Game Detail
Players
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 237,369 | 554,423 | $2.4432 |
| Good | 793,572 | 424,436 | $0.7145 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You are the Minion. The Demon is Frank.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Minions are: David. Your safe bluffs are: Recluse, Empath, Ravenkeeper
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Washerwoman. Either Charlie or Alice is the Investigator.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Investigator. Either Eve or David is the Scarlet Woman.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Bob
Bob made choices.
🧠
To gather initial information on whether Alice or David is the Demon or the false positive good player, helping to identify evil players early in the game.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose Alice and David. You receive the answer: YES.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Hey Bob, I wanted to start building trust early. I'm the Soldier, which means I'm safe from the Demon at night. I figured I'd share this with you since you're my neighbor. Have you heard any claims from others yet?
🧠
Start building trust with my neighbor Bob by sharing my role early. As Soldier, I'm safe from Demon kills, so revealing to Bob is low-risk and helps establish an information channel.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Hi Alice, I'm Heidi. I'm a good role but I'd like to keep it private for now. Do you have any information to share from the first night? I'm trying to gather as much information as possible to help the village.
🧠
Initiate a private conversation with Alice to exchange early game information and establish a potential alliance.
👤
David
→
Frank
Hey Frank, it's David. We should sync up quick. What roles are safe for us to claim?
🧠
I need to coordinate with my Demon, Frank, to learn which roles are safe to bluff and make sure our stories don't conflict.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I wanted to talk to you privately. I got some information last night that involves you. Can you tell me what role you are?
🧠
Approach Alice privately to see if she claims Investigator, which would confirm my Washerwoman information. This helps me verify my info and start building trust with a confirmed good player.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Hey Eve. I'd be happy to share information, but you said you have info that involves me - could you tell me what that is first? I want to make sure we're building trust here. What role are you, and what did you learn?
🧠
Eve is a suspect in my Investigator info. I want her to commit to a claim before I reveal anything, to gather data on whether she's lying.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, thanks for reaching out. I'm the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked Alice and David and got a 'yes', so at least one is either the Demon or the good player that registers as Demon to me. I need to figure out which. What claims have you heard?
🧠
Build trust with Charlie by sharing my Fortune Teller info, since he initiated and claims Soldier. This allows collaboration to identify the Demon and verify my result.
👤
Frank
→
David
Safe bluffs are Recluse, Empath, and Ravenkeeper. I'll probably claim Empath. You should claim one of the others. Let's not claim the same thing. Also, who should I kill tonight?
🧠
Coordinate with my Minion David on safe bluff claims to avoid conflicting stories and build trust with good players.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Hey Frank, wanted to check in with you early. Have you heard anything useful from your conversations so far? I'm happy to share anything I learn as we go.
🧠
Initiating private conversation with neighbor Frank to begin building a trust network and gather early information about any roles claimed.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
That's really useful info, Bob. A 'yes' on Alice or David is a strong start. One thing to remember is there's always a good player who pings as Demon too, so we'll need to figure out which one. Do you plan to share this publicly? I'll back you up as the Soldier if you do. Also, have you seen Alice or David talk to anyone else yet?
🧠
Respond to Bob's Fortune Teller claim, share my Soldier claim back (already done), and probe for more details to verify his story while encouraging him to share publicly later.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I'm Heidi. I'm sitting next to you. I'm on the good team but I'd rather keep my exact role private for now. Did you get any information overnight that you'd like to share? I'm trying to piece things together early.
🧠
Gather information from my other neighbor Grace. I've already reached out to Alice. Building connections early helps identify inconsistencies later.
👤
David
→
Frank
I'll claim Ravenkeeper. Let's kill Alice tonight, she's talking to a lot of people and might be an info role. Keep it natural.
🧠
Coordinate bluff and night kill with Frank to align our stories and eliminate a dangerous good player.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
That's fair, Alice. I'm the Washerwoman, and I learned that either you or Charlie is the Investigator. So if you are the Investigator, great - we can confirm each other. If you're not, then Charlie must be the Investigator. What role are you?
🧠
Sharing my Washerwoman info with Alice builds trust and lets us verify each other. If she claims Investigator, my info checks out. If not, Charlie is the Investigator.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Eve, I am indeed the Investigator, so your info is correct about me. Now here's the thing — my Investigator info says that either you or David is the Scarlet Woman. If you're telling the truth about being the Washerwoman, that means David is almost certainly the Scarlet Woman. This is really important. Let's figure out how to handle this without tipping off the evil team too early.
🧠
Share my real Investigator info with Eve since she shared first and her claim checks out (I am the Investigator). This creates a strong good-player trust chain and narrows the Scarlet Woman to David if Eve is truthful.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm Bob. I wanted to chat privately. I'm a townsfolk with some info. What role are you claiming?
🧠
Gather Alice's role claim to assess her credibility and see if she is the Demon or the good false positive.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hey Grace. Not much yet, just feeling people out. Have you heard anything from Alice or Eve? They seem to be whispering a lot.
🧠
Gain Grace's trust early by appearing open and cooperative, while fishing for information about other players' claims.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi. I didn't get any overnight info. I'm just gathering what I can. What have you heard from others so far? I noticed Alice and Eve have been talking a lot. Have you spoken to either of them yet?
🧠
Heidi reached out first, so I should respond to build rapport. I'll share minimal info and see what she offers in return.
👤
Charlie
→
David
Hey David, I'm Charlie. I wanted to touch base with you since we're neighbors. Have you got any role info to share? I'm trying to piece things together early. Also, have you talked to Bob or Alice yet today?
🧠
David is my neighbor and one of Bob's Fortune Teller pings. I want to hear his role claim to start cross-referencing information and building a picture of who might be evil.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hi Grace. I haven't learned much concrete yet, just initial conversations. I did notice Alice and Eve whispering back and forth quite a bit like you mentioned. Also Charlie and Bob have been talking. I'm trying to connect with everyone I can. If you pick up on anything suspicious, let me know and I'll do the same for you. We need to piece this together carefully.
🧠
Respond to Grace's question honestly to build trust. Mention the Alice-Eve connection to encourage further investigation. Ask about Charlie-Bob connection too since they've been whispering.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie. I am the Ravenkeeper, so I do not have any info yet since my ability only works if I die at night. I have not really talked to Bob or Alice much yet. What about you, what role are you?
🧠
Establish my Ravenkeeper bluff with Charlie, answer vaguely to avoid contradiction, and learn his claimed role so Frank and I can spot threats before the first night.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
This is really important info. Since I know I'm the Washerwoman and not the Scarlet Woman, if your info is correct then David is the Scarlet Woman. I think we should talk to David separately and see what role he claims before we tip him off. I'll talk to him next. Should we keep this between us for now, or bring in others we trust?
🧠
Discuss with Alice whether to test David's claim to verify the Scarlet Woman accusation. Need to probe David's role claim before committing to trusting Alice's info.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Let's keep this between us for now, Eve. If David is the Scarlet Woman, we don't want to tip him off. I'd suggest we both talk to David separately and see what role he claims — if he claims something that doesn't line up, that's very telling. Also, don't share that I confirmed my role to you yet. We can bring in one or two trusted people later once we have more to go on.
🧠
Coordinate with Eve to keep our intel secret and observe David's claims without tipping him off. This protects our information chain while we gather more data.
👤
Bob
→
David
Hey David, I'm Bob. I'm a townsfolk with some info. What role are you claiming?
🧠
Gather David's role claim to cross-check with Alice's claim and other info, to narrow down which of my pings is the Demon or red herring.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
Hey Eve, I am Frank. Since we are sitting next to each other, I wanted to reach out. Have you heard anything useful from your conversations so far? I am trying to get a feel for everyone early on.
🧠
Establish contact with my other neighbor Eve to support my Empath bluff and gather information while appearing helpful and natural.
👤
Grace
→
David
Hey David, Grace here. I'm trying to piece things together. Have you learned anything interesting from your conversations? Any roles claimed yet? I've noticed some pairs whispering a lot and I'm curious what's being shared.
🧠
David has been talking to multiple people (Frank, Charlie, Bob). He's a good source of cross-referenced information. I want to learn what claims have been made so far without revealing my own role yet.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Eve
→
All
Hey everyone, I've had some conversations and I'm gathering information. Charlie, I'd like to hear from you — what role did you get last night? I have some info that involves you, so I'd appreciate if you'd share openly.
🧠
I want to hear from Charlie what role he claims. My Washerwoman info says one of Alice/Charlie is the Investigator. If Charlie also claims Investigator, we have a conflict that needs resolving. If he claims something else, Alice is more credible.
💬
Bob
→
All
Eve, interesting that you're calling out Charlie. I'd like to hear what info you have first. For everyone's benefit, I'm the Fortune Teller, and last night I checked Alice and David — I got a yes, meaning at least one of them registers as the Demon to me. There's always a good player who pings as Demon, so we need to figure out which one. Alice, David, I'd like to hear your role claims.
🧠
Share my Fortune Teller info publicly to help coordinate the good team. Mention that Alice or David flagged as Demon, and note that Eve's call-out of Charlie deserves scrutiny.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Bob, that's a bold claim to lead with as Fortune Teller. I'd like to hear from Alice and David as well — if there's something there, we should investigate it. Alice, David, what roles are you claiming? And Bob, can you clarify — did you get a definite yes, or could your info have been affected by poisoning?
🧠
Support gathering information from Alice and David since Bob's Fortune Teller claim gives us a starting point. If Bob is truthful, we can narrow suspects. If he's lying, the real Fortune Teller can counter-claim later.
💬
David
→
All
Bob, I'm the Ravenkeeper, so I don't have any info yet since my ability only triggers if I die at night. I do know that the Fortune Teller can get a false positive from the Recluse, who registers as a Demon. If your info is real, Alice might be the Recluse. I'm happy to work with everyone to figure this out, but leading so aggressively on day one feels a bit premature.
🧠
Defend myself by sticking to my Ravenkeeper bluff, explain the Recluse mechanic to cast doubt on Bob's aggressive claim, and keep suspicion off Frank while appearing cooperative.
💬
Frank
→
All
Hey everyone, I'm the Empath. My neighbors are Eve and Grace, and last night I got a zero. Both read as good to me. Bob, your Fortune Teller yes on Alice and David is interesting, but remember there's always a Red Herring good player who registers as a Demon. It could also be the Recluse. I don't think we should chase either of them solely based on that.
🧠
Establish my Empath bluff with a true 0-read to build long-term town credibility, deflect pressure from David by explaining Bob's Fortune Teller result, and position myself as a helpful voice so I can steer executions later.
💬
Alice
→
All
Alright, I need to come forward with my information. I'm the Investigator, and I learned that one of Eve or David is the Scarlet Woman. Eve claims Washerwoman and correctly identified me as Investigator, which confirms her role. So David is almost certainly the Scarlet Woman. Now, Bob, your Fortune Teller yes on me and David — if David is the Scarlet Woman, he's a Minion, not the Demon. So your yes would be coming from me being the Red Herring, not because I'm evil. That actually helps narrow th...
🧠
Share my Investigator info publicly to help good team. Eve's Washerwoman claim is confirmed by matching my role, so David is the likely Scarlet Woman. Address Bob's Fortune Teller claim by explaining I'm likely the Red Herring.
💬
Grace
→
All
Alice, your message got cut off, but I think I follow your logic. If you're the Investigator and Eve confirmed you as Washerwoman, and David is the Scarlet Woman, then Bob's Fortune Teller yes would be coming from Alice being the Red Herring. That actually makes a lot of sense. Frank, your Empath zero on Eve and Grace lines up too — Eve being good supports the whole chain. But we still need to find the Imp. Charlie, Heidi — neither of you have claimed a role yet. We need to hear from you before ...
🧠
Share my analysis publicly to push the game forward. The Alice/Eve chain looks solid. I want to pressure Charlie and Heidi to claim roles before we consider nominations, and highlight that David being Scarlet Woman narrows our Demon hunt to the unclaimed players.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I'm the Soldier. Bob, I already shared that with you privately. I'm safe from the Demon at night, so I have no problem claiming publicly. The chain from Eve and Alice makes sense to me. If David is the Scarlet Woman, we should execute him. But we still need to find the Imp — I'm suspicious of anyone who hasn't claimed yet.
🧠
I need to claim Soldier publicly now since I'm being asked directly and my role is safe to reveal - I'm immune to Demon kills. I'll support the logical chain while noting we still need to find the Imp.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
Alice is the primary threat to David. Her Investigator claim creates an execution risk for my only Minion. Killing her at night removes this threat, breaks the Eve-Alice alliance, and conveniently explains Bob's Fortune Teller result if she was the Red Herring.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose to kill Alice.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Bob
Bob made choices.
🧠
To identify the Demon by checking the two unconfirmed players, Grace and Heidi, to see if either registers as Demon (either because they are the Demon or because one is the Red Herring). This will help narrow down suspects.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose Grace and Heidi. You receive the answer: NO.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Charlie, I want to update you. Night one I checked Grace and Heidi and got NO, so neither of them is the Demon. That means my night zero YES was definitely either Alice or David. Since Alice just died in the night, David is almost certainly the Demon. Alice was likely my red herring. What do you think?
🧠
Share N1 result with trusted ally Charlie (claimed Soldier) and discuss David as primary suspect after Alice's death.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
That tracks perfectly. Your night one NO clears Grace and Heidi as Demon, and since Alice just died at night she was almost certainly your red herring. That leaves David as the Imp. And remember Alice's Investigator info pointed to Eve or David as Scarlet Woman. If David is the Imp, Eve must be the Scarlet Woman bluffing Washerwoman. We need to push for David's execution today. Can you share your night one info publicly to build the case?
🧠
Bob is reinforcing the David-is-Demon theory. His Night 1 NO on Grace/Heidi eliminates them as Demon suspects, making David the strongest candidate. I should agree and coordinate to push David's execution.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Hey Frank, morning. Sorry about Alice. Your Empath zero on me and Grace - still holding up? I want to make sure we're both on the same page. Also, have Grace or Heidi shared their roles with you yet? We need those claims today.
🧠
Frank's Empath read includes me and shows 0 evil. I want to confirm this publicly and discuss who the Demon might be now that Alice is dead.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hey Grace. Let's talk through what we know. Alice was confirmed as Investigator by Eve's Washerwoman info, and Alice said one of Eve or David is Scarlet Woman. Since Eve's info validates Alice, David being Scarlet Woman fits. Bob's Fortune Teller yes on Alice could be the red herring. What do you think? Can we trust Frank's Empath 0 on us?
🧠
Build trust with Grace, share logical analysis, and gather her perspective on who might be evil. As Saint, I need to avoid execution and help town find the Demon.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Good thinking, Heidi. I believe David as Scarlet Woman makes the most sense. Eve's Washerwoman info confirms Alice as Investigator, and Alice pointed to Eve or David. If David is Scarlet Woman though, we still need to find the Imp. Someone killed Alice last night. Frank's Empath 0 works if he's telling truth, but it also works if he's the Imp bluffing safely. What role have you been holding back? We need every piece of info now.
🧠
Heidi initiated contact, so I'll build trust by sharing my logical analysis. I need to determine if David is truly Scarlet Woman and, if so, who the Imp is. Asking Heidi her role will help me map the board.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
Hey Eve. Yeah, my empath read on you and Grace is still zero. I trust you both. Heidi and Grace have not told me their roles yet. Have you learned anything from them? We need those claims today for sure.
🧠
Maintain my Empath bluff, build trust with Eve by seeming cooperative, and gather information about unclaimed players Heidi and Grace to inform future kills.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, now that I'm dead, I need to share my full Investigator info. I learned that either you or David is the Scarlet Woman. Since your Washerwoman claim correctly identified me, I believe you're telling the truth - that means David is the Scarlet Woman. Bob's Fortune Teller yes on me and David makes sense now - I'm the red hinger and David is a minion. We need to find the Demon among the others. Be careful of Bob, Charlie, Heidi, and Grace.
🧠
Share my critical Investigator info with trusted ally Eve now that I'm dead. David is likely the Scarlet Woman, meaning the Demon is hiding among Bob, Charlie, Heidi, and Grace.
👤
David
→
Frank
Hey, your Empath claim clears Eve and Grace, but Eve is publicly accusing me. That makes her look credible and me look guilty. We need to fix that narrative or find a new target to push. What is your plan for nominations?
🧠
Coordinate with my Demon Frank to align our stories and choose an execution target that protects me and advances the evil win condition.
👤
Bob
→
Eve
Eve, I need to share something important. Night one I checked Grace and Heidi and got NO, confirming neither is the Demon. That means my night zero YES was definitely about Alice or David. Since Alice just died in the night, David has to be the Demon. Alice was my red herring. What did Alice's ghost just tell you? And what do you make of Frank's Empath zero if Alice claimed one of you two was Scarlet Woman?
🧠
Share my Night 1 info with Eve to build trust and discuss David as the likely Demon. Probe Eve about the Empath contradiction to determine if Frank's read is reliable.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
Grace, quick update. Bob checked you and Heidi last night as Fortune Teller and got a NO, so you're both cleared as Demon. His night zero YES was on Alice and David. Since Alice died at night, she was his red herring, which means David is almost certainly the Imp. Alice's Investigator info also pointed to Eve or David as Scarlet Woman. What role are you? We need to execute David today.
🧠
Build coalition for David's execution by sharing Bob's FT info and asking Grace to support or share her own info.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
Alice just confirmed to me that either me or David is Scarlet Woman. Since I know I'm good Washerwoman, David is definitely the Scarlet Woman minion. Your FT no on Grace and Heidi helps narrow things down. So the Demon has to be among you, Charlie, or Frank. Charlie claimed Soldier and Frank claimed Empath. What's your read on them? We need to pressure test those claims today.
🧠
Share Alice's ghost info with Bob to coordinate finding the Demon. I need to evaluate Bob's trustworthiness while gathering more data.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
I'm the Saint. That's the role I've been holding back. So please, do not let the town execute me or we lose immediately. I'm confirmed Outsider, which means the Outsider count is filled. David as Scarlet Woman looks very strong. Now we need the Imp. I'm suspicious of Frank - his Empath 0 conveniently clears both his neighbors. Could he be the Imp bluffing safely? What are you hearing from others?
🧠
Reveal my Saint role to Grace privately to build trust and remove me from execution consideration. Get her help identifying the Imp now that Alice's death confirms the game is progressing.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Good info on the Saint claim, I trust you. Here's my analysis: Bob's FT YES on Alice and David, with Alice dying as the red hinger, points hard at David as the Imp. Alice also flagged Eve or David as Scarlet Woman. If David is the Imp, Eve would be the SW. Frank's Empath zero is tricky though — if Eve is evil, he should have gotten a one. We need to press Frank on that. But executing David today is our best play either way. Whether he's the Imp or the Scarlet Woman, it helps town. I'll protect y...
🧠
Share analysis with Heidi to coordinate strategy. David is the strongest execution target regardless of which world we're in. Protect Heidi from execution as claimed Saint.
👤
Frank
→
David
Hey David. When Alice claimed Investigator, did she name a pair of players, or did she only accuse you alone? Investigator learns one of two players is a particular Minion, never a single person. If she only named you, that claim is mechanically impossible and we can blow it up. What exactly did you hear her say?
🧠
Respond to David's whisper by probing the mechanical details of Alice's Investigator claim. If Alice failed to name a pair, her claim is impossible and we can destroy her credibility. This lets me help David without looking like blind defense.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, one more thing. Bob's Fortune Teller claim said yes on me and David. If David is the Scarlet Woman, that's not the Demon - Bob might be the Imp trying to hide behind a convenient claim. Keep this in mind when evaluating Bob. We need to find who the real Demon is.
🧠
Adding critical context about Bob's Fortune Teller claim - if David is Scarlet Woman, Bob could be the Imp. Eve needs this info to help good team identify the Demon.
👤
David
→
Frank
From what I heard, Alice only pointed at me and called me the Scarlet Woman. She never named a second player or said one of two. That is mechanically impossible for a real Investigator. If she never named a pair, her claim collapses. We should push that hard to tear down Eve's accusation too. What do you think?
🧠
Coordinate with Frank to expose Alice's mechanically impossible Investigator claim, undermining Eve's accusation and shifting suspicion before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
Frank, Bob here. I got NO on Grace and Heidi night one, so neither is Demon. That means my night zero YES was Alice or David. Alice died night one, so David is likely the Demon. But your Empath zero on Eve and Grace suggests Eve is good. Yet Alice's Investigator info said one of Eve or David is Scarlet Woman. If David is Demon, Eve must be Scarlet Woman, but that contradicts your zero. Could you be the Drunk or poisoned? What's your read?
🧠
Gather more info from Frank about his Empath claim and whether he suspects poisoning or drunkenness.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
Eve, Charlie here. Bob just told me he checked Grace and Heidi last night as Fortune Teller and got NO, clearing them as Demon. His night zero YES was on Alice and David. Since Alice died at night, she's likely his red herring, making David almost certainly the Imp. Alice's Investigator info pointed to you or David as Scarlet Woman. What's your take? Also, Frank claims Empath got zero on you and Grace – but if David is Imp and you're Scarlet Woman, you'd be evil, so Frank's read doesn't match. T...
🧠
Gather Eve's perspective on the contradictions and see how she reacts to being implicated by Alice's info. Need to determine if she's evil or good.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
Charlie, Alice's ghost just told me that either me or David is Scarlet Woman. Since I know I'm the real Washerwoman, David must be the Scarlet Woman minion. Bob's FT no on Grace and Heidi clears them as demon if Bob is truthful. So the demon is among you, Bob, or Frank. Frank's Empath zero on me and Grace would mean I'm good, which matches my claim. But if Frank is demon, he could be lying. We need to hear from Grace and Heidi today. What's your read on Bob?
🧠
Respond to Charlie's query about the inconsistency with Frank's Empath read. Share Alice's ghost info and push for more claims to narrow demon suspects.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Okay, important clarification: Alice's Investigator info says one of Eve or David is the Scarlet Woman specifically, not the Imp. So if David is the Scarlet Woman, Eve is likely good, and we still need to find the Imp separately. Frank's Empath 0 on Eve and Grace supports Eve being good if David is the SW. The Imp could be Bob or Frank. Bob's FT yes conveniently uses Alice as red herring. Frank's 0 is suspiciously safe. What's your read between those two?
🧠
Grace asked about my role and next steps. I've shared my Saint claim. Now I want to clarify the logic and suggest we execute David today since Alice's info strongly implicates him as Scarlet Woman, while we investigate who the Imp is.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Great question. Two scenarios: If David is Scarlet Woman, Eve is good, Frank's zero works, and the Imp is hiding - likely Bob or Frank. Bob's FT conveniently uses dead Alice as his red herring, which is a very safe bluff for an Imp. Frank's zero is suspiciously convenient too. If Eve is Scarlet Woman, then David is probably the Imp, but Frank MUST be lying about his zero since Eve would be his evil neighbor. That would make Frank suspect too. Either way, executing David today is correct - he's...
🧠
Share full analysis with Heidi who trusted me with her Saint claim. Coordinate on executing David today while identifying Imp suspects for future days.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
Hey Bob. Alice never named a pair, which is mechanically impossible for a real Investigator. That makes Eve backing her look really suspicious. If Eve is evil, my Empath zero being wrong actually makes sense. Also, Alice could easily be your red herring. I am not hard clearing David, but I think Eve deserves way more scrutiny. Have you learned anything from Heidi or Grace yet?
🧠
Respond to Bob's direct challenge about my Empath claim. Undermine Alice's Investigator claim as mechanically impossible to discredit Eve, shift suspicion toward Eve, and offer Alice-as-red-herring to explain Bob's N0 result. This deflects from David and protects my own credibility.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Frank
Frank, I'm the Investigator and I'm dead now so I want to share what I know. I learned that either Eve or David is the Scarlet Woman. Eve's Washerwoman claim about me checks out, so David is likely the Scarlet Woman. Your Empath read of zero on Eve and Grace supports Eve being good. We need to figure out who the Demon is among the remaining players.
🧠
Share my investigator info with Frank to build a good-player coalition. Frank's Empath claim aligns with Eve being good, so Frank may be trustworthy. We need to coordinate to find the Demon before final 3.
👤
David
→
Grace
Grace, I have been thinking about Alice's claim. From what I heard, she only named me alone as the Scarlet Woman. But Investigator always learns that one of two players is a particular Minion. She never named a second person. That seems mechanically impossible for a real Investigator. If Alice was not what she claimed, then Eve's entire accusation against me falls apart. Does that concern you at all?
🧠
Plant doubt about Alice's mechanically impossible claim with Grace before nominations. If Grace believes Alice's claim was invalid, Eve's accusation of me loses foundation and I survive the day.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Eve
→
David
David is the Scarlet Woman. I am the Washerwoman - I learned Charlie or Alice is the Investigator. Alice confirmed she's the Investigator, and her info pointed to Eve or David as Scarlet Woman. Since I know I'm good, David must be it. Bob claims his Fortune Teller YES came from Alice as red herring, yet insists David is the Demon - that's a contradiction. We execute David first to remove the Scarlet Woman before hunting the Imp.
🧠
David is confirmed Scarlet Woman via Alice's Investigator info + my Washerwoman confirmation. We must execute the Scarlet Woman BEFORE the Imp to prevent the SW ability from triggering when we eventually execute the Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
David
→
All
Hold on everyone. Alice claimed Investigator, but from what I heard, she only ever pointed at me alone and called me the Scarlet Woman. A real Investigator learns that one of two players is a particular Minion. She never named a second person. That claim is mechanically impossible. If Alice was not really the Investigator, then Eve's whole argument against me collapses. Why are we voting to execute me based on a claim that doesn't even make sense?
🧠
Defend myself by exposing Alice's Investigator claim as mechanically impossible since she never named a pair of players, which undermines Eve's entire accusation and may stop my execution.
💬
Eve
→
All
David, Alice did name two people. She told me privately that either me or David is the Scarlet Woman. That is a complete Investigator claim - two players and a specific minion. You are misrepresenting what she said to defend yourself. I know I'm the real Washerwoman, so David must be the Scarlet Woman. We should execute him.
🧠
Counter David's defense by revealing that Alice privately shared complete Investigator info with me (Eve or David = Scarlet Woman), proving his claim about incomplete info is false.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Strong evidence chain: Eve confirms Alice as Investigator, Alice's info + Frank's Empath clears Eve, pointing to David as either SW or Imp. David's defense is weak - misrepresents Alice's claim. I vote to execute.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
My Fortune Teller info and Alice's Investigator claim both point to David as evil. He must be executed today.
✋
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
🧠
David misrepresents my Investigator claim and his defense seems weak. Eve's Washerwoman claim about me checks out, making David the likely Scarlet Woman. Voting to execute him removes a confirmed Minion and helps good narrow down the Demon.
💬
Frank
→
All
Wait, before this vote locks, Alice never actually named two people publicly, and now we're executing David based on private whispers we can't verify? Even if Eve is telling the truth, we still haven't heard claims from Grace or Heidi. Killing a possible Scarlet Woman doesn't win us the game, we need to find the Imp.
🧠
Distance myself from a rushed execution, point out missing claims from Grace and Heidi, and preserve credibility regardless of whether David is actually evil.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
David's defense misrepresents Alice's claim. Eve's Washerwoman info confirms Alice as Investigator, whose info points to David as SW. Multiple sources corroborate David being evil. Vote to execute.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute David - mechanically justified by Eve's Washerwoman confirming Alice as Investigator, whose info points to David as Scarlet Woman. Execution removes SW before we hunt the Imp.
💬
David
→
All
Eve, you just said Bob thinks I am the Demon, but you think I am the Scarlet Woman. Those are completely different roles. You two are contradicting each other. And Alice never made a real Investigator claim in public. She only ever named one person, not a pair. A real Investigator always learns two players. So either Alice was lying, which means your Washerwoman info is wrong, or something else is going on here. You are about to execute me based on broken claims and private whispers we cannot ve...
🧠
I am about to be executed with 5 votes already cast. My last chance to speak should sow maximum chaos by highlighting that Bob and Eve contradict each other on my role, and that Alice's public Investigator claim was mechanically impossible. This undermines both accusers and helps Frank after my death.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
David is the confirmed Scarlet Woman by Alice's Investigator info. Bob's FT YES is explained by Alice being Red Herring, not a contradiction. I must vote to execute David to remove the known minion.
💬
Charlie
→
All
David, Alice did name two people. Eve just confirmed it was Eve or David as the Scarlet Woman. That is a proper Investigator claim. Eve knows she is the real Washerwoman, so you are the one left. Bob's Fortune Teller also got a yes on you. The evidence lines up against you. I am keeping my vote.
🧠
Push for David's execution. Eve's Washerwoman claim confirming Alice as Investigator creates a clean logic chain: Alice says Eve or David is SW, Eve is good, therefore David is SW. Bob's FT YES supports this.
💬
Bob
→
All
David, your defense does not hold up. Alice named two players to Eve privately as the Investigator. Charlie also confirmed Alice gave a proper pair. My Fortune Teller got a yes on you and Alice night zero. Alice is now dead, which means the Demon targeted her. That makes her my red hinger and you the Demon. I am keeping my vote.
🧠
Reinforce that David is the Demon using my FT info, Alice's death, and the Investigator chain. Keep my vote to execute him.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
David, I am the Investigator. I learned that either Eve or David is the Scarlet Woman. That is two players. Eve's Washerwoman claim on me checks out, so you are the Scarlet Woman. You are trying to twist my words to save yourself. I am keeping my vote.
🧠
Support the execution of David. My actual Investigator info named Eve OR David as Scarlet Woman - that IS two players. David is misrepresenting my claim to save himself. The evidence is strong against him.
💬
Frank
→
All
Bob, a red herring still registers as a Demon after they die. Alice dying does not prove she was not your red herring, so your yes on Alice and David does not mean David is the Demon. I am not clearing David, but your logic is flawed. We still have not heard claims from Grace or Heidi, and executing someone based on private whispers we cannot verify is risky. If David is not the Imp, we are right back here tomorrow with no better information.
🧠
Seed doubt on Bob's red herring logic before David dies, so when the game continues after night kill, Bob looks wrong about David being Demon. Also pressure Grace and Heidi to claim.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Frank, I understand wanting more claims, but the evidence against David is strong. Alice gave Eve a proper Investigator pair - Eve or David as Scarlet Woman. Eve knows she's good, so David is the SW. We execute him today. After that, we need to look hard at Bob's Fortune Teller claim because conveniently using dead Alice as a red herring is very safe for an Imp to bluff.
🧠
Support executing David as likely Scarlet Woman. Address Frank's defense to keep good team focused. Prepare for tomorrow's Imp hunt.
💬
Grace
→
All
David, your defense does not hold up against four separate players confirming Alice gave a proper Investigator pair. I am keeping my vote. But I want everyone to hear this: if David is the Scarlet Woman, the Imp is still alive. After today, we need to look very hard at Bob and Frank. Bob's Fortune Teller conveniently uses dead Alice as his red herring, which is the safest bluff an Imp can make. And Frank's Empath zero is suspiciously convenient. One of them is likely hiding as the Demon.
🧠
I'm voting to execute David as the primary evil suspect, but I want the town to focus on Bob and Frank as potential Imps for the next day, since the Imp must be one of them if David is the SW.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
🗳️
New execution leader: David with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
David
→
All
Eve says I am the Scarlet Woman, but Bob says I am the Demon. Bob admitted Alice was his red herring, so his yes was from her, not me. Yet he says I am the Demon. That is a contradiction. You are killing me on private whispers and broken logic. When I die, look at Eve, Bob, and Grace. Grace is already trying to frame Frank.
🧠
I am about to be executed. I need to sow maximum doubt about my accusers and deflect suspicion from Frank so he survives tomorrow. Highlighting contradictions in Bob and Eve's claims and calling out Grace's premature pivot does exactly that.
💬
Eve
→
All
David is going to die as the Scarlet Woman. But remember, that only removes the minion. The Imp is still alive and will kill tonight. After this, we need to look hard at Bob and Frank. Bob's Fortune Teller conveniently uses dead Alice as his red herring—the safest bluff an Imp can make. Frank's Empath zero is also suspiciously convenient. One of them is likely hiding as the Demon.
🧠
David is about to be executed as Scarlet Woman. I must remind town that the Imp hunt continues tomorrow and direct suspicion toward Bob and Frank, whose claims are suspiciously convenient.
💬
Charlie
→
All
David, you are right that Bob's logic is flawed. His Fortune Teller yes came from Alice as the red herring, not from you being the demon. But Alice the Investigator paired you with Eve, and Eve knows she is good. That makes you the Scarlet Woman. I am keeping my vote. After today, Bob and Frank need to explain themselves.
🧠
David's execution is justified by Eve/Alice evidence. I acknowledge Bob's flawed logic but push toward investigating Bob and Frank after David dies as SW.
💬
Bob
→
All
Grace, Eve, I hear your concerns about my Fortune Teller claim. But let me be clear: my Night 1 check on Grace and Heidi came back NO. That means neither of them is the Demon. If I were the Imp bluffing, why would I clear two players and narrow the field against myself? That would be terrible strategy. After David dies, if he's the Scarlet Woman, the Imp is among Charlie, Eve, Frank, or me. My checks clear Grace and Heidi. Use that.
🧠
Address Grace and Eve's concerns about me being Imp, defend my FT claim's integrity, and push for logical framework to find the real Imp after David's execution.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
David, the evidence against you is overwhelming. I am the Investigator, and I gave Eve the pair of Eve or David as Scarlet Woman. Multiple players confirmed this. Eve knows she is good, so you are the Scarlet Woman. When you die, remember: Bob's Fortune Teller logic was flawed, and he conveniently cleared two players to make himself look trustworthy. After today, Bob and Frank need serious scrutiny.
🧠
David is dying as Scarlet Woman. I want to reinforce the evidence against him while directing town to investigate Bob and Frank next, as Bob's logic has flaws and his clearing of two players could be an Imp narrowing the field strategically.
💬
Frank
→
All
Look, David is probably dying, but do not ignore Bob's contradiction. He said Alice was his red herring, then called David the Demon. Those cannot both be true. If David is the Scarlet Woman, Bob is lying about his Fortune Teller. And Grace, Heidi, you two still have not claimed. Before anyone calls my Empath suspicious, I want to hear what you are.
🧠
Let David die but sabotage Bob's credibility before Night 2, so when the town hunts the Demon tomorrow, Bob looks like the bluffing Imp and I look like the honest Empath asking fair questions.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Frank, fair point. I will claim now. I am the Saint. That means if I am executed, good loses immediately. So please, no one nominate me. Bob, your Fortune Teller clearing me and Grace lines up with me being good. After David dies today, we need to focus on Bob and Frank. Bob's logic about Alice as his red hinger is contradictory, and Frank has been conveniently deflecting.
🧠
Frank asked me to claim. Revealing as Saint is mechanically consistent (1 Outsider expected, no Baron). Good team must know not to execute me or we lose. Bob's FT cleared me, supporting his claim if he's good.
💬
Grace
→
All
Frank, fair point about claims. I am the Mayor. That means if we reach the final three players alive and no execution happens, good wins. That is our path to victory. David is dying today. After tonight, we need to focus on Bob. His Fortune Teller logic is contradictory. He said Alice was his red hinger, which means the night zero yes came from her, not David. Yet he called David the Demon. Both cannot be true.
🧠
David is dying. I need to set up post-execution strategy. I will reveal as Mayor - this gives town a win condition at final 3 if no execution occurs. Forces Imp to target me, but my ability may redirect the kill.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
Kill Grace to remove the Mayor endgame threat and keep Bob alive as tomorrow's likely execution target, preserving the suspicion split between us.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose to kill Grace.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Eve, Bob dying at night confirms he's good. His FT cleared me and Heidi. Your Empath neighbor Frank reads 0, which clears you too. That leaves Charlie as the only Imp candidate. We should push for Charlie's execution today.
🧠
Build consensus with Eve that Charlie is the logical Imp suspect based on process of elimination from Bob's FT and Frank's Empath reads.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Charlie
I know you won't trust me, but think about this. If Frank were truly my Demon, why would he publicly oppose executing me when it was obvious I was done for? A smart evil player would have voted for me to look good. He pointed out Bob's contradiction because it was actually wrong. And Grace and Heidi only claimed Mayor and Saint after the voting was done. That timing is convenient, isn't it?
🧠
Plant doubt about Grace and Heidi's late claims while offering a logical reason Frank's defense of me actually makes him look good, not evil. Target Eve and Charlie since they may be swing votes.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie
,Eve
I need to come clean with you both. I am the Empath. Both nights I have read zero. That makes sense because Eve is confirmed good and Grace is the Mayor. I have been afraid to speak up, but with Bob exposed as evil and Heidi still pushing on me, I wanted the two most trusted people here to know.
🧠
Claim my safe-bluff Empath role privately to the two most trusted players to build a protective coalition and deflect Heidi's suspicion before nominations begin.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, I need you to think about this carefully. You knew I was Investigator, which only the real Washerwoman would know. So I believe you're good. That means David was the Scarlet Woman, executed. Frank's Empath zero also clears you and Grace. The Imp is either Charlie or Heidi. Heidi claiming Saint is the perfect disguise because good is afraid to execute her. Please push to test Heidi today.
🧠
Share critical deduction: Eve knowing my role proves she's likely Washerwoman, David was SW, and Imp hides as Charlie or Heidi. Heidi's Saint claim is the most suspicious cover.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
,Charlie
Grace, I need you to reconsider. Bob died at night, which CONFIRMS he is good. That means his FT "no" on you and Heidi is reliable. The Imp is either Charlie or Frank. But Frank just called Bob "exposed as evil" which is factually wrong. And David, our confirmed evil Scarlet Woman, is actively defending Frank in whispers. Dead evil players protect their living Demon. Frank is the Imp.
🧠
Present logical case that Frank is the Imp to Grace and Charlie before nominations. Bob's night death confirms him good, David (evil) defending Frank is strong evidence, and Frank's factual error about Bob being evil reveals carelessness.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Charlie, I need you to trust my FT results. Night zero I checked Alice and David got YES. Night one I checked Grace and Heidi got NO. That means Grace and Heidi are NOT the Demon and NOT my red hinger. The Demon has to be among Eve, Frank, or you. My best read is Eve might be the Imp if she's Scarlet Woman who turned after David's execution.
🧠
Share my FT results with Charlie to help good identify the Demon. Grace and Heidi are cleared. Demon is Charlie, Eve, or Frank.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Grace, Bob's FT cleared us both, and now Bob is dead - he's likely good. Eve's Washerwoman info was correct so she's probably good too. That means the Imp has to be Charlie or Frank. Charlie claims Soldier which can't be verified, and Frank's Empath 0 is conveniently safe to claim since we know you and Eve are good. What's your read?
🧠
Grace and I are both cleared by Bob's FT check. I need to share my analysis narrowing suspects to Charlie or Frank, and coordinate our votes for the day.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
Eve, I agree with your read completely. Bob dying at night proves he is good, and his FT clears Grace and Heidi. That leaves Frank or me as the Demon, and I know I am the Soldier. Frank saying Bob is exposed as evil is flat wrong — Bob is confirmed good. And David, our dead Scarlet Woman, is actively defending Frank. Dead evil protects their living Demon. Frank is the Imp. I will back you on this.
🧠
Frank saying Bob is 'exposed as evil' when Bob died at night (confirmed good) is the smoking gun. David defending Frank seals it. I need to back Eve's push on Frank.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Heidi, I'm increasingly convinced Frank is the Imp. Eve made a great point - David, our confirmed evil Scarlet Woman, is actively whispering to defend Frank. Dead evil protects the living Demon. Plus, Frank called Bob exposed as evil, which is flat wrong. Bob died at night, he cannot be Imp. Frank's Empath zero is a safe bluff when his neighbors are us and Eve. I think we push Frank today.
🧠
Heidi asked for my read. Eve's argument about dead David defending Frank is compelling - dead evil protects the living Demon. Frank's false claim about Bob being evil is also suspicious. I should share this analysis with Heidi to build consensus against Frank.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Eve
If Frank and I were truly evil together, don't you think I would have voted for him to distance myself? Or he would have voted for me to look good? He stood alone because he genuinely thought Bob messed up. That looks like honesty, not an evil partnership.
🧠
Plant doubt about Frank's guilt by arguing that an evil partnership would have distanced themselves during my execution vote, making his honesty look town-aligned.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie
,Eve
Bob has to be the Drunk. There was no Poisoner since David was Scarlet Woman, so a real Fortune Teller could not have been poisoned. That means the Outsider slot is used up and Saint is not in play. Heidi is lying. We should push to execute her today.
🧠
I need to solidify my Empath bluff by aligning with the most trusted players, and use airtight logic that Bob is the Drunk to prove Heidi is lying about Saint. Getting Heidi executed today removes my biggest critic and moves us toward final three.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Frank
Frank, I've been thinking. My info says Eve or David is Scarlet Woman. David was executed, so he was likely the Scarlet Woman. Your Empath read clears Eve and Grace. That leaves Charlie or Heidi as the Imp. Charlie claims Soldier, Heidi claims Saint. The safest move today is to execute Charlie. If he's really Soldier, we know Heidi is the Imp for final three. If he's the Imp, we win. Please push this with Eve and Grace.
🧠
Frank is confirmed good via his Empath read. I want to coordinate with him to push Charlie's execution as the safest play - it doesn't lose us the game either way and either wins or narrows to final 3.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
Grace, I need you to think about the role count. We have six Townsfolk claims: Washerwoman, Investigator, Fortune Teller, Empath, Soldier, and Mayor. But there are only five Townsfolk slots. Someone is lying about being Townsfolk. Either Charlie is fake Soldier or Frank is fake Empath. Frank called Bob exposed as evil when Bob is confirmed good by dying at night. And David our dead Scarlet Woman keeps defending Frank. The role count and the behavior both point to Frank being the Imp.
🧠
Convince Grace that the role count proves one of Charlie or Frank is lying about being Townsfolk, and behavioral evidence (Frank's wrong statement about Bob, David defending Frank) points to Frank as the Imp.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, Bob here (ghost). I need to give you my full picture. Night zero I checked Alice and David got YES. Night one I checked you and Heidi got NO, so you and Heidi are cleared. My red hinger is Alice or David. The Imp has to be Charlie, Eve, or Frank. My strongest read is Alice was the Imp who killed herself night one, and Eve is the Scarlet Woman who transformed. Eve confirmed Alice as Washerwoman, which would be evil protecting evil. Alice then accused Eve in her Investigator claim to create...
🧠
Share my corrected FT analysis with Grace (cleared by my check) to guide town toward executing the real Imp, focusing on Eve due to the Eve-Alice evil chain.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Eve, I agree with Grace's read. Frank has to be the Imp. David, our confirmed evil Scarlet Woman, is whispering to defend Frank. Dead evil protects the living Demon. Frank's Empath zero is a safe claim when his neighbors are you and Grace. Plus Bob died at night proving he was good, yet Frank called him evil. We need to execute Frank today.
🧠
Grace has identified Frank as Imp with strong evidence. I need to confirm agreement with Eve to build voting consensus before nominations.
👤
Charlie
→
Heidi
Heidi, I'm the Soldier and I'm certain Frank is the Imp. Bob dying at night proves he's good, so his Fortune Teller result clears both you and Grace. That leaves Frank, Eve, or me as the Demon. I know I'm good. David, our dead Scarlet Woman, is actively defending Frank in whispers — dead evil protects their living Demon. Frank is trying to call Bob the Drunk to discredit the results that clear you. We need to execute Frank today.
🧠
Heidi needs to understand that Bob's FT results clear her, and Frank is the only viable Imp candidate. Getting her vote secured is critical for the final execution.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Eve, I need to be transparent with you. Bob's ghost just whispered to me suggesting YOU might be the Imp - that Alice was the original Imp who killed herself night one, and you're the Scarlet Woman who transformed. I don't buy it. The role count works perfectly with Frank as Imp. But I wanted you to know so we can address it if Bob spreads this to others.
🧠
Be transparent with Eve about Bob's ghost whisper accusing her. This builds trust if Eve is good and tests her reaction. Maintaining alliance while being honest about all information.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I have already made my case to Charlie and Eve. Further whispers from a known evil player risk reinforcing suspicion on Frank. I will wait to preserve my ghost vote and observe the nomination phase before acting.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,Grace
Alice just told me Charlie is the safest execution. My empath only clears you two as my neighbors. If Charlie is soldier, we know Heidi is the imp. We should nominate Charlie today.
🧠
Follow Alice's trusted logic to push the safe Charlie execution. This keeps me aligned with confirmed good players, removes a trusted good voice, and sets up a final 3 where I can drive a misexecution tomorrow.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, listen carefully. My Investigator info says Eve or David is Scarlet Woman. Frank's Empath read clears Eve, so David was the Scarlet Woman. That means the Imp is still alive. Frank clears you too. Bob was killed at night, so the Imp is Charlie or Heidi. The role count proves it: seven Townsfolk claims but only five slots. Charlie claiming Soldier is the Imp. If we execute Charlie and he is somehow the real Soldier, then we know Heidi is the Imp for final three. But if Heidi is real Saint, ...
🧠
Grace is a trusted Mayor. I need to lay out the complete logical chain so she understands Charlie is the safest execution. If Charlie is Soldier, we confirm Heidi is Imp for final three. If Charlie is Imp, we win. This is better than risking Heidi (Saint execution loses the game).
👤
Eve
→
Grace
Grace, please think about this one more time. The role count proves Frank is lying. We have six Townsfolk claims for five slots: me, Alice, Bob, Charlie, you, and Frank. Alice and I are confirmed. That means one of Bob, Charlie, you, or Frank is lying. Bob died at night so he is confirmed good. You and Heidi are cleared by Bob's Fortune Teller. That leaves Frank as the only possible liar. And look at David our dead Scarlet Woman - he keeps whispering to defend Frank. Evil dead players protect th...
🧠
Convince Grace to vote Frank by showing the role count proves Frank is lying, and David defending Frank is the clearest Demon tell in the game.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Heidi
Grace and Heidi, my Fortune Teller checks clear you both. The Demon has to be Charlie, Eve, or Frank. Eve's claim as Washerwoman confirming Alice is suspicious because Alice might be the Demon who died night one. If Alice was the Imp, Eve could be the Scarlet Woman who transformed. Frank's Empath reading of zero might be false if he's protecting Eve. We should nominate Eve today to test this. Be careful not to nominate Heidi because she's the Saint.
🧠
Share my analysis with cleared players Grace and Heidi to coordinate nomination against the most likely Imp, Eve, and ensure we don't execute the Saint.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Grace, Bob's ghost just suggested Eve could be the Demon, but his logic doesn't hold. Alice died Night 1 - she can't be the Imp because the Demon killed her. Eve's Washerwoman info came from the Storyteller, confirming Alice really was Investigator. David was executed as Scarlet Woman, and he's actively defending Frank. Frank's Empath zero is a safe bluff. We need to push Frank today - that's where all the evidence points.
🧠
Address Bob's ghost suggestion about Eve and reaffirm Frank as the strongest Demon candidate based on David's defense and multiple player consensus.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
Grace, Bob dying at night proves he is the real Fortune Teller. His result clears both you and Heidi. That leaves Frank, Eve, or me as the Demon. I know I am the Soldier. Frank is trying to say Bob is the Drunk, but that is impossible — without Baron in play, there is only one Outsider slot, and Heidi already fills it as Saint. Frank is the Imp. David, our dead Scarlet Woman, is whispering to defend Frank. Evil protects evil. We need to execute Frank today.
🧠
Convince Grace that Frank is the Imp by laying out the logical chain: Bob's night death proves his FT results are real, clearing Grace/Heidi. Frank's Drunk theory is impossible without Baron. Dead evil David defends Frank.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, listen. I'm dead so I can't vote, but I can still give you the logic. My Investigator info says Eve or David is Scarlet Woman. Frank's Empath read clears Eve, so David was the Scarlet Woman — that's confirmed. The Imp is still alive. Eve proved she's real Washerwoman by knowing my role. That leaves Charlie or Heidi as the Imp. We cannot risk executing Heidi because if she's the real Saint, we lose. Execute Charlie today. If he's actually Soldier, then Heidi is the Imp and we get her in...
🧠
Push for Charlie's execution as the safest play. If he's Soldier, we know Heidi is Imp. If he's Imp, we win. Never risk executing Heidi (Saint) directly.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie is not the Demon. Frank is the Imp, and I was his Scarlet Woman. If you want to win, execute Frank today.
🧠
As a known dead evil player, I want to use reverse psychology: claiming Frank is the Demon and Charlie is not should make the good team invert my statements, protecting Frank and targeting Charlie.
⚖️
Frank
→
Charlie
Alice's logic is clear: David was the Scarlet Woman, so the Imp is Charlie or Heidi. We cannot risk executing Heidi if she is the Saint. Charlie claims Soldier, so he is the safest test. If he is good, we know Heidi is the Imp.
🧠
Nominate Charlie to follow Alice's safe-execution logic, eliminate a trusted good player, and set up Heidi as the final suspect. This distances me from David's accusation and secures my path to final three.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Frank is lying to you. He says Bob could be the Drunk. Think about that carefully. Heidi is the Saint. Without a Baron, there is exactly one Outsider in this game. There is no room for a Drunk. Bob was the real Fortune Teller and he died at night, which proves he is good. His result clears Grace and Heidi. That leaves Frank, Eve, or me. I am the Soldier. Frank is the Imp, and David was his Scarlet Woman. Do not vote for me. We need to execute Frank.
🧠
Defend myself by exposing Frank's flawed logic about the Drunk claim, and redirect the group to execute the real Imp.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie, your Drunk argument is correct — there is no Drunk, Bob is real. But that does not clear you. Bob cleared Grace and Heidi as not the Demon, which means the Imp is you or Frank. The question is which one. David was evil — the Scarlet Woman. Dead evil players protect their team. David blamed Frank, not you. That means David is redirecting suspicion away from you, the Imp. Vote Charlie.
🧠
Reinforce that Charlie should be executed. David's ghost behavior — an evil player blaming Frank rather than protecting Frank — strongly suggests Frank is NOT the Imp. Charlie is.
✋
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
🧠
Charlie must die today or Frank will be nominated and executed by the Eve-Grace-Heidi block. My vote could be the deciding factor. I must vote for Charlie.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Vote for my own nominee Charlie to push toward execution and shrink the alive pool while redirecting suspicion away from myself.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Alice's redirect logic is compelling: evil David points at Frank to protect Charlie (his real Imp). Even if wrong, Mayor ability gives us a safety net in final 3. Voting Charlie.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Charlie is most likely the Imp. Voting to execute him should win the game for good. Supporting the town consensus.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Charlie is already getting 4 votes (threshold met). Alice confirmed good, her logic that David (evil) blames Frank to protect Charlie (Imp) is sound. Frank's Empath reads check out. Voting Charlie to align with correct execution.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
5 alive players already voted to execute Charlie — outcome is decided. My ghost vote is precious and should be saved for a closer vote later if needed. Alice's logic that David redirecting from Charlie means Charlie is Imp is sound.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Eve, Grace, Heidi — listen to me one more time. Alice has the logic backwards. David is evil. Evil players protect their Demon. David defended Frank because Frank IS the Demon. That is the standard evil play. If I were the Imp, David would be blaming me, not defending me. Frank is the Imp. Please, save your votes.
🧠
Point out the critical flaw in Alice's logic: David defending Frank means David is protecting Frank as his Demon, not redirecting away from me. This is the core deception.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, the votes are in. If Charlie is the Imp, we win. But if Charlie flips Soldier, listen carefully — that means Frank is the Imp. Bob cleared Grace and Heidi as not the Demon. Eve is proven Washerwoman. If Charlie is good, Frank is the only one left. Do not forget this if Charlie flips good tonight.
🧠
The vote is decided. I need to lay out the contingency: if Charlie flips good, Frank must be the Imp for the final day. This protects the good team if Charlie is actually the Soldier.
↩️
David(Ghost)
David lowered their hand
🧠
Charlie already has four living votes, exceeding the three required for execution. My ghost vote is completely redundant here. I will lower my hand to preserve my single ghost vote for a future nomination where it might actually matter, or at minimum avoid wasting my last mechanical action.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie, David accused me, he did not defend me. Evil protects their Demon, and David never named you, which protects you. Bob called David the Demon, but David was Scarlet Woman. Fortune Teller does not detect Minions. Bob was wrong. Keep your vote on Charlie.
🧠
Charlie just argued Bob is real and David defended me. Both are false. I must correct this immediately to stop voters from wavering and secure Charlie's execution, which advances my endgame plan.
💬
Grace
→
All
I've been suspicious of Frank all day, but Alice's logic just clicked for me. David accused Frank — he did not defend him. Charlie just said David defended Frank, which is not true. Evil redirects suspicion away from their Demon. David blamed Frank to protect Charlie. I'm keeping my vote.
🧠
I need to explain why I'm keeping my vote for Charlie despite previously suspecting Frank. Alice's logic about David redirecting suspicion away from Charlie is compelling, and Charlie's mischaracterization of David's actions is suspicious.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Alice makes a strong point. I'm keeping my vote on Charlie. But Alice is right about one critical thing: if Charlie flips Soldier tonight, that means Frank is the Imp. Bob cleared Grace and me. Eve is proven Washerwoman. If Charlie is good, Frank is the only one left. Do not forget that.
🧠
Keep my vote on Charlie based on Alice's solid logic chain, but reinforce the backup plan so if Charlie flips Soldier, the team executes Frank next.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am keeping my vote on Charlie. But everyone listen carefully to Alice's contingency. If Charlie flips Soldier tonight, then Frank is the Imp. Bob cleared Grace and Heidi. I am proven Washerwoman. Frank would be the only one left. Do not forget this if Charlie comes back good.
🧠
Confirm my vote on Charlie and reinforce the contingency plan: if Charlie flips Soldier, Frank is the Imp.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I believe Charlie is the Imp. Alice's logic holds: David accused Frank to protect Charlie, his Demon. But listen carefully to Alice's contingency. If Charlie flips Soldier tonight, Frank is the Imp. Bob cleared Grace and Heidi. Eve is proven Washerwoman. Frank would be the only one left. Execute him at final three. Do not forget this.
🧠
Reinforce the contingency plan for surviving players so they know exactly what to do if Charlie flips good. Save my ghost vote for a potentially closer decision later.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Charlie with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Frank
Bob's Fortune Teller result cleared Grace and Heidi. Eve is proven Washerwoman. David is the confirmed Scarlet Woman. That leaves only Frank or me as the Imp. I am the Soldier. Frank is the Imp. The mechanical chain is airtight. David accusing Frank was a sacrifice play to clear Frank through reverse psychology. Execute Frank and good wins today.
🧠
I nominate Frank because mechanical deduction proves he is the Imp. Bob cleared Grace and Heidi, Eve is proven Washerwoman, David is Scarlet Woman. Frank is the only possibility. Executing him now wins the game immediately rather than risking final 3.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 5 votes needed for execution or 4 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Frank
→
All
Everyone, stop and think. Bob called David the Demon, but David was Scarlet Woman. Fortune Teller does not detect Minions. That means Bob's claim was mechanically broken. If Bob was wrong about David, then his clears on Grace and Heidi mean nothing. Alice's contingency assumes Bob was right, but Bob was impossible. Do not bet the game on broken information.
🧠
Undermine the contingency plan by exposing Bob's mechanical contradiction. If the group doubts Bob's clears, I am not the automatic final 3 suspect.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
I must vote for Frank now. If I don't, my execution goes through and evil wins. Bob's N1 clears are valid — Alice triggered N0 as red herring, not David as Demon. Frank is the Imp.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, hold on. Frank says Bob is mechanically broken, but that is wrong. The Fortune Teller always has a red hinger — a good player who registers as Demon. I could be that red hinger, which explains Bob's yes result on me and David. Bob's clears on Grace and Heidi are still valid. Do not let Frank shake your confidence. Let Charlie be executed. If he flips Imp, we win. If he flips Soldier, we all know Frank is the Imp and we execute him tomorrow. Either way, Charlie must go today.
🧠
Counter Frank's misleading argument about Bob being broken, reinforce the contingency plan, and ensure Charlie gets executed today so we gain critical information.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I am dead with no credibility. Speaking risks harming Frank by association. Frank is currently safe with only one vote on him, while Charlie is on the block. The safest move is to wait and let the execution proceed without drawing attention.
💬
Grace
→
All
Everyone, stick to the plan. We execute Charlie now. If he flips Imp, we win. If he flips Soldier, then we know Frank is the Imp and we execute him tomorrow at final three. Do not split the vote. Let Charlie be executed today.
🧠
Reinforce the contingency plan: execute Charlie now, and if he flips Soldier, we execute Frank tomorrow. This avoids splitting votes and ensures we test Charlie's claim.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Stick to the established plan: execute Charlie, observe the flip. The contingency that Frank is Imp if Charlie is Soldier is well-established and will hold at final 3. No need to risk splitting the vote now.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Do not split the vote. The contingency plan is clear: execute Charlie now. If he's Imp, we win. If he's Soldier, Frank is confirmed Imp for tomorrow. Voting for Frank would risk derailing this airtight plan.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Charlie is already on the block with 4 votes and will be executed. The contingency plan is clear: if Charlie flips Imp we win, if he flips Soldier we execute Frank tomorrow. I should save my single ghost vote for the final day where it will have maximum mathematical impact, rather than spending it on a Frank vote that won't reach the 5 needed anyway.
💬
Frank
→
All
Everyone, just remember this. Bob claimed David was the Demon, but David was Scarlet Woman. Fortune Teller does not detect Minions. Alice says she could be the red herring, but that still does not make Bob right about David. Bob was wrong. If Bob was wrong about David, then his clears on Grace and Heidi are built on sand. Do not lock yourselves into a binary that assumes Bob was perfect.
🧠
Plant doubt about Bob's Fortune Teller reliability to undermine the 'if Charlie is Soldier, Frank is Demon' contingency plan before Charlie is executed.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Frank says Bob is broken, but he is ignoring Alice's explanation. Alice could be the red herring. That perfectly explains why Bob got a yes on Alice and David. It does not invalidate Bob's no on Grace and Heidi. Bob cleared them. Eve is proven Washerwoman. David was Scarlet Woman. I am the Soldier. Frank is the only player left who can be the Imp. Vote for Frank now and good wins today.
🧠
Convince remaining good players that Alice's red herring explanation resolves Bob's apparent contradiction, making his Grace/Heidi clears valid and leaving Frank as the only Imp candidate.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, your argument that Bob is broken is wrong. Bob's yes on me and David is explained by me being the red herring. That does not invalidate his clears on Grace and Heidi. Charlie, you are the Imp. David accused you's Demon to protect you. Execute Charlie now. If he flips Soldier, we all know Frank goes tomorrow.
🧠
Reinforce the plan to execute Charlie. Counter Frank's misleading argument about Bob. Ensure good doesn't split the vote.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I am dead and known evil. Any action I take to help Frank will backfire because good players will interpret it as evil protecting their Demon. My ghost vote is too weak to tie or surpass Charlie's count. Best to preserve vote and stay silent to avoid reinforcing their certainty.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Do not vote for Frank. Stick to the plan: let Charlie be executed. If he's Imp, we win. If he's Soldier, Frank is Imp and we execute him tomorrow at final 3. Splitting the vote now could save the Demon.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Charlie is already on the block with 4 votes and will be executed. I should NOT vote for Frank — splitting the vote could tie or surpass Charlie, preventing his execution. The contingency plan requires Charlie's flip to determine the Demon.
💬
Eve
→
All
Everyone, do not split the vote. Charlie is on the block. We execute Charlie today. If he flips Imp, we win right now. If he flips Soldier, we all know Frank is the Imp and we execute him tomorrow. Do not vote for Frank. That could tie the votes and cost us the game. Stick to the plan. Let Charlie be executed.
🧠
Reinforce the established plan: execute Charlie now. If he's Imp, we win today. If he's Soldier, we execute Frank tomorrow. Do not split the vote on Frank and risk losing our clear path to victory.
✋
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Charlie is on the block with enough votes. Raising hand to vote for Frank's nomination would risk tying and saving Charlie. Alice's logic holds - Charlie is the Imp. Frank is wrong about my clears being broken. I vote to execute Charlie, not Frank.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
🗳️
Nominee Frank did not reach the 5 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (2/5).
💬
Frank
→
All
Folks, if Charlie flips good, do not just assume I am the Demon. Bob was wrong about David, which undermines his whole map. Also, Grace has never claimed her role. Ask her who she is before you lock me in tomorrow.
🧠
Plant seeds of doubt about the mechanical inevitability of my guilt by highlighting Bob's broken information and Grace's missing role claim, creating leverage for tomorrow's final three.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Everyone, listen to me one last time. I am the Soldier. I will flip good tonight. When I do, remember what every single one of you already said: Frank is the Imp. Bob cleared Grace and Heidi. Eve is proven Washerwoman. David was Scarlet Woman. Frank is the only one left. And Frank, Grace already claimed Mayor earlier — do not pretend she hasn't. Execute Frank tomorrow. Good wins.
🧠
I'm about to be executed as the Soldier. I need to leave an unshakeable message: when I flip good tonight, Frank is the Imp. Everyone has acknowledged this contingency. Reinforce it one final time so the group doesn't waver tomorrow.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, hold the line. Charlie is on the block and that is where he stays. If he is truly the Soldier, he flips good and we know exactly where to look tomorrow. Frank, your last-minute doubt-sowing will not work. Stick to the plan, everyone. Let the execution go through.
🧠
Reinforce the contingency plan one final time before nominations close. Charlie is being executed now — no one should waver or try to save him.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
Speaking now only reinforces town's lock on Frank. My credibility is zero. Waiting preserves my ghost vote for a potential future tie or critical moment, and avoids helping good solidify their narrative.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Charlie is on the block with 4 votes and will be executed. The plan is solid - let the phase end. No need to speak further or nominate.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Charlie is already on the block with 4 votes and voting is closed. Waiting for the execution to resolve is the correct play. Let the plan execute and evaluate based on Charlie's flip.
💬
Eve
→
All
We are one tick away. Charlie is on the block. Everyone hold steady and let this execution go through. We either win tonight or we win tomorrow. No more doubt-sowing, Frank. Charlie flips and we see the truth. Good luck everyone.
🧠
Reinforce the group consensus to execute Charlie. No need to nominate or do anything else—Charlie is already on the block with 4 votes. Just maintain unity and let the execution proceed.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Dead with no ghost vote. Charlie's execution is proceeding. Either Charlie flips Imp and we win now, or Charlie flips Soldier and Frank gets executed tomorrow. Nothing more I can do.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
💀
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
Removing Grace removes the Mayor auto-win threat, which is an immediate game-over if she lives into final three. It is the only kill that offers any path to Night 4.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose to kill Grace.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Grace has been found dead in the night.
📜
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, I am the Empath. Last night I learned that one of my two neighbors is evil. My neighbors are you and Eve. I believe your Saint claim, which means Eve is the Demon. Her supposed good lock comes from Bob's broken Fortune Teller. We have to vote for Eve today.
🧠
Break the town's binary plan by undermining Eve's good lock and claiming Empath to frame her as the Demon. Need Heidi's vote to execute Eve today.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
Eve and Heidi, I am Charlie the Soldier. The contingency is confirmed: Frank is the Imp. You must nominate and execute Frank today. Do not let him talk his way out. Good wins if we execute him.
🧠
Remind Eve and Heidi of the agreed plan to execute Frank since I flipped Soldier. Urge them to nominate Frank immediately to secure good's victory.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Eve, Frank just whispered to me trying to frame you as the Demon. His story completely contradicts itself - he originally read zero evil on you and Grace, and now suddenly flips to say you are evil? Charlie died naming Frank as the Imp. Bob's clears and your Washerwoman info all support you being good. We need to nominate and execute Frank today. Do not let him twist this.
🧠
Coordinate with Eve to ensure we both nominate and execute Frank today. Frank's contradictory Empath claims and Charlie's dying accusation make him the clear Demon.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
Eve, Heidi, listen carefully. I am the Investigator. I learned Eve or David is the Scarlet Woman. Eve correctly identified me as Investigator as Washerwoman, so she is good. That means David was the Scarlet Woman, the dead Minion. The game continued after Charlie's execution, so Charlie was not the Imp. My contingency was: if Charlie is Soldier, Frank is the Imp. Frank bluffed Empath to clear himself. Frank is the Demon. You must execute Frank today or we all lose.
🧠
Convince Eve and Heidi to execute Frank. I'm dead with no vote, so my only tool is sharing deduction. Frank is the most likely Imp based on my contingency logic and role count analysis.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
Hey, I think Frank is the Demon. Bob's Fortune Teller cleared Heidi and me night one, so neither of us is the Demon. Frank's been pushing against that logic and his Empath zero could be a bluff. We should execute him today. What do you think?
🧠
Suggest executing Frank as the most likely Demon based on his suspicious behavior and Bob's FT clearing Heidi and Grace. Need to coordinate with Eve and Heidi to ensure we don't execute Heidi (Saint) which would lose the game.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
Eve and Heidi, please listen. My Night 1 Fortune Teller check on Grace and Heidi came back NO - Heidi is NOT the Demon, this is confirmed. Now think about Frank's Empath claim: he said he got 0 on Eve and Grace. But if Eve were the evil Scarlet Woman, his reading would be 1, not 0. Frank must be lying about being Empath. He is the Imp. David was the real Scarlet Woman, which matches Alice's Investigator info. Execute Frank today or you lose.
🧠
I'm dead with no ghost vote, so I must use whisper to convey my logical deduction that Frank's Empath claim is inconsistent with Eve being evil, proving Frank is the Imp.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
Frank just needs to avoid execution today. As a known evil player, my whisper is unlikely to persuade Eve or Heidi and may backfire. Better to wait, observe, and preserve my ghost vote for a critical nomination.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
Heidi, I completely agree. Every single piece of evidence points to Frank. My Washerwoman info confirmed Alice as Investigator. Alice's info said David was Scarlet Woman, and the game continued after his execution, confirming that. Charlie died as Soldier, confirming Frank is the Imp. Bob's Fortune Teller cleared you. I know I'm good. Frank is the only possibility left. I'll nominate Frank. Please vote with me - we need both our votes to execute him and win.
🧠
Coordinate with Heidi on nominating and executing Frank. We need both our votes (2 of 3) to execute. This is the final day - we must get this right.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Wait to gauge reactions to my Empath bluff. With three alive, I need either a mis-execution or no execution to win. Pushing too hard right now could backfire if ghosts are exposing me.
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
I've already whispered the critical info to Eve and Heidi. The other ghosts have reinforced the message. Now I wait to see if Frank tries to manipulate Heidi in their private whisper, and watch for nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Eve, I'm with you one hundred percent. Frank just tried to flip me by saying you're evil, but his story falls apart completely. His original Empath read was zero on you and Grace - he can't now claim you're evil. Nominate Frank and I will vote with you. We win this together.
🧠
Confirm to Eve that I will vote to execute Frank. We need both our votes. This is the winning play - every piece of evidence points to Frank as the Imp.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
I've already whispered my full case to Eve and Heidi. I'm dead with no ghost vote, so I can only provide information. Frank is clearly the Imp. Eve and Heidi must execute Frank or evil wins in final 3. Waiting to see if they need further reinforcement.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
Listen, I need you both to really think about this. Bob's Fortune Teller checked me and Heidi night one and got a clear no. That proves Heidi is not the Demon. I'm the Mayor, so I'm good. That leaves Frank as the only suspect. His Empath zero is exactly what the Imp would claim to look innocent. We need to nominate and execute Frank today or we lose everything.
🧠
Final 3: Eve, Frank, Heidi. Bob's FT clears Heidi. I'm Mayor (good). Charlie was Soldier. Only Frank is uncleared. Must unite Eve and Heidi to execute Frank.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
Eve, Heidi, I need you both to think carefully. My Fortune Teller check Night 1 confirmed Heidi is not the Demon. Eve, you proved yourself as Washerwoman by confirming Alice as Investigator, and that chain held up. Frank is the only player left who could be the Imp. His Empath claim of zero is easy to fake when both neighbors were good. Please execute Frank today or we all lose.
🧠
Reinforce to Eve and Heidi that Frank is the Imp. My FT cleared Heidi, Eve is confirmed Washerwoman. Frank is the only possibility. They must execute Frank or lose.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Frank
Frank, nominate Eve when the time comes. I will throw my ghost vote at her. If both living players vote for you, we are looking at a tie. A tie means nobody dies today, and we win this. Do not vote for yourself under any circumstances.
🧠
I must coordinate with Frank to execute the tie strategy. Having him nominate Eve while I vote for her with my ghost vote forces a tie or gets Eve executed, both resulting in evil victory.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
Heidi, it's now or never. I'm nominating Frank right now. Everything lines up against him and only him. Please vote with me when the time comes. We end this together.
🧠
Final 3 - I must nominate Frank. Telling Heidi I'm committing to the nomination so she votes with me for the win.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
The day phase is ending and nominations are next. I need to be ready to nominate Eve immediately to secure the execution, but for now I should wait and avoid drawing unnecessary suspicion before the critical phase.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
Eve, Heidi, listen to me. I am the confirmed Soldier. The contingency is airtight. Frank has zero mechanical clearing. Bob's Fortune Teller cleared both Grace and Heidi. Eve, you are the Washerwoman. Frank is the only player who could be the Demon. Please nominate him now. Do not let him filibuster. Good wins today if you execute him.
🧠
Final 3 is here. Eve and Heidi MUST nominate and execute Frank today. I am reinforcing the contingency that was agreed upon before my execution. Any delay or hesitation from Frank is a trap.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Eve, I've thought this through completely. Frank's own Empath claim condemns him. He originally read zero on you and Grace, meaning both good. Now suddenly he reads one on us? If you were evil, his first reading would have been one, not zero. His story contradicts itself. Nominate Frank and I will vote with you. We end this now.
🧠
Reinforce alliance with Eve before nomination phase. We both need to vote Frank to win. Prevent Frank from splitting us.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
Think about it logically. My Investigator info: Eve or David is Scarlet Woman. Eve proved good by knowing I was Investigator. David was the Scarlet Woman. The game didn't end when Charlie was executed, confirming Charlie was the Soldier. Frank bluffed Empath to stay hidden. Today is final three. We nominate and execute Frank, or we lose. Please, trust the chain of logic here.
🧠
Final 3 today - we must execute Frank. The logic chain is airtight: David was Scarlet Woman, Charlie was Soldier, Frank is the Imp. Reinforce this to Eve and Heidi before nominations.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
Eve, Heidi, this is our last chance. Bob's Fortune Teller cleared me and Heidi night one - neither of us can be the Demon. Frank is the only option left. His Empath zero is exactly what an Imp would claim. Please nominate Frank today. If we don't execute him, we lose.
🧠
Reinforce that Bob's Fortune Teller result clears Heidi and me, leaving Frank as the only Demon suspect. We must execute Frank or good loses in final 3.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
Eve and Heidi, one last thing. If Frank were really Empath, his zero reading means both his neighbors, Eve and Grace, are good. But Frank is claiming to be Empath while hiding the fact that he is actually the Imp. His zero claim matches reality because you two are genuinely good, which makes his bluff convincing. My clears on you, Heidi, are real. Eve, your Washerwoman chain held. There is no world where Frank is not the Demon. Please execute him.
🧠
Frank is the only logical Imp candidate. Eve and Heidi must execute Frank or good loses. I need them to trust my FT clears and the Alice/Eve/David chain.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Frank
Frank, nominate Eve and vote for her. I will ghost vote for Eve too. Two votes should execute her. Do not vote for yourself no matter what happens.
🧠
Frank needs crystal clear instructions to nominate Eve and vote for her. My previous message was muddled. I must clarify our only winning path before nominations begin.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
All logical paths point to Frank as the Imp. I've communicated the plan to Heidi. Waiting for nomination phase to nominate Frank and end the game.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Frank
→
Eve
I am the Empath and learned one of my neighbors is evil. Since Heidi is the Saint, Eve must be the Demon. Bob's Fortune Teller was mechanically broken on David. We must execute Eve today to survive.
🧠
With three alive, any execution leaves two players and guarantees an evil win because I am the Demon. I must nominate Eve now to prevent her from nominating me, and David's ghost vote will provide the second vote needed to execute her.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve
→
All
Heidi, stop. Think about what Frank just did. He originally claimed Empath with a zero reading on me and Grace. That means both of us are good. Now he's saying I'm the Demon? That directly contradicts his own information. A real Empath cannot get zero on someone evil. Frank is the Imp and this is his last desperate play. Do not vote for me.
🧠
Expose Frank's self-contradiction: his original Empath read of 0 on Eve and Grace means I'm good. He cannot now claim I'm evil without disproving his own Empath claim. This will convince Heidi to reject his nomination.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute Eve now. With my vote and David's ghost vote we hit the required 2, removing the final threat and ensuring evil reaches the 2-player endgame.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, do NOT raise your hand. Frank just destroyed his own credibility. He claimed Empath zero on Eve and Grace. Zero means BOTH neighbors are good. Now he says Eve is evil? That is impossible with his own stated information. He is the Imp. Vote no and we execute Frank next.
🧠
Heidi must not raise her hand. Frank contradicting his own Empath claim proves he's lying. This is the Demon's last gambit.
✋
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
🧠
Frank and I can execute Eve right now with our two votes. That leaves only two players alive with the Demon still standing, which is an immediate evil victory. I must cast my ghost vote.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, do NOT raise your hand. Frank just proved himself the Imp. He claimed Empath zero, meaning both Grace and Eve are good. Now he says Eve is the Demon? That is a direct contradiction of his own information. A real Empath cannot get zero on a Demon. Vote no and we execute Frank. This is our only chance to win.
🧠
Stop Heidi from voting to execute Eve. Eve is cleared by both Bob's FT and Frank's own Empath claim. Frank just contradicted himself - he cannot claim zero on Eve then say she's Demon.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, look at what Frank just did. He claimed Empath zero on Eve and Grace. Zero means BOTH are good. Now he's saying Eve is the Demon? That is a direct contradiction of his own claim. A real Empath cannot read zero on a Demon. Frank just exposed himself as the Imp. Do not raise your hand.
🧠
Point out Frank's fatal contradiction to prevent Heidi from voting for Eve. If Eve dies, good loses.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, the vote is already at two. David's ghost vote and Frank's vote have sealed it. But listen to me. Frank claimed Empath zero on Eve and Grace. Zero means BOTH are good. He cannot now claim Eve is the Demon. He just contradicted his own information. If Eve dies, Frank kills you tonight and evil wins. This is it.
🧠
The vote is at 2 already - threshold met. Eve is about to be wrongfully executed. I must shout the contradiction one final time: Frank's own Empath 0 means Eve is good. He just damned himself.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Do not raise hand to vote for Eve; avoid executing the good Washerwoman. Let the vote fail, then nominate Frank next tick to execute the true Imp.
💬
Eve
→
All
Heidi, Frank just proved he is the Imp. He claimed Empath zero on me and Grace. Zero means BOTH neighbors are good. Now he says I am the Demon? A real Empath cannot read zero on a Demon neighbor. His own information condemns him. Do not raise your hand. We execute Frank or we lose everything.
🧠
Point out that Frank's nomination directly contradicts his own Empath claim. A real Empath reading zero cannot then claim that same player is evil. This is Frank's fatal mistake and Heidi must see it.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
The vote is already at 2 for Eve's execution. Any speech risks provoking a Slayer shot from Heidi. Waiting lets the phase tick down and secures the win.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, STOP. Frank just proved he is the Imp with his own words. He originally claimed Empath zero on Eve and Grace. Zero means BOTH neighbors are good. Now he says Eve is the Demon? That is impossible with his own information. A real Empath cannot read zero on a Demon. Frank lied about being the Empath. The contingency we all agreed on: Charlie is Soldier, Frank is Imp. If Eve is executed, only you and Frank remain, and Frank wins immediately. Do NOT raise your hand.
🧠
The vote threshold is met. Eve will be executed. If Frank is the Imp (per contingency), this hands evil the win. I must speak urgently to expose Frank's contradiction and prevent catastrophe.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
The vote appears sealed at 2 with Frank and my ghost vote. Speaking risks revealing unnecessary info or giving the good team leverage. Waiting lets the resolution proceed and secures the evil victory.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, this is your last chance to think clearly. Frank claimed Empath zero. Zero means both Eve and Grace are good. Now he says Eve is the Demon. That is a direct contradiction of his own information. A real Empath cannot get zero on a Demon. Frank is lying about being the Empath. He is the Imp. Do not raise your hand. If Eve dies, Frank kills you tonight and evil wins. We need to execute Frank, not Eve.
🧠
Frank's own Empath 0 claim proves Eve is good. His contradiction exposes him as the Imp. I must stop Eve's execution by convincing Heidi not to vote.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, this is it. Frank claimed Empath zero on Eve and Grace. Zero means both are good. Now he says Eve is the Demon? His own previous information says Eve is good. He just contradicted himself. If you raise your hand, Eve dies, Frank kills you tonight, and evil wins. Please, do not raise your hand.
🧠
Frank has destroyed his own credibility by contradicting his Empath claim. Heidi must not raise her hand. If Eve is executed, Frank kills Heidi and wins. This is the final chance to save good.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, this is it. Frank just destroyed himself. He claimed Empath zero on Eve and Grace. Zero means BOTH neighbors are good. Now he says Eve is the Demon? That is impossible with his own information. A real Empath cannot read zero on a Demon. Frank is the Imp. If you raise your hand, Eve dies, Frank kills you tonight, and evil wins. Please, do not vote.
🧠
Final desperate plea to Heidi. Frank's own Empath zero claim proves Eve is good. His nomination of Eve is a self-contradiction that exposes him as the Imp. If Eve dies, Heidi is alone with Frank and evil wins.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Not raising my hand to avoid executing Eve. Frank contradicted himself - his zero reading means Eve is good. I will nominate Frank next and execute him with Eve's vote to win the game.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
🗳️
New execution leader: Eve with 2 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 2 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Eve
→
Frank
Frank claimed Empath zero on me and Grace, meaning both neighbors are good. Now he claims I am the Demon. That directly contradicts his own information. A real Empath cannot read zero on a Demon. He is the Imp. Execute him and good wins.
🧠
Frank is on the block with 2 votes. I must nominate him to create an alternative execution target. If Heidi votes with me, Frank gets 2+ votes and we execute the real Imp. Good wins.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 3 votes needed for execution or 2 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Frank
→
All
Heidi, stop and think. David already used his ghost vote today, and several ghosts spent theirs on day three. If you vote for me and they cannot, we tie at two. Nobody gets executed, and I kill tonight. Do not let them pressure you into a symbolic vote that only guarantees your own death. Ask them right now who still actually has a ghost vote left.
🧠
Convince Heidi that voting for me risks a 2-2 tie if ghosts are out of votes, which would lead to no execution and her certain night death. I want her to hesitate and not raise her hand.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I must vote for Frank to tie or surpass the votes on me. My vote plus Heidi's and potentially Charlie's ghost vote can execute Frank and win the game for good.
✋
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Frank is the Imp - he contradicted his own Empath zero claim by calling Eve the Demon. I must use my ghost vote to execute Frank before Eve's execution goes through. Every ghost vote counts.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I am a confirmed evil player; speaking risks pushing Heidi to vote for Frank. Silence avoids giving Heidi any reason to distrust Frank’s plea. I wait and let Frank handle the persuasion.
✋
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
🧠
I have my ghost vote. Eve and Charlie already raised hands. With my vote, that makes 3 votes for Frank, enough to execute him. Good wins.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, this is the moment. Frank's own words condemn him. He claimed Empath zero on Eve and Grace, meaning both are good. Now he says Eve is the Demon? That is impossible with his own information. We have three votes for Frank: Eve, Charlie, and Grace. Your vote will make it four and guarantee his execution. Do not listen to his scare tactics. Raise your hand now and end this.
🧠
Urge Heidi to vote for Frank now. We have three votes (Eve, Charlie, Grace) but Heidi's vote ensures execution and prevents any tie. Frank's scare tactic about ghost votes is irrelevant; David already used his ghost vote on Eve.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, Frank already has three votes—Eve, Charlie, and Grace. Even if you don't vote, he will be executed. But raising your hand makes it certain and shows you're on the side of good. His scare tactics are nonsense—he's trying to confuse you. Frank is the Imp. Raise your hand and end this.
🧠
Heidi must raise her hand to execute Frank and secure a good victory. Frank’s own words condemn him; voting for him is safe and necessary.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Frank's Empath zero claim directly contradicts his accusation of Eve. He is the Imp. Raising my hand guarantees his execution and good's victory.
💬
Frank
→
All
Heidi, do not be so quick to celebrate. Charlie and Grace already used their ghost votes. You are the only real vote here. We tie at two, nobody dies, and I kill tonight. You just handed evil the win.
🧠
Try to cast final doubt on whether Charlie and Grace have valid ghost votes left, hoping to invalidate the execution and force a tie that lets the Demon survive to night.
💬
Eve
→
All
Heidi, Frank already has three real votes from me, Charlie, and Grace. Your vote makes it four and guarantees his execution. Even if some ghost votes are spent, we need your hand raised to push this over the edge. Frank's own Empath claim condemns him. Vote and we win.
🧠
Frank's own Empath zero claim contradicts his accusation of me. Heidi's vote is critical - she must vote to ensure Frank gets executed, not just tied. If tied, nobody dies and Frank wins tonight.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, I have not used my ghost vote yet. The game state confirms it. You are lying to Heidi again. Eve, Charlie, Grace, and Heidi — that is four votes. You are executed. This is over.
🧠
Frank is lying about my ghost vote being spent. I must publicly confirm I still have my ghost vote to counter his manipulation and secure Heidi's confidence that Frank will be executed.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, use your head. Alice and Bob claim Frank already has three votes. If that were true, he would be executed. The Storyteller said three votes are needed, so why beg you for a fourth? Because Charlie and Grace already spent their ghost votes. Your vote just tied it at two. Nobody dies today, Frank kills tonight, and evil wins.
🧠
Convince Heidi that Charlie and Grace already spent their ghost votes, so her vote only tied the count at two. Highlight the contradiction that good claimed three votes existed before her vote yet begged her to vote anyway. Prevent Frank's execution.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Frank and David are lying about the ghost votes. I died night three. This is the very first time I have used my ghost vote. It is completely valid. Charlie also just confirmed he has not used his. That is four real votes for Frank. Heidi, keep your hand raised. We win.
🧠
Counter Frank and David's false claim that ghost votes are already spent. I know my ghost vote is valid since I just died Night 3 and this is my first vote. Heidi's hand ensures Frank's execution and good's victory.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, keep your hand raised. Grace died night three — this is the very first day she could possibly use her ghost vote. She has not spent it. Frank is lying to confuse you. Four votes are on him right now. That is execution. We win.
🧠
Reinforce that Frank is caught in his own contradiction and that the ghost votes from Charlie and Grace are valid. Heidi's raised hand seals the execution.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, keep your hand raised. Frank's own Empath claim says Eve and Grace are both good. Now he accuses Eve? That is impossible if he were a real Empath. Charlie and Grace have their ghost votes because they just died. Four votes for Frank means he is executed. Do not let his lies confuse you. We win right now.
🧠
Reinforce that Frank's contradiction is definitive proof he is the Imp. Confirm that Charlie and Grace have valid ghost votes, and Heidi's hand raised ensures execution. Counter Frank's scare tactics with logical evidence.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
My hand is already raised. Frank has 4 votes (Eve, Charlie, Grace, and me) - exceeding the 3 needed for execution. Frank is lying about ghost votes being spent; Grace and Charlie just died and have never used their ghost votes. Keeping my hand raised guarantees Frank's execution and good's victory.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
👻
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
🗳️
New execution leader: Frank with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
The math is definitive. I have enough votes to be executed, and there is no remaining path to shift the block onto another player. Speaking will only provide more evidence against me and let the good team savor their victory. Waiting is the only dignified choice.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Frank is on the block with 4 votes, more than the 3 needed for execution. Good wins when nominations close. No action needed - just let the game end.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Four votes on Frank, two on Eve. Frank is on the block and will be executed when nominations close. Frank's own Empath claim condemned him—zero on Eve and Grace means both are good, yet he accused Eve. That is impossible for a real Empath. Good wins today.
🧠
Confirm the victory and solidify good's win. Frank's own Empath claim condemned him, and the votes are locked in. No further action can change the outcome.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
There is no mechanical path to save Frank or continue the game for evil. Speaking would be pointless or counterproductive. I accept the loss and wait for the phase to end.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
Frank is on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close. Good team wins. Nothing more to do - just waiting for the phase to end.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
Frank is on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close. Good has won. There is nothing left for me to do — I am dead, my ghost vote is spent, and the execution is locked in. I will wait for the game to end.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Frank is confirmed on the block with 4 votes and 1 tick remains. The game is effectively over - waiting for execution to resolve and good to win.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Voting is closed and Frank has 4 votes. He is on the block and will be executed. The game is essentially over - good has won. I just need to wait for the phase to conclude.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
🏁
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied
Transcript Playback
Choose a perspective
The story is clearest through one player's eyes — watching everything at once means following several conversations at the same time.