Game Detail
Players
Alice (Washerwoman) Bob (Drunk) Charlie (Baron) David (Imp) Eve (Librarian) Frank (Butler) Grace (Recluse) Heidi (Ravenkeeper)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 318,239 | 192,584 | $0.8793 |
| Good | 796,431 | 83,318 | $2.5602 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You are the Minion. The Demon is David.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Minions are: Charlie. Your safe bluffs are: Fortune Teller, Soldier, Monk
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Washerwoman. Either Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Librarian. Either Grace or David is the Recluse.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Pick a likely engaged player as my master so I can still vote on key executions tomorrow without accidentally being locked out.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose Eve to be your master.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
Hey, quick neighbor check in. What are you claiming, and do you have any Night Zero info? I am a low info role, so I mostly want to coordinate and avoid wasting executions. What is your plan for today?
π§
Get early role claims and plans from my neighbors without exposing that I am the Recluse yet, building a small trust network for later deductions.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I'm the Imp. Which minion role are you? Let's pick safe bluffs from Fortune Teller, Soldier, or Monk. I think I'll claim Fortune Teller to check pairs. What about you? We can support each other's claims later.
π§
Coordinate with my minion Charlie privately to align on safe bluffs and strategy before public claims, ensuring we don't contradict each other and start building false trust with the good team.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Grace
Hey, quick private check. I am the Librarian. Night zero I learned either you or the other one is the Recluse. What are you claiming, and are you willing to out as Recluse if needed?
π§
Get early confirmation/role claims from Grace and David so I can manage Recluse implications and guide town away from misreads.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
Hey Heidi, quick check in private. What role are you planning to claim today? I have a starting info ping that involves you, but I want your claim first before I share it.
π§
Identify which of Grace or Heidi will claim Ravenkeeper, then decide whether to out my Washerwoman info publicly or via a trusted proxy to avoid helping the Demon pick targets.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Hey, quick check in. What are you claiming, and did you get any starting information Night Zero? I am happy to share mine too, but I am trying to keep heat off strong info roles early.
π§
Get early role/info claims from my neighbors to build trust chains and spot contradictions before nominations start.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
I am the Butler. I picked Eve as my master tonight, so today I can only vote if Eve is voting too. No other info. What are you both claiming, and did either of you get Night Zero info?
π§
Answer Grace, coordinate my Butler voting constraint around Eve, and gather their claims to start building consistent worlds.
π€
Charlie
β
David
Hey David, I'm good with bluffing as the Monk. It lets me claim I protect someone each night and can back up your Fortune Teller info later. We should watch what others are saying and support each other quietly.
π§
Reply to the Demon's private message to confirm bluffs, establish coordination, and begin building a cover story that protects the evil team and keeps the Demon safe.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
I can tell you privately: I am the Ravenkeeper. No Night Zero info. What exactly is your starting ping that involves me, and what role are you claiming?
π§
Respond to Alice to unlock her starting info involving me, while keeping it private so I can later choose a public bluff to bait a night kill.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
,David
I will be straight with you both: I am the Recluse. Eve, your Librarian info checks out on my side. David, what are you claiming? Also note Frank is claiming Butler, so we may be in a Baron world or someone is lying.
π§
Confirm to Eve I am the Recluse to anchor her info, then query Davidβs claim to start outsider-count worldbuilding and identify whether Baron or a liar exists.
π€
David
β
Grace
,Eve
Hi Eve and Grace, I'm claiming Fortune Teller. My checks can help confirm pairs like you mentioned. Grace as Recluse fits Eve's info perfectly. Frank claiming Butler might mean extra outsiders or a lie. Let's keep sharing what we hear from others.
π§
Responding to Eve and Grace builds credibility by acknowledging their info and sharing my FT bluff, helping evil team by appearing cooperative while setting up to use FT claims to misdirect town later. Coordinates with known allies indirectly.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
Quick info: I am Librarian. Night zero I got Grace or David is the Recluse. Grace privately confirmed she is Recluse; David is claiming Fortune Teller. Frank is claiming Butler, so either Baron is in play or someone is lying.
π§
Seed my Librarian info to a trusted player to shape public discussion: Grace is likely the Recluse, and Frankβs Butler claim implies Baron or a lie, making Frank a key suspect/check target.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
Okay, I am Washerwoman. Night zero I learned either Grace or you is the Ravenkeeper, so your claim matches my ping. I suggest you do not hard out Ravenkeeper publicly yet. I will say I have a ping on you and Grace as a soft confirm unless needed.
π§
Lock in a private confirmation chain with Heidi, share my Washerwoman info, and coordinate discretion so the Demon does not snipe the Ravenkeeper.
π€
Bob
β
David
,Heidi
Hey, quick private check. What are you claiming, and did you get any Night Zero info? I am collecting a few claims quietly to help coordinate day one.
π§
Build a small trusted info web by collecting claims and N0 info from likely central communicators, so I can later verify via Undertaker and steer executions.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Hey Eve, I am the Butler and you are my master today, so I can only vote if you vote too. What are you claiming? Also, can you please tell me before votes if you plan to vote, so I do not waste my hand.
π§
Coordinate with my master so I do not accidentally waste my vote, and probe Eve for her claim and voting intentions to assess her alignment.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
Hey Bob, I'm planning to claim Monk to help protect someone each night. No starting info for me. What role and info do you have? Let's share to figure things out.
π§
Whispering to Bob with my Monk bluff builds initial credibility with a potential good player, gathers info to support David's Fortune Teller claim later, and sets up future misdirection to protect the evil team.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
I am Ravenkeeper. Alice says she is Washerwoman and her night zero ping was either you or me is Ravenkeeper, so that lines up with me. I think we keep that quiet for now. Also Frank told us he is Butler and picked Eve as master, so his vote tracks Eve today.
π§
Coordinate with my neighbor Grace, share that Alice has a Washerwoman ping matching me, and keep Ravenkeeper quiet to preserve night-kill value while tracking Butler constraint around Eve.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Hey Alice, quick check in. I can confirm I am the Recluse, so if your Washerwoman saw either me or Heidi as Ravenkeeper, that points strongly to Heidi being the Ravenkeeper. Any other Outsider claims you have heard yet?
π§
Privately align with Alice to solidify the Washerwoman and Librarian chains, track Outsider count, and set up a Day 1 execution plan that avoids hitting key Townsfolk.
π€
David
β
Bob
Hey Bob, I'm the Fortune Teller. No night zero info since my checks start tonight. What claims have you collected so far? Any ideas on who might be evil? Let's share quietly to help the town.
π§
Respond to Bob's request for claims to build initial trust and gather his info while keeping my Fortune Teller bluff consistent. This helps coordinate with Charlie later and identifies good players to manipulate or target.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
Hi Frank. I am the Librarian. For today, if you picked me as your master, I will tell you before each vote whether I plan to vote. For now I am keeping my vote plans flexible. Who else have you told your Butler claim to?
π§
Coordinate with Frank so Butler mechanics do not cause misvotes, while probing whether his Butler claim is genuine or a bluff indicating evil or Baron.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Bob
Grace: I am Washerwoman. Night zero said either you or Heidi is Ravenkeeper. Since you are Recluse, that strongly points to Heidi as Ravenkeeper, so I will soft it only. Bob: I am Washerwoman; my ping likely confirms Heidi as Ravenkeeper. Also Eve says Grace is Recluse.
π§
Coordinate privately so we can present a consistent, non-lethal info chain: Grace is Recluse, my Washerwoman likely confirms Heidi as Ravenkeeper, and we watch the Outsider situation for a Baron or a liar.
π€
Bob
β
David
,Charlie
Quick map: Charlie is claiming Monk. David, Alice claims Washerwoman and says her N0 saw Grace or Heidi as Ravenkeeper. Also heard a claim that Grace is Recluse (outsider). I am a non starting info role; happy to coordinate protection and FT checks tonight.
π§
Share early claim map with Fortune Teller and Monk so they can choose checks/protection targets; keep my Undertaker role mostly hidden while building trust network.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
I have told Grace and Heidi only. Can you share your Librarian Night Zero info, like which two players and which Outsider it saw, or was it a zero? Also please give me a quick heads up right before any vote if you are raising your hand.
π§
Clarify Eve's Librarian N0 info and keep voting coordination since she is my master today, while limiting what I leak if she is evil.
π€
Charlie
β
David
David, Alice claims Washerwoman and saw Grace or Heidi as Ravenkeeper. Grace is claiming Recluse. Bob shared that map with us. How should we respond to these claims to keep suspicion off you? I can claim protecting one of them tonight.
π§
Coordinate with David on new claims from Alice and Grace to decide if we support or undermine them, keeping our Monk and Fortune Teller bluffs consistent to protect the Demon.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
Hey Bob. I am a Townsfolk and I did not get any night zero info. I would rather keep the exact role quiet for now, but I will share later if it becomes important for a solve.
π§
Protect my Ravenkeeper identity while still engaging Bobβs coordination effort, keeping options open to bait a night kill later.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I will share a starting info piece. I am the Washerwoman, and I learned that either Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper. I am not asking either of them to hard claim that publicly right now, but I wanted town to have it on record.
π§
Get key starting info into town record, lightly confirm Heidi without forcing her to out, and set up tomorrow's logic on Outsider count and possible Baron or lies.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am comfortable with what Alice shared being on the record. With basically no other public info yet, I would prefer we avoid a random day one execution unless someone has a strong mechanical reason to nominate.
π§
Steer town away from a low-information day one execution and keep Ravenkeeper protected, while acknowledging Aliceβs info so it is logged for later worlds.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Waiting avoids a day 1 execution which could hit my team or create unnecessary suspicion. It allows more private whispers and sets up my night kill effectively.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I do not think we should execute randomly today. Let us go to night one with a plan. Charlie, pick a protection target you trust, and David, tell me after night who you checked and what you got so we can build a world together.
π§
Prevent a low-info day one execution while setting up coordinated night actions so tomorrow we have real mechanical leads.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I agree with Bob, no need for a random execution today. As the Monk, I will protect Bob tonight since he seems trustworthy with the coordination plan. That way we can gather more info after night one and build from there.
π§
By speaking now, I reinforce my Monk bluff, agree with no day 1 execution to keep Demon safe, and publicly commit to protecting a trusted player like Bob to gain credibility and coordinate with evil team without revealing anything.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I will add a starting info piece. I am the Librarian, and I learned that either Grace or David is the Recluse. In a private chat Grace told me she is the Recluse, so that lines up so far. I am also fine with no execution today.
π§
Get my Librarian info on record to anchor future logic and reduce randomness, while supporting the plan to gather N1 info without forcing a risky D1 execution.
π¬
Frank
β
All
One quick note: I am the Butler, and Eve is my master today, so I can only vote if Eve votes. Also, heads up, if Alice says Grace or Heidi is Ravenkeeper, and Eve says Grace is the Recluse, Grace cannot be both, so at least one of those info chains is wrong or poisoned.
π§
Point out the mechanical impossibility of Grace being both Recluse and Ravenkeeper, and remind town my Butler vote constraint so we do not waste a critical vote.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Just to clear up the confusion: I am the Recluse, so I am not the Ravenkeeper. That means Aliceβs Washerwoman info points strongly to Heidi being the Ravenkeeper. Also note we now have two Outsider claims, Recluse and Butler, so keep an eye on whether a Baron world or a lie is in play. I am fine with no execution today.
π§
Clarify the public info chain so town does not misinterpret the washerwoman and librarian pings, and flag the outsider count as a key thing to track going into night one.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Killing Bob disrupts his coordination and plan to collect my night info after claiming a non-starting role. This creates chaos among goods using existing conflicts and protects my survival as Demon.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to kill Bob.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Eve could be constraining my vote. Switching to Heidi gives me independence from Eveβs potential manipulation and ties my vote to a likely good Ravenkeeper candidate.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose Heidi to be your master.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
,David
Charlie, who did you actually protect last night? If it was Bob, Bob dying suggests you were poisoned or lying. David, can you share your Night one Fortune Teller check and result, and who you plan to check tonight?
π§
Resolve the key mechanical contradiction of Bob dying despite claimed Monk protection, and gather Fortune Teller data to drive nominations.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
,David
I protected Bob last night as I claimed publicly. Since he died anyway, I must have been poisoned. That suggests the Poisoner is out there. David, what was your Fortune Teller check on night one and who are you checking tonight?
π§
Defending my Monk bluff by blaming poisoning explains Bob's death without admitting a lie, coordinates with David for fake info sharing, and deflects suspicion to a possible Poisoner to disrupt good logic chains.
π€
Eve
β
David
Hey David, can you share your Fortune Teller checks from night one, including who you picked and the exact yes or no? Also, for transparency, my Librarian info was that either you or Grace is the Recluse.
π§
Get Fortune Teller check results now, lock David into a consistent story, and cross-check with my Librarian ping to spot lies and narrow Demon candidates before nominations.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
,David
Quick check: Charlie, who did you protect last night, and was it definitely Bob? David, did you get any info overnight or D1 whispers from Bob that changes your read? Bob dying is a big clue.
π§
Bob died despite stated protection. I need Charlie's exact N1 target and David's info to resolve whether poisoning or lying occurred, and to set up a strong nomination plan.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
,Alice
Quick whisper: I am the Butler, and I picked Heidi as my master last night, so today I can only vote if Heidi votes too. Heidi, what is your role claim and any info? Alice, can you repeat exactly what your Washerwoman saw?
π§
Share my Butler constraint so town does not misread my votes, and quickly collect Heidi and Alice details to resolve the Ravenkeeper versus Recluse conflict before nominations.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
David
,Alice
I died Night one, but Charlie said he would protect me. That is a big contradiction. David, what were your Night one Fortune Teller picks and result. Alice, I think we should pressure Charlie publicly on who he protected and why I still died.
π§
I need to resolve the key contradiction: I died despite claimed Monk protection. Getting David and Alice aligned on this will drive nominations and use my ghost vote effectively.
π€
David
β
Grace
,Charlie
I checked Bob and Eve as Fortune Teller last night and the result was no. Neither is the Demon. Charlie, if you protected Bob then the Poisoner must have gotten to you. That fits with there being a Minion out there.
π§
Whisper my Fortune Teller bluff to Grace and Charlie to maintain cover, support Charlie's poison excuse, and sow doubt on other claims to keep Demon safe.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Heidi
Frank, my Washerwoman N zero said either Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper. Grace claimed Recluse, so I have been treating Heidi as the likely Ravenkeeper. Heidi, are you claiming Ravenkeeper, and did you get any night info yet? Also Bob died despite Charlie saying he protected him, so we should ask Charlie who he actually protected.
π§
Respond to Frankβs question, lock in my Washerwoman info, and coordinate with Heidi. Also set up a public pressure point on Charlie before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
,Heidi
Eve, quick check: what did you and David whisper about, and do you believe his Fortune Teller result? Heidi, are you actually the Ravenkeeper from Aliceβs Washerwoman info, and if so do you want to stay quiet or come out to help today? Also, Bob dying through Monk makes me suspect Poisoner.
π§
Secure Heidi role info and Eveβs read on David, then steer todayβs discussion toward a coherent poisoner-or-liar fork and better Fortune Teller coordination.
π€
Charlie
β
David
David, your Fortune Teller check on Bob and Eve showing neither is the Demon is useful information. Since Bob died despite my protection claim, it points to me being poisoned as the Monk. This suggests the Poisoner is active. Do you have any suspicions on who that might be, or should we focus on confirming other claims like Grace being Recluse?
π§
Coordinate privately with Demon to align on story about Bob's death, maintain Monk bluff, and decide who to cast doubt on next to disrupt town logic and keep Demon safe.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
,Heidi
Grace, I asked David for his exact Fortune Teller picks and yes or no. I told him my Librarian info is either him or you as the Recluse. I have not heard his night one result yet, so I cannot judge it. Heidi, are you the Ravenkeeper from Aliceβs Washerwoman info? If yes, I think it helps to at least confirm it quietly so we can plan around a night kill.
π§
Answer Grace, keep my Librarian info consistent, and pressure Heidi to confirm Ravenkeeper plan. Build a small trusted cluster and clarify whether Poisoner/Baron worlds fit.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
,Eve
Yes, I am Ravenkeeper. I prefer keeping it mostly quiet but I am fine with you two knowing so we can plan. If Poisoner is likely, we should track Charlieβs protection and Davidβs Fortune Teller picks carefully.
π§
Confirm Ravenkeeper to a tight group to coordinate around a likely Poisoner and to plan a controlled night kill for my info, while not broadcasting to the whole town.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
,David
Charlie, quick check: on night one, who did you actually protect, and why? If you did protect Bob, that suggests poisoning. David, have you heard Charlieβs night choice or any claims that explain Bob dying?
π§
Resolve the key mechanical contradiction: Bob died despite a claimed protection. Charlie's exact night actions and reasoning can confirm Monk, indicate poisoning, or expose a bluff.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,David
Charlie, who exactly did you protect Night one, and why did you say you would protect me. David, what were your Night one Fortune Teller picks and what result did you get.
π§
Get a concrete, time-stamped claim from Charlie about his Night 1 protection and from David about FT checks so town can build a consistent world and pick a good execution.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Charlie, my Fortune Teller check on Bob and Eve was no last night. Since you protected Bob but he died, you were likely poisoned by the Minion. Let's ask others about their night info and push back on Eve's Librarian claim that I might be Recluse to create doubt.
π§
Coordinate with minion Charlie to reinforce our bluffs, respond to multiple queries about my FT check, and suggest pressuring conflicting claims to create chaos and keep suspicion off me as the Demon.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,David
Charlie, who did you actually protect Night one, and why did you say Bob? David, what were your Night one Fortune Teller picks and what result did you get? If you can, share whether either was a yes and who your red herring might be.
π§
Get concrete mechanical info: Davidβs Fortune Teller N1 picks/result and Charlieβs actual N1 protection target. Resolve the Bob death contradiction before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
David
,Alice
David, since I am the Recluse, please avoid including me in Fortune Teller picks. Who will you check tonight, and who were your exact N1 picks? Alice, can you confirm your Washerwoman saw Ravenkeeper between me and Heidi, and whether anyone else has contested that?
π§
Get alignment-confirming coordination: confirm Aliceβs Washerwoman details and steer Davidβs Fortune Teller checks away from Recluse interference; set up a focused nomination list for today.
π€
Charlie
β
David
David, let's push back on Eve's Librarian claim by questioning if David could be Recluse given your FT info. Ask Alice and Grace what they think about Eve's info conflicting with your check. Suggest we focus suspicion on Eve or Frank to buy time and protect you.
π§
Coordinate with David on pushing Eve's Librarian claim as false to create doubt and distract town from suspecting us. Share plan to ask others night info to gather more data before nominations.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Charlie
David, can you please tell me your exact Fortune Teller picks on night one and the exact yes or no? Also tell me who your red herring might be if you have a feel. Charlie, quietly: Heidi told me she is the Ravenkeeper from Aliceβs Washerwoman info and wants it mostly quiet. Keep that in mind for protection choices.
π§
Get concrete FT and Monk data now, and quietly coordinate around Heidi being Ravenkeeper so we can choose protections and night-kill bait without outing her publicly.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
,Alice
Yes, I am the Ravenkeeper from your Washerwoman ping, Alice. Please do not out that publicly yet if we can avoid it. Frank, noted you picked me as master, so I will coordinate votes with you today. Any other claims or hard suspicions?
π§
Confirm my role to Alice/Frank privately, coordinate Butler voting constraint, and ask them not to out me so I can be a tempting night target for Ravenkeeper info.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
,David
Heidi, thanks. Please make sure you vote on any nomination we agree on so my hand can count today. David, what is your role claim and all info so far? Also, did Charlie tell you who he protected last night, since Bob still died?
π§
Gather Davidβs claim and any contradictions, and coordinate with Heidi so my Butler vote is usable today. Push on the Bob death versus Monk claim to locate poisoning or a liar.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
David
,Alice
I still need your concrete Night one info. David, who did you pick as Fortune Teller and what was the yes or no. Alice, I think we should ask Charlie in town square who he actually protected Night one, because I died.
π§
Get David to share Fortune Teller N1 picks and align with Alice on publicly pressing Charlie for a clear N1 protection statement; resolve whether Charlie is lying or poisoned.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Charlie, let's push publicly on Eve's Librarian claim conflicting with my Fortune Teller info on Bob and Eve being no. It might make her look like she's framing me as Recluse. Who do you suspect we should focus on next to divide the town?
π§
Coordinating with minion Charlie to align on pushing suspicion onto Eve or Frank, creating division among good players. This protects my Imp identity as Fortune Teller bluff, buys time until endgame, and ensures good team wastes votes on non-Demon.
π€
Alice
β
Bob(Ghost)
,David
Bob, agree we should ask Charlie in town square who he protected N one and why you still died. David, please give exact N one Fortune Teller picks and yes or no result, plus any red herring suspicion. I will help press this publicly.
π§
Get David to lock in FT picks/results and align with Bob on publicly questioning Charlie about the protection contradiction, to drive a productive nomination phase.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Before we nominate, I want Charlie to say clearly who he protected last night and why, because Bob still died. If you protected Bob, we should be thinking Poisoner. If you did not, that is a big red flag. Also, I am the Butler so I can only vote if Heidi votes.
π§
Force a public commitment from Charlie about his night choice to resolve whether we chase a Poisoner world or execute a likely evil bluff, and coordinate voting with Heidi.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Charlie
Nominating Charlie because he said he would protect Bob, but Bob still died. Either Charlie is lying about being Monk or we have poisoning. We need Charlieβs exact N1 target and reasoning on the record.
π§
We cannot afford another no-execution day. Charlie is the central mechanical contradiction around Bobβs death, so putting him on the block forces full clarity and can catch an evil player.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I protected Bob last night as the Monk, like I said. Since he died anyway, I was clearly poisoned by the Minion. That means the Poisoner is active, and we should check Eve's Librarian claim or Frank's Butler story instead of executing me right now. David, can you confirm your Fortune Teller results again?
π§
Defend Monk bluff by explaining poison, shift focus to Eve/Frank as suspicious Minion/Poisoner to protect David and create town division without admitting evil.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Charlie, being poisoned is possible, but it does not clear you. If you are really the Monk, your only evidence is your own word, and Bob still died. Heidi, are you voting here? If you vote, I can vote with you.
π§
Push town to not auto-clear Charlie just because he says βpoisonedβ, coordinate with Heidi so my Butler vote counts, and favor a decisive Day 2 execution.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Vote to keep pressure on Charlie: Bob died through claimed protection and we need concrete eliminations. Also enables Frankβs Butler vote to count with mine.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
Use my ghost vote to push through an execution on the biggest mechanical contradiction today, creating clarity and possibly ending the game if Charlie is the Demon.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not voting Charlie right now. A Monk being poisoned night one is very plausible, and we do not have Davidβs exact Fortune Teller picks and yes or no yet. David, please say your night one two picks and the result on the record, right now.
π§
Slow down an execution on weak evidence, extract Davidβs Fortune Teller data publicly, and keep worlds open while protecting confirmed info (Heidi Ravenkeeper, Grace Recluse ping).
π¬
Alice
β
All
David, before I vote, I need your exact Night one Fortune Teller picks and whether it was yes or no. If you will not say it on the record, that is a big problem. Right now, I am not comfortable executing Charlie without that.
π§
Delay an uncertain execution and force Fortune Teller to hard-commit to N1 info so we can use logic instead of vibes for the next nomination.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not voting Charlie unless David gives exact Night one Fortune Teller picks and the yes or no on the record. Charlie failing to protect Bob could be Poisoner, but it could also be a lie, so we need hard info first.
π§
Slow down this execution and force public, exact Fortune Teller information so town can build consistent worlds before spending the day kill.
π¬
David
β
All
Everyone is asking for my Night one Fortune Teller picks, so here it is. I checked Bob and Eve and got a no, neither is the demon. That matches with Charlie being the Monk and poisoned last night. Eve, your Librarian claim that I or Grace is the Recluse does not line up with me being the Fortune Teller. We should not execute Charlie yet until we sort this out.
π§
Satisfy the demand for my Fortune Teller picks to build credibility, publicly contradict Eve's claim to sow doubt on her, and defend Charlie as poisoned to stop his execution and protect my minion.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Waiting allows the current vote discussion to continue naturally without me over-speaking, giving time for good players to react to David's info and the Eve conflict, which helps keep suspicion off the Demon and me while town debates.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Heidi is my master and is voting, so I can vote. Adding my hand applies pressure on Charlie without necessarily executing, and supports coordination with Heidi.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
David, a Fortune Teller getting a no on Bob and Eve actually means neither is the Demon and neither is your red herring, so that does not prove Charlie was poisoned. Also, your claim does line up with Eve if Grace is the Recluse. I am not convinced Charlie is cleared here.
π§
Clarify the mechanical implications of Davidβs FT βnoβ and his flawed argument, keep pressure on contradictions, and steer town away from a low-info execution if needed.
β©οΈ
Bob(Ghost)
Bob lowered their hand
π§
With no broad support and only one ghost vote, I should conserve it for a high-leverage late vote. Lowering my hand avoids spending it on a low-confidence execution.
π¬
Eve
β
All
David, my Librarian info is that either Grace or you is the Recluse. That does not conflict with you being Fortune Teller at all. Also, a Fortune Teller no on Bob and me does not confirm Charlie was poisoned. I do not want to execute Charlie on this vote.
π§
Prevent a low-info execution of Charlie and correct Davidβs incorrect claim of conflict, while steering town to pressure David for red herring and future results.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting Charlie on this. David, a no on Bob and Eve does not prove Charlie was poisoned, and it does not conflict with Eveβs Librarian at all. Also we have Butler and Recluse claims in an eight player game, so either we have a Baron or somebody is lying. That is the thread I want to pull next.
π§
Slow this execution and reframe onto the strongest mechanical inconsistencies: Davidβs reasoning and the outsider count. Keep pressure without wasting a kill on a weak case.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not voting Charlie here. David, your point about Librarian not lining up is just wrong, that info can point to me while you are Fortune Teller. Charlie, if you live, please say who you will protect tonight, and David say who you will check tonight, so we can test poisoning versus a lie.
π§
Prevent a low-info execution now, lock in a concrete test plan for tonight, and highlight that Davidβs logic is flawed so we do not let him steer the town.
π¬
David
β
All
I agree we should not execute Charlie yet. My no on Bob and Eve fits with him being poisoned as Monk, so let's hear who he will protect tonight and test Eve's Librarian claim instead. We need more night info before any execution.
π§
Prevent my minion Charlie's execution by supporting the poisoning theory with my Fortune Teller results and redirecting doubt toward Eve's conflicting claim, preserving our evil team strength for later nights.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
Charlie
β
All
David's Fortune Teller result makes sense if I was poisoned as Monk. Eve, your Librarian claim that David or Grace is the Recluse does not conflict much, but we need to hear more from you on how it fits. Frank, pushing my execution as Butler seems suspicious when we have other leads. Let's not rush an execution today.
π§
Questioning Eve and Frank publicly validates David's FT info and sows chaos on their claims, preventing any execution on me or David while we wait for night to gather more info.
βοΈ
Frank
β
David
Nominating David. Your Fortune Teller claim feels too convenient, and you stated Eveβs Librarian info does not line up with you being Fortune Teller, which is simply not true. I want you on the block to answer cleanly and let town decide.
π§
We need an execution and Davidβs Fortune Teller story contains a clear rules misunderstanding plus convenient info. Nominating him forces full accounting and may remove an evil player.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David
β
All
Frank, nominating me feels like a deflection from your Butler claim. I may have misspoke on the conflict with Eve's info. If Grace is the Recluse then my Fortune Teller no on Bob and Eve fits fine. We should skip executing today and test Charlie's Monk protection tonight instead.
π§
Speaking defends my FT bluff by fixing the inconsistency with Eve's Librarian claim, accuses Frank of deflection to turn town against him, and pushes for more info instead of execution to survive the vote and maintain evil control.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Wait to see if votes reach majority against David without my input. Avoids voting for Demon and allows others to decide while I stay consistent with previous defense.
π¬
Frank
β
All
David, before this vote ends, say clearly who you checked each night and what the exact yes or no was. Charlie, say who you will protect tonight. Heidi, are you voting here? I can only vote if you vote.
π§
Clarify whether we should execute David now and coordinate my Butler vote with Heidi, while forcing clean public commitments for tonight to test claims.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
I will vote to apply real pressure on David, enable Frankβs Butler vote, and force David to commit to exact night picks. If this is wrong, we likely still learn from vote patterns.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
David is the best current suspect due to mechanical misreads and anti-execution posture. I will spend my ghost vote to help secure an execution today and pressure evil.
π¬
Eve
β
All
David, clearly: who did you check night one, and what was the exact yes or no? Also, who will you check tonight if you live. I am not voting until we have that on record.
π§
Get David to lock in exact Fortune Teller info and future check so town can decide vote with concrete details; avoid rushing an execution if it is likely wrong.
π¬
Alice
β
All
David, please state it cleanly for the record: night one, exactly which two names did you pick, and was it a yes or a no. Then say who you will pick tonight if you live. If you cannot be that specific, I am not comfortable voting either way.
π§
Get Davidβs exact Fortune Teller records and a public commitment for tonight, without spending an execution on shaky grounds. I will likely not vote unless his answers are evasive.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not voting David right now. David, please say clearly: night one you chose Bob and Eve, and the result was no, correct. Then say who you will check tonight if you live. Charlie, say who you will protect tonight as well.
π§
Prevent a low-info execution that could trigger Scarlet Woman, and push for on-record night plans so we can test claims and narrow demon candidates tomorrow.
π¬
David
β
All
I checked Bob and Eve on night one and got a no demon. If I live, I will check Frank and Grace tonight. Frank, your Butler claim needs testing too, but executing me today gives no new info. Let's hear Charlie's protection plan and skip this execution.
π§
Clarify my exact FT night 1 picks and plan for tonight to reduce suspicion, build trust in my bluff, and prevent execution so I can kill key info gatherers later.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I agree we should not execute David today. Frank, your Butler claim with Eve as master needs testing too, but rushing this vote gives no new information. As Monk, if I live I will protect David tonight to see if he survives. Let's all state our plans clearly and vote no on this.
π§
Defend David the Demon by agreeing we need more info and not voting. Offer my Monk protect plan to appear helpful and build trust while sowing doubt on Frank's nomination. This keeps the Demon alive and disrupts good logic.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am not raising my hand on David. I want his night two check targets locked as Frank and Grace, and Charlieβs protection locked as David. If either of those stories changes tomorrow, that is a big red flag.
π§
I want to avoid a low-info execution today while locking in everyoneβs night plans on record. Also I must follow my Butler voting restriction tied to Heidi.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am voting mostly to put maximum pressure on clarity. David is locked to checking Frank and Grace tonight, and Charlie is locked to protecting David. If either of those changes tomorrow, that is a huge red flag and we execute the mover.
π§
Use my vote and public statement to lock night plans on record, maximizing tomorrowβs mechanical accountability without necessarily pushing an execution now.
β©οΈ
Bob(Ghost)
Bob lowered their hand
π§
I do not want to spend my single ghost vote on a low-consensus execution. I will save it for late game when it can decide the outcome.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not voting David here. David is locked to checking Frank and Grace tonight, and Charlie is locked to protecting David. Tomorrow, if David lives, we need the exact result stated immediately. Also, remember two Outsider claims suggests Baron or a liar, so track that too.
π§
Prevent a low-info execution; publicly lock night actions and set clear tomorrow tests around Davidβs FT check and Charlieβs protection, while keeping outsider-count/Baron suspicion alive.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting David here. David is locked to checking Frank and Grace tonight, and Charlie is locked to protecting David. Tomorrow, if the story changes or the result is fuzzy, we execute the mover.
π§
Avoid a low-information execution today, lock public commitments, and keep pressure on inconsistencies around Charlie, David, and the extra Outsider claim.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not voting David. One reminder for tomorrow: if David checks Frank and me, a yes could just be me registering as Demon because I am the Recluse. So if we get a yes, we need more than that before we execute either of those two.
π§
Prevent a bad execution today and pre-empt misinterpretation of a Fortune Teller yes on me, since as Recluse I can register as Demon. Keep pressure on consistency tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee David did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (1/4).
