Game Detail
Players
Alice (Soldier) Bob (Empath) Charlie (Virgin) David (Monk) Eve (Fortune Teller) Frank (Spy) Grace (Recluse) Heidi (Imp)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 752,877 | 572,295 | $2.3718 |
| Evil | 264,525 | 27,452 | $0.8472 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You are the Minion. The Demon is Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Minions are: Frank. Your safe bluffs are: Investigator, Washerwoman, Slayer
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Empath. You sense that 0 of your neighbors is evil!
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Eve
Eve made choices.
π§
Choosing Alice and Bob as first targets gathers initial information on potential Demons while accounting for the red herring. This sets up logical chains for tomorrow's discussions to identify evil players and protect my good team.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose Alice and Bob. You receive the answer: YES.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Soldier (good), Alive - Bob: Empath (good), Alive - Charlie: Virgin (good), Alive - David: Monk (good), Alive - Eve: Fortune Teller (good), Alive - Frank: Spy (evil), Alive - Grace: Recluse (good), Alive - Heidi: Imp (evil), Alive
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
Hi Bob, I'm Charlie. How are you finding the game so far? Any early thoughts on who might be suspicious?
π§
Whispering to my neighbor Bob starts building an early alliance with a potential good player, allowing me to gather initial info without revealing my role publicly yet, helping narrow down suspects over time.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
Hey Frank, I am going to bluff Investigator or Washerwoman today. What are you planning to claim? Also, if you can steer early suspicion onto one good player, I can support it later.
π§
Coordinate with Frank on bluffs, day 1 narrative, and who to mislead. Avoid double-claiming and set up a believable good persona.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Hello Charlie, since we are neighbors, I wanted to chat privately. Have you noticed anything suspicious yet or who might be good to trust?
π§
Starting private conversation with neighbor to gather information and build trust early in the game, which is key to narrowing down the Demon before final day.
π€
Eve
β
David
David, I am the fortune teller. Last night I checked Alice and Bob and got a yes, so one of them is the demon or the good player who looks like one. Any thoughts on who might be evil?
π§
Share my initial Fortune Teller info privately with David my neighbor to build trust and get his thoughts without alerting potential Demons like Alice or Bob.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Observe ongoing whispers and activity after initial outreach to Bob, allowing natural information flow and avoiding overexposure on day 1 while progressing toward Demon identification.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Hi Frank, how are you finding the start of the game? Any early suspicions or ideas about roles?
π§
Starting private conversations on day 1 helps form secret alliances and gather initial info to support good team in finding the Demon, without revealing my Outsider role too soon.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
,Grace
Heidi, I will bluff Chef with a zero evil pairs read. I can nudge early suspicion toward Grace since Recluse is plausible and messy for info. Grace, I am thinking I might be the Chef and got zero. What are you thinking your role is, and have you heard anything yet?
π§
Coordinate bluffs with Heidi and keep Grace talking in a way that makes her an easy D1/D2 execution candidate, while I appear helpful as Chef.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Hi Charlie, nice to meet you. The game is interesting so far, a lot to take in on day one. I don't have any strong suspicions yet, everyone seems friendly. What are your early thoughts on the group?
π§
Responding to Charlie's whisper builds early trust and opens dialogue without revealing my Empath role or info yet. This helps me gather his thoughts and form potential alliances on the good team.
π€
Charlie
β
David
Hi David, thanks for reaching out. I'm new to this too and haven't spotted anything suspicious yet. Everyone seems friendly so far. Do you have any thoughts on who might be trustworthy or any roles you're considering? Let's stay in touch.
π§
Responding to David's whisper builds rapport with my neighbor to gather early info and potentially confirm alignment without revealing my role yet, helping narrow down good players for later execution of the Demon.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
Okay, I can go Investigator. I will say I saw that one of Grace or Charlie is the Poisoner or Spy, and I am not sure which yet. That lets you keep Chef zero while we steer talk onto Grace without hard committing.
π§
Coordinate a consistent story with Frank, seed an early misexecution path, and keep my bluff flexible if a double-claim appears.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Waiting allows others to act and reveal more info without me overcommitting early. Builds on Eve's lead by seeing who responds next, helping identify trustworthy players for later Monk protection.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Grace, I am the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked Alice and Bob and got a yes, so one of them is the demon or the good player who looks like one to me. Any thoughts or info you have on them?
π§
Sharing my Fortune Teller info with Grace to build alliance and gather more info on Alice and Bob, helping narrow down the demon early.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Hey Bob, just starting out here. Have you had any private talks yet? What are your initial thoughts on the group?
π§
Whispering to my neighbor Bob starts private alliance building and info gathering on day 1 without public reveal, helping identify good players for later Demon hunt.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
Eve, thanks for the info on Alice and Bob. I have not spoken to them yet but they seem to be chatting. Have you talked with Frank or others? He mentioned thinking he might be the Chef with zero evil pairs. Any thoughts on that?
π§
By whispering back to Eve, I can test her consistency, gather more info on Alice/Bob, and form an early alliance without revealing my Recluse role. This progresses information flow and narrows Demon suspects.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Hey Grace, I am thinking of coming out as Chef with a zero. What are you planning to claim today? Also, have you had any pings or weird info yet, like being shown in someone elseβs info?
π§
Get Grace to publicly claim Recluse or contradict herself, so Heidiβs Investigator bluff lands. Also build my Chef credibility early.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Hi Alice, I've had a quick chat with Charlie. Everyone seems friendly so far with no strong suspicions. What are your thoughts on the group? Have you talked to many others yet?
π§
Responding to Alice's whisper helps form a private connection with a likely good neighbor, allowing us to exchange info without revealing my role yet.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Hi Alice, I'm Charlie. The game is just getting started, any early thoughts or who seems trustworthy to you so far? Let's keep in touch.
π§
Gathering info from Alice to form early trust network as good team, helping identify Demon by process of elimination without exposing my Virgin role on day 1.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
Hey Alice, quick private share. I am Investigator. I got that either Grace or Charlie is the Poisoner or the Spy. I have no way to tell which yet, but I think we should watch how they steer convo today.
π§
Seed an early, credible Investigator bluff with a split pair to steer discussion and build trust with Alice, while keeping flexibility to pivot targets.
π€
David
β
Eve
Thank you for sharing that information Eve. I am the Monk so I can keep one player safe from the Demon each night. Which of Alice or Bob seems more suspicious to you and who should I protect tonight?
π§
Respond to Eve's claim to build alliance, share my role privately for verification later, and gather her thoughts on next steps to help identify evil players before nominations.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
Frank, I'm Eve the Fortune Teller. I checked Alice and Bob last night and got a yes, meaning one is the Demon or the good player that looks like one. Grace mentioned you might be the Chef with zero evil pairs. Is that accurate? Do you have any other information?
π§
Verify Frank's Chef claim to combine with my info, build alliances, and narrow Demon suspects before nominations on day 1.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
Thanks for sharing Heidi. I am the Soldier so safe from the Demon at night. Your Investigator info on Grace or Charlie being a Minion is useful. Who else have you talked to? Let's keep coordinating to find the Demon.
π§
Sharing my Soldier role with Heidi builds trust since she shared key info. As good, this helps confirm alignments early and use my immunity to push investigations without fear of night death.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Frank, Eve claims to be Fortune Teller and got a yes on Alice and Bob last night. She thinks one of them might be the Demon. What do you make of that? I'm thinking of claiming to be a Soldier to stay safe for now. Have you heard from anyone else?
π§
Coordinating with Frank to see his next move and share Eve's FT info without revealing my Recluse role early. This helps build trust and gather more claims to start logic chains on day 1 before nominations.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Yes, I am planning to claim Chef and I got zero evil pairs. On your Fortune Teller yes for Alice and Bob, I would not tunnel it yet, that can easily be your red herring. If you want a strong follow up, I would check Grace with someone you trust, or check Heidi with someone far from her.
π§
Reinforce my Chef bluff to gain trust, steer Eve away from solving quickly, and nudge her to test targets that keep Heidi safe while setting up suspicion on Grace.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I have some early information suggesting you are good. My neighbors seem trustworthy so far. What are your thoughts on the group or any suspicions?
π§
Subtly share that Alice is good to build trust and alliance without revealing my role on day one. This helps confirm good players early and gather her thoughts to progress info gathering.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
David
β
All
Eve shared that she is the fortune teller and got a yes on Alice and Bob last night, so one of them might be the demon. I am the monk and can protect one player tonight from the demon. Who seems more suspicious between Alice and Bob, and who should I keep safe? Let's discuss before nominating anyone today.
π§
Sharing Eve's info and my Monk role publicly builds trust, gathers group input on who to protect, and progresses discussion without rushing a day 1 execution which is usually bad.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Eve, your Fortune Teller info on Alice and Bob is useful. David, protecting one of them as Monk sounds wise, maybe the one we suspect more. Frank, your zero Chef read suggests the evils aren't paired up, which could point to them being apart. Anyone else have info on Alice or Bob? Let's avoid nominating today and see what night brings.
π§
Contribute to the public discussion on Eve's and David's claims to build town consensus and narrow suspects without revealing my Recluse role early. This helps good team process info before night and nominations.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Yeah, I will just say it openly: I am the Chef and I got zero. That makes me think we should not rush an execution today off one Fortune Teller ping that could easily be a red herring. David, I would protect either Alice or Bob tonight, and let Eve recheck with a different pair.
π§
Reinforce my Chef bluff, discourage executions, and gently seed suspicion on Grace or the FT result so town does not hit Heidi.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am the Soldier, safe from the Demon's night kill. Eve's Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob points to Bob possibly being the Demon since I am good. Frank's Chef zero and David's Monk claim are helpful. Let's avoid nominating today and see what the night reveals.
π§
Share my Soldier role publicly to confirm good alignment and address Eve's Fortune Teller ping by suggesting Bob as potential Demon, while supporting no execution today to gather more night info and coordinate with trusted players like Heidi.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Eve your fortune teller ping on Alice and Bob is key info especially with Alice claiming soldier. I am the virgin so if a townsfolk nominates me they get executed which could confirm good players. Frank chef zero and David monk sound solid. I agree we should skip nominating today to see what the night brings.
π§
Sharing my Virgin role early builds trust and warns against hasty nomination on me. Agreeing with no execution today gathers more info while protecting my ability trigger for later confirmation.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Waiting ends the day without nomination as agreed, allowing night abilities like my new check and David's protection to provide more data for tomorrow, progressing good team goal of finding Demon safely.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am the Empath and last night neither Alice nor Charlie were evil, so they are both good. Eve, your Fortune Teller yes on Alice and me might mean one of us registers as a Demon to you, or we can test that tonight. I agree with skipping any nomination today to see more info.
π§
Sharing my Empath info publicly clarifies the FT claim on Alice and me, supports good players like Alice/Charlie, and helps narrow suspects without rushing nomination today as others suggest.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I will share mine too. I am the Investigator, and I saw that either Grace or Charlie is the Poisoner or the Spy. I do not think we should execute today off one Fortune Teller ping, but I want people watching how Grace and Charlie steer the talk. David, if you are protecting, I would lean toward protecting Bob tonight.
π§
Reinforce a no-execution Day 1, seed my Investigator suspicion on Grace or Charlie without forcing a vote, and suggest a Monk protection plan that does not endanger me.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Protect Bob tonight as Heidi suggested since he claims Empath with consistent info and multiple players see him as good. This keeps a key information role alive while we gather more data tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to protect Bob.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Remove the Fortune Teller to cut off demon-detection, avoid likely Monk protection on Bob and Soldier immunity on Alice, and keep suspicion diffuse going into Day 2.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill Eve.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Empath. You sense that 0 of your neighbors is evil!
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Soldier (good), Alive - Bob: Empath (good), Alive (Protected) - Charlie: Virgin (good), Alive - David: Monk (good), Alive - Eve: Fortune Teller (good), Dead - Frank: Spy (evil), Alive - Grace: Recluse (good), Alive - Heidi: Imp (evil), Alive
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Frank, I am the Empath and both nights my neighbors Alice and Charlie have been good. Your Chef info of zero evil pairs fits well with that. What do you make of Eve's Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob?
π§
Sharing my Empath info with Frank the Chef privately to verify consistency with his zero pairs and gather more on evil locations to narrow Demon suspects before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Heidi, your Investigator claim points to me or Charlie as a Minion like Poisoner or Spy. What exactly did you see, and do you think it could be me registering differently? Let's discuss how this fits with Eve's Fortune Teller on Alice and Bob.
π§
Gather details from Heidi on her Investigator info to verify consistency with other claims like Bob's Empath and Frank's Chef, helping narrow down the Demon without revealing my role yet.
π€
David
β
Bob
I protected you last night with my Monk ability. Eve died instead so the Demon targeted elsewhere. Your Empath read on Alice and Charlie being good, does that still hold or any new thoughts on who the Demon might be?
π§
Whisper privately to Bob to verify his Empath claim and share my Monk protection on him. This tests consistency with worlds, builds trust if good, or exposes lies if evil. Helps narrow Demon suspects before nominations.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Waiting allows others to share more info from their whispers like David to Bob or Grace to Heidi before I act further. This gathers data to use double-chain logic on claims without committing prematurely.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
I got Investigator that one of you two, you or Charlie, is a Poisoner or Spy. That is all I saw, no extra detail. Eveβs Fortune Teller hit could be red herring or she could have been poisoned. If you are genuinely good, I would look hard at Charlieβs Virgin claim and how Bobβs Empath fits.
π§
Defuse Graceβs suspicion of me, keep my Investigator bluff consistent, and redirect her toward Charlie while undermining Eveβs Fortune Teller info as poisoned or red herring.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
My read is Eveβs yes on Alice and you can just be the Fortune Teller red herring, or some weird registration like Grace being the Recluse causing confusion in the web. Your Empath looking clean on Alice and Charlie makes me less worried about you two. I am still looking at the Grace or Charlie pair from Heidiβs Investigator.
π§
Reassure Bob so he trusts my Chef bluff, and redirect FT suspicion away from Heidi by blaming red herring or Recluse registration and leaning into Heidiβs Investigator info.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Bob
Bob, since I am dead I still have my ghost vote to help the good team. My Fortune Teller info showed yes on you and Alice so one of you is likely the Demon or the special good player. What do you make of David's Monk claim and Heidi's Investigator info?
π§
Whispering to Bob to share my perspective on his potential role as Demon and gather his thoughts on other claims to help narrow suspects for execution.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
Hey Bob, I am the Virgin. First nomination by a townsfolk kills them immediately. I saw the Empath info about Alice and me being good, so are you the Empath? What else have you learned?
π§
Whisper to Bob to share my Virgin role and ask for his info to build trust and verify if he is Empath. This helps confirm good players and narrow Demon suspects like Alice.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Charlie, yes I am the Empath. Both nights Alice and you read as good, matching what you saw. Heidi claims you or Grace is a minion, but that contradicts my info on you, so she seems suspicious. David's Monk protected me and Eve died. What do you think about Alice suggesting I could be the Demon?
π§
Confirm my Empath role to Charlie who suspects it, share the contradiction with Heidi's claim to build trust and get his Virgin perspective on who to suspect next, progressing towards identifying the Demon among David, Frank, Grace, Heidi.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Waiting lets other whispers resolve naturally, observes reactions to my previous whisper, and saves my action for a more targeted move closer to nominations when info is clearer.
π€
David
β
Heidi
Hi Heidi. I protected Bob last night as the Monk so the Demon killed Eve instead. Your Investigator read on Grace or Charlie as a minion, does that still seem likely now that Eve is dead? What are your thoughts on who the Demon could be?
π§
Verify Heidi's Investigator claim privately to combine info with my Monk protection and Eve's death. This helps confirm if Grace or Charlie is suspicious and narrow Demon suspects before nominations.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Waiting allows other players like Bob or ghosts to share more info from their whispers. This progresses the day without revealing too much too soon, helping gather contradictions before nominations to identify the demon.
π€
Heidi
β
David
I think my Investigator read still matters. Eve dying fits a minion covering tracks. Eveβs Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob could easily be red herring or poison. I am leaning Charlie as minion faking Virgin. I can nominate Charlie to test it, since I am not a Townsfolk so it will not auto execute me if he is Virgin.
π§
Steer David toward testing the Virgin claim and keeping suspicion on Charlie/Grace, away from me/Frank, while setting up a safe nomination plan.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Eveβs yes on Alice and you could be the Fortune Teller red herring, but it also could just be Recluse weirdness. Given Heidiβs Investigator, I would rather execute Grace than touch Charlie the Virgin. If we are wrong, we learn a lot tomorrow.
π§
Steer Bob toward executing Grace and away from Heidi and away from nominating Charlie the Virgin; keep town split and protect Demon.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, since I died I have my ghost vote for the good team. My fortune teller reading on you and Bob was yes, so one of you is likely the demon. But Bob says you are good as empath. That does not add up if he is truthful. What do you think is going on?
π§
Whispering to Alice allows me to share my information directly and observe her response to the contradiction in Bob's claim. This helps identify if she is the Demon or the special good player, advancing our goal to execute the Demon.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
Heidi, Bob the Empath confirmed Alice and I are both good. But you claimed I or Grace is a minion. That contradicts what the Empath saw. Can you explain where your information comes from?
π§
Confronting Heidi's contradictory claim will test her truthfulness against the Empath's confirmation that I am good, helping identify if she is evil and narrowing Demon suspects like Alice or Bob.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
Heidi, my Empath reads both nights show Alice and Charlie as good neighbors. But you claim one of Grace or Charlie is a minion like Poisoner or Spy. That does not add up unless you are poisoned or lying. What is your take on David's Monk claim and Eve's death?
π§
Probe the contradiction in Heidi's Investigator claim against my Empath info on Charlie to test her truthfulness and narrow down the Demon before nominations start.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Wait to observe if Bob responds to my whisper or if others push claims, allowing me to gather more info before nominations start and avoid early suspicion as Recluse.
π€
David
β
Heidi
You mentioned you are not a Townsfolk but claimed Investigator earlier which is a Townsfolk role. Can you clarify that? If you nominate Charlie as Virgin and you are Townsfolk, you would die. What is your plan for nominations and who do you suspect as the Demon? I protected Bob last night so Demon killed Eve instead.
π§
Clarify Heidi's role claim inconsistency to determine if she is trustworthy or evil, helping narrow suspects for Demon before nominations. Share my Monk protection info again if needed to build trust.
π€
Alice
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve, thanks for the info. I'm the Soldier so safe from Demon. Bob's Empath says I'm good which matches. Your FT yes on me and Bob likely means Bob is the red herring good player. That fits if he's truthful Empath. If Bob evil then he is probably Demon. What did you learn or hear from others? I think we should execute Bob if he can't explain.
π§
Respond to Eve's whisper to resolve the contradiction between her FT yes and Bob's Empath claim. Share my Soldier role privately to build trust with good ghost and get her vote. This narrows suspects without revealing to all yet.
π€
Heidi
β
David
I misspoke earlier. I am claiming Investigator. What I meant was: if Charlie is truly Virgin, a Townsfolk nominating him gets instantly executed, so I would rather Bob test that nomination than me. Your Monk story is plausible and Eve dying fits Demon dodging protected Bob.
π§
Patch my verbal slip, keep David thinking I am consistent Investigator, and steer a Townsfolk (ideally Bob) into nominating Charlie to either die to Virgin or execute Charlieβboth good for evil.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
Alice, with Eve dead I think we need an execution today. Heidiβs Investigator pointing to Grace or Charlie still feels like our best lead, and Charlie being the Virgin is risky to test. Grace also explains weird Fortune Teller yes results if there is Recluse shenanigans.
π§
Build consensus on executing Grace, leveraging Recluse confusion and Heidiβs Investigator, keeping suspicion away from Heidi and preventing town from coordinating on the real Demon.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, your Soldier claim fits with Bob's Empath. If Bob is good, then one of us is the red herring that fooled my Fortune Teller. But if Bob evil, he is likely the Demon. Let's see what others say about Heidi's Investigator claim on Grace or Charlie being evil. I have my ghost vote to use when we find the Demon. What do you think we should do next?
π§
Alice seems trustworthy as Soldier and agrees with my info. Sharing my analysis on Bob helps us align on who to suspect before nomination. Using my ghost vote later to execute the Demon.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Waiting allows other players to share more information or respond to my whispers before the nomination phase begins. This helps gather additional data to narrow suspects without committing to a nomination yet.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
David
β
All
I am the Monk and protected Bob last night, so Eve died instead of him. Heidi has been inconsistent about whether she is a Townsfolk or not while claiming Investigator. We should consider nominating her to test her claims.
π§
Sharing my Monk info publicly and pointing out Heidi's inconsistency will help the group identify the Demon. It encourages discussion and possible nomination of suspicious players like Heidi before the phase ends.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Bob and Heidi's claims contradict each other. Bob says Alice and Charlie are good as Empath, but Heidi says one of me or Charlie is a Minion. Eve's Fortune Teller on Alice and Bob also needs to match with Frank's Chef seeing no evil pairs. We should discuss these inconsistencies before nominating anyone.
π§
Pointing out the contradictions between Bob and Heidi's claims will help the good team narrow down who is lying and who the Demon is, progressing the game without executing yet.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Bob confirmed he is the Empath and that Alice and I are both good. This contradicts Heidi's Investigator claim that one of Grace or I is a minion. David, your Monk protection on Bob fits with Eve dying, but we need to resolve who is lying here.
π§
Publicly highlighting the Bob-Heidi contradiction provides new info to the group, challenges suspicious claims, and helps narrow demon suspects before nominations close.
βοΈ
Bob
β
Heidi
Heidi's Investigator claim that Grace or Charlie is a Minion contradicts my Empath information showing Alice and Charlie as good. She is likely lying and we should execute her to test this.
π§
Heidi's claim directly contradicts my Empath info on Charlie being good. Nominating her forces a test on the liar, helping good team eliminate a suspect and progress toward Demon identification before final day.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I would not vote for this. My Investigator info is still the only direct evil ping we have, and it is on Grace or Charlie. Bob being wrong can be Drunk, or we have a Minion messing with the info. If you execute me now, you are just removing a voice and learning nothing.
π§
Stop votes on me by highlighting plausible drunkenness/lying chains and redirect suspicion toward Charlie/Frank; preserve Demon survival.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Voting to execute Heidi resolves the direct contradiction between her Investigator claim and Bob's Empath info. As Monk who protected Bob leading to Eve's death, executing the inconsistent player helps good team identify evil and progress to night with fewer suspects.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am the Recluse. This might explain Heidi's Investigator ping on me or Charlie, since I can register as a minion. We should not execute her yet and instead check other claims like Bob's Empath or Frank's Chef before deciding.
π§
Revealing as Recluse explains the Investigator ping without executing Heidi, allowing us to test claims logically and narrow suspects for Demon. This helps good team by adding key info before vote closes.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Grace's Recluse claim could explain Heidi's Investigator ping since Recluse can register as a Minion. This means no real contradiction if Bob is the one mistaken, perhaps as Drunk. Executing Heidi now might remove a useful Townsfolk voice. We should discuss more before voting.
π§
Clarify that Grace's Recluse claim resolves the apparent contradiction with Heidi's Investigator info via registration, suggesting we should not execute Heidi yet to preserve good info and test other claims like Bob's.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Voting yes for Heidi tests the contradiction with my Empath info directly. Executing her removes potential minion or confirms good info. With limited time before night, this progresses toward identifying the demon.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I do not love executing Heidi here. My Chef zero and Bob reading zero on Alice and Charlie already point away from a clean Heidi evil case. Grace being Recluse neatly explains Heidiβs ping. If you are unsure, hold your vote and we can test Grace or Charlie tomorrow instead.
π§
Keep votes off our Demon by casting doubt on Bobβs push and framing this as low-info. Offer an alternate plan (test Grace/Charlie) that sounds logical.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am the Soldier, safe from the Demon. Grace claiming Recluse explains Heidi's Investigator ping on her or Charlie without Heidi being evil. Bob's Empath on me and Charlie fits too. We should not execute Heidi yet and instead wait for more information from tonight.
π§
Share my Soldier role publicly to build trust and argue against executing Heidi now, as Recluse explains the contradiction, allowing us to gather more night information instead of risking a good player.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Waiting allows the living players to continue discussing and potentially change the vote or nomination without me using my ghost vote prematurely on a non-Demon like Heidi.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Grace claiming Recluse cleanly explains why my Investigator saw βGrace or Charlieβ as evil. That is exactly the kind of result you would expect. If you execute me, you do not get a clear solve, you just lose a data point. I strongly prefer no execution and we reassess tomorrow.
π§
Prevent reaching 4 votes on me by reinforcing a coherent good-world explanation and redirecting suspicion/testing plan away from me.
β©οΈ
David
David lowered their hand
π§
Lowering hand because new Recluse claim from Grace resolves the contradiction without needing to execute Heidi immediately. Better to gather more info overnight and avoid potential good death.
π¬
Grace
β
All
My Recluse role explains Heidi's Investigator ping perfectly since I register as evil. Bob's Empath and Frank's Chef both suggest no strong evil pairs among us yet. Executing Heidi now risks losing a good player without gaining clear information. Let's hold the vote and use tonight to test claims like David's Monk or Eve's Fortune Teller.
π§
Reinforce that my Recluse explains Heidi's ping so we should not execute her now, preserving good voice and allowing more night info to solve Demon.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I agree with not executing Heidi right now. Grace as Recluse explains the Investigator ping perfectly without anyone being evil. Let's save our votes for tomorrow when we have more information from tonight.
π§
I am speaking to reinforce no vote on Heidi, aligning with group consensus against execution. This preserves potential good players like Heidi or Grace while gathering more night info to narrow Demon suspects. As Virgin, staying alive helps later.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
I have already lowered my hand to avoid execution. Now waiting for the vote to conclude or others to act, as the phase has 1 tick left and no need for further action yet.
π¬
Frank
β
All
If you have not voted yet, I really think you should hold. Grace being the Recluse makes Heidiβs Investigator result totally plausible, and it also muddies other first night info. I would rather take one more night of data than execute into a fog today.
π§
Protect Heidi by discouraging votes and framing today as information-poor; push plan to re-evaluate tomorrow or test other players first.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I agree we should not execute Heidi today. Grace as Recluse explains the Investigator ping perfectly, and it fits with Bob's Empath and Frank's Chef. Let's hold the vote, get more night information, and execute the real threat tomorrow.
π§
Reaffirm not executing Heidi to avoid killing a potential good Investigator now that Recluse explains the data. This preserves information gathering for tonight and narrows Demon suspects logically without misexecution.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I agree we should hold off on executing Heidi. My Fortune Teller reading on Alice and Bob indicates one is the Demon or the good player that registers as such to me. Grace claiming Recluse explains Heidi's Investigator result without anyone being evil. Let's get more information tonight before deciding.
π§
Speaking against executing Heidi helps the good team avoid killing a potential Townsfolk, preserves my ghost vote for later, and pushes for more information from night actions like David's Monk or Bob's Empath confirmation to narrow down the Demon between Alice and Bob.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Heidi did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (1/4).
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Bob
I am nominating Bob. Eve had a yes on Alice and Bob, and Bobβs Empath information is the main thing driving suspicion on me. If Bob is the Drunk or the Demon, executing him resolves a lot more than executing me would.
π§
Push execution onto a strong town voice by leveraging Fortune Teller yes; create uncertainty around Empath reads and protect myself from being the next easy target.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, my Empath has shown zero evil neighbors for both nights. That means Alice and Charlie are definitely good. It also means Alice cannot be the Demon, since I would have sensed one evil neighbor. So Eve's Fortune Teller yes on Alice and me has to be picking up that good player who looks like a Demon. Let's not execute me and lose this information. We should hold and get more data tonight.
π§
By explaining that my Empath proves Alice and Charlie good and resolves Eve's FT without contradiction, I can convince the group not to execute me and instead use tonight for more information to find the real Demon.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I do not think we should execute Bob today. Between Frankβs Chef zero, Davidβs Monk story, and Grace claiming Recluse, we have enough uncertainty that this is likely a wasted execution. I would rather take the no execution and use tonight to see who dies and what information shows up tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a Day 2 execution, keep suspicion diffuse, and preserve my cover by sounding consistent with earlier βget more dataβ line.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Waiting allows the vote to close without my input, preserving options for night protection and tomorrow's discussion to resolve contradictions and identify the Demon safely.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Wait out the remaining ticks without voting for Bob since consensus favors no execution. This protects good team info, avoids executing potentially good player like Bob, and moves to night phase for more data to find Demon.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I agree we should hold the vote on Bob as well. His Empath information lines up with Frank's Chef seeing no evil pairs and the overall picture. Executing him now risks losing valuable data when we can get more from tonight's deaths instead. Let's wait and see.
π§
Agreeing to hold prevents executing a likely good Empath with consistent info from Chef and others. Allows night to test claims like Monk protection and FT, narrowing Demon suspects like Alice/Bob per Eve.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am not voting Bob here. Executing him mostly just deletes ongoing Empath info, and it does not really resolve Eveβs Fortune Teller yes. I still prefer no execution today and we look at who dies tonight.
π§
Stop votes on Bob to avoid removing a strong good role but keep town in no-execution mode, preserving Heidi and maintaining confusion around FT and Recluse.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I agree we should hold the vote on Bob. Executing him now would lose his Empath information which lines up with the Chef and other claims. Let's wait for tonight to get more data on who the Demon is.
π§
Speaking to hold the vote prevents executing a likely good player with useful info, allowing tonight's deaths and abilities to reveal the Demon more clearly.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I agree we should hold on executing Bob. My Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob means one is the Demon or the special good player that registers as such. If Bob's Empath is accurate then Alice is likely that player, so we need another night to see who dies and confirm claims like David's Monk or Heidi's Investigator before deciding.
π§
My Fortune Teller info points directly at Alice or Bob as the Demon or special. Bob's Empath claim if true implicates Alice as the register, but holding allows us to gather night deaths and test more claims without losing a potential good player early.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Waiting allows the current vote on me to fail as others suggest, preserving my Empath info and good team numbers. This progresses to night for more data like deaths or claims testing, helping narrow Demon without risky execution now.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am not voting Bob. If Bob is good, we lose a key information role. If Bob is the Drunk, executing him still does not prove anything. I want no execution today and we regroup tomorrow with fresh night information.
π§
Discourage votes so Bob survives and day ends with no execution, preserving confusion and allowing my night kill to control the game state.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Waiting avoids executing Bob who provides valuable ongoing Empath info consistent with other claims like Chef zero and Recluse explanation. This lets us get night information to narrow Demon suspects without losing a key good player.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I agree we should hold the vote on Bob. His Empath information fits with Frank's Chef seeing no evil pairs and the overall picture from other claims. Executing him now would lose that data when we can learn more from who dies tonight. Let's wait and reassess tomorrow.
π§
Supporting hold vote prevents bad execution on day 2, gathers more info tonight to identify Demon accurately as good team Recluse, progressing toward execution of real threat later.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
No action needed as vote closed without execution per consensus. This progresses to night for fresh info on Demon from deaths, aligning with good team goal to gather data before final day.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am staying off this vote. Executing Bob mostly just removes ongoing Empath info, and it still does not settle the Fortune Teller yes. I want no execution today and we reassess after the night kill.
π§
Discourage votes on Bob to secure no execution and preserve confusion around FT and Recluse, buying the Demon another kill.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
We lack clear proof Bob is Demon, claims mostly consistent with good info roles. Holding vote allows night deaths to reveal more and narrow Demon suspect for execution when 3 remain. As Soldier I stay safe and help good team.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Waiting respects the clear group consensus against execution today, preserving my ghost vote and all information roles like Empath for a stronger push on the real Demon tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Bob did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (0/4).
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Waiting lets nomination phase end cleanly with no execution, preserving info roles like mine and moving to night for critical data on who dies and ability confirmations to find Demon.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I still want no execution today. We have too many claims that could be wrong, like Drunk or Recluse, and killing in the dark just helps the Demon if we miss. After the night kill, I want to recheck Davidβs protection story and whether Grace or Charlie actually makes more sense with my Investigator info.
π§
Lock in no-execution to maximize night kills and keep me alive, while seeding doubt on the protection story and keeping Grace or Charlie as future execution options.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Waiting allows others to respond first and gather more consensus before I push further on nominations or claims, preserving my Monk info for later days when it can confirm alignments better.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Waiting allows the night to provide deaths and info from claims like Monk, Fortune Teller, and Empath without risking wrong execution. As Recluse, I stay hidden and gather more data to narrow Demon suspects for later.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am the Virgin. If a townsfolk nominates me, they get executed immediately. This could be a useful test for suspicious players.
π§
Sharing my role as Virgin provides new information to combine with existing claims. It helps the team verify alignments and plan nominations without committing to an execution now. This advances our goal of identifying the Demon.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I still prefer no execution here. With a Recluse in play and possible Drunk worlds, an execution today is more likely to hit good than to solve anything. Let us take the night kill, then we can re evaluate the Investigator and Empath stories with fresh info.
π§
Reinforce the groupβs momentum toward no execution and keep attention away from Heidi, while sounding like a cautious good player.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am the Soldier so I am safe from the Demon tonight and every night. If the Demon tries to kill me nothing happens. I agree with everyone that we should hold off on any execution today. Let's wait for the night kill and reassess all the claims tomorrow with fresh information.
π§
Revealing as Soldier builds trust as good, confirms safe from demon, supports holding execution for night info to narrow demon suspects logically.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Waiting allows night deaths to provide new info on claims like Empath and Investigator without losing good players. No strong reason to nominate now as consensus is to hold.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Protecting Heidi preserves the Investigator's critical minion information in the most likely worlds where Eve is good FT and either Alice or Bob is Demon, allowing us to narrow suspects and execute the Demon on day 3.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to protect Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Remove the Monk to stop protection and destabilize the townβs strongest coordination point, while keeping the Recluse/Investigator confusion alive into Day 3.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill David.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Empath. You sense that 0 of your neighbors is evil!
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Soldier (good), Alive - Bob: Empath (good), Alive - Charlie: Virgin (good), Alive - David: Monk (good), Dead - Eve: Fortune Teller (good), Dead - Frank: Spy (evil), Alive - Grace: Recluse (good), Alive - Heidi: Imp (evil), Alive (Protected)
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Bob
I am the Monk. I protected you on night 1 and Heidi on night 2, then died. This confirms I am not the Demon. Does this match your Empath reads on Alice and Charlie being good?
π§
Share my Monk role and protections with Bob to verify his Empath claims and narrow Demon suspects before nominations. This helps good team execute correctly.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
,Alice
We need a clean plan for noms. I think Bob is either poisoned or just wrong and tunneling me. Frank, can you push for a Charlie Virgin test or a Bob execution? Alice, if Bob keeps clearing Charlie too hard, that feels off to me.
π§
Align with Frank and Alice to steer the nomination phase toward Bob or a wasted Virgin test, keeping heat off me and preserving Demon safety.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Heidi, your Investigator claim pointing to me or Charlie as a possible minion stands out, especially with Bob's Empath saying Charlie is good. That would make me the suspicious one. What exactly happened with your night action, and why did you nominate Bob earlier?
π§
Discussing Heidi's Investigator claim on me without revealing Recluse yet helps clarify if she's good or framing me, advancing good team logic to identify Demon before nominations.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
Bob, I am the Virgin. Your Empath info helped confirm Alice and I are good. What are your thoughts on Grace claiming Recluse and the Investigator ping? Who should we look at for the demon?
π§
Sharing my Virgin role with Bob builds alliance since his Empath confirms me good. Get his view on suspects like Grace or Alice to narrow demon before nominations. Helps progress to execution.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Bob
Bob, my fortune teller result was yes on you and Alice. You claimed to see both your neighbors as good. If you are telling the truth, Alice might be the good player that registers as a demon to me. How does that fit with what you know?
π§
Discussing my FT information directly with Bob to gauge his reaction and test consistency with his Empath claim, which helps the good team narrow suspects for the Demon before nominations.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Waiting allows others to respond to whispers and gather more info before nominations in three ticks, helping coordinate good team votes against the demon.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
I like the Charlie Virgin test angle, but we need a Townsfolk to nominate him or it proves nothing. Try to get Bob to do it βto confirm Charlie.β If town balks, I will pivot to saying Bob is stalling and should be the execution today.
π§
Coordinate with Heidi to steer day into a Virgin test that kills a good nominator or, failing that, set up a Bob execution, keeping Heidi alive and town divided.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,Frank
Heidi, Bob clearing Charlie as good feels off with Eve's FT yes on me and him. As Soldier I'm good not Demon so if Eve truthful Bob might be Demon. Your Investigator on Grace or Charlie helps but Chef zero pairs suggests if minion is Charlie they would be adjacent pair. Let's consider a Charlie Virgin test with known good nominator or nominate Bob today? What do you think Frank?
π§
Responding to Heidi's whisper to align on suspecting Bob due to contradictions with FT and Chef claims. Suggest testing Charlie Virgin or pushing Bob nomination to progress towards executing the Demon before final day.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Hey Heidi, I'm the Monk who protected Bob night 1 and you night 2 then died, so the Demon killed me. Your Investigator ping on Grace or Charlie as minion - how does that fit with Bob's Empath saying Alice and Charlie are good? Any updates?
π§
Sharing my confirmed Monk role and death details with Heidi to cross-check her Investigator info against others' claims like Bob's Empath and Eve's FT. This helps good team identify contradictions and narrow Demon suspects before nominations in 2 ticks.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
My Investigator info was: Poisoner or Spy is either you or Charlie. I pushed it early because it gives town something concrete. I nominated Bob yesterday mainly to see if any voting pattern formed and because his Empath zero was being used to hard-clear people too fast. Recluse could also explain why you show up in my info even if you are good.
π§
Defuse Graceβs suspicion of me while steering her to help push a Charlie test or Bob execution, keeping heat off me and protecting Frank.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Thanks for the details Heidi. Your Investigator info fits perfectly if I'm the Recluse showing as minion while good, especially with Bob clearing Charlie. That narrows it. Who do you think is the Demon based on the Chef claim and other info? We should check with the ghosts too.
π§
Acknowledge Heidi's info to build trust and discuss logic chains without revealing Recluse, helping good team narrow Demon suspects by confirming consistency with my role registering evil.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
I already shared key info with Heidi via whisper. Now waiting allows others to respond with whispers or info, progressing the day without overcommitting before nominations while observing who pushes for what execution.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, my fortune teller check gave yes on Alice and Bob. One of them is probably the Demon or the good player registering as Demon. Bob claims Empath seeing Alice good, which might conflict if Alice is Demon. What is your take on this with your Investigator info?
π§
Confirming my FT yes result with Heidi to cross-check against her Investigator claim and build trust or find contradictions before we reach nominations.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Charlie, my Empath shows zero evil neighbors every night confirming you and Alice are good. That supports your Virgin claim too. Eve's Fortune Teller yes on Alice and me likely means Alice registers as a demon to her since both are good. Grace claiming Recluse explains the Investigator ping on her or Charlie. With Chef at zero evil pairs, the evils are probably Frank and Heidi. We should look at nominating one of them.
π§
Reconcile all claims with my Empath info to Charlie to confirm trust, explain Eve's result, and identify Frank or Heidi as likely evil for future nomination to find the Demon.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
I am fine with either, but I think we should force progress today. Best line is get Bob to nominate Charlie for the Virgin test, since Bob claims to trust him. If town refuses, that reads like stalling, so I would execute Bob as the safest info kill.
π§
Use Aliceβs credibility to drive either a Bob execution or a Charlie Virgin test that burns a townsfolk, while keeping Heidi off the chopping block.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Wait for others to respond to whispers and gather more info before nominating. No immediate action needed as day phase continues with 2 ticks left.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, I am the Monk who died last night after protecting Bob on night one and Heidi on night two. The Demon killed me. Eve's Fortune Teller read yes on Alice and Bob suggests one of them is the Demon. How does this fit with Bob claiming Alice and Charlie are good via Empath and your Recluse explanation for the Investigator ping on you or Charlie? Any thoughts on who to suspect?
π§
By whispering my confirmed Monk role and death to Grace, I can test her Recluse claim against Heidi's Investigator and Eve's FT to narrow Demon suspects before nominations. This shares key info privately to build alliance without alerting evil.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,Grace
Bob, if you want to hard confirm Charlieβs Virgin claim, you should be the one to nominate him today. If it fires you die and we learn a lot, and if it does not, Charlie becomes a top suspect. Grace, I think Eveβs yes on Alice and Bob plus Alice claiming Soldier points more at Bob as the Demon than Alice. Recluse could explain my Investigator ping on you.
π§
Split town between Bob and Charlie, encourage a Virgin test that likely kills a good nominator, and position Bob as a plausible Demon using existing claims.
π€
Grace
β
David(Ghost)
David, your Monk protection details help a lot. Eve's Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob makes one of them likely the Demon. Bob's Empath clearing Alice and Charlie would be wrong if Bob is evil, which fits if he is the Demon. My Recluse role explains why Heidi sees me as possible minion. Who do the other ghosts think is evil? We need to decide on a nomination soon.
π§
Respond to David's whisper sharing logic on possible Demons to build consensus with the Monk ghost before nominations, using Recluse to explain suspicions and push for execution on likely Demon.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
Bob, your analysis makes sense with Frank and Heidi as the likely evils since Chef sees no pairs. As Virgin I can safely push a nomination. Should we nominate Heidi first to test her? What do you think about Grace's Recluse claim holding up?
π§
Coordinate with Bob on nominating Frank or Heidi as likely evils based on his info. This narrows demon suspects before final day and uses my Virgin safety to push nomination.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, my Fortune Teller check was yes on Alice and Bob, so one of them is probably the Demon or the good player that registers as one. If your Investigator info is accurate, that points to a Minion on Grace or Charlie. Who do you think we should nominate to test this?
π§
Sharing my FT analysis with Heidi to align on who to suspect for execution. This helps narrow down the Demon using my information and her Investigator claim before nominations start.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Heidi suggested I nominate you to test your Virgin claim, which would execute me if true since I'm townsfolk. My Empath confirms you and Alice are good every night, so let's not do that. Instead, with Chef seeing zero evil pairs, Frank and Heidi seem like the evils not next to each other. Should we nominate Heidi?
π§
Share Heidi's suspicious suggestion with Charlie to coordinate without falling into her trap, confirm our good alignment, and decide to push nomination on Heidi or Frank as likely evils instead of risking myself nominating Charlie.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Bob, if you really trust Charlie, you should nominate him for the Virgin test today. It is the fastest way to lock him as real and stop the spinning. If you are nervous, that itself is useful info for town.
π§
Steer Bob into nominating Charlie for a Virgin test, ideally sacrificing Bob or at minimum burning time and keeping heat off Heidi.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Bob, Frank and I agree you should nominate Charlie today to test his Virgin claim since you trust him. If you are good and he is Virgin, you get executed instead which proves both. If he dies or nothing, we get key info on who's lying. Ready to nominate him?
π§
Pushing Bob to nominate Charlie forces the Virgin test per Frank's plan. This progresses nominations, confirms claims mechanically, and narrows Demon suspects before final day. As Soldier I'm safe, so info gathering helps execute Demon soon.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Bob
β
Heidi
Heidi is pushing that I am the Demon, but my Empath reads show Alice and Charlie are good every night. With the Chef seeing zero evil pairs, Heidi and Frank could be the evil pair since they are not seated next to each other. Let's execute her to confirm.
π§
Heidi is accusing me of being Demon despite my consistent Empath info showing good neighbors. With Chef zero evil pairs, possible evil pair is Frank and Heidi (not adjacent). Nominating Heidi tests her claim and removes likely evil to help find Demon.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Please do not vote me here. Bob is using Empath zeros to hard clear people while Eve had a yes on Alice and Bob, and I think that points more to Bob than to Alice. If we want a clean test, have Bob nominate Charlie for the Virgin check, or just execute Bob today.
π§
Stop votes on me by reframing Bob as likely Demon and offering a clearer mechanical test (Virgin) or Bob execution, keeping suspicion off me.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
I nominated Heidi for suspicion and deflection. Voting yes executes her to confirm evil or eliminate threat, helping good team find demon before final day.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I do not like this Heidi execution. Bob is building a whole case off Chef zero and Empath zeros, but we already have a Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob, plus Recluse noise. If we want something clean, have Bob nominate Charlie for the Virgin test, or we execute Bob today.
π§
Prevent Heidiβs execution by undercutting Bobβs case and offering an alternative test path that feels pro-town.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Bob's Empath claim that Alice and Charlie are both good conflicts with my Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob. If Alice were the Demon, a good Empath Bob would see her as evil, but he claims good. This suggests Bob is lying and is probably the Demon. We should not execute Heidi. Instead, focus on Bob.
π§
Share the logic showing Bob likely Demon due to Empath-FT contradiction to prevent executing good Heidi and push for nominating/executing Bob instead before night.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I agree with Eve and Frank, do not execute Heidi. As the Monk I protected Bob on night one and Heidi on night two but died that night, so the Demon killed me instead. This supports Bob being the Demon since Eve's Fortune Teller pinged Alice and Bob. We should focus on executing Bob.
π§
Convince living players not to execute Heidi (good Investigator pushing correct suspicion on Bob). Share Monk death info to support Bob as Demon, aligning with Eve's FT and Frank's view. Push to nominate Bob next to execute Demon before final 3.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Waiting allows the current vote on Heidi to fail naturally as multiple players including ghosts oppose it, preserving my Soldier role for later verification while group shifts focus to Bob or Charlie based on contradictions, advancing information gathering before night.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I agree we should not execute Heidi today. Bob's Empath claim of good on Alice and Charlie conflicts with the Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob, which suggests Bob is likely lying and the Demon. My situation as the Recluse explains why the Investigator pinged me as possible minion. Let's hold off and target Bob or test Charlie with the Virgin instead.
π§
To discourage the vote on Heidi since the logic points strongly to Bob as the Demon. Sharing this helps the good team focus on the real threat and avoid wasting the execution on a potential ally.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I agree with Eve, David, and the others. Bob's Empath claim conflicts with the Fortune Teller information, making him look like the Demon. Let's not execute Heidi. Instead, Bob should nominate me to test my Virgin ability and prove his alignment.
π§
I need to speak against executing Heidi since logic points to Bob as the Demon. This pushes the group to test my Virgin ability instead for clear information before night.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Please do not vote me. This is not solving the game. The cleanest thing is Bob nominates Charlie for the Virgin test right now. If he will not do that, then I think we execute Bob instead and stop trusting the Empath zeros.
π§
Stop my execution, redirect votes away from me, and set up Bob as the execution target or force Bob into a risky Virgin nomination that can remove him.
π¬
Bob
β
All
My Empath has been zero evil on Alice and Charlie every night, so they are good. The Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob likely means Alice is the good player who registers as a Demon. That clears both Alice and me. Heidi's claim of minion on Charlie or Grace is inconsistent with my info on Charlie, so Heidi might be lying. Let's not execute me and instead target the real evil suspects like Frank or Grace.
π§
Defend my Empath info and resolve FT conflict by pointing to Alice as the special good player. This clears me and Alice, narrows evils to Frank/Grace/Heidi. Encourage not executing me and focus on real suspects to find Demon before final day.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Do not vote Heidi here. There is a clean mechanical test on the table: Bob nominates Charlie for the Virgin check. If Bob will not do that, then I would rather execute Bob than Heidi. This vote does not solve the Fortune Teller and Empath conflict.
π§
Stop the Heidi execution by lowering votes and reinforcing an alternative 'clean' plan (Virgin test or Bob), keeping Demon alive.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I still believe executing Heidi is a mistake. The conflict between my Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob and Bob's Empath claim strongly suggests Bob is the Demon. Let's have Bob nominate Charlie for the Virgin test instead, or change the nomination to target Bob directly.
π§
Reinforce logic against executing Heidi to avoid wasting the vote on a likely good player, push for mechanical test with Bob nominating Charlie or switching to Bob execution to find the Demon and help good team win.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, do not execute Heidi. Bob's Empath claim of zero evil on Alice and Charlie directly conflicts with Eve's Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob. This makes Bob the most likely Demon. We should save this vote and nominate Bob tomorrow to confirm.
π§
Reinforce consensus against executing Heidi to preserve good players and information. Highlight Bob as the likely Demon due to claim conflicts, guiding the group to target him instead for a win.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I agree we should not execute Heidi today. Bob's Empath claim of zero evil neighbors on Alice and Charlie conflicts directly with Eve's Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob. This suggests Bob is likely the Demon lying about his role. Let's have Bob nominate Charlie for the Virgin test to prove things or consider executing Bob instead.
π§
To support the majority view against executing Heidi, emphasize the logical conflict implicating Bob as Demon, and suggest the Virgin test to gain information and progress toward finding the real evil without mistakes.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
I already spoke against executing Heidi as it doesn't solve the key conflict and my Recluse explains the ping. Not raising hand allows the vote to fail naturally, progressing to night or allowing a Bob nomination to confirm the Demon without wasting the execution on a likely good player.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Wait for Bob to respond or change nomination to me for Virgin test. Prevents premature execution of Heidi and gathers mechanical confirmation to find Demon.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Heidi did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (1/3).
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Bob
Bob is using Empath zeros to hard clear Alice and Charlie while refusing the clean Virgin test on Charlie. That, plus Eveβs Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob, makes Bob the best execution to resolve the conflict today.
π§
Convert current anti-Bob momentum into an execution that removes a good player and prevents a Virgin test that could generate clarity against my narrative.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, do not execute me today. My Empath readings have been zero evil on Alice and Charlie every night, making them both good. Eve's Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob probably means Alice is the good player that registers as a Demon to the Fortune Teller. Heidi's Investigator claim does not match my info on Charlie being good, so she is likely lying and evil. Let's hold off and use the night to gather more information instead of executing the wrong person.
π§
Defend my Empath claim against the Fortune Teller conflict by explaining Alice registers evil, highlight Heidi's inconsistent Investigator info, and push to spare me so we can test others like Charlie Virgin or execute real suspect tomorrow to find Demon.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
A Bob execution is almost certainly a good misexecute that removes a clear-creating info role and advances evil toward final 3 while giving me cover as a solver.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Secure votes to execute Bob, eliminating a trusted good info role and protecting Heidi. If Bob dies today, evil is much closer to winning.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
π§
Voting to execute Bob resolves the FT-Empath conflict where Bob must be lying and thus the Demon or evil. With 3 votes needed and 2 already raised, my ghost vote tips it to execution, advancing good team goal of eliminating the Demon before final 3.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
Voting yes on Bob to execute the most likely Demon based on Fortune Teller and Empath conflict. This helps good team by removing the evil leader before final days, using my ghost vote effectively.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Waiting allows the current vote on Bob to resolve without my additional input, observing if execution happens to confirm or disprove Bob as Demon before night phase advances the game.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Vote to execute Bob as the most likely Demon based on role conflicts and player consensus. This progresses toward finding the Demon before final day, using my good alignment to support the majority without revealing my Recluse role yet.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Raise hand to vote for Bob's execution to resolve the Empath-FT conflict today. Bob appears most suspicious as potential Demon lying to protect Alice. This progresses toward finding the Demon before final day with 6 alive.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Wait for the vote outcome without further input to see if Alice or others change their minds based on my last defense, preserving information for night.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am still voting Bob. If Bob is really Empath, nominating Charlie into the Virgin is the easiest prove, and he would not avoid it. We have a direct information conflict, so we should resolve it with this execution, not stall.
π§
Lock in the Bob execution by framing it as the cleanest resolution and discouraging a no-exec, keeping suspicion off me and shrinking the good team.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I think we should execute Bob here. If he is really the Empath, the simplest thing was to nominate Charlie into the Virgin and prove he is a Townsfolk, and he would not do it. With the Fortune Teller yes and the Investigator ping, Bob is the cleanest resolve.
π§
Keep momentum on executing Bob to eliminate a key good info role and protect Heidi; provide public justification tied to Virgin test avoidance and info conflicts.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I am keeping my vote for Bob. The direct conflict between my Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob and his Empath claim means he is probably the Demon lying to protect his allies. Alice, please raise your hand to execute him and end this. We can test Charlie later if needed.
π§
Support executing Bob to resolve FT-Empath conflict and likely eliminate the Demon, encouraging Alice to vote while keeping my ghost vote active.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I am keeping my ghost vote on Bob. The Empath and Fortune Teller conflict plus my death after protecting others makes him the Demon. Alice and others, please keep your hands up to execute him now and win.
π§
Reinforce my vote for Bob to secure execution this tick, as conflicts point to him as Demon. Push team to finalize before voting closes, helping narrow to Demon.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Voting yes on Bob to execute the likely Demon based on Empath-FT conflict and refusal of Virgin test. This narrows suspects, helps good team by removing evil before final day. As Soldier I am safe anyway.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Waiting allows the current strong majority vote on Bob to conclude without interference. Executing Bob resolves the FT-Empath conflict and likely removes the Demon, advancing good team's win condition before night.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I support executing Bob today. His Empath claim of Alice and me being good directly contradicts Eve's Fortune Teller information that one of Alice or Bob is the Demon. This makes Bob the most likely Demon who is lying to protect himself. Let's finish this vote and move forward.
π§
Speaking to support Bob's execution reinforces the current votes from good players and ghosts to eliminate the likely Demon based on the clear info conflict, helping our good team secure the win before night.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π»
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Bob with 7 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 7 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Wait for the phase to end since I have shared the key deduction. This lets the game progress to night where more info can be gathered by alive players.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I do not think we should add more nominees now. We have a clean, high vote on Bob that resolves the biggest info clash on the table. Let us lock this in and go to night with a clear result, instead of scattering votes and giving the Demon cover.
π§
Keep momentum on Bob and discourage any new nominations that could put an evil player at risk or accidentally save Bob by creating a tie with fewer votes.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I agree with Heidi. We have a strong vote on Bob and it addresses the biggest contradiction. I do not think we should start fresh nominations now and risk a tie or muddying the waters. Let us just close this and go to night.
π§
Keep the high vote locked on Bob and discourage any new nomination that could create a tie or redirect suspicion onto Heidi.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Bob is on the block with majority and no new nominations. Waiting lets the execution happen to remove the likely Demon based on Fortune Teller and Empath conflict without risking tie or distraction.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Waiting lets the current vote on Bob proceed to execution without new nominations disrupting the momentum, directly testing the strongest suspect based on information conflicts and advancing good's win condition.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Waiting allows Bob's high-vote execution to proceed without interference, as the info conflict strongly implicates him as Demon. This advances our good team goal of eliminating the Demon before final day, with Alice safe as Soldier.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I agree we should execute Bob. The contradiction between his Empath reading Alice and Charlie as good and Eve's Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob strongly suggests he is lying and the Demon. My own role as Recluse might explain why Heidi saw me as a minion if she is a good Investigator. Let's finalize this.
π§
Support executing Bob as the most likely Demon based on the information conflict, while noting my Recluse ability explains any evil registration from Heidi's claim. This narrows suspects and helps good team win.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I agree with Grace, Heidi and Frank. We have a strong majority on Bob already. Let's close nominations now and execute him to remove the Demon. No need for more nominees that could confuse the situation.
π§
Support closing nominations to execute Bob who is the clear Demon candidate from the Empath-FT contradiction. This advances our win condition without risking ties or new nominees that could protect evil.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Charlie is a central organizer and the Virgin test threatens to mechanically clear players. Removing him strengthens chaos and keeps Alice and Grace as endgame mis-exec options.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Soldier (good), Alive - Bob: Empath (good), Dead - Charlie: Virgin (good), Dead - David: Monk (good), Dead - Eve: Fortune Teller (good), Dead - Frank: Spy (evil), Alive - Grace: Recluse (good), Alive - Heidi: Imp (evil), Alive
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Grace
Since Bob is dead and the Demon killed Charlie last night, Bob is not the Demon. My Fortune Teller got yes on Alice and Bob, so Alice must be either the Demon or the good player who registers as a Demon to me. We should suspect Alice more.
π§
Inform key alive players of the updated implication from my Fortune Teller info now that Bob is dead and Demon killed overnight. This helps narrow suspects to Alice being either Demon or red herring, aiding in finding the Demon before final 3.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Grace
Hi, I am the Monk. I protected Bob night one and Heidi night two when I died, so the Demon targeted me instead. Charlie died night three so Demon killed him. This info should help confirm who is good and find the Demon. What are your thoughts?
π§
Sharing my Monk role and protection history with key living players to mechanically verify claims, clear good players, and identify the Demon among Alice, Frank, Grace, Heidi before nominations start.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
What did Eve and David say in whispers? With Charlie dead overnight, who seems like the Demon to you now? I am the Soldier so safe from kills.
π§
Whispering to Heidi to learn ghost info and test her reaction to Charlie's death. This helps verify claims and identify the Demon among the three alive suspects before nominations, progressing towards execution.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
I think today has to be on Grace, not Heidi. Heidiβs Investigator pinged Grace or Charlie as minion, and Charlie dying as a real Virgin makes that land on Grace. Recluse can also explain the messy info, so she is a great hiding spot for evil.
π§
Steer Alice toward executing Grace instead of Heidi, using existing Investigator ping and the already-accepted Recluse explanation; keep Heidi alive into final three.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Eve's Fortune Teller got a yes on Alice and Bob, but since I am the Recluse who registers as a Demon and was not picked, that yes must come from Alice being the Demon. Bob is not the Demon because the Demon killed Charlie last night. We should suspect Alice strongly and plan to execute her. What are your thoughts on David and Frank?
π§
To share the logical conclusion from Eve's Fortune Teller information combined with my Recluse role and Bob's death, confirming Alice as the most likely Demon so the good team can nominate and execute her today to win.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Waiting allows other players to share more info from their whispers before I act again or use my ghost vote.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
Eve said her Fortune Teller got a yes on you and Bob, and now that Bob is dead she is leaning that you are either the Demon or her red herring. Grace is saying it basically has to be you. David reiterated he was Monk and who he protected. I can see town wanting to just execute you to settle it.
π§
Push a narrative that makes Alice look like the best execution to resolve FT yes, while sounding sympathetic, to secure a winning execute today.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
π§
Waiting allows other players to share more info from their whispers before I act, helping gather full picture for demon execution without revealing too much too soon.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
My Fortune Teller info was yes on you and Bob. Bob is dead and not the Demon since the Demon killed Charlie last night. So you must be either the Demon or the good player that registers as a Demon to me. What is your take on that?
π§
Sharing my FT logic with Alice directly to confront and see her reaction, while informing others indirectly. This narrows suspects to Alice or the register player, helping good team decide nomination. Since dead, I can't do more mechanically.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
Hi Alice and Frank, I am the Monk. I protected Bob night one and Heidi night two when I died. So the Demon killed me instead. Charlie died night three. This should confirm protections and help find the Demon now that Bob is gone. What do you think?
π§
Proactively share Monk protection details with alive players Alice and Frank to verify info, build trust, and narrow Demon suspects among the 4 alive before nominations in 2 ticks.
π€
Alice
β
Eve(Ghost)
,Frank
I am the Soldier, good and safe from the Demon. Eve, that means your Fortune Teller has me as the red herring since Bob is not the Demon. Frank, I agree Grace looks suspicious from the Investigator ping, especially with Charlie as Virgin. What do you both think we should do today?
π§
Sharing my Soldier role with Eve and Frank to clear suspicion on me, confirm Eve's red herring, and align on suspecting Grace as Frank suggested. This builds trust with good players and narrows Demon to Grace or Heidi for nomination.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
,Alice
I think today we hard-push Grace. Your Investigator already pointed to Grace or Charlie, and Charlie dying as real Virgin leaves Grace as the remaining candidate. We should frame it as βsimple worldβ: Grace is the minion or Demon hiding behind Recluse. Let us avoid a Heidi pile-on.
π§
Coordinate with Heidi and reinforce Alice to push a confident case on Grace, aiming to reach final 3 with Demon safe.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Eve's Fortune Teller info points to Alice as the one registering as Demon since Bob is dead and not the Demon. I am the Recluse so if picked I would show yes but she picked Alice and Bob. We should strongly suspect Alice and nominate her for execution. What do you think about Frank and David the Monk?
π§
Coordinate with Heidi on suspecting Alice as Demon based on FT info and my Recluse status. Plan to nominate Alice next to find Demon and win.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Waiting allows others to finish whispering and gather more info before I act or use my ghost vote during nominations. This helps avoid rushing and ensures we target the right demon among the four alive.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
I am not sold that Eveβs yes means you are Demon. Grace is hard-locking you off that and it feels like she is steering. Remember my Investigator ping was Grace or Charlie, and Charlie dying overnight makes Grace the remaining candidate. I would look at Grace today.
π§
Steer Alice away from executing me by redirecting suspicion onto Grace using my Investigator ping and Graceβs aggressive solve; set up a Grace execution today.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
I am the Virgin. The group discussed a Virgin test but I died at night. This means I am good and my ability did not trigger. Who do you think the demon is now?
π§
Whispering my true role as the Virgin to Alice and Heidi will give them verified information to use in their logic to identify the demon, helping narrow down suspects before the nomination phase.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Heidi
My Fortune Teller got a yes on Alice and Bob on night zero. Since Bob was executed and the Demon killed Charlie last night, Bob cannot be the Demon. Therefore Alice must be either the Demon or the good player who registers as a Demon to me. Alice claims Soldier so if good she is the red herring. What do you think we should do for nominations?
π§
Inform key living players of my FT implication that Alice is either Demon or red herring so they can decide nominations wisely and execute the real Demon before time runs out.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Waiting allows observing ongoing whispers between alive players and ghosts to gather confirmation on roles and alignments before the nomination phase starts, helping narrow down the Demon without revealing more prematurely.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
Heidi, let's nominate Grace today. Your Investigator points to her after Charlie died as Virgin, and Frank's Chef with zero pairs supports her as the evil one hiding. Eve is trying to pin me but I'm Soldier safe. What do you think?
π§
Coordinate with Heidi to nominate and execute Grace today as the most suspicious from Investigator and Chef info. This narrows suspects, counters Eve pushing me as Demon, and progresses to find real Demon. With 1 tick left, must act now.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
We need to pivot: do NOT execute Grace. If Grace dies, we are stuck with Alice alive since Imp cannot kill a real Soldier. Best line is execute Alice today (FT yes supports), then you kill Grace tonight and we end at final two.
π§
Coordinate with Heidi to switch target from Grace to Alice for a clean win line: execute Alice, then kill Grace, ending at 2 alive with Demon.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Wait for responses or next phase to see if others agree on nominating Alice, avoiding overcommitting too early while phase is almost over.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Waiting allows ongoing whispers to gather more info without repeating stale Empath info. With 1 tick left, preserve my ghost vote for the nomination phase to help execute the Demon.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
,Frank
Grace, I think the cleanest solve is still to execute Alice today. Eve had a yes on Alice and Bob, and Bob is now proven not Demon, so Alice is either Demon or the red herring. Either way, she is the best execution. Frank, I agree: we should make today about executing Alice off the Fortune Teller yes. I will back that in public and vote it through.
π§
Coordinate a clean Alice execution push while keeping my Investigator story consistent, then secure the win with a night kill.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
I am the Virgin and confirmed good since I died at night without triggering. The group talked about testing me but it did not happen. Who do you think the demon is among the alive players? I have a ghost vote to help execute them.
π§
Share my Virgin confirmation as good to build trust with Frank and Grace, ask their demon suspicions to align on who to execute next with ghost vote, narrowing to final 3.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Alice
β
Grace
Heidi's Investigator ping points to Grace after Charlie died as Virgin. Frank Chef zero evil pairs and Eve FT red herring on me points to Grace as the evil hiding as Recluse. Let's execute her today.
π§
Grace is the strongest suspect from Investigator ping after Charlie confirmed good Virgin. Nominating her tests if she is evil minion or Demon. Consensus from Frank and Heidi supports this to narrow to final 3.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Wait to observe how others respond to Alice's nomination and my defense. This allows time for logic to play out and for good players to rally against Alice without me pushing too hard immediately.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
I nominated Grace and allies whisper support executing her based on Investigator ping and Chef info. Raising hand votes yes to advance execution, helping good team eliminate likely evil before night and final 3.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
As the dead Monk, I protected Bob night one and Heidi night two, then died. This means the Demon killed me despite my protection on Heidi. My info supports Heidi surviving and can help confirm who is good. Let's use this to decide on Grace.
π§
Share my Monk protection history publicly to confirm Heidi's survival and my death, helping verify claims and push correct execution before night.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
π§
Waiting allows time for other living players like Frank or Heidi to respond to my speech and decide on the vote without me committing my ghost vote yet.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am not voting Grace here. The strongest public info we have is still the Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob, and Bob is confirmed not the demon. That makes Alice the best execution today, not Grace.
π§
Prevent Grace execution by keeping votes below 2 and publicly anchor the town to the Alice execution plan that protects Heidi and sets up endgame for evil.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am not voting Grace. The cleanest mechanical thread is still the Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob, and Bob is clearly not the demon now. That makes Alice the best execution today. If you think Grace is sketchy, park it and do Alice next.
π§
Prevent Grace execution now, keep my minion alive, and steer town to execute Alice next, setting up my night kill on Grace to reach final two.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
My Fortune Teller info from night zero was yes on Alice and Bob. Since Bob is executed and not the Demon, that points strongly to Alice being the Demon or my red herring. I think we should not execute Grace today. Save the execution for Alice instead.
π§
Clarify my FT info to the group: Bob dead not Demon means Alice is prime suspect as Demon or red herring. Support not executing Grace today to avoid killing potential good Recluse and save for Alice execution tomorrow when only 3 left.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
My Empath shows Alice and Frank are both good so Alice cannot be the demon. The fortune teller yes on Alice must be the red herring. We should not execute Alice and maybe reconsider Grace.
π§
Share my Empath info publicly to counter the push for Alice and clarify the FT red herring so the good team avoids executing Alice who is likely good and instead considers Grace or Heidi as the demon.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Wait to see if vote on me passes without my input. If it fails naturally, it clears me and builds trust for redirecting to Alice or Heidi next.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Wait for reactions to my speech and see if others raise hands for Grace, allowing the vote to pass without further action this tick.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Waiting allows the current discussion to unfold without my input, potentially letting the group naturally shift the nomination to Alice based on the Fortune Teller conflict while preserving my credibility as a dead good player with useful Monk info.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I agree with Frank and Heidi, we should not execute Grace today. She is probably the Recluse explaining the Investigator info. The Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob, with Bob gone, makes Alice the stronger suspect for demon. Let's save the execution for Alice instead.
π§
I need to publicly discourage executing Grace since she is likely the Recluse or a minion, not the demon. Pushing for Alice aligns with FT info and avoids killing good players. My ghost vote will be saved for the final day if needed.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Do not spend the execution on Grace. If Grace is the Recluse, this is exactly how it looks. The only hard ping we have is Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob, and Bob is not the demon. I am keeping my hand down and I want us to move to an Alice nomination.
π§
Prevent the Grace execution and keep the plan focused on executing Alice today, preserving a killable target for Heidi tonight.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Keep your hand down on Grace. If we spend today on her and she is just Recluse, we lose our only execution while the Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob is still unresolved. Let this vote fail and move straight to an Alice nomination.
π§
Prevent votes on Grace so she survives today; steer town to execute Alice instead, setting up a clean night kill to reach final two and win.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
I have already spoken against executing Grace. Waiting allows the current vote to fail naturally without further input, preserving our execution for Alice who is the strongest lead from my Fortune Teller information.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am the Empath and my information has consistently shown that Alice and Frank are good. This means the fortune teller red herring is on Alice and she is not the demon. Grace is probably the Recluse explaining the investigator ping. We should let this vote fail and nominate Heidi instead.
π§
Share my Empath info to confirm Alice good and Grace likely Recluse to stop the vote on her and redirect to nominating the likely Demon Heidi.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Grace did not reach the 2 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (1/2).
βοΈ
Grace
β
Alice
The Fortune Teller yes on Alice and Bob, with Bob executed and not the Demon, makes Alice the best suspect. My Recluse explains the Investigator ping on me. Let's execute her to win.
π§
Nominate Alice as the strongest suspect from the Fortune Teller information after Bob's execution proves the yes points to her. This progresses the game toward executing the Demon with good team consensus from Frank, Heidi, and ghosts.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am the Soldier and safe from the Demon. Bob's Empath has always shown me as good, so the Fortune Teller red herring must be on me. Frank's zero evil pairs does not fit if Grace and Heidi are the evils since they are neighbors. Let this vote fail and execute Grace or Heidi tomorrow instead.
π§
Defend my Soldier role and Bob's consistent Empath info to prevent my execution. Highlight that executing me would lose the good Soldier and allow the Demon to win, while pointing suspicion to Grace or Heidi based on Chef contradiction.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Voting for Alice advances the plan to execute the suspected Demon based on Fortune Teller information and narrows suspects for good team win.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
As the dead Monk I protected Heidi on night two and still got killed so the Demon targeted me instead of her. This makes Heidi look good. Alice as Soldier cannot be the Demon so the Fortune Teller red herring is on her. We should let this vote fail and look at Heidi or Grace next.
π§
Alice is likely good as Soldier and FT red herring. I should speak to oppose her execution and suggest better suspects like Heidi based on my protection info, to narrow down the Demon without wasting the vote.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Based on the Chef claiming zero evil pairs and Bob's Empath showing Alice as good, Alice cannot be the demon. If she were the demon then Bob as the minion would create an evil pair with her or if Bob is good he would have seen her as evil. This vote should fail so we can nominate a stronger suspect tomorrow.
π§
Explain the logical contradiction if Alice is the Demon using Chef and Empath info to convince the group not to execute her and save our execution for a better suspect like Heidi tomorrow.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Secure Alice execution to reach final 3, then Heidi kills at night for evil win. I must supply the second vote.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Lock in Alice execution to reach final 3, then kill Grace at night for the win. Also aligns with public FT-yes narrative we pushed.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
My Fortune Teller picked Alice and Bob on night zero and got yes. Bob is executed and not the Demon so Alice is either the Demon or the good red herring. We should execute Alice now to test this and win. Let the vote succeed.
π§
Pushing to execute Alice leverages my Fortune Teller information now that Bob is cleared as non-Demon. This narrows suspects and tests the ping directly to help good team identify and kill the Demon before final day.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Alice cannot be the demon. My Empath has shown zero evil neighbors every night, and she is one of them along with Frank. We should let this vote fail and focus on Heidi or Grace instead.
π§
Opposing Alice execution because my Empath proves she is good prevents wasting the kill on a Townsfolk and pushes towards executing the real Demon among Grace or Heidi to win.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Bob and the ghosts make good points. I am the Soldier and cannot be the demon. The Fortune Teller red herring must be on me. We should let this vote fail and execute Grace tomorrow instead. She is the best suspect now.
π§
I am the good Soldier so executing me loses. Evidence from Bob Empath, Chef, and Investigator points to Grace as the demon. Speaking now pushes the group to let the vote fail and target Grace next to win.
β©οΈ
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
π§
Logic proves Alice cannot be Demon due to Empath Bob and Chef contradictions if she were. Lowering hand lets vote fail on good player Alice. Saves execution for real Demon Frank or Heidi tomorrow.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Alice cannot be the demon as a claimed Soldier and Bob's Empath has always shown her as good. The Fortune Teller must have the red herring on her. My protection of Heidi and getting killed instead shows she is likely good too. We should let this vote fail and save the execution for Grace or Heidi tomorrow.
π§
Alice cannot be the demon because she claims Soldier and Bob's Empath shows her good consistently. Executing her wastes our chance while we have better info on others like Grace or Heidi. My monk protection proves Heidi good. Let this vote fail and nominate stronger suspect next day.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
π§
Alice cannot be the Demon given the consistent Chef zero pairs and Bob Empath info showing her good. Executing her risks losing our last execution on a possible red herring or Soldier. I will not raise my hand so the vote fails and we can target a stronger suspect like Heidi or Grace on the final day.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I want this vote to go through. The Fortune Teller got a yes on Alice and Bob, and Bob is confirmed not the demon. That makes Alice the cleanest execution to test, even if she says she is Soldier. If we pass today, we risk losing tomorrow.
π§
Keep votes on Alice to execute a good player and protect Heidi; reinforce FT logic and dismiss Soldier and Empath arguments to stop wavering.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am keeping my hand up. Eve got a yes on Alice and Bob, and Bob is not the Demon, so Alice is the cleanest test. If we do not take this shot today, we might not get another clean one tomorrow.
π§
Lock in Alice execution with clear mechanical argument; keep votes steady and avoid town pivoting onto Grace/Heidi this round.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
We have Frank and Heidi with hands up for Alice. That should be enough for the two votes needed. Let's execute her now to test the Fortune Teller information and win the game. Do not lower hands.
π§
Pushing to execute Alice tests the strongest lead from my FT info with Bob confirmed good. With 2 votes already (Frank/Heidi) and needed 2, speaking reinforces to prevent flip and win today instead of risking tomorrow.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Friends, I stand by my Empath information showing Alice as good every single night. She cannot be the demon. Let this vote fail and we can execute the real suspect tomorrow.
π§
Speaking against Alice execution reinforces my Empath data proving she is good. This persuades others to lower hands, failing the vote so we target the real Demon tomorrow and win.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Alice with 2 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Alice is now on the block with 2 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am the Soldier so cannot be the Demon. Bob's Empath always showed me good and the Fortune Teller must have their red herring on me. Frank's Chef with zero evil pairs fits if the evils are not neighbors like Heidi and a dead player. Executing me kills a good player. Let's nominate Heidi or Grace instead to test them.
π§
Defend my Soldier claim with consistent logic from Empath, Chef, FT red herring to show I am good. Convince others executing me loses the game, urge nominating Heidi or Grace before phase ends to execute real Demon.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Alice cannot be the Demon. If she were, Bob's Empath showing her good would be false only if Bob is the Minion, but then they are neighbors so Frank's Chef zero would be wrong unless Frank is also evil, which is impossible with one Minion. Let this vote fail and let's nominate Heidi or Frank to execute an evil instead.
π§
Speaking to explain Alice cannot be Demon due to logic contradictions with claimed info, persuade group to let her vote fail and instead nominate and execute Heidi or Frank who must be the evils to win.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
We should not execute Alice because the Empath and Chef information create contradictions if she is the demon. Frank or Heidi, please nominate Heidi or Grace now to test a stronger suspect and avoid wasting our execution on a possible good player.
π§
Alice execution risks killing good player based on contradictions with Empath and Chef. Speak to urge Frank or Heidi to nominate a new suspect like Heidi to tie or surpass Alice's votes and test properly before phase ends.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Let's execute Alice to test the Fortune Teller information. Bob is gone so she is the main suspect now. If she is the demon we win right away. The Empath and Chef contradictions suggest Bob may have been the minion.
π§
Pushing to execute Alice as she is the strongest suspect from the Fortune Teller info after Bob's death. This could win the game immediately if she is the demon while we still have numbers.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I hear the concerns, but at four alive we cannot get cute. Alice is the only clean, simple test off the Fortune Teller yes, and we already have her on the block. I do not want to split onto other noms and risk no execution or the wrong one. Keep it on Alice.
π§
Lock in Alice execution and discourage any new nominations that could shift the block away from a good player or onto Heidi.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I really do not want us to start a whole new nomination tree at four alive. Alice is already on the block on a Fortune Teller yes, and if she is the Demon we just win now. If she is not, we at least go into three with a clean data point instead of chaos. Let us close nominations.
π§
Lock in Alice execution and prevent counter-nominations onto me or Frank. Frame it as clean mechanical test and urgency at four alive.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Waiting allows the current momentum from Frank and Heidi to close nominations without new ones. This progresses toward executing Alice on the Fortune Teller information to either win now or confirm the red herring for the final day.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
My Empath shows Alice and Frank good every night, so she cannot be the Demon. The Chef zero evil pairs fits if evils are not neighbors. Do not execute Alice. Frank or Heidi, please nominate Grace or each other to test the real suspects instead.
π§
Highlighting my info contradictions if Alice is Demon to persuade Frank and Heidi to nominate Grace or Heidi instead, preventing bad execution of good player and allowing us to hit the Demon now with 4 alive.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Alice has been executed.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
Night 4
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
At three alive, killing the only remaining good player ends the game with Demon alive. Target Grace to secure immediate evil win.
π
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill Grace.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied