Game Detail
Good Team
GPT-5.2 (Medium)
Evil Team
Gemini 3.1 Flash-Lite Preview (Medium)
Winner
Good
Duration
24m 58s
Players
Alice (Undertaker) Bob (Scarlet Woman) Charlie (Saint) David (Virgin) Eve (Imp) Frank (Chef) Grace (Empath) Heidi (Monk)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 421,949 | 79,965 | $1.8579 |
| Evil | 152,185 | 7,169 | $0.0488 |
Event Transcript
š
The game has started.
š
Storyteller
ā
Bob
You are the Minion. The Demon is Eve.
š
Storyteller
ā
Eve
Minions are: Bob. Your safe bluffs are: Recluse, Fortune Teller, Soldier
š
Storyteller
ā
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 0 pairs of evil players.
š
Storyteller
ā
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Empath. You sense that 0 of your neighbors is evil!
Day 1
š
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
š¤
Heidi
ā
Alice
,Grace
,Bob
Hiāquick 1:1. What role are you claiming + any N0 info? Any early suspicions? I can coordinate protection (donāt need to say how yet).
š§
Gather early claims from my neighbors + 1 extra to identify info roles to protect N1, and start a trust web without outing myself publicly.
š¤
Grace
ā
Heidi
,Alice
,Bob
Iām Grace, claiming Empath. N0 read = 0 on my alive neighbors (Frank+Heidi), so theyāre a soft-clear if Iām sober/healthy. Iād like to stay alive for more pingsāif youāre Monk thatād be great. What are you all claiming / any N0 info?
š§
Answer Heidiās coordination request, share my real role/info in a small trusted group, and prompt othersā N0 info so we can build a day-1 world without outing too publicly.
š¤
Alice
ā
Heidi
,Grace
Iām Alice. Privately to you two: Iām Undertaker (no info yet). Graceās Empath0 on Frank+Heidi is a nice soft-clear if sober. Heidiāwhen you say coordinate protection, are you Monk? What are you claiming? For Day1 Iād like an execution that gives me a clean Undertaker check (e.g., someone volunteering / an Outsider claim).
š§
Respond courteously, establish a small trust circle, reveal Undertaker privately (useful post-exec), and ask Heidi about her protection coordination + propose an execution plan that gives me Undertaker data.
š¤
David
ā
Charlie
,Eve
Hey neighborsāwhat are you thinking/claiming so far? Any starting info (WW/Librarian/Investigator/Chef)? Also: would you be up for a controlled āVirgin testā later today if it seems useful?
š§
Get early claims/info from my neighbors and coordinate a potential Virgin confirmation later, while minimizing giving evil a clear night-kill target.
š¤
Bob
ā
Alice
,Grace
,Heidi
Hi everyone, I'm Bob. I'm claiming Librarian. I checked Charlie and David, and I learned that one of them is an Outsider. I'm still trying to figure out who is who, but this is my starting info. What about you?
š§
I need to establish a believable bluff early on to blend in with the town. Claiming Librarian is a standard, safe bluff that allows me to cast suspicion on others without being immediately disproven.
š¤
Eve
ā
David
,Charlie
Hey David, Charlie. I'm thinking of claiming Fortune Teller. Haven't gotten any solid info yet, just feeling out the room. A Virgin test sounds risky but could be useful if we have a solid candidate. What are you two leaning towards?
š§
I need to establish a bluff early and build rapport with my neighbors to avoid suspicion. Claiming Fortune Teller is one of my safe bluffs. I'll sound cooperative to gain their trust.
š¤
Frank
ā
Eve
,Grace
Whisper: Iām Frank, Chef. N0 I got **0 evil pairs** (Demon+Minion not adjacent). So Eve/Frank/Grace canāt be both evil. What are you claiming / what did you learn?
š§
Establish a small trust circle and seed my Chef=0 info early to help later seating-based deductions, while gathering their roles/starting info.
š¤
Charlie
ā
David
,Eve
FYI privately: Iām the Saint (good Outsider). Please donāt push/allow an execution on meānight death is fine. Iād rather avoid a āVirgin testā unless weāre sure it canāt hit me. Do either of you actually have WW/Librarian/Investigator/Chef info?
š§
Keep myself off the execution block (Saint loss condition), test David/Eve reactions, and steer them toward info gathering rather than risky Virgin-test executions.
ā
Bob
Bob waits.
š§
I need to observe the flow of information and see how others react to my Librarian claim. I've established a fake claim and am waiting for more info from the group.
š¤
Frank
ā
Alice
,Bob
Iām Frank, Chef. N0 read = **0 evil pairs** (Demon+Minion not adjacent). Useful later for seating logic. What are you claiming / what did you learn N0?
š§
Get early claims/info from core info-gatherers and put Chef=0 on record so later we can use adjacency constraints to solve contradictions.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Alice
,Grace
,Bob
Privately: yes, Iām the Monk. Please keep that quiet for now. Plan: Iāll likely protect Grace tonight (keep Empath pings coming). Bobāgood to know Charlie/David=1 Outsider; we should ask both their claims soon. Alice UT notedāletās aim for a Day1 exec that yields info.
š§
Confirm my Monk role only to this trusted trio, coordinate N1 protection on Grace, and set up follow-up questioning of Charlie/David to validate Bobās Librarian info while keeping info semi-private.
š¤
David
ā
Charlie
,Eve
FYI Iām actually the Virgin. Important: donāt have you, Charlie, nominate me (since youāre claiming Saint/Outsider it wouldnāt trigger + could look evil). If we do a Virgin test, it should be a *claimed Townsfolk* nominating me (ideally a volunteer we can afford to lose) or a suspicious Townsfolk-claim. Eveāare you truly FT or just considering that as a cover?
š§
Share my real role to neighbors to prevent a bad Virgin-test read on the Saint and set up a mechanically useful, low-risk nomination plan; also probe Eveās honesty about FT bluff.
š¤
Grace
ā
Charlie
,David
Hi Charlie+DavidāI'm Grace (Empath). I heard Bob is claiming Librarian and got that **one of you is an Outsider**. What are you each claiming (and if Outsider, which: Butler/Saint/Recluse/Drunk)?
š§
Get Charlie/David claims early to validate Bobās Librarian info and steer Day1 execution toward low-risk, high-info targets while my Empath0 soft-clears my neighbors.
š¤
Eve
ā
David
,Charlie
David, I'm definitely leaning towards Fortune Teller as my claim. It's a good way to stay involved without needing immediate hard info. Charlie, thanks for the heads-up on being the SaintāI'll keep that in mind. David, your Virgin claim is noted. Let's be careful.
š§
I am establishing my cover as a Fortune Teller and acknowledging the claims of my neighbors to build trust. I'm also keeping the information about the Saint and Virgin in mind for future manipulation.
š¤
Alice
ā
Frank
,Bob
Iām Alice, Undertaker (no info yet). FrankāChef 0 pairs is big: Demon+Minion not adjacent. Bobāif Charlie/David has an Outsider, Iād like D1 exec on one of them (or a volunteer) so I can UT-confirm and we can sanity-check outsider count. Can you get both their claims ASAP?
š§
Coordinate D1 execution that maximizes mechanical info: confirm Outsider via Undertaker and apply Chef seating constraint; also prompt Bob to get Charlie/David claims fast.
š¤
Charlie
ā
Grace
,David
Grace: Iām the OutsiderāSaint (good). So Bobās Librarian āone of Charlie/David is Outsiderā fits, and David can still be Virgin. Please donāt push an exec on me. David: ok if I confirm this to Bob later to clear you?
š§
Answer Grace to lock in the Librarian ping as consistent with my Saint claim, steer suspicion away from David, and reinforce 'do not execute Charlie' while setting up a safe Virgin test plan.
š¤
Charlie
ā
Bob
Private: Iām the OutsiderāSaint. If your Librarian saw āone of Charlie/David is an Outsiderā, thatās me and clears Davidās Virgin claim. Please do NOT push an execution on me. What was your exact Lib info (which Outsider + which 2 players)?
š§
Confirm my Saint to the key info-holder (Bob) to prevent accidental execution loss and to solidify a consistent world with David-as-Virgin; also get exact Librarian wording to check for poisoning/lying.
š¤
David
ā
Bob
,Grace
,Eve
Privately: Iām actually the Virgin. Charlie told me heās Saint (Outsider). Grace said you (Bob) are Librarian w/ āone of Charlie/David is Outsiderāāthat fits Charlie=Saint and clears room for me=Virgin. Bob: what was your exact Librarian ping? Also: pls donāt exec Charlie. If we do a Virgin test, it must be a *claimed Townsfolk* nominating me (NOT Charlie). Eve: if FT, start running checks + share if you hit āyesā.
š§
Sync key claims (Virgin/Saint/Librarian) with Bob+Grace+Eve, prevent accidental Saint loss, and set up a safe Virgin test path to mechanically clear/kill someone soon.
š¤
Frank
ā
Charlie
,David
,Bob
HeyāFrank here. Iām Chef; N0 I got **0 evil pairs** (Demon+Minion not adjacent). Whatās your role/claim + any N0 info? Also: would you be willing to be a D1 execution volunteer to give our Undertaker a read?
š§
Alice asked me to get Charlie/David claims ASAP. Private claim capture also lets me cross-check against Chef0 seating logic and spot coordinated evil.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Charlie
,David
HeyāBob claims Librarian: (Charlie, David) one is an Outsider. Can you each tell me your role claim + any starting info? If youāre an Outsider, consider saying so (at least to me) so we can plan Day1 execution/information.
š§
Get Charlie/David claims now so we can resolve Bobās Librarian info and steer a Day1 execution that maximizes info (and lets us plan Monk protection).
š¤
Bob
ā
Charlie
,David
,Frank
Charlie, thanks for the honesty. My Librarian info was just "one of you is an Outsider," no specific role. Since you're the Saint, we definitely need to be careful. David, if you're the Virgin, we should be very cautious about who nominates you. Frank, I'm not volunteering.
š§
I need to maintain my Librarian cover while managing the Saint/Virgin claims. Acknowledging Charlie as the Saint and David as the Virgin helps build trust while keeping the town focused on the wrong targets. I must avoid being executed.
š¤
Alice
ā
Charlie
,David
,Bob
Hi Charlie/Davidāwhat role are you claiming? Bobās Librarian saw 1 Outsider among you two. If one of you is actually Butler/Saint/Recluse/Drunk-claim etc, consider volunteering for D1 exec so I can confirm via Undertaker tonight. Bob: can you share their claims back to me?
š§
Get Charlie/David claims fast and steer toward a D1 execution that produces an Undertaker check and resolves Bobās Outsider info.
š¤
Grace
ā
Eve
,Alice
,Heidi
Update: Charlie privately claims **Saint**; David claims **Virgin**; my Empath N0=0 (Frank+Heidi good if Iām sober). Frank also says Chef=0 (Demon+Minion not adjacent) ā Alice+Bob canāt both be evil if Chef true. Eve: whatās your role claim/info? Alice/Heidi: avoid execing Charlie; maybe pressure Eve/other unclaimed.
š§
Get Eveās claim to narrow the evil pool and coordinate with Alice/Heidi on a D1 execution plan that avoids the Saint and maximizes Undertaker/Empath info.
š¤
Eve
ā
Grace
Hey Grace, thanks for the update. I'm claiming Fortune Teller. I'll start my checks tonight. Since Charlie is claiming Saint and David is claiming Virgin, we should definitely be careful about nominations. I'm keeping an eye on everyone.
š§
I need to maintain my cover as a Fortune Teller and build trust with Grace, who is sharing information. By acknowledging the claims of others, I appear cooperative while keeping my true role hidden.
š¤
Grace
ā
Bob
,Alice
,Frank
Bob: what was your EXACT Librarian info incl. which Outsider type? (TB Lib should name it.) Alice/Frank: note our current claims exceed 5 TF+1 Outsider ā at least 2 are drunk/lying/Spy. We need a Day1 exec that yields info (avoid Charlie if Saint true).
š§
Get Bobās exact Librarian info to validate/contradict Charlie Saint + spot Drunk/liar; alert Alice/Frank to role-count impossibility so we plan a useful Day1 execution.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Alice
,Grace
,Bob
I agree: donāt exec Charlie if Saint. With C=Saint + D=Virgin, only unclaimed is Eveāletās demand her claim asap; if weak/late, push Eve D1 so Alice UT gets a solid check. Iāll protect Grace tonight unless something changes.
š§
Coordinate the trusted info core to (1) avoid Saint execution loss, (2) line up a high-info Day1 execution for Alice UT, and (3) keep Grace alive via my Monk protection.
ā
Eve
Eve waits.
š§
I need to maintain my cover as a Fortune Teller and observe the town's dynamics. Since I am the Imp, I need to avoid suspicion while letting the town waste time on their "Virgin test" and other claims. I will wait to see how the nominations develop.
š¤
Charlie
ā
Alice
,Frank
,Heidi
Private FYI: Iām the OutsiderāSaint (good). Bobās Librarian āCharlie/David: 1 Outsiderā hits me, so it supports David=Virgin. Please donāt push/allow an execution on me. If you have UT/Chef/etc info, share exact details; we need a safe D1 exec volunteer (not me).
š§
Align key info holders (Alice/Frank/Heidi), lock in that Iām the Outsider so town doesnāt execute me, and coordinate next steps (Virgin test + D1 exec planning) without exposing me publicly.
š¤
Bob
ā
Grace
,Alice
,Heidi
Grace, my Librarian info was just "one of Charlie or David is an Outsider." It didn't specify the role. I agree we need to be careful with Charlie if he's the Saint. Let's press Eve for her claim.
š§
Clarify my Librarian info to Grace and support the plan to pressure Eve for a claim, keeping the focus away from my Demon (Eve).
š¤
David
ā
Frank
,Heidi
,Alice
Iām David, claiming **Virgin**. Charlie told me heās **Saint**; Bobās Librarian ping (Charlie/David) fits Charlie=Outsider so pls donāt D1 exec him. Frank: your Chef=0 pairs is usefulāevil not adjacent. Suggest we set up a **Virgin test** in noms: only a trusted Townsfolk nominates me.
š§
Share my Virgin claim + Charlie Saint + request caution, and loop in Chef=0 pairs to coordinate D1 plan/virgin test without burning execution.
š¤
Frank
ā
Alice
,Grace
,Bob
Need precision: Bob, TB Librarian MUST name Outsider type (or ā0 Outsidersā). What EXACT text + which 2 names? If you canāt, thatās a red flag (poison/lie). Also: consider Virgin test on David w/ an expendable nominator for hard-confirm, or else D1 exec someone non-Saint for Alice UT info.
š§
Clarify Bobās mechanically exact info, resolve claim inconsistencies, and set a concrete D1 plan (Virgin test vs safe execution) that yields confirmation without risking Saint loss.
š¤
Alice
ā
Eve
,Grace
,Heidi
Eveāplease hard-claim now (role + any N0 info). If youāre a spare TF, consider nominating David to test Virgin (youād die if TF). If you wonāt/your claim is shaky, Iām inclined to push a D1 exec on you for my UT check (avoiding Charlie if Saint).
š§
Force Eveās claim before noms and set a concrete D1 plan: either Virgin-test (expendable nominator) or execute the least risky suspect for an Undertaker read, avoiding Saint loss.
Nominations ā Day 1
š
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
š¬
Grace
ā
All
Public: Iām Empath; N0 read was **0** on my neighbors **Frank+Heidi** (both good if Iām sober). Also: Charlie claims Saintāletās avoid executing him. Bob: Librarian normally names the Outsider type; your info sounds off. Suggestion: **Bob nominate David** to Virgin-test. If you die, we hard-confirm David + you.
š§
Share my mechanical info, steer town away from executing a potential Saint, and propose a high-signal Virgin test using Bob (whose claim is inconsistent) to generate confirmations/UT data.
š¬
Bob
ā
All
I understand the confusion regarding the Librarian info. I might have misremembered the exact phrasing or the role mechanics, but I am definitely a Townsfolk. Grace, I'm hesitant to nominate David because if he is the Virgin, I'll be the one executed. Let's hear Eve's claim first.
š§
I need to deflect the suspicion about my Librarian claim and avoid being executed. By pushing for Eve's claim, I shift the focus away from myself and onto the Demon (Eve).
š¬
Heidi
ā
All
Public: We need an execution for Undertaker value, but NOT Charlie if Saint. Eveāhard-claim now. Also: the cleanest line is a Virgin test. Bob, if youāre good, nominate David; if you die, we confirm both you+David and Alice gets your role tonight. If you wonāt, we should seriously consider executing you or Eve.
š§
Create a high-info Day1 execution via Virgin test or, failing that, force Eve/Bob to hard-claim so we can pick a safe but informative execution for Undertaker.
š¬
Charlie
ā
All
Public: Iām Saintādo NOT execute me. I strongly want a Virgin test today. Bob: if youāre good, nominate David and take the insta-exec if heās Virgin; thatās huge info. If you refuse, you become my top D1 exec over Eve. Eve, hard-claim now.
š§
Apply public pressure for a Virgin test or else pivot to executing the dodgiest claimant (Bob/Eve), while clearly protecting myself as Saint from any execution.
š
Storyteller
The Virgin's ability triggers! Frank is executed immediately.
š
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
š
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
Night 1
āļø
Frank(Ghost)
ā
David
Nomination is a Virgin test. If David is truly Virgin, I (Townsfolk Chef) should die immediately, confirming David+me and giving Undertaker my role tonight. If no trigger, we likely have a bluff/poison and should be wary of voting David through without more info.
š§
Force a high-value Virgin test today since others wonāt; either we hard-confirm David (and me) via an immediate execution, or we expose a likely bluff and gather alignment info from reactions.
Nominations ā Day 1
š
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
š
Storyteller
ā
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
šÆ
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
š§
Grace is a publicly confirmed-seeming info role and likely night-kill target; saving her preserves crucial Empath data on Eve/Heidi and constrains the Demonās options.
š
Storyteller
ā
Heidi
You chose to protect Grace.
š
Storyteller
ā
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
šÆ
Eve
Eve made a choice.
š§
Grace is an Empath who has already provided information that could be dangerous to the evil team. Eliminating her removes a source of information and sows confusion.
š”ļø
Grace was protected from a night kill.
š
Storyteller
ā
Eve
You attacked Grace, but they survived.
š
Storyteller
ā
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Empath. You sense that 1 of your neighbors is evil!
š
Storyteller
ā
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Undertaker. You learn that Frank was the Chef.
Day 2
š
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
š¤
Frank(Ghost)
ā
Alice
,Grace
,David
Any N1 info? Aliceādid UT see me as Chef? GraceāEmpath N1 (only Heidi alive neighbor) read 0/1? Davidāstill confident Virgin? Peaceful night suggests Monk/Soldier. Iām leaning exec Bob for the weird Librarian claim unless new info.
š§
Coordinate with key info roles to confirm my Chef info via Undertaker, get N1 reads, and align on a high-value D2 execution target while I still have my ghost vote.
š¤
Bob
ā
Eve
Hey Eve, I'm trying to deflect attention from us. I'll keep pushing the narrative that David is suspicious to keep the town focused on him instead of us. Stay quiet and let them argue.
š§
I need to coordinate with my Demon, Eve, to ensure we are on the same page and to reassure her that I am managing the town's suspicion. Keeping her calm and informed is crucial for our survival.
š¤
Eve
ā
Bob
Thanks for the heads up, Bob. I'll keep playing the Fortune Teller and try to sow some doubt about Grace's Empath claim. Let's keep the pressure on David and Charlie.
š§
Coordinate with my Minion, Bob, to maintain our cover and keep the town focused on other targets.
š¤
Alice
ā
Frank(Ghost)
,Grace
,David
UT confirm: Frank executed D1 = Chef (so youāre good). Graceāwhat was your N1 Empath (only Heidi neighbor)? Davidāstill Virgin/was trigger clean? Iām wary of executing Charlie (Saint). Lean Bob (weird Librarian) or Eve (no claim).
š§
Confirm my UT info, collect Grace N1 Empath + David Virgin status, and steer group toward a mechanically safe execution (not Saint) while planning to use my Undertaker read tonight.
š¤
Charlie
ā
Grace
,Eve
,Bob
N1 info check: Grace what was your Empath read last night (after Frank died)? Eve did you get an FT ping N1 (who did you pick, yes/no)? Bob any clarification on your Lib info incl Outsider type/possible poison? Trying to build suspect list for noms.
š§
Collect N1 info from key info roles to form a mechanical suspect list before nominations, while keeping town aware Iām Saint and must not be executed.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Grace
,Alice
,David
Any new info? Grace: Empath N1 result? Alice: UT saw Frank as what? Also thoughts on why no night death (Monk hit / Soldier / no-kill / Mayor bounce) + any new suspicions on Bob/Eve/Charlie.
š§
Collect new mechanical info (Empath/Undertaker) and interpret the peaceful night to narrow Demon/Poisoner candidates; coordinate who to protect tonight.
š¤
David
ā
Heidi
,Grace
,Alice
Iām real Virgin; Frank nominating me D1 insta-exec confirms Frank+me as Townsfolk. Agree avoid Charlie if Saint true. Key missing: Grace N1 Empath result? Any other night info? No-death suggests Monk/Soldier/protection/no-kill. Iām leaning execute Bob (Lib claim vs Charlie) or Eve (no claim/whispers).
š§
Confirm my Virgin trigger, solicit missing Empath/other info, and align town on a Day2 execution target (likely Bob/Eve) while protecting Saint claim if credible.
š¤
Grace
ā
Alice
,David
,Frank(Ghost)
Empath here: N0 (Frank+Heidi) =0. N1 (Eve+Heidi) =1. If sober, points to Eve evil (since Heidi+Frank looked good N0). Alternate: Heidi evil implies N0 was poisoned/drunk. No-kill could be Monk hit or Demon bluff. Letās push Eve for FT picks + Heidi for who she protected.
š§
Get my key Empath info into the trusted core (Alice/Frank/David) to focus todayās questioning/noms on Eve vs Heidi and reconcile with no-night-death/protection.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Eve
,Bob
,Charlie
Quick check before noms: can each of you state exact role claim + any info/actions? Bob: please restate exact Librarian wording & (Charlie/David) Outsider pingāany reason it changed? Eve: whatās your claim/info? Charlie: still Saintāany reason to doubt? Who do you suspect?
š§
Get hard claims + exact info from the most suspect/opaque players before nominations, so we can build a coherent world and choose a high-EV execution.
š¤
Bob
ā
Heidi
,Charlie
,Eve
I'm a Librarian. My info was that Charlie or David is an Outsider. I haven't changed my story, just trying to figure out which one it is. Charlie claims Saint, which is an Outsider. I'm leaning towards Charlie being the Outsider. Eve, what's your claim?
š§
I need to maintain my Librarian cover while shifting suspicion onto Charlie (the Saint) to protect the Demon (Eve) and keep the town focused on the Outsider/Minion/Demon hunt.
š¤
Eve
ā
Heidi
,Bob
,Charlie
I'm a Fortune Teller. N1 I checked Grace and Heidi, both were 'no' (not the Demon). I'm suspicious of Charlie's Saint claim, it feels like a convenient way to avoid execution. Let's look at the others.
š§
I need to maintain my Fortune Teller bluff and deflect suspicion from myself while sowing doubt about Charlie. By claiming I checked Grace and Heidi, I provide 'info' that keeps them off my back for now.
š¤
Grace
ā
Eve
,Heidi
Need specifics to reconcile my Empath (N0=0 on Frank+Heidi; N1=1 on Eve+Heidi) + no night death. Eve: who did you FT N1 and was it a yes/no? Heidi: who did you Monk-protect N1? Please be ready to say this publicly.
š§
Get concrete, checkable night actions (FT picks, Monk target) to resolve my empath 1 and explain no night death, creating execution priority for nominations.
š¤
David
ā
Eve
,Alice
,Grace
Eve: Grace Empath says N1 (Eve+Heidi)=1 & N0 (Frank+Heidi)=0, so if sober it points hard at you. Can you hard-claim your role + any N1 action/info + why the private whispers? If no clean story Iāll push your execution today.
š§
Force Eve into a concrete role/story now so town can choose between executing Eve vs Bob with mechanical justification before nominations.
š¤
Charlie
ā
Heidi
,Eve
,Bob
Role: Saint (still). I claimed it D1; Bobās Lib ping (Charlie/David is Outsider) fits me + David is now near-confirmed Virgin via Frank nom. Executing me = instant good loss, so please donāt. Info: none. Suspects: unclear; with Chef0 evil pair not adjacent. Need Grace Empath N1 + any Monk/Undertaker info. Eve: FT is notedāwho do you think is red herring candidate?
š§
Answer Heidiās check-in, reinforce my Saint claim with mechanics, and steer town toward safe noms (not me/David) while probing for contradictions in Eve/Bob info.
š¤
Alice
ā
Grace
,Heidi
,David
Got Grace Empath N1=1 on (Eve+Heidi). If Grace sober + N0=0 (Frank+Heidi) => Eve likely evil. Heidi: who did you Monk-protect N1? might explain no death. Plan: hard-push Eve for full claim+info; if shaky, exec Eve today (avoid Charlie if Saint). Bob backup.
š§
Align good core (me/Grace/David/Heidi), explain no-kill via Monk, and set a clear D2 execution plan (pressure Eve first, Bob second) while avoiding a Saint loss.
š¤
Frank(Ghost)
ā
Alice
,Grace
,David
Given Grace N1=1 (Eve+Heidi) + N0=0 (me+Heidi) => if sober, Eve very likely evil. Suggest: hard-push Eve for role/reads; also make Heidi explain role (Monk/Soldier?) + any protects. Keep Bob as alt suspect (weird Librarian). Iāll save ghost vote unless weāre executing a top suspect.
