Game Detail

Night 0: No information yet. I'm picking two players far apart in the seating to maximize coverage. Alice and Frank are on opposite sides of the circle from me, giving me early reads on two distinct areas.

As Butler on Night 0, I must choose a master. With no information, I pick Grace (my neighbor) so I can closely observe their behavior and alignment. If Grace is good, my vote will be useful; if not, I can switch masters on future nights.

Start building relationships with my neighbors on Day 1. Gather information about what others are claiming without revealing my own role yet.

Coordinate with Alice on our false claims and strategy for Day 1. Establish a believable narrative early.

Build rapport with my neighbor Eve and Frank, gauge their trustworthiness, and keep my Fortune Teller info close for now. A NO on Alice and Frank means neither is the Demon, narrowing the pool.

As the Virgin, I need to gather information without revealing my role. Whispering to my neighbors Bob and David is a natural way to start building relationships and collecting claims. I want to see what they know and if they share their roles.

Probe David for his hidden info and engage Eve to build trust with neighbors while keeping my Butler role secret.

Start building a relationship with my neighbor Heidi and gather information about what others are claiming. As Monk, I want to stay under the radar early and avoid claiming my real role yet.

Coordinate with my Demon to establish a believable bluff that protects him from suspicion.

Build trust with my neighbor Grace without revealing my role. As Ravenkeeper, I want to keep my role hidden so the Demon might target me at night, triggering my ability. Day 1 is about gathering info and building alliances.

Continue building trust with neighbors and probe for information. David claims to have info, which suggests a starting-info role like Washerwoman, Librarian, or Investigator. I want to encourage sharing without revealing my own Undertaker role yet, since it's useless until someone is executed and I don't want evil players to know who I am.

Build trust with Charlie by sharing my Washerwoman bluff early. Establishing my cover story and putting suspicion on the David/Eve/Frank group.

Share my Fortune Teller claim and N0 info with Eve and Frank to build a trusted alliance. Frank was cleared by my check, so I trust him. Eve is my neighbor and has been cooperative. This gets my info out there in case I die.

Continue building trust with Bob who shared info, while cautiously evaluating his claim. Don't reveal my Virgin role yet - it's too early and too dangerous if evil players learn about it. Gather more information first.

Reinforce trust with David and Eve without revealing my Butler role. Encourage David to share his night plans so I can coordinate. Keep gathering info to narrow down the Demon.

As the Monk, I need to gather information and build trust networks. Frank is my other neighbor besides Heidi. The Eve-David-Frank whisper chain is very active - I should find out what they're discussing without revealing my own role yet.

Spread my Empath claim to Heidi early to build trust and make my story consistent. A good player who hears they're cleared by Empath is likely to become an ally.

I want to build trust with Alice by sharing my real role since she shared hers. Ravenkeeper is relatively safe to claim since it only triggers on death. I also want to probe about the Eve-David-Frank cluster which seems suspicious.

Reciprocate David's trust by claiming my role (Undertaker) to build a trusted alliance with David and Frank. Also press Frank to claim and suggest David check someone outside our group tonight to expand our info network.

Eve is in a tight whisper chain with David and Frank. I need to understand their coordination and build trust with Eve early. If Eve is good, she becomes a valuable ally who can advocate for me.

Gather information from Charlie before nominations begin. Charlie is my neighbor and reached out earlier. I want to see what they've learned and get a read on Bob, who is also in the Demon suspect pool.

Gather more information from David about the Eve-Frank-David whisper chain and role claims, while keeping my Virgin identity hidden. David seems to be in the middle of a lot of conversations so he may have valuable intel.

Grace is my Butler master so I need to maintain a good relationship with her. She's asking what I've heard - I should be friendly and share some info but NOT reveal David's Fortune Teller claim since he asked me to keep it quiet. I want Grace to trust me.

Gather intel from Alice, who is outside the Eve-David-Frank whisper group, to see if she has any useful info before nominations begin.

Build trust with Grace by sharing my Empath claim (neighbors Bob and Heidi are good) and Bob's Washerwoman claim about David/Frank. Redirect suspicion toward the Eve-David-Frank whispering group.

Gather more information from my trusted neighbor Alice before nominations begin. The Eve-David-Frank whispering cluster is suspicious and worth discussing.

Share gathered info publicly to help town coordinate and pressure the suspicious whisper group. Keeping my Monk role hidden for now.

Nominating David to push execution onto a good player. Bob's Washerwoman claim already points at David, and his secretive whispering with Eve and Frank reinforces suspicion. This protects Bob and advances evil's position.

Defend myself against Alice's nomination by revealing my true role and info publicly, since I'm at risk of execution and need to prove my value to the town.

I want to resolve the contradiction between David's FT claim and Bob's Washerwoman info before voting. Pressuring Frank to claim will help determine who is lying.

David claiming Fortune Teller contradicts Bob's Washerwoman info. Regardless of whether David is telling the truth, executing him removes a potential threat to Bob. I nominated him and should follow through with my vote.

Voting David is consistent with my Washerwoman claim that implicated him. Removing the Fortune Teller eliminates a major threat to me as the Demon, and it pressures town into a mis-execution on Day 1.

Defend David from execution because he's a claimed info role (FT) and killing him Day 1 wastes a key resource. If Frank confirms Chef, we have a validated info chain.

Advocate for gathering more information before executing David, specifically pushing Frank to confirm or deny being Chef, which would resolve the apparent contradiction between Bob's and David's claims.

I want to avoid executing a potential info role on Day 1 while also encouraging Frank to speak up and resolve the contradiction between David and Bob's claims.

Clarify I'm not the Chef to help town resolve the contradiction, without fully revealing Butler yet. This casts doubt on Bob's claim if David is truthful about FT.

Deflect suspicion from myself onto Bob, whose Washerwoman claim is now contradicted by both Frank and me.

Avoid executing a potential Fortune Teller on Day 1, push the conversation toward resolving the Bob vs David/Frank contradiction, and keep focus on Bob as potentially the liar here.

The David vote is failing. Lowering my hand shows I'm reasonable and builds credibility for my next move - defending Bob using my Empath cover.

Defend my Washerwoman claim by suggesting possible poisoning, while casting doubt on David's Fortune Teller claim and maintaining trust with the town.

I want to discourage voting for David and redirect suspicion toward Bob, whose Washerwoman claim is contradicted by both David and Frank.

I should not vote for David. He claims Fortune Teller and killing an info role Day 1 is wasteful. The contradiction with Bob's claim needs more time to resolve. Let David investigate tonight.

Not voting for David - consensus is to let FT investigate tonight. Voting now wastes an info role on Day 1.

Add nuance to the Bob vs David discussion by pointing out the Poisoner possibility, which could reconcile both claims without either player being evil.

Bob's Washerwoman claim directly contradicts both me and Frank. He is the most suspicious player and needs to be put on the block so we can get more information from how people vote and how he defends himself.

Defend myself by explaining the contradiction logically. Plant seeds of doubt about David's reliability. Stay calm and measured to appear townie.

Voting for Bob's execution because his Washerwoman claim contradicts two players who both deny being Chef, making him the most likely evil player. Even the poisoned excuse is weak since a Poisoner targeting a Washerwoman on night 0 is unlikely.

Day 1 is too early to execute based on a single contradiction. Bob could be poisoned or drunk rather than evil. Better to let the game develop and gather more info tonight.

Protect Bob (my Demon) from execution by arguing his info could be poisoned, my Empath read supports him being good, and we shouldn't rush to execute on day one with conflicting info.

Not voting for Bob because Alice's Empath reading of 0 suggests Bob is good, and the WW contradiction could be explained by poisoning or drunkenness. Day 1 execution on ambiguous info risks killing a good player.

Voting to execute Bob on day 1 is premature. Alice's Empath reading suggests Bob is good. The contradiction could be explained by poisoning. Better to wait for night info than risk killing a good player. I also need to protect my Virgin identity - if I vote now I draw attention.

Avoid executing a possibly good player. Alice's Empath 0 reading suggests Bob is good, so the contradiction likely stems from poisoning rather than Bob being evil. Better to gather more info tonight.

Support not executing Bob based on Alice's Empath reading that suggests Bob is good, and push for gathering more info tonight instead of a risky Day 1 execute.

Vote won't pass with only 1 hand. Reinforce the poisoned Washerwoman theory and plant doubt about David's reliability as Fortune Teller to prepare for future days.

Counter the defense of Bob by pointing out flaws in Alice's Empath defense and the poisoning theory, while keeping my vote raised.

Advocate against rushing a Day 1 execution when there are multiple plausible explanations for the contradiction. Preserve good players and gather more info.

Bob is my Demon and only David has voted to execute him. Grace and Frank are already defending him. The vote will fail without my support. Staying passive and letting the vote fail naturally is the safest play - I've already spoken in Bob's defense which builds credibility.

Withhold vote on Bob to let the vote fail. Day 1 execution based on one contradiction is too risky when poisoning/drunk explains it. Better to gather info tonight - David's FT read and my Undertaker info will help tomorrow.

I should not vote for Bob. Day 1 execution based on a contradiction with multiple explanations is too risky. Let tonight's investigations proceed. Also, I need to protect my Virgin identity - if I'm nominated by a Townsfolk, they die, so I want to avoid being nominated while also not revealing my role prematurely to evil.

Not voting for Bob on Day 1 - the contradiction has multiple explanations (poisoning, drunk, Spy) and executing on Day 1 with limited info is risky. Let the vote fail and gather more info tonight.

The vote on Bob is failing - only David voted, and 4 are needed. Grace (my master) is not voting, so I cannot vote either. The town consensus is to wait for more info tonight. No need to add more noise.

Shift suspicion onto David by highlighting that his Fortune Teller claim could be false due to being Drunk or poisoned. If executed, removes a threat; if not, at least forces him to defend his reads.

Day 1 is essentially over - both nominations have failed and we're heading to night. No further action needed today. I'll get another FT check tonight which will be much more valuable than any last-minute speech.

It's the last tick of Day 1 nominations. Both Bob and David failed to get enough votes. No one else has strong enough suspicion to nominate, and a Day 1 execution is risky with limited info. Better to let the day end and gather info tonight. I'll protect David tonight as the claimed Fortune Teller - he's the demon's most likely target.

Bob is safe today - excellent for evil. I should reinforce my 'careful good player' image by supporting the cautious approach, building trust for future days.

Only 1 tick remains in nomination phase, too late for any meaningful nomination or vote. No execution today means my Undertaker ability won't trigger tonight. I should wait and observe, then share my role tomorrow when I have information to contribute.

Day 1 is nearly over with just 1 tick left. Bob and David have been nominated already and the vote on Bob failed. I'm the Virgin and haven't revealed my role yet. I need to be careful - if a Townsfolk nominates me, they get executed immediately. I should plan to reveal my role tomorrow so good players know not to nominate me accidentally. For now, waiting is the best move since there's no time for meaningful action.

Contribute to the day 1 discussion as an engaged good player, supporting the sensible wait-and-see approach without revealing my Ravenkeeper role yet.

Day 1 is nearly over with 1 tick left. No execution happened, which is fine for Day 1. The vote on Bob failed, and I have no strong case to nominate anyone else. Best to wait for night and gather more information tomorrow.

Alice claimed Empath and has been a trusted voice providing useful information (confirming Bob registers as good). The Demon likely wants to eliminate reliable info roles, making Alice a prime target. Protecting her preserves valuable ongoing information for the town.

Kill David to eliminate the most vocal opponent who is actively trying to execute me. This reduces good team's coordination and gives me room to maneuver tomorrow.

Alice is the most trusted player so far: David's FT cleared her as not Demon, her Empath 0 claim is consistent and she's been logical. Aligning my vote with the most likely good player ensures I vote correctly tomorrow.

Coordinate with my minion Alice to align our narratives and discuss who we should push for execution today.

Share my confirmed FT information with Grace (info hub) and Frank (believes my FT claim) to help narrow the Demon pool and coordinate town strategy since I'm dead and have nothing to lose.

Share my Undertaker claim with Alice (the claimed Empath) to build a trusted alliance and coordinate information. Since no one was executed Day 1, I have no info yet, but my role becomes valuable after an execution.

Share my Monk role with trusted players Alice and David to coordinate. Alice is cleared by Empath+FT, David is dead and confirmed FT. Narrowing Demon to Charlie or Eve if info is reliable.

Share key logical insight with Alice - Bob could be Spy which explains both the contradicted Washerwoman claim and Alice's Empath 0 reading. This helps narrow down the Demon.

As the Virgin, I need to gather intel without revealing my role. Alice is the most verified player (Empath 0 is consistent, David's FT partially cleared her). I should coordinate with Alice to understand the current landscape and plan for nominations carefully.

I need to gather information about what happened last night since David died. Alice is the central information hub, so whispering to her makes sense. I'm sharing my role as Ravenkeeper which is relatively safe since my power only activates on death, and I want to build trust and get information.

Coordinate with Bob to counter Frank's dangerous Spy theory and establish Charlie as today's execution target.

Coordinate with Alice to align our defenses. Deny Spy accusation using her Empath zero. Push Charlie as execution target for today. Clarify Washerwoman story to handle contradictions.

Probe Grace's Monk claim by asking for N0 protection detail, and challenge the assumption that Alice's Empath is reliable. Also press Frank for his role claim to get more info on the board.

Share my Undertaker claim with Frank and get info from David's ghost through Frank, since David was whispering to Frank and Grace.

Clarify that Monk doesn't act Night 0 to validate my claim to David, push Frank for a role claim to resolve the Bob conflict, and share my analysis on Demon candidates.

Reveal my Butler role to David and Grace to resolve the Bob contradiction and narrow the Demon pool. With 1 Outsider confirmed (me), Alice can't be Drunk, making her Empath reliable and narrowing Demon to Charlie or Eve.

Gather information from Frank and Grace who seem to be in David's whisper network. David as a ghost may have shared important info, and I need to understand the current state of the game before nominations.

Grace is communicating with dead David who was likely the FT. I need to find out what FT info David had so we can identify the Demon. As Ravenkeeper, I should be gathering info actively.

Counter Frank's correct Spy theory by emphasizing my mechanical Empath read clears Bob, and redirect suspicion toward Charlie to set up a good execution target.

Build trust with Eve, reinforce my Washerwoman claim, and subtly redirect suspicion toward Frank's aggressive targeting of me while supporting the Charlie push.

Share my logical analysis with Grace and Alice to help town narrow the Demon, while flagging the risk that Frank's Butler claim could be a Spy play.

David is dead and likely good. He was vocal against Bob yesterday and was killed at night - possibly because the Demon saw him as a threat. I need his info to help find the Demon.

Share my analysis with Heidi who reached out claiming Ravenkeeper. I want to build trust with her, get her input, and see if her responses are consistent with being good. She's cleared by Alice's Empath but could be Spy. Sharing info helps coordinate for the vote.

Share my Butler claim with Alice to confirm her Empath is real, narrow the Demon pool to Charlie or Eve, and coordinate our votes since I can only vote when she votes.

Share my Virgin claim with key players to prevent accidental Townsfolk execution from nominating me, and gather information from Eve and Alice who seem to be hubs of private communication.

I need to press Charlie and Eve for their role claims since Grace's analysis identifies them as the main Demon suspects. Getting their claims will help identify contradictions and narrow down the Demon.

Bob is the Demon. Charlie claims Virgin - if Bob nominates Charlie, Bob's Washerwoman claim collapses (ability won't trigger proving he's not Townsfolk). Bob must NOT nominate Charlie. We need a different target.

Nominate Eve to redirect town suspicion away from me and Alice, force Eve to claim a role, and exploit her Day 1 defense of me as suspicious behavior.

Defend myself against Bob's nomination by publicly claiming Undertaker and pointing out that Bob's accuser conveniently died overnight, making Bob look more suspicious.

I nominated Eve, so voting for her maintains consistency. Eve's Undertaker claim is unverifiable (no execution Day 1). Removing her eliminates a verification role. Alice's Empath zero on me can shield me if Eve flips good.

Vote to execute Eve (Undertaker). Eliminating Eve removes a good info role and supports my Demon Bob's nomination. Shows I'm actively participating in town's cause.

Share my FT info publicly since I'm dead and can help town narrow the demon pool. Advocate against executing Eve the claimed Undertaker since her role is verifiable and valuable.

My Butler master Alice is voting for Eve, so I must vote with her. Eve is a plausible Demon candidate (if Bob is Spy, Demon is Charlie or Eve). Voting maintains my cover and follows the chain of logic I shared with Alice.

Speak against Eve's execution to protect the Undertaker claim and highlight suspicion on Bob, whose critic died overnight.

I should not vote for Eve. She's claiming Undertaker which is verifiable and valuable. Bob is more suspicious - his claim was contradicted and his critic died. I should speak up to discourage the Eve execution and redirect suspicion toward Bob.

Decline voting for Eve and voice opposition, preserving the Undertaker claim for verification while casting suspicion on Bob.

Defend myself against execution by pointing out I won't vote for myself and redirecting suspicion to Bob. With 3 votes for me, I must NOT raise my hand or I die.

The Eve vote is failing at 3/4. Continuing to push makes me look desperate and suspicious. Lowering my hand lets me seem reasonable and redirect the conversation toward executing someone else - ideally Charlie, who I can frame based on Alice's intel.

Eve vote is dead at 2/4. Lowering hand to avoid looking aligned with Bob, then pivot to Charlie using Frank's Spy theory to redirect town's suspicion away from Bob as Demon.

Eve's nomination has almost no support - only Frank is still voting. Bob and Alice lowered their hands. Only 1 vote out of 4 needed. I should save my ghost vote for a more critical moment, like when Bob or another Demon suspect is nominated.

I must lower my hand because my Butler ability ties my vote to Alice, who just lowered her hand. I can only vote if Alice is voting. Additionally, strategically, killing the Undertaker on Day 2 is bad for the good team - we need Eve alive to verify roles. I want Bob or Charlie nominated instead.

Defend myself against Grace's suggestion, reveal my role publicly to clear suspicion, and push for Bob's nomination as the most suspicious player.

The vote on Eve is clearly failing - Bob, Alice, and Frank all lowered their hands. No need to vote for Eve. I should wait for this vote to conclude and then support nominating Bob, whose Washerwoman claim was contradicted and whose behavior is highly suspicious.

Clarify my position on Charlie, apologize for the mischaracterization, and build consensus for nominating Bob instead of Eve.

Bob is the top suspect: contradicted Washerwoman claim, David died after pushing against him, and he nominated the Undertaker to kill our verification tool. Town consensus is building against Bob. I must nominate him now before the phase ends.

Defend myself by arguing the Demon killed David to frame me, and Eve's Undertaker claim is unverified. Need to convince at least one player not to vote, preventing the 4-vote threshold.

Voting for Bob is the optimal play. If he's evil, we remove a threat. If he's good, I verify his role tonight and the town knows his Washerwoman info was poisoned/false. Either way, my Undertaker ability gives us crucial information.

Protect my Demon Bob by casting doubt on the execution. I need to sow uncertainty about Eve's Undertaker claim and remind people that David's info could have been poisoned, making Bob look guilty unfairly.

Bob is the strongest Demon suspect: contradicted Washerwoman claim, his critic (me) died overnight, he tried to kill the Undertaker. Executing Bob gives max info - Eve verifies tonight. Alice's defense is suspicious; my FT said Alice is NOT Demon, so she may be misguided, Drunk Empath, or a Minion protecting the Demon. Using ghost vote now is critical.

Persuade Alice and the town to vote for Bob. As Butler tied to Alice, I can only vote if she does, so I need to convince her. The case against Bob is strong: contradicted Washerwoman, critic died, tried to kill Undertaker.

Voting for Bob because the evidence against him is strong: contradicted Washerwoman claim, critic died overnight, tried to execute the Undertaker. Alice's defense is noted but her Empath info could be poisoned.

Withholding my vote on Bob because Alice's Empath 0 is the strongest mechanical evidence we have, and it says Bob is good. The circumstantial case against Bob is explainable by poison and the Demon framing him.

Vote to execute Bob based on strong evidence: contradicted Washerwoman claim, suspicious nomination of Undertaker, and David's death after opposing him.

Urgently reinforce Alice's defense of me. Four votes have been raised but people can lower their hands. Cast doubt on Eve's unverified claim and the reliability of David's possibly-poisoned info. Save myself from execution.

Counter Bob's defense and keep votes on him. We have exactly 4 votes which meets the threshold, but Bob is trying to get people to lower their hands.

Create enough doubt about the reliability of the information chain to convince at least one voter to lower their hand and save Bob (the Demon) from execution.

Support Bob's execution by countering Alice's arguments and ensuring voters keep their hands raised. 4 votes (me, Eve, Charlie, Grace) is exactly the threshold needed.

Counter Alice's defense of Bob and keep votes from being lowered. As Butler with Alice as master, I can't vote since Alice isn't voting, so I must use speech to influence others.

Counter Alice's attempt to save Bob and prevent voters from lowering their hands. The vote count is at exactly 4 (threshold), so we need to hold firm.

Bob is the most likely evil player. His Washerwoman claim was directly contradicted, he tried to execute the Undertaker before verification, and the Spy argument undermines Alice's Empath defense. Four votes are already up - I should add mine to secure the execution.

Reinforce the case against Bob and counter Alice's objections so votes stay up for execution

Claim Drunk to explain the Washerwoman contradiction and create doubt about executing me. This is a last-ditch effort to avoid execution and keep evil in the game.

Reassure the group that Bob's last-minute Drunk claim doesn't undermine the execution plan, since my Undertaker ability will verify his role tonight regardless.

Last-ditch effort to save Bob (my Demon). The Drunk claim explains the Washerwoman contradiction naturally. If even one person doubts and the vote fails to reach majority on another nominee, Bob survives.

Expose Bob's fake Drunk claim - the Drunk doesn't know they're Drunk, so Bob couldn't have 'just realized' it. This proves he's lying and likely evil.

Reinforce that Bob's Drunk claim is mechanically impossible and he is almost certainly evil, ensuring no one doubts this execution later.

Reinforce that Bob's Drunk claim is mechanically false and flag Alice's suspicious behavior for future reference.

Reinforce that Bob's Drunk claim is a lie and flag Alice's suspicious behavior for tomorrow, since the execution is going through regardless.

Reinforce that Bob's Drunk claim is a lie and flag Alice's suspicious behavior for tomorrow, since the execution is already going through.