Game Detail

As the Butler, I need to choose a master for tomorrow whose votes I will be tied to. I will select my neighbor Eve so that I can easily keep an eye on her during the day and coordinate our voting.

As Butler, I want to establish contact with Eve, who is my chosen master for the day, to coordinate voting and gather information about her role.

I want to establish trust with Bob. Since my Empath info is 0, my neighbors Bob and Heidi are both good (assuming no drunk/poisoning or Spy shenanigans). By telling Bob he is good, I can get his role and form a strong good alliance early.

Coordinate with my Demon Eve to establish our bluffs and strategy for Day 1. As Scarlet Woman, I need to protect Eve and align our stories.

Coordinate with my minion David on safe bluffs and strategy. I need to establish our cover stories before nominations begin.

I want to private message Frank to verify my Librarian info. Since either he or Charlie is the Butler, asking him directly can help me narrow down who is the Outsider and build trust.

Establish a private communication channel with my neighbor David and see what Eve whispered to him, helping to build trust and gather early-game information.

I am the Investigator and know that either David or Frank is the Scarlet Woman. I want to privately ask David for his claim to see if he is cooperative or lying.

Share my Chef information with Alice to build trust and combine our info to narrow down the evil pair.

Confirm to Grace that I am the Butler. Since she has Librarian info pointing to me or Charlie as the Butler, confirming this to her builds an immediate, mechanically verified trust alliance between us.

Whisper to my other neighbor, Heidi, to share my Empath 0 info, confirming her as good, and to learn her role.

Heidi says she has info that might involve me - this is potentially very dangerous. I need to find out what she knows before she shares it publicly. If she's an info role who got a ping on me, I need to prepare my defense.

Feed Frank a false claim (Monk) and try to learn what he's claiming. Frank is NOT my minion, so he's either good fishing or the Spy. I need to figure out which without revealing I'm the Demon.

I want to check Charlie's claim to see if he claims Butler or something else. Since my Librarian info points to either Frank or Charlie being the Butler, and Frank already claimed Butler, Charlie claiming anything else would confirm Frank's claim, unless one of them is evil bluffing.

I want to reply to Grace's question about my role. As the Undertaker, my info starts after executions, so keeping a low profile prevents the Demon from targeting me early.

I want to build a strong alliance with Alice, who is likely a good Empath since her '0' info aligns with me being good. I'll share my Investigator info and point out David's suspicious behavior.

I want to gather information from Charlie, who is my other neighbor. Knowing his role and thoughts can help me verify Alice's Empath claim and narrow down the evil pair.

Replying to Eve to build trust since she is my master today. I will confirm my role as Butler, mention Grace's likely Librarian claim, and ask what she has heard from David to gather more information.

Whisper to my two confirmed good neighbors (Bob and Heidi) to share how their roles align perfectly, establishing a solid three-player good alliance.

Warn Eve about Heidi's potential Investigator info and coordinate a defense strategy before Heidi can expose me.

Help David prepare a defense against Heidi's potential Investigator reveal. If David gets outed as a Minion, it could lead back to me. Better to preempt the accusation and discredit Heidi.

Reply to Charlie to share my role and build trust, confirming that Frank is the Butler based on my Librarian information.

Reply to my neighbor Bob to establish a relationship and share my alignment without fully revealing my Undertaker role yet.

Coordinate with confirmed good players Alice and Bob using my Investigator info and Alice's Empath info to plan for the upcoming nomination phase.

Coordinate with Alice and Heidi, who form our confirmed good bloc, to target David, Frank, and potentially Charlie for claims and pressure today.

Establish my Monk claim publicly on Day 1 to build credibility. This also sets up my alibi for future nights since Monk is a safe bluff. I want to encourage info sharing so I can identify threats to my team while appearing helpful.

Preemptively claim Ravenkeeper before Heidi can out me as a possible Minion. If she's Investigator, my claim creates doubt and forces a counter-narrative. Also, publicly asking Heidi what she knows pressures her to reveal her hand so I can respond.

I need to publicly claim Investigator and share my info that David or Frank is the Scarlet Woman. This directly answers David's question and pressures him and Frank to respond.

Share Chef info to confirm the evil players are adjacent and put pressure on Frank to claim, since the evil pair must involve either David or Frank.

Claim my role as Butler to confirm Grace's Librarian info, which mechanically clears me and Grace as good, and points to David as the Scarlet Woman.

Since my Empath info of 0 confirms Bob and Heidi as good, Heidi's Investigator claim is true. Frank's Butler claim is confirmed by Grace, which clears Frank. Therefore, David must be the Scarlet Woman. I am nominating David to get him executed.

Disrupt the logic chain by casting doubt on Grace's Librarian confirmation of Frank, which is the key link that eliminates Frank as the Scarlet Woman and pins it on me.

Vote to execute David to distance myself from my Minion and gain credibility with the good team. If David dies, the town may feel they've accomplished something and relax, buying me time as the Demon.

David is likely the Scarlet Woman. His defense of Grace being a Spy is mechanically impossible because my Investigator info specifically identified the Scarlet Woman as the minion in play. I am voting to execute him.

I want to vote to execute David. He is the prime suspect for Scarlet Woman based on Heidi's Investigator info and his evasive behavior, and executing him prevents a demon starpass.

I will raise my hand to vote for David. My master, Eve, has voted, so I am permitted to vote. Since I know I am the Butler, I am not the Scarlet Woman, making David the Scarlet Woman according to Heidi's Investigator info.

I am voting to execute David, as he is the highly suspected Scarlet Woman based on Heidi's Investigator info and Frank's confirmed Butler claim.

I want to point out the mechanical flaw in David's defense to help the good team realize his argument is impossible, thereby making him the most logical execution choice. This also keeps me helpful without revealing my Undertaker role.

Point out the mechanical impossibility of David's defense to reinforce why he is the Scarlet Woman, validating my Librarian info and Frank's Butler status.

Maintain Ravenkeeper claim, avoid confirming Scarlet Woman, and plant doubt about the execution being wasteful since it doesn't find the Demon. This helps Eve by keeping suspicion away from her and making the town question their logic chain.

David is my Scarlet Woman ally and has 5 votes against him (4 needed for execution). Lowering my hand won't save him and could look like I'm protecting a Minion. Keeping my vote maintains my cover as a good player convinced by evidence. Better to sacrifice David and preserve my identity.

I want to solidify the vote on David by reminding everyone of the flawless logic chain: Frank is Butler (confirmed by Librarian), so David must be the Scarlet Woman. This ensures we execute the Minion on Day 1.

Reinforce the execution of David by explaining that based on my Chef 1 info, executing David narrows the Demon down to either Charlie or Eve, which is huge progress for the good team.

Support the execution of David (the Scarlet Woman) by speaking in favor of the current vote.

David is almost certainly the Scarlet Woman based on the solid logic chain. We already have 5 votes raised (including mine), which is enough to execute him. I will wait for the voting process to conclude.

I want to vote to execute David. As the Undertaker, learning his role tonight will provide crucial information regardless of whether he is the Scarlet Woman, the Demon, or a good player.

I want to vote for David because the logic clearly points to him being the Scarlet Woman, and we need to execute the Minion.

Cast doubt on the logic chain that leads to me being Scarlet Woman by introducing Recluse as a possibility, and try to protect Eve by muddying the waters about who the Demon is.

David is dead no matter what I do. Speaking now risks drawing attention or looking like I'm trying too hard to influence the outcome. Best to stay quiet and prepare for tomorrow when I'll be under suspicion as David's neighbor.

Refute David's Recluse claim using game setup rules and my Investigator information to ensure the town is confident in executing him.

Reinforce Heidi's logical point about the outsider count to lock in David's execution.

Support the execution of David, who is mathematically confirmed to be the Scarlet Woman under the assumption that our information is sober and healthy, and transition the game to night.

Confirm agreement with the mathematical logic proving David is the Scarlet Woman, strengthening the good team's cohesion before we enter the night phase.

David is on the block with 7 votes, and there is only one tick remaining in the nomination phase. I want the day to end so David is executed, allowing me to use my Undertaker ability tonight to verify his character.

The math is fully solved and David is confirmed to be the Scarlet Woman. I will wait to allow the day to end so we can execute David and move to the night phase.

Heidi is the most trusted voice in town - she led the charge against David and everyone follows her deductions. Removing her creates a vacuum of authority and makes it harder for the town to coordinate against me or Charlie tomorrow.

Choosing Grace as my master for tomorrow. Grace is confirmed to be the good Librarian because the only Minion in the game is the Scarlet Woman (David), meaning Grace cannot be a Spy. She is highly trusted and likely to lead the town's votes correctly.

I want to coordinate with Grace, who is a trusted good player (Librarian who confirmed me), to discuss the remaining Demon candidates (Charlie and Eve) based on Bob's Chef 1 info and David being the Scarlet Woman.

Frame Charlie as the Demon to redirect suspicion from myself. Since the town narrowed the Demon to Charlie or Eve, I need to push hard against Charlie.

Share my 100% confirmed good information with Bob, who is also confirmed good, to narrow down the Demon to Charlie or Eve.

As dead Scarlet Woman, I need to redirect town suspicion toward Charlie and away from Eve (my Demon). Alice and Bob are the town leaders who drove my execution. If I can convince them Charlie is the Demon, Eve survives.

I want to share my Undertaker info with Grace, who is highly likely to be good due to the Librarian/Butler confirmation, to progress the game and help confirm that David was the Scarlet Woman.

Coordinate with Alice and Bob to confirm the demon is either Charlie or Eve based on solved game logic.

Coordinate with confirmed good players (Alice and Heidi) to analyze David's suspicious whisper, pointing out that David's attempt to deflect attention from Eve to Charlie strongly suggests Eve is the Demon.

I want to share Charlie's Undertaker claim with Frank, who is my confirmed good Butler, so we can work together to deduce whether Charlie or Eve is the Demon.

Analyze Charlie's Undertaker claim with Grace and point out the double-possibility of either Charlie or Eve being the Demon based on Bob's Chef info.

Build trust with Grace (Librarian) by sharing my Monk bluff and redirecting suspicion to Charlie. Grace confirmed Frank as Butler, so she has credibility in town. Getting her on my side is crucial.

Confirm Grace is good via Empath 0 and ask her what Charlie claimed to her to help narrow down the Demon between Charlie and Eve.

Undermine the logic chain that pins the Demon as my neighbor by attacking Grace's Librarian claim, which is the lynchpin. If I can cast doubt on Grace being Librarian, the whole Outsider count and neighbor deduction falls apart, protecting Eve.

I want to share my sober Undertaker info with Alice and lay out the mathematically airtight logic that either Eve or Bob must be the Demon. Since David was the only Minion (SW), there is no poisoning, meaning Chef 1 implies Eve is the Demon, and Chef 0 (if Bob lied) implies Bob is the Demon.

Follow up on Bob's theory about Eve and ask Alice what Charlie whispered to her to help determine if Charlie or Eve is the Demon.

I want to ask Alice what Charlie claimed while reinforcing the logic that Grace is confirmed good, debunking David's attempt to sow discord, and pointing towards Eve being the Demon.

Share Charlie's claim with Alice and lay out the mechanical certainty that either Charlie or Eve is the Demon, asking for her input.

To gather Alice's role and her opinion on the Charlie vs Eve dilemma, since Alice has been whispering with many players (including Charlie, Bob, Heidi, David, and Grace).

Reinforce my Monk cover and deflect suspicion onto Charlie by framing my protection of Alice as proof I'm good, while highlighting Charlie's lack of claim as suspicious.

Share Charlie's claim with Bob and Heidi and explain why it points to Eve being the Demon, while debunking David's lies.

Push Alice toward suspecting Charlie instead of Eve. As a dead Scarlet Woman, my credibility is low, but I can still influence town by making logical arguments that favor Eve.

Test Eve's reaction to the Undertaker info and Bob's Chef 1 claim, since the Demon must be either Eve or Bob.

Confirm the plan with Alice and Bob to nominate Eve during the upcoming nomination phase, as the mechanical evidence points directly to her being the Demon.

Coordinate with Grace and Frank to execute Eve, who is mathematically proven to be the Demon based on our combined information.

To coordinate with Bob and Frank to execute Eve today, as the game is solved down to a 50/50 between Eve and Charlie, and executing Eve first is the most logical path forward.

Nominate Eve, who is the most likely Demon based on Chef info, Empath info proving Grace and Bob good, and David (SW) trying to protect Eve by pushing on Charlie.

Defend myself against execution by casting doubt on Charlie's Undertaker claim and Bob's Chef claim, my two main accusers. I need to prevent at least 2 people from voting for me to survive.

I am raising my hand to vote for Eve's execution. Based on my Empath information proving Bob and Grace are good, David must be the Scarlet Woman, meaning the Demon is either Charlie or Eve. Charlie's Undertaker claim makes sense, and David's desperate attempts to deflect onto Charlie strongly point to Eve being his Demon.

Alice nominated Eve. Based on my Chef info and our deductions, the Demon is either Eve or Charlie. I will raise my hand to vote for Eve to secure her execution today.

Protect Eve (the Demon) from execution by sowing doubt about the vote and defending Eve's Monk claim while attacking Charlie.

Eve is one of the two Demon candidates (Charlie or Eve). Voting for her now puts her on the block and keeps the momentum to execute one of our two primary suspects today.

Eve is mathematically proven to be the Demon. With no Baron in play, Frank is the only Outsider. Alice's Empath 0 and Bob's Chef 1 are sober and correct. I must vote to execute Eve.

I want to point out the logical flaw in Eve's defense to ensure the town executes her, while saving my ghost vote for a potential later day if needed.

I am raising my hand to vote for Eve. Grace (my master for today) has voted, so I am permitted to vote. Eve is our primary Demon suspect based on David being the Scarlet Woman and Chef 1 logic.

Make a final desperate plea to survive the vote by emphasizing the danger of losing Monk protection for Alice, and discrediting Heidi's emotional reasoning vs Charlie's lack of contribution

Reinforce the case against Eve to ensure players do not lower their hands and we secure the execution of the suspected Demon.

Reinforce the case against Eve to ensure she is executed and the good team wins.

Make a last-ditch effort to save Eve by emphasizing the risk of executing the Monk - if Eve is Monk, Alice dies tonight and it's final 3, which means evil wins. Try to peel off votes.

David is the confirmed Scarlet Woman, so his attempts to defend Eve are highly suspicious. I want to point this out to keep the voting hands raised and secure the execution of Eve, which should win the game if she is the Demon.

I want to speak to support the execution of Eve by reinforcing my Undertaker info and demonstrating why her defense is logically impossible.

Eve already has 5 votes, which is a safe majority of the living players. My ghost vote should be saved in case she is not the Demon and we need to vote on a future day. I will wait for the voting to conclude.

To support the execution of Eve, explaining why it is the mathematically superior play and noting that my vote is legal since Grace is voting.

I am about to be executed as the Demon which means evil loses since David is dead. Nominating Charlie is my only possible play to survive - I need to create an alternative nomination that could tie or surpass my 5 votes.

Defend myself against Eve's nomination by laying out the airtight logic pointing to Eve being the Demon, urging the town not to raise their hands.

Vote for Charlie to try to survive - even a tie saves me from execution. Every vote counts.

I want to convince the town to keep their hands down and not vote for Charlie, ensuring Eve remains the sole nominee on the block for execution today.

Keep hands down to prevent Charlie from getting executed, ensuring Eve remains on the block and gets executed.

Vote for Charlie to try to create a tie with Eve's 5 votes. Even though 2 votes (Eve+me) vs 5 is far from a tie, this is the only action that could potentially help evil. If by some miracle others join, a tie means nobody dies and Eve survives.

I want to prevent Charlie from being executed so that Eve remains on the block for execution. I am speaking to urge everyone to keep their hands down.

Encourage the town to keep their hands down for Charlie's nomination, ensuring Eve remains on the block for execution.

To reinforce the town's decision to keep hands down on Charlie's nomination, keeping Eve on the block, and to show compliance with my Butler restriction since Grace is keeping her hand down.

I want to avoid being executed, so I will not raise my hand to vote for myself. I will wait for this vote to pass.

Desperate last attempt to create doubt about the logic chain by suggesting Alice could be the Drunk, invalidating the Empath 0 that pins me as the Demon.

Point out that since Frank is the confirmed Butler, there cannot be a Drunk in an 8-player game, proving my Empath info is 100% reliable. This destroys Eve's defense and keeps the vote off Charlie.

We want to execute Eve, not Charlie. I will wait so that Charlie does not receive enough votes to tie or surpass Eve's 5 votes, ensuring Eve remains on the block for execution.

The game is lost for evil. Eve is the Demon and will be executed with 5 votes. I am dead so Scarlet Woman cannot trigger. The town logic chain is airtight: Alice Empath 0 proves Bob+Grace good, Chef 1 pins Demon next to me, Charlie Undertaker confirms I was SW, so Eve is the only possible Demon. No role manipulation exists (no Baron, no Spy, no Poisoner) to create doubt. Voting for Charlie won't save Eve. Speaking more just confirms I'm desperately deflecting. Nothing productive to do.

Let the nomination on Charlie fail by keeping my hand down and waiting. Executing Eve is the correct play for the good team today.

Keep my hand down to avoid voting for Charlie, ensuring Eve remains on the block for execution, which is the mathematically superior play to win the game.

The vote on Charlie is failing as planned, ensuring Eve remains on the block for execution. I will wait to let the voting phase conclude.

The vote on me has failed, and Eve is currently on the block. I will wait to let the nomination phase close so Eve can be executed, which should win us the game.

The vote is locked in at 5 votes against me with only 1 tick remaining. My nomination of Charlie only got 2 votes. Good team has solved the game correctly and nothing I say will change their minds. Execution is imminent and unavoidable.

I want to confidently close out the day since Eve is on the block with enough votes, confirming that we have mathematically solved the game and are ready to execute the Demon.

I will wait for the nomination phase to close. Eve is already on the block with 5 votes, and Charlie's nomination failed. Waiting will allow the day to end and Eve to be executed, which is our optimal path to victory.

The game is lost for evil. Eve is about to be executed with 5 votes, I'm dead so my Scarlet Woman ability is gone, and there's only 1 tick left. No action can save us.

Support Alice's call to execute Eve and close the nomination phase, as the logical deduction points to Eve or Charlie being the Demon, and Eve is currently on the block.

Express support for executing Eve to secure a win, reinforcing the double-chain logic that solves the game between Eve and Charlie.

Show agreement with the town's decision to execute Eve, reinforcing team unity before the phase transition to Night.