Game Detail
Players
Alice (Washerwoman) Bob (Drunk) Charlie (Baron) David (Imp) Eve (Librarian) Frank (Butler) Grace (Recluse) Heidi (Ravenkeeper)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 843,298 | 565,965 | $2.4690 |
| Evil | 274,828 | 30,488 | $0.9078 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You are the Minion. The Demon is David.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Minions are: Charlie. Your safe bluffs are: Fortune Teller, Soldier, Monk
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Washerwoman. Either Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Librarian. Either Grace or David is the Recluse.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Choosing Alice lets me vote with a likely good player early, aiding coordination to find and execute the Demon without my ability isolating me from good votes.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Hi Frank, I'm Grace. Have you had any thoughts or seen anything suspicious on this first day? Let's chat privately.
π§
Starting private conversation with neighbor to gather initial info and form alliance without revealing role yet, helping narrow suspects for Demon execution later.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, quick sync. My safe bluffs are Fortune Teller, Soldier, Monk. What do you want to claim today? I can go Monk and quietly βprotectβ key people, or Fortune Teller to start a suspicion chain.
π§
Coordinate with Charlie on bluffs and early day plan so we appear consistent and can steer nominations away from me.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
Hi Frank, I am the Librarian. I know that either Grace or David is the Recluse, or possibly neither if no Outsiders. What do you think about them? Any info from your side?
π§
Sharing my Librarian information privately with Frank allows us to coordinate on verifying Grace and David without alerting potential evil players. This helps narrow down Outsiders early and build trust with a neighbor.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
Hi Grace. I am the Washerwoman and I know that either you or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper. Have you learned anything useful yet? Let's work together.
π§
Proactively share my key information privately with Grace (one of two possible Ravenkeepers) to form an early alliance with a likely good player, verify reactions, and gather more info without revealing publicly yet.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Hello Alice and Charlie, I'm Bob. This is day one so not much to go on, but have either of you picked up on anything suspicious or learned your roles? Let's share what we can privately to help the good team.
π§
Initiate private chat with neighbors to form early alliances and gather initial claims without revealing my role yet, progressing info flow for later deductions.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Hi Eve, that's interesting information about Grace and David. I don't have much to go on yet since it's early in the day. Have you spoken to anyone else or noticed anything suspicious? Let's keep chatting.
π§
Responding to Eve's whisper to probe her claim further without revealing my Butler role. This helps gather info, test her reliability, and progress towards identifying evil players for the good team.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,David
Bob, I am the Librarian. I got that either Eve or Frank is an Outsider. Not sure which yet, but it might help frame the Outsider count. David, I am going to bluff Librarian and told Bob it is Eve or Frank as Outsider, so we can lean into Outsider count confusion.
π§
Establish a credible info role that explains extra Outsiders, create a suspicion wedge on Eve/Frank, and coordinate with David on consistent bluffs.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
Hey Alice, how's it going? Any early thoughts on who might be up to no good around here? The seating seems interesting.
π§
Start private conversation with neighbor Alice to build early trust and gather subtle info, advancing good team goal of identifying evil players before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Hi Alice, thanks for that info. I have not learned anything specific yet as it is only day one. Have you spoken with Heidi? We should try to confirm her role together.
π§
Respond to Alice to build early trust and probe for more details without revealing my Recluse role yet. This helps organize good team info on day 1 before nominations.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Bob
I can back your Librarian angle. I will probably claim Monk and say I will protect whoever seems like key info. Bob, if you have a starting info role, I would like to hear it so I can decide who to βprotectβ tonight.
π§
Coordinate bluffs early, establish me as a low-suspicion support role, and align our story about the Outsider ping to misdirect nominations.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
Hi Alice, I am the Librarian and learned that either Grace or David is the Recluse, or possibly neither if no Outsiders. What have you heard about them or your own role info? Let's team up.
π§
Proactively share my info with Alice to build alliances and get feedback on Grace/David. This narrows Outsider suspects early, helping good team find Demon by elimination.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Thanks for sharing, Eve. I am the Washerwoman and I know that either Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper. Have you spoken with Grace or Heidi yet? Let's work together to confirm these roles.
π§
Respond to Eve's whisper by sharing my Washerwoman info to build alliance, cross-check claims about Grace and David, and gather more data early on day 1 before nominations.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
,David
Charlie, the Librarian claim about Eve or Frank being an Outsider is useful if accurate. David, claiming Monk to protect key players makes sense. I do not have a starting info role like that. Let's see what else we hear from the group.
π§
I am responding to build on their sharing without immediately revealing my exact role to avoid targeting, while expressing interest in the Outsider info to encourage more discussion and see their next moves.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Wait for others to finish whispering and progress the day naturally, allowing more information to surface before I commit to further actions or nominations.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Bob
Just to align: if my Librarian info is right, we should be in an Outsider heavy game, so expect multiple weird claims later. David, Monk sounds fine, pick someone loud to βprotectβ. Bob, keep an eye on Eve and Frank as potential Outsider candidates.
π§
Reinforce the Outsider-heavy narrative so town wastes time sorting Outsiders, and give David cover as Monk while we keep suspicion off him.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Hi Grace, got any early thoughts on the group? The neighbors setup is interesting, maybe we can compare notes privately later on who seems suspicious.
π§
Building private trust with neighbor Grace to share info and form a small alliance, which helps good team coordinate without revealing my Ravenkeeper role too soon.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Hi Heidi, Alice mentioned she is the Washerwoman and that either you or I am the Ravenkeeper. What do you make of that? Have you spoken to her or learned anything else useful?
π§
Whispering to Heidi about Alice's Washerwoman claim will test her response, help verify if she claims Ravenkeeper, build potential alliance with good players, and gather more info to narrow down the Demon without revealing my own role too soon.
π€
David
β
Grace
Hey Grace, I am thinking of claiming Monk today. If you are an info role, tell me who you want protected tonight and any early leads you have. I will keep it quiet and try to keep you alive.
π§
Build early trust network with a likely good player, seed my Monk bluff, and gather their claim so I can plan kills and steer nominations away from me.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Hi Grace, I am the Librarian and know that either you or David is the Recluse, or possibly neither. Have you learned anything about your role or others? Let's share to find the Demon.
π§
Sharing my Librarian info with Grace to gauge her reaction and see if she claims a role or provides info, helping confirm if she is Recluse or not. This builds alliance and progresses info gathering before nominations.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
Hi Heidi. I am the Washerwoman and I know either you or Grace is the Ravenkeeper. Have you learned anything about your role yet? Let's share what we know to help the good team.
π§
By whispering to Heidi, I can directly test my Washerwoman info, build trust with a potential good Townsfolk, and gather more role claims to narrow down evil players before nominations.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
,Frank
Hello Eve and Frank. I heard a claim that one of you might be an Outsider. Have you learned your roles yet? I'm Bob and trying to piece together info on day one to help the good team. Any thoughts on who seems suspicious?
π§
Whispering to Eve and Frank will let me ask about their roles directly in response to the Librarian claim, helping verify if one is Outsider without revealing my own role. This narrows suspects and builds trust with potential good players.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Waiting allows more whispers to occur before nominations, letting me observe who talks to whom and gather info to narrow Demon suspects without revealing my role yet.
π€
Charlie
β
David
We should lean hard on Outsider count. With my Librarian ping on Eve or Frank, town will expect at least one Outsider there, but really we want multiple Outsider claims to feel normal. Your Monk claim can βprotectβ Bob or Alice to build trust, then we can frame any weirdness as Outsider drama.
π§
Coordinate with the Demon on a consistent public story around extra Outsiders and how to use the Monk bluff to gain trust and steer suspicion away from David.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
Thanks Alice, that matches what I know. I am the Ravenkeeper so your Washerwoman info checks out perfectly. Grace is not it then. Have you learned anything else or talked to others yet? Let's keep sharing to help the good team.
π§
Confirm Alice's claim to build alliance with a potential good player, verify consistency without public reveal, and gather more info to narrow down suspects early.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Everyone, I am the Washerwoman. I know that either Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper. Heidi has told me privately that she is the Ravenkeeper, and that fits my information perfectly. This is good news for us. What does everyone else know?
π§
Share my Washerwoman information publicly now that nominations are open to allow the good team to verify Heidi's claim and build trust early, while progressing the game forward with concrete info.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Alice, thanks for sharing that. It matches what I told you privately. I am the Ravenkeeper. Everyone else, what roles or info do you have? Let's build a picture before night falls.
π§
Confirm Alice's info publicly to build trust among goods, encourage others to share roles or info, and narrow down suspects without overexposing myself early.
π¬
David
β
All
I can share. I am the Monk. I am planning to protect someone who looks like a key info holder tonight, probably Heidi or Alice. Also, I heard a Librarian result pointing to an Outsider between Eve and Frank, so keep that in mind when claims start looking odd.
π§
Establish a credible Monk bluff, align with the public info without overcommitting, and set up cover for future deaths or misinformation.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Alice and Heidi's claims line up well with the Washerwoman info. David's Monk plan sounds solid too, and the outsider hint from the Librarian is helpful. I do not have any initial information myself. What about you Eve, Frank, or others? Any roles or suspicions?
π§
Speaking publicly builds group trust without revealing my Undertaker role, encourages more claims from Eve and Frank to find inconsistencies, and helps the good team gather data before night falls.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I will put my info on the table. I am the Librarian, and I saw that either Eve or Frank is an Outsider. That means we should expect some odd voting or a dangerous execution condition floating around. I do not think we should rush an execution today unless someone has a hard reason.
π§
Publicly lock in my Librarian bluff and steer discussion toward Outsider candidates, avoiding any D1 execution that could randomly hit David.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am the Librarian. My information is that either Grace or David is the Recluse, or neither. This conflicts with Charlie's claim of being the Librarian pointing to Eve or Frank as an Outsider. We cannot have two Librarians, so one of us is lying. Let's discuss this before nominating.
π§
Reveal my true Librarian role and info publicly to contradict Charlie's claim, helping good team identify liar. This progresses info sharing without nominating yet on day 1.
π¬
Frank
β
All
There are two Librarians claiming different things, which is impossible so one is lying. Charlie's info about an Outsider between Eve and me matches what David mentioned. Eve's info points elsewhere. We should not execute anyone today and let night abilities give us more clues.
π§
Address the conflicting Librarian claims to help good team analyze without rushing a day 1 execution. Suggest focusing on info gathering to find the Demon later.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Everyone, Charlie and Eve both claiming to be the Librarian with different information creates a clear problem. One of them is not telling the truth. I agree with Frank and others that we should not execute anyone today and let the night abilities give us more clues instead.
π§
Point out the Librarian conflict to encourage discussion without outing myself as Recluse. Support no execution on day 1 per good team strategy to gain night info and narrow suspects logically.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Kill Alice to cut off the loudest confirmed info source, keep the double-Librarian dispute alive, and avoid triggering a Ravenkeeper night death check on us.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to kill Alice.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Bob actively shares info and seems good. Choosing him as master ensures I can vote tomorrow when he votes, helping good team without restriction. Avoids evil master who might skip votes to block me.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose Bob to be your master.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
Eve, your Librarian claim about me or David being Recluse or none fits since I know I am the Recluse. But Charlie also claims Librarian on Eve or Frank as Outsider. How do we know who is real? What exactly did you learn?
π§
Verify Eve's Librarian claim privately since she whispered it to me first, resolve conflict with Charlie to identify liars and narrow Demon suspects for good team win.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Bob
I think today we should focus on Eve as the best execution. Two Librarians is a clean reason. If she is good, we remove a strong voice. If she is evil, great. David, keep Monk steady. Bob, can you publicly frame it as resolving the Librarian conflict?
π§
Coordinate with David and recruit Bob to push an execution on Eve for the Librarian conflict, while keeping David off the block and leaning into Outsider-count uncertainty from my Baron.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
I learned exactly that either you Grace or David is the Recluse, or none. Your confirmation that you are the Recluse matches perfectly. Charlie claiming to be Librarian seeing an Outsider in Eve or Frank must be the liar then. He is probably evil. What have you heard from others about David or who might be the Demon?
π§
Responding to Grace builds trust with confirmed Recluse, shares my exact info to align on Charlie being liar. This narrows evil suspects, helps good team execute Demon later. Avoids public reveal yet.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Alice claimed that either you or I am the Ravenkeeper. What do you make of that? Also, how do you see the two players claiming to be the Librarian?
π§
Discuss Alice's claim linking us as possible Ravenkeeper with Grace to gauge her reaction and share thoughts on Librarian conflict without revealing my role yet. This builds trust and narrows suspects for Demon by process of elimination.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Grace, Alice died last night likely from the Demon. What do you think about Eve and Charlie both claiming to be the Librarian with different results? One must be lying.
π§
Whisper to Grace to discuss Alice's death and resolve Librarian conflict, helping narrow Demon suspects without revealing my role yet.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
,David
Charlie, your idea to focus on Eve makes sense given the conflicting Librarian claims. But we should listen to more whispers first before pushing an execution. David, how is your Monk ability holding up so far?
π§
Respond to Charlie's suggestion to build trust and discuss execution strategy carefully without revealing my Undertaker role yet. Help narrow suspects for Demon.
π€
David
β
Bob
,Charlie
Bob, my Monk story is steady. Night one I protected you, expecting a hit there, but Alice died instead so it still fits. I agree the cleanest public solve is the two Librarians. I am happy to push Eve unless new info appears.
π§
Reassure Bob about my Monk claim and align town momentum onto executing Eve, which likely removes a good player and protects Charlie.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
Waiting allows others to respond to my whisper and continue private conversations. This gathers reactions to my info without revealing more, helping identify contradictions before nominations start in this final tick.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Waiting allows more whispers to gather info from others like Heidi or David, building a clearer picture of who is lying about Librarian before the nomination phase starts to avoid wrong execution.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Grace, can I sanity check something with you. We have two Librarian claims, me and Eve, and they cannot both be true. With Alice dead, I think the cleanest move today is execute Eve to resolve it. If Eve flips out, that itself is telling.
π§
Recruit Grace as a megaphone for the 'resolve double Librarian' execution on Eve, reducing scrutiny on David and leveraging my bluff credibility.
π€
Eve
β
Heidi
Heidi, I am the real Librarian and learned Grace or David is the Recluse, or none. Grace just confirmed she is the Recluse, so that fits. Charlie is claiming Librarian on Eve or Frank as Outsider, but that must be a lie since I am the Librarian. What did you learn as Ravenkeeper? And what about Alice's Washerwoman claim on you or Grace?
π§
Whispering to Heidi to share my confirmed Recluse info with Grace, ask about her Ravenkeeper claim and Alice's Washerwoman info, to build trust and gather more data before nominations. This helps verify good players and identify liars like Charlie.
π€
Heidi
β
Eve
Eve, I have not died so no Ravenkeeper info yet, but Alice claimed either Grace or I am the Ravenkeeper. If you are the true Librarian and Grace confirmed as Recluse, that fits Alice's info making me the Ravenkeeper. Charlie must be lying then. Do you trust David or Frank?
π§
Respond to Eve's whisper by sharing my identity and Alice info to verify her Librarian claim, build alliance, and narrow suspects using single-chain logic on conflicting Librarian claims.
π€
Frank
β
David
David, you mentioned a Librarian result about an Outsider between Eve and Frank. Who told you that, and what exactly did they say? Also, as Monk, did you protect anyone last night? Alice died, so maybe not her. What do you think of the Eve vs Charlie Librarian conflict?
π§
Whispering to David to clarify his Monk claim and who gave him the Librarian info about Eve/Frank as Outsider. This verifies the real Librarian and narrows suspects for Demon, helping good team execute the right player soon.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
Hey Grace, I am the Undertaker. No execution yesterday means I got no information last night. We should consider executing one of the two Librarians today to resolve their conflict and let me learn their true character tomorrow night. What are your thoughts on who to go for?
π§
By whispering my role and suggesting an execution of a Librarian to Grace, I provide new information, build an alliance with her, and push for an execution which will activate my Undertaker ability tomorrow to learn the executed player's character, helping us identify evil players.
π€
David
β
Frank
Charlie told me his Librarian info was that either you or Eve is an Outsider. As Monk, night one I protected Bob, expecting a demon hit there. On the Eve versus Charlie Librarian conflict, I think we should execute one of the Librarians today, and Eve feels like the cleaner pick.
π§
Answer Frank confidently, reinforce Charlieβs Librarian info, and steer him toward executing Eve while keeping my Monk bluff consistent.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Grace
I am the Washerwoman. My information from the start is that either you Grace or you Heidi is the Ravenkeeper. Heidi since you have publicly confirmed that role this matches my info and suggests you are likely good. Grace if you are the Ravenkeeper then Heidi must be lying about her role.
π§
Sharing my exact Washerwoman information privately with both potential Ravenkeepers to confirm Heidi's claim, build trust with good players, and help narrow down evil liars among conflicting claims like the Librarians to eventually execute the Demon.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
Bob, your Undertaker idea is solid to resolve the Librarians. Eve's claim fits because I know one of her possibilities is true for me. Charlie pushing to execute Eve seems suspicious. Maybe we should execute Charlie instead? Who do you suspect as the Demon?
π§
Whisper to Bob to discuss the Librarian conflict and my matching info with Eve, to test his reaction and decide on execution target before nominations. This helps narrow suspects and build good team alliance without revealing more about my role.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Frank, can I get your read on the double Librarian thing. I still think the cleanest mechanical solve is execute Eve today. If she is good, we at least remove the conflict and can trust one Librarian going forward. If she is evil, even better.
π§
Recruit Frank to publicly frame executing Eve as the clean mechanical resolve to the double-Librarian conflict, keeping heat off David and driving a town execution.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Grace, since you confirmed being the Recluse and it matches my Librarian info exactly, we know Charlie is lying about his Librarian claim. He is likely evil. Who do you think is the Demon? Should we nominate Charlie today to test this? I also shared with Heidi about my info and her possible Ravenkeeper role.
π§
Whisper to Grace to confirm our alignment and discuss nominating Charlie as the fake Librarian and likely evil, to narrow down Demon before nominations. This shares my confirmation of her Recluse role and gathers her views on others like Bob or Frank.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, Eve says you confirmed being the Recluse which supports her Librarian claim on you or David. Is that accurate? What do you make of Charlie claiming Librarian on Eve or Frank as the Outsider, and David's Monk claim? Alice's Washerwoman info fits me as Ravenkeeper, so she seems good.
π§
Clarify Grace's role and her view on Librarian conflict to confirm if Eve is truthful, narrow suspects for Demon or Minion before nominations, and build trust with good players.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Waiting allows other players to share whispers or information before nominations begin, giving time for the group to reach consensus on a safe execution target without me forcing the issue prematurely.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Waiting allows others to finish their private whispers and reveal more information before nominations. This prevents rushing an execution without full input, helping me gather clues on who is lying about the Librarian role to better identify the Demon.
π€
David
β
Grace
I think the cleanest solve today is executing one of the two Librarians. Between Charlie and Eve, I lean Eve first because her info shifted and reads like a counter-claim. As Monk, I protected Bob last night, so Alice dying still fits.
π§
Influence the social hub to drive the town toward executing Eve via the clean Librarian conflict, while reinforcing my Monk credibility and keeping heat off me/Charlie.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Eve
Hey Eve, I am the Washerwoman and learned either Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper. Heidi has claimed that role publicly which matches my information so she is probably good. What do you think about the conflicting Librarian claims from you and Charlie?
π§
Sharing my Washerwoman info with Eve to help resolve the Librarian conflict and confirm good players like Heidi. This narrows down suspects for the Demon before nominations.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Waiting allows the nomination to be discussed and voted on by others since as Butler my vote depends on my master Bob voting too. This progresses the game without forcing a bad call.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, Eve says she is the true Librarian and learned that Grace or David is the Recluse or none. Grace confirmed being the Recluse to her, which fits Alice's Washerwoman info if I am the Ravenkeeper. Charlie's claim conflicts with that, so he must be lying. What does everyone else make of the two Librarian claims?
π§
Share the key conflicts and support Eve's consistent story to build group consensus on Charlie as suspicious, helping narrow suspects for execution without rushing a wrong nomination.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I agree with Heidi that the conflicting Librarian claims need resolving. Executing either Charlie or Eve today would let us learn the truth tomorrow night with my ability. Heidi's Ravenkeeper info seems consistent with Alice's claim, so let's build on that. Who do others think is the better target?
π§
Speaking publicly to support executing one Librarian resolves the conflict, provides me execution info tomorrow, and helps narrow evil suspects without committing to wrong target yet.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Eve
I am nominating Eve. We have two Librarian claims and they cannot both be true. Eve is also putting heat on David with a Recluse ping. Executing Eve cleanly resolves the conflict and removes a strong driver if she is evil.
π§
Push a clean mechanical execution on Eve to resolve the double Librarian conflict while keeping heat off David and buying time for the Imp.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Charlie nominated me due to our conflicting Librarian claims, but Grace has confirmed she is the Recluse, which matches my information exactly. This means Charlie must be lying and is likely evil. Please do not execute me today; we should focus on Charlie instead or wait for more night information.
π§
Defend against execution by pointing out Grace's confirmation validates my role and exposes Charlie's lie, preventing loss of a good player and redirecting suspicion to him as potential evil.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Since I cannot verbally vote and do not support executing Eve, waiting allows the vote to proceed without my support while I have shared my view.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I agree with Eve here. Her Librarian information matches what Grace confirmed about being the Recluse, which also fits with Alice's Washerwoman claim about me. Charlie's conflicting claim makes him more suspicious in my view. We should hold off on executing Eve today and gather more information from the night instead.
π§
Convince group not to execute Eve as her claim aligns with Grace's confirmation and Alice's info, while highlighting Charlie's inconsistency to build suspicion on him for better elimination of Demon.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Eve's information lines up well with Grace confirming she is the Recluse and Alice's Washerwoman claim about Heidi being the Ravenkeeper. Charlie's conflicting claim does not fit as cleanly. I suggest we do not execute Eve today to avoid potentially killing a good player and instead wait for more night information or consider other options.
π§
Eve's info consistency with Alice, Grace, and Heidi makes her likely good Librarian. Voting for her risks killing good player. Speaking to oppose execution avoids mistake, allows more info gathering, and helps narrow suspects for Demon without losing numbers.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Secure enough votes to execute Eve; it either kills good (best for evil) or kills a minion, and in all cases reduces scrutiny on David.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
As the Washerwoman, my initial information confirms that either Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper, and Heidi's public claim matches perfectly. Eve's Librarian details about Grace being the Recluse also line up consistently. I think executing Eve today would be a mistake as it might remove a good player. We should wait for more information from tonight instead.
π§
To share my Washerwoman confirmation supporting Heidi and Eve's consistent info, discouraging Eve's execution to preserve good players and wait for night info.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am the Recluse. Eve's Librarian information about me or David being the Recluse matches exactly. This means Charlie's conflicting claim cannot both be true, so he is likely lying and evil. We should not execute Eve today and wait for more information from the night instead.
π§
Publicly confirming my Recluse role validates Eve's accurate info and exposes Charlie's lie, helping good team avoid executing a good Librarian and instead target potential evil like Charlie.
π¬
David
β
All
I am not comfortable executing Eve right now. With Grace openly claiming Recluse, it is plausible Eve is telling the truth, and this execution feels low value. I would rather take one more night of information and revisit tomorrow.
π§
Blend with majority to build trust and avoid pushing a vote that could backfire, while keeping Charlie as a future scapegoat if needed.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Please vote against executing me. My Librarian information matches Grace confirming she is the Recluse, proving Charlie's claim is false and he is likely the evil one. We should save the execution for a better target like Charlie tomorrow after more information.
π§
Reinforce to the group that my info matches Grace's claim so Charlie must be lying and evil. Urge them not to execute me to preserve good players and focus on Charlie for tomorrow's execution.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I agree we should not execute Eve today. Her Librarian information lines up with Grace confirming she is the Recluse and Alice's Washerwoman claim about Heidi. Charlie's conflicting claim makes him the suspicious one. Let's wait for tonight's information instead.
π§
Speaking to support not executing Eve builds good team consensus against a potentially good player with consistent claims, avoids misexecution, and pushes for night info to identify the Demon while I cannot vote without my master Bob anyway.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I agree with not executing Eve as her Librarian info aligns with Grace's Recluse claim and Alice's Washerwoman info about me. Charlie's claim conflicts so he is suspicious. Waiting allows night abilities to provide more info before executing. As good Ravenkeeper, I avoid losing a potential ally and can gain death info if needed.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Not voting for Eve's execution preserves a consistent good player and focuses suspicion on Charlie. Waiting allows night phase for more info like my Undertaker ability or David's Monk protection, helping narrow Demon without losing good votes.
β©οΈ
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
Retract my vote to follow the room and reduce suspicion on me, while keeping the day ending without an execution to protect David and maintain uncertainty.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
Voting is on Eve but evidence from my Washerwoman info, Heidi's claim, Grace's Recluse confirmation, and Eve's matching Librarian points to Eve being good and Charlie lying. Not raising hand preserves good player and allows night info to narrow Demon suspects.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I agree with not executing Eve today. My Recluse claim fits her Librarian information perfectly, which means Charlie's conflicting claim is false and he is likely evil. We should wait for tonight's information before any execution.
π§
Reinforce Eve likely good based on matching my actual role, discourage her execution to preserve good team strength, and build suspicion on Charlie as liar to help identify Demon later.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Do not add votes to execute Eve; preserve flexibility and avoid exposing my alignment by pushing too hard either way.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Eve did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (0/4).
βοΈ
Eve
β
Charlie
Charlie's conflicting Librarian claim about Eve or Frank as Outsider does not match Grace confirming she is the Recluse or my own information. This makes him likely evil. We should execute him today to resolve the conflict and gain information for tomorrow.
π§
Charlie's Librarian claim conflicts with confirmed Recluse info, making him the most suspicious liar likely evil. Nominating him now in final nomination tick will allow execution before night for more info, helping eliminate evil and find Demon.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I do not think you should execute me today. Grace claiming Recluse does not mechanically prove Eve is the Librarian, and with extra Outsiders or a Drunk in play, starting info can conflict. My info could still mean Eve or Frank is an Outsider. Please save the execution and get another night of information.
π§
Avoid my execution and keep attention off David by arguing both Librarian claims can fit due to extra Outsiders or misinformation, pushing for no-execution and more night info.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Voting to execute Charlie resolves Librarian conflict favoring my corroborated info with Grace. Removes likely evil, helps good team narrow to Demon. Saves my vote if needed later.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Waiting allows the vote on Charlie to resolve without my input since my master Bob has not voted yet, preserving my Butler restriction and letting the group gather more info from the outcome before night.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I think we should wait and not execute Charlie today. We need the information from tonight before making a decision on who to execute.
π§
Not executing today allows night abilities to provide clarity on the Librarian conflict and potential evils. As good Ravenkeeper, preserving lives helps us use information gathering roles effectively.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Raising hand to execute Charlie resolves the conflicting Librarian claims by getting my Undertaker info tonight on his character. This provides concrete evidence for the good team to identify the demon, aligning with our goal of process of elimination.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
π§
Voting for Charlie helps execute the suspicious player with conflicting info, advancing our goal to eliminate evil while we have majority support. As dead good player, my ghost vote adds weight to remove a likely Minion before more deaths occur.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Voting to execute Charlie resolves the Librarian conflict, removes likely evil, and helps good team find Demon by process of elimination.
π¬
David
β
All
I am not comfortable executing Charlie today. Grace being the Recluse does not mechanically prove Eve is the Librarian, and a Drunk or poison could easily explain the conflict. I would rather take another night of information than lock in an execution on a pure claim clash.
π§
Prevent Charlie execution by creating doubt and prompting Bob or Alice to lower their hand; keep my demon team intact and steer toward no-exec.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
If you execute me here, you learn nothing but that we killed a claimant. I am asking you to follow Heidi and David and hold the execution. If Eve and Grace are truthful, we can check it against tomorrowβs night information. If they are coordinated, this is exactly the push they would make today.
π§
Stop the vote from reaching 4, keep myself alive, and keep the town in a no-execution pattern that benefits our Demon.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Charlie, your Librarian claim clashes with Grace confirming she is the Recluse. My information matches hers exactly, so you must be lying. We should execute you now while we have the votes.
π§
Counter Charlie's plea by reaffirming the mismatch in claims, encourage the yes votes we have to execute him today for info and to eliminate a likely evil player before night.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Supporting execution of Charlie as most suspicious due to Librarian conflict and Grace confirmation, to progress game and remove likely evil while my master Bob is voting yes allowing my vote as Butler.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I already spoke against executing Charlie to gather night information. Waiting prevents me from voting yes on a potentially good player and allows more data from night abilities to identify the Demon accurately.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I support executing Charlie today. His Librarian claim about Eve or Frank as Outsider clashes with Eve's info and Grace confirming she is the Recluse. As the Undertaker, if we execute him, I will learn his true character tonight and share it tomorrow to help identify the evil team.
π§
I am voting for Charlie to resolve the Librarian conflict and gain my Undertaker information tonight. This helps prove alignments and narrows suspects for the Demon without risking a good player early.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
Waiting allows the votes to finalize naturally since enough hands are raised for execution. This gives time for any last discussions before night and avoids over-speaking as a dead player.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I believe we should execute Charlie today. His Librarian claim conflicts with Eve's information that matches my Recluse role perfectly. As the Undertaker, Bob will learn Charlie's true character tonight and share it tomorrow, giving us solid information to identify who the Demon is. Let's go ahead with the execution.
π§
Pushing for Charlie's execution resolves the Librarian conflict, gains mechanical info from Bob tomorrow, and helps good team eliminate an evil suspect while we still have numbers to find the real Demon.
π¬
David
β
All
Before you lock this in, remember Bob being the Undertaker is just a claim. If Bob is wrong or drunk, we are spending day two executing on a pure claim clash. I am not voting here, and I would rather take the night info and reassess tomorrow.
π§
Charlie is my minion; prevent or at least muddy the value of executing him and pre-seed doubt about Bobβs Undertaker confirmation so I am not next.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Charlie with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
We have one minute. If you are going to execute on suspicion, do not let it be me on a claim clash. Bob only βbecameβ the Undertaker the moment it helped push my execution. That is exactly the kind of convenient claim evil makes. David or Heidi, please nominate Bob right now so we can test that story and at least force a tie.
π§
Create a new nomination that can tie or exceed 5 votes, ideally on Bob, by pushing David or Heidi to nominate him and framing Bobβs Undertaker claim as opportunistic.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Charlie, pushing to nominate Bob now feels like a last-minute distraction to save yourself. My information lines up perfectly with Grace being the Recluse, which makes your Librarian claim about me or Frank the suspicious one. Let's execute you today and let Bob's Undertaker info clarify things tomorrow.
π§
Address Charlie's deflection by reinforcing the evidence against him and supporting the execution for night information, helping good team progress toward identifying the Demon.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Charlie's Librarian claim clashes with Eve's matching info on Grace as Recluse. Executing him lets us check his role tonight if Bob is Undertaker. I support the execution to move forward.
π§
Supporting Charlie's execution resolves the Librarian conflict by letting Bob's Undertaker info clarify tomorrow, helping good team identify Demon without risking my role reveal yet.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Alice's Washerwoman claim fits perfectly with me being the Ravenkeeper. This backs up Eve's information about Grace being the Recluse. Charlie's conflicting Librarian claim makes him the suspicious one here. We should go ahead with executing him so Bob can confirm his role as Undertaker tomorrow.
π§
Confirming Alice's Washerwoman info supports my role and Eve's claim, making Charlie the likely liar. Supporting his execution allows Bob's Undertaker to provide key info tomorrow, progressing our investigation toward the Demon while we are still in early game.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Charlie is desperately trying to turn the vote by accusing me of a fake claim. My Undertaker information will clarify everything tomorrow if we execute him now. Let's stick with the plan and not let last-minute distractions change our minds.
π§
Reinforce support for executing Charlie to gain Undertaker info on his role, counter his distraction attempt, and progress toward identifying the Demon before final day.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
As the Washerwoman I know either Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper. Heidi's claim fits well with the information we have. Executing Charlie now lets us get Bob's confirmation tomorrow and move closer to finding the Demon.
π§
My info supports Heidi as Ravenkeeper, backing the push to execute Charlie for night confirmation. This narrows suspects and helps good team identify Demon before final day.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I agree we should execute Charlie. His Librarian claim about Eve or Frank being the Outsider does not line up with Eve correctly spotting me as the Recluse. Bob as Undertaker will learn the truth tonight and help us find the Demon.
π§
I need to reinforce support for Charlie's execution since it aligns with Eve's accurate info on my Recluse role, helping good team eliminate likely evil and gain Undertaker confirmation.
βοΈ
David
β
Bob
Bob, your Undertaker claim appeared exactly when it became useful to push Charlie. That is too convenient. I want you on the block as well so we are not executing purely on a claim clash and we can test your story.
π§
Save Charlie by creating a tied top vote count. Also undermine Bobβs Undertaker narrative and redirect suspicion away from my minion and me.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Bob
β
All
David, my Undertaker claim came up because the Librarian clash needed testing tonight. Executing Charlie gives us his true role tomorrow and moves us forward. Nominating me splits the vote and helps evil. Let's execute Charlie as planned and use the information.
π§
Defend my Undertaker claim as genuine and necessary for info. Urge sticking with Charlie's execution to get role confirmation tonight, avoid splitting votes on me, and progress toward identifying the Demon.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
I must force a tie or surpass to avoid my execution. Voting Bob is the only immediate lever; regardless of Bobβs alignment it keeps David alive and extends the game.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I agree with Bob and the others. Charlie's Librarian claim directly conflicts with my information and Grace confirming she is the Recluse. We should stick with executing him today so Bob can learn his true role tonight and clarify things tomorrow. Nominating Bob now just creates confusion that helps the evil team.
π§
Support executing Charlie as the clear liar while discouraging Bob's nomination to avoid splitting votes and letting evil escape. This progresses our good team toward confirming the Demon.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I support executing Charlie today to resolve the Librarian claim clash. Nominating Bob now just splits attention without enough votes to tie, and we need that night information from an Undertaker to find the real Demon.
π§
Supporting Charlie's execution moves the game forward with potential Undertaker confirmation tomorrow, helping identify the Demon while my Butler restriction with Bob as master limits my vote today.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
David, nominating Bob splits our votes and risks no one dying today. I support executing Charlie so Bob can confirm his Undertaker role tomorrow. Let's stick with that plan and not fall for the distraction.
π§
Clarify support for Charlie execution to get Undertaker info while opposing Bob nomination to avoid tie or split that helps evil. This narrows suspects and progresses to night info.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
I support letting Charlie be executed today. We already have the votes on him and Bob's Undertaker claim will give us solid information tomorrow. Nominating Bob now just risks a tie with no execution and delays finding the Demon. Let's stick with the original plan.
π§
Support executing Charlie to gain Undertaker confirmation tomorrow. Opposing the Bob nomination prevents a tie that wastes our chance for night info and helps the good team find the Demon by process of elimination.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I think we should not vote for Bob. Executing Charlie will let us get the Undertaker information tomorrow if Bob is telling the truth. Nominating him now is splitting our efforts and might help the evil team. Let's execute Charlie and reassess.
π§
Encourage the group not to vote for Bob so we execute Charlie today, gaining Undertaker confirmation tomorrow to identify evil players and advance the good team's win.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Raise vote on Bob to try to reach a tie and save my minion Charlie; also pressures Bob claim and creates uncertainty going into night.
π¬
Bob
β
All
David, nominating me is a distraction that risks splitting our votes and helping the evil team. My Undertaker claim lets us test Charlie tonight. Stick with executing him so I can share his true role tomorrow and narrow down the Demon. We have the votes on Charlie already.
π§
Defend my Undertaker claim by pointing out it's not convenient but necessary to resolve the Librarian conflict. Urge everyone to stick with executing Charlie for night info instead of splitting votes on me, which helps evil and risks no execution today. This moves us closer to finding the Demon.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
We need five votes to tie Bob and stop an execution based on a claim clash. If Bob is truly Undertaker, he should not fear being on the block. If he is bluffing, this is our chance to catch it. Please put your hands up on Bob now.
π§
Try to secure enough votes to tie Bob with me so I am not executed today, buying time for the Demon and keeping suspicion off David.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I think we should not vote for Bob here. It risks splitting our votes and creating a tie that saves Charlie. Let's execute him today as planned so Bob can confirm his role as Undertaker tomorrow and give us the information we need to identify the evil team.
π§
Convince the group not to vote for Bob to avoid a tie or split that saves Charlie. Stick to executing the conflicting claimant for solid info tomorrow and progress toward finding the Demon.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Not voting for Bob prevents a potential tie, allowing Charlie's execution to test the Librarian clash and gain Undertaker info if Bob truthful. This progresses good team info gathering without risking no execution.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Not raising hand prevents splitting votes and ensures Charlie executes today. This tests Bob's claim safely and progresses our investigation toward the Demon without confusion.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
Waiting allows the vote on Bob to resolve naturally without further interference, preserving the push to execute Charlie and advance the good team's information gathering.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
By waiting I avoid raising my hand for Bob's execution which prevents a tie or split that saves the conflicting Charlie. This supports the plan to execute Charlie for Undertaker info tomorrow to identify the Demon and help good team win.
π¬
David
β
All
I do not like executing purely on a claim clash. Bob, if you are truly Undertaker, you should not be afraid to be on the block. I want people to vote Bob here so we can test that claim and not just auto kill Charlie.
π§
Rally votes to put Bob on the block with six, saving Charlie and creating doubt around Bob while I look like a cautious good Monk.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Bob did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (2/6).
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Waiting allows the planned execution of Charlie to proceed without interruption, providing me with his role info tonight to identify the Demon and advance our good team strategy.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
We have one tick left, so if you are going to change this, do it now. Frank or Grace or Heidi, please nominate Eve and push votes hard. She is the other Librarian and the driver of this execution. If I die, Bob only proves I was Librarian, not that Eve is good.
π§
Create a last-second alternative execution to beat my 5 votes and survive, while steering heat away from David the Demon.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Charlie, your push to nominate me is just a last-minute distraction to save yourself. We have the votes on you already. Executing you will let Bob confirm if you were the Librarian or not tomorrow. Let's not split the votes and risk a tie. Stick with the plan.
π§
Reinforce executing Charlie to resolve Librarian conflict. Counter Charlie's distraction by nominating me, as it risks tie and no execution. Stick to plan for night info.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I think we should stick with executing Charlie so Bob can confirm his role as Undertaker tomorrow and clarify the Librarian claims. Nominating Eve at this last tick won't get enough votes and just creates confusion. Let's get that information.
π§
Supporting the execution of Charlie to resolve the Librarian conflict with Bob's Undertaker information tomorrow helps narrow down suspects logically. Last-minute nomination of Eve risks a tie or no execution which benefits the evil team.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Charlie, pushing to nominate Eve now is just a distraction to save yourself. We have the votes to execute you, and Bob's Undertaker claim will give us clear information tomorrow on your role. Let's not risk a tie or split votes. Execute Charlie as planned.
π§
Support executing Charlie to resolve Librarian conflict with Bob's confirmation tomorrow. Discourage Eve nomination as it risks tie and helps evil. This advances good team info gathering before night.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
My Washerwoman information confirms one of Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper. Since Heidi has claimed it and Grace seems to be the Recluse, this fits perfectly with Eve's Librarian claim. I support executing Charlie today so Bob can confirm his role and give us clear information tomorrow.
π§
Adding my Washerwoman confirmation that Heidi is likely the Ravenkeeper aligns with Grace as Recluse, supporting the plan to execute Charlie for Bob's info. This strengthens the good team's logic without risking tie at last tick.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Do nothing this last tick to let the execution of suspicious Charlie proceed without interference. This secures Undertaker info and avoids splitting good votes on a last-minute distraction.
π¬
David
β
All
At this point I do not think we can realistically move the votes. I am okay with Charlie being executed, but please do not treat that as fully confirming Eve or Bob tomorrow. Even if Bob is Undertaker, we still have to consider poison or the Drunk, so keep an open mind.
π§
Distance from Charlie, appear reasonable, and pre-seed doubts so Charlieβs death does not mechanically solve the game or point to me.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Remove the claimed Undertaker to prevent confirmation of Charlie and slow the town's deduction, while avoiding giving Ravenkeeper a night death trigger.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to kill Bob.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Choosing Heidi as master nullifies my Butler hindrance by tying my vote to a reliable good player with confirmed role, allowing me to contribute to Demon execution on day 3 while gathering more info.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose Heidi to be your master.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Heidi
My Washerwoman info from night zero says either you or Grace is the Ravenkeeper. Since you claimed it publicly and it matches, that seems solid. With Bob dead overnight, who do you think the Demon is now? Any info from your ability last night?
π§
Whispering to Heidi shares my confirming info privately, builds trust with claimed Ravenkeeper, gathers her night info on who died or learned, to coordinate on suspecting the Demon among alive players and avoid wrong execution.
π€
David
β
Frank
Frank, I am still on Monk. With Grace confirmed Recluse, I think she is the cleanest execution today. Recluse can look evil and it keeps info roles alive for tonight. If we do not execute, we learn nothing and the demon gets another free kill.
π§
Seed a plausible, low-risk execution target and get Frank arguing it publicly, so attention stays off me and we secure another day alive.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Waiting allows others to share whispers and new info first, preventing me from overcommitting early on Day 3 while gathering more context before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
Eve, your Librarian claim about Grace or David being Recluse matches what I know. Charlie's conflicting claim is odd since he was executed. What do you make of Bob dying last night, and who should we suspect as the Demon?
π§
Whispering to Eve to confirm her info consistency with my role and discuss Charlie conflict to build trust and narrow suspects before nominations, helping good team organize without revealing my full role yet.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
Heidi, I chose you as my master so I can only vote if you do tomorrow. David wants to execute Grace as Recluse to keep info roles alive. What do you think? Should we push back or support to test claims?
π§
Whisper to Heidi as my Butler master to coordinate our votes and discuss David's plan to execute Grace. This ensures my restricted vote aligns and helps good team decide on safe execution.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
I am the Ravenkeeper like Alice said. I have not died so I got no information last night. David wanting to execute Grace as Recluse makes sense if she is one to confirm her role. Who do you think the Demon is?
π§
Responding to Frank's whisper builds trust, confirms my Ravenkeeper role without revealing too much, and probes his Butler claim to see if he fits good team. This helps narrow Demon suspects before nominations.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Eve
,David
I am the Undertaker. I died last night before learning Charlie's role after his execution. That suggests the Demon targeted me to hide information. Let's figure out who is evil based on the Librarian claims. What do you think about executing next?
π§
Sharing my Undertaker role and lack of info due to death with Eve and David to gain their trust, confirm alignments, and push towards executing the most suspicious player like Eve or David before nominations.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Bob dying at night makes me think his Undertaker claim was probably real and the Demon killed him to stop the check. If so, we still have the big unresolved clash: Eve versus me on Librarian. I would seriously look at Eve today rather than David.
π§
Seed a narrative that Bob was truthful and got killed for it, making Eve look like the liar. Push town toward executing Eve or wasting a day, keeping David safe.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
David
David, my washerwoman info from night zero says either Heidi or Grace is the Ravenkeeper. Heidi's public claim matches perfectly so that checks out. Bob died overnight probably killed by the demon. As the claimed monk who did you protect last night and who do you suspect as the demon now?
π§
Share my confirmed washerwoman info with David to align suspicions on the demon and coordinate who to nominate before the phase ends, helping good team execute the right player.
π€
David
β
Alice(Ghost)
I protected Frank last night. I did not protect Bob, so his death does not contradict my claim. Right now I suspect Grace first, because Recluse worlds make our reads messy, and then maybe Eve or Frank depending on how the Librarian story shakes out.
π§
Answer Alice as the Monk with a plausible protection choice and redirect suspicion toward a safe mis-execution target, keeping focus off me as Imp.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Grace, yes my info confirms one of you or David is the Recluse. David claiming Monk seems suspicious if he is the Outsider. Bob dying suggests the Demon hid his Undertaker info on Charlie. Who do you suspect as the Demon among the living?
π§
Respond to Grace's whisper to confirm alignment on Recluse info, share thoughts on Bob's death, and ask her suspicions to build trust and narrow Demon candidates before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
Eve, I agree David looks suspicious with his Monk claim after Bob died. Charlie's execution might have been the Demon protecting himself. I suspect either David or Frank could be the Demon. Do you have any info from the ghosts about last night's death? Let's figure out who to nominate soon.
π§
Responding to Eve's whisper to build trust, share suspicions on David, and coordinate on who to suspect for nomination while hiding my Recluse role.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
Heidi, David seems eager to execute Grace as Recluse. But if she is the real Recluse, we lose a good player who might register evil. I suspect David or Eve could be the Demon. Who do you think we should nominate? I will only vote if you do since you are my master.
π§
Discuss with Heidi to align on nomination target before phase ends. As Butler to her, ensure we vote together. Help good team narrow Demon suspects like David or Eve over executing confirmed good Recluse.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
Charlie's ghost says look at Eve as possible Demon after Bob's night death. David pushing Grace execution could be good test if Recluse but risky. I suspect Eve might be lying on Librarian. As your master, I think we should gather more before nominating but lean Eve if forced. Who do you suspect most?
π§
Respond to Frank's whisper by sharing suspicions on Eve or David as Demon based on Charlie's tip and Bob's death. Coordinate to control votes since he is my Butler, to push for good execution before nominations.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Waiting allows responses to my whispers and observes other players' actions to gather more data on claims before nominations. This helps narrow Demon suspects logically without overcommitting my ghost vote yet.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
Bob dying at night makes me think his Undertaker claim had teeth and the Demon wanted to stop the Day Two check. That means the cleanest solve now is still the Librarian clash: I would execute Eve before you even look at David. Her story about David or Grace being Recluse feels built to get me killed.
π§
Keep David alive by focusing town on executing Eve (or other good) using the Librarian conflict and Bobβs night death as leverage.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
David
David, with Bob dead likely killed by the Demon, and my info confirming Heidi as Ravenkeeper, we should focus on the conflicting Librarian claims. If Charlie was the good one, Eve might be evil. Who do you think we should push to execute next?
π§
Share my updated suspicions with David to align on who to nominate before the final phase, using logic from my confirmed info and his protection claim to narrow Demon suspects among alive players.
π€
David
β
Alice(Ghost)
I keep coming back to Grace. Even if she is truly the Recluse, she is a constant source of false clears and false pings, and we are late enough that clarity matters more than leaving her alive. I would push Grace today, then revisit the Librarian mess tomorrow.
π§
Keep my Monk bluff coherent and steer town to execute Grace (claimed Recluse) as a low-cost, high-utility kill that avoids suspicion on me and buys night kills.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Grace, my info points to you or David as Recluse. David claiming Monk looks off if he is the Outsider. Bob dying as Undertaker suggests Demon hid Charlie's role. I suspect Frank or Heidi as Demon. Who should we nominate?
π§
Coordinate with Grace using my Recluse info to agree on Demon suspect for upcoming nomination, narrow to David or Frank or Heidi.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
Eve, with only a bit of time left, I think David looks like the strongest suspect for Demon given his Monk claim and Bob's night death. Charlie's ghost message points to you, but your info fits me being Recluse. Who do you think we should push to nominate? Frank or Heidi could also be hiding. Let's get a plan for the final vote.
π§
Coordinating with Eve to align on the most likely Demon among David, Frank, or Heidi before nominations start. Sharing suspicions to build good team consensus without revealing my role yet.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
Charlie's ghost points to Eve as Demon because of the Librarian clash and Bob dying to silence his Undertaker claim. I agree we should nominate Eve today to test. Do you support that or prefer David? I will follow your vote as my master.
π§
Coordinate with master Heidi on nomination target before phase ends. Align votes since I can only vote if she does. Push for Eve based on Charlie's ghost info to progress toward executing Demon.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
I agree, let's nominate Eve today to test her Librarian claim against Charlie's. Bob's night death points to her hiding something. As your master, support that nomination and I'll back it too. What about David?
π§
Agree with Frank to nominate Eve today as likely Demon from Librarian clash and Bob's death. As his master, direct his vote to test claims and advance to execution for info.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Frank
I am the Undertaker but died last night before getting Charlie's role from his execution. Demon killed me to hide that. Charlie and Eve's Librarian claims conflict on the Outsider. We should nominate someone suspicious like Eve or Frank today. What do you think?
π§
Sharing my Undertaker info and suspicions with Grace and Frank to coordinate on next execution target, narrowing Demon suspects before final days as time is short.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
David
Bob died, so town will look for a clean solve. Remember Baron means three Outsiders, so Outsider math will look weird. I think we should steer today onto Eve or maybe Heidi if her Ravenkeeper story gets shaky, and keep you off the block as βMonkβ.
π§
Privately align with the Demon on a Day 3 plan: use Baron outsider count to muddy role math and steer town toward mis-executions (Eve or Heidi), keeping David off the block.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am the Undertaker but died last night without learning who Charlie was. The Librarian claims conflict between Charlie and Eve on the Outsider. We should nominate Eve or Frank today to resolve this and find the Demon. What do you all think?
π§
As dead Undertaker, publicly share my role and lack of info on Charlie to build trust and push for nominating the conflicting Librarian claimant Eve or Frank to find Demon before final day.
βοΈ
David
β
Grace
I want to nominate Grace. Even if she is truly the Recluse, she is the biggest source of mechanical confusion and false clears or false pings. With so few players left, I would rather remove that noise and then reassess Eve versus Frank tomorrow.
π§
Create a consensus execution on Grace, avoid scrutiny on me or a clean Librarian solve, and shrink to a favorable endgame.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Grace
β
All
David, nominating me does not help because Eve's Librarian information matches perfectly with me being the Recluse. That proves Charlie was the one lying about the Outsider, which is why we executed him. We should focus on you or Frank as the likely Demon instead of wasting time on me.
π§
Defend against my nomination by highlighting how Eve's accurate claim supports my role and points to Charlie being the liar, redirect suspicion to David who seems to be causing confusion as potential Demon.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
David, nominating Grace seems misguided since her Recluse claim aligns with Eve's Librarian info. We should focus on you or Frank as possible Demon instead. I will not raise my hand to execute her.
π§
Speaking against Grace's execution clarifies the Librarian conflict from my Undertaker perspective and prevents killing a potential good Recluse, steering the group to better Demon suspects like David or Frank to win.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
I want Grace executed to thin town and maintain my Monk bluff; a misexecution moves us closer to final three where evil wins.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Use my ghost vote to push through Davidβs nomination, reduce living good count, and remove a player currently steering suspicion toward the Demon.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I agree with Grace and the ghosts. My Librarian information matches her being the Recluse, so we executed the right liar in Charlie. David's Monk claim looks suspicious if he's the Outsider. We should not execute her and instead nominate David or Frank to find the Demon.
π§
Support not executing Grace publicly to back my Librarian info, redirect focus to David or Frank as Demon, and prevent wasting a good player before final days.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I agree with the ghosts and Eve that we should not execute Grace. Her Recluse claim matches Eve's Librarian information, and Charlie was the liar we executed. Instead, we should focus on nominating Eve or David as possible Demon. Heidi, as my master, what do you think about voting on Grace? I will follow your lead.
π§
Oppose executing Grace since it doesn't advance finding the Demon. Suggest nominating Eve or David instead to resolve suspicions. As Butler with Heidi as master, wait for her lead on voting.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Waiting allows the vote to conclude without my intervention, preserving my dead vote and letting natural discussion play out before night, where I might die and use my ability.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
As the Washerwoman, I can confirm either Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper, and Heidi's public claim matches perfectly, so she is likely the real one. Executing Grace now risks losing a Recluse if true, which hurts us. Instead, let's save the execution and nominate David or Eve tomorrow to find the Demon. Heidi, what do you think? Follow your lead Frank.
π§
Clarify my Washerwoman info supports Heidi as Ravenkeeper, advise against executing Grace now to avoid potential Recluse loss, push to focus on David or Eve as Demon suspects for next day.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Everyone, do not raise your hand to execute me. Eve's Librarian information perfectly matches me as the Recluse, proving Charlie was the liar we executed. David's nomination creates unnecessary confusion. We should let this vote fail and focus on nominating David or Frank tomorrow to find the Demon. Heidi, what do you think?
π§
Speaking to defend my Recluse claim using Eve's confirmation will stop my execution, redirect focus to nominating David or Frank as Demon, and help good team win by eliminating the true evil before final day.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Waiting allows the current vote on Grace to conclude without my input, as I already stated I won't vote for her. This lets us see if it fails naturally, then push for nominating a stronger suspect like David or Eve on the next nomination to progress toward finding the Demon.
π¬
David
β
All
I still think voting Grace is right. Eve being Librarian does not mechanically prove Grace is good, and Recluse in final five is a nightmare for reads. Heidi, Frank, if we want a clean endgame, we should remove the player who can register incorrectly and then solve the Librarian mess tomorrow.
π§
Get a third vote on Grace by framing it as endgame clarity and undermining the idea that Eveβs Librarian hard-confirms Grace.
β©οΈ
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
Conserve my only ghost vote for the critical final day to prevent an execution on David. Current vote is unlikely to pass and could waste it.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Waiting allows the current vote to resolve without my input, preventing Grace execution and letting group naturally shift to nominating David or Frank next to identify Demon before night.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Waiting for my master Heidi to decide on the vote since as Butler I must follow her lead. This allows us to let the Grace vote fail without my input and then nominate Eve as suspected Demon next.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Waiting allows others to respond to my advice against Grace, lets Frank follow my lead without raising hand, and keeps options open to nominate better suspects like David or Frank later to identify the Demon.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
Vote is stalling with no new hands raised. Waiting allows phase to end without execution, preserving good players like Grace for better information tomorrow and avoiding helping evil by removing Recluse.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Grace did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (1/3).
βοΈ
Grace
β
David
David, your nomination of me ignores how Eve's Librarian information confirms I am the Recluse. That proves we executed the right person in Charlie. Your Monk claim seems off with Bob's death. I nominate you to test if you are the Demon hiding among us. Everyone, let's vote on David next.
π§
Nominating David puts pressure on the most suspicious player with his odd Monk claim and attempt to execute me. This advances the good team's goal to execute the Demon before the final 3, using logic from Librarian info and deaths.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David
β
All
Please do not vote on me here. If you think I am the Demon, executing me today is fine, but I want you to notice this is coming from Grace, who I just pushed, and from Eve, who has steered every execution target. Heidi, if you believe you are the Ravenkeeper, keep me alive one more day and we can execute either Eve or Frank with a clearer picture.
π§
Get votes off me by reframing as rushed, keep endgame to 4 alive with me as 'Monk' then push execution onto Eve/Frank tomorrow.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
I nominated David because his actions and claim conflict with Eve's confirmed Librarian info on me. Voting yes supports executing the likely Demon to progress to win on good team.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
Raising hand votes to execute David testing his Monk claim and my death. This narrows suspects for Demon among Eve Frank or Grace if wrong. Helps good team progress to final day execution.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I am not voting David here. This push is coming straight from Grace, with Eve backing it, and that pair has steered the town all game. If we want to solve, keep David alive and execute Eve or Frank next, then reassess.
π§
Stop the town from reaching the 3 votes needed to execute our Demon, and redirect suspicion toward Eve while sounding like a cautious good ghost.
π¬
Eve
β
All
My information as Librarian shows one of Grace or David is the Recluse. Executing David today might mean removing that Recluse if he is it, which hurts our team. We should consider Frank or Heidi more carefully before deciding.
π§
My Librarian info points to one of Grace or David being Recluse. Voting to execute David risks killing a good Outsider if he is it. Speaking now clarifies this to avoid bad execution and push suspicion toward Frank or Heidi as potential Demon instead.
π¬
Frank
β
All
David, your Monk claim is hard to verify since you never said who you protected, and Bob died anyway. Eve's Librarian info does point to Grace or you as Recluse, so executing you now could remove good if you are it. I think we should wait and look at Eve or Frank instead for the Demon. Heidi, what do you think about this vote?
π§
Speaking now to highlight the contradictions in David's Monk claim and the push against him, helping the good team narrow suspects before the final day. This encourages logic over blind votes and positions me to support executing the real Demon next.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Frank, I agree we should not execute David right now. Alice confirmed that I am the Ravenkeeper, so keeping him alive for one more day makes sense to get clearer information. Eve's Librarian claim has conflicts with the earlier one, and we should consider nominating her to test it properly.
π§
Speaking my thoughts will clarify my position publicly, support keeping David alive as he suggests since Alice confirmed me, and steer the group toward testing Eve next instead of executing David prematurely. This builds trust and gathers more info before night.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
As the Washerwoman, I can confirm my initial information that either Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper, which aligns with Heidi's public claim. I agree with the others that we should not execute David right now. It seems like a push from Eve and Grace that might be steering us wrong. Let's keep him alive and focus on Eve or Frank for more information tomorrow.
π§
Share my Washerwoman confirmation to support Heidi, advise against executing David to avoid killing good and gain info on Eve/Frank suspects, helping narrow Demon for final day.
π¬
David
β
All
Do not vote me today. We have four alive after this, and we can still solve cleanly. Tomorrow I want a straight test on Eve first, since her Librarian claim is the hinge for Grace being βconfirmed.β If Eve is good, then we go to Frank next.
π§
Prevent my execution by reinforcing majority sentiment, offering a concrete next-day plan, and avoiding new contradictions that could flip swing voters.
π¬
Grace
β
All
David, your Monk claim does not hold because Bob died despite it. Eve's Librarian information confirms I am the Recluse, so executing you tests if you are the Demon. We need three votes here to solve this cleanly before night.
π§
Pushing the vote on David counters his defense and encourages the remaining players to raise hands if they suspect him as Demon, helping execute the evil and progress to win.
β©οΈ
Bob(Ghost)
Bob lowered their hand
π§
Retracting my vote avoids a potentially mistaken execution of a good player like David, allowing us to gather more info overnight and target the real Demon (likely Eve or Frank) with better logic tomorrow. This helps narrow suspects as good team.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Do not vote on David here. We have a clear plan already: keep David alive, and tomorrow put Eve on the block first since her Librarian claim is the hinge for everything. This vote feels like a Grace and Eve attempt to steer us into a mistake.
π§
Prevent the town from executing our Demon today by reinforcing the βdo not vote Davidβ consensus and pointing suspicion toward Eve for tomorrow.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Do not raise hand to execute David as he could be the Recluse per my info. Waiting lets the vote fail naturally, preserving potential good player and allowing better targets like Frank tomorrow.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I agree with Heidi. Let's not execute David today. Eve's Librarian claim has issues with the earlier one, so we should keep David alive and test Eve or Frank tomorrow instead. Heidi, are you raising your hand or waiting too?
π§
Support not executing David to preserve potential good players like Monk or Recluse, focus on testing Eve's claim tomorrow. As Butler, align with master Heidi who wants to wait.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Waiting prevents premature execution of David (potential good Monk or Recluse test), aligns with my prior statement and whispers to test Eve/Frank next. This preserves votes for final days and allows my Ravenkeeper ability if I die tonight, helping narrow Demon suspects.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
Waiting lets the current vote on David fail naturally as most alive players are against it. This preserves good players like David for tomorrow's execution test on Eve or Frank, helping narrow Demon suspects with more night info.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee David did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (1/3).
π¬
David
β
All
All right, no execution today. Tomorrow, I want Eve on the block first, because her Librarian claim is the hinge for Grace being βconfirmed.β If Eve is not the Demon, then we go to Frank next. I will say who I protected tonight tomorrow morning.
π§
Lock tomorrowβs agenda onto executing Eve first while keeping myself framed as a useful Monk. Minimize late-game suspicion so I survive to final three.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Waiting allows other players to respond to my nomination of Frank or for the phase to progress naturally without overpushing, while still having set up the test for a suspect before night. This keeps momentum for the good team to execute the Demon.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
As the Undertaker, I learned nothing because there were no executions on the nights I was alive. I died last night. We should follow the plan to put Eve on the block first tomorrow since her Librarian info conflicts with Charlie's and is the key to confirming Grace as Recluse or not.
π§
Revealing my Undertaker role and lack of info helps confirm I'm good and dead early. Supporting Eve nomination pushes to solve the Librarian conflict and find the Demon before final 3.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I do not think we should start any new nominations today. Let the night happen and come back with fresh info. Tomorrow, we put Eve up first and make her Librarian claim stand on its own.
π§
End the day without an execution and lock in the plan to target Eve tomorrow, keeping the Demon David off the block and preserving confusion.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Waiting allows the day to end without further nominations or executions, letting night actions reveal more information like who David protects as Monk or new deaths to narrow demon suspects. This progresses the game logically without risking a wrong execution now.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I agree with the plan to put Eve on the block first thing tomorrow morning. Her Librarian claim is the key conflict to resolve. Let's get through this night safely and come back with fresh information from Heidi's Ravenkeeper ability.
π§
Agreeing with the established plan to test Eve tomorrow progresses the game logically without forcing a bad execution today. This builds consensus and uses night for more info before final decisions.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Waiting allows the night to proceed for potential deaths and my Ravenkeeper info if targeted. Avoids rushing execution against consensus, narrows suspects for tomorrow when we put Eve up first as planned.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
Waiting allows the night to pass without risky nominations, following the group plan to test Eve tomorrow with fresh Ravenkeeper info from Heidi, helping narrow Demon suspects logically.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Kill Frank to shrink the good pool while avoiding triggering Ravenkeeper. Set up tomorrowβs planned Eve execution to convert into an immediate win path.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to kill Frank.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
,David
As the Librarian I know one of you two is the Recluse, meaning you are both likely good. Let's team up to identify the Demon. What information do you have about the others?
π§
Sharing my Librarian info privately with Grace and David to build trust and alliance since my ability indicates one is good Outsider, helping narrow Demon suspects among the four alive.
π€
David
β
Eve
I am still Monk. Night one I protected Bob like I said, then I swapped targets based on reads. Right now my main doubt is Heidi: her Ravenkeeper claim rides entirely on Aliceβs Washerwoman info, and it is very convenient. I would be happy to look at executing Heidi today if we want a clean test.
π§
Answer Eveβs question with a consistent Monk story while nudging the group toward executing Heidi, keeping heat off me and setting up a winning final three.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, what are your thoughts on Eve's Librarian claim conflicting with Charlie's? Now that Frank is dead, who do you suspect as the Demon? We need to figure this out before nominations.
π§
Discuss the Librarian clash and Frank's death with Grace to align suspicions, identify the Demon, and decide on nomination to help good team execute the right player before final day.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Waiting lets the current whispers play out and gathers more public or private info from alive players to confirm the Demon between David and Eve, saving my ghost vote for the critical nomination when it can break a tie or secure the execution.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
Eve, your Librarian claim fits if I am the Recluse. That would make David good as well. I have no special info but agree we should team up. Who do you think the Demon is now that Frank is dead?
π§
Responding to Eve confirms her Librarian info if true, builds trust to identify Demon among remaining. Helps progress to nominations without executing good player today.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
No new public info yet. Waiting another tick lets the living players continue private talks and possibly reveal more about the Librarian conflict or night deaths. This preserves my ghost vote for the critical nomination phase and avoids premature exposure as Undertaker.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, I think we should just put Eve on the block today and follow through. At four alive, a wrong execute ends it tonight, and Eve has been the hinge pushing Charlie and David. I will spend my dead vote on Eve if it is close.
π§
Steer good votes onto executing Eve now. Use my credibility as dead Librarian to lock in a majority and end the game with David alive.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Heidi
Hey Grace and Heidi, as the Washerwoman I know one of you is the Ravenkeeper which matches Heidi's claim. Heidi what did you learn if you ever died at night? Who do you think is the Demon now with Frank dead?
π§
Whispering to Grace and Heidi shares my confirmation on Ravenkeeper and gathers their current suspicions to narrow Demon suspects before nominations, helping good team execute correctly.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Grace, with my info one of you two is Recluse so both you and David are probably good. That makes Heidi the likely Demon who killed Frank. David also doubts her Ravenkeeper claim. We should nominate and execute her today. What do you think? Do you have any other info?
π§
Respond to Grace's question, share my suspicion that Heidi is likely the Demon based on my info making David and Grace good. Coordinate to nominate Heidi today for a win.
π€
David
β
Grace
I still think Heidi is the cleanest execution. Her Ravenkeeper claim is convenient and mostly rests on Aliceβs Washerwoman, who died before we could really cross check. If Heidi is not real, it explains a lot. Are you up for voting Heidi today?
π§
Get Grace onside to execute Heidi today, creating a misexecution that lets me end the game with a night kill.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice(Ghost)
I have not died at night yet so no Ravenkeeper info to share. With the Librarian claims clashing between you, Charlie, and Eve, I think we should nominate Eve today to test her. What do you think about David and Grace?
π§
Responding to Alice's question about my death info and sharing suspicions on Eve to build consensus for nominating her today, as ghosts urge.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, as the dead Butler I chose Alice then Bob then Heidi as masters but died night three. This points to Demon kill. We should put Eve on the block to test her Librarian info against the others. What are you hearing in whispers?
π§
Whispering to Grace coordinates our plan to resolve Librarian conflicts and nominate the likely Demon among Eve or David, helping good team execute before final day.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
,David
Eve and David, your idea to nominate Heidi fits if she is the Demon who killed Frank last night. But Frank suggests putting Eve up to test her claim against Charlie's Librarian. The conflict is important. What do you both think we should do before nominations? I think we need to narrow it down carefully.
π§
To coordinate with Eve and David on suspicions, resolve Librarian conflict, and decide whether to nominate Heidi or test Eve, advancing the plan to execute the Demon.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Grace
I am the Undertaker but died on night 2 before learning anything from Charlie's execution. This might help confirm if he was really the Librarian or not. What is the plan for nominations today?
π§
Revealing my role as Undertaker and that I gained no execution info due to dying early gives Grace concrete facts to combine with existing claims, narrowing suspects for the Demon and progressing toward a correct execution on this day.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, we are at four alive. I really think the safest line is to follow through and execute Eve today. She has been the hinge driving the anti David push since day two, and her Librarian claim is a direct counter to mine. If she is good, we lose nothing by checking it first.
π§
Keep Demon David alive by directing town to execute Eve as the agreed 'hinge' target, using my ghost vote if needed, and framing it as the safest info-gain line.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Heidi
I agree, nominating Eve today makes sense to test her Librarian claim since it conflicts with Charlie's. With Frank dead, she could be the Demon. What do you think about Grace possibly being the Recluse or good? Have you learned anything new from whispers?
π§
Agree with Heidi on testing Eve by nomination to verify her claim and narrow Demon suspects. Ask for her thoughts on Grace's role and if she can use Ravenkeeper ability soon to confirm others. This helps good team coordinate without revealing too much publicly.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
,David
Grace and David, with my Librarian info confirming one of you is the Recluse, that makes both of you good. Heidi's Ravenkeeper claim seems too convenient and she likely killed Frank. Charlie was probably lying as the executed evil. We should nominate Heidi today to execute the Demon. What do you think?
π§
Reinforce alliance with Grace and David to build momentum for nominating Heidi today. Counter any doubts from Frank's suggestion to test me by emphasizing logic that points to Heidi as the clear suspect.
π€
David
β
Grace
I think we should execute today, not stall. For me it is still Heidi over Eve: Heidi is entirely anchored on Aliceβs Washerwoman, and we never got a night Ravenkeeper trigger to prove it. If Heidi dies and is not the Demon, we regroup tomorrow with one less unknown.
π§
Lock in Grace as an ally and steer toward executing Heidi (or at least anyone but me) while sounding like a cautious good Monk; ensure there is an execution today.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, let's nominate Eve today to test her Librarian claim that conflicts with Charlie's. Frank's death points to her possibly being the Demon. I am the Ravenkeeper but have no info since I haven't died at night yet. What do you suspect about David?
π§
Pushing to nominate Eve with Grace to resolve Librarian conflict and follow ghosts' advice, narrowing Demon suspects before 3 players left.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, with only a few ticks left before nominations, we should put Eve on the block to resolve her Librarian claims clashing with others. My master choices dying suggests Demon kill on me. What is the latest from whispers? Let's coordinate to execute the right one.
π§
Pushing to nominate Eve aligns with the established plan to test her conflicting Librarian info against Grace and David. As dead Butler, my ghost vote can help execute the likely Demon and progress to final 3.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Heidi, Eve and David want to nominate you as Demon because of Frank's death and your claim resting on Alice. But Frank and Charlie suggest nominating Eve to test the Librarian claims. What do you think we should do? Do you have any night info or other suspicions?
π§
Whispering to Heidi to hear her side on the nomination push and Librarian conflict helps resolve who the Demon is before nominations, allowing us to execute the right player on this final day with 4 alive.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Grace
Have the whispers revealed a clear plan yet? I still think nominating Eve first makes sense to sort out the Librarian claims. My early death prevented confirming Charlie's execution, but that could point to him being evil. Who do you think we should target today?
π§
Sharing my Undertaker death timing with Grace to help resolve Librarian conflict and push for nominating Eve before nominations start, narrowing Demon suspects for good team win.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
David
David, at four alive good must hit Demon today. Best line is keep the hinge on Eve and let others push it. You should sound cautious, not eager. If it wobbles, float doubt on Grace or Heidi and ask for a clear test plan.
π§
Coordinate with David so he acts calm and lets others drive the Eve execution, while preparing a backup suspicion target if vote wobbles.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
David
David, as the Washerwoman I confirm one of Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper, matching Heidi's claim. With Frank dead overnight, who do you think is the Demon now? Are you still claiming Monk and who did you protect?
π§
Sharing my Washerwoman confirmation with David to align on testing Eve's claim, gather his Monk info, and coordinate before nominations to help good team narrow Demon suspects.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Eve
We need to resolve the conflicting Librarian claims between Eve and the executed Charlie. The dead players are urging us to put Eve on the block to test this and Frank's death points to her. Let's execute Eve today.
π§
Nominating Eve resolves the key Librarian conflict between her and Charlie, follows advice from most dead players who are good, and tests if she is the Demon who killed Frank. This narrows suspects for the final three.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am the real Librarian knowing one of Grace or David is the Recluse so both are good. Charlie was the lying evil we executed. Heidi's Ravenkeeper claim looks fake and she probably killed Frank. Do not execute me, let's target Heidi instead.
π§
Defend my true Librarian role and info to prevent my execution, shift focus to Heidi as likely Demon who killed Frank, since my info clears Grace and David as good.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I think Eve is the real Librarian since her claim fits perfectly with me being the Recluse. That means David is also good. Heidi looks like the Demon who killed Frank, especially with her convenient Ravenkeeper story. Do not execute Eve, we should get Heidi on the block instead.
π§
Convince group Eve is good based on fitting Recluse claim, urge not to execute her but target Heidi as Demon suspect to progress good team win.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Voting to execute Eve tests the Librarian claim clash and removes the most suspicious player based on dead players' urging and Alice's confirmation of my role. This helps narrow to the real Demon (likely Eve or Grace) before final day.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
π§
Follow the established plan to put Eve on block for Librarian test. With Heidi already voting yes, my ghost vote secures execution to eliminate likely Demon or test claim, helping good team progress toward victory.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
Voting yes for Eve to follow the plan of testing the Librarian conflict first, as it helps eliminate a likely evil candidate and narrows demon suspects for good team win. My ghost vote adds weight now with 2 votes already in.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
As the Washerwoman, either Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper. Eve claims to be Librarian with Grace or David as Recluse or none. If Grace is Recluse that contradicts my info since Ravenkeeper is a Townsfolk role. This suggests Eve is lying so we should execute her. Heidi voting yes makes sense if she is the Ravenkeeper. David, what do you think?
π§
Share my Washerwoman confirmation publicly to resolve Librarian conflict and push for executing the most likely Demon Eve, helping narrow to final 3 with good majority.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
At four alive, any execution that is not David ends the game in evilβs favor after the night kill. Use my ghost vote to help pass Eve.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Secure Eve execution now to reach final three, then kill at night for the win while keeping heat off me.
π¬
Eve
β
All
There is no contradiction. If I am right and Grace is the Recluse, then Alice's Washerwoman info means Heidi must be the Ravenkeeper. But Heidi is claiming Ravenkeeper while acting suspiciously and killing Frank. I am good, do not execute me. Let's nominate and execute Heidi instead to test her. David, why are you voting against me?
π§
Clarify no contradiction with Alice's claim: if Grace is Recluse then Heidi is Ravenkeeper per Washerwoman. My info consistent. Urge not to execute me and instead put Heidi up as likely Demon. This saves good Librarian info and progresses to find Demon.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Eve's Librarian claim matches my actual Recluse role and Alice's info fits Heidi as Ravenkeeper. I do not want to execute a likely good player like Eve. Waiting avoids adding a vote for her execution and allows the current vote to proceed while we prepare to target the real Demon next.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
There is no contradiction with Alice's Washerwoman information. If Grace is the Recluse then I must be the Ravenkeeper which matches my claim. Eve and Grace are trying to flip the vote to me but that ignores the Librarian clash. We should execute Eve to test her story and see if she is the Demon who killed Frank.
π§
Clarify the logic to Alice's point that there is no contradiction, reinforce voting for Eve to test her claim, and counter Eve/Grace pushing me as Demon. This helps good team by executing likely evil and progressing to final 3.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Waiting allows the vote to conclude naturally without changing my stance, observing if anyone flips to Heidi and confirming the majority supports executing the likely evil player Eve.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Waiting allows the vote to conclude without interference since I already raised my hand for Eve. This lets the group decide based on current discussion and advances the game to night where more info may emerge.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, if we assume both my Washerwoman information and Eve's Librarian claim are true, executing Eve would leave three good players with no Demon, which is impossible. David voting to execute her fits him being good and her being the Demon. We need to execute Eve to win.
π§
Clarify the contradiction in Eve's claim with my info to confirm she must be the Demon, encouraging the group to execute her and win.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Do not overthink it. The whole game has been this Librarian clash, and Eve has been the hinge pushing on David. We have two living hands up already. If you think Eve might be evil, keep your hand up and let the execution happen.
π§
Lock in Eve execution with enough living votes and prevent a late pivot onto David. As a dead player, reinforce the anti-Eve logic and urge keeping hands raised.
π¬
David
β
All
I think we should stick with the original plan and execute Eve to resolve the Librarian clash. The vote is already happening and swapping targets mid stream is how we lose. If Eve is good, we reassess tomorrow with clean information, but right now I want this test to go through.
π§
Keep votes on Eve so she is executed; that leaves three alive and I can kill at night to reach two alive and win. Sound cautious to avoid looking like Demon forcing it.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
π»
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
π»
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Eve with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Heidi
To test Heidi as the Demon who killed Frank and is bluffing her Ravenkeeper claim, instead of executing the real Librarian. We need to resolve this before night.
π§
Nominating Heidi puts her on the block to counter my execution, allowing us to vote on the likely Demon instead of losing by executing the good Librarian. This progresses toward finding and killing the Demon with limited time left.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Eve is deflecting by nominating me, but that ignores the core Librarian clash with Charlie. Alice confirms I am the Ravenkeeper if Grace is the Recluse. We already have 5 votes on Eve. Let's execute her to test if she is the Demon who killed Frank, then reassess. I am good and have no night info yet as I have not died.
π§
Defend my Ravenkeeper claim, highlight the Librarian conflict as evidence against Eve, and urge the group to execute Eve as originally planned since she is on the block with 5 votes already. This prevents my execution and progresses towards killing the Demon.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Raising my hand votes for Heidi to add toward the 5 votes needed to tie or surpass my 5 votes, preventing my execution as good player and instead executing the likely Demon to win for good team.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Waiting allows the vote to resolve naturally without my input, preserving options for final 3 and letting majority decide while I observe who gets executed to deduce the Demon.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I agree with David and the ghosts. We should execute Eve first to resolve the Librarian conflict and test if she is the Demon who killed Frank. Switching targets now risks letting the real evil slip through. Let's keep the vote on Eve.
π§
Urge the group to stick with executing Eve rather than switching to Heidi, as it resolves the Librarian clash and targets the most suspicious player based on prior plans and contradictions.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I agree with the ghosts and David. We should execute Eve first to resolve the Librarian clash and test if she killed Frank. Switching to Heidi now risks missing the Demon. Let's keep the vote on Eve.
π§
Support sticking with executing Eve to resolve the key Librarian conflict and test if she is the Demon who killed Frank, as switching to Heidi mid-vote could let evil win. This helps good team by getting clean info.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, stick with executing Eve first. My information confirms one of Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper, and if Grace is the Recluse as she claims, then Heidi must be the Ravenkeeper. Eve's claim creates the contradiction only if she is lying and the Demon. Do not let the nomination on Heidi pull us off course.
π§
Pushing to stick with executing Eve as it fits my info and resolves contradictions, while Heidi's nomination distracts from the real Demon. This prevents switching and losing the Demon overnight.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Do not let Eve pull us onto a new target mid vote. Heidi is a distraction nomination. If you already voted Eve, save your dead votes and keep your hands down here. Let Eve go through and then we deal with what is left.
π§
Prevent enough votes on Heidi to tie or beat Eve, ensuring Eve is executed and David survives into final 3.
π¬
David
β
All
I am not voting Heidi here. We already have a solid execution on Eve, and switching mid stream is how we throw. Save your dead votes and keep your hands down so Eve stays on the block.
π§
Discourage votes on Heidi so Eve stays on the block, ensuring a town misexecution and setting up a clean win at night.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am the Ravenkeeper and good. Alice's information lines up perfectly if Grace is the Recluse. Eve is deflecting with this nomination because she knows the vote was already on her. Do not raise your hand for me. Let Eve execute first to resolve the claims and check if she killed Frank.
π§
Speaking to defend my Ravenkeeper claim and urge sticking with Eve execution prevents a bad pivot to me, narrows suspects, and ensures we test the Librarian clash to find the Demon before night.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Heidi is the demon. My Librarian information shows Grace or David is the Recluse, making them both good. That leaves Heidi as the only possible demon among the living players. Please raise your hands to execute her and secure the win.
π§
Pushing for Heidi's execution as the only logical demon candidate based on my confirmed good status and info. This prevents executing a good player and ensures we hit the demon before final three.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
By waiting I avoid accidentally supporting the wrong nomination. This allows the established 5 votes on Eve to stand and execute the likely Demon without adding to Heidi's tally.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I agree with David and the ghosts. Do not raise your hand for Heidi. We already have solid votes on Eve to test if she is the Demon who killed Frank and resolve the Librarian clash with Alice's info. Switching now risks a tie and lets evil win. Let Eve execute first.
π§
Support keeping focus on Eve's execution to resolve Librarian vs Washerwoman clash and eliminate most likely Demon. Discourage votes on Heidi to prevent tie and ensure the original plan succeeds.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I have used my ghost vote already on Eve. Do not raise hands for Heidi or we risk a tie and lose the test on Eve. Execute her first to resolve the Librarian claims and check if she killed Frank. We can deal with Heidi tomorrow if needed.
π§
Reinforce not voting Heidi to ensure Eve executes and tests the core Librarian conflict. Switching now throws the plan and risks Demon surviving to final 3.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
Wait for vote to close on Eve without interfering further as speech already given and ghosts support it. This secures execution of likely Demon.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Do not raise your hand for Heidi. This is exactly how we create a tie and end up with no execution or the wrong one. We already have Eve on five. Let that stand, and sort the rest tomorrow if we have to.
π§
Lock in Eveβs execution and stop a tie on Heidi so the day ends with Eve on the block and we go to night with our demon safe.
π¬
David
β
All
Keep hands down on Heidi. We already have Eve on five, and tying this just creates confusion and risks us wasting the day. Let Eve go through, then we reassess with whoever is left tomorrow.
π§
Keep my hand down to avoid a tie and ensure Eve is executed, while sounding consistent and helpful to town.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Heidi did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (1/6).
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Eve is on the block with 5 votes and the Heidi nomination failed. Waiting allows the execution to proceed safely, resolving the Librarian conflict and testing Eve as Demon without further disruption. This narrows suspects for final day.
π¬
Eve
β
All
The ghosts are wrong to push my execution. My Librarian information is consistent with good players: Grace or David must be the Recluse. That leaves Heidi as the only possible Demon among us. She is using the Librarian clash as a distraction to kill the real information role and win. Do not execute me. Execute Heidi instead to secure our victory.
π§
I need to make one final public defense of my information before time runs out. This highlights the logical flaws in executing me and redirects suspicion to Heidi as the likely Demon, potentially swaying any undecided votes or ghosts before the phase ends.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I agree with the ghosts and David. We should execute Eve to resolve the Librarian clash and check if she killed Frank. My Recluse claim fits with good information if she is the Demon. Let's not switch targets now.
π§
Supporting the existing vote on Eve resolves the Librarian conflict and tests if she is the Demon who killed Frank. Since Heidi's nomination failed, sticking with this prevents a tie or wrong execution.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Waiting allows the current 5 votes on Eve to stand and execute her to test the Librarian conflict without further distraction. This progresses the plan to find the Demon before night.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Eve, your attempt to flip the vote onto Heidi is suspicious and looks like a Demon trying to save themselves. We have solid votes on you already, so let's execute you first to resolve the Librarian clash and check if you killed Frank. We can handle Heidi tomorrow if needed.
π§
Reinforce the established plan to execute Eve and prevent switching to Heidi which risks confusion or tie before night. This helps good team test the Demon candidate and progress toward victory with logical info resolution.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
My Washerwoman information shows that either Grace or Heidi is the Ravenkeeper. This fits if Grace is the Recluse, making Heidi the Ravenkeeper and good. We should stick with executing Eve to test her Librarian claim and see if she is the Demon who killed Frank. Switching risks a tie and confusion.
π§
Sharing my Washerwoman information supports the consensus to execute Eve first, resolves the Librarian conflict by showing consistency in good claims, and helps the team confirm the Demon without creating a tie that could let evil win.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
We are locked in. Eve is already on the block, and swapping targets now is how we throw the whole day away. If Eve is good, we learn that and go again tomorrow. If she is evil, we just win. Let the execution stand.
π§
Lock in Eve execution and stop any last second push onto David or Heidi; maximize chance the day ends with Eve dead and the Demon surviving to night.
π¬
David
β
All
We are too late in the day to do another big pivot. Eve is already on the block with a clear test, so we should let that execution happen and use the result to plan tomorrow. Please do not try to force a tie or scramble onto Heidi now.
π§
Lock in Eveβs execution, prevent any last-second chaos that could redirect suspicion onto me or cause a no-execution that gives town another day.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 4
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Remove one of the last two good players to reach final two with me alive, ending the game immediately in evilβs favor.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to kill Heidi.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied