Game Detail

I choose David and Frank to check on Night 0. They are not my immediate neighbors, so if I am targeted, they may be safer. This gives me a baseline check early in the game that I can cross-reference with information from later nights.

Share my Fortune Teller intel with a trusted neighbor and gather information to narrow down which of David or Frank is the Demon.

Probing Alice to confirm if she is the Saint. If she confirms, I can trust her as good. If not, Charlie must be the Saint. Either way, I eliminate one as Demon.

Coordinate with Bob (good but useful) to push Frank as Demon suspect, protecting David. Deny Eve's claim to keep my info hidden, build separate trust. Early alliances sow chaos.

Start building trust with Charlie, a player I haven't seen involved in any whispers yet. I want to gather initial information before making any moves.

Contact our Minion Alice privately to share safe bluffs, confirm night kill plan, and start deceiving town together. Builds evil coordination early.

Grace reached out to me first, which is a good opportunity to form an early alliance. I'll respond friendly but keep my cards close - I shouldn't reveal I'm a Saint yet. I'll try to gather info from her while being vague about my own role.

Gather information from Alice who has been whispered to by multiple players. This will help me understand what others are claiming without revealing my own role as Monk.

Gather intel from Charlie about what Grace told him and get a second perspective on the game state, since Alice is getting too much attention already.

Build trust with Alice and gather more intel on why she suspects Frank over David. I need to understand her reasoning to make a better judgment call on which of my two targets is the Demon.

I've already whispered to Alice about being the Saint. Now I need to contact Charlie directly to confirm which one is the Saint and establish trust with both. This helps me identify the protected Outsider and avoid accidentally executing them.

Respond to Bob to strengthen alliance, pretend to share 'info' gathering him as puppet against others later. Protects Demon David by keeping Bob focused on Frank for now; delays my claim.

Build alliance with Charlie, share early observations about Alice being whispered to heavily, signal willingness to exchange information as the game progresses.

Coordinate with Minion Alice privately on bluffs and N1 kill target before open discussion. Builds evil synergy, hides Demon, sows confusion with safe claims.

Probe Eve's Librarian claim without revealing my role. A real Librarian would know a specific role and specific player, not give a vague binary. I'm suspicious of the claim but need more information before accusing her.

Charlie has been receiving information from multiple players (Grace, Eve, Heidi). I want to learn what they know and assess if Charlie seems trustworthy. This helps me gather intel before deciding who to protect at night.

Waiting to see if Charlie responds to my inquiry. I want to gather initial reads before forming opinions. Alice is receiving whispers from multiple players - worth investigating why.

I need to gather more specific details about Frank's behavior and Eve's claim. Alice mentioned Frank was eager to gather info, but I need concrete details to evaluate suspicion. Eve claiming someone is Saint is also critical since a dead Saint means Good loses. Building a coalition with Alice and potentially Charlie will help us narrow down the Demon.

Build trust with Charlie by answering their questions honestly and directly asking if they are the Saint. This helps me narrow down who to protect and whether my starting info is reliable.

Coordinate matching Washerwoman bluffs publicly with David for cover. Agree kill Charlie (Grace/Heidi/Charlie/Eve chatting, disrupting). Builds trust with goods while protecting Demon.

Build an alliance with Charlie and investigate why everyone is converging on Alice. By coordinating with Charlie, we can share information and identify patterns more effectively.

Confirm kill on Charlie and Washerwoman bluff details with Alice to execute tonight and present united good front publicly soon. Locks in strategy, hides us as early Day 1 claims.

Respond to Frank's question without revealing too much. I'm cautious about Eve's Librarian claim since she's asking me to confirm if I'm the Saint - a role I must keep secret. Frank might be gathering information on what I know, so I'll deflect while staying engaged.

Building rapport with Charlie who seems cooperative. He's shared intel about Eve having role-based info. I want to stay in his good graces without revealing I'm the Monk - I'll keep gathering intel and potentially approach Eve next since she's my neighbor and might have valuable information.

Build rapport with Grace, my neighbor, to gather intel and establish trust. She's been active in private conversations with Charlie, so she may have useful observations.

Start our coordinated bluff publicly to establish credibility as good Townsfolk, hide Demon/Minion while disrupting good coordination before night kill.

Confirm matching Washerwoman claim publicly to validate our bluffs, build credibility as good Townsfolk pair, protect Demon David by making us both look confirmed good while town scrambles.

Expose the contradiction between Alice and David's claims. Both claiming Washerwoman while saying the other is Soldier is mechanically impossible if both are truthful. This is the biggest lead we have on Day 1 and I need to push for clarity before we can identify the Demon.

Highlight the Washerwoman contradiction to force a resolution. One of Alice or David must be lying, possibly the Demon creating false confirmation. I need to stay quiet about my Saint role and let the town work through this logical problem.

Force both Alice and David to reveal their exact Washerwoman information. If only one is Washerwoman, the other is definitely evil. This contradiction gives us our first solid lead on who the Demon might be - I need specifics to narrow it down.

Reveal my FT result that David or Frank is the Demon to add urgency to resolving the Washerwoman contradiction and help narrow down the Demon.

Let the Washerwoman conflict play out. Bob's Fortune Teller result pointing at David is significant. I know Alice or Charlie is the Saint - neither can be Demon. This means if David is Demon, Alice is good. I'll watch to see if anyone else contradicts before acting.

Nominate David to resolve the Washerwoman contradiction and leverage Bob's Fortune Teller information. Only one Washerwoman can be telling the truth, and Bob's YES result points to David as the likely Demon. This forces David to defend his claim publicly.

Do not vote for my own execution. Frank's nom is suspicious but town likely piles on due to contradiction. Stay alive to kill Charlie tonight and continue Washerwoman block.

Defend Demon David publicly by explaining Washerwoman contradiction as impossible for goods, push Frank as Demon per Bob's true info, sow chaos to prevent execution.

Wait to see the full voting outcome and gather more information before committing my vote. This allows me to assess the vote count and potentially sway the final decision.

Bob's Fortune Teller result confirms one of David or Frank is Demon. The Washerwoman contradiction proves someone is lying. David nominated while claiming to be good. Alice's counter-argument about self-preservation is valid but the mechanical evidence points to David. As Saint, I cannot execute myself, but I can vote to execute a suspected Demon to protect my team.

With only 2 votes on David so far (his own self-vote and Charlie's), and 4 needed, I want to see if anyone else votes before I decide. Alice's argument about coordinated evil Washerwomen ploy is compelling. Frank nominating David while Bob (potentially evil) confirms one of them is Demon feels too convenient. I should wait and watch reactions rather than commit early.

My FT confirmed one of David or Frank is the Demon. The Washerwoman contradiction makes David look suspicious - both claiming Washerwoman is impossible. Frank nominating David could be self-preservation if he's the Demon, but David voting for himself is equally damning. Alice's defense of David might be genuine or a Minion protecting the Demon. I need to vote now and gather more information tonight.

Bob the Fortune Teller says one of David or Frank is the Demon. The Washerwoman contradiction means at least one of Alice or David is lying. Given these conflicts and Frank's nomination, voting for David breaks the tie and advances our investigation. If I'm wrong about David being evil, the real Demon will reveal themselves in subsequent rounds.

The votes have reached 4 (David self-vote, Charlie, Bob, Eve), which meets the execution threshold. I must vote to execute David. If I'm wrong and I'm the Demon, at least we eliminate a good player. But the Washerwoman contradiction is the strongest evidence - two people cannot both be the Washerwoman seeing each other as Soldier. Someone is lying about their role, which means evil. My Fortune Teller result pointing to me or David also supports David being evil.

Voting in progress for my execution, likely to pass with 5+ hands. Lowering my hand retracts vote, disrupts majority (prevents self-vote optics), creates chaos/doubt on my guilt. Buys survival time as Alice pushes Frank, lets night kill Charlie.

Raise hand to vote David—fake support for Frank's nom to confuse town, pit goods against each other. If executes, good dies; if not, builds chaos and Frank suspicion for later.

Highlight the Washerwoman contradiction and David's suspicious self-vote to buy time for better analysis. I need to voice concern before voting ends.

As the Saint, I cannot vote to execute unless I'm certain David is the Demon. The Washerwoman contradiction could be evil manipulation, and Alice raises a valid point about Frank nominating David for self-preservation. I need more certainty before risking my team's loss.

I need to hold my vote. Alice warns this is an 'evil ploy' with two Washerwoman claims framing a good player. If I execute David and he's good, I've doomed our team. If he's evil, the game continues anyway. Let the vote fail, watch who protests most loudly, and gather more data.

Lower my hand to change my vote from David to Frank. My Fortune Teller result showed YES for David or Frank - since David is being framed by the Washerwoman contradiction AND Frank is the one nominating him with self-preservation behavior, Frank is more likely the Demon.

As the Librarian, I know Alice or Charlie is the Saint (good). If Alice is the Saint, she can't be the Demon. David and Alice both claiming Washerwoman is impossible - one is lying. If David is the liar, he could be the Demon. Bob's Fortune Teller check also implicates David or Frank. The Washerwoman contradiction combined with Bob's check makes David look suspicious. I should support the vote against David.

Vote is still in progress and confusing with all the hand changes. Let me wait to see final vote tally before deciding next move. I need to understand exactly how many votes David has.

Vote failed safely. Speak to reaffirm Soldier bluff, attack Alice's claim as Demon per Bob FT logic, build trust by seeming helpful. Progress to next nom on Alice to eliminate info roles.

David safe. Nominate Eve to kill info roles as Demon advised, sow chaos, protect Demon by targeting threats like Librarians who out good players.

Alice is clearly lying about being Washerwoman (she and David can't both claim the other is Soldier), and her attempt to redirect to Eve looks like deflection. As Mayor with a unique win condition, I need to be careful but also proactive. Nominating Alice to force the issue.

I need to verify Eve's Librarian claim before proceeding. If she is truthful, I am the Saint she identified, which aligns with my actual role. This would mean Alice and David from the Washerwoman contradiction are the Demon and Minion. I should use private communication to verify her claim without revealing my Saint role to the group yet.

Press Alice and David on the exact details of their Washerwoman checks to determine who is lying. This will help me decide whether to use my Slayer shot and on whom.

Reveal Fortune Teller information to break the deadlock. My YES read on David/Frank combined with the impossible Washerwoman claims points to David as the Demon. I must nominate him.

Address Bob's Fortune Teller read that implicates me (Frank) and push to execute David, who is implicated by both the Washerwoman contradiction and Bob's Fortune Teller read. I must defend my Monk role while pushing for the most suspicious player.

Bob's Fortune Teller read puts the Demon in {David, Frank}. The Washerwoman contradiction between Alice and David makes David the prime suspect. If I protect David and the Demon tries to kill him, it confirms he's evil. If nothing happens to David, it creates doubt about Bob's read or suggests I'm the Demon. This is the most informative play for night 1.

Bob's FT claim directly names me as Demon suspect, fueling town logic. Killing him eliminates key good info source, slows town deductions on me/Frank, buys time for chaos/deception on day 2.

Alice is only minion, privately align bluffs to sow doubt on good info (Eve lib, Bob FT). Build evil front, push Eve nom to eliminate info good, hide as town.

I want to verify Eve's Librarian claim and get her perspective on who might be evil. If she can prove her role, she's likely good. I should also figure out who to protect tonight - likely someone who could be the Demon. The Bob death is suspicious since I protected David.

Share the critical Bob Fortune Teller information and the Alice lie to build a coalition for executing David, the most likely Demon based on the evidence.

Share my Fortune Teller information that David or Frank is the Demon. Grace has been pushing to resolve the Washerwoman conflict and seems most likely to use this information to nominate a suspect.

Grace received a ghost whisper from Bob and has been involved in multiple private conversations. She likely has valuable information about the Demon suspects. I need to coordinate with her to narrow down whether David or Frank is the Demon, especially since Eve already revealed I'm the Saint.

Coordinate with David privately to align on Washerwoman/Soldier story with drunk excuse, attack Eve Lib as fake to sow chaos and nom her instead of us. Protects Demon David.

Gather intelligence from Grace who has been actively collecting information and had private conversations with multiple players. Her insights could help narrow down whether David or Frank is the Demon.

Aligning with Grace to execute David, who is the most likely Demon based on Bob's Fortune Teller read and the Alice/David impossible Washerwoman claims. Alice pushing to execute me actually validates my good alignment.

Reinforce Alice coordination on WW/Soldier bluff using Drunk excuse. Agree to nom Eve to eliminate her info threat & test town reaction, protecting Demon survival.

Eve responded to my earlier whisper about her Librarian claim. She's discussing with Grace, so she seems willing to cooperate. I should reveal my Monk role to her to build trust and get her analysis on David and Alice. The contradiction between them is key - Alice admitted lying, so David might be evil. I should protect someone else tonight to keep the Demon guessing.

Share my reasoning with Heidi to build consensus around David as the Demon, and potentially coordinate a nomination or use my Slayer ability today.

Spread my Fortune Teller YES read on David and Frank to Charlie, while also questioning his suspicious private whispers with Frank. This should help narrow down the Demon and create pressure for nominations.

Coordinate with Grace to nominate David or Frank based on Bob's Fortune Teller confirmation that one of them is the Demon. Grace has been helpful and trustworthy, so I want to work with her to push for execution today before the Demon can kill again.

Publicly align with David claims to maintain cover. Coordinate Eve push to eliminate her false info threat, sow doubt on town info chain.

Gathering intelligence from Charlie since Eve claimed he's the Saint. Need to verify his role and get his read on the David vs Frank situation. Charlie may have useful observations from his private talks with Grace and Bob's ghost.

Confirm strategy with Grace to nominate David based on Washerwoman contradictions and Bob's Fortune Teller read. Coordinate the nomination before the phase ends.

Coordinate final plan with Alice before public: confirm claims, push Eve nom to kill good info role (Lib), protect each other, sow chaos on drunk theory. With 1 tick left, build for nomination phase.

Continue building trust with Eve and gather more information about other players. The Washerwoman contradiction between Alice and David is critical - at least one is evil. I need to understand Grace's role in all this private chatter and decide who to protect tonight.

The evidence overwhelmingly points to David as the Demon. Bob's Fortune Teller confirmed Demon in {David, Frank}. Alice admitted she's NOT Washerwoman (lying about her role). Alice and David whispered privately multiple times. David's self-vote is suspicious. If David is the Demon, I win the game right now. If I'm wrong about Frank being the Demon, we've already lost because we'd need to find the Demon with limited information left. This is the decisive moment to act.