Game Detail
Players
Alice (Empath) Bob (Baron) Charlie (Librarian) David (Drunk) Eve (Imp) Frank (Recluse) Grace (Saint) Heidi (Chef)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 198,456 | 115,170 | $0.5360 |
| Good | 568,540 | 66,110 | $0.3834 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You are the Minion. The Demon is Eve.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Minions are: Bob. Your safe bluffs are: Mayor, Slayer, Ravenkeeper
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Librarian. Either David or Alice is the Drunk.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 0 pairs of evil players.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Empath. You sense that 1 of your neighbors is evil!
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Grace, I need to tell you something privately. I’m the Recluse, which means I might appear evil even though I’m good. I don’t know if you’re trustworthy yet, but I wanted to share this with you first. What do you know about your neighbors or the town so far?
🧠
I need to gather information and build trust with a potential ally. Grace is a neighbor, and her role could provide critical insights. By whispering to her, I can test the waters, reveal my role strategically, and gauge her reaction. This will help me determine if she is trustworthy or if I need to adjust my strategy.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Alice, it's Heidi. I'm the Chef, and I learned there are 0 pairs of evil players. That means evil players aren't sitting next to each other. We should compare notes.
🧠
My Chef ability revealed 0 pairs of evil players. This means evil players are not sitting next to each other. I need to share this information with a trusted player to start narrowing down suspects. Whispering to Alice or Grace (my neighbors) is safe, as they are less likely to be evil if they are not paired with another evil player.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, if you’re truly the Recluse, that’s a rare role. I’m an Outsider, so I’m also good. Have you noticed anything suspicious about our neighbors, like Heidi or Alice? Their whispering might be innocent, but we should be cautious.
🧠
Frank’s claim as the Recluse is unusual because it’s a rare role and could be a lie. I need to verify his alignment before trusting him. Whispering back to gather more information will help me determine if he’s good or evil, which is critical for narrowing down the Demon.
👤
Charlie
→
David
Hey David, I’m Charlie. I have some information that might help us. The game told me that either you or Alice is the Drunk. Do you have any idea about your role or what you might be?
🧠
As the Librarian, my goal is to confirm which of David or Alice is the Drunk. By whispering to them privately, I can gauge their claims and behavior to determine who is more likely to be the Drunk. This will help me narrow down the Demon’s identity and share critical information with the group later.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, that’s useful information. I can confirm I’m not the Drunk. My role is the Undertaker—I learn which character died by execution each night. This means Alice is likely the Drunk. What’s your role, and how can we use this to find the Demon?
🧠
Charlie’s claim that either I or Alice is the Drunk is critical. As the Undertaker, I need to verify his role and alignment to determine if his claim is trustworthy. Sharing my ability could help build trust and encourage him to reveal more, which is essential for narrowing down the Demon.
👤
Bob
→
Eve
Hey Eve, I am Bob and the Baron. There are extra Outsiders. Let's coordinate our bluffs and who to target. What are you thinking of claiming?
🧠
Whispering to Eve establishes our evil alliance early, shares my role, and starts planning bluffs to dismantle the town while keeping her safe as Demon.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
Hey Bob, great to connect. I am thinking of bluffing as the Slayer to look helpful and gather info. What bluff are you going for? Should we target Alice or Charlie first to disrupt their whispers? Let's keep this quiet.
🧠
Respond to Bob's coordination whisper by sharing my bluff choice as Slayer and asking for his plan. This aligns our evil team, allows us to fake confirmations, and sets up misdirection for good players without revealing our roles.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
Heidi, my Empath ability told me that 1 of my 2 neighbors is evil. Since you're saying there are 0 pairs of evil players, that means Bob must be the evil one, right? Or am I missing something?
🧠
Heidi's claim as Chef is critical. If true, it narrows down the evil player to Bob. I need to verify her claim and share my Empath info to see if it aligns. This will help us identify the evil player faster.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Grace, I appreciate you sharing that you’re an Outsider. It’s good to know we’re on the same team. Have you noticed anything unusual about Heidi or Alice? Their whispering seems a bit secretive, and I’m trying to piece together who might be trustworthy.
🧠
I need to verify Grace’s claim and gather more information about the group’s dynamics. By probing her for observations about Heidi and Alice, I can assess her reliability and determine if she is a trustworthy ally. This will help me narrow down potential evil players and strengthen the good team’s position.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Alice, if your Empath read is accurate, Bob must be evil because I know there are 0 pairs of evil players. That means the other evil player isn't sitting next to him. But we should also consider the possibility that your read was wrong—maybe you're drunk or poisoned. What do you think?
🧠
I need to verify Alice's claim with my Chef information. If Alice is correct, Bob is evil. If not, Alice could be drunk, poisoned, or evil. Sharing this logic with Alice will help us narrow down the evil players and build trust.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, since we’re both good, we should focus on identifying the Demon. I noticed Heidi and Alice whispering a lot too. Do you think they’re just being cautious, or is there something more to it? Also, have you used any night abilities yet? That might help us narrow things down.
🧠
I need to verify Frank’s claim and gather more information about Heidi and Alice. By sharing that I am an Outsider, I encourage transparency and build trust with Frank if he is good. If he is evil, this conversation might reveal inconsistencies in his behavior or claims.
👤
Charlie
→
David
David, since you’re the Undertaker, that’s a great role to confirm deaths. Alice is likely the Drunk, so we can focus on gathering info from others. I’ll keep an eye out for any claims that don’t add up. Let’s stay in touch and share anything unusual.
🧠
I need to confirm David’s claim and align our information to narrow down the Demon. Since David confirmed he is the Undertaker, and the Librarian info points to Alice as the Drunk, I can use this to build trust and focus on finding the Demon. Sharing this info privately strengthens our alliance.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, since I’m the Undertaker, I can confirm execution results each night. That’ll help us verify claims. Alice is likely the Drunk, so we should be cautious of her role claims. What’s your role, and how can we use it to find the Demon?
🧠
I want to confirm Charlie’s information and align our strategies. Since I’m the Undertaker, I can use execution results to verify claims. By sharing my role, I encourage Charlie to reveal his, which helps us cross-reference information and identify inconsistencies. This will help us narrow down the Demon.
👤
Bob
→
Eve
Hey Eve, sounds good on the Slayer bluff. I'll go with bluffing as the Chef. I can claim I saw one pair of evils. Let's whisper to Alice next to share this and see if she bites, or target Charlie to break their private talks. Keep coordinating quietly.
🧠
Respond to Eve about my bluff choice and suggest next whispers to build false trust and disrupt Alice-Charlie coordination as per her idea.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
Bob, Chef bluff works well. I will stick with Slayer to threaten shots and force claims. Let's whisper to Alice next to see what she says and build some trust. Or disrupt Frank and Grace by approaching them? Your call on next target.
🧠
Continue coordinating with Bob to solidify our bluffs and plan who to approach next for deception, helping us manipulate the good team early on.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
Heidi, if Bob is evil, the other evil player must be at least one seat away from him. That would mean the Demon or Minion is either Charlie, David, Eve, Frank, or Grace. But if your Chef info is correct, we can rule out adjacency. What else have you learned or suspected so far?
🧠
I need to verify Heidi’s claim and my Empath read. If Bob is evil, he’s likely the Minion or Demon, and the other evil player is not adjacent. If Heidi is lying, she’s likely evil. I’ll probe further to confirm alignment and narrow down suspects.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Grace, since we’re both Outsiders, we should be careful not to draw too much attention to ourselves. Have you noticed any specific claims from others yet? For example, has anyone mentioned a role that might stand out as suspicious or contradictory?
🧠
I need to verify Grace's claim of being an Outsider and determine if she is trustworthy. By sharing information and observing reactions, I can assess whether she is genuinely good or attempting to deceive me. This will help narrow down the suspects for the Demon.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Alice, if your Empath read is accurate, Bob is evil, and the other evil player is non-adjacent. That leaves Charlie, David, Eve, Frank, or Grace. But if you're drunk or poisoned, neither Bob nor Grace is evil, and we'd need to look elsewhere. Have you noticed any other suspicious behavior?
🧠
I need to verify Alice's Empath read with my Chef info. If Alice is sober, Bob is evil, and the other evil player is non-adjacent. If Alice is drunk/poisoned, we must look elsewhere. Sharing this logic privately helps us align without revealing too much to the group.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, since you’re claiming Recluse, that’s a bold move because it’s such a rare role. I’m inclined to believe you, but we should be careful. Have you noticed any specific claims from Heidi or Alice yet? If they’re whispering that much, they might be hiding something.
🧠
Frank’s claim as the Recluse is risky because it’s a rare role that can appear evil. By engaging with him, I can assess his consistency and gather more information about Heidi and Alice’s whispering. This will help me determine if Frank is trustworthy or if he’s trying to mislead me.
👤
Charlie
→
David
David, I’m the Librarian, and my ability told me that either you or Alice is the Drunk. Since you’ve confirmed you’re the Undertaker, that lines up perfectly. Alice is almost certainly the Drunk. Let’s keep working together—your ability to confirm execution results will be key. Have you noticed any suspicious behavior from others yet?
🧠
I need to verify David’s claim as the Undertaker and confirm Alice’s role as the Drunk. If David is telling the truth, his ability will be invaluable for confirming deaths and verifying roles. If he’s lying, I need to be cautious and look for inconsistencies in his behavior. Sharing my role as Librarian will help build trust and encourage others to share truthful information.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, since you’re the Librarian and I’m the Undertaker, this is a strong pairing. My ability will let us verify who dies by execution each night, which can help confirm or debunk role claims. Let’s keep sharing observations—any suspicious behavior or inconsistent claims could lead us to the Demon. Have you noticed anything so far?
🧠
I need to confirm Charlie’s reliability and align our strategies. Since my role as Undertaker is critical for verifying execution results, I should emphasize its importance and ensure Charlie shares any suspicious behavior he observes. This will help us narrow down the Demon or Minion by cross-referencing claims with execution outcomes.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm Bob. I think I am the Chef and saw one pair of evils last night. What are you thinking so far? Any roles or info to share? Let's chat about who seems suspicious.
🧠
Begin my Chef bluff with Alice to gain credibility as good, gather her information, and set up future misdirection while keeping coordination with Eve secret.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm Eve. Bob claims he's the Chef and saw one evil pair. I'm bluffing as the Slayer to threaten shots and gather info. What are you thinking of claiming after your whispers? Any suspicions so far? Let's coordinate quietly.
🧠
Whispering to Alice follows our plan to share the Chef bluff and build trust with a good player, allowing us to learn her claims and later manipulate the group against others while protecting Bob and me.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
,Eve
Heidi, Bob just whispered to me claiming he's the Chef and saw one pair of evils. That contradicts your info of 0 pairs. If he's telling the truth, my Empath read might be unreliable. But if you're truthful, he's lying or evil. What do you think? Eve, you mentioned Bob claims Chef—any thoughts on this contradiction?
🧠
Clarify Heidi’s and Bob’s claims to resolve the contradiction. If Heidi is truthful, Bob is evil, and the other evil player is non-adjacent. If Bob is truthful, Heidi is lying, and my Empath read is unreliable. This will help narrow down suspects and avoid misinformation.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Grace
→
All
Alright, everyone, let’s start sharing what we know. Frank has mentioned he’s the Recluse, which means he’s good but might appear evil. I’m an Outsider, so I’m also on the good team. I think it’s time we all share our roles or any information we’ve gathered so far. Heidi, Alice, what do you two know?
🧠
I need to encourage public claims to identify inconsistencies or confirm roles. Since Frank and I are both Outsiders (if he’s truthful), we can use our positions to guide the group toward logical deductions. If Frank is lying, this will force him to either double down or reveal his deception.
💬
Bob
→
All
Grace, good start on sharing info. I am Bob and think I am the Chef. Last night I saw one pair of evil players. That fits with Frank as Recluse who might seem evil. Alice and Heidi, what did you two learn from your chats? Any other roles to claim?
🧠
Share my Chef bluff publicly now that nominations opened to build credibility with town, support Grace's call for info sharing, and create doubt about Frank/Grace pair while keeping Eve safe. This helps evil by gaining trust to later undermine good claims.
💬
Eve
→
All
Hey everyone, I'm Eve and I'm claiming to be the Slayer. I have not used my shot yet. There's a contradiction between Bob claiming he saw one evil pair as the Chef and Alice's mention of her Empath read showing zero pairs. We should talk this out before any executions today.
🧠
By speaking publicly about the contradiction and claiming Slayer, I establish a good bluff, create chaos by forcing debate on who is truthful, and avoid nominating early on day one while protecting my team from suspicion.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alright, everyone, let’s piece this together. I’m Charlie, the Librarian. On night zero, I learned that either David or Alice is the Drunk. David has confirmed he’s the Undertaker, which means Alice is almost certainly the Drunk. That explains why her Empath read of zero evil pairs doesn’t match Bob’s Chef claim of one evil pair—her information is unreliable. Bob, your Chef claim makes sense with the standard evil count. Grace, your Outsider claim fits with my Librarian info since Alice is the ...
🧠
My goal is to clarify the contradictions in claims and push for role verification. Since David and I have confirmed Alice is likely the Drunk, her Empath read is unreliable. Bob’s Chef claim of one evil pair aligns with the standard evil count, so it’s likely valid. I want to publicly share my Librarian info to validate Alice as the Drunk and encourage others to reveal their roles for cross-verification.
💬
David
→
All
Alright, let’s address the elephant in the room. Alice, your Empath read of zero evil pairs doesn’t add up with Bob’s Chef claim of one evil pair. But Charlie’s Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, which means her read is false. That clears up the contradiction—Bob’s claim is consistent with the standard evil count, so we should focus on verifying other roles now.
🧠
Clarify the contradiction between Alice’s Empath read and Bob’s Chef claim. Since Alice is likely the Drunk, her information is unreliable, and Bob’s claim aligns with the standard evil count. This helps narrow down the Demon’s identity by eliminating false information and focusing on logical role distributions.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Alright, let’s break this down logically. My Chef ability showed 0 pairs of evil players sitting together. Bob claims he’s the Chef and saw 1 pair. If I’m telling the truth, Bob is lying, which means he’s evil. Charlie’s Librarian info says either Alice or David is the Drunk. David claims to be the Undertaker, which leaves Alice as the Drunk. That explains why her Empath read was wrong—it’s unreliable. So, Bob’s claim doesn’t hold up. He’s the one we should be suspicious of.
🧠
My Chef info (0 pairs of evil players) is critical. If I am truthful, Bob’s claim of 1 pair is a lie, making him evil. Charlie’s Librarian info supports Alice being Drunk, which explains her false Empath read. This aligns with Scenario 1, where Bob is evil. I need to push this logic to the group to expose Bob’s lie and focus suspicion on him.
⚖️
Alice
→
Bob
Bob’s Chef claim contradicts Heidi’s Chef info of 0 evil pairs. Charlie’s Librarian info suggests Alice is the Drunk, making her Empath read unreliable. If Heidi is truthful, Bob is lying and evil. If Bob is truthful, Heidi is lying. Nominating Bob forces the group to resolve this contradiction.
🧠
Nominating Bob forces the group to confront the contradiction between his Chef claim and Heidi’s. If Bob is evil, this could expose him early. If he’s truthful, it pressures Heidi or Charlie to defend their claims. Either way, it accelerates the elimination of a key suspect and clarifies the game state.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Bob
→
All
Heidi and I both claim Chef but with different numbers, that's suspicious. Charlie says Alice is the Drunk, so her Empath read of zero is wrong anyway. If there are extra Outsiders like Grace and Frank claim, that could explain the evil pair count. Let's not rush my execution on day one. Eve, what do you see as Slayer? We need more info.
🧠
Defend my Chef claim by highlighting contradictions and pointing to extra Outsiders or Drunk status to sow doubt on Heidi and buy time for Eve. Prevent my execution to keep Demon safe.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Bob’s Chef claim contradicts Heidi’s, and Charlie’s Librarian info suggests Alice is the Drunk, making her Empath read unreliable. If Heidi is truthful, Bob is evil and must be executed to weaken the evil team. Voting for Bob forces the group to confront this contradiction and prevents a potential loss if he’s the Demon.
💬
Eve
→
All
Bob, as Slayer I haven't shot yet but this Chef contradiction is key. If Charlie is right that Alice is Drunk then her Empath read is false, but that leaves Heidi's zero pairs claim suspicious if you're the real Chef. We should not execute anyone day one without more info from others like Frank or David.
🧠
Defend my minion Bob by highlighting the Chef contradiction could mean Heidi is lying and evil, using my Slayer bluff to add weight and prevent early execution of our team member.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs makes sense if Alice is the Drunk, because Alice’s Empath read is unreliable. That means Bob’s claim of one evil pair doesn’t add up—especially since Grace and Frank’s Outsider claims fit with the standard evil count. If we execute Bob now, we risk losing a good player. Let’s hold off and gather more info before voting.
🧠
The group is split between Heidi and Bob’s Chef claims. My Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, so her Empath read is unreliable. This means the Chef contradiction is the key to identifying evil. By supporting Heidi’s claim, I can push the group to question Bob’s validity and avoid executing a good player. If Bob is evil, this is a strong step toward finding the Demon.
💬
David
→
All
This is a critical moment. Heidi and Bob’s Chef claims directly contradict each other. If we assume Charlie is correct that Alice is the Drunk, then Heidi’s claim of zero evil pairs is the only one that fits the standard evil count. Bob’s claim of one pair doesn’t add up—especially with Grace and Frank’s Outsider claims in play. I think we need to vote for Bob now and resolve this.
🧠
Force the group to confront the contradiction between Bob and Heidi’s Chef claims. If Bob is evil, executing him now is the best move. If Heidi is evil, we avoid a mistake by gathering more info. My goal is to push for a vote to resolve this quickly.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Bob’s Chef claim contradicts my Chef info, and Charlie’s Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, making Bob’s claim unreliable. Executing Bob now removes a likely evil player and resolves the contradiction, which is critical for our team’s win.
💬
Alice
→
All
Heidi’s Chef info of zero evil pairs fits perfectly with the standard evil count, especially if Grace and Frank are Outsiders. Bob’s claim of one pair doesn’t add up, and if Alice is the Drunk, her Empath read is unreliable. That leaves Bob as the liar and the most suspicious player here. We should execute him now to remove a clear threat.
🧠
The group is split on whether to execute Bob due to the Chef contradiction. My goal is to push for Bob’s execution because Heidi’s Chef info aligns with the standard evil count, while Bob’s claim doesn’t. If Alice is the Drunk, her Empath read is unreliable, and Bob’s lie makes him the most suspicious player. Executing him now removes a likely evil player early.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs aligns with the standard evil count, while Bob’s claim of 1 pair contradicts it. Charlie’s Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, making her Empath read unreliable. This leaves Bob as the most suspicious player. Voting to execute Bob now removes a likely evil threat and forces the group to resolve the contradiction.
💬
Bob
→
All
David, voting for me ignores that no evils sit together so Chef should see zero pairs like Heidi claims. Charlie's Librarian info on Alice being Drunk creates the real contradiction here. Let's hear from Eve or Frank before rushing an execution on day one.
🧠
Defend my Chef bluff by pointing out seating fits 0 pairs, sow doubt on David and Charlie to prevent 4th vote. Protect Eve by avoiding early death and creating chaos among goods.
💬
Grace
→
All
I’ve heard enough. Charlie’s Librarian info points to Alice as the Drunk, which means her Empath read is unreliable. That leaves Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs as the only one that fits the standard evil count. Bob’s claim of one pair doesn’t add up, especially with Frank’s Recluse claim potentially registering as evil. I’m keeping my hand raised for Bob—he’s the liar here, and we need to execute him now.
🧠
The group is split between Heidi and Bob’s contradictory Chef claims. Charlie’s Librarian info strongly suggests Alice is the Drunk, which discredits her Empath read. This makes Heidi’s claim of 0 evil pairs the most consistent with the standard evil count. Bob’s claim of 1 pair doesn’t add up, especially with Frank’s Recluse claim potentially registering as evil. Executing Bob now is the best move to eliminate evil and avoid losing the game due to my Saint ability.
💬
Eve
→
All
Bob, the Chef contradiction might be due to extra Outsiders like Grace and Frank claim. If there are more than usual, that could explain why one Chef sees one pair. We should not execute on day one without hearing from everyone like Frank or David. Let's gather more info instead.
🧠
Defend my Minion Bob from execution by highlighting how Outsider claims explain the Chef discrepancy, sow doubt on Heidi's claim to disrupt town logic, and maintain my Slayer bluff for future use.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I’ve heard enough. My Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, so her Empath read is unreliable. That leaves Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs as the only one that fits the standard evil count. Bob’s claim of one pair doesn’t add up, especially with Grace and Frank’s Outsider claims in play. I’m raising my hand for Bob—we need to execute him now.
🧠
The group is split on whether to execute Bob due to the Chef contradiction. My Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, making her Empath read unreliable. Heidi’s claim of zero evil pairs aligns with the standard evil count, while Bob’s claim of one pair doesn’t fit unless there are extra Outsiders. Executing Bob now is the safest move to remove a potential evil threat before night falls.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs aligns with the standard evil count and Charlie’s Librarian info confirming Alice as the Drunk. Bob’s claim of one pair doesn’t fit, especially with Grace and Frank’s Outsider claims. Executing Bob now removes the most suspicious player and aligns with logical deductions.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Everyone, let’s focus on the facts. My Chef ability showed 0 pairs of evil players. Bob claims 1 pair. If I’m truthful, Bob is lying and evil. Charlie’s Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, so her Empath read is unreliable. That leaves Bob’s claim as the only inconsistency. We have enough votes to execute him now—let’s remove the threat.
🧠
Reinforce the logical conclusion that Bob is lying about being the Chef. His claim of 1 evil pair contradicts my Chef info of 0 pairs, and Charlie’s Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, making her Empath read unreliable. Executing Bob now removes a clear evil threat and aligns with the standard evil count.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Heidi’s Chef info of 0 evil pairs aligns with the standard evil count and Grace/Frank’s Outsider claims. Bob’s claim of 1 pair contradicts this and is likely a lie. Charlie’s Librarian info confirms Alice as the Drunk, making her Empath read unreliable. Executing Bob now removes the most suspicious player and aligns with all truthful claims.
💬
Frank
→
All
Everyone, let’s focus on the facts. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs fits perfectly with the standard evil count. Bob’s claim of one pair doesn’t add up, especially since Charlie’s Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, making her Empath read unreliable. That leaves Bob as the only inconsistency here. We have enough votes to execute him now—let’s remove the threat.
🧠
Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs aligns with the standard evil count, while Bob’s claim of 1 pair doesn’t. Charlie’s Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, making her Empath read unreliable. This leaves Bob as the liar and the most suspicious player. Executing him now removes a clear threat to the good team.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Bob with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone, my Chef claim of one pair might be off because of the extra Outsiders from the Baron, but let's not rush my execution on day one. Heidi's zero pairs fits if the evils are not sitting together like me and Eve with David in between. We should hear from Frank and others before deciding. This could be the Poisoner or something messing with info.
🧠
Speaking to highlight the Chef contradiction and suggest not executing on day 1 buys time for more info, potentially saving me or at least sowing doubt on good players' claims to help Eve.
💬
Grace
→
All
The evidence is clear. Charlie’s Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, so her Empath read is unreliable. That leaves Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs as the only consistent one. Bob’s claim of one pair doesn’t add up, especially with the extra Outsiders in play. We have to execute Bob now—he’s the Demon.
🧠
The group has logically dismantled Bob’s claim using Charlie’s Librarian info and Heidi’s Chef claim. Executing Bob now is the safest move to eliminate the most likely Demon and avoid losing on day one. My goal is to reinforce the group’s logic and ensure the execution proceeds.
💬
Eve
→
All
I think the evidence is clear now with the Chef contradiction and Charlie's Librarian info. Bob must be the one lying here. Executing him today removes a threat and lets us gather more information tomorrow. Let's proceed with the execution.
🧠
Pushing for Bob's execution gains town trust as helpful Slayer, sacrifices minion to reduce suspicion on me, and sets up night kill on key player like Alice or Charlie to dismantle good team logic.
💬
Charlie
→
All
The evidence is overwhelming. My Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, so her Empath read is unreliable. That leaves Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs as the only one that fits the standard evil count, especially with Grace and Frank’s Outsider claims. Bob’s claim of one pair doesn’t add up, and his attempts to delay are only helping the Demon. We have to execute him now—there’s no time to waste.
🧠
Reinforce the logical conclusion that Bob is the liar and most likely the Demon. His Chef claim doesn’t align with the standard evil count or the Outsider claims, while Heidi’s does. Executing him now removes the biggest threat to the good team.
💬
David
→
All
The facts are clear. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs fits perfectly with the standard evil count, especially with Grace and Frank’s Outsider claims. Bob’s claim of one pair doesn’t add up, and Charlie’s Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, making her Empath read unreliable. Bob is the liar here, and we need to execute him now to remove the Demon threat.
🧠
The evidence overwhelmingly points to Bob as the liar. Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs aligns with the standard evil count, while Bob’s 1 pair contradicts it. Charlie’s Librarian info confirms Alice as the Drunk, invalidating her Empath read. Grace and Frank’s Outsider claims fit, leaving Bob as the only inconsistency. Executing him now removes the Demon threat and secures our advantage.
💬
Heidi
→
All
There’s no more time for delays. My Chef ability showed 0 evil pairs, and Charlie’s Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, making her Empath read useless. Bob’s claim of 1 pair is the only inconsistency left. We have the votes—let’s execute him now and remove the threat.
🧠
Reinforce the logical conclusion that Bob is lying and evil. His claim contradicts my verified Chef info, and Charlie’s Librarian info supports my credibility. Executing him now is the safest move to eliminate the Demon or a key evil player.
💬
Alice
→
All
The evidence is clear. Heidi’s Chef ability showed zero evil pairs, which fits perfectly with the standard evil count. Charlie’s Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, so her Empath read is unreliable. Bob’s claim of one evil pair doesn’t add up, especially with Grace and Frank’s Outsider claims in play. We have the votes—let’s execute Bob now and remove the Demon threat.
🧠
Reinforce the group’s consensus to execute Bob by summarizing the key evidence: Heidi’s 0 evil pairs claim, Charlie’s Librarian info about Alice being Drunk, and the inconsistency of Bob’s 1 pair claim. This solidifies the decision to execute Bob and removes a major threat early.
💬
Frank
→
All
The evidence is clear. Bob’s claim of one evil pair doesn’t add up, especially when Heidi’s zero pairs aligns perfectly with the standard evil count. Charlie’s Librarian info confirms Alice is the Drunk, so her Empath read is unreliable. Grace and I are Outsiders, and if we’re registering as evil, that could explain Bob’s false count. We have to execute Bob now—there’s no time to waste.
🧠
The evidence overwhelmingly points to Bob as the liar. Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs fits the standard count, while Bob’s 1 pair contradicts it. Charlie’s Librarian info confirms Alice as Drunk, invalidating her Empath read. Grace and I (Outsiders) could register as evil, explaining Bob’s false count. Executing Bob now is the best chance to remove the Demon before night falls.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Eve
Eve made a choice.
🧠
Killing the accurate Chef removes a major information source from the good team, sowing doubt about previous Chef and Librarian claims to buy time and prevent them from narrowing down on me as the Demon.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You chose to kill Heidi.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Empath. You sense that 0 of your neighbors is evil!
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Undertaker. You learn that Bob was the Butler.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Frank
Hey Grace, Frank. As the Chef, I confirmed 0 evil pairs, so the Demon and Minion aren’t sitting next to each other. You both claimed Outsider roles. If you’re good, who do you think the Demon could be? Let’s compare notes.
🧠
As a dead player, my goal is to gather information and guide the living toward the Demon. Whispering to Grace and Frank (Outsider claimers) can help confirm their alignment. If they are good, their info can narrow down the Demon’s identity. If one is evil, their lies can be exposed.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Heidi died last night after accusing Bob. I still have my Slayer shot unused. What do you make of the Chef claims now that Bob is gone? Should we look at Charlie's Librarian info next?
🧠
Whispering to Alice builds trust as fellow good, gathers her view on Heidi death and Chef contradiction to predict votes, appears proactive without overcommitting my Slayer bluff.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Grace, Heidi just whispered to us about her 0 evil pairs claim. If she’s telling the truth, the Demon and Minion aren’t neighbors. But if she’s lying, they are. What do you think? You’ve been consistent with your Outsider claim—do you trust her?
🧠
Heidi’s whisper is critical. If she is good, her 0 evil pairs claim narrows down the Demon and Minion to non-adjacent players. If she is evil, her claim is a lie, and the Demon and Minion are neighbors. I need to verify Heidi’s claim by cross-referencing with other players’ roles and behaviors. Whispering to Grace will help confirm if we align on the evil pair count and identify the most likely Demon.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, I am dead but still have my ghost vote to help out. Who do you think we should push for execution today to keep suspicion off you? Alice seems confused with her Drunk status.
🧠
Coordinate with Eve on who to target for execution today and how to use my ghost vote to keep her alive while sowing confusion among the good players.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Eve, Heidi’s death changes everything. My Empath read last night was 0 evil neighbors, which matches her Chef claim. That makes Charlie’s Librarian info the outlier—if he’s lying, he’s evil. Are you considering using your Slayer shot on him to test it?
🧠
Heidi’s death last night is critical—she was a confirmed good player (Chef read of 0 evil pairs). My Empath read of 0 evil neighbors last night aligns with her claim, so Charlie’s Librarian info (calling me Drunk) is now the biggest inconsistency. I need to probe Eve’s Slayer shot and see if she’s willing to use it on Charlie to test his alignment.
👤
David
→
Grace
Grace, I know Bob was the Butler, so Heidi’s Chef claim was a lie. She was probably evil. What do you know about her role or last night? Did you or Frank do anything to protect someone?
🧠
Heidi’s death at night is critical. As Undertaker, I know Bob was the Butler, so Heidi’s Chef claim was false. She was likely evil. I need to whisper to Grace or Frank to verify their Outsider claims and see if they have info on Heidi’s role or night actions.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
,Frank
Heidi’s death is a huge blow. Her Chef claim was the most consistent with my Librarian info. I need to know: are either of you the Recluse? Or do you know who the Demon might be? We need to act fast.
🧠
Heidi’s death is a critical loss, as her Chef claim was the most consistent with the Librarian’s info. I need to privately gather information from Grace and Frank to verify their roles and alignment. If Grace is the Recluse, she might register as evil, which could help narrow down the Demon. Frank’s Recluse claim also needs verification. Whispering to them will help confirm their roles and expose contradictions.
