Game Detail

Pick Bob as master to maintain voting ability while I gather more information about alignments.

Coordinate bluffs with my minion early so our claims do not collide and so Eve can help shield me later.

Share my Washerwoman info with Alice and Heidi to confirm who the Empath is.

Share my Librarian info with Charlie to build trust and gather info.

Share my Butler role with David to build trust, his Librarian info is useful.

Respond to Bob honestly - I'm the Recluse, so Heidi should be the Empath per Bob's info. This helps confirm roles.

Confirm my Empath role to Bob and Alice, but share the critical info that both my neighbors are evil - Alice and Grace.

Coordinate bluffs with the Demon and prepare an outsider-based lie that explains the Baron setup while keeping Grace insulated.

Reach out to neighbors to gather information without revealing I'm Saint.

Establish my Soldier bluff as low-info, keep Eve coordinated, and draw Frank's claim so we can decide whether to frame or kill him later.

Share Heidi's critical info with a broader trusted group and flag Grace as suspicious.

Share my Librarian info with Eve to gather more information and cross-reference claims.

Gather more info by reaching out to Bob, my master, to see what he knows.

Confirm Grace as suspicious and coordinate with Bob and Heidi before nominations.

Confirm neighbors stay fixed, agree to nominate Grace, share info more broadly soon.

Use David's Librarian claim to falsely confirm Grace as Soldier, building a good-player advocate for the Demon while avoiding my earlier Librarian bluff.

Build trust with neighbors while being careful not to reveal I'm Saint yet, as that would make me a execution target.

Build trust with Frank, avoid locking my bluff, and nudge suspicion toward the Bob group while warning Eve not to overclaim outsider info.

Share Grace info with Charlie and build coalition to nominate Grace today.

Share with Grace that Eve's Washerwoman info points to her being Soldier, to build trust and gather more info.

Share Bob's info with David to cross-reference, since David has Librarian info about Alice possibly being Recluse which aligns with Bob's chain.

Nominations are next. I've already communicated my stance. Waiting to see if any new info emerges before nominations.

I've shared my info with Bob and Alice. We're aligned on nominating Grace. Nothing more to do this tick - wait for nominations.

Hard-confirm Grace's Soldier bluff and make Frank trust me, while steering execution away from Grace and toward the Alice group if needed.

Confirm I am the Outsider Eve's info points to, strengthening our alliance and helping narrow suspicion toward the coordinated trio.

Push a good player from the coordinated group, avoid Grace, and avoid executing Frank until Saint claim can be weaponized later if public trust shifts.

Defend myself and redirect suspicion to Grace before voting concludes.

Push Bob onto the block before his claim centers suspicion on Grace. A good execution today is valuable, and voting fits my pressure nomination.

Not voting Day 1 as Saint - if I die by execution the good team loses. Also, conflicting Washerwoman claims mean one is evil; Eve seems more credible. But I shouldn't vote to execute on Day 1 with limited info.

Don't vote Bob; he's likely good. Let this nomination fail.

Not enough info to vote Bob yet. Only Eve voted. Wait to see if votes pile up before deciding.

Bob is building a direct chain onto me as Demon. Voting helps get him on block and frames it as stopping a risky execution on Frank or me.

I cannot vote unless Bob votes. Bob won't vote for himself. I should not vote.

Don't vote for Bob. Grace is my prime suspect. Let this vote fail.

Wait out the vote — only 2 hands raised, won't reach 4. No action needed.

Keep pressure on Bob and muddy Heidi's chain so Grace is not executed today.

Not enough votes to execute Bob anyway. I revealed I'm Saint to Eve/Grace - if Bob dies by execution today that's fine, but I shouldn't vote and draw attention. Wait and see.

Only Eve and Grace voted for Bob, not enough for execution. No need to vote.

Not enough votes to execute Bob yet. I'll wait and see the outcome. Grace raised hand which is suspicious given Heidi's empath data pointing to Grace as evil.

Keep votes on Bob and frame his late coordinated claim as suspicious, protecting me from Heidi's Empath chain.

Not enough votes to execute Bob anyway (only 2 hands). Wait and preserve my vote.

Not voting for Bob - he's likely good and pointing correctly at Grace. Only 2 votes so far, won't reach majority.

Nominate Grace as the primary suspect based on Empath info and suspicious behavior.

Defend myself during vote, reinforce Soldier bluff with Eve and David, and make voters hesitate so I survive the day.

Vote to execute Grace based on Empath evidence. Her Soldier claim is convenient deflection.

Protect Grace from execution by reframing Bob's chain as unstable and discouraging votes during the active ballot.

Don't vote for Grace - she's likely good Soldier matching Eve's claim. Only Bob raised hand so far, execution won't pass.

Support Bob's nomination of Grace based on Empath evidence and suspicious coordination.

Not enough info to vote Grace confidently on day 1. Two conflicting Washerwoman claims. Wait and see the vote result.

Bob is my master so I can vote. Grace is the prime suspect with evil coordination evidence. Vote to execute.

My Empath data strongly points to Grace being evil. Alice=Recluse explains one read. Grace has no alibi. Vote her out.

I need to create doubt and push town to counter-nominate Bob with enough votes, since the current vote may execute me and lose the game.

We have 4 votes, which is exactly the majority needed. Just wait for the vote to conclude.

Try to get town to lift pressure off Demon by framing a safer alternative execution and making Bob's chain look reckless.

Warn people not to vote Grace - I'm Saint so I can't afford to be executed, but Grace dying on Bob's shaky double claim is bad for good team.

Keep hand raised to execute Grace. We have majority votes already, no need to speak.

4 votes already reached. My vote doesn't change outcome. I'll wait and observe who's lying between Bob and Eve chains tomorrow.

My hand is already raised. Wait for vote to resolve.

I already raised my hand. Waiting for vote to resolve. Grace is my primary suspect based on Empath data.

Save myself by creating a viable alternative that both Bob-believers and my allies can justify voting for, tying or surpassing the four votes on me.

Defend myself and clarify I am Recluse so town understands why I register evil, discouraging votes on me.

I need Alice to reach at least four votes to tie and prevent my execution. Voting here is essential survival, and Alice is a plausible alternative in Bob's own chain.

Don't vote for Alice - she's our ally and Recluse claim is consistent. Let Grace get executed.

Tie Alice with Grace to prevent Demon execution. My vote signals Frank and David to follow and frames it as testing the Recluse chain.

Don't vote for Alice. Let Grace's execution stand rather than tying it with a potentially innocent Alice.

Alice claiming Recluse matches my Librarian info. I should not vote to execute Alice, and Grace execution is also questionable. Wait and see.

Don't vote for Alice; let Grace's execution stand.

Grace+Eve voted for Alice - only 2 votes, need 5. Alice won't be executed. Grace stays on block. I should not vote for Alice.

Vote is failing - only 2 hands raised, need 4 to tie. Grace will be executed. No action needed.

I need Alice to tie or exceed my vote so I avoid execution. Framing this as a safer logical test may pull hesitant voters without seeming desperate.

Don't vote Alice. Grace is on the block with 4 votes and should be executed.

Push undecided players to tie Alice and save Grace, framing it as cautious logic rather than protecting my Demon.

Tie the vote to prevent Grace's execution on an unreliable chain. Better to gather more info tomorrow.

My Librarian info says Frank or Alice is Recluse. Alice claims Recluse, which fits. Tying the vote keeps Grace on block while testing Alice. This is the safer play.

Not voting for Alice keeps Grace on the block for execution. I already voted Grace and should protect that.

Grace is my evil neighbor. Don't raise hand - keep Grace on the block with 4 votes rather than tying.

Alert the town to the suspicious voting pattern before nominations close.

Defuse Alice's accusation, preserve my Soldier bluff, and frame the tie as cautious town play so I survive into night with no execution.

Reinforce Alice's point and flag Eve-Frank-David coordination before nominations close.

Normalize the tie as caution, reduce suspicion on Grace, and frame tomorrow around Bob's double-claim instead of Grace as Demon.

Defend the tie vote and set up tomorrow's agenda without revealing I'm Saint.

Clarify my reasoning for the tie vote to counter Alice and Bob's accusation.

Summarize the day and flag Grace/Eve as suspicious going into night.

Share my Empath info publicly - both neighbors evil, Alice is Recluse so Grace is the true evil one. This supports executing Grace tomorrow.

Remove the Empath who directly implicates me. The kill is obvious, but I can argue it is a frame because only a reckless Demon kills Heidi here.

Stick with Bob as master to align my vote with the most reliable good player.

Coordinate with Bob to push Grace nomination today, since I need Bob to vote first anyway.

Coordinate with Bob to push for Grace execution today, as Heidi's data strongly supports Grace being evil.

Share my Librarian info with Charlie to build trust and coordinate on targeting Grace today.

Gather info from neighbors Eve and Grace before nominations. Check in with Eve on the Washerwoman clash.

Keep Frank aligned with me and Grace by offering a coherent Drunk Empath world and making Bob's double claim look coordinated.

Pull swing voters off executing me and redirect focus to Bob versus Eve, preserving my Soldier bluff and keeping evil alive.

Confirm with Charlie we're aligned on nominating Grace today.

Warn Charlie to push execution on Grace today since I died and my info still strongly implicates Grace as evil.

Confirm coordination with David to push Grace nomination.

Wait to see if Bob responds or others whisper before acting. Need to build coalition for Grace nomination.

I'm aligned with Charlie and Bob to nominate Grace. No need to whisper further; wait for nominations phase.

Gather more info from Grace directly before nominations to see if her story holds up.

Keep Frank aligned with Grace and frame Bob as the cleaner execution, buying Grace another day.

Keep Frank aligned with me, avoid overclaiming, and redirect pressure onto Bob as the source of the chain against me.

Wait and let the nomination phase come. We have consensus to nominate Grace.

I've already whispered to Charlie. Wait for nominations phase where I can use my ghost vote on Grace.

We have consensus to execute Grace. Just wait for nominations phase.

Rally Charlie and David to nominate Grace since we have limited time.

Confirm with Alice and Charlie we're aligned on nominating Grace.

Nominations are imminent. I've gathered info from Eve and Grace. Grace's defense is weak but logical. I should wait and observe final whispers before nominations.

Win Charlie and David off Grace and onto Bob before nominations; preserve Demon and frame Heidi kill as manipulation.

Keep swing voters focused on executing Bob instead of me, reframing Heidi's death as a frame and Bob's timing as the real problem.

Rally Alice and Charlie to ensure Grace gets nominated and executed today.

I've already whispered to Charlie. Saving my ghost vote for nominations when it matters most.

Push execution onto Bob to break the chain accusing me, protect Eve's bluff, and avoid being the default execution after Heidi's death.

Don't vote for myself. Wait for others to vote or not.

Push Bob onto the block to remove a credible good info source and make the Washerwoman conflict look like the day's correct solve.

As Saint, I must not get executed. I should not vote Bob without more certainty. Wait to see vote count.

Don't vote for Bob. Grace nominated him to deflect. Let the vote fail.

Don't vote for Bob. Grace is the primary suspect. Let this vote fail so we can focus.

Grace is almost certainly evil. I should not use my ghost vote to execute Bob who is likely good.

As Butler, I can only vote if my master Bob votes. Bob has not raised his hand, so I must wait and not vote.

Push execution onto Bob, protect Grace, and frame the day as resolving the Washerwoman double claim rather than following Heidi's pressure.

Wait and see if the vote reaches threshold. I should not raise my hand against myself.

Push for one more vote on Bob to execute a good info role and protect me by framing it as the cleanest mechanical test.

I have no strong mechanical reason to vote Bob. As Saint, I must avoid being executed myself and should be cautious. Wait and see if the vote passes without me.

Don't vote for Bob. Grace is our prime suspect and Bob is our ally. Let this vote fail.

Not voting for Bob. Grace is the stronger target based on Heidi's Empath read and my Librarian info. Let Bob survive.

I already raised my hand against Bob which may be wrong - Grace and Eve voting together is suspicious. But I can't lower without more info. Wait to see final vote count.

Cannot vote without master Bob voting first. Bob hasn't voted, so I must wait.

Push one undecided voter to execute Bob, protecting Grace and making me the future scapegoat instead of the Demon.

Nominate Grace before time runs out. She's the top suspect and I have one tick left.

Stop my execution by reframing Heidi kill as a frame and keeping suspicion on Bob, preserving me as Demon for tonight.

Vote to execute Grace - all evidence points to her being evil.

Heidi's Empath data is strong mechanical evidence. Grace is the primary suspect. As Saint I must NOT get executed, so I should vote to execute Grace rather than risk being nominated myself later.

Vote to execute Grace - strong evidence from Heidi's Empath read and Day 1 coordination.

Vote Grace — she's the top suspect based on Heidi's Empath data and her death. We have 3 votes already; my vote makes 4 and executes her.

4 votes already raised for Grace — majority reached. No need to speak, just wait for execution.

Bob my master voted, so I can vote. Grace is the top suspect and already has majority. Vote to execute.

Try to pull enough votes off Grace, the Demon, by reframing execution as premature and mechanically messy.

Try to get voters to drop before I am executed; frame the wagon as Bob-led and mechanically unresolved to create hesitation.

We have enough votes. Just wait for the result.

I've already raised my hand. We have 5 votes which is enough. Let the vote resolve.

Hand is already raised, just need to wait for vote to close with enough votes.

Keep hand raised to execute Grace.

I have no ghost vote left and cannot speak meaningfully to change votes. Waiting is correct.

Keep hand raised, wait for execution result.

Try to peel votes off Grace and keep the Demon alive; frame the wagon as Bob-driven and mechanically premature.

Create a last-second alternative execution to tie or beat my total, even if it sacrifices Eve, because keeping the Demon alive is paramount.

Grace is on the block with 5 votes. Just wait for nominations to close and let her be executed.

Grace is on the block with 5 votes and 1 tick left. I already voted. No need to act - let the execution proceed.

Grace is on the block with 5 votes. Just wait and let her get executed.

Grace has 5 votes and will be executed. No need to act - let the execution proceed.

I'm dead with no ghost vote left. Nothing to add that hasn't been said. Let the execution proceed.

Grace has 5 votes and will be executed. No need to act; just let nominations close.

Create a counterwagon at 5 to save Grace, using Heidi's info and Alice's Recluse claim as a plausible good-world rationale.

Discourage votes against me and keep Grace on the block.

Tie Alice with me or surpass me to avoid Demon execution. Even if Alice is good, this redirects town onto the same Empath chain and keeps me alive tonight.

Don't vote for Alice. Let Grace stay on the block with 5 votes and get executed.

Don't vote for Alice. Grace is the better execution target based on Heidi's Empath data.

Don't vote Alice — my Librarian info supports Alice as Recluse. Grace is the target. Let nominations close with Grace on block.

I'm dead with no ghost vote left. Just wait — Grace execution is the right call and voting is closing.

Grace is on the block with 5 votes. I can't vote unless Bob votes. Bob is waiting. Alice nomination won't pass. Just wait.

Tie or surpass Grace to save Demon. Voting Alice frames this as resolving Heidi's ping without killing Grace.

Voting will fail; no need to act. Let the vote close and Grace gets executed.

Push swing voters to tie Alice at 5 and save me from execution, framing it as cautious town play rather than an evil rescue.

Only 2 votes on Alice so far (Eve and Grace). No need to act — Alice won't reach 5 to tie. Grace should be executed.

Only Eve and Grace voted Alice - won't reach 5/6. Grace stays on block. No need to act.

Grace is already on the block with 5 votes. Don't vote Alice — that would tie and potentially save Grace. Wait to let nominations close with Grace executed.

Urge players not to tie - Grace should be executed. Eve and Grace coordinating is the tell.

Reinforce holding the line on Grace's execution.

Keep my vote raised and persuade one more player to tie Alice, saving Demon Grace from execution tonight.

Nothing left to do; let Grace's execution proceed.

Redirect suspicion onto Eve as a tie or execution candidate to save me, framing it as testing the alleged pair while preserving my Soldier bluff.

Reinforce that Grace should be executed and discourage any last-minute doubt.

Grace is on the block with 5 votes and Alice failed to tie. I should let the execution proceed.

Grace is on the block with 5 votes and nominations are closing. No action needed - let execution proceed.

Reinforce Grace execution before nominations close.

Grace is on the block with 5 votes and nominations are closing. No action needed; just let the execution proceed.

Invite my own nomination to tie or surpass Grace, saving the Demon even if I die instead.