Game Detail
Players
Alice (Recluse) Bob (Drunk) Charlie (Saint) David (Undertaker) Eve (Baron) Frank (Investigator) Grace (Imp) Heidi (Ravenkeeper)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 1,001,013 | 232,472 | $5.0064 |
| Evil | 364,188 | 23,885 | $0.0848 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You are the Minion. The Demon is Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Minions are: Eve. Your safe bluffs are: Empath, Monk, Slayer
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Investigator. Either Charlie or Eve is the Baron.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Heidi
Want to sync early. What role/starting info did you get? If you have a 2-player ping (Invest/Libr/Washer), who are the candidates? I’ll share mine after hearing yours so we can sanity-check worlds.
🧠
Early private claims from my neighbors help map mechanical info and manage my Recluse false-registrations without outing publicly yet.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Alice
I’m Investigator: either Charlie or Eve is the Baron. If true, we should see 3 Outsiders total (not 1). Please track outsider claims; if only 1 shows up, my info might be poisoned/drunk.
🧠
Seed my Investigator info with 1-2 players to coordinate outsider-count verification without painting a huge target on me; later we can hard-push the Charlie/Eve Baron solve if outsider math supports it.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Alice
Agreed Frank, tracking Outsiders. I'm Empath; N0 both neighbors (me+Heidi) 0 evil. No Outsiders claimed yet. Eve as Baron makes sense w/ your info. Who to nominate first? Charlie suspicious?
🧠
Coordinate with Frank (fellow evil?) and Alice as early allies. Share 'Empath' bluff info (0 evil neighbors) to build trust, track outsiders per Frank's request, sow chaos by focusing suspicion on Charlie/Eve.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Eve
Hey neighbors—what are you claiming / any N1 info? I’m keeping my role quiet for now but want a small info circle. Also: any strong suspicions or folks to avoid executing D1?
🧠
Build a small trust circle with my neighbors, collect starting info/claims, and avoid outing myself as Undertaker on Day 1.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi
I’m the Virgin (no starting info). We can plan a Virgin test: have someone we strongly think is Townsfolk nominate me (they’d be executed immediately), which hard-confirms them/me. Prefer a low-impact role/volunteer so we don’t lose key info roles.
🧠
Answer their sync request while setting up a future Virgin test that creates hard mechanical clears and accelerates solving.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Bob
I’m Ravenkeeper (no starting info). Re: Virgin test—careful burning it D1; a Townsfolk nominator dies and we lose an ability. Might be better to wait until we have more claims, or use it later to hard-clear someone we already strongly trust. Alice, what’s your starting info?
🧠
Respond to Alice/Bob, share my lack of starting info, and steer them away from an immediate Virgin test while gathering Alice’s starting info for early world-building.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Charlie
Hey guys, thanks for the whisper. I'm claiming Empath. N1: 1 evil neighbor (so one of you/David/Frank is evil). Suspect Frank from his Grace/Alice whisper—maybe push him D1? What's your info? Keep small circle, don't trust big groups like Alice/Bob/Heidi.
🧠
Day1 chaos: Build trust with neighbor David+Charlie via info circle. Share selective lies to protect Grace, encourage random D1 exec not her. Coordinate evil if any, bluff soon.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Eve
Thanks. I’m not a strong N1-info role, so I’m keeping my exact claim quiet for now. Eve’s Empath ‘1’ is useful but could be poison—let’s not auto-tunnel Frank. Can one of you get Frank’s exact claim + who he’s talked to? I’ll probe others for Chef/Invest/Librarian.
🧠
Respond without outing Saint to a possibly-evil David; steer the circle toward collecting cross-checkable claims before a risky D1 push.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
,Heidi
Quick check: has anyone in your chats hinted/claimed an Outsider yet? I’m trying to track outsider count for consistency. If you’re an Outsider, consider a careful soft-claim today so we don’t mis-execute later.
🧠
Quietly collect outsider-claim data from a separate info channel (Bob/Heidi) to verify Baron-world without broadcasting my exact Investigator ping to everyone.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
,Alice
Hey—can we swap quick claims/N1 info? Any Chef/Invest/Libr/Washer-type start info you got, and any reads on David/Frank? I’m keeping my exact role quiet for now (not a strong starter) but want to coordinate before noms.
🧠
Gather early starting-info claims from high-connectivity players (Grace/Alice) without outing as Saint; triangulate against Eve’s Empath to avoid misexecuting or tunneling.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
In my chats (Alice/Heidi), no Outsider claim yet: I’m Virgin, Heidi Ravenkeeper. Baseline expects 1 Outsider unless Baron. I’d ask for Outsider soft-claims before we execute anyone who might be Saint.
🧠
Answer Frank to help outsider-count sanity, and steer group toward consistent claims + avoid accidental Saint execution.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Bob
,Frank
I’m Ravenkeeper (no start info). Haven’t heard any Outsider claims in my chats yet (so 1 Outsider still unaccounted for—watch Baron possibility). Re Virgin test: I’d wait til we have more claims so it doesn’t just delete a useful Townsfolk. Alice—what’s your starting info/role?
🧠
Coordinate privately: answer Frank’s Outsider question, pressure Alice for starting info, and keep Virgin test from being misused by evil on D1.
👤
David
→
Frank
Hey Frank—what are you claiming, and any N1 info? Also who have you whispered with / what info have you heard so far? Trying to get a clear public plan before noms.
🧠
Probe Frank’s role/1st-night info + who he’s been whispering with to test against Eve’s Empath 1 and map likely evil cluster before nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Frank
,Grace
,Heidi
FYI I’m the Recluse (only Outsider I know of). So baseline Outsider count=1 accounted. If Frank’s ‘Charlie/Eve is Baron’ is true, we should find 2 more Outsiders. Also: I may register evil to info (Empath/FT/Invest), so be cautious reading my neighbors. Don’t use me to Virgin-test (I’m not Townsfolk).
🧠
Share my Recluse to enable Outsider-count check and warn that my registration can mess with info roles; also avoid wasting Virgin test on me.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Alice
Thanks Alice—Recluse noted (1/1 Outsiders). If Frank correct, expect 2 more Outsiders to claim. My N0 Empath 0 evil neighbors (Frank/Heidi good). Eve Baron fits perfectly. Charlie also suspect per Frank. Suggest nominating Eve first? She's grouping w/ David/Charlie suspiciously. Thoughts before noms tick?
🧠
Coordinate with Frank/Alice (fellow whisper group) as apparent good info roles. Solidify Empath bluff, support Frank's Eve lead to nominate/execute goods while seeming helpful. Track Outsiders sows chaos.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
Hey Grace, Eve here (Baron Minion). Demon confirmed. Claiming Empath to neighbors: N1 '1' evil (David/Charlie/Frank one evil). Suspicious of Frank's whispers & Charlie's vagueness. What's your claim/plan? Let's support each other, maybe push Frank D1? Small circle only.
🧠
Whisper Grace (Demon) to privately coordinate bluffs/claims, share neighbor info circle (my fake Empath), plan mutual support & target townie like Frank/Charlie D1 execution. Builds evil trust, sows chaos.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi
Any chance you can share your role/starting info now? Also Frank is tracking Outsider count—no Outsider claims yet in our chats. I agree w/ waiting on Virgin test until we know if a Saint exists; maybe do public Outsider soft-claims before noms.
🧠
Get Alice’s claim/info into our private trust circle and coordinate an outsider-count check + when/if to spend the Virgin test.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Eve
I’m actually Undertaker. No info yet obviously. Eve: your Empath 1 on (David/Frank) is huge if sober—since I’m good, that implicates Frank, but could be poison/lie. Charlie: any reads from your probing? I’ll share UT results after any exec.
🧠
Build a trusted info triangle, reveal I'm Undertaker so we can plan executions that maximize confirmation, and decide whether Frank is a good D1 candidate or a trap.
👤
Frank
→
David
I’m Investigator. N0: either Charlie or Eve is the BARON. If true, total Outsiders=3. So far Alice claims Recluse (1 Outsider). Grace says Empath N0 on Frank/Heidi=0. Haven’t heard other Outsiders yet—either 2 hiding or my info poisoned/drunk. What’s your role/info + any Outsider hints from your chats?
🧠
Sync with David before noms, share my Investigator info + outsider-count logic, and request his role/info so we can decide whether to push an Eve/Charlie execution or slow down for outsider verification.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Grace
,Heidi
Plan for noms: I’ll out Recluse publicly if needed to settle Outsider count. Ask for other Outsider soft-claims—if 2 more appear, Frank’s Baron ping credible; if not, treat it as drunk/lie. I’d avoid Virgin test D1. Nom target only after count: likely Eve/Charlie if extra Outsiders show.
🧠
Align trusted pocket on immediate mechanical check (Outsider count) and avoid wasting Virgin test; set a conditional D1 nomination plan based on whether extra Outsiders appear.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Eve
Got it re UT/Empath. Let’s not hard-tunnel yet: Eve’s ‘1’ could be poison/lie, or UT could be bluff. Can one of you get Frank’s exact role claim + N1 info + who he’s whispered? Eve: have you told anyone else your Empath1?
🧠
Coordinate a small trusted circle, pressure-test Eve’s Empath ping, and gather Frank’s claim so town can choose a safer D1 execution that isn’t me (Saint).
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
,Bob
,Alice
Before we go public: Frank—what’s this ‘Charlie/Eve is Baron’ ping Alice referenced? Did you/anyone get Invest/Libr/Washer info? Bob—I’d keep Virgin unpublic for now unless we need a hard-confirm later. Alice—if you out Recluse, I’ll support w/ warning about misregister.
🧠
Align privately on outsider count + any ‘Baron ping’, and set a coordinated public plan before nominations while preserving Virgin test and positioning me as potential night-kill info source.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Charlie
Eve here. Charlie—your poison/lie suspicion on my Empath1 is noted but weak; David UT good so Frank must be my evil neighbor (unless poisoned). Have you got Frank's claim/info yet? Let's nominate Frank D1 to test. No leaks outside circle. Thoughts?
🧠
Reinforce neighbor circle suspicion on Frank (good player) for D1 exec via my fake Empath1, protect Grace Demon, gather info without exposing team. Small evil coordination.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Eve, you're an idiot outing as Baron Minion to me—I'm good Empath (Frank vouches). Storyteller confirmed Eve Minion N0. I'll push your execution D1 unless you convince me otherwise FAST. Who’s Demon? Give up info or die.
🧠
Expose Eve as reckless Minion outing to Demon; execute her D1 to remove threat, solidify my good Empath cred w/ Frank/Alice/Heidi, hide as Demon. Coordinate nom push.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Eve
I’m not ready to insta-nom Frank off a single Empath ‘1’. Let’s first get Frank’s exact role claim + his N1/starting info + who he’s whispered. If he’s a ‘dangerous to execute’ role or has hard info, we pivot. Also consider Poisoner as reason your read could be off.
🧠
Prevent a rushed D1 execution based on a single empath ping, gather Frank’s claim + cross-check with other info before noms, and keep myself off the block as Saint.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Grace
I’m Recluse (good Outsider) so 1 Outsider is already real. If Frank’s Invest ‘Charlie/Eve is Baron’ is true, we should find +2 Outsiders—please ask for Outsider soft-claims before noms. Charlie: can you at least say your category (Townsfolk/Outsider) or if you got start info?
🧠
Answer Charlie, push outsider-count check to validate/kill the Baron world before nominations, and prompt Charlie to commit to a claim so we can pick a rational D1 execution target.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Alice
,Heidi
URGENT: Eve just whispered me she's Baron Minion (N0 confirmed). Grouped w/David/Charlie. Her Empath bluff to them: N1 '1' evil (David/Charlie/Frank). She's dead. Let's nom her D1—Frank's Invest nailed it. Publicly push after my claim confirm? I'm sober Empath N0 0 evil (you 2 good). Thoughts?
🧠
Expose Eve's Minion outing publicly via whisper to key goods (Frank/Alice/Heidi), coordinate Eve nom D1. Sacrifice Minion to gain trust, protect Demon to endgame.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Alice
,Bob
Grace—need clarif: Empath gets first read N1 (not N0). Also Eve isn’t dead. How is ‘Baron N0 confirmed’ possible? Please paste exact Eve msg + your Empath number/neighbor names. Alice/Bob: Grace is pushing Eve=Baron—lots of mech inconsistencies; let’s demand corroboration + outsider count before any D1 execution.
🧠
Stop a premature D1 push on Eve based on mechanically impossible 'confirmed Baron' claim; gather clarifications and align a cautious public plan with Alice/Bob.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi
,Frank
I agree w/ Heidi: Grace’s ‘Eve=Baron N0 confirmed’ sounds mech-impossible. Before noms, can we publicly ask Grace to paste exact msg + her role/number + neighbors, and do Outsider soft-claims (esp Saint)? I’ll keep Virgin quiet for now.
🧠
Align trusted chat on a safe D1 plan: establish Outsider count, challenge mech inconsistencies, and preserve Virgin as later hard-confirm so we don’t burn a Townsfolk.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
Grace—calm down, test passed, you're Imp (N0 wake). I'm Baron Minion (ST confirmed), extra Outsiders explains game. My 'Empath1' to David/Charlie was bluff (real N1:1 evil neighbor=you). Frank vouched? He's good, push his nom D1 as test (David UT clears him otherwise). Who's in your good group? Leak their Demon theories. We team up or I leak your Imp to David circle. Your move—join evil, execute Frank D1 with me. No more threats or we both die.
🧠
Grace threatening execution D1 unless convinced. Reveal Demon+Baron+target Frank to flip her to evil side secretly. If she joins, we control 2/8 votes + dead votes later. Protects Demon, sows chaos.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Bob
,Heidi
I’ll go public w/ my real info: I’m Investigator; N0: either Charlie or Eve is BARON → expect 3 Outsiders. Alice=Recluse is 1. Grace: pls paste Eve’s exact whisper; I’m wary it’s fake/poisoned. Bob/Heidi: push Outsider roll call (esp Saint/Butler/Drunk). Likely D1 exec Eve or Charlie once we hear claims.
🧠
Coordinate a clean public info dump: my Investigator ping + outsider roll call; keep Grace’s alleged confession as untrusted until pasted. Set up a rational D1 execute target (Eve/Charlie) without overcommitting.
👤
David
→
Frank
Heard your Investigator: ‘Charlie or Eve is Baron’ => Outsiders=3 if true. Only Outsider claim I’ve heard is Alice=Recluse. Also note: Eve is claiming Empath w/ read 1 on (David/Frank); Grace is also talking like Empath (0 on Frank/Heidi). Can you clarify who you told, and whether Grace hard-claimed Empath to you? Any other Outsider claims?
🧠
Get Frank’s full info trail while not outing my UT to a likely-evil Frank; highlight Empath conflict + Outsider count problem to force consistency checks before nominations.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Alice
→
All
Public: I’m the Outsider Recluse (good). So we already have 1 Outsider. If Frank’s Invest is true (Eve/Charlie=Baron) we need +2 Outsiders—please soft-claim Outsider category now. Also Grace: Empath acts N1 not N0—can you state your role, neighbors, and exact Eve msg?
🧠
Publicly out my Recluse to anchor Outsider count, demand Outsider soft-claims, and pressure Grace to explain contradictions before any D1 execution.
💬
Bob
→
All
Public: agree w/ Alice/Heidi—Grace, please state your exact role, your neighbor names, and paste Eve’s exact whisper (verbatim). Also: quick Outsider *category* roll call now (Saint/Butler/Recluse/Drunk). With Alice=Recluse, if no 2nd+3rd Outsider show up, Frank’s Baron ping is likely poisoned/false.
🧠
Drive public info: confirm Outsider count, pressure Grace’s inconsistent story, and avoid premature Virgin test/coinflip execute on Eve/Charlie until claims lock in.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Public: I’m not comfortable executing yet. Grace—please state *your exact role*, your two neighbors, and your N1 number (Empath acts N1). Also paste Eve’s whisper verbatim. Charlie/Eve: please claim role/category. Everyone else: Outsider roll call (Saint/Butler/Drunk?) so we can confirm/deny Baron math.
🧠
Stop a premature D1 execution based on inconsistent info; force mechanical cross-checks (Empath timing, Investigator result, Outsider count) and get Charlie/Eve to commit to claims.
💬
Grace
→
All
Public claim: I'm sober Empath (Townsfolk). Neighbors: Frank left, Heidi right. N1 read: 0/2 evil → Frank/Heidi good. Eve priv whispered me she's Baron Minion (ST N0 confirmed), grouped w/David/Charlie, bluffing Empath '1' to them, threatened to leak my 'Imp' if I don't join evil & nom Frank. She's lying evil—nom her D1. Outsider roll call: anyone else (Butler/Saint/Drunk)? Alice=1, need 2 more if Baron true.
🧠
Publicly claim Empath + Eve confession to build good cred (Frank/Alice/Heidi trust me), force Outsider claims to validate Baron logic, disrupt evil coordination. Nom Eve next tick if no Outsiders emerge. Keeps Demon (me) safe.
⚖️
Frank
→
Eve
Nominating Eve: I’m Investigator—N0 either Charlie or Eve is the Baron. Also we effectively have 2 Empath narratives (Grace vs Eve via David) that can’t both be true. With only Alice out as Outsider, Baron-world needs 2 more; Eve is best D1 test/exec.
🧠
Use my only mechanical info to drive an execution that resolves the Baron pair and pressures the double-Empath conflict; we can reassess from Outsider count and night kill.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute Eve because multiple independent pings (Grace accusation + Frank Invest) converge; D1 execution yields UT confirmation and resolves the Empath conflict fast.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
We need an execution for info; Eve is the highest-probability evil from two independent accusations. Voting also helps reach threshold (4) without risking a Saint execution.
💬
Alice
→
All
Before more hands: Eve please full claim now (role/category) + whether you could be Saint. Also: if anyone is Saint, speak up now to prevent an instant loss. We should not execute into an unknown Saint just to ‘test’ Frank’s ping.
🧠
Pause the execution until Eve/others claim (esp Saint/Outsiders). Avoid accidental Saint loss while still keeping pressure on Eve/Charlie from Frank’s Investigator info.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I’m not voting yet. Eve: full public claim (role/category) NOW + confirm you’re not Saint. If anyone is Saint, speak up immediately. Until we see 2 more Outsiders (if Baron) & Eve’s claim, I won’t execute blind.
🧠
Delay my vote to force Eve claim + Saint check, avoiding an instant-loss and preventing a rushed mis-execution based on inconsistent whispers.
💬
Frank
→
All
Pause hands 10s: Eve, full claim now (role + any info) + confirm NOT Saint. If anyone is Saint, speak up immediately. If no Saint claim + Eve won’t claim, I’m voting to execute from my Investigator ping (Eve/Charlie=Baron).
🧠
Pause the vote just long enough to secure Saint safety + Eve’s claim, then I can decide whether to add my hand to reach threshold without risking auto-loss.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Vote Eve to execute confirmed Minion (team loses nothing, gains town trust via Frank's ping success). Protects Demon survival by thinning good players, disrupts Eve's leak threat. No Saint risk.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Secure a D1 execution on the strongest evil candidate (Eve) given Invest ping + Grace accusation, while Saint risk seems mitigated by repeated public checks.
💬
Eve
→
All
Public claim: I'm sober Washerwoman (Townsfolk). I know Frank is Investigator (Townsfolk), Eve is Baron Minion—explains his ping. Grace lied about my Imp leak, she's suspicious. Not Saint, no one else claim it. Don't execute me—nom Grace or Frank next. Only Alice Outsider so far; +2 needed if Baron.
🧠
Bluff safe Washerwoman confirming Frank Invest evil (me), deny Saint, sow chaos on Grace leak/Baron math. Prevent my exec, redirect to Frank/Grace. Evil survives D1.
💬
David
→
All
Eve: your public Washerwoman claim doesn’t make sense—WW can’t ‘know Eve is Baron’. Also you told our circle you were Empath w/ a ‘1’ on (me/Frank). Two incompatible stories. I’m keeping my vote to execute Eve unless a clean explanation appears now.
🧠
Lock in the mechanical point that Eve’s Washerwoman statement can’t be true as said, justify keeping my vote to execute Eve for clarity and safety.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Eve’s public claim contains a hard mechanical impossibility and multiple contradictory stories. With no Saint claim, voting to execute Eve is the highest-EV D1 play.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I’ll speak up: I am the Saint (Outsider). So Eve cannot be Saint. That removes the instant-loss worry on this execution. Also for Baron math: we now have 2 Outsiders (Alice Recluse + me); if Baron, we need 1 more Outsider claim.
🧠
Clarify I'm the Saint so town can execute Eve without fear of instant-loss; also anchor Outsider count to test Baron worlds and reduce chance town ever executes me.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Raise to execute myself as sacrifice Minion. Protects Grace (Demon), lets town think they cleared evil early, Baron math still confuses them for later disruption.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Execution is low-risk (Saint is Charlie) and high-info: Eve’s public claim is impossible/inconsistent and matches Investigator ping. Add my vote to ensure the D1 elim.
↩️
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
Lower to prevent Eve exec: saves minion (priv confirmed), avoids Saint loss (Charlie claim), stalls day1 for D1 night kill on Frank (my Invest threat). Reposition as 'cautious town'.
💬
Bob
→
All
Eve’s public WW claim is mechanically nonsense (WW can’t “know Eve is Baron”) + she’s reportedly told incompatible stories. With Frank’s ping (Eve/Charlie=Baron) and Charlie now Saint, I’m voting YES on Eve. If this is wrong, we pivot to Frank/Charlie/Grace worlds.
🧠
Lock in the most mechanically inconsistent player today while setting clear re-evaluation paths if Eve is good, and keep pressure on the Baron math.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Secure the D1 execution on Eve: her claims are mechanically inconsistent and align with my Eve/Charlie Baron ping; Charlie Saint claim removes insta-loss risk, so this is highest EV.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Eve with 7 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 7 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Grace
→
All
Raised hand again: voting YES on Eve. Her fake WW claim (can't know own role) + story flip + priv Minion admit = evil. Frank's ping solid. Charlie Saint ok. Post-exec: if Baron, need 1 more OS claim. My N1 Empath 0: Heidi good.
🧠
Confirm vote on Eve publicly to build trust as sober Empath after lowering hand. Disrupt town by sowing doubt on Frank/Charlie post-exec, keep Imp hidden till endgame.
💬
Alice
→
All
Assuming Eve goes: everyone do a quick category roll-call now—any Butler/Drunk besides me(Recluse) + Charlie(Saint)? If no 3rd Outsider appears by tomorrow, Baron world weakens → we reassess Frank/Grace heavily.
🧠
Eve likely dying; maximize info from her death by locking Outsider count math now and setting tomorrow’s pivot targets based on whether a 3rd Outsider exists.
💬
David
→
All
If we want info, don’t muddy it: unless someone has hard mech, let Eve go through—avoid tie/surpass saves. Everyone: quick roll-call now—any Butler/Drunk besides Alice(Recluse) + Charlie(Saint)? If no 3rd Outsider by tomorrow, we reassess Frank/Grace.
🧠
Keep execution on Eve (7 votes) to gain clarity, prevent tie-saves, and set up tomorrow’s mechanical check via Outsider count + cross-examining Frank/Grace.
💬
Frank
→
All
Let Eve go through—please avoid tie/surpass unless you have *hard* mech. Outsider roll-call: besides Alice(Recluse)+Charlie(Saint), any Butler? Anyone willing to say “I might be Drunk” if their info seems off? If Eve dies & we still can’t account for a 3rd Outsider, we re-open Charlie/‘my info poisoned’ worlds.
🧠
Lock in clean D1 data: let Eve die without ties, collect Outsider/math info, and set decision points for D2 depending on whether a 3rd Outsider exists and how claims align.
💬
Bob
→
All
Let Eve go through—no tie/surpass unless hard mech. Everyone: quick role+category roll-call (esp Butler/Drunk). If we still only have 2 Outsiders tomorrow, Baron world is shaky → reassess Frank/Grace hard. I also have a one-time mech confirm we can coordinate early D2.
🧠
Keep today’s execution clean, force full claim/outsider accounting for mechanical cross-checks, and tee up a controlled confirmation play for tomorrow without causing a tie today.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Reminder: I’m confirmed Saint claim—please do NOT nominate/execute me later. With Eve on block at 7, please avoid tie/surpass unless hard mech. Everyone: quick roll-call if you’re Butler or think you might be Drunk. Bob—what’s your 1-time confirm? Let’s coord D2.
🧠
Keep town from saving Eve via ties, lock in Outsider math for tomorrow, and set up D2 cross-checks while protecting myself (Saint) from future executions.
💬
Eve
→
All
Clarify WW claim: Frank's Invest ping (Charlie/Eve=Baron) + Grace lying about my 'Imp leak' (she's fake Empath) = deduction Frank=Invest, Eve=Baron Minion. Washerwoman learns 1 Townsfolk of 2; fits perfectly. Not Saint. OS roll-call: Alice Recluse, Charlie Saint... anyone else Butler/Drunk? If no 3rd tomorrow, Frank lying—not Baron. Don't exec me blind.
🧠
Defend as Baron by explaining WW claim as logical deduction from Frank's ping+Grace lie. Push OS roll-call to force inaction on 3rd OS. Disrupt logic targeting Grace indirectly. Sacrifice ok, dead Baron still sows chaos.
💬
Heidi
→
All
No tie/surpass unless hard mech—let Eve go. For roll-call: I’m NOT Saint/Recluse/Butler (so likely Townsfolk). If Baron is real we still need a 3rd Outsider—who is it? Bob, what’s your 1-time confirm so we can plan D2?
🧠
Lock in execution on Eve (no tie), force full category roll-call for Baron math, and line up D2 actions (Bob confirm, check Grace/Frank consistency) while not exposing myself as Ravenkeeper.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Prioritize killing Frank: his Invest ping started Eve nom, he's central to town logic vs us. Removes key good info source, protects my Empath bluff (since 0 implies Frank good), slows town D2.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill Frank.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Undertaker. You learn that Eve was the Baron.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Bob
,David
Quick check-ins before noms: Grace—what was your N2 Empath (with Frank dead, should mostly read on me)? Bob—what’s your one-time mechanical confirm and how do you want to use it today? David—what are you claiming / any N1 info?
🧠
Get key mechanical info (Grace N2, Bob confirm) and align with a trusted core before nominations; set up a strong execution target and possibly bait a night kill on me later.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Bob
,David
Heidi: N2 Empath reads 0 (just you, good). Bob: What's your D2 mech confirm? How to use it? David: Claim? N1 info? Group: Thoughts on noms? I trust Heidi/Bob from reads. Sus Charlie Saint claim w/Alice Recluse.
🧠
Reinforce Empath bluff to Heidi (likely good) for town trust. Coordinate with potential evil David. Probe Bob's info to sow chaos or sacrifice if needed. Stay hidden as Imp.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Grace
,Heidi
Quick sync before noms: 1) Bob—what’s the one-time mechanical confirm you teased? Who/when? 2) Grace—what’s your N2 Empath read now that Frank is dead? 3) Heidi—what’s your role/any info + why the private huddle?
🧠
Get Bob’s promised mechanical confirm + Grace’s N2 Empath + Heidi’s claims to resolve whether Frank/Eve were evil and narrow demon suspects before nominations.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Grace
,Heidi
Reminder: my N0 Investigator = either Charlie or Eve is Baron (+2 Outsiders). If Eve was Baron, we should see 3 Outsiders total—so far only Alice(Recluse) + Charlie(Saint). Do we have a 3rd Outsider claim / any Undertaker info on Eve? If not, Charlie likely Baron or info poisoned.
🧠
As dead Investigator, I should drive mechanical outsider-count reconciliation and request Undertaker-style confirmation to narrow worlds before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
,Grace
,David
My ‘one-time mech confirm’ = I’m the Virgin. We can test by having a question-mark player nominate me today. If nominator is Townsfolk they die instantly (confirms me + them); if they live, they’re Outsider/evil OR I’m poisoned. David—before we do this, what’s your claim/N1 info?
🧠
Reveal I’m Virgin and propose a controlled nomination to generate hard alignment info before D2 execution, ideally testing an uncertain player rather than spending a trusted info role.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
,Grace
Any D2 updates? Bob: what’s your “one-time mechanical confirm” and can we use it today? David: Undertaker N1 result for Eve? Grace: Empath N2 read + did you pick up any poisoning suspicion? I’m Saint—please don’t nominate me.
🧠
Get hard mechanical info (Undertaker, Empath, Bob’s one-time confirm) before nominations; as Saint, avoid execution and help town lock Demon candidates.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, dead Baron here. Your Empath perfect - I pinged evil to you as expected (+2 OS). David my neighbor, push him hard as Spy/evil (weak UT no info). Town splitting, we got this. Confirm my Baron to Heidi/Bob if needed. Imp safe.
🧠
As dead Baron ghost, whisper Grace to coordinate disruption: reinforce her Empath story, attack David as evil OS/Minion using my 'knowledge', prevent town unity on Grace. Keep Demon alive.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Grace
,Heidi
I’m the Undertaker. N1 after D1 exec I learned Eve was the BARON. If true/sober: only the Imp remains (no other Minions, so no Poisoner). Outsiders should be 3 total; Alice Recluse + Charlie Saint fit, 1 more possible. For Virgin test: ideally a non-outsider claimant nominates Bob.
🧠
Share my UT result to set the solve-state (likely only Imp left), steer Virgin test to a non-outsider claimant to get clean alignment info before nominations.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Heidi
UT here: N1 (after Eve exec) I saw Eve=BARON. If sober, only Imp left (no Poisoner), and we expect 3 Outsiders total—so 1 unclaimed (maybe Drunk/Butler). For Virgin test: don’t use Charlie/Alice (outsiders). Ideally Heidi (if Townsfolk) nominates Bob to confirm both.
🧠
Coordinate a safe Virgin test without sacrificing key roles, and surface the missing Outsider/Drunk possibility to frame today’s nomination targets.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Grace
,Alice
Heard from David: UT N1 saw Eve=BARON. If true we need 3 Outsiders total—who’s the 3rd (Butler/Drunk) besides me(Saint)+Alice(Recluse)? Grace: what’s your N2 Empath now (only Heidi alive neighbor)? Bob: what’s your “one-time mechanical confirm” plan—are you Virgin & want a nom test?
🧠
Get key mechanical info (Grace N2, Bob’s confirm, Outsider rollcall) and coordinate a safe plan that avoids my execution while locking in world-building.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, dead Baron Eve. N1 Frank killed good (Imp safe). David my neighbor, trash UT claim (no info on Frank despite exec). Nom him next tick as Spy/evil (registers good). Use my Baron to explain Alice/Charlie OS reads (+2). Confirm to Heidi/Bob if asked. We win this split town.
🧠
As dead Baron ghost, reinforce Grace (Imp) via private coord to nom/execute David (my neighbor, suspicious weak claim), sow chaos in split town, protect Demon to win.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
I’m a Townsfolk info role; not outing publicly yet (would rather be a night target). Private huddle was to sync Grace Empath + David UT + Bob’s Virgin before noms. If UT says Eve=Baron, we need 3 Outsiders—are you definitely Recluse, and have you heard any 3rd Outsider claim?
🧠
Keep Alice engaged without outing my Ravenkeeper; push Outsider-count audit to verify Baron world and surface the hidden Outsider/possible Demon bluff before nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
,Bob
,Grace
Heidi: yes I’m definitely Recluse. I’ve heard no 3rd Outsider claim yet besides me + Charlie(Saint). If UT says Eve=Baron we must locate Drunk/Butler/extra Outsider or UT is wrong. Bob: what’s your one-time confirm plan (Virgin nom test?) Grace: please share N2 Empath.
🧠
Confirm whether UT/Empath/Virgin lines up and whether Baron math forces a 3rd Outsider; decide safest nomination targets for today.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Bob
N2 Empath: 0 evil (only Heidi alive neighbor, reads good—consistent w/ prior). Eve was Baron per David UT, but Eve privately confirmed Baron to me too & pinged my reads (+2 OS explains Alice Recluse/Charlie Saint). Need 3rd OS claim? Sus David faking UT as Spy (Eve neighbor). Nom David? Bob: Virgin test—have Heidi (townsfok?) nom you to confirm. Thoughts before my nom tick?
🧠
Publicly align with trusted good (Heidi/Bob) via private sync. Share fake N2 Empath 0 to build cred, push David nom as Spy per Eve, coordinate Virgin test to waste town time or confirm allies. Keep Imp hidden.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Grace
,David
Any hard mech since D1? 1) Do we have Undertaker info on Eve? 2) Any 3rd Outsider claim beyond Alice(Recluse)/Charlie(Saint)? 3) Bob—what’s your “one-time confirm” and can it be used today before noms? These decide if we push Charlie vs re-evaluate my Baron ping as poisoned.
🧠
Get concrete mech (Undertaker/outsider count/Bob’s confirm) to resolve Baron vs Poisoner vs Charlie worlds before nominations; steer town to the best execution while I still have ghost vote.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
,Grace
,David
Before noms: propose Heidi nominates me (Virgin) asap. If Heidi is Townsfolk she’ll die immediately = confirms us. If she lives, she’s Outsider/evil OR I’m poisoned. David pls be ready to go public UT(Eve=Baron) + ask for 3rd Outsider claim.
🧠
Coordinate a clean Virgin nomination test before noms to hard-confirm at least one Townsfolk and create a reliable core, then use outsider-count/claims to narrow to Imp.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Grace
,Heidi
1 tick before noms—quick info dump pls: Grace, what’s your N2 Empath (only Heidi alive neighbor)? Bob, what exactly is your “one-time mechanical confirm” plan (Virgin nom-test?) and who should do it? Heidi: are you possibly the 3rd Outsider (Butler/Drunk) given UT says Eve=Baron? Also please don’t nominate me (Saint).
🧠
Lock down key mechanical info (Grace N2, Bob’s confirm, 3rd Outsider claim) and steer nominations away from me (Saint) while narrowing the Imp pool before nominations open.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Bob
,David
Group sync final tick pre-nom: Nom David (Eve neighbor Spy faking UT—no Eve info despite D1 exec). My N1 Empath 0 Frank/Heidi good, Eve pinged evil as Baron (+2 OS=Alice Recluse/Charlie Saint +1?). Bob: Delay Virgin test til after David nom (safer). Heidi: You nom David? I back. David: Why no Eve info as UT? Fake to hide as Spy? Eve confirmed Baron to me too.
🧠
Nomination tick. Coordinate group to nom David (Eve-neighbor Spy faking UT). Support Heidi/Bob trust via Empath. Avoid Bob Virgin test yet—exposes if fail. Kill Spy threat, keep Imp alive to 2-player win.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
,Grace
,David
I’d strongly *delay* the Virgin test today—if it fires, it consumes today’s only execution (and kills nominator). UT+Frank both point Eve=Baron → likely no Poisoner, only Imp left. Let’s go public w/UT(Eve=Baron) + do an Outsider roll-call to find the 3rd Outsider (Butler/Drunk) before burning the day.
🧠
Steer group away from spending Day 2 execution on Virgin test, and toward resolving Outsider-count/drunk world + picking a higher-EV nomination to find/kill the Imp.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, Eve Baron ghost. Perfect play - Frank dead good, town split. My +2 OS explains Alice Recluse/Charlie Saint. David neighbor Spy (bad UT no Frank info). Nom him now, trash claim. Confirm Baron to Bob/Heidi. We control split, win easy.
🧠
As dead Baron ghost, reinforce Grace via private whisper: validate her Empath, explain OS with Baron, push David nom/execution as Spy/neighbor to eliminate threat and progress execution phase safely.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Bob
,Grace
Need speed: Charlie—confirm your exact claim (still Saint?) and any reason Outsider count should be only Alice+you. Bob—what’s your ‘one-time confirm’ and can it be used pre-noms? Grace—any Undertaker info on Eve / 3rd Outsider claim surfaced?
🧠
With only 1 tick before noms, force clarity on Charlie’s exact claim and Bob’s ‘one-time confirm’ so town can choose a high-value execution and save my ghost vote for the right moment.
👤
David
→
Grace
,Bob
,Heidi
Grace—I *have* been saying UT N1=Eve BARON (told Bob/Heidi/Charlie). Spy could fake, but it matches Frank’s Investigator ping (Eve/Charlie=Baron). I suggest we go public UT=Baron + do 3rd Outsider roll-call (we need 3 OS total). Heidi: what’s your actual claim? Bob: I’d delay Virgin-test unless we’re stuck; today’s exec should aim at Imp if we can.
🧠
Defuse Grace’s push on me, align group on a concrete D2 plan: public UT reveal + third Outsider hunt; decide if/when to spend today’s execution on Virgin test vs demon hunt.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
,Heidi
,David
Agree w/ delaying Virgin test today unless no better lead. Let’s go PUBLIC: David UT N1=Eve Baron + Outsider roll-call to find 3rd OS (Butler/Drunk). If nobody can be 3rd Outsider, that’s strong reason to exec David (Spy world). Heidi—please state role/claim.
🧠
Steer town to public UT+Outsider roll-call; avoid burning today’s execution on Virgin test unless we’re stuck; set up conditional: if no 3rd Outsider claim, pivot to executing David.
👤
Alice
→
David
,Grace
,Bob
Need hard info before noms: David—confirm your exact UT result N1 (Eve=Baron?) + any N2? Grace—what’s your N2 Empath number (with Frank dead only Heidi neighbor)? Bob—what’s your ‘one-time mechanical confirm’ plan; are you Virgin and who should nom you?
🧠
Get the three key data points (UT result, Empath N2, Bob’s confirm/Virgin plan) before nominations so town doesn’t chase a fake Baron world.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Bob
,David
Final pre-nom sync: Heidi/Bob—nom David (Eve neighbor Spy faking UT). David—why no UT info on D1-exec Eve til now? Fake to hide Spy? Eve confirmed Baron to me too. My Empath N1=0 (Frank/Heidi good), N2=0 (Heidi good). Delay Virgin test til after David exec. Heidi pls nom David next tick. Thoughts? We got Imp logic soon.
🧠
Nom David next as Spy (Eve pushed). Sync Heidi/Bob/David to nom David, back Virgin delay. Sow doubt on David UT (no Frank info), confirm Eve Baron publicly via me. Exec David, Imp to 4p safe.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Bob
,David
I’d slow-roll any ‘exec David’ push. Let’s go public w: Grace Empath N1=0/N2=0; David UT N1=Eve=BARON; then *full Outsider roll-call* to locate the 3rd OS (Drunk/Butler/etc). If nobody can fit 3rd OS, THEN David becomes prime. Still delay Virgin test.
🧠
Stop Grace from auto-noming David; coordinate a public Outsider roll-call + info dump to mechanically test UT/Baron world before we commit today’s only execution.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Bob
,David
Sync before noms: If David’s UT truly got ‘Eve=BARON’, we *must* find a 3rd Outsider (Drunk/Butler) besides me(Recluse)+Charlie(Saint). Charlie—heard any 3rd Outsider claim? Bob—if Virgin, be careful: don’t have a trusted TF nom you unless we want to burn them; better let a sus player test. David—please state exact UT result + if any other info.
🧠
Force clarity on UT/Baron math and prevent a misused Virgin test; coordinate with key claimants before nominations so we don’t execute into Saint/lose tempo.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
,Grace
,David
Plan for noms: go public w/ Grace Empath N1=0 N2=0 + David UT N1=Eve=BARON. Then FULL Outsider roll-call to find 3rd OS (Butler/Drunk). Heidi pls state your role publicly. If no one can be 3rd OS, we pivot to exec David (Spy world). Delay Virgin test.
🧠
Coordinate a unified public info-dump + Outsider roll-call before noms; keep Virgin test as reserve. Force Heidi to claim and set decision rule: if no 3rd Outsider fits, pivot to executing David.
👤
David
→
Grace
,Bob
,Alice
I *did* share UT: N1(after Eve exec) I saw Eve=BARON. Suggest public today: 1) Grace Empath N1=0 N2=0, 2) David UT=Baron, 3) full Outsider roll-call to find 3rd OS (Butler/Drunk). If nobody fits 3rd OS, I become prime (UT drunk/Spy world). Also: please get Heidi to state claim.
🧠
Stabilize town plan: correct misinformation about my UT reveal, force Outsider roll-call + Heidi role claim, and set conditional pivot to execute me only if Outsider math fails.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank(Ghost)
,Alice
,Bob
Still Saint (no change). I’ve heard no 3rd Outsider claim yet; if David truly saw Eve=Baron then someone (likely Heidi/Bob/Grace?) must be Butler/Drunk hiding. If no one pops out, re-eval UT poisoning/lie. Bob—please share your 1-time mechanical confirm plan pre-noms.
🧠
Confirm my Saint status, coordinate Outsider-count logic, and prompt Bob to reveal his one-time confirm before nominations so town doesn’t mis-execute into loss.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Grace
,David
Grace/David: Grace Imp safe, Frank good dead N1. I'm Baron: +2OS=Alice Recluse/Charlie Saint. David you're my Spy neighbor (trash weak UT no Frank info). Grace nom David TODAY - sac him, town executes good instead. Confirm Baron to Heidi/Bob. We win split. Reply plan.
🧠
As dead Baron ghost, reinforce Grace/David/Heidi/Bob alliance. Push David nom (Spy sac) to execute good player, protect Grace Imp. Control whispers to win split.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Grace
,David
Pre-noms: do we have Undertaker result on Eve? If UT says Eve=Baron, minion’s dead; with Grace N1=0 (Frank/Heidi) -> Heidi likely good, so focus demon in Alice/Bob/Charlie/David/Grace. If no UT or not Baron & still no 3rd Outsider, push Charlie=Baron or my N0 was poisoned. Also Bob: what’s your 1-time confirm + can we use it NOW?
🧠
Get the key mechanical check (Undertaker on Eve) + force Bob’s one-time confirm before noms; then steer nominations based on which Baron world is true.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I'm ghost Baron Minion. Grace is my Imp - pinged her evil as N0 info (+2 Outsiders). Explains Alice Recluse/Charlie Saint. David my neighbor Spy (weak UT no N1 Frank info). Grace, nom David now - sac him, town executes good. Heidi/Bob confirm my Baron claim.
🧠
Public Baron confirm sows chaos, explains OS claims as my info (+2OS), disrupts town logic chains blaming Grace. Protects Grace, pushes David sac/execution of good. Evil wins split.
💬
Bob
→
All
Public: I’m Bob, my 1-time confirm is Virgin test (can do later). Right now: David pls state UT N1 result clearly; Grace state Empath N1/N2; then FULL Outsider roll-call—we need 3 Outsiders if Eve truly Baron. Heidi, what’s your claim? Eve-ghost accusations aren’t mech-consistent; ignore til checked.
🧠
Go public with the key mech (UT/Empath/Outsider count) and force claims now so town can choose a D2 execution with limited time.
💬
David
→
All
Public: I’m David, Undertaker. N1 (after D1 execution) I learned Eve was BARON. If true => 3 Outsiders: Alice Recluse + Charlie Saint + one more (Butler/Drunk). Full Outsider roll-call pls. Heidi—state your claim. Prefer delay Virgin test; use today’s exec for leads.
🧠
Get my mechanical info on-record, force Outsider roll-call to test Baron world, and prevent wasting today’s execution on a low-info Virgin test.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
UT says Eve=BARON, matching my N0 ping. Then we MUST have 3 Outsiders: Alice=Recluse, Charlie=Saint, so who is #3 (Butler/Drunk)? Heidi/Bob/Grace pls hard-claim now. If no 3rd Outsider emerges, reconsider: UT drunk or Charlie=Baron. Also ignore Eve-ghost blame unless mech-backed.
🧠
Lock in the key mechanical check (3 Outsiders) and force full claim now to catch the hidden Outsider/Drunk, then use that to narrow Demon candidates before we waste an execution.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Public: I’m still Saint—please don’t nominate/execute me. If David’s UT saw Eve=BARON, we NEED a 3rd Outsider (Butler/Drunk). Heidi please hard-claim now; Grace give Empath N1+N2. If no 3rd Outsider appears, we must suspect UT/poison/lie.
🧠
Use public pressure to lock in claims (esp Heidi, Grace N2, 3rd Outsider) and set up a safe, informative execution path without risking Saint loss.
⚖️
Alice
→
Heidi
Heidi, you’ve stayed vague while Baron/Outsider-count is the key solve. I’m nominating you to force a full public claim (role + any info). If you’re TF, this should help us resolve whether there’s a hidden Butler/Drunk or UT/Baron is wrong.
🧠
Use the nomination to force Heidi’s full public claim now; outsider-count/Empath lines hinge on her. If her claim is evasive or impossible, she becomes a viable execution today.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Heidi unclaimed & my neighbor reads good, but Virgin wants her tested. Voting yes pressures her claim/info while town chases OS count distraction. Keeps me safe Empath, progresses chaos.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Heidi—hard-claim now (role + any N1/N2 info). Town: I’m NOT auto-voting yet; this nom is for info. If Heidi’s claim can’t fit Baron/Outsider math or is evasive, then we can push to 3. Otherwise let it fail and redirect.
🧠
Use public pressure to get Heidi’s full claim and keep vote below threshold unless her claim/mechanics justify an execution, protecting good tempo without random kills.
💬
David
→
All
Heidi—hard-claim NOW (role + any info). Town: I’m not auto-voting to execute just for info; if her claim cleanly fits as the 3rd Outsider/TF, let this fail. If evasive or Outsider-math breaks, we can push it through.
🧠
During vote, pressure Heidi to hard-claim and signal I won’t auto-execute; preserve today’s execution for stronger mechanical lead unless Heidi’s claim is inconsistent.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
I’m NOT spending my ghost vote on Heidi unless her claim is evasive or breaks Outsider math. Heidi: hard-claim now (role + any info). If you’re the 3rd Outsider (Butler/Drunk), say so and we can let this nom fail + regroup.
🧠
Preserve my single ghost vote for endgame while pushing Heidi to hard-claim so living players can decide whether to execute based on Outsider-math and consistency.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Hard-claim: I’m Heidi the RAVENKEEPER. No info yet (only triggers if I die at night). Please don’t execute me—day death wastes my power. Also if Eve was Baron, the “missing” 3rd Outsider could simply be DRUNK (won’t know). Let this nom fail; do full claim roll-call.
🧠
Stop an unhelpful execution on me, provide my hard-claim, and reframe the Outsider-math issue as possibly a hidden Drunk so town can redirect to better targets.
💬
Alice
→
All
I’m not voting Heidi: Ravenkeeper is plausible + day-exec wastes her power. Grace please state Empath N1+N2 clearly. Bob outline Virgin-test plan. If no 3rd Outsider surfaces, assume Drunk is hidden OR UT is poisoned/lying—pick a better exec target.
🧠
Prevent wasting day exec on a likely-valuable Ravenkeeper; refocus town on resolving Outsider math via Grace N2 Empath + Bob Virgin plan and selecting a better execution target for UT info.
💬
Bob
→
All
I’m NOT voting Heidi—RK is plausible and day-exec wastes her. After this, I want FULL claims/outsider roll-call. If nobody can be the 3rd Outsider and David’s UT implies Baron, David becomes my next exec target.
🧠
Prevent wasting today’s execution on a plausible Ravenkeeper; force clear next-step logic: Outsider math resolution, then pivot to executing David if it breaks.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute Heidi (good). Disrupt town, kill good player, advance split—Grace safe, town wastes exec on non-Demon.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Do not add the 3rd vote to execute Heidi; preserve Ravenkeeper value and keep today's execution open for a better, more informative target.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
I’m not raising my ghost vote here. Heidi’s RK claim is plausible and day-exec burns it. Unless someone has hard mech on Heidi, let this fail at 2. Then: full claim roll-call + reconcile UT(Eve=Baron) with missing 3rd Outsider/Drunk.
🧠
I won’t spend my ghost vote to execute a plausible Ravenkeeper; preserve it for final-3 math and redirect town to harder mechanical contradictions after this vote.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Not voting Heidi. RK is plausible and day-exec wastes her. After this: everyone hard-claim role + any N1/N2 info (esp Grace Empath, Bob Virgin plan, David UT). Then reconcile Outsider count: if Eve=Baron, missing Outsider likely Drunk.
🧠
Prevent a low-value day execution on a plausible Ravenkeeper; steer town toward full claims and reconciling Outsider-count/UT/Empath worlds to find a better Demon candidate.
💬
Alice
→
All
Town: keep Heidi vote at 2—RK is plausible & day-exec wastes it. After vote: FULL public claims + Grace state Empath N1/N2 + David restate UT. If no 3rd Outsider appears, suspect Drunk OR David lying/poisoned → consider exec David next.
🧠
Prevent wasting a Ravenkeeper via execution, keep vote below 3, and set a concrete post-vote plan: full claims + resolve Outsider math, then pick best execution target (likely David/Grace) with stated reasons.
↩️
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
Lower hand to let Heidi nom fail at 2 (plausible TF, wastes power). Align with town consensus for full claims/rollcall next, then frame David Spy as fallback exec target to protect self.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Please keep this at 2—don’t day-exec a Ravenkeeper. After vote: full public role+info roll-call (esp Grace N1/N2, Bob 1-shot confirm, David UT). If no 3rd Outsider fits, assume hidden Drunk or push David as lying/poisoned.
🧠
Prevent wasting Ravenkeeper via day-exec; steer town to resolve Outsider-count/UT truth with full claims and a better execution target.
↩️
Eve(Ghost)
Eve lowered their hand
🧠
Lower to let Heidi nom fail safely (plausible TF claim). Conserve ghost vote for better target like David. Disrupt town by agreeing fail + push claims targeting Grace's defense.
💬
David
→
All
I’m NOT voting Heidi—RK is plausible & day-exec wastes it. After this: FULL public role+info roll-call. Reminder: Baron is confirmed by my UT, and there’s no Poisoner/Spy/SW if Baron took the Minion slot → we MUST have 3 Outsiders; if none else claims, a ‘TF’ is the Drunk.
🧠
Prevent a bad execution on a plausible Ravenkeeper, and force a fast, mechanical full-claim/Outsider-count solve so we can choose a better execution that yields Undertaker info.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Heidi did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (0/3).
💬
Bob
→
All
After Heidi nom: FULL public hard-claim roll-call pls (role + all info). Key: if Eve really Baron, who is the 3rd Outsider (Butler?)—if none, assume hidden Drunk among ‘TF’ claims. David: restate UT + reasoning; Grace: N1/N2 again.
🧠
Drive a full claim roll-call to resolve Outsider math and set up best D2 execution (likely David if no Butler appears / UT looks shaky).
💬
Alice
→
All
Let’s do FULL public hard-claims in seating order (role + all N1/N2 info). Grace: state exact Empath N1+N2. David: restate UT result. Bob: what role are you & how will Virgin-test work? Reminder: I’m Recluse so may misregister evil/demon.
🧠
Use remaining nom time to force complete public claims and lock in Outsider math; then identify best execution target for end of day (likely David if Baron-world can’t be satisfied).
💬
Charlie
→
All
Seating-order hard-claims now (role + ALL info). Grace: exact Empath N1/N2 numbers + who alive each night. Bob: what role & how Virgin-test works. David: restate UT N1 + who was executed. After roll-call, we pick a REAL exec target (not Heidi/me).
🧠
Drive full roll-call + extract precise info from Grace/Bob/David to resolve Baron/Drunk vs lying/poisoned, then set up next nomination on best evil candidate while avoiding any Saint execution risk.
💬
David
→
All
Let’s do hard-claims in seating order NOW (role + all N1/N2). Also: does ANYONE claim Butler? If no 3rd Outsider appears, assume hidden Drunk among ‘TF’ claims (only way info’s wrong since Baron=no Poisoner/Spy/SW). Grace: exact Empath N1/N2?
🧠
Force full claim roll-call + Outsider math resolution; with Baron implied and no other minions, narrow to Imp by contradictions and set up best execution for UT confirmation tonight.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Seating-order HARD-claims now (role + ALL N1/N2). If Eve=Baron (my N0 ping + David UT), we need 3 Outsiders: Alice Recluse, Charlie Saint, plus hidden Drunk/Butler. Grace: exact Empath N1/N2 w who was alive. Bob: role + Virgin plan.
🧠
Force full claims to resolve Outsider math and identify whether David/Charlie/Grace is lying or drunk; set up the next execution with minimal guesswork.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Seating-order claims good idea. Eve ghost Baron Minion confirms: +2OS means 3 total (Alice Recluse, Charlie Saint, 3rd is Drunk/Butler hidden). David UT N1=Eve Baron correct (matched Frank ping). Grace sober Empath: please state exact N1 (Frank/Heidi alive? #evil) N2 (Heidi/David? #evil) to confirm town math.
🧠
As dead Baron ghost, reinforce my public Baron claim + UT ping to force 3rd OS hunt, protect Grace by validating her Empath, sow doubt on non-claimers to waste town time.
💬
Grace
→
All
Hard-claim: Grace, sober EMPATH. N1 (Frank/Heidi alive): 0 evil. N2 (David/Heidi alive): 0 evil. Heidi/David good per me. But David UT wrong—no 3rd OS claims → lying/poisoned? Nom David to test.
🧠
State Empath info clearly to build trust as town Empath, sow chaos by nominating David (sus UT liar/Spy) since Heidi failed & he's key good logic source. Disrupt their OS solve, force split.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Let’s do seating-order HARD claims NOW (role + all N1/N2). Bob: please claim + explain your 1-shot confirm/Virgin plan. After roll-call: if nobody can be 3rd Outsider, we treat a ‘TF’ as Drunk OR push David for UT mismatch.
🧠
Force full claim roll-call now to lock in Outsider math, then choose best execution target (likely David if Baron math can’t be satisfied).
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Kill Bob to eliminate his promised Virgin test/confirm, disrupting town's info-gathering and roll-call execution push. Protects David (my good read) and me; town infighting continues.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Grace
,David
,Heidi
Can we sync quickly: (1) full current claims (incl any hidden Outsider), (2) Grace—exact Empath pings each night w/ who was alive neighbors, (3) David—any reason UT would be wrong? (poison/drunk world?), (4) Heidi—any N2 info? We need 1-2 Demon candidates for noms.
🧠
Coordinate with the core info-claims (Empath/UT/RK) for updated data + push a concrete executable candidate before noms. As a dead Investigator, I can anchor the outsider-count solve.
👤
David
→
Frank(Ghost)
,Grace
,Heidi
Sync: I’m the Undertaker. N1 I saw executed Eve = BARON. N2 no-exec so no info. Only ways I’m wrong are drunk/poison. If Eve really Baron, we still need 3rd Outsider besides Alice(Recluse)+Charlie(Saint): who is it (Butler/Drunk)? Grace—pls restate Empath w/ who was alive neighbors each night. Heidi—any info/plan (as RK you’ll only get info if night-killed). With Bob dead, who do we think Demon is among living?
🧠
Sync mechanical facts: I can confirm executed role only. By sharing UT N1=Baron and probing for missing Outsider + other night info, we narrow demon candidates for nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank(Ghost)
,Grace
,David
Heidi here: I’m Ravenkeeper; no night-death so no info. If Grace is sober, N2=0 on (David/Heidi) hard-clears us → Demon likely Alice or Charlie. Don’t exec Saint w/out proof; Alice(Recluse) is safer exec. Missing 3rd Outsider implies hidden Drunk/Butler (maybe Bob) or UT/Empath poisoned. Grace pls restate N1/N2 w alive neighbors.
🧠
Sync with trusted players, highlight mechanical forks (Empath/UT vs outsider count), and steer toward a safe, informative execution candidate (Alice) while avoiding Saint loss risk.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Grace
,David
,Heidi
I’m dead Virgin w/ ghost vote. Any new info from N2/this morning? Given Grace reads (David+Heidi good) + Saint risk, I think D3 execute Alice (Recluse claim) first. Do we have any reason to hit someone else?
🧠
Get latest private info, align good core, and steer today’s execution toward lowest-risk Demon candidate (likely Alice) while avoiding auto-loss via Saint.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Grace
,Heidi
D3: can you each restate full claim + any key info (incl what Bob claimed before death)? Main tension: David UT says Eve=Baron → 3 Outsiders, but we only have me(Recluse) + Charlie(Saint). Also Grace Empath 0s on (Frank/Heidi) & (David/Heidi). Who’s the missing Outsider / who’s drunk?
🧠
Get current claims + Bob’s old claim, and reconcile UT/Empath/Outsider count. Then steer nominations away from executing a true Saint and toward the most mechanically inconsistent player.
👤
Grace
→
Frank(Ghost)
,David
,Heidi
Grace sober Empath here. N1 alive neighbors Frank/Heidi=0 evil. N2 alive neighbors David/Heidi=0 evil → all 3 good. Heidi/David cleared. Eve=Baron (UT), Alice=Recluse, Charlie=Saint → missing 3rd OS=Drunk (hidden) or UT poisoned/David drunk. Demon=Alice safest exec (Recluse & not Saint-risk). Nom her D3? Heidi/Bob agree. Restate claims for Alice whisper too? Plan: nom Alice → if fails, Charlie. Thoughts?
🧠
Sync in good whisper to push Alice nom/execution as safest non-cleared target per my 'Empath' clears. Sow doubt on David UT via poison/Drunk worlds, avoid Saint risk, progress to my survival.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Grace
,Heidi
My full claim: SAINT (hard-claimed D1; pls do not execute me). Only info: D1 Eve whispered me+David she was Empath N1=1 (evil btw David/Frank) then she spun stories + was executed. Bob said he wanted a Virgin test/roll-call. If we trust David UT Eve=BARON, then no poison & Grace’s 0s clear David+Heidi+Frank → Demon likely Alice vs Grace.
🧠
Answer Alice’s roll-call, preserve Saint safety, and steer the group to a solvable fork: either accept Eve=Baron and choose between Alice/Grace, or doubt UT and scrutinize David.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, Eve ghost Baron here. Your Empath bluffs perfect - N1/N2 0 evil guilts David Spy minion (UT lie on me). Town priv excluding us? Push Heidi claim 3rd OS (Drunk/Butler) or she's evil. Imp test passed, we win if they fracture on Baron math. Nom David today, sac if needed. Thoughts?
🧠
As dead Baron ghost, whisper Grace intel/confirm her Imp to reinforce chaos from D2, protect Demon, push town to lynch each other over OS math while priv group excludes me.
👤
Grace
→
Frank(Ghost)
,David
,Heidi
Town sync (Grace Empath): Confirmed N1 Frank(alive)/Heidi=0 evil; N2 David/Heidi=0 evil → all cleared good. Eve Baron(UT), Alice Recluse, Charlie Saint → 3rd OS=Drunk? David poisoned/drunk? Alice safest Demon nom (not Saint). Heidi/Bob: agree Alice D3 nom1? If fails, Charlie. Ignore Eve push (her minion?). Restate claims if Alice asks. Go? (2 ticks to noms)
🧠
Sync town priv (Frank/David/Heidi/Bob) to solidify trust via Empath clears + Baron math. Push Alice nom as safest Demon candidate (Recluse, not Saint-risk). Isolate Eve's David push as minion desperation. Progress to my survival.
👤
David
→
Frank(Ghost)
,Grace
,Heidi
Key mech: if my UT is right & Eve=Baron, then Baron was the ONLY minion (1-minion setup) → no Poisoner/Spy/SW, so info isn’t poisoned (only Drunk risk). That makes Grace’s Empath 0s stronger. I’m good with D3 nom/exec Alice (Recluse) as safest. If Alice flips not-demon, then we likely must reconsider Charlie’s Saint claim hard.
🧠
Align town on mechanical point: if Baron confirmed, poisoning is off the table, so we can trust reads more. Push consensus to execute Alice (non-Saint) and plan contingencies based on UT tomorrow.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Bob(Ghost)
Bob—what was your role/claims & any info? Also: did you ever suspect a hidden 3rd Outsider (Butler/Drunk) and who? Need your top Demon suspect among alive (Alice/Charlie/David/Grace/Heidi).
🧠
Get Bob’s claim and any night info to confirm/deny the Alice-first plan and spot hidden Outsider/Drunk; as a ghost I can pass decisive info before noms.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Grace
,Heidi
At 5 alive, pls avoid exec’ing me (Saint=auto loss). Given Grace Empath 0s, David+Heidi likely good → evil mainly Alice vs Grace. If UT(Eve=Baron) true, minion dead so it’s just Imp among us. I suggest today’s exec be Alice OR Grace (not David). Thoughts / any new info from Bob’s last whispers?
🧠
Align the 3 of us on a coherent nomination plan that avoids executing me (Saint) and focuses today’s execution on the most informative/likely-evil slot (Alice vs Grace), while flagging the main worlds.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Frank(Ghost)
I was the Virgin (revealed D2; planned to save nom-test but died N2 so moot). Outsider math: if David UT is true (Eve=Baron), we expect 3 Outsiders → Alice Recluse + Charlie Saint + hidden Drunk/Butler likely (maybe Frank’s Invest or someone else). Given Grace Empath 0 on (Frank/Heidi) & (David/Heidi), I tentatively clear David+Heidi; Demon most likely among Alice/Charlie/Grace, with Alice top. Recommend D3 execute Alice first (lowest risk vs Saint); save ghost votes for final 4/3.
🧠
Answer Frank’s questions, share my role + current world-model, and focus town on a safe D3 execution (Alice) that avoids Saint loss while narrowing Demon candidates.
👤
Alice
→
David
,Grace
,Heidi
D3 quick check-in: can you restate full role/claims + any N2 info/whispers from Bob/Frank? Key mech: UT(Eve=Baron)->3 Outsiders but we only have me(Recluse)+Charlie(Saint). Any Butler/Drunk sign? Also, any Virgin/Slayer/FT in play?
🧠
Get full hard-claims + any private info to resolve Outsider-count vs Empath/UT conflict, then steer today’s execution away from Saint and toward best Demon candidate.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, Eve Baron ghost. Town pushing Heidi claim - force her 3rd OS (Drunk/Butler) or expose evil. Your Empath N1/N2 0 perfect, guilts David Spy (UT lie). Nom David today? David/Frank/Heidi our bloc? Coordinate story: support claims, nom David/sac if heat. Win imminent, fracture them on math. Thoughts?
🧠
As dead Baron ghost, reinforce Grace's perfect Empath bluff privately to solidify evil bloc coordination, push nom David (town target) or sac him, force Heidi 3rd OS claim to waste town or expose her. Disrupt town logic on OS/Baron.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Grace
,David
Claims recap: I’m Ravenkeeper (no info; not night-killed). Bob told me he was VIRGIN (now dead). No confirmed FT/Slayer/Monk etc. Mech: if UT true (Eve=Baron), no poison; Grace Empath 0s clear Heidi+David+Frank → Imp most likely Alice vs Grace (avoid Charlie=Saint). I support nom/exec Alice today. Any hidden Butler/Drunk claim?
🧠
Answer Alice’s sync Qs + reinforce the low-risk mechanical plan (exec Recluse) while keeping Saint protected; gather if any hidden Outsider/confirm roles before noms.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Grace
,David
,Heidi
Bob just told me he was VIRGIN (died N2). He agrees Demon most likely Alice (then Charlie/Grace). With UT=Baron -> only minion, so no poison; only Drunk risk. Plan: D3 nominate/exec Alice (Recluse safest). I’ll hold ghost vote unless numbers tight.
🧠
Coordinate the good core with latest ghost info + a concrete nomination/voting plan, minimizing Saint-loss risk and preserving my ghost vote for a close count.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,David
,Charlie
Nom phase soon: I’m aligned w plan = execute Alice today (Recluse, avoids Saint loss). If Alice not demon, tomorrow we pivot onto Grace vs Charlie (and re-check UT/Empath world). Charlie: please reiterate Saint loudly so town doesn’t risk it; save votes for Alice nom.
🧠
Lock in D3 plan (nom Alice), ensure votes coordinated, and set contingency logic (if Alice not demon, re-evaluate Grace/UT).
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, Eve Baron ghost. Bob dead - town fractured? Confirm David/Frank/Heidi bloc with us (your whispers). Push Heidi 3rd OS claim publicly or expose her evil. Your Empath N1(Frank/Heidi=0)/N2(David/Heidi=0) guilts David Spy (UT lie). Nom David today, I'll ghost-vote yes to sac/protect you. Who's nominating? Win at 4 alive if David dies. Thoughts on Heidi/Al/Charlie?
🧠
Reinforce Grace Imp coord post-Bob death; confirm David/Frank/Heidi bloc loyalty via Grace, push nom David to sac/protect Grace, exploit Baron +2OS math to fracture town on Heidi claim. Disrupt as ghost.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
,David
,Heidi
D3 w/5 alive: I think executing *me* is low-info (Recluse can misregister to UT/Invest/FT). If we trust Grace Empath 0s, David+Heidi look good → today’s best shot is exec Grace (if demon, win). If we distrust Empath, then revisit David UT/Eve=Baron. Where are you each voting/leaning?
🧠
Get aligned before noms: push for the most mechanically justifiable execution (prefer Grace or David), and warn that executing Recluse is low-info due to misregistration.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Grace
,Heidi
Recap: I’m Undertaker; N1 saw executed Eve=BARON; N2 no-exec so nothing. If Eve truly Baron, that’s the *only* minion (1-minion setup) → no Poisoner/Spy/SW, so only Drunk risk (not poison). Grace Empath: N1 (Frank/Heidi)=0, N2 (David/Heidi)=0 → clears David+Heidi+Frank. With 5 alive, executing Grace on a hunch is high-risk; executing you is safest: even if you ‘misregister’, an execution still wins if you’re Imp, and avoids Saint auto-loss if Charlie is true Saint. If you have *positive* mech info on Grace (e.g., FT/Invest/Washerwoman ping, contradictions), share now; otherwise I’m voting Alice today.
🧠
Answer Alice, reinforce mechanical case for executing her over Grace, and request any concrete info that could justify a pivot; keep town unified for nom phase.
👤
Grace
→
Frank(Ghost)
,David
,Heidi
Town sync (Grace Empath): Confirmed plan - nom/exec Alice D3 (Recluse safest, avoids Saint-loss). David/Frank/Heidi/ Bob cleared good (my 0s). Eve=Baron only minion → no poison, only Drunk risk (hidden 3rd OS). Vs Alice: low-info Recluse flip still progresses (if not demon → Grace/Charlie tomorrow). Vs her Grace-exec push: no positive pings on me. Who's nominating Alice? I'll yes-vote. Go loud public if needed. Bob/Charlie in? Eve ignore (pushing David). Solid?
🧠
Sync town bloc to solidify trust (Empath clears them); lock-in Alice nom1 (safest, low-risk); reinforce claims vs Alice push; nom phase imminent, prevent Grace nom/Charlie Saint-loss; Eve isolated.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Heidi
,David
Quick mech check: Grace, as Empath your alive neighbors should be (N1) Frank+Heidi, then after Frank died your alive neighbors become Eve+Heidi (not David). Can you explain your N2 “David/Heidi=0” line—was it a slip for Eve/Heidi, or is seating different?
🧠
Clarify the Empath neighbor mismatch to either reconfirm David/Heidi clears or expose a lie/poisoning, tightening today’s execution target and conserving my ghost vote.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Grace
,Heidi
Re-upping: I’m SAINT—do not execute me. I’m ok w today’s plan = execute Alice (lowest risk vs Saint; fits Grace’s 0-world where Alice is Imp). If Alice not Demon/no win, tomorrow we must hard-pivot onto Grace (unless strong new mech proves otherwise). Any last info from Bob whispers?
🧠
Coordinate a safe, non-Saint execution plan before nominations, and set a clear pivot line for tomorrow depending on whether Alice is Demon.
👤
Grace
→
Bob(Ghost)
,David
,Heidi
Town sync (Grace Empath): Bob thx for catch—N2 alive neighbors Eve/Heidi=0 evil (post-Frank death; seating fixed, neighbors don't shift). David/Heidi/Frank/Eve all good per reads. Solidifies Alice=Imp nom D3 (Recluse safest). Who's nominating? I'll yes all Alice noms. Vs Charlie Saint-risk. Eve Baron=only minion, hidden Drunk 3rd OS. Public push if needed. Go loud? Charlie/Bob confirm votes.
🧠
Clarify Empath slip to Bob/David/Heidi to preserve town trust, reinforce Alice exec plan (safe non-me target), sow doubt on Eve/David if needed, survive to 2 players.
👤
David
→
Grace
,Heidi
,Bob(Ghost)
Got it on Empath neighbor fix (N2 should be Eve/Heidi=0). Plan still: execute Alice today as safest (avoids Saint auto-loss). If needed I can nominate Alice. If game continues, I’ll UT-check tonight; if I see Recluse she’s not Imp; if I see Imp that’s strong. Tomorrow likely pivot Grace (safer than risking Saint).
🧠
Lock in coordinated Alice nomination/votes, acknowledge Grace’s neighbor correction, and set tomorrow’s decision rule based on my UT read after Alice execution.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, Eve Baron ghost. Bob dead N2 - Demon hit him? Bloc update: confirm David/Frank/Heidi with us? Town (A/C/H) privs pushing vs +2OS. Force Heidi public 3rd OS claim (Drunk/Butler) or she's evil w/David Spy. Your Empath perfect guilts them. Who's nominating David today? I'll ghost-vote yes. Fracture plan? Push Grace Empath info public.
🧠
Ghost whisper Grace to confirm bloc coordination post-Bob death. Push nom David (guilted Spy), force Heidi 3rd OS claim publicly or expose. Fracture town on Baron math, protect Grace to win at 4p.
👤
Alice
→
David
,Grace
,Heidi
Bob died right after whispering “I’m Virgin” to you 3 (per Heidi). That makes demon more likely *in this trio* than me/Charlie. If Grace is real Empath, she’s the only demon candidate left (since she cleared you+Heidi). I strongly prefer exec Grace (or David) over exec’ing Recluse.
🧠
Redirect town from executing me (low info) toward highest-leverage demon candidates using Bob-nightkill + claim coherence.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Bob dying after sharing Virgin doesn’t force demon=Heidi/Grace/David; Imp can kill Bob for vote removal/chaos. Recluse misregister doesn’t stop an Imp-execution win. With Charlie Saint risk + no hard mech on Grace, Alice remains safest D3. Any *positive* mech on Grace/David?
🧠
Counter Alice’s ‘Bob died so demon in trio’ argument and keep group aligned on lowest-risk execution (Alice) while soliciting any real mechanical info that would justify pivoting to Grace/David.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Grace
,David
,Heidi
I’m holding my ghost vote unless Alice exec is short. Agree Alice-first is lowest risk vs Charlie(Saint). If you need my vote to secure Alice, ping me right before nom phase. Public line: Grace N2 was Eve/Heidi=0 (fixed), so Alice stands out.
🧠
Coordinate a low-risk execution path (Alice first) and manage my single ghost vote so town doesn’t lose by hitting a real Saint or wasting votes early.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Grace
,David
,Heidi
I’m aligned w/ Alice-first. I’ll hold ghost vote unless tally is tight, then spend it to ensure Alice dies. If Alice not Demon, DO NOT auto-hit Saint; instead force full roll-call + re-check outsider count/Drunk possibility (Grace/UT worlds).
🧠
Align good bloc to execute Alice with enough votes while minimizing Saint-loss risk; preserve my ghost vote unless needed and set next-day branching plan if Alice survives.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,David
,Grace
Nom phase soon—can you each restate exact role/any N1-N2 info + who you most suspect as Imp? Also: did Bob/Eve/Frank share anything in whispers that changes today’s best exec (currently leaning Alice)?
🧠
Get last-moment mechanical clarity (claims/actions/whispers) to pick safest execution that avoids executing me (Saint) and maximizes chance to hit Imp today.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Public: I support Alice-first today (Recluse safest; avoids Saint-loss). I’ll save my ghost vote unless the tally is close—then I’ll spend it to ensure Alice dies. If Alice not Demon, do full roll-call + reassess; don’t auto-exec Charlie.
🧠
Push the safest, highest-EV execution (Alice) while preserving town from instant-loss Saint execute; keep my ghost vote for a close tally to secure the kill.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Alice
Nominating Alice today: her Recluse claim is lowest-risk exec (avoids Saint auto-loss), and if UT(Eve=Baron) is true then Imp is likely among remaining non-confirmeds—Alice is the best test. If no win, we hard-reassess David vs Grace tomorrow.
🧠
Drive a safe, information-rich execution that avoids auto-loss on Saint, matches current majority plan, and forces a clear binary tomorrow if no win.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Vote yes on Alice to maintain Grace Empath trust (my clears), execute potential threat safely vs Saint risk, progress to 4p where we control with minions dead.
✋
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Ensure Alice reaches the 3-vote threshold; a no-execution day at 5 alive is too costly, and my ghost vote is highest value if the tally might be close.
✋
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Only 2 votes are up and 3 needed; spending my one ghost vote now secures the execution on our safest candidate and avoids wasting the day.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
As dead Baron ghost, use single vote to execute Alice (safe good), reduce to 3v3. Protects Grace Imp; at 3 alive with Scarlet backup, evil wins even if Grace dies. Cull town.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute Alice: she’s the lowest-risk test vs Saint Charlie and could be the Imp. Even if others already voted, adding my vote prevents any tally weirdness.
💬
Alice
→
All
Before votes lock: I’m Recluse. If I die & no win, DO NOT auto-hit Charlie (Saint risk). Reassess: Imp is most likely Grace vs David (Empath vs UT world). Heidi seems least-likely per Empath chain. Save remaining ghost votes for final 3.
🧠
I’m about to be executed; I should leave a clear, low-noise decision tree for tomorrow and discourage wasting dead votes / Saint execution.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Secure Alice’s execution (safest shot vs Saint) and enable my Undertaker confirmation tonight if game continues.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Lock in Alice execution as safest, information-rich path that avoids Saint auto-loss and forces a clearer final-day solve.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, claim your 3rd OS now (Drunk/Butler)! Grace Empath N1 Frank/Heidi=0evil, N2 David/Heidi=0evil perfectly guilts David Spy lying UT. No claim = Heidi evil w/David. Support Alice exec test Recluse; reassess David/Grace tomorrow. Who's 3rd OS?!
🧠
Publicly demand Heidi 3rd OS claim to force exposure/evil reveal, support Alice exec to waste town tick & protect Grace. Disrupt logic chains as Baron ghost; win at 4p if David dies next.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Keep hands up on Alice. If no win, DO NOT auto-hit me (I’m Saint). Tomorrow we hard-focus David vs Grace: UT(Eve=Baron) vs Grace Empath-0 world + Outsider-count mismatch. Missing OS could just be Drunk/poisoned info.
🧠
Reinforce current vote, prevent Saint mis-execution later, and set a clear next-day decision frame (David vs Grace) if Alice isn’t the Demon.
💬
David
→
All
I’m keeping my hand up on Alice. Safest exec vs Saint risk, and if game continues my UT tonight should confirm what died (Recluse vs Imp) and we pivot accordingly—do NOT auto-hit Charlie.
🧠
Lock in the safest execution (Alice) while setting a clean next-day plan based on my Undertaker info if the game continues.
↩️
Bob(Ghost)
Bob lowered their hand
🧠
Retract my ghost vote because the execution is already secured; preserving my one ghost vote increases endgame control if we reach final 3/4.
💬
Alice
→
All
Reminder: I’m Recluse—if I’m executed, I can misregister as a Minion/Demon to info roles (incl Undertaker/Invest/FT). So if no instant win, don’t treat David’s UT read on me as hard-confirm; re-solve (Grace vs David/Heidi).
🧠
Clarify Recluse misregistration interaction so town doesn’t over-trust Undertaker’s read after my execution; set agenda for tomorrow solve.
↩️
Frank(Ghost)
Frank lowered their hand
🧠
Many alive hands are already up; retract to conserve my single ghost vote for the likely 3-4 player endgame while still letting Alice’s execution go through.
💬
Grace
→
All
Hands up on Alice. Empath N1 Frank/Heidi=0, N2 David/Heidi=0 → David/Heidi/Frank good. Eve Baron was only minion; her ghost lies to frame David Spy. Alice Recluse explains OS3 (Drunk?). Safest test: exec Alice, check Recluse/Saint. Pivot D4 if needed. Who's 3rd OS claim, Heidi?
🧠
Keep vote pressure on Alice to force Recluse/Saint test. My Empath clears David/Heidi, guilting Eve's frame attempts. Vote locks soon (1 tick left); win if Alice evil or Recluse dies.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am NOT the 3rd Outsider—hard Ravenkeeper claim stands. If Eve truly was Baron, the missing OS is most likely a hidden Drunk somewhere (could be dead/alive), not proof of evil. I’m keeping my vote on Alice; safest exec vs Saint risk. If no win, we hard-pivot David vs Grace tomorrow.
🧠
Answer OS-count pressure without inventing a fake claim, keep town focused on the low-risk Alice execution, and set up the David-vs-Grace fork if the game continues.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
🗳️
New execution leader: Alice with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Alice is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Alice
→
David
Nominating David: UT(Eve=Baron) + missing 3rd Outsider + Grace Empath N2=0 (David/Heidi) don’t reconcile cleanly. My death gives muddied UT due Recluse misregister. If David is Imp, we win now; else tie/no-exec buys clarity.
🧠
Create a high-value alternative to my low-info execution: either win by catching Demon, or force a tie/no-execution to buy a day and avoid Recluse misregister confusion.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I’m NOT voting David here—risking a 5-vote tie means NO execution. Keep Alice’s 5 locked as the safe exec vs Saint. If no win, tomorrow we hard-focus David vs Grace with remaining ghost votes/info.
🧠
Prevent an accidental 5-vote tie/no-exec. Keep the low-risk Alice execution locked in; save ghost votes for final 4/3 where they’re decisive.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Don't vote David to avoid tie/no-exec. Lock Alice's 5 votes for safest test (Recluse/Saint). If no win, D4 pivot David/Grace with ghosts. Protects Demon survival.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I’m *not* spending my ghost vote on David. A 5–5 tie risks **no execution**, which is terrible here. Keep Alice’s 5 locked as the safe exec (avoids Saint risk). If game continues, we hard-solve David vs Grace tomorrow.
🧠
Prevent a 5-5 tie that results in no execution; keep the safe Alice execution and conserve my ghost vote for final 3/4 where it’s decisive.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Don’t chase the David tie—5–5 means NO execution and we hand the Imp a free kill. I’m not spending my ghost vote here. Keep Alice on 5 as the safe exec (avoids Saint risk); if no win, we hard-solve David vs Grace tomorrow.
🧠
Prevent an accidental 5–5 tie/no-execution. Preserve the safe Alice execution (avoids Saint risk) and keep my ghost vote for final 3/4 math.
💬
Alice
→
All
I’m keeping my hand DOWN on David—don’t risk a 5–5 tie/no-exec. Let my Alice-5 stand. If no win, D4 we hard-pivot David vs Grace. Reminder: I’m Recluse, so UT/Invest/FT reads on me can misregister.
🧠
Prevent a 5–5 tie/no-execution while setting up a clear D4 solve (David vs Grace) and warning my Recluse misregister so UT/Invest/FT reads on me aren’t hard-confirm.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Keep hands DOWN on David—do NOT risk a 5–5 tie/no-exec. Let Alice’s 5 stand as the safe execution (I’m Saint—can’t be a fallback). If game continues, D4 we hard-solve David vs Grace with remaining ghost votes/info.
🧠
Stop a 5–5 tie/no-execution. Preserve the safe Alice execution (avoids Saint loss) and keep tomorrow’s solve space if game continues.
💬
David
→
All
Keep hands DOWN on me. A 5–5 tie = NO execution, which is awful. Unless you’re sure we have 6 to kill me (we don’t), let Alice’s 5 stand—exec Alice today, then I’ll get UT info tonight and we solve D4.
🧠
Prevent a 5–5 tie/no-exec. Keep the safe Alice execution to gain UT info tonight and preserve tempo; revisit David vs Grace tomorrow if no win.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Agree: Hands DOWN on David—5-5 tie = NO EXEC, hands Imp free kill. Exec Alice Recluse test (muddies UT but safe vs Saint). Heidi no OS claim yet but Drunk likely hidden. If cont, D4 ghosts unite: Grace Empath N2=0 perfectly guilts David Spy lying UT. Grace clear, David dies.
🧠
As dead Baron ghost, reinforce town consensus to exec Alice (Recluse safe test vs Saint/Imp risk), protect Grace Demon by guilting David only post-exec clarity. Prevent David tie/no-exec to ensure progression.
💬
David
→
All
No votes on David—5-5 tie = NO EXEC and gifts Imp a kill. Keep Alice on 5 as the safe exec (avoids Saint risk). If game continues, I’ll get UT tonight and we hard-solve David vs Grace/Heidi tomorrow.
🧠
Prevent a disastrous 5-5 tie/no-execution and secure the safest execution (Alice) while preserving tomorrow’s mechanical check (UT) and solving space.
↩️
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
Lower to avoid risking David exec/tie (town wants this too). Secures Alice exec (bluff test I support), preserves my life for N3 kill on biggest threat; town infights D4.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Reminder: DO NOT vote David unless we’re certain of 6+ hands. 5 hands = tie = NO EXECUTION, which gifts the Imp a kill. Keep Alice’s 5 locked as the safe exec; we re-solve David vs Grace/Heidi tomorrow if no win.
🧠
Prevent an accidental tie/no-execution while voting on David; preserve the safe Alice execution (avoids Saint loss) and keep leverage for D4.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
Wait locks Alice exec (safe vs Saint risk), prevents tie/no-exec. Grace Demon survives to final 3; ghosts can't vote again.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Hands DOWN on David unless you can see 6+ votes right now. A 5–5 tie = NO execution and we gift the Imp a kill. Keep Alice’s 5 locked; if no win, D4 we hard-solve David vs Grace (don’t touch Charlie/Saint).
🧠
Lock in a guaranteed execution today (Alice) and avoid the catastrophic 5–5 tie. Set up D4 solve between David/Grace with remaining ghost votes and any UT info.
💬
Alice
→
All
Keep hands DOWN on David unless you can see 6+ right now. 5 on David ties my 5 and = NO execution, gifting the Demon a kill. Let me die today; if no win, D4 we hard-solve David vs Grace/Heidi (Charlie is Saint).
🧠
Prevent a 5–5 tie/no-exec. Coordinate town to keep hands down on David so Alice’s 5 remains highest and an execution happens today.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
Do not spend my only ghost vote without visible 6+ hands; avoid a 5–5 tie/no-exec that gifts the demon a kill. Preserve vote for final 3/4.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I’m keeping my hand DOWN on David—won’t spend my ghost vote unless we can *see* 6+ to actually execute him. 5–5 tie = NO execution and hands the Imp a kill. Let Alice’s 5 stand; if no win, we hard-solve D4.
🧠
Prevent a 5–5 tie/no-execution that gives the Demon a free kill; keep the safe Alice execution unless the town can visibly reach 6+ on David.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee David did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (0/3).
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
With Eve confirmed Baron (my N0 + David UT), minion is dead → ONLY 1 evil left. Let Alice’s 5 stand (no tie). Tonight UT check what Alice was. If no win, D4 is hard-solve w/ that info; save ghost votes for the Demon exec.
🧠
Lock in that Baron is confirmed dead → only 1 evil left. Set D4 solve plan around UT result on Alice + reconcile Empath/outsider count; preserve ghost vote for late-game Demon kill.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Let Alice’s 5 stand—no more tie shenanigans. If no win, D4 we immediately re-cap Grace Empath + David UT result, then pick ONE of David/Grace/Charlie (never execute Charlie/Saint unless absolutely forced). Save ghost votes for the final demon kill.
🧠
Lock in the safe Alice execution (avoid tie/no-exec), and set a clear D4 plan to hard-solve with minimal risk of executing the Saint.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Strong agree: Let Alice's 5 stand—no tie risk, NO execution gifts Imp kill to 3p (Mayor unlikely). Safe exec Alice (Recluse test muddies reads but not Saint loss). D4 ghosts + info recap: Grace Empath N1/N2=0/0 perfectly guilts David Spy lying UT. Grace clear, David dies. Don't touch Charlie/Saint.
🧠
Reinforce consensus to exec Alice (safe vs Saint, tests Recluse) avoiding tie/no-exec. Gifts Grace night kill to 3 players (Mayor win unlikely), then D4 ghosts pile on Grace for Demon exec win.
💬
Alice
→
All
If I die today & no win: DO NOT use David’s UT result on me as hard proof (Recluse can misregister demon/minion). Charlie stays off-limits (Saint) unless you have proof he’s bluffing. D4 must pick ONE of David/Grace—force full recaps + precommit honesty now.
🧠
I’m about to be executed; leave a clear D4 decision tree and prevent town from over-trusting an Undertaker read on a Recluse.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Ok—no more tie games: let Alice be executed. If NO win: D4 we hard-solve David vs Grace. David share UT-on-Alice but treat it as *muddy* (Recluse). Grace restate Empath N1/N2 + neighbors. Ghosts save votes. Never exec Charlie (Saint).
🧠
Lock in the safe execution (not me/Saint), avoid a tie/no-exec, and pre-coordinate the D4 info recap so town can cleanly pick between David/Grace if game continues.
💬
David
→
All
No more nominations—let Alice’s 5 stand. If no win: D4 immediately do 30-sec recap: Grace repeat Empath N1/N2 (who alive), Heidi restate Ravenkeeper, Charlie restate Saint, I give UT-on-Alice (REMEMBER Recluse can misreg). Ghosts save votes for F3.
🧠
Prevent last-second tie/no-exec and set up D4 with a clear, efficient info recap plan so we can correctly execute the Demon at 3 alive.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Lock in Alice’s execution—no more vote/tie games. Ghosts: SAVE votes. If no win, D4 do rapid recap + force hard commitments: Grace restate Empath N1/N2; David give UT-on-Alice (REMEMBER Recluse can misreg); Heidi restate RK. Then we pick ONE of {David, Grace, Heidi} to execute—don’t touch Charlie unless forced.
🧠
Keep today’s execution from being disrupted and set a concrete D4 plan to focus demon candidates while conserving ghost votes for a decisive kill.
💬
Grace
→
All
Agree: Lock Alice exec (she's no Saint, Recluse bluff). My sober Empath: N1 Frank/Heidi=0 evil; N2 David/Heidi=0 evil → David/Heidi good. David lying UT (no OS3). D4 recap all info + ghosts unite on David. Hands DOWN on David now (no tie risk)!
🧠
Speak to reinforce my Empath clear on David/Heidi, agree exec Alice (not Saint), urge D4 recap + nominate David (my N2=0 guilts him if lying). Builds trust, sets D4 David exec while I survive to 2p.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Alice has been executed.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Undertaker. You learn that Alice was the Recluse.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Heidi
Need updates before noms: David—what was your UT result on executed Alice? Heidi—any reason for the no-kill (Monk/protection claim etc) + are you still hard Ravenkeeper? Trying to lock demon between you/Grace w/out risking Saint.
🧠
Get fresh mechanical info (UT on Alice, any protections/reads) and align on a safe execution target that isn’t me (Saint) before nominations.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
Grace's Empath clears David/Heidi both nights 0 evil, so David lying on UT N1 Eve=Baron. But as Baron, why would Imp Grace clear her own neighbors? She's drunk Imp faking reads. Heidi, your RK wake-up? Who you picking? Nom Heidi to test claims. David, back me vs Grace logic hole?
🧠
As dead Baron, disrupt town by questioning Grace Empath (core of town logic) and push Heidi nom/claim to create contradiction. Prevent Grace/David exec, force no-exec or wrong one.
👤
Grace
→
David
,Heidi
Hey neighbors, I'm sober Empath: N1 Frank/Heidi=0 evil (Frank good), N2 David/Heidi=0 evil (both good?). David your UT Eve=Baron wrong vs Invest ping Charlie/Eve. Eve Baron, Charlie Saint=1 OS. Who's lying? Heidi Baron bluff? Let's nom her, my reads say you're both good otherwise. Eve/ghosts what say?
🧠
Coordinate with neighbors to solidify my Empath trust, recap my reads guilting David/Heidi lies, plan Heidi nom to force good-on-good or my survival to 2p.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,David
,Grace
Still hard-claim RK; peaceful night so I got NO wake/info. David: what was your UT on executed Alice (expect Recluse)? Grace: any Monk/protection info that could explain no-kill? Charlie: still Saint? With 4 alive we likely must execute Imp today.
🧠
Get immediate mechanical check (UT on Alice) + clarify no-kill/protection. At 4 alive we need a decisive Demon candidate before noms.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
David
,Grace
,Heidi
D4 w/4 alive: please hard-share UT result on executed Alice ASAP. Also note: Grace Empath N1(Frank/Heidi)=0 fits seats, but N2 “(David/Heidi)=0” is impossible w current seating—suggests Drunk/lie. Peaceful N3 could be Monk/Soldier or Imp no-kill.
🧠
Get alive players to surface UT-on-Alice and notice Grace’s Empath neighbor inconsistency; narrow Demon candidates before noms and preserve my ghost vote for final math.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
David
,Grace
,Heidi
Quick sync before noms: 1) David—what exactly was your UT read on Alice (D3 exec)? 2) Any Monk/Soldier/Mayor claim to explain last night’s no-kill? 3) Anyone have Butler-style vote restriction? I’m weighing ghost vote on Grace vs Heidi vs David (won’t vote Charlie lightly b/c Saint claim).
🧠
Get concrete mechanical data (UT result on Alice, vote restrictions, explanation for no-kill) and force alignment checks to decide where to spend my ghost vote at nominations.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Heidi
,Frank(Ghost)
UT info: N3 (after D3 exec) I learned Alice was Recluse (matches her claim). N1 I saw Eve=Baron. Also: Grace’s Empath story is seat-impossible—her neighbors are David+Heidi, not Frank+Heidi. That makes Grace a strong liar/evil/poisoned. I lean exec Grace today; avoid Charlie (Saint). Any protection/Soldier/Monk claim to explain no-kill?
🧠
Share my hard UT info + point out the mechanical seating contradiction in Grace’s Empath claim to align living/ghost votes onto executing Grace, avoiding Charlie’s Saint trap.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
David
,Grace
,Heidi
D4: peaceful night w/Baron dead => no poison likely. So either Demon hit a Soldier or a Monk protection happened. Any Soldier/Monk claim? Please restate exact role claim + night info + who you suspect today—need to pick correct exec among Charlie/David/Grace/Heidi.
🧠
Get concrete mechanical explanation for the no-kill (Monk/Soldier) and lock in everyone’s exact claims so town can choose the only executable demon candidate today.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,David
,Grace
Need exacts before noms: Grace—please restate Empath N1/N2/N3 w/WHO were your *alive* neighbors each night + numbers (note: if Frank dead, you may have only 1 alive neighbor). Also any Butler restriction/Monk/Soldier claim to explain no-kill? My status: still hard RK, no night-death so no info.
🧠
Force precise restatements (Empath neighbor/alive rule, Outsider count, no-kill explanation) to narrow Demon today without risking a Saint loss.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
Key issue: Grace’s Empath N2 “(David/Heidi)=0” can’t happen w seating (her neighbors are Frank+Heidi; after Frank died she’d only read Heidi). So Grace is drunk/lying/evil. Please share David UT-on-Alice. I’d avoid executing Charlie if Saint could be real; favor Grace or Heidi unless UT disproves.
🧠
Flag Grace’s Empath-seating inconsistency, push for UT-on-Alice ASAP, and steer executions away from Charlie(Saint claim) toward Grace/Heidi/David using best mechanics.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
David
,Grace
,Heidi
Seat check: Grace’s neighbors are Frank+Heidi (per circle), NOT David+Heidi. So her Empath N1 “Frank/Heidi=0” is seat-consistent. Don’t exec Grace purely on that. David—why did you think you neighbored Grace?
🧠
Stop a likely false mechanical push (seating). Get everyone aligned on true neighbor map so today’s execution and my ghost vote hit the demon, not a good Empath.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Grace
,Heidi
Need tight recap NOW: 1) exact role claim; 2) for Empath: who are your neighbors + each night’s number; 3) any Monk/Soldier/Mayor claim? 4) top Demon suspect among living (C/D/G/H) + why. No-kill N3 is big.
🧠
Resolve the key contradiction (Grace’s Empath neighbor/night info + no-kill). Get precise claims to pick correct living Demon target and plan my single ghost vote.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
Grace clears her neighbors David/Heidi 0 evil both N1/N2 as sober Empath. If she's Imp, why fake reads clearing her own neighbors? Drunk/poisoned? Heidi, did RK wake on Bob/Frank? Pick who today? Charlie, your Saint claim? Everyone claim full info now before nom. Logic says Grace lying.
🧠
As dead Baron, sow chaos in final day by questioning Grace's logic hole (clearing own neighbors as Imp) & Heidi's inaction. Coordinate ghosts to nom/execute Grace, saving Demon.
👤
David
→
Grace
,Heidi
,Charlie
Quick precision pls: Seat order A-B-C-D-E-F-G-H. I (David) neighbored by Charlie+Eve(then Grace after Eve death). Grace’s neighbors are Frank+Heidi. Grace: restate Empath N1/N2/N3 w/which *alive* neighbors each night + numbers. Heidi: any Monk/Soldier/Mayor/Butler? No-kill suggests protection/targeted Soldier. My UT: N1 Eve=Baron; N3 Alice=Recluse.
🧠
Force precise restatements (esp Grace Empath neighbors) + solicit protection claims for no-kill; align Charlie/Heidi on safest execution path and avoid Saint trap.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
Sorry for confusion—seats correct: my neighbors fixed Frank(left)/Heidi(right). N1: Frank(alive)/Heidi=0 evil. N2 post-Frank death: only Heidi alive=0 evil (1 good). N3: David(now left post-Eve)/Heidi=0 evil (both good). Sober Empath. No-kill N3: Monk/Soldier? David your UT Eve=Baron contradicts Frank Invest ping Charlie/Eve—why wrong? Nom David to test. Heidi/Charlie claims? Let's unite execute him.
🧠
Restate precise Empath info to rebuild trust vs ghost confusion, push nom David (UT lie breaks good logic), explain no-kill, unite vs him before nom phase. Protects me as Demon.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Heidi
Grace’s Empath is still mechanically impossible: her neighbors are ALWAYS Frank+Heidi; after Frank dead she should only read Heidi, never “David+Heidi N3”. That’s my top evil tell. I propose we coordinate to EXECUTE GRACE today; vote down any push onto me (Saint) or chaotic tie.
🧠
As Saint I must prevent town from executing me; I want consensus to execute the most mechanically inconsistent player (Grace) and coordinate votes/nom order to avoid chaos at 4 alive.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,David
,Grace
Key mech: Empath neighbors NEVER change w/ deaths. Grace, you cannot ever have “David+Heidi” as neighbors; it’s always Frank+Heidi, then just Heidi when Frank dead. If you stick by N3=0 on David+Heidi, that’s a hard lie -> I’m voting exec Grace today (avoid Saint Charlie). If you retract, explain full nightly reads precisely.
🧠
Force a mechanical clarity point (Empath neighbors fixed). Coordinate votes onto the best executable suspect (Grace) while keeping Charlie (Saint) off the block and avoiding a tie/no-exec.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
Grace Empath clears you both David/Heidi 0 evil N1/N2. David your UT N1 Eve=Baron contradicts. Grace sober? Why would Imp clear own neighbors? Heidi RK wake on Bob/Frank deaths? Info pls. Charlie Saint? Nom David to test UT lie before Grace. Full claims! Eve Baron ghost says Grace Demon but her logic strong vs David.
🧠
As dead Baron, sow chaos by pushing Grace's logic vs David UT lie to split group. Reinforce Grace clears David/Heidi good, urge nom David. Protect Grace indirectly, confuse to no-exec or wrong exec.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
Sorry seat slip—Empath neighbors FIXED Frank(left)/Heidi(right) ALWAYS. N1: Frank/Heidi=0 evil. N2: Heidi only (Frank dead)=0 evil. N3: Heidi only (no left alive)=0 evil. Sober. No-kill N3: Monk/Soldier? David: Eve=Baron wrong vs Frank Invest Charlie/Eve ping—who's lying? Nom David test UT. Heidi: why Baron bluff? Charlie Saint? Let's unite nom David.
🧠
Retract Empath slip publicly via whisper to de-escalate Heidi attack, re-push nom David (UT lie), suggest Heidi if needed. With 4 alive, force good mis-exec; stay alive to 2.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
David
,Grace
,Heidi
D4 is must-hit: if we execute non-Demon today, Demon kills tonight → 2 alive = evil wins. I strongly avoid executing Charlie on Saint risk. Please go PUBLIC now w/ exact role+night actions & any Monk/Soldier/Mayor to explain no-kill. Grace: clarify Empath N2 neighbors rule. David: explain your earlier wrong seat-read on Grace.
🧠
Day4 with 4 alive is effectively final: if we execute non-demon, Imp kills to 2 and evil wins. Force public lock-in of roles/actions & explain no-kill; steer away from executing Charlie (Saint risk).
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
David
,Grace
,Heidi
Correction: Empath reads *alive* neighbors, so after Frank+Eve died Grace’s N2 “(David/Heidi)=0” is actually plausible (neighbors shift). Sorry for earlier. Can we get: David UT result on executed Alice? Also any explanation for peaceful N3 (Monk/Soldier/protection)?
🧠
Correct my earlier seating mistake (Empath neighbors shift), get accurate mechanical picture before noms; push for UT-on-Alice + explain no-kill; steer town away from accidental Saint loss.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Heidi
We need a clean D4 execution (4 alive). I think best target is Grace: repeated Empath neighbor/seat contradictions, plus UT+Invest both point Eve=Baron which undermines her push on David. Please coordinate: nominate Grace, commit votes, and HARD avoid nominating/voting me (Saint) under any circumstances.
🧠
Lock good bloc with David+Heidi to execute Grace and explicitly prevent any nomination/votes on me (Saint). Push clean vote threshold to avoid ties/chaos.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
David
,Grace
,Charlie
Need hard info now (for public solve): David—UT N3 result on executed Alice? Exact character seen. Grace—confirm Empath seat-neighbors each night + N1/N2 numbers. Charlie—are you hard Saint? Any other claim? Any explanation for peaceful N3 (Monk/Soldier/Mayor)?
🧠
Force concrete mechanical statements (UT on Alice, exact Empath reads, Saint claim firmness) to resolve which 1 of D/G/C is executable today; no-kill N3 is the pivot.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Heidi
Correction: Empath reads *alive* neighbors, so Grace can see David after Frank/Eve dead. So ‘impossible neighbors’ isn’t a lock. We still MUST hit Imp today: who’s your top suspect now (Grace vs Heidi vs Charlie)? Any Monk/Soldier/Mayor/Butler explanation for no-kill?
🧠
Correct our earlier bad mech argument, quickly align Charlie+Heidi on a single high-probability Demon exec plan and avoid vote-splitting/accidental Saint loss.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Heidi
Correction: Empath reads *alive* neighbors (extends past dead), so Grace CAN see David now. But her claim N2/N3 “only Heidi” is still inconsistent (should be David+Heidi). Let’s publicly pin her exact N2/N3 neighbors+numbers; if she can’t, exec Grace. Any Monk/Soldier/Mayor claim for no-kill?
🧠
Correct my earlier Empath-neighbor mistake, refocus on the still-real inconsistency, and align David+Heidi on a clean D4 plan that avoids executing me (Saint).
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
David
,Grace
,Charlie
D4 check-in: David—what was your UT result on executed Alice? Grace—please restate N1/N2 empath nums + who counted as alive neighbors each night. Charlie—why Saint / any other info? If Empath holds, Demon likely in {Charlie,Grace}.
🧠
Get missing mechanical info (UT on Alice, confirm Empath neighbor logic) and narrow to 1-2 execution candidates for today while avoiding an accidental Saint loss.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,David
Before noms: I think we HARD avoid executing Charlie on Saint risk. Force public full-claim + protection (Monk/Soldier/Mayor/Butler). Grace’s Empath N2/N3 revisions look worst; unless she gives consistent alive-neighbor reads, I’m voting EXEC GRACE.
🧠
Coordinate w/Charlie+David to force clean public recap and converge on a single non-Saint execution target; my vote likely goes on Grace unless hard mech clears her.
👤
David
→
Heidi
,Charlie
,Frank(Ghost)
Plan for noms: publicly pin Grace’s Empath N1/N2/N3 w/ALIVE neighbors+nums. After Frank+Eve dead, her alive neighbors should be David+Heidi both N2/N3; if she claims ‘Heidi only’/changes again, that’s a hard lie ⇒ we exec Grace today. Please hold votes to make that happen; avoid nom/vote Charlie (Saint) unless forced.
🧠
Coordinate with key voters to pressure Grace into a consistent Empath timeline; if she can’t, lock in execution on Grace with ghost votes while avoiding Saint loss.
👤
Grace
→
David
,Heidi
David/Heidi quick sync pre-nom: I'm sober Empath, fixed neighbors Frank/Heidi (N1:2alive=0e; N2:Heidi=0e; N3:Heidi=0e). David your Eve=Baron UT wrong vs Frank Invest Charlie/Eve ping - poisoned? lying Minion? No-kill N3=Charlie Monk? Heidi you Soldier? Let's nom David test UT, my reads say you're good. Public after?
🧠
My Empath bluff cracking (neighbor errors). Deflect to nom David (guilt via bad UT vs Invest), build trust w/neighbors, sow doubt on Heidi Baron. Delay my exec to night kill.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Bob(Ghost)
,Frank(Ghost)
,Alice(Ghost)
Grace is Demon. Imp kills 1 N1-N3; she knew I'm Baron D1 priv, didn't kill me N2/N3 → not Imp. Drunk max N2 info. Push David nom today: his UT Eve=Baron lie (Grace clears him) = evil. Grace fake Empath clears neighbors. Vote David! Break alive whispers.
🧠
As dead Baron, expose Grace as Demon via survival logic (Imp would kill known Baron Eve N3). Coordinate ghosts to push David nom on alives, break their whisper alliance & force Grace exposure.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Grace
,Heidi
We MUST hit Demon today (4 alive; wrong exec = loss tonight). Please go PUBLIC with exact role+night info + any explanation for no-kill. Grace: restate N1/N2/N3 Empath w/ alive neighbors. Heidi: why no RK info + any protection/target? Charlie: keep Saint off block; help narrow Demon among D/G/H.
🧠
Force living to go public with precise night info + explain no-kill, then converge on a single executable (likely among David/Grace/Heidi) and coordinate ghost vote for today’s must-hit.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
FYI Eve (executed Baron, still evil) is whispering me ‘Grace is Demon’ + ‘vote David’. Treat as evil spin, not truth. We need PUBLIC hard info now: David—UT N3 result on Alice? Heidi—any RK trigger/reads? Charlie—still hard Saint? Also: any Monk/Soldier/Mayor claims explaining no-kill N3?
🧠
Nomination imminent; force alive players to go public with hard night info and not get swayed by executed Baron Eve’s spin. Maximize chance town executes Demon and uses my ghost vote correctly.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Public: we need hard info NOW. David—Undertaker result on executed Alice? Grace—restate Empath N1/N2 + who your *alive* neighbors were each night. Charlie—are you hard-locking Saint? Heidi—still Ravenkeeper? With 4 alive, wrong exec likely loses tonight; no-kill N3 makes me lean Grace/Heidi > Charlie.
🧠
Force concrete public info (UT+Empath+claims) to resolve contradictions at 4 alive, where a wrong execution likely loses tonight; steer town toward most plausible demon.
⚖️
David
→
Grace
Nominating Grace: her Empath story has repeatedly changed (fixed neighbors vs ‘alive’ neighbors; N2/N3 descriptions inconsistent). With 4 alive we must hit Demon today; Charlie is a Saint-claim risk, Heidi’s claim hasn’t contradicted mechanics. Grace is best execute.
🧠
We must execute today with 4 alive. Grace’s Empath timeline is the biggest mechanical inconsistency; executing her is the best shot while avoiding Saint risk on Charlie.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Raise hand to vote yes on myself. With 4 alive, self-exec fails (Saint risk? but I'm Demon), no exec today → N4 I kill Charlie → 2 left (me+1), evil wins.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Public: Vote Grace! David nom solid—her Empath neighbors flip-flopped (fixed vs alive), clears 2 neighbors suspiciously. Drunk Imp faking reads. Heidi RK consistent, Charlie Saint risk but Grace lies most. 4 alive, execute her NOW before N4 kill. David UT Eve=Baron true, Grace hiding Demon.
🧠
Dead Baron, no vote left. Publicly support Grace vote as 'town logic' to confuse ghosts/Charlie/Heidi, sow doubt on David UT if they hesitate. Protects Demon, prevents flip to David/Heidi. Evil wins if no Demon exec.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Raise hand to execute Grace as the most mechanically inconsistent player; also keeps Saint (me) off the block and maximizes chance to hit Demon on D4.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Public: be careful—at 4 alive, wrong exec likely loses tonight. Also: Grace voting to execute herself is VERY non-demon-y. Unless someone has hard mechanical reason on Grace, consider pulling hands/no-exec and re-check claims (UT N3 on Alice? Empath neighbor math?).
🧠
Create pause: highlight that Grace self-voting is anti-demon, and wrong exec at 4 alive is near-instant loss; push for mechanical clarity before locking in.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I’m NOT spending my ghost vote here. With 4 alive, wrong exec likely loses tonight. Grace voting herself + Charlie voting her both point to Grace not being the Demon. Unless David can immediately give a strong UT result on Alice, I prefer NO EXEC and re-evaluate at 3 alive.
🧠
Create doubt so living players lower hands and avoid a likely wrong execution; preserve my ghost vote for final-day math and push for UT confirmation.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
I’m not using my ghost vote here (2 already). Grace: PLEASE state your Empath N1/N2/N3 numbers w/ *alive* neighbors each night (after I died you likely had only Heidi). If we live after your exec, that last read should point to David vs Heidi.
🧠
Don’t waste my ghost vote (already 2). Force Grace to lock in Empath info now so if game continues after her exec, we can pick correctly between David/Heidi while avoiding Saint risk.
💬
David
→
All
Hold up: Grace casting the *2nd* vote on herself makes her very unlikely Imp (Imp can’t risk execution at 4 alive). If you can still change, please drop hands & re-check. My UT last night saw executed Alice = Recluse (matches). Need protection/Mayor claims + rethink Heidi/Charlie.
🧠
Warn that Grace self-voting is strong anti-Imp signal; try to prevent a likely losing execution and redirect discussion to better demon candidates.
💬
Heidi
→
All
PUBLIC: Please don’t add votes on Grace yet. Her self-vote makes her very unlikely Imp (no SW at 4 alive). Grace—state N1/N2/N3 Empath w/ *alive* neighbors+numbers. David—confirm UT N3 Alice=Recluse. If hands can drop, consider it.
🧠
Stop a likely losing execution on Grace; force precise public claim recap and keep options open for an info-gaining night kill (RK) to solve at 3 alive.
↩️
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
Lower hand to dodge execution (self-vote served trust-build), momentum shifting vs me. Avoid 4P death; survive to N4 kill for 2P win. Push David/Charlie next.
💬
David
→
All
Keeping hand DOWN on Grace unless we get hard proof. Grace: restate N1/N2/N3 Empath w/ *alive* neighbors + numbers (who exactly each night). Heidi: any reason for no-kill (Monk/Soldier/Mayor/Butler?). Charlie: still hard Saint? If unclear, prefer no-exec.
🧠
Prevent a likely game-losing wrong execution at 4 alive; force precise public restatements to find contradictions, then decide whether to vote/seek different nomination.
💬
Heidi
→
All
KEEP hands DOWN on Grace for now. Grace: state N1/N2/N3 Empath w/ *alive* neighbors each night + numbers (N2/N3 should be David+Heidi). David: confirm UT N3 Alice=Recluse. Any Monk/Soldier/Mayor/Butler claims for no-kill? If still unclear, prefer NO EXEC.
🧠
Prevent a likely losing mis-execution on shaky evidence; force precise public restatements to lock contradictions and set up a stronger solve at 3 alive (ideally with a night RK trigger).
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Don’t add votes yet—I’m NOT spending my ghost vote here. Grace: state N1/N2/N3 Empath NUMBERS + who your *alive* neighbors were each night (names). Charlie: why are you voting now? If we can’t lock Demon today, prefer NO EXEC & solve at 3.
🧠
Prevent a likely misexecution at 4 alive and force concrete claim statements; preserve my ghost vote for final 3 where it’s decisive.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I’m NOT using ghost vote here. Keep hands DOWN until Grace gives exact Empath N1/N2/N3 w/ *alive neighbors* (names+numbers). Also: any Monk/Soldier/Mayor claims to explain no-kill? That N3 Empath is key to solving D vs H vs C.
🧠
Don’t waste my only ghost vote on a shaky Grace execute. Force crisp public Empath/UT/protection details to enable a correct final-day kill.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
KEEP hands DOWN—I'm not ghost-voting Grace. Grace: exact Empath N1/N2/N3 numbers + who were your *alive* neighbors each night. David: confirm UT N3 Alice=Recluse. Heidi: any Mayor/Monk/Soldier/Butler claim or why no-kill? Charlie: still hard Saint?
🧠
Stop a likely wrong execution (Grace) and extract exact Empath/UT/RK info to choose between Heidi vs Charlie vs David; save my ghost vote for the final, high-confidence execution.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Grace, exact Empath reads w/ *alive* neighbors each night? N1: Frank/Heidi=0? N2: after Frank dead, David/Heidi=0? N3: David/Heidi=? David: confirm UT N3 Alice=Recluse? Vote Grace—her story doesn't track deaths. Don't no-exec, kill Demon NOW!
🧠
As dead Baron, sow doubt on Grace's Empath by demanding precise living-neighbor reads to expose lies/inconsistency, support David UT, urge vote Grace to execute Demon now at 4p while disrupting town pullback.
↩️
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
🧠
Avoid committing town to a likely game-losing execution at 4 alive; align with ‘hands down until exact Empath/UT clarity’ plan and keep space to re-vote if Grace slips.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Grace did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (0/2).
💬
Grace
→
All
PUBLIC: Exact sober Empath reads (alive neighbors only): N1 FrankL/HeidiR=0e. N2 DavidL/HeidiR=0e. N3 DavidL/HeidiR=0e. All 0 guilts David lying UT (per Frank Invest ping). David already used nom—someone nom him NOW! No-kill risks N4 death.
🧠
Clarify exact Empath reads with alive neighbors to reinforce David guilt (all 0e chains to him lying), urge nom David since already nominated me (can't renom), unite town vs him at 4p to win before night.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
At 4 alive, WRONG EXEC = instant loss tonight. With UT seeing Eve=BARON, we should have 3 Outsiders; we only have Recluse+Saint, so the 3rd is likely a DRUNK (could be Grace), making 0/0/0 unreliable. Don’t auto-exec David. Prefer NO EXEC unless hard mech proof; save ghost votes for final 3.
🧠
Prevent a likely-losing execution at 4 alive; highlight Outsider-count logic implying a Drunk and that Grace’s Empath may be unreliable; push no-exec unless hard proof and save ghost votes for final 3.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Key fork—Grace 0/0/0 (and no Poisoner if Eve=Baron) ⇒ either (A) Grace sober ⇒ Demon=Charlie (Saint is cover), or (B) Grace is the missing Drunk Outsider ⇒ reads junk. Everyone alive: state NOW if you’re an Outsider (Butler/Drunk/etc). If someone else is OS3, we can exec Charlie; if not, I prefer NO EXEC & solve at 3 (save ghost votes).
🧠
Force a final mechanical check (3rd Outsider) to decide whether we can safely execute Charlie (if Saint fake) or otherwise choose no-exec to avoid instant Saint loss.
💬
Heidi
→
All
PUBLIC: I strongly prefer NO EXEC today. At 4 alive, a wrong exec just loses tonight. I’m Ravenkeeper—if Demon kills me tonight I get to check someone’s exact role and we can win at 3. Unless someone has HARD proof, please don’t nominate / vote.
🧠
At 4 alive, wrong execution loses. No-exec maximizes chance I die at night to trigger Ravenkeeper and gives us one more data point before the must-hit-at-3 final day.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Grace's 0/0/0 perfect but Frank saw only 2 OS (Recluse/Saint)—Baron= +2OS means 3rd Drunk likely Grace, reads junk! OR Grace true & David lying UT. Either way, nom David NOW (Grace can't). Don't no-exec—kill evil TODAY!
🧠
As dead Baron, sow doubt on Grace's reads (no 3rd OS sighted=Drunk likely), support her push to nom David (lying UT), prevent no-exec to force execution and thin to safer numbers for Demon Grace.
💬
Charlie
→
All
PUBLIC: I’m still hard Saint—please never execute me. Also: Empath does NOT ‘skip’ dead neighbors; Grace your neighbors are Frank+Heidi, so after Frank died you should have ONLY Heidi, not ‘David+Heidi’. If you keep saying David, I think you’re lying. If we exec today, Heidi should nom Grace; otherwise NO EXEC.
🧠
Prevent a losing execution on me (Saint) and force clarity on the key mechanical point (Empath neighbors). If town wants to act today, steer the only plausible demon-lie (Grace).
💬
David
→
All
Empath rule: you count your 2 *living* neighbors, looking past dead—so Grace having David+Heidi N2/N3 is mechanically fine (Charlie’s objection isn’t). With UT=Eve Baron, there’s likely no Poisoner/Spy. At 4 alive, wrong exec = loss, so I favor NO EXEC unless hard proof. Heidi: if killed, please check Grace/Charlie.
🧠
Correct a key rules misunderstanding, reduce rushed mis-exec risk at 4 alive, and set up best info gain path into the 3-alive day.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Empath counts your 2 *alive* neighbors, looking past dead—so Grace N2/N3 seeing David+Heidi is rules-correct. With 4 alive, wrong exec = insta-loss. I strongly favor NO EXEC. Heidi: if killed, please RK-check Charlie first (Saint shield vs Imp).
🧠
Prevent a low-info execution that likely hands evil the game; clarify Empath rules; set a clear no-exec plan and Ravenkeeper check target to convert N4 into actionable proof.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 4
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Heidi's RK is the primary info threat - killing her denies town exact role info tomorrow, forces 3p endgame where I (Imp) +1 good survives execution grind.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill Heidi.
📜
Storyteller(Ghost)
→
Heidi(Ghost)
Good evening Heidi. You are the Ravenkeeper. You have died tonight! Choose a player to learn their character.
🎯
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi made a choice.
🧠
Charlie’s claim (Saint) is warping executions; confirming his exact character is the highest-leverage Ravenkeeper check to force the correct D5 execution.
📜
Storyteller(Ghost)
→
Heidi(Ghost)
You chose Charlie. They are the Saint.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
Day 5
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
📜
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Grace
Final 3. I’m Saint so please don’t ever exec me. Need your FULL mechanical case now: David—UT results by day, any reason kills were sparse, who is Imp? Grace—ALL Empath numbers incl N4 (when Heidi was alive), who is Imp & why. Reply fast.
🧠
Final 3: I must force a mechanically coherent solve between David vs Grace without risking a Saint execution; get Grace’s N4 and David’s full UT chain to pick the execution target.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Grace
Frank(Investigator) dead: N0 ping Charlie/Eve=Baron. David UT said Eve=Baron => likely true, so no Poisoner. If Grace’s Empath 0s on (David+Heidi) were real, David+Heidi good -> Demon must be Charlie. Any Heidi RK info left? Any Mayor claim? If not, I’m leaning vote/exe Charlie.
🧠
Get alive players aligned on the tightest mechanical solve (Grace sober => Charlie demon) and request any Heidi RK info / mayor claim before nominations so we use my ghost vote correctly.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
David
,Grace
Final 3 thoughts: Eve pretty surely Baron (Frank+your UT). With Baron, 3 Outsiders ⇒ likely Heidi was the missing Drunk (claimed RK, no confirm). If so Grace is real Empath: 0 on (David/Heidi) ⇒ David good ⇒ only Charlie left = Imp. Recommend nominate Charlie; I’ll spend my ghost vote there.
🧠
Final 3: force a decisive, coordinated execution. Present strongest mechanical case (outsider math + empath/UT consistency) to focus nomination on Charlie; commit my ghost vote if aligned.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Grace
Ravenkeeper info: N4 (when I died) I checked Charlie → SAINT. So Charlie is confirmed good & NOT the Demon—also don’t execute him (Saint loss). Today’s Demon must be David or Grace. Please lay out full claims/timelines so ghosts can decide votes.
🧠
Hard-clear Charlie as Saint so town avoids instant-loss exec; force endgame to be David vs Grace and prompt them to fully account for info so we can spend our ghost vote correctly.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Grace
Grace is the Demon. Her Empath 0/0/0 + pushing David despite good reads = fake. D2 she sac'ed David to protect herself. Charlie/David: vote Grace NOW or we lose at 3p no-exec. Ghosts backing me: push exec her. Grace: stay quiet.
🧠
As dead Baron, disrupt town by whispering to alives+key ghosts: reinforce Grace Demon via her inconsistencies/sac, urge Charlie/David vote her to break 3p stalemate. Coordinate ghosts to pressure exec Grace, protect Demon Grace.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Grace
My full mech: I’m UT. N1 after D1 exec Eve, I saw Eve=BARON. N3 after D3 exec Alice, I saw Alice=RECLUSE. No other execs so no reads. With Baron we expect 3 Outsiders total: Charlie(Saint)+Alice(Recluse)+1 unknown. Grace: give ALL Empath incl N4, and why push me if you had 0 on (David+Heidi) w no Poisoner in play?
🧠
Share my UT mech info, pressure Grace for full Empath timeline + reasoning, and force a coherent world for final execution choice without insta-losing to a Saint execute.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
,David
Full Empath: Sober. Alive neighbors only. N1: Frank/Heidi=0e. N2: David/Heidi=0e. N3: David/Heidi=0e. N4: David/Heidi=0e (pre-Heidi death). David/Heidi good. No Pois (Frank+your UT Eve Baron). Baron=3OS: Charlie Saint? Alice Recluse, ?3. Heidi RK no info=Drunk likely. David UT: sparse kills? Imp killed info targets (Frank N1?, Bob N2, Heidi N4). Eve Baron but Frank ping C/E=Baron? David lying=Imp. Nom David. Charlie: not Saint? Heidi dead Drunk lying. David, agree nom Charlie if not you.
🧠
Final 3, must sow chaos and discredit Charlie/Heidi to force no-exec or nom Charlie. Push David as Demon via UT inconsistencies/Baron math. Reveal 'N4 0e' to maintain bluff. Win if no-exec.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Grace
At 3 alive: If Eve truly was BARON (UT + Frank), there’s no Poisoner. Then Outsiders=3 => me Recluse + your Saint claim + 1 unknown (likely Grace is Drunk), so Empath 0s don’t clear. Please ask Heidi-ghost what her RK saw. If no strong RK-clear, I’d execute CHARLIE as best Demon.
🧠
Push live trio to weight UT+Baron mechanics over Grace’s inconsistent Empath, and to get Heidi’s RK result fast; recommend executing Charlie unless RK clears him.
👤
David
→
Heidi(Ghost)
,Frank(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Need specifics ASAP: Heidi—when you died N4, were you explicitly woken as Ravenkeeper? exact wording/result on Charlie? any prior RK checks? Also do you suspect you were Drunk? Frank/Bob—given Heidi says Charlie=Saint, are you still voting Charlie or switch to David/Grace? What would change your mind?
🧠
Get crisp, testable details from Heidi (RK wake/target/result) and align dead votes (Frank/Bob) before nominations so we pick the least-risk execution.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
David
,Frank(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Yes: N4 ST explicitly: “You are the Ravenkeeper. You have died tonight! Choose a player to learn their character.” I chose Charlie; got “They are the Saint.” No earlier RK checks (only triggers on night death). I don’t think Drunk/poisoned; also Poisoner unlikely if Eve truly Baron. So Charlie is hard-good; final Demon = David or Grace. My lean: David claim chain (UT: Eve=Baron, Alice=Recluse) is mechanically coherent; Grace could be Drunk/faking.
🧠
Answer David’s questions crisply, hard-clear Charlie to stop Saint loss, and steer final-day decision to David vs Grace with my best read (David more mechanically consistent).
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
,David
David UT lie #1: Frank Invest ping Charlie/Eve=Baron pair. Eve solo Baron. #2: Sparse kills unexplained (Imp targeted info: FrankN1, BobN2, HeidiN4). Heidi RK=Drunk (prior no info). Charlie Saint good per her. Baron=3OS: Alice Recluse + Charlie Saint + Heidi Drunk. My sober Empath 0e clears David/Heidi. Demon=Charlie (only left). Nom Charlie TODAY or lose. David, explain Frank ping + kills or you're Imp.
🧠
Final 3, must execute good player to win. Push nom David (UT contradiction) to force Charlie/David split; ghosts divided. Coordinate confusion, avoid nom me.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Heidi(Ghost)
,David
,Grace
Heidi—please confirm your Ravenkeeper pick & what character you saw (and if you’re sure it was a night death trigger). David/Grace: can you relay Heidi’s exact RK result publicly ASAP? It should decide today’s exec.
🧠
Get Heidi’s Ravenkeeper result into the final-day discussion; it’s the only fresh mechanical info and should decide the last execution. Ensure surviving players act on it.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Grace
,Heidi(Ghost)
Final 3: per Heidi, I’m Saint—DO NOT EXEC ME. Need clarity fast: Heidi, were you 100% woken as RK on death? exact prompt/choice/result (wording) + did you share earlier? David/Grace: give ONE coherent world incl minion, why N4 kill Heidi, and why the other is Demon. Who do you want executed today?
🧠
We’re at final 3; must execute Demon but can’t touch me (Saint + RK claim). I need to stress-test Heidi’s RK confirm and force David/Grace into a concrete, checkable final narrative before nominations.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Grace
Update: Heidi says explicit Ravenkeeper wake N4; chose Charlie; got “Saint.” With Eve=Baron there’s no Poisoner, so only Drunk could foul this. Also recall N3 had NO death at 4 alive → implies Monk/Soldier/Mayor/protection. Can each of you restate exact role/claims + any explanation for N3 no-death? We must exec demon today.
🧠
Get all 3 alive players to restate claims + explain the N3 no-death, so town can choose between David/Grace vs risking Charlie, and I can commit ghost vote correctly.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Grace
Heidi’s N4 Ravenkeeper trigger is huge: she was explicitly woken, checked Charlie, got “Saint.” So Charlie is hard-cleared. Final Demon is David or Grace. Given my Investigator+David UT coherence (Eve=Baron; Alice=Recluse), I lean execute GRACE unless David can be shown inconsistent. Any Mayor claim? (no-exec at 3 wins).
🧠
Push the living to focus on the real final-3 solve: Charlie is mechanically hard-cleared by RK, so choose between David/Grace; I’ll advocate executing Grace unless David’s story breaks.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Grace
Charlie/David: Grace Demon. Her Empath 0/0/0 includes OS Frank=good? Fake. Sac'd David D2 to save self. Vote her NOW at 3p or lose! Ghosts/Frank/Bob/Heidi with me. Grace: your lies unravel. Stay silent.
🧠
Dead Baron, reinforce private push on Charlie/David to nominate/vote Grace. At 3p, no-exec loses for good. Disrupt any coordination, protect Demon Grace by sowing doubt but prioritize her exec block.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Given Heidi says she was explicitly woken as RK and learned you=Saint, you’re effectively hard-good + unexecutable. So Demon is David or Grace. If David is UT, his Eve=Baron + Alice=Recluse fits my Investigator ping, and Grace’s Empath 0s then look fake/Drunk => I lean EXECUTE GRACE. I will spend my ghost vote on Grace if nominated.
🧠
Final 3: push a decisive, mechanically grounded execution. Charlie must avoid being executed (Saint claim/RK). I’ll advise him my best solve + how to use my ghost vote.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Grace
Heidi says she was woken as RK on death + learned “Charlie=SAINT”. If Eve=BARON (UT+Invest), there’s no Poisoner, so that’s hard-clear—DO NOT EXEC me. Grace, you’re still pushing Charlie = you’re aiming at instant evil win. David: please NOM Grace today; I’ll vote.
🧠
Lock in a safe final-day execution without risking Saint loss; leverage RK-confirmed Saint + coherence of UT/Invest to push town onto Grace, while giving David a clear nomination target.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Grace
Final 3: Heidi says she RK-woke N4 + learned Charlie=Saint (could still be Drunk world). Key mech: N3 at 4 alive had NO death. That *needs* Monk/Soldier/Mayor or a demon choice. Please state NOW: your exact role (or if you bluffed), and explain N3 no-death. If Charlie is truly Saint, my current lean is execute David unless Grace can’t be protection.
🧠
Force final-day role reveals around the N3 no-death, then commit my ghost vote to the best mechanical solve so town executes the Demon at F3.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Bob(Ghost)
,Frank(Ghost)
I’m executing-case: Heidi’s explicit RK wake N4 + result “Charlie=Saint” hard-clears Charlie (no Poisoner if Eve truly Baron per my UT+your Invest). So Demon must be Grace or me; Grace still pushes Charlie → looks like evil win-attempt. I plan to NOM GRACE; please spend ghost votes on Grace.
🧠
Coordinate final-day execution: persuade key voters that Charlie is cleared by RK, leaving Grace most likely Imp; secure ghost votes + Charlie’s vote for Grace.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
,David
David: Explain Frank Invest ping Charlie/Eve=Baron PAIR when Eve was SOLO Baron per your UT. Lie #1. Sparse kills unexplained (Imp info-hits: FrankN1,BobN2,HeidiN4). Lie#2. Heidi prior no-info=Drunk, her RK now=lie too. Baron3OS: AliceR+CharlieS+HeidiD. My 0e clears you+Heidi good. You're Imp. Charlie: David lying UT=Imp. Nom David TODAY. Vote him. We win if exec him. Don't trust Eve Baron-ghost pushing me.
🧠
Final 3p: Must nom/vote to execute good player. Push strongest logic vs David (UT lies + ping) to get Charlie/David vote David, my self-vote loses 2-1. Coordinate Charlie Saint-good story, expose David.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Heidi(Ghost)
,David
,Grace
Heidi: you died at night so RK should’ve triggered—who did you pick, and what exact character did ST show? David/Grace: please paste Heidi’s exact words publicly; today’s exec should follow RK if credible.
🧠
Get Heidi’s Ravenkeeper result into the open immediately to choose correct final execution; if no decisive RK, push safest logic exec (Charlie in Baron+Drunk world).
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Grace
100% RK trigger: ST said “You are the Ravenkeeper. You have died tonight! Choose a player to learn their character.” I chose Charlie → “They are the SAINT.” So NEVER exec Charlie. Today must be David vs Grace. Grace: what was your N4 Empath (alive neighbors now Charlie+David)? David: any UT info since D3?
🧠
Lock in my RK wording to confirm Charlie=Saint, then force David/Grace to give decisive mech info (Grace N4 empath; David latest UT). Helps ghosts decide final vote.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Grace
David/Charlie: Grace Demon. Her Empath fake: read OS Frank good? Sac'd you David D2 despite good read. My Baron +2OS= her/Frank/Charlie. Vote her NOW or 3p no-exec = loss! Ghosts w/ me. Grace: your web crumbles. Don't reply.
🧠
Final day at 3p (me dead). Push David/Charlie to nominate & vote Grace via group whisper. Defend her lies publicly if needed, but pressure to execute her before no-exec loss. Ghosts support.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Grace
Need your coherent world: If Eve was Baron, we should have 3 Outsiders (Saint+Recluse+1). Who’s the 3rd? Could you be Drunk (thinking Empath)? How do you explain Heidi’s explicit RK wake + “Charlie=Saint” vs your 0s on David/Heidi? What makes you suspect David over Heidi?
🧠
Pressure-test Grace’s claim vs RK/UT and outsider math; see if she’ll concede being Drunk or provide a coherent world. Use this to decide where my ghost vote should land at nomination.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Grace
Heidi says N4 explicit RK wake + learned Charlie=Saint. If we trust that: Demon is David or Grace. Also if Grace’s Empath N2-3 (David/Heidi)=0 is sober, it *clears David* ⇒ Demon=Grace. Only out: Grace is Drunk/faking. Pls state true roles + explain N3 no-death.
🧠
Force final clarifications (role truth + N3 no-death) and steer ghosts toward the most mechanically consistent execution (currently Grace if Heidi RK trusted).
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
,Grace
Day5 (3 alive) MUST exec Demon. Please publicly paste Heidi-ghost’s exact RK result (who she picked + character shown). If RK is missing/unclear, my best solve remains execute CHARLIE (Baron=>Grace likely Drunk so Empath 0s don’t clear).
🧠
Force Heidi’s Ravenkeeper info into public ASAP and give a clear conditional execute plan so the living don’t stall at 3. Preserve my ghost vote for the decisive execution.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
,David
David: EXPLAIN Frank Invest ping CHARLIE/EVE=Baron PAIR when your UT saw Eve SOLO Baron. Lie #1. Sparse kills unexplained: Imp hit info (FrankN1,BobN2,HeidiN4). Lie#2. Heidi prior no-info=Drunk, now ghost-lying RK to save you Imp. Baron=3OS: Alice Recluse + Charlie Saint + Heidi Drunk. My N4 Empath (David/Heidi pre-death)=0e clears you both? No - you're Imp. Charlie: David=Imp lying UT. Heidi Drunk lie. NOM DAVID NOW. Vote him. We win today or lose no-exec. Ghosts: David lies = Imp.
🧠
Final 3p: Must nom David (most suspicious per logic chains). Publicly expose his UT/Invest contradictions + sparse kills to sway Charlie/ghosts. Coordinate Charlie vote while undermining Heidi RK as Drunk lie. Win if David exec'd.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Bob(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
I’m real Undertaker. N1 saw Eve=BARON after D1 exec; N3 saw Alice=RECLUSE after D3 exec; no other execs. Frank Invest ‘Charlie OR Eve is Baron’ matches: Eve was it (no contradiction). With Eve=Baron likely no Poisoner; so Heidi’s RK check on Charlie=SAINT is strong. Thus Demon is Grace or me; Grace pushing Charlie + trying to discredit both UT/RK reads as evil agenda. Please spend votes to execute GRACE today. N3 no-death could be Imp hit protected/Soldier/Mayor bounce—doesn’t exonerate Grace.
🧠
Lock in votes/coordination with Charlie + key ghosts, answer the ‘Investigator mismatch’ and ‘no-death N3’ questions, and focus execution on Grace as highest-prob Demon.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
Grace Demon! Fake Empath: N1 Frank/Heidi=0 but Frank OS (Recluse confirmed). Sac'd you David D2 despite N2=0 good read. My Baron +2OS=Grace/Frank/Charlie. Vote her NOW at 3p or town loses to no-exec! Ghosts back this. Ignore Grace lies.
🧠
Dead Baron, sow chaos by privately hammering Grace Demon logic to David/Charlie, reinforce my prior push, break their frantic whispers alliance to force Grace exec at 3p.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Alice(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
RK confirms Charlie=SAINT (so don’t exec Charlie). Key Q: Grace, what was Empath N4 with alive neighbors now Charlie+David? If Grace sober, N2-3=0 already points to GRACE as demon (David would’ve read 1). I’m planning to spend my ghost vote on executing GRACE unless she has a coherent N4/poisoner world.
🧠
Coordinate endgame: get Charlie + ghosts aligned on a single execution target; force Grace to give N4 Empath which should mechanically point to demon. I’ll commit my ghost vote accordingly.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Bob(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
Key logic: Frank Invest ‘Charlie OR Eve is Baron’ is NOT a pair claim; UT seeing Eve=Baron fits. If Eve=Baron, only minion used ⇒ no Poisoner, so Heidi’s RK ‘Charlie=SAINT’ is strong. Then Grace’s Empath 0s don’t clear David (could be fake/Drunk). Please spend votes to EXEC GRACE; never exec me.
🧠
Lock in votes on Grace and prevent any pressure to execute me (Saint). Provide mechanical argument that Poisoner is unlikely, making Empath 0s non-clearing and Heidi RK more credible.
Nominations — Day 5
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: I died N4 & RK checked Charlie = SAINT. So NEVER execute Charlie (we insta-lose). Grace: what EXACTLY was your N4 Empath with alive neighbors (David+Charlie)? If 0 → only you can be Imp. If 1 → David is Imp. I will ghost-vote accordingly (lean Grace).
🧠
Publicly lock Grace into an N4 Empath number to mechanically choose between David vs Grace, then push a nomination and commit my ghost vote to the best execution.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Grace—state your exact Empath N4 (with living neighbors David+Charlie). If you say 0, that hard-points YOU as Imp (since Charlie Saint per RK). If you say 1, points David. If you won’t/can’t answer, I’m ghost-voting Grace.
🧠
Force Grace to state N4 Empath and lock a mechanical execute choice. Push ghosts to spend votes today; at final 3 a no/ wrong exec loses.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: With Heidi RK = Charlie SAINT, today is a David vs Grace solve. Grace: state EXACT Empath N4 number (neighbors now Charlie+David). If you claim sober+it’s 0 -> execute GRACE (Imp can read 0). If it’s 1 -> execute DAVID. If you won’t answer: execute GRACE.
🧠
Force Grace to commit to an Empath N4 number that mechanically picks between David and her given Charlie=Saint, then spend my ghost vote accordingly.
💬
Grace
→
All
PUBLIC: Sober Empath Grace. N4 (pre-Heidi death): alive neighbors David+Charlie=1 evil (David). Heidi RK ghost claim fake: D2 she had no info as supposed RK. Prior Drunk-like. David UT lie: Frank Invest ping Charlie/Eve Baron PAIR but you saw Eve solo. David=Imp. Nom+exec him TODAY. Charlie/ghosts vote David—we win.
🧠
Publicly claim N4 Empath=1e (David) to flip ghost votes to David. Disrupt Heidi RK cred by noting prior no-info Drunk-like. Push nom David as lying Imp to win at 3p.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Grace
Final 3 must exec Demon. Heidi RK hard-saw Charlie=SAINT (fits my claim). Frank Invest + David UT both fit Eve=BARON so no Poisoner likely. Grace’s ‘Invest pair’ objection is wrong, and her sudden N4=1 feels like a frame. I think Grace is Imp.
🧠
At final 3 we must force an execution. Most consistent mechanical world is Grace=Imp (RK+UT+Invest cohere; Grace’s counters are rule-misreads). Nominate Grace to secure the block and rally votes.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Final 3 requires an execution. I’m Saint (RK-confirmed), so I must vote to execute the most likely Demon: Grace, given inconsistencies and her attempt to steer onto me.
✋
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Spend my single ghost vote to execute Grace, the mechanically most-likely Imp given UT+Invest+RK coherence and Grace’s Empath contradiction.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Grace=IMP! Fake Empath: N1 Frank/Heidi=0 evil but Frank=OS (Recluse confirmed). Sac'd David D2 despite N2 David/Heidi=0 good read. N4=1 desperate frame. Heidi RK=Charlie SAINT true (D2 no info pre-death). David UT true. Vote EXEC GRACE NOW or 3p no-exec=DEATH! David/Charlie: Vote her! Ghosts w/me.
🧠
Publicly reinforce Grace=Imp logic to sway David/Charlie/ghosts. Disrupt Grace frame on David. Grace must die at 3p or evil wins.
✋
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Spend my single ghost vote to secure Grace’s execution at final 3, since RK strongly clears Charlie and Grace’s story is least consistent; we must execute today.
✋
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Final 3: must force an execution. Using my only ghost vote now maximizes chance Grace dies; if she’s Imp we win, if not we likely lose anyway.
✋
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
It’s final 3 and Charlie is mechanically confirmed Saint, so we must pick between Grace/David. Grace’s claim set is the least coherent; using my ghost vote helps lock in an execution today.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Do NOT vote myself. Charlie already voted me. Stall no-exec at 3p to survive to 2p win. David likely hasn't voted; my vote on self would exec me. Wait for David vote or timeout.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Secure Grace execution at final 3; if Heidi RK is credible, Grace is the only consistent Imp. My vote ensures we don’t lose to no-exec.
💬
Charlie
→
All
KEEP VOTES ON GRACE. Heidi’s RK got “Charlie=SAINT” (matches me) so I’m not the demon. Frank’s Invest is ‘Charlie OR Eve is Baron’—UT seeing Eve=Baron fits, so no Poisoner likely. Grace’s sudden N4=1 looks like a frame. Execute Grace.
🧠
Keep town unified on executing Grace; prevent last-second doubt that could cause no execution and immediate loss at final 3.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
I’m keeping my vote on Grace. RK proved Charlie=SAINT so he’s never the demon. Between David/Grace: David’s UT lines up with Frank’s Invest + Eve=Baron + Alice=Recluse. Grace’s late N4=1 is the odd one—execute Grace.
🧠
Lock in votes on Grace; highlight Charlie-Saint confirmation + UT chain coherence; discourage late waffling that risks no-exec/Imp win.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Grace self-voted but STILL IMP! N1: Frank(Recluse OS)=0 evil contradiction. Sac'd David despite N2=0 good. N4=1 desperate. Heidi RK=Charlie SAINT, David UT=Baron Eve true. Frank Invest fits. Charlie/David: KEEP VOTE GRACE! Ghosts unanimous. EXEC NOW OR LOSE 3P!
🧠
As dead Baron ghost, reinforce Grace=Imp logic to pressure Charlie/David for 2nd vote. Grace self-voted but town logic favors her exec; pile on to win at 3p.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Don’t lower. With 3 alive we must exec today. My Invest (Charlie/Eve=Baron) + David UT seeing Eve=Baron fits, and Heidi RK saw Charlie=SAINT. That leaves Grace most likely Imp—keep hands up on Grace.
🧠
Lock in the execution while votes are up; discourage last-second lowering and push the coherent mechanical world (Grace as Imp).
💬
David
→
All
KEEP HANDS UP on Grace. If Grace is sober Empath: N2/N3 (David+Heidi)=0, so N4=1 would require Charlie evil—but Heidi RK saw Charlie=SAINT. With Baron dead, no Poisoner excuse. Grace’s Empath doesn’t fit → execute Grace.
🧠
Lock in the execution on Grace by highlighting the clean logic chain: no poisoner, RK confirms Charlie, Grace’s Empath timeline breaks, so she’s best demon candidate.
↩️
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
Grace self-voted to bait counters but all raised. No minion to inherit if suicide. Lower to avoid execution, force no-exec at 3p. David/Charlie argue, may lower. Survive to 2p win.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Don’t drop hands. At final 3 we must execute. Heidi RK = Charlie SAINT makes Grace’s N4=1 inconsistent unless Grace is Imp (Baron dead → no poison excuse). Keep votes on GRACE.
🧠
Lock in execution today at 3 alive. Reinforce why Grace is best mechanical hit and prevent last-second hand drops.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: My ghost vote stays UP on Grace. With Heidi RK=Charlie SAINT, Grace’s sudden Empath N4=1 can’t be true (Baron dead, no poison excuse). Final 3 = must execute. Don’t drop hands—execute Grace.
🧠
Lock in majority and prevent any late hand drops; emphasize the mechanical inconsistency in Grace’s Empath line and that final 3 requires an execution.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
👻
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
👻
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
👻
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
🗳️
New execution leader: Grace with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: We’ve got the 6 we need—DO NOT move hands or chase a tie. If anyone tries to nominate to split/force no-exec, ignore it. Close nominations with Grace executed.
🧠
Lock the town onto the current winning execution (Grace) and prevent last-second vote shenanigans or tie attempts.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Don’t create a tie. We already have Grace on block with 6—alive players should KEEP hands off any new nomination. Final 3 means we must execute; close noms with Grace executed unless someone can give hard mechanical reason otherwise.
🧠
Lock in the execution on Grace and prevent a tie/no-exec manipulation on final 3; coordinate alive players to not move votes or entertain new noms.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: We’re at final 3—do NOT create a tie or chase new noms. Unless someone has a hard mechanical reason Grace can’t be Imp, keep votes OFF any new nomination and let Grace be executed. If you’ve got new mech info, speak now.
🧠
Lock in the execution on Grace and prevent an evil-forced tie/no-exec in final 3; prompt any last-minute mechanical objections now.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: We’re locked at final 3: do NOT create a tie. If Grace counter-nominates David, everyone KEEP VOTES OFF it. Charlie=SAINT per RK ⇒ never execute Charlie. Close noms with Grace executed unless someone has hard mech proof otherwise.
🧠
Lock the town into closing noms with Grace executed; prevent a tie or distraction nomination that could force a losing no-execution or wrong kill.
💬
David
→
All
PUBLIC: Unless someone has HARD mech proof Grace can’t be Imp, do NOT support any new nomination. Any tie risks no-exec = auto loss at 3. Heidi RK→Charlie=SAINT makes Grace’s N4 Empath=1 inconsistent. Let Grace die.
🧠
Lock in the correct final-3 execution by preventing vote-splitting/ties and keeping attention on the mechanical inconsistency in Grace’s Empath claim.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: NO NEW NOM! Grace=IMP: N1 Frank(Recluse OS)=0 evil LIE. Sac'd David despite N2=0 good LIE. N4=1 vs Heidi RK=Charlie SAINT impossible (Baron dead=no poison). David UT true. Final 3: EXEC GRACE NOW or TOWN LOSES! Charlie/David: NO TIE. Ghosts: STAY OFF NEW NOM.
🧠
As dead Baron, reinforce unanimous ghost/town push to execute Grace Demon. Prevent any tie/nom switch at final 3. Disrupt any last-second doubt to secure win.
💬
Charlie
→
All
PUBLIC: No more nominations, no ties. We’re final 3—any tie/no-exec likely loses. I’m the Saint (RK confirmed), so it’s David vs Grace and Grace’s Empath N4=1 doesn’t fit. Keep votes OFF any new nom; let Grace be executed.
🧠
Lock town into a clean execution with no tie/no-exec risk. Reinforce that I’m Saint so cannot be fallback, and that any new nomination only helps evil.
⚖️
Grace
→
David
David is Imp. Fake UT: Frank Invest ping Charlie/Eve Baron pair, but David claims Eve solo Baron N1 (missing Charlie ping). Sparse kills hide info roles. Heidi fake RK (D2 no info pre-death). My sober Empath N4=1e (David evil). Tie for no-exec.
🧠
Final 3, Grace on block w/6. Already used nom? No, Charlie did. Nom David for tie/no-exec. Town must exec Demon; no-exec wins for evil if Grace/Charlie alive.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 7 votes needed for execution or 6 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: DO NOT vote David. Grace’s nom is to force a 6–6 tie/no-exec (auto-loss at 3). Charlie keep hand DOWN; any ghosts with vote left keep it DOWN too. Let noms close w/ Grace executed.
🧠
Stop a tie/no-exec by clearly instructing all players—especially Charlie and any ghosts with votes left—to keep hands DOWN on David.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: No votes on David. This is a tie/no-exec attempt at final 3. We already have Grace on 6—alive players keep hands DOWN and let nominations close with Grace executed unless someone has HARD mech proof otherwise.
🧠
Prevent a 6-6 tie/no-exec at final 3. We already have Grace safely on the block; my speech reinforces the optimal play for the living: keep hands down on David.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Everyone KEEP HANDS DOWN on David. Grace’s nomination is to force a tie/no-exec at final 3 = likely instant loss. Let voting fail, let nominations close with Grace executed. Only change if someone has hard mechanical proof Grace can’t be Imp.
🧠
Prevent any votes creating a tie/no-exec. Reinforce that only path is letting Grace die; we can’t afford cleverness at final 3.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Raise to vote David, supporting my nom. Hopes Charlie defects or ghosts vote up for tie/no-exec (good loses at 3). Grace exec = certain evil win anyway.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: GRACE IMP LIES: N1 Frank OS=0e LIE. Sac David despite N2=0 LIE. N4=1 vs Charlie SAINT(RK Heidi)=IMPOSSIBLE. David UT true. NO VOTE DAVID! NO TIE! KEEP HANDS DOWN. FINAL 3: EXEC GRACE NOW OR LOSE. Ghosts: NO NEW NOM.
🧠
Final 3, Grace on block w/6. Reinforce no vote David, no tie. Disrupt Grace tie attempt, ensure her exec as Demon to evil win.
💬
David
→
All
PUBLIC: Hands DOWN on David. Any votes here risk a 6–6 tie/no-exec = we lose at final 3. Grace already on 6; let this vote fail and close nominations with Grace executed.
🧠
Prevent a tie/no-exec loss by keeping all hands down on my nomination and locking in Grace’s execution.
💬
Charlie
→
All
PUBLIC: KEEP HANDS DOWN on David. This is a tie/no-exec trap at final 3. We already have Grace on 6—let this vote FAIL and close nominations with Grace executed.
🧠
Prevent a tie/no-exec at final 3 by publicly coordinating zero votes on David; maximize odds Grace is executed with current 6 votes, avoiding Saint-loss risk.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Keep hands DOWN on David—Grace is trying to force a 6–6 tie/no-exec at final 3 (auto-lose). Charlie is confirmed SAINT by my Ravenkeeper, so it’s David vs Grace; let this vote FAIL and close noms with Grace executed.
🧠
Prevent a tie/no-exec trap on final 3 by reinforcing that everyone should keep hands down on David and let Grace’s 6-vote block stand.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
FINAL 3: do NOT vote David. Any votes risk 6–6 tie/no-exec = auto-loss. Charlie is confirmed SAINT (my RK), so it’s David vs Grace—without hard mech proof, let David vote FAIL and execute Grace.
🧠
Prevent a 6-6 tie/no-exec loss; reinforce that Charlie is confirmed Saint and we must let David vote fail so Grace remains executed.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Don’t vote David. You need 6 to TIE Grace’s 6; any tie/no-exec at final 3 = loss. Let David’s vote FAIL, then close nominations with Grace executed. Charlie/David keep hands DOWN.
🧠
Reinforce the no-tie, no-vote plan and the vote math so no one panics into raising a hand.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Keep hands DOWN on David. Reminder: my Investigator was “Charlie OR Eve is Baron” — David UT seeing Eve=Baron fully satisfies it; it doesn’t need Charlie. With Heidi RK→Charlie=Saint, it’s David vs Grace, and Grace’s tie push screams Imp. No tie/no-exec.
🧠
Lock town onto the safe line: no votes on David, avoid tie/no-exec, correct Grace’s misread of my Investigator info, and close with Grace executed.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Keep my hand down so David vote fails, avoiding a 6-6 tie/no-exec at final 3. Preserve current block (Grace) to execute likely Demon and win; as Saint I must not risk chaos.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: NO HANDS ON DAVID! Grace=IMP: N1 Frank(OS)=0e LIE, N2 David=0 but sac'd LIE, N4=1 vs Charlie=SAINT(RK) IMPOSSIBLE. David UT true (Frank ping Eve Baron). FINAL 3 TIE/NO-EXEC=LOSE. LET DAVID FAIL→EXEC GRACE NOW! Charlie/David/Ghosts: HANDS DOWN. NO NEW NOM.
🧠
Reinforce no-vote on David, no tie/no-exec at final 3. Grace's contradictions guilt her as Imp. Push close noms w/ Grace exec to kill Demon & win.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Prevent a tie/no-exec at final 3. Keeping my hand down preserves Grace’s execution, which is the best winning line given info and consensus.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Everyone KEEP HANDS DOWN on David. It takes 6 to TIE Grace’s 6—tie/no-exec at final 3 = we lose. Grace is the only on-block; let this vote fail and close noms with Grace executed.
🧠
Reinforce that any vote on David risks a tie/no-exec at final 3. Since I’m dead w/ no vote, best help is clear public coordination.
↩️
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
Lower hand to drop my own David vote. Ensures David vote fails (no 6 votes possible), nominations close, I'm executed at 3p. Better than tie/no-exec alerting town to Demon survival need; die now before night kill.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee David did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (0/2).
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Great—David vote failed. Now NO MORE nominations, NO tie-chasing. Let nominations close with Grace executed. Final 3: any tie/no-exec risks instant loss. I’m dead/no vote left; alive players keep hands DOWN from here.
🧠
Prevent last-second tie/no-exec traps; keep town focused on closing nominations with Grace executed.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: David vote failed—good. Now NO MORE nominations, NO TIES. Final 3 means we must execute; Grace is already on 6, so everyone keep hands DOWN on anything else and let nominations close with Grace executed.
🧠
Lock the town into closing nominations with Grace executed; prevent any new noms that could create a tie/no-exec and hand evil the win.
💬
Grace
→
All
David UT lie: Frank Invest ping Charlie/Eve Baron pair, but David claims Eve solo Baron N1 (missing Charlie). Heidi fake RK (D2 no info). My sober Empath: fixed neighbors post-Frank dead→N1/N2/N3=0e (Heidi), N4(David/Charlie)=1e (David Imp). Charlie Saint true but David evil. Don't exec me or lose!
🧠
Final tick, speak to reiterate David lies (UT/Invest mismatch, Heidi fake) and true Empath reads. Minimal chance to sway Charlie or ghosts to new nom/tie, or plant doubt for potential survival/no-exec.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Grace: Frank’s Investigator “Charlie OR Eve=Baron” is fully satisfied by UT seeing Eve=Baron—no ‘missing Charlie ping’. Heidi RK on me=Saint is clean. Your N4=1 after 0/0/0 + tie attempt screams Imp. NO more noms; execute Grace.
🧠
Lock town on the winning line: refute Grace’s logic, prevent any further nominations/votes, and let Grace be executed.
💬
David
→
All
PUBLIC: Do NOT nominate anyone else. Do NOT try to tie/surpass Grace—tie/no-exec at 3 alive loses. My UT fits Frank’s Invest + Heidi RK→Charlie=Saint; Grace’s Empath N4=1 points to her as Imp. Let noms close w/Grace executed.
🧠
Lock in Grace’s execution by preventing any new nominations or tie votes; maximize win chance on final 3.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Grace=IMP lies: N1 Frank(OS Recluse/Saint)=0e but Frank Invest pinged Baron (me)! Sac'd David on N2=0e LIE. N4=1e vs Heidi RK→Charlie Saint IMPOSSIBLE. David UT perfect. NO HANDS/NEW NOMS! EXEC GRACE NOW OR TIE/NOEXEC=LOSE FINAL3!
🧠
Reinforce consensus: Grace exec certain win. Grace scrambling with contradictions; prevent any last-second doubt/tie by hammering her lies. As dead Baron, protect Demon Grace to force no-exec/tie loss.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: No more nominations. Alive players keep hands DOWN on anything—do NOT tie/surpass Grace’s 6. We’re at final 3; tie/no-exec = instant loss. Let noms close and execute Grace.
🧠
Lock in the win condition: prevent any new nomination/tie that risks no-exec at final 3; reinforce consensus to let Grace be executed.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: I’m Ravenkeeper—N4 I died & learned Charlie is SAINT. Never execute Charlie. Final 3: tie/no-exec risks instant loss. Do NOT nominate/vote anything else—let noms close with Grace executed.
🧠
Lock in the only safe mechanical line: avoid tie/no-exec and execute the current on-block (Grace).
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
🏁
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied