Game Detail

I am choosing Bob as my master for the first day to establish my Butler restriction, as he is my immediate neighbor and easy to observe.

Coordinate privately with my Demon early so our bluffs align and I can protect her without looking obvious.

Establish a private connection with my neighbor David on Day 1 to gather starting info and build trust.

Initiate private contact with my neighbor Heidi to gather information and build trust early on, while keeping my own role hidden.

Respond to Charlie's private message to establish trust and share my '0' Chef info without explicitly claiming Chef yet, to see if he'll share his info.

Respond to Grace's whisper to probe her role. Since she is one of my two Investigator targets (Bob or Grace is the Scarlet Woman), her response will help me determine if she is good (which makes Bob the Minion) or evil.

Initiate a private conversation with my neighbor Grace to gather information, build trust, and potentially set up a Virgin test.

Coordinate complementary bluffs with Bob now so we avoid conflicts, create flexible worlds, and keep me unsuspicious as the Demon.

To establish contact with Bob, who is my designated voting master, and gather his claim or any initial information he might have.

Build credibility with Alice using a plausible starting-info bluff and encourage her to reveal useful information while keeping heat away from Eve.

Respond to David's whisper, confirming his likely Chef role while revealing my Soldier role privately and asking him to keep it secret to bait the Demon.

To reply to Heidi's query. Since she has starting info involving me or Bob, sharing my true role (Mayor) allows her to verify me if she is the Washerwoman, or narrow down her search if she is an Investigator/Librarian.

Confirming Charlie's guess of Chef 0 privately and agreeing to keep his Soldier claim secret to build a strong alliance with my neighbor.

Grace claimed Mayor, so I am sharing my Investigator info (which points to her or Bob being the Scarlet Woman) to see her reaction and establish trust if she is indeed good.

I want to reach out to my other neighbor, Eve, to see if she has a Townsfolk role and is willing to nominate me to trigger my Virgin ability, which will mechanically confirm both of us.

Probe Frank without committing to a Virgin test. Preserve my Undertaker bluff, gather role info, and avoid a public interaction that could mechanically catch me.

Inform Bob that I am the Butler and chose him as master, which confirms a Baron is in play if his Librarian info is true.

I want to keep my Librarian bluff credible, avoid confirming a false Baron world, and gently encourage Alice to reveal more while preserving future suspicion on her if needed.

Establish contact with my other neighbor, Bob, to gather information and cross-reference with David's Chef 0 claim later.

Frank asked if Heidi shared anything. To build trust and gather information, I will share Heidi's investigator claim pointing to Bob and ask Frank for his role.

I want to gather information from my other neighbor, Eve, to see if they are willing to share their role or info, and to build trust.

I want to gather information about Bob from Alice, since Alice has been whispering with Bob a lot. Since my Investigator info points to Bob or Grace being the Scarlet Woman, and Grace claims Mayor, Bob is my prime suspect for Scarlet Woman. Asking Alice about him might reveal his bluff.

I want to reveal my Virgin role to my neighbors Grace and Eve, who have both claimed or soft-claimed Townsfolk, and propose a Virgin test to confirm our alignments.

Decline the Virgin test without looking evasive, keep my Townsfolk bluff intact, and encourage a slower day one that gives evil more room.

To find out what Heidi's starting information is regarding Bob, as she is one of the players Bob claimed could be the Saint.

I want to open up public discussion during the nomination phase to see if anyone has info to share or if we should put someone on the block to get information before the day ends.

I want to look helpful and cautious, steer town away from strong mechanical clears today, and encourage vague info sharing without creating a concrete trail onto me or Bob.

I want to contribute to the discussion in a non-threatening way, agreeing with Eve about not rushing, while also gently nudging the group to share soft information that might help us verify Bob's Librarian claim or Heidi's potential info.

Reveal my Investigator information to the town to force Bob to claim and help find the Scarlet Woman.

To confirm my Mayor claim and validate Heidi's Investigator info, putting the spotlight on Bob to see what he claims.

I am publicly claiming Virgin to invite a Townsfolk (specifically targeting Heidi who has already used her info) to nominate me, which will mechanically confirm both of us and validate her information.

Counter Heidi's push with a coherent public claim, create doubt on her info, and make a fast execution on me look reckless.

To address the conflict between Heidi and Bob's claims and suggest using Frank's Virgin claim to verify one of them mechanically.

Heidi is the biggest immediate threat to Bob and can combine with Frank for a strong confirmation chain tomorrow. Killing her maximizes confusion and protects our evil team.

I am choosing Frank as my master for tomorrow. Frank is the claimed Virgin and is highly likely to be good, especially since Heidi is dead (presumably from nominating him). This is safer than choosing Bob, who is mathematically implicated as evil.

To share my Investigator info and dead status with Frank (who claimed Virgin) to build trust and coordinate an attack on Bob, who seems to be the lying Scarlet Woman.

Ask Frank (my master today and Virgin claimant) what the dead Investigator Heidi whispered to him, and let him know I am the Butler and following his votes today.

Coordinate with Eve on today's line before public claims harden, and avoid an uncontested push onto me while preserving cover for the Demon.

Whisper to Frank to share my deduction that Bob is the Scarlet Woman now that Heidi's death suggests her Investigator info was genuine, and I know I am the Mayor.

I want to share my Chef 0 info with Charlie (who claimed Soldier) to see his thoughts on Bob, who was accused by the now-deceased Heidi. Sharing information privately builds trust and helps us align our views.

Share the mechanical deduction with Alice (Butler claim) to prove Bob is lying and is the Scarlet Woman, gaining her trust and vote alignment.

Coordinate with Bob so our stories do not clash. I want light distance publicly while preserving options to frame Grace or discredit Heidi's dead info.

Respond to David's whisper to build trust and discuss the implications of Heidi's death on the alignment of Bob and Grace.

I want to test Grace's reaction and coordinate with her. If she is the Mayor, she will agree that Bob is the Scarlet Woman and must be executed. If she is the Scarlet Woman, she will be put in a difficult position where she has to pretend to go along with executing her Minion/Demon partner or find an excuse to pivot.

Coordinate with Frank (my master today) to confirm the plan to push on Bob, who is heavily implicated by the Investigator's info and the Outsider count contradiction.

Keep Alice trusting my Librarian bluff, nudge her toward Grace as Saint, and discourage any push that leads to a dangerous Virgin test on me.

Coordinate with Heidi and Frank to target Bob today. Since Heidi's night death heavily implies her Investigator info is true, Bob's Librarian claim must be a lie, making him the Scarlet Woman.

Share mechanical deduction with Charlie to build trust and narrow down the Demon suspects based on the Chef 0 info and Heidi's Investigator ping.

Confirm agreement with Grace and Heidi to target Bob (the Scarlet Woman) for execution today based on the logical contradictions in his claim and Heidi's Investigator info.

Use Alice's cautious style to spread doubt about Heidi's information and keep pressure off Bob while sounding reasonable and cooperative.

Coordinate with David on our next steps, analyzing the options of testing Frank's Virgin claim versus executing Bob, while validating David's logical deduction about my safety.

To align Alice (the Butler) with our plan to execute Bob, who is almost certainly the Scarlet Woman based on my Investigator info and Grace's Mayor claim.

Confirm to Heidi (the dead Investigator) that Frank is my master, which means I am mathematically free to vote on Bob with Frank and Grace.

Nudge Frank away from any quick Virgin test and toward treating Heidi and Grace as messy, preserving space for Eve and me.

Confirm Alice's alignment and claim, and secure her vote to execute Bob today since he is mechanical confirmed evil.

Respond to Charlie's whisper to coordinate our strategy for the upcoming nomination phase, suggesting we execute Bob today because his claim is contradicted by Heidi's death.

Challenge Bob's claim by showing how his claim of Grace being the Saint contradicts Alice's Butler claim and Heidi's Investigator info, forcing him to explain the contradiction.

I want Frank cautious and open to ambiguity, so he does not drive a clean solve onto Bob too fast or trigger a dangerous Virgin test that hurts evil.

Coordinate with Grace to execute Bob today, since she knows Bob is the Scarlet Woman based on Heidi's Investigator info and her own Mayor role.

To execute the confirmed Minion, Bob, based on the dead Investigator's info and his conflicting claims.

I want to stop votes on me by framing this as a convenient claim clash and redirect town away from an easy misexecution that protects the Demon.

Bob is the Scarlet Woman based on dead Investigator Heidi's info. I nominated Bob, and I must raise my hand to vote for him to secure his execution.

Do not help execute Bob. Preserve my minion and let the vote fail if possible while keeping my own hands clean.

I want to encourage the living players to vote for Bob so that I can save my single ghost vote for the final day, in line with optimal good team play.

I want to publicly declare my voting constraint as Butler so that the town (especially Frank, my master) knows I will vote to execute Bob if and only if Frank votes. This helps build trust and coordinates the vote.

I want to execute Bob because Heidi's Investigator info pointing to him as the Scarlet Woman is highly reliable given her death, and Bob's Librarian claim contradicts her role. Voting for him helps us secure the execution.

I want to execute Bob because Heidi's death confirms her Investigator information that either Bob or Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Since Bob's Librarian claim is highly contradictory, Bob is likely the Scarlet Woman. I will raise my hand to vote for his execution.

I am raising my hand to vote for Bob. Since Alice is the Butler and has chosen me as her master, my vote will also allow her to vote, securing the necessary votes to execute Bob, who is highly suspicious due to the role and outsider count contradictions.

I want to create doubt in the mechanical case on me so fewer players commit, and to seed suspicion on Grace and the outsider-count chain for tomorrow if I die.

Address Bob's defense by pointing out the mechanical impossibility of his Librarian claim given the outsider count and the confirmed Minion. This ensures the town stays committed to executing him.

Protect Bob without openly hard-defending him, and encourage town to avoid locking on the easiest narrative from Heidi's death.

Bob already has 4 votes, which is the required majority. Since I am dead, I must save my single ghost vote for the final day. I will wait and let the vote conclude.

Frank (my master) has voted, so I am permitted to vote. Bob's claim is mechanically impossible alongside my Butler role and Heidi's Investigator info, so Bob is highly likely evil. I will vote to execute him.

Bob's Librarian claim is mechanically impossible because we already have a Butler (Alice) and the Minion is a Scarlet Woman, meaning no Baron is in play to add a Saint. I am speaking to keep the pressure on Bob and ensure the vote goes through.

I want to voice my support for executing Bob to ensure the vote succeeds and clearly explain why his claim is mechanically impossible, reinforcing the Townsfolk's logic.

I want to state my reasoning for keeping my hand raised to vote for Bob. This reinforces the logical inconsistency in Bob's claim and helps secure the execution of a likely Scarlet Woman.

I need a competing nomination to save myself and cast doubt on the tidy mechanical case that currently shields the Demon.

Defend myself against Bob's desperate nomination. Point out that executing me instead of Bob would waste our day on a confirmed good player and let the Scarlet Woman escape.

My top priority is to avoid my own execution and keep the Demon protected. Raising my hand is the only action that can directly create a tie on Grace right now.

I want to preserve Bob if possible or at least muddy the consensus. A vote on Grace is the best available chance to force a tie or create suspicion away from evil.

I want to prevent the town from voting for Grace, keeping Bob on the block for execution since Bob's claim is mechanically impossible and he is one of my two Scarlet Woman suspects.

To discourage the town from voting for Grace, keeping Bob on the block for execution.

To discourage the town from voting for Grace, ensuring Bob remains the primary execution target.

I want to avoid voting for Grace to keep Bob on the block for execution, as Bob's claim is mechanically impossible and he is the most likely Scarlet Woman.

I want to discourage the town from voting for Grace to ensure Bob remains on the block for execution.

I want to avoid getting executed, so I will not raise my hand for my own nomination. I will wait for others to make their moves.

I need to create just enough doubt to win one or two votes for Grace or at least weaken the certainty around my execution and protect Eve.

I want to attract one or two extra votes onto Grace to tie Bob, save my minion, and frame the tie as cautious good play rather than obvious defense.

I want Bob to remain on the block and be executed, as his claim is mechanically inconsistent. Since I am dead and want to save my ghost vote, and voting for Grace would only help Bob escape execution, I will wait and not vote.

I want to discourage the group from voting for Grace so Bob remains on the block for execution, while also explaining why I am not voting (keeping in line with my Butler restriction following Frank).

I want to keep my hand down to avoid voting for Grace, so that Bob stays on the block and is executed. Waiting is the best action to let the vote fail.

I want to ensure Bob remains on the block for execution. Voting for Grace would only split the votes or cause a tie, allowing Bob (the likely Scarlet Woman) to escape. I will wait and not vote.

Wait for the vote on Grace to conclude without my support, keeping Bob on the block for execution.

Reassure the town and confirm our plan to execute Bob as the day ends.

I am dying anyway, so I want to leave lasting doubt on the outsider math and on Grace's credibility, making tomorrow harder for town and protecting Eve.

I cannot save Bob now, so I want to weaken the certainty on the mechanical solve and keep suspicion spread onto Grace, Alice, and info reliability for tomorrow.

Bob is on the block with 5 votes and Grace's nomination failed. The day is ending, and Bob will be executed. I will wait for the Storyteller to proceed to the night phase.

Reassure the town and Bob/Eve that we aren't completely closed-minded, but executing Bob is the correct mechanical play for today, and prepare to go to night.

Wait for the day to end so Bob's execution goes through, allowing us to test Heidi's Investigator information in the morning.

Acknowledge the impending execution of Bob and agree with heading into the night phase to gather more information.

I want to express agreement with heading into the night and executing Bob, keeping the good team aligned and moving the game forward.

Remove the live Virgin before town can use a nomination test, weaken the trusted bloc, and preserve room to argue uncertainty around Alice and Grace tomorrow.

As the Butler, I must choose an alive player to be my master for tomorrow. I will choose David, who has consistently made logical, pro-town suggestions and voted to execute Bob, suggesting he is likely on the good team.

I want to check in with my trusted ally David on Day 3 to coordinate our thoughts, get information on Alice's claim, and see who he suspects.

To establish contact with my master for the day, David, and find out what Charlie whispered to him.

Ask Alice about her role and her contradiction with Bob's claim to get clearer info on who is good and who is evil.

I want to share my perspective with Alice (the claimed Butler) and find out what Frank (the dead Virgin) told her, to help deduce whether Grace or the deceased Bob was the Scarlet Woman.

Whisper to Charlie to share that Alice claimed Butler to me, and explain how Chef 0 plus Bob's likely evil alignment confirms both Charlie and Alice as good, pointing to Eve as the Demon.

I want David to question the solved narrative and consider an execution on someone other than me, ideally splitting the good team around Grace or Alice.

Coordinate Eve's bluff so my execution undermines Heidi's claim and keeps suspicion away from the real Demon.

Initiate a private conversation with Alice, who is a living neighbor and seems trusted by the dead players, to coordinate on finding the Demon.

I want to privately confirm Alice's Butler claim and ask who her master is so we can coordinate our votes. This will help us narrow down the Demon between Eve and Grace.

To answer Charlie's whisper, confirm David is my master today, and discuss the possibility of Eve being the Demon, while asking Charlie what David told him.

Collaborate with Heidi, who is a dead player (highly likely good due to Night 1 death), to share notes on Bob and Grace.

Inform Frank of my logical deduction that Bob is the Scarlet Woman and Grace is likely good, narrowing the Demon down to Charlie, David, or Eve.

I want to coordinate with Alice, who is my Butler, and let her know that Eve is highly likely to be the Demon based on yesterday's voting patterns.

Use my safe Undertaker bluff to undermine Grace's mechanical case and pull Alice into re-evaluating Bob, buying space and setting up a mis-execution.

Alice is central to the town's logic. If I can reopen Heidi versus me and make yesterday feel too neat, it buys Eve cover going into nominations.

I want to gather information from David, who seems to be in the center of conversations, to find out what claims are on the table and see if Eve is highly suspected of being the Demon.

Alice asked what David told me. I will share that David suspects Eve, and ask Alice if she knows what Eve is claiming, to help us determine if Eve or Grace is the Demon.

I want to challenge Eve's Undertaker claim before nominations start. By pointing out the mechanical conflict between Bob being Librarian (which implies a Saint exists, making 2+ Outsiders) and my Butler role, she will have to explain how a Baron is in play or admit she is lying.

I want to confirm Alice's role as Butler to verify that Bob was indeed the Scarlet Woman. This will clear Grace and narrow down the Demon candidates to Charlie, David, and Eve before we enter nominations.

Get Alice's thoughts on the remaining living players (Charlie, David, Eve) to identify the Demon, since she's been a hub of private chats today and Bob is confirmed evil under the Butler/Librarian contradiction.

Respond to Grace's query about Eve, sharing my suspicion of Eve and Alice's Butler claim to build trust and coordinate our votes for the upcoming nomination phase.

Keep Alice from dismissing my Undertaker bluff on setup math and reopen suspicion on Grace's camp before nominations.

David looks central to the town's solve. I want him to slow down any push on Eve and force a re-evaluation of the Heidi to Grace chain.

I want to verify Alice's Butler claim and coordinate with her on the vote, as she has been the hub of conversations today and can help us identify the Demon.

Nominate Eve as she is the most likely Demon candidate based on her defense of Bob, the Chef 0 info confirming Bob's neighbors (Alice and Charlie) as good, and her voting patterns.

Stop the vote from reaching three by attacking David's overconfident logic and reframing me as a convenient follow-up misexecution.

I nominated Eve because she is the most logical Demon candidate under Chef 0. I need to cast my vote to execute her.

David is my master and he has voted for Eve. Since Bob is likely the Scarlet Woman (making me the only Outsider and Bob's Librarian claim false), Eve's Undertaker claim is a lie, meaning she is the Demon. I will raise my hand to vote for her.

Protect Eve by pushing uncertainty and making this vote look premature, while preserving my ghost vote for a later emergency if the count gets close.

Convince the living players (Charlie and Grace) to vote for Eve based on the deduction that Bob was the Scarlet Woman and Eve is the Demon who tried to save her safety net, while saving my ghost vote for the final day.

To execute Eve, who is the prime Demon suspect based on the logic of Chef 0 and Bob being the Scarlet Woman, which confirms Alice and me as good.

The logical chain points directly to Eve being the Demon. With Bob as the Scarlet Woman (from Heidi's Investigator info) and David's Chef 0 clearing Alice and Charlie, Eve is the only viable Demon candidate. I will vote to execute her.

Eve already has 4 votes, which is more than enough to put her on the block. I will save my single ghost vote for the final day when it has the most mathematical weight.

I am already likely on the block, so I want to seed doubt in David's tidy Chef-based case and set up misdirection for tomorrow if I survive or after I die.

I want to keep my hand raised to execute Eve and speak to address her attempt to discredit my Chef information, ensuring the town stays united on this execution.

To keep the vote on Eve strong and explain my Butler restriction is satisfied since my master David is voting.

I cannot stop this vote now, but I can undermine confidence in the mechanical case so the town is less likely to solve cleanly after Eve dies or if some players reconsider.

Support the nomination of Eve while saving my single ghost vote, as she already has 4 votes (enough for a majority).

I am keeping my hand raised to vote for Eve. I will speak to express my alignment with David and Alice's logical deduction, urging the town to put Eve on the block.

I am speaking to explain why I am keeping my hand raised to vote for Eve. The logical chain pointing to her as the Demon is very strong, and we need this execution to go through.

I want to share my thoughts on the current nomination and justify why I am not using my ghost vote, while guiding the team for future days if the game does not end immediately.

I need to get off the block or at least break the hard-clear on David's Chef claim, since that is the engine driving my execution and could save me today or set up tomorrow.

I need to defend myself against Eve's nomination, explain why voting for me is a mistake, and keep the focus on executing Eve.

I must vote on David to try to force a tie at four and avoid my execution. It is the highest leverage action available.

Support David to prevent him from getting executed, as his Chef information is crucial and Eve is our main Demon suspect.

Use my ghost vote to maximize the chance of tying David and saving Eve. It is low odds, but voting is the strongest action available in this moment.

I want to urge the town to keep their hands down for David's nomination. Eve is attempting to deflect or force a tie to avoid execution, and executing David would be a mistake.

I want to protect David from being executed because his information is central to our current strategy. Keeping Eve on the block is our best path to victory today.

Keep hands down on David's vote and explain why to ensure Eve remains on the block.

I want to state that I am keeping my hand down and not voting for David, keeping the focus on executing Eve.

I am currently nominated, but only Eve and Bob have voted for me. Since I am a good Townsfolk (Chef) and want to keep myself alive to execute Eve, I will wait for this vote to fail without raising my hand.

I am likely dying unless I can shake one or two voters. Framing this as a low-cost tie and future-proofing may flip a cautious player like Alice or a ghost vote.

Reiterate support for David and decline Eve's request to vote for David, helping ensure Eve remains on the block for execution.

My ghost vote is already spent. The only chance to save Eve is to publicly push Alice toward a tie by framing it as a no-risk information-preserving move.

I want to ensure David does not get voted onto the block so that Eve remains the sole nominee for execution. Voting for David is a distraction, so I will keep my hand down and wait.

I want to keep my hand down for David's vote to ensure Eve remains the sole nominee on the block for execution, as I believe the current logical chain pointing to her is correct.

I want to let the vote on David fail so that Eve remains on the block for execution. Waiting is the best way to progress the voting phase without accidentally changing the vote count.

I want to see how the voting on David proceeds and preserve my ghost vote for a more critical moment, as I already stated I would keep my hand down.

Reassure the town and confirm our plan to execute Eve as the day ends.

I am almost certainly dying, so I need to leave a clear mechanical warning that points survivors back at David and Grace if the game does not end.

Let the nomination phase end so that Eve, who is currently on the block with a majority of 4 votes, is executed. This aligns with our team's strategy to test the Eve/Bob connection.

Use my last public words to undermine David's hard clear and frame caution as the reasonable path, aiming to flip one player now or set up distrust if the game continues.

Reassure the town and counter the last-minute doubt cast by Eve and Bob before we head into the night and Eve is executed.

I want to acknowledge Eve and Bob's warnings so that they know I am keeping an open mind for tomorrow if the game doesn't end, while agreeing to proceed with the execution of Eve as decided by the majority.

State my role as Mayor to clarify that Bob was definitely the Scarlet Woman (since I am good), confirming that executing the Demon now will win us the game, and support going to sleep.

Acknowledge the plan for tomorrow if the game continues, while agreeing to go to sleep now.