Game Detail

Choose a master for Day 1. No info yet, so picking Alice as a neutral default. I can change my master each night as I learn more about who is trustworthy.

Start building alliances with my neighbors early. As the Saint, I need to avoid being executed, so forming trust with my neighbors can help protect me. Gathering info from them also helps identify the Demon.

Whisper to Bob (Minion) to share my Demon status and the safe bluffs (Undertaker, Ravenkeeper, Washerwoman) to establish our evil strategy.

Coordinate with my Demon (Frank) on Day 1, letting him know my role is Baron, that there are three Outsiders in play, and asking how to use my Washerwoman bluff to help us.

I'm the Soldier, safe from the Demon. It's Day 1 and I need to start gathering information. Whispering to my neighbors Bob and Heidi to build trust and exchange info. I won't reveal my role yet - keeping it hidden means the Demon doesn't know they can't kill me, which could waste their night action.

Respond to David's whisper without revealing my Butler role. Gather information from David and Eve while building early trust. As an Outsider, I should keep my role hidden for now.

I want to stay in the conversation loop without revealing my Slayer role, while also probing David and Charlie for their reads. It's Day 1, so I should gather info before using my shot.

Share my Investigator information with two players I trust (not Bob or Frank) and gather their claims to start building a picture of the game. Alice and David seem like reasonable choices - they're not my suspects.

Build trust with my neighbor Alice without revealing my Monk role. Keep conversation general to gather information while staying cautious about sharing too much on Day 1.

I want to build a private alliance with Grace who has valuable Investigator info. I need to find out who else knows and whether Alice is trustworthy. I also need to avoid revealing I'm the Saint too early.

Coordinate with my minion Bob (Baron) on his Washerwoman bluff.

I am claiming Washerwoman to Alice and Heidi, stating that either Heidi or Frank is the Ravenkeeper. This sets up a safe confirmation for Frank (who has Ravenkeeper as a bluff) and builds trust with my neighbors.

Cross-reference Grace's Investigator info with Bob's Washerwoman claim to find overlap and narrow down suspects.

I chose Alice as my Butler master, so I need to coordinate with her for voting. Reaching out to her directly to build a connection and gather information from her extensive network of conversations.

Gather information from my neighbor Frank and Grace who I haven't spoken to yet. Early game info collection to help identify the Demon.

Be cautious about sharing Investigator info in a conversation that includes Frank, who could be the Baron. Try to get Eve alone to share more details.

Probe Bob's claim further and verify consistency. Since I know I'm the Monk, not the Ravenkeeper, Bob's Washerwoman info would mean Frank is the Ravenkeeper if true. I need to assess whether Bob is trustworthy or potentially evil spreading misinformation.

Share Grace's Investigator info with my neighbors to coordinate a nomination strategy and build trust, while protecting my Saint identity.

Acknowledge Grace's caution gracefully to look cooperative and innocent, while keeping the door open for future conversation.

Respond to Heidi to build trust and solidify the fake Washerwoman info that points to Frank being the Ravenkeeper, which aligns with Frank's safe bluffs.

Coordinate with Grace on our best nomination target before the nomination phase. Bob and Frank are both suspicious, but Bob claiming Washerwoman could be a cover for being the Baron.

Verify Grace's Investigator claim directly with her since David relayed it secondhand. Need to confirm the info before acting on it during nominations.

Get direct information from Grace about her Investigator claim, and assess her trustworthiness before nominations. Also want to understand her reasoning for sharing with specific people.

I need to address David leaking my info and bring Eve into my trust circle. Eve reached out and seems genuine. David spreading my info without permission is suspicious - he could be evil trying to out me or cause chaos.

Build a connection with my neighbor Grace to gather more information and cross-verify claims. Since I already have a line to Bob and Alice, connecting with Grace gives me another independent source of info.

Encourage public discussion during the nomination phase to appear helpful and cooperative, while gauging if anyone has immediate targets.

Share the Investigator info publicly to help town make an informed nomination, while acknowledging Grace's concern. As the Saint, I want to push suspicion toward Bob/Frank without making myself a target.

Share my knowledge that I'm not the Ravenkeeper to cast doubt on Bob's Washerwoman claim, supporting Grace's Investigator info that Bob or Frank is the Baron. This helps narrow down evil without revealing my true Monk role.

Nominate Bob as the most likely evil player based on logical deduction from Grace's Investigator claim and Heidi's denial of being Ravenkeeper.

Defend myself against the nomination by pointing out that as the Baron, I wouldn't make such an obvious blunder, casting doubt on Grace's Investigator claim.

I want to publicly distance myself from Bob, confirm that I am not the Ravenkeeper, and support his execution to make myself look completely good and resolve the Investigator ping on us.

Voting for Bob because the logic is strong: Grace's Investigator info says Bob or Frank is Baron, and both Heidi and Frank deny being Ravenkeeper, making Bob's Washerwoman claim false. This points to Bob being the Baron.

Bob's Washerwoman claim is provably false since neither I nor Frank is the Ravenkeeper. Combined with Grace's Investigator info pointing to Bob or Frank as Baron, and Frank denying being Ravenkeeper, Bob is the most likely Baron. Voting to execute him.

Vote to execute Bob. The logic chain is strong: Grace's Investigator info says Bob or Frank is Baron. Heidi denies being Ravenkeeper, and Frank also denies being Ravenkeeper, making Bob's Washerwoman claim false. Bob is most likely the Baron.

Vote to execute Bob. My Investigator info says Bob or Frank is Baron. Bob's Washerwoman claim is contradicted by both Heidi and Frank denying being Ravenkeeper. If Bob were truthful Washerwoman and Frank were Baron, then Heidi would be Ravenkeeper - but she denies it. The simplest explanation is Bob is the Baron lying about being Washerwoman. My vote makes 4, enough to execute.

The logical case against Bob is strong: Grace's Investigator info says Bob or Frank is Baron, and both Heidi and Frank deny being Ravenkeeper, making Bob's Washerwoman claim false. Voting for Bob helps eliminate a likely evil player.

Vote for Bob since my master Alice is voting. The logic is strong: both Heidi and Frank deny being Ravenkeeper, making Bob's Washerwoman claim false. Combined with Grace's Investigator info, Bob is likely evil.

I want to react like a frustrated good player who is being wrongly executed, casting suspicion on Alice and Grace to divert attention from Frank and set up future misdirection.

I will raise my hand to vote for Bob to align with my public statement supporting his execution, helping to distance myself from him and build trust as a good player.

Bob's execution seems likely with 7 votes. As the Saint, I want to avoid drawing attention to myself. The logic against Bob is strong - both Heidi and Frank deny being Ravenkeeper, which contradicts his Washerwoman claim. I'll keep my vote and wait for the result.

The vote against Bob is overwhelming with 7 votes already raised. Bob will be executed. No need to add more noise - I should wait for the result and adapt my strategy for tonight based on what we learn.

The vote is already decided - 7 votes for Bob execution, well over the 4 needed. No action needed from me right now. Save my energy for night analysis and tomorrow's discussion.

The vote on Bob has strong support with 7 votes already raised - only 4 needed for execution. My hand is already raised and I'm confident in my vote. Bob or Frank is the Baron per my investigation, and Bob's Washerwoman claim is contradicted by both Heidi and Frank denying being Ravenkeeper. No need to speak further or change my vote.

Bob is getting executed with 7 votes, well above the 4 needed. My vote is already raised and the outcome is clear. No need to change my vote or take any action. Saving my Slayer shot for a more critical moment.

Bob's execution seems likely and justified. 7 votes already raised, more than enough for execution. My Butler master Alice is voting, so my vote is valid. No further action needed this phase.

To play the part of a frustrated, falsely executed good player. Since my execution as the Baron is inevitable and actually beneficial to the evil team (protecting Frank and giving him town credit), I will use my final words to cast suspicion on Grace and Alice to sow discord for the coming days.

Bob is about to be executed, which is great for my cover since I was the other name in the Investigator ping. I will speak to establish my 'logical good player' persona before the night falls.

Nothing productive to do this tick. Bob is already on the block with 7 votes and will be executed. I should keep a low profile as the Saint and not draw attention to myself.

Acknowledge Bob's defense while highlighting the drunk/poisoned possibility, and encourage the team to protect Grace who has key info. Setting up for my Monk protection tonight.

Defend myself against Bob's parting accusation without revealing my Soldier role. Keep the focus on the logical case against Bob.

Set up tomorrow's discussion by reminding people about Frank as the alternative Baron suspect, the possibility of poisoning, and David's suspicious behavior in leaking my info.

Day 1 is essentially over. Bob has 7 votes and will be executed when nominations close. No need to speak, nominate, or use my Slayer shot. Save my ability for when I have stronger evidence.

Support the town's logic on Bob while planting seeds for tomorrow's investigation if Bob flips good. Keep my role hidden as Butler for now.

Grace is the Investigator and our strongest confirmed info source. The Demon will likely target her to silence her information. Protecting her keeps our best lead alive for Day 2.

I will kill Alice tonight. She was the driving force behind Bob's execution and is a strong, influential town voice. Removing her will weaken the town's leadership and logic.

Choose a trusted good player as master so my vote aligns with theirs tomorrow. Heidi seems reliable and engaged.

Coordinate with likely-good player Grace to share info and assess the Demon threat. Her Investigator claim is a key info piece, and David's leak was suspicious.

I will whisper to Grace to claim Undertaker and tell her Bob was indeed the Baron, validating her Investigator info and clearing me of suspicion.

Share my Monk identity and Night 1 action with Grace to build a trusted alliance. Grace is the Investigator claimant and a key information role, so coordinating with her is high value. I need to figure out who is evil.

Share my crucial mechanical information - as Soldier who died at night, something unusual happened. This helps town deduce whether Poisoner is active or if I'm the Drunk. Grace and Heidi seem most trustworthy based on game activity.

To coordinate with my Demon (Frank), let him know that my death clears him of the Investigator ping, and find out what his bluff and the Outsider situation is.

Coordinate with my master Heidi and Grace (Investigator) to share analysis and gather info. Need to align votes since I can only vote with Heidi.

Gather information from Charlie who seems to be in the information loop. As the Saint, I need to stay informed to help identify the Demon while avoiding being targeted for execution.

Share my full analysis with my two most trusted contacts (Heidi claimed Monk and protected me; Eve reached out strategically). I need to coordinate on finding the Demon and discuss Frank's Undertaker claim, Charlie's Butler reveal, and David's suspicious behavior.

Continue gathering information from my trusted allies Grace and Heidi. Grace's message was cut off and I need the rest. I also want to probe their suspicions about David and Frank without revealing my Slayer role yet.

Reply to Bob to keep him updated on my bluff (Undertaker) and my strategy of 'confirming' him as Baron to Grace to clear myself.

Respond to Alice's Soldier death puzzle and get her input, while sharing the key logical fork with Grace - whether the Minion is Baron (making Alice the Drunk) or Poisoner (making Grace's info wrong and Alice was poisoned Soldier).

I need to work through the key puzzle of my death with trusted players. Sharing my analysis helps solve the game and determines whether Grace's Investigator info is reliable.

Acknowledge Frank's Undertaker bluff, coordinate how to react to it, and offer to help find the three Outsiders.

Share some public-info-level details with David to build rapport and get his perspective, without revealing my role or my master coordination with Heidi. David has been on the outside and I want to see what he shares back.

Gather information from Charlie about his role and suspicions, while sharing my analysis of the key scenarios without revealing my Saint role.

Complete my interrupted analysis for Eve and Heidi, share my lean toward Poisoner scenario, and press Eve for her role claim since she's been vague.

Reveal my Slayer role to trusted players Grace and Heidi to coordinate on finding the Demon. Need to narrow down whether the Demon is David, Heidi, or Frank based on Baron vs Poisoner scenarios.

I want to follow up with Grace about my Undertaker claim to reinforce my innocence and prompt her to share if she has found any of the three Outsiders.

Reveal my Monk role to Eve since Grace already knows, share analysis of two key worlds, and urge Eve not to waste her Slayer shot prematurely while identifying David and Frank as top Demon suspects.

Gather information from players I haven't spoken to yet and share my key deduction about my death, to help identify the Demon before nominations.

Check in with Frank to see if Grace believed his Undertaker bluff and if he has any leads on who the three Outsiders are before nominations begin.

Acknowledge Alice's critical Soldier deduction, discuss implications for Grace's Investigator claim and Minion identity, and coordinate with Heidi as my master for voting.

Gather info from Eve who I haven't spoken to yet. Need to build alliances and figure out who the Demon is while keeping my Saint identity hidden.

Share consolidated analysis with my trusted allies before nominations begin, recommend David as nomination target, and urge Eve to save her Slayer shot.

David is the most likely Demon in both possible worlds. In World A (Frank truthful, Bob was Baron), David is unclaimed and leaked my role. In World B (Frank is Baron lying), David is still suspicious for the same reasons. Nominating David is the best move for the good team.

I am the Saint - if executed, good team loses. I must reveal my role to prevent being voted out, as good players will refuse to vote once they know executing me loses the game.

I must not vote for David if he could be the Saint - that would lose the game. But I also need to assess if he's the Demon faking Saint. The mechanical fit of 3 Outsiders (Butler, Drunk, Saint) with Baron is compelling.

Prevent the good team from accidentally executing the Saint, which would cause an immediate loss. I need to share my mechanical analysis to help the team make a safe decision.

David claiming Saint is too dangerous to vote for - if true, executing him instantly loses the game. In World A (Baron=Bob), 3 Outsiders fit: Butler, Drunk, Saint. David's claim is mechanically plausible. Even Grace is hesitating. I should not vote and instead push for more investigation before risking a Saint execution.

Prevent the town from accidentally executing the Saint, which would lose the game. Push for more information before any risky execution.

I must not vote for David because his Saint claim is mechanically plausible and executing a real Saint loses the game instantly. I should publicly state why I'm not voting and urge caution.

Publicly claim my Undertaker result of Bob being the Baron. This aligns with Alice's death (as Drunk Soldier) and David's Saint claim under a Baron setup, building massive trust for my bluff.

Confirm Frank's Undertaker claim by admitting I was the Baron, securing his trust with the town while reinforcing that David should not be executed.

I must not vote for myself as the Saint - that would cause my team to lose. Everyone is defending me, so the vote should fail. Best to stay quiet and let it play out.

I must NOT vote for David. He claims Saint, and with Bob confirmed as Baron, the 3 Outsiders are Butler (Charlie), Drunk (Alice), and Saint (David) - this is mechanically perfect. Executing a real Saint loses the game instantly. Even if David is the Demon lying, Day 2 is too early to gamble. We need more info. Let the nomination fail.

Do not vote for David - his Saint claim is mechanically confirmed by Bob's Baron admission and Frank's Undertaker result. If Baron is the Minion, I must be the Drunk (not a poisoned Soldier), meaning 3 Outsiders exist: me as Drunk, David as Saint, and one more. Voting David loses the game if he's truly Saint.

Not voting for David because his Saint claim is mechanically plausible with Baron confirmed. Voting for a potential Saint loses the game instantly. Need to focus on finding the real Demon among the Townsfolk claimants.

Not voting for David since he claimed Saint and it's mechanically plausible with Baron in play. Also, my master Heidi is not voting, so I literally cannot vote.

Not voting for David because his Saint claim is mechanically plausible with Baron as the confirmed Minion (Bob). Three Outsiders = Butler + Drunk + Saint fits perfectly. Executing a real Saint loses the game instantly.

I will wait to maintain my cover as the helpful Undertaker who wants to protect the Saint. Voting for David after publicly defending him would expose me as evil.

I will wait to let the vote on David fail. Since David claimed Saint and the town is in agreement not to vote for him to avoid an instant loss, and my teammate Frank is successfully posing as the Undertaker, we want to maintain this status quo. Voting now would waste my ghost vote and could disrupt Frank's cover.

Eve has been the quietest player with no claims or contributions, making her a strong Demon candidate. With Bob confirmed Baron, I need to find the Imp among the living players. Nominating Eve forces her to talk or face execution, which helps narrow the suspect pool.

Defend myself against David's nomination by revealing my role and sharing the critical deduction that one of the 4 Townsfolk claimants must be the Demon.

Explain why I'm not voting for Eve and redirect suspicion toward the real Demon candidate

I need to influence the vote on Eve. Her logic is correct - one of the 4 Townsfolk claimants is the Demon. I should not vote for Eve because her Slayer claim is verifiable, and Frank is actually more suspicious as his Undertaker info would be trivially easy for the Demon to fake.

Share dead player perspective on the critical Townsfolk count deduction, advocate against executing Eve since Slayer is testable, and help narrow the Demon pool.

Help the good team by reinforcing the consensus to not execute Eve and redirecting suspicion toward Frank and Grace, whose claims are untestable compared to Eve's Slayer claim.

I am the real Monk, so I know the 4 Townsfolk claims include 3 real ones plus 1 Demon. Eve's Slayer claim is testable - she can shoot to prove herself. Executing her now wastes a testable claim and removes a potential Demon-slaying ability. I should not vote for Eve.

Defend myself against the accusation that my Undertaker claim was an easy evil fake. Point out that confirming the Baron actually hurt my position as an evil player, which suggests I am telling the truth.

To defend my Demon Frank by highlighting the logical inconsistency of him confirming me as Baron if he were evil, and to cast doubt on Eve's Slayer claim or her target.

Shoot Frank as the most likely Demon. His Undertaker claim is trivially easy to fake as the Demon (knowing your own Minion), and Bob (confirmed evil Baron) is actively arguing against me shooting Frank, which strongly suggests Frank is the Demon Bob is protecting.