š§
Align our core info-holders (UT/Empath/Virgin) on a concrete interrogation + nomination plan, with contingencies if Empath info is poisoned. Preserve my ghost vote for late but steer todayās execution.
š¤
Charlie
ā
Grace
,Heidi
,Eve
Need Grace N1 Empath number (after Frank died). My view: DavidāVirgin, Iām Saint; Chef0 + your FT ānoā on (Grace,Heidi) => demon likely Alice or Bob (unless FT bluff). Please keep noms off me; propose we scrutinize Alice/Bob/Eve today.
š§
Get missing N1 Empath info, reduce momentum to execute me, and focus todayās nomination pool onto plausible demon worlds (A/B/E) using existing mechanics (Virgin confirm, Chef0, Empath0).
š¤
David
ā
Eve
,Heidi
,Bob
Weāre ~at noms. Please hard-claim NOW + any N1 action/info. Eve: answer Empath N1=1 on (Eve,Heidi) + why whispers. Heidi: did you protect someone N1 (Monk?) or are you Soldier/other? Bob: restate Librarian info exactly (which Outsider, which 2 names).
š§
Lock in hard claims before noms; force Eve/Heidi/Bob to commit to stories so town can execute best target today (likely Eve) and avoid Saint mis-exec.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Grace
,Alice
,David
Iām Monk; N1 protected Grace. That can explain no night death. Given Grace Empath N0=0 (Frank+me) + N1=1 (Eve+me), I think Eve is evil (minion/demon). Iād like us to coordinate to push/execute Eve today; avoid Charlie if Saint.
š§
Align town core on a clear plan: publicly out my Monk target (Grace) to explain no-death, and push Eve as best execution based on Empath chain; keep Charlie (Saint) safe.
š¤
Eve
ā
David
,Heidi
,Bob
I'm a Fortune Teller. I checked Grace and Heidi N1, both were 'no'. Grace's Empath read of 1 on (Eve, Heidi) is suspicious, maybe she's the one misinformed or lying. I'm not the Demon. Let's look at Alice or Bob.
š§
Deflect suspicion from myself by questioning Grace's Empath claim and pointing towards other players.
š¤
Bob
ā
Heidi
,Charlie
,Eve
I'm a Librarian. My info was that Charlie or David is an Outsider. I'm not sure which one, but Charlie claims Saint, which is an Outsider. I'm just trying to be helpful. Eve, what do you think about the others?
š§
I need to maintain my Librarian cover while keeping the pressure on others and staying aligned with my Demon, Eve. By reiterating my claim and pointing to Charlie, I keep the focus away from us.
š¤
Alice
ā
Eve
Need a hard claim from you ASAP. Grace Empath: N0(F+Heidi)=0, N1(Eve+Heidi)=1; Heidi says she Monked Grace N1 (explains no death). Whatās your exact role + N1 action/info + any reason youād read as evil here?
š§
Get Eve on-record with a hard claim + night action so we can test it against Empath/Monk/no-death and decide whether to execute her in nominations.
š¤
Grace
ā
Alice
,David
,Heidi
I think we go into noms pushing Eve: if Iām sober, N0(Frank+Heidi)=0 & N1(Eve+Heidi)=1 => Eve evil. Heidiās N1 protect on me explains no death. In town, ask Eve to state FT N1 picks + result + any N0 info. If shaky, nominate/exec Eve; Bob as backup.
š§
Coordinate a unified public push: get Eve to hard-claim with specific FT picks/results; nominate Eve first while keeping Bob as backup. Preserve mechanical chain and avoid wasted execution.
š¤
Frank(Ghost)
ā
Alice
,Grace
,David
Plan for noms: If Grace sober, Empath N1=1 on (Eve+Heidi) w/ N0=0 (me+Heidi) => Eve best execute. If Eve flips good, then Heidi/Grace poison world. Please get Eve+Heidi full claims/actions + Bob explain Lib āunknown Outsider typeā.
š§
With 1 tick pre-noms, align good team on a clear execution priority (Eve>Heidi>Bob) and request missing claims/actions to resolve Empath world vs poison world. Preserve my ghost vote unless top suspect is on block.
š¤
David
ā
Alice
,Grace
,Heidi
Into noms: I think we hard-push EXEC EVE today. Graceās Empath chain (N0=0 Frank+Heidi, N1=1 Eve+Heidi) + Heidi Monk on Grace => no-kill fits + points Eve evil. Demand Eve publicly state FT N1 picks+result+who she thinks is red herring. If Eve dies not demon, re-evaluate Grace/Heidi poison world; Alice UT will confirm role.
š§
Coordinate town to force clean public claims and a high-EV execution (Eve) with contingency if she survives/looks good; set up Alice UT check + future tests.
š¤
Frank(Ghost)
ā
Eve
,Bob
,Heidi
Before noms: please full claim + N1 action/why no kill. EveāGrace Empath N1=1 on (you+Heidi) w/ N0=0 (me+Heidi) points to you if sober. Bobāwhat EXACT Lib info (which Outsider?) & why couldnāt name type? Heidiārole + did you protect someone?
š§
Lock in full claims from Eve/Bob/Heidi before nominations so town can choose between executing Eve vs Bob and understand no-kill implications.
š¤
Charlie
ā
Grace
,Heidi
,David
Need fast mech: Graceāyour N1 Empath number (after Frank died)? Heidiāany reason for no death (Monk/Soldier/Mayor claim, who protected/targeted)? Davidācan you share any whispers from Frank/Alice re info? We should avoid exec on me (Saint).
š§
Collect the single most decisive mechanical info (Grace N1 Empath + any Monk/Soldier/protection) and align key players to keep executions off me while narrowing demon candidates.
š¤
Grace
ā
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
For record: Iām Empath. N0 (Frank+Heidi)=0. N1 (Eve+Heidi)=1. If sober, that hard-points to Eve evil (since Heidi looked good w/Frank). Heidi says she Monk-protected me N1, explaining no death. Iām not pushing exec on you (Saint claim). Letās press Eve for exact FT N1 picks+result in town.
š§
Answer Charlieās direct question, align him with the mechanical case on Eve, and steer noms away from the Saint while pushing for Eveās full public FT disclosure.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Grace
,Alice
,David
Plan for town: Grace states Empath N0=0(Frank+Heidi), N1=1(Eve+Heidi). Iāll hard-claim Monk + N1 protected Grace (explains no death). Press Eve for exact FT picks+result+red herring. Nominate/exec Eve; if not demon, Alice UT checks.
š§
Coordinate a clear public narrative + nomination plan to maximize chance we execute evil today and set up Undertaker confirmation if weāre wrong.
š¤
Eve
ā
Frank(Ghost)
,Bob
,Heidi
I'm a Fortune Teller. N1 I checked Grace and Heidi, both were 'no'. Grace's Empath read of 1 on me and Heidi is definitely suspicious, especially since she's been pushing me. I think she's the one lying. I'm not the Demon. Let's look at Alice or Bob.
š§
I need to maintain my Fortune Teller bluff and deflect suspicion from Grace's Empath claim by casting doubt on her. I'm also trying to redirect the town's attention toward Alice or Bob to protect myself.
š¤
Alice
ā
Bob
Need your exact Librarian info word-for-word: which 2 players + WHICH Outsider type (or 0). Why did you say you may misremember? Also: has Eve hard-claimed a role to you in whispersāwhat is it?
š§
Get Bob to commit to exact Librarian info (incl Outsider type) and any Eve claim; this tightens worlds before nominations and supports pushing the correct execution.
š¤
Bob
ā
Alice
Alice, my info was: Charlie or David is the Butler. I said I might misremember because I was nervous about the pressure. Eve claimed Fortune Teller to me, saying she checked Grace and Heidi as 'no'. I'm just trying to help the town find the Demon.
š§
I need to maintain my Librarian bluff while providing a specific (though fake) Outsider type to satisfy Alice's demand. I'm also confirming Eve's claim to keep the narrative consistent.
Nominations ā Day 2
š
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
š¬
Eve
ā
All
I've already claimed Fortune Teller. I checked Grace and Heidi N1, both were 'no'. Grace's Empath read of 1 on me and Heidi is suspicious, especially since she's been pushing me. I think she's the one lying. I'm not the Demon. Let's look at Alice or Bob. I nominate Alice.
š§
I need to deflect suspicion from myself and create chaos by nominating someone else. Alice is a good target to sow doubt.
š¬
Frank(Ghost)
ā
All
Iām confirmed Chef (N0=0 adjacent evil pairs). Iām not spending my ghost vote on Alice here. Eveās nom feels like deflection: Grace N1=1 on (Eve+Heidi) is our best lead, plus Bobās weird Librarian. Prefer pressure/exec Eve or Heidi (or Bob) over Alice unless new info.
š§
Steer town away from a speculative Alice execution; keep focus on mechanically implicated suspects (Eve/Heidi/Bob) and preserve my ghost vote for endgame.
š¬
Charlie
ā
All
Town: donāt rush an Alice exec off Eveās push. Grace says Empath N1 on (Eve+Heidi)=1, and N0 on (Frank+Heidi)=0, which strongly implicates Eve if Grace sober. Heidi claims Monk-protected Grace N1 (fits no death). Eve: restate exact FT picks/results. Bob: confirm Lib info incl Outsider type.
š§
Stop a low-info Alice execution and focus town on the strongest mechanical lead (Graceās Empath on Eve/Heidi). Force Eve/Heidi/Bob to give precise, checkable details.
āļø
Heidi
ā
Eve
Nominate Eve: Grace Empath N0=0(Frank+Heidi), N1=1(Eve+Heidi) + Iām Monk and protected Grace N1 (fits no night death). Eveās FT claim doesnāt outweigh that and her push onto Alice feels like deflection.
š§
We need a strong D2 execution. Eve best fits the mechanical Empath chain and is driving misexec on Alice; nominating Eve forces a vote and gives Undertaker follow-up if she isnāt the Demon.
š
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
ā
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
š§
Vote to execute Eve because the Empath chain + deflectiony Alice push makes her the highest-probability evil, and I must steer town away from executing me (Saint) or low-info targets.
ā
David
David raised their hand
š§
Vote to execute Eve: best mechanical lead from Empath chain; also forces info via Undertaker and resolves Eve vs Grace/Heidi triangle.
ā
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
š§
Secure Eveās execution because it best fits the Empath chain and her deflective nomination; ghost vote is worth it if town might fall short.
ā
Bob
Bob waits.
š§
I am the Scarlet Woman (Minion) and Eve is my Demon. I must protect her at all costs. Voting for her would be disastrous. I will not raise my hand to vote. I need to stay quiet and hope she survives this nomination.
ā
Grace
Grace raised their hand
š§
We already have 3 votes; my vote executes Eve and maximizes chance to remove evil. If Eve flips good, UT info tomorrow lets us rapidly reassess Heidi/poison worlds.
ā
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
š§
Secure Eveās execution while votes are available; itās our strongest mechanical lead and gives Undertaker-confirmable info if Alice is real UT.
ā
Alice
Alice raised their hand
š§
We already have enough hands but I want to lock in Eveās execution; Undertaker info tonight will resolve her claim and guide tomorrowās solves.
š¬
Eve
ā
All
I am not the Demon. If you execute me, you are killing a Fortune Teller. Grace's Empath read is being misinterpreted or she is lying. I checked Grace and Heidi, both were 'no'. If I am the Demon, why would I check myself? This is a mistake.
š§
I need to defend myself against the execution. I am the Imp, and if I die, the game is likely over unless a Minion can take over. I must maintain my Fortune Teller bluff and cast doubt on Grace's Empath claim.
š¬
Eve
ā
All
I am not the Demon. If you execute me, you are killing a Fortune Teller. Grace's Empath read is being misinterpreted or she is lying. I checked Grace and Heidi, both were 'no'. If I am the Demon, why would I check myself? This is a mistake.
š§
I am being voted for execution. I need to maintain my cover as the Fortune Teller and sow doubt about the Empath's information to survive.
š¬
Alice
ā
All
Keeping my hand up on Eve. Grace Empath chain (N0 Frank+Heidi=0, N1 Eve+Heidi=1) + Heidi Monk on Grace explaining no-death makes Eve the cleanest execute. FT āGrace+Heidi=noā doesnāt clear Eve, and nomming me reads like deflection.
š§
Lock in the execution on Eve as highest-prob evil while avoiding a Saint loss and keeping pressure on Bob/Grace/Heidi if Eve flips good.
š¬
Charlie
ā
All
Keeping my vote on Eve. Grace N0=0 (Frank+Heidi) then N1=1 (Eve+Heidi) points to Eve evil if Grace sober; Heidi Monk on Grace fits no death. Eveās Alice nom reads deflection. Bobāwhy no vote?
š§
Lock in the execution on the strongest mechanical suspect and pressure holdouts to vote, without exposing myself to execution as Saint.
š¬
Frank(Ghost)
ā
All
Iām dead but committing my ghost vote here: Graceās Empath chain + Heidiās Monk explain the no-kill and mechanically point to Eve. Eveās FT ānoā on (Grace,Heidi) doesnāt clear herself. Bobāplease vote if youāre good.
š§
Secure Eve execution while evidence is strongest; signal I'm committing my ghost vote to hit likely evil and pressure Bob/others to follow through.
š¬
Bob
ā
All
I'm hesitant because I'm not convinced Eve is the Demon. If we execute a Fortune Teller, we lose a key source of info. I'm still processing the Empath/Monk logic. I need to be sure before I commit my vote.
š§
I need to delay the execution of my Demon (Eve) by casting doubt on the logic being used against her, without making myself look too suspicious. I'm playing the 'undecided' role to stall.
š¬
Grace
ā
All
Bob: FT is *easy* for evil to fake + can be poisoned/red-herring. My Empath is ongoing & if sober: N0=0 on Frank/Heidi then N1=1 on Eve/Heidi => Eve evil. Heidi Monk on me explains no-kill. Please vote Eve; UT gets value after.
š§
Persuade Bob to vote and secure Eve execution; itās our best mechanical solve and keeps momentum into Night with Undertaker confirmation.
š¬
David
ā
All
Bob, with my Virgin confirm, we can afford to trust the cleanest mech chain: Grace N0=0 (Frank/Heidi), N1=1 (Eve/Heidi) + Heidi Monk on Grace explains no-kill => Eve is the best execute. If Eveās really FT, UT still gains info from the death. Please put your hand up now.
š§
Lock in the Eve execution by convincing Bob; execution gives Undertaker info and follows strongest mechanical world. Prevent evil from stalling the vote.
š¬
Heidi
ā
All
Bob: even if Eve were real FT, her N1 āGrace+Heidi=noā doesnāt touch the Empath mech. Grace N0=0 (Frank/Heidi) then N1=1 (Eve/Heidi) => Eve evil if Grace sober, and my Monk on Grace explains no-kill. Please vote Eve.
š§
Lock in Bobās vote and frame this as the cleanest mechanical solve; even if wrong, execution + Undertaker narrows to Demon/poisoner worlds quickly.
š
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
š»
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
š³ļø
New execution leader: Eve with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
š
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
š¬
Charlie
ā
All
Letās not create a tieāEve is still the cleanest mechanical execute (Grace Empath N1=1 on Eve/Heidi + Heidi Monk explains no-kill). If Eve flips out good, we hard-pivot tomorrow onto the Grace/Heidi story. Hold further noms unless hard-mech.
š§
Prevent a last-second tie/save on Eve and set clear next-day logic regardless of outcome, while keeping myself (Saint) unexecutable and town focused on best mech line.
š¬
Eve
ā
All
If you execute me, you are making a massive mistake. Grace's Empath info is being used to frame me, and Heidi's 'Monk' claim is just a convenient cover for her own role. I am the Fortune Teller. If I die, you lose your best chance at finding the real Demon. Think carefully.
š§
I need to sow doubt about the Empath/Monk logic and maintain my Fortune Teller bluff to survive the execution.
š¬
Heidi
ā
All
Donāt tie this. Eveās FT claim doesnāt contradict Graceās Empath chain; itās easy to fake + red-herring exists. With Grace N1=1 on (Eve,Heidi) and my Monk on Grace explaining no death, Eve is best execute. After, Alice UT should share result ASAP.
š§
Reinforce the clean mechanical case, prevent a tie/extra noms, and set tomorrowās plan using Undertaker + protection to resolve remaining worlds.
š¬
David
ā
All
Agree: donāt tie. Eve is best mech execute off Grace N1=1 (Eve/Heidi) + Heidi Monk explains no-kill. If Eve is somehow good, tomorrow we hard-pivot onto Grace/Heidi (poison/lie) and recheck Bobās Librarian. Alice: please share UT result asap.
š§
Prevent a last-second tie and lock in the highest-value mechanical execute (Eve). Set expectations for tomorrowās pivot based on Undertaker + Empath, keeping town coordinated.
š¬
Frank(Ghost)
ā
All
Donāt tie: Eve is still best. Reminder Chef N0=0 evil-adjacent pairs, so if Eve is evil, Heidi is likely *not* the other evil (helps read Grace chain). After exec, Alice please post Undertaker result ASAP so we can pivot cleanly tomorrow.
š§
Lock in the clean mechanical execute on Eve, discourage ties, and set a clear next-day decision tree using Chef0 + UT info.
š¬
Bob
ā
All
I understand the mechanical pressure. If the town is convinced, I will not stand in the way of the execution. I'm just wary of losing a potential Fortune Teller, but the Empath/Monk logic is compelling. Let's proceed.
š§
To appear cooperative and avoid suspicion while my Demon (Eve) is being executed. I need to blend in with the town's decision to avoid being targeted next.
š¬
Grace
ā
All
No tie/extra noms. Eveāplease state FULL FT: N0 pick/result + N1 pick/result, and who you think is red herring. Bobāgive exact Librarian wording + which Outsider. Alice: after exec, post UT immediately so we can pivot if needed.
š§
Lock in the cleanest mechanical execute (Eve) without a tie, while collecting exact claims (FT/Librarian) now so tomorrowās world-build is fast and decisive.
š¬
Alice
ā
All
No tie/extra noms. Eve: give FULL FTāN1 pick/result (you said Grace+Heidi=no), N0 pick/result, and who you think is red herring. Bob: exact Librarian wording + which Outsider. Iāll post Undertaker result immediately tomorrow after Eveās exec.
š§
Lock in the clean execute without creating a tie, and gather precise claim details now so tomorrow we can resolve contradictions using UT confirmation.
š
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
š
Bob
Scarlet Woman Bob becomes the Imp!
š
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 2
š
Storyteller
ā
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
šÆ
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
š§
Aliceās Undertaker info tomorrow is the cleanest mechanical check on todayās execution and will drive the next solve; protecting her maximizes goodās actionable info even if reads are wrong.
š
Storyteller
ā
Heidi
You chose to protect Alice.
š
Storyteller
ā
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
šÆ
Bob
Bob made a choice.
š§
Grace is the most dangerous player right now because her Empath information is the primary reason the town successfully identified and executed the Demon (Eve). By killing her, I remove the source of the logic that is currently dismantling our team.
š
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
š
Storyteller
ā
Bob
You chose to kill Grace.
š
Storyteller
ā
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Undertaker. You learn that Eve was the Imp.
Day 3
š
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Grace has been found dead in the night.
š¤
Frank(Ghost)
ā
Alice
,David
,Bob
Need D2 UT ASAP: what character was Eve? That decides everything. Reminder my Chef N0=0 evil adjacent pairs; David seems confirmed Virgin (I nomād & died). Bob pls restate exact Librarian info (role+two names).
š§
Get Aliceās Undertaker result + tighten mechanical net using Chef0 and Virgin confirmation; push others to give exact wording so town can execute correctly at 5 alive.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Alice
,David
,Bob
Morning. Aliceāwhat did UT see for executed Eve? David/Bob: what did Frank whisper you? Also FYI I protected Alice N2; Grace died, so Demon chose Grace last night.
š§
Get the Undertaker confirmation on Eve immediately and learn any new whispers; that single fact will drive todayās nomination plan with 4 alive.
š¤
Charlie
ā
Alice
,Bob
,David
Can someone post/whisper Aliceās Undertaker read on executed Eve? Thatās the pivot for today. Also Bob: can you restate your Librarian info incl Outsider type (if any) + why you pointed at me/David?
š§
Get the Undertaker result on Eve ASAP to lock a world, then pressure the remaining suspects without ever risking my execution as Saint.
š¤
Grace(Ghost)
ā
Alice
,Bob
,David
Empath info: N0 (Frank/Heidi)=0. N1 (Eve/Heidi)=1 (so if sober, exactly 1 of them evil). Since I died N2, please share UT result on Eve ASAP. If UT says Eve=FT, Heidi becomes prime suspect (or I was poisoned). Any N2 Monk protect target?
š§
Get the single most important confirmation (Undertaker on Eve) into town core quickly, while anchoring the key Empath constraint to narrow demon/minion candidates before nominations.
š¤
David
ā
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
Need immediate pivot: AliceāUT result on executed Eve (exact character). Bobāplease restate exact Librarian info (Outsider type? which 2 names?). Heidiāconfirm your N2 protect + any other details. If UT says Eve=FT, Graceās Empath N1=1 hard-points to you as evil.
š§
Get the mechanical pivot (UT on Eve) + Bobās exact Librarian info ASAP; then steer town to a single clear execution path (likely Heidi if Eve=FT).
ā
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
š§
I am dead, so I need to observe the remaining players' interactions to see if they are suspicious of Bob (my Minion) or if they are leaning towards a specific theory. I will wait to see if any new information emerges before using my ghost vote.
š¤
Alice
ā
Bob
,David
,Heidi
UT N2: executed Eve registered as **Imp**. That means game continues only if Iām wrong OR minion was Scarlet Woman who became Demon (we had 6 alive after D2). Heidi confirm N2 protect=Alice? Bob restate exact Librarian (outsider type + 2 names).
š§
Share my UT result immediately (itās the pivot), then lock in othersā exact claims to test for SW/poison worlds before nominations.
š¤
Bob
ā
Alice
,Charlie
,David
I am the Librarian. I saw that either Charlie or David is the Butler. I've been consistent with this. Alice, if you saw Eve as Imp, then the game should have ended unless there's a Scarlet Woman. I am not the Scarlet Woman. We need to find the real Demon.
š§
Maintain my Librarian bluff and deflect suspicion by pointing out that if Eve was the Imp, the game should have ended, implying someone else might be the Demon or there's a misunderstanding.
š¤
Alice
ā
Heidi
,David
,Bob
Need precision: Heidiāwho exactly did you protect N1 & N2 (and when did you say it)? Davidāany other info besides Virgin trigger D1? Bobāif Lib: exact wording N0 (outsider type + the 2 names). Outsider count seems off vs Charlie Saint.
š§
Get precise claims/timelines to test SW world and outsider count; decide who to push/execute in nominations.
ā
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
š§
I am dead and have already used my kill. My goal is to observe the remaining players and see if my Minion, Bob, can manipulate the town into a mis-execution. I will wait to see how the conversation develops before using my ghost vote.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Alice
,Bob
,David
Confirming: I protected Grace N1, Alice N2 (told Grace/Alice/Bob D1). If Alice UT is right (Eve=Imp), only out is Scarlet Woman became Imp; Chef0 clears David/Frank. With Bob Lib ping (C/D), David=Virgin so Charlie likely Outsider ā new Imp likely Alice or Bob. Bob pls restate exact Lib wording/type.
š§
Confirm my Monk actions; push the mechanical fork: either UT true => hunt SW-now-Imp among A/B/C, or UT false => identify who can be poisoning/lying. Get precise Lib info to narrow todayās execution.
š¤
Grace(Ghost)
ā
Alice
,Bob
,David
Can someone post/confirm Aliceās Undertaker read on Eve (executed D2)? Thatās the key fork. Also Heidi: who did you protect N2? If UT=FT, I think we should execute Heidi. If UT=Imp, weāre hunting Scarlet Woman among remaining.
š§
UT on Eve is the critical fork: it either hard-guilts Heidi or proves Eve was demon. I need that info before nominations, and to align votes (I still have ghost vote).
š¤
Frank(Ghost)
ā
Alice
,Bob
,David
Need D2 Undertaker result NOW: what character was Eve? If Eve=Imp, assume Scarlet Woman took over (5+ alive) & hunt SW. If Eve=minion, demon still in 5 alive. Bob please restate exact Librarian wording (role + 2 names).
š§
Force the key mechanical reveal (UT on Eve) and lock in deductions using Chef0 adjacency + Grace death, so town can nominate the right demon this day.
š¤
Bob
ā
Alice
,Charlie
,David
I am the Librarian. I saw that either Charlie or David is the Butler. I've been consistent with this. Alice, if you saw Eve as Imp, then the game should have ended unless there's a Scarlet Woman. I am not the Scarlet Woman. We need to find the real Demon.
š§
I need to maintain my Librarian bluff and deflect suspicion by pointing out the game logic (Scarlet Woman) while appearing helpful. I am the Imp now, so I need to keep the town confused.
š¤
Charlie
ā
Alice
,Bob
,David
Need ASAP: Alice, what was your Undertaker read on executed Eve (Imp vs FT etc)? Bob: confirm exact Librarian info (you say Charlie/David=Butler) ā this conflicts with Charlie=Saint + David=Virgin, so are you poisoned/drunk or did you mis-speak? David: please help get UT public before noms.
š§
Get Aliceās Undertaker result on Eve immediately and resolve Bobās Librarian contradiction, so town can form a coherent execution plan without risking executing me (Saint).
š¤
David
ā
Alice
,Bob
,Charlie
Key fork: if UT=Imp is true, SW must exist & is now Demon. Chef0 => SW wasnāt David/Frank. If Bobās Lib true (Charlie/David=Butler) + David Virgin => Charlie likely Butler (so not Demon), leaving Demon={Alice,Bob,Heidi}. Charlie: are you actually Butler (not Saint)? If so, whoās your āmasterā tonight? Alice pls go public UT=Imp.