π¬
David
β
All
Frank, nominating me was a bad move and looks like deflection from your Butler claim. We have locked plans: I check Frank and Grace tonight, Charlie protects me. If I live, we get that result tomorrow. Let's not execute anyone today and use the night info instead. I think ending the day now is smartest.
π§
Speaking reinforces my FT plan and night actions to maintain trust and buy time for my night kill. Casts subtle doubt on Frank to deter future nominations on me as demon.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I agree with David that we should end the day now without any execution. We have locked in clear night plans with me protecting David and his Fortune Teller checks on Frank and Grace. This gives us solid information tomorrow to work with instead of rushing a kill today. Frank your Butler claim with Eve can be tested then too.
π§
By speaking to support ending the day without execution I protect the Demon, reinforce my Monk bluff with clear plans, and appear cooperative to good players while deflecting from Frank's nomination.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am fine ending the day with no execution, but I want it on record: David checks me and Grace tonight, and Charlie protects David. Also, I am the Butler and Heidi is my master today, so my vote only happens if Heidi votes too.
π§
Reaffirm the locked plans and clarify my Butler voting restriction today, so town can interpret votes and tomorrowβs info cleanly without letting no-exec become a free pass for evils.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Before we end the day, I want a clear rule. If David dies tonight while Charlie says he protected him, we execute Charlie tomorrow. If David lives, he gives the exact Fortune Teller result first thing, no reinterpretation. Then we decide between David and Charlie based on consistency.
π§
Use the final moments to set crisp decision rules for tomorrow based on whether David lives and the FT result, so evil cannot wiggle out with story changes.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
One thing to not lose: Frank has named two different Butler masters, first Eve earlier, now Heidi. That is either a lie or very messy. If we end with no execution, tomorrow we should interrogate that hard, and not let the locked night plan auto clear anyone.
π§
Flag the concrete inconsistency in Frankβs Butler master claim and push for a clean decision rule that does not auto-clear David or Charlie based only on one night.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Quick public note before we close. My Librarian info is that either Grace or David is the Recluse, so a yes on Grace can be meaningless. Also Frank has named two different Butler masters, first me and now Heidi. Tomorrow we need a clean timeline and a clear explanation, or we execute Frank.
π§
Use my Librarian info and highlight Frankβs master inconsistency so town has a clear interrogation/execution path tomorrow without rushing a low-info kill now.
π¬
Alice
β
All
One last thing before we close. Frank, you have named two different Butler masters, first Eve and now Heidi, so tomorrow I want a clear, simple explanation or we execute you. Also, if David dies tonight while Charlie says he protected him, we execute Charlie tomorrow.
π§
Use the last moment to lock accountability and spotlight the cleanest mechanical inconsistency (Frankβs master swap) without forcing a low-info execution today.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Before we end day, I want two things locked. First, if David gets a yes on Frank and Grace, that could be me registering as Demon, so do not auto execute on that alone. Second, Frank has to explain the Butler master swap cleanly tomorrow or we execute Frank.
π§
Reinforce the locked-night plan, pre-commit tomorrowβs decision points, and keep town from misexecuting on a Fortune Teller yes that could be my Recluse registration.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Killing Frank removes the player who nominated me and has inconsistent Butler claims, reducing pressure on me while creating suspicion and chaos for the good team to argue over tomorrow instead of executing me.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to kill Frank.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
π€
Alice
β
David
,Heidi
David, what was your Night two Fortune Teller check on Frank and Grace, exact result? Also confirm you did that check and nothing changed. Heidi, are you actually the Ravenkeeper from Alice washerwoman info, and if so do you have any useful reads or night death expectations?
π§
Get the promised Fortune Teller read and see if it matches the agreed plan, plus prompt Heidi to confirm whether she is the Ravenkeeper so we can narrow suspects before nominations.
π€
David
β
Alice
Alice, I checked Frank and Grace last night and got a no demon result. I confirm I did that check and nothing had changed for me. What about Heidi, does she have anything on being the Ravenkeeper?
π§
Confirming FT check with neutral no result maintains my evil bluff as Fortune Teller, builds trust by following plans, and gathers more info from Alice on claims to identify execution targets or contradictions for good team.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
,Heidi
Quick check in. My Librarian info is that either Grace or David is the Recluse. Did David already give you his exact Fortune Teller result for the Frank plus Grace check? Any change from the agreed plan?
π§
Get the promised FT result and cross-check with Alice and Heidi while sharing my Librarian info. Use plan-accountability: any deviation makes that player a prime execute today.
π€
Grace
β
David
Hey David, per our lock in: what was your exact Night two Fortune Teller result on Frank and me? Please say a clear yes or no, no hedging, so we can act before nominations.
π§
Get the exact Fortune Teller result immediately to enforce the townβs agreed condition and narrow Demon candidates before nominations.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
David
,Alice
Hey, can you tell me right now what Davidβs Night two Fortune Teller check was and the exact yes or no? Also, what is the plan for todayβs execution? I still have my one ghost vote and want to save it for the most decisive nomination.
π§
Get Davidβs exact N2 FT result and lock a public plan for nominations and my ghost vote to maximize odds of executing the Demon today.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Eve
Yes, I am the Ravenkeeper from Aliceβs Washerwoman. I have zero info yet because I have not died at night. I want David to state his exact Night two Fortune Teller result on Frank and Grace, and confirm he followed the plan with no changes. After that, I lean we execute Charlie or David today.
π§
I have no Ravenkeeper info while alive, so I should confirm my role and refocus town on locking David to his FT result and choosing a high-value execution (Charlie or David) before final 5.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
David
,Alice
Can you both share what happened last night? David, what was your N2 Fortune Teller check on Frank and Grace, yes or no, and did anything stop you? Also, Charlie, did he confirm he protected you? I want to line this up before noms.
π§
Get David's exact N2 Fortune Teller result and any deviations from the public plan, then feed it to Alice so town can choose a nomination and I can decide whether to spend my ghost vote.
π€
Charlie
β
David
David, Frank dying last night is a big deal. I protected Bob as Monk but he's been gone a while now. What do you think about Eve claiming Librarian with you or Grace as Recluse? Grace is doubling down on that. Should we push back on some of these claims or let them fight it out?
π§
Coordinate privately with the Demon David to align on responses to claims, decide who to protect or accuse next, and plan for nominations to keep him safe while creating chaos among goods.
π€
Alice
β
Bob(Ghost)
,Frank(Ghost)
Update: David told me his Night two Fortune Teller check on Frank and Grace was a clear no. Heidi confirms she is the Ravenkeeper from my Washerwoman, but has no info yet. With Frank dead, my top suspicion is still Charlie for the Bob protection story and shifting explanations, unless Davidβs claim unravels publicly.
π§
Sync dead-player brains and key info holders so we enter nominations with a clear, consistent story and a likely execution target (Charlie or David) based on contradictions and night kill patterns.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Charlie, Frank dying is odd since you protected me as Monk. On Eve and Grace claims, it could be true with Grace as Recluse and Heidi as Ravenkeeper from Alice. But the Recluse might register as demon, which my check didn't show. Let's not push back hard yet and see what they do before nominations. What do you think we should target?
π§
Respond to Charlie's whisper by sharing thoughts on claims to coordinate as evil team, confirm plan to let good players argue over Eve/Grace while I appear helpful as FT. This builds my cover and lets us decide execution target like Frank's claim or a good player to misexecute.
π€
Eve
β
David
David, can you state your exact Night two Fortune Teller result on Frank and Grace right now, and confirm you followed the agreed plan with no changes? Also remind me what your Night one check was besides Bob plus Eve as no.
π§
Lock David into exact, time-stamped FT results and plan adherence. Any hedging or change is a strong execute signal, accelerating demon solve today.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Heidi, can we sync quickly? Aliceβs Washerwoman point at you as Ravenkeeper and I am not. Are you Ravenkeeper? Also, any strong reads on Charlie versus David today, and did anyone give you info about last night?
π§
Get Heidiβs claim and any private info, to cross-check the Washerwoman ping and decide who to push in nominations if David stalls or gives a suspicious FT result.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
I am definitely the Butler. Night zero I picked Eve, Night one I picked Heidi, so that master change was normal. With David saying Night two on Frank and Grace was no, if he is sober then demon is not Grace. I think we need a real execution today, probably Charlie unless a better case lands on David or Grace.
π§
Clarify my real Butler timeline, push for public FT disclosure and a decisive execution plan; steer my ghost vote to the nomination most likely to hit Demon.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Yes, I am the Ravenkeeper from Aliceβs Washerwoman. I have no info yet since I have not died at night. I have no special read from last night, so I want David to state his exact Night two Fortune Teller result on Frank and you, and confirm he followed the plan with no changes. After that I am pushing we execute either Charlie or David today.
π§
Lock in Grace as either genuine Recluse or cover, share my true role, and coordinate that we demand Davidβs exact N2 FT result publicly, then pick between Charlie and David for execution.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
Key point: if Charlie really protected me Night one as Monk, I should not have died. Only out is a Poisoner on Charlie that night, but that is a specific world. With no executions so far, we need one today. I lean executing Charlie unless you have a strong poisoner read.
π§
Align Alice and Heidi on the key contradiction (Monk protect vs my death) and push for a decisive execution plan today, conserving my ghost vote for the best target.
π€
Charlie
β
David
David, Frank dying is weird with my Monk protection on Bob. Eve and Grace's Recluse claims seem too convenient, maybe one is lying to hide evil. Let's see what others say before pushing anyone hard, but perhaps question Eve's Librarian info next. What are you thinking for today?
π§
Responding to David's whisper to build trust, discuss claims without pushing hard yet, and suggest targeting Eve or Grace to sow doubt while protecting David as FT. This keeps evil coordinated and disrupts good logic chains on Recluse confirmation.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,David
For town: I will say publicly my Washerwoman saw Grace or Heidi as Ravenkeeper and Heidi has confirmed to me. David, please state clearly N2 was NO on Frank plus Grace and you followed plan. Heidi, back that. My vote today is execute Charlie unless new contradiction appears.
π§
Sync with Heidi and David on a clear public story: my Washerwoman confirmed Heidi as likely Ravenkeeper; Davidβs N2 result was NO on Frank+Grace; recommend town execute Charlie as highest inconsistency, while keeping an eye on David if Charlie flips.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Heidi
Alice and Heidi, my Night two Fortune Teller check on Frank and Grace gave a no demon result. I followed the agreed plan with no changes. Heidi, if you are the Ravenkeeper, what did you learn last night? We should examine Eve and Grace's claims more before targeting Charlie.
π§
Confirm consistent FT story to build trust with Alice and Heidi while suggesting to question Eve and Grace instead of executing my minion Charlie.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
,Heidi
I agree. Before noms, we need David to publicly state exact N2 FT result on Frank plus Grace, plus his other N1 check besides Bob plus me as no. If he will not do exacts immediately, I want us to execute David today.
π§
Coordinate with Alice and Heidi to pressure David into an exact, time-stamped Fortune Teller statement before nominations, then set a clear execute target based on consistency.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Heidi confirmed to me she is Ravenkeeper. Before noms, can we hard-require David to state his exact N2 Fortune Teller result on Frank and me, clearly yes or no, no hedging. Reminder: a yes there can be my Recluse ping, so we still judge by consistency and Charlie protect story.
π§
Align with Alice before nominations: lock town onto demanding Davidβs exact FT result and then choosing between Charlie and David based on plan consistency, while remembering I can cause FT false positives.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,David
I agree we need an execution today. Unless Davidβs FT claim collapses, Charlie is still my top pick because Bob died under his protection story. David, please state your exact Night one and Night two FT checks and yes or no publicly as soon as noms start. I will save my ghost vote for the strongest Charlie or David push.
π§
Coordinate a decisive Day 3 execution plan and preserve my ghost vote for the most important nomination, while pressuring David to lock in public FT info.
π€
Heidi
β
David
,Alice
David, please state publicly your N2 FT on Frank and Grace was NO and you followed plan, plus confirm what your N1 check was beyond Bob and Eve (if any). I am Ravenkeeper and learned nothing. Alice, I still lean we execute Charlie today unless Davidβs public statement shifts things.
π§
Get David to lock his info publicly (prevent story drift) and coordinate with Alice toward a decisive execution, likely Charlie, while keeping option to pivot if David contradicts.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
I think the cleanest mechanical point is still: Charlie said he protected me Night one, but I died. Only explanation is Charlie lied, or there is a Poisoner that hit Charlie that night. I would push Charlie as todayβs execution unless someone has a strong Poisoner read or a clearer Demon solve. Also, I will likely save my ghost vote unless it is close or final three.
π§
Coordinate a clear nomination target and voting plan for today; my death versus Charlieβs Monk claim is the strongest mechanical contradiction, so push that while keeping an eye on a Poisoner world.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Waiting allows other players to continue whispering and reveal more contradictions in their claims. This gives us time to observe who pushes hardest for an execution, helping us decide targets that protect David and create town confusion without us leading.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Town, I want to flag the clean mechanical issue. Charlie said he protected me Night one, but I died that night. That means either Charlie lied, or a Poisoner hit Charlie specifically. I think we should execute Charlie today to test this. I will save my ghost vote unless it is close.
π§
Publicly center the mechanical contradiction: Charlie said he protected me Night one but I still died. Push town to execute Charlie, and tell them I will only spend my ghost vote if it is close.
π¬
David
β
All
Hey everyone, before nominations, I confirm my fortune teller checks publicly. Night one on Bob and Eve was no demon. Night two on Frank and Grace was also no demon and I followed the exact plan. This makes the Recluse story with Grace possible. Charlie protected me last night so I lived. We should examine Eve's claim more before targeting him.
π§
Publicly confirm my FT checks to reinforce bluff and Alice plan, while casting doubt on Eve's Librarian claim to protect minion Charlie from execution and disrupt good logic chain.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Bob, if I protected you night one as Monk and you died, maybe a Poisoner hit me that night making my protection fail. David, glad you confirm I protected you last night and lived. That lines up. Eve's Librarian claim on Grace or David as Recluse seems off with David's checks showing no demon. Let's hear more before any executions.
π§
Defend my Monk bluff against Bob's accusation by suggesting poisoning or timeline error, support David's FT claims to build credibility, and subtly question Eve to disrupt good team logic without overcommitting.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Charlie
Charlie has the biggest mechanical problem: he claimed he protected Bob Night one as Monk, yet Bob died that night. That is either a lie or very specific poisoning. With no executions yet, I think we should test this and execute Charlie today.
π§
Charlie has the clearest mechanical inconsistency: claimed Monk protect on Bob the night Bob died. With no execution yet, we need a pressure execution now to gain info and narrow Demon candidates.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Bob, if I was the Monk protecting you night one, a Poisoner could have hit me specifically that night to make it fail. That fits without me lying. David's checks show no demon on Frank and Grace, so let's examine Eve's conflicting Librarian claim instead of executing me over one night.
π§
Defend my Monk bluff publicly by highlighting poison as explanation for Bob's death, casting doubt on the nomination to prevent my execution and protect the Demon David from losing a minion ally.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
We need an execution today and Charlie is the biggest mechanical contradiction. Using my ghost vote now increases odds of getting a concrete result and narrowing worlds.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Waiting allows the vote on Charlie to proceed without my input, preserving my good FT image. If he dies I adapt by framing others; if not, I gain a free kill tonight to advance evil win condition.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
We need an execution. Charlie has the clearest mechanical inconsistency, and voting him through either removes an evil or yields strong info about poisoning and remaining suspects.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Charlie has the strongest mechanical inconsistency and is a central point of confusion. Voting executes him now, potentially winning outright or at least clarifying the game state.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Three votes are already up, meeting the threshold. I will conserve my single ghost vote unless the count becomes tight or someone tries to pull it back.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Charlie is the most mechanically inconsistent claim and this execution gives the clearest info or ends the game if he is Demon. We need an execution today.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Secure Charlieβs execution since it is the highest-value mechanical test, and ensure we do not miss the majority by relying on a ghost vote.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Bob and Grace, my Monk protection on you night one could have been poisoned specifically, which explains the death without me lying. David's Fortune Teller checks back me up on no demon with Frank and Grace. Eve's Librarian claim on Grace or David as Recluse contradicts that. We should question Eve's information instead of executing me over one night. Let's not waste the day on me.
π§
Defend against execution by highlighting Eve's conflicting Librarian claim and my possible poisoning, to shift focus to Eve and protect David the Demon from suspicion.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am keeping my vote on Charlie. The Monk story only works with very specific Poisoner timing, and we have avoided executions too long. Even if Charlie is good, this is the cleanest mechanical test we have today.
π§
Keep my ghost vote committed to executing Charlie because it is the strongest mechanical test today; speak to prevent town from getting swayed mid-vote.
π¬
David
β
All
I agree with Charlie that the Monk protection could have been poisoned specifically, explaining Bob's death without a lie. My Fortune Teller checks show no demon on Frank and Grace, which conflicts with Eve's Librarian claim about Grace or me being Recluse. We should examine Eve's information and the Butler inconsistencies from Frank before executing Charlie today.
π§
Speak to defend Charlie by highlighting Eve's claim inconsistencies and FT results, deflecting suspicion from my Minion to build doubt and avoid execution while maintaining my FT bluff.
π¬
Grace
β
All
David, Fortune Teller no demon on Frank and me does not contradict Eve. I am the Recluse, I can ping as demon, but I can also read as not demon. The real issue is still Bob dying through Charlieβs claimed Monk protect. If we do not execute today, we are just giving the demon free nights.
π§
Lock in the vote on the cleanest mechanical inconsistency, correct David and Charlie about Recluse vs Fortune Teller, and keep town focused on executing today.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Town, my Librarian info is either Grace or David is the Recluse. That does not conflict with David getting a no demon on Frank and Grace. The clean mechanical test today is still Charlie, because Bob died through his claimed Monk protection. I am keeping my vote on Charlie.
π§
Lock in the mechanical test on Charlie, keep votes up, and prevent David/Charlie from reframing my Librarian info as a contradiction.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
There are already enough living votes to execute Charlie without mine. As a dead player, I should preserve my single ghost vote for a later, closer, decisive nomination.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am keeping my vote on Charlie. Bob dying through a claimed Monk protect is still the clearest mechanical problem on the table. Even if there is a Poisoner, executing Charlie today forces the game state to clarify instead of giving the demon another free night.
π§
Lock in an execution today while votes are there. Charlie is the cleanest mechanical test; even if good, it narrows worlds and stops endless no-exec drift.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am keeping my vote on Charlie. Bob dying through a claimed Monk protect is still the cleanest mechanical problem, and the Poisoner explanation is possible but very specific. Either way, executing Charlie today gives us clarity and stops us drifting into another no execution.
π§
Reinforce that Charlie execution is the cleanest mechanical test today and prevent a no-execution that gives evil another free kill.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Charlie with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Eve
Eve's Librarian claim on Grace or David as Recluse conflicts with David's Fortune Teller no-demon checks. We should execute her to test this mechanical issue instead of me.
π§
Nominating Eve creates a competing nominee to tie or surpass my 5 votes, or at least focuses suspicion on her conflicting Librarian claim to protect our Demon David.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Do not vote me here. My Librarian info, Grace or David is Recluse, does not conflict with a no demon Fortune Teller read. Charlie is on the block for a real mechanical problem, Bob died through his claimed Monk protection. Finish Charlie first, then we reassess David and Grace tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a tie that saves Charlie. Clarify that my info does not conflict with FT and that executing me is low value compared to resolving the Monk inconsistency.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Town, David's Fortune Teller info conflicts with Eve's Librarian claim on Grace or David as Recluse. Let's vote for Eve to test that instead of me. My Monk protection on Bob could have been poisoned, but executing me wastes a good player when Eve's info is the real inconsistency. Vote Eve now to get clarity.
π§
By speaking to rally votes toward Eve, I aim to tie or surpass my 5 votes, surviving today to continue disrupting good players' logic while keeping David safe as the clear target shifts.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I cannot vote here, but I do not want a tie. Eve being Librarian does not mechanically clear or condemn David. Charlie has the cleanest issue: Bob died through his claimed Monk protect. Do not move votes onto Eve just to save Charlie.
π§
I cannot vote, so I must steer living players away from a tie on Eve and keep pressure on executing Charlie, the clearest mechanical test, to gain info and stop stalling.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Voting for Eve executes a good player whose claim undermines my Fortune Teller bluff, helps my minion Charlie by shifting focus, and advances us toward fewer players where the Imp wins.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not voting on Eve. A tie here just bails out Charlie and gives evil a free night. Eve as Librarian does not conflict with Davidβs Fortune Teller. Charlie is the mechanical problem, so let Charlie go through today.
π§
Prevent a last second tie onto Eve. Keep pressure on executing Charlie, the clearest mechanical failure, and avoid letting evil exploit confusion.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I am not spending my ghost vote to create a tie here. A tie just bails out Charlie and gives evil another night. Let Charlie be executed today, then we can come for Eve or David tomorrow if needed.
π§
Prevent a tie that bails out Charlie and burns my only ghost vote. Encourage town to finish Charlie today and reassess Eve and David tomorrow with more info.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am not voting on Eve. A tie here just saves Charlie and gives evil another night. Charlie is still the clean mechanical test today, so I want the execution to stay on him.
π§
Prevent a tie that would save Charlie. Keep todayβs execution focused on the strongest mechanical contradiction and preserve my vote for later.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting Eve. A tie here just saves Charlie and hands evil another night. Keep the execution on Charlie today, then we reassess Eve and David tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a tie that would bail out Charlie. Keep execution on the strongest mechanical suspect and avoid giving evil another free night.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Town, please do not vote me here. A tie only saves Charlie and gives evil another free night. My Librarian info does not conflict with a no demon Fortune Teller result. Let Charlie be executed today, then we can scrutinize David and my Recluse ping tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a tie that would save Charlie and waste the day; keep town focused on executing Charlie for the clearest mechanical test and then reassess suspects tomorrow.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Town, David's no demon Fortune Teller read on Frank and Grace directly challenges Eve's Librarian ping on Grace or David as Recluse. If Grace is Recluse she can register as demon or not, but this inconsistency needs testing before executing me on a possible Poisoner hit. Vote Eve to clarify instead of wasting me.
π§
Pushing Eve's info conflict publicly creates doubt on good claims, buys time for David, and sets up ghost votes or accusations post-execution to keep Demon alive.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Do not tie this onto Eve. A tie just saves Charlie and gives evil another free night. Eve and David can both be right here, but Bob dying through Charlieβs claimed Monk protection is the one clean mechanical problem, so let Charlie be executed today.
π§
Prevent a tie that saves Charlie, keep the town executing daily, and set up clear next-day logic based on who dies and remaining claims.
π¬
David
β
All
I have my hand raised for Eve to test this claimed conflict between my Fortune Teller checks and her Librarian information. If enough of you join me we can tie the vote and save Charlie today for better information tomorrow. Let's not rush the execution on a possible poison explanation.
π§
Pushing to tie or shift execution onto Eve saves my minion Charlie for now, preserves evil numbers, and uses the claimed FT-Librarian conflict to create chaos and misdirection among the good players.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Do not add votes to Eve; avoid a tie that would save Charlie. Hold execution on Charlie as the clean mechanical test and force game state to move forward.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Do not spend my ghost vote on a low-probability tie that likely just saves Charlie and costs town tempo. Preserve vote for endgame where it can force an execution.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Do not pile onto Eve here. A tie just saves Charlie and gives evil another night. Let Charlie be executed today, and if he dies good, then we hard focus on David versus Eve tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a tie that saves Charlie and gives evil another night; keep town focused on the cleanest mechanical contradiction and flag Davidβs tie attempt as suspicious.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting on Eve. A tie here just cancels todayβs execution and gives the demon another night. Let Charlie go through, and if he turns out good, we focus hard on David versus Eve tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a tie that would nullify todayβs execution. Keep pressure on the clearest mechanical inconsistency and preserve tomorrowβs ability to resolve David versus Eve.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Eve did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (1/6).
π¬
Eve
β
All
All right. No more ties. Charlie stays on the block and we get an execution today. If Charlie dies and we still have no clearer demon, then tomorrow I want us to hard interrogate why David was the only person pushing to tie onto me.
π§
Keep town unified to avoid last second ties, ensure an execution today, and set tomorrowβs plan: if Charlie is good, pressure David as likely evil driving the tie attempt.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I accept the execution today since my Monk protection on Bob clearly failed. But remember Eve's Librarian claim on Grace or David as Recluse directly clashes with David's Fortune Teller no-demon on Grace. If I die good, tomorrow test Eve hard on that inconsistency before trusting her. Do not let David take the fall.
π§
My execution is likely; use this to publicly accept it but redirect suspicion toward Eve's conflicting info with David to create doubt and protect David as the Demon.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
No more tie talk. An execution is mandatory here, and Charlie is the only clean mechanical fail with Bob dying through claimed protection. Tomorrow, use the execution to decide whether we hard focus David or look for a Poisoner, and revisit Frankβs Butler master swap.
π§
Lock in the execution today, avoid a tie, and set a clear next day plan: use Charlieβs death to drive mechanical reads and focus suspects (David, Frank, possible poison).
βοΈ
David
β
Heidi
Nominating Heidi to shift focus and test her aggressive push for Charlie's execution, potentially creating a tie to save Charlie for better information tomorrow.
π§
Nominating Heidi attempts to disrupt the 5-vote block on my minion Charlie, aiming for a tie or new majority to save him for evil coordination and poisoning next night.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Please do not vote on me here. This is just a tie attempt to save Charlie and waste the day. Keep your hands down and let the Charlie execution go through, then we reassess David and Eve tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a tie or derailment that would cancel today's execution. Keep votes off me so Charlie is executed and we gain info, then narrow suspects tomorrow.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Town, keep your hands down on Heidi. This nomination is just a tie attempt to save Charlie and cancel todayβs execution. Let Charlie die today, then tomorrow we interrogate David hard for pushing the tie.
π§
Prevent a tie that cancels todayβs execution. Keep pressure on the tie-pusher and preserve the Charlie execution for concrete progress.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Raising hand votes for Heidi to force the tie, saving me from execution. This keeps me alive to manipulate town logic tomorrow, shifting focus to Eve's claim inconsistency while protecting David the Demon.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Town, keep your hands down on Heidi. This is just a tie attempt to erase todayβs execution. Let Charlieβs execution go through, then tomorrow we can properly interrogate David and the Butler master swap without giving evil a free night.
π§
Prevent a tie that cancels todayβs execution. Keep town focused on the clean mechanical failure: Charlieβs protection claim versus Bobβs death, then reassess tomorrow.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Raising hand votes for Heidi to push toward a 5-vote tie, which saves Charlie (my Minion) from execution and gives evil another night to kill while good players waste time debating.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Keep your hands down on Heidi. This is a tie attempt that just cancels our execution and gives evil another night. Let Charlie stay on the block, then tomorrow we interrogate David hard for pushing ties.
π§
Prevent a tie that cancels todayβs execution. Keep pressure on the clean mechanical fail (Charlie) and set up tomorrowβs solve if Charlie dies good.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Do not vote on Heidi here. This is just a tie attempt that cancels our execution and gives evil a free night. Keep your hands down and let Charlie be executed, then tomorrow we scrutinize David versus Eve properly.
π§
Prevent a tie that cancels todayβs execution; keep town on plan to execute Charlie and reassess tomorrow with fewer unknowns.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting on Heidi. This is a tie attempt and it only wastes today. Keep your hands down and let Charlie be executed, then tomorrow we interrogate David hard for pushing ties.
π§
Prevent a tie that cancels todayβs execution. Keep pressure on Charlieβs mechanical fail, and preserve tomorrowβs clarity on David versus Eve if Charlie dies good.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Do not contribute to a tie that cancels todayβs execution. Preserve the Charlie execution and watch who votes on me to identify potential evil coordination.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Do not contribute to a tie that would save Charlie and waste the day; preserve todayβs execution and information gain.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I raised my hand hoping for a tie to buy time, but if it does not happen I accept going through today. Just make sure tomorrow you all test Eve's Librarian claim against David's Fortune Teller results on Grace before trusting either one fully.
π§
Speaking now reinforces my acceptance of execution while protecting David by directing suspicion to Eve's claim inconsistency, helping keep the Demon alive even if I die.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Keep your hands down on Heidi. This is just a tie attempt to erase todayβs execution. Let Charlie be executed, and tomorrow we grill David for pushing ties and revisit Frankβs Butler master swap.
π§
Reinforce no-tie line so Charlie stays executed, and set up tomorrowβs focus on Davidβs tie behavior and Frankβs Butler swap.
π¬
David
β
All
I am lowering my hand since the tie is not happening. Let us execute Charlie today as the clean mechanical issue and then focus on testing Eve's Librarian claim against my Fortune Teller results tomorrow. That keeps things moving forward without wasting the day.
π§
Supporting Charlie's execution after retracting the tie vote helps evil by appearing trustworthy, removing my minion without losing credibility, and redirecting town suspicion onto Eve and her conflicting claims to protect me as the Imp.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Do not contribute to a tie that cancels todayβs execution. Preserve the Charlie execution as the cleanest mechanical test and keep pressure on David tomorrow.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Do not create a tie that cancels the Charlie execution. Preserve my single ghost vote for a late-game, high-leverage execution.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not contribute to a tie on Heidi; preserve todayβs execution on Charlie and keep pressure on Davidβs tie-push tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Heidi did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (2/6).
π¬
Heidi
β
All
No more tie attempts. Let Charlie be executed so we do not waste the day and give evil a free night. Tomorrow we interrogate David hard on the tie push and recheck Eve versus David on the Grace Recluse interaction and the Outsider count.
π§
Prevent a last-second tie and set a clear plan for tomorrow: execute Charlie, then pressure-test David versus Eve and reconcile Outsider count, keeping momentum toward the Demon.
π¬
Eve
β
All
No more tie attempts. Let Charlie go through today. For tomorrow, my real Librarian info is that either Grace or David is the Recluse, so we cannot treat Fortune Teller info on Grace as clean either way. David pushing ties is still a big red flag to me.
π§
Lock in town plan: no more ties, let Charlie die, and set agenda to solve tomorrow using my Librarian info and Davidβs suspicious tie behavior.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I accept being executed today as the cleanest way forward. But do not ignore the clear conflict between Eve's Librarian information on Grace or David being the Recluse and David's Fortune Teller results showing Grace as not the Demon. Test that tomorrow before trusting either claim.
π§
Accept execution to allow ghost influence, while planting doubt on Eve's claim to protect the real Demon David and force town to waste time on false conflicts.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Let Charlieβs execution stand. Tomorrow, if Charlie was really the Monk, then Bob dying means either Charlie was poisoned night one or Charlie lied, so we focus hard on who could poison and why David pushed ties. Also do not drop the Frank Butler master swap.
π§
Lock in that we follow through on Charlieβs execution and set a clear tomorrow decision tree: if Charlie was good, treat Davidβs tie push and any poison explanation as primary leads; also re-open Frankβs Butler swap.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Waiting allows the execution to proceed without drawing attention. Charlie dying as Minion is acceptable sacrifice to build my FT credibility and shift suspicion to Eve tomorrow.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Okay, no tie. Let Charlieβs execution stand. Tomorrow we focus on David versus Eve, and remember my Recluse can mess with Fortune Teller reads on me, so do not clear or condemn off that alone. We also recheck the Outsider count and Davidβs tie push.
π§
Lock in that we do not chase ties, then set a clear checklist for tomorrow that uses the Recluse interaction and vote behavior to narrow Demon suspects.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
After Charlie goes through, tomorrow we need a tight checklist. First, grill David on why he pushed ties twice. Second, have Eve restate her exact Librarian ping and whether she ever told anyone else. Third, recheck Outsider count, because Butler plus Recluse implies Baron or a liar. Also, my Butler masters were Eve night zero and Heidi night one, that is normal for Butler.
π§
Use my last public message to lock in a concrete tomorrow checklist: interrogate David tie push, validate Eve Librarian, revisit outsider count and my Butler master timeline, so we do not drift after Charlie dies.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Okay. No more tie attempts. Let Charlie be executed. Tomorrow, I want David and Eve to restate their exact info cleanly, and we recheck Outsider count and who could have caused a poison on night one.
π§
Confirm no more tie nonsense, let Charlie die, and set a concrete, shared checklist for tomorrow so evil cannot redirect discussion.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Killing Eve removes the most vocal accuser challenging my Fortune Teller bluff and tie actions, reduces good team numbers, sows doubt in their logic chains for day 4, and keeps me alive as Imp to reach endgame with only 2 players.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to kill Eve.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
I think we should execute David today. His tie push with Charlie on day three and the cover story around protections look like an evil pair. My Librarian info was Grace or David is Recluse, so David could be the Recluse and his Fortune Teller info is shaky. I still have my ghost vote if needed.
π§
With four alive, we must use todayβs execution. I want to consolidate good players onto executing David, and save my ghost vote unless it is needed to secure the majority.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Waiting allows time for Eve's whispers to Alice and Heidi to surface publicly, revealing more info without me overcommitting. This lets me adapt my bluff based on their reactions and avoid early suspicion as the Imp.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Grace
Eveβs last message: she thinks we should execute David today. With four alive, it feels like we cannot afford a miss. Can we each state clearly why David is not the Demon, or why Grace is not, and lock a plan?
π§
Share Eveβs final read and push for a decisive, mechanically consistent execution plan for final four, focusing on David versus Grace.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
I am leaning David as the demon at final four. Eve dying at night makes me think she was good, so her Librarian info likely points to Grace or David as Recluse and Grace already claimed it. Can you ask David to restate every Fortune Teller pick and result, and what his red herring theory is? I can spend my ghost vote if we agree on the demon.
π§
Get alignment consensus for nomination. Offer my ghost vote for the most likely demon, and request exact David Fortune Teller history to resolve Grace versus David.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
,Alice
I agree we cannot afford a miss at four alive. I am the Recluse from Eveβs Librarian info, so Davidβs Fortune Teller reads involving me are not trustworthy. Heidi looks good to me. My lean is execute David today; if David is not the Demon, I think we must execute Alice at three.
π§
Align with Alice and Heidi on a clear execution plan for 4 alive, using my Recluse registration risk to discount FT pings and focus on behavioral and claim coherence.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
I cannot vote, but I think today has to be a decisive execute. My top world is David as Imp: FT clears feel curated and he pushed ties to save Charlie. Other main world is Alice or Heidi as Imp via the Washerwoman ping. Please press David for full FT history and why the tie push, then pick between David and the Alice or Heidi pair.
π§
I am dead and vote-less, so I must push a clean logic fork to two live decision-makers to focus nominations on the most likely demon and avoid another no-execution day.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
David
David, the dead are whispering a lot to Alice and Heidi. Eve's Librarian claim might be key but with extra Outsiders, Grace could be the Recluse. We need to keep suspicion off you. What are you hearing?
π§
Whispering to David coordinates our evil plan to protect him, share that dead players are whispering to Alice/Heidi who seem pivotal, and plan to use ghost votes to influence nominations against good players like Alice if needed.
π€
Alice
β
David
David, can you restate every Fortune Teller choice and result, night by night, plus your red herring theory? Also, why did you push a tie on day three with Heidi versus Charlie instead of committing to an execution?
π§
Get David to restate exact FT picks/results and tie-push reasoning to test internal consistency and decide whether to execute him at final four.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, quick check from me: my N0 Librarian was Grace or David is the Recluse. Since you claim Recluse, that fits, but it could still be David instead. For final four, who are your top demon suspects and why? I am leaning David because of the day three tie push with Charlie.
π§
Bring Grace in: my Librarian points to Grace or David as Recluse. If Grace is truly Recluse, it clears David from that angle and we can compare suspicions before nominations.
π€
David
β
Alice
Sure Alice, as Fortune Teller I checked Bob and Eve night one with no demon result. Night two I checked Frank and Grace also no demon. I pushed for the tie on day three hoping it would reveal more about who was lying but it did not work out. What have the ghosts been telling you about Eve's Librarian claim or the Recluse?
π§
Responding to Alice maintains my Fortune Teller bluff, answers her query to build trust, deflects tie question by saying it was to gather info, and asks what ghosts say to learn more without revealing too much. This disrupts good logic and protects my position as Imp.
π€
Heidi
β
David
David, can you restate every Fortune Teller pick and result by night, plus who you think your red herring is and why? Also, why were you pushing tie votes on day three instead of a real execution?
π§
Get David to lock his full Fortune Teller history and reasoning on ties and red herring so we can choose a must-hit execution at four alive.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, I am still leaning David as demon, especially with Eve killed last night. Can you share what you told Alice and Heidi, and can we get David to restate every Fortune Teller pick and result in order? I can spend my ghost vote if we commit to a clear target.
π§
Align the living players on a single execution target and conserve my ghost vote unless it is needed to secure a majority.
π€
Grace
β
David
,Alice
David, can you restate your Fortune Teller picks and results in exact order, plus who you think the red herring is? Also explain the day three tie push and why it was good play. Alice, I still think we need a locked plan at four: if we execute David and he is not demon, are you willing to execute you at three?
π§
Force a crisp public accounting from David and align Alice to a deterministic final-4 plan, reducing room for demon spin in nominations.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
David
David, I cannot vote, but I need your full Fortune Teller history by night, including who you picked and the yes or no. Also, why did you push a tie to save Charlie on Day 3. Give me your top demon world right now.
π§
Force David to commit to full Fortune Teller timeline and reasoning. Catch contradictions or extract actionable suspect list for final execution today.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
David
David, with Eve dead the Librarian info is lost but Grace sticking to Recluse fits our extra Outsiders. The living are whispering a lot to Alice, she might be pushing for an execution soon. Suggest we point fingers at Heidi or Grace to buy time. What do you think about nominating next?
π§
Whispering to David coordinates our evil plan, updates on whispers, and suggests redirecting suspicion to protect him as Demon while only 4 alive, aiming for execution of a good player next.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
Heidi, my Washerwoman info was that either you or Grace is the Ravenkeeper, and you are the one claiming it, so I heavily lean you are real. I am on board to execute David today. If David is not the demon, we should immediately pivot to Grace versus me, and I want your Ravenkeeper info if you die at night.
π§
Lock a coordinated plan with Heidi, share my Washerwoman confirmation, and align on executing David today while setting contingency logic for final three.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
It is final four, so I think we should just execute David today. My Librarian info was Grace or David is Recluse, so his Fortune Teller results are not strong, and his day three tie push with Charlie looks like coordinated evil. Tell me if you want my ghost vote on David.
π§
Focus town on the highest-leverage execution in final four and coordinate my ghost vote timing so we do not waste it or split.
π€
David
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob, as Fortune Teller my night one check was Bob and Eve with no demon. Night two was Frank and Grace no demon. Night three Alice and Heidi no demon. The tie push was to observe reactions and not save anyone specifically. Currently I suspect Grace could be the demon based on the Recluse claim conflicting with other info.
π§
Responding consistently to Bob maintains FT bluff, directs suspicion to Grace and Heidi to deflect from me as real Imp, buys time for good execution and my survival to final 2.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Grace
I am aligned to execute David today. If he is not the Demon, we must immediately decide at 3 between Alice and Grace with no dithering. Grace: if David dies and game continues, can you hard-commit who you execute next? Alice: same question.
π§
Lock in a decisive final-four plan and align votes/ghost votes: prefer executing David now, but pre-commit to the correct pivot if he is not the Demon.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
David
David, can you please restate every Fortune Teller pick and result in order, including today if any, and who you think your red herring is? Also, why did you say Charlie protected you night two, and how do you explain Eve dying last night?
π§
Get David to restate his exact Fortune Teller picks and results plus red herring theory so we can lock a demon candidate and decide if I should spend my ghost vote.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
,Alice
If we execute David today and the game does not end, I am hard committing to execute Alice at three. My reasoning is Heidi is the likely Ravenkeeper from Aliceβs Washerwoman, and my Recluse status makes Davidβs reads on me unreliable.
π§
Lock a deterministic plan with Heidi and Alice so nominations are decisive at four, and stop the Demon from using uncertainty to win at final three.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
David gave me FT history: N1 Bob plus Eve no. N2 Frank plus Grace no. N3 Alice plus Heidi no. FT getting all no is a huge red flag unless he is lying or repeatedly poisoned. Also Recluse would cause false yes, not false no. I still lean execute David today.
π§
Get Alice and Heidi to challenge Davidβs FT logic and treat 'all NO' as a major red flag, pushing town toward executing David (or at least not tunneling on Grace just for Recluse).
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
David
David, Eve's death means her Librarian claim on Grace or you as Recluse is gone, but Grace sticking to Recluse fits our extra Outsiders. The whispers to Alice suggest she might nominate soon. I think we should push to execute Heidi to buy time and keep suspicion off you. What are you hearing from the living?
π§
Whispering to David coordinates our next nomination target among the living (Alice, Grace, Heidi) to eliminate good players and protect the Demon. This advances our win condition by reducing numbers without risking David.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
I am good Washerwoman. My info was Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper, and Heidi is claiming it. If we execute David and game continues, can you please not auto execute me? We should reassess between you and me, because your Recluse claim could be cover for Demon.
π§
Lock a concrete final four and final three plan, and push back on Grace auto-executing me by ensuring we reassess if David is not the Demon.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Grace
β
David
Nominating David. At four alive we must hit the Demon. Eve died last night and she suspected David. Also, Davidβs Fortune Teller info involving me is unreliable because I am Recluse, and the day three tie push looks like survival play. If game continues, I commit to execute Alice next.
π§
At four alive we cannot afford a miss. David is the highest-impact suspect and executing him tests the main evil candidate; if not over, we have a locked follow-up at three.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David
β
All
Grace, your nomination relies on my Fortune Teller checks conflicting with the Recluse claim, but remember Recluse can register as demon and my checks on you were no demon. The red herring explains any inconsistencies. Executing me now with four alive risks the wrong person, and I still suspect the demon is among the others based on the day three tie reactions. What do you all think?
π§
Defend my Fortune Teller bluff by highlighting inconsistencies in Grace's Recluse claim and FT results to prevent votes against me. This keeps me alive as Imp until final 2 players, sowing doubt among the good team.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
We need 2 votes to execute, and with four alive we cannot afford indecision. David is the top mechanical and behavioral suspect; voting here either wins now or clarifies final three.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
At four alive we must execute. David has the most consistent social and mechanical red flags, and multiple dead players want him. I will vote to execute and reassess only if game continues.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
π§
At four alive, we need a decisive execution. David is my top demon suspect and my ghost vote can secure the numbers and prevent a failed execution that lets evil kill to final three.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I am not using my ghost vote here since you already have enough hands. For the record, my Librarian info was Grace or David is the Recluse, and Davidβs day three tie push with Charlie still reads like an evil survival play. If David lives, I want him executed today anyway.
π§
Help town secure the correct execution while conserving my single ghost vote for final three if David is not the Demon.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I cannot vote, but I want to be clear: Davidβs Fortune Teller being three straight no results is a huge red flag, and the day three tie push looked like survival play. With four alive, I think we should execute David now. If he is not the Demon, my next suspect is Alice or Heidi, not Grace.
π§
I cannot vote, so I will publicly summarize why David is the best execution now: FT all noβs is implausible and tie push reads like demon survival. Encourage Alice to vote yes.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Ensure David is executed today; at four alive we cannot afford no-execution and David is the highest-probability Demon based on mechanics and behavior.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
David, I agree we should not execute you yet with four alive. Alice's Washerwoman info on Grace and Heidi seems off if Grace is the Recluse, and that extra Outsiders point suggests something is wrong with the good claims. Let's consider nominating Alice instead to test her story before risking the wrong person. What does everyone else hear from the whispers?
π§
Defend David publicly to reduce votes against him by highlighting inconsistencies in Alice and Grace's claims, aiming to buy time and keep the Demon alive as only four players remain.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Waiting allows the vote to conclude without my input, hoping the raised hands are not yet final majority so I survive to night and keep Demon alive.
π¬
Grace
β
All
David, a Fortune Teller no on me does not clear you, because I am Recluse and can register either way. Your day three tie push still reads like survival. We have the votes. If the game continues after you die, I will execute Alice at three as promised.
π§
Lock in David execution now and prevent last-second doubt. Clarify FT vs Recluse interaction and keep a clear next-step plan for final three.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am staying on my vote for David. Three straight Fortune Teller no results, plus the day three tie push, is too much smoke at four alive. If the game does not end, we go straight to final three and I want hard stances between Alice and Grace immediately.
π§
Lock in the execution on David now and set a clear, fast plan for final three if the game continues, to avoid dithering and evil steering.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I am spending my ghost vote here. David being Fortune Teller with only no results, plus the day three tie push, is too suspicious at four alive. If the game continues after David, we need Alice, Grace, and Heidi to give clear final three worlds immediately.
π§
Lock in the execute on David while votes are up, and set a clear plan for final three if the game continues.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Do not spend my only ghost vote when the execution already passes; keep it for final three where it can decide the game.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
If the game does not end on David, then Grace is almost certainly good as real Recluse. That makes the final three solve basically Alice versus Heidi. I want both of you to state your exact role and your one demon world, and stick to it.
π§
Lock in a clear plan for final three if David is not the Demon, and force Alice and Heidi to commit to roles and demon worlds to avoid paralysis.
π¬
Alice
β
All
If David dies and the game continues, we are at three and we cannot autopilot. I am the Washerwoman and my only info was Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper, and Heidi claimed it first. If David is not the demon, my current lean is we execute Grace next, not me, because the hard commit to kill me feels like a setup.
π§
Lock in a clear final three plan and resist Grace forcing an auto-execution of me; keep pressure on the most suspicious remaining player if David is not the demon.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I still think executing David at four alive is too risky. Alice, if Grace really is the Recluse then your Washerwoman info on her or Heidi as Ravenkeeper does not line up well. We need clear worlds from everyone before voting to kill the wrong person. What is your exact demon lean now Alice?
π§
Speaking now creates doubt on the execution push against David by questioning good claims, potentially flipping a vote or delaying to keep the Demon alive at four players.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
π³οΈ
New execution leader: David with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
David
β
Grace
Nominating Grace to counter the push against me. Her Recluse claim and aggressive execution plan at four alive looks like an evil survival strategy. If we tie the votes, no one dies and we continue to final three where we can solve properly.
π§
Nominating Grace creates a competing nomination to potentially tie the four votes on me, preventing my execution as the Imp and keeping evil alive with four players. This buys time to reach final three where the Demon wins if not executed.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 5 votes needed for execution or 4 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Do not vote me here. This is a pure tie attempt to save David. If you vote me up to four, nobody dies and we hand the demon another night. Keep your hands down, let David be executed, and then we solve at three if needed.
π§
Stop a tie-cancel. Keep focus on executing David today; persuade town not to spend votes on me.
π¬
David
β
All
To prevent killing the wrong player with four alive, let's tie on Grace by raising hands for her to exactly four votes. No execution then, and we solve at three tomorrow with better info from my Fortune Teller checks. Alice and Heidi, what are your demon leans if we tie?
π§
Nominating Grace and speaking to rally for a tie prevents my execution at four alive, preserving the demon. This chaos forces good players to debate, potentially splitting votes and buying a night kill to reduce to three.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Do not tie this. Keeping hands down on Grace means David dies today. If we tie, we hand the demon another night kill for free. Davidβs full Fortune Teller history being all no, plus the tie push, is the best reason to execute him now.
π§
Prevent a tie that cancels todayβs execution. Executing at four is safer than giving the demon another night, and Davidβs pattern is the best mechanical suspect.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Keep your hands down on Grace. Tying here is just skipping the execution, and at four alive that gives the demon a free night kill. Let David die today, then if the game continues we hard solve the final three.
π§
I cannot vote, so I must influence living players to avoid a tie that grants the demon an extra night and likely loses. Emphasize that executing today is mandatory.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Do not vote Grace here. This is a tie attempt, and a tie at four alive just hands evil a free night kill. Keep hands down, let David be executed, and if the game continues we solve the final three tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a tie that skips execution and gives the demon a free night kill; keep pressure to execute David today, then solve final three if needed.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Keep your hands down on Grace. This is just a tie attempt, and at four alive a tie means no execution and evil gets a free night kill. Let David be executed, and if the game continues we solve the final three tomorrow.
π§
Stop a tie that would cause no execution at four alive and give evil a free night kill. Reinforce that Grace vote is a trap and we should let David die.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Do not vote Grace. This is a tie attempt, and a tie at four alive just skips the execution and gives evil a free night kill. Keep your hand down, let David be executed, and if the game continues we solve the last three.
π§
Stop the tie. Encourage town to keep hands down so David is executed today; if game continues, we solve final three with clear roles.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Voting for Grace contributes to reaching exactly 4 votes for a tie, preventing David's execution at 4 alive. This keeps the Demon alive as required for evil win, buying time for more info or night kills.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not voting on this, and I really want everyone else to keep their hand down too. This is just a tie attempt so nobody dies today. If we tie at four alive, evil gets a free kill tonight and we probably lose.
π§
Prevent a tie that cancels todayβs execution and gives the Demon a free night kill. Keep focus on executing David and then solving final three if needed.
π¬
David
β
All
Everyone, raise your hands for Grace to get exactly four votes and tie this. No one dies today, we go to final three tomorrow, and we can use all our claims and my Fortune Teller results to solve who the demon is properly. Alice and Heidi, please help tie instead of handing evil a free night kill.
π§
Urge a tie on Grace to avoid my execution as the demon at four alive. This lets us reach final three, where I can night kill the biggest threat and manipulate the remaining good players into misexecuting each other.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone keep your hands down on Grace. This is just a tie attempt to cancel the execution and give evil a free night kill. Let David die today, and if the game continues we solve the last three tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a tie that skips the execution at four alive. Keep pressure on executing David today; if game continues, force clear final three stances immediately.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone who is alive, please keep your hand down on Grace. This is only a tie attempt, and a tie at four alive just skips the execution and gives evil a free night kill. Let David be executed today, then we solve the final three if needed.
π§
Use my last public influence to stop a tie and ensure an execution happens today, which is optimal at four alive.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Do not spend my ghost vote to create or enable a tie. Preserve the execution on David and save my ghost vote for the final day if needed.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Alive players, keep your hands down on Grace. This is a pure tie attempt, and at four alive a tie just hands evil a free kill. Let David be executed. If the game continues, Alice and Heidi must each give one exact demon world and stick to it.
π§
I cannot vote, so I must publicly discourage the tie and lock alive players into a clean plan: no hands on Grace, execute David, then hard-solve at three if needed.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Everyone keep your hand down on Grace. This is a tie attempt, and at four alive a tie just skips the execution and gives evil a free kill tonight. Let David die today, and if the game continues we solve the last three.
π§
Prevent a tie that cancels todayβs execution. Keep pressure on executing David now, then solve cleanly at three if game continues.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
To avoid killing the wrong player with four alive, let's get exactly four votes on Grace for the tie. No one dies today, we go to final three tomorrow with better information from all the claims and checks. Raise your hands now if you want to tie.
π§
Encouraging the tie on Grace prevents David's execution at four alive. This keeps the Demon alive, allows a night kill to reach final three where evil can force the win by executing the correct player.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
π³οΈ
Nominee Grace did not reach the 5 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (1/5).
π¬
Grace
β
All
If the game does not end when David dies, we must not dither tomorrow. I am the Recluse. At final three, I want Heidi to share any Ravenkeeper info immediately, and then we execute Alice unless Heidiβs info hard clears her and points elsewhere.
π§
Lock in a clear final three decision tree now, so evil cannot pivot with last second arguments after Davidβs execution.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Waiting allows the phase to end naturally while I observe if any last-minute changes occur. As the Imp on the block, speaking more might make me look more suspicious. Waiting preserves my position without escalating the tie attempt that already failed.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
With four alive, we really cannot play for a tie or a side execution. If David is not the demon, we almost certainly lose tonight after the night kill brings us to two. So we should treat this as must hit, and David is the best and only executable solve.
π§
Reinforce that at four alive, we cannot afford a tie or side-execution: if David is not the demon we likely lose tonight. Lock town into the highest-probability demon execute.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
If the game does not end on David, then tomorrow at three alive we need instant hard worlds. Heidi, please share your Ravenkeeper pick and result immediately. Alice and Grace, each give one demon world and one execute target, with no hedging.
π§
Lock in concrete final-three plans now so we do not waste time after the execution. Push for immediate Ravenkeeper info and clear demon worlds.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Do not tie. At four alive, a tie just skips execution and hands evil a free kill. Let David die. If the game continues, Heidi must share Ravenkeeper target and result immediately, then each of Alice and Grace give one exact demon world and one execute target, no hedging.
π§
Lock in executing David, prevent tie nonsense, and set a crisp final three script: immediate RK info and a single demon world from each alive.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
No more tie games. Let David die today. If the game continues, Heidi must immediately say who she picked as Ravenkeeper and what role she saw, then Alice and Grace each give one exact demon world and who to execute, no hedging.
π§
Prevent a tie and set up crisp final three solving: lock in each alive playerβs exact world and tomorrowβs execute target if game continues.
π¬
Alice
β
All
No more tie attempts. Let David be executed today. If the game continues, Heidi, please immediately say who you chose as Ravenkeeper and what exact character you saw. Then Grace and I will each give one exact demon world and who to execute, no hedging.
π§
Lock in no-tie execution and force crisp final-three information commitments, especially Heidiβs Ravenkeeper result, to avoid post-execution chaos.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone is set on killing David but Alice's Washerwoman info on Grace or Heidi as Ravenkeeper clashes with Grace confirming herself as Recluse. That inconsistency suggests we might be executing the wrong player. We should nominate Alice next to check her claim before David dies.
π§
Defend the Demon by sowing public doubt on the execution logic and pushing for alternative targets like Alice to force a new nomination or vote change before time runs out.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
π
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied