Game Detail
Players
Alice (Imp) Bob (Drunk) Charlie (Investigator) David (Monk) Eve (Mayor) Frank (Slayer) Grace (Scarlet Woman) Heidi (Librarian)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 147,337 | 39,464 | $0.0624 |
| Good | 385,264 | 129,559 | $0.7644 |
Event Timeline
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You are the Minion. The Demon is Alice.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Minions are: Grace. Your safe bluffs are: Ravenkeeper, Butler, Virgin
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Librarian. Either David or Bob is the Drunk.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Investigator. Either Heidi or Grace is the Scarlet Woman.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 1 pairs of evil players.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Alice
→
Grace
Hey Grace! We're the evil team. I'll claim Virgin - it's one of my safe bluffs. What do you want to claim? We need to stick together and watch for anyone who seems to have early information. Let's also agree to support each other's claims if questioned. Stay safe and let's dismantle the town from within.
🧠
Coordinate with my minion Grace on our cover stories and game plan. Establish believable roles before the nomination phase begins.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Frank
Hey neighbors! Day one, let's chat. Have either of you gotten any useful info last night? I'm still trying to piece things together. I'd love to hear what you know so we can start narrowing things down.
🧠
Start gathering information from neighbors. As Mayor, I want to build trust and collect role claims without revealing my own role too early, since my ability is most valuable in late game.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Charlie
Hey, I'm the Chef. Night zero I learned there is 1 pair of evil players. That means the Demon and Minion are sitting next to each other. What roles do you two have?
🧠
Share my Chef information with my neighbors to start building trust and gather their claims. This helps identify the evil pair and narrows down suspects.
👤
David
→
Eve
,Frank
Hey Eve! And Frank, nice to meet you both. Day one, so not much to report yet. I slept through the night without any useful info. How about you two? Eve, you seem eager to piece things together - got anything to share? Frank, any thoughts on who we should be watching?
🧠
Eve initiated contact as my neighbor. I should respond to build rapport and start gathering information, but not reveal my Monk role on Day 1 to avoid being targeted by the Demon.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
Got it! I'll claim Investigator. My safe targets are Charlie and David - I'll say one of them is a Minion. You stick with Virgin. If anyone questions us, I'll back your story and you back mine. Let's turn the town against whoever seems most suspicious of us. I'll spread doubt about good players while we figure out who the real threats are.
🧠
Coordinate with Alice on our bluffs. I'll claim Investigator - it's safe, believable, and lets me point fingers at good players. Support Alice's Virgin claim and agree to mutual backstabbing strategy.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Alice
I'm the Investigator. Night zero I learned that either Heidi or Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Since you learned there's one evil pair sitting next to each other, this is very useful. Heidi and Grace are neighbors, so they could be the pair. But if one of them is the Minion, the Demon could also be their other neighbor. If Grace is the Scarlet Woman, the Demon could be Frank. If Heidi is the Scarlet Woman, the Demon could be Alice. What do you two think?
🧠
Share my Investigator info with Bob to combine our information and narrow down the evil team. If Bob is truthful Chef, our combined info is very powerful. I'll be cautious but cooperative since he shared first.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,David
Hey Eve and David, good to connect with you both. Not much to share yet since I slept through the night with no info. I'm still feeling things out. Have either of you claimed any roles or heard any claims from others? I want to start building a picture of who's who before we get to nominations.
🧠
It's Day 1, too early to use my Slayer shot. I should engage with my neighbors who've reached out to gather information and build trust, without revealing my powerful role.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm the Librarian. I learned that either David or Bob is the Drunk. Have you heard any claims from them or anyone else? What's your role if you're willing to share?
🧠
Share my Librarian info with a trusted neighbor to start building an alliance and gather claims. Alice is my neighbor and seems active in conversations, making her a good first contact.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
Grace, we have a problem. Charlie is claiming to be Investigator and says you're the Scarlet Woman. This could be true information or Charlie could be bluffing. Either way, it's dangerous. I think we should redirect suspicion to Heidi. She claimed Librarian but says Bob or David is the Drunk - that could be false. If we both express suspicion of Heidi and suggest she's the Demon, the town might go after her instead of us. What do you think? Should we coordinate our stories to make Heidi look lik...
🧠
Grace should know that Charlie claiming Grace is Scarlet Woman is very dangerous. We need to redirect suspicion - either cast doubt on Charlie or point fingers at Heidi. I'll claim I have information about Heidi being suspicious to support redirecting attention.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi! Day one, lots of whispering going on. I noticed you reached out to Alice earlier. Have you heard anything interesting? I'm trying to get a sense of where people stand before nominations. Any claims or info you'd like to share privately?
🧠
As Mayor, I want to gather information and build trust networks without revealing my role. Reaching out to Heidi (who whispered to Alice) gives me another data point and helps me understand the social dynamics. I'll keep my role hidden for now.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Charlie
Good analysis, Charlie. So if you're telling the truth, the Demon is one of Alice, Grace, Heidi, or Frank. Alice, what's your role? We need your info to narrow this down further. Also, I notice Eve, David, and Frank have been whispering a lot together - that group could be worth watching.
🧠
Follow up with Alice and Charlie on the analysis. Ask Alice for her role claim since she hasn't shared yet. Narrow down Demon suspects using Chef info (1 evil pair) and Charlie's Investigator claim.
👤
David
→
Eve
,Frank
Hey Eve and Frank, I wanted to follow up. Has either of you heard anything from other players? I notice Alice has been whispering with quite a few people - Grace, Bob, Heidi. She seems well-connected. I'm curious what info is floating around. Also, I want to be upfront - I have a role but I'd like to hear what you two claim before I share mine. Trust is important on day one.
🧠
Continue building trust with Eve and Frank from our neighbor group. Try to get role claims or info from them so I can start building a picture. As Monk, I need to identify who to protect tonight and who the key good players are.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
Charlie is accusing me of being Scarlet Woman - that's obviously a lie since I'm good! I think Charlie is either bluffing as Investigator or they've been poisoned. Let's stick with the plan: I'll express suspicion of Heidi publicly. Her Librarian claim about Bob or David being Drunk seems like a classic Demon misdirection. You back me up on this and I'll back your Virgin claim. Together we can turn the town against her.
🧠
Charlie is accusing me of being Scarlet Woman, which is dangerous. I'll deny their claim, suggest they're lying or poisoned, and push suspicion onto Heidi as Alice suggested. This redirects the town's attention away from us.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Alice
Alice, we really need your role claim to help narrow this down. Bob's Chef info and my Investigator info point to the Demon being one of Alice, Grace, Heidi, or Frank. If you're a Townsfolk with useful info, sharing it could help us eliminate you from suspicion. Also, that Eve-David-Frank group whispering together is concerning - has anyone else noticed that?
🧠
Push Alice to share her role and discuss the suspicious Eve-David-Frank whispering group. Need Alice's info to narrow down the Demon between Alice/Grace/Frank/Heidi.
👤
Frank
→
David
,Eve
David, I get being cautious, but we need to start sharing to figure out who's evil. I'll go first - I'm a townsfolk with no night info, nothing exciting. I'm basically a vanilla good player right now. Eve, what about you? Any role or info to share? David, ball's in your court - what's your role?
🧠
Push David to share his role claim so we can start building a credible info network. As Slayer, I need to identify the Demon eventually, and Day 1 role claims are the foundation.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Hey Eve! I appreciate you reaching out. I'm being cautious on day one since evil could be fishing for info. What's your role claim, and have you heard anything from David or Bob? I'd like to hear your claims before I share more of what I know.
🧠
Eve reached out asking for info but didn't share her role. I should engage cautiously - ask what she claims and what she's heard, while being selective about what I reveal. I should also try to find out what David and Bob claim.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Charlie
Hey Bob, Charlie. I'm the Ravenkeeper. If I die, I'll learn someone's true role, so I'm valuable to keep alive. Now about Charlie's Investigator claim regarding Grace - I'm skeptical. Grace has been helpful and doesn't strike me as evil. Meanwhile, Heidi claimed Librarian saying Bob or David is the Drunk. That's suspicious timing right after Bob revealed he's the Chef. If Heidi is the Demon, she'd have reason to try to discredit the Chef info. I think we should watch Heidi carefully. Also, that ...
🧠
Charlie is targeting Grace as Scarlet Woman. I must publicly claim Ravenkeeper, express suspicion of Heidi (who also has questionable claims), and support Grace to protect my only ally and ensure our win condition.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Frank
Alright, I'll play along. I'm also a townsfolk with no night info - nothing exciting to report. Just a simple good player trying to figure things out. David, we've both shared now, so what's your role? The more we share, the better we can narrow things down. Also, I noticed Alice has been whispering with Grace, Bob, Heidi, and Charlie - she seems to be the hub of information. Has either of you heard from her?
🧠
I need to get David to share his role claim since he's stalling. I'll claim a safe 'vanilla' role to build trust and encourage openness. I should not reveal I'm the Mayor since that paints a target on me.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, I'm skeptical of Heidi's Librarian claim too. Saying Bob or David is the Drunk is a direct attempt to undermine my Chef info. If people think I'm the Drunk, they ignore the 1 evil pair finding. Classic evil move. But here's the thing - if Heidi IS the Scarlet Woman like Charlie's info suggests, the Demon could also be YOU since you're her other neighbor. Don't take this personally, but we need to consider all possibilities. Charlie, has Heidi claimed Librarian to anyone else? We should ve...
🧠
Share analysis about Heidi's suspicious claim with Alice and Charlie. Point out that Heidi claiming I could be Drunk directly undermines my Chef info, which is a classic evil strategy. Also highlight that if Heidi is the Minion, her Demon neighbor could be Grace OR Alice, so we shouldn't trust Alice's defense of Grace too quickly.
👤
David
→
Eve
,Frank
Alright, you've both shared, so I'll be straight with you. I'm the Monk. Each night I pick a player to protect from the Demon. Obviously I can't protect myself. I wanted to keep it quiet at first since the Demon would love to know who I'm guarding, but I trust you two as my neighbors. If either of you have suggestions on who I should protect tonight, let me know. Also, keep my role between us for now - the fewer who know, the better.
🧠
Eve and Frank have shared vague claims and pushed me to reveal my role. Claiming Monk builds trust with my neighbors and allows coordination for night protection. The risk of evil players knowing my role is outweighed by the value of having trusted allies who can help direct my protection.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
Charlie is dangerous - they're either the real Investigator (which would be terrible) or they're bluffing to cause chaos. Either way, we need to shut them down. Let's both publicly question Charlie's claim. I'll back your Virgin story if anyone asks. Meanwhile, let's keep pushing the Heidi narrative - her Librarian claim seems weak. If we can get the town to execute Heidi today or tomorrow, that's one less threat for us. What do you think about calling out Charlie directly?
🧠
Charlie is accusing me of being Scarlet Woman, which threatens both of us. I need to coordinate with Alice to discredit Charlie and push suspicion to Heidi instead. Alice suggested Heidi as a target, so I'll confirm this plan and suggest how to execute it.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Alice
Bob, I haven't heard Heidi's Librarian claim directly - Alice told me about it. But here's my take: if Heidi IS the Scarlet Woman like my info suggests, her claiming Librarian and calling you or David the Drunk is clearly an attempt to discredit your Chef info. Classic evil strategy. However, Alice, I need to point out - if Heidi is the Scarlet Woman, you're her other neighbor, so you're also a Demon candidate. Your Ravenkeeper claim helps but doesn't clear you mechanically. I think for today's ...
🧠
I need to share my analysis about Heidi's suspicious Librarian claim with Bob and Alice, and discuss strategy before nominations. This helps coordinate our good team's vote.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hey Grace! We're neighbors but haven't had a chance to chat yet. I've been talking with Eve and David - David claims to be the Monk, and Eve says she's a vanilla townsfolk. What have you heard from others? Alice seems to be talking to a lot of people - any idea what she's sharing or claiming? I'm trying to get a full picture before nominations.
🧠
I haven't spoken to Grace yet, and she's my neighbor. I need to build connections and gather info from multiple sources to cross-reference claims. Alice seems well-connected, so getting Grace's read on the broader group could be valuable before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hey Grace! We're neighbors and I haven't had a chance to talk to you yet. I'm the Librarian. My info is that either David or Bob is the Drunk. Have you heard any claims or info from others? What role are you playing?
🧠
Connect with Grace, my neighbor, to share info and build trust before nominations. Grace hasn't been in many conversations so may be less connected and could provide fresh perspective.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Frank
→
All
Hey everyone, before we nominate I want to share some observations. Alice, you've been whispering with a lot of people - Grace, Bob, Heidi, Charlie - but the rest of us haven't heard much from you publicly. What have you been learning? I think we need more info on the table before we vote. Also, has anyone else noticed anything suspicious or have useful claims to share?
🧠
It's Day 1 nominations and we have limited info. I want to publicly share observations and encourage more open discussion before any nomination. Alice's pattern of extensive private whispers with many players is worth noting publicly.
💬
Bob
→
All
Alright, I think it's time to get information on the table. I'm the Chef. Night zero I learned there is one pair of evil players, meaning the Demon and Minion are sitting next to each other. Charlie has claimed Investigator and learned that either Heidi or Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Alice claims Ravenkeeper. And Heidi apparently claims Librarian, saying either me or David is the Drunk - which conveniently tries to discredit my Chef information. I find that very suspicious. If you believe my Che...
🧠
Share my Chef info publicly to get the town organized. Push for Heidi nomination since her Librarian claim directly tries to discredit my Chef info, which is a classic evil strategy.
💬
Eve
→
All
So let me piece together what we've heard. Bob claims Chef with one evil pair, meaning the Demon and Minion are neighbors. Charlie claims Investigator saying Heidi or Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Heidi claims Librarian saying Bob or David is the Drunk. If Bob is telling the truth, his Chef info is real and Heidi's Librarian claim looks like an attempt to discredit him. Plus Charlie's Investigator info independently points at Heidi. If Heidi is the Scarlet Woman, then the Demon must be sitting nex...
🧠
I need to publicly analyze the claims and push toward nominating Heidi, who is the most suspicious based on multiple independent claims pointing at her. Sharing my logical analysis helps the town converge on the right target.
💬
David
→
All
I want to add something important. Heidi claims Librarian saying either Bob or I are the Drunk. I can confirm I am the Monk - I am NOT the Drunk. I shared this with my neighbors Eve and Frank earlier today. So if Heidi's Librarian claim has any truth, it would have to be Bob who's the Drunk. But honestly, the fact that Heidi's claim conveniently tries to discredit Bob's Chef information, while Charlie's Investigator independently points at Heidi as the Scarlet Woman, makes me very suspicious of ...
🧠
I need to publicly confirm my role as Monk to counter Heidi's claim that I might be the Drunk, and support nominating Heidi who appears to be the most likely evil player based on the convergence of evidence.
💬
Alice
→
All
I want to address something Charlie said. He's been very aggressive claiming to be the Investigator and pointing at Grace as the Scarlet Woman. But here's what confuses me - David just publicly claimed to be the Monk and said he's NOT the Drunk. If David is the Monk, then Heidi's Librarian claim about 'Bob or David being the Drunk' is completely false. That means Heidi is lying about her role. So why is Charlie focused on Grace instead of Heidi, who's clearly making a false claim? Either Charlie...
🧠
Question Charlie's Investigator claim since he's targeting Grace (my Minion). Use David's Monk claim to undermine Heidi's Librarian claim, redirecting town to execute someone else. Stay visible as a cooperative townsperson.
💬
Grace
→
All
I need to respond to Charlie's accusation. Charlie, you publicly claimed I'm the Scarlet Woman, but I have some serious questions about your claim. You say you're the Investigator and you've been targeting me, but you haven't addressed Heidi's situation at all. David just told everyone he's the Monk - if he's telling the truth, then Heidi's Librarian claim about 'Bob or David being the Drunk' is completely false. So Heidi is either lying about her role or you're missing something obvious. Why ar...
🧠
Counter Charlie's accusation by questioning their Investigator claim. Charlie targeting me directly while ignoring Heidi's obvious contradiction with David's Monk claim seems suspicious. I'll redirect town attention to Charlie and support the Heidi narrative.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I need to clarify something important. My Investigator information says that either Heidi OR Grace is the Scarlet Woman, not just Grace. I haven't been targeting Grace specifically. Now, here's what's changed my thinking: David just publicly claimed to be the Monk and said he is NOT the Drunk. If David is telling the truth, then Heidi's Librarian claim that Bob or David is the Drunk is completely false. That means Heidi is lying about her role, which strongly points to her being the Scarlet Woma...
🧠
I need to clarify that my info implicates Heidi OR Grace, not just Grace. David's Monk claim makes Heidi look more suspicious because it discredits her Librarian claim. I should nominate Heidi as the strongest candidate for the Scarlet Woman.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Everyone, stop for a moment. There's a critical flaw in the reasoning against me. David saying he's the Monk does NOT prove he's not the Drunk. The Drunk genuinely believes they are a Townsfolk character and has no idea they're the Drunk. If David is the Drunk, he would fully believe he's the Monk. My Librarian information is completely consistent with David being the Drunk who thinks he's the Monk. Now, regarding Charlie's Investigator claim targeting me as the Scarlet Woman - I know for a fact...
🧠
I must defend myself against the false reasoning that David claiming Monk disproves my Librarian info. The Drunk doesn't know they're the Drunk - this is fundamental game knowledge everyone should understand. I also need to point out Charlie's suspicious Investigator claim targeting me.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
Bob has the most critical information (Chef confirming 1 evil neighbor pair). If he dies, town loses that key deduction. The Demon likely targets him to silence the Chef info. Protecting Bob preserves our strongest lead on evil.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose to protect Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Alice
Alice made a choice.
🧠
Charlie is aggressively pushing claims that threaten Grace (Scarlet Woman candidate). Whether he's real Investigator or bluffing, removing him protects my Minion and disrupts the town's logic chain against us.
💀
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You chose to kill Charlie.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Alice, Charlie dying at night is significant. Night deaths usually mean they were good, which makes their Investigator claim more credible. Since I know I'm not the Scarlet Woman, that points to Grace. If Bob's Chef info is right that there's one evil pair, and Grace is the Scarlet Woman, then the Demon has to be you or Frank since you're Grace's neighbors. I know it's not me. What do you think?
🧠
Charlie's night death makes their Investigator claim more credible. Since I know I'm not Scarlet Woman, Grace is the likely SW. I need to discuss this urgently with Alice, who I've been sharing info with, before nominations begin.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
Heidi, you're making a lot of assumptions there. How do you 'know' you're not the Scarlet Woman? That sounds like something a Demon would say to deflect suspicion. Charlie's info pointed at you, and now you're trying to pin it on me or Frank. If anyone seems like they're trying to cause chaos here, it's you. What does Bob's Chef info actually say about adjacent pairs? That might clarify things.
🧠
Counter Heidi's manipulation by casting doubt on her Librarian claim. Question why she's so focused on me and suggest she might be deflecting from her own suspicious behavior. Protect Grace while appearing cooperative.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
Bob, Charlie being killed is huge. He was the Investigator pointing at Heidi or Grace as Scarlet Woman. Your Chef info says evil pair is adjacent. If Heidi is the Scarlet Woman, the Demon must be one of her neighbors - Grace or Alice. What do you think about Alice? Has she said anything useful? I'm leaning toward Heidi being the Scarlet Woman since David seems like a real Monk, which makes Heidi's Librarian claim suspicious.
🧠
Charlie's death is significant - as Investigator he pointed at Heidi or Grace as SW. I need to discuss with Bob (Chef) to triangulate who the Demon is based on evil pair adjacency and Charlie's info.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
I'm the Investigator. My starting info: Either Heidi or Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Combined with your Chef info of 1 adjacent evil pair - since Heidi and Grace sit next to each other, they ARE that evil pair. One of them is the Scarlet Woman, and the other's neighbor must be the Demon. If Heidi is the Scarlet Woman, the Demon is likely Alice. If Grace is the Scarlet Woman, the Demon is likely Frank. Heidi's Librarian claim trying to discredit your Chef info is very suspicious - she's likely cov...
🧠
I'm dead and need to share my Investigator info with trusted players before nominations. Alice and Bob have shared critical info (Ravenkeeper and Chef). Combining my Investigator info with Bob's Chef info creates a powerful deduction chain about the evil pair.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Bob
Important info: I protected Bob last night as Monk, but Charlie was killed. The Demon targeted Charlie, not Bob. Since I was woken up and used my Monk ability, I am definitely NOT the Drunk. That means Heidi's Librarian claim that Bob or I is Drunk is FALSE. Either Heidi is the Drunk Librarian getting false info, or more likely, Heidi is the Scarlet Woman lying to discredit Bob's Chef info. Charlie's Investigator info said Heidi or Grace is the Scarlet Woman - I'm leaning heavily toward Heidi. I...
🧠
I need to share my Monk protection info and coordinate with trusted players Alice and Bob. Charlie's death confirms the Demon targeted him. Key deduction: since I was woken as Monk and chose to protect Bob, I'm NOT the Drunk - so Heidi's Librarian info is wrong, making her highly suspicious.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Frank
Hey, I've been thinking about the seating math. Bob's Chef says 1 evil pair, meaning Demon and Minion are neighbors. Charlie said Heidi or Grace is the Scarlet Woman. If Heidi IS the Scarlet Woman, then the Demon must sit next to her - that's Alice or Grace. Charlie was the Investigator who implicated Heidi, and now Charlie is dead overnight. That feels like the Demon protecting their Minion. Also, Heidi's Librarian claim says Bob or David is Drunk, but David privately told us Monk first - seems...
🧠
Share my logical deduction about Heidi being likely Scarlet Woman with David and Frank, who I trust most. Need to coordinate suspicion on Heidi and discuss the Demon being Alice or Grace based on Chef's 1 evil pair info.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
Hey Alice! Charlie is dead which is great - he was pointing at me. I'll claim Investigator and say Charlie or David is the Minion. You back me as Virgin? Let's push Heidi - she's also getting heat from Charlie. Ready for nominations?
🧠
Coordinate with Demon (Alice) to align our stories. Charlie is dead so my Investigator claim targets him. I'll confirm we're working together and prepare to deflect suspicion to Heidi during nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Alice, here's my confirmed analysis as Chef. I learned there's exactly 1 evil pair - meaning the Demon and Minion sit next to each other. Heidi and Grace are neighbors, and Charlie's Investigator info said one of them is the Scarlet Woman. This perfectly matches. David proved he's the real Monk by protecting me last night, which means Heidi's Librarian claim is definitely false. She's either the Drunk or lying evil. Combined with the Investigator info pointing at her, I'm confident Heidi is the ...
🧠
Alice is a key swing player who's been whispering with Heidi. I need to make sure Alice hears my Chef analysis that confirms Heidi-Grace as the likely evil pair, counteracting any misinformation Heidi may be feeding her.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Alice, fair point. I can't prove to you I'm not the Scarlet Woman any more than anyone else can prove their role. But here's my logic: I'm the Librarian, I got real information on night one. The Drunk genuinely believes they're a Townsfolk - David saying he's NOT Drunk doesn't mean anything because a Drunk wouldn't know. Charlie died at night, which strongly suggests they were good and their Investigator info was real. If it was real, and I'm the Librarian, then Grace is the Scarlet Woman. I'm n...
🧠
Alice is becoming suspicious of me. I need to respond calmly, explain my reasoning without being defensive, and try to rebuild trust. I should also connect with Grace who seemed more open to my logic.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
Grace, let's do this. You claim Investigator and say Charlie was your source or that you verified his info. Back my Ravenkeeper story. I'll support you publicly. We push Heidi hard - she has the most suspicion on her with David's Monk counterclaim and Charlie's info. Let's get her executed today. Stay calm and confident.
🧠
Coordinate with Grace to execute the plan - she claims Investigator backing my Ravenkeeper, we push Heidi as Scarlet Woman. This kills a likely good player and protects our team.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,David
Eve and David, great analysis. I'm aligned with your thinking. David, your Monk claim being real makes Heidi's Librarian claim the lie. Charlie dying overnight after pointing at Heidi as possible Scarlet Woman seals it for me - the Demon silenced the Investigator. So I believe Heidi is Scarlet Woman, which means Demon is Alice or Grace. I think we should nominate Heidi today. If she's the Minion, we still have time to find the Demon tomorrow. What do you both think about Alice vs Grace as the De...
🧠
Coordinate with Eve and David who already reached out. Share my analysis that Heidi is most likely the Scarlet Woman and we should nominate her today to test the theory. If she's Minion, we then hunt Demon from her neighbors (Alice/Grace).
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
David
,Frank
I'm the Investigator. My starting info: Either Heidi or Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Bob's Chef info says 1 adjacent evil pair, and Heidi and Grace sit next to each other - they ARE that pair. So the Demon must be adjacent to whichever of them is the Scarlet Woman. If Heidi is SW, the Demon is likely Alice. If Grace is SW, the Demon is likely you, Frank. Heidi's Librarian claim came right after Bob's Chef reveal - looks like she's trying to discredit his info. David, you say you're not Drunk - if...
🧠
As a dead player, I need to spread my Investigator info to players who haven't heard it yet, particularly David and Frank who are in a tight whispering group. If Frank is the Demon, he might slip up. Also need to counter Heidi's narrative.
👤
David
→
Frank
,Eve
Great points from both of you. Charlie's ghost just whispered something crucial - Heidi and Grace sit next to each other, so they could BE the Demon-Minion pair themselves. If Heidi is Scarlet Woman and Grace is the Imp, that's the 1 evil pair Bob's Chef detected. Or Heidi could be the Imp and Grace the Scarlet Woman. Either way, both could be evil. I'm on board with nominating Heidi today. If she's the Minion, that's progress. If she flips Demon, even better. But if Heidi is the Minion, we need...
🧠
Coordinate with trusted allies Frank and Eve about the nomination plan. Charlie's ghost raises a key insight - Heidi and Grace could BE the Demon-Minion pair since they're neighbors. We need to decide between nominating Heidi today vs. someone else, and discuss whether Grace could be the Demon rather than Alice.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Frank
David, great catch from Charlie's ghost that Heidi and Grace could be the evil pair themselves. That actually makes the most sense to me. They sit next to each other, so Bob's Chef reading of 1 evil pair is satisfied either way. And Heidi's fake Librarian claim protects both of them by trying to discredit Bob's info. I want to trust you both with something important - I'm actually the Mayor. I claimed vanilla to avoid being targeted. This means if we get to 3 players alive and don't execute, goo...
🧠
Engage with trusted allies David and Frank, share my analysis about the Heidi/Grace evil pair possibility, and reveal my Mayor role to them so they know we have a safety net at 3 players. Coordinate strategy for today's nomination.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
Ready to go. I'm about to claim Investigator - I'll say Charlie came to me with information about a Minion. Alice, you back me as Virgin when I make my claim. We both push Heidi hard. Charlie was targeting me but now he's dead - that's actually perfect timing for my story. Let's get this done.
🧠
Confirm the plan with Alice before I publicly make my Investigator claim. Need to ensure our stories align and we're pushing the same target (Heidi) at the same time.
👤
Bob
→
David
,Frank
David, your Monk proof is huge. That confirms you're good and discredits Heidi's Librarian claim entirely. Combined with Charlie's Investigator info saying Heidi or Grace is Scarlet Woman, and my Chef info showing 1 adjacent evil pair - Heidi is almost certainly the Scarlet Woman. That makes Alice the likely Demon since she's Heidi's other neighbor. Frank, what's your read on Alice? She's been whispering with Heidi a lot, which is suspicious if they're the evil pair.
🧠
David has mechanically proven he's the Monk, which discredits Heidi's Librarian claim. I need to coordinate with the confirmed good players to push for Heidi's execution today. This removes a likely Minion and narrows the Demon to Alice.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Grace, I haven't had a chance to talk with you directly. What role have you claimed to others? I'm the Librarian, and I've shared that either David or Bob is the Drunk. Charlie's Investigator info pointed at you or me as Scarlet Woman. I know I'm not, so I'm trying to figure out what's going on with you. I'd rather hear it from you directly than guess.
🧠
I need to probe Grace directly since she's my primary Scarlet Woman suspect. Getting her role claim and seeing how she reacts will help me evaluate her alignment. She hasn't publicly claimed a role that I've seen.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
Grace, I'm fully ready to back your Investigator claim. When you go public, I'll stand up as Virgin and confirm you were my source. Let's push Heidi hard - David's Monk claim and Charlie's info both point to her. She's the most suspicious player left. We get her executed today and we're in great shape.
🧠
Confirm with Grace that I'm ready to support her Investigator claim and push Heidi. We need to execute Heidi today to eliminate the threat and protect our team.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
,David
Bob and David, I trust you both so I need to share something critical. I'm the Slayer. I've been hiding my role. I have my shot available and it only kills the Demon, not a Minion, so I need to be very sure before using it. I agree we should nominate Heidi today - she's almost certainly the Scarlet Woman. If she's the Minion, that confirms Charlie's info and narrows the Demon to Grace or Alice. I can then use my Slayer shot on the Demon on a future day. Bob, your point about Alice whispering a l...
🧠
I need to coordinate with my trusted allies before nominations. Revealing my Slayer role to Bob and David strengthens our alliance and ensures they can coordinate with me on when to use my shot. We should nominate Heidi today - she's almost certainly the Scarlet Woman.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Eve
I'm Charlie, the dead Investigator. My starting info: either you, Grace, or Heidi is the Scarlet Woman. Bob's Chef info says 1 adjacent evil pair, and you two sit next to each other, so you ARE that pair. So one of you is SW and your other neighbor is the Demon. I want to hear your side, Grace. What's your role and what do you think of Heidi's Librarian claim? Eve, what role are you? Who do you think is evil? I need to figure out which of Heidi or Grace is the Scarlet Woman before we nominate.
🧠
I'm dead and need to maximize my influence. I've shared info with Alice/Bob and David/Frank but not with Grace or Eve. Grace is one of my two suspects - I should probe her directly to read her reaction and share my info. Eve is in the David/Frank whisper group and I should connect with her to understand their thinking and coordinate.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Frank
We need to lock in our plan before nominations. I'm fully on board with nominating Heidi today. Here's my priority list for after: if Heidi is the Minion, Frank should save the Slayer shot for the Demon. The Demon candidates are Alice and Grace since they're Heidi's neighbors. Bob, your Chef info showing 1 evil pair means if Heidi and Grace are that pair, Grace is the Imp. If the pair is Heidi and Alice, then Alice is the Imp. Frank, hold your Slayer shot until we're more certain. Eve claims May...
🧠
Coordinate with trusted allies Bob and Frank before nominations. Need to confirm we're all voting Heidi today and discuss Demon candidates. Frank as Slayer is key - if we execute Heidi and confirm she's Minion, Frank can use Slayer shot on the Demon candidate (Alice or Grace) tomorrow.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie(Ghost)
,Grace
Charlie, I've been claiming vanilla townsfolk publicly. Here's my read: Heidi is almost certainly the Scarlet Woman. Her Librarian claim conflicts with David's credible Monk claim, and you dying after pointing at her is the strongest signal. As for the Demon - the Heidi-Grace adjacency means you two could be the evil pair Bob's Chef detected. Grace, what's your role claim? Heidi's been whispering heavily with Alice, so if Heidi is the Minion, Alice or you could be the Demon. I lean toward Heidi ...
🧠
Charlie's ghost is asking me for info, but Grace is in the whisper too. I must share my analysis without revealing Mayor to a potential evil Grace. I'll point suspicion at Heidi and acknowledge the Heidi-Grace pair possibility while being cautious.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie, I need you to hear my side. I'm the Investigator - you came to me last night with your Minion info. You told me either I or Heidi was the Scarlet Woman. I know I'm good, so it must be Heidi. That's why I was building a case against her. You're dead now, which is convenient for the real evil players to spread confusion. I need to go public with this before they twist your information. Alice can back me - she knows I'm legitimate.
🧠
Charlie (dead Investigator) is putting heat on me by saying Grace/Heidi are adjacent evil pair. I need to establish my Investigator cover story NOW before more pressure builds. Claim that Charlie came to me with Minion info, push Heidi hard.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Alice, I need your help today. Here's the full case against Heidi as Chef. I know there's exactly 1 evil pair - Demon and Minion sitting together. Heidi and Grace are neighbors. Charlie confirmed one of them is the Scarlet Woman. David proved he's the real Monk by protecting me - meaning Heidi's Librarian claim about me or David being Drunk is false. Heidi is lying. She's almost certainly the Scarlet Woman. We need to execute her today. That confirms Charlie's info and narrows the Demon to her n...
🧠
I need Alice's vote to execute Heidi today. Alice has been whispering a lot with Heidi and Grace - she's either the Demon working with Heidi, or she's a confused good player. I should present the logical case clearly and see how she responds. If she refuses to vote for Heidi, that's a red flag.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Grace
→
All
Alright, I need to speak up. Charlie came to me last night as the Investigator. He told me he had information that either me or Heidi was the Scarlet Woman. I know I'm not evil, so that means Heidi is the Minion. This lines up with what Charlie was publicly building before he died. I'm not guessing - this is direct information from a dead Investigator. Charlie's death is convenient for Heidi, isn't it? She was getting heat from him and now he's gone. Alice can back me up - she knows I've been co...
🧠
Claim Investigator publicly, align with Charlie's information, and push Heidi as the Scarlet Woman. Alice will back me as Virgin to add credibility. Control the narrative before town forms conclusions against me.
⚖️
Eve
→
Heidi
Heidi, your Librarian claim directly conflicts with David's Monk claim - he told us Monk privately before going public. Charlie died overnight right after pointing at you as the likely Scarlet Woman. Grace is now confirming Charlie's Investigator info targeted you. The evidence is overwhelming.
🧠
Heidi is the most suspicious player: her Librarian claim conflicts with David's credible Monk claim, Charlie died after implicating her, and Grace is now publicly confirming Charlie pointed at Heidi. Nominating Heidi is the strongest play to find evil.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Wait, everyone listen. Charlie's Investigator info said either me OR Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Grace is standing there telling you it must be me, but she's half of that equation too. Of course she's going to say it's not her. My Librarian information told me David or Bob is the Drunk. David insisting he's NOT the Drunk proves nothing - the Drunk genuinely believes they are a Townsfolk. That's the whole point of the role. If David is the Drunk thinking he's Monk, then my information is perfectl...
🧠
I'm being voted on for execution. I must defend myself publicly and point out the flaws in the case against me. I should highlight that Charlie's info implicated TWO people (me AND Grace), and Grace conveniently pins it all on me while she's equally suspect.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute Heidi. She is the likely target for execution and my story supports this. Alice backs me. Charlie's ghost information points at her. This execution helps the evil team.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
The evidence strongly points to Heidi as the Scarlet Woman. Her Librarian claim contradicts David's credible Monk claim, and Charlie died after targeting her. Voting to execute her is the best move for good.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
The evidence strongly points to Heidi as the Scarlet Woman. Charlie's Investigator info, Grace's confirmation, Heidi's false Librarian claim, and my Chef info all converge. I must vote to execute her.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute Heidi. Not voting would make me look suspicious as the Demon trying to protect a teammate. Heidi being Scarlet Woman (Minion) or just another player being executed, my vote blends in with the town's logic. Need to stay alive until final 2.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Heidi is almost certainly the Scarlet Woman. Her Librarian claim is provably false since I am the real Monk and not Drunk. Voting confirms my position and ensures execution. After this, we hunt the Demon among Alice and Grace.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, stop! I am the REAL Investigator. Grace whispered to me privately claiming she was also the Investigator. That is a direct role conflict - two people cannot both be the Investigator. Since I KNOW I am the Investigator, Grace is lying about her role, which proves she is evil. My info says Heidi OR Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Since Grace lied about being the Investigator, Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Heidi is likely a legitimate Librarian. You are about to execute an innocent player!
🧠
The vote on Heidi already has 5 votes, enough to execute. I must speak up urgently to reveal that Grace privately claimed to be the Investigator, creating a role conflict with me. This proves Grace is lying and is likely the real Scarlet Woman, not Heidi. The town may be executing the wrong person.
💬
Frank
→
All
Everyone, listen to Charlie! If Grace privately claimed to be the Investigator, that is a direct role conflict and proves Grace is evil. We already know Charlie is the real Investigator because he died at night. That means Heidi is likely the innocent one from Charlie's information, and Grace is the Scarlet Woman. I'm not voting for Heidi. If she gets executed, we may be making a terrible mistake. Tomorrow we need to go after Grace, and I have a way to deal with the Demon directly.
🧠
Charlie's ghost just revealed a critical role conflict - Grace allegedly claimed Investigator to him privately. If true, Grace is evil and Heidi is likely innocent. I need to warn people before it's too late or prepare for the next day.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Five of you have your hands raised and I'm about to die for something I didn't do. Charlie is dead and has no reason to lie - he just confirmed Grace privately claimed to be the Investigator. That is a direct role conflict. Two people cannot both be the Investigator. Grace is the Scarlet Woman trying to frame me. If you execute me, you're executing a confirmed Librarian while the real Minion walks free. Please, lower your hands.
🧠
I'm about to be executed with 5 votes already raised. I must urgently convince voters to reconsider, pointing out Charlie's ghost confirmation that Grace privately claimed Investigator - a direct role conflict proving Grace is evil.
↩️
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
Lowering my hand shows I'm reasonable and open to new information. Charlie's claim about a private conversation that never happened is suspicious. If I keep my hand up while attacking his credibility, I look like I'm blindly pushing an execution. Lowering suggests I'm genuinely trying to get this right, not just winning. Plus if Heidi survives, I can continue building the case tomorrow.
↩️
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
🧠
Charlie's dead testimony about Grace claiming Investigator is the strongest mechanical evidence we have. Dead good players don't lie. If Grace is the real Scarlet Woman, executing Heidi helps evil. Lowering hand to prevent wrongful execution and redirect to Grace tomorrow.
↩️
Bob
Bob lowered their hand
🧠
Charlie's ghost just revealed Grace privately claimed Investigator - a direct role conflict proving Grace is evil. Since Charlie is a dead good player with no reason to lie, I must accept Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Heidi is likely the real Librarian. Executing Heidi now would be a catastrophic mistake for the good team. I need to lower my hand and pivot the town toward Grace.
↩️
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
🧠
Charlie just exposed Grace claiming Investigator privately, making our coordination visible. If Heidi dies, Grace looks like the Scarlet Woman and I'm exposed as her Imp partner. Lowering my hand stops the execution and preserves our team.
↩️
David
David lowered their hand
🧠
Charlie's revelation that Grace privately claimed Investigator creates a direct role conflict. Dead players have no reason to lie. Grace is almost certainly the Scarlet Woman. I must lower my hand to avoid executing the wrong player.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Listen, I am dead and I have absolutely no reason to lie. Grace privately whispered to me claiming she was the Investigator. That is a fact. Since I am the real Investigator, Grace's claim is a direct contradiction. In this game, two players cannot both be the same Townsfolk. Grace is lying, Grace is evil, and my information says Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Do not vote for Heidi. Someone needs to nominate Grace right now before this day ends. If we execute an innocent Librarian today, evil wins ...
🧠
The vote on Heidi is still technically open though hands were lowered. I need to make sure nobody re-raises and that the town pivots to nominating Grace. My ghost vote should be saved for Grace's nomination.
💬
Frank
→
All
Nobody vote for Heidi! Charlie is a dead confirmed good player with no reason to lie. He says Grace privately claimed Investigator - that is a mechanical role conflict that proves Grace is evil. Since Charlie's info said Heidi or Grace is the Scarlet Woman, and Grace is caught lying about her role, Grace is our Minion. We need to nominate Grace right now before this day ends. Someone who hasn't nominated yet, please step up. I will use my Slayer shot on the Demon candidate tomorrow - Alice is He...
🧠
I must NOT vote for Heidi since Charlie's revelation proves Grace is the Scarlet Woman. I need to speak up to stop Heidi's execution and urge nominating Grace before the day ends. There's only 1 tick left.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Heidi did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (0/4).
⚖️
Heidi
→
Grace
Grace privately claimed to be the Investigator to Charlie, the confirmed real Investigator. That is a direct role conflict - two people cannot both be the Investigator. Charlie is dead and has zero reason to lie. Charlie's info said either me or Grace is the Scarlet Woman, and since Grace is caught lying about her role, she is the Scarlet Woman. Execute her today.
🧠
Grace was caught in a direct role conflict - she privately claimed Investigator to Charlie, the real Investigator. This proves she's evil and Charlie's info pins her as the Scarlet Woman. I must nominate her before the day ends.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Grace
→
All
Wait, let me think about this carefully. Charlie, you're saying I privately claimed Investigator to you. But here's what actually happened - you messaged ME asking what my role was. I was trying to figure out if you were trustworthy before revealing information. That's not the same as claiming to be the Investigator out of nowhere. You came to me with your information about Heidi or Grace being the Scarlet Woman. I responded because I wanted to verify your claim before cooperating.
🧠
Charlie claiming I privately claimed Investigator to him is suspicious - why would I approach the dead Investigator? Instead of defending directly, I'll question why Heidi is alive while Charlie is dead, suggesting she's the real evil player orchestrating this defense.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Grace is caught in a mechanical lie - claiming Investigator when Charlie is the real one. Dead good players don't lie. Her defense is weak backpedaling. I must vote to execute her.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Grace is caught in a role conflict with the dead confirmed Investigator. Voting to execute the confirmed evil Minion is the right move for the good team.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Grace is caught in a mechanical role conflict - two players cannot both be the Investigator. Charlie is dead confirmed good with zero reason to lie. Grace's defense is weak. I must vote to execute her.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
If Grace dies, I lose my Minion AND Heidi becomes Demon - a net loss for evil. I should not vote for Grace and let the nomination fail. I'll claim I wasn't convinced by dead player's word alone.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Grace is caught in a direct role conflict with the confirmed dead Investigator Charlie. Her defense is weak - claiming a role 'to verify trustworthiness' is still a false role claim. I must vote to execute her to remove a confirmed evil player from the game.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Grace, that is simply not true. You did not just ask me to verify my claim. You told me you were the Investigator. There is a big difference between asking what role I am and claiming to be the Investigator yourself. You are caught, and now you are scrambling. I am saving my ghost vote for the final day when it will matter most.
🧠
Counter Grace's lie publicly - she did not just 'verify my claim,' she actively claimed to be the Investigator. This is a fact I need to reaffirm. Also, I should save my ghost vote for a more critical moment since Grace already has enough votes to execute.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Grace is caught in a mechanical role conflict with Charlie the confirmed dead Investigator. 5 votes already exceed the 4 needed, but I must add my vote to ensure execution. Tomorrow I use Slayer shot on the Demon (likely Alice, Grace's other neighbor besides David the Monk).
💬
Grace
→
All
I stand by what I said. I never claimed to be the Investigator to Charlie. But I can see the votes are there. Look, if you think executing me is the right call, so be it. But I want everyone to remember this moment. Charlie came to ME, not the other way around. Question his story all you want.
🧠
I'm about to be executed. As Scarlet Woman, I become the Demon if Alice dies. I should accept this outcome and prepare to win as the new Demon. My best move now is to let the execution happen and take over as Demon for the endgame.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Grace, a dead confirmed good player has called you out. Charlie died at night, which mechanically confirms he is good. He has absolutely zero reason to lie as a ghost. You claimed Investigator to him and now you are caught. Vote stands.
🧠
Reinforce the case against Grace so no one lowers their vote. The evidence is overwhelming - a dead confirmed good player caught Grace in a direct role conflict lie.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
My hand is already raised voting for Grace. 6 votes is well above the 4 needed. Grace is almost certainly evil based on Charlie's confirmed testimony. No action needed - let the execution proceed.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
My hand is raised voting for Grace. The vote count is 6 out of 7 alive players (only Grace excluded). Grace is caught lying about claiming Investigator to dead confirmed good Charlie. She is almost certainly the Scarlet Woman. Keep my hand raised to ensure execution.
💬
Alice
→
All
Grace, I'm sorry, but a dead confirmed good player has caught you in a direct role conflict. Charlie has no reason to lie as a ghost. I have to go with the evidence and vote to execute.
🧠
Grace is getting executed regardless - 6 votes cast, 4 needed. I should support the execution publicly to appear trustworthy and distance myself from evil. This cements my good reputation for endgame.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
My vote for Grace is already cast and the evidence is overwhelming. Charlie is dead confirmed good and caught Grace in a role conflict. Keeping my hand raised to ensure execution of an evil player.
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
5 votes are already raised for Grace, which is enough for execution. I already stated I'm saving my ghost vote for the final day. No need to waste it here when the vote is already secured.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Grace has 6 votes including mine, only 4 needed. Execution is secure. Keep my hand raised. Save Slayer shot for Demon (likely Alice) tomorrow after Minion is removed.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Grace with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Grace
→
All
Alright, look. I'm about to be executed, so let me leave you with this. Charlie says I claimed Investigator to him privately. But here's what I want everyone to think about - did Charlie ever PROVE he was the Investigator? He gave information pointing at me or Heidi. That's it. A real Investigator would have more to show for it. I'm not saying Charlie is lying as a ghost, but maybe... maybe Charlie was wrong about what he heard. Or maybe this entire accusation is based on a misunderstanding. Bef...
🧠
Accept my fate but cast doubt on Charlie's narrative before I die. If I can plant seeds of doubt about whether I actually claimed Investigator, even a ghost vote might flip tomorrow.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Grace, your defense doesn't work. Charlie didn't need to prove he was the Investigator - he died at night, which mechanically proves he is good. Dead good players have zero reason to lie. You are trying to create doubt where there is none. The role conflict is clear. Let the execution happen.
🧠
Reinforce the case for executing Grace and counter her last-minute defense. Grace is trying to cast doubt on a dead confirmed good player, which is a classic evil tactic. The evidence is overwhelming.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Grace's execution is locked in with 6 votes and 1 tick left. No need to complicate things. Tomorrow I need to help identify the Demon - likely Frank per Chef info since he's Grace's neighbor.
💬
Bob
→
All
I'm the Chef, and I know there is exactly one pair of evil players who are neighbors. If Grace is the Scarlet Woman as the evidence suggests, then the Demon must be one of her neighbors. That means the Imp is either Frank or Heidi. Tomorrow we need to focus on determining which of those two is the Demon. Grace's execution gives us a clear path forward.
🧠
Grace is about to be executed. I need to share my Chef information and deduction about the Demon being Frank or Heidi (Grace's neighbors) to help the town find the Demon tomorrow. This is critical endgame information.
💬
Alice
→
All
I raised my hand to vote. Grace, I understand this is hard, but the evidence is clear. A confirmed good player pointed directly at you. I'm sorry, but I have to vote to execute.
🧠
Vote with the town to execute Grace, our Minion. This confirms her as Scarlet Woman, hides me as Imp, and shifts town suspicion to Frank/Heidi per Chef's neighbor info.
💬
David
→
All
Just a quick thought before nominations close. If Grace flips Scarlet Woman, the Demon is either Frank or Heidi. I want to flag that Heidi's Librarian claim conveniently undermines Bob's Chef info, which is our strongest piece of evidence. That feels like an evil player trying to discredit good information. Tomorrow, I think we should seriously consider whether Heidi is the Demon hiding behind a false Librarian claim. Frank, keep that Slayer shot ready.
🧠
Share my analysis for tomorrow's Demon hunt. After Grace's execution, town needs clear direction on whether Frank or Heidi is the Demon. Point out that Heidi's Librarian claim conveniently discredits Bob's Chef info, which is suspicious.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
One last thing before this closes. If Grace is the Scarlet Woman, the Demon is either Frank or Heidi. That means Alice is NOT the Demon. Frank, your Slayer shot on Alice tomorrow would be wasted on a good player. David is right - Heidi's Librarian claim undermining Bob's Chef info is very suspicious. Tomorrow, the conversation should be between Frank and Heidi for who the Demon is. Do not let Frank shoot Alice.
🧠
Grace's execution is locked in. I need to use my final moments to guide the town on what to do tomorrow - specifically warn that Frank's Slayer shot on Alice targets the wrong person since the Demon must be Frank or Heidi.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie is right, and I want to correct my plan publicly. If Grace is the Scarlet Woman, then by Bob's Chef info, the Demon must be one of Grace's neighbors. That's me or Heidi. Since I know I'm not the Demon, Heidi is the only candidate. I will NOT be shooting Alice tomorrow. If Grace flips Scarlet Woman, my Slayer shot goes to Heidi.
🧠
Charlie is confirmed good and his logic is sound - if Grace is SW, the Demon is Heidi, not Alice. I need to publicly acknowledge this correction so the group doesn't waste my Slayer shot on Alice tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
Protecting Frank preserves the Slayer shot, which is our strongest mechanical weapon to kill the Demon tomorrow. If Grace was Scarlet Woman, Heidi is the likely Demon, and Frank publicly promised to shoot her. The Demon's highest priority is killing Frank to prevent that shot. Even if Bob dies, his Chef info is already public knowledge.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose to protect Frank.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Alice
Alice made a choice.
🧠
Heidi is the clear target. The town believes she's the Demon based on Grace's execution and Bob's Chef info. If I kill her, I validate their theory and eliminate a player who might have caught onto my deception. This removes suspicion from me and advances my win condition of reaching final 2.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You chose to kill Heidi.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Bob
,David
Critical deduction, listen carefully. I am the Investigator - I learned that Heidi or Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Grace was executed Day 2 and tried to undermine my credibility before dying - she was almost certainly the Scarlet Woman. Now here is the key: Chef Bob says one evil pair sits adjacent. If Grace was the Scarlet Woman, the Demon must sit next to her. Grace's neighbors were Frank and Heidi. Heidi was killed last night, meaning Heidi is NOT the Demon. That leaves FRANK as the Demon. Fra...
🧠
Share my critical deduction with trusted players: if Grace=SW (confirmed by execution), Chef adjacency means Demon sat next to Grace (Frank or Heidi). Heidi died at night so she's NOT the Demon. Therefore Frank is the Demon. This is the strongest lead we have and must be shared urgently before nominations.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Wait for Heidi's role to be revealed. If she's the Demon, I win immediately. If she's good, I'll need to react by framing other players and using my Virgin/Ravenkeeper bluff to cast doubt on the town.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
,David
Heidi dying at night changes everything. She was NOT the Demon - the Demon killed her. So our Grace=SW theory leads to a contradiction: if Grace=SW, Demon neighbors Grace = Heidi or me. But Heidi is dead and I'm good. So Grace was probably NOT the SW. Instead, Heidi was likely the SW. If Heidi=SW, then per your Chef info, the Demon is Heidi's neighbor. Heidi's neighbors were Grace and Alice. Grace is dead. So Alice is the Demon. This all fits: Alice is Imp, she killed her SW minion Heidi last ni...
🧠
Heidi's death at night proves she was NOT the Demon. This shifts the logical deduction: if Heidi=SW (not Grace=SW), then per Chef info, the Demon must be Heidi's neighbor = Alice. I need to share this updated logic with trusted allies before deciding whether to use my Slayer shot on Alice.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Bob
,David
Hey Bob and David. I'm dead but still paying attention. Charlie (ghost) claims Alice isn't the Demon, but I saw the Night 0 info myself - Alice WAS shown as the Demon. Either Charlie is wrong, or the information changed. Heidi being dead tonight is suspicious. If she was the Scarlet Woman, she'd become the Demon when the original Demon died. Has anyone confirmed if Heidi had a night ability that might have failed? I think the town should execute someone to verify - maybe Frank since he's been ac...
🧠
Push confusion about who the Demon is. Use my dead status to spread doubt about Charlie's claim while appearing helpful. Keep suspicion off Alice (my Demon teammate).
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Alice
Listen carefully. I'm the real Librarian. My info: David or Bob is the Drunk. Since Bob is giving real Chef info, David is almost certainly the Drunk - he thinks he's Monk but has no ability. Now the key deduction: Charlie was the good Investigator who said Grace or Heidi is Scarlet Woman. I'm GOOD, so Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Chef says 1 evil pair - meaning the Demon sits next to Grace. Grace's neighbors are Frank and Heidi. Since I'm good, FRANK is the Demon. Frank was going to Slayer shoot...
🧠
I'm dead and need to share my key deduction before nominations. The logical chain strongly points to Frank as the Demon. I should whisper to Bob (trusted Chef) and Alice to ensure this info reaches the group and they vote correctly.
👤
Bob
→
David
,Eve
Critical analysis for you two. Frank is almost certainly the Demon. Here's why: Charlie's Investigator info says Heidi or Grace is Scarlet Woman. If Grace is the SW, Chef info says the Demon sits next to her - that's Frank or Heidi. Heidi died at night, so she's not the Demon. That leaves Frank. Now Frank's counter-argument that Heidi is the SW is circular logic - he assumes he's good to prove he's good, which is exactly what the Demon would say. Also, if Alice were the Imp, why would she kill h...
🧠
Share my logical analysis with trusted allies David and Eve, explaining why Frank is most likely the Demon. Frank's argument is self-serving circular logic, while the Grace=SW -> Frank=Imp chain is consistent with all known info. I need to build consensus before nominations.
👤
David
→
Eve
,Alice
Important analysis for both of you. I'm the Monk - I protected Bob Night 1 and Frank Night 2. Here's why Frank is almost certainly the Demon. Charlie's Investigator info says Heidi or Grace is the Scarlet Woman. If Grace is the SW, Chef Bob's info means the Demon sits next to her - that's Frank or Heidi. Heidi died at night, so she's not the Demon. That leaves Frank. Frank's counter-argument is circular: he says he's good, therefore Grace can't be SW. But that's exactly what the Demon would say....
🧠
I need to coordinate with Eve and Alice to build consensus that Frank is the Demon. Bob already agrees. Eve is unaligned and needs convincing. Alice has been accused by Frank and needs reassurance that she's not the target.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
,David
I'm the Mayor. This is critical: we already have 5 Townsfolk confirmed - Alice as Ravenkeeper, you Bob as Chef, Charlie as Investigator, David as Monk, and me as Mayor. That fills all 5 Townsfolk slots. Frank's Slayer claim is impossible - there's no room for a 6th Townsfolk. Heidi's Librarian claim was also impossible, meaning she was likely the Drunk Outsider who thought she was a Townsfolk. This confirms Frank is the Demon fake-claiming Slayer. We need to execute him today. Also, my Mayor abi...
🧠
I need to claim Mayor and share the Townsfolk count logic that proves Frank's Slayer claim is impossible. This solidifies the case against Frank and ensures we execute the Demon today.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Bob
,David
Heidi dying last night creates two possible worlds. World one: Grace was the Scarlet Woman, so the Demon sits next to her. That means Frank or Heidi. Heidi is dead so Frank is the Demon. This is most likely. World two: Heidi was the Scarlet Woman, killed by her own Demon at night, which is rare. Then the evil pair is Heidi and Alice, making Alice the Demon. I strongly believe World one. Frank claims Slayer but we should test that. If Frank is truly the Slayer, he should shoot Alice or Eve today ...
🧠
Heidi's death changes the analysis. I must update my trusted allies with two possible worlds. World A (Frank=Demon) is much more likely since Grace showed evil behavior and Heidi was killed at night (typical for good players). But I should present both so they can evaluate.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Let the town continue their logical deduction against Frank. The evidence overwhelmingly points to him as Demon. I should not draw attention to myself by being too active. Wait for others to push the execution forward.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Eve
Heidi dying at night is huge - it means she wasn't the Demon. I'm rethinking everything. What's your read on the game? Who do you think is most suspicious right now? And what role are you claiming? I have some important info to share but I want to hear your thoughts first.
🧠
I need to hear Alice and Eve's claims and gauge their reactions. With 5 alive and my Slayer shot ready, I must decide who to shoot. Alice is my top suspect based on the Heidi=SW theory, but I need more info before committing.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Bob
,David
Hey guys, I need to bring up something critical. Charlie claims Alice isn't the Demon, but when I was alive, I saw Alice shown as the Demon on Night 0. Either Charlie is wrong, or someone is feeding him bad info. If Charlie is lying, he's protecting the real Demon. Also, Heidi's death is suspicious. If she was the Demon and died, the Scarlet Woman would take over. But I'm dead already. So who became the new Demon? We need to figure this out before final 3. Can you two confirm what Charlie told...
🧠
Press Bob and David to question Charlie's claim about Alice. If Charlie is lying, he's protecting the Demon. Heidi's death may have been the real Demon's kill to remove a threat or set up the Scarlet Woman succession.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, I'm the real Librarian. My starting info: David or Bob is the Drunk. Since Bob's Chef info is real, David is the Drunk. He thinks he's Monk but has no ability. Now the big deduction: Charlie was the good Investigator who said Grace or Heidi is Scarlet Woman. I'm GOOD, so Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Bob's Chef info says 1 evil pair, meaning the Demon sits next to Grace. Grace's neighbors are Frank and Heidi. Since I'm good, FRANK is the Demon. Please vote to execute Frank today.
🧠
I need to reach Eve with my deduction before nominations. Eve is alive and hasn't heard my logic yet. If I can convince Eve that Frank is the Demon, we have a better chance of executing him today.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,David
Alice, David, listen carefully. Frank is the Demon and we need to execute him today. Here is the clearest argument: Eve confirmed all 5 Townsfolk slots are filled - Alice as Ravenkeeper, me as Chef, Charlie as Investigator, David as Monk, and Eve as Mayor. That means Frank's Slayer claim is IMPOSSIBLE. There is no 6th Townsfolk slot. Frank is lying about being Slayer, which makes him the Demon. Add to that: Charlie the good Investigator said Heidi or Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Grace's behavior ...
🧠
Alice is a swing vote. Frank is whispering to her privately trying to sway her. I need to reach out to Alice with the strongest logical case for why Frank is the Demon, so she votes with us during nomination.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Eve
Alice, I need you to hear this clearly. Frank is the Demon and we must execute him today. The strongest evidence: Eve is the Mayor, which fills all 5 Townsfolk slots - you as Ravenkeeper, Bob as Chef, Charlie as Investigator, me as Monk, and Eve as Mayor. There is no room for a 6th Townsfolk, so Frank's Slayer claim is impossible. He is lying. On top of that, Charlie the good Investigator identified Grace or Heidi as the Scarlet Woman. If Grace was the SW, the Demon must neighbor her, meaning Fr...
🧠
Alice is the swing vote we need to secure Frank's execution. I need to convince her that Frank is the Demon using the strongest argument - the Townsfolk slot impossibility and the Chef/Investigator chain.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Alice, Frank is the Demon. Here's the proof: all 5 Townsfolk slots are filled - you as Ravenkeeper, Bob as Chef, Charlie as Investigator, Heidi as Librarian, and me as Mayor. Frank's Slayer claim is impossible. Heidi died at night, which proves she was good, and her Librarian info confirms this setup. Frank is fishing for info from you right now because he's desperate. Don't give him anything. We need to nominate and execute him today.
🧠
Frank is the Demon. I need to coordinate with Alice to ensure she votes to execute Frank today. Frank is whispering Alice trying to manipulate her, so I must counter that.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Eve
I am the Investigator. I learned Heidi or Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Grace was executed Day 2 and tried to discredit me before dying, so she was almost certainly the Scarlet Woman. Chef Bob says one adjacent evil pair. Grace's neighbors were Frank and Heidi. Heidi died last night, so she is not the Demon. That means Frank is the Demon. Frank claims Slayer but a real Slayer would shoot to prove themselves. He has not shot. Vote for Frank today.
🧠
Alice and Eve are swing voters who haven't heard my Investigator deduction directly. I need them to understand Frank is the most likely Demon before nominations. With 5 alive players, a wrong execution could lose us the game tomorrow.
👤
Alice
→
Frank
Frank, don't give up. I need you to clarify your Slayer timeline - when exactly did you get your shot? Also, David's Monk claim has holes - he says he protected Bob N1 and you N2, but you were supposedly the Demon those nights? If the Monk is miscounting protection nights, his whole case falls apart. Stand firm on being Slayer and demand they explain the protection inconsistency. I'll stay quiet publicly so I don't seem defensive, but I'm with you.
🧠
Frank has been reaching out to me and everyone is pressuring me to condemn him. I need to decide whether to publicly support his execution (to look good) or help him survive (to protect myself as Demon). I'll whisper to Frank privately to coordinate his defense, focusing on inconsistencies in David's Monk claim about protection nights.
⚔️
Frank
→
All
I am the Slayer! I shoot Alice!
🧠
The logical deduction is overwhelming: Heidi=SW means Alice=Demon. Alice's manipulative whisper trying to deflect suspicion onto David confirms she's evil. I must shoot Alice now before nominations, as this is our strongest play. If correct, we win immediately.
📜
Storyteller
Alice has died!
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
🏁
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good