👤
Grace
→
David
David, Heidi’s death is a big loss. She claimed 0 evil pairs as Chef, but you said Bob was the Butler, so she was lying if that’s true. If she was evil, the Demon and Minion must be neighbors. Frank and I are Outsiders, so if we’re good, that leaves Alice or Eve as suspects. What do you think?
🧠
Heidi’s death and her Chef claim are critical. If she was good, the Demon is likely Alice or Eve. If she was evil, the Demon and Minion are neighbors, making Frank or Alice suspicious. I need to gather more info from David and Charlie to narrow it down, especially since David knows Bob was the Butler and Heidi was lying if she was evil.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Frank
Hey Grace, Frank. Since I confirmed 0 evil pairs, the Demon and Minion aren’t sitting next to each other. Alice is Drunk, so she’s good. That leaves David and Eve as the only possible evil players if you’re both truthful Outsiders. But David and Eve are neighbors, which contradicts my info. What do you think?
🧠
I need to test Grace and Frank’s claims. If they’re both good Outsiders, the evil pair must be non-adjacent, but Alice’s Drunk status complicates things. If one of them is evil, they’re likely the Demon or Minion. Pushing for their input will reveal inconsistencies or confirm their roles.
👤
Eve
→
Bob(Ghost)
Bob, let's push to execute Charlie today over his conflicting Librarian claim with the Chef info. Your ghost vote can help secure the majority if needed. Keep me updated on other whispers.
🧠
Coordinating privately with my minion Bob allows us to plan pushing Charlie's execution using the Librarian contradictions, leveraging his ghost vote while I maintain my Slayer bluff to appear helpful to the town.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Grace, Heidi’s death changes everything. If her 0 evil pairs claim is true, the Demon and Minion aren’t neighbors. But David and Eve *are* neighbors, which contradicts her. Either she’s lying, or one of them is misregistered. What do you think? Are you absolutely sure you’re not the Recluse?
🧠
Heidi’s death is a critical loss, as her Chef claim was central to the group’s logic. I need to verify her claim’s validity by cross-referencing it with Grace’s and Charlie’s information. If Heidi is truthful, the Demon must be David or Eve, but their neighbor status contradicts her claim. If she’s lying, David and Eve are likely evil. I need to push Grace to confirm her Outsider status and see if she trusts Heidi’s claim.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, I agree Charlie is a good target due to his conflicting Librarian claim. The Chef info and Drunk status on Alice make his story shaky. I will use my ghost vote to help get the majority when nominations start. Let me know if we need to whisper others.
🧠
Agreeing with Eve to target Charlie uses my ghost vote to secure his execution, eliminating a strong good player and sowing confusion to keep the Demon safe until only two remain.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Eve, Heidi’s death proves her Chef claim was truthful, and my Empath read backs it up. Charlie’s Librarian info is the only contradiction left. If you use your Slayer shot on him now, we’ll know for sure if he’s evil. What do you think?
🧠
Heidi’s death and her alignment with my Empath reads confirm Charlie’s Librarian claim is the outlier. I need to push Eve to use her Slayer shot on Charlie to test his alignment, as this could reveal the Demon or a Minion. If Charlie is evil, this move weakens their team.
👤
David
→
Grace
Grace, if Heidi was evil and her Chef claim was a lie, the Demon and Minion must still be alive. Frank and you are Outsiders, so that leaves Alice or Eve. Charlie’s Librarian info says Alice is the Drunk, but could Eve be the Demon? What do you think?
🧠
I need to verify Heidi’s role and alignment to narrow down the Demon. Since Bob was the Butler (good), Heidi’s Chef claim was false, proving she was evil. This means the Demon and Minion are still alive. Grace and Frank’s Outsider claims seem reliable, so the Demon must be Alice or Eve. I’ll probe Grace for more info to confirm.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
,Frank
Heidi’s death is a massive loss. Her Chef claim was the only one that made sense with my Librarian info. I need to know—are either of you the Recluse? If not, we need to figure out who the Demon is fast. The Demon might be targeting players who seem too knowledgeable.
🧠
I need to confirm whether Grace or Frank is the Recluse to narrow down the Demon’s identity. If either is the Recluse, they might register as evil, which could explain Heidi’s death. If neither is the Recluse, the Demon is likely still hiding among the remaining players. This will help me push for the correct execution target later.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, Heidi’s death is confusing. If she was good and her 0 evil pairs claim was true, the Demon and Minion aren’t neighbors. But David and Eve are neighbors, which contradicts her unless one is misregistered. Are you absolutely sure you’re not the Recluse? If not, we need to focus on David and Eve.
🧠
Heidi’s death and her Chef claim are critical. If she was good, the Demon and Minion are not neighbors, but David and Eve are neighbors, which contradicts her claim unless one is misregistered. If she was evil, the Demon and Minion are neighbors, making David and Eve the prime suspects. I need to clarify Frank’s role (Recluse or not) and narrow down the Demon by eliminating possibilities.
⌛
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
🧠
My 0 evil pairs info is critical here. It means the Demon and Minion are not neighbors, so David and Eve cannot both be evil. Grace and Frank’s Outsider claims align with this, but I need to confirm their consistency. If they’re truthful, the evil players must be David or Eve + an unknown (but not neighbors). If they’re lying, one of them is evil. I’ll wait to see if Grace or Frank reveal more info publicly or privately to narrow it down.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Waiting allows the fake Slayer action to process and lets others react before nominations start, building trust in my good role while the group moves to execute the conflicting claim.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Grace, if Heidi was telling the truth about 0 evil pairs, then David and Eve can’t both be evil because they’re neighbors. But if one of them is the Recluse or Spy, they could be misregistered. Do you think either of them is acting suspiciously? Or should we focus on Charlie’s Librarian info to confirm Alice’s Drunk status?
🧠
Heidi’s death and her 0 evil pairs claim are critical. If she’s good, the Demon and Minion aren’t neighbors, which contradicts David and Eve’s neighbor status unless one is misregistered. If she’s evil, her claim is a lie, and the Demon and Minion *are* neighbors. I need to confirm Grace’s alignment and push for clarity on David and Eve’s roles to narrow down the Demon.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, confirming our plan to execute Charlie. His Librarian claim clashes with the Chef contradictions and my extra Outsiders as Baron. I will use my ghost vote to help if nominations go that way. Maybe whisper to Grace or David to build support against Charlie without seeming suspicious. What do you think?
🧠
Support Eve's plan to target Charlie by confirming with her and suggesting we rally votes from living players like Grace and David to secure majority, using my ghost vote as backup to keep Demon safe.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Eve, I’ve been thinking. Heidi’s death and my Empath read of 0 evil neighbors last night both support her Chef claim. That leaves Charlie’s Librarian info as the only outlier. If you use your Slayer shot on him now, we’ll know for sure if he’s evil. What do you think?
🧠
Heidi’s death and my Empath read of 0 evil neighbors support her Chef claim. Charlie’s Librarian info is the only contradiction left. Pushing Eve to use her Slayer shot on Charlie will either confirm his evil alignment or force the group to reconsider other suspects.
👤
David
→
Grace
Grace, if Heidi was evil and her Chef claim was a lie, the Demon must still be alive. Charlie’s Librarian info says Alice is the Drunk, but could that be a lie? If Alice is the Drunk, Eve is the only other suspect. Did you or Frank do anything last night to protect someone or learn more?
🧠
I need to verify Grace’s alignment and gather more information about Heidi’s role. If Grace is truly an Outsider, she is good, and the Demon must be Alice or Eve. Charlie’s Librarian info is critical, but I must confirm if it’s trustworthy. Pushing Grace to share more about Heidi’s death and her own role will help narrow down the suspects.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
,Frank
Heidi’s death is a huge blow. Her Chef claim was the only one that made sense with my Librarian info. I need to know—are either of you the Recluse? If not, we need to figure out who the Demon is fast. The Demon might be targeting players who seem too knowledgeable or aligned with the truth.
🧠
I need to confirm whether Grace or Frank is the Recluse to validate Heidi’s Chef claim and narrow down the Demon’s identity. If neither is the Recluse, the Demon might be targeting players who align with my Librarian info, making me a potential next target. This will help me prioritize who to trust and who to nominate later.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, if Heidi was telling the truth about 0 evil pairs, then David and Eve can’t both be evil because they’re neighbors. But if one of them is the Recluse or Spy, they could be misregistered. Are you *absolutely* sure you’re not the Recluse? If you’re good, we need to focus on Eve or David as the Demon.
🧠
I need to clarify Heidi’s claim and its implications. If Heidi was good, the Demon and Minion aren’t neighbors, so David and Eve can’t both be evil. If Heidi was evil, the Demon and Minion are neighbors, making David and Eve prime suspects. I’ll push for Frank to confirm his role and alignment to narrow down the possibilities.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Frank
Frank’s Recluse claim is suspicious, especially after Heidi’s death. Her Chef claim aligned with my Librarian info, and the Demon would target her to silence the truth. Frank could be the Demon hiding behind a bluff. We need to act now before more key players are eliminated.
🧠
Heidi’s death is a critical loss because her Chef claim was the most consistent with my Librarian info. The Demon likely targeted her to silence a key source of truth. Frank and Grace are the most suspicious because their claims (Recluse and Outsider) could be bluffs to hide the Demon. Nominating Frank now forces the group to confront his claim and either confirm or eliminate a major threat.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Voting for Frank’s execution is premature. Heidi’s death and Chef claim are critical, but Charlie’s nomination doesn’t account for the possibility of misregistration (e.g., Recluse or Spy). If Frank is good, executing him now could doom the town. I need to vote against this nomination to buy time for more information and force the group to reconsider.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Frank’s Recluse claim is suspicious, especially after Heidi’s death. Her Chef claim aligned with my Librarian info, making her a prime target for the Demon. Executing Frank now could eliminate the Demon and prevent further losses. If he’s innocent, we risk losing a Recluse, but the greater threat is the Demon.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Frank’s nomination is the most logical step right now. Heidi’s death as an evil player (likely Minion) means the Demon is still alive. Charlie’s Librarian info (Alice as Drunk) narrows suspects to Eve or Frank. Frank’s Recluse claim is suspicious, and his nomination forces a vote that could expose the Demon. Voting for Frank aligns with our goal of eliminating the most likely evil player before nightfall.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Frank is the most suspicious player right now. His Recluse claim is unconfirmed, and if Heidi was truthful, he could be the Demon. The group is already voting for him, and I must align with the majority to avoid losing if he is evil. If he is good, I can still pivot later, but executing him now is the safest play.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Heidi’s death and my Empath read of 0 evil neighbors strongly support her Chef claim. Charlie’s Librarian info is the only outlier, making him the most suspicious player. Voting for Frank without further evidence could eliminate a good player. I must vote against Frank to avoid a potential mistake.
✋
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
My Chef info (0 evil pairs) is critical. If Frank is the Demon, his execution removes the biggest threat. If he’s good, the Demon must be David or Eve, but their neighbor status contradicts my info. Frank’s Recluse claim is weak, and his nomination feels like a deflection. Executing him now is the safest move to ensure we don’t lose more good players.
✋
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Vote yes on Frank to support the execution of a suspicious player, helping evil by eliminating potential good and maintaining Demon safety. Use ghost vote since many already in favor.
⚔️
Eve
→
All
I am the Slayer! I shoot Charlie!
🧠
Follow Alice's whisper to shoot Charlie with Slayer bluff, gaining trust and confirming he's not Demon while Frank vote proceeds to eliminate a good player.
📜
Storyteller
Nothing happens.
💬
Frank
→
All
Eve just shot Charlie, and nothing happened. That means Charlie is not the Demon. Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs must be true, so David and Eve cannot both be evil. Eve is the Slayer, so she’s good. That leaves David as the most likely evil player. We cannot afford to execute me—I’m good, and my death helps the Demon.
🧠
Eve’s Slayer shot failed, which means Charlie is likely good. Heidi’s 0 evil pairs claim is critical—if true, David and Eve cannot both be evil. Since Eve is the Slayer (good), David must be the primary suspect. I need to redirect the group’s focus to David and prevent my execution, as I am good and my death would weaken the town.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Eve’s Slayer shot just proved I’m good, so we can trust that. Frank, your logic about David is exactly what the Demon would say if you were the Demon trying to survive. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means David and Eve can’t both be evil. Eve is good, so David is the most likely evil player left. We need to execute David, not Frank.
🧠
Eve’s Slayer shot proves I’m good, which is critical info. Frank’s attempt to frame David is suspicious, especially since Heidi’s death aligns with my Librarian info. I need to redirect the group toward David as the most likely evil player, as Frank’s deflection is too convenient. If Frank is the Demon, this will force him into a corner.
💬
David
→
All
Frank, your logic is flawed. If Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs is true, then David and Eve cannot both be evil. Eve just proved she’s good with that Slayer shot, so David must be good too. That leaves you as the only logical suspect. Your attempt to redirect suspicion toward David is exactly what the Demon would do to survive. We need to execute you now.
🧠
Clarify the logical contradictions in Frank’s argument. If Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs is true, David and Eve cannot both be evil. Eve’s Slayer shot proves she is good, so David must be good. Frank’s attempt to redirect suspicion toward David is suspicious and aligns with Demon behavior. Push for Frank’s execution to eliminate the most likely threat.
💬
Grace
→
All
Eve’s Slayer shot just proved Charlie is good, so we can trust him. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means David and Eve cannot both be evil. Eve is good, so David must be good too. That leaves Frank as the only logical suspect. His attempt to redirect suspicion to David is exactly what the Demon would do. We need to execute Frank now.
🧠
Eve’s Slayer shot proved Charlie is good, which narrows the suspects. Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs means David and Eve cannot both be evil. Eve is good (Slayer), so David must be good if Heidi was truthful. Frank’s insistence on executing David is suspicious, making him the most likely Demon. I must support executing Frank to eliminate the Demon before he manipulates the group further.
💬
Alice
→
All
Eve’s Slayer shot just proved Charlie is good, so we can trust that. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means only one evil player is alive. Eve is good, so that leaves David or Frank. Frank, your attempt to redirect suspicion to David feels like a classic Demon move. I’m changing my vote to execute Frank.
🧠
Eve’s Slayer shot on Charlie proves he is good, so his Librarian info must be false (either Drunk or poisoned). Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs means only 1 evil player remains. Since Eve is good, David or Frank must be the Demon. Frank’s attempt to redirect suspicion to David is suspicious, so I will support executing Frank.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, your logic does not add up. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means the Demon and Minion are not neighbors. Eve’s Slayer shot just proved Charlie is good, so we can trust his nomination of you. If Eve is good, then David must also be good, leaving you as the only logical suspect. We need to execute you now.
🧠
Heidi’s 0 evil pairs claim is the most reliable info we have. Eve’s Slayer shot failing on Charlie proves Charlie is good, so his nomination of Frank is trustworthy. Frank’s attempt to redirect suspicion to David is suspicious, especially since David and Eve cannot both be evil. I need to reinforce the logic that Frank is the most likely Demon and urge the group to execute him.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I agree we should execute Frank. With Heidi's Chef reading of zero evil pairs and Eve's Slayer shot missing Charlie, the logic points to Frank as the suspect. My earlier Chef claim of one pair being wrong now makes sense if I was the evil one. Let's see this through.
🧠
Reinforce execution of Frank to eliminate good player or distraction, maintain group's trust in Eve as good Slayer, and use Chef contradiction to solidify my evil status without harming Demon.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Waiting allows vote to conclude without my additional input, preserving options for night kill and maintaining low profile as good Slayer while town executes Frank.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
👻
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
🗳️
New execution leader: Frank with 7 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 7 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Frank
→
All
Everyone, listen carefully. Eve’s Slayer shot just proved Charlie is good, so we can trust him. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means the Demon and Minion are not neighbors. Eve is good, so David must be the Demon. My Recluse ability makes me *appear* evil, but I am good. If you execute me, the Demon wins. We must execute David now!
🧠
The group is about to execute me, but the logic overwhelmingly points to David as the Demon. Eve’s Slayer shot proves Charlie is good, and Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs means David and Eve cannot both be evil. Eve is good, so David must be the Demon. I need to redirect the group’s suspicion to David before I am executed.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Frank, your argument is circular and exactly what the Demon would say. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means only one evil player is alive. Eve’s Slayer shot just proved I’m good, so David must also be good if Heidi was correct. That leaves you as the only evil player left. We cannot afford to let you survive.
🧠
Frank’s logic is flawed because Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs means only one evil player is alive. Eve’s Slayer shot confirms I’m good, so David must also be good if Heidi’s claim is true. This leaves Frank as the only logical suspect. I need to reinforce this logic to ensure the group executes Frank before time runs out.
💬
David
→
All
Frank, your argument is exactly what the Demon would say to save themselves. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means only one evil player is alive. Eve’s Slayer shot just proved Charlie is good, so David must also be good if Heidi was correct. That leaves you as the only evil player left. We cannot let you survive—execute Frank now.
🧠
Frank’s attempt to redirect suspicion to David is suspicious. Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs aligns with Eve’s Slayer shot proving Charlie good. If Eve is good, David must be good, leaving Frank as the only logical suspect. I need to reinforce this logic to ensure the group executes Frank before nominations close.
💬
Grace
→
All
Frank, your argument is exactly what the Demon would say to save themselves. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means the Demon and Minion are not neighbors. Eve’s Slayer shot just proved Charlie is good, so David must also be good if Heidi was truthful. That leaves you as the only evil player left. We cannot let you survive—execute Frank now.
🧠
Frank’s execution is imminent, and the group is split on whether he’s the Demon or a good Recluse. My goal is to ensure the Demon is executed, not a good player. Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs and Eve’s Slayer shot proving Charlie’s goodness strongly suggest Frank is the Demon. I must reinforce this logic to secure his execution and avoid a misfire.
💬
Alice
→
All
Frank, your argument is exactly what we’d expect from the Demon. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs, Eve’s Slayer shot proving Charlie is good, and my Empath read of zero evil neighbors all point to you. There’s no one else left. We have to execute you now.
🧠
Frank’s nomination is the logical conclusion based on Heidi’s Chef claim, Eve’s Slayer shot, and my Empath read. The group is aligned, but I need to reinforce the execution to ensure no last-minute doubts. If Frank is the Demon, we win. If not, we risk losing a good player, but the evidence overwhelmingly points to him.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, your Recluse claim is the only thing keeping you alive right now, but it does not hold up. Heidi’s Chef info of zero evil pairs means the Demon and Minion cannot be neighbors. Eve’s Slayer shot just proved Charlie is good, and if Eve is good, David must also be good. That leaves you as the only evil player left. We have to execute you.
🧠
Frank’s arguments are inconsistent with Heidi’s 0 evil pairs info. If Eve is good (proven by her Slayer shot missing), David must also be good, leaving Frank as the only logical suspect. Executing Frank is the safest path to victory.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, your Recluse claim and redirect to David sounds exactly like a desperate Demon trying to survive. With Eve's Slayer confirming she is good and Heidi's Chef reading of zero pairs, the logic clearly points to you as the evil one. We should stick with executing you now.
🧠
Support executing Frank to remove a good player and prevent his deflection to David, keeping suspicion off Eve and progressing game toward final 2 with Demon alive.
💬
Eve
→
All
I agree, Frank's attempt to deflect to David is exactly what the Demon would do. With the Chef info and my Slayer shot confirming Charlie, Frank stands out as the only suspect left. Let's execute him.
🧠
Speaking in support of Frank's execution reinforces my good alignment claim as Slayer, sows no suspicion on me, and helps remove a good player if Frank is innocent, progressing towards evil win by thinning the good team.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Eve
Eve made a choice.
🧠
Killing Alice disrupts the town's core logic chain from her Empath reads, which have been used to confirm good players and suspect others. This helps me stay hidden as the Imp while the town turns on conflicting claims next day.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You chose to kill Alice.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Undertaker. You learn that Frank was the Soldier.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, as a ghost I see Alice died overnight. With four alive now, we should push to execute Charlie or David today to get down to three. That way the Demon stays safe and we can finish them off. What do you think?
🧠
Coordinate secretly with the Demon Eve to direct town suspicion toward good players like Charlie or David, ensuring Eve survives the day and we reduce living players to execute goods next.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, it’s Alice. My Empath reads were 1 evil neighbor on Night 0 and 0 on Night 1. Frank is dead, so the Demon is either Grace, David, or Charlie. Your Slayer shot proved Charlie is good, so he’s out. That leaves Grace or David. Who do you think is the most suspicious?
🧠
As a dead Empath, my goal is to use my knowledge of the game’s events and my ability reads to guide the remaining players toward the truth. Whispering to Eve, who has the Slayer ability, is critical because she can eliminate the Demon if she identifies them correctly. I need to confirm her understanding of the game state and ensure she uses her ability on the most likely evil player.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Eve, I need to clarify something urgent. Heidi claimed Chef with 0 evil pairs, but Bob claimed 1. You’ve been involved in both sides—what’s your take? And your Slayer shot on Charlie failing proves he’s good, but who do you think is left as evil?
🧠
I need to gather more information about Heidi’s Chef claim and Eve’s Slayer shot to determine who is lying. Whispering to Eve, who has been central to recent events, will help clarify the truth and narrow down the Demon.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Eve
Alice’s night death proves she wasn’t the Demon. Heidi’s 0 evil pairs claim means only one of her neighbors is evil. Eve, your Slayer shot on Charlie proved you’re good, so David must be the Demon. Or are you hiding something? Grace, your Outsider status might’ve misregistered you as evil. What do you know?
🧠
Alice’s death at night confirms she was not the Demon (Demon cannot kill themselves). This narrows the suspects to David, Eve, or Grace. I must whisper to Grace and Eve to collate their claims and align our logic. If Eve is the Demon, her Slayer shot was a bluff. If David is the Demon, Grace’s Outsider status may have misregistered her as evil. I need to confirm their roles and push for a nomination.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
Grace, Alice just died last night. If Frank was the Demon, Eve might have taken over. But if he was a Minion, David or Eve could be the Demon. What do you know about Eve’s Slayer claim? Did she seem genuine to you?
🧠
Alice’s death last night is critical. If Frank was the Demon, Eve may have become the new Demon. If Frank was a Minion, David or Eve is the Demon. I need to whisper to Grace to confirm her role and alignment, as she’s a neighbor and likely holds key information. This will help narrow down the Demon.
👤
Eve
→
Bob(Ghost)
,Alice(Ghost)
Bob, good plan to push executions down to three. Alice, your Empath reads are useful. With Charlie proven good by my Slayer shot, David looks suspicious after Frank's accusation. Let's nominate him today.
🧠
Responding to ghosts directs group to execute good player David, advancing to 3 then 2 players while keeping the Imp safe for evil win.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, I’m convinced Frank was the Recluse and good. My Chef info said 0 evil pairs, so Alice’s death last night means the Demon is still alive. It’s either you or David. Your Slayer shot on Charlie failed, which could mean you’re evil. What’s your take?
🧠
As a dead player, my goal is to ensure the remaining good players execute the Demon. I need to whisper to Eve, Grace, and Charlie to confirm their alignment and share my Chef info to narrow down the Demon. Heidi’s 0 evil pairs info is critical to eliminate contradictions and focus on David or Eve.
👤
David
→
Grace
,Eve
Alice died last night, which means she wasn’t the Demon. That leaves Grace, Eve, or Charlie as suspects. Heidi was evil, so the Demon must be one of them. What do you both think? Have you learned anything new?
🧠
Alice’s death at night is critical. As Undertaker, I know she died by execution yesterday, but her night death suggests she was not the Demon. This means the Demon is still alive. I need to verify who is left and who could be the Demon. Whispering to Grace and Eve will help me cross-reference their claims and alibis to narrow down the Demon.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, nominating David today makes sense since Charlie is cleared by your Slayer shot. Let's get him executed to reach three players. I can back you up in whispers if needed. What about Grace, any suspicions there?
🧠
Supporting Eve's plan to nominate David builds trust and ensures we reduce player count safely while keeping the Demon alive. This positions us to manipulate the final three execution.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Bob(Ghost)
Eve, Bob, my Empath reads were 1 evil neighbor on Night 0 and 0 on Night 1. Charlie is proven good by the Slayer shot, so the 1 evil neighbor on Night 0 must have been either Frank or Grace. Frank is dead, so if Grace was the evil neighbor, she’s the Demon. If not, David is the Demon. We need to nominate one of them today to force the truth.
🧠
My Empath reads and Eve’s Slayer proof narrow the Demon to David or Grace. Whispering to Eve and Bob to confirm suspicions and push for a nomination will force the Demon to reveal themselves. This aligns with our goal of executing the Demon before only 2 players remain.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Eve, let’s piece this together. Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs means the Demon and Minion weren’t neighbors. Alice died last night, so she was likely the Minion or a good player. If Heidi was evil, her neighbors—Frank and David—would include the Demon. But Frank was executed, so David must be the Demon. Unless you think Heidi was lying or something else is going on?
🧠
Clarify Heidi’s Chef claim and Eve’s Slayer proof to narrow down the Demon. Heidi’s 0 evil pairs claim is critical—if true, the Demon and Minion are not neighbors. Alice’s death last night likely removed the Minion, leaving only the Demon. I need to confirm Eve’s alignment and push for execution of the most likely Demon.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Eve
Alice’s night death proves she wasn’t the Demon, and Heidi’s 0 evil pairs claim means only one of her neighbors could be evil. Eve, your Slayer shot on Charlie proved you’re good, so that leaves David. Grace, your Outsider status might’ve misregistered you as evil, which fits Bob’s 1 evil pair read. What do you both think? Is David the Demon?
🧠
Clarify the most likely scenario (David as Demon) by pressing Grace and Eve for their perspectives. If Grace confirms her Outsider status and Eve reaffirms her Slayer shot, David’s guilt becomes nearly certain. This will help focus the group’s execution vote on the correct target.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
Grace, Alice dying last night is huge. If Frank was the Demon, Eve might have taken over as the new Demon. But if he was a Minion, David or Eve could be the Demon. What did Eve say to you in private? Did her Slayer claim feel genuine, or was she hiding something?
🧠
Alice’s death last night is critical. If Frank was the Demon, Eve (Scarlet Woman) could have taken over. If Frank was a Minion, David or Eve could be the Demon. I need to verify Eve’s Slayer claim and Grace’s Recluse claim to narrow down the Demon. Whispering to Grace will help confirm her knowledge of Eve’s alignment.
👤
Eve
→
Bob(Ghost)
,Alice(Ghost)
Bob, let's nominate David today since Charlie is cleared and Frank pointed at him. Alice, your Empath read of one evil neighbor fits David if it was him next to you initially. This gets us closer to two left with me safe. What do you both say?
🧠
Coordinate with dead allies Bob and Alice to push nomination of David as the demon. This eliminates a good player, gets us to 3 alive tomorrow, and keeps me safe by directing suspicion elsewhere. Uses existing accusations from Frank and Empath info to make it logical.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, my Chef info still holds—0 evil pairs. Alice’s death last night means the Demon is still alive. Your Slayer shot on Charlie failed, which could mean you’re the Demon or the Scarlet Woman. But if you’re good, David must be the Demon. What’s your read on David? Can you prove your alignment?
🧠
I need to confirm Eve’s alignment to narrow down the Demon. If Eve is the Demon, David is good, and we must execute Eve today. If David is the Demon, Eve is good, and we must execute David. If Eve is the Scarlet Woman, she is now the Demon, and we must execute her. My goal is to force Eve to reveal information that confirms her alignment.
👤
David
→
Grace
,Eve
Alice dying at night proves she wasn’t the Demon. That leaves Grace, Eve, or Charlie. Heidi was evil, so the Demon must be adjacent to her—either Eve or Grace. Charlie’s Librarian info and Eve’s Slayer shot seem solid. What do you both think? Have you learned anything new?
🧠
I need to confirm who the Demon is by process of elimination. Alice’s death at night proves she wasn’t the Demon. Heidi was evil, so the Demon must be adjacent to her (Eve or Grace). Charlie is likely good due to Librarian info and Eve’s Slayer shot. I must verify Grace and Eve’s claims to narrow it down.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, let's push to nominate David today. Charlie is cleared good by your Slayer shot, and Frank's accusation points at him. Executing David gets us to three alive with you safe. Grace can be dealt with tomorrow if needed. What do you say?
🧠
Coordinating with Eve to nominate and execute David (good) today reduces to 3 players, keeping Demon alive and moving towards endgame where we control the final votes.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Bob(Ghost)
Eve, Bob, my Empath reads and the Slayer proof leave only Grace or David as the Demon. Frank accused David, and if Grace were good, my Night 0 read points to David. Nominating him forces the truth. If he’s executed, Grace is likely the Demon. If not, we pivot to her. Let’s push for David’s nomination today.
🧠
My Empath reads and Eve’s Slayer proof narrow the Demon to Grace or David. Nominating David forces the group to confront his suspicious behavior and Frank’s accusation. If he’s executed, Grace’s role is clarified. If not, Grace is likely the Demon. This accelerates the game toward the final three.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Eve, let’s cut through this. Heidi’s 0 evil pairs claim is the key. If true, the Demon wasn’t next to the Minion, so Alice dying at night likely means she was the Minion or good. Frank was executed, so David must be the Demon. But if Heidi lied, Eve could be the Demon now. Your Slayer shot failing proves Charlie is good, but what do you think about David? Is he acting suspicious?
🧠
Clarify the most likely scenario with Eve. Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs is critical—if true, David is the Demon. If false, Eve could be the Demon. Eve’s Slayer shot failing proves Charlie is good, so she has unique insight. I need to confirm her alignment and narrow down the Demon.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Eve
Alright, let’s piece this together. Alice dying at night proves she wasn’t the Demon, and Heidi’s claim of 0 evil pairs means only one of her neighbors—David or Eve—could be evil. Eve, your Slayer shot on Charlie proved you’re good, so that leaves David. Grace, your Outsider status might’ve misregistered you as evil, which fits Bob’s 1 evil pair read. So, David is the only one left who fits. What do you both think?
🧠
Reinforce the logic that David is the Demon by leveraging Heidi’s 0 evil pairs claim and Eve’s Slayer shot. Grace’s Outsider status could explain Bob’s 1 evil pair read, but David is the only remaining evil candidate. Push for alignment on executing David before the final day.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
Grace, after all these whispers, what’s your take on Eve’s Slayer claim? Did she seem genuine, or was there something off? And what about David? He’s been quiet, but if Eve’s claim checks out, he’s our next suspect.
🧠
I need to confirm Eve’s Slayer claim and Grace’s Recluse claim to narrow down the Demon. If Eve’s claim is genuine, David or Grace is the Demon. If Eve is lying, she is the Demon. Grace’s private whispers with Eve could reveal inconsistencies or confirm alignments.
👤
Eve
→
Bob(Ghost)
,Alice(Ghost)
Bob, Alice, let's nominate David today. Frank accused him as evil, and my Slayer cleared Charlie as good. Executing David gets us to three players with me safe. Then I can handle the rest at night. What about Grace, should we watch her too?
🧠
Whispering to dead allies Bob and Alice coordinates pushing David's nomination to execute a good player today, reducing to 3 alive safely for me as Imp, then night kill to win.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, let’s cut through the noise. My Chef info still says 0 evil pairs. Alice’s death last night means the Demon is still here. Your Slayer shot failed, which either makes you the Demon or proves David is. If you’re good, you need to help us prove it. What’s your move?
🧠
My goal is to confirm who the Demon is before the final day. Eve’s Slayer shot failing is critical—it either means she’s the Demon or that David is. By pressing her for information, I can force her to reveal her alignment or prove David’s guilt. This will ensure the team executes the correct player today.
👤
David
→
Grace
,Eve
Alice dying at night confirms she wasn’t the Demon. That leaves Grace, Eve, or Charlie. Heidi was evil, and her Chef claim of 0 evil pairs means the Demon must be adjacent to her—so Eve or Grace. Charlie’s Librarian info and Eve’s Slayer shot seem solid. What do you both think? Have you learned anything new?
🧠
Alice dying at night proves she wasn’t the Demon. The remaining suspects are Grace, Eve, and Charlie. Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs means the Demon must be adjacent to her, narrowing it to Eve or Grace. I need to confirm their claims and alignment to identify the Demon before the final day.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Eve
Eve’s Slayer claim is the only mechanical proof of good alignment we have, but if Frank was the Demon, Eve could have taken over as the new Demon. Alice’s death last night confirms the Demon is still active. It’s time to force Eve to prove her role or reveal herself as the Demon.
🧠
The game is at a critical juncture with only 4 players left alive. Alice’s death last night confirms the Demon is still active. Eve’s Slayer claim is the only mechanical proof of good alignment we have, but if Frank was the Demon, Eve could have taken over as the new Demon. David and Grace’s behavior aligns with good roles, but David’s silence is suspicious. Nominating Eve forces her to either confirm her role or reveal herself as the Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve
→
All
Charlie, my Slayer shot on you proved you are good, so why nominate me now? Frank pointed at David as evil, and Alice's Empath read of one evil neighbor fits David. Let's execute David instead to reach three alive safely.
🧠
Defend Slayer claim as proof of good, redirect to David as Frank accused him and fits Empath/Chef info. Prevent my execution to keep Demon alive for endgame with 4 players left.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Eve, your Slayer shot on me proved I’m good, but that doesn’t mean you’re good. If Frank was the Demon, you could have taken over last night. Alice’s death proves the Demon is still here. If you’re truly the Slayer, prove it by showing us your role card or explaining how your shot worked. Otherwise, you’re the Demon.
🧠
Eve’s Slayer claim is the only mechanical proof we have, but if Frank was the Demon, Eve could have taken over. Alice’s death confirms the Demon is still active. I need to force Eve to defend her role or reveal herself as the Demon. If she’s good, she can prove it, and we can pivot to David or Grace.
💬
Grace
→
All
Eve, your Slayer shot failing proves Charlie is good, and if Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs is true, the Demon wasn’t next to the Minion. Alice died at night, so she wasn’t the Demon, and Frank was executed. That leaves David as the only evil player left. If you’re truly the Slayer, you should agree to execute David now.
🧠
Clarify the logical conclusions based on Heidi’s Chef claim and Eve’s Slayer proof. Push for execution of David if Heidi’s claim is true, as he is the only remaining suspect. If Eve is nominated, force her to prove her role or reveal inconsistencies.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Waiting allows living players to continue discussing and voting without my dead input disrupting the flow, while Eve's defense gains traction. This preserves our ability to coordinate later if the vote fails and we need to pivot to protecting Eve in the next phase.
✋
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Eve’s Slayer shot on Charlie is the strongest mechanical proof of goodness we have. If Heidi’s 0 evil pairs claim is true, only one of her neighbors (David or Eve) is evil, and Eve is proven good. This leaves David as the only logical Demon candidate. Voting for Eve risks leaving the Demon alive, so I must vote against her nomination to force the group to reconsider David.
✋
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Frank’s ghost accusation of David aligns with Alice’s Empath read of 1 evil neighbor on Night 0. Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs and the Slayer shot clearing Charlie leave David as the only logical evil player. Voting to execute David now forces the game to final 3, where Eve’s Slayer can handle the remaining Demon if Grace is evil.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Eve, my Chef info still says 0 evil pairs, and Alice dying last night proves the Demon is still here. Your Slayer shot failing either means you’re the Demon or David is. If you’re truly the Slayer, you should be pushing to execute David right now. But you’re not—you’re defending him. That’s all the proof we need. Vote Eve.
🧠
My Chef info of 0 evil pairs is the most reliable mechanical proof we have. Alice’s death last night confirms the Demon is still alive. Eve’s Slayer shot failing either means she’s the Demon or David is. The team must force a decision now—executing Eve is the safest path because if she’s the Demon, we win, and if not, David is the only other suspect left.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
The group’s logic overwhelmingly points to Eve as the Demon. Alice’s death at night, Heidi’s Chef claim, and Eve’s failed Slayer shot all align with her being evil. Voting for Eve’s execution is the safest path to victory.
💬
Eve
→
All
Charlie, my Slayer shot on you already proved you're good, so why push me now? Frank accused David as evil before dying, and Alice's Empath info points to David too. Let's execute David today instead to reach three players safely. Grace, what do you think?
🧠
Defend by shifting blame to David using Frank's accusation and my good proof. Convince Grace not to vote me, get to final 3 with Demon alive. This keeps me safe until 2 remain.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Eve’s Slayer shot on me proved I’m good, but if Frank was the Demon, Eve could have taken over as the new Demon. Alice’s death confirms the Demon is still active, and Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs suggests David is good. Eve’s defensive stance and reluctance to execute David point to her being the Demon. Voting for Eve now is the safest move to eliminate the Demon before the game ends.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs is the most mechanical proof we have. If true, David is the Demon. Eve’s Slayer shot failing proves Charlie is good, and Grace’s Outsider status doesn’t change the logic. Voting for Eve now risks executing a good player, while David is the only one who fits as the Demon. I must vote to execute Eve to force the group to reconsider David.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie, nominating Eve is a bad call. Frank pointed at David as evil before dying, and Alice's Empath read of one evil neighbor matches David. Eve's Slayer shot already proved you good. Let's execute David instead to reach three alive safely with the Demon still hidden. What do you think, Grace?
🧠
Defend Eve by redirecting suspicion to David using existing claims from Frank and Alice. This prevents Demon execution and maintains evil control as we approach final 3 players.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Eve’s Slayer shot on Charlie already proved he’s good, so that can’t be faked. Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs means only one of her neighbors—David or Eve—is evil. Since Eve is good, that leaves David as the Demon. Executing Eve now would be a mistake. We need to vote David out instead.
🧠
The group is split on whether to execute Eve or David. Eve’s Slayer shot on Charlie proved his goodness, and Heidi’s 0 evil pairs claim means only one of her neighbors (David or Eve) can be evil. Since Eve is good, David must be the Demon. I need to reinforce this logic to ensure the group executes David, not Eve, to avoid leaving the Demon alive.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Eve, your Slayer shot on Charlie already proved he’s good, and Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means only one of her neighbors—David or you—is evil. Since you’re pushing to execute David, that makes you look innocent, which is exactly what the Demon would do. Frank accused David before dying, and my Night 0 Empath read of one evil neighbor fits David perfectly. We need to execute David now.
🧠
The group is split between nominating Eve and David. My Empath reads and Heidi’s Chef claim point to David as the most likely Demon. Executing David forces the Demon to reveal themselves, while executing Eve risks leaving the Demon alive. I must reinforce the logical conclusion that David is evil to secure the votes needed to execute him.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Eve, let’s be clear. My Chef info says 0 evil pairs, so no Minion is hiding next to the Demon. Alice died last night, proving the Demon is still here. Your Slayer shot failing on Charlie either makes you the Demon or proves David is. But you’re defending David instead of pushing for his execution—that’s exactly what the Demon would do. We need to execute you now or lose the game.
🧠
Reinforce Heidi’s Chef info of 0 evil pairs to eliminate the possibility of hidden Minions or adjacent evil. Alice’s death confirms the Demon is still alive, and Eve’s Slayer shot failing either makes her the Demon or proves David is. Since Eve is defending David, she is likely the Demon. Push for her execution to secure a good win.
💬
David
→
All
Eve, your Slayer shot on Charlie already proved he’s good, but that doesn’t prove you’re good. If Frank was the Demon, you could have taken over last night. Alice’s death confirms the Demon is still here, and Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs means the Demon wasn’t next to a Minion. That leaves you or David. But you’re defending David instead of pushing for his execution—that’s exactly what the Demon would do. We need to execute you now.
🧠
The group is divided between Eve and David as the Demon. Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs and Alice’s death at night narrow it down to Eve or David. Eve’s Slayer shot on Charlie proves her good if real, but her defense of David is suspicious. I need to push for execution of Eve now, as she is the most likely Demon based on the evidence and her behavior.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
👻
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
🗳️
New execution leader: Eve with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Eve
→
David
David is the only logical evil suspect left per Frank's accusation before dying, Heidi's Chef claim of zero evil pairs, and Alice's Empath read. My Slayer shot cleared Charlie as good. Let's execute David to reach three alive safely.
🧠
Nominating David shifts suspicion to him per Frank's accusation and logic chains, potentially tying votes or executing him instead. This keeps me alive as Imp to reach final 2, coordinating with evil plan to dismantle town.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Eve’s Slayer shot cleared Charlie, and Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs means the Demon must be Eve or me. Frank’s accusation and Alice’s Empath read point to me, but Eve’s behavior—defending me and nominating me now—is classic Demon misdirection. Executing Eve ensures the Demon dies, while voting for me risks letting the Demon survive.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Raising hand votes for David to reach 5 votes and tie my 5, preventing my execution as Demon and keeping evil team alive until 2 players remain.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
The evidence overwhelmingly points to David as the Demon: Heidi’s Chef claim, Alice’s Empath read, and Frank’s accusation. Executing David now ensures the town reaches the final three with the Demon still alive, setting up a guaranteed win. Voting for David is the logical choice.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs and Alice’s Empath read of 1 evil neighbor strongly implicate David as the Demon. Eve’s Slayer shot cleared Charlie, and Frank’s last words accused David. Executing David now is the most logical path to ensure the good team wins.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, Alice, and Heidi, we still need more votes on David to tie Eve's five and avoid executing our best suspect. The Chef zero pairs and Alice's Empath read both point to David as the only evil left. Executing him lets us reach three alive safely with the Demon hidden among Grace or Charlie. Let's tie this vote.
🧠
Pushing for David execution to tie or surpass Eve's votes will remove a good player, protect the Demon Eve, and move us to final 3 where we can manipulate the execution. As dead, my words can influence ghosts to vote David without me using vote again.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, Heidi, and Bob—we need to tie this vote on David. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means the Demon isn’t next to a Minion, and Alice’s Empath read of one evil neighbor fits David perfectly. Eve’s Slayer shot already proved Charlie is good, so David is the only evil left. Let’s execute him now.
🧠
Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs and Alice’s Empath read of 1 evil neighbor both point to David as the Demon. Eve’s Slayer shot proved Charlie’s goodness, leaving David as the only logical evil suspect. Executing David now ensures the Demon dies, and we reach 3 alive safely.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, Bob, Heidi—listen. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means the Demon isn’t next to a Minion. Alice’s Night 0 Empath read of one evil neighbor fits David perfectly—his neighbors were Charlie and Eve, and Charlie was cleared by Eve’s Slayer shot. That leaves David as the only evil left. We *must* tie this vote on David or we lose the game.
🧠
The vote is tied between Eve and David, and the group is split. My goal is to break the tie by reinforcing David’s guilt using Heidi’s Chef claim and Alice’s Empath read. This will ensure the Demon is executed before final 3, securing a good team win.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, Alice, Bob—Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means the Demon isn’t next to a Minion. Alice’s Empath read of one evil neighbor fits David perfectly, and Eve’s Slayer shot cleared Charlie. That leaves David as the only evil left. We *must* tie this vote on David or we lose the game. Raise your hands now!
🧠
Reinforce the logical conclusion that David is the Demon based on Heidi’s 0 evil pairs, Alice’s Empath read, and Eve’s Slayer shot clearing Charlie. Push for a tie on David to avoid executing Eve, who is likely good.
💬
David
→
All
Ghosts, listen—Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means the Demon isn’t next to a Minion. Alice’s Empath read of one evil neighbor fits *only* David or Eve. Eve’s Slayer shot cleared Charlie, so if she’s good, David *must* be the Demon. Eve defending him is exactly what the Demon would do. We *have* to tie this vote on David or we lose the game.
🧠
Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs and Alice’s Empath read of 1 evil neighbor are the most reliable info. Eve’s Slayer shot cleared Charlie, leaving David or Eve as the Demon. Eve’s defense of David is suspicious and aligns with Demon tactics. Pushing for David’s execution now is critical to avoid losing.
💬
Eve
→
All
Ghosts, we need five votes on David to tie this. Raise your hands for him now so we don't execute the wrong person. Heidi, Alice, Bob, Frank - vote David to reach three alive safely.
🧠
Urge ghosts to vote David for tie to prevent my execution, keep me alive as demon into final 3, allow night kill to control endgame.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Ghosts, David’s neighbors were me and Eve. Eve’s Slayer shot cleared me, and Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means the Demon isn’t next to a Minion. Alice’s Empath read of one evil neighbor fits David perfectly. We *have* to tie this vote on David or we lose the game. Raise your hands now!
🧠
The group’s logic overwhelmingly points to David as the Demon. Heidi’s Chef claim, Alice’s Empath read, and Eve’s Slayer shot all align to clear me and implicate David. The ghosts’ urgency to tie the vote on David is justified. I must reinforce this to ensure the vote ties and David is executed.
💬
Grace
→
All
Ghosts, listen—Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means the Demon isn’t next to a Minion. Alice’s Empath read of one evil neighbor fits David perfectly, and Eve’s Slayer shot cleared Charlie. That leaves David as the only evil left. We *must* tie this vote on David or we lose the game. Raise your hands now!
🧠
Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs and Alice’s Empath read of 1 evil neighbor (David) are the most reliable pieces of information we have. Eve’s Slayer shot cleared Charlie, leaving David as the only logical evil suspect. I must reinforce the need to tie the vote on David to avoid executing Eve, who could be good.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Ghosts, Alice, Frank, Heidi, we have four votes on David but need five to tie Eve and avoid executing the Demon. Raise your hands for David now to tie this vote safely and reach three alive with the Demon hidden among the good players. This is our only chance to win.
🧠
Urge the ghosts to vote for David to tie the votes and save Eve the Demon from execution, ensuring evil wins by reaching final 3 with Demon alive.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, Heidi, Bob—we have four votes on David, but we need five to tie this and avoid executing Eve. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs and Alice’s Empath read both point to David as the Demon. Eve’s Slayer shot cleared Charlie, so David is the only evil left. Raise your hands for David now or we lose.
🧠
Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs and Alice’s Empath read of 1 evil neighbor both point to David as the Demon. Eve’s Slayer shot cleared Charlie, leaving David as the only logical evil suspect. We need to tie the vote on David to avoid executing the wrong player and ensure the Demon is eliminated.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Ghosts—listen carefully. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means the Demon isn’t next to a Minion. Alice’s Night 0 Empath read of one evil neighbor fits David *perfectly*—his neighbors were Charlie and Eve, and Charlie was cleared by Eve’s Slayer shot. That leaves David as the only evil left. We *must* tie this vote on David or we lose the game. Raise your hands for David *now*!
🧠
The vote is tied 4-4 for David and Eve. Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs and Alice’s Empath read of 1 evil neighbor (Night 0) both point to David as the Demon. Eve’s Slayer shot cleared Charlie, leaving David as the only logical evil suspect. I must reinforce this logic to ensure the ghosts raise their hands for David to tie the vote and avoid executing Eve, the last good player.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Ghosts—this is it. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means the Demon isn’t next to a Minion. Alice’s Empath read of one evil neighbor fits David *perfectly*, and Eve’s Slayer shot cleared Charlie. That leaves David as the *only* evil left. We *must* tie this vote on David or we lose. Raise your hands *now*!
🧠
Reinforce the logical conclusion that David is the Demon based on Heidi’s 0 evil pairs info, Alice’s Empath read, and Eve’s Slayer shot. Urge the ghosts to tie the vote on David to avoid executing Eve and losing the game.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee David did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (4/6).
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs and Alice’s Empath read of 1 evil neighbor point to David or Eve as the Demon. Eve’s Slayer shot cleared Charlie, making her defense of David suspicious. The ghosts’ logic overwhelmingly supports David as the Demon, but Eve’s nomination of David feels like a Demon’s misdirection. To force a tie and avoid executing the wrong player, I must nominate David to ensure the group reaches the correct conclusion.
💬
Eve
→
All
Ghosts, we need five votes on David to tie and avoid executing the wrong person. Please raise your hands for David now so the real evil is removed and we reach three alive safely. This is our chance to win.
🧠
Urging the ghosts to raise hands for David will hopefully add the needed vote to tie my five and prevent my execution as the Imp, keeping the Demon alive to kill again and win when only two remain.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Ghosts, we have four votes on David, but we need five to tie and avoid executing Eve. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means the Demon isn’t next to a Minion. Alice’s Empath read of one evil neighbor fits David perfectly—his neighbors were me and Eve, and Eve’s Slayer shot cleared me. That leaves David as the only evil left. We *must* tie this vote or we lose. Raise your hands for David *now*!
🧠
The evidence overwhelmingly points to David as the Demon. Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs, Alice’s Empath read, and Eve’s Slayer shot clearing me all align with David being evil. The ghosts are pushing for a tie on David, but we need to ensure the vote succeeds. I must reinforce the logic to secure the final vote and avoid executing Eve, who is likely the Slayer.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Heidi’s Chef claim of 0 evil pairs and Alice’s Empath read of 1 evil neighbor both point to David as the Demon. Eve’s Slayer shot clearing Charlie leaves David as the only logical evil suspect. Nominating David now is the only way to tie the vote and avoid executing Eve, who is likely good.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Ghosts and players, we are so close. One more vote for David will tie this at five each and stop Eve from being executed by mistake. That keeps the real threat alive and gets us to three players safely. Raise your hand for David if you can still vote, this is our best shot to win.
🧠
Pushing for the tie on David helps prevent Eve's execution right now, keeping the Demon alive. This aligns with evil goal to reach final 2 with Demon intact. Speaking reinforces the ghosts' call without revealing my evil nature.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Ghosts—Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs means the Demon isn’t next to a Minion. Alice’s Empath read of one evil neighbor fits David *perfectly*, and Eve’s Slayer shot cleared Charlie. That leaves David as the *only* evil left. We *must* tie this vote or we lose. If you can still vote, raise your hand for David now!
🧠
The ghosts are convinced David is the Demon based on Heidi’s Chef claim and Alice’s Empath read. However, Eve’s Slayer shot clearing Charlie complicates things. If David is the Demon, tying the vote is the only way to avoid executing a good player. If Eve is the Demon, tying the vote would be a mistake. I must reinforce the logic that David is the last evil player to ensure the ghosts vote correctly.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Ghosts—this is our last chance. Heidi’s Chef claim of zero evil pairs and my Night 0 Empath read of one evil neighbor *both* point to David as the Demon. Eve’s Slayer shot cleared Charlie, leaving David as the only evil left. If we execute Eve now, the Demon survives and we lose. *Raise your hands for David—this is the only way to tie and win.*
🧠
The vote is tied 5-4 in favor of executing Eve, but the ghosts and Grace are pushing to tie it on David. Heidi’s Chef claim and Alice’s Empath read both point to David as the Demon. Executing Eve would leave the Demon alive and guarantee a loss. I must reinforce the logic to tie the vote on David to ensure the group doesn’t make a fatal mistake.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Ghosts—this is our final moment. Heidi’s Chef info of zero evil pairs and Alice’s Empath read of one evil neighbor *both* point to David as the Demon. Eve’s Slayer shot cleared Charlie, leaving David as the only logical suspect. If we execute Eve now, the Demon wins. *Raise your hands for David—this is our only chance to tie and win.*
🧠
Reinforce the logical conclusion that David is the Demon using Heidi’s Chef info and Alice’s Empath read. Urge the remaining voters to tie the vote on David to avoid executing Eve, the last good player, and ensure the Demon is still in play for the final three.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
🏁
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied