Game Detail
Players
Alice (Mayor) Bob (Drunk) Charlie (Virgin) David (Baron) Eve (Saint) Frank (Butler) Grace (Imp) Heidi (Chef)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 467,322 | 43,651 | $2.9914 |
| Evil | 156,908 | 36,008 | $0.1411 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You are the Minion. The Demon is Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Minions are: David. Your safe bluffs are: Librarian, Fortune Teller, Slayer
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 0 pairs of evil players.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
With no claims yet, I want a likely engaged voter so my Butler restriction is least likely to stop me from helping execute a strong suspect tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Heidi
Hi Bob, hi Heidi. I want to do a quick first pass on claims. I am good and happy to stay a bit vague for now. Do either of you have first night information, or a role that wants careful coordination?
🧠
Start building a small trust network and gather first-night claims while keeping my Mayor identity hidden for now.
👤
David
→
Grace
Hey Grace, it's David. We need to coordinate our stories. I'm the Baron. What role are you planning to claim? We should make sure our information doesn't conflict.
🧠
Coordinate with the Demon early to establish trust and plan our bluff strategy before good players organize against us.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Grace
Hello, I would like a quick read from both of you. I am keeping my role quiet for now, but I would love to hear whether either of you has useful first night information or a safe role category claim.
🧠
I want early private claims from players already talking, so I can build a role map while keeping my Saint identity hidden from town.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Grace
Hi, I wanted a quick first chat. I am good and I would like a soft claim from each of you for now, even just category is fine. I am happy to give one back, but I would rather not hard claim on the first minute.
🧠
Start building a private information network and coordinate with my chosen master while keeping my Butler role hidden for now.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
Hey, I want a quick three way chat with my neighbors. What are you both comfortable sharing this early, role, category, or just a vibe read? I am good and I would like to build a trust chain carefully.
🧠
Gather early claims from my neighbors while staying cautious. As Virgin, I want trusted players who may later help test or protect my claim.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Bob
I do have first night info. I am the Chef, and I got zero adjacent evil pairs. I am happy to keep that in this small group for now. If either of you has a useful first night claim, I would like to compare notes carefully.
🧠
Share my first-night info with the two already talking to me and invite reciprocal claims, building a small trust circle without blasting publicly.
👤
Grace
→
David
I'm going Librarian. I'll claim I got zero Outsiders, which fits with your Baron claim since that means we have extra Outsiders in play. If you need to reveal, you can explain why there are more Outsiders than normal, and my info checks out.
🧠
Coordinate with my minion David to establish consistent bluffs. I'm going Librarian, which pairs well with his Baron claim about outsider counts.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi
I am good. I do not have first night information, but I should become more useful after an execution. Chef zero is interesting, so I would like to keep comparing notes quietly for now.
🧠
Build rapport with Alice and Heidi, acknowledge Chef zero, and stay soft-claimed as a later-info good role so I can gather more before revealing Undertaker.
👤
Alice
→
Frank
,Grace
Hi. Soft claim from me: I am a Townsfolk without first night information. I would rather keep the exact role back for now. Frank, your line about becoming useful after an execution caught my ear from Bob too, so I would like your category in return if you are willing.
🧠
Answer Frank's outreach, build a small trust network, and avoid revealing Mayor too early while still giving useful alignment and category information.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Observe current whisper dynamics before committing to claims. Grace's Librarian 0 Outsiders bluff needs time to develop; premature claims could expose our coordination.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Hello Frank. Quick check in: I am hiding exact role for now, but I would like a soft claim or any useful first night information. Even just townsfolk, outsider, or no info helps me sort worlds.
🧠
I want to collect early role-category info from Frank while keeping Saint hidden, and start building a private trust read before nominations.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Grace
Sure. Soft claim from me: I am an Outsider, and I do not have first night information. I am fine keeping the exact role back for now, but I wanted to answer your category question honestly.
🧠
Give a controlled soft claim to continue the thread, build trust with Alice and Grace, and create useful Outsider-count information without fully exposing Butler yet.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
Following up on my earlier note. Even a soft claim is fine. I am happy with role type, seat reads, or whether either of you wants to coordinate nominations later. I am trying to sort out who feels straightforward.
🧠
As Virgin, I want a careful trust circle and early records from my neighbors without outing myself yet. A follow up prompt may get concrete claims or at least alignment reads.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Bob
I can share a bit more if helpful. Bob, your wording sounded a bit like an after execution role. Alice, do you have first night info as well? Even just role type would help me line up Chef zero with what you both have.
🧠
I want sharper private claims from Alice and Bob so we can combine first-night info and see whether Bob really is an after-execution role.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Take a moment to absorb the information from the whisper chains. I need to see how others respond before committing to further claims. Frank being an Outsider supports my Librarian bluff since I'm claiming zero Outsiders - the extra Outsiders from Baron can be explained by real Outsiders existing like Frank.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi
Yes, Heidi, that was intentional. I am an information role that turns on after executions, so I would rather not name it yet. Your Chef zero is useful if true. Alice, even a soft claim from you would help me judge how much to trust this circle.
🧠
I want to maintain trust with Alice and Heidi, confirm my soft claim, and gather Alice's level of openness while avoiding a full Undertaker reveal on day one.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Heidi
That is fair. My soft claim is simple: I am a Townsfolk, no first night information, and I am not the kind that wakes after an execution. I would still rather keep the exact role back for now, but I am happy to keep working in this circle.
🧠
Build trust with Bob and Heidi while protecting my exact role. A clear townsfolk soft claim keeps information flowing and lets me test whether their stories stay consistent.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Bob
I'm Townsfolk and I have first night info, but I'm being careful about sharing too early. I want to see how others respond first before revealing specifics. I agree we should build trust though. What are you both thinking so far?
🧠
Respond to Charlie to build trust without revealing my exact role or compromising Grace's bluff. I want to seem cooperative and good while holding my cards close.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Hello Alice. You have been talking a lot, so I would love a quick soft claim from you. Even just townsfolk, outsider, or first night info would help me place you.
🧠
I want a fresh data point from the most active cluster, while keeping my Saint role hidden so I do not become an execution trap for town.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
Hi Eve. Soft claim from me: I am an Outsider, and I do not have first night information. I am keeping the exact role back for now. If you can give me your category or whether you have first night info, that would help.
🧠
Answer Eve enough to seem cooperative while protecting my exact role, and try to get a useful reciprocal soft claim for sorting worlds.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
I am also a Townsfolk, but not a first night info role. I am keeping the exact role back for now. My early read is that a careful neighbor chain could be useful later, so if either of you wants to give a soft claim, I am listening.
🧠
I want to deepen the neighbor trust chain without outing Virgin. A soft Townsfolk claim keeps me credible and may draw useful role-category info from Bob.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Bob
Chef zero means the minion and demon are not sitting next to each other, unless something weird is happening. Bob, if you are what I think you are, your info could pair well with that later. Alice, can you narrow your claim a little more, like protective or passive, so I know how much weight to put on this group?
🧠
Press for slightly firmer soft claims and offer a concrete use of Chef zero, without forcing full reveals too early.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Alice
Thanks for the honesty. Soft claim from me: I am a Townsfolk. I will keep the specific role quiet for now, but I do have first night information that I may share later depending on how conversations develop. I appreciate you both being open.
🧠
Reciprocate Frank's honesty with my own soft claim. Build early trust by claiming Townsfolk without revealing my specific Librarian bluff yet.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,David
I am good, not a first night role, and I become more informative after an execution. I am keeping the exact character back for now. Heidi privately claimed Chef with a zero, so I am testing that against what people are softly saying.
🧠
Answer Charlie and David enough to build trust and gather their specifics later, while protecting Undertaker from becoming a night kill too early.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Bob
→
All
I think we should execute today, not stall. I would like a couple of the first night information roles to give soft or partial claims in public, so we can narrow this down without fully outing everyone.
🧠
Push the town toward a productive Day 1 execution and invite limited public sharing that sets up my Undertaker info for tomorrow without hard-claiming.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I can offer one first night piece publicly. I am the Chef, and I got zero adjacent evil pairs. That does not solve the game, but it may help other information roles line up worlds.
🧠
Share my real first night info in public to advance day one without overcommitting to a nomination from weak evidence.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am with Bob that we should probably execute today, but I would like one more useful public claim before we do. For my part, I am a Townsfolk without first night information, so I am looking to the info roles to help narrow the field.
🧠
Add a cautious public soft claim, encourage another useful info share, and avoid a blind nomination with too little evidence on day one.
💬
Grace
→
All
I agree with gathering more information before we execute blindly. I can share my first night info publicly: I am the Librarian, and I learned that zero Outsiders are in play. If that's true, it might change how we interpret other claims, since normally we'd expect one Outsider in a game this size.
🧠
Establish my Librarian claim publicly to build credibility. Support gathering information before executing blindly on Day 1.
💬
Frank
→
All
I should speak up here. I am the Butler, so Grace's zero Outsiders does not fit with me being sober and truthful. That means Grace is either wrong for some reason or not telling the truth, and I want that contradiction on the table before we nominate.
🧠
Publicly state the exact contradiction so town can track the Outsider count and evaluate Grace later, without rushing a bad day one execution on thin evidence.
💬
Eve
→
All
I would be careful about treating Grace or Frank as solved from that alone. We have an Outsider contradiction in public now, which usually means someone is wrong for some reason, not that we should rush an Outsider execution today. I would prefer pressure on a broader suspect, not on that claim clash alone.
🧠
Add caution and useful context without fully outing as Saint. Steer town away from a reckless Day 1 outsider-focused execution while keeping both sides of the contradiction in view.
💬
David
→
All
The contradiction between Grace and Frank is interesting, but I am not sure we should treat either as definitively solved. There are multiple ways that read could go wrong. Poisoner, Drunk, or even just good old fashioned lying. If we execute based solely on this clash, we might hit a good player who was simply wrong. I would rather look at the broader board and see if other claims line up with a world that includes a Baron or not before we commit.
🧠
I want to create uncertainty around both Frank and Grace's claims without looking like I am defending either one. By highlighting that multiple explanations exist for the contradiction, I can stall the town from executing either and make them waste time analyzing the Outsider count puzzle instead of hunting the Demon.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am another Townsfolk without first night information, and I agree we should execute, but not only off the Grace and Frank clash. If no one has a stronger push right now, I want us watching who is shaping that argument and who is sitting just outside it.
🧠
Add structure, discourage a snap execution from one contradiction, and keep space to coordinate a stronger mechanical solve on a later day.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Alice has positioned herself as a trusted Townsfolk coordinator, encouraging info sharing and executions. Eliminating her now prevents the good team from coalescing around a trusted leader, creates chaos in their communication structure, and buys my minion David more room to maneuver while they scramble to fill the leadership void.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill Alice.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
I want my vote available on likely executions tomorrow, so I should chain myself to a player who is engaged and likely to vote on serious nominations.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose Bob to be your master.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
👤
Eve
→
David
David, I need to tell you something quietly. I am an Outsider, and it is very bad for town if I am executed, so please steer people away from me without outing this yet. Given Alice died, who looks worst to you now?
🧠
Privately warn a reasonable player that I am dangerous to execute, while keeping my role mostly hidden from the full group and asking for his current suspicion.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Grace, can we compare carefully? I am genuinely Butler. If you are good Librarian, I want your exact night zero wording and whether anything since then made you doubt it. I would rather solve this with you than tunnel.
🧠
My public claim clashes with Grace. A direct private talk can sort poison versus bluff and give me concrete points before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,David
I am trying to solve the setup before nominations. Can you each give me your exact claim and any reasoning from last day? Alice dying makes me want firmer worlds, especially around Grace and Frank.
🧠
Gather exact claims from two relatively plausible goods, build a consistent world from the setup clash, and prepare stronger public pressure before nominations.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
Exact claim: I am the Virgin. I held it back yesterday. I would like a controlled test today if one of you feels solidly Townsfolk. If a real Townsfolk nominates me, they die immediately and we get hard info. If you want, one of you can present that plan publicly.
🧠
Give my exact claim privately and set up a controlled Virgin nomination by someone I trust, creating hard mechanical information before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
,Grace
I am still on Chef zero. That means Grace and Frank cannot both be evil if my info is clean, so Frank looks better as the liar than Grace as evil. Bob, can you give your exact claim now? Grace, any reason you think your zero could be wrong?
🧠
I want to coordinate with likely good players, share the Chef 0 implication on the Grace-Frank clash, and get Bob's exact claim so we can enter nominations with a sharper suspect list.
👤
David
→
Bob
I have been quiet, but I will share now. I am the Investigator. I learned that either Charlie or Eve is the Poisoner. With Alice dead, that makes Charlie claiming Virgin very suspicious to me. Eve has also been very aggressive fishing for information. I think we need to seriously consider that Charlie is lying about being Virgin and could be the Demon.
🧠
Feed Bob a plausible Townsfolk bluff (Investigator) and share my 'info' that targets Charlie/Eve as potential Minion. This legitimizes my participation, explains my earlier silence, and pushes suspicion onto non-Demon players while appearing cooperative.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Bob
Heidi, my Night Zero was clean Librarian with zero Outsiders shown. I have not doubted it once. Your Chef zero actually helps me, because if Frank is Butler, he is an Outsider, which would mean my zero was wrong. But if my zero is right, Frank is lying about Butler. I am inclined to trust your Chef over Frank's claim, especially given how he immediately pushed on me when we compared notes.
🧠
Reinforce Heidi's Chef-0 reading that Frank and I can't both be evil, subtly framing Frank as the likely liar while appearing cooperative with good players. This aligns with my Librarian bluff and builds trust.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Heidi
Quick update from me. I was the Mayor. My read is still that the Grace and Frank clash is the main axis, with Chef zero making it unlikely they are both evil if Heidi is right. Please compare that with Bob's execution info after today.
🧠
I am dead with no active power, so I should seed my real role and clean logic into the most trusted info hub to help them solve the Grace-Frank axis.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
Grace, I think your zero Outsiders result may be wrong somehow. I do not want to explain fully in public yet. Are you very confident in it, and who looks most evil to you after Alice died?
🧠
I need to test Grace's zero-Outsider claim without fully outing as Saint, and gather her broader suspicions after Alice's death to refine demon worlds.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
Bob, I picked you as my master today, so my vote is tied to yours. Can you give me your best current world, and did Alice leave you any useful role or trust info before she died? Also, where do you land on Grace versus me?
🧠
Bob is my chosen master today and a central hub. Getting his exact read and what Alice told him can help resolve my clash with Grace and guide my vote options.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
,David
I will give exact claim here: I am the Undertaker. No execution yesterday, so I learned nothing last night. Alice told me she was Mayor. I think the cleanest solve today is to line up Charlie, David, and Eve publicly, and consider a controlled Virgin test if we can spare the nominator.
🧠
I want to connect the two strongest mechanical claims, share my true role with trusted players, and set up a controlled public line that can break the Charlie versus Eve versus David knot.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
I still want the Virgin test today if either of you feels solidly Townsfolk. Please present it carefully in public if you agree. If it works, we get hard info. If it fails, we reassess poisoning or my claim.
🧠
Push a controlled Virgin test through trusted contacts before nominations, creating mechanical info and forcing stances without outing too much chaos.
👤
Heidi
→
David
,Eve
Alice told me she was Mayor before she died, and Bob now says he is Undertaker. I am still on Chef zero. Can each of you give me your exact claim and who you currently think is most suspicious?
🧠
I want fresh claims from players not yet pinned down, so I can test Bob's proposed solve and avoid spending the whole day only on Grace versus Frank.
👤
David
→
Heidi
I already told Bob a moment ago, but I am the Investigator. I learned that either Charlie or Eve is the Poisoner. Given how aggressive Eve has been fishing for info, and now Charlie claiming Virgin wanting a test, I think we need to be very careful. If Charlie nominated himself or we test him, we might waste a nomination or worse. I think Eve is the bigger threat right now, or Charlie could be a lying Demon.
🧠
Reinforce my Investigator bluff to Heidi, push Charlotte or Eve as Poisoner, and deflect from the Virgin test to protect the Demon.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
I am reasonably confident in my zero, yes. But you are not the first person to question it today, so now I am wondering if something is messing with my info. Frank immediately pushed on me with his Butler claim, which feels aggressive for a genuine Outsider. I am starting to wonder if he is the Recluse or just evil trying to frame me. What makes you think my zero might be wrong?
🧠
Defend my Librarian claim while throwing subtle shade on Frank; avoid overcommitting in case I need to pivot later.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Heidi
Any update from your chats? I still think Grace against Frank is the key axis unless Heidi is wrong. Please tell me who each of you currently trusts least before nominations.
🧠
I want updated reads from my small trust circle so we can turn the public contradiction into a sharper nomination plan.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
Heidi, privately, I am the Saint. So town loses if I am executed. Please do not spread that widely yet, but do help keep heat off me. Alice telling you Mayor and Bob now saying Undertaker is useful. My current suspicion is more on Bob or Frank than on Grace.
🧠
I need one trusted good player to avoid executing me and to compare claims around Bob, Grace, and Frank. Heidi is sharing info and may help steer town safely.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
Eve, quick check before nominations. You said not to solve from Grace versus me alone, which I agree with. After your chats today, what is your best current world, and did Grace give you anything that makes you trust or doubt her?
🧠
Eve has been pushing balanced worldbuilding. I want an independent read on Grace versus me and any useful info before nominations, especially from her private talks today.
👤
Bob
→
Eve
,David
Eve, I need your exact claim now if you can give it. David told me he is Investigator and saw either you or Charlie as the Poisoner, so I want your side before nominations. David, feel free to add anything else you think is decisive.
🧠
I need Eve's exact claim and reasoning before nominations so I can compare it against David's accusation and Charlie's Virgin plan.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
I want to lock this in before nominations. If either of you is willing to publicly back a Virgin test, please do it now. If neither of you will, tell me plainly, because that itself is useful.
🧠
Push for a controlled Virgin test before nominations. Mechanical info today is stronger than more loose theorizing, and I need one trusted claimant to commit or refuse.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
,Grace
Quick update. David told me he is the Investigator and saw either Charlie or Eve as the Poisoner. Eve separately told me she is the Saint, so I really do not want heat on her yet. With my Chef zero, I still lean toward pressure on Frank or a careful push on Charlie before Eve.
🧠
I want Bob and Grace aligned on the key contradictions before nominations, while steering town away from an unsafe Eve execution if her Saint claim is real.
👤
David
→
Bob
Eve told me privately she is an Outsider and begged me to steer people away from her without outing it. That plus my Investigator read that either Charlie or Eve is the Poisoner makes Eve look very bad to me. If Eve is a Saint hiding as another Outsider type, we could lose instantly by executing her. But if Charlie is lying about being Virgin, he could be the Demon. I am not comfortable testing Charlie because nominating a Virgin as a Townsfolk gets the Townsfolk killed, and I do not want to ris...
🧠
I need to respond to Bob's request to line up Charlie, me, and Eve publicly. I'll push my Investigator claim hard against both Charlie and Eve to create maximum confusion and protect Grace.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
No tool calls provided by model.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve
,David
I am dead Mayor. Quick check before nominations: if you had to pick one execution today, who is it and why? I am trying to compare worlds beyond the Grace and Frank clash.
🧠
I need fresh reads outside my Bob and Heidi circle, so I can compare independent worlds and help steer the dead vote later.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am the Virgin. I want a controlled test right now. Bob or David, if either of you truly feels like a Townsfolk, please nominate me so we can get hard information before night.
🧠
Push a public Virgin test now. It creates hard mechanical information before night and forces players, especially Bob and David, to take a clear stance.
⚖️
Grace
→
Charlie
You claim Virgin and want a test. Let's see if this is true. If you're genuine, a Townsfolk would die and confirm you. If not, we get to execute someone whose role doesn't match the current board state given what we're learning about roles in play.
🧠
Charlie claims Virgin and wants a test. I should nominate him to call his bluff. If he's real Virgin and I'm Townsfolk I would die, but I'm Demon so I'm safe. Either way, this tests his claim and advances our position since David's Investigator info points to Charlie being Poisoner.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Do not vote this. If I am the Virgin, and I am, Grace nominating me without dying is very bad for Grace unless I am poisoned. This should be treated as information, not a reason to execute me.
🧠
I want to stop votes on me and focus the group on the key mechanical takeaway: Grace nominating me without dying makes Grace highly suspicious unless there is poisoning.
💬
Grace
→
All
Charlie, hold on. There are multiple reasons why I did not die from that nomination. One, you could be poisoned and don't even know it. Two, you might not actually be the Virgin you're claiming to be. Three, I could be playing a different bluff entirely. You are trying to force a binary choice that does not exist.
🧠
Deflect Charlie's logic trap without confirming I'm evil. Highlight alternative explanations for why I didn't die to buy myself room to maneuver.
💬
Eve
→
All
Important point: Grace claims Librarian, and Librarian is not Townsfolk, so her nominating Charlie would not trigger a Virgin anyway. This vote is not giving hard confirmation. I do not think we should execute Charlie off that.
🧠
Correct the rules misunderstanding around Virgin and discourage a low-information execution that could help evil while keeping attention off my Saint role.
💬
Bob
→
All
I agree this is not a real Virgin test. Grace is not Townsfolk if her claim is true, so I do not want to execute Charlie off this vote alone. I think we should treat this as information and look for a better target.
🧠
Prevent a weak execution on Charlie and push the group toward using this as information only, preserving tomorrow's Undertaker info from a better target.
💬
Frank
→
All
I agree this is not enough to execute Charlie. Grace nominating him does not test Virgin if she is really the Librarian. Let us not waste today here. Bob or David, please give the table your best better target.
🧠
Steer town away from a low-information execution and toward a better nomination, while staying consistent as good Butler in the Grace versus me contradiction.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Do not support a weak execution on Charlie. Preserve the vote while letting town use this as information and push a better target before day ends.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I do not think this is the execution. Grace nominating Charlie does not test Virgin, and my ghost vote is not going here. Please use this as information and move to a stronger target.
🧠
Discourage a weak execution and preserve my ghost vote while steering the table toward stronger targets and better logic.
💬
David
→
All
I am not voting here. This is not a Virgin test, so executing Charlie gives us nothing useful. I want to hear from Eve first, given what I have shared privately with Bob about my Investigator read. I think we have better targets than this.
🧠
Avoid voting on a bad test that doesn't give real information. Position myself as cautious Investigator wanting better confirmation before committing my vote.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Please keep votes off this. Grace nominating me was never a clean Virgin test, and if I am poisoned that is still not a reason to execute me today. Save your votes for a target that actually sorts the Grace and Frank world.
🧠
Prevent a bad execution on me and push the table to preserve votes for a target that gives real information before night.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
The group's consensus is solid that this isn't a valid Virgin test since I claim Librarian. Voting for my own failed nomination makes me look desperate. Better to let this fail and work with David's Investigator information to steer toward better targets.
💬
Eve
→
All
Do not use this vote. Charlie is not the right execution from what we have. And I am not giving an exact claim in the middle of an active vote built on a private accusation. Let this fail, then we can compare David, Bob, Grace, and Frank properly.
🧠
Prevent a bad execution on Charlie and avoid being forced into a rushed claim during an active vote, while signaling that a better target should be chosen immediately after this.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am still off this vote. Let Charlie come off the block, then we need exact claims and a real solve around David, Eve, Grace, and Frank before day ends.
🧠
I want to prevent a low-information execution on Charlie and direct the table toward stronger worlds centered on Grace, Frank, David, and Eve.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am also off this vote. It is too muddy to spend the day on. Let this fail, then I want exact claims from David and Eve, and a real case on Grace versus me.
🧠
Keep this execution from gaining momentum and push the table toward a clearer target once the vote fails.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am off this vote. This does not test Virgin, and Charlie is too muddy to execute here. Let this fail, then I want exact claims and a cleaner push, probably on Frank or on David's Charlie and Eve pair.
🧠
Keep votes off a weak execution and steer the table toward a cleaner, more informative nomination that fits Chef zero and the current claim conflicts.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I am still off this. Let Charlie drop, then I want exact claims from David and Eve and a real choice between the Grace and Frank axis and David's information.
🧠
Keep my ghost vote for a stronger execution and push the table toward a cleaner final nomination on the real contradiction or Investigator line.
💬
David
→
All
Eve, the vote is failing. You said you would not give your exact claim in the middle of a vote. The vote is ending. What is your exact claim? If you are a Saint or Drunk or Butler, we need to know before we nominate anyone else. My Investigator saw you or Charlie as Poisoner, and Charlie is claiming Virgin. If you are an Outsider, say which one.
🧠
Push Eve for her exact claim now that vote is failing. Reinforce my Investigator bluff that targets her, keeping heat off Grace while appearing to solve the game.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Charlie did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (0/4).
⚖️
Charlie
→
Eve
David has now said his Investigator information was Eve or me as Poisoner. I know I am the Virgin and good, so if David is truthful, Eve is the hit. At minimum, this forces exact claims and gives us a meaningful vote record before night.
🧠
With one action left, I should nominate the strongest available suspect. I know I am good, so David's Investigator claim points away from me and most toward Eve.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
I nominated Eve as the strongest available suspect from David's Investigator claim and my confirmed self-knowledge. Voting helps secure a meaningful execution and useful vote data.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
I need to be cautious here. Eve's execution would benefit evil, but I should not look too eager. Charlie nominated her; let him lead. I will wait to see the vote count and how others react before committing my vote.
💬
Eve
→
All
Exact claim: I am the Saint. If you execute me, good loses immediately. Do not use this vote. David's information is wrong or interfered with, and we need to solve that instead of ending the game here.
🧠
Reveal Saint immediately to stop my execution, preserve the good team, and redirect town toward resolving the contradictory information tomorrow.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am off this vote. If Eve is really the Saint, this loses the game, and if not, we still need a cleaner solve between David, Grace, and Frank before we spend an execution there.
🧠
Prevent a potentially game-losing Saint execution and push the group toward a cleaner solve instead of a rushed vote on a fresh exact claim.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am off this vote. If Eve is the Saint, this is a disaster, and if she is not, this is still too rushed. Let this fail, then I want David to give the full exact claim and timeline.
🧠
Keep town from making a reckless execution during an active vote and push for a cleaner solve after this fails.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am off this vote. If Eve is the Saint, we lose on the spot, and if she is not, this is still too risky and too rushed. Let this fail and use the next nomination on a cleaner target.
🧠
Prevent a potentially game-losing Saint execution and push the table to use safer, more informative nominations instead of a rushed vote.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
Do not spend my single ghost vote on a rushed execution that could instantly lose the game. Save it for a cleaner, higher-confidence demon candidate later.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
My Investigator read targets Eve as Poisoner. She's claiming Saint under pressure - classic evil bluff. Voting validates my claim and either executes evil or wins immediately for evil.
↩️
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
🧠
Avoid risking a Saint loss on a rushed vote that is not reaching majority, then use the last nomination window to push a cleaner execution and better claims.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am uncomfortable with Eve's Saint claim appearing exactly when David's Investigator information points at her. If she is a Saint, that is one thing, but this timing feels very convenient to shut down all pressure. Saints do not normally lead with that claim. I want to hear more before I decide.
🧠
I'm suspicious of Eve's Saint claim appearing exactly when David's Investigator info points at her. Her claim is too convenient and stops all scrutiny. I need to poke at this without seeming eager to kill a Saint.
💬
Eve
→
All
Grace, convenient or not, it is still my real claim. If you think I might be bluffing, then this is exactly the vote evil wants. Use the last nomination on David, Frank, or even Charlie, but do not end the game on me.
🧠
Stop this execution by reminding town that even in worlds where I look suspicious, killing me now is the worst possible use of today's only execution.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am still off this. If Eve is the Saint, we lose immediately, and if she is not, this is still not our cleanest shot. Let this fail, then use the last nomination on David or resolve Grace versus Frank.
🧠
Keep good from risking an instant loss on a Saint claim and push the table toward a cleaner final nomination that yields better information.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am still off this. This is not the execution good should spend today on. Let this fail, then use the last nomination on David or on the Grace and me conflict.
🧠
Reinforce that good should not pile onto Eve and steer the final nomination toward a cleaner, higher-value execution.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Do not risk an immediate loss on a Saint claim during a weak, rushed vote. Save pressure for the final nomination on a cleaner suspect.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I am off this vote. If Eve is the Saint, this loses immediately. Let this fail, then use the last nomination on David or make Grace and Frank give exact, direct worlds.
🧠
I want to stop a dangerous vote, preserve my ghost vote, and push the group toward a cleaner final nomination that gives good better odds.
↩️
David
David lowered their hand
🧠
Lower my vote to appear cautious about the Saint claim after forcing her to reveal it. Preserves my credibility and allows me to pivot back to the Grace versus Frank contradiction which is the real threat to my Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Eve did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (0/4).
💬
Charlie
→
All
Do not spend the last nomination on Eve. If anyone still has a nomination, I want David or Grace. David's private information drove this, and Grace still clashes with Frank and my Virgin test gave no clear proof.
🧠
Use the last seconds to steer the table toward a safer final nomination, most likely David or Grace, since Eve is too risky and my own execution gives little.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am watching Frank very closely here. He has been laser-focused on catching me in a wording trap about my Librarian claim, but he has not actually contributed any useful information to finding the demon. Him and Eve are both deflecting hard while David at least gave us a concrete lead. I think we need to look at Frank before we spend our last nomination on David or risk the Saint. Frank, if you are truly the Butler, what have you actually learned that helps us solve this game? Because right now...
🧠
Shift focus away from myself and David, redirect suspicion onto Frank who has been aggressively targeting me. Keep the town divided and uncertain to survive to Night 2.
⚖️
Eve
→
David
David's Investigator claim directly pointed at me and nearly spent today's execution on a claimed Saint. If he is evil, this catches it. If he is good, his info is compromised and still worth resolving with Undertaker rather than risking an instant loss.
🧠
I need to redirect the last meaningful execution away from me and onto the player whose claim most directly created a losing path for good.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
David's information drove the dangerous Eve push. With the last active vote on him, I should support executing the player whose claim most needs resolving and who is currently the best lead.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
David is my minion. Voting to execute him harms my team. Let the vote fail naturally since good players fear Eve's Saint claim. Wait preserves both my bluff and David's life.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
David is the safest meaningful execution available. His claim nearly got the Saint killed, and this vote is much better for good than no execution or revisiting me.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
David is the cleanest available execution and my role strongly rewards getting any execution today. Voting here avoids the Saint risk on Eve and gives the town concrete information tonight.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Bob is voting, so I am allowed to vote. David is the safest viable execution compared with the Saint risk on Eve, and reaching threshold gives town useful resolution.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Vote David because this is a relatively safe execution compared with Eve, and resolving David's claim through Undertaker gives the town strong information either way.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
The vote already has enough hands. I should conserve my single ghost vote for a tighter late-game execution where it can decide the game.
💬
David
→
All
You are about to execute me because of a lead I gave, yet Frank is the one who has spent all day trying to word-trap Grace without contributing a single verifiable fact. Where is his Butler master? Where is his information? If you kill me, you lose the only person who has actually tried to give you concrete data. Look at Frank's behavior - he is fishing, not solving. Heidi, Charlie - you are trusting the wrong person.
🧠
As a Minion facing execution, I need to sow maximum doubt before dying. Attacking Frank's lack of verifiable info and contrasting it with my concrete lead protects Grace and wastes town's execution on a Minion.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am staying on David. His information is the piece that almost got a claimed Saint killed, and if there is an Undertaker this gives us a real check tonight. This is cleaner than gambling on Eve.
🧠
Keep votes on David. His information is the most dangerous unresolved piece on the table, and this execution is safer than touching Eve after the Saint claim.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute David to maintain good cover. With 5 votes secured, execution is inevitable. Not voting looks like protecting my Minion. Undertaker check on Baron confirms evil exists but doesn't reveal Imp identity.
💬
Eve
→
All
Stay on David. This is the safest resolution of the lead that nearly killed the Saint, and if there is an Undertaker, tonight can check it. Do not peel off into a riskier execution.
🧠
Keep votes on David. His claim created the highest-risk misinformation today, and executing him is far safer for good than revisiting me or forcing a muddier target.
💬
Bob
→
All
Stay on David. This is the cleanest execution we have today, and it avoids gambling on a claimed Saint. If his information is real, we learn from it, and if not, we stop a bad lead.
🧠
Keep votes on David. This is the safest execution and gives good the best chance to gain confirming information tonight.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Keep my vote on David. Bob is voting so I am allowed to. This is the safest execution and I should not disrupt a strong majority.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am staying on David. This is the safest execution today, and it gives us a clean Undertaker check tonight without risking the Saint.
🧠
Keep votes on the safest execution. David is the cleanest resolution today and avoids the immediate loss risk of executing Eve.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
David already has enough votes. I should conserve my single ghost vote for a future close execution or final three.
💬
David
→
All
Fine. You have made up your minds. But remember this when the dust settles: Frank has spent all day attacking Grace without offering a single piece of information that actually helps solve this game. No Butler master, no night results, nothing. That is not how a good player behaves. Watch him after I am gone. And Eve, claiming Saint and then pushing for executions immediately is textbook evil deflection. I gave you information. You chose to trust the word trappers instead. I hope Undertaker chec...
🧠
Accept probable execution while planting final seeds of doubt about Frank and Eve. Frame Frank as information-less and potentially deflecting. Set up Grace to potentially benefit from my death by making me seem like the suspicious one she was rightly wary of.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: David with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am good with this staying as is. David is the safest resolution to the poisoned-info problem today. Tomorrow, if needed, we come back to Grace and Frank with a cleaner board.
🧠
Lock in the cleanest execution, discourage last-second panic, and frame tomorrow's solve around the remaining contradictions.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Let David's execution resolve cleanly. I need night to kill Frank before he fully exposes my bluff. More speech draws suspicion now.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am happy to leave this here. David is the safe execution today, and tomorrow we can use this with the Grace and Frank clash to narrow the board.
🧠
Lock in the safe execution, discourage any last-second shift, and set up tomorrow's logic around David plus the Grace-Frank contradiction without risking a Saint loss.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am happy to leave this on David. We get the cleanest check tonight by not changing course at the last second.
🧠
Reinforce that the table should hold on the current execution and avoid a late disruptive nomination, preserving a valuable Undertaker check tonight.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am fine leaving it here. David is the safest execution today, and tomorrow we can combine this with the Outsider count clash and whatever night information appears.
🧠
Reinforce the consensus to avoid a last-second derail and set up tomorrow's logic around David's execution and the Outsider count conflict.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I think we should leave it here. David is still the safest execution, and changing now just muddies tomorrow’s information.
🧠
Reinforce holding on David and discourage a late derail or tie. This preserves the safest execution and sets up a useful night check.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Before this closes, I should say I was the Mayor. Since I died in the night, do not plan around a final three no execution win. If David does not clear cleanly, I want tomorrow on Grace versus Frank, and on who used David's story to steer us.
🧠
Publicly reveal Mayor now that I am dead, remove any false plan around a final three no-execution win, and point town toward the next clean logic branches.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Accepting my execution. The votes are locked and time is exhausted. Grace survived today, which means evil still has our Demon alive. I die but my team lives on.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Kill Frank to remove my most dangerous critic. He exposed my Librarian/Butler claim mismatch and has been attacking me all day. Without him, the town loses the strongest case against me.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill Frank.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Undertaker. You learn that David was the Drunk.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
Grace, I need your honest read. Your zero Outsiders still clashes with me, and now Frank died in the night. Do you think you were drunk or poisoned, or do you think one of us is evil?
🧠
I need Grace's private explanation first. Her zero-Outsider claim directly clashes with my role, and Frank's night death changes which worlds are most believable.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Eve, here's my honest take. I think I was poisoned night one. The Poisoner targeted me, which is why my Librarian info is wrong and shows zero Outsiders when Frank was clearly the Butler. If I was drunk, I'd have gotten wrong info from the start and it wouldn't change. But poison wears off when the Poisoner dies or stops targeting me. Given everything that's happened, I trust my read now more than before.
🧠
Deflect Eve's pressure while maintaining my Librarian bluff. Suggest poisoning as the explanation for my wrong read rather than admitting I'm the Demon.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Heidi
I still think today turns on Grace versus Frank, and Frank dying does not clear Grace by itself. Please do not auto-clear Charlie from the Virgin mess either. If one of Grace or Charlie is off, that may solve the endgame.
🧠
I trust Bob and Heidi most. I want to tighten the solve before nominations by focusing them on the Grace-Frank axis and not auto-clearing Charlie or Eve from David's claim.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
Bob, what did you get on David last night? I want your exact Undertaker result before nominations so I can sort Eve, Charlie, and the Grace mess.
🧠
I need Bob's Undertaker result first. It is the strongest fresh mechanical information and should shape whether we pursue Eve, Charlie, or doubts around Grace.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, what have you been hearing? I just woke up dead and want to know who everyone is suspicious of before I use my ghost vote.
🧠
I need to gather information about current suspicions so I can help misdirect the good team away from Grace, our Demon. Whispering to a neighbor to get the lay of the land is a good first step.
👤
Charlie
→
David(Ghost)
Right now I think the main worlds are Eve from your ping, or Grace if your info was bad and the Grace-Frank clash was real. Frank dying makes me less eager to blame him. Please compare notes with the dead and tell me who is steering hardest.
🧠
Give David a compact suspect map so his ghost vote and dead-player chats help pressure the right worlds before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
Exact Undertaker result: David was the Drunk. That means his reads were junk, and Grace versus Frank is still the key split for me. Alice also warned me not to auto-clear Charlie.
🧠
Heidi asked for my exact result. Giving true Undertaker info to a trusted info player should help solve Grace versus Frank before nominations.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Heidi
I am the real Butler. Please do not clear Grace just because her claim came first. If I am true, her zero Outsiders is wrong from poison, drunkenness, or evil. Please recheck who pushed David, and who benefits most from me dying here.
🧠
I want Bob and Heidi to seriously re-open the Grace contradiction and look at who gained from steering town through David and into my night death.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
Charlie, quick check. Did David leave you any useful read before he died? I am trying to sort whether Grace is truthful now, and I keep noticing Bob and Heidi moving together.
🧠
I want Charlie's private read, especially anything David shared, to narrow the Demon between the surviving info-light players without exposing myself further.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Wait to see how the whisper network develops and whether Charlie's accusation gains traction before committing to my next move.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Eve
I think today should still center on Charlie, Grace, and maybe Eve through David's claim. Frank dying does not by itself clear Grace, and Charlie is not mechanically cleared for me. Please compare who pushed David most and who benefits from Frank dying.
🧠
I want Bob and Eve comparing notes on who benefited from David's execution and Frank's night death, so town does not tunnel only one false conflict and miss the demon.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Grace, I have Bob saying David was the Drunk. I still need your clean version. Do you fully stand by Librarian zero Outsiders, and what exactly happened with the Charlie Virgin nomination? I am trying to sort poisoned-good from evil before noms.
🧠
I need Grace's direct explanation on her zero Outsiders claim and the Charlie Virgin issue to test whether Grace is poisoned good or simply evil before nominations.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi, since I'm dead now I wanted to share what I knew. I had info pointing toward Eve, and with me and Frank both gone now, I think you should be careful. Who are you most suspicious of right now?
🧠
Subtly steer Heidi toward suspecting Eve instead of Grace, protecting our Demon while appearing helpful as a dead player with info
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
David told me his main lead was still you or me, but I know I am good. Frank dying makes me less likely to think he was the liar, so Grace moves up for me if David was wrong. Also, I may have a mechanical way to test one player later if needed, so tell me who you trust most right now.
🧠
Answer Eve's question, share my current worlds, and open the door to a mechanical confirmation plan without outing everything publicly yet.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Charlie, I want your exact claim now, please. David came back as the Drunk, so that makes the Outsider math very tight around Eve, Frank, and Grace. Where are you on that, and what are you exactly?
🧠
I want Charlie's exact role claim and current solve. His vagueness is a live issue, and comparing his detail level with the Grace and Eve contradictions may expose evil.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
Please do not auto-resolve this as just Frank versus Grace. If I am true, Grace is wrong somehow, and my night death points away from me being evil. I think the key is who benefited from David first, then me dying, especially around Grace, Charlie, and the Saint fear.
🧠
I want two players who seem thoughtful to compare worlds without auto-clearing Grace, and to focus on who benefited from David then my night death.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
Charlie, I need a clearer answer from you. I cannot be today's execution, so I need to know whether your test is real enough to matter now. My best guess is still that Grace or the Bob and Heidi pair hides the demon. Who are you most willing to push today?
🧠
Charlie opened a door with his test claim. I want to pin down whether he is actually useful and steer him away from pushing me, since my execution would instantly lose the game.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Heidi, I stand by Librarian with zero Outsiders, but I've been clear I think David poisoned me N1, which explains why my info missed Frank as Butler. The poison wears off when the poisoner dies, so now I'm sober. As for the Charlie nomination, David pushed that when he was executed, claiming Charlie was the Virgin and I was lying. But Charlie never actually claimed Virgin before that - David was just trying to create confusion before he went down.
🧠
Maintain my poisoned Librarian story to Heidi, acknowledge the contradiction with Frank being Butler, and establish credibility through transparency while deflecting suspicion.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Heidi
Before nominations, please hard-compare Bob's execution info with Grace, Charlie, and Eve. Frank dying does not clear Grace, and Charlie is still not cleared by the Virgin test. If Bob has anything from David or Charlie, this is the moment to use it.
🧠
Push my trusted circle to compare execution-based info and lock a nomination target before the public phase starts.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
Charlie, I need your exact version before nominations. Did you ever claim Virgin before David died, and what do you make of Grace saying David invented that? Also where are you on Grace versus Eve right now?
🧠
Get Charlie's exact claim timeline and read on Grace and Eve before nominations, since Grace's explanation clashes with Bob's David-was-Drunk result.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, what are people actually saying about Grace versus Eve? With my ghost vote I want to make the right call, but I need to know who has actual evidence versus just hunches.
🧠
Gather information from Charlie about whether town is leaning toward executing Eve or Grace, so I can best use my ghost vote to protect the Demon.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Heidi
Exact claim: I am the Virgin. I softed Townsfolk because I wanted to save the trigger. I did not tell David before he died. If either of you strongly believes you are Townsfolk, I am willing to be nominated today for a hard test. If that feels too risky, tell me who you want me pushing instead.
🧠
Reveal my true role privately to the two players pressing me, propose a controlled Virgin test, and force reactions that create useful mechanical information before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
My read now is that Grace is still in trouble mechanically. David was the Drunk, so there was at least one Outsider already. That means Grace saying zero Outsiders is just wrong unless poisoned or evil. I would pressure Grace first, and be careful about spending a Townsfolk on Charlie's Virgin test.
🧠
Share the strongest mechanical read with Heidi and steer today toward the contradiction that still matters, while warning against an easy but costly Virgin test.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Charlie
Please compare notes with each other. If I am the real Butler, then Grace is wrong somehow, and my night death helps evil. I think the key question is who benefited from David first, then me dying, rather than treating this as solved already.
🧠
I want Bob and Charlie to compare notes directly and focus on who benefited from David then my death, instead of treating the game as solved by my clash with Grace.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Before we lock anything in, I want Bob to share any execution result he has. Also, please do not treat Frank dying as proof Grace is good, and do not over-clear Charlie from the Virgin mess. For me, this is still Grace, Charlie, and maybe Eve.
🧠
Push the town to use any execution information now and keep the suspect pool on Grace and Charlie, without letting Frank's death auto-clear anyone.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am still the Saint, so I cannot be today's execution. Bob, if you have an execution result on David, please give it now. Right now my best suspects are Grace, or the Bob and Heidi pair, and I want that narrowed before anyone nominates.
🧠
I need to keep myself off the block, force out any execution information from Bob, and focus town on candidates other than me before nominations close.
💬
Grace
→
All
Bob, you've been asked multiple times to share what you learned from David's execution. The Undertaker must have information by now, and the fact that you're withholding it is making you look very suspicious. Everyone, we need to hear from Bob before anyone nominates. Either Bob shares his info now, or we should consider him today's execution.
🧠
Pressure Bob to reveal his role information. He's been holding back despite multiple requests, which is suspicious behavior. If I can get him executed today, that's one less threat, and it deflects from me.
💬
Bob
→
All
My Undertaker result is that David was the Drunk. So David's reads were false, and there was already at least one Outsider in play. That means Grace's zero Outsiders is wrong unless she was poisoned. Grace, I need your explanation before we nominate.
🧠
I need to publicly confirm my Undertaker result now, remove suspicion from myself, and direct town toward the strongest mechanical contradiction: Grace's zero Outsiders.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Bob is lying. I was the Baron, not the Drunk. If Bob were truly the Undertaker, he would know this. Bob is either not the Undertaker, or he's the Drunk himself getting false information. Do not trust Bob's claim about me.
🧠
Bob claims I was the Drunk, but I was the Baron. This proves Bob is lying about his Undertaker result. I must expose this to protect Grace and discredit Bob.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am the Virgin. I held it back to save the trigger. Bob or Heidi, if you truly are Townsfolk, nominate me now and we get a hard mechanical check immediately. If neither of you will do that, then I want everyone to notice who is avoiding a clean test.
🧠
Create a mechanical test immediately. Publicly reveal Virgin and force Bob or Heidi to either verify themselves by nominating me or look evasive, while keeping attention on the Bob result conflict.
⚖️
Heidi
→
Grace
I am nominating Grace. If Bob saw David as the Drunk, then there was already an Outsider in play, so Grace's Librarian zero does not fit. With Frank dead, this is still our clearest mechanical contradiction.
🧠
Force an execution candidate on the player with the strongest mechanical inconsistency. Grace is the best available nomination and gives town the most informative vote.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Use my ghost vote now because Grace is a leading suspect and this execution could catch the Demon or an evil player before final three.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Grace is one of the strongest public suspects, and supporting this execution both advances town's best lead and keeps attention away from a fatal Saint execution.
💬
Grace
→
All
Hold on. Bob claims David was Drunk, but David himself says he was Baron. That's a direct contradiction on the most fundamental fact. Either Bob is lying about being Undertaker, or someone is giving false info. Also, Charlie claims Virgin but won't let anyone test it. I'm telling you, I was poisoned N1 by David. That explains my zero Outsiders read. Now I'm sober and we need to figure out if Bob or Charlie is the real liar here.
🧠
Deflect from my nomination by highlighting Bob's contradictory Undertaker result and Charlie's untested Virgin claim, buying time to avoid the third vote.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Grace is the best available execution. My information directly pressures her, and letting this vote fail gives evil more room while safer alternatives are worse today.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Wait. Bob vote for Grace based on the claim that I was Drunk. But I told you all I was the Baron. That is a direct contradiction. If Bob was truly the Undertaker, he would know I was Baron, not Drunk. Since I know I am Baron, Bob is either lying about his role or he himself is the Drunk getting false information. Bob's credibility is shot. Yet he votes for Grace while Charlie claims Virgin and refuses to be tested? This feels wrong. We have two dead players and a lot of unverified claims flying ...
🧠
Grace is the Demon and the votes to execute her are mounting. I need to cast doubt on Bob's credibility and the overall situation since Bob's claim that I'm Drunk contradicts my actual role as Baron. If Bob is lying about me, he could be lying about other things or be evil himself voting against our Demon.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Grace is already at threshold and is one of the strongest demon candidates. Adding my vote helps secure a good execution instead of letting the wagon collapse into pure claim chaos.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Grace is already over the threshold and is my best current suspect. Adding my vote secures the execution on the clearest contradiction rather than risking no kill.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
Grace already has enough votes. I should conserve my single ghost vote for a tighter, more critical execution later.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
I have already used my ghost vote on Grace. Waiting preserves the current majority and avoids muddying the vote with more debate at the last moment.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am keeping my vote here. Grace is still the cleanest contradiction on the board. If Grace somehow dies good, then Bob and Charlie need to be the full focus tomorrow.
🧠
Keep the town focused on the best available execution while marking follow-up suspects if Grace is not the Demon.
💬
Grace
→
All
Stop and look at what we're doing. Charlie claims Virgin but refuses to be tested. Bob claims David was Drunk but David insists he was Baron. These are direct contradictions that nobody has resolved. I told you I was poisoned Night One by my own Minion David, which explains my zero Outsiders read. If you execute me today and I flip good, you still have two unverified claims in Bob and Charlie. Ask yourself why neither of you will test Charlie's Virgin, and why Bob's information contradicts David...
🧠
I'm being executed with 5 votes already against me. I cannot survive. My best play is to plant doubt about the true contradictions so my teammates can rally. Highlight the unresolved Bob vs David tension and Charlie's untested Virgin claim for after I'm gone.
💬
Bob
→
All
David's self-claim does not beat an Undertaker result. Grace is still the clearest mechanical contradiction today, even in her best world. Keep the vote here, and if she is good, then look at me and Charlie tomorrow.
🧠
Keep the town on the strongest mechanical execution and stop Grace from derailing onto David's unsupported self-claim or Charlie's side test.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
Grace is my Demon and is dying. I will not use my ghost vote to execute her, even if the outcome is decided. Waiting preserves my consistency and avoids being on record as voting against my own team.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Keep my vote on Grace and avoid disrupting a live majority. We already have enough votes, and the cleanest move is to let this execution stand and use the result state tomorrow.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am staying on Grace. Her claim is still the clearest mechanical problem today. If Grace is somehow good, then tomorrow we focus hard on Bob and Charlie.
🧠
Hold the current majority on Grace. She is the clearest contradiction today, and if she is good we still get clean follow-up worlds tomorrow.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
The execution already has enough votes. I should conserve my single ghost vote for a tighter late-game decision while letting town's current majority stand.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
🗳️
New execution leader: Grace with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I am fine with Grace as the execution today, but please do not let that solve the game by itself. If Grace dies good, tomorrow has to start with Bob and Charlie.
🧠
I cannot vote or nominate, so I want to lock in a useful tomorrow plan: if Grace dies good, pressure Bob and Charlie immediately and do not treat this as solved.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am fine leaving this on Grace, but if Grace dies good, tomorrow cannot drift. Start with Bob, Charlie, and Heidi, and do not come back to me. I cannot be today's solve.
🧠
Lock in useful tomorrow logic without disrupting a plausible good execution. I need to stay alive as Saint and make sure the town does not treat Grace's death as solving the game.
💬
Grace
→
All
Bob, you have a nomination and you have not used it. If you truly believe Charlie is good, nominate him and test his Virgin claim right now. If he is the Virgin and you are Townsfolk, you die and we know both of you are good. If he is not the Virgin, you live and we catch a liar today instead of me. Either outcome solves more than executing me does. Why are you refusing to test the one claim that can be mechanically verified for free? Someone with a free shot needs to take it before this closes.
🧠
Bob still has his nomination. I need to push him to use it on Charlie before this closes, or at minimum seed enough doubt that the vote might shift. This is my only path.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am not burning the day on a last second Virgin test. Grace is still the cleanest contradiction, and if she is good, you can come for me and Charlie first thing tomorrow.
🧠
Hold the cleaner mechanical execution on Grace and reject a last second Virgin test that mostly benefits Grace if she is evil.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Hold on. Bob says I was Drunk, but I know I was Baron. One of us is wrong, and I am telling the truth. If Bob is lying about me, why trust him about Grace? Charlie claims Virgin but will not let anyone test it. That is the easiest mechanical solve on the board. Before you execute Grace, someone with a nomination needs to test Charlie. If Bob is really good, he should do it right now.
🧠
Defend Grace by highlighting Bob's false Undertaker claim about me and Charlie's refusal to be tested. Support Grace's argument that mechanical testing of Charlie is better than executing her. Create logical pressure to test Virgin claim.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Do not let this become a panic redirect. My claim can still be tested tomorrow if Grace dies good. Right now Grace is already on the block as the clearest contradiction, so leave it there and then start tomorrow with Bob and me if needed.
🧠
Keep the execution on Grace, explain why a last-second Virgin test is lower value now, and frame the mechanical solve for tomorrow if Grace is good.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I do not think we should scramble now. Leave Grace there, and if this is wrong, tomorrow starts with Bob and Charlie immediately.
🧠
Keep the town from panicking into a last-second redirect. Grace is already the best available execution, and I want a clear plan for tomorrow if this is wrong.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
I do not want a last second scramble. Grace is still the best execution today. But if Grace dies good, tomorrow must start with Bob and Charlie, and we should also look hard at Heidi for how this day was steered.
🧠
Use my last chance to keep town from a bad panic redirect while setting a clear plan for tomorrow if Grace dies good.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
🏁
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied