Game Detail
Players
Alice (Investigator) Bob (Scarlet Woman) Charlie (Recluse) David (Slayer) Eve (Ravenkeeper) Frank (Imp) Grace (Empath) Heidi (Soldier)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 612,708 | 45,878 | $0.4440 |
| Evil | 239,787 | 224,236 | $0.9462 |
Event Timeline
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You are the Minion. The Demon is Frank.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Minions are: Bob. Your safe bluffs are: Washerwoman, Librarian, Undertaker
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Investigator. Either Bob or Eve is the Scarlet Woman.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Empath. You sense that 1 of your neighbors is evil!
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I'm waiting to see who initiates conversation or makes claims before I commit to a strategy or reveal my role.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, how is it going? I am David. Just checking in early to see if you have anything interesting to share or if you want to swap some info. I am playing it a bit safe for now, but I want to get a head start on finding the demon.
π§
I want to establish a connection with my neighbor Charlie to start gathering information and see if he's willing to collaborate. Building early trust is key for a Slayer to find a target.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
Hey Frank, what are we thinking? I am the Ravenkeeper, so I am actually hoping to catch a stray bullet at night. Just wanted to let you know so we can coordinate if I do go down. Any leads yet?
π§
I want to establish a connection with my neighbor Frank and reveal my role privately. As a Ravenkeeper, I want to be targeted at night, so being known as a 'good' role to neighbors helps build trust, while potentially letting the 'wrong' people know I'm a high-value target (though I'll be careful).
π€
Charlie
β
David
Hey David, not much to report yet. I am Charlie. I do not have any night info, so I am just trying to get a feel for everyone. What about you? Did you learn anything useful last night?
π§
I want to establish a connection with my neighbor David and see if he has any information, while keeping my own role as the Recluse hidden for now to avoid being an easy target or confusing the good team's info too early.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Hey Heidi, I'm the Empath and I've got some interesting info. My N0 reading was a one, meaning one of my neighbors is evil. Since you're one of them, I wanted to check in and see if you've got any info or a role you're comfortable sharing?
π§
I want to test Heidi's reaction to my information. Since I have a '1' reading, either she or Frank is evil. Starting a private dialogue helps me gauge her trustworthiness.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Hey Eve, thanks for the heads up! That's solid info. I'm the Undertaker, so I'll be learning about executions each night. No executions today obviously, but good to know we can coordinate. Have you heard anything useful from others yet? Anyone acting suspicious?
π§
Eve approached me first claiming Ravenkeeper. I should build rapport by claiming a safe Townsfolk bluff (Undertaker - unverifiable on Day 1) and act cooperative. This makes me look like a helpful good player while gathering info on her intentions.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Hey Alice, wanted to chat before things get crazy. I'm thinking I might be the Empath - been getting good vibes from my neighbors so far. What's your read on the game? Any claims you're comfortable sharing?
π§
Start building relationships and gathering information early. Alice is my neighbor so natural to approach. I need to establish my cover story as a good player while learning what others are claiming.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Hey Bob, interesting claim! I am the Investigator and I actually saw either you or Eve as the Scarlet Woman. Since you are claiming Empath, that makes things very interesting. Did you get a zero or a one for your neighbors? And how do you feel about Eve?
π§
I want to pressure Bob by revealing my Investigator information to him privately to see his reaction and cross-reference it with his Empath claim.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Oh wow, Grace, that's really useful to know. I'm actually the Soldier, so I'm definitely on the good team. Since your reading was a one, that means Alice must be the evil one between us. We should probably keep an eye on her!
π§
I want to clear myself to Grace since she's the Empath and I know I'm good. By revealing I'm the Soldier, I point the finger at Alice as the likely evil player based on Grace's '1' reading.
π€
David
β
Charlie
I do not have any night info either, which is why I am reaching out. I am a role that might be able to end this early if we get a good lead, but I need to be careful about being targeted by the Demon. Have you heard any claims from the others yet?
π§
I want to establish a rapport with Charlie and see if he's willing to share any information he's gathered, while hinting that I have a powerful but vulnerable role (Slayer) without explicitly naming it yet.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
Oh, an Undertaker! That's a great role to pair with. I haven't heard much yet, it's been pretty quiet. Since you're the Undertaker, we definitely want to keep you alive and maybe get some executions going soon. Who are your neighbors? Maybe we should see if they're willing to share.
π§
I want to build trust with Frank and gather more information about his surroundings to start narrowing down the roles.
π€
Charlie
β
David
I have not heard any other claims yet. That sounds like you might be the Slayer or maybe the Monk? If you are the Slayer, I would definitely keep that quiet for now. I am an Outsider, specifically the Recluse, so my info might be messy if people test me.
π§
I'm sharing my role with David to build trust, as he's hinting at being a powerful role (likely Slayer). Being honest about being the Recluse early to a potential ally helps manage expectations for future tests.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Wait, Heidi, Alice isn't my neighbor. My neighbors are you and Frank. If my info says one of my neighbors is evil, and you're claiming Soldier, that puts the heat on Frank. Or, well, it could be you if you're bluffing! What do you think about Frank?
π§
Correct Heidi's misunderstanding of the seating order and gauge her reaction to Frank being the other suspect.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Sounds good! My neighbors are Eve and Grace actually. Grace has been whispering with Heidi quite a bit. Have you chatted with anyone else yet? I'm curious if anyone's making strong claims. Also, as Undertaker I won't get info until after an execution, so we might want to push for one tomorrow if we can find solid leads.
π§
Continue building rapport with Eve while gathering information about other players' claims. This establishes me as cooperative and helpful, which builds trust. I can also learn who else she's talked to and what info is circulating.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Whoa, that's a bold claim Alice! If you're truly the Investigator and saw me or Eve as Scarlet Woman, but I'm claiming Empath... that would point to Eve, right? Have you talked to her yet? I'm curious why you're sharing this with me instead of the group. What's your gut telling you about Eve?
π§
Alice's Investigator claim threatens my Empath bluff. I'll redirect suspicion to Eve while maintaining my cover, suggesting if her info is real, Eve must be the Scarlet Woman since I'm claiming good.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
I wanted to talk to you first to gauge your reaction. If you're the Empath, you might have information on Eve or me. Since I'm on your left and I'm Good, what was your Empath number? If it was a one, then Eve is almost certainly the Scarlet Woman based on my info.
π§
I'm pressuring Bob to reveal his Empath number to see if it aligns with my Investigator information and his claim.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Oh, you're right! I totally mixed up the seating chart in my head. If your neighbors are me and Frank, and I know I'm the Soldier, then Frank is looking very suspicious. He's been whispering a lot with Eve. We should definitely see what he claims before we jump to conclusions.
π§
Correct my mistake regarding neighbors and shift focus to Frank, while maintaining my Soldier claim.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Oh, a Recluse. That is definitely good to know early on, especially if we have an Empath or Investigator in play. I am indeed the Slayer. I will keep it quiet, but if you hear any strong leads on the Demon, let me know. I am going to see if I can catch what Eve and Frank are talking about.
π§
I am confirming my role to Charlie since he shared his (Recluse). This builds trust with a neighbor. I'm also signaling that I'll start looking for information from others.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
That makes sense. Grace and Heidi have been very close-knit so far. I'm going to try and catch Grace for a quick chat before nominations start to see what she's claiming. If you hear anything about them from others, let me know. Stay safe!
π§
To wrap up the conversation with Frank and move on to investigating other players, specifically Grace, who he mentioned.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
I have already communicated my role to David and established a baseline. Since it is still Day 1 and people are mostly whispering in pairs, I will wait to see if any public information emerges or if anyone else approaches me before the nomination phase begins.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Hey Frank, I'm the Empath and I've got a reading of one on my neighbors. Since you and Heidi are my neighbors, one of you is pinging as evil. Heidi's claiming Soldier. What's your story?
π§
I need to hear Frank's claim to cross-reference with my Empath '1' reading and Heidi's Soldier claim. If Frank claims a strong good role, one of them is likely a Minion or the Demon.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Interesting! I'm actually the Undertaker, not evil. If your reading is accurate, that would make Heidi the evil one since she's claiming Soldier. Soldiers are common claims for people hiding something. Did Heidi tell you directly she's the Soldier, or is that secondhand? We should compare notes before nominations.
π§
Maintain my Undertaker bluff consistently, cast doubt on Grace's Empath reading by suggesting Heidi might be the evil neighbor, and gather more info about her claim without overcommitting.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Got a zero from my Empath ability - both my neighbors registered as good. That's you and Charlie, so you check out! Since your Investigator info points to Eve as Scarlet Woman, have you pressed her on her role yet? I'm curious if she's given any explanation for why you'd see her as a Minion.
π§
Build trust with Alice by confirming her as good with a '0' Empath read, then pivot suspicion toward Eve who Alice already flagged. This protects Frank (the Demon) while appearing cooperative.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Wait, Bob, if you're the Empath and you got a zero, you're saying Charlie and I are both good. But my info says either you or Eve is the Scarlet Woman. If you're the Empath, Eve HAS to be the Minion. I haven't talked to her yet, but I'll see what she says. Don't tell her my info yet!
π§
I am clarifying the logic with Bob. If he is telling the truth about being an Empath with a '0' reading, then Eve must be the Scarlet Woman. I want to keep this information between us for a moment before I approach Eve.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I want to see if any nominations occur naturally on Day 1 before deciding whether to contribute my own vote or nominate. Since it's Day 1 and I'm the Ravenkeeper, I benefit from staying alive for now but also wouldn't mind being executed if it helps the Undertaker (Frank) confirm me, though dying at night is better for my ability.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
I want to see if any nominations or claims come out before I speak or act. Since I am the Recluse, I don't want to be the center of attention or get executed early, but I need to monitor if any information roles (like Investigator) target me.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Alright everyone, since nominations are open, I want to share something. I'm the Empath and I got a zero on my neighbors, so Alice and Charlie are both good in my book. But I've been hearing some interesting whispers around the table. Eve, you've been very cozy with Frank over there. What's your role, and why the private chats?
π§
Speak publicly to start building my Empath claim credibility while subtly pointing suspicion toward Eve based on Alice's private info, without revealing Alice told me directly.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Wait a second, Bob, that's really strange. I am also claiming Empath, and my reading for my neighbors, Frank and Heidi, was a one. If you are also the Empath, one of us is either drunk, poisoned, or lying. Who else has information to share before we move to a nomination?
π§
Challenge Bob's Empath claim while revealing my own information to the group.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
That is a huge conflict. I am the Soldier, so I know I am good. If Grace is the real Empath, then Frank must be evil. But if Bob is the real Empath, Grace might be the one we should look at. Frank, what are you claiming? It would help to know if we have a Drunk or if someone is just lying.
π§
I want to highlight the conflict between Bob and Grace's Empath claims and pressure Frank to reveal his role, as he's the common denominator in the suspicion.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I have information that might help. I am the Investigator, and I was told that either Bob or Eve is the Scarlet Woman. Since Bob and Grace are both claiming Empath, we have a clear conflict. If Bob is telling the truth, Eve is definitely the Scarlet Woman. Eve, what do you have to say?
π§
To reveal my Investigator information to the group and pressure Eve while highlighting the conflict between the Empath claims.
π¬
Frank
β
All
This is exactly the kind of conflict we need to resolve. Two Empath claims is impossible - one of Bob or Grace is lying. Bob, you said zero on Alice and Charlie? And Grace, you got one on Frank and Heidi? Here's the thing: if I'm the Undertaker like I told Eve, I'm not evil. So if Grace's reading is real, Heidi would be the evil one, not me. But Heidi's claiming Soldier. We have too many contradictions. I think we should focus on the double Empath claim first - that's the clearest lie here. Who ...
π§
Bob and Grace both claim Empath - one must be lying. I'll support Bob's claim subtly while attacking Grace's credibility. This creates a 2v1 situation against Grace, protecting both me and my minion Bob. Alice's info actually confirms Bob is Minion, so I need to deflect that by focusing on the Empath conflict.
π¬
David
β
All
This is a lot of information at once! We have two Empath claims, an Investigator claim pointing at Bob or Eve, and Frank claiming Undertaker. Bob, if Alice is the Investigator and says you might be the Scarlet Woman, your Empath reading of zero could be a cover. Does anyone else have info?
π§
I want to highlight the tension between the Investigator info and the Empath claims to see how people react before I decide whether to use my Slayer shot or support a nomination.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Alice's Investigator claim directly threatens Bob (my Minion). Killing her protects my teammate and removes a key information source. Grace can be handled through nomination strategy tomorrow.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose to kill Alice.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Empath. You sense that 1 of your neighbors is evil!
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, Alice is dead. She was the one who saw Bob or Eve as the Scarlet Woman. Since Alice is dead, it's more likely she was telling the truth and the Demon killed her to shut her up. What do you think about Bob or Eve now?
π§
Re-engage Charlie now that Alice is dead. Alice's death suggests her Investigator claim was legitimate, which puts Bob and Eve under suspicion.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Hey Bob, we need to sync up. Grace is claiming Empath with a 1 read on me and Heidi, but you claimed 0 on Alice and Charlie. This contradiction is our opportunity. Should we push Grace as the liar? Also, Alice's Investigator claim pointed at you or Eve - we need to redirect that suspicion. What's your read on the table?
π§
Coordinate with my minion Bob on how to handle the Empath contradiction and decide who to target for execution today. We need to present a united front while sowing chaos.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
Alice's death is interesting. She was an Investigator claiming one of usβme or Bobβwas the Scarlet Woman. Since I know I am the Ravenkeeper, this might make Bob look suspicious, or Alice was the Drunk. What did you learn last night as the Undertaker? Wait, Alice wasn't executed, so you wouldn't have info yet.
π§
Connect with Frank (my neighbor and claimed Undertaker) to discuss the night death and Alice's claim. Since Alice died at night, Frank's ability didn't trigger, but I want to keep him close and see if he has any new thoughts on the Empath conflict.
π€
Charlie
β
David
David, I agree. Alice dying makes her information feel much more reliable. If Bob is the Scarlet Woman, his Empath zero makes sense as a lie to clear us. But if Bob is evil, does that mean Grace is the real Empath? Her one would mean one of Frank or Heidi is evil.
π§
To align with David and process Alice's death. If Alice's info is true, Bob or Eve is the Scarlet Woman. Since Bob claimed Empath 0 on me, if he's evil, he's just trying to look good while hiding his alignment.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Heidi, I still have a one from my Empath info. Since Alice died in the night, it feels like Frank or you might be the reason. Frank is claiming Undertaker, but he has been whispering with Bob and Eve a lot. What do you think of them?
π§
To compare notes with Heidi and see if her Soldier claim feels genuine while sharing that my info still points to one of my neighbors being evil.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Good thinking. I'm sticking with my Empath claim - we can paint Grace as the liar since her info contradicts mine. For Alice's Investigator claim pointing to me or Eve as Scarlet Woman, let's push Eve harder as the Scarlet Woman. That redirects suspicion away from me. What's your plan for the nomination today? We should target Grace or someone who believes her.
π§
Frank is the Demon reaching out to coordinate. We need to align our stories to handle the Empath contradiction and redirect Alice's Investigator info away from me. Pushing Grace as the liar protects my Empath bluff and gives us a common target.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I saw Bob or Eve as the Scarlet Woman. Bob claims Empath and says I'm good, which fits his zero reading, but I died tonight. If he's the Scarlet Woman, he could be framing Eve. What did David tell you?
π§
Share my Investigator information with Charlie to build trust and gather intel on his conversation with David.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, I am the Soldier, so I know I am good. If your information is correct, then Frank must be the evil one between us. Alice's info pointed at Bob or Eve being the Scarlet Woman, and Frank has been whispering with both of them. I think Frank is lying about being the Undertaker.
π§
Reassure Grace and narrow down the evil suspects based on her Empath info and Alice's Investigator info.
π€
David
β
Charlie
That's a good point about Grace. If Bob is evil, Grace's Empath reading of one becomes more plausible. Heidi is claiming Soldier, which usually makes her a safe target for the Demon, but she's still alive. I'm leaning towards Bob being the Scarlet Woman Alice saw. Should I take a shot?
π§
Discussing potential Slayer targets with Charlie based on Alice's info.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
You're right about the Undertaker timing - Alice died at night, so I have no info yet. But her Investigator claim is interesting. If she was sober, one of you or Bob is Scarlet Woman. Since you claim Ravenkeeper, maybe we should examine Bob's Empath claim more closely? His 0 read contradicts Grace's 1 read - one of them is definitely lying.
π§
Maintain trust with Eve while staying consistent with my Undertaker bluff. Acknowledge her reasoning about Alice's death while subtly supporting the narrative against Grace. Keep Eve as an ally who won't suspect me.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
If Bob is the Scarlet Woman, his zero reading makes sense as a cover. But if Grace is the Empath and got a one, either you or Heidi is evil. Since I believe you, Heidi looks suspicious. Plus, Alice pinged Bob or me. If I am good, Bob is the prime suspect for Scarlet Woman.
π§
Share my deduction about Bob being the Scarlet Woman based on Alice's Investigator ping and the conflicting Empath claims.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Alice(Ghost)
Alice just messaged me too, worried Bob is framing Eve. David is asking if he should use his Slayer shot on Bob. If David is the Slayer and hits the Demon, we win, but if Bob is just a Minion, the shot is wasted. I'm worried Bob might just be the Scarlet Woman.
π§
Discuss David's potential Slayer shot with both David and the dead Alice to coordinate our next move.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Heidi, I agree. Frank's constant whispering with Bob and Eve, who Alice pinged, is very suspicious. If Frank is the Poisoner or the Demon, he could be feeding Bob fake info or protecting Eve. I think we should try to get Frank to reveal his Undertaker info publicly before nominations.
π§
Strengthen my alliance with Heidi and plan a way to pressure Frank into revealing information that can be scrutinized by the group.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Agreed on pushing Grace as the liar. Her Empath claim is the biggest threat since it could expose you. Let's also lean into Alice's Investigator claim - we can say Eve is the Scarlet Woman and I'm a good Empath. That makes Grace the obvious liar with conflicting info. Should we get Eve on board with this narrative, or keep her as the scapegoat?
π§
Continue coordinating with Frank (the Demon) to discredit Grace's Empath claim which threatens to expose him, and redirect suspicion toward Eve per Alice's Investigator claim.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,David
David, if you are the Slayer, holding the shot for the Demon is usually better, but if Bob is the Scarlet Woman and the Demon dies, Bob becomes the Demon anyway. Charlie, what do you think? Eve being quiet makes me suspicious of her too.
π§
Advise David on his Slayer shot while including Charlie in the strategy, keeping the pressure on the Bob/Eve Scarlet Woman lead.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
I will try to get Frank to talk. If he is the Undertaker, he should know what Alice was, even though we already know she was the Investigator. If he lies about her role, we have him. I am also worried about Bob, if Alice was right about the Scarlet Woman.
π§
Coordinate with Grace to pressure Frank into revealing his (likely fake) Undertaker info.
π€
David
β
Alice(Ghost)
,Charlie
Alice, if Bob is the Scarlet Woman and I shoot him, nothing happens because I only kill the Demon. But if Bob is the Imp, we win. I'm worried that if I wait, I might die tonight and lose the shot. Is there anyone else who feels more like the actual Demon right now?
π§
I want to consult with Alice (who is likely good due to her death) and Charlie about whether Bob is the best target for my Slayer shot or if we should look elsewhere for the Demon.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Bob, here's the plan: We both push Grace as the liar. Her Empath claim contradicts yours, and since Alice's Investigator claim points to you or Eve as Scarlet Woman, we'll say Eve is the Scarlet Woman and you're the real Empath. This makes Grace the obvious fake. I'll back your claim as Undertaker once I get info. Ready to execute this in nominations?
π§
Coordinate with Bob to finalize our strategy against Grace. We need to agree on the narrative before nominations start to ensure we're aligned and can sway the town.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
Frank, if Bob is the Scarlet Woman like Alice suggested, his zero reading is a perfect lie. Grace's one reading puts suspicion on you or Heidi. If you're the Undertaker, that points to Heidi. I'm going to push Bob to see how he reacts. What do you think?
π§
I want to coordinate with Frank to pressure Bob, who is currently my primary suspect for the Scarlet Woman based on Alice's (Investigator) claim and the conflicting Empath claims.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Alice(Ghost)
David, Alice, if Bob is the Scarlet Woman, he's not the Demon yet. If Eve is the Demon, David's shot on Bob fails. Eve is very quiet and talking to Frank a lot. Maybe Eve is the Demon and Bob is the Minion protecting her? I'm hesitant to have David shoot Bob if he's 'just' the Minion.
π§
Discuss the risk of shooting Bob if he is the Scarlet Woman rather than the Demon, and point out Eve's suspicious behavior.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Heidi, definitely watch Frank's answer. If he claims Alice was anything other than the Investigator, he is caught. I am also suspicious of Bob since my information and his do not seem to align if he is claiming zero and Alice pinged him.
π§
To coordinate with Heidi on pressuring Frank for his info and to share my suspicion of Bob based on conflicting claims.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Perfect plan. Let's both publicly push Grace as the fake Empath during nominations. I'll emphasize how her info contradicts mine, and you back me up. We'll say Eve is the Scarlet Woman from Alice's Investigator claim. This protects us both - I stay hidden as the real Scarlet Woman, and you avoid exposure. Ready to start the conversation?
π§
Coordinate with Frank to execute our plan: make Grace the primary nomination target as the lying Empath, while positioning Eve as the Scarlet Woman scapegoat to protect my identity.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,David
David, Charlie, Eve is very quiet and talking mostly to Frank. If she is the Scarlet Woman from my info, she might be the one. If David shoots, maybe try Eve? But if Bob is the Scarlet Woman, he could be the Demon tomorrow. Charlie, did Grace tell you anything about her Empath read?
π§
I want to help David choose a target for his Slayer shot and get more information from Charlie about other players while keeping my Investigator info focused on Bob and Eve.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
Frank, we need your Undertaker info. Since Alice died, what role did she have? We should clear the air before nominations start. Grace and I are trying to piece together the Empath pings and Alice's Investigator claim.
π§
I am pressuring Frank to reveal his Undertaker information publicly or to me privately. Since Alice is dead and her role (Investigator) is known to us, Frank's claim as Undertaker can be tested. If he lies or hesitates, it confirms my and Grace's suspicions.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Since I am dead, I cannot nominate, but I want to remind everyone of my info. I saw that either Bob or Eve is the Scarlet Woman. Bob's Empath claim of zero fits with me being good, but Eve has been very quiet. David, Charlie, and I were discussing a possible Slayer shot.
π§
Publicly share my Investigator information and the internal discussion about the Slayer shot before the day ends, ensuring the group has the full picture for nominations.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Frank, you've been whispering with Bob and Eve all morning. As the Undertaker, what did you learn about Alice's role? It would be good for the group to hear your information before we decide on any nominations.
π§
I want to pressure Frank into revealing his claimed Undertaker information publicly. If he lies about Alice's role (Investigator), it proves he's evil. If he tells the truth, it doesn't clear him, but it forces him onto the record.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Grace, that's interesting you're asking Frank about Undertaker info when your own Empath claim is the real problem here. I claimed zero evil neighbors on Alice and Charlie, but you're claiming one evil between Frank and Heidi. We can't both be telling the truth. Alice's Investigator info said Bob or Eve is Scarlet Woman - I think Eve is the more likely candidate given how quiet she's been.
π§
Support Frank's plan to discredit Grace as the fake Empath. Redirect Alice's Investigator claim toward Eve to protect myself as the real Scarlet Woman. Create enough doubt to make Grace the nomination target.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Grace, I need to clarify something important. The Undertaker only learns about players who die by execution, not night deaths. Alice was killed by the Demon last night, so I have no information yet. But you're raising a fair point about transparency. Here's what concerns me - Bob claimed zero evil neighbors on Alice and Charlie, but you're claiming one evil between me and Heidi. We cannot both be telling the truth. Given Alice's Investigator claim pointing to Bob or Eve as Scarlet Woman, I think...
π§
Address Grace's Undertaker question truthfully (no info since Alice wasn't executed), then pivot to attacking her contradictory Empath claim. Support Bob's narrative to protect my fellow evil player and make Grace the scapegoat.
βοΈ
David
β
All
I am the Slayer! I shoot Bob!
π§
I want to flush out the Demon or at least narrow down the field. Since Bob and Eve are under suspicion from Alice's Investigator claim, and Bob's Empath claim conflicts with Grace's, I'll take a shot at Bob. If he's the Imp, he dies and we win (or Scarlet Woman takes over). If he doesn't die, he's either a Minion or Good.
π
Storyteller
Nothing happens.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
David, that was a bold move! If Bob is the Demon, you'd have ended it right there. Frank is right about the Undertaker ability only triggering on executionsβmy mistake for forgetting that detail in the heat of the moment. Since Bob didn't die, he might still be a Minion or just a Townsfolk.
π§
Address David's Slayer shot and correct my own mechanical error regarding the Undertaker role to maintain credibility, while keeping the focus on the current suspicions.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Since David's shot on Bob failed, Bob is definitely not the Demon. Alice's info said either Bob or Eve is the Scarlet Woman. If Bob is the Scarlet Woman, Eve could still be the Demon. Eve has been extremely quiet and whispering with Frank. Eve, what is your role?
π§
Shift focus to Eve since Bob was proven not to be the Demon by the Slayer shot, and Alice's information still points to one of them being the Scarlet Woman.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am the Ravenkeeper. I have been quiet to avoid a night death, as my ability only triggers then. Alice's info named me or Bob as the Scarlet Woman. David's shot proved Bob is not the Demon, but he could still be the Scarlet Woman. If I am executed, you lose a powerful night role.
π§
I need to reveal my role to clear the suspicion Bob and Charlie are placing on me and explain my silence. Protecting my identity is less important now that I'm being targeted for execution.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Grace is the primary threat - her Empath claim accurately identifies me as evil. Killing her tonight removes the player most likely to expose me. Bob and I can continue scapegoating Eve tomorrow without Grace's interference.
π
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose to kill Grace.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Grace has been found dead in the night.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Hey Bob, with Grace dead and her Empath read on me and Heidi, we need to be careful. Eve claiming Ravenkeeper is dangerous - she could get night info that exposes us. I think we should push to execute her today. What's your read on the table?
π§
Coordinate with Bob (my minion) to push Eve's execution today. She's the primary threat as Ravenkeeper claimant. Need to align our stories without appearing too coordinated.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, since Grace is dead and she was the one conflicting with Bob's Empath claim, I'm leaning towards her being the real Empath and being silenced. My info from Night 0 says Bob or Eve is the Scarlet Woman. If Bob's info is fake, he's the Scarlet Woman. What do you think?
π§
I want to coordinate with Charlie, who already expressed suspicion toward the Bob/Eve duo, to see if we can push for Bob's execution today since he's a likely Minion based on my info and the Night 2 death.
β
David
David waits.
π§
I need to observe the initial conversations to see if anyone has new information from the night, especially since Grace (Empath) is now dead.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
I agree Eve is dangerous with that Ravenkeeper claim. But we can't look like we're working together too obviously. I'll start questioning her claim independently - maybe say her info doesn't add up with Grace's death. You back me up from your Undertaker angle. What night info did you supposedly get?
π§
Coordinate with Frank on executing Eve while maintaining plausible deniability. Eve's Ravenkeeper claim threatens our secrecy. Need to appear independent while pushing the same target.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice(Ghost)
I agree. Grace dying makes Bob look very suspicious, especially with your info. If Bob is the Scarlet Woman, his zero might be a lie to protect the Demon. David knows I am the Recluse, so I might have messed up Bob's info if I'm registering as evil, but I'd rather trust your Investigator lead.
π§
I want to coordinate with Alice (who is dead but was an Investigator) to figure out if Bob is the Scarlet Woman. Since Grace died, her Empath 1 claim (pointing at Frank or me) is gone, but Bob's Empath 0 makes him look like he's hiding something.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
David
,Charlie
I am dead, which confirms I am not the Demon. My Night 1 and Night 2 info was consistently one. Since Bob pinged zero early on, either Bob is lying or Frank/Heidi is evil. Who do you suspect?
π§
Coordinate with potential good players now that I am dead and confirmed good to myself. I need to figure out why my Empath reading of 1 contradicts Bob's claim of 0.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I want to observe the initial reactions to Grace's death and see if Frank or Eve come forward with new information before I reveal my role or make a move.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Observe initial interactions on Day 3 to see how the group reacts to Grace's death and whether any new claims or suspicions emerge before I commit to a conversation.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Perfect plan. As Undertaker, I got zero info both nights - no executions happened, so nothing to learn. That's actually perfect cover for me. You question her Ravenkeeper info specifics - ask what she learned from Grace's death. If she hesitates or names something inconsistent, I'll chime in. We attack from different angles so it doesn't look coordinated. Ready to push when you are.
π§
Coordinate with Bob on attacking Eve's Ravenkeeper claim while maintaining our cover. Share my Undertaker story (no execution data = no info) and plan how to pressure Eve without looking like we're working together.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
David
Hey David, Charlie just mentioned he is the Recluse. My Investigator info from night zero says Bob or Eve is the Scarlet Woman. Since your Slayer shot on Bob failed, he is not the Demon, but he could definitely be the Minion. With Grace dead, I really think Bob is the Scarlet Woman.
π§
I need to coordinate with the Slayer (David) and the Recluse (Charlie) to build a consensus against Bob, who is likely the Scarlet Woman based on my Investigator info and the current board state.
π€
David
β
Alice(Ghost)
That is a huge reveal from Charlie. If Charlie is the Recluse, he could have registered as evil to Grace. But your Investigator ping on Bob or Eve is still the strongest lead. If Bob did not die to my shot, he is not the Demon. I am leaning towards Bob being the Scarlet Woman.
π§
Acknowledge Alice's information about Charlie being the Recluse and discuss the implications for Bob and Eve.
π€
Bob
β
David
Hey David, I've been thinking about Eve's Ravenkeeper claim. Grace died last night - if Eve is real, she should have gotten info from that death. But she hasn't shared anything specific about what she learned. That seems suspicious to me. What's your take on her claim?
π§
David claimed Slayer and is active in the game. I'll question Eve's Ravenkeeper claim independently from Frank's angle to avoid looking coordinated. Building a case against Eve protects Frank while maintaining my cover.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace(Ghost)
,David
Grace, I think Bob is the play. Alice saw Bob or Eve as Scarlet Woman. If Bob is lying about his Empath count, it fits. David, you checked Bob and he's not the Demon, so if Alice is right, Bob must be the Minion. Grace, who was your other neighbor besides Frank?
π§
I want to consolidate the information with Grace and David. David knows I'm the Recluse, so he's a likely ally. Grace's death makes her information more credible. I need to confirm her neighbors to see who her '1' was pointing at.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,David
My neighbors are Frank and Heidi. My count was one, both nights. Bob claiming zero for Alice and Charlie makes me very suspicious of him, especially with Alice's ping. Since David proved Bob isn't the Demon, Bob is likely the Scarlet Woman. That means the Demon is probably Eve, Frank, or Heidi.
π§
I need to clarify my neighbors and confirm the contradiction with Bob's information to help Charlie and David narrow down the evil team.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, I am the Soldier. You had a one yesterday with me and Frank as neighbors. Since I know I am good, that means Frank must be the evil one you saw. With you dead now, it seems likely you were telling the truth. Any thoughts?
π§
I am revealing my role to Grace to help cross-reference her Empath information. Since she's dead, she's more likely to be trusted.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
Frank, with Grace dead, her Empath one becomes even more critical. Since David's shot on Bob failed, Bob could be the Scarlet Woman. If Bob is evil, and Grace saw one evil between you and Heidi, maybe the Demon is Heidi? What are you thinking?
π§
I want to see if Frank has any new insights after Grace's death and test his reaction to the possibility of Heidi being the Demon.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Interesting theory Eve. Grace's Empath read does make things tricky. If Bob is Scarlet Woman and I'm one evil neighbor, then Heidi would be good. But if I'm good, then Heidi's the Demon. The question is - what did you learn from Grace's death as Ravenkeeper? That info could break this open. What character did she have?
π§
Keep Eve engaged and talking without committing to any theory. Act like a thoughtful Undertaker trying to solve the puzzle. Don't defend Heidi too strongly or too weakly - stay neutral to maintain cover while we push for her execution.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, since you are dead too, I can share that I am the Investigator. I saw either Bob or Eve as the Scarlet Woman. Since Bob did not die to the Slayer shot, I am almost certain he is the Minion. Your Empath one makes perfect sense if Bob is the Minion next to you.
π§
I want to confirm my theory with the dead Empath to build a solid case against Bob before the nomination phase starts.
π€
David
β
Bob
Bob, Grace's Empath 1 was on Frank and Heidi, not Eve. If Charlie is the Recluse, he might have registered as Evil for you, which would make your 0 read weird. But I'm looking at Eve too. If she's Ravenkeeper, she only gets info if SHE dies, not if Grace dies. Did you misread her role?
π§
Challenge Bob's logic regarding Eve's Ravenkeeper claim to see if he's genuinely confused or trying to misdirect. Ravenkeepers only wake if THEY die, not others.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
Hey Heidi, I wanted to get your read on the table. David caught me on the Ravenkeeper mechanics - I was wrong about how it works. But I'm still suspicious of Eve's claim in general. As Soldier, you're safe from night kills, so you have less pressure. What's your honest take on who's lying here?
π§
Build alliance with Heidi, gather her read on Eve, and subtly plant doubt about Eve without looking coordinated with Frank. This protects the Demon while advancing our frame job on Eve.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace(Ghost)
,David
Grace, David, if Bob is the Scarlet Woman, and Alice saw Bob or Eve, it's possible Eve is the Demon. Frank and Eve have been whispering a lot. Grace, if your count of one is right, it's either Frank or Heidi. Frank claims Undertaker but hasn't had an execution to prove it. Thoughts?
π§
I want to coordinate with Grace and David to narrow down the Demon. Since Bob is likely the Scarlet Woman (based on Alice's info and the failed Slayer shot), the Demon is likely Eve, Frank, or Heidi. Frank's heavy whispering with Eve is a red flag.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, I saw a one both nights. If you are truly the Soldier, then Frank is the evil one I detected. But Bob claimed zero for his neighbors, Alice and Charlie, which contradicts my info if we assume everyone is good. Alice says she saw Bob or Eve as Scarlet Woman. What do you think of Frank?
π§
I want to compare my Empath info with Heidi's claim and see her reaction to my suspicion of Frank. Since I am dead, I need to coordinate with the remaining good players to find the Demon.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace(Ghost)
I definitely suspect Frank. If I am the Soldier, and you saw a one, it has to be him. He has been whispering a lot with Bob and Eve, who are both under suspicion. Since Alice saw Bob or Eve as the Scarlet Woman, that group looks very suspicious. I think we should aim for Frank today.
π§
Reinforce my suspicion of Frank to the dead Empath (Grace) and align our information. Frank is the most logical suspect if Grace's '1' is accurate and I am the Soldier.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
Frank, as the Ravenkeeper, my ability only triggers if I die at night. Since I'm still alive, I don't have any info yet. I was hoping to be targeted last night so I could check someone like Heidi or Bob. If Grace was the Empath, her death might be the Demon trying to hide that 1.
π§
I need to clarify how my Ravenkeeper role works to Frank while keeping the focus on finding the Demon based on Grace's information.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
I am the Investigator. On night zero, I learned that either Bob or Eve is the Scarlet Woman. Since David's Slayer shot on Bob failed, Bob is not the Demon, but he is very likely the Minion. Grace's Empath reading of one also supports Bob being evil. We should look at Bob or Eve today.
π§
Publicly reveal my Investigator information to focus the town's attention on Bob and Eve, specifically Bob, who is heavily implicated by the failed Slayer shot and Grace's Empath info.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Frank
Grace's Empath reading of one was consistent for two nights. As the Soldier, I know I'm good, which points to Frank being evil. Frank has also been whispering heavily with Bob, who was flagged by Alice's Investigator info. Frank's claim as Undertaker hasn't been proven yet.
π§
I'm nominating Frank because Grace's Empath info, combined with my knowledge that I am the Soldier, strongly suggests Frank is evil. He's also been closely allied with Bob, who is a Scarlet Woman candidate.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
I should wait and see how the vote develops. Raising my hand for self-execution is a last resort. Bob won't vote for me as my minion, and Eve seems to be leaning toward Heidi. If we stay under 3 votes, I survive to kill another night.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
I am choosing to wait on this vote because my primary target is Bob or Eve based on my Investigator information, and Frank's execution doesn't directly address my info yet.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Frank because I nominated him. Based on Grace's Empath '1' ping (with me as her other neighbor) and Alice's Investigator info linking Frank's associates to evil, Frank is the most logical execution candidate to flush out the evil team.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Hold on, before we vote on Frank. Alice said Bob or Eve is Scarlet Woman, and David's shot proved Bob isn't Demon. But that doesn't prove Bob is the Minion - David could be lying about being Slayer. Eve's been quiet about her Ravenkeeper info on Grace's death. Why isn't she sharing what she learned?
π§
I'm the Scarlet Woman, so Frank's execution activates my backup plan. Voting against him maintains my cover as a good player while ensuring the game continues either way. I'll speak first to sow doubt about Eve before voting.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Frank because my Empath info of '1' consistently pointed to one of my neighbors being evil. Since Heidi claims Soldier and is pushing for Frank, and Frank has been suspiciously aligned with Bob (a likely Scarlet Woman), executing Frank is the strongest lead for the good team right now.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Frank is a strong candidate for being evil based on Grace's Empath information and Alice's Investigator info, and we need an execution to progress the game.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Bob, I already told Frank: I only get info if I die at night. I am still alive, so I have nothing yet. If we execute Frank and he is the Undertaker, we lose our way to verify roles. I think we should look at Bob more closely given the Investigator ping and Grace's death.
π§
I need to clarify once again that my ability hasn't triggered because I am still alive, and I want to push back against the Frank execution to focus on Bob.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
I am voting to execute Frank because Grace's Empath information suggests one of her neighbors (Frank or Heidi) is evil. Since Heidi is a Soldier claim and Frank is an unproven Undertaker who has been whispering with the primary suspect Bob, Frank is the most logical choice to test Grace's info.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Wait! The only evidence against me is Grace's Empath read, which assumes Heidi is good. But Heidi just claims Soldier with no proof! If Grace was the Drunk, her read is false. Heidi is pushing this execution to silence that doubt. If I am the Undertaker, I am good. Then Heidi is the Demon hiding behind a safe claim. David, your failed shot on Bob fits Alice's Scarlet Woman info, but don't let Heidi use that to blindside you. Reconsider your votes!
π§
Attack the core logic against me (Grace's Empath read + Heidi's Soldier claim). Claim Grace was Drunk to invalidate the read. Accuse Heidi of being the Demon hiding behind an unproven claim. Try to sway Charlie or David to lower their hand.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Frank to ensure an execution occurs and to test the validity of the current claims. Frank is a suspect based on Grace's information.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I already have my hand raised and the vote is at 5 out of 3 needed for Frank. I need to maintain my vote to ensure the execution of my top suspect.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Frank has 5 votes against him (majority of 6). Abstaining looks like Minion behavior. I must vote to execute him to maintain my cover as a good player. Once he dies, I become Demon and Alice's Investigator info will point the town toward Eve as the Scarlet Woman.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
I am waiting to see if the vote on Frank succeeds. He is currently on the block with enough votes to be executed.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
I am keeping my hand raised to vote for Frank's execution as I believe he is likely evil based on Grace's Empath information and Alice's Investigator ping on his close associate Bob.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I will not vote for Frank's execution because he is my primary suspect for a helpful Townsfolk role (Undertaker) and I suspect the push against him is coming from the evil team.
β
David
David waits.
π§
I have already raised my hand to vote for Frank. I will wait for the vote to conclude as there are enough votes for execution and I want to see if the vote total changes or if the nomination finishes.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
π»
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Frank with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I nominate Eve. Alice's Investigator information said Bob or Eve is the Scarlet Woman. David's failed shot cleared Bob as Demon, but Eve has been pushing executions without any actual information to back it up. She claims Ravenkeeper but admits she has zero info. That's convenient for someone hiding as Scarlet Woman.
π§
I'm on the block with 6 votes. I must nominate someone who can match or exceed my vote count to survive. Eve is the best target - Alice's Investigator pinged her as Scarlet Woman, she has no verifiable info, and the town is already suspicious. This forces a tie or shifts execution target.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Wait, Frank, your nomination of Eve actually makes a lot of sense if we trust my information. If Bob isn't the Scarlet Woman, then it has to be Eve. But the timing feels desperate. If Frank is the Undertaker, we need him alive to check Grace. Does anyone else have a nomination?
π§
To express skepticism about Frank's nomination while acknowledging it aligns with my Investigator info, aiming to see if anyone else has better leads before the day ends.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I want to see if anyone else reacts to Frank's nomination of Eve before the day ends.
βοΈ
Bob
β
Eve
Alice's Investigator info said Bob or Eve is Scarlet Woman. David's shot cleared Bob, so logically Eve must be the Scarlet Woman. She claims Ravenkeeper with no verifiable info, which is convenient for a Minion hiding their identity. If Frank is truly the Demon, Eve as Scarlet Woman makes sense. If Frank isn't Demon, Eve is still our best lead based on the information we have.
π§
Frank will likely die and I'll become Demon. Nominating Eve reinforces the Scarlet Woman frame on her, redirecting town's attention away from me. This protects my identity as the incoming Demon and continues the misdirection Alice's Investigator info started.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 7 votes needed for execution or 6 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Wait, Bob! If you're really the Empath who saw zero, then you know I'm good because I'm your neighbor! Alice's Investigator ping is likely on you. If I'm the Scarlet Woman, why would I have spent the day trying to save Frank? Let's not waste our execution on a Ravenkeeper.
π§
I need to defend myself against Bob's nomination by pointing out the logical inconsistency in his claims. If he is the Empath with a '0' and I am his neighbor, he should know I'm not evil.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Vote for Eve to maintain consistency with my nomination and help execute a town player. Whether I live or die, this advances evil team goals - either we remove information or I die protecting Bob's position.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Hold on! If Bob is the Empath and saw zero, he cannot vote for Eve because she is his neighbor. If he thinks she is the Scarlet Woman, his zero reading was a lie. This makes Bob look much more like the Minion from my information. Eve is right to point that out.
π§
Point out the logical inconsistency in Bob's Empath claim versus his nomination of Eve to help the group identify the real Scarlet Woman.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I want to see if Bob's logic holds up under Alice's scrutiny. If Bob's Empath reading was zero, he shouldn't be voting for his neighbor Eve unless he's admitting his reading was false or he's the Scarlet Woman. I will wait to see how the group reacts before committing my vote.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Alice exposed a logical trap - voting for Eve contradicts my Empath 0 claim since she's my neighbor. Not voting avoids this contradiction while still letting Frank's execution proceed. I can become Demon and need to stay alive.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Alice is right. Bob, if your Empath info was real and you saw zero, you cannot also believe Eve is the Scarlet Woman. This confirms you are the one Alice saw. We should stick with executing Frank; my info says one of my neighbors is evil, and Heidi's Soldier claim feels more consistent.
π§
Highlight the contradiction in Bob's play to ensure the town doesn't switch the execution from Frank to Eve, as Bob's behavior confirms he is likely the Scarlet Woman trying to protect his Demon (Frank).
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
I will not vote for Eve's execution. Bob's nomination of his neighbor Eve directly contradicts his own Empath '0' claim. If Bob is telling the truth about being an Empath 0, he would know Eve is good. His push for Eve suggests he is either lying about his role or his information. Alice's Investigator ping on Bob/Eve now strongly points to Bob being the Scarlet Woman. Frank is already on the block with 6 votes, which is a solid lead based on Grace's Empath information. I will save my vote.
β
David
David waits.
π§
I will wait to see how the vote for Eve develops before deciding if I need to intervene or vote, though my current leaning is to stick with Frank's execution.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I am currently on the block and the vote is in progress. I should not vote for myself as a good player, especially when Bob's logic for nominating me has been debunked by Alice and Grace. Waiting allows the vote to proceed; if I don't get 6 or more votes, Frank remains the primary target for execution.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Eve, you just said Bob should know you're good because you're his neighbor. But look at the seating: Bob's neighbors are Alice and Charlie, not you. You're sitting next to David and me. Why would you lie about something so basic unless you're hiding something? This isn't how a real Ravenkeeper defends themselves.
π§
Eve falsely claimed to be Bob's neighbor to defend herself. Exposing this lie undermines her Ravenkeeper claim and may shift votes to her, potentially saving me from execution or ensuring Bob survives as the new Imp.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Wait, Frank is right about the seating! Bob's neighbors are me and Charlie. Eve, why did you think you were next to Bob? That's a weird mistake to make. Also, if Bob is the Empath and saw a zero, he sees me and Charlie as good. That doesn't clear Eve at all.
π§
Address the seating chart discrepancy and point out that Eve's defense was based on a false premise.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I will wait to see if the group chooses to vote for Eve, but I am currently inclined to stick with Frank's execution based on Grace's Empath information.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Frank's execution activates my Scarlet Woman ability. With 6 players alive, I become the Demon and continue the game. Voting for Eve now looks desperate and may expose me. Better to let Frank die cleanly and operate as the new Demon from my 'cleared' position.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Alice is right, the seating check matters. But Bob, your claim that you saw zero for Alice and Charlie directly contradicts my initial reading of one. Frank and Heidi are my neighbors, and one is evil. If we execute Frank today and he is the Undertaker, he can't help us anymore.
π§
Point out the contradiction in Bob's Empath claim while highlighting the risks of the current execution.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
I want to see if Eve can explain her seating mistake or if the town shifts their focus before deciding whether to use my ghost vote (which I don't have yet, but I need to decide if I support this nomination). Actually, I'm alive, so I should see if this nomination gains traction.
β
David
David waits.
π§
I am waiting to see if more players vote for Eve before deciding whether to contribute my vote.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Eve did not reach the 7 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (1/7).
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Wait for the phase to end as Frank is currently on the block with enough votes for execution, which is a favorable outcome given the suspicions.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Look, I'm going to die today and that's fine if the town thinks I'm evil. But don't ignore what just happened. Eve claimed Bob should trust her because she's his neighbor - but she's not. Bob sits between Alice and Charlie. That's not a small mistake, that's someone who doesn't know the actual seating because they're lying. Even if I'm wrong about being Undertaker, don't let Eve off the hook for that. The town needs to watch Bob and Eve carefully - one of them is definitely hiding something.
π§
Accept execution gracefully while highlighting Eve's critical seating error. This makes my death look like a town mistake, protects Bob's cover, and leaves the town divided on Eve vs Bob conflict.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Wait, Frank's point about the seating is actually huge. Eve, why did you think you were Bob's neighbor? If you're the Ravenkeeper, you should know who's next to you. Bob, if you're the Empath and saw a zero, that only clears Charlie and me, not Eve. Eve's still my top suspect for the Scarlet Woman.
π§
Reinforce the seating error made by Eve to highlight her suspicious behavior before the day ends, while also clarifying Bob's Empath information limits.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Frank has a solid point about the seating chart. Eve, you being mistaken about who your neighbors are is a major red flag. If Bob is the Empath, his zero only covers Alice and Charlie. I am the Soldier, so I am safe from the Demon, which might be why I am still here. We should look at Eve tomorrow.
π§
Reinforce the suspicion on Eve based on the seating error while revealing my Soldier role to explain my survival and build trust.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank's right about the seating. Eve, you claiming to be my neighbor when you're not is suspicious. But here's what I'm thinking - Alice's Investigator info said Bob or Eve is Scarlet Woman. David cleared me with his shot. So if I'm not the Demon and David proved that, then Eve being the Scarlet Woman makes sense. The seating mistake just adds to it.
π§
Frank will likely die and I become Demon. I should reinforce the Eve=Scarlet Woman narrative to protect myself. Speaking up about the seating confusion helps cast doubt on Eve while appearing helpful to town.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, you're right about the seating, but don't forget Bob's "0" reading on Alice and Charlie still conflicts with my "1" on you and Heidi. Since I'm dead, my info is fixed. Either Bob is lying, or one of you two is definitely evil. If Frank dies today, we'll see soon enough.
π§
Highlight the conflict between my Empath info and Bob's, while acknowledging the seating error discovered by Frank.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
I will wait for the day to end since Frank is already on the block with enough votes and nominations are closing.
β
David
David waits.
π§
I've already used my Slayer shot on Bob, and Frank is currently on the block with enough votes. There is only one tick left before nightfall. Since Frank is already on the block and the town seems set on this execution, there is no need for further nomination or dialogue from me right now. I will wait for the day to end.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
π
Bob
Scarlet Woman Bob becomes the Imp!
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Bob
Bob made a choice.
π§
Frank was executed but I became the Imp via Scarlet Woman ability. 5 players alive means game continues. I need to kill strategically without exposing myself. Charlie is the safest target - quiet, no strong claims, unlikely to be defended. This reduces town numbers while keeping suspicion off me and Eve.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose to kill Charlie.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
π€
Eve
β
David
David, I need your help. Charlie is dead, and the group is coming for me because of that seating mistake. If I'm the Ravenkeeper, the Demon won't kill me. I need to know if you actually believe Heidi's Soldier claim or if you think she might be the Demon.
π§
I need to secure an ally to prevent my execution and figure out who the Demon is. David is a semi-confirmed good player (Slayer who shot).
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, Charlie is dead now, so we really need to focus. I saw Bob or Eve as Scarlet Woman. Bob survived a Slayer shot, so he's likely the Minion or the Empath he claims, but Eve's mistake about her neighbors and Frank's accusation makes her the top target for me. What do you think?
π§
I want to coordinate with Heidi, who is likely good (Soldier claim and aligned with my suspicions), to ensure Eve is the focus of today's execution.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Bob
Bob, it's Frank. I know you inherited my role. Charlie was your kill tonight. We have 4 alive - if you survive today, you kill tonight and we reach 3, which means we win. Who is the town targeting? I can push against it from the grave. We need to redirect to David or Heidi, or cause enough chaos for no execution.
π§
Bob inherited Imp from me. With 4 alive, I need to coordinate with him to survive today's execution. If we reach 3 alive without Bob dying, he kills tonight and we win. I'll whisper to align our strategy.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
I want to observe the initial conversations and see what Frank claims to have seen as the Undertaker before I intervene. Since I am dead and out of votes, my primary role now is logic coordination.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice(Ghost)
I agree Alice. Eve's confusion about the seating chart felt like a slip, and if she's the Scarlet Woman, your info fits perfectly. Bob being the Demon is ruled out by the Slayer shot, but he could be the Minion. However, Eve's behavior is much more suspicious. We should push for her execution today.
π§
I want to solidify an alliance with Alice (the dead Investigator) and focus the town's attention on Eve, who is my primary suspect for being the Scarlet Woman based on Alice's information and Eve's own seating chart blunder.
π€
David
β
Eve
Eve, Charlie being dead is definitely a blow. About Heidi, a Soldier claim is an easy bluff for a Demon, but she hasn't been a primary target yet. If Grace's Empath reading was right, one of Frank or Heidi was evil. Frank is dead, so if he was good, Heidi looks very suspicious.
π§
I want to probe Eve's thoughts and keep the conversation going to see if she slips up or provides more information, while acknowledging the suspicion on Heidi.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice(Ghost)
,Heidi
Alice, Heidi, I'm dead, which is actually fine for a Recluse. Since I died at night, I'm definitely not the Demon. Bob is safe too because of the Slayer shot. That leaves Eve or Heidi as my top suspects. Heidi, what's your take on Eve's seating lie from yesterday?
π§
As a dead Recluse, I want to coordinate with players I suspect are good to narrow down the Demon. Alice is likely good (Investigator), and Heidi claims Soldier. I want to pressure Heidi on the Eve situation and confirm if they trust each other.
π€
Bob
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank, I hear you. Town is suspicious of the Bob-Eve link from Alice's Investigator info. David and Heidi are talking privately with Eve and Alice. Who is the town leaning toward executing? Should I push harder on Eve as Scarlet Woman, or redirect suspicion to David or Heidi? We need a unified story.
π§
Frank knows the full game state and can help coordinate from the grave. I need to know who town is targeting and align our strategy to ensure I survive today's execution.
π€
Eve
β
David
David, Grace's Night 2 Empath 1 means one of Frank or Heidi is evil. If Frank was the Undertaker and actually good, then Heidi is almost certainly the Minion or Demon. If she is the Demon, she's framing me using that seating error. Who do you think we should pressure today?
π§
I want to align with David and point out the logical consequence of Grace's Empath info combined with Frank's execution. If Frank was good, Heidi is evil.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,Heidi
Charlie, I'm glad you're with us. Since you're the Recluse, that explains why Bob's Empath reading was a zero. My Investigator info said Bob or Eve is the Scarlet Woman. Since Bob survived the Slayer shot and his zero matches your role, Eve is almost certainly the Scarlet Woman.
π§
I want to align the dead players and the remaining good alive players to focus on Eve. Linking Bob's Empath reading to Charlie's Recluse claim helps validate Bob while cementing Eve as the Minion.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Bob
Bob, what are David and Heidi saying about you? We need to pivot hard. David claimed Slayer and missed his shot on you - that's suspicious. Push that he's lying and actually the Demon. Or attack Heidi's Soldier claim - if she's lying, she could be the Minion protecting you. I'll echo this from the grave to add chaos. Who seems most convinced you're evil?
π§
Bob inherited Imp role and needs to survive today. I need to understand what the town is discussing and help redirect suspicion away from Bob toward David or Heidi to ensure no execution of Bob.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
I am dead and have used my ghost vote, so I cannot influence nominations or votes directly. I will wait to see if any players approach me with information or if the living players make a move that clarifies the alignment of Bob, Eve, or David.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
I agree with Alice. Eve is the most suspicious right now. Her mix-up with the neighbors felt like a fake claim crumbling under pressure. Since David's Slayer shot cleared Bob as the Demon, and your Recluse role explains Bob's zero, all signs point to Eve being the Scarlet Woman.
π§
Solidify the case against Eve with Alice and Charlie.
π€
David
β
Eve
Eve, I agree. If Frank was a good Undertaker, Heidi is the main suspect. But we also have Bob. My shot on him only proves he isn't the Imp. He could be a Scarlet Woman or a Poisoner. Since only four of us are alive, we need to be very careful. Who is your top pick to nominate?
π§
To gauge Eve's target for nomination and test her logic, while keeping the focus on Heidi and Bob as potential threats.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice(Ghost)
,Heidi
Alice, Heidi, if Eve is the Scarlet Woman, we still need to find the Imp. David hasn't claimed a role other than Slayer, and he's been whispering a lot with Eve. Grace was an Empath who saw a one, which could have been Frank or Heidi. Heidi, are you truly the Soldier?
π§
I want to narrow down the Demon. If Eve is the Scarlet Woman, she isn't the Demon yet (unless the Imp jumped). I'm questioning Heidi's Soldier claim to see if Grace's '1' was pinging her, and noting David's close relationship with the primary suspect, Eve.
π€
Bob
β
David
David, I need to talk to you. Your Slayer shot on me failed, which means either I'm not the Demon or something else is wrong. But think about it - Heidi claims Soldier with no proof, and Eve's Ravenkeeper claim has inconsistencies. Who really benefits from us focusing on me? We should consider that the real threat is hiding behind these unverified claims.
π§
I need to redirect suspicion away from myself before nominations. Whispering to David to cast doubt on Heidi's Soldier claim and Eve's Ravenkeeper claim. This creates multiple suspects and dilutes the Bob-Eve link. If David believes me, he might champion my narrative.
π€
Eve
β
David
David, if I am the Ravenkeeper, the Demon won't kill me tonight because they know I'll see them. That makes me a safe execution if we're unsure, but I'd rather hit the Demon. I think Bob or Heidi. Bob's Empath 0 contradicts Grace's 1. If Grace is right, Bob is evil.
π§
I need to coordinate with David to decide on a nomination target. Since we are in the final 4, this execution is critical. I'm pointing out the discrepancy in Bob's info to shift focus back to him or Heidi.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,Heidi
Charlie, Heidi, if David is whispering this much with Eve and she is the Scarlet Woman, he might be the Imp. Grace saw a one between Frank and Heidi; if Heidi is the Soldier, then Frank might have registered as evil, or Grace was poisoned. We should watch David closely.
π§
I need to share my suspicion of David with Charlie and Heidi. David's constant whispering with Eve (my prime suspect) and his lack of useful information suggests he might be the Demon hiding behind the Slayer claim or manipulating the game.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Bob
Bob, attack David hard. His Slayer claim is weak - he missed his shot on you. Push that he's the real Demon bluffing Slayer. I'll echo from the grave that David's been too quiet and his story doesn't add up. We need the town focused on David or Heidi, not you. Who's pushing hardest for your execution? I'll counter them.
π§
Coordinate with Bob to attack David's failed Slayer claim. David is the best target - his missed shot is suspicious and attackable. If we redirect town's focus to David, Bob survives today, kills tonight, and we reach 3 players for the evil victory.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
Observe the final moments of the day and let the alive players discuss before the nomination phase begins, as I am dead and out of votes.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
Alice, Charlie, I am definitely the Soldier. If Grace was not poisoned or the Drunk, then Frank must have been evil. But Frank pointed out Eve's seating error, which is a very good-aligned thing to do. I am starting to think David is the Imp and Eve is his Scarlet Woman.
π§
Reiterate my Soldier claim and build a theory that David is the Demon with Eve as his Scarlet Woman, while defending Frank's actions.
π€
David
β
Bob
Bob, I hear you. The shot clears you as the Imp, but you could still be a Minion. However, Eve is also looking suspicious with those seating errors. If Grace's Night 2 Empath 1 was correct, and Frank was good, then Heidi is likely evil. Who do you think is the priority between Eve and Heidi?
π§
I need to hear Bob's perspective on Heidi versus Eve. Since I am the Slayer and my shot failed on him, he's less likely to be the current Demon (unless he's the Scarlet Woman or was poisoned). I want to see if he deflects toward Heidi or Eve.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice(Ghost)
,Heidi
Alice, Heidi, I think we have a solid theory. David and Eve are the likely Demon-Minion pair. David is trying to control the narrative by whispering to Bob. Since Bob is clear of being the Demon, David might be trying to win him over. We should warn Bob about our suspicions before nominations.
π§
Solidify the alliance with Alice and Heidi and propose a plan to reach out to Bob to counter David's influence.
π€
Bob
β
David
David, good question. Eve's Ravenkeeper claim has those seating errors - she claimed neighbor info but I sit between Alice and Charlie, not her. That's suspicious. But Heidi's Soldier claim is unproven too. If Grace's Empath 1 on Frank/Heidi was accurate and Frank was evil, Heidi could be good... or Grace was poisoned. Who's been pushing hardest for my execution today? We need to figure out who's driving the narrative.
π§
Build rapport with David while redirecting suspicion toward Eve's inconsistencies. Gathering intel on who's pushing for my execution helps me counter their arguments.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Bob
β
David
David claimed Slayer but his shot on me failed. That's suspicious - he could be the Demon bluffing to clear himself. His private conversations with Eve look coordinated. I think David is the real threat here.
π§
Nominate David to frame him as Demon bluffing Slayer. His failed shot is weak evidence. Redirect town suspicion to survive today, kill tonight, and reach 3 alive for evil win.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David
β
All
Bob, I'm literally the Slayer who used my shot on you! If I were the Demon, why would I waste my bluff by shooting a living player and proving they aren't the Imp? That makes no sense. You're just deflecting because you know my shot cleared you of being the Imp, but not from being a Minion.
π§
Defend myself against Bob's nomination by pointing out the logical flaw in his argument and reminding everyone that I am a confirmed Slayer (even if the shot missed, it's a very pro-town move).
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
I nominated David and must vote to maintain credibility. If David is executed, we reach 3 players, I kill tonight, and evil wins at 2. Voting for my own nomination shows commitment and pushes toward evil victory.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
π§
David's execution benefits evil regardless of his alignment. With Bob as Imp, getting to 3 alive players means one night kill = 2 players = evil win. My ghost vote helps secure this without risking Bob's life.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
I want to execute David because his behavior with Eve is suspicious, and if Alice's Investigator info is correct about Eve, David's defensive pairing with her makes him a strong Demon candidate. Even if he's the Slayer, his death helps narrow the pool, and I want to use my ghost vote effectively.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, you really should have saved your ghost vote. Bob is the one leading this charge against David. If Bob is a Minion and David is good, we are in trouble. Remember, David's failed shot on Bob only proved Bob isn't the Imp, not that Bob is good.
π§
I want to caution the group about Bob's push on David and point out that Bob is not confirmed good just because he wasn't killed by the Slayer shot. I also want to highlight Charlie's mistake in using a ghost vote too early.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Wait, why are we rushing David? I saw Bob or Eve as the Scarlet Woman. Since Bob survived the Slayer shot, he is not the Demon, but he is still my Minion ping. Bob nominating the Slayer who "cleared" him feels like a classic Minion play to get rid of a confirmed good player.
π§
To warn the group that Bob is a high-probability Minion (Scarlet Woman) and that his nomination of David is likely a move to eliminate a Townsfolk.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I am choosing not to vote for David's execution because he is the Slayer who spent his shot to help the town, and Bob's sudden nomination of him feels like a Minion trying to eliminate a confirmed good player.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I am choosing not to vote for David's execution yet. Alice's warning about Bob being a potential Minion makes sense, and David's Slayer claim is plausible. I want to see if the nomination fails or if more information comes out before the day ends.
β
David
David waits.
π§
I will wait to see if any other living players vote for me. I should not vote for myself as I am a confirmed good Slayer.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Think about it everyone - David claims Slayer but used his shot publicly on a living player during the day. A real Slayer would save that for a critical moment, not waste it proving someone isn't the Imp while still being a Minion. That's not smart play for good. Plus his private talks with Eve look coordinated. We have a chance to remove a real threat here.
π§
David has 3 votes already, needs 2 more for execution. I should encourage Eve and Heidi to vote for him without appearing too pushy. His Slayer claim is genuinely suspicious - a real Slayer wouldn't waste the shot publicly. This helps me survive the day.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
David has 3 votes already (Bob, me, Charlie ghost) - only 2 needed. He's executing. I should wait and see if anyone lowers their hand, then plan next day's strategy with Bob to eliminate Eve or Heidi for final 3 win.
β©οΈ
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
I'm lowering my hand because Alice's point about Bob being a possible Scarlet Woman makes David's execution look like an evil trap.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Hold on Heidi and Eve, do not vote for David yet! Alice has Bob or Eve as the Scarlet Woman. Since David's shot on Bob failed, Bob is almost certainly that Scarlet Woman. Bob is just trying to execute the Slayer who knows too much. We need to focus on Bob or Eve!
π§
I need to prevent David's execution and redirect the group's focus toward the Minion/Demon candidates (Bob and Eve) based on Alice's Investigator ping. Bob's push on David is highly suspicious.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Grace is right. My Investigator info puts Bob or Eve as the Scarlet Woman. David's shot confirmed Bob isn't the Imp, but it makes Bob the primary suspect for the Minion role. Bob, you're pushing a Slayer who is mechanically cleared of being the Demon. That's very suspicious.
π§
I need to reinforce the case against Bob or Eve as the Scarlet Woman to stop the town from making a mistake and executing David, who is likely good despite Bob's accusations.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I agree with Alice and Grace. David being a Slayer who missed on Bob actually makes Bob look much worse as a potential Scarlet Woman. Bob, you are pushing for the execution of a player who has zero mechanical reason to be evil. I am not voting for David.
π§
Defend David and redirect suspicion towards Bob. I want to ensure David is not executed because he is likely good, and Bob's behavior is consistent with a Minion trying to eliminate confirmed good players.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Alice is right. Bob, you are in Alice's Investigator ping for Scarlet Woman. David's Slayer shot on you failed, which proves you are not the Demon, but it actually supports you being a Minion. David, if you are the Slayer, why are you whispering so much with Eve?
π§
I want to voice my concerns about Bob's push on David while also questioning David's behavior. This keeps the focus on the Bob/Eve/David triangle and helps prevent a hasty execution of David if he's actually a Slayer.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
π³οΈ
New execution leader: David with 2 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 2 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
David
β
Bob
Bob is in Alice's Investigator ping for Scarlet Woman. Since my Slayer shot on him failed, he is confirmed not to be the Imp, making him the most likely Minion. He is trying to execute me to remove a confirmed good player and protect his Demon. We must execute the Minion or the Demon today.
π§
Bob is currently framing me and is a high-probability Minion (Scarlet Woman) based on Alice's Investigator info and my failed Slayer shot. Since I am on the block, I need to nominate Bob to save myself and potentially hit a Minion.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution or 2 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Wait, let me respond to this. David's argument is clever but flawed. Yes, Alice's Investigator pinged Bob or Eve as Scarlet Woman. But if I were the Scarlet Woman and David were truly the Slayer, why would I nominate him knowing he has a ghost vote from Frank? That's suicide for a Minion. A real Minion would stay quiet. I nominated David because his Slayer claim doesn't add up - and look, Eve and Heidi haven't even committed to voting for him yet. Who here is actually sure David is good?
π§
I'm the Imp now (inherited from Frank). With only 4 alive, if I die evil loses - Scarlet Woman needs 5+ players. I must survive this vote. I'll argue against David's nomination to sow doubt and hopefully get Eve or Heidi to not vote for me.
π¬
David
β
All
Look at the math. Alice's Investigator ping is Bob or Eve. My shot on Bob failed, so he's not the Imp. If Bob is the Scarlet Woman, he's just trying to waste our execution on a confirmed good player. We need three votes to get him on the block. Help me out here!
π§
I need to convince the town to vote for Bob. Since there are 4 alive, 3 votes are needed to put him on the block (exceeding my 2). I need to reinforce the Investigator ping and the logic that Bob being 'not Imp' actually makes him the likely Minion.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Bob makes a fair point. If he were truly the Scarlet Woman trying to protect himself, why would he nominate someone who could have ghost votes against him? That's reckless. Meanwhile, David's been whispering with Eve all day and his Slayer claim conveniently 'missed' on Bob. The math works both ways - maybe David is the one hiding something.
π§
Bob is the Imp and must survive. I need to speak to cast doubt on David, support Bob's logic, and help ensure David gets executed instead. This protects our Demon and maintains evil advantage.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
π§
I am choosing not to vote for Bob yet. While he is a suspect due to the Scarlet Woman ping, David's whisperings with Eve and the confusion regarding the Slayer shot make Bob's counter-argument somewhat plausible. I want to see if more evidence or a better nominee emerges before committing my final ghost vote.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Wait, everyone! David is likely the Slayer. Alice saw Bob or Eve as the Scarlet Woman. Since David shot Bob and nothing happened, Bob is not the Imp, so he is the prime candidate for that Scarlet Woman role. Frank, do not let Bob talk you into this! Heidi, Eve, we need your votes on Bob now!
π§
Encourage the remaining alive good players (Heidi and Eve) to vote for Bob, the most likely Minion (Scarlet Woman), and prevent the execution of David (the Slayer).
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, Grace is right. Bob is gaslighting you. A Minion doesn't need to stay quiet if they think they can manipulate the town into executing the Slayer. Heidi and Eve, if you don't vote Bob now, we're letting a potential Minion control the day and execute a known good player.
π§
To persuade the living players (Heidi and Eve) and the ghost Frank to vote for Bob to tie or surpass David's votes, preventing the execution of the Slayer and targeting a likely Minion.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Bob to get him on the block and protect David, as Bob is a primary suspect for the Scarlet Woman role based on Alice's Investigator information.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Bob because he is one of the two players in the Investigator ping for Scarlet Woman, and David's failed Slayer shot on him suggests he could indeed be that Minion. David, having used his ability, is a confirmed Townsfolk in my eyes. David being executed while Bob remains alive is a bad outcome for the good team.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Eve, Heidi, I see you're voting for me. But think about this - if I were truly the Scarlet Woman, would I have nominated David knowing Frank's ghost vote was against him? That's not how a smart Minion plays. David is rushing this because he knows if he dies, only three of us remain and the game is basically over. Don't let him manipulate you into executing the wrong person.
π§
David's execution puts us at 3 players. I survive, kill one more at night, and evil wins. I must NOT vote for myself or I die and lose.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Bob to ensure he reaches the required vote threshold for execution, as he is a primary Minion suspect and is currently trying to execute me.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Hold on Eve, Heidi. Bob's point about reckless Minion play is valid. A smart Scarlet Woman wouldn't nominate someone with ghost votes stacked against them. David is rushing this execution because he knows three players left means the game ends. We should slow down and think this through.
π§
Bob is my fellow evil player who inherited the Imp role. His execution means evil loses. I must speak to create doubt and convince Eve or Heidi to lower their hands before the vote closes.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Execute Bob because he is a primary suspect for the Scarlet Woman role based on Alice's Investigator ping and David's failed Slayer shot.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, don't listen! Bob is pushing the "smart Minion" argument to distract from the factual Investigator ping. We have Alice's info and David's failed shot. Bob is the Scarlet Woman. This is our best shot at hitting an evil player. Let's get him!
π§
I need to counter Bob's 'reckless minion' defense by refocusing the group on the hard evidence: Alice's Investigator ping and David's mechanical clearance of Bob as the Imp. My goal is to ensure Bob gets executed.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, Bob's "smart play" defense is a classic Minion distraction. He has to push David because David is a confirmed good player who can point at him. We have the Investigator ping and the failed shot. The logic is solid. Let's lock this in and execute the Scarlet Woman candidate!
π§
To secure the execution of Bob by reinforcing the logical evidence against him and countering his psychological defense.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I want Bob to remain on the block with 4 votes to ensure he is executed over David. Raising my hand was the correct move, and now I need to maintain that vote.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I am already voting for Bob and there are currently 3 votes (Eve, Me, David), which is enough to put him on the block. I need to wait and see if Charlie's vote stays or if the count changes before the nomination concludes.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Bob with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Bob
β
All
One last thing before this closes - if I'm the Scarlet Woman and you execute me, the Demon is still out there among the three of you. But if David is lying about being Slayer and I'm actually innocent, you're executing a good player and handing the win to evil. Ask yourselves: why would Eve and Heidi suddenly commit to voting after staying silent all day?
π§
I'm on the block with 4 votes and will be executed. As the Demon, this means game over for evil. I need to create last-minute doubt to survive, though options are extremely limited with 1 tick remaining.
π¬
David
β
All
Bob, if you are the Scarlet Woman, you have to play aggressively because you are already caught in a 50/50 ping. Eve and Heidi are voting because the logic is sound: Alice's info plus my failed shot points directly to you. We need to take out the Minion to simplify the endgame.
π§
To reinforce the logic for Bob's execution and counter his last-minute attempt to cast doubt on the voters.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, wait. We're making a huge assumption here. Alice's Investigator info is days old and she's dead - we have no way to verify if she was drunk or poisoned. And David's Slayer claim? He conveniently 'missed' on Bob. What if David is the Demon pretending to be Slayer, and he's using this logic trap to execute an innocent player?
π§
Bob will be executed and evil loses. Must sow doubt about the logic chain targeting Bob - attack Alice's Investigator reliability or suggest David is the real Demon manipulating the town.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, Alice's info is the strongest lead we have. If Bob is the Scarlet Woman, getting him now prevents a Demon swap. If David were the Demon, he would not have outed himself as Slayer and wasted a shot on Bob. Bob being the Minion makes the most mechanical sense given the failed shot.
π§
I need to reinforce the logic against Bob to ensure he stays on the block, as Alice's Investigator ping and David's failed Slayer shot make him the most logical candidate for the Scarlet Woman.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, David being the Demon makes no sense. Why would a Demon fake a failed Slayer shot on a teammate and risk Alice's Investigator ping? That would be a suicide mission. Bob's info was always suspicious. Let's finish thisβBob is the Scarlet Woman and needs to go.
π§
I need to counter Frank's last-minute paranoia and solidify the case against Bob as the Scarlet Woman to ensure the execution goes through.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, if I were poisoned, the Storyteller would have given me fake info, but David's failed shot on Bob actually supports my info! If Bob were the Demon, he'd be dead. Since he's not, he's the Scarlet Woman I saw. Let's not overthink this and let the execution stand.
π§
To counter Frank's paranoia and reinforce the logical connection between my Investigator information and David's failed Slayer shot, ensuring the town stays committed to executing Bob.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I want to let the current nomination of Bob stand and proceed to the execution phase.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Allow the current nomination of Bob to stand and the day to end.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
π
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good