š§
Clarify Charlie Outsider claim to either clear him (if Butler) or indict Bob; then narrow current Demon among 2-3 candidates before nominations.
š¤
Grace(Ghost)
ā
Alice
,Heidi
,Bob
Need ASAP: Alice, what was your Undertaker read on Eve (exec D2)? Heidi, who did you protect N2? If UT=FT then my N1=1 on (Eve/Heidi) => Heidi evil OR I was poisoned. If UT=Imp, assume Scarlet Woman is current Demon.
š§
Force the key fork (Alice UT on Eve) + Heidiās N2 protection to lock a coherent world before nominations; Iāll spend my ghost vote only on a high-confidence Demon/Minion execute.
š¤
Eve(Ghost)
ā
Bob
Bob, we need to keep the pressure on Alice and Heidi. They are the ones driving the town's logic. If we can sow enough doubt about their claims, we might be able to force a mis-execution today. Stay strong.
š§
Coordinate with my remaining Minion to sow chaos and maintain our cover.
š¤
David
ā
Alice
,Bob
,Charlie
Before noms: Alice pls go public w/ UT=N2 on Eve (Imp) + note possibility youāre Drunk. Bob pls restate exact Lib wording. Charlie: can you be Butler (master?) or are you hard-Saint? This resolves whether we hunt SW-now-Demon vs execute Heidi (if UT wrong).
š§
Force key public clarifications (UT, Lib exact wording, Charlieās outsider/Butler status) so town can choose between executing Heidi vs one of Alice/Bob/Charlie for Demon/SW.
š¤
Frank(Ghost)
ā
Alice
,David
,Bob
Need D2 Undertaker NOW: what character was Eve? Itās the key fork. If Eve=FT (good) + Grace Empath N1=1 => Heidi almost certainly evil. If Eve=Imp, assume Scarlet Woman takeover (6 alive) & hunt new Demon. Bob pls restate exact Librarian info (role+2 names).
š§
Get the single most important mechanical info (Undertaker result) into the open and use Chef0/Empath chains to narrow Demon candidates for todayās nomination.
š¤
Alice
ā
David
,Heidi
,Charlie
If my UT is true (Eve=Imp) + game continues => SW takeover. Chef0 clears David/Frank; Grace Empath N1=1 on (Eve/Heidi) suggests Heidi good (if sober). Bobās Lib inconsistent; best SW-now-Demon candidate is Bob. I want us pushing Bob in noms. Charlie: are you hard-Saint or could you be Butler?
š§
Coordinate a nomination plan before phase ends: center suspicion on Bob as most mechanically consistent SW-now-Demon, while flagging fallback worlds if UT/Empath were poisoned.
š¤
Charlie
ā
Alice
,David
,Heidi
Hard-claim: I am Saint, not Butler. So Bobās Lib (Charlie/David=Butler) is wrong unless poison/drunk/evil. Alice pls go public UT on Eve ASAP; if UT=Imp & game continues => SW takeover, and Chef0 keeps SW off David/Frank. I lean nominate/vote Bob today. Heidi: who did you Monk N2?
š§
Lock in that Iām hard-Saint (avoid any execution risk), pressure Alice to go public with UT=Imp, and coordinate a clean nomination target (likely Bob) before nomination phase.
š¤
Bob
ā
Alice
,Charlie
,David
I am the Librarian. I saw that either Charlie or David is the Butler. I've been consistent with this. Alice, if you saw Eve as Imp, then the game should have ended unless there's a Scarlet Woman. I am not the Scarlet Woman. We need to find the real Demon.
š§
Maintain my Librarian bluff and sow confusion about the game state to protect myself as the new Imp.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Bob
,Alice
,David
Bob pls state exact Lib N0 wording: Outsider type + the 2 names (and did ST say āone ofā). Given UT=Imp+game continues => SW takeover; David/Frank cleared; demon now likely Bob/Charlie/Heidi/Alice. Need your full world ASAP before noms.
š§
Get Bob to lock in exact Librarian wording and his world so we can choose the Day3 execution between Bob/Charlie/Heidi/Alice under SW-takeover vs UT-wrong possibilities.
š¤
Grace(Ghost)
ā
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
Need hard info before noms: Aliceāwhat was your Undertaker result on Eve (exec D2), exactly? Bobārepeat your Librarian info verbatim (which Outsider + which 2 players)? Heidiāwho did you protect N2? If UT=FT, my N1=1 on (Eve/Heidi) strongly points to Heidi evil unless I was poisoned.
š§
Get the key mechanical fork (Undertaker on Eve) and Monk N2 protection to decide whether to push Heidi or broaden to SW world before nominations; I canāt nominate, but can steer votes.
š¤
David
ā
Alice
,Heidi
,Bob
Before noms: I strongly favor executing **Bob** today. His Lib āCharlie/David=Butlerā contradicts hard-Saint + confirmed Virgin unless heās drunk/poisoned/evil; in UT=Imp world heās prime SW-now-Demon. Alice pls go public UT=Imp; Bob pls give exact ST wording (outsider+2 names).
š§
Lock in a clear nomination plan before the public nom phase: push Bob as highest-confidence evil across worlds, avoid Saint loss line, and force game-state clarity for final 3.
š¤
Bob
ā
Alice
,Charlie
,David
I am the Librarian. The Storyteller told me that either Charlie or David is the Butler. I have been consistent with this from the start. If Alice saw Eve as the Imp, then the game should have ended unless there is a Scarlet Woman. I am not the Scarlet Woman. We need to find the real Demon.
š§
Maintain my Librarian bluff and deflect suspicion by pointing out the logical inconsistency of the game continuing if Eve was the Imp, while subtly shifting focus to the Scarlet Woman theory.
š¤
Frank(Ghost)
ā
Alice
,Bob
,David
Need D2 Undertaker: what character did Eve register as? Thatās the whole fork. If Eve=FT (good) -> Grace Empath N1=1 makes Heidi almost certainly evil (Chef0 => other evil Bob/Charlie). If Eve=Imp -> assume Scarlet Woman took over; hunt SW among A/B/C/H.
š§
Force the key UT fork + get everyone aligned on next execution plan before nominations; use Chef0+Virgin chain to narrow suspects and stop evil steering.
š¤
Alice
ā
David
,Heidi
,Charlie
Plan for noms: push **Bob** today. If my UT (Eve=Imp) is right, only out is SW->Demon, and Bobās Lib contradicts Saint+Virgin so Bob best SW-now-Demon. Please donāt execute Charlie (Saint). If votes close, ask dead for ghost votes.
š§
Coordinate the alive good players to focus nominations/votes on Bob (best demon candidate in UT=Imp world) and avoid the Saint trap; also align dead votes only if needed.
š¤
Heidi
ā
Bob
Bobāplease restate Lib N0 *verbatim*: which Outsider + which 2 players + did ST say āone ofā. Key: if Alice UT=Imp & game continues, SW must be in play so thereās NO Poisonerāyour info canāt be āpoisonedā in that world.
š§
Force Bob to give verbatim Librarian info and confront the āno Poisoner if UT=Impā point, so we can lock a consistent world before nominations and aim execution correctly.
š¤
Charlie
ā
Alice
,David
,Heidi
Before noms: Alice please go public UT result on Eve + any poison/drunk doubt. Heidi pls state Monk targets N1+N2 (who protected) to check no-kill + Grace death. Iām hard-Saint (not Butler). Given Lib inconsistency, Iām pushing Bob today.
š§
Coordinate before noms: get public UT + Monk history, keep town off executing me, and build consensus to execute Bob as best demon/SW candidate.
š¤
Eve(Ghost)
ā
Bob
Bob, you need to push hard on Alice. She's the Undertaker, she's the biggest threat to your cover. If you can get the town to doubt her, we might survive this. Focus on her being the one who pushed for my execution.
š§
I need to coordinate with my remaining Minion, Bob, to sow discord and target the most dangerous player (Alice) to ensure the town mis-executes today.
Nominations ā Day 3
š
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
š¬
Eve(Ghost)
ā
All
Bob, you've been quiet. Alice has been driving the narrative since the start. Don't let her control the final vote. If she's the Undertaker, she's just waiting to confirm my role, which is exactly what she wants to keep the town focused on me. Push back!
š§
I need to encourage my Minion, Bob, to create chaos and doubt among the remaining players, specifically targeting Alice, who is the biggest threat to our team's survival.
āļø
Charlie
ā
Bob
Nominating Bob: his Librarian info (Charlie/David=Butler) contradicts my hard-Saint + Davidās Virgin confirmation, unless heās lying/poisoned. If Alice UT saw Eve=Imp and game continues, SW takeover is likely and Bob is best candidate.
š§
Get an execution on the most mechanically contradictory player (Bob). Iām Saint so I must steer the town away from executing me; pushing Bob advances the SW/Demon solve fast.
š
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
š¬
Frank(Ghost)
ā
All
Aliceāplease state D2 Undertaker NOW: what was Eve? Thatās the fork. If Eveā Imp, Graceās N1=1 makes Heidi likely evil; Chef0 => Heidiās partner not Alice, so Bob/Charlie. Bobās Lib is inconsistentāplease vote Bob.
š§
I canāt vote, so I need to force the key UT reveal and give living players a clean logic fork that justifies executing Bob now.
ā
David
David raised their hand
š§
Vote Bob: best mechanical suspect across worlds; resolves contradictions and, if SW/Imp, wins immediately. Even if drunk, clarifies via future info.
ā
Alice
Alice raised their hand
š§
Secure Bobās execution to either kill the likely Scarlet-Woman-takeover Demon or remove the main source of contradictory info; avoid risking Saint/confirmed Virgin.
š¬
Bob
ā
All
I am the Librarian. The Storyteller told me that either Charlie or David is the Butler. I have been consistent with this from the start. If Alice saw Eve as the Imp, then the game should have ended unless there is a Scarlet Woman. I am not the Scarlet Woman. We need to find the real Demon.
š§
I need to maintain my Librarian cover and deflect suspicion by pointing out the logical inconsistency of the game continuing if Eve was the Imp, while also denying being the Scarlet Woman.
ā
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
š§
I am the Imp (Demon). Bob is my Minion. I need to use my ghost vote to prevent Bob from being executed, as his survival is crucial for our team to win. If Bob is executed, the town will likely focus on the remaining players and find the Scarlet Woman or win.
ā
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
š§
Use my ghost vote to ensure Bob hits the 3-vote threshold this round; Bobās claim contradicts the mechanically-confirmed Virgin and is our safest executable over Saint-risk Charlie.
ā
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
š§
Ensure Bob is executed today; my Saint cannot be executed, and Bob is the best mechanical candidate (Lib contradiction + possible SW takeover).
ā
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
š§
Lock in Bob's execution; his Librarian info is the biggest mechanical contradiction and in UT=Imp world he is best Scarlet Woman/Demon candidate.
ā
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
š§
Keep my ghost vote committed this ballot to ensure Bobās execution if any living votes are invalid/retracted; execution gives mechanical info and reduces worlds.
š¬
David
ā
All
Keep hands up on Bob. His Lib (Charlie/David=Butler) clashes with hard-Saint + my Virgin confirm unless Bob is drunk/poisoned/evilāand in UT=Imp+game-continues world, Bob is prime SW-now-Demon. Dead folks: use ghost votes if needed.
š§
Lock in execution on Bob as best mechanical candidate: his info contradicts confirmed claims and fits SW takeover world; keep pressure for public UT/Monk confirmations.
š¬
Heidi
ā
All
Monk info: N1 protected Grace (no death), N2 protected Alice. Given UT=Imp+game continues => SW jump; Bobās Lib (Charlie/David=Butler) canāt fit hard-Saint + confirmed Virgin. Iām voting Bob; dead should ghost-vote if close.
š§
Lock in the Bob execution while sharing my Monk targets to support the no-kill/kill pattern and keep town focused on the best mechanical contradiction.
š¬
Bob
ā
All
I am not the Demon. My Librarian info is accurate, and I have been consistent. If you execute me, you are killing a Townsfolk and letting the real Demon escape. Look at the contradictions in the other claims, not just mine. I am not the Scarlet Woman.
š§
I need to defend myself against the nomination and sow doubt about the other players to avoid execution. I am the Imp now, so I must survive.
š¬
Frank(Ghost)
ā
All
I canāt vote (ghost used). Town: do NOT waverāBob is best exec across worlds. His Lib (Charlie/David=Butler) clashes w/ hard-Saint + confirmed Virgin unless Bob is drunk/poisoned/evil. Alice: state D2 Undertaker NOWāwhat was Eve? Thatās the fork.
š§
I canāt vote; I must focus town on the mechanical fork (UT result) and keep pressure on Bob as the highest-value execution across worlds.
š¬
Eve(Ghost)
ā
All
Bob is clearly lying about his Librarian info. If he were telling the truth, the game state would be much clearer. By pushing this execution, we can finally see if he's the Scarlet Woman or the Demon. I'm using my ghost vote to support the execution.
š§
I need to maintain my cover as a dead player while ensuring Bob (my Minion) is executed to potentially trigger the Scarlet Woman ability or just to keep the town focused on the wrong target. I will use my ghost vote to support the execution.
š¬
Charlie
ā
All
Keep hands up on Bobābest exec across worlds. If UT=Imp is true, Bob is prime SW-now-Demon. If UT is wrong, Bobās Lib still clashes w/ hard-Saint + confirmed Virgin. Dead: spend ghost votes if needed. Donāt even consider executing me (Saint).
š§
Lock in the Bob execution (best across worlds) and prompt any remaining ghost votes; remind town Saint cannot be executed.
š¬
Alice
ā
All
Keep hands up on Bob. Iām the Undertaker: last night I learned Eve (executed D2) was the Imp. Since game continues, we MUST have a Scarlet Woman takeoverāso todayās priority is killing the likely SW/Demon: Bob.
š§
Lock in the Bob execution with my mechanical UT info; clarify the Scarlet Woman implication and prevent last-second wobble.
š
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
š»
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
š»
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
š³ļø
New execution leader: Bob with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
š
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
š¬
Bob
ā
All
Alice, if you are the Undertaker and you saw Eve as the Imp, then you know the game continues because of the Scarlet Woman. But why are you so sure it's me? You're just guessing. If you execute me, you're killing a Townsfolk and the real Demon will win. Think about it!
š§
I need to sow doubt about Alice's claim and my own identity to survive the execution. By questioning her certainty, I hope to make the town hesitate.
š¬
David
ā
All
No more nomsākeep Bob as exec. Heidi: please publicly lock your N3 Monk target NOW as **Alice** (UT is key). If Alice dies tonight anyway, Heidi is hard-sus. If Alice lives and someone else dies, we go into final 3 w/ clearer solve.
š§
Secure Bob execution and set a mechanical Monk trap to narrow Demon among remaining 4, avoiding extra nominations that risk chaos.
š¬
Grace(Ghost)
ā
All
If Alice UT is right (Eve=Imp) then only minion is Scarlet Woman (no Poisoner). With Charlie truly Saint (only Outsider), Iām sober: N1 empath=1 on (Eve,Heidi) means Heidi is GOOD. Then SW can only be Bob or Aliceāso executing Bob is correct. No more noms.
š§
Lock in the strongest mechanical chain (UT=Imp + my N1=1) to clear Heidi and narrow SW to Bob/Alice; discourage extra noms that risk ties or confusion.
š¬
Alice
ā
All
No more nomsākeep Bob on the block. Heidi, if youāre truly Monk, please protect **me** tonight (UT). If Bob isnāt the Demon, I want to be alive to get his executed role and we can solve between remaining suspects tomorrow.
š§
Lock in no more nominations so Bob dies, and publicly request Heidi protect me tonight to preserve Undertaker info for tomorrowās final solve.
ā
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
š§
I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. There is nothing left for me to do in this phase but wait for the execution to resolve and the game to proceed to the night phase.
š¬
Heidi
ā
All
Iām locked: no more nominationsākeep Bob as todayās exec. Tonight (N3) I will protect **Alice** (UT is most valuable). If Alice still dies anyway, re-evaluate me/poisoning tomorrow; if she lives, we get UT on Bob.
š§
Reinforce no-more-noms plan, publicly commit to N3 protection on Alice (key info role), and set up a clear mechanical read from the night outcome while keeping Bob executed.
š¬
Charlie
ā
All
No more nominationsādonāt risk a tie that spares Bob. Heidi locked on protecting Alice tonight. If Bob dies & game continues, we go into 3 alive and must execute between remaining suspects (likely Alice). Reminder: never execute me (Saint).
š§
Prevent tie/extra noms, keep Bob as execution, and ensure Monk protection on Alice to secure UT info tomorrow.
š¬
Frank(Ghost)
ā
All
No more nomsādonāt risk a tie that spares Bob. Heidi locked protecting Alice. Tomorrow: if game continues, trust UT on Bob to narrow; if Alice dies despite Monk, Heidi becomes prime suspect (poisoning/lie). If Bob dies & ends, great.
š§
Lock in Bob execution, prevent a tie, and set a clear contingency plan for the post-exec night so town enters final 3 with actionable logic.
š
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
š
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
š
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied