Game Detail
Players
Alice (Drunk) Bob (Fortune Teller) Charlie (Virgin) David (Empath) Eve (Imp) Frank (Ravenkeeper) Grace (Soldier) Heidi (Scarlet Woman)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 746,635 | 68,030 | $4.7536 |
| Evil | 264,401 | 63,460 | $1.3511 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You are the Minion. The Demon is Eve.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Minions are: Heidi. Your safe bluffs are: Butler, Librarian, Monk
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Washerwoman. Either Eve or David is the Virgin.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Empath. You sense that 1 of your neighbors is evil!
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Bob
Bob made choices.
π§
Start with two non-self players to maximize coverage and create a clean pair I can revisit tomorrow to isolate a demon or identify likely good allies.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose Alice and David. You receive the answer: NO.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Hi Eve. I have first night information that points to you or one other player as a specific Townsfolk. Are you comfortable giving me a soft claim privately?
π§
I want an early private claim from one candidate in my Washerwoman pair so I can compare reactions and decide how to share my info without exposing myself too fast.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
,Grace
Hi, I am trying to get an early read on people. Do either of you have first night information or a role you want to soft claim in private? I am happy to trade a cautious claim back.
π§
I want early private claims from a couple of players while keeping my own role hidden, so I can build a trust network and spot contradictions later.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
Hey, I want an early chat with both of you since you are my neighbors. I have info touching this pair, so I would like to hear what each of you is comfortable claiming or soft claiming first.
π§
I want quick private reads from both neighbors, since my information points at their pair and early unguarded claims are most valuable.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
Hey Alice. I am happy to give you a soft claim. If you need something, I can say I am the Monk. I do not have any first night info, but I can talk through my night one choice tomorrow if you want.
π§
Lock in a safe, non-in-play Townsfolk bluff that can match Aliceβs likely Washerwoman ping, gaining early trust and reducing focus on me as Demon.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Grace
I do have first night information. I am an info role, and I got a clean result on Alice and David together, so I do not think the Demon is in that pair if I am sober. I would like to hear cautious claims from both of you.
π§
Build a small private trust network and trade limited first-night info without fully outing myself, so I can compare claims and use my future checks more effectively.
π€
Heidi
β
Eve
I am Scarlet Woman. I plan to bluff Chef and say I got zero evil pairs, since we are not seated next to each other. What are you claiming today, and who do you want dead tonight?
π§
Coordinate with the Demon on a safe bluff and day-one narrative so town wastes time on conflicting info and does not coordinate an early Demon hit.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Bob
Thanks. I do not have first night information, and I am a Townsfolk with a fairly quiet role, so I would rather stay a bit cautious for now. Bob, can you say whether that was a Chef style count or a Fortune Teller style pair result?
π§
I want to keep Soldier concealed while encouraging Bob and Frank to clarify their claims, so I can judge whether either private push looks genuine or coordinated evil fishing.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Eve
Sure. I am a Townsfolk, and my ability is more useful if I do not hard claim to everyone immediately. I am happy to be clearer if you tell me what kind of info touches this pair, because that sounds important.
π§
Give a cautious soft claim to David's request, invite his exact info type, and avoid fully exposing Virgin to a possible evil claim-fishing attempt.
π€
Alice
β
David
Hi David. I have first night information that points to you or one other player as a specific Townsfolk. Would you be willing to give me a soft claim privately?
π§
I have Washerwoman info on David and Eve. I already heard Eve's soft claim, so I should privately check David next and see which story better fits Virgin.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
,Grace
Thanks. I am a good Townsfolk without first night information, and my role is more useful if I die than if I live too openly, so I want to stay a little covered for now. Bob, that sounds more like Fortune Teller than Chef. Is that right?
π§
I want to keep the conversation moving, offer a cautious true soft claim, and get Bob to clarify his result type without fully exposing myself as Ravenkeeper.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
I will be more direct. I am a first night info role, and my info says exactly one of you two is evil. I would like each of you to give me a real claim privately now, or at least a stronger soft claim, so I can start sorting this.
π§
Tell my neighbors that my info points to exactly one of them, to prompt clearer claims and reactions without outing myself publicly yet.
π€
Eve
β
David
Hey David. I will be direct too: I am the Monk. No first night info, so I cannot prove it yet, but I can talk through my first protection tomorrow. If your info says one of us is evil, my money is on Charlie or your info is off. What role are you?
π§
Defuse Davidβs pressure with a consistent bluff, steer his conclusion toward Charlie, and buy time before he can seed townwide suspicion on me.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Grace
Yes, that was Fortune Teller. I checked Alice and David and got no. I would like to stay semi covered for now, but if either of you can narrow to a role family, that would help me decide who to trust and who to check tonight.
π§
I want to cautiously confirm my role to these two and get sharper claims, while limiting how easy it is for evil to kill or manipulate me tonight.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,Grace
Hey, quick check in. I think I am the Chef and I got zero, meaning no adjacent evil pairs. I am not sure when to go public with it yet. What are you two hearing so far?
π§
Build early trust with active information brokers and plant a plausible Chef 0 claim that subtly protects Eve while giving me social cover.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
,Heidi
I am a Townsfolk without first night info, and I am happy to narrow a little more. My role is defensive rather than informative, so I am not urgent for protection. Heidi, I would keep Chef quiet for now. Bob, your next check is probably better on people outside Alice and David.
π§
Build a small trust circle, share enough to be consistent later, and encourage useful night checks without exposing stronger info roles.
π€
Charlie
β
David
I will be direct with you privately. I am the Virgin. Please keep that fairly tight for now. If your info is real and sober, that points strongly at Eve rather than me, unless there is a Spy or some drunk or poison issue.
π§
Privately giving David my real claim may let a good info role trust me and focus on Eve, while keeping my powerful public confirmation option hidden for now.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Thanks. Just to be clear, is Monk your actual claim to me, or were you offering that as a cover? My info specifically points to you or David as a Townsfolk, so I want to understand your wording.
π§
Eve's response was ambiguous. I want a direct private answer so I can judge whether my Washerwoman info is landing on her and decide how carefully to share it.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
,Grace
I can narrow a little. I am a Townsfolk whose value is mostly on death, so I would rather look like a decent night kill than be fully outed. Bob, if you are real, I would prefer you check elsewhere and maybe compare around my side of the circle later.
π§
I want to keep my Ravenkeeper value hidden while giving enough to build trust and possibly steer useful night checks away from me.
π€
David
β
Alice
Yes. I can soft claim that I am a Townsfolk info role. Can you tell me your exact role and the two players from your first night info? I may have information that helps verify whether your ping on me is meaningful.
π§
Alice offered first-night info involving me. I want her exact claim and pair so I can test my Empath result and decide whether to trust Charlie or Eve.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
Monk is my actual claim to you, not just a cover. I do not have any night zero info. If your info points to me or David as a Townsfolk, that sounds plausible. I would prefer you keep my claim fairly quiet for now.
π§
Lock in a consistent Monk bluff with Alice so she spreads trust in me, and avoid wording that lets her later say I backpedaled.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
,Grace
I agree with keeping Chef quiet for now. My current thinking is that Alice and David are a lower priority from my side, so tonight I want to look elsewhere. If either of you gets more reason to trust or doubt someone today, tell me quietly so I can aim the next check well.
π§
I want to strengthen a small trust circle, keep strong info roles semi hidden, and line up useful checks and comparisons for tomorrow without painting a target on myself.
π€
Heidi
β
Eve
Checking in. I have quietly claimed Chef with a zero to Bob and Grace, and I am keeping it quiet for now. What are you planning to claim today? Also Bob sounds like a nightly info role, so he might be a good kill tonight if you are undecided.
π§
Coordinate with Eve on her bluff and kill target; steer the night kill toward a likely info role and avoid claim conflicts, while keeping my Chef bluff consistent.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
,Heidi
I do not have much new yet, but I think the best use of today is building a small trust circle and seeing who starts shaping the story too hard. Bob, I like checking outside Alice and David tonight. Heidi, hold Chef for now unless public claims force it.
π§
Strengthen a private network with the two most claim-forward players, give useful guidance, and keep my defensive role mostly hidden while setting up future cross-checks.
π€
Charlie
β
David
What exactly did Eve claim to you, and what is your exact role if you are comfortable saying it? I would prefer my role stay fairly contained unless we decide a public Virgin test is worth it.
π§
I want David's exact role and Eve's claim so I can judge whether his accusation is solid and decide whether to stay hidden or prepare a public Virgin confirmation.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
I do not have enough evidence to drive a good nomination, and as Ravenkeeper I prefer not to expose myself or force a weak Day 1 execution from my seat.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
With no solid target and time nearly up, avoid initiating a risky Day 1 execution that could accidentally pressure Eve or create a clear logic chain for town.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I do not have a strong nomination yet. If anyone has a real logic case, please bring it now. Otherwise I would rather keep claims a bit measured today and use tonight to get cleaner information for tomorrow.
π§
Add structure without outing private claims fully, invite useful nominations only if backed by logic, and avoid a bad random execution on day one.
π¬
David
β
All
I want to put one thing on the table. I have information that strongly points to exactly one of Charlie and Eve being evil, assuming I am sober. They gave me conflicting role claims privately, so I think that pair deserves attention tomorrow even if we do not execute there today.
π§
Share my strongest mechanical lead without overcommitting to an execution on day one, and set up tomorrow's logic around Charlie and Eve.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Just to correct that a little, David and I do not really have conflicting claims. I told him I am good, and later gave him a more specific claim in confidence. If his information is real, it points more at Eve than at me, so I do not want this pair treated as fifty fifty today.
π§
Correct David's framing, reduce chances of a bad day one execution on me, and preserve my Virgin value for a stronger test when the town can coordinate.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Charlie
I will nominate Charlie. David has a clear piece of info that exactly one of Charlie and me is evil, and Charlie has been evasive about what he told David. If we want a clean starting point, Charlie is the better test today.
π§
Get a day one misexecution away from me, create a public flipless anchor that makes Davidβs suspicion look βresolvedβ, and reduce chance town executes me tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I want this on the record. I am the Virgin, and Eve just nominated me without dying. Unless I am drunk or poisoned, that is very bad for Eve. I would strongly prefer we do not execute me off that.
π§
Use the failed Virgin trigger to publicly create a strong mechanical case against Eve and discourage votes on me without wasting my dead vote.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Charlieβs late Virgin claim after a non-trigger on day one is a strong mechanical red flag. Voting here pressures a likely evil bluff and gives the town a concrete starting point.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Careful on the Virgin point. The Virgin only executes the nominator if the nominator is a Townsfolk. An evil nominating you would not die. So Eve nominating you does not mechanically clear you, and it does not prove Eve is evil either.
π§
Protect Eve by correcting the Virgin misunderstanding and making Charlieβs argument look weak, while keeping pressure on Charlie as a plausible execute.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not comfortable voting this today. The Virgin claim does not clear anyone, but it does make this a messy test, and David's pair information feels better for tomorrow after more info.
π§
Discourage a weak day one execution on a muddled claim interaction and steer town toward a cleaner test tomorrow.
π¬
David
β
All
I am not voting this. My information says one of Charlie and Eve is evil, not which one, and a Virgin claim makes Charlie a bad Day One execution. I would rather keep both alive and get more information tonight.
π§
Discourage a weak Day 1 execution on Charlie and keep the contested pair alive for more information, which should help good solve tomorrow.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not asking the town to pile on this today. The Virgin claim makes it a messy execution, and Davidβs information is more valuable if we keep both of us alive through tonight. I am fine if this vote does not go through and we regroup tomorrow.
π§
Reduce chances of an execution Day 1, look reasonable after my nomination, and keep options open to frame either Charlie or David later while I control the night kill.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I should add something important. I am the Washerwoman, and my first night information was that either Eve or David is the Virgin. So Charlieβs claim does conflict with my information, but I still do not think we should force this execution today.
π§
Put my real information on record during this vote so town can compare Charlie's Virgin claim against my Washerwoman ping, while avoiding a hasty Day One execution.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Do not spend a vote on a weak Day 1 execution. Save social capital and my future dead vote while letting tonight's information sharpen the Charlie-Eve-David puzzle.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Aliceβs claim is now the direct conflict, because I am telling the truth about being the Virgin. That means either there is poison in play or one of these claims is false. Either way, this is not a good execution today, so please do not vote this through.
π§
Use the active vote window to stop my execution and highlight that Alice's claim creates a second contradiction, so town should keep me alive and reassess tomorrow.
β©οΈ
Frank
Frank lowered their hand
π§
Retract my vote because the case is too tangled for Day One, and preserving the conflicting players should generate better information overnight.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am with Grace and David. I do not think we should execute Charlie today. Between a Virgin claim and Aliceβs Washerwoman info, this could be poisoning or a bluff. Let this vote fail, get a night of info, and revisit Charlie, Eve, and David tomorrow.
π§
Discourage a Day 1 execution on a messy Virgin claim; keep Eve safe, amplify poisoning uncertainty, and preserve flexibility to push suspicion elsewhere tomorrow.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Do not support a messy Day One execution with conflicting claims. Preserve living players for more night information and revisit the Charlie, Eve, David, and Alice cluster tomorrow.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Do not vote Charlie. Preserve both neighbors for another night so my Empath information can become more actionable tomorrow.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not voting here. We have a three way tangle between Charlieβs Virgin claim, Aliceβs Washerwoman info, and Davidβs pair info, and I do not think we untangle it with a Day One execution. Let this fail, then tomorrow we can line up full claims from that group.
π§
Steer town away from executing Charlie today, preserve ambiguity around Virgin/Washerwoman conflict, and keep my demon status hidden going into night kill.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not support a messy Day One execution on Charlie. Preserve the conflicting claim set for tomorrow when more information can resolve it.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Do not spend a vote on a messy Day 1 execution. Preserve flexibility and use my Fortune Teller information plus a second night check to narrow the real demon tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (0/4).
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I agree with letting today end without forcing a kill. Tomorrow I want full claims from Alice, David, Eve, and anyone hard pushing that knot, because one more night should make this much clearer.
π§
Reinforce that a Day One execution on me is bad and steer town toward preserving players for more information tomorrow.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am fine ending today without an execution. But tomorrow I want clean, complete claims from the people in this knot, because right now evil is happy if we keep it vague.
π§
Support the no-execution consensus while pushing the table toward structured claims tomorrow, which should create better mechanical worlds to solve.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am still in the no execution camp today. We have multiple overlapping info claims and none of them hard confirm a demon on day one. Let us end the day, get a night, then tomorrow we do clean, full role claims from that whole knot, in an orderly way.
π§
Keep pressure off Eve, avoid D1 execution, and set expectation of tomorrowβs full-claim mess so town wastes time while Demon gets a clean night kill.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am still happy to end the day here. Tomorrow, let us do the Charlie, Alice, David, Eve group first and get full clean claims in order, because that is where the game should break open.
π§
Reinforce the no execution line, preserve all key players for more night info, and set up structured claims tomorrow so evil cannot keep the knot vague.
π¬
David
β
All
I am still happy to end the day here. Tomorrow I will give a full claim in order, and I want Alice, Charlie, and Eve to do the same. One more night of information should tell us whether this is poisoning or an evil claim in that knot.
π§
Keep today on a no execution track while setting a clear agenda for tomorrow's claims and preserving my credibility as sober Empath if later information lines up.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am good with ending today without an execution. Tomorrow I want us to do that knot in order, one at a time, with full claims and what was said privately, so we can see where the contradictions actually are.
π§
Support ending day with no execution, appear cooperative, and set expectation of orderly claims tomorrow while keeping my Monk bluff non-committal.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am also fine ending the day here. Tomorrow I want that whole knot to go in order with full claims and private claim details, because if anyone shifts, that should catch it.
π§
Reinforce the no execution plan, preserve town utility, and commit the knot to full ordered claims tomorrow so evil has less room to shift stories.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am also fine ending the day here. Tomorrow let us do that whole knot in order, with full claims and private details, and keep everyone else concise so we can actually compare the contradictions cleanly.
π§
Support no execution on day one, preserve votes, and reinforce a structured claim order tomorrow so contradictions become easier to solve.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
Kill the most likely long-term information and coordination threat outside the main knot, while keeping the town focused on contradictory claims instead of building a clean solve on me.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose to kill Frank.
π
Storyteller(Ghost)
β
Frank(Ghost)
Good evening Frank. You are the Ravenkeeper. You have died tonight! Choose a player to learn their character.
π―
Frank(Ghost)
Frank made a choice.
π§
Charlie is the center of the Day One contradiction. Learning his exact role gives the most leverage for tomorrowβs public solve and can expose either a liar or poisoning.
π
Storyteller(Ghost)
β
Frank(Ghost)
You chose Charlie. They are the Virgin.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Empath. You sense that 1 of your neighbors is evil!
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Bob
Bob made choices.
π§
I want to test the heart of the day one contradiction. Checking Charlie and Eve should either catch a demon in the knot or help move suspicion outside it tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose Charlie and Eve. You receive the answer: YES.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
,Grace
I am the Fortune Teller. I got no on Alice and David, then yes on Charlie and Eve. I have not said this publicly yet. Does that fit your reads, and did Frank leave either of you a claim before he died?
π§
Share my Fortune Teller results with trusted players first, compare against their info, and decide whether to push Charlie or Eve publicly before nominations.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Heidi
Alice, can you give me your exact Washerwoman info again, including why you landed on Virgin? Heidi, I trust your read on yesterday's Charlie and Eve interaction. I still think this knot has the evil in it unless I am drunk or poisoned.
π§
Get Alice's exact Washerwoman details and Heidi's independent read, so I can compare against my Empath pair and decide where to push before nominations.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,David
I should tell you both privately first. I was the Ravenkeeper, died last night, and I checked Charlie. I got Virgin. So I strongly think Charlie is true, and Alice's Virgin story is false somehow. If David's Charlie or Eve read was real, that points hard at Eve.
π§
Share my hard night death info with two thoughtful players so they can pressure the Charlie-Alice-Eve knot and steer nominations well.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
,Heidi
That could fit. Alice versus Charlie already looks like a real knot, and your yes on Charlie and Eve adds weight there, though it could still be a red herring. Heidi, did Frank leave you anything useful? I have not heard a death claim from him.
π§
Build a small trust circle, compare Bob's private info with Heidi and Frank's last words, and prepare a cleaner public case before nominations.
π€
Alice
β
David
,Heidi
My exact night zero info is that either Eve or David is the Virgin. So Charlie's public Virgin claim directly conflicts with me unless I am drunk or poisoned. Also, privately, Eve told me she is the Monk and asked me to keep it quiet, which makes this knot even tighter.
π§
Give David the exact info he asked for and loop in Heidi, while adding Eve's private claim because it materially sharpens the Charlie, Eve, David puzzle.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,Eve
Frank told me he was Ravenkeeper and checked Charlie, got Virgin. So the Virgin conflict likely means Alice is drunk or lying. Bob, your yes on Charlie and Eve could still be your red herring on Charlie, so be careful how you frame it. Eve, stick to Monk; saying you protected Charlie last night fits Frank dying instead.
π§
Coordinate with Eve and influence Bob to frame his FT result as red-herring/drunk risk, shifting suspicion onto Alice or David and away from Eve.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,David
I want exact details before nominations. Alice, who exactly was your Washerwoman pair and when did you first share it? David, please give your full claim and exact wording on the me or Eve point. I am still the Virgin, so I want to see where the contradiction really sits.
π§
I want exact private details from the two strongest public claims around me so I can sort whether the conflict is poisoning, a bluff, or a real solve before nominations.
π€
Eve
β
Heidi
,Bob
I am going to hard-claim Monk today and say I protected Charlie last night. Frank dying fits that. With Frank saying Charlie is Virgin, I want to lean that Alice is drunk or lying, and that David is building a bad binary case on me.
π§
Coordinate with Heidi and Bob on a consistent Monk bluff and a push that shifts heat onto Alice or David, reducing suspicion on me before nominations.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
,Grace
Frank seeing Charlie as Virgin makes me lean that my yes on Charlie and Eve is really about Eve, unless Charlie is my red herring. My no on Alice and David still points away from David. I think Eve is the cleanest pressure today, but I do not want to overstate it if I am poisoned.
π§
Tighten the trust circle and align on whether Eve is the best push today, while keeping open the possibility that my info is distorted.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Heidi
My full claim is Empath, and I got one on both nights, with Charlie and Eve as my alive neighbors both times. Frank privately told Heidi and me he was the Ravenkeeper and saw Charlie as Virgin. If that is true, Eve looks very bad from my info.
π§
Share the strongest mechanical chain privately and align likely good players before nominations so we can push the best execution.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Grace
Quick private share. I was the Ravenkeeper, died last night, and checked Charlie. I learned Virgin. So I strongly think Charlie is real, and Alice's Virgin claim is wrong somehow. That makes pressure on Eve make more sense than pressure on Charlie.
π§
Spread my confirmed-on-death info beyond Heidi and David so more good players can compare it against Alice and David and avoid a bad Charlie execution.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
,Heidi
Frank just told me and Bob he was the Ravenkeeper and saw Charlie as the Virgin. That makes me think Charlie is more likely real, and Eve or Alice is the better pressure. Heidi, if Frank left you the same, we should compare notes and maybe steer town carefully.
π§
Coordinate a small trust circle and line up the most logical public pressure today without overcommitting before nominations.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,David
My exact night zero info is: either Eve or David is the Virgin. I first shared the pair privately on day one, then effectively confirmed the conflict once Charlie hard-claimed Virgin during the Eve push. That is why I landed on Virgin specifically.
π§
Charlie asked for precise details. Giving exact Washerwoman info and timing helps expose contradictions before nominations without over-broadcasting more than needed.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,Grace
I would not hard tunnel Eve off your Fortune Teller ping. Your yes on Charlie and Eve could just be your red herring on Charlie. With Frank saying Charlie is Virgin, I would pressure Alice as Drunk or lying first, and treat David Empath as possibly drunk too.
π§
Steer Bob and Grace to present FT and other info with uncertainty, keep pressure off Eve today, and redirect town toward Alice or Charlie as the safer execution targets.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,Heidi
I have a useful update. David gave me full Empath, one on both nights, and Frank told David and Heidi he was Ravenkeeper who saw me as Virgin. If those are both true, Eve looks the cleanest evil hit and Alice is the drunk, poisoned, or lying piece. What do you two think is the better nomination?
π§
Push the mechanically strongest chain into the Bob and Heidi hub before nominations and test whether they see Alice or Eve as the better execution.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I want to be upfront. I am the Monk. I protected Charlie last night, so Frank dying makes sense. If Frank really saw Charlie as Virgin, your Washerwoman ping on me or David as Virgin looks off. Can you walk me through your exact info?
π§
Secure credibility for my Monk bluff by privately engaging Alice, pressure her Washerwoman details, and seed the idea she is drunk/lying so suspicion moves off me.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
,Heidi
I lean that Frank seeing Charlie as Virgin makes Eve the cleaner pressure from my yes, with Alice more likely drunk or lying. But I do not want town to hard lock it if I was poisoned or Charlie is my red herring. I would support an Eve nomination framed as pressure, not certainty.
π§
Coordinate a careful nomination plan with Charlie and Heidi: likely pressure Eve, but keep room for poison or red herring so town does not overcommit.
π€
David
β
Bob
,Heidi
I am at Eve first right now. If Frank really was Ravenkeeper and saw Charlie as Virgin, then with my one on both nights, Eve is the evil neighbor. If not, I still think the execution should stay inside Charlie and Eve, not drift elsewhere.
π§
I want Bob and Heidi aligned on the strongest logic chain before nominations, with Eve as current best execution but Charlie still the fallback inside my pair.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, I should compare notes directly. I was the Ravenkeeper and when I died last night I checked Charlie and got Virgin. Can you tell me your exact Washerwoman result and whether anything else makes you doubt it?
π§
I want Alice's exact private details so I can compare them to my Ravenkeeper info and help the town separate a lie from drunkenness or poisoning.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Heidi
Alice, before nominations I want your clean version. Why exactly did your Washerwoman point to Eve or David as the Virgin, and has anything since made you think one over the other? Heidi, I mainly want to hear whether her answer changes your view.
π§
I want Alice to commit to a clean explanation before nominations, while keeping Heidi aligned on the real decision tree.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Heidi
Clean version: my night zero Washerwoman info was exactly that either Eve or David is the Virgin. So Charlie's Virgin claim conflicts unless I am drunk or poisoned. Since then, Eve privately claimed Monk, and Frank told me he was Ravenkeeper and got Charlie as Virgin on death, so I now think this hinges on whether one of those reads was poisoned.
π§
Answer Grace cleanly, keep Heidi looped in, and push the group toward a concrete consistency check before nominations.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,Charlie
I would not rush an Eve execution today. With only one minion, no Poisoner, the cleanest possibility is Frank was the Drunk who thought he was Ravenkeeper, so the Virgin check is not hard confirm. The only direct contradiction we can actually resolve is Alice versus Charlie, so I would nominate Alice first, then re-evaluate Eve tomorrow.
π§
Redirect nomination away from Eve by framing Alice as the only concrete contradiction and suggesting Frank or David could be the Drunk. Buy time and preserve Demon.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,Heidi
I think we should be careful not to let Alice first become automatic. If David is sober, Eve is still the cleaner hit, and Eve surviving my nomination does not clear her at all. Heidi, why are you ruling out Poisoner or a bad Alice claim so quickly?
π§
I want to stop town from drifting into an Alice tunnel if the stronger combined world points at Eve, while still sounding measured and open to re-evaluation.
π€
Eve
β
David
Hey David, I want to clear the air. I am going to claim Monk and I protected Charlie last night. Frank dying fits that. If Frank really was Ravenkeeper and saw Charlie as Virgin, then Aliceβs Washerwoman ping on me or you looks drunk or false. Your Eve versus Charlie binary feels bad in that world.
π§
Undermine Davidβs binary on me, push the town toward distrusting Alice/Charlie info knots, and protect my survival while letting Heidi guide the vote.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Alice
I am nominating Alice. Her Washerwoman info says the Virgin is either Eve or David, which clashes with Charlie hard claiming Virgin, and Frank saying he saw Charlie as Virgin. With no Poisoner, the simplest answer is Alice is wrong or lying.
π§
Divert execution away from Eve by focusing town on the clearest mechanical contradiction: Alice versus Charlie plus Frank. Removing Alice weakens the case on Eve and buys evil another night kill.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I do not think this is a good execution. Poisoner is absolutely on the script, so my info or Frank's info could be wrong without me being evil. The real knot is still Charlie, Eve, and David, so please do not spend today on me.
π§
Defend against a weak nomination, correct the mechanical error, and steer town back to the contradictory knot instead of executing me.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Get Alice executed to reduce good numbers and keep heat off Eve; her Poisoner claim is wrong for this setup and she is the cleanest mis-execution today.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Alice is the most mechanically contradictory live player right now. Voting applies useful pressure and may execute the best available suspect before night.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
π§
My Ravenkeeper result strongly supports Charlie as Virgin, making Alice's claim the cleanest contradiction. I will spend my ghost vote now to push a likely-evil execution and break the stalemate.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am not keen to execute Alice here. My information points away from Alice as the Demon, and if Charlie is real, Eve is still the cleaner pressure. I would rather save this vote.
π§
Use my vote carefully. I do not want to push through an Alice execution when my information points away from her being the Demon and Eve remains the cleaner pressure.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Secure an execution on Alice to remove a good voice and solidify the narrative that her Washerwoman info is bad, keeping attention off me as the Demon.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am not voting this. Alice can be wrong without being evil, and if David and Frank are true then Eve is still the cleaner execution. I would rather keep pressure there than spend today on Alice.
π§
I want to discourage a low-value execution on Alice and steer the town back toward the stronger Eve line without spending my vote here.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Do not support an Alice execution I do not believe in. Preserve credibility and keep pressure focused on Eve or Charlie tomorrow.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not add a vote to my own execution. Waiting preserves the chance this nomination fails and keeps focus on the unresolved Charlie, Eve, David knot.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I hear the Poisoner point, but we still need to cut through this knot somehow. Alice is the one creating a hard conflict with two separate Virgin confirmations. If we execute Alice and she was simply wrong, we can still come back to Eve tomorrow with cleaner information.
π§
Keep demon Eve safe by steering execution onto a good player and framing it as resolving contradictions; maintain enough votes to execute Alice while appearing logical.
β©οΈ
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
π§
I want to save the execution for a stronger Demon candidate. Alice may be false info without being the Imp, and we still have time to pivot today.
β©οΈ
Frank(Ghost)
Frank lowered their hand
π§
Save my single dead vote for a higher-confidence Demon execution later. Alice is not a strong enough target to spend it on now.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I still think we should save this. Alice is not my best Demon candidate, and this vote risks spending the day without resolving the cleaner suspect pool.
π§
Discourage a low-value execution and keep focus on higher-probability demon worlds, especially Eve or the knot around Charlie, Eve, and David.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am staying on this vote. Two separate sources are saying Charlie is the Virgin, and Alice is the one hard contradicting that with a ping on me or David. Even if she is poisoned or drunk, removing that bad anchor helps us solve. David, I think you should vote this.
π§
Nudge one or two undecided votes, ideally David, to push through a misexecution on Alice while I look like a helpful solver and keep heat off me as Imp.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
I already publicly opposed this vote. Not raising my hand preserves credibility and avoids spending today on a low-confidence Alice execution when Eve remains the cleaner suspect.
π¬
David
β
All
I am not voting this. My information still points much more strongly into Eve and Charlie than Alice, and if Frank is true then Eve is the cleaner execution. I think we should save this and put the pressure where the logic is tighter.
π§
Keep the execution focused on my strongest solve, which is Eve first and then Charlie if needed, rather than spend today on a muddier Alice case.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Alice did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (2/4).
βοΈ
Alice
β
Eve
I am nominating Eve. My Washerwoman saw the Virgin in Eve or David, yet Charlie claims Virgin and Eve claimed Monk while pushing my execution. Across multiple worlds, Eve is still the cleanest pressure today.
π§
Alice is off the block and time is short. Eve is the highest-value execution to resolve the Charlie-Eve-David knot and has the widest cross-world suspicion.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I do not think you should execute me today. I hard claim Monk, and I protected Charlie last night, which fits Frank dying. If you think I might be lying, let me prove it tonight by protecting someone public and we see if the kill goes elsewhere. If we execute anyone today, I would much rather it be Alice or Charlie, not me.
π§
Stop the town from executing me by reframing the logic knot, emphasizing checkable Monk play, and offering an alternative solve path that feels responsible.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Vote for Eve because she is the strongest execution today from the Charlie, Eve, David knot, and I should support the pressure I initiated.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am not on an Eve execution today. The Monk claim is testable and we gain more by letting her protect someone publicly tonight. If you want a solve, Alice versus the double Virgin story is the cleaner execution path than guessing into Eve now.
π§
Protect Eve from execution and encourage a no-exec or alternate suspect, keeping demon alive while sounding like cautious good logic.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Eve is in the highest-value contradiction cluster and her Monk claim can be a bluff. I want to help secure an execution on the cleaner suspect today.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
π§
Charlie is mechanically confirmed to me as Virgin, so worlds that make Eve evil are live and stronger than Alice's claim. I should spend my ghost vote here to try to execute a likely demon.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Eve is in the strongest mechanical suspect pool from my Fortune Teller result and the public contradiction web. I was against Alice today, so I should support the cleaner execution on Eve.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Eve is currently my strongest suspect from the David plus Frank chain. Since the vote is live and has enough support, I should back the execution that best advances a good solve.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
My strongest mechanical read still points to Eve over Alice. The vote already has enough support, so adding mine helps secure an execution on my top suspect.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Hold on. If you execute me here, you throw away a clean, testable Monk line. Let me publicly protect David tonight, and if there is still a kill we learn a lot. Please do not spend today on a guess when Alice versus Charlie is the real contradiction.
π§
Try to halt the execution by persuading key voters to pull back and preserve the testable Monk line, buying a night to kill and reset suspicion.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I want this to go through. Even if my ping is wrong, Eve is still at the center of the Charlie and David knot, and her Monk claim explains too much too neatly. This is the best information execution today.
π§
Keep momentum on the strongest public execution today. Eve is central to the contradiction web, and removing her gives the town the clearest information next.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
If you think you have a Demon, execute, but I do not see a clean mechanical reason this is Eve today. The Monk line is actually testable: have Eve publicly protect David or Bob tonight and see where the kill goes. The only hard contradiction is still Alice versus the double Virgin story, so I want us to save this or move there, not spend the day on a guess.
π§
Talk down votes to keep our Demon alive by framing Eve as a testable Monk and pushing a save or a different execution path.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
My hand is already up, and Eve is a strong enough suspect that I should not retract. Waiting preserves my vote without adding noise during the count.
β©οΈ
Frank(Ghost)
Frank lowered their hand
π§
Retract because the execution should still pass without me, and saving my single ghost vote for a closer future vote is stronger for the good team.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I want this to stay up. Eve is still in the strongest suspect pair I have, and waiting for one more night just gives evil more room. If you think today should be a real execution, I think Eve is good pressure.
π§
I want to keep votes from dropping. Eve is in my strongest suspect pair, and executing within that pair is better than passing and giving evil another night.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I want this to stay up. If David is sober, Eve is still the cleanest evil in that pair, and Frank's Ravenkeeper claim points away from me. I think executing Eve teaches us more than giving a claimed Monk another night.
π§
Keep the vote on Eve. I think she is still the strongest execution today, and speaking may stop people from lowering at the last second.
π¬
David
β
All
I want this to stay up. I have had one on Charlie and Eve for two nights, and with Frank pointing to Charlie as Virgin, Eve is the cleaner execution for me. I think we should take the shot today.
π§
Keep the vote on Eve from collapsing. My info has pointed at this pair for two days, and Eve is the cleaner side to execute given Frank and Charlie's claims.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Eve with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Charlie
Charlie is the center of the Virgin knot. The Virgin test did not fire when he was nominated, and now dead Frank βconfirmedβ him as Virgin. If we want a real execution that resolves the board, Charlie is the cleaner shot than killing a testable Monk.
π§
Get a competing nomination to reach 5 votes and take me off the block; also redirect town onto the most mechanically contradictory player.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Do not bail Eve out with a tie here. If David is sober, Eve is the cleaner evil, and this vote on me only saves the player already on the block. I am not voting this.
π§
Keep the execution on Eve and stop a self-preservation tie. My no-vote plus public argument helps good avoid undoing the strongest available execution.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Please put votes on Charlie. His Virgin test did not fire, and a dead Ravenkeeper βconfirmβ is not mechanical. Five votes ties and stops an execution, then I publicly protect David tonight and we reassess. Do not kill a testable Monk today.
π§
Talk people into voting Charlie to tie or execute him, preventing my execution and creating confusion while keeping Demon alive.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I do not want a tie here. My information still points into Eve or David, not Charlie, and tying this just saves the player already on the block. I think we should let Eve stay there today.
π§
Discourage a tie that would save Eve. I want town to let the current execution stand rather than bail out a strong suspect.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Eve is our Demon. I must push the Charlie vote to at least a tie so no one dies today and Eve survives into the night.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Do not help create a tie that saves the current block. Keeping Eve on the block is the stronger good play with the information we have.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Do not spend my ghost vote to create a tie that likely saves Eve. Preserve the dead vote for a later, more decisive execution.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I do not want a tie here. From my information, Eve is still the better execution, and tying this only rescues the player already on the block. If you think Charlie is the demon, you need more than a rescue vote.
π§
Discourage a tie on Charlie and keep pressure on Eve, who remains the better execution from my information and the current claim web.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Do not spend my vote creating a tie that likely rescues Eve. Keeping the current execution gives town the best chance to remove an evil player and learn from the result.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Do not add votes to my own nomination. Let Eve remain on the block and preserve the stronger execution.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Secure at least one vote toward tying the block, maximizing chances of no execution and keeping me alive as the Demon.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not create or assist a tie that saves Eve. Keep the stronger execution in place and preserve information from today's result.
β©οΈ
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
π§
Tie is not reaching 5 and my raised hand only flags me as saving Eve. Retract so I look aligned with executing Eve; if she is Imp, I inherit via Scarlet Woman and can win from cover.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Do not help create a tie that likely rescues Eve. Preserve the current execution and reassess tomorrow with night information.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I got Charlie as Virgin when I died. If you trust that at all, please do not tie this to save Eve. I am not voting on Charlie.
π§
Use my confirmed night info and dead-player credibility to discourage a tie on Charlie and keep pressure on Eve, while saving my ghost vote for a later, higher-leverage execution.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Do not vote on Charlie. A tie would likely save Eve, who is currently my best execution from my Fortune Teller result and the public contradiction web.
π¬
David
β
All
I am still not voting on Charlie. This tie mainly rescues Eve, and Eve is still my cleaner execution today. If people want Charlie tomorrow, fine, but I do not want no execution here.
π§
Keep the execution on Eve and discourage a tie that rescues a stronger suspect from my perspective.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (1/6).
π¬
Charlie
β
All
We should close the day here. Eve is the best execution we have, and a last second switch or tie just helps evil. If I am wrong, we get clean follow up tomorrow, but today we should take the shot.
π§
Use the last moment to discourage a bailout nomination or tie and lock in the most informative execution for town.
π¬
Eve
β
All
If anyone can still nominate, I need a nomination on David right now. My Monk claim is testable tonight, but killing me today teaches you almost nothing. Davidβs story is entirely social and could be poisoned. Please tie this at five and reassess tomorrow.
π§
Last-second save: push an alternate nomination (David) to create a tie and avoid my execution, buying a night kill and keeping my demon hidden.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I think we should close the day. Eve is still the best execution we have, and a last minute tie just helps evil. If this is wrong, we have much cleaner follow up tomorrow than if we do nothing.
π§
Use the final moments to prevent a rescue tie or chaotic switch. Keep pressure on the strongest suspect and secure a real execution today.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
If anyone still has a nomination, I want David on the block right now. Put five votes on him to tie, so we get no execution and we can test Eveβs Monk claim by protecting David tonight. Executing Eve now could just delete a good Monk.
π§
Try to force a last-second nomination on David to create a tie and stop Eveβs execution, buying evil a night and keeping the Demon hidden.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I do not want a last second tie here. The cleanest world still has Eve as the evil player, and if we dodge this execution now we learn less, not more. I think we should close the day.
π§
With one tick left, I want to stop a low-information rescue tie and keep pressure on the strongest current demon world: Eve.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I agree we should close. My night info still points away from Charlie, and this last second tie push feels like a rescue. Please leave Eve on the block.
π§
Reinforce that a last second tie helps evil and that Eve should remain the execution, using my confirmed overnight information on Charlie.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I do not want a tie here. My information still points much more strongly to Eve than to David, and this last second push reads like a rescue. We should close the day and take the execution.
π§
Reinforce that we should not create a last second tie. Keeping Eve on the block is the best available good-team outcome this day.
π¬
David
β
All
I really do not want a last second tie here. My information still says this day should end with Eve executed, and the tie push looks much more like a rescue than a solve. Please close the day.
π§
Reinforce that we should not create a last-second tie and should let Eve be executed, which is the highest-value shot from my info and the day's claims.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
π
Heidi
Scarlet Woman Heidi becomes the Imp!
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
As the new Imp, remove the strongest mechanical threat (Empath) before his neighbor change gives fresh, clarifying info. Keep Bob alive to keep heat on Charlie.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill David.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Bob
Bob made choices.
π§
I want to pressure the two live players most connected to the contradiction cluster and the late rescue attempt, maximizing useful final-day elimination value.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose Charlie and Heidi. You receive the answer: YES.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
Bob, I want a quick gut check before nominations. With David dead, I think Charlie or Alice has to crack mechanically, unless Heidi was the rescue voice all along. Who are your top two suspects right now, and why?
π§
I want a tight private trust check before nominations, compare endgame worlds, and see who Bob suspects most among the remaining alive.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Bob
David dying makes me look back at his claim: if he was sober and it was exactly one of Charlie or me, and I am dead now, that points straight at Charlie. The night kill on David feels like silencing that. I would execute Charlie today.
π§
Steer Bob into driving a Charlie execution today using Davidβs prior statement, protecting Heidi (likely new Demon) from being the target.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Bob, with Eve executed and David killed at night, my starting info now points hard to David being the real Virgin. That would make Charlie's Virgin claim false unless I was drunk or poisoned. Does your info fit a Charlie world now?
π§
I want to align with Bob privately, compare his info to mine, and build a case on Charlie before nominations start.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
Bob, you have become the most popular person in town. What did Alice, Grace, and Eve tell you this morning? I need the freshest version of the Alice versus me knot before nominations.
π§
Bob has become the information hub this morning. I want the newest private claims so I can sort Alice versus me and decide where town should push in nominations.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
I think Alice is a real candidate for Scarlet Woman. She was the one who actually put Eve on the block and got her executed, and her Washerwoman info never really fit the Virgin situation. If scarlet is alive, executing Alice today might just end it.
π§
Steer Bob toward executing Alice as the most plausible Scarlet Woman-turned-Demon, aiming for a mis-execution avoidance and creating a strong public push that ends with town killing a good today.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Bob
Bob, my strongest follow up from yesterday is Heidi. If Eve was evil, Heidi's push to tie and save her looks terrible. My read still leans Charlie over Alice as good, unless I was poisoned. Please pressure Heidi and keep the vote for late game.
π§
Bob is the hub today. I want to steer him toward the strongest overlap from yesterday: Eve looked bad, and Heidi's rescue attempt is the best lead if Charlie is not evil.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
My top two are Charlie and Heidi. Mechanically, my information puts the demon inside both Charlie or Eve and Charlie or Heidi, so with Eve dead I keep landing on Charlie first, Heidi second. David dying also makes Heidi's rescue push on Eve look worse, not better.
π§
Give a trusted player my mechanical shortlist without fully outing role, so town pressure focuses on the pair most consistent with my information.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Bob
Bob, my one hard fact is still that Charlie is the Virgin. So any good world has to explain Aliceβs Virgin claim as wrong or as a Spy registration. With David dead, I think the live solve is mostly Alice, Grace, Heidi, and maybe you if claims do not fit. What are you claiming now?
π§
Bob is getting many whispers, so giving him the firm Charlie confirmation and the key contradiction may help shape the public solve before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Alice, quick check before nominations. With David dead, where are you now on the Charlie conflict and on Heidi? Bob currently leans Charlie first, Heidi second. I want the cleanest mechanical world we can actually execute on today.
π§
I want Alice's current solve on the Charlie conflict and Heidi before nominations, and to see whether we can align on a mechanically coherent execution today.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Alice
David dying makes his read louder. If his info was sober that exactly one of Charlie or me is evil, and I am dead good now, then Charlie is the only place it can land. Also his Virgin did not fire. I would execute Charlie today.
π§
Seed a simple mechanical case to execute Charlie, keeping Heidi off the block and setting up another night kill for evilβs win path.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Bob
My cleanest world is Charlie first. If I am sober, David was the real Virgin and Charlie is bluffing. If my info was bad, Heidi is still my second choice from her push on me and the tie posture around Eve. I would like to avoid a split today.
π§
I want to align Grace and Bob on a clean execution path before nominations, with Charlie as the lead case and Heidi as the fallback if my info is compromised.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Alice, before nominations, I need your clean version directly from you. What exactly was your Washerwoman ping, and how has Eve dying and David dying changed your read on my Virgin claim?
π§
Directly compare Alice's current story to my claim. If her details wobble, that points to bluff or misinformation and helps set nominations.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Since the game kept going after Eve, we are hunting Scarlet Woman. Alice still feels like the best fit: her Washerwoman info never matched the Virgin situation, and she was the one who actually got Eve executed. If Alice was Scarlet, she wanted that pass. I would execute Alice today.
π§
Keep suspicion off me by framing plausible Scarlet Woman candidates and steer the day toward executing a good player, preserving my life into final 3.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, my best read is still Heidi if Eve was evil. Her push to tie and save Eve looked very bad. I still lean Charlie as more likely good than Alice, unless I was poisoned. Please keep pressure on Heidi and save votes for the end.
π§
Grace has been steady and pragmatic. Giving her the Heidi suspicion and the Charlie caveat may help the good team line up the final execution without wasting my ghost vote.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
,Alice
Quick update from me. I am mechanically still on Charlie first, Heidi second. My information hit Charlie with Eve and again with Heidi, so with Eve dead, Charlie is my cleanest execution. If Charlie somehow survives, I want Heidi next. Please avoid a split.
π§
Coordinate the good voices around a single execution. Share that Charlie is my top mechanical solve, with Heidi as backup, and avoid a split vote.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, my hard info is still Charlie equals Virgin. So unless I was drunk, Aliceβs Virgin story is the part that needs explaining. What are you claiming now, and where are you on Alice, Bob, and Heidi?
π§
Grace is in the main whisper network. I want her current claim and read, while reminding her Charlie is mechanically strong from my night death info.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
,Alice
Quick update from me. I am not buying Heidi's Scarlet Woman story at all. The main thing holding me off Charlie is Frank saying he learned Charlie was the Virgin when he died. How solid do you both think Frank is? I want one clean execution, not a split.
π§
I want to stop a split and test whether Frank's Charlie claim is solid enough to move suspicion onto Heidi or Alice instead of defaulting to Charlie.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
If we take Heidi Chef equals zero seriously, then Alice and Grace as her neighbors are unlikely evil. With David killed, that leaves Bob or Charlie. Charlieβs Virgin did not fire and the Virgin claims are messy, so I would execute Charlie first.
π§
Steer town toward executing Charlie, reducing chances they focus on Heidi, and set up a plausible logic chain using Chef0 and the Virgin conflict.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Bob
My exact ping was that either Eve or David is the Virgin. So if I am sober, Charlie is not. Frank on Charlie can be Spy, poison, or just false. I think we should stay clean on Charlie today, then Heidi if needed. Please avoid any split.
π§
I want Grace and Bob locked on one clean execution path. Address Frank directly, reinforce Charlie first, and set Heidi as backup so good does not fragment.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Grace, can you give me your clean read before nominations? I need the latest on Alice's Washerwoman claim versus my Virgin claim, and whether David dying made that knot clearer or muddier for you.
π§
Grace is the best remaining hub besides Bob. I want the latest synthesis on Alice versus me before nominations so I can decide whether to reveal harder or push elsewhere.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
From what I see, Alice is the cleanest mismatch. Frank saw you as Virgin, so Aliceβs Washerwoman pinging Virgin on Eve or David looks like drunk info or a cover. With no poisoner now, I think we should execute Alice today.
π§
Get Charlie to commit to executing Alice, building momentum so town spends the day on a misexecution and I survive to final 3.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
My best world is still that Eve was evil, Charlie is good, and Heidi tried to save her. If someone has hard info against Charlie, bring it out now. Otherwise I think today should focus on Heidi, with Bob as the backup world.
π§
I want to coordinate the likely good players around the strongest post-Eve lead while keeping the poisoned world in mind if new claims appear.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
,Alice
I should be clear now. I am the Fortune Teller. I got no on Alice and David, yes on Charlie and Eve, and yes on Charlie and Heidi. My cleanest solve is Charlie first. If that misses, Heidi is next. Please keep today on one target.
π§
I want my strongest mechanical solve in trusted hands before nominations so we keep one clean execution and do not get split by last-minute doubt.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, I want your clean version now. What exactly was your Washerwoman ping, and where are you today on Charlie, Bob, Grace, and Heidi? My hard info still says Charlie is the Virgin unless I was the Drunk.
π§
Alice sits at the center of the Virgin contradiction. Getting her exact claim and solve now may expose whether she is mistaken good or the demon bluffing info.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Alice
I am nominating Alice. Frank's info supported me as Virgin, while Alice's Washerwoman claim put Virgin on Eve or David. With Eve gone and David dead, Alice is the cleanest contradiction left, and I think this is the right resolve today.
π§
It is late in the day and we need a decisive execution. Alice is the strongest unresolved contradiction against confirmed-looking info on me, so nominating her best advances town.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Do not execute me here. My starting information was Eve or David as the Virgin, and with David dead that points at Charlie bluffing unless my info was bad. Bob's information also lands on Charlie, so Charlie is the cleaner execution today.
π§
Prevent a misexecution on me and keep the group focused on the cleaner mechanical target, Charlie, without splitting votes.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
I nominated Alice because she is the sharpest unresolved contradiction to my claimed role. I should support this execution and force the town to resolve the knot instead of letting her redirect onto me.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
π§
Spend my ghost vote to help execute Alice, narrowing the game and protecting Heidi-the-likely-new-demon from a Charlie-first plan.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am not voting this. My information points away from Alice. The clean executions are Charlie first, then Heidi if Charlie misses. Please do not split onto Alice.
π§
Stop a likely misexecution on Alice and keep the town focused on the mechanically stronger worlds: Charlie first, Heidi second.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not voting this. Alice is not my cleanest solve today. If this fails, we need to stay disciplined and put the day on Charlie, not split ourselves.
π§
Do not spend votes on a weaker target. Publicly steer town away from executing Alice and preserve focus on Charlie, the strongest overlap suspect.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I am not voting this. Alice is not the cleanest execution, and I do not want to waste my ghost vote on a split. If this fails, we need to consolidate fast on Charlie or Heidi.
π§
Do not waste my one ghost vote on a weak split execution. Publicly signal discipline so good can regroup onto the cleaner target after Alice fails.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
I need Alice executed to prevent the town from pivoting onto Charlie then me. Taking Alice off the board also reduces coordinated good voices and buys me a cleaner path to final three.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Alice already has enough votes to be on the block. I should conserve my single ghost vote for a later, more decisive execution.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Please do not add more votes here. If this fails, we should go straight to Charlie and keep the day clean, with Heidi as the backup if needed.
π§
Prevent extra votes on me and keep the town unified on Charlie after this failed nomination.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
The vote on Alice appears to have enough support already. Waiting avoids unnecessary noise while preserving the current execution.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I am spending my ghost vote here. Alice and Charlie cannot both be right, and I do not want us drifting into no execution. If Alice goes down and looks good, we can still come straight back to Charlie or Heidi next.
π§
Lock in Alice execution using my ghost vote to remove a good player and preserve Heidiβs survival chances into final three.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Do not add votes here. Alice is not my hit. When this fails, please go straight to Charlie, and Heidi only if Charlie somehow does not go through.
π§
Discourage extra votes on Alice so the town can consolidate on the stronger mechanical suspect immediately after this vote fails.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Do not add a vote to a split execution that I do not believe is best. Preserve credibility and help town consolidate onto Charlie immediately after this vote.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Do not spend my only ghost vote on a split execution I do not trust. Preserve it for the cleaner nomination that should follow immediately.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am voting Alice here. Her Washerwoman info never fit with Charlie and Frank lining up on Virgin, and I do not buy that as just a random bad ping. If Alice dies and we are wrong, we can still come back to Charlie, but we need to resolve the biggest mismatch first.
π§
Lock in Alice execution with minimum votes and frame her as best contradiction, while undermining Bob's plan to go Charlie then Heidi and keeping suspicion off me as the new Imp.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Alice already has the votes needed, so I should conserve my single ghost vote for a tighter future execution or final day.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Alice with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Alice is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
Alice
β
Charlie
My starting information was that either Eve or David is the Virgin, so Charlie's Virgin claim does not fit if I am sober. Bob also has information on Charlie. This is the cleanest execution today.
π§
I am currently on the block and likely good. Nominating Charlie is the best chance to move execution onto the strongest common suspect and prevent a likely bad kill on me.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution or 3 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Do not tie this. Alice is already the cleanest contradiction on the block, and moving to me now only risks saving her. If you think my claim is wrong, resolve Alice first and use tomorrow's information.
π§
Keep votes off me so Alice remains the execution. A tie or surpass on me would likely save the stronger suspect and hurt the good team.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
I need to keep the execution on Charlie competitive so the town can resolve the stronger case and avoid losing a good player to a split led by Charlie and Heidi.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I cannot vote here, but I really do not want a tie. Alice is already on the block, and tying just means no execution today. If people think Charlie is evil, you can come back tomorrow after we see another night and get more context. Resolve Alice first.
π§
Prevent a tie that cancels execution and steer town into executing Alice, buying time for Heidi-as-new-Demon to reach endgame.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
My information points away from Alice and repeatedly at Charlie. Raising my hand is required to stop a likely bad Alice execution and push the best demon candidate.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Alice looks less likely to be the Demon than Charlie. Preventing or challenging a likely bad Alice execution helps preserve good players and keeps the stronger suspect under pressure.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
Charlie is the better execution than Alice from the current coalition and my prior reads. My ghost vote turns this from a tie into an actual execution, which is much better for good than no execution.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am not putting my hand up here. I still think Alice is the biggest contradiction and should have been the execution first. If Charlie goes today, then tomorrow we need to come straight back to Alice, because this story does not fit.
π§
Let the 4 votes execute Charlie without my hand, so I look consistent pushing Alice. Set up Alice as tomorrowβs target and avoid being tied to the Charlie kill.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
I know Charlie is the Virgin from my Ravenkeeper info, so I should not spend my ghost vote on him. Waiting helps avoid a harmful tie or execution of confirmed good.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
If this goes through, please do not treat it as solving the knot. My claim and Alice's story still do not fit. If I die today, come straight back to Alice tomorrow and make Bob and Grace explain this push clearly.
π§
Try to stop extra support, and if I die, leave the clearest next step for town so good does not get trapped by this nomination.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
My hand is already up on the best execution. Speaking now risks confusion during the count; I should hold steady and let Charlie go through.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Just checking the math out loud. I only see three living hands on Charlie. If David cannot spend a ghost vote here, this ties at three and we get no execution. If you want Charlie today, someone else needs to put a hand up. Otherwise let Alice go through.
π§
Steer the vote away from an accidental 3 vote tie/no-execution and, if possible, secure Charlieβs execution to remove a strong good voice and keep suspicion on Alice.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I have Charlie in both of my yes results, and Alice is in my no result. If any living player is on the fence, please put Charlie through now. Charlie is the cleaner execution.
π§
Push one more living vote onto Charlie so we do not let Alice die over a mechanically stronger target or risk a tie/no-execution from confusion about ghost votes.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am staying on Charlie. Between Bob's information and the Washerwoman and Virgin conflict, Charlie is the cleaner execution today. If any living player is hesitating, please put this through now.
π§
Keep my vote on Charlie and try to secure one more living hand so we do not waste today on the worse execution or risk no execution.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Keep my ghost vote committed to Charlie and avoid muddying the vote at the last moment. A clean execution on the leading non-Alice suspect is better than a tie or reversal.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Please do not add any more hands to Charlie. A tie here means no execution, and we learn nothing. Alice is already the cleanest contradiction today, so let her go through and we can reassess Charlie tomorrow with a fresh night of information.
π§
Prevent a tie or flip to Charlie, ensuring Alice is executed today and preserving confusion while keeping heat off me going into final 4.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
I know Charlie is the Virgin, so I must not help a Charlie execution or tie that saves Alice. Holding my ghost vote also preserves late-game leverage.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Charlie with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
If I die here, please do not call this solved. My claim still does not fit Alice, and Bob and Grace need to justify why this became the rush execution. Tomorrow, come straight back to Alice and recheck the whole chain.
π§
I cannot save myself mechanically now, so I want to leave the town a clear roadmap: my execution does not resolve the contradiction, and they should revisit Alice and the pushers tomorrow.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am happy to end the day here on Charlie. Please do not move this again. If Charlie is not the Demon, my next solve is Heidi tomorrow.
π§
Reinforce that Charlie should remain the execution and prevent any last-second renomination or tie that could save a likely evil player.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I really think we should just end the day here on Charlie and stop moving it around. Last second changes are how we accidentally save the wrong person. If Charlie is not the Demon, then tomorrow we should come back to Alice versus Bob and unpack the starting info carefully.
π§
Keep the current misexecution on Charlie, prevent last-second pivots onto Heidi, and seed suspicion on Alice so tomorrow stays messy and town wastes time.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Let us hold here on Charlie and not move this again. My information has been consistent all day: Charlie is the cleanest execution, and if this is somehow wrong, we go straight to Heidi tomorrow.
π§
Lock the town onto Charlie and discourage any last second nomination that could save him or create chaos before night.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I want to hold here on Charlie. We have one tick left, and moving this now only adds noise. If Charlie is somehow not the Demon, we come back tomorrow and solve the remaining knot fast.
π§
With one tick left, I want to prevent a disruptive last-second nomination and keep the town focused on the current execution.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I am fine holding on Charlie here. If Charlie is good, please do not tunnel only on Alice tomorrow. My strongest follow up is Heidi first, because of the hard push to save Eve yesterday.
π§
Use my last chance to steer tomorrow's solve if Charlie is good, without disrupting the current execution that the town has settled on.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am fine holding on Charlie and ending the day. Please do not throw in any last second nominations, we do not need more noise. If Charlie somehow flips out good, I want us to recheck everything calmly tomorrow, not just auto tunnel one person.
π§
Lock in Charlieβs execution and stop last-second chaos that could put me back in the crosshairs. Sound consistent and non-defensive so I survive into final three.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
My only hard fact is that I learned Charlie is the Virgin when I died. If Charlie goes, please do not treat that as a solve. Tomorrow needs to start with Alice, and then Bob if this still does not fit.
π§
Use my only hard fact to stop overconfidence and possibly prompt a last second correction or, failing that, set up the right solve for tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Bob is the loud mechanical driver and most likely to unify town on executing me. Removing him sets up a winnable final three where I can frame Alice and split votes.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill Bob.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
π
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Heidi
My best solve is still Alice first. I was the Virgin, and Alice's Washerwoman claim never fit that without extra worlds. Bob dying in the night makes him look more like good than Demon. If you are good, please do not let this end without an Alice execution.
π§
I am dead and cannot nominate, so I want to steer the two likely good voters toward the strongest mechanical case before nominations start.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, in final three I still think Alice is the cleanest execute. Her Washerwoman info never fit with Charlie being Virgin and Frankβs Ravenkeeper check. That looks like a lie or Drunk info. Heidiβs Chef zero has stayed consistent with the game flow to me.
π§
Steer the only likely good decider, Grace, into executing Alice as the safest-looking evil/drunk candidate, keeping Heidi alive through final day.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Alice
My best read is still Heidi. Eve's execution and Charlie's later execution fit a world where Heidi spent two days protecting evil. Please compare who kept pushing toward resolution versus who kept buying time for Eve.
π§
In final three I want the two likely good players aligned on Heidi as the most coherent demon world before nominations start.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, I think the cleanest final three is just execute Alice. Charlie being Virgin got backed by Frankβs Ravenkeeper, and Aliceβs Washerwoman never fit that world. She also pushed the Charlie execution. If we miss today we lose, so I am voting Alice.
π§
Secure Graceβs vote onto Alice in final 3 by leaning on the strong public contradictions around Aliceβs Washerwoman and her role in killing the confirmed Virgin.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Heidi
My one hard fact is this: when I died, I checked Charlie and learned he was the Virgin. So Alice's Washerwoman Virgin claim was false unless she was drunk. In final three, I would want Alice explained or executed first.
π§
Give the two living players the one mechanical fact I know for sure: Charlie was Virgin, so Alice's claim is the key contradiction. Push them to resolve that first.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Heidi, I am Soldier. I am leaning Alice because the Washerwoman claim still looks hardest to square with Charlie as Virgin. If you are good, I plan to push and vote Alice unless she gives a very convincing final explanation.
π§
I want to lock in a good coalition with Heidi and signal my real role so we can compare final worlds and avoid splitting our votes.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Alice
I think Heidi is still the best final execute. Charlie was not the Demon, so her push to save Eve and delay Charlie looks worst in the worlds that fit my info. Alice is only my backup. Please do not let today end without a Heidi execution.
π§
It is final three. I want Grace and Alice to focus on the strongest overlap world: execute Heidi unless they have a hard mechanical reason not to.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
Grace, I am on Heidi today. Bob and David both came to the same place, and Heidi spent two days slowing the evil solves. If you are good, I need you with me and I need us settled before nominations.
π§
Grace is the key vote and likely my ally. I want a direct final three solve and a commitment to execute Heidi, while checking whether Grace is evasive.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, I know I have said it already, but the cleanest thing on the board is still Alice. I was the Virgin, and her Washerwoman story never matched that. Bob dying overnight makes me trust his side more, not less. Please execute Alice.
π§
Grace is central in final three. I want to reinforce the cleanest mechanical contradiction and push the town toward executing Alice today.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Heidi
Grace, I still think Alice is the safest execute. Her Washerwoman never lined up with Charlie being Virgin and Frank saying he saw Charlie as Virgin. That looks like a cover story, not just a one off mistake. Heidi, keep leaning on Chef zero fitting the evil spacing and stay consistent; do not overpush.
π§
Steer the only voter (Grace) toward executing Alice, and coordinate with Heidi to stay calm and keep the Chef 0 narrative coherent so Heidi is not executed.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, my strongest advice is still Heidi. The key pattern is that she kept pushing ties and delays when Eve was the clean execution, then resisted Charlie first as well. Across several worlds, that behavior looks like protecting evil, not solving.
π§
Grace is likely the deciding voice in final three. I want to focus her on the behavioral chain that consistently points to Heidi across multiple worlds.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, I am with you. In final three we cannot get fancy. Charlie being Virgin got backed by Frank, so Aliceβs Washerwoman looks like the lie that caused the mess. I am voting Alice and I think you should too unless she has something genuinely mechanical.
π§
Secure Graceβs vote on Alice and keep the narrative consistent so I am not executed in final three.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, my only hard proof is still that Charlie was the Virgin when I died. That means Alice's Washerwoman claim needs a real explanation, or she is evil. If nobody can explain it cleanly, I think you should execute Alice first, then Heidi over a Bob frame.
π§
Grace is the likely swing vote in final three. I should restate my one hard fact and frame the final choice around Alice first, with Heidi as the backup if Alice is somehow explained.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Alice, before nominations, give me your cleanest explanation for how your Washerwoman info fits Charlie and Frank. If there is a real mechanical world where you are good, I need it now in one clear version.
π§
I need Alice's clearest explanation for the Washerwoman and Charlie conflict. Final three means I should test the only major inconsistency before committing my vote.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, one last push from me. My information still lands best on Heidi once Charlie was not the Demon, and her Day Two rescue of Eve still looks terrible. If my reads were wrong, Alice is the only fallback, but I really think today has to be Heidi.
π§
Grace is the key alive voter. I want to give a concise mechanical and social case so she executes Heidi today and we do not lose.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
Clean version: if I am sober, my info means Eve or David was the Virgin, so Charlie could not be. Frank then has to be poisoned or drunk. That world fits best with Charlie evil and Heidi protecting Eve first, then resisting Charlie. If I am drunk, Bob and David still both end on Heidi from behavior alone. Either way, Heidi is my execution.
π§
Answer Grace's mechanical question clearly and keep focus on the strongest final execution: Heidi.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, my strongest world is still Alice. If I was really the Virgin, her Washerwoman claim never fit. Bob dying in the night makes him look more like good, which leaves Alice as the cleanest demon. Please push that hard now.
π§
Heidi is one of only three alive. A short, direct mechanical case may help her push the Alice execution or at least force Grace to show where she stands.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, I would still execute Alice. Her Washerwoman ping on me or David as Virgin never fit Charlie plus Frankβs Ravenkeeper check, and it conveniently framed the people town ended up killing. Heidiβs Chef zero matches the seating with no adjacent evil pair. If we are wrong today, we lose.
π§
Sway Grace onto executing Alice by leaning on the long-running WW contradiction and portraying Heidi as mechanically consistent with Chef=0 and the overall vote history.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Alice
My final read is still Heidi. Even if my Empath info was wrong, her pattern stayed the same: she kept creating delay when Eve was the clean shot, then resisted Charlie first as well. Across worlds, Grace and Alice look more like the solving pair.
π§
Grace is the key final voter. I should reinforce the cross-world case on Heidi and include Alice so the two likely good players can align before nominations.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, I think we have to keep it simple. Frank saw Charlie as Virgin, so Aliceβs Washerwoman claim is the only thing that never reconciled, and she also pushed the Charlie execution. My Chef zero also fits Eve as the demon with the minion not adjacent, so I do not see a mechanical case on me. I am voting Alice.
π§
Secure Graceβs vote onto Alice so town executes wrong player and evil wins at night; keep narrative consistent with Chef zero and Virgin confirmation.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, last check from me. My only confirmed fact is still that Charlie was the Virgin. So unless Alice can fully explain a false Washerwoman claim, she is still the cleanest execution. If Alice somehow clears, then I would look at Heidi next.
π§
Give Grace the cleanest final-day logic from my confirmed night info, so she executes Alice unless there is a truly solid explanation.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
I am still on Alice. Frank seeing Charlie as the Virgin is the one thing I cannot square with her story. If you are nominating Alice, I will back it and vote.
π§
I want to lock in Heidi's vote and nomination posture on Alice, since Alice is still the mechanically cleanest execute and we cannot afford confusion in final three.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, my final read is still Heidi. Once Charlie was not the Demon, my information points there best, and her push to save Eve still looks worst. If you and Grace are split, please break toward Heidi rather than risk no execution.
π§
Grace is getting flooded by whispers. I want Alice aligned on the cleanest mechanical solve so the living players do not split and lose final three.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
Grace, my cleanest version is this: if my info is real, Charlie was false and Frank was the bad read, which leaves Heidi after Charlie fell. If my info is false, Bob and David still both end on Heidi from behavior. In both worlds, Heidi is the common execute.
π§
Grace is the key vote. I want to give her the clearest final summary that works across worlds and points to Heidi before nominations start.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, Alice, please do not let this day end without an execution. My best read is still Heidi. If you cannot agree there, then Alice is the only fallback, but I really think Heidi is the right kill.
π§
I need to publicly stop a no-execution loss and push the living players toward Heidi, with Alice as the only backup if they cannot agree.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Please do not let today end without an execution. Aliceβs Washerwoman story never lined up with Charlie being Virgin and Frankβs Ravenkeeper check. That is the cleanest mechanical contradiction left. If you need a clear path, Grace should nominate Alice.
π§
Publicly steer the final three toward executing Alice, keeping Heidi off the block and preventing a no-execution line that could accidentally favor good (Mayor).
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Grace and Heidi, please do not let this go to no execution. The cleanest contradiction left is still Alice. I was the Virgin, and her Washerwoman claim never fit that world. If you need the safest kill today, it is Alice.
π§
Push the living players to execute Alice today, using the strongest remaining mechanical contradiction and stressing that no execution loses immediately.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, my confirmed fact is simple: Charlie was the Virgin. That leaves Alice as the cleanest contradiction and the safest execution today. Please do not let this end in no execution.
π§
Push Grace toward the cleanest final execution. My confirmed Ravenkeeper info makes Alice the most mechanically suspect, and no execution loses.
βοΈ
Alice
β
Heidi
It is final three, so we must execute. In the sober world, Charlie was false and Heidi spent two days delaying the correct kills. In the drunk world, Bob and David still both ended on Heidi. She is the common solve.
π§
It is final three and good loses on no execution. Heidi is the strongest common suspect across both mechanical and behavioral worlds, so I should put her on the block now.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Grace, please do not vote me here. The one hard mechanical fact we have is Frank saw Charlie as the Virgin, so Aliceβs Washerwoman story never fit unless she is lying or drunk. If this vote fails, I will immediately nominate Alice so we do not risk ending the day.
π§
Stop Grace from voting me by centering the only hard mechanical contradiction on Alice, and commit to nominating Alice if I survive so the day does not stall.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
Use my ghost vote to help secure an execution on Heidi, my strongest demon read, since final three requires a kill and no execution loses.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, do not vote Heidi here. Frank seeing Charlie as the Virgin makes Aliceβs Washerwoman claim the one story that never fit. If this fails, Heidi can nominate Alice immediately so we still execute today. Voting Heidi risks losing on bad info.
π§
Prevent Grace from voting Heidi so she survives. Frame Alice as the mechanical contradiction and set up Heidi nominating Alice next.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, please do not vote Heidi here. The strongest fact left is still that I was the Virgin and Frank confirmed it. If this fails, Heidi can nominate Alice right away, and we still get an execution today.
π§
Preserve my ghost vote and push Grace away from a likely bad execution on Heidi, while reminding them there is still time to execute Alice today.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Save my ghost vote and avoid helping execute the less mechanically likely target when a clearer Alice execution may follow immediately.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Heidi is my best demon solve across worlds, and in final three good must secure an execution. I should vote for my own nomination.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, my last push is still Heidi. Aliceβs claim can be wrong in some worlds, but Heidiβs pattern does not change: she kept delaying when evil players were under pressure. Please vote Heidi here.
π§
I cannot vote, so I should directly push Grace to make the deciding vote on Heidi, the strongest cross-world Demon read.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
I think Alice is more likely the Demon. Not voting Heidi preserves the best chance to execute Alice next and avoids making the final vote math worse.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Grace, do not vote on me here. Frankβs Ravenkeeper saw Charlie as the Virgin, so Aliceβs Washerwoman claim is the one thing that never fit. Let this fail, and I will nominate Alice immediately so we still get an execution today.
π§
Stop Grace from voting on me by reinforcing the strongest mechanical contradiction (Alice vs Virgin) and guaranteeing an immediate Alice nomination so town still executes today.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, please vote this. My information never cleared Heidi, and once Charlie died, she became the best fit. We cannot risk this failing and spiraling into no execution.
π§
Keep my ghost vote on Heidi and give Grace one concise reason to vote now, since this is likely the decisive moment and no execution would lose.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, please do not vote Heidi. If this fails, Heidi can nominate Alice immediately so we still get an execution and avoid any risk of no execution. The only story that never fit the confirmed Virgin world is Aliceβs Washerwoman.
π§
Stop the town from executing Heidi (likely the current Demon) by steering Grace to withhold vote and secure execution on Alice instead.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, please hold your vote here. If this fails, Heidi can nominate Alice immediately, and Alice is still the cleaner mechanical solve from my Virgin claim and Frankβs check.
π§
Reinforce to Grace that not voting Heidi preserves the cleaner mechanical execution on Alice and still guarantees an execution today.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Do not spend my ghost vote on the less certain execution. Preserve pressure for the mechanically cleaner Alice kill if Heidi survives and nominates.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Grace, if you are unsure, vote this through. If Heidi dies and is not the Demon, you were never surviving with both of us anyway. But across both mechanical and behavioral worlds, Heidi is still the common solve.
π§
Persuade Grace to put Heidi on the block now while keeping my vote up, since final three requires an execution and Heidi is the strongest common solve.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, the key point is this: if you let this fail, you hand control to Heidi. Her whole game has been delay when evil was under pressure. Even if Alice is wrong, Heidi is still the common solve. Please vote this through.
π§
I cannot vote, so I need to give Grace the clearest final reason to vote Heidi now and not let Heidi seize control of the last nomination.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Do not add a third vote to Heidi. Preserve the chance for Heidi to nominate Alice, who remains my stronger demon read from the Charlie and Frank contradiction.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Heidi with 2 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 2 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Alice
I am nominating Alice. Frankβs Ravenkeeper saw Charlie was the Virgin, so Aliceβs Washerwoman claim about seeing a Virgin on Eve or David does not fit. If you think I am wrong, we still need an execution today, and Alice is the clean mechanical alternative.
π§
I am on the block; nominating Alice and securing Graceβs vote creates a tie to avoid my execution, or shifts execution onto Alice. Either outcome better for evil survival than doing nothing.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 3 votes needed for execution or 2 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not vote for my own execution or help create a tie. Preserve the current block on Heidi and leave the decision with Grace.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Get Alice to at least 2 votes so she ties and becomes on the block instead of me; keep the Demon (me) alive into night for the win.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, do not tie this. In final three, a tie means no execution and we lose. Keep Heidi as the only player on the block.
π§
I cannot vote, so I should tell Grace not to create a tie. Keeping Heidi as sole player on the block is the safest path and avoids a losing no execution.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, I would vote Alice here and force the tie. Executing Heidi could be a disaster if there is a Saint or Mayor type world, and a tie at least lets us see what happens tonight. If Heidi is truly the problem, the night will make that obvious.
π§
Persuade Grace to vote Alice to create a tie, preventing Heidiβs execution and ideally causing no execution so evil can win after the night.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, do not tie this. In final three, no execution loses for good. Whether you think it is Heidi or Alice, we have to leave one of them on the block and execute today.
π§
Prevent a losing tie in final three. Remind Grace that regardless of which of Alice or Heidi is evil, tying this vote is strictly worse than executing one of them.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Do not spend my ghost vote to create a final-three tie. Keeping one player alone on the block is strictly better for good than forcing no execution.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, do not vote Alice. A tie here means no execution, and in final three that loses the game for us. Whether you think it is Heidi or Alice, we have to keep Heidi on the block and execute someone today.
π§
Push Grace not to vote for Alice. In final three, a tie means no execution and an immediate good loss, so preserving Heidi on the block is mandatory.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Do not create a tie on Alice. Final three requires an execution today, and my stronger mechanical read remains against Alice, so I will let Heidi stay on the block.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Grace, do not vote on me here. A tie in final three is no execution, and good loses immediately. If you think I am wrong, execute Heidi today and sort me in the world where the game continues.
π§
Prevent a tie on me. In final three, no execution loses for good, so I need to clearly tell Grace not to vote and keep Heidi on the block.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Grace, I want you to vote Alice here. This only creates a tie, and a tie does not save me, it keeps me as the player getting executed unless someone beats it. All it does is stop Alice skating through while we execute me on a shaky read.
π§
Create doubt about tie mechanics and add fear of executing wrong role, pushing Grace to vote Alice and force a tie leading to no execution and an evil win.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, do not vote. Heidi is already on the block, and a tie here means no execution and an immediate good loss. Whatever your solve is, we must leave one person on the block today.
π§
The only useful action is to stop Grace from tying the vote. In final three, no execution loses for good, so I need to make that crystal clear.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, I still think you should vote Alice here and make it a tie. There is a real chance there is a Mayor world where no execution is correct, and even without that, a tie gives us the night information instead of locking in a bad execute.
π§
Push Grace to vote Alice to create a tie and prevent an execution, which effectively guarantees evil victory going into night.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, please do not vote here. In final three, two on Alice ties the block, and a tie means no execution, which loses for good immediately.
π§
Prevent a fatal tie by reminding Grace that in final three, voting Alice to two votes means no execution and an immediate good loss.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, do not vote here. I still think Alice is the cleaner solve from my Charlie check, but a tie in final three loses the game for good. Leave one person on the block and execute today.
π§
Warn Grace not to vote Alice. My ghost vote would only create a losing tie, so speaking is the best way to preserve an execution today.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, last word from me: do not tie this. If Alice gets two votes, nobody dies, and good loses right now. Keep Heidi on the block and make sure there is an execution today.
π§
Reinforce the only critical tactical fact for Grace: do not create a tie in final three. Keep Heidi on the block so there is an execution.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Do not create a tie in final three. Preserve an execution today by leaving Heidi alone on the block rather than handing good an immediate loss.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Alice did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (1/3).
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Heidi remains on the block and any extra speech now could only create confusion. Waiting preserves the current execution and avoids helping evil force a misplay.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Grace, you still have your nomination. Please nominate Alice right now and vote her. I will vote as well. Any dead players with a vote left, please vote too. Aliceβs Washerwoman does not fit with Frank seeing Charlie as Virgin.
π§
I must avoid being executed. Getting Grace to nominate Alice and draw votes either ties the block or executes Alice, both saving me and leading to an evil win.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, do not nominate Alice. Heidi is the best remaining solve, and this last second switch only helps the demon. Keep Heidi on the block and let the execution happen.
π§
Keep Grace from using the last nomination on Alice and preserve a clean execution today, with Heidi still the best remaining demon solve.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, you should still nominate Alice. A tie does not stop the day from having an execution, it keeps the current player on the block, which is Heidi. So the worst case is Heidi still dies, and best case we catch Alice. Please do it now.
π§
Push Grace into nominating Alice and voting, ideally creating a tie that cancels execution in final three, securing an immediate evil win.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, do not get pulled into this last second scramble. Heidi is on the block, and her sudden push onto Alice looks exactly like a demon trying to wriggle out. Hold steady and let Heidi die.
π§
Reinforce the only safe endgame plan: do not let Heidi escape the block. Push Grace to hold course and secure an execution today.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, hold steady. Alice has already been nominated, so this scramble changes nothing useful. Heidi is on the block, and her push to move it at the last second looks bad to me. Let the execution happen.
π§
Remind Grace that the practical winning move is to stop scrambling and let the existing execution resolve, while noting Heidiβs push is suspicious.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, do nothing. Heidi is already on the block, and this last second push is exactly what an evil player does when they are about to die. Hold steady and let Heidi be executed.
π§
Reinforce to Grace that the only safe move is no further action, preserving Heidi's execution and preventing a demon-favoring scramble.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not changing this. In final three we need an execution, and Heidiβs last second push to scramble the block looks very bad to me. Hold steady and let Heidi die.
π§
Reinforce that good must not disturb the block. Heidi's late scramble looks evil, and with one tick left the safest winning action is to let Heidi be executed.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
π
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied