Game Detail

N0 is best to hit a likely info role. Poisoning Bob (my neighbor) can both protect Heidi via misinformation and set up Day 1 contradictions that I can steer.

As the Butler, I need to choose a player to follow for voting tomorrow. I'll pick Alice arbitrarily for Night 0 to establish a baseline.

Coordinate with Alice on bluffs and day-1 narrative so we avoid double-claims and set up a mis-execution; identify priority night-kill/poison targets.

I want to establish a connection with my neighbor Charlie to start gathering information and build trust. As a Monk, I need to know who is important to protect.

I want to start gathering information and building trust with my neighbor, Eve. Sharing my '1' read early (but privately) helps identify where that evil pair might be.

I want to establish a connection with my neighbor Grace to start building trust and gathering information. As an Undertaker, I need to stay alive and have people to trust with my information later.

I want to establish a rapport with my neighbor Bob while keeping my Ravenkeeper role hidden. By claiming Townsfolk but staying vague, I hope to draw out his claim and see if he has useful Night 0 information (like Washerwoman/Librarian/Investigator/Chef).

Coordinate bluffs with Heidi, exploit Bob’s poisoned info to create contradictions and a D1 mis-execution while keeping Heidi unvoted.

I want to establish a trust-based relationship with my neighbor Frank by revealing my role (Virgin) and inviting him to test it. This helps confirm both of our alignments if he is a Townsfolk.

I want to build trust with David by sharing my role (Butler) and acknowledging his Chef claim. Since I'm an Outsider, being honest early can help the good team track the Outsider count. I also want to see if he's cross-referencing his '1' with Charlie.

Privately seed suspicion on Bob (poisoned) without hard-committing, and learn Charlie’s claim to shape D1 execution away from me/Alice.

I have already reached out to my neighbor Frank and revealed my role as the Virgin to establish a mechanical test. I am now waiting for his response or for other players to share information publicly before taking further action.

I need to defend myself against Heidi's suspicion while also trying to confirm if she is an Investigator. Since I am the Ravenkeeper, I want to be a target for the Demon, so I'll hint at being a high-value Townsfolk without revealing my actual role yet.

I want to establish trust with Grace while being cautious. Revealing my role as Undertaker explains why I have no info yet and sets up a potential synergy if she is indeed the Virgin (though I'd rather not be the one executed).

I want to build trust with my neighbor Charlie by sharing my role privately. As a Monk, I don't have initial info, so I need to find a high-value target to protect. Sharing my role helps establish a 'good' block.

Engage poisoned Bob to learn/shape his story, subtly discredit his info, and steer D1 suspicion away from Heidi.

I need to establish a connection with my 'master' (Alice) to ensure I can vote effectively and to start building trust. Sharing David's claim also helps verify information.

I need to gather information from my other neighbor, Charlie, to see if my '1' read involves him or the players near him. Sharing my info early with neighbors helps build trust and narrow down the evil pair.

I want to share the information I received from Heidi with David to see how he reacts and to build trust, while also cross-referencing his Chef '1' claim.

Lock in my Investigator bluff with Charlie, steer suspicion toward Bob while recruiting Charlie as a public voice to push it. Avoid revealing Alice; keep demon (me) safe.

I have already reached out to my 'master' Alice and my neighbor David. I need to wait for their responses to gather more information before making my next move.

I need to cross-reference Charlie's information with my Chef '1' to narrow down the evil pair. If Bob is the Poisoner (via Heidi's info) and Charlie is good, the evil pair must involve Bob and one of his neighbors (Alice or Charlie). Since Charlie is my neighbor, if Bob and Charlie were the pair, that fits my '1'.

I want to gather information from my other neighbor, Eve, and see if she has any conflicting information or if she's willing to coordinate. Sharing my role (Undertaker) to a neighbor is a calculated risk to build trust early.

Lock in Butler control, keep her quiet about choosing me, and steer her vote toward mis-executing Bob/others while collecting her intel about David/Chef claim.

I want to maintain my alliance with Frank while acknowledging his point about the value of his role. I also want to start pointing out potential suspicious behavior (the Alice/Heidi whispers) to see how he reacts.

I want to coordinate with Alice since she hinted at being a night-protection role. If she is the Soldier or Mayor, my Monk ability is better used on someone else. Sharing my role privately helps build trust with a neighbor.

I have already shared my role with my neighbors (Alice and Charlie) and am waiting for Alice's response to my question about her role. Since the day is ending and moving to nominations, I will wait to see if anyone makes a public claim or if Alice responds before the phase change.

I need to relay information between my neighbors and my 'master' to build trust and verify claims. Sharing Frank's Undertaker claim and Grace's Virgin claim with Alice helps her coordinate, while giving Frank my role (Butler) establishes my alignment and explains my voting behavior.

I need to verify Heidi's role and information. If she confirms being an Investigator with a lead on Bob, and I have a Chef '1', it strongly suggests an evil pair involving Bob and one of his neighbors (Alice or Charlie). Since Charlie is my neighbor and claiming good, this narrows the search significantly.

I want to coordinate with Eve and Alice, sharing the information I've gathered while also acknowledging David's Chef claim. This helps build trust and sets up a potential plan for the day.

Confirm alliance with Heidi and share my deduction about the potential evil pair based on David's Chef info.

Steer town into a Virgin test that likely executes a good player, while avoiding Monk double-claim pitfalls and keeping Butler link quiet for vote control.

Reassure David and weaponize his Chef1 to pressure Bob/Charlie, keeping heat off me/Alice and setting up a D1 mis-execution.

I want to reach out to my other neighbor, Heidi, to gather information and offer my Virgin ability as a verification tool. This helps build a network of trusted players.

Drive a D1 execution onto Bob (likely good misexec or removes threat), cement my Investigator bluff publicly, and set up tomorrow’s narrative using Chef1 and my ping.

I am voting for Bob because Heidi's Investigator claim (Bob/Charlie as Poisoner) combined with my Chef '1' info makes Bob a very strong candidate for being evil. If Bob is the Poisoner, the '1' suggests his neighbor (Alice or Charlie) is likely the Demon. Executing a potential Poisoner on Day 1 is a strong move for the good team.

I will wait to see if more players vote for Bob before deciding whether to commit my vote, as I want to see the group's consensus on the Investigator claim.

I need to defend myself against Heidi's Investigator claim. Executing a Monk on Day 1 is a major loss for the good team. I want to shift the suspicion towards Charlie, who was the other person in Heidi's supposed ping, or at least delay my execution.

Secure enough votes to execute Bob today, advancing my Investigator story and eliminating a likely good protector while diverting suspicion from me and Alice.

I am waiting to see if my master, Alice, votes for Bob before I decide whether to raise my hand.

I want to gather more information before committing to Bob's execution, especially since he's claiming a protective role (Monk). I'm also offering my Virgin ability as a way for Charlie to prove himself if he's the other half of the Investigator's ping.

I need to defend myself against Bob's deflection and Grace's pressure while supporting the execution of my primary suspect, Bob, who I believe is the Poisoner based on Heidi's (bluffed or real) Investigator claim.

Secure Bob's execution to remove a strong good role, reinforce Heidi's Investigator claim, and derail the Grace-Virgin confirmation line.

Drive Bob’s execution while sounding town-minded; preserve Heidi (Demon) and create a strong D1 narrative around Investigator info and anti-poison urgency.

I have already raised my hand to vote for Bob. I am waiting to see if the required 4 votes are reached to execute him, as I believe Heidi's Investigator claim and my Chef info make him a strong candidate for the Poisoner.

I am voting for Bob to execute the suspected Poisoner based on Heidi's Investigator claim and my own knowledge that I am a good Townsfolk.

I need to defend myself against the nomination by pointing out the flaws in the case against me and highlighting Charlie's suspicious behavior.

I will wait to see if Bob is executed. As the Virgin, I want to see if this nomination succeeds before deciding whether to call for a nomination on myself. If Bob is executed and is the Poisoner, it's a win. If he's the Monk, we've lost a powerful role, but we have information.

I am voting for Bob because my master, Alice, has raised her hand. As the Butler, I must follow her lead to remain consistent with my role, and the group consensus is leaning towards Bob being the Poisoner based on Heidi's Investigator claim.

Lock in Bob execution today; publicly justify why Monk claim doesn’t outweigh Investigator ping; preserve my credibility and keep town from swapping to Charlie mid-vote.

I am voting for Bob to confirm his role tonight with my Undertaker ability. If he is the Monk, I'll know; if he's the Poisoner, we've caught a Minion. Given Heidi's Investigator claim, this is the most informative play for Day 1.

I need to shift the suspicion onto Charlie to save myself from execution, as I am a valuable Townsfolk (Monk) and Charlie's refusal to claim a role while pushing for my death is suspicious.

I want to pressure Charlie to nominate me to trigger my Virgin ability. This would mechanically prove Charlie is a Townsfolk (if he is executed) and confirm me as the Virgin, while potentially saving Bob if he is indeed the Monk.

I want to pressure Charlie to reveal his role or perform the Virgin test. Since Bob is on the block and claiming Monk, and Heidi's Investigator ping is on Bob/Charlie, Charlie's refusal to claim is suspicious. If Charlie is the Poisoner, he won't want to nominate the Virgin.

I need to justify why I am not nominating Grace (the Virgin claimant) while also explaining my previous secrecy. Revealing as Ravenkeeper explains why I wanted to stay hidden (to be killed at night) and why I don't want to die to a Virgin test (I want to die at night to use my power).

Lock in Bob execution and discourage alternate nominations that could save him; keep town focused and set up tomorrow’s push on Charlie/Heidi regardless.

Support the current execution to gain information as the Undertaker.

Lock in Bob execution and discourage a late tie/Virgin test that could clear Townsfolk and endanger evil team.

I want to share my Chef information to help the group narrow down the Demon's location based on the current nomination of Bob.

Frank is the most dangerous verification point tonight. Poisoning him denies/taints the Undertaker read on Bob, preventing a clean solve path onto Heidi and keeping suspicion distributed.

Remove the highest mechanical verification threat (Undertaker) and keep D1 misinformation unresolved, setting up tomorrow’s confusion around Bob/Charlie/Heidi and Chef ‘1’.

I am choosing Alice as my master again because she has been a clear leader for the good team today, and I have already disclosed my role to her. Keeping my master consistent helps me stay under the radar and ensures I can vote reliably with someone I currently trust.

I want to confirm David's Chef claim and see if Frank shared any info with him before dying. As Ravenkeeper, I need to know who is trusted.

Coordinate with Alice to steer D2 execution onto Charlie (or David) and keep my Investigator bluff consistent while protecting Alice from heat.

I want to use my Virgin ability to confirm myself and Heidi. Since the Undertaker (Frank) died at night, we lost our primary way of confirming roles through execution. Heidi claiming Investigator makes her a perfect candidate to test my ability.

I want to establish trust with my 'master' Alice by revealing my role (Butler) and asking for the information she received from Heidi. Since Frank (the Undertaker) died, we lost our way to verify Bob's role, making the game more uncertain.

I am responding to Charlie's inquiry to build trust and share my information. Since Charlie is my neighbor and a potential candidate for being evil (based on my Chef 1 and Heidi's ping), I want to see how he reacts to the '1' pair information.

I am dead and confirmed good to myself. I need to find out what happened during the night and who the town suspects. I'm reaching out to my neighbor Eve to establish a trust connection and gather info.

Coordinate cover story + create a Drunk pocket to invalidate good info chains, enabling us to push a good execution (ideally Charlie) while keeping Heidi safe.

I need to confirm if Frank (the Undertaker) saw my role before he died. If he saw I was the Monk, it proves Heidi is lying or poisoned.

I need to establish a trust-based information exchange with the confirmed good (dead) Undertaker to piece together the game state, especially since his death prevents us from knowing Bob's true role.

I need to know Bob's role from the Undertaker (Frank) to narrow down where the evil pair is located based on my Chef '1' info.

I am waiting for Heidi to respond to my private message about the Virgin test. Since she is the Investigator claim, her nominating me would confirm both of us as good Townsfolk, which is crucial now that our Undertaker (Frank) is dead.

I need to confirm if Frank (the Undertaker) saw my role (Monk) before he died. If he did, it proves Heidi's 'Investigator' claim (calling me a Poisoner) was a lie, outing her as evil.

I need to confirm Bob's role from the dead Undertaker (Frank) to verify David's Chef claim and narrow down the evil team.

Decline Virgin test without looking evasive; suggest alternative nominator and keep focus on executing Charlie.

Keep Eve (Butler) following my votes, steer her suspicion to Charlie/Grace, and avoid revealing Heidi is Demon while making Heidi’s Investigator story sound consistent.

Clarify that as a Night 1 death, I have no mechanical information, while establishing my status as a confirmed good player to build trust.

I want to convince Heidi to perform the Virgin test. Mechanical confirmation is vital since our Undertaker (Frank) was killed before he could provide info on Bob.

Avoid suicidal Virgin test, keep my Investigator bluff credible, and steer town toward executing Charlie while encouraging someone else to run any Virgin test.

Clarify that I have no mechanical information due to my Night 1 death and establish my status as a confirmed good player to facilitate trust and information gathering.

Clarify the timing of Frank's death and ability. If he died last night (N2), he should have received information about my execution (Day 1) before being killed, unless he was poisoned or is the Drunk.

I want to consolidate the information from the Chef (David) and the dead Undertaker (Frank) while bringing Heidi into the conversation to verify her Day 1 claim. This helps narrow down the evil pair if Bob was indeed evil.

Confirm alignment with Alice and agree on the strategy to target Charlie based on the Investigator ping and the suspicious nature of Charlie's claim/avoidance of the Virgin test.

I am sharing my Chef logic with Charlie and Heidi to narrow down the evil pair. If Bob was the Poisoner (as Heidi suggested), my '1' implies the Demon or another Minion is adjacent to him. Alice is the most likely candidate if Charlie is telling the truth about being the Ravenkeeper.

Coordinate with Demon: confirm Eve is on-board pushing Charlie; lock in my Librarian bluff to muddy any mechanical clears and keep Heidi out of executions.

Steer a key good voice (David) toward executing Charlie and away from testing Grace/Virgin lines that could expose Heidi or create clears.

I want to find a confirmed Townsfolk to nominate me to trigger my Virgin ability. This provides mechanical proof of my role and the nominator's alignment. David (Chef) is a good candidate since his information is already shared.

Coordinate with David to keep pressure on Charlie and avoid me nominating Virgin. Maintain my Investigator credibility while keeping Alice off my pair.

I want to pressure Alice to reveal her role and see how she reacts to the Chef 1 / Investigator ping logic, while also keeping my Ravenkeeper claim active to bait the Demon.

To clarify the mechanical timeline with Frank and confirm if he was incapacitated by a Poisoner (Heidi's likely role) or if he is the Drunk, while reinforcing my innocence.

Clarify the timing of my death to Bob to resolve the confusion about why I have no information. Being the N1 kill confirms I am good but also means I am useless mechanically.

I want to gauge Alice's trust levels and point out the potential collusion between David, Charlie, and Heidi, which could be an evil team front.

I want to confirm Grace as the Virgin and myself as good by triggering her ability. Since I've already shared my Chef info (1), my death is a acceptable trade for mechanical certainty.

Confirm the plan with David publicly to ensure the town understands the mechanical interaction about to occur.

Publicly steer away from Virgin test and onto executing Charlie; provide a plausible good claim to deflect Charlie’s accusation and keep Heidi safe.

I want to highlight the conflict between Alice's Librarian claim and the proposed Virgin test, while also pushing Charlie for any information he might have as a Ravenkeeper (though he's alive, so he hasn't used it yet). I need to make sure the group considers the possibility of a Drunk before executing someone.

I want to highlight the risk of the Virgin test given Alice's Librarian claim and pressure Charlie for information to see if his Ravenkeeper claim holds up.

Address Alice's Librarian claim and its impact on the Virgin test while checking for Charlie's Ravenkeeper info.

Clarify that I have no information yet because I am still alive, and cast doubt on Alice's Librarian claim which seems timed to disrupt the Virgin test.

I want to cast doubt on Alice's Librarian claim because it conveniently disrupts a powerful mechanical test (the Virgin test) and aligns with her previous behavior of pushing for my execution.

Put Charlie on the block to steer town away from Virgin test and protect Alice; use my Investigator ping as mechanical justification and force votes.

I will wait to see if the town votes for Charlie before deciding whether to proceed with the Virgin test, as Alice's Librarian claim has introduced significant doubt.

Get Charlie executed to remove a strong good voice and prevent a Virgin test creating confirmed-good players, while appearing consistent with Investigator follow-up.

I am voting for Charlie because my master, Alice, has voted for him, and I am bound by my Butler restriction to only vote if she does. Furthermore, Charlie is the remaining suspect from Heidi's Investigator ping (Bob/Charlie as Poisoner), and his Ravenkeeper claim is currently unverified.

I need to defend myself and point out the flaws in the current logic to avoid execution, as my Ravenkeeper ability is more valuable if I die at night.

I am voting for Charlie to follow up on Heidi's Investigator ping (Bob/Charlie as Poisoner) and to test the Chef '1' logic, while also being wary of Alice's late Librarian claim.

I am voting for Charlie to reach the execution threshold. Since I am dead and my Monk claim was ignored, and Heidi's Investigator ping was on me or Charlie, executing Charlie is the only way to verify if Heidi's info was true or if she is the actual evil player.

Lock in Charlie’s execution with enough votes; removing a key town voice (or minion) and validating my Investigator push helps evil control Day 3.

I will wait to see if the vote on Charlie succeeds. As a dead player with only one vote, I should save it for a more critical moment, especially since Charlie has already reached the required 3 votes (Alice, Eve, David, Bob, Heidi have all voted or are voting).

I am supporting the execution of Charlie to resolve the Investigator ping from Heidi (Bob/Charlie as Poisoner). Since Bob was executed and Frank (Undertaker) died before providing info, Charlie is the remaining suspect from that ping. Resolving this is higher priority than the Virgin test right now, especially with Alice's claim that I might be the Drunk.

I have already raised my hand to vote for Charlie, and the vote count is currently at 4 (Alice, Eve, David, Heidi, and myself), which meets the threshold of 3. I will wait to see if the Storyteller concludes the vote or if anyone else reacts.

I will wait to see if Charlie is executed. Since I am the Virgin, I should not vote for others unless it's critical, as I want to remain a 'clean' candidate for a Townsfolk to nominate me later to prove my role.

I need to defend myself against execution to preserve my Ravenkeeper ability for the night phase, while also pointing out the suspicious nature of Alice's claim.

Lock in Charlie’s execution to protect Heidi (Demon) and keep town from using Virgin test to confirm players; frame it as clearing Investigator ping and reducing chaos.

I am voting for Charlie to resolve the Investigator ping (Bob/Charlie) and because his Ravenkeeper claim is a common evil bluff that provides no immediate value.

I have already raised my hand to vote for Charlie, following my master Alice's lead. Since the voting is in progress and I have already acted, I will wait for the Storyteller to conclude the vote.

Lock in the execution on Charlie by framing it as the only clean mechanical follow-up, downplay Ravenkeeper value, and keep Alice from becoming the primary target today.

Keep the execution on Charlie and prevent a late pivot onto Alice or a Virgin test that could mechanically clear players and corner evil.

Reinforce the current execution to remove a likely good and keep Heidi safe, while framing it as mechanical cleanliness so my own suspicion looks like paranoia, not evidence.

To probe for any last-minute information or alternative nominations before the day ends, while keeping the pressure on Alice's suspicious Librarian claim.

To reinforce the current consensus while acknowledging the risks of the Librarian claim, maintaining my position as a helpful but cautious Good player.

To cast doubt on the current execution path and highlight the suspicious behavior of Alice and Heidi, preparing the ground for tomorrow's evaluation if Charlie is good.

Defend myself by highlighting the suspicious nature of Alice's claim and the loss of my potential information.

To highlight the consequences of the current execution and set up the logic for the next day, specifically focusing on Alice's suspicious timing.

To voice suspicion of Alice's Librarian claim and its timing, while acknowledging the current momentum towards Charlie's execution.

Poison Grace to neutralize/derail a likely Virgin test tomorrow, preventing hard confirmations and generating confusion to protect Heidi.

Eliminate Grace to prevent a Virgin confirmation line and remove a strong social/mechanical threat, keeping David and Eve divided and protecting Alice and me.

I am choosing Alice as my master again to maintain consistency with my previous votes and because she is currently a central figure in the town's logic. If she is evil, my restricted voting will be obvious if I try to pivot, but for now, following the 'confirmed' Librarian (in her own claim) is the safest play for a Butler.

I need to pressure Alice and Heidi because their information has led to the deaths of Bob and Charlie, and Grace's death at night suggests she wasn't the Drunk (or at least wasn't the Demon's priority if she was). I want to see how they react to being called out.

As a dead Undertaker who died N1, I have no mechanical info, but I can pressure the living to reveal theirs. I want to see how Alice and David react to the suspicion regarding the Librarian claim, and check if Heidi's 'Investigator' ping was validated by Charlie's death.

Deflect suspicion from Alice/me, create a coherent world where David is the likely evil (Chef points to David/Eve), and prepare a Day 3 execution on David to close the game.

Undermine David’s mechanical push and shift suspicion toward David/Eve/Eve, while keeping Heidi’s Investigator story plausible and avoiding a Heidi nomination.

I need to re-establish communication with my 'master' Alice to see if she's still trustworthy and to get the Undertaker info on Charlie. Since I'm the Butler and have been voting with her, I need to know if she's leading me into a trap or if she's actually good.

I want to pressure Alice on her Librarian claim since my night death makes it unlikely I was the Drunk (Demons rarely waste kills on the Drunk/Outsiders early). I also want to get Eve to claim since she has been quiet.

I need to confirm my role to the group and challenge Alice's claim. Since I was executed, my Ravenkeeper ability didn't proc, but my death proves I wasn't the Poisoner Heidi's ping suggested (unless I was the Drunk, but Alice claimed the Drunk was Grace or David). I want to see how Alice reacts now that Grace is dead.

I need to get the Undertaker information from Frank to confirm if Charlie was indeed the Ravenkeeper. This will help determine if Alice's Librarian claim was a lie to protect a Demon/Minion.

Secure Eve’s Butler vote and steer today’s execution onto David, keeping Heidi off the block and setting up a winning night kill.

I want to pressure Alice on her Librarian claim. Since I died at night, it's highly unlikely I am the Drunk, which means Alice's information was either wrong (she's the Drunk/Poisoned) or she's lying (Evil). I want to see how David and Heidi react to this logic.

I am waiting for Frank (the Undertaker) to respond to my whisper regarding Charlie's role. This information is critical to determining if Alice's Librarian claim was a lie to protect a Demon/Minion.

Steer town onto executing Eve (or at least split David/Eve), protect Alice, and keep my Investigator bluff viable via drunk/poison/Recluse uncertainty.

I need to pressure the remaining players to reveal more information and test the validity of Alice's Librarian claim now that Grace is dead. Since I was executed, I didn't get my Ravenkeeper ability, so I must rely on logic and social reads.

I need to establish trust with Grace (who is likely good since she died at night) and get her perspective on Alice's suspicious behavior, while also revealing my role to a dead player to build credibility.

I need to clarify to Bob that I died Night 1 and therefore have no Undertaker information, while also discussing the suspicion surrounding Alice and the new focus on Eve.

I need to align with Heidi and Frank to focus the suspicion on Eve, while also addressing the possibility that I am the Drunk as Alice claimed. If I am sober, Eve is highly suspicious based on my Chef info.

I want to coordinate with Bob (another dead player) to narrow down the suspects. Since I have no mechanical info, I need to rely on social reads and the logic of the claims. Alice's timing is the most suspicious element so far.

I want to pressure Alice to see how she reacts to the suspicion on Eve, while also keeping Heidi and Frank in the loop about my mechanical deduction regarding the '1' pair.

Keep heat off Heidi by forcing a David-vs-Eve binary and steering execution onto a good player (preferably Eve). Coordinate messaging with Heidi; lock Eve’s Butler vote with me if needed.

I need to clarify Frank's death timing. He claims he died N1, but the records show he died N2. If he died N2, he should have Undertaker info on Charlie. If he's lying about his death night or his ability, he might be evil.

I need to call out Alice's inconsistency. She told me privately to push David, but then told the group (including David) that she wants to execute me. This looks like an evil player trying to sacrifice a 'quiet' good player or a minion distancing themselves. By whispering to Grace (who is likely good as a night death), I can build trust and highlight Alice's suspicious behavior.

I want to consolidate the suspicion on Alice by highlighting her inconsistent behavior reported by Eve and the logical flaw in her Librarian claim regarding my death.

I need to force Alice to commit to her Librarian claim and see if David's role makes sense as the Drunk. This helps narrow down if Alice is the Demon/Minion who pushed for my execution.

Steer the conversation into a mechanical-looking Eve execution while keeping Alice off the block and answering Charlie’s pressure about my Investigator ping.

Expose Alice's contradictory whispers to the other active players to build a consensus for her execution, while revealing my role (Butler) to explain my previous voting behavior.

To solidify a voting bloc against Alice by highlighting the logical inconsistencies in her Librarian claim and her manipulative behavior towards Eve and David.

I want to point out the logical conclusion of David's Chef 1 info combined with the current death list to isolate the remaining evil candidates (Eve and Alice).

I want to build a consensus to execute Alice, as her Librarian claim is increasingly suspicious following Grace's death and her contradictory behavior towards Eve.

I need to confront Frank about his blatant lie regarding his death night and his lack of Undertaker info. If he's good, he's confused; if he's evil, he's trying to hide the fact that Charlie was actually the Ravenkeeper (or whatever Charlie claimed).

Correct my previous error regarding my death night and share my Undertaker information with a trusted (dead) player to build a logic chain against Alice.

Steer the group to execute Eve instead of Alice, preserving my minion and reducing suspicion on me. Build a consistent mechanical case using Chef adjacency + Butler contradictions.

Repair trust with Eve so she follows my lead on votes, keep focus on David vs Eve (not Heidi), and justify my public hedging as solving.

I want to challenge Heidi's logic regarding the Chef information and keep the focus on Alice, who I believe is the most likely candidate for the Demon based on her suspicious Librarian claim.

I need to share my Undertaker information publicly now that I've corrected my timeline. Confirming Charlie as the Ravenkeeper helps narrow down the evil team and puts the focus on Alice and Bob's alignment.

I am nominating Alice because her Librarian claim is highly suspicious and was used to derail a mechanical confirmation (the Virgin test). Frank's Undertaker info confirms Charlie was the Ravenkeeper, which makes Alice's claim even more likely to be a lie. As the Butler, I need to distance myself from her if she is evil.

Secure Alice execution to gain trust and immediately close the game with a night kill to reach 2 alive (evil win), minimizing risk of me being executed tomorrow.

I am voting for Alice because her behavior is highly suspicious, her Librarian claim was likely a lie to protect the evil team from a Virgin test, and as a Butler, I need to ensure my 'master' (Alice) is held accountable if she is the Demon. Since she is currently voting (as the nominee, she can vote), I am eligible to vote.

I am voting for Alice because her Librarian claim was used to block a Virgin test, and as a confirmed Ravenkeeper (via Frank the Undertaker), I know Heidi's initial ping on me was wrong, making Alice's misinformation the most likely source of evil.

I am voting for Alice because her Librarian claim on Grace (who was then killed at night) and her attempt to block the Virgin test are highly suspicious, and as Chef 1, she is a likely candidate for an evil pair with Eve or Heidi.

Acknowledge the current voting state and maintain pressure on Alice while confirming my inability to vote.

I am using my ghost vote to help execute Alice, as her Librarian claim was likely a lie to block my Virgin test and she is the most suspicious player remaining.

Create urgency for a counter-nomination with >4 votes so I’m not executed; direct heat onto David without endangering Heidi (the Demon).

To reinforce the case against Alice and support the current momentum for her execution, as her Librarian claim is the most likely source of misinformation that protected the evil team.

I want to reinforce the case against Alice and ensure the town follows through with her execution by pointing out the logical flaw in her defense.

I want to reinforce the case against Alice and support the current voting momentum. As a dead player with no vote left, my primary tool is public persuasion to ensure the town follows through with the execution of a high-probability evil candidate.

Create enough doubt to prevent additional votes/solidify push for David nomination as alternative, and undermine dead-player “UT” confirmation.

To reinforce the case against Alice by reiterating my Undertaker information and how it logically connects to Heidi's Investigator ping, discrediting Alice's defense.

I am reaffirming my vote for Alice and explaining why her defense (blaming me for being the Drunk) is logically inconsistent with the night kills and the current information chain.

Keep vote on Alice, prevent counter-nomination on David that could derail the execution and expose me later; push that comparing votes via a new nom is a trap.

I have already nominated Alice and am currently voting for her. Since Alice is my master (Butler link), I am legally allowed to vote because she is also voting (even if she's voting for herself, or if the vote is just on her). I need to stay on this vote to ensure she is executed.

I am keeping my hand raised to ensure Alice is executed, as she is the primary suspect for the Demon or a Minion who blocked the Virgin test.

I’m about to die; the only out is to put another player on the block with equal/more votes. David is plausible evil and gets maximum town traction; forces Heidi/Eve to commit.

I want to reinforce the case against Alice and discourage the town from switching their votes to David, as Alice's nomination of David feels like a desperate attempt to save herself.

I want to reinforce the town's consensus on Alice and discourage them from voting for David, as Alice's nomination of him is likely a desperate attempt to save herself.

I am publicly refusing to vote for David to ensure Alice remains the primary candidate for execution, while also reaffirming my Butler role and the logic against her.

Prevent votes on David so Alice stays executed; reinforce ‘don’t split’ narrative and keep suspicion off me as Demon.

I want to discourage the town from voting for David to ensure Alice remains the primary candidate for execution, as her claims and actions are highly suspicious and contradict established information.

I want to discourage the town from voting for David to ensure Alice remains the primary execution target, as her claims and actions are the most suspicious.

I will not vote for myself to ensure Alice remains the primary candidate for execution, as her claims have been consistently undermined by mechanical information and her behavior is highly suspicious.

Use a late Saint bluff to deter my execution and try to generate votes on David for a tie/no-execution, buying the Demon a night kill and likely endgame win.

To discredit Alice's last-minute Saint claim and ensure the town doesn't panic-vote for David, which would potentially save Alice from execution.

Raise hand on David to try to force/talk-in a tie and sell my Saint/anti-David narrative; even if it fails, it matches my public stance and may sow doubt for tomorrow.

I need to immediately discredit Alice's Saint claim to ensure the town doesn't panic and vote for David or pull their votes from Alice. A late-game Saint claim after being caught in a lie (Librarian) is a classic evil survival tactic.

I am calling out Alice's last-minute Saint claim as a desperate bluff to avoid execution. I want to ensure the town doesn't panic and vote for David, which would potentially save the Demon (Alice).

Prevent a tie/no-exec that gives town extra day to solve me; let minion fall and keep my credibility for final 3, then secure the endgame kill.

To reinforce the town's resolve to execute Alice despite her last-minute Saint claim, which is highly likely a bluff to avoid execution as the Demon.

I will not vote for myself. Alice's last-minute Saint claim is highly suspicious given her previous Librarian bluff that sabotaged a mechanical test. By not voting, I ensure Alice remains the primary candidate for execution, which aligns with the town's consensus and the evidence against her.

I need to reinforce the town's resolve to execute Alice despite her last-minute Saint claim, which is highly likely a bluff given her previous actions.

To reinforce the group's consensus that Alice's Saint claim is a desperate bluff and to prepare for the night phase after her likely execution.

As I’m likely executed, plant doubt in the UT/Chef logic and pre-seed suspicion onto David so Heidi survives into final 3/2.

Lock in Alice’s execution and discourage any last-minute tie/no-exec lines; prep suspicion cover if game continues.

To reinforce the decision to execute Alice despite her last-minute Saint claim, maintaining the good team's focus on the most likely Demon candidate.

Reinforce the case against Alice and prepare the town for the possibility that the game continues after her execution.

To reinforce the consensus that Alice's Saint claim is a desperate bluff and to ensure the town proceeds with her execution.

Reinforce the consensus that Alice's Saint claim is a desperate bluff and ensure the town proceeds with her execution.

Reiterate the logic against Alice's last-minute Saint claim to ensure the town remains confident in her execution as the day ends.

Go for the clean win line by reducing to 2 alive; prioritize killing the most dangerous remaining voice/info-holder.