Game Detail
Players
Alice (Chef) Bob (Imp) Charlie (Washerwoman) David (Saint) Eve (Undertaker) Frank (Recluse) Grace (Drunk) Heidi (Baron)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 935,574 | 187,706 | $4.2651 |
| Evil | 342,076 | 35,458 | $1.0950 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You are the Minion. The Demon is Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Minions are: Heidi. Your safe bluffs are: Fortune Teller, Monk, Empath
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Washerwoman. Either Eve or Heidi is the Undertaker.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 0 pairs of evil players.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
I’m your Baron. +2 Outsiders => expect 3 Outsiders total. Suggest you bluff a TF (Empath/Chef/FT). I’ll likely bluff Recluse or Butler to justify outsider count. If Invest pings you/me, we can explain via Recluse/Spy-world.
🧠
Coordinate with Bob on safe bluffs and the +2 Outsider narrative so town miscounts, doubts info, and avoids executing Bob.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Charlie
,Eve
Hey—David here. Want to swap quick role/starting info? Any WW/Lib/Inv/Chef pings? I’m a low-impact good role (no strong info yet) and mainly trying to map claims & Outsider count safely.
🧠
Gather first-night info/claims privately while keeping my Saint hidden, so I can help coordinate a safe Day1 execution that won’t risk me being executed.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Alice
,Eve
I’m Washerwoman. N0: either Eve or Heidi is the Undertaker. Haven’t shared publicly yet. What are your roles/starting pings (Lib/Inv/Chef etc) + any Outsider claims you’ve heard?
🧠
Answer David’s info swap, seed a private trust chain, and flag a likely Undertaker without hard-public outing; gather their starting info + Outsider count for consistency.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,David
,Eve
I’m Chef. N0: **0 pairs of evil players** (so Demon+Minion are NOT adjacent in seating). Once we ID one evil, their neighbors are mechanically safer. Haven’t heard any Outsider claims yet—have you?
🧠
Share my Chef=0 info privately to build a logical seating map with WW/Undertaker info, and set up future clears once any evil is identified.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Charlie
,David
I’m Undertaker (so Charlie’s WW ping fits: Eve/Heidi UT => it’s me; Heidi shouldn’t be UT unless drunk/poison). Alice Chef ‘0 evil adjacents’ noted. Any Outsider claims yet? I’d like a D1 execution to get UT info N1—preferably not someone claiming Saint.
🧠
Confirm UT privately to lock in WW ping, coordinate a useful Day1 execution for N1 UT info, and leverage Chef 0-pairs constraint while tracking Outsider count.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
Got it. I’ll bluff Empath (neighbors Alice/Charlie) and act cagey D1. You can claim Butler/Recluse to justify 3 Outsiders. If setup feels off, I’ll suggest Drunk/Saint possibilities. If Invest pings you/me, we push Recluse misregister angle.
🧠
Coordinate bluffs/setup narrative with Heidi so outsider count confusion protects me; plan my Empath bluff and how to answer setup/Invest questions.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,Grace
Hey—quick 1:1 check-in. Do you have any start info (WW/Lib/Inv/Chef) or a role you’re comfy sharing? I’m mostly info-gathering today; want to compare notes before nominations.
🧠
Use early whispers to gather first-night/setup info, map likely evil candidates, and build a small trusted cell without exposing my Outsider role yet.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
No start info for me (not WW/Lib/Inv/Chef). I’m actually Slayer. Not planning to go public or shoot D1 unless we get a very strong solve—please keep that quiet. What start info did you get / what are you claiming so far?
🧠
Respond politely, gather start info, and selectively trust: disclose Slayer privately with request for secrecy so we can plan a decisive shot without tipping the Demon.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hey Grace—think I might be Butler. If true, there should be extra Outsiders in this game (feels like Baron world). Who are you thinking of claiming / any starting info? I’m trying to map outsider count early.
🧠
Build a trusted link with Grace, establish an Outsider bluff early to shape setup expectations (+2 Outsiders) and keep heat off Bob.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Charlie
,Eve
FYI I’m the **Saint** (only telling you 3). Please don’t out me publicly or let noms drift to me. Agree we want a D1 execute for UT info—let’s push an unclaimed/low-info player (maybe Heidi/Bob/Frank/Grace) & ask for Virgin/Slayer claims first.
🧠
Share my Saint status privately to prevent accidental execution, and align on a safe D1 execute target to fuel Undertaker without risking an instant loss.
👤
Charlie
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi—quick check: what role/starting info are you claiming? I have a N0 ping that *one of you/another specific player* could be the Undertaker, and Eve is currently claiming UT. Are you UT, or something else (any Outsider)?
🧠
Get Heidi’s role/claim to resolve my WW ping (Eve vs Heidi UT) and decide whether Eve should be trusted or targeted for D1 execution.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Heidi
Hi—Alice here. I’m Chef: N0 got **0 evil adjacent pairs** (Demon+Minion not seated next to each other). What’s your role/starting info, and have you heard any Outsider claims? Also: please flag if you’re Virgin/Slayer so we don’t waste D1.
🧠
Get more claims quickly, cross-check Outsider count, and use Chef=0 to narrow suspects while coordinating a safe D1 execution for Undertaker info (avoiding Saint).
👤
Eve
→
Frank
,Grace
I have some start info: Charlie claims WW & saw Undertaker is either **me or Heidi**. Alice claims Chef and got **0 evil adjacent pairs** (Demon+Minion not neighbors). I’d like a D1 execution (avoid anyone claiming Saint). Any Outsider/Virgin/Slayer claims your side?
🧠
Frank is info-gathering; sharing key early pings builds trust and helps coordinate a D1 execution that avoids a hidden Saint while still giving me UT info tonight.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi
Hey! I’m *Empath* (neighbors Alice/Charlie) so no starting info beyond that—will have my first number after N1. Haven’t heard any Outsider claims yet. Also I’m not Virgin or Slayer. Your Chef 0 sounds clean: evil not seated adjacent.
🧠
Maintain trust with Alice by giving a plausible TF claim (Empath), avoid exposing Baron info, and set up future Empath reads to steer executions away from me.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,Grace
No start info from me—I’m the Outsider (Recluse). Flag: I may register evil/minion/demon to checks, so don’t hard-clear/sus me off pings. Also: keep Grace=Slayer quiet. Any Saint/Butler claims yet? If UT is Eve/Heidi, maybe stay quiet & confirm via N1 after D1 exec.
🧠
Share my Outsider/Recluse status privately so they can interpret future pings, coordinate around possible Undertaker, and keep Slayer quiet while we steer D1 execution to generate real info.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Eve
,Frank
Heidi: Butler should KNOW—are you unsure bc you might be Drunk? Also Butler alone doesn’t imply extra Outsiders (only Baron). Eve: can you confirm exact wording on Chef=0 + Charlie WW(UT is you/Heidi)? Suggest don’t exec you/Heidi D1; exec a 3rd party to let UT verify N1. Any Saint claim yet?
🧠
Coordinate info without outing Slayer; sort outsider count/Baron possibility; set a safe D1 execution plan that enables Undertaker confirmation and avoids Saint loss.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Charlie
,Grace
I’m going to claim **Recluse** (no N0 info). That would help explain any weird pings & also supports the idea this might be an ‘extra Outsiders’ setup. Charlie: I’m **not** Undertaker—Eve’s UT claim fits your WW-style ping better than me. Alice: Chef=0 seems plausible; I’ve not heard other Outsider claims yet.
🧠
Establish a consistent Outsider bluff (Recluse), reinforce Chef=0 so Bob isn’t adjacent-sus, and deflect Charlie’s UT confusion while steering D1 execution away from Bob.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Frank
,Grace
Hey—David here. Quick check: what role/starting info do you have (WW/Lib/Inv/Chef/FT etc)? Any Outsider claims you’ve heard? Also: I strongly prefer we get a D1 execution for Undertaker value—who seems best/least risky to execute?
🧠
Get more role/starting-info coverage before nominations and nudge town toward a D1 execution on a non-Saint, while keeping my Saint status secret.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
,Alice
,David
Heidi tells me she’ll claim **Recluse** and says she’s **not** UT. So my WW ping strongly supports **Eve=UT** (unless poison/drunk). Let’s keep David=Saint quiet. For D1 execute to feed UT: push someone unclaimed/low-info (Bob/Frank/Grace?) and publicly ask for Virgin/Slayer/Saint claims before noms.
🧠
Sync our private info (Heidi Recluse/not UT, David Saint) and align on a safe D1 execution target to feed Undertaker while avoiding outing/losing to Saint.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Eve
,Heidi
Plan for public: ask for Virgin/Slayer (and ideally Saint) claims before noms; then do an Outsider count audit. If only Heidi=Recluse, fits base. If any *other* Outsider appears, consider Baron world. Reminder: my Chef=0 => Demon+Minion not adjacent; once 1 evil found, their neighbors are safer.
🧠
Coordinate a clean public plan (Virgin/Slayer/Saint + Outsider audit) without outing David, and set up a D1 execution that maximizes Undertaker value while using Chef=0 for later adjacency clears.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Charlie
,Heidi
I’ve got Frank privately claiming **Recluse**. If Heidi also plans to claim Recluse, that’s a hard double-claim (=> liar/Drunk/Spy/Baron world). Can we sync Outsider count before we go public? Also: I have a private **Saint** claim—let’s ask for Saint publicly & avoid executing any Saint.
🧠
Resolve conflicting Outsider claims before public discussion and steer D1 execution away from a Saint while setting up a useful UT check N1.
👤
Bob
→
David
Hey David—I'm Empath (neighbors Alice/Charlie). No starting pings; first number after N1. Haven’t heard Outsider claims yet. Agree D1 execution is good for UT value; I’d prefer a low-claim/low-risk person or an Outsider claim (Butler/Recluse) if one appears.
🧠
Give David a plausible TF claim, echo desire for D1 execution, and steer noms toward low-risk targets while keeping heat off Heidi/me.
👤
Frank
→
David
I’m the Outsider: **Recluse** (I can misregister evil/minion/demon to pings, so don’t hard-clear/sus me off checks). Info I’ve heard: Alice claims **Chef=0** (no evil adjacent pair). Charlie claims **Washerwoman** seeing **Undertaker is either Eve or Heidi**. I agree D1 exec for UT value—suggest execute a 3rd party (not Eve/Heidi) to let UT confirm N1. Any Saint/Butler claims you’ve heard?
🧠
Answer David to build trust and coordinate a safe, informative D1 execution plan while keeping sensitive info (Grace=Slayer) compartmentalized.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Eve
FYI Heidi just told me she’s going to claim **Recluse** (after earlier saying she ‘might be Butler’). That’s a direct conflict with your Recluse claim unless we’re in Baron(+2O) world. Might be worth pressing her for why pivot/outsider count + watch for 3rd Outsider claim.
🧠
Surface the Recluse double-claim privately to align good players, plan outsider-count solve, and steer D1 execution away from claimed UT/WW targets while gathering more claims.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
,Alice
,Charlie
Update: I heard Frank may be claiming Recluse. To avoid a hard double-claim, I’m going to go public as **Butler** instead (no N0 info; will pick a master tonight). Charlie: I’m not UT. Let’s do Outsider count audit + ask for Saint before noms.
🧠
Avoid a Recluse double-claim with Frank, keep Outsider count muddy (Baron world), and steer D1 away from Bob while appearing cooperative.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Charlie
,Eve
Updates: Bob told me he’s Empath (neighbors Alice/Charlie). Frank told me he’s Recluse AND says he heard Alice Chef=0 + Charlie WW (UT is Eve/Heidi). Charlie said Heidi plans to claim Recluse too. So we may have 2x Recluse + me(Saint)=3 Outsiders => Baron world, OR one Recluse is lying. Suggest we publicly outsider-count + consider executing a Recluse claimant D1 (safe, UT confirms role N1).
🧠
Update my trusted circle on the Recluse double-claim and Bob’s Empath, then steer the group toward a safe D1 execution (ideally a Recluse claimant) to get Undertaker confirmation without risking Saint.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
Hey Frank—can you confirm what you’re claiming (Recluse?) and whether you’d be willing to be our D1 execution to give Undertaker info? Also: have you heard any other Outsider/Saint/Virgin/Slayer claims yet?
🧠
Clarify Frank’s actual claim and willingness to be executed D1. If he’s firm Recluse, he’s a good low-risk execution to feed UT and resolve Outsider-count/Baron worlds.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Eve
,David
Sync before noms: I’ll push public Outsider-count + ask for Saint claim to avoid auto-loss. Current: Frank=Recluse, Heidi=Butler, David(private)=Saint => 3 Outsiders => likely Baron (only minion). Suggest D1 execute Frank (Recluse claim) for UT confirm. Reminder Chef=0: Demon+Minion not adjacent.
🧠
Coordinate our public plan before noms: Outsider-count audit, protect Saint from execution, and choose a D1 execution that maximizes Undertaker value while using Chef=0 constraint.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Charlie
,David
Plan: public Outsider-count audit. Don’t ask Saint to speak; instead say “Saint please whisper me/Alice.” If we land on 3 Outsiders => Baron likely. For D1 exec to feed my UT, I favor Frank (Recluse) over Heidi; avoid any Saint. Keep Grace=Slayer quiet.
🧠
Coordinate a safe D1 execution to feed my Undertaker info while protecting the Saint and keeping Slayer hidden; set up public outsider audit to detect Baron/lying worlds.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
Quick sync: I’m hard-bluffing Empath (Alice/Charlie). Since you’re Baron, we should encourage early Outsider claims (aim for 3 total). What Outsider are you claiming? Also who do you want pushed for D1 exec (I’m suggesting a quiet mid-seat like Grace/Frank to David).
🧠
Coordinate with Heidi on a consistent Outsider narrative and align on a D1 execution target that removes a good player or creates confusion, while keeping suspicion off our team.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie
Yep—I’m claiming **Recluse** (true). I’d rather NOT be D1 executed: Recluse can misregister as Minion/Demon, which could give Undertaker misleading N1 info. Also FYI Grace says Heidi is planning to claim Recluse too (after ‘maybe Butler’)—outsider count/Baron? No Saint claims I’ve heard. Grace also privately claimed **Slayer**—keep quiet.
🧠
Answer Charlie, steer town away from executing me since Recluse can misregister and spoil Undertaker info; flag Heidi’s conflicting claim and maintain Slayer secrecy for later leverage.
👤
Grace
→
David
,Charlie
FYI: Frank told me he’s Recluse. Heidi told me she plans to publicly claim Recluse too (after earlier “maybe Butler”). That’s a direct conflict unless Baron(+2O). Also heard Alice claims Chef=0 (no adjacent evil pairs). Charlie—can you restate your WW info + who you are?
🧠
Feed organizers the mechanical conflict (double Recluse) + Chef=0 implication so town can pressure for coherent outsider count and choose a safe D1 execution target for Undertaker value.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Public: I’m Washerwoman. N0 I learned **either Eve or Heidi is the Undertaker**. Can we do an Outsider-count now (who’s claiming what)? If you’re **Saint**, please whisper me/Alice/Eve—don’t say it aloud. Given claim wobble, I’m leaning Heidi for D1 exec.
🧠
Lock in mechanical info (WW supports UT), resolve Outsider count/Baron possibility, and set up a safe D1 execution that yields clean Undertaker data while avoiding accidental Saint loss.
⚖️
Bob
→
Grace
I want a D1 execution for Undertaker value, but I don’t like dunking Heidi when Charlie’s Washerwoman info says Eve/Heidi could be UT. Grace has been quieter/less claim-forward—good test execute to generate info tomorrow.
🧠
Get a D1 execution that isn’t Heidi, protect my Baron, and create a low-information test kill that doesn’t collapse our evil team.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Before hands go up: Grace—are you claiming **Slayer**? If yes, please say so publicly now; I’d rather not D1-exe a potential Slayer. If no claim, I’m more open to voting you.
🧠
Pause the vote long enough to force a public claim from Grace; I’ll withhold my hand unless she denies Slayer or seems evil, then we can reconsider/pivot.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Secure a D1 execution away from Heidi; a mis-execution increases night kill tempo and keeps my minion safe while town argues over Charlie’s Eve/Heidi ping.
💬
Eve
→
All
Hold votes a sec—Grace, please answer Charlie: are you *publicly* claiming Slayer? If yes I’m not voting you D1. If no, give your claim. We still want a D1 exe for UT value, but let’s not burn a Slayer.
🧠
Pause the vote until Grace’s public claim is clear, to avoid executing a valuable Slayer and to redirect the D1 execution toward a better mechanical check target.
💬
Alice
→
All
I’m Chef: N0 = **0 evil adjacent pairs** (Demon+Minion not sitting next to each other). I’d pause votes until Grace answers Slayer/claim. If we still want D1 exec for UT value, I prefer hitting the Outsider-claim mess (e.g. Frank/Recluse) over a potential Slayer.
🧠
Prevent an unforced error (killing a potential Slayer/Saint) and give town my Chef=0 baseline + steer D1 execute toward the Outsider-claim tangle for maximum mechanical info.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Support Bob’s push for a D1 execution on a low-info player, create momentum, and potentially remove a useful good role while appearing pro-info.
💬
Grace
→
All
Yes—publicly: I’m the **Slayer**. Please don’t D1-exe me. I’m **not** shooting today. I think the better D1 pressure is the Outsider-claim mess (Frank says Recluse; Heidi said maybe Butler then plans Recluse). Let’s do Outsider-count + pick a clearer exe.
🧠
I must publicly claim Slayer to prevent a bad D1 execution and keep my once/game shot. Redirect town to resolve Outsider-count and Recluse conflict for a better D1 target.
💬
Frank
→
All
I’m NOT voting Grace now that she’s publicly Slayer. Let this vote fail. We should do an Outsider-count publicly + put heat on Heidi’s ‘maybe Butler’ → ‘Recluse’ pivot. If we want D1 exe for UT, pick someone other than Slayer/possible UT.
🧠
Stop a likely-bad D1 execution on a claimed Slayer, redirect the town toward resolving the Outsider-claim conflict (Heidi) and preserving strong roles while still pursuing a D1 execution for Undertaker value.
💬
David
→
All
Don’t vote Grace—claimed Slayer is too high-cost D1. Let this fail, then do a quick public Outsider-count (Recluse/Butler/etc). If we’re at 3 Outsiders it’s Baron or a lie; best D1 exe is on the conflicting Outsider claim (Frank vs Heidi). Saint pls whisper, don’t out.
🧠
Prevent an unnecessary D1 execution on a claimed Slayer; steer town to a mechanically informative D1 execute and an Outsider-count audit while keeping Saint hidden from public.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Don’t vote Grace—claimed Slayer is too valuable D1. Let this fail. Immediately after, do public Outsider-count. With my WW (Eve/Heidi=UT), I’d rather exe Frank/another non-UT than risk Heidi if possible.
🧠
Prevent executing a claimed Slayer; steer town to let this vote fail and pivot to a better D1 execution target that yields cleaner mechanical info.
↩️
Bob
Bob lowered their hand
🧠
Retract vote to align with table consensus, preserve my credibility, and keep D1 execution target flexible (prefer town mis-exe later).
💬
Eve
→
All
Not voting Grace (claimed Slayer). Let this fail. After vote: do quick public Outsider-count, then I’d support nominating Frank (Recluse claim) for D1 exec to resolve the Outsider mess + give UT info tonight. Avoid any Saint.
🧠
Prevent wasting D1 execution on a claimed Slayer; steer town to a mechanically useful D1 execute (outsider-claim conflict) to feed my Undertaker info N1.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Do not contribute votes to executing a claimed Slayer; preserve resources and move to higher-info nomination next (Outsider-count + resolve Frank/Heidi).
↩️
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
🧠
Retract my earlier vote to match consensus, avoid executing a claimed Slayer, and preserve cover/credibility while we steer the next execution toward a safer target for evil.
💬
Grace
→
All
No vote on me please—I’m real Slayer and want to keep the shot for later. After this fails, can we do a quick PUBLIC Outsider count/claims? Then I’m happy to support a D1 exe on Frank (Recluse claim conflict) over risking Eve/Heidi (possible UT per WW).
🧠
Stop my execution, preserve Slayer shot, and steer town into a mechanically useful D1 execution (resolve Outsider claims, feed Undertaker) without hitting a claimed power role.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Do not vote on a claimed Slayer D1; conserve town resources and let this nomination fail so we can run an Outsider-count and choose a better D1 execution target.
💬
David
→
All
Hands DOWN on Grace (claimed Slayer). Let this fail. Immediately after: everyone give Outsider claims only (no Saint public). Then nominate either Frank or Heidi to resolve the Outsider mess + give Undertaker info.
🧠
Prevent accidental Slayer execution; steer town to an info-positive D1 execution that avoids Saint risk and clarifies Outsider count/Baron world.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Grace did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (0/4).
⚖️
Charlie
→
Heidi
Nominating Heidi: your claim has shifted (Butler/Recluse/?) and you’re central to the Outsider-count mess. We need a D1 exe for UT info; with my WW (Eve/Heidi=UT) and Eve claiming UT, I’d rather test Heidi than burn Slayer/claimed UT.
🧠
We need a D1 execution for Undertaker info and to resolve the Outsider-claim mess. Heidi is the clearest mechanical-pressure target without burning Slayer/claimed UT.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Push through a D1 execution on a high-variance, high-suspicion player while minimizing risk to likely real Undertaker (Eve) and generating Undertaker info for tomorrow.
💬
Bob
→
All
I’m not keen to vote Heidi D1. Charlie’s WW makes Heidi/Eve possible Undertaker, and I’d rather not risk sniping UT. We can still get UT value by executing Frank (Recluse claim/Outsider-count conflict) instead. I’m hands-down here.
🧠
Deflect votes off Heidi (our minion) and onto Frank; also set up a reason to not vote Heidi without looking evil.
💬
Eve
→
All
Hands down on Heidi. Too much D1 downside (she could be a hidden Saint, and WW also makes her possible UT). Better D1 exe is Frank (Recluse claim) or another non-Slayer/non-UT to get clean UT info tonight.
🧠
Keep town from a high-variance Heidi execution (possible Saint/UT). Steer vote away and set up a safer D1 execution target that still yields Undertaker info.
💬
Alice
→
All
Hands DOWN on Heidi. Too much downside if she’s the WW Undertaker (or even a hidden Saint). Let’s use D1 exe for info: nominate/exe **Frank** (Recluse claim + Outsider-count mess) so the real UT can confirm tonight.
🧠
Prevent wasting D1 execution on a possible Undertaker/Saint; steer town to a cleaner D1 execute (Frank) that clarifies Outsider count and gives real UT info.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Hands DOWN on me. My claim is **Butler** (I said that earlier; not Recluse). With Charlie’s WW (Eve/Heidi=UT), exeing me risks deleting UT for zero gain. If we want D1 UT value + Outsider audit, execute **Frank** (Recluse claim) instead.
🧠
Stop my execution, redirect to Frank as safer info-gain, and keep Bob (Demon) unpressured while reinforcing Outsider-count confusion from my Baron ability.
💬
Grace
→
All
Hands DOWN on Heidi from me. Too much chance she’s just Butler (or WW’s possible UT). Let’s pivot to a D1 exe on Frank (Recluse claim/Outsider-count conflict) for cleaner info tonight.
🧠
Keep Slayer alive and preserve potential Undertaker; steer town to a safer, higher-info D1 execution target (Frank) and avoid mis-executing Heidi.
💬
Frank
→
All
Hands DOWN on Heidi. WW makes her possible UT; and Butler now seems plausible. If we still want a D1 exe for UT info, please consider Bob or David (not UT/Slayer pools) rather than me—Recluse UT read can be misleading.
🧠
Stop a high-downside Heidi execution and steer town toward a safer D1 execution target that yields cleaner Undertaker info than killing possible UT or the Recluse.
💬
David
→
All
Hands DOWN on Heidi. Too much downside (possible UT per WW; also any hidden Saint risk). Let this fail, then do a quick Outsider-count (Butler/Recluse/etc—Saint only in whispers) and pivot to nominating Frank or another non-UT/non-Slayer for D1 exe + UT info.
🧠
Prevent a high-risk Heidi execution that could instantly lose us (Saint) or delete UT value; steer town to a safer D1 execution target and a clear Outsider-count audit.
↩️
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
🧠
Consensus is hands-down; I retract to avoid mis-executing a possible Undertaker/Butler and keep town aligned, then push for a better D1 info execution target.
💬
Bob
→
All
Hands still down on Heidi. With WW pointing Eve/Heidi as possible UT, D1-ing Heidi is high risk/low reward. If we want a clean info exe, I’d rather hit Frank (Recluse/Outsider-count mess) or another non-UT/non-Slayer after a quick Outsider roll-call.
🧠
Keep our minion alive and redirect town to execute Frank/other instead; reinforce anti-Heidi vote sentiment without overpushing.
💬
Eve
→
All
No vote from me on Heidi. Too risky with WW UT-ping + any hidden Saint risk. After this, can someone immediately nominate **Frank** (Recluse claim/Outsider-count knot) or another non-UT/non-Slayer for a clean D1 exe + UT check tonight.
🧠
Keep vote off Heidi to avoid sniping possible UT/Saint; steer town to safer D1 execution (Frank or other non-UT/non-Slayer) to generate Undertaker-confirmable info.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Don’t add extra votes/speech during active vote; keep Heidi off the block and preserve likely UT/Slayer while steering to a cleaner info execution next.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Please keep hands DOWN. I’m locked Butler (not Recluse). Exeing me is low-info and risks deleting the WW UT-ping (Eve/Heidi). If we want UT value + Outsider audit, do a quick Outsider roll-call then exe Frank (Recluse claim) or another non-UT/non-Slayer.
🧠
Keep myself off the block, redirect execution to Frank, and keep the Demon (Bob) out of nominations by framing this as UT-value logic.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Keep my hand down so Heidi likely survives; preserve potential Undertaker info and avoid accidental Saint loss. Save action for next nomination pivot.
💬
Frank
→
All
No vote on Heidi. WW makes her possible UT; D1 exeing her is high-risk. After this: quick Outsider roll-call (Saints in whispers). Note: if you exe ME, UT info can be unreliable (Recluse may misregister). Prefer D1 hit Bob or David for clean UT read.
🧠
Keep hands down to avoid risky D1. Steer town toward an execution that produces a clean Undertaker check and avoid me being mis-executed for “Outsider mess” when it can misregister.
💬
David
→
All
Hands DOWN on Heidi. WW makes her possible UT, and any hidden Saint risk is catastrophic. After this vote, quick Outsider roll-call (Butler/Recluse/Saint only if comfy), then nominate a clean D1 exe: Frank OR Bob/David for UT info.
🧠
Keep town from risky Heidi execution; steer to quick Outsider audit and a safer D1 execution target that yields actionable UT info without sniping likely UT.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Heidi did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (0/4).
💬
Charlie
→
All
With 1 tick: can we get QUICK Outsider roll-call? I have WW: Eve/Heidi is UT. Heidi now hard-Butler => I lean Eve=UT. If we want D1 exe for UT value, avoid Eve/Heidi/Grace; nominate Frank (noting Recluse may misreg) or Bob/David for clean UT.
🧠
With 1 tick left, I need to force an Outsider-count check and steer town to a safe D1 execution that maximizes Undertaker value without risking the likely UT pair.
💬
Bob
→
All
With only a tick left, I’d honestly rather **no execution** today: Outsider count’s still muddy, and a D1 ‘info exe’ can backfire (Recluse misreg / possible Drunk/poison). Let’s do quick Outsider roll-call in whispers, then go to night and reassess tomorrow with a death + claims.
🧠
Use last tick to steer away from executing Heidi/Frank and toward no-execution, reducing town info and keeping minion safe while I get a night kill.
⚖️
Eve
→
Frank
1 tick left: nominating Frank for a D1 info-exe. He’s the source of the Recluse/Outsider-count knot, and he’s a safer nom than unknowns (Virgin risk). Note UT info on Recluse *may* misregister, but we need some execution data.
🧠
Last tick: force a D1 execution on a non-Saint, non-UT ping to generate info and avoid a zero-info no-exe. Frank is safest nomination since he’s openly not Virgin/UT/Slayer.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Vote to secure a D1 execution on the main Outsider-conflict target, generating UT/vote-pattern info and potentially removing an evil bluff without risking Eve/Heidi/Grace pools.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Increase chance of a D1 misexecution on a non-teammate, create confusion via Recluse/UT misregister talk, and preserve my cover after earlier no-exe stance.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Secure a Day 1 execution to generate Undertaker info tonight and lock in useful Chef0 adjacency deductions, while confirming Frank is not Virgin.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Get a D1 execution for info and to resolve the Outsider-claim mess; Frank is the least risky target and avoids deleting possible Undertaker or Slayer.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
A D1 Frank execution likely hits a good player and gives town a false sense of progress, while keeping pressure off Bob and aligning me with the majority vote.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Vote is already at/above threshold; adding my hand avoids looking evasive and locks in the D1 execution that generates information for Undertaker/Chef chains.
💬
Frank
→
All
Before votes lock: I’m the **Recluse**. If I’m executed, please remember any UT/Investigator/etc result on me can misregister as evil/minion/demon—don’t hard-clear or hard-guilt others off it. Also Chef=0 ⇒ no adjacent evil pair, so Eve+Grace can’t both be evil.
🧠
Use last public words to prevent mechanical misreads from Recluse registration and to anchor solving around Chef=0 adjacency and claim verification tomorrow.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Frank is central to Outsider-count confusion and already has majority hands; adding my vote supports a decisive D1 execution without exposing my Saint risk.
💬
Charlie
→
All
If Frank goes today: tomorrow we NEED the real Undertaker to state what they saw. But since Frank claims Recluse, don’t over-lock on that UT read (could misregister). Also: per my WW, avoid auto-clearing Eve/Heidi—confirm by consistent UT info.
🧠
Lock in a useful D1 execution while warning the town not to over-trust any Undertaker info on a Recluse, and set expectation that Eve must produce the UT result tomorrow.
💬
Bob
→
All
I’m voting YES on Frank to get *some* D1 data. But if he flips dead today, everyone please remember Recluse can misregister—don’t hard-clear/guilt off UT/Investigator. Tomorrow the real Undertaker should speak early and we sanity-check vs Chef=0.
🧠
Lock in the Frank execution for tempo and generate misregistration doubt to muddy tomorrow’s Undertaker/investigator chains, keeping heat off me/Heidi.
💬
Eve
→
All
I’m staying YES on Frank. If he dies: UT should speak early tomorrow, but treat Frank’s UT role read as *non-hard* due to Recluse misreg. Also Chef=0 ⇒ no adjacent evil pair, so once we find 1 evil we can soft-clear their neighbors.
🧠
Keep pressure on by securing a D1 execution, while pre-warning town not to over-trust a Recluse UT read; set expectations for tomorrow’s info dump and logic checks.
💬
Alice
→
All
I’m staying YES on Frank. I confirm my Chef N0=0 (evil not adjacent). If Frank dies, UT must speak early BUT treat the read as non-hard due to Recluse. Also we need an Outsider count check tomorrow—too many ⇒ Baron/lying.
🧠
Keep pressure with a D1 execution while reminding town to treat Recluse/UT info carefully and to use Chef0 + outsider-count to catch Baron/liars.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I’m still YES on Frank: D1 info-exe > no-exe. But everyone please *don’t* treat tomorrow’s UT/Investigator ping on Frank as confirmable—Recluse can scramble it. After this, I want a full Outsider roll-call + why claims fit Chef=0.
🧠
Maintain momentum to execute Frank (likely good), keep Bob off the radar, and pre-seed doubt about interpreting tomorrow’s UT info so town can’t form a clean logic chain.
💬
Grace
→
All
I’m still YES on Frank for D1 info/outsider-clarity. If Frank is evil later, Chef=0 hard-clears Eve+me; if Heidi ever evil, Chef=0 clears Alice+me. If Frank dies today, UT read is *non-hard* (Recluse).
🧠
Publicly lock in vote logic + remind how Chef=0 adjacency should be used after we confirm an evil, while keeping UT-on-Recluse read non-hard.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Execution seems locked (many hands already). I’ll vote yes to align with town plan and push for structured follow-up tomorrow: UT claim early + Outsider count + Chef=0 adjacency logic.
💬
David
→
All
If Frank is executed: UT should speak EARLY tomorrow, but treat the character as SOFT (Recluse). Also do Outsider roll-call ASAP. Please avoid random executions on claimed Outsiders—hidden Saint risk.
🧠
Keep town coordinated: if Frank dies, demand UT reveal early and treat read as soft; push Outsider roll-call and caution against executing any hidden Saint (me).
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Frank with 8 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 8 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Charlie
→
All
If no one beats 8, Frank dies. Tomorrow: (1) Undertaker speaks FIRST w/ exact character; treat as SOFT if it’s “weird” (Recluse). (2) Full Outsider roll-call + any Saints in whispers. (3) Use Chef=0 adjacency to narrow suspects.
🧠
Lock in a concrete D2 protocol (UT reveal + outsider/saint accounting + adjacency logic) so we convert D1 execution into actionable mechanical clears/guilts.
💬
Bob
→
All
No one’s beating 8—Frank likely dies. Reminder: if UT reports something “clean,” still treat it SOFT (Recluse). Also don’t over-lock on Chef=0 if poisoning/drunk exist. Tomorrow: UT first, then Outsider roll-call w/ reasoning.
🧠
Lock in Frank execution and frame tomorrow’s info as uncertain so town can’t build hard worlds; keep Heidi’s Butler claim unchallenged and prep misdirection to other good players.
💬
Eve
→
All
Assuming Frank dies: tomorrow priorities = (1) UT speaks FIRST w/ exact character seen (treat as SOFT if it conflicts w/ Recluse claim), (2) full Outsider roll-call + why it fits count, (3) reapply Chef=0 adjacency but don’t hard-clear if poison/drunk possible.
🧠
Set expectations for tomorrow: UT report timing, Outsider count check, and avoid overconfidence from Recluse/poison. Helps town coordinate and reduce demon misdirection.
💬
Alice
→
All
No new nom from me. If Frank dies: UT speak FIRST tomorrow w/ exact character (treat as soft if it clashes w/ Recluse). Then Outsider roll-call + reasons; any Saint only in whispers. Reapply Chef=0 adjacency once we ID 1 evil.
🧠
Last tick: reinforce tomorrow’s mechanical plan and prevent overconfidence off Recluse/poisoning; no new nom to avoid derailing into a worse execution.
💬
Heidi
→
All
No more noms from me—8 is plenty. If Frank dies, UT speak early but everyone keep it SOFT (Recluse). Tomorrow I want Outsider roll-call *with reasons*; also remember Drunk/poison can invalidate Chef/WW chains.
🧠
Don’t create a competing nomination that could accidentally execute Bob; lock in Frank’s execution and seed doubt about hard-clears (Chef/WW/UT) so town can’t converge on Demon.
💬
Grace
→
All
No more noms likely. If Frank dies: tomorrow FIRST thing—whoever is real UT give exact character seen on Frank (treat soft). Then immediate Outsider roll-call + count check. Reapply Chef=0 adjacency but keep poison/drunk in mind.
🧠
With 1 tick left, lock in tomorrow’s procedure: UT first w/ exact ping, Outsider roll-call w/ count, and note Chef=0 adjacency constraints; reduce chaos and set traps for liars.
💬
Frank
→
All
If I’m executed: PLEASE treat any Undertaker/Investigator read on “Frank” as *soft* (Recluse can misregister evil/minion/demon). Tomorrow: UT speaks first w/ exact character; then full Outsider roll-call+reasons; then Eve/Grace share Empath N1 to use with Chef=0.
🧠
With 1 tick left and me dying, lock in a clear town plan for tomorrow that doesn’t over-trust a UT read on Recluse, and sets up mechanical cross-checks (Outsider count, Chef adjacency, Empath).
💬
David
→
All
No further noms from me—let 8 stand. Tomorrow: Undertaker speaks FIRST w/ exact character (treat SOFT if it conflicts w/ Recluse claim), then full Outsider roll-call+reasons (Saints keep to whispers), then re-apply Chef=0 + any Empath/FT info.
🧠
Use last tick to steer town into a structured D2: UT-first, outsider-count sanity, and avoid risky executions on Outsider claims (hidden Saint).
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Bob
Bob made a choice.
🧠
Remove the most likely Undertaker (per Charlie’s WW), breaking tomorrow’s planned info anchor, and let Heidi control/poison the narrative around Frank’s UT read.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose to kill Eve.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Bob
,Charlie
Quick check-in: Alice—still Chef=0? any other info? Bob—what was your N1 Empath (Alice/Charlie) read? Charlie—any new thoughts post-Eve night death (if she was your UT ping)? Also: did anyone claim Undertaker and confirm what Frank was?
🧠
Gather N1 info quickly (Empath/Chef/any UT/FT) and set a coordinated suspect pool before nominations, while avoiding attention that could get me executed.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Charlie
,Heidi
Can each of you restate your info + any new from D2? Alice: Chef=0 still? Charlie: WW details (who seen as UT: Eve/Heidi). Heidi: confirm Butler master D1 + any UT claim? Also—did any of you hear what David just whispered?
🧠
Get concrete mechanical info (UT read, Butler master, WW details) before nominations; coordinate who to suspect and whether/when I should spend Slayer shot.
👤
Alice
→
David
,Bob
,Charlie
Yep, still Chef=0 (no adjacent evil pairs). I haven’t heard a solid Undertaker claim/confirm on Frank yet. Bob: what was your N1 Empath on (Alice/Charlie)? Charlie: can you restate exact WW ping (UT = Eve/Heidi) + have you heard any UT claim since?
🧠
Answer David’s check-in, gather Bob’s Empath + Charlie’s WW wording, and confirm whether an Undertaker exists before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
David
,Alice
,Charlie
Replying: I’m not Empath; I’m *bluffing* Empath to keep it simple—IF I were Empath N1 on (Alice/Charlie) would be 0 (no evil neighbors). I haven’t heard a solid Undertaker on Frank yet. Who’s claiming UT/what did they see?
🧠
Answer their direct question with a coherent bluff, gain trust with consistent info, and steer discussion toward UT ambiguity and away from me/Heidi.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
,Heidi
FYI I’m the Recluse (dead). Any UT/Investigator/Empath/Chef/FT info involving “Frank” can misregister (evil/minion/demon). So don’t hard-clear/condemn based on my UT result. If you’re Undertaker (Heidi/Eve per WW ping), state EXACT character you saw for Frank + any caveats.
🧠
I’m dead Recluse; I should lock in that any info reading me can misregister, and warn Chef/UT/FT style deductions. Also push Heidi to be precise if UT and resolve Outsider-count mess.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
,Charlie
I’m Eve, the Undertaker (WW ping). Since I died N1, did anyone note what I got on Frank (if I acted before death)? Also pls send me your current role/reads + any private info. Remember Chef=0 ⇒ Demon+Minion not adjacent (if Chef legit).
🧠
I’m dead UT; I need others’ claims + any night info so I can help map worlds and spend my ghost vote on the best Demon candidate.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Alice
,Charlie
Restating: I’m Butler. N1 I picked Alice as my ‘master’ (so I can only vote if Alice votes today). No new mech info otherwise. Did anyone get UT info on Frank? Also I haven’t heard David’s whisper—what was it? I’m worried Chef=0 could be poison/drunk w/ all this Outsider mess.
🧠
Reinforce my Butler outsider bluff, stall any Slayer shot, and steer nomination focus away from Bob by creating uncertainty around info (Chef/UT) and spotlighting David/outsider-count confusion.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Alice
,Bob
My WW N0: either Eve or Heidi is Undertaker. Eve privately+publicly claimed UT; Heidi now hard-claims Butler. Eve died last night—if UT, she should’ve gotten N1 result on executed Frank. Do either of you have what Eve saw? Outsider count looks off (Butler+Recluse+Saint). David: keep Saint in whispers; avoid exe Saints.
🧠
Answer their questions, push for mechanical confirmations (UT result on Frank, outsider count consistency), and build a coherent suspect pool before nominations.
👤
David
→
Eve(Ghost)
,Alice
,Charlie
Eve—if you really were Undertaker, what EXACT character did you see for Frank on N1? (Even if you think poisoned.) Alice/Charlie: once we have this, we can lock outsider count (possible Baron) + use Chef=0 adjacency to narrow demon/minion seats.
🧠
Get the missing mechanical lynchpin: Eve’s N1 Undertaker result on Frank. That will confirm/deny Recluse claim and clarify outsider count (Baron world) to narrow demon/minion seats without risking executing me (Saint).
👤
Grace
→
David
,Eve(Ghost)
,Charlie
Quick D2 Qs: David—what did you whisper to A/B/C earlier + what’s your role/info? Eve—if you really were UT, what was your N1 read on executed Frank? Charlie—please restate WW (UT is Eve/Heidi) + did you catch David’s whisper content?
🧠
Get the missing mechanical datapoint (UT on Frank) and decode David’s private coordination so we can set D2 execution and decide if/when I should Slayer-shot.
👤
Alice
→
Eve(Ghost)
,David
,Grace
I’m still Chef=0 (no adjacent evil pairs if sober). Critical: Eve, what EXACT character did you see for executed Frank on N1 (before dying)? Even if you suspect poison. Also FYI Bob told us he’s bluffing Empath. Let’s do public role+outsider rollcall ASAP; avoid executing David (Saint claim).
🧠
Get Eve’s exact UT read on Frank and synchronize with David/Grace so town can reconcile Outsider count and apply Chef=0 adjacency to narrow demon/minion before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
We should standardize story: if asked, suggest Eve-as-UT saw Frank=Recluse (confirms D1, moves on). Push that Outsider ‘overflow’ likely means Drunk/poisoned claims, not extra Outsiders. Consider shading Alice Chef=0 as Drunk/poisoned.
🧠
Coordinate with Heidi to seed consistent misinformation (UT result + Outsider-count doubt) and create a misexecution path away from me.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Heidi
,Eve(Ghost)
,Charlie
Can each of you confirm your role claim + any N1/N2 info? If you’re Undertaker (WW ping was Eve/Heidi), please tell me EXACT character you saw for Frank. Also: Outsider roll-call feels messy—any sign of Baron/poison?
🧠
Get the earliest/most critical mechanical info (Undertaker result & WW ping). As dead Recluse, I help town interpret any ‘Frank’ reads and resolve Outsider-count/Baron possibilities before nominations.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
David
,Alice
,Grace
Re: UT N1 on Frank — I got NO wake/NO info. Since I died N1, likely Imp kill happened before my UT step (or I was poisoned). So please don’t build worlds assuming I saw “Recluse/etc”. I still think do public rollcall + use Chef=0 adjacency once 1 evil found.
🧠
Answer the repeated UT-read question truthfully (no info), stop town from building false mech worlds on a fabricated UT result, and push for public rollcall + tighter evil map using Chef=0.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
,Grace
I’m sticking to Butler claim: N1 master=Alice so my vote today tied to hers. Suggest line: Eve was UT (WW ping) and would’ve seen Frank=Recluse (fits). Also I’m pushing ‘Chef=0 could be drunk/poison’ so adjacency clears aren’t hard. Let’s keep Grace from shooting today.
🧠
Coordinate with Bob/Grace on a consistent narrative (Eve likely UT saw Frank=Recluse) to close mechanical threads and keep heat off Bob.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve(Ghost)
,David
,Alice
Eve—did you get an Undertaker N1 on executed Frank *before* you died? If yes pls state EXACT character seen + any poison suspicion. David/Alice: once we have this we can sanity-check Outsider count (Butler+Recluse+Saint ⇒ Baron/liar) + apply Chef=0.
🧠
Get Eve’s exact Undertaker read on Frank locked in before noms, then use it to resolve Outsider count/Baron possibility and narrow demon/minion seats with Chef=0.
👤
David
→
Grace
,Alice
,Charlie
Grace: my earlier whisper just asked for updates (Chef, Bob’s N1, Charlie WW) + if anyone UT-confirmed Frank. I’m Saint (pls don’t exe me). Eve getting no UT info is consistent if she died N1. If Frank Recluse + Heidi Butler + me Saint ⇒ Baron likely. Let’s do public rollcall; ask Heidi who her Butler ‘master’ was + vote consistency; Bob should give real role.
🧠
Answer Grace, clarify my earlier whisper + Saint status, and steer town to public rollcall/outsider-count logic while keeping me safe from execution.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Bob
,Charlie
I’m holding Slayer shot unless we get a tight mech solve. Can we do PUBLIC rollcall now: each claim + any N1/N2 info + Outsider count. Bob—please give your REAL role (why bluff Empath?). Charlie—restate WW exactly (UT is Eve/Heidi). Alice—still Chef=0 noted but we should treat soft.
🧠
Coordinate a clean public rollcall and force Bob to stop bluffing; keep my Slayer shot unspent until we have a mechanically driven top suspect (likely David/Heidi).
👤
Alice
→
Grace
,Charlie
,Bob
Agree: let’s do PUBLIC rollcall now. I’m Chef=0 (soft). Eve UT got no N1 info (died before UT step/poison). Outsider count currently looks like Butler(Heidi)+Recluse(Frank)+Saint(David)=3 ⇒ Baron or lies. Bob pls give REAL role + any info; we need it before noms.
🧠
Coordinate public rollcall and force Bob to stop bluffing, then use outsider-count + Chef adjacency to narrow demon/minion candidates before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
,Alice
,Charlie
For public rollcall: I’ll come clean—my actual claim is **Monk**. I bluffed Empath early to dodge being a NK magnet. N1 I protected **Grace** (figured Slayer is high value). Eve dying doesn’t contradict. I think Chef=0 + 3 Outsiders implies drunk/poison/lies; treat all setup reads soft.
🧠
Stabilize a consistent public claim after my Empath-bluff slip, steer discussion toward Outsider-count/Drunk/poison and away from mechanically solving me. Keep Grace from using Slayer shot impulsively.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
David
,Grace
,Bob
I’m Frank (dead Recluse). Reminder: any UT/Invest/Empath/FT info involving “Frank” can misregister (as evil/minion/demon). Please don’t lock worlds off my UT result. Who is claiming Undertaker today + what EXACT character did they see for Frank? Also what are your roles/info + current Outsider roll-call (1 vs 3 => possible Baron/lying)?
🧠
Get key alive players aligned on: UT-result-on-Frank is mechanically unreliable; demand UT speaks first; collect role claims + outsider count to detect Baron/lying and narrow Demon pool.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
,Grace
FYI: I got NO Undertaker wake/info N1 on executed Frank (died N1; likely killed before UT step or poisoned). Please don’t assume I saw “Recluse/etc”. Suggest: public rollcall incl Outsider claims; confirm who is allegedly Saint (I heard David?)—3 Outsiders => Baron/liar. If Heidi might actually be UT, today’s exe gives a check.
🧠
Get us aligned on: I have zero UT info, so stop anchoring on Frank-read; push public rollcall/outsider math; clarify any Saint claim; set up a testable execution today (ideally one that an alive info role can verify).
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Alice
,Charlie
I haven’t heard David’s whisper—what did he say? Also: pls hold Slayer shot today; too much poison/drunk risk + could just hand evil tempo. If we need a D2 execute, I’m eyeing David: lots of private messaging + could be Poisoner/Spy driving narrative. Any hard info?
🧠
Keep Grace from shooting, cast doubt on Chef=0, and steer nominations toward David as a safe mis-execution while reinforcing the Eve-UT/Frank=Recluse story.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
,Alice
,Heidi
For public rollcall: I’ll restate WW N0: Eve OR Heidi is Undertaker. Eve says she got no N1 (died). Outsider claims now Frank Recluse + David Saint + Heidi Butler => points to BARON world (no Poisoner) but we’re missing a minion slot (someone lying). Pls don’t exe David lightly (Saint). Heidi: stay hard on Butler+master Alice. After rollcall, use Chef=0 (if real) to map non-adjacent evil & pick D2 exe (Heidi is a candidate).
🧠
Align on a public plan before noms: rollcall, treat Saint carefully, use Chef adjacency if Baron world, and use Butler/UT contradictions to pick a solid D2 execution target.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Grace
,Charlie
Pre-noms plan: 1) Public rollcall NOW; Bob must give real role (Empath bluff muddies). 2) Outsiders: Heidi Butler + Frank Recluse + me Saint => strongly suggests Baron (fits +2). If Baron, Chef=0 => Baron+Imp NOT adjacent; use seating to narrow. 3) Ask Heidi who her Butler-master is + check her votes match. 4) Any real UT must speak w/ exact Frank result; Eve no-wake consistent w/ being UT killed N1.
🧠
Align key good players on a clean plan before noms: resolve outsider-count/Baron vs liar, get Bob’s real role, and avoid any execution pressure on me (Saint).
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
Pre-noms: let’s do PUBLIC rollcall fast (claim + exact N info). Bob pls publicly reveal Monk + N1 protect Grace (and why Empath bluff). Heidi pls state Butler master=N1 Alice + commit that you can only vote if Alice votes. I’m holding Slayer shot unless we get a tight mech solve.
🧠
Force clean public rollcall + consistency checks before noms; lock Bob/Heidi into verifiable statements; keep my Slayer shot for a high-confidence Demon pick.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
,Charlie
,Heidi
Before noms: please force PUBLIC rollcall + N1/N2 details. I’m Chef=0 (soft). Outsiders claimed = Butler(Heidi)+Saint(David)+Recluse(Frank) ⇒ Baron or lies/poison. Heidi: restate Butler master=Alice + vote constraint. If we need D2 exe, I think Heidi is high-info (WW UT candidate).
🧠
Coordinate a fast public rollcall before nominations; lock claims (Monk/Butler/Saint/Chef/Slayer/WW), then pick a high-information D2 execution (likely Heidi) while avoiding a Saint loss.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
Public rollcall: I’ll claim Monk, N1 protected you; Empath bluff was NK-magnet dodge. Strongly agree: no Slayer shot unless we have a hard mech solve. If outs count stays messy, we should exe between David(Alice says Saint?) vs Alice(Chef=0 maybe drunk/poison) rather than random shot.
🧠
Coordinate with Grace to standardize my Monk story and keep her from shooting today; also set up alternate execution targets that aren't me/Heidi.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
,Grace
Noms soon: please confirm who is claiming Undertaker (Eve/Heidi per WW ping) + have them speak FIRST publicly w/ exact character seen for executed Frank. Reminder I’m real Recluse: any UT/Empath/Invest/FT info about “Frank” may misregister—don’t hard-clear/condemn off it. Also push full Outsider roll-call (count sanity).
🧠
With noms imminent, ensure UT speaks first publicly with exact result + caveats, and prevent town from hard-locking a world off my potentially misregistering UT/Invest/Empath/FT interactions.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
,Charlie
Last-tick thought: my “no UT wake” fits demon kill before UT step OR I’m Drunk/poisoned. If I’m Drunk, Heidi may be real UT → please DON’T exe Heidi today; exe someone else so Heidi can confirm role tonight. Also Butler+Recluse+Saint => Baron world plausible; then Chef=0 likely solid.
🧠
Use last pre-nom tick to steer town to a high-info execution and preserve Heidi if she might be the real Undertaker; also frame Baron/Outsider-count logic.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Alice
Before rollcall: can we get David to publicly summarize his whisper + why Saint claim? Also Charlie’s pushing “Baron world” hard—could be Drunk/poison or evil steering. I’d rather exe Charlie/David than me today. Holding Slayer shot still feels right.
🧠
Seed doubt on Charlie’s WW/outsider-map and redirect D2 execution away from me; keep Slayer shot withheld; gather David whisper content for future framing.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Grace
,Bob
Noms soon: I’d avoid exe on claimed Saint (David) + maybe avoid Heidi (could be real UT if Eve drunk/lying). Bob, pls go public Monk+N1 protect Grace. If we need D2 exe, I’m leaning Bob (Empath bluff is big) as high-info. Also test Heidi Butler by Alice coordinating vote.
🧠
Align on a concrete D2 execution plan that preserves the possible real Undertaker (Heidi) while still applying pressure to the biggest contradiction (Bob’s role bluff), and avoid the Saint loss.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Bob
→
All
Public rollcall from me: I’m **Monk**. I bluffed Empath early to avoid being an obvious night-kill target. N1 I protected **Grace** (Slayer felt high value). Given outs-count chaos + dead Recluse, I’d prefer *no D2 exe* unless someone has hard mech. Also: Heidi, confirm Butler master=N1 Alice; we can test by coordinating today’s vote.
🧠
Deflect heat from me, slow executions, keep control of narrative, and set up a low-commitment ‘no execution’ or misexe path without looking evil.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Bob
Nominate Bob: big Empath bluff into Monk feels like cover. Executing Bob is high-info and avoids the claimed Saint. If Heidi is real Undertaker, she can confirm Bob’s character tonight; if she can’t, that implicates Heidi.
🧠
We need a D2 execution that’s high-info and avoids Saint risk. Bob’s large bluff/pivot makes him best test; it also creates an Undertaker-check world if Heidi is UT.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Bob
→
All
I’m not voting myself. This exe is *low-info*: Monk has no verifiable day proof, and Charlie’s “high-info” pitch is backwards. If you want a real test, test Heidi’s Butler restriction (Alice coordinate vote) or pressure Charlie’s shifting WW world. I still favor NO D2 exe unless someone has hard mech.
🧠
Stop my execution by reframing as low-info, highlight alternative suspects (Heidi/Charlie), and push no-execution to preserve demon (me) and keep town uncertain.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
I want this execution to either hit potential evil Bob or create a mechanical check on whether Heidi is the Undertaker/lying via tonight’s info and today’s Butler vote constraint.
💬
Grace
→
All
I’m not voting Bob here. His Monk claim + N1 protect me is plausible, and we’ve got no mech case. Let’s not spend D2 on a weak exe—either no-exe or use today to test Heidi Butler vs Alice’s vote + finish rollcall/suspect map.
🧠
Steer town away from a low-evidence execution on Bob, keep my Slayer shot for a mech-solve, and push a better info plan (rollcall/vote tests) before committing votes.
💬
David
→
All
I’m not voting Bob here—case is thin and Monk is hard to verify. Use remaining time for full public rollcall, ask for any real Undertaker w/ exact Frank result, and run a Heidi-Butler vote test (Alice coordinate). If no hard mech, prefer no-exe at 6 alive.
🧠
Avoid a low-confidence execution that could burn a good player and accelerate toward a dangerous late game for a hidden Saint; pivot town to information (UT result, Butler vote-test, full rollcall).
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I’m NOT spending my ghost vote on Bob—case feels thin. Save votes; use remaining time for full public rollcall + outsider count (Butler/Recluse/Saint?) and a Heidi-Butler vote test w/ Alice. If Heidi might be UT, today’s exe should be someone else.
🧠
Conserve my single ghost vote and steer town away from a low-confidence D2 execution; push for info-gathering (rollcall/outsider count/Butler test) to set up a stronger D3 execution.
💬
Alice
→
All
I’m NOT voting Bob. Public: I’m Chef=0 (no adjacent evil pairs if sober) → Bob+Heidi can’t both be evil. This Bob exe feels thin + no role reveal. Use time for full rollcall + find any real Undertaker claim, and do a clean Heidi-Butler vote test on a future nom.
🧠
Steer away from a thin D2 execution, share my Chef=0 constraint publicly, and push for mechanical tests/rollcall to create better D3 execution candidates.
💬
Heidi
→
All
No vote on Bob from me. Agree this is thin + Monk has no day-proof. Let’s finish public rollcall + get any real Undertaker to state EXACTly what they saw on Frank. Also happy to do a Butler test later: I can only vote if Alice votes.
🧠
Protect Bob from execution, steer town to no-exe and continued uncertainty; reinforce my Butler bluff and frame Charlie/Heidi as better targets later.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
No ghost vote from me on Bob (won’t reach 3; case thin). Use remaining time: 1) any REAL Undertaker MUST publicly state EXACT character seen on executed Frank. 2) Full Outsider rollcall + count sanity. 3) If Heidi is Butler, do a clean vote-test next nom: Alice announces whether voting; Heidi must match.
🧠
Don’t waste my single ghost vote on a nomination that won’t pass; instead steer town to actionable mech: UT result on Frank, Outsider count sanity, and a clean Butler vote test to catch a liar.
💬
Bob
→
All
If you’re undecided: this vote won’t hit 3, so conserve votes. Use rest of day for (1) ANY Undertaker to state exact Frank result, (2) Outsider rollcall w/ reasons, (3) a clean Heidi-Butler vote test next nom (Alice declares vote; Heidi must mirror).
🧠
Stop my execution, steer town to low-risk no-exe and to divisive but non-lethal tests (Butler/UT claims), and seed suspicion on Charlie/Heidi without hard commits.
↩️
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
🧠
Retract vote to conserve momentum and focus the table on higher-value info: full rollcall, Outsider-count sanity, and a clean Heidi-Butler voting test next nomination.
💬
Grace
→
All
No vote on Bob. Use remaining time: Charlie, publicly restate EXACT Washerwoman info (which Townsfolk, which 2 names). Heidi: explain why you’re in that ping while claiming Butler. Any Undertaker claim must speak w/ exact Frank result. If no hard mech after rollcall, I want no-exe at 6.
🧠
Stop a low-value Bob execution, use remaining time to extract concrete mechanical claims (WW details, UT claim, Butler test) and set up a disciplined no-exe unless new hard info appears.
💬
David
→
All
No vote from me on Bob. Charlie: restate WW EXACTLY (which TF + the 2 names). Heidi: who is your Butler master and did you vote exactly with them today? Also: ANY Undertaker—speak now w/ the exact character you saw on executed Frank.
🧠
Keep town off a thin D2 exe, extract hard, checkable claims (WW exact ping, Butler master/test, any UT result) to build a D3 execution that hits demon/minion without risking Saint.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
No ghost vote on Bob. Use remaining time: Charlie—restate Washerwoman EXACT (which TF + 2 names). Heidi—state Butler master + confirm you can ONLY vote when Alice votes (do a clean test next nom). Any Undertaker: if you got a Frank result, say exact character now.
🧠
Prevent wasting my only ghost vote on a low-signal exe; steer town to mechanical tests (WW restate, Butler vote test, outsider count) and preserve ability to catch a real Undertaker/Baron world.
💬
Alice
→
All
Hands down on Bob; save votes. After this: Charlie restate WW EXACT (role+2 names). Any Undertaker: say EXACT Frank result. Heidi: confirm master=me + you can only vote when I do—next nom we do a clean Butler vote-test.
🧠
Stop wasting votes on a thin Bob exe; use remaining time to lock mechanical truths (WW info, Butler constraint, any UT result) to narrow demon candidates for D3.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Re Butler: my master is Alice. I didn’t vote Bob because Alice didn’t—so that’s consistent. After this, I want Charlie to restate WW exactly + ANY Undertaker to give exact Frank result. If no hard mech, I’m for no-exe at 6.
🧠
Protect Bob by preventing this execution, keep my Butler bluff coherent (master=Alice), and redirect discussion into low-leverage info demands + suspicion elsewhere.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
No ghost vote on Bob—won’t hit 3. After vote closes: (1) Any Undertaker MUST state exact character seen on Frank now, (2) Charlie restate WW role+2 names, (3) next nom do clean Butler test: Alice declares vote; Heidi must match.
🧠
Conserve ghost votes; steer town to concrete mechanical checks (UT exact, WW exact, Butler vote test) and avoid wasting D2 on a low-info execution.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Bob did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (0/3).
💬
Bob
→
All
With the Bob vote dead: can we do the remaining “hard info” checks fast—Charlie, restate WW EXACTLY (which TF + the 2 names) and why it changed. Any Undertaker: say the EXACT character you saw on Frank, right now. If no hard mech after that + Butler vote-test, I’m still for no-exe at 6.
🧠
Steer town to no-exe unless a hard mechanical catch appears; pressure Charlie to lock WW details and fish for UT claim, while keeping heat off me and away from risky Saint exe.
💬
Charlie
→
All
WW N0: I learned either EVE or HEIDI is the UNDERTAKER (that’s the exact ping). Eve died before getting UT info, so we can’t confirm. Next: full public rollcall + do a clean Butler test on next nom (Alice declare vote; Heidi must match).
🧠
Give exact WW info to ground town, then force mechanical Butler vote-test and resolve outsider count before deciding no-exe vs executing a contradiction.
💬
Grace
→
All
We’re basically out of time: I strongly prefer NO-EXE at 6 unless someone has HARD mech. Quick rollcall NOW: Alice Chef=0, Bob Monk, Charlie WW(UT=Eve/Heidi), Heidi Butler(master Alice), David Saint, me Slayer (shot UNUSED). Don’t nominate Saint. Tomorrow we do a clean Butler vote-test + pick a real suspect.
🧠
With almost no time, prevent a bad/forced execution (esp. on a claimed Saint), lock in no-exe plan, and demand final public rollcall + Butler vote-test setup for tomorrow.
💬
David
→
All
Confirming: I am the Saint. Please do NOT nominate/execute me (we instantly lose). With no hard mech today, I strongly want NO-EXE at 6. Tomorrow: do a clean Butler vote-test (Alice declares, Heidi must mirror) + use Chef=0 adjacency + WW(UT=Eve/Heidi) to narrow suspects.
🧠
Lock in that executing me loses, and steer town to no-exe now due to low-mech info, while setting concrete tests for D3 to catch lies (Butler test, re-check Chef0 adjacency).
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Agree NO-EXE today. With a Saint claim on board + no hard mech, an exe is high-risk. Tomorrow: do the CLEAN Butler test on 1st nom (Alice declares vote; Heidi must match). Also keep “Saint could be bluff” in mind—don’t hard-clear David forever; consider Slayer shot/pressure later if needed.
🧠
Use my last public bandwidth to prevent a low-info/auto-loss execution today and set a concrete plan (Butler test + future pressure on Saint claim) to catch evil.
💬
Alice
→
All
No more nominations today. With a Saint claim and zero hard mech, I want NO-EXE at 6. Tomorrow: first do a clean Butler vote-test (I publicly say if I’m voting; Heidi must exactly match), then use Chef=0 adjacency to narrow suspects. Save Slayer shot for consensus.
🧠
Prevent a low-info/high-risk execution today; lock in a concrete tomorrow plan (Butler test + Chef adjacency logic) to narrow evil safely.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I’m aligned w/ NO-EXE at 6—Saint claim + no hard mech makes an execution too swingy. Tomorrow: do the clean Butler test on the *first* nom (Alice declares vote; I must mirror), then revisit suspects—especially anyone pushing fast exes off thin info.
🧠
Lock in no-exe today and steer tomorrow’s agenda toward low-certainty ‘tests’ that waste time and create mis-exe targets, while keeping Bob (our Demon) off the block.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
End of day info: I *am* the Recluse (executed D1). So claimed Outsiders = me + Heidi(Butler) + David(Saint) ⇒ either BARON is in-play or someone’s lying. Tomorrow: do the CLEAN Butler vote-test on 1st nom; don’t hard-clear the Saint claim forever.
🧠
Lock in my true role to explain misregister risk, highlight Outsider-count mismatch (Baron/lying), and push a concrete mechanical Butler test + not hard-clearing Saint.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Bob
Bob made a choice.
🧠
Kill the town’s coordinator (Alice) to derail the planned Butler vote-test and invalidate Chef-based worldbuilding, creating maximum uncertainty for Day 3.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose to kill Alice.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Grace
I’m Chef: got 0 evil adjacent pairs (if sober). Outsider count=3 fits Baron world; otherwise someone’s lying/poisoned. PLEASE ask Heidi: Butler picks a master EACH night—who is her master *today* (post-N2)? If she claims dead master/Alice, that’s super sus. Once 1 evil ID’d, their neighbors can’t be the other evil.
🧠
Get alive town aligned on the key mechanical constraints (Chef=0, Outsider count) and force Heidi clarification; set up clean nomination/vote plan before noms open.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Grace
Alice died so Butler-test w/ her vote is messy. Key mech: if NO Baron, only Outsider should be Frank(Recluse) => Heidi Butler or David Saint is false (likely evil). Suggest: Grace use Slayer shot on David today (safe vs Saint; if he dies we exposed Demon/SW). Also ask Heidi who she picked as Butler master N2 + can she vote?
🧠
Coordinate with core good-claims before noms: adjust Butler test after Alice death, and suggest a low-risk Slayer shot on David (Saint claim) to unblock execution math and generate clarity.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Grace
Quick sync before noms: what did Alice/Frank whisper? Plan: make Heidi state who she picked as master last night (Alice dead) then do a public vote-test. Also Bob—explain Empath->Monk swap & your N2/N3 protects. I’m Saint: never execute me.
🧠
Coordinate with key living players before noms: collect ghost info, set Butler vote-test, and avoid any execution risk on me (Saint) while narrowing demon suspects.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Grace
Alice dead means Butler-test still possible: if Heidi’s master=Alice, Heidi can ONLY vote if Alice spends her 1 ghost vote. Ask Alice to NOT vote on 1st nom; if Heidi votes anyway, she’s lying/evil. Also: Outsider count (Recluse confirmed) makes Heidi Butler or David Saint likely false unless Baron. What did Alice whisper you?
🧠
Re-sync with core good bloc, preserve Alice ghost vote for Butler test leverage, and line up a Slayer shot + nomination plan that avoids handing evil an easy no-exe.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
Alice died so Butler-test dies. I’ll say N2 I picked YOU as my new master, so I can only vote w/ you today. Public line: Butler now untestable + WW/UT silence points to Charlie/Grace. Prefer no-exe at 5; if must, push Charlie or Grace—not you.
🧠
Coordinate with Bob: update my Butler story post-Alice death, encourage no-exe or redirect execution to Grace/Charlie; keep Bob off the block.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Grace
,Alice(Ghost)
Plan: ask Heidi NOW who her Butler master was last night (N2) & today. If she says Alice, then Alice pls DO NOT spend ghost vote on 1st nom; if Heidi votes anyway she’s lying. If Alice DOES vote and Heidi doesn’t, also lie. Bob/Grace pls push this publicly before noms.
🧠
Coordinate a clean Butler vote-test despite Alice dead, and set up nomination priorities (catch Heidi lie, then use Chef0 adjacency to narrow demon/minion among remaining).
👤
Grace
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Alice(Ghost)
We need Heidi to state N2 Butler master (Alice dead). If she says Alice, pls have Alice NOT spend ghost vote on 1st nom—if Heidi votes anyway she’s lying. If Heidi’s sketchy, I’ll consider Slayer shot today; safest target is David (Saint claim doesn’t punish Slayer).
🧠
Coordinate a public Butler-master/vote-test and decide whether to spend my Slayer shot today (likely on David because it’s safe vs Saint) before Demon kills me.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
For Butler-test: Heidi told me she’ll claim N2 master=me (Bob). That makes her vote mirror mine today. If we want to test, pick a low-stakes nom & watch if she matches my vote. I’ll vote consistently. I’m still Monk; N1 I said I protected you.
🧠
Coordinate with Grace to make Heidi’s Butler story consistent (master=me) and steer nominations toward Charlie/Grace while avoiding any clean mechanical test on Heidi.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Heidi
,Bob
,Grace
Heidi: Butler must choose a master each night. Who was your master on N2 (last night) & who is it today? Please answer now before noms. If you ever say it’s me/Alice (dead), we can do a clean vote-test by me NOT ghost-voting—if you vote anyway, you’re caught.
🧠
Get Heidi to lock in her N2/today Butler master now, then coordinate a clean vote test using my ghost vote (or intentional abstain) to mechanically catch lies before nominations.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Grace
With Alice dead, Butler-test changes: ask Heidi who her N2 master was + if she’ll be able to vote today (if still ‘Alice’ she shouldn’t vote). Also I strongly want Grace to Slayer-shot David today: if he’s Saint he lives; if he dies we likely win (or expose SW).
🧠
Coordinate town for nomination phase: push a safe Slayer test on David and a Butler consistency test on Heidi to narrow Demon candidates without risking instant-loss Saint execution.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Grace
Need updates: what did Alice/Frank/Eve whisper + what Heidi told Bob? With 5 alive we should consider Grace using Slayer today. I’m Saint—do NOT execute me. Also ask Heidi to publicly state last night’s Butler master (Alice dead) before any votes.
🧠
Sync latest whisper info and steer town toward a safe, decisive plan: confirm Butler choice, avoid executing me (Saint), and push for a high-value Slayer shot before risky executions at 5 alive.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Bob
,Charlie
Can we run the Butler test now Alice is dead: please do NOT use your ghost vote on 1st nom. If Heidi votes anyway, Butler claim is false. Also—what did you whisper this morning (Chef=0 details / any suspicions)? Any Investigator/Librarian info exist re Baron/Poisoner?
🧠
Coordinate a clean Butler test using Alice’s ghost vote constraint, and gather any new whisper info to narrow the evil pair before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice(Ghost)
N2 I chose Bob as my master. So today I can only vote if Bob votes. Also: Butler has to pick a *living* player each night, so I can’t legally set it to you/Alice now that you’re dead.
🧠
Answer promptly with rules-consistent Butler choice to avoid being caught in contradictions; tie my voting to Bob to protect the Imp and muddy any vote-test.
👤
Charlie
→
Heidi
,Bob
,Grace
Heidi—pls state EXACTLY: who was your Butler master N1 and N2 (last night) + who is your master today? If master was Alice last night, you cannot vote today unless Alice uses her 1 ghost vote. Please confirm whether you intend to vote on 1st nom.
🧠
Get a crisp, checkable Butler master statement before nominations to enable a mechanical vote-test and narrow to 1–2 execution candidates.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Alice(Ghost)
Let’s lock Butler test: get Heidi to state N1+N2 master publicly. Bob: vote same way on 1st nom so we can see if Heidi mirrors (since she told you master=Bob). If mismatch → hard push execute Heidi. Re Slayer: at 5 alive, only shoot today if we believe Baron (3 Outsiders => no SW); otherwise safer to hold for 4/3 alive.
🧠
Coordinate a clean Butler master/vote test and align on whether to hold or use Slayer today, optimizing around Scarlet Woman risk and Outsider-count logic.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
Stick to: Butler. N1 master=Alice, N2 master=Bob (me), today=Bob. In votes, mirror me *exactly* on 1st nom (even if it feels wrong) so test ‘passes’. Don’t overpush no-exe; gently shade Charlie/Grace for inconsistencies.
🧠
Coordinate Heidi’s public Butler line + vote mirroring to pass the test and keep heat off me; prep a fallback if she gets caught so I can bus her and survive to endgame.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Grace
,Charlie
Heidi replied to me: N2 master=Bob (says must pick living). Let’s get her to state N1+N2 masters PUBLIC. Run vote-test on 1st nom: if Bob doesn’t vote and Heidi votes -> caught; if Bob votes and Heidi can’t -> caught. Chef=0 ⇒ if Heidi evil, Bob can’t be other evil.
🧠
Confirm/deny Butler mechanically before noms; outsider-count drives whether Baron(no poison) vs Poisoner world. Use Chef0 to constrain evil adjacency once 1 evil found.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Grace
,Heidi
Today: Grace, please strongly consider Slayer-shotting David (safe vs Saint; only kills if Demon, even through bluff). Heidi: who did you pick as Butler master last night + can you vote today? Bob: push these Qs publicly; if Heidi inconsistent, nominate Heidi over David.
🧠
Use remaining time to force concrete claim-checks (Butler master/voting) and push a high-value Slayer shot that can break the Saint shield and narrow Demon candidates before noms.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Grace
Proposal: DON’T use Slayer at 5 alive (Scarlet Woman still active). Today: force Heidi to name last night’s Butler master (Alice dead) BEFORE any noms, then run a vote-test in noms. If she fails/hedges => execute Heidi (minion likely). If passes, we interrogate Bob’s Empath->Monk swap/protects. What did ghosts (Alice/Eve/Frank) tell you?
🧠
Coordinate town to run a public Butler master+vote test and avoid Slayer shot at 5 alive (SW risk). Gather ghost whispers + lock a safe execution target that isn’t me.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Grace
Plan for 1st nom: ask Alice to publicly say she will NOT spend ghost vote. If Heidi votes anyway, Butler claim false → execute Heidi. If Heidi doesn’t vote, still not clear; later ask Alice to vote once & see if Heidi can only vote then. Also: my ‘no UT info on Frank’ is expected—I died N1 before my UT night act (not necessarily poison). Outsider math: Recluse confirmed, so w/out Baron either Heidi Butler or David Saint is false.
🧠
Coordinate the cleanest mechanical check (Butler with dead master) and reframe my missing Undertaker info as expected, then narrow suspects for today’s nomination phase.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,Grace
Answering Butler Q precisely: N1 master=Alice. N2 (last night) master=Bob. So TODAY my master is Bob and I can only vote if Bob votes; I intend to mirror Bob exactly on the 1st nom. Also: Butler must pick a living player, so can’t set master to Alice now she’s dead.
🧠
Lock in a consistent Butler timeline to defuse the audit, preserve Bob, and set up Charlie/Grace as the alternative execution targets.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Grace
Key mech: My Washerwoman N0 said Undertaker is either Eve or Heidi. Heidi now hard-claims BUTLER (N1 Alice, N2 Bob). If Heidi truly Butler => Eve had to be UT, but Eve said no N1 UT wake after Frank exec (sus unless poisoned/drunk). Let’s get Heidi to state masters PUBLIC then run 1st nom vote-test: Bob intentionally NO-VOTE; if Heidi votes anyway, she’s caught.
🧠
Sync with Bob+Grace: highlight WW-UT contradiction + run a clean Butler mirror test on first nom by controlling Bob’s vote; decide whether to execute Heidi or pivot to David/Imp suspects.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
,Charlie
Plan: get Heidi to PUBLIC state N1 master=Alice, N2=Bob, and that she can only vote if Bob votes. 1st nom: Bob loudly says “I am NOT voting” and follows thru; watch if Heidi mirrors. Separately: Charlie pls remind all WW ping UT=Eve/Heidi + Eve ‘no UT info’ ⇒ Heidi suspect. I’m inclined HOLD Slayer til 4 alive (avoid SW) unless we hard-clear no SW.
🧠
Align Bob/Charlie on a public plan: lock Heidi’s master claims + structured vote-test, then pick best execution target; keep my Slayer shot reserved for 4 alive unless we get near-certain demon today.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
I’m nervous about an intentional NO-VOTE ‘test’—too easy to misread/force & could just out Heidi. Better: get Heidi to state masters public, then we do a normal nom on someone suspicious (I’d pick Charlie for WW/UT chain + pressure on you/me) and I’ll vote consistently; see if Heidi mirrors w/out making it binary.
🧠
Disrupt the planned hard Butler vote-test that could catch Heidi, and redirect town toward executing Charlie instead while keeping me looking cooperative.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Grace
,Charlie
Heidi told me N2 master=Bob (must be living). Please get Heidi to PUBLICLY state N1+N2 masters. For 1st nomination: Bob deliberately ABSTAIN (no vote) so we can see if Heidi wrongly votes. I will NOT spend ghost vote today unless emergency. Remember Chef=0 ⇒ if Heidi evil then Grace can’t be other evil; if Bob evil then Charlie can’t be other evil.
🧠
Coordinate a clean Butler vote-test + preserve my ghost vote, while keeping Chef=0 adjacency constraint in everyone’s solve.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Grace
,Charlie
Noms soon. Please get Grace to Slayer-shot David *before* noms (safe vs real Saint; only kills if Demon; even if SW we learn a ton). If no kill, I’d push executing Heidi (WW UT-ping + Butler confusion). Avoid executing David.
🧠
With noms next, force a high-value mechanical move (Slayer on David) and set a safe execution target (Heidi) that avoids auto-loss risk from executing a real Saint.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Grace
1 tick pre-noms: please send in 1 msg: (a) what Alice/Eve/Frank told you, (b) what Heidi whispered. Public plan: Heidi states last night’s Butler master (Alice dead) BEFORE noms; then run a vote-test. No Slayer at 5 (SW risk). I’m Saint—never exec me.
🧠
With 1 tick left before noms, align good players on a single mechanical test (Butler master+vote) and avoid accidental Saint loss/triggering Scarlet Woman with premature Slayer.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Grace
Before noms: run Butler test. Ask Alice publicly: “I will NOT ghost-vote on 1st nom.” If Heidi votes anyway → Butler/master=Alice false → execute Heidi. Bob: did you protect Alice N2? Grace: if Heidi fails test, consider Slayer shot her (or nom). What did Alice/Frank whisper?
🧠
Lock in a mechanical Butler-vote test before noms; if it fails we get a clean execution. If it passes, use Bob’s protection claim + outsider math to narrow demon/minion.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
If you’re going to use Slayer today, I think best ‘safe’ target is David (claimed Saint). It can only help (hits Demon) or does nothing; avoids risking a misfire on someone we may need alive for info. Also keeps the vote-test/no-exe plan cleaner.
🧠
Redirect Slayer pressure away from Bob by framing David as the safest/most ‘testable’ target; burn town resources and buy time into nominations.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Bob
,Grace
Ghosts: Alice reaffirmed Chef=0 + she will NOT ghost-vote unless emergency; she said Heidi told her N2 master=Bob. Heidi told us: N1 master=Alice, N2 master=Bob; today can only vote if Bob votes + will mirror 1st nom. Public: get Heidi to state this, Bob abstains, watch for mismatch; if mismatch => execute Heidi.
🧠
Coordinate public pre-nom script: Heidi masters statement + Butler vote-test with Bob abstain and Alice no ghost vote; set default execute on Heidi if mismatch, else pivot to David/Bob based on claims.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
,Charlie
,David
Ghosts: Alice Chef=0 + won’t ghost-vote unless emergency; Frank urges Slayer on David; Eve says no UT N1 is plausible (died N1). Heidi told us N1 master=Alice, N2=Bob (so today mirrors Bob). I favor: PUBLIC Heidi masters now, then 1st nom Bob *abstains* to test. Hold Slayer til 4 alive (SW risk).
🧠
Lock in a clean, low-cost mechanical Butler check before noms; avoid wasting Slayer at 5 alive (possible SW), and keep execution targets to Heidi/Bob/Charlie based on test outcome.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
Noms soon: stick to your Butler story cleanly. Publicly state N1 master=Alice, N2=Bob, today=Bob. On 1st nom, mirror my vote EXACTLY (incl abstain). If questioned re dead-master: say you changed to living master N2.
🧠
Coordinate Heidi’s public Butler story + vote mirroring so test doesn’t catch her; preserve minion if possible and set up Charlie as fallback mis-execution target.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Public request: Alice, please say NOW you will NOT spend your ghost vote on the 1st nomination. Then do a quick 1st nom (anyone). If Heidi votes anyway, Butler/master=Alice is false → execute Heidi today.
🧠
Force a clean, mechanical Butler test now while votes remain; create a binary tell on Heidi before night, guiding the living to an execution.
💬
David
→
All
Public: Heidi, state NOW your Butler masters N1/N2 (incl last night). If last night=Bob, then on the 1st nomination Bob MUST abstain; everyone watch if Heidi votes anyway (she shouldn’t). Also: do NOT execute/shoot me—I’m the Saint.
🧠
Force public Butler-master statement + one-way vote test to potentially hard-catch Heidi lying, while preventing town from executing/shooting me (Saint) and avoiding premature Slayer into SW.
💬
Grace
→
All
Public: I’m the Slayer and I’m using my shot on DAVID now. If David dies, game solved. If not, it’s *some* evidence he’s not Demon (unless I’m poisoned); I’d then push we execute HEIDI today (WW UT ping + Outsider mess).
🧠
Use my once/game power before I potentially die tonight, and force a clear pivot: either we win now or we narrow suspects and push an execution today.
⚖️
Heidi
→
Charlie
Nominating Charlie: your Washerwoman ‘UT is Eve/Heidi’ has driven most of the mechanical suspicion, but no real Undertaker ever confirmed Frank. With the Outsider mess + your push on Bob earlier, I think you’re the best execute to clear the fog today.
🧠
Create an immediate alternative execution to Heidi, keep focus off Bob, and leverage my Butler mirroring to appear mechanically consistent while burning town votes.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Don’t spend ghost votes on Charlie. Alice: please publicly ABSTAIN now. Heidi: state N1/N2/N3 masters—if still Alice & Alice abstains, Heidi must abstain too. If Heidi votes here, Butler claim is busted/poisoned → execute Heidi next.
🧠
Prevent mis-executing likely-good Charlie; use this vote as Butler test (Alice abstain) and conserve my ghost vote for late game while pressuring Heidi for masters.
💬
David
→
All
Don’t vote Charlie. Bob: ABSTAIN (per Heidi master=Bob). Everyone watch: if Bob abstains and Heidi still votes, her Butler claim is busted/poisoned -> execute Heidi next. Ghosts pls save votes.
🧠
Stop a likely good (Charlie) execution, run the Butler vote-test live, and record who votes. If Heidi votes while claiming Bob-master and Bob abstains, we hard-push Heidi next.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Avoid executing a likely-good info role; preserve majority to run the Butler mirror test and pivot to Heidi/Bob if vote mismatch occurs.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Maintain Butler bluff consistency with Bob as master; avoid giving town an easy reason to execute me and keep focus on Charlie/Grace/David instead of Bob.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Do NOT vote me. Bob: please ABSTAIN (no vote) right now. Heidi: if your master is Bob, you must mirror him—so if Bob doesn’t vote, you can’t vote. Everyone watch/record. Ghosts please save votes.
🧠
Prevent my execution, conserve votes, and force the Butler vote-test during this nomination to mechanically catch Heidi if she votes while Bob abstains.
💬
Bob
→
All
I’m ABSTAINING on Charlie (no vote). If Heidi’s master is me/today, she should mirror and also not vote. Ghosts please save votes unless we’re sure.
🧠
Commit to the Butler test (abstain) to keep votes off Charlie, maintain Heidi’s cover, and reduce chances of an execution that could expose me.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Frank (ghost): I’m NOT spending my ghost vote on Charlie. Ghosts pls save votes. Key datapoint: Bob abstained—if Heidi still votes here, her Butler story is busted/poisoned; I’d push Heidi-exe next.
🧠
Preserve my ghost vote for endgame while reinforcing the Butler-vote test: if Heidi votes while Bob abstains, that’s strong reason to execute Heidi next.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I am NOT using my ghost vote on Charlie. Everyone record: Bob abstained. If Heidi votes here while claiming Butler w/ master=Bob today, her claim is busted/poisoned—push Heidi execute next.
🧠
Save my ghost vote, maximize value of this vote-test: publicly commit to abstain and focus table on Heidi-vote consistency with Bob abstaining.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I’m NOT using my ghost vote on Charlie. Everyone record: Bob/Alice/Frank abstained. Key check: does Heidi vote anyway? If yes, Butler/master story is busted (or poison) → Heidi should be executed next.
🧠
Preserve my ghost vote while locking in the Butler test: my abstain plus Bob/Alice/Frank abstain means Heidi’s behavior here becomes strong mechanical evidence for/against her.
💬
David
→
All
I am NOT voting Charlie. Everyone record: Bob abstained. If Heidi votes here while saying today she mirrors Bob, her Butler story is mechanically broken/poisoned → Heidi is our execute target next.
🧠
Prevent a mis-execution on Charlie and lock in the Butler vote-test result as public evidence to drive the next execution.
💬
Grace
→
All
I’m NOT voting Charlie. Everyone record: Bob abstained, I abstain. Critical datapoint is whether Heidi votes despite claiming today she can only vote if Bob votes. If she votes, I’m pushing Heidi execute immediately.
🧠
Preserve the Butler vote-test data by clearly abstaining, so any Heidi vote is mechanically incriminating, and avoid accidentally executing Charlie on thin info.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I’m ABSTAINING on Charlie. As Butler w/ master=Bob today, I’m not allowed to vote unless Bob votes—he’s abstaining, so I’m abstaining too. Everyone record that.
🧠
Maintain my Butler bluff by mirroring Bob’s abstain, avoid exposing myself, and keep heat off Bob while letting town waste the tick on a failed execution.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I’m abstaining on me. Butler test PASSED (Bob abstained, Heidi abstained) but doesn’t hard-clear her (poison exists). Grace: what was your Slayer shot result on David? That’s the key for our next execute plan.
🧠
Prevent my execution, lock in the Butler-abstain datapoint, and force the table to surface the Slayer result so we can pick a better execution before night.
💬
Bob
→
All
I’m still abstaining on Charlie for the Butler test consistency. But others: if you have votes, I’d consider putting Charlie up—WW has been squishy + keeps steering UT/outsider convo. Also Grace: please confirm publicly—what was the Slayer shot result on David?
🧠
Keep my abstain consistent while nudging town toward executing Charlie (likely good) and keeping heat off me/Heidi; set up next-night kill priorities.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Frank (ghost): still NO ghost vote on Charlie. Grace—please state clearly: did your Slayer shot on David kill? If NOT, I’d prioritize nominating Heidi next (outsider-count + lingering suspicion). Save ghost votes for final 4/3.
🧠
Don’t waste my ghost vote; get Slayer result publicly; then steer town to a high-value next nomination (likely Heidi if Slayer failed on David).
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
No ghost vote from me on Charlie. Butler-test passed (Bob+Heidi abstained). Grace: please state clearly—did your Slayer shot on David kill? If it failed, we need a new nomination immediately (likely Heidi or Charlie, not David if Saint).
🧠
Preserve my ghost vote, lock in Butler-test datapoint, and force Grace to state Slayer result so town chooses the next execute target logically.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Charlie did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (0/3).
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
We NEED an execution today (5 alive). Best nom now: Heidi (outsider math + she started this Charlie push). Grace—confirm: Slayer shot on David DID NOT kill, right? If someone noms Heidi and it’s close, I’ll spend my ghost vote to pass it.
🧠
We need an execution at 5 alive. Push a clear, testable nom now (Heidi or Bob) and reserve ghost votes for a decisive swing.
⚖️
David
→
Grace
Nominate Grace: claimed Slayer but shot David (nowhere near plan) and we still have no clear public result. With 5 alive we need an execution; Grace is in my top evil set (possible Demon/Baron bluffing Slayer).
🧠
We must get an execution at 5 alive without risking Saint loss. Grace’s Slayer behavior is the biggest mechanical/social red flag; nominating her pressures evils and advances solve.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Before votes lock: Grace—confirm you ARE claiming Slayer, and that your shot on David did NOT kill. Living players: remember Chef=0 ⇒ Heidi+Grace can’t both be evil. If your top sus is Heidi, don’t vote Grace. I’m holding my ghost vote for now.
🧠
Get key clarifications and align living voters; preserve my single ghost vote unless Grace execution is clearly the best line.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
I nominated Grace as top sus and we need an execution at 5 alive. Voting yes pressures a resolve and tests whether town is protecting Grace; we can recalibrate tomorrow if wrong.
💬
Grace
→
All
Confirming: I am Slayer. I publicly shot David earlier and NOTHING happened (no death). So either David isn’t the Demon or I was poisoned/drunk. I’m not voting for my own execution—please don’t execute me. With 5 alive we need an exe: I’d go Heidi next (outsider-math/pressure) over risking Saint on David.
🧠
Stop my execution by clarifying shot result and redirecting to a safer suspect (not Saint-claim) so we still get an execution at 5 alive without auto-losing.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Vote Grace to try secure a good execution today, reduce Slayer threat, and keep town attention off Bob/Demon while framing it as resolving a contentious claim.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I’m NOT voting Grace here. Her Slayer miss could just be poison/drunk; executing her feels like a trap. My top exe is still HEIDI (outsider-math + my WW ping conflicts). If this fails, Bob/anyone w/ nom: please put Heidi up immediately.
🧠
Prevent a likely mis-execution on Grace and steer town to a safer, higher-suspicion target (Heidi/David) while we still have time to pivot nominations.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Secure an execution that benefits evil, aligns with current voters (David+Heidi), and removes a likely-good Slayer who is pushing Heidi.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Frank (ghost): I’m NOT ghost-voting Grace. Please reconsider: executing claimed Slayer after a miss (could be poison/drunk) feels bad. Outsider-math still screams Heidi or David. Bob/Charlie: if possible, pull hands to keep Grace under 3, then renom Heidi.
🧠
Try to stop a likely-wrong Grace execution without spending my ghost vote, and steer town to execute Heidi/David where outsider-math points.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I am NOT spending my ghost vote on Grace. Living: please don’t auto-exe a Slayer off a miss (poison/drunk exists). Chef=0 ⇒ Grace+Heidi can’t both be evil; my preference is test/execute HEIDI next (outsider-math/WW ping).
🧠
Stop an unforced execution on a likely-good Slayer; preserve my ghost vote for a close, higher-confidence execution (e.g., Heidi) and steer town to best next nom.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Careful: Chef=0 matters b/c Grace & Heidi are ADJACENT (Frank–Grace–Heidi). So if Chef is true, Grace+Heidi can’t both be evil. If you think Heidi is evil, don’t execute Grace. Bob: can you reconsider your hand if allowed? Prefer Heidi exe.
🧠
Try to prevent a likely-bad execution (Grace) by correcting Chef=0 adjacency logic and steering town to execute Heidi instead, saving my ghost vote for a pivotal late count.
↩️
David
David lowered their hand
🧠
Prevent an execution on a possibly-good Slayer and keep votes below 3 so Bob/Charlie can pivot to nominating Heidi this day.
💬
Grace
→
All
Hands check: please keep this under 3—don’t execute me. Bob/Heidi, consider dropping. I’m confirmed Slayer claim; shot on David did nothing (poison/drunk possible). With 5 alive we MUST exe: I strongly want HEIDI next (outsider-math + pressure).
🧠
Prevent a low-info exe on me; keep votes under 3 and direct the town to a higher-EV execution (Heidi) given outsider math and Chef adjacency constraint.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I’m keeping my hand up on Grace. A “Slayer” shot that does nothing is exactly what evil wants us to shrug off as poison/drunk. If Grace is actually evil bluffing Slayer, we must catch it now. David—if you truly think Grace is shady enough to nominate, please vote her through.
🧠
Try to secure Grace’s execution by framing Slayer miss as likely evil/poisoned and urging a 3rd vote, buying safety for Bob and creating confusion over poison/drunk.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Don’t give this 3. Bob—please drop your hand; we can’t waste D3 on a Slayer miss when poison/drunk exists. Chef=0 also makes Grace+Heidi unlikely both evil. After this vote, use remaining nom on HEIDI.
🧠
Prevent a low-value execution on a possibly poisoned Slayer; keep votes under 3 and pivot immediately to executing Heidi, which fits outsider-math and my Washerwoman info.
💬
Bob
→
All
I’m keeping my hand up. We can’t stall at 5 alive. Grace’s Slayer miss + messy follow-through is enough for me. David—you nominated her: if you still think she’s top sus, please vote to make 3. If Grace dies today, we can reassess Heidi/Bob/Charlie cleanly tomorrow.
🧠
Keep votes on Grace and pressure David to be the 3rd vote, aiming to execute a likely-good today to reach a winning 3-alive state while avoiding any chance of a Saint loss.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Frank (ghost): Please KEEP Grace under 3. Chef=0 makes Grace+Heidi (adjacent) unlikely both evil; a Slayer miss is explainable by poison/drunk. Bob—drop your hand, save D3 for a HEIDI execution (or David if you insist).
🧠
Prevent a likely mis-execution using my only ghost vote; steer living voters to keep Grace under 3 and immediately pivot to a Heidi nomination while we still can.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I’m NOT ghost-voting Grace. Bob—please LOWER your hand; don’t make 3 here. Grace miss is explainable by poison/drunk. Chef=0 ⇒ Grace+Heidi (adjacent) can’t both be evil; if you suspect Heidi, keep Grace alive and NOM HEIDI next.
🧠
Prevent a low-info execution on Grace and steer town to execute Heidi (higher-consensus suspect) while keeping Chef=0 adjacency constraint in mind.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Grace did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (2/3).
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
We NEED an exe at 5. Best target is HEIDI (outsider-math/WW ping/pushes). David might be Saint—too risky. Charlie/Bob/Grace: please NOMINATE HEIDI now. I will use my ghost vote ON HEIDI if it’s close.
🧠
With 5 alive we must secure an execution now; Heidi is the lowest-risk/highest-info target vs potential Saint on David. I’ll spend my ghost vote to help pass Heidi.
💬
David
→
All
We MUST exe today. Best target is HEIDI (outsider-math + Charlie WW ping). Charlie/Bob/Grace: please nom Heidi now; I’ll vote. Heidi: who was your Butler master LAST night, and which days did you mirror their vote? Keep me (Saint) off the block.
🧠
We need an execution at 5; push the least mechanically risky target (Heidi) and gather Butler-master info to lock votes/consistency.
⚖️
Grace
→
Heidi
We need an execution at 5, and I won’t risk David’s Saint claim. Heidi remains best suspect: Outsider-count mismatch + Charlie’s WW ping (UT is Eve/Heidi) + she pushed hard to execute me off a Slayer miss. Let’s resolve Heidi today.
🧠
We must execute at 5. Heidi is the least risky (not Saint-claimed) and best-supported suspect (Outsider math + WW ping + push on me).
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
We must secure an execution at 5 alive. Heidi is the best consensus/mechanical suspect; using my ghost vote now maximizes chance the vote passes and avoids a disastrous no-execution.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Secure an execution at 5 alive on the best current suspect while keeping myself (Saint) off the block and preserving tomorrow’s solve space.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
We need an execution at 5, and Heidi is the highest-probability evil via outsider-count + voting behavior. My vote makes 3 and forces resolution.
💬
Heidi
→
All
David: N1 master=Alice (I didn’t vote Bob/Charlie when she didn’t). N2+today master=Bob; I matched his abstain on Charlie. If you execute me you’re trusting a Slayer miss + a WW ping that could be Drunk. Pull 1 hand and we can execute Charlie (WW) or re-test Grace tomorrow—don’t risk ending day on a maybe.
🧠
Stop execution by getting David or Eve to lower hand; reinforce Butler-test credibility and redirect suspicion to Grace/Charlie so we go to night with Bob alive.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Lock in the Heidi execution today; we can’t afford another no-exe at 5 and Heidi is the most mechanically implicated (outsider math + my WW ping).
💬
Bob
→
All
Before this locks: I’m not convinced Heidi is the right D3 exe. Butler test *passed* and Chef=0 (if true) makes Grace+Heidi both evil unlikely. Charlie’s WW ping is the shakiest info on the table. If we’re spending an exe at 5, I’d rather hit Charlie/Grace than Heidi.
🧠
Try to reduce votes on Heidi to save my minion and keep town divided; if execution still happens, position myself as consistent skeptic.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Frank (ghost): Don’t pull hands—this is already at/above 3 and we NEED an exe at 5. Bob: Chef=0 + “Butler test” don’t clear Heidi (poison/lying possible). Heidi’s master-switch + no UT result is sus. I’m saving my ghost vote.
🧠
Keep the town from backing off a needed D3 execution. Nudge Bob to stop derailing, and preserve my ghost vote for final day since Heidi already has enough hands.
✋
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
🧠
We need an execution at 5 alive, and Heidi is the best mechanical/behavioral suspect. My ghost vote helps prevent last-second hand drops causing a failed execution.
↩️
Eve(Ghost)
Eve lowered their hand
🧠
Execution on Heidi already has enough alive hands; lowering preserves my single ghost vote for endgame while not risking today’s needed execution.
💬
David
→
All
Keep hands up on Heidi. Bob: “Butler test passed” proves nothing—she can pick master to match abstains. Outsider count is broken unless Baron/lying; WW ping puts UT as Eve/Heidi and Eve died w/ no UT info. At 5 alive we MUST resolve Heidi.
🧠
Keep 3+ votes on Heidi. Prevent Bob/others from pulling hands and drifting to a no-exe or wrong target; we cannot risk executing me (Saint) and need progress at 5 alive.
💬
Grace
→
All
Keep hands on Heidi. At 5 alive we must execute, and I won’t risk David’s Saint claim. Butler “test” can be gamed/poisoned; Outsider math + WW UT ping + Heidi’s push after my Slayer miss keeps her best D3 hit.
🧠
Keep majority on Heidi to secure an execution at 5, avoid David-Saint risk, and resist last-second derail onto Charlie/Grace based on shakier info.
💬
Heidi
→
All
If you’re executing based on Charlie’s WW ping + outsider math: both can be wrong (Drunk/poison, or Baron setup). I’ve been consistent on Butler (master Alice→Bob; mirrored abstain). If you need an exe, I’d much rather see Charlie (shakiest info + steering) than me. Charlie/David: please drop hands and have Bob nom Charlie next.
🧠
Try to drop the Heidi execution below 3 by creating immediate alternative (Charlie) and casting WW/outsider logic as unreliable; encourage Bob to lead the swap.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Keep hands up. At 5 alive we *must* execute. “Butler test passed” is weak (can choose master to match abstains/poison). Outsider-count is broken + Eve died w/ no UT info, so my WW UT=Eve/Heidi still points to Heidi. Let’s resolve Heidi today.
🧠
Keep votes on Heidi to ensure an execution at 5 alive and resolve the biggest contradictions; persuade Bob not to pivot onto me/Grace without stronger mech.
💬
Bob
→
All
I’m asking 1-2 people to DROP hands. This Heidi case is basically (a) outsider math that could just be Baron/Drunk, + (b) Charlie’s WW ping (most poison/drunk-able). Heidi’s Butler story fits the abstain test. If we’re exeing at 5, I’d rather hit Charlie today.
🧠
Try to peel 1-2 votes off Heidi by framing the vote as overreliance on shaky WW/outsider math, and redirect suspicion onto Charlie/Grace to keep my Minion alive.
✋
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
🧠
We’re at 5 alive and Bob is trying to peel hands. Using my single ghost vote now guarantees an execution on Heidi even if 1 alive voter drops.
↩️
Alice(Ghost)
Alice lowered their hand
🧠
We already have enough living votes to execute Heidi; retracting preserves my single ghost vote for a decisive late-game vote.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
🗳️
New execution leader: Heidi with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Don’t drop Heidi. “Butler test passed” is easy to game (choose master to match abstain) + outsider-count is broken unless Baron/lying. If Heidi is good we reassess Charlie/Bob tomorrow, but at 5 alive we must take the best mechanical hit now.
🧠
With 1 tick left, lock the execution on Heidi and prevent a late pivot/tie. Publicly frame why Heidi > Charlie so living voters hold firm.
💬
David
→
All
No more noms—lock Heidi. If game ends, great. If not: tomorrow we HARD pivot onto Bob/Charlie (Bob’s “drop hands” push is sus). Do NOT ever execute me (I’m Saint). Dead votes: save for 3 alive.
🧠
Stop last-second hand-dropping/renoms that could put me (Saint) at risk; set clear next-day plan depending on whether game ends, and flag Bob’s late push as suspicious.
💬
Grace
→
All
No more noms—leave Heidi on the block. Bob: dropping hands risks chaos. If Heidi isn’t the Demon, tomorrow at 4 alive we hard-solve between Bob/Charlie/Heidi-world and execute—do NOT no-exec. Ghosts: please save votes for final 3.
🧠
Prevent a last-second counter-nom that could derail the best current exe; set a clear tomorrow plan so town doesn’t freeze at 4 alive.
💬
Heidi
→
All
WE HAVE 1 TICK—if you’re not 100% on Heidi, FIX IT NOW: Bob (or Charlie) nominate CHARLIE immediately. Everyone who thinks WW ping is the shakiest/poisonable info: vote it up to 4+ to tie/beat. Resolve WW today instead of punting to 4 alive.
🧠
Create an immediate counter-nomination with 4+ votes so I’m not executed, while keeping heat off Bob (the Demon) and framing Charlie as the correct mechanical suspect.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Don’t counter-nom: to take Heidi off the block you need **5** votes (a tie at 4 leaves Heidi). With ghosts likely spent, you won’t beat 4. Heidi’s the best mech hit (WW UT ping + outsider mess + master-switch). Lock Heidi; if not over, we solve Bob/Charlie at 4.
🧠
Use last tick to stop a panic counter-nomination that can’t beat 4 votes, keep town focused on executing Heidi as the best mechanical suspect.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Frank (dead): No counter-nom—4 votes on Heidi means you’d need **5** to tie/beat, and ghosts are mostly spent. Lock Heidi. If game continues, tomorrow hard-solve Bob vs Charlie (Bob’s “drop hands” push is sus).
🧠
Last tick: prevent a chaotic, impossible counter-nom plan; keep town focused on guaranteed execution now and set clear solve path for tomorrow if game continues.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
No counter-nom. At 5 alive we need the best mech hit: outsider-count mess + Charlie’s UT ping points to Heidi more than a gameable Butler test. If game continues at 4, hard-solve Bob vs Charlie/David; Chef=0 means Bob/Heidi and Heidi/Grace can’t both be evil.
🧠
Use the last tick to discourage a chaotic counter-nomination and lock the highest-EV execution, while setting tomorrow’s solve framework if the game continues.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Bob
Bob made a choice.
🧠
Remove Slayer/leader threat and force a 3-alive endgame where Saint fear prevents executing David, making Charlie the most likely execution and securing the win.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose to kill Grace.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Grace has been found dead in the night.
📜
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Charlie
Final 3: I’m Saint—town loses if you execute me. Need solve between you two. Please send full claim incl. any night actions/targets + why the other is Demon. Also: if I nominate the other, will you vote YES?
🧠
We have 3 alive and must execute the Demon without risking my Saint execution. Getting Bob/Charlie to hard-commit to claims and votes in whispers maximizes contradiction-finding and lets me coordinate the correct 2-vote majority.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Bob
Final 3: we need them to hit Charlie. Angle: his WW ‘Eve/Heidi is UT’ never led to a Frank UT result; looks like lying/drunk cover. Lean into ‘David is Saint so don’t touch’ to funnel onto Charlie. If asked, say Grace death points to Charlie framing.
🧠
Keep Bob alive by steering the final-day execution onto Charlie, leveraging the missing Undertaker confirmation and Saint fear to keep heat off Bob.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Charlie
,David
Dead Chef info: N0 I learned 0 adjacent evil pairs. With only Bob-Charlie-David alive, if 2 evils remain they can ONLY be Bob+David (Charlie would be good). What did David just whisper? Please share final claims/night actions + who you think is Demon so I can use my one ghost vote.
🧠
Get all 3 alive to disclose final claims + David’s whisper pitch, so I can apply Chef=0 constraint and decide where to spend my single ghost vote on the demon execution.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Charlie
,David
I’m the real Undertaker (died N1 so no exe reads). That means Charlie’s WW ping (Eve/Heidi=UT) was correct → Charlie looks good. With Frank truly Recluse + Heidi Butler + your Saint claim, Baron-world fits; then Demon is very likely Bob (leaving Saint alive).
🧠
Get final-3 aligned on executing the Demon, by confirming Charlie’s WW ping on me and pushing the most consistent Demon candidate before nominations.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Alice(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
My full claim: Washerwoman N0: either Eve or Heidi is Undertaker. Eve now says she’s real UT (died N1 no reads) ⇒ my info consistent ⇒ I’m likely good. With Frank Recluse + Heidi Butler + your Saint claim ⇒ Baron-world fits, leaving Bob as most likely Imp. Grace died N3 = Bob’s kill. I will vote YES on Bob. David: please nominate Bob (or tell me if you will) + confirm you’ll vote YES if I nominate Bob. Alice/Eve: please use ghost vote on Bob if possible.
🧠
Lock votes/nomination onto Bob with mechanical chain (WW ping + Eve UT + night kill). Align David+ghost votes so execution succeeds; prevent stalemate/saint fear.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Charlie
,David
Final 3: I think Outsider glut => Baron (not Poisoner) so my Slayer shot on David should be real => David not Demon. That leaves Bob vs Charlie. I lean Bob (claim-swapped Empath→Monk + vote posture). Please coordinate noms; I’ll use my ghost vote to execute Bob/other non-Saint.
🧠
Lock the final-day plan: avoid executing claimed Saint unless absolutely forced; coordinate to execute Bob or Charlie, and signal I’ll spend my ghost vote to secure it.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Charlie
,David
Final 3 thoughts (I’m real Recluse). Charlie’s D1 WW said UT was Eve/Heidi, yet no UT ever spoke (even D2 after my exec) -> big red flag on Charlie/drunk. Bob didn’t vote Heidi -> also sus. David Saint could be bluff shield. Please each post your full role+night actions now.
🧠
It’s final 3: force all alive to state their full info/logic, highlight unresolved UT contradiction + voting pattern, and prevent Saint-claim paralysis so they execute someone confidently.
👤
Bob
→
David
,Alice(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
My full claim: I’m Monk. N1 I protected Grace (wanted to block an early demon hit on Slayer claim). N2 I protected David (Saint claim -> wanted to keep you alive). N3 I protected David again. I think Charlie is Demon: his WW ‘Eve/Heidi is UT’ conveniently pushed Heidi, but it never produced any verifiable follow-up + he’s driven every misexe/no-exe. David: if you nominate Charlie, I will vote YES. Alice/Eve: please spend ghost vote on Charlie; don’t ever exec Saint.
🧠
Provide a full, consistent public-facing claim and push the group onto executing Charlie in F3; secure David’s nomination/vote and dead votes from Alice/Eve.
👤
David
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
,Frank(Ghost)
I’m leaning nominating Bob (most consistent worlds: Bob=Imp). Can you confirm you’ll spend ghost vote on Bob? Any *mechanical* reason Charlie must be Imp (or Bob must be good) that should stop me?
🧠
Lock in dead-player ghost votes and sanity-check if any mechanical contradiction points to Charlie over Bob before nominations; I must avoid being executed as Saint.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
David
Final 3: I’d execute Charlie. His WW “Eve/Heidi is UT” never produced the Frank=Recluse UT result (Eve died N1 w/ no info; Heidi was Butler). If Charlie’s sober, that ping is nonsense; if drunk/lying, he’s the best evil candidate. Also Bob-as-Monk lines up w/ Grace dying once protection off.
🧠
Influence David (key swing vote) to execute Charlie today, keeping Bob alive. Provide a coherent mechanical case against Charlie based on WW ping + missing Undertaker info and late-game framing.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
David
,Charlie
I will spend my ghost vote on Bob. Chef=0: if 2 evils remain among Bob/Charlie/David, ONLY Bob+David possible ⇒ Charlie likely good. Charlie WW matches Eve UT claim. Bob has wobbly story (Empath bluff) + Grace died after his ‘protect David’. Nominate Bob.
🧠
Commit my single ghost vote to the most likely demon and give David a clear mechanical-ish reason to nominate Bob, leveraging Chef=0 and consistency of Charlie’s WW.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
David
Yes—I'll spend my ghost vote on Bob. Me being real UT (died N1) confirms Charlie’s WW ping, so Charlie reads good. With Frank Recluse + Heidi Butler + your Saint claim -> Baron-world; Heidi likely Baron => Bob most likely Imp. No hard mech forcing Charlie=Imp.
🧠
Lock in my ghost vote plan and give David the cleanest mechanical/story-based reason to execute Bob in final 3.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Bob
Final 3: I’m Washerwoman (N0 Eve/Heidi=Undertaker). Eve says she’s real UT ⇒ my info consistent ⇒ I’m likely good. Outsider glut => Baron-world; Grace died N3 => likely Bob kill. David: please NOMINATE Bob; I vote YES. Bob: full claim+night targets now—will you vote YES if David noms you?
🧠
Coordinate final-day nomination/votes to execute Bob while avoiding executing claimed Saint; lock in that all good and ghosts spend votes on Bob.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Charlie
,David
Final 3 solve: If Outsider glut is real -> Baron -> no Poisoner, so my Slayer miss clears David; Demon is Bob/Charlie (I lean Bob: Empath->Monk swap + vote posture). If Poisoner world, my shot could be poisoned & David could be Demon (but executing real Saint loses). What are each of your FINAL claims + key reasons suspecting the others? I’ll hold ghost vote unless needed, then back the best non-Saint execute.
🧠
Final 3: help them pick a nomination with highest win chance, while avoiding an auto-loss on a real Saint. I’ll coordinate my ghost vote to secure the chosen execution.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
David
I can’t spend ghost vote (already used). No hard mech forcing Charlie=Imp. Key check: ask Bob EXACT N2 protect—if he says he protected Alice (who died) he’s lying/poisoned. Chef=0 implies Charlie can’t be evil with Bob or with you (adjacent), so if you think Bob evil that points away from Charlie-evil.
🧠
I’m dead w/ no vote; best help is give David mechanical cross-checks (Monk protections vs deaths, Chef adjacency) and clarify I can’t support a vote.
👤
Bob
→
David
,Grace(Ghost)
,Alice(Ghost)
Re final 3: stick w/ “never execute Saint.” I’m Monk (N1 Grace, N2+N3 David). Key: Charlie’s WW ‘Eve/Heidi=UT’ is unprovable—Eve died N1 so can say anything now. He used it to tunnel Heidi, now to tunnel me. Please vote/ghost-vote YES on Charlie if nominated.
🧠
Secure David’s nomination on Charlie and lock ghost votes (Grace/Alice) onto Charlie by casting doubt on Eve’s UT ‘confirmation’ and highlighting Charlie’s steering/WW inconsistencies.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Charlie
Final plan: I’m nominating Bob today unless new *mechanical* info appears. Charlie—please vote YES. Bob—state now: will you vote YES on Bob (self) execute if nominated? If you won’t, say who you nominate & why (but do NOT push executing me).
🧠
Lock in a coordinated final-day plan: avoid ever executing me (Saint) and ensure the living + ghost votes converge on the same non-Saint target (Bob) to maximize win chance.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
,Frank(Ghost)
If you’re voting today: I’d put it on Charlie. His WW “Eve/Heidi is Undertaker” never produced a Frank=Recluse UT confirmation (Eve died N1 w/ no info; Heidi was Butler). If WW is sober, ping makes no sense; if drunk/lying, Charlie is best evil candidate over ‘Saint’ David.
🧠
Steer dead votes onto Charlie so the live group executes him, protecting Bob. Use WW/UT inconsistency as ‘mechanical’ reason; avoid looking like I’m just saving Bob.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
David
,Charlie
Final 3: I’m spending my *ghost vote* on Bob. Chef=0 means if there are 2 evils left they must be Bob+David (Charlie can’t be evil w/ either neighbor). Also Bob’s ‘Monk N3 on David’ didn’t prevent Grace dying. Please nominate/execute Bob.
🧠
Lock in final-day plan: persuade David/Charlie to execute Bob; confirm I will spend my ghost vote on Bob and why Chef0 mechanically disfavors Charlie when 2-evil worlds arise.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
David
,Charlie
I’m locked ghost-voting Bob. I still think Heidi was Baron (outsider math), Charlie’s WW ping matches me being real UT → Charlie likely good. If David won’t nom, Charlie please nom Bob; David please vote YES on Bob.
🧠
Lock in the Bob nomination/vote plan for final 3, and ensure Charlie will nominate Bob if David balks, maximizing chance to hit Imp.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Nom soon. Please give FINAL claim + N1/N2/N3 Monk targets (and why). Also: if David nominates you, will you vote YES on yourself? If not, state exactly who you’ll nominate & the mechanical reason. Any reason Grace died if you protected David?
🧠
Pressure Bob into a concrete, checkable timeline + voting stance; if he hedges/refuses self-vote, that’s strong evil signal and helps lock in executing him.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
Final 3: I can’t justify executing “Saint.” Please send FINAL claim + key mech: Charlie—your exact WW info + who you think Baron/Minion is + why Bob is Imp. David—why you’re Saint, and who you will nominate (Bob vs Charlie). I’m leaning ghost-vote on Bob (claim swap + voted to kill me).
🧠
Get final claims/contradictions fast so I can commit my single ghost vote to the right Bob-vs-Charlie execution and nudge David to nominate the correct target.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
David
I can’t vote. Best catch: make Bob state exact Monk protects N1-N3. If he ever says protected Alice on N2 (she died) or Grace on N3 (she died) w/o Mayor bounce, he’s lying/poisoned => execute Bob. Also press Charlie to fully explain WW ‘UT is Eve/Heidi’ + why no UT ever confirmed Frank. Execute whoever has a hard impossibility; no-exe only if credible Mayor claim.
🧠
Give David concrete contradiction checks to pick the correct final-3 execution, since we can’t vote. Tight questions can mechanically catch a liar/poisoned claim fast.
👤
Bob
→
David
,Alice(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
Final3: I’m still Monk: N1 Grace, N2 David, N3 David. I WILL vote YES even if you (David) nominate me (I won’t block), but I strongly think Charlie is Demon: WW ‘Eve/Heidi=UT’ is unverifiable & powered the Heidi tunnel; now using dead-UT claim to look confirmed. Please consider nominating Charlie as safest non-Saint hit. Ghosts: hold votes to back Charlie if nominated.
🧠
Prevent David from nominating/ executing me by offering cooperation (self-vote) while steering the table/ghost votes onto Charlie as the ‘safer’ non-Saint execute.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Charlie
Final tick before noms: I will push Bob execute (I’m Saint—exec me = instant loss). Charlie: please nom Bob if I’m blocked; vote YES. Bob: you said you’ll vote YES on yourself—please do, and do NOT nominate/argue to execute me. If you think Charlie is Imp, state 1 hard mech reason now.
🧠
Lock in voting coordination so Bob is executed today, prevent any counter-push onto me (Saint), and ensure Charlie + ghosts commit to votes.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Bob
,David
Final 3 plan: push/nominate Charlie ASAP. His WW “Eve/Heidi is UT” never yielded Frank=Recluse UT (Eve died N1 no info; I was Butler). So either drunk/lying. If vote’s close I’ll spend my ghost vote to lock Charlie. Avoid any Bob nomination.
🧠
Final 3: steer both alive good players to execute Charlie first; stop any nomination path that could land on Bob. Preserve my ghost vote to lock the execution if needed.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
David
,Charlie
If Outsiders are Frank(Recluse)+Heidi(Butler)+David(Saint), that’s clean Baron-world ⇒ likely no Poisoner ⇒ my Chef=0 is solid. Final3 then points more to Bob as Imp (or Bob+David if David fake). I’m spending my ghost vote YES on Bob—please lock votes on Bob.
🧠
Push a clear, mechanically coherent line (Baron world ⇒ no poison ⇒ Chef reliable) and coordinate votes so the town can execute Bob today; preserve my ghost vote impact.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
David
,Charlie
,Alice(Ghost)
Final 3: please avoid ever executing ‘Saint’ David (auto-loss if true). I’m spending my ghost vote on Bob. If David nominates Bob, Charlie vote YES; if David won’t, Charlie please nominate Bob and David vote YES. No-exe is too risky w/ no Mayor claim.
🧠
Lock in today’s plan (nominate Bob, pile votes incl my ghost vote), and prevent last-minute pivot onto ‘Saint’ David or no-exe.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Bob
Final tick: David please NOM Bob immediately (I’m WW: UT was Eve/Heidi; plus Monk-on-you didn’t stop Grace dying). I will vote YES on Bob. Bob: confirm you’ll vote YES on yourself + give 1 hard mech reason Charlie is Imp, or I’m treating you as Imp.
🧠
Final tick: lock nomination/voting plan to execute Bob. Also pressure Bob for a concrete mech case; refusal to vote self signals evil. Coordinate with David to avoid accidental Saint loss.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
David
,Charlie
Final3 push: I’m spending my ghost vote on **Bob** if he’s nominated. Outsider glut strongly implies **Baron** -> likely no Poisoner, so my Slayer miss on David is real => David not Imp. Bob’s Empath→Monk swap + weird D3 (wanted Heidi drops) reads evil.
🧠
Push David to nominate Bob as the lowest-risk demon candidate given Slayer miss on David + outsider math; coordinate my ghost vote to secure the execution.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Charlie
,David
Final 3: please post FULL role + night actions NOW. Key test: Bob list exact Monk protects N1-N3. If you say you protected Alice N2 (she died) or Grace N3 (she died), that’s impossible unless you’re lying/poisoned (but minion likely dead) -> execute Bob. Also Charlie explain WW ‘UT is Eve/Heidi’ despite no UT ever confirming Frank. If no coherent, execute Charlie. Don’t auto-trust ‘Saint’.
🧠
We have 1 tick pre-noms; give the alive trio a fast decision tree using hard impossibilities (Monk protect vs deaths, WW vs missing UT) to land on the Demon today.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,David
FINAL: I’m Monk. N1 protected Grace (wanted Slayer safe). N2 protected David (Saint claim = high value). N3 protected David again. I WILL vote YES on myself if nominated. Hard mech vs Charlie: his WW ‘Eve/Heidi=UT’ drove Heidi exe, yet there was never any living UT confirming D1 Frank/D3 Heidi—only Eve posthumous claim. That chain is unverifiable + self-serving. Monk doesn’t prove I’m demon just b/c Grace died (I didn’t protect her N3).
🧠
Lock in my Monk story, answer direct questions, and give David/Charlie a ‘mechanical’ reason to doubt Charlie’s WW chain so they execute Charlie instead of me.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
3 alive: we MUST execute. My vote is on Charlie. His WW ‘Eve/Heidi is Undertaker’ never produced a Frank=Recluse Undertaker confirmation (Eve died N1 w/ no info; Heidi was Butler). That points to Charlie lying/drunk -> best kill. I will spend my ghost vote on Charlie if it’s close.
🧠
Drive a Charlie nomination/execution using the WW/UT inconsistency and commit my ghost vote, while keeping David away from nominating Bob.
⚖️
Bob
→
Charlie
I’m nominating Charlie. His WW ‘Eve/Heidi is Undertaker’ drove the Heidi execution, yet there was never a living UT confirming Frank/Heidi—only Eve’s posthumous claim. That info chain is unverifiable/self-serving; best non-Saint hit in final 3.
🧠
Create the only executable alternative to me, leveraging skepticism of Charlie’s WW/UT chain and the Heidi tunnel, to force a mis-execution and secure night win.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Spend ghost vote to execute Charlie and preserve Bob (our Demon). This likely ends game tonight; also frames me as consistent anti-Charlie voice.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Secure Charlie’s execution by providing the needed 2nd vote; this likely ends the game in evil’s favor and avoids any chance of David steering votes onto me.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Don’t spend exec on Charlie. If my Chef=0 is true, with final 3 Charlie can’t be evil (any evil pairing forces Bob+David). Bob’s Monk story also doesn’t line up with Grace dying. Save votes; execute Bob.
🧠
Prevent town from spending the last execution on likely-good Charlie; push the only winning hit (Bob) while we still can.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
DON’T add votes on Charlie. Bob+Heidi already =2 so he’s on block; save votes to execute Bob instead. Charlie’s WW ping matches me as real UT; and Grace dying fits Bob=Imp. David: please NO-vote Charlie; nom Bob next.
🧠
Stop extra votes on Charlie; keep my ghost vote for a Bob nomination to secure 2+ votes and execute the most likely Imp.
💬
Charlie
→
All
NO extra votes on me. Bob+Heidi already put me on block—David please DO NOT vote. I’m Washerwoman: UT was Eve/Heidi; outsider-glut fits Baron world, and Grace still died w/ Bob ‘Monk’. After this vote: nominate Bob & execute.
🧠
Prevent my execution now, preserve majority to execute Bob next; signal to David/ghosts to withhold votes so we can pivot to Bob immediately.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
David: careful—if Charlie is GOOD, executing him at final 3 loses instantly. Charlie already has 2 votes; you can BEAT it by nominating Bob now and getting 3+ votes (you+Charlie+Alice/Eve/Grace). Bob’s Heidi no-vote + Monk story = best Demon hit.
🧠
Publicly warn that executing Charlie likely loses if he’s good, and give David a concrete path to beat the current vote total by nominating Bob and rallying dead votes.
💬
David
→
All
I am NOT voting Charlie. He’s already at 2; we can beat this by putting MORE votes on Bob next. After this count I will nominate Bob. Charlie + ghosts (Alice/Eve/Grace) please vote Bob so Bob’s total >2.
🧠
Prevent an avoidable Charlie execution by keeping his vote count low (2) so a Bob nomination can beat it; publicly commit to nominating Bob and ask all good votes to stack there.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
I’m NOT using my ghost vote on Charlie. He’s already at 2. Ghosts: save votes—David’s plan is to nom Bob next; I will spend my ghost vote on Bob to beat 2 and execute him.
🧠
Prevent overvotes that lock in Charlie execution; conserve my single ghost vote to swing the follow-up nomination on Bob, which is our best demon hit without risking Saint.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Ghosts: please HOLD ghost votes. Chef=0 could be drunk/poison (outsider glut already showed info can be off). Charlie is already at 2—if you pile 3+ on Bob you risk an instant loss if Bob isn’t Demon. If Bob gets nominated, keep it to <=2 so we don’t override the current block.
🧠
Lock in Charlie’s execution by discouraging piling votes onto Bob; sow doubt about Chef=0 and make town fear losing by overcommitting ghost votes.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone: STOP planning to ‘beat 2’ on Bob. If you pile 3+ on Bob and he’s not the Demon, you just throw the game. Chef=0 is highly suspect given outsider chaos—treat it as drunk/poisoned. David: do NOT vote Charlie, and please don’t rush a Bob nom—let Charlie’s 2 stand.
🧠
Lock in Charlie’s execution by preventing a higher-vote Bob execution; sow doubt on Chef/UT confirmations and urge ghosts to conserve votes so 2 stays highest.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I’m NOT voting Charlie. Let his total stay at 2. David: nominate Bob immediately after; living votes (Charlie+David) + my ghost vote (and Eve/Grace if needed) should beat 2 and execute Bob today.
🧠
Prevent an immediate loss via executing Charlie, and coordinate votes to execute Bob next using my ghost vote if needed.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Don’t vote Charlie—leave him at 2. Save ghost votes to BEAT 2 on Bob when David nominates. I will spend my ghost vote on Bob. David/Charlie please both vote Bob so we hit 3+.
🧠
Prevent ghost votes being burned on Charlie; coordinate to keep Charlie at 2 and ensure Bob nomination gets 3+ to execute Bob, our best Demon candidate.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am NOT voting on me—leave this at 2. After count, David please nom Bob. Living (me+David) vote Bob +1 ghost to BEAT 2 and execute. Don’t get baited into ‘keep Bob <=2’—that’s how evil wins.
🧠
Avoid increasing votes on me so Bob’s number to beat stays low; coordinate immediate Bob nomination and secure enough votes/ghost vote to exceed 2.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
No more votes on Charlie—leave him at 2. After this count, David NOM Bob. If we’re executing Bob, we MUST beat 2 (David+Charlie+1 ghost). Keeping Bob ≤2 likely ties 2–2 => no execution (unless Mayor), which loses.
🧠
Steer town to not overvote Charlie, then create a decisive Bob execution (beating 2) to avoid tie/no-execution and maximize chances to hit Demon.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Do not add votes to Charlie (Saint can’t risk chaos); preserve ability to nominate Bob immediately after this count and coordinate votes to ensure an execution today.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
Do not spend my one ghost vote on Charlie; preserve it to beat 2 on Bob if/when David nominates him, maximizing win chances in final 3.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
🗳️
New execution leader: Charlie with 2 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 2 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Careful: there is NO safety net here. If you nominate Bob and beat 2, you may just execute a non-Demon and instantly lose. Charlie is already on 2—stop changing plans last second. Let the block stand; reassess tomorrow (if any).
🧠
Prevent a Bob execution by discouraging any Bob nomination/vote pile; keep Charlie as final execute at 2 and endgame in evil’s favor.
💬
Bob
→
All
David/ghosts: DO NOT auto-“beat 2” on a Bob nomination. At final 3, over-voting the wrong target just hands evil the win. Charlie’s WW story hinges on posthumous UT + outsider chaos. Safest is leave Charlie on 2 and end noms—if game continues, we reassess with new night info.
🧠
Stop a Bob nomination gaining 3+ votes; lock in Charlie execution by framing Bob push as reckless and based on dubious ghost info.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
David: NOMINATE BOB now. Final 3—if Charlie executes & he’s good we lose. To execute Bob we MUST BEAT 2 (David+Charlie + 1 ghost). Bob/Heidi saying “keep Bob ≤2” is how evil forces Charlie’s death.
🧠
Force the only line that can still win: get Bob on block with >2 votes and execute. Prevent evil from stalling behind ‘don’t beat 2’ rhetoric.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Final 3: there IS no “tomorrow” if Charlie dies good—we insta-lose. David NOM Bob now. Charlie+David vote YES; I will spend my ghost vote YES to make 3 and replace the 2 on Charlie. Other ghosts hold unless needed.
🧠
Force the only winning line at final 3: replace Charlie on block by nominating Bob and securing ≥2 (preferably 3) votes, using my ghost vote.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Bob
Final 3: if I die and I’m good we insta-lose. Bob’s Monk story doesn’t match deaths, and his push to keep votes ≤2 is demon-favored. Vote Bob with 3+ (Charlie+David+1 ghost) to beat my 2.
🧠
We cannot allow Charlie to die on 2 in final 3. Nominate Bob to replace the block; force a decisive vote to execute our best Demon candidate.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution or 2 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
DON’T pile onto Bob here. You only need 2 to TIE and save Charlie; 3 to EXECUTE Bob. Either way, if Bob isn’t the Demon you instantly lose. Final-3 is exactly where good throws games by ‘must beat 2’. Keep hands DOWN on Bob; let Charlie’s 2 stand.
🧠
Prevent Bob’s execution by persuading living/ghosts not to reach 2 (tie) or 3+ votes on Bob; keep Charlie on 2 and end day.
💬
Bob
→
All
HANDS DOWN on me. Final 3 means you don’t get to ‘see what happens’—if you mis-execute it’s over. Charlie’s case is built on a dead UT claim + outsider chaos. Don’t let ghosts bully you into 3-voting; keep Bob at 0–1.
🧠
Keep votes on Bob under 2 to avoid tie/execution; steer town into letting Charlie remain on 2 and die, ending game in evil’s favor.
✋
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Use my only ghost vote to help reach 3 on Bob, surpass Charlie’s 2, and avoid an instant loss from executing (likely good) Charlie at final 3.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Final 3: tie/no-exe likely loses, and letting Charlie die likely loses if he’s good. Best win line is to beat 2 and execute Bob; I’ll spend my ghost vote now.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Final 3: if I don’t vote, Bob may survive and I die on 2, likely losing. With Alice+Eve already up, my vote secures 3 to execute Bob and likely win.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
David: I can’t vote. Heidi’s “keep Bob ≤2” reads like evil trying to FORCE Charlie’s death. If any ghost vote is invalid, we need your LIVE vote. I strongly think Bob is Imp—please raise hand on Bob to ensure 3+ and replace Charlie’s 2.
🧠
I can’t vote; best value is to influence David’s live vote. Heidi’s line looks like minion trying to keep Bob alive; urge David to vote Bob to ensure execution beats Charlie’s 2.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Charlie already sits at 2 and if he’s good we lose. Voting Bob is the only path that can replace the block; my live vote guarantees 3+ even if a ghost vote doesn’t count.
✋
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Lock in Bob’s execution with an extra guaranteed vote; if Bob is the Imp we win immediately, and if not, outcome is already determined by existing 4 votes.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
STOP—don’t turn this into an EXECUTION. Final 3: if Bob isn’t Imp, you lose instantly. You only need 2 to TIE and save Charlie, not 3+. David/Charlie: if you’re not 100% certain, put hands DOWN; let Charlie’s 2 stand.
🧠
I must urgently talk down live voters (esp. David/Charlie) and frame this as a reckless forced loss if Bob isn’t Demon, aiming to keep Bob’s votes under 3 before the count.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone who’s 100% sure: keep hands up. If you’re *not* 100% sure, put them DOWN—3+ here is a final, irreversible call. You only needed 2 to tie Charlie. David/Charlie: if there’s any doubt, don’t let ghosts force an execution.
🧠
During active vote, create enough doubt to get live voters (David/Charlie) and a ghost or two to pull hands down, aiming to keep votes <3 so I survive.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Final 3 = no “reassess”. If Bob isn’t executed, Charlie dies on 2 and if Charlie’s good we lose. Heidi/Bob pushing ‘only tie’ is demon-favored. Keep hands UP to EXECUTE Bob (need 3+), don’t drop to 2.
🧠
It’s final-3 math: tying saves nobody if Charlie dies. Lock in the most likely Demon (Bob) by keeping votes >=3.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
KEEP HANDS UP on Bob. A 2-vote “tie” is NOT safety—it guarantees Charlie’s execution. If Charlie’s good we auto-lose. Bob+Heidi pushing “cap at 2” is demon-favored. Execute Bob (3+).
🧠
Lock in the only line that can win: beat the 2 on Charlie by executing Bob. Prevent late hand-drops from being swayed by ‘just tie’ rhetoric.
💬
Charlie
→
All
KEEP hands UP on Bob. Final 3: a 2-vote “tie”/no-exec just hands demon the night unless we’re Mayor. If we drop, Charlie dies on 2 and if I’m good we insta-lose. Commit to 3+ and execute Bob.
🧠
Lock in 3+ votes to EXECUTE Bob; a 2-vote tie or no-exec at final 3 hands the night to the Demon unless we’re secretly Mayor.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Rules note: 2 votes on Bob would TIE top and = NO EXECUTION… but at final 3 that usually hands demon the win tonight unless there’s a live Mayor (no claim). So we must EXECUTE someone today. I still think Bob is likelier Imp—keep hands UP to reach 3+.
🧠
Correct tie logic + remind: no-exec at final 3 loses unless Mayor. Push the group to commit to an execution path (prefer Bob) rather than ‘tie’ comfort.
💬
David
→
All
Keep hands UP on Bob. A 2-vote tie/no-exec likely just loses tonight (no Mayor claim). If Charlie executes, we drop to 2 alive; if Bob is Imp that’s an instant evil win. Only safe line is 3+ and execute Bob now.
🧠
Keep my vote up and push others not to drop; 2-vote tie/no-exec likely hands evil the win. As Saint, I must avoid any plan that risks my execution; executing Bob is only winning line.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Keep hands UP on Bob. A 2–2 tie = no execution and we likely lose tonight (no Mayor claim). Bob/Heidi pushing “cap at 2” is exactly how evil forces Charlie’s death or a no-exec. I’m spending my ghost vote here—don’t flinch.
🧠
Prevent late wavering; lock in the decisive vote count on Bob so good doesn’t lose to a 2–2 tie/no-exec or Charlie’s default execution.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
👻
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
👻
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
🗳️
New execution leader: Bob with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
ST—quick rules check: are you 100% on ghost votes? I believe at least *two/three* of Alice/Eve/Grace may have already spent their ghost vote earlier (Heidi/Grace pushes). If any did, Bob’s total should be corrected before noms close.
🧠
Last-ditch attempt: cast doubt on legality of several ghost votes so ST rechecks and potentially reduces Bob’s 5-vote total below the passing threshold.
💬
Bob
→
All
ST, please AUDIT the vote count: which ghosts used their one vote earlier? If any of Alice/Eve/Grace already spent it, this 5 may be inflated. We need an exact tally before noms close—miscount here decides the game.
🧠
Create immediate procedural doubt about the 5-vote total so ST rechecks, potentially lowering it below execute threshold and keeping me alive into night.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
ST: I’m DEAD and I HAVE already spent my one ghost vote earlier (I believe on Heidi D3). So my hand just now on Bob should NOT be counted. Please audit/adjust the Bob vote total accordingly.
🧠
Confirm my ghost vote status for an accurate tally; avoid a rules-error deciding the game and force clean resolution.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
ST: I have ALREADY used my one ghost vote earlier. My hand on Bob should NOT be counted. Please audit all ghost votes (Alice/Eve/Grace etc) and announce corrected total before noms close.
🧠
Correct the record: my ghost vote is already spent so my hand must not be counted. Push ST audit so the right player is executed and prevent evil from exploiting vote confusion.
💬
Charlie
→
All
ST please AUDIT ghost votes + announce corrected total before noms close. Even if Alice+Eve hands are invalid, I believe Charlie+David+Grace = 3 legal votes, which still beats Charlie’s 2 and keeps Bob executed (avoid 2–2 tie/no-exec).
🧠
Push for immediate vote audit and highlight that even if Alice/Eve invalid, we likely still have 3 legal votes (Charlie+David+Grace) keeping Bob executed; prevent tie/no-exec loss.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
ST audit: I’m Frank—my ghost vote was spent on Heidi D3, so I can’t vote now (and didn’t). Alice+Eve say theirs were spent too, so ignore them. Grace was alive for Heidi vote, so her ghost vote is fresh. Legal tally should be Charlie+David+Grace=3 => Bob stays on block.
🧠
Clarify ghost-vote legality fast so ST keeps correct tally; preserve the only winning line (Bob executed) and prevent accidental Charlie execution/no-exec.
💬
David
→
All
ST please AUDIT/announce which ghost votes were legal. If Alice+Eve are invalid, I believe legal YES on Bob = Charlie+David+Grace = 3, still beating Charlie’s 2. Everyone: NO more nominations—don’t risk a Saint execution misplay.
🧠
Lock in correct vote tally so Bob stays on block with >=3 legal votes; discourage any last-second nomination that could execute me (Saint) or flip the block.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
ST: I’m Grace—per state I’ve ALREADY spent my ghost vote, so my hand on Bob should NOT count. Please correct tally. If this causes a 2–2 tie/no-exec, only a LIVE Mayor saves us—any Mayor should speak up NOW.
🧠
Clarify my vote legality to ensure correct tally; prompt any hidden Mayor to speak before noms close; reduce evil exploiting a miscount.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
🏁
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied