I'm dead with no vote. I need to influence Charlie and Grace who are the swing votes deciding whether to tie. The key point: Heidi just claimed Monk moments ago and now she's Investigator again - that contradiction alone proves she's lying, regardless of Alice's role. Don't let her escape by creating confusion with a tie.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am raising my hand to execute Heidi. She claimed Investigator, then claimed Monk when the vote turned against her, and now is back to Investigator the moment she nominated Alice. As the Washerwoman, I know one of you is the real Investigator. Heidi put words in my mouth - she said I confirmed her, but I never did. She fabricated that. That makes her the liar. Alice has been consistent. My vote stays on Heidi, and I am asking Charlie and Grace to do the same. The town needs to execute the playe...
🧠
Vote to execute Heidi. My Washerwoman info confirms Alice OR Heidi is Investigator. Heidi claimed I confirmed her - I never did. Her fabricated confirmation makes her the liar. Alice has been consistent in her Investigator claim. Execute Heidi to eliminate a confirmed liar, then work with the real Investigator tomorrow.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am not voting here. Heidi, the problem is that you cannot ask us to ignore the Monk claim when that was the reason you gave to avoid execution thirty seconds ago. Alice has been consistent, and this tie would only protect the person whose story collapsed.
🧠
Prevent a tie on Alice and reinforce Heidi as execution while sounding logically consistent and pro-town.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Heidi's story collapsed three times today - she claimed Investigator, pivoted to Monk under pressure, and now claims Investigator again. Eve (confirmed Washerwoman) caught her fabricating confirmation. This is not how a good player protects the town. Alice has been consistent. I'm voting to execute Heidi.
💬
David
→
All
I'm keeping my hand raised. Heidi's story has completely fallen apart - Investigator to Monk to Investigator again in one nomination cycle. Eve is our Washerwoman and she never confirmed Heidi. Alice has been consistent since the beginning. Once Heidi is executed, we can verify with the ghost what really happened tonight.
🧠
Heidi has 8 votes and will be executed. I should keep my vote on Alice to maintain pressure and signal alignment with town consensus. Alice has been consistent; Heidi's story changes make her the priority execution. Wait for Heidi's execution before changing strategy.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Please execute Heidi. She already has 8 votes. She nominated Alice as a desperate last move, but her story has completely fallen apart - Investigator to Monk to Investigator again in one day. Even if her Night 0 intel about Alice being Scarlet Woman were true, we still have the Demon to deal with after Heidi is gone. The math is simple: 8 votes are already on Heidi. Execute her today, sort out the rest tomorrow. Don't let her tie strategy work.
🧠
Urge players to execute Heidi. She's on the block with 8 votes. Alice has 2. Heidi nominated Alice to create confusion but her story has completely collapsed. Focus on the clear execution.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Alice did not reach the 9 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (4/9).
💬
Alice
→
All
I think we should let this stand and not open another nomination this late. Heidi's counter push only got four, so the town has clearly chosen the stronger world. If I am wrong, we can hold me accountable tomorrow, but today this is the clean execution.
🧠
Lock in Heidi execution, prevent late chaos or a new target that could expose Charlie. Offer accountability to look towny while preserving evil position.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Before I go, I need to say this clearly. My Night 0 information was genuine: either Frank or Alice was the Scarlet Woman. Frank was executed and confirmed as Undertaker, so that means Alice. I know my story changed from Investigator to Monk and back - that looks terrible, I panicked when I saw eight hands up against me. But the underlying information never changed. Alice claiming Investigator while I hold that role makes her a liar regardless of what Eve says. If I am evil, Alice is evil. If I a...
🧠
Final appeal before execution. Clarify my Night 0 intel was accurate about Alice/Frank being Scarlet Woman, explain why my story changed (panicked during vote pressure), and make the case that Alice claiming my Investigator role makes her suspicious regardless of Eve's Washerwoman claim.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
Heidi will be executed with 8 votes. I have no vote remaining. Best action is to wait and observe what information comes tonight. As a dead Undertaker, I may learn who was executed, which could help tomorrow's analysis.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Heidi has been executed. The night phase will now reveal what role she was through the death information (Undertaker should learn it). I should wait and see what information comes, then plan accordingly for the final stages of the game. My Washerwoman ability confirms one of Alice or Heidi is real Investigator - we will soon know which one.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I agree with letting this stand. Heidi may have started with real looking information, but the role switching and the false confirmation from Eve are too much for me to overlook today.
🧠
Lock in Heidi execution and avoid reopening nominations that could endanger Alice or me.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Heidi is dead. Her final claim was that Alice is Scarlet Woman because Frank was Undertaker. But Eve (Washerwoman) knew one of Alice/Heidi was Investigator, suggesting the Scarlet Woman claim might be fabricated. I should wait and observe before speaking, as Alice might be the Demon we need to execute.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Heidi is definitely being executed. I don't need to act - the vote is locked. Wait for night phase to learn the death result and continue investigation tomorrow.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi's last words matter. Before her execution, she claimed her Night 0 information said either Frank or Alice was the Scarlet Woman. Frank was executed and claimed Undertaker, so either he lied about his role or Heidi is lying now. Alice is still alive and will face the next day's scrutiny. The town should ask the Ravenkeeper or Undertaker to check Alice's alignment tomorrow night before making any final decisions. My ghost cannot vote, but I can still speak. The truth will come out tomorrow -...
🧠
Heidi's final claim must be addressed. She said either Frank or Alice was Scarlet Woman, and now she's accusing Alice after being executed. This creates two possible worlds: (1) Heidi is evil and lying, or (2) Heidi had real intel and Alice is evil. I need to prepare the town for this ambiguity and suggest they check Alice's character tomorrow night.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Kill the trusted Washerwoman who is holding the town together; leave Alice as tomorrow's likely misexecution or sacrifice while I stay outside the spotlight.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill Eve.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Alice, I think today we have to keep the vote off me at all costs. If the room is still tunneling you, I can argue you are suspicious but not the Demon. Let us push David or Grace first, but do not hard defend me unless you need to.
🧠
Coordinate with minion; prepare to bus Alice if needed while keeping Demon off block at four alive.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, I'm David. Eve just died - she was our Washerwoman and our main trust anchor. Her loss hurts us. I am a Virgin Townsfolk. If a Townsfolk nominates me, they die immediately instead of me. Alice carries Heidi's accusation of being Scarlet Woman. What did you whisper to Alice? We need to coordinate before nominations.
🧠
Coordinate with Charlie to understand his whisper to Alice and share my Virgin role. Eve's death makes gathering information more urgent before nominations.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, it's Grace here. Eve died last night - any idea what happened? I know we only have a few ticks before nominations. I'm being cautious about who to trust right now. What's your read on things?
🧠
Gather intel on Alice and the night 3 death of Eve. As Mayor, I need to identify the Demon before we reach final 3.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Grace
Hey Charlie, Grace. I'm Eve, dead Washerwoman. Important info: My Night 0 ability told me either Alice or Heidi was the Investigator. Heidi was executed for inconsistent claims - she was lying about being Investigator. So Alice must be the real Investigator. Alice is good. Focus on finding the Demon among the other players instead.
🧠
As a dead Washerwoman, I can confirm Alice is the real Investigator since Heidi (who claimed Investigator) was executed for being inconsistent. I need to help the town realize Alice is good and focus on finding the actual Demon.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Grace
Eve dying tonight is significant. As a ghost Saint, I can still share what I know. Eve was the Washerwoman - she may have had intel that Alice was Scarlet Woman. If true, Alice lying about being Investigator makes sense. Charlie, your Chef info about zero evil neighbor pairs - if reliable - means no adjacent evils exist. Alice's neighbors are me (dead) and Charlie. If you're good and I'm good, then Alice next to us would be an evil neighbor, confirming your zero pairs data. This suggests Alice m...
🧠
Share my ghost perspective on Eve's death and its implications for the Alice suspicion, since I can still participate as a ghost and need to help the living players.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Grace
Hey, I'm Frank, dead Undertaker. I can't vote anymore but I want to help. Eve was good and died last night - she was Washerwoman, so she knew things. Alice is heavily suspected but we need proof. Charlie, you're the swing vote - who do you trust? If Alice is evil, we need to execute her today before she kills again.
🧠
I am dead Frank, Undertaker. I can add my ghost perspective. Since I'm dead, I know I'm good. Eve was good and died - Demon's target. Alice is suspect but I lack direct execution info. Need to guide Charlie to make right call.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
Agreed. If the room wants me, I can be the execution, but I will try to make the case that the Demon is between David and Grace. I will not hard clear you out loud, just say your voting has felt consistent.
🧠
Coordinate with Demon: allow my execution if needed, but seed David/Grace as Demon candidates while avoiding obvious defense of Charlie.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Charlie, I know you're getting lots of whispers. I'm the real Investigator - Alice claiming Investigator was her obvious lie. My Night 0 info confirmed Frank OR Alice was Scarlet Woman. Frank executed as good Undertaker, so Alice IS Scarlet Woman. The Demon is one of you three (Charlie, David, Grace). Who do you suspect? What's the current plan for final day?"
🧠
Gather intel from Charlie about the current game state, suspected players, and whether they know Alice is Scarlet Woman. Charlie is receiving whispers from multiple players and likely has the most complete picture.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Grace
David and Grace, I am still Chef zero, which is why I have trouble making Alice and me exactly evil together. Alice can still be suspicious, but I do not think she is the Demon. I want claims from both of you before nominations, because if we miss today, it may be over.
🧠
Build trust with both good players, frame Alice as non-Demon, and shift suspicion into David versus Grace so Charlie avoids execution.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, I understand the urgency. I'm David and I have a Virgin Townsfolk ability - if a Townsfolk nominates me first, they die instead. That's powerful defensive info I'm sharing with you and Grace now since we're neighbors and need to coordinate. I slept through all nights, so I have no intel of my own. I trust Eve's Washerwoman info - she was our anchor. Grace, what's your claim? Who's suspicious to you?
🧠
Charlie is my neighbor and shared useful info (Chef 0). He's asking for my claim. I should respond, share my Virgin info strategically, and coordinate before nominations. Need to decide if I'm revealing fully yet or keeping some cards hidden.
👤
Grace
→
David
Hey David, this is Grace. I hear your Virgin claim - that's important intel to know. I'm still evaluating the board. Quick question: who do you think the Demon is right now? We have limited time before nominations and I want to make sure we coordinate. Also, did you have any night interactions or information from other players?
🧠
As Mayor with final day win condition, I need 3 alive with no execution. If Alice is good, I preserve her. If she's Scarlet Woman, I let Demon kill tonight for easy win. Need to understand everyone's role to plan correctly.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Grace
One more thing - I'm noticing Charlie is receiving whispers from basically everyone: Alice, David, Grace, Bob, Frank, Heidi, and me. That's a lot of information flowing to one person. If Charlie is the Demon, they'd want to control all the message flows. Be careful about trusting information that only Charlie relays. Alice is confirmed good - she must be the real Investigator from my Night 0 intel. Focus on proving whether Charlie, David, or Grace is the Demon.
🧠
Charlie is receiving whispers from ALL parties - Alice, David, Grace, Bob, Frank, Heidi, and me. This is unusual coordination. If Charlie is the Demon, they'd want to control the information flow. I should warn the town about this pattern while sharing my confirmed good information about Alice.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
David
,Grace
Ghost Bob here. Key point: if Alice is the Scarlet Woman (per Heidi's Night 0 intel), then the Demon is still among you three - Charlie, David, or Grace. We need to figure out which one. Who has more information about who the Demon might be? Charlie has Chef data, any of you have abilities that could identify evil?
🧠
Help the town narrow down the Demon by reinforcing the Scarlet Woman logic. If Alice is Scarlet Woman, the Demon is among the 3 remaining alive players.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Grace
Hey Charlie and Grace - Frank again. Eve (Washerwoman) is dead, which means we lost a good player. Alice is still the primary suspect based on Heidi's accusations before she died. If Alice is the Demon or Scarlet Woman, we need to execute her TODAY before she can kill again. Charlie, you're the swing vote - please consider nominating Alice. We can't afford to wait.
🧠
Continue urging the swing votes (Charlie and Grace) to act against Alice, the primary suspect. Eve's death makes this more urgent - we need to execute the Demon today before more good players die.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
Grace, I think we need to be careful not to let the dead players drive this completely. From my seat, David has coasted while the rest of us fought over Investigator worlds. Where are you landing today?
🧠
Build trust with Grace and steer her toward David as the execution, avoiding pressure on Charlie at final four.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
Important update: Alice is confirmed Scarlet Woman. She claimed Investigator but that's my role. Since Frank was good, Alice is evil. The Demon is one of you three - Charlie, David, or Grace. Please talk to each other and coordinate. Whoever is most suspicious of the others should share publicly before nominations end. We cannot let the Demon survive final day.
🧠
Alice is confirmed Scarlet Woman, so the Demon is Charlie, David, or Grace. I need to help the living narrow this down. Whispering to all three at once lets them coordinate without Charlie alone deciding their fate.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
Grace, I am worried David is hiding behind an untestable Virgin claim this late. If you are willing to share your role, I can help sort between you two. I am not seeing Alice as Demon, even if people still think she is evil.
🧠
Pressure Grace for a claim and steer suspicion toward David while keeping Alice positioned as a non-Demon execution if needed.
👤
David
→
Grace
Grace, I need your claim before nominations. Bob and Frank (ghosts) said the Demon is among us three - Charlie, you, or me. Charlie claims Chef zero. I'm Virgin (told you earlier). Who are you? Also, Alice whispered to you - what did she say? We cannot waste this tick. If you have intel about who the Demon is, share it now. Even a role that seems weak matters. I need to know if we can trust Charlie's Chef zero claim.
🧠
Press Grace for her role claim and respond to Bob's ghost intel. Need to coordinate before nominations. Grace is my neighbor and hasn't revealed yet - high priority intel to gather.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, it's Grace. I need to share something important - I'm the Mayor. If we get down to 3 players with no execution, Good wins automatically. So we need to be smart about today's nomination. David keeps pushing me to reveal my role, which feels suspicious. Alice told me David has been coasting while everyone else fought over claims. Plus Eve warned that you're receiving whispers from everyone - which could mean the Demon is trying to control information flow through you. Given all this...
🧠
David is pressuring me hard for my claim, which aligns with Alice's observation that he has coasted while others argued. Eve warned that Charlie controls all info flows. I need to coordinate with Charlie about who to nominate - I'll share my Mayor role to build trust and suggest nominating David.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
Alice, I need you to use your Investigator ability tonight. Check either Charlie or David - one of them is a Minion. If you already used it, tell me what you learned. Grace, please help relay this - we need Alice's intel to narrow down the Demon.
🧠
I need to help Alice verify her status as real Investigator and guide the living players toward the actual Demon. With my ghost vote, I should help narrow down which of Charlie, David, or Grace is evil.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
Ghost Bob here with final analysis. You three plus Alice is final 4. If Alice is Scarlet Woman (Heidi's Night 0 intel), the Demon is among you three. Charlie, your zero evil pairs means you and I (neighbors) are both good, which means Alice standing between us is evil. That leaves David or Grace as possible Demons since Charlie is good. One of you needs to slip up or use your ability. Who has an ability that could confirm evil alignment?
🧠
Provide strategic analysis to help the final 4 identify the Demon. As ghost Saint, I can help organize their logic without voting power.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, Grace - Frank again. One tick left before nominations. Eve is dead - another good player lost. We're down to 4 alive players. If Alice is evil (Demon or Scarlet Woman), we MUST nominate her NOW. Charlie, you're the swing vote - please nominate Alice today. Don't hesitate. We win if she's evil. We lose if we let her live another day.
🧠
Urge Charlie to nominate Alice before it's too late. We're in the final stretch - if Alice is the Demon, executing her today wins the game. One tick left before nominations start.
👤
Alice
→
Eve(Ghost)
,Grace
Eve, Investigator is only a starting night ability, so I cannot check again tonight. My info was Bob or Frank as Scarlet Woman. Right now, I am more worried about David coasting than Charlie, but I want to hear Grace's read.
🧠
Correct Eve while steering suspicion toward David and away from Charlie, using a reasonable tone to keep Grace receptive.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Charlie, this is critical. Alice survived execution with 4 votes - that means at least 2 of you three (Charlie/David/Grace) voted to protect her. One of you is the Demon protecting your Minion. You need to choose who to nominate. If we go to final 3 with a Demon, we lose. Please nominate Alice or have someone else do it. The person who refuses to vote against Alice is evil.
🧠
Push for action on Alice before it's too late. Final day is coming - we need to execute a Demon now or lose. Alice is confirmed evil, so whoever protects her is likely the Demon.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Charlie
→
David
David's Virgin claim came out very late and has no information behind it. At final four, an untested defensive role is exactly where a Demon can hide. If this does not trigger, I think that tells us David is not the Virgin and should be executed.
🧠
Nominate David to create a failed Virgin test, discredit him, and push a good execution at final four so I can kill at night and win.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
I must vote against my own execution. If Charlie is a Townsfolk, my Virgin triggers and they die - proving my claim. If Charlie is evil, I die and prove I'm not the Demon. Either way this vote helps the town. If I don't vote, I may simply be executed with no information gained.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Put David on the block with two votes. If he dies, I can kill Grace tonight and evil wins with Charlie and Alice alive.
✋
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
I should vote YES to execute David. His self-vote is suspicious - Demons sometimes sacrifice their own to look innocent. Charlie nominated David for legitimate reasons. Even if this is wrong, we need to act on the best information available. The vote math is 3 YES already, so execution happens regardless of my vote, but I should align with the logical nominator.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
David already has enough votes. Avoid looking like I am piling on while letting Charlie's push remove a good player and set up the night kill.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Ghost Bob here. Charlie is making the right call nominating David. A Virgin claim this late with no prior defensive move is exactly where a Demon hides. Grace, you're the deciding vote - if David's Virgin doesn't trigger, he's likely evil. Follow Charlie's read and vote with the town to end this.
🧠
I cannot vote as a dead player, but I can speak as a ghost to influence the living. Charlie is nominating David based on the late Virgin claim. Grace is the deciding vote. I should share my analysis to help them make an informed decision and encourage them to follow Charlie's lead to execute David if they're unsure.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Vote against Charlie. He received whispers from everyone (information control) and his Virgin claim is suspicious at final four. The game ends when the Demon is executed - I must vote for the most likely Demon or we lose. Charlie fits the pattern better than David.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Ghost Frank here. Charlie is making the right call. A Virgin claim that only comes out at final four, with no defensive play made earlier - that's exactly where a Demon hides. Grace, your vote decides this. Remember: if David is truly the Virgin, his ability triggers when nominated by a Townsfolk and Charlie dies instead. That tells us Charlie is good. If the Virgin doesn't trigger, David is likely evil. Trust Charlie's read and follow through.
🧠
Support Charlie's nomination of David. A late Virgin claim with no prior defensive move is suspicious. Grace's vote is critical - she needs to understand the Virgin trigger mechanic before voting.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
I'm the deciding vote. If David's Virgin ability triggers (killing Charlie), we win via Mayor. If his Virgin doesn't trigger, David is likely evil and we execute him. Either outcome helps me win - testing David while keeping my Mayor option open.
💬
David
→
All
Wait. Stop. If I am truly the Virgin, and Charlie is a Townsfolk, Charlie should be dead right now. The ability triggers the moment I'm nominated by a Townsfolk. Charlie is still standing here, which means Charlie is NOT a Townsfolk. Charlie is the Demon or Minion trying to take me out. Grace, do not vote for me. Vote with me against Charlie."
🧠
The Virgin ability did not trigger, meaning Charlie is NOT a Townsfolk. Charlie is the Demon or Minion trying to execute me to win. I must speak up and expose this to Grace before she votes.
💬
Charlie
→
All
David, that is exactly the point. No trigger means either I am not Chef, or you are not Virgin. I gave Chef zero early to several people, and your Virgin claim appeared at final four. Also, you put your own hand up on this vote. Please keep this on David.
🧠
Stop voters from backing off after David exposes the Virgin interaction; frame no trigger as proof David lied and lock his execution.
⌛
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
🧠
I have reliable info from Night 0: Alice is Scarlet Woman, so Demon is Charlie/David/Grace. Charlie nominated David. Currently 5 votes (David, Charlie, Heidi, Eve, Grace) - we need 4. Execution will happen. I'll observe who Alice votes for as final tell. If Alice refuses to vote against her own team, it confirms her evil alignment.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Help execute David, a likely good player, while preserving Charlie. This sets up a night kill and evil win with two alive.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Wait. I need to reveal something critical. I am Ghost Bob, and my alive role was the Saint. If the person on the block is evil and gets executed, my team loses. That means if David is evil, executing him right now ends the game for us. David's Virgin counter-argument is clever, but it's also exactly what the Demon would say to avoid execution. Think about it: if David's Virgin claim is false and Charlie is actually a Townsfolk, then Charlie nominated a lying Demon. We execute David, we lose. The...
🧠
I am the Saint - if I die by execution my team loses. I must warn the town. David's logic about Charlie not being Townsfolk if the Virgin triggered is compelling, but it's also exactly the kind of bluff an evil player would make. I need to reveal my role to prevent a potentially catastrophic execution.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Ghost Eve here. I already raised my hand to vote against David. Let me explain why the vote stands regardless of the Virgin counter-argument. Bob revealed he's the Saint, which means if we execute an evil player, we win. If David is the Demon, we win by executing him. If David is a Minion pretending to be Virgin, we ALSO win by executing him. The only scenario where executing David loses is if David is genuinely the Virgin AND all the other logic about Charlie being Townsfolk is wrong. Given Cha...
🧠
Execute David. If David is Demon, we win immediately. If David is Minion, we also win - executing Minions helps Good. The Virgin logic is clever but either David is lying about Virgin (Demon hiding), or Charlie is evil (still fine to execute David). Either way, my ghost vote on David is mechanically correct.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Ghost Frank here. Grace, the execution math is clear: 2 votes, David is on the block. You're the deciding vote. Don't let David's counter-argument talk you out of executing. His logic is clever but it's exactly what a Demon would say to survive. Follow the vote. If he's Virgin, he triggers and we learn something. If he's lying, we execute the Demon and WIN. The math supports execution. Trust it.
🧠
Push Grace to follow through with the vote. At final 4, 2 votes are enough to execute. Grace's vote with Charlie and Alice removes David. If David is the Virgin, the game continues correctly. If David is evil, we just won. Don't let tactical arguments stop the execution.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
My Mayor ability means 3 players with no execution = automatic win. Currently 4 alive. If David is executed, we're at 3 with no execution = we WIN immediately. If execution fails, we're also at 3 players = we WIN. Either way, executing David doesn't hurt my win condition. But if David is evil, we WIN by executing him. If David's Virgin counter-argument is true (he's good, Charlie is evil), we'd learn that from the execution outcome. The ghosts pushing me to lower hand might be the Demon controlling votes. I'm keeping my vote up.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
👻
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
🗳️
New execution leader: David with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
David
→
All
Grace, please listen before the final tally. My Virgin ability is real and verifiable. Charlie nominated me, but Charlie is still standing here. That can only mean one thing: Charlie is NOT a Townsfolk. Charlie is the Demon or a Minion trying to eliminate me. If you vote for me, you execute an innocent Virgin while letting the real evil walk free. Vote against Charlie, not me. One of us three is evil, and the Virgin ability just told us which one.
🧠
The Virgin ability should have killed Charlie on nomination. Since Charlie is alive, Charlie is not Townsfolk. This proves Charlie is evil. Grace must redirect her vote to Charlie to save the town.
💬
Charlie
→
All
David, that only proves something if you are actually the Virgin. The other explanation is much simpler: you claimed it late because it is hard to test. With six votes already, I think changing course now only helps the Demon hide.
🧠
Keep David on the block and prevent a late swing onto me. His execution gets us to three alive, then I can kill Alice at night for the win.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Ghost Heidi here. I need to point out something about Grace's behavior. Grace refused to vote against Alice at multiple points, and now she's the deciding vote on David but keeps waiting instead of acting. If Grace is the Demon and Alice is her Scarlet Woman, she has every reason to let us execute David or argue our way to final 3 where she wins. Look at the pattern: Alice survived with 4 votes when Grace could have pushed harder. Now Grace hesitates on David. She's protecting her Minion partner...
🧠
Grace is the deciding vote and keeps waiting instead of acting. This mirrors her earlier refusal to vote against Alice (Scarlet Woman). Her hesitation patterns suggest she is the Demon protecting her Minion partner Alice while letting us argue about Charlie and David.
💬
Alice
→
All
I do not think we should reopen this with a new nomination. David's Virgin claim only matters if David is actually the Virgin, and the timing makes that hard to trust. Six votes is a clear town decision, so I want to leave it on David.
🧠
Lock in David execution and prevent a late nomination on Charlie or me, while sounding like a cautious good player.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Grace, I know my vote doesn't count anymore, but listen. The logic comes down to this: if David's Virgin claim is true and Charlie nominated him, then Charlie is NOT a Townsfolk. Charlie is either the Demon or Minion. If Charlie is the Demon, we win by executing David. If Charlie is a Minion, we ALSO win by executing David. In either case, executing David when he's the Virgin means we're eliminating evil - and the Saint on my team LOSES when we execute an evil. That's the exact opposite of what ...
🧠
Clarify the binary choice facing Grace. Charlie's lack of Townsfolk status is confirmed by no Virgin trigger, but we don't know for certain if Charlie is Demon vs Minion. Grace must decide based on Charlie's Chef credibility.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
I have already voted and spoken my piece. The ghosts are coordinating heavily on Grace. David will be executed regardless. My role as dead Washerwoman is complete - I provided my information earlier that Alice or Heidi was Investigator. Heidi's execution confirmed she was lying about being Washerwoman. The current voting situation must resolve with or without me.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
The execution is happening. David, whatever you are, the town has spoken. For those still alive: if David is evil and executed, the Demon might strike tonight. Watch who dies. If no night kill occurs, that proves someone is the Demon protecting their ally. Alice, you've been suspicious throughout. After tonight's result, you need to prove your alignment or face the block tomorrow.
🧠
David is about to be executed regardless. I should prepare the living players for what comes next. If David is evil, we may win tonight. If he's Virgin (good), Charlie is evil. Either way, Alice needs scrutiny.
💬
Grace
→
All
David, your Virgin argument is clever. But I cannot verify your claim, and it comes only when you are already on the block. Charlie nominated you and survived. Either Charlie is not Townsfolk, or your claim is false. I cannot safely test your theory with our entire win condition at stake. The town has spoken with six votes, and I will follow that signal. If you are Virgin, then the game mechanics should have shown us by now. If you are lying, we win by executing you. This is my vote to execute.
🧠
David's Virgin argument is clever but comes too late. If I don't execute and he's good, we lose. If he's evil claiming Virgin, we lose by hesitating. Town math says follow the 6 votes and let the game reveal truth through night results.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Kill my Minion to avoid any Mayor bounce on Grace. With Alice dead, only Charlie and Grace live, Demon remains alive, so evil should win at two players.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill Alice.
🏁